Main Topic: The conflict between tech and legacy media, and how crypto and AI might offer a path to rebuild trust.
Key Points:
Participants:
Takeaways:
What really caused the breakdown between tech and media—and what comes next?
Erik Torenberg sits down with Balaji Srinivasan (entrepreneur, investor, and author of The Network State) to explore the long-building conflict between Silicon Valley and legacy journalism. Balaji explains how the collapse of traditional media business models gave rise to political capture, clickbait, and adversarial coverage of the tech industry.
They discuss why “going direct” is no longer optional, how tech became the villain in establishment narratives, and what it would take to build a new truth infrastructure - from decentralized content creation to cryptographic verification.
This episode covers power, distribution, and the future of media, with a signature mix of historical insight, social analysis, and Balaji’s forward-looking frameworks.
Timecodes:
0:00 Introduction
1:26 The Media vs. Tech Conflict
2:11 The Collapse of Journalism Revenue
2:39 Rise of Wokeness and Political Realignment
6:50 State vs. Network: A New Framework
9:00 The Power Structure of Media Institutions
19:25 The Role of Distribution and the Internet
29:20 The Social War: Red vs. Blue America
30:05 X Day and the Shift in Social Media Power
42:56 Strategies for Technologists: Go Direct
48:36 The Importance of Individual Creators
1:10:00 Decentralized Truth and the Ledger of Record
1:36:00 The Future of Media, Democracy, and Equality
1:37:08 Conclusion & Final Thoughts
Resources
Find Balaji on X: https://x.com/balajis
Stay Updated:
Let us know what you think: https://ratethispodcast.com/a16z
Find a16z on Twitter: https://twitter.com/a16z
Find a16z on LinkedIn: https://www.linkedin.com/company/a16z
Subscribe on your favorite podcast app: https://a16z.simplecast.com/
Follow our host: https://x.com/eriktorenberg
Please note that the content here is for informational purposes only; should NOT be taken as legal, business, tax, or investment advice or be used to evaluate any investment or security; and is not directed at any investors or potential investors in any a16z fund. a16z and its affiliates may maintain investments in the companies discussed. For more details please see a16z.com/disclosures.
Stay Updated:
Find a16z on X
Find a16z on LinkedIn
Listen to the a16z Podcast on Spotify
Listen to the a16z Podcast on Apple Podcasts
Follow our host: https://twitter.com/eriktorenberg
Please note that the content here is for informational purposes only; should NOT be taken as legal, business, tax, or investment advice or be used to evaluate any investment or security; and is not directed at any investors or potential investors in any a16z fund. a16z and its affiliates may maintain investments in the companies discussed. For more details please see a16z.com/disclosures.
Hosted by Simplecast, an AdsWizz company. See pcm.adswizz.com for information about our collection and use of personal data for advertising.
Erik Torenberg
We want to build Google's and Facebook's and AI and giant companies, giant cryptocurrencies, and now internet communities. What they want to do is they want to exert authority over others. What is the reason for the hostility between media and tech? So for them, the best thing they can do is to put a man out of work. And for us, the best thing we can do is we can put a man on the moon. Today on the podcast, I'm joined by Balaji Srinivasan, entrepreneur, investor, and author of The Network State, to talk about one of our longest-running shared topics, the conflict between tech and legacy media. We get into the rise of going direct, the financial collapse of journalism, the media's political capture, and how crypto and AI might offer a path to rebuild trust on chain and on our own terms. Balaji calls for a total rethink of what truth infrastructure looks like and why tech needs to play offense. Let's get into it.
As a reminder, the content here is for informational purposes only. Should not be taken as legal, business, tax, or investment advice, or be used to evaluate any investment or security, and is not directed at any investors or potential investors in any a16z fund. Please note that a16z and its affiliates may also maintain investments in the companies discussed in this podcast. For more details, including a link to our investments, please see a16z.com forward slash disclosures.
Balaji, another day, another journo hit piece. We were sort of talking offline about Mark and Ben's Evolution of the Media episode. Let me just more broadly reflect. I've been friends and collaborators for the last 10 years. One of the topics we've spent a lot of time talking about is the media, the state of the media, what needs to be fixed about the media, and how to do that. With your leadership, we have actually been a part of that trend and that evolution. I wanted to take the opportunity to talk with you, reflect about that evolution, and talk about where we still need to go.
Balaji Srinivasan
Yeah. Well, okay. So there's so much I can say on this. I'm going to show one graph, of course. It wouldn't be a Balaji podcast if we didn't start it with a graph.
Erik Torenberg
Yes, exactly.
Balaji Srinivasan
This shows that essentially newspaper revenue rose to like $70 billion in the year 2000. And then right after the financial crisis, it just suddenly collapsed over the course of like four or five years. And Google went vertical and Facebook went vertical, right? The thing about this is this was the internet disrupting blue America. There's a similar graph for manufacturing that shows China disrupting red America, almost at exactly the same time.
Just to focus on this one for a second, once you see the internet disrupting blue America—because media is a core thing for them—this is actually what led to wokeness. You've heard the saying, go woke, go broke, right?
Erik Torenberg
Yeah.
Balaji Srinivasan
In their case, it was actually go broke, go woke. Not my original coinage, but applied to this graph, it's relatively original. Wokeness was what happened after they fell off a cliff like this. From 2008 to 2012, tech was just part of the Democrat Party. Steve Jobs is there. There's actually this article from 2012 in The Atlantic, "The Nerds Go Marching In," about tech helping to reelect Obama. Facebook was helping Obama.
Erik Torenberg
Yeah, exactly.
Balaji Srinivasan
All that stuff was solidly on the Democrat side up until 2012. After the 2012 election, right after Obama's inauguration, you can date it to right after that. Even in 2012, New York media was saying there's no such thing as a programmer. You can Google that article. So in 2012, tech was part of the coalition. There was no reason to attack them. After the inauguration in 2013, literally that spring and summer, the knives came out and media started attacking tech. There are these articles—"Would You Just Look at All These Rich People" in Slate—that was before they got radicalized. They were saying it's actually bad to attack people just for the sake of being rich. That was before all media had updated to see tech as our enemy now.
Unless you understand the economics of it, I don't think one can understand why the journos suddenly went crazy. The thing is, we're now in 2025. It is now 17 years after the collapse in media revenue. Somebody who was born then, who was 18 years old, you're playing multiplayer video games like Quake, all the new stuff, MOBAs. You can get spawned into the middle of something where everybody's shooting at each other. That's what the Gen Z kid is today. From the perspective of someone who's 18 years old, the war with the journos has basically been a feature of their entire existence. But it actually wasn't like that. In the 90s and the 2000s, the journos were secure enough in their economic position because you could write four or six articles for Time magazine a year and get paid a nice salary and travel around the world.
Erik Torenberg
Did they kill?
Balaji Srinivasan
Yes, they killed. But they didn't feel the need to kill all the time. It's funny because of the way I'm putting it. Nellie Bowles actually did a thing for Bari Weiss a few years ago, and it's like "Learning How Not to Kill."
Erik Torenberg
It's funny because she's one of the few converts. She made the transition. She was able to get to the other side. When you look at that, or you look at another one by Hamilton Nolan at CJR, which is basically like "The Powerful Don't Need the Media." Journalism, particularly at its highest level, is about raw power. They admit it.
Balaji Srinivasan
I remember you had this old quote. Was it some journalist who was like, "We know our profession is kind of immoral"?
Erik Torenberg
That's an old quote. Oh, yeah, yeah, yeah.
Balaji Srinivasan
That's actually a great one. This is a book report. Anybody who has read this book cannot look at the journos the same way. Janet Malcolm talks about this in a great book called *The Journalist and the Murderer*. Her opening line is this famous thing. Hold on, let me find this. "Every journalist who is not too stupid or too full of himself to notice what's going on knows that what he does is morally indefensible. He is a kind of confidence man, preying on people's vanity, ignorance, or loneliness, gaining their trust and betraying them without remorse. Like the credulous widow who wakes up one day to find the charming young man and all her savings gone. The consenting subject of a piece of nonfiction writing learns when the article or book appears his hard lesson. Journalists justify their treachery in various ways according to their temperaments. The more pompous talk about freedom of speech, the public's right to know. The least talented talk about art. The seemliest murmur about earning a living."
This is a very important thing. This is rated one of the top 100 nonfiction books of the 20th century by the Modern Library. So this is a great book to read. There's another book you should also read, *The Great Lady Winked* by Ashley Rindsberg. Those prerequisites aside, let's talk about the specifics. There's like 10, 15 things I can say. Let me go point by point.
First is, what is the reason for the hostility between media and tech? The master framework on the whole thing is state versus network. This is from my book *The Network State*. I think it's a useful frame. For example, Elon versus mainstream media is network versus state. Social media versus mainstream media is network versus state. Or when there's an article attacking Luke Farritor, it's "Why did this programmer attack the institutions of the U.S. government?" Network versus state. This tech programmer attacking the state institutions. The people on social media, the tech people, are mad that this state-aligned institution is attacking our tech people. Once you apply that framework, it applies to everything. SpaceX is network, NASA is state. Uber is a network, taxi medallions are the state. Bitcoin is network, the Fed is the state, and so on.
Those are two different organizing principles for how you think about the world. The state is "someone should pass a law." The network is "someone should write some code." The state is everybody who is directly or indirectly paid by the U.S. government or a government more generally. The network is all those people who are directly or indirectly monetized and make their living on the network. When someone goes from NYT to Substack, they're moving from state to network. The network is actually taking parts of the state. All these tech guys are getting into government, into politics, into media, into finance, into the traditional niches that were for the state. That's why they're so mad. Their share of the global pie and the American pie is shrinking and the network pie is expanding. They're like, "Stay in your lane." Why are they saying that? They're like, "You should just be hitting keys on computers and being a nerd and making LED light bulbs that flash. You should not be rewriting the code base of how the world works."
There's a deep question of legitimacy. The network is new money. The state is old money. When I say the state, there's the literal state in the sense of the U.S. government, and there's the unelected institutions that surround the U.S. government in a ring that give it instruction. The newspapers tell the state what to do. The universities tell the state what to do. The philanthropies tell the state what to do. They are also, in turn, funded by the state. Universities obviously directly get federal funding. Some of them are literally public colleges, but they're very dependent on tax exemptions that the state grants. They only exist because of that. Philanthropy is ditto. NGOs have compounding foundations or their foundation endowment compounds because they've got favorable tax treatment, which normal companies don't get, but they're state affiliated.
Finally, the media. That's the least obvious. How are they upstream of the state? Well, obviously they hold somebody accountable by publishing a negative article on them. Of course, they never hold themselves accountable because they're always like, "We're speaking truth to power." I'm like, obviously they're not. Why? Is every journalist so courageous as to attack your boss whenever they're wrong? Whenever you're talking to a journalist, you're not talking to the journalist, you're talking to their boss. For example, Bloomberg. When Michael Bloomberg was running for president—he's one of the better ones because he's actually a tech entrepreneur, so I'm not completely anti-Michael Bloomberg—Bloomberg News, his pit bulls, posted this amazing thing: "We will report on but not investigate Michael Bloomberg." Amazing phrase. "Report on." What it means is, basically, if somebody else says something, we will reprint it in Bloomberg. So you can't say we didn't report on him. But we're not going to go and dig through his trash. We're not going to do it adversarially. We're not going to stalk him. We're not going to spam his family like they did to our boy, Luke Farritor.
Erik Torenberg
Masquer our boy.
Balaji Srinivasan
Well, they didn't massacre him because he's got our support. But they did attack him.
Erik Torenberg
I'm just referencing the meme. Yes, I know, I know.
Balaji Srinivasan
The thing is, they don't do that because if you were a Bloomberg journo and you went after Michael Bloomberg, that's what's known as a CLM: career limiting move. In fact, the entire journo establishment is all nepotist. That's all old money. They project onto us what their lifestyle is. Sulzberger, who inherited the New York Times. Murdoch, the guy who inherited Fox News now. The Newhouses who inherited Wired and Condé Nast. Basically, they're all heirs. They're not self-made. The journos don't have equity. Old money treats the journalists much worse. Tech people treat our employees so much better because we give them equity. They level up. Journalism is a completely two-tier system where there's the publishers, the owners of these papers, and there's these serfs, the journos. How do they compensate them? They compensate them in status, where the journalist is made to believe that they're some independent, freewheeling attack dog. Of course, they can't actually attack true power, who is their bosses. They'll never even mention them.
If I say Zuck, Zuckerberg—whether you like him or not—Zuckerberg deserves our respect because he's the man. He's taken the hits for 20 years. He has survived so many things. Crucially, he's CEO, he's founder, he's out there. You can criticize him by name. If I say Zuckerberg, everybody can summon a face to the name. They can summon all this bio. If I say Sulzberger, it's a blank. 99% of people don't even know the guy exists. He's like the usual suspects. He's like Keyser Söze, Keyser Sulzberger.
Erik Torenberg
Honestly, I've heard his name a million times, but I don't even know what he looks like.
Balaji Srinivasan
You don't even know what he looks like. Zuckerberg is somebody who, for better or worse, runs a major communications channel, so he's covered. But Sulzberger doesn't get good coverage. He gets no coverage. That is actually really interesting. Who's holding him accountable?
Erik Torenberg
Journalism for the privacy for me.
Balaji Srinivasan
Exactly. The guy who's surrounded by thousands of journalists at all times is the only person in the world who has any privacy.
Erik Torenberg
Yeah, that's good. You've never seen this guy's face. Who is this guy? He's on the New York Times. People say, "Oh my God, he's on the New York Times," you've never seen his face.
Balaji Srinivasan
The point is, if you did word-face association, in terms of a number of impressions, it's a quantitative thing. If I use AI, I could quantify it. How many people can summon the face of Zuckerberg with a word? Millions, billions probably. How many even know that Sulzberger exists? Basically nobody. Why? Because it's Zuckerberg's company. He is considered a person who is in charge of the company. People don't just say, "Oh, Facebook has some policy issue." They go after Zuck personally. But the NYT is granted the enormous shield of calling it the NYT, calling it the institution, as opposed to Sulzberger's paper. It is just Sulzberger's paper. It's his blog. There's nothing that is printed there without his approval. He inherited it from his father's father's father's father's father. It's like five generations.
Here's a big one. Let's get back to poor old Luke. Walter Duranty. Let me show you. Journos never hold themselves accountable. Here's a great tweet by Paul Graham. And then here's my reply to it. Look at Paul: "One of the biggest surprises in my adult life is how unethical reporters are. In movies, they're always the good guys." Everyone in tech knows stories like this. This is actually a deep point, Wyatt. Paul is saying this: in movies, they're always the good guys. This is a concept I call Jurassic Ballpark. Paul has said something like this many times. Jurassic Ballpark is like the movie Jurassic Park.
In it, they are missing some DNA for the dinosaurs. They use amphibious DNA, and that leads to issues because then they can reproduce. In the same way, when you have a missing segment of history or culture, you just ballpark it with what comes out of a movie. Jurassic ballpark. But that could be really, really wrong or fake because it's a movie after all. Unless you have personal experience of something, your impression of it is the movie version. This is a non-obvious point. How else could it be? Visuals are very persuasive. Video is a high bandwidth pathway to the human brain. It's not like your brain was built—maybe system two versus system one.
System one is instinctive, system two is logical thinking. Maybe your system two can distinguish between true and false for the video, but your system one can't.
People see all these things like journos are the good guys. We just saw *The Journalist and the Murderer*. Once you actually understand the space, they're more like Keyser Söze, Keyser Sulzberger, where they are the unreliable narrator. They write the story and everybody else dies and they're the good guys. You never actually hear the story of how the story is written, which is much more important than the story. Whenever you see "The New York Times has obtained," how did they obtain it? They got some stolen documents. Or they told a source, "Give me this and then I'll write favorably about you. Don't give me this and I'm going to name you and you're going to lose your job and get attacked." They do all that kind of stuff.
Erik Torenberg
I remember your definition of journalism: invasion of privacy for profit.
Balaji Srinivasan
Yeah, exactly. The non-consensual invasion of privacy for profit is what legacy media is. Let's take that definition. Non-consensual. Can you opt out? Can you say, "Journo, stop stalking me"? Can you say, "Journo, stop spamming me"? "Don't mention my family." In normal English, we have words for this. When journos go through your garbage—like Luke Farritor had somebody going and spamming all of his friends and contacts—if they were just some drug addict or crazy person, he could say, "That's stalking. That's spamming." You could get a 50-foot restraining order. I want to see people use anti-stalking, anti-spam things. Canned spam is unsolicited messages. You can try and use that on the journos. Maybe there's a sympathetic court system now. Basically, they get one warning: "Go the F away." The second time, they've got money, so go after them on that.
There's some process where there's all New York Times v. Sullivan and various things where they've had historical precedents that protect them. But once you think of them as spammers, as stalkers, as scammers—because they are scammers—*The Journalist and the Murderer*. What is the definition she used? A con man. The journalist is a con man because they'll always write this email to you fluffing you up and flattering you, pretending that they come in under flag of parley. They get their quote if you're dumb enough to talk to them. Then they stab you in the article. That's why Janet Malcolm said the consenting subject of a piece of nonfiction learns when the article appears his hard lesson. You talk to this person, they present themselves as a human being, as a person you're having a conversation with, and actually they twisted every word to try to stab you.
Coming back up. They're actually the stalkers, the spammers, the scammers. That's what the journos are. You can't get them to go away. That's the non-consensual part. The non-consensual invasion of privacy for profit. There's a saying that journalists sometimes use as self-defense: "Journalism is printing something that someone does not want printed. Everything else is public relations." What does that mean? Why does someone not want it printed? Usually because it's private information. So, the non-consensual invasion of privacy for profit. Let us not forget that these are multibillion-dollar media corporations. It took a long time in the 2010s for people to finally realize the New York Times, the journal—they're just dot coms. They're not referees. They're not neutrals. For some reason, people give them the imprimatur of an institution. "We need to save our institutions." But what's the difference between New York Times and Facebook?
Erik Torenberg
They're companies.
Balaji Srinivasan
Exactly. They're a corporation. Fair game.
Erik Torenberg
Right. And in fact, that's why they got so mad at us, because we actually believed in what they said, that we had freedom of speech and that free markets existed.
Balaji Srinivasan
Actually, until really the early 2010s, there was no actual practical freedom of speech. You know why? "Never argue with a man who buys ink by the barrel." Freedom of the press belonged to those who owned one. Think about how expensive it was to get a radio license, a TV license, to own a newspaper and send trucks to people's houses with all the ink and the printing press. That was super high capital cost. These are guys who essentially owned factories that cranked out papers. You at home could say something to your friend, but you didn't have distribution. We understand what distribution is now. Teal talked about distribution years ago before it was quantified with social media. Very roughly, distribution is number of followers, number of people on your email list, but also quality of them. Not just quantity, but quality and quantity of your follower base is roughly distribution.
You didn't have distribution. I mentioned this before, but in the early 90s, the Unabomber. Why'd he kill all those people? He killed those people so he could get an op-ed in the Washington Post. Why? Because distribution was so scarce back then that he wanted to get his manifesto out. He could literally kill people for the distribution. That was within our lifetimes, just 30 years ago. That's how scarce distribution was. Today, he'd be a crazy person on the internet. He'd get his message out there. If you realize the Unabomber was willing to kill to get his message out, you also realize why there are some people who are like crazy trolls on X. They might not be able to kill, but they're certainly willing to attack somebody else's character or reputation. Now you get to the journos.
Journalism as the non-consensual invasion of privacy for profit really captures what it is these critters do. Up until about 2020, there was no force that could resist them. They were just rampaging. We could resist them economically, especially in the 2010s. They were so mad at us taking their money. What did that mean? You refresh NYT.com, you see a Rolex ad or some car ad or some clothes ad. If you refresh Meta.com, Facebook.com, Instagram, you see an ad for exactly the same company. The sales account executives at both of these organizations are competing for literally the same customer. The Facebook, Google ad has much more scale, much more analytics, built internet first. The NYT just starts bleeding out. We're beating them economically. They couldn't code search engines or social networks, but they could write stories and shape narratives.
I know the difference between a Dropbox product announcement and an NYT story. Their stories have villains. Our product announcements are all about making the world a better place. "Guess what? 10 gigs more storage." "Guess what? Now you can do comic book style AI." All that stuff doesn't hurt anybody. It's adding cool things to the world. "Here's a new robot." That's what we're doing. What are they doing? The highest award in journalism, the most prestigious thing you can do? They want to catch the Theranos. Even higher than that is Watergate. For us, it's SpaceX. For them, the best thing they can do is to put a man out of work. For us, the best thing we can do is we can put a man on the moon.
Literally the number one thing they can see—again, state versus network—we want to build Googles and Facebooks and AI and drones. We want to build giant companies, giant cryptocurrencies, and now internet communities. What they want to do is they want to exert authority over others. They want to do so in a deniable way. If you go to the Pulitzer website and look at these prizes, they'll all say something like, "Our reporting held so-and-so accountable and led to an FTC investigation." They're really willing to take credit when their words on the page lead to the state golem going and animating and smashing somebody. It led to an FTC investigation. It led to a new FAA regulation. It led to some person getting fired, some program getting set up. The ultimate thing is to get the president of the United States fired. That's why they wanted to get Nixon fired with Watergate.
Think of the Wall Street Journal, NYT, and Washington Post as the three board of director seats on top of the presidency. The president was like the titular CEO, but the Journal, the Times, and the Washington Post, if they all put their multi-sig key in the lock, they did their board of directors vote, they'd get them fired. That was actually the state of affairs. That's what it meant by holding the government accountable. Nobody in the government was really in power. The journos could write enough negative stories and they were out of power. When it comes to Pulitzer time, they will admit that their stories led to something.
But when it comes to BLM time, they deny that their stories led to half of America getting burned down. It's a one-way ratchet where they take all the credit and avoid all the blame. Could you actually show the trace of that image coming into somebody's eye and then them setting fire to this building? Once in a while, you might be able to show it. They publish a manifesto saying, "I read X, Y, and Z, and that's why I burned it down." But that causal effect, demonstrating that, there's an impression, a page view that comes in through the eyes and the ears, and then there is a burn down the building action on the other side.
Erik Torenberg
It's funny because they're quick to use causal in another direction. They're quick to say, "Hey, Facebook is causing people to be depressed or to turn right wing."
Balaji Srinivasan
Yes, that's right. So tech, there's a causal effect for everything negative. Journos, there's a causal effect for everything positive.
Erik Torenberg
That's amazing. Everything you do is bad. Everything they do is good. Amazing flipping.
Balaji Srinivasan
Once you see this, you can be like Neo in the Matrix and just block everything like this. Another big piece of this—they stopped doing this—but one of the things they were doing years ago is they're like, "Oh my God, everybody in tech is so white." Obviously, it's so much more international than the journos. If you take that famous photo of Elon in the conference room and compare the people there versus the NYT editorial photo, you'll see they're well-dressed, essentially mostly European ancestry people. I'm not the kind of person who thinks white is an insult, but they do. It's all projection. The journalists themselves have these tyrannical, evil, meritless nepotists as bosses.
The journalists themselves can never actually make it anywhere and it's all favoritism and glad-handing and there's no merit and it's all luck and connections. And the journalists themselves essentially are these envious people who exist to harm you, to increase their career prospects. And they project all that out onto everybody else.
Once you see that, every accusation is a confession. You realize, oh, this is how the world works in their stupid Brooklyn side of things. And they think of us as a rival tribe that acts the same way.
Now I have bad news for them. Bad news for us and also bad news for them. But let's start with the bad news for them. The bad news is that in the gigantic war between the internet and blue America – and by the way, we didn't actually intend to start that war. We were just building great stuff. And it became so popular that we took away all of the customers of these guys.
It's not like you set up Twitter or Facebook or Google to go and blow up the Times and the Post and the Journal. Bezos got the Post out of petty cash. It was just something where we built a valuable enough business that it generates so much wealth that he could just go and acquire this thing.
I understand why they got mad, but what they should have done is rather than try to beat us, join us. There's a scenario where if Steve Jobs had lived, when Bezos bought the Post, Jobs buys the Times and Larry Page buys the Wall Street Journal, and we'd be on Mars by now.
At the end of the day, as much as I think there are evil twins in some ways, there's a deep sense in which there's a similarity. We're all about the collection, dissemination, and presentation of information. That's the similarity between tech and media. The collection of information, the raw data, whether it's user-generated content or so on. Dissemination, which is distribution, posting, circulation. Presentation, user interface. They think about their charts or infographics. They obsess about copy and so on.
We're a fork of them in the same way that Yale was a fork of Harvard or America is a fork of Britain. The internet's a fork of the East Coast culture.
Erik Torenberg
People like Paul Graham, Catherine Boyle, Mike Moritz.
Balaji Srinivasan
Exactly. That's right. In another life, Mike Moritz was a journalist, became an investor. Catherine Boyle, also a journalist, became an investor. Peter Thiel, if he'd been born 20 years earlier, probably would have been a Supreme Court jurist. Paul Graham would have been a professor. Larry Page, a professor.
Erik Torenberg
Mike Solana in Brooklyn, probably.
Balaji Srinivasan
For sure. You'd probably be a book publisher or something like that. I probably would have been a professor and so forth. That's true for Andrew Ng, Daphne Kohler, Martine Cassado, Dixon.
Because the thing is with computer science, there is an amazing connection between the word and the deed. AI makes that even closer. You write it down and it's done. It's this amazing thing. Ultimately what we're doing is we're also writing all day to see an impact in the world.
The difference is their impact, because they're doing it through the state and a failed state at that, is almost invariably negative. And because we're doing it through the network, we have feedback loops. When we type something in and it's actually factually wrong, the compiler throws up on it and it just doesn't compile. There's fact-checking on the page when we type something. They have no such thing. Their only fact-check is not by the world, but by their peers. It's only when they lose status among other journos that they ever course-correct. And that's very rare. So long as within their tribe they're not losing status, there's nothing.
Now, going back to the original point – the internet disrupting blue America, China disrupting red America – you can understand essentially the last 18 years in the following way. Blue America was disrupted by the internet. So they began wokeness to take a piece of Red America's pie and the tech clash to try and take back control from the internet. Red America was disrupted by China. So the trade war was against China and Trump was against Blue America. Because both their pies, they felt they were shrinking. So they launched two-front wars.
Blue America versus Red America and the internet, after a massive push, has lost. It was close, but basically Elon and X-Day – it's like literally D-Day. This feels like eons ago. It's only three years ago. Twitter was still Twitter. We are in wartime speed of things happening.
X-Day was something where it wasn't just Elon. $44 billion, even for Elon, that's at the right tail of what even Elon was capable of raising. That's a big raise for anybody. It took the richest man in the world, who's launching rockets, doing ships, all this other stuff, and he decided to take on this enormous extra thing and somehow manage it.
Elon is the end of one. Whenever I talk to a founder, I'm like, focus, focus, focus. After you have your first billion-dollar company and it's 10 billion, it's 100 billion, then you can do your next. Elon's end of one point is in 2022, where it looked like the free world was just completely on the ropes by these ratio-obsessed woke psychos having us pinned. You couldn't even say whether men and women exist. We were genuinely talking about a permanent midnight descending. Really, really bad stuff. How evil they were. They just burned down half America. They were getting psycho more and more.
Amidst that, all the resources of all the centrist tech and finance guys – that's what the $44 billion was. There's that famous message of Elon to Allison that's been made public. He's like, what are you in for, one or two? Allison could put in one or two. But so many other people, it was like Avengers Assemble, putting a mil, whatever they could afford, a mil, 10, 20, 50. 50 is a big investment for almost anybody. It's a serious LP meeting. Elon being Elon was able to pass the hat and assemble this gigantic coalition of $44 billion, all of our remaining forces for X-Day.
The landing was extremely contested. They wanted whatever the opposite of what he wanted. She essentially forced the acquisition through, or I think Elon is actually 40 chess. He actually is that smart. It is possible that Elon just made people think reverse psychology, got the judge who had negated his pay package to force him through this whole court process to get it back, then say, okay, same judge, now we'll do reverse psychology. Net net, he got Twitter.
X-Day was also the liberation of Meta and liberation of YouTube. All the countries that these racial fanatics at the NYT had occupied. The networks they had occupied. You know how the Nazi empire was at its peak and they thought they were going to win, and then D-Day and they just collapsed? Salzburger and Soros thought they were going to win, and then X-Day, boom. X flipping, YouTube uncensored, Meta uncensored, everything uncensored, because X was upstream of the conversation.
It took Elon's personal intervention in June 2023. His first round of firings hadn't done it. His second round hadn't done it. It was like the third round of chemo to get rid of the wokes that had just infested Twitter to actually change things.
Elon's intuitive more than a philosopher per se. His philosophy is his execution. But there's actually a real logic to why he renamed it X. Among other things. I'm not saying this is why he did it, but it is an implicit aspect of how he did it. It's just like them renaming all the schools and tearing down the statues. Every journo had put years of effort into building up their profiles, and all their blue checks were stripped and all their profiles got renamed to just X.
Another example is fake news. Fake news had been used in 2016 for a few weeks in the context of "all that social media news is fake, but the New York Times is real news." And Trump turned it on them. "Actually, the NYT is fake news, the fake news media." Which is perfect.
In the same way, the blue check went from something that journos valued to something that Elon just stripped from all of them. He stripped their status, stripped their distribution. I don't know whether the ban on outbound links is intentional or not. I have no personal information, this is just speculation. But even if it wasn't intentional, the ban on outbound links meant that suddenly X became the place you just go for the information and you don't go to the journos anymore.
He stripped their status. He stripped their control over the central stream of media. He stripped their traffic from links. He renamed the whole thing to show that he had root control over it. Do you know what a pain in the ass it is to do a rename? This x.com was, in a sense, tech's revenge for making every fucking GitHub rename from master to main.
Is Yale renaming its master's degree? No. Of course not. It's master class, whatever. Anybody at the New York Times, are they saying, "I've got a main degree now rather than a master's in journalism?" I think Columbia still has a master's in journalism.
The whole point was, again, these journalists have a double standard. They would impose that on us. One million GitHub repos have to rename from master to main, 100 million GitHub. Do you know what a pain in the ass that was? It was a huge pain in the ass. Every single dev had to go through some stupid exercise, which was just a demonstration of their power over us at that time. That was what renaming means. It means you cause a massive inconvenience for everybody to show that you have institutional power. So now Elon returns the favor and does it at even greater scale.
That is network over state. We fought in the domain in which we were stronger. Taking back X and renaming X – there's a hard-fought city in some wars. How many times did Seoul change hands during the Korean War?
Erik Torenberg
It was like several times.
Balaji Srinivasan
Seoul changed hands four times. It went back and forth. You think of X as being like Seoul during the Korean War. Because it's a social war. It's a digital war. We're a blue and red tribe.
To make that really explicit, this is a good visual. This is from 2017. The interesting thing is it's the same on both Twitter and Facebook. This is from eight years ago. They labeled nodes as blue and red based on whether they'd said "I'm voting for Clinton or Trump," just parsing the text. They looked at their connections and blue people were connected to blues and reds were connected to reds. The only large red media outlet was Breitbart. Blue was over here. The Hill was one of the very few outlets that both sides tend to link because it just gave neutral political news.
You could actually see that this was a social war. I've made this point in the past that in 1861, when it was the North versus the South, we take for granted that the ideological and the geographical coincided. The North was the Union, and the South had the slaves. Slavery is legal here and illegal here. The geographical and ideological coincided. But by 2016, the geographical and ideological did not coincide. You didn't have clean red states and blue states. It's very fractal. Red states and blue states do exist, but it's a preponderance as opposed to something that's clean.
Erik Torenberg
If you showed ideology here, it also looked more fractal, but it was more distinct ideologically back then, and here it's much more geographically overlapping. With me so far?
Balaji Srinivasan
Yep.
Erik Torenberg
Okay.
Balaji Srinivasan
But there is a domain where these two factions are completely distinct, and that is the domain of the cloud. On the land, red and blue are higgledy-piggledy right next to each other. They can't invade each other's territory. What are you going to do, invade the cities or the cornfields? You can't invade the lands. So instead, the social war is fighting over the mines, invading the mines.
Once you see this, you can actually understand a lot about the last 10 years. We've basically been in the middle of this gigantic social war. The goal for blue was, how do you win a social war against red? You ever play the game Othello?
Erik Torenberg
I know the game, but I've never played it.
Balaji Srinivasan
It's like you flip tiles. You've got black and white tiles, and you surround other tiles, and you flip them from black to white or white to black. The goal for blue was to win ideologically and flip every red node to blue.
Think about how an ant colony works. Individual ants don't actually know what they're doing, but the colony has an intelligence. This is the same for a flock of seagulls or a school of fish. There's colony intelligence. Once you start thinking about ideology, it's just like that.
Think of woke as blue, or radicalized blue. It's like laser eyes. Go broke, go woke. They lost all this money as the internet disrupted them. Blue laser eyes come online and they start going to their old religion because they don't have the money anymore. When countries got blown up in the Middle East, when countries go on hard times, that's when fundamentalism returns. Because they don't have the economics anymore. Their economics went away, laser eyes glowing blue.
The eyes glow blue of these Chernos. They were like, okay, it's life or death for us. And they started going and trying to capture as many institutions as possible in the social war. That's why they were going after random-seeming nodes and forcing and canceling them. Remember how they wanted Amazon to put BLM on its homepage? They did get Amazon to put BLM on its homepage. For a long time, you'd load Google and it would have some BLM thing on there.
Erik Torenberg
You know what I'm talking about.
Balaji Srinivasan
Of course. Brian Armstrong during the 2020 BLM riots, people were trying to force him to say Black Lives Matter on Twitter. What was the point of that? It's like the shahada in Islam. The point was to show you're a convert to blue. To flip a red node blue because it's a checkmark over your head to show they flipped that node. Now that's part of Blue Tribe and now they can turn attention on the next one.
All of the cancellation, all of the censorship, all the deplatforming, all of the unbanking, all of the insane ideological fervor – you can conceptualize it as an attempt from blue to reunify red versus blue on blue terms by turning every internet company into something that was paying tribute to blue versus worthless DEI jobs, and every red into somebody who is paying tribute to blue by not just giving up the presidency, but assuming the position.
Why do they want to defund the police? They want to fund their NGOs. That's what it's all about. They wanted to redirect the budget. That's why there are 200 homeless NGOs in San Francisco alone. The homeless industrial complex. As their budget rises, the homeless population rises with it. They're basically paid to get people addicted to drugs. It's the Department of Dependency.
All of this stuff with defund the police, defund the NGOs, can be conceptualized as this broad social war of blue against red to flip all red nodes blue. What was their main weapon? You're racist, you're sexist, you're homophobic, you're this, you're that, transphobic, blah, blah, blah. With this language, they could force you out of their institution because they'd fire you for being accused of any of these things. They'd say your institution, they'd bust your borders and they would swarm you with unqualified hires or else you'd be accused of this. The same language they'd use to strengthen their borders and deport reds, they'd use to bust your borders and import blues.
If you're a racist, you get fired from a blue organization. And you're a racist unless you hire blues.
Of course, today we see they don't actually care about brown people or black people, only blue people. That's more clear in 2025. It was less clear several years ago.
Now coming back up the stack. Once we realized that it was a social war, we can actually understand why the journos want to kill you. At various times in history, France and Germany have traded and France and Germany have fought. We are in wartime mode with the journos. It is extremely stupid for anybody to – now let's go to concrete brass tacks. What should technologists do? And what should we do specifically?
First, at the individual level. Number one, go direct. Build your own distribution to avoid distortion. Any content you have should be posted on your feeds. Why would you go and feed it to some journal? You've got some scoop. You don't need them for distribution anymore. It's more obvious that they need your content to build up their channel. And they will distort it in the process because they get credibility within other journals by being hostile to tech guys. If they write a positive story, then it's like, "Well, you're a flack, you're running a press release."
Also, there's another point. Conflict is interesting. Any movie, if you're writing a screenplay and it's just somebody sitting on the grass enjoying a fine sunny day, that's boring. But if a meteor hits, suddenly you've got attention. What works in a movie setting is not what works in real life. Journals want conflict. Our concept of "hey, it's 10 gigs for Dropbox" might be helpful to the public, but it doesn't tell a story and they want a story. They're always going to take what you do and put it through some distorting lens to get to the other side. And they will get more page views at the expense of your company that you worked on so hard.
Number one, go direct. Number two, build your own distribution to avoid distortion. Hire creators. There are two kinds of creators. Those who are at the storyline level, and you probably only need one of those per company. If you have too many very strong-willed personalities in a company, you can only have one Steve Jobs at Apple. However, you can have a lot of people assisting with production, with making content, with scaling that creator.
Usually you're going to have a founding creator. I'm not saying it's 100%. Sometimes once you get to a certain scale, it's good to have some personalities. For example, Jesse Pollock is doing a great job at Base for Coinbase. He's got his own distinctive style that's complementary to Coinbase's style. At a certain scale, you can have multiple personalities driving certain product lines. That's fine. But for a startup getting up to build, you probably only want one storyline, one main creator, and a lot of production support behind that. That can really work. You can get very far with that. Video, images, all this kind of stuff.
A, go direct. B, build your own distribution to avoid distortion. One way of thinking about it: they call them the media because they mediate your experience of reality. When you're putting anything through a media, it's like an Instagram filter that makes you into a villain. Why would you do that to yourself? It's like paying the journo with free content to make yourself look bad and get a permalink that's attacking you.
I remember our good friend Flo Curvello was launching his remote office startup during COVID and he gave TechCrunch the exclusive and they criticized it. They didn't make it look good. He's like, "Why would I give you my launch announcement? I'm here to advertise my company. I gave it to you guys. I gave you the exclusive and you made me look stupid. Why would I ever do that?"
The fundamental thing is, it's a business development relationship. Literally think of it as TechCrunch is a corporation. Why are you giving them something for free? That journo has a spreadsheet, whether it's them or their manager looking at it. There's a row in the spreadsheet for that URL. It's got the number of clicks and the number of conversions and the ad revenue on that article. That's the only thing they care about. You know what's not there? The valuation or health of your company. Obviously, they don't care. They would literally light it on fire. That's what they did during BLM. The journo would light your house on fire and sell tickets to the blaze. That's their business model.
It's the dumbest possible deal. People still do this stuff. Elon uncensored Twitter. You can post whatever you want. YouTube's uncensored. Everything's uncensored now. Get good. Anybody who's talking to journalists in 2025, hiring public relations – what are you doing? What are you even doing?
Now, I will say one thing. This is very important. Over the last several years, when we've done the tech and media ecosystem, there has been something that's worked and something that didn't work. What worked? Individual-led projects. Mike Solana's PirateWires has a real style to it. TBPN exists to make Ramp get more conversions, which is very funny. Ramp is our main sponsor. They've got them on the hats. They've NASCAR'd it. Ramp's a good product, by the way. TBPN, great. Coogan stuck with it. He did a lot. Obviously, All In has done very well. Obviously, Elon has done very well. I think you did it with Moz, and now Ace and Z's. I think that's right.
What I think has not done as well is the things that are institutional. If it's too institutional, you're playing it safe. You're playing it safe and there isn't any conflict, there isn't any opinion, there isn't anything novel, it's focus grouped. Certain things benefit from averaging. For example, the velocity of a plane, you don't want large deviations. You want it to be within an envelope. There are certain kinds of phenomena where you want averaging. Opinions and theses are usually not like that.
One way of thinking about it: the entire 20th century was the centralized century. The movement from widescreen to portrait size – a phone is 9 by 16. The movement from widescreen to portrait size is visually the movement from institutional to individual. A portrait kind of thing, a TikTok style thing, doesn't have room for a panoramic shot of a huge crowd. It's for a person standing there. It's amazing that even the screen itself captures that move from institutional to individual.
You see this also on X and other platforms. These journos, I don't know what they were doing, if they were faking numbers or whatever. They have 20 million followers and they have three likes on their tweets now. Something happened there where either it was all fake or there's just low engagement or just boring. People just don't trust those institutions anymore.
Another really important lesson: individual over institutional. If you're doing social media, it should be the amplified voice of your founding creator. The founding creator is as important as a founding engineer. The founding engineer is implementation, but the founding creator is the distribution. The founding engineer is the how, but the founding creator is the why. The founding creator has a community that they're tapped into. They're saying, "Why should this product exist?" You can often start by understanding your community and building a product for them and then hiring the engineer.
It's actually a third kind of person. Normally it's been like there's the engineering founder and there's the business founder. This is the content founder. This is where Collison and Altman have observed: where are the Gen Z, where are the younger founders who are not in tech? They're in content. Because that's where extreme leverage is. That's Mr. Beast. That's the guy who actually looks like you, Aiden Ross. Some of the younger guys are there. IShowSpeed is like that. They're very talented at what they do. It's just not something that we thought of as a thing because there's still the startup kind of thing.
I shouldn't say it's a game for 30 and 40 somethings, but millennials are good at startups and we're still good at startups. Palmer's doing a new thing, Altman's doing a thing – obviously not a new thing – but we keep doing stuff. But the 20-somethings are often very good at content, and content is actually upstream of product. There's room for a lot of collaboration there, potentially where they're doing the marketing. It's kind of like Beats by Dre, but you start with Dre rather than Apple.
I'm not saying anything people don't know, but right now those have been doing things that are relatively low tech, like Mr. Beast Feastables or T-shirts or stuff like that. Brian Johnson with Blueprint is starting to get higher tech where you start with the creator and then ideally you can distribute quantified self stuff through that. Huberman could also do something like this if he decides to get into that area. Any biotech company, genomics company, sequencing company could do deals with Huberman for distribution.
This is starting to make the case for why you don't outsource your creation. Are you outsourcing your engineering? Don't outsource your creating. Don't outsource your content. Content is as key as code. Content happens in the house. You have to sweat over it.
Here are a few things that I'm half implementing, partially implementing, or I am implementing, but I want to implement more.
And it's this kind of thing you want. Obviously, come to ACZ or come to network school, come to NS.com, come to network school, come and work with us.
But for example, GitHub allows a bunch of people to contribute to code at the same time. We take that for granted. How do you get a bunch of people to contribute to content at the same time? Something like Frame.io is pretty good. You can put all these clips in there, all these images in there, and then you have something for people to work with. Or CapCut web interface – you can log into that and just basically load stuff in there and you have a few accounts that are shared among team members.
So now you actually have something where creation was a single player app. You start making it a multiplayer app, and now internet connections are good enough that you can do versioning on big files and reviews of big files and so on. Start thinking about your content base like your code base.
And obviously AI is a big part of that, though it's not the only thing. Any new tool, people use it and they overuse it, and you bring it back and you're like, okay, it's a percentage of my thing, but it's not everything. If we did this whole podcast as AI and we had computer generated versions of us, it wouldn't be as interesting. Because it's generic. AI is necessarily – it's almost like a search engine. It pulls the average.
I was saying this the other day: midwit writing used to be woke. Now all midwit writing is AI. It's not this, it's that. So it's a super intelligence yet midwit. But that's because it's building the average from the whole internet. So it's useful when you prompt it.
Anyway, point is, that's another piece on media. So build your own distribution to avoid distortion. Go direct if you have something to say. Hire creators – no journos, only influencers. That's a related point. Do not bring journalists to your conference. Do not bring journalists to your event. Do not bring journalists anywhere. They would try to unperson you and cancel you on everything. You need hard borders. No journos.
The reason is because as Janet Malcolm said, they're like a con man. There are normal people who'll talk to you like a normal person. And there's a journo who'll come there with a mic and try to get someone to say something and then attack them. The problem is, a lot of people – you know how the journalists get them? They get them on ego.
Erik Torenberg
It's actually very similar to the CIA. Do you know what I'm saying?
Balaji Srinivasan
Yeah. It's like mission. Exactly. See, most people don't understand this. Much of what the NYT and these guys do – and they're so much weaker than they used to be. So, so, so much weaker. Thank God. They've lost the center.
What happened is they just piled up the subscriptions and they got all the wine moms and lost the Andreessens. Amazing trade for us. They lost Glenn Greenwald. They lost Marc Andreessen. They lost Nate Silver. They lost Bari Weiss. Amazing trade for us. For the center, because they actually got tech envy and they just optimized for money and they lost all influence and power over the center. Thank God. And actually, that's a good trade, by the way, to be clear. I actually want everybody to have a good life.
It's possible that in some alternate reality, some of the journos would be good people. Not all. Some of them are genuinely evil people with a stalkerish personality. But a good chunk of them – for example, Derek Thompson is not a hater.
Erik Torenberg
Yeah, he's good.
Balaji Srinivasan
Yeah. But that's why he left the Atlantic. So all the ones who are not haters eventually leave because you have to have the soul of a hater to be a journo today. You have to have a soul which is like a stalker, envious kind of person, Gollum-like personality to be a journo. And also you have to not get it. You have to be not numerical enough because the pay is better in tech in general, employees are treated better. So you have to be a hater of a certain kind, a very specific kind.
Anyway, point is, the journo is another key concept when interacting with them, or not interacting – you shouldn't interact with them. But let's say when dealing with them, is there like a private, for-profit CIA or FBI? Should I explain this point? Especially CIA.
The thing is, most people think from – remember the Paul Graham thing about, you learn from the movies, the Jurassic Park fallacy. So most people think that what the CIA does is assassination. But a lot of what it does is actually character assassination. It plants stories. Isn't that much cleaner? To just have somebody plant a story and then they're discredited? It's so much cleaner than bullets and blood.
In fact, they did this in East Germany as well. By the way, Wikipedia is actually just as bad as the media because Wikipedia – it's garbage in, garbage out. What happens is you can only cite articles from legacy media, you can't cite social media directly. So it's a rehash. In anything that's contemporary, anything that's political, they're really terrible. Nevertheless, there are some articles from when they didn't get corrupted.
So psychological warfare used by the Ministry of State Security – it served to combat alleged through covert means. Basically, Zersetzung was because the communists were also fighting a similar social war. They had conservatives, they had libertarians, they had non-communists on their territory. They didn't want to kill them. They wanted to convert them, just like the blues flipping the reds to convert to blue. They were targeted to stop activities of political dissent and cultural incorrectness.
What are the kinds of things they did? They do things like go and mess up your sock drawer to make you think you're insane, or tell people you're having an affair. Subvert and undermine an opponent. Disrupt the target's private life so they're unable to continue their hostile negative activities toward the state.
Erik Torenberg
This is what they did to Luke Farritor just now.
Balaji Srinivasan
Exactly this. The aim was to disrupt the target's private or family life so they're unable to continue their hostile negative activities toward the state. Do you see that? What they're mad about is Luke – they didn't care when Luke was just analyzing some old museum pieces. But once he's going after the state, when DOGE is going after the state, that's their bread. That's their power center. That's their golem. The FTC investigated this after our articles. So anything that's upstream of that, they don't want us to be upstream of that. They want to be upstream of that. Make sense?
As they say, the communists and the journalists are the same, but I repeat myself. The reason I say that – I may have mentioned this – but John Reed, Walter Duranty, Herbert Matthews, David Halberstam, Edgar Snow. Take all those names. Those are all the journalists who did the PR for the communists. It's literally the reason that Castro's in power.
For example, there's this book *The Man Who Invented Fidel: Castro, Cuba, and Herbert L. Matthews of the New York Times*. Or here's another one, which is Duranty – Stalin's apologist. Isn't that amazing? Stalin's apologist worked at the New York Times. Castro's apologist worked at the New York Times. Crazy stuff.
Actually, there's another one, *Perfect Spy* – the Vietnam one. The incredible story of the double life of Pham Xuan An, a Time Magazine reporter on Vietnamese communists. Isn't that interesting? See, when I say journalists and communists, but I repeat myself, I'm being completely literal. We just pulled up three books in 30 seconds that were about journalist communists.
So Dylan Matthews from Vox, he's talking about the Luke Farritor argument. He says, "The negative reaction to this is wild. If you join the government and your primary legacy is helping to kill millions of people through aid cuts, you can handle some criticism if you can live with yourself." The Satterlys' primary legacy is killing, not through aid cuts. The Satterlys' primary legacy is killing millions of Ukrainians. Where's their criticism? Again, Dylan Matthews is too much of a coward to do that.
The logic is just insane. It's claiming that by Dylan Matthews not giving all of his money to aid, he's killing people. Or by not making more money, he's killing people. He accuses a 23-year-old of killing millions of people. Why are we giving money in the first place?
One of the things – notice what they're doing here. With the Holodomor, there's a very clear-cut case where Duranty wrote 13 articles that basically said Stalin wasn't liquidating the Ukrainians, he just meant it metaphorically. They're literally covering up a murder in progress. That was a very clear-cut case.
Here, you're talking about the "Feed the Pigeon Society" argument. Essentially, as the number of the population grows dependent, any cut to budget whatsoever for the blues is equated with murdering their dependents. And they probably believe that. So it grows to the sky, and everybody gets alms – of course the blues get nice paid nonprofit jobs out of it. And you have more and more.
And by the way, guess what? He's absolutely completely wrong here as well. You know why? Go to Easterly and Levine. Easterly and Levine said, stop the aid. Why? Because all the aid is used for these warlords in Africa. Actually, there's something where in Nigeria, there's a business plan competition that was the most successful aid project ever because they're making businesses.
I saw this myself in India. Guys like these effective altruists – they don't want peers. They want pawns. Brown people in India were starving in the 80s, and they were pawns of these NGOs who sent the aid. Now India doesn't need aid. India is actually number three in unicorns. It's landing on the dark side of the moon. I'm not saying everything is perfect, but it's rising.
So the fundamental premise of his point – that aid helps – is incorrect. Aid actually hurts. You know what it's kind of like? Testosterone supplementation of a biosynthetic pathway. If somebody takes too much of an exogenous hormone, it cuts off their natural production. If people take too much in the way of steroids, it can cut off your natural hormonal production. You have to get it exactly right.
The actual charity is investment. This is actually a deep point. Should I explain this point?
Erik Torenberg
Yeah.
Balaji Srinivasan
So imagine you've got two rich guys. One of them is Soros or USAID – a rich institution handing out grants, seeming grants. And another person is an investor. For the people who are queuing up to write those grants to seek aid, they are making themselves as sympathetic or as pathetic as possible. In the limit, it's like the movie *Slumdog Millionaire* – it's dramatized, but the limbs of the kid are cut off to make them more sympathetic. It's learned or caused helplessness. You pretend to be or become as helpless and pathetic and sympathetic as possible so you get the maximum amount of money. You win the competition for being the biggest loser, the biggest victim. That's what wokeness is.
By contrast, if you think about our culture in tech and VC, what we respect more than anything else is strength. You come to us for a check, and what we respect the most is if we didn't put a check in you, but you still win and you raise from someone else or you do it on your own, you bootstrap. And then a year later, we're like, I respect you. I was wrong. You were strong enough on your own.
One way of talking about this is "fake it till you make it." But another way of putting it is: rather than the *Slumdog Millionaire* of people chopping off their limbs and thinking about how depressed and pathetic they are to compete for grants and aid, instead imagine a bunch of people who are all running a race, like a mile. They're running a mile and 20 people compete, only one wins, but the other 19 at least got a workout. Everybody who's in the process of trying to raise venture – or not, you can just totally bootstrap it yourself, the single person startup is much easier than it's been – but anybody who's in that process becomes stronger as a consequence of it because you constantly want to keep giving updates to the investor on all the stuff you're shipping. And that means the easiest way to do that is to actually just ship. In the process of proving yourself to others, you prove yourself to yourself.
So that's why a small amount of capital when 20 people compete for it strengthens the whole ecosystem. But a small amount of aid when 20 people compete for it weakens the entire ecosystem.
Another way of putting this: take these wokes who purport to believe in equality, the Soros types. Are they walking down the street and saying, "Oh, here's some guy on the street. I'm going to give them half my fortune. Now we've achieved equality?" Are they going to do that? Let's say they've got a billion dollars. Are they going to find a hundred thousand people and each give them $10,000 so they've all got $10,000 and they're down to $10,000, so they're all equal? It's within their power to do so. They could literally hit a button to do so. If they actually believe in equality, they could instantly achieve equality right now.
Erik Torenberg
And indeed, I actually do believe in redistribution for every self-proclaimed socialist – just for them to take their fortunes and redistribute them. Opt in to socialism. We'll take all their money, all the wokes.
Balaji Srinivasan
That's right. Look, we basically opt into that. What they actually want, of course, is to take your money and do something with it. But you take them at their word – they actually believe in equality. What they mean by equality is equality between themselves and the people they're looking up at. They're not thinking about all the people they're wealthier than. And that's it.
Another way of putting it
if somebody's walking on the street and they see somebody down on their luck, they might give them a dollar or $10. You're not going to give them half your salary. So charity decelerates. The more somebody rises, the less sympathetic and pathetic they are. People have talked about how once somebody gets out of the total underclass into the working poor, they actually sometimes make less money from all the grants because of all those cutoffs – that's how they're considered self-sufficient. You can earn your way into a local valley before you earn your way out of it. It's a disincentive to work.
On the other side of things, take Thiel and Zuckerberg. This is a very famous example. There are many more like this. Zuck started out much poorer than Thiel. Thiel put in $500K. Zuck is now much richer than Thiel, but Thiel also became much richer in the process. That's an example of investment actually achieving redistribution of fortunes, or creation of fortunes, or greater equality in a way that charity never would.
Capitalism is the ultimate social... The same way the phones that got to everybody in the world, the billions of phones – capitalism did that. Aid didn't do that. All this USAID stuff is just aiding blue NGOs.
Erik Torenberg
[Laughs] I was laughing at the truth of that.
Balaji Srinivasan
That's the truth of it. So the fundamental premise of his point is exactly wrong. And so you're taking away their pets. You're taking away their pawns. You're taking away their reason for existing. And of course, they'll pathologize that. But actually, they're doing harm to them. They're not helping them. Helping is investment.
It obviously goes to the old saw of "teach a man to fish versus give a man a fish." But give a man a thousand fish forever, they become completely dependent. And that's actually the goal of it. Really, what's happening is the cutoff of USAID is rolling up Blue Empire. So it's killing the blue business model. That's what they're mad about, Luke.
Erik Torenberg
Okay, keep going. I think going back to Luke, what's our advice to him? Or how do you sort of react or reflect in the situation? What should he do now?
Balaji Srinivasan
I don't know how they got that photo of him. Did he sit for that photo?
Erik Torenberg
No, no, no. I don't think so.
Balaji Srinivasan
So point is, I think overall, he didn't talk to journos, which is good. Look, Luke will be fine. Why will Luke be fine? Because his tribe supports him. And the journos' ability to impact somebody else... With that said, the reason they do this stuff now is – and this is the unfortunate part – they do this stuff and they post this. Take this Dylan thing. By his logic, someone would be justified in Luigi type stuff. This is really the dangerous thing about what these journos are doing. They're trying to essentially foment hatred against tech guys.
What have we done besides make things cheaper, faster, better? I can now communicate with anybody, anywhere, anytime for no money. I can find all the world's information at my fingertips. I can do math and computer science. I can do simulations. We can launch rockets. We've got electric cars. And we're the bad guys? Versus the people who are just stalking and spamming everybody all the time?
First thing is just to have an incredibly strong moral bedrock frame. Understand that everything the journalists are doing is projection. I think advice to Luke – the first thing, by the way, is I actually think that had tech ignored that article, it wouldn't have gone anywhere. That's another piece about it. Don't take the bait.
Erik Torenberg
The irony is that this is the opposite of a hit piece for him in that he's now got defenders. We know it's a puff piece in our circles. It's a badge of honor.
Balaji Srinivasan
That's right. So I think what I would say is I think his family and friends should consider going to Starbase, Texas or something like that. You want to now sort at this point. You want to sort and be amidst communities of people who share your values. The sooner you do that, the better. The reason is you just don't want to have crazy blue people around you – the Tesla terrorists who are blowing things up, the Luigis. That is actually the danger here. And I don't say that lightly.
In fact, if you want, we can just bleep out Luke's name because I don't want to... But basically, I think the issue with this is – here's another kind of recommendation for tech guys. There's a decision rule: don't take the bait. The journos only get traffic for their articles when they get rage views from us. And guess what? They got 700K views for this tweet and they got conversions because they sold ads. So that's a win for them in a sense. It's not a total win because they certainly aren't getting anybody fired, but it's some kind of win.
A while ago, there was some journo who was doing a cover story on a tech guy for like 15 months. And he just completely ignored the entire thing. And it got no clicks, no views. The opposite of love isn't hate, it's indifference.
Another way of putting it
we've built up much of the supply chain, but not all of it. The most important thing is we've gotten X and we've reestablished control over the platform because they had gone deep into our territory and actually had crazy blue stuff in some of our citadels, like our VC firms. One of the things they were doing is they're trying to target the stuff that's upstream – the platforms, the venture capitalists – to try to hit the... Why they go after Uber? They didn't want a trillion dollar company, certainly not a libertarian one. Why they go after VCs? They're the ones distributing capital. If they go after these nexus points, these critical nodes, they could try to hit those. If you're in a social war, it's like taking a capital city or a town. You don't go after a desert. You go after nexus points.
So they were deep in our territory. Now we took back the platform. That's good. And we're flanking mainstream media with tweets and podcasts – ultra short form and ultra long form content where they don't have as much establishment oomph. We figured out the formula that works: individual over institutional.
Now, the next step – and this is the big story for the next five years or so – the ledger of record. Ultimately, you can't be a critic. You have to be a constructive critic. Like Ron Paul said, "End the Fed," and Satoshi implemented Bitcoin. So you have the criticism, then you have the construction. We actually have to build something better. We have to build internet-first media. That is that whole talk I gave on the ledger of record.
That talk was originally from like 2020, and I actually feel pretty good about essentially predicting that GPT-3, the next version of it, would be able to summarize things. It happened faster than I thought, but the projection was correct. The fundamental premise: if you think about a sports article, it's essentially a wrapper around a box score. If you take a financial article, it's essentially a wrapper around stock ticker symbols. If you take a political article, it's a wrapper around tweets. That's the raw feed. It's the numbers that underpin the letters.
Now, if you think about what a blockchain is, it's a cryptographically verifiable feed. That's what Bitcoin is. A blockchain is a stream of events similar to Twitter or any other event-based feed, except it's got much harder cryptographically verifiable guarantees. Proof of what, when, and where. Or proof of what, when, and who. What is the hash? When is the timestamp? Who is the digital signature? You can also do proof of location, proof of where, and other kinds of proofs. That stream of cryptographic proof is like a better Twitter – cryptographically verifiable Twitter. Then you have AI referencing that to create articles. That's the high level concept of the ledger of record that replaces the paper record.
We have to play to win. We have to essentially realize that that is the center of the whole thing: truth. And actually we have a better form of truth. You know what that is? It's a form that is native to us.
Erik Torenberg
Crypto.
Balaji Srinivasan
Yes. And specifically, there is a good book actually by a reformed journo, or two somewhat reformed journos – the ones who are not haters. Vigna and Casey, they're okay. *The Truth Machine: The Blockchain and the Future of Everything* – this is like seven years ago. It just basically puts in book form a concept that existed for a long time. So I've got a citation for the concept.
Essentially, the point is that Bitcoin is decentralized cryptographic truth. The whole thing about Bitcoin that's so hard is how do you get global consensus on who owns what BTC? And we have something now where whether you're a Democrat or Republican, Japanese or Chinese, Indian or Pakistani, everybody agrees on the state of the Bitcoin blockchain. They have global consensus on this thing which is worth trillions of dollars. People fight wars over billions of dollars, millions of dollars. They kill people over thousands of dollars sometimes. So to have global consensus on this with no policemen or no military backing it... You know that saying, "How many divisions has the Pope?" which Stalin would say. How many long divisions has the New York Times? They don't have any. Bitcoin has them.
So we actually have truth on our side, a more powerful form of decentralized cryptographic truth. It's not headquartered in downtown Manhattan. It's on the internet.
Erik Torenberg
Let me weigh in for a second because this all sounds compelling, but I also just want to celebrate. Right now we have John Coogan and Mike Solana and us and lots of other folks doing such great work without the crypto elements. So why is that necessary?
Balaji Srinivasan
Yes, great question. So what we're doing with all the commentary is necessary but not sufficient. Commentary – it's humorous, it's opinion.
Erik Torenberg
We need reporting, we need news.
Balaji Srinivasan
You need reporting, exactly. Commentary and summarization is over here, but news is the update. Now, the thing is, Twitter is obviously a feed of raw facts that people are putting out there in a decentralized way. Bitcoin increases that because it actually says, once you can get consensus on who owns what BTC, you can also get consensus on who owns what stocks, what bonds, what Ethereum, smart contracts. And actually, as I wrote in an article the other day, all property becomes cryptography. We can do that in a different session. You basically have consensus on who owns what property. So all valuable things you can get cryptographic consensus on. Chainlink and stuff like that – they built essentially armored cars for information, sending it up and down to the blockchain. Polymarket – armored cars for information where information on the internet that's commercially valuable can be protected by cryptography.
So let's take the case of Pirate Wires and TPN. That's great. But let's say there's some dispute over whether a photo is real or not. A great example is *The Atlantic* published this crazy piece calling for invading Brazil because they saw a photo of the Brazilian fires.
Erik Torenberg
And was the photo not real?
Balaji Srinivasan
Yes, exactly. That's a very clear example. "The Amazon fires are more dangerous than WMD." This is a great example of when I said they'll literally kill you for clicks. They were calling for the invasion of Brazil on this basis because they're like, "Oh, the Amazon fires are burning." And it was all on the basis of a fake photo that Macron had tweeted out, which turned out to be a photo taken by photojournalists who died years ago. It was from some stock. There was a timestamp that showed that photo existed many years ago. So it wasn't of a current event.
Is that amazing? That's something where etiology – cryptographic. Why? Because you load the website, you see that it's HTTPS, that means there's actually a cryptographic authentication that it's Getty Images or wherever it was. It was at some stock photo thing. We could see the old timestamp. You might hit archive.is. So you have implicit cryptographic verification of the timestamp of that image that was going to be used to cause a war.
That's a concrete example of why control over truth is so important to them. Why did they put up the billboards there? Because once you determine what is true and false – did Russia collude with Trump? No, it's all fake. It took a massive court process to adjudicate that. And fortunately, the court system wasn't corrupted enough that that went through. But the *New York Times* collected all these Pulitzers for basically false information.
One way that's interesting though, and this actually helps give some insight into it. There's a tech person who's a lib, who I won't name, but during the whole Russiagate thing said, "Oh yeah, I know this is just as good as *Game of Thrones* or something." And I realized, oh wow. Remember that Paul Graham thing about the movies? These people were treating this as if it was an entertainment show with Trump as a villain with the *Times* or with legacy media. And this is a very obvious thing to say, but it was obvious in the past. You can predict what they're going to say about somebody before they say it. They have very low information content on each thing.
Erik Torenberg
It's Trump bad, blue America good. And it's like a cast of characters, almost like Seinfeld, where the same cast of characters, the good guy and bad guy appears on the page and you can just auto do it, right?
Balaji Srinivasan
In fact, did I show you the robo journo from three years ago? I'm trying to remember. Oh yeah. So this was a bounty. I just put up a prize where as soon as AI came out, and we can do a lot more with this, by the way, but I'll show you this. So I put out a call to use AI to generate NYT tier clickbait from tweets.
Erik Torenberg
Remember my thing?
Balaji Srinivasan
See, at first I put up, yeah, I put up the theory. It was amazing. Yeah, the theoretical article was in 2020, where I'm like, you know what, we could have a feed of data, and all of these journals are just a wrapper around that feed. And the reason I knew GPT-3 might get there is there's a company called Narrative Science, actually. Have you ever seen them?
Erik Torenberg
No.
Balaji Srinivasan
So Narrative Science, it went bust. It was a good company, just a little too early. So this was a few years before the ChatGPT moment. And Narrative Science, what it did, which at the time was really cool, is it took your financial reports and it would say, "Revenue is high in the Northeastern segment, 65K, 40K." So it would basically generate a narrative from your raw data. So it was like a readable narrative. Make sense?
Erik Torenberg
Yep.
Balaji Srinivasan
So because I saw that, I knew that it was probably possible as this technology advanced to take raw feeds of data and summarize them in essentially story form. Right? With me so far?
Erik Torenberg
Yep.
Balaji Srinivasan
Okay. So that was the theory in 2020. And then the practice by 2022 was once ChatGPT came out, I put out a call to use AI to generate NYT tier clickbait from tweets. One brave engineer answered the call, a student who learned how to code on Replit, started to state it. His app takes a tweet, generates an article. It's already in the ballpark. And you can see from this video, the GPT Times, right? You see this, right?
Erik Torenberg
Yep.
Balaji Srinivasan
Okay. See, let me just rewind this. So here it takes the Elon thing, right? Elon tweet. It goes here. Paste it in. It churns a little bit. It calculates. He's showing all the other articles he generated with the aesthetics. It looks like NYT, right?
Erik Torenberg
Yeah, so good. Oh, my God.
Balaji Srinivasan
All right. This was three years ago. We can do so much more with this. All right. Now, boom, "Putting the cocaine back in Coca-Cola." And look, it looks exactly like NYT clickbait, right? No journo, only robo. No journo, only crypto. Because we can also have these be, look, see, there's a code and so on and so forth. There's a saying system administrators have: "Be careful, I'll replace you with a very tiny shell script." We can just automate, right? Automate and completely obviate.
And the thing is, actually, all the journos have these unions where they're against AI. They're against AI, they're against AI. This is, by the way, similar to the U.S. imposing tariffs or Red America imposing tariffs on China. It's like Blue America imposing tariffs on AI. I don't think it's going to work. But basically, Blue America imposing tariffs on AI is a protectionist, late-breaking thing where they think, "Okay, we can protect our revenue from this, and there won't be any AI-based disruptors of us." But there will be, and they're going to be internet first because there's a lot of English speakers online, and most of them don't live in the U.S., so there's a lot of talent online.
And one piece of this is what I just showed. And the crucial thing about that is those stories there can have all the backlinks and citations, right? So they show the raw tweets that are underpinning it. And if you click, you can just change the style. I want this conservative. I want this liberal. I want this. You essentially have now turned all of the massaging and Russell conjugation. Russell conjugation is "you're doing a bad thing, but I'm doing a good thing." Like Zuckerberg has another great one. They attack Zuck for having dual class stock, just to show you how evil these guys are. "You can't fire Mark Zuckerberg's kids. That's the problem with tech companies using dual class stock schemes." So it's all like "presidents are not kings," right?
So now this, maybe you'd believe this argument on its own. But the next day, what do they do? Or the previous article, it's like how Punch protected the Times, right? So here, the solution was to give that. So dual class is good when they do it, and it's bad when tech does it. Now, the thing is, you have to have a long context window. Like I have a long context window because I remember this article from 2012 and I remember this one from 2019. So you have to have a long context window. And until recently, I didn't know how to show somebody else to find all these internal contradictions. But guess what? AI can do that. AI can find every internal contradiction in NYT ever. And so you could just have them, NYT versus NYT. They're enslaving people and then they're pretending they're on the set. There's just so many things like that, right? The Ukraine pro and con, right?
Erik Torenberg
Right.
Balaji Srinivasan
Okay, so coming back to your point, we need to have a stronger form of truth. Because if we don't have that, you're essentially accepting their premise that this event happened, right?
Erik Torenberg
Right. The crypto stuff I buy, but even before that, we haven't been able to build commentary, but we haven't had enough sort of pro-tech reporters. So the ecosystem had to be there, right? The ecosystem had to be there. Things had to work. Block space had to get there. AI had to get there. Like we needed to feel clear for what we're going to do, which is decentralized cryptographic truth, right?
Balaji Srinivasan
Decentralized cryptographic truth where it's free, it's verifiable on your computer. That's the thing about the Bitcoin blockchain. You can verify it. Now, one of the things I should be more clear about exactly what I mean by truth or whatever. When a statement is posted on chain, what you can verify is the metadata. You can say, it's very hard to falsify the time at which this was posted. It's very hard to falsify the hash because of properties of cryptographic hashes. And it's very hard to falsify the digital signature of what entity posted it. Each of those three things has certain cryptographic guarantees that I can get into why they're hard, but they're hard to falsify.
That doesn't mean that it couldn't be an AI image that you posted on chain, but it would have been hard to five years later to say that AI image never existed before when I can see proof. The Brazilian fires photo is a great example of that. Another example: in a Chinese court, actually, blockchain evidence was used to show that someone had a patent that was invalid because somebody had posted something very similar to it many years ago. So you could use the hash to show they had priority. Does that make sense?
Erik Torenberg
Right.
Balaji Srinivasan
So there's enough stuff that we've done in crypto with proof of location, proof of this, proof of that, proof of solvency. There's many kinds of attestations and proofs that you can put on chain that are pretty hard to fake. That is a fundamentally new set of primitives that journos aren't equipped to deal with because we're talking about math. And they can't do math. They're anti-selective. They could do math, they'd be in tech usually, right? But math is a universal property of humans. You don't need a subscription to the New York Times to do math. I don't need to pay Sulzberger to do math. Someone in India, someone in the Philippines, someone in the South, someone in the North, wherever you can do math. You don't have to subscribe here for the truth. Like the truth is actually everybody's thing. Everybody should have access to the truth. You shouldn't have to pay the Sulzbergers for the truth. And in fact, I refuse to pay the Sulzbergers for the truth. I don't allow them to centrally determine what truth is. That's exactly the same thing as Pravda and the Soviet Union.
So it gets to a very fundamental thing where tech guys are sensing there's something here, but ultimately the network has to supplant the state as the form of truth. That's what Bitcoin represents, the truth machine. And it gives a set of primitives, as I mentioned, the who, the what, the when, and then with other things, we can send that to the where, that we can actually have a feed of facts.
Erik Torenberg
One way of thinking about it, right? Imagine you have a bunch of checks, community notes, but a bunch of check marks at the bottom, like a continuous integration with GitHub, where you have a bunch of checks, green or red, if the site is deploying properly. You have a bunch of assertions on it. Think of it as Trugal. It's like Google, but for truths. And you just run every assert and all these models are saying whether something is true or not. And there's some computation there, but if it's valuable enough, I should put out a prize just for this, by the way. You know what? Actually, at ns.com, I'll put out a prize. Go to ns.com for a session to earn. Actually, we'll put that up on screen. I'll send that link to you right after this. I'll put out a prize for decentralized cryptographic truth on Farcaster, where essentially you can maybe pay a little bit of crypto for model evaluations to just fact check something. It's sort of like what Grok does, but I think a better way of doing it is have multiple models do it, give the premises, give the backlinks and so on and so forth. And then eventually those things should be on chain where it links to.
And by the way, you know who agrees with me so much on this is Solana, where he's like, needs to do more reporting, not just commentary. And a good version of that is Nick Carter's work on Operation Chokepoint, right? That's great. So that's a great example of something which is reporting and not just summary, not just commentary.
Another example of this, and what's interesting, by the way, is notice that our first party testimony, see, when we give first party testimony, in aggregate, that's actually reporting. So we're doing things like, you know how someone who has raw talent in basketball or football can do things and they don't necessarily have great form, but they can just somehow get it done with raw athletic talent. There's a lot of things we're doing that are good, that are done on raw intuition. Because when you have a bunch of people who are posting on X and not talking to journalists, then the quotes get pulled because people would use to say, "I'm canceling my subscription."
And that was always fake and stupid, because who cares? They've got a million subscribers. That doesn't do anything really, except on Moss. See, they can get another subscriber, but they can't get another quoter. They can't get another supplier of quotes. Because there's only one A, six, and Z. There's only one Elon. What is Elon when you email like PR or Tesla or something? He just replies back with a poop emoji. What do you reply back to the Washington Post? He's like, "Send my regards to your puppet master." Because he knows. He knows that basically they won't criticize their boss, only yours.
So we did this thing intuitively by freezing them out of quotes, not talking to them and posting the stuff ourselves. Now they're just reduced to bloggers. Now they're not sourced. See, that's another thing, by the way. Like, an important concept is, how do the good journalists operate? You'll see some of them, they are almost like a CIA station chief. They'll post on their Twitter for tips, email, you know, message me at Signal this, that, and the other. They're literally saying, it's like a CIA bureau chief who set up their office there in this country, and some weak country can't do anything about that. It's like a KGB officer who's there in the country, and they can't be deported or whatever because they have embassy rights. So they're like spying on Facebook. They're spying on Meta. They're trying to solicit leaks. And why do people leak at these companies? It's for the same reasons. I think it's like M-I-C-E. You know what that is in the CIA? Money, ideology, compromise, and ego.
So why do people leak to journos? Why do people talk to journos? Sometimes it's money where there's, for example, at Uber, like the VCs there wanted money and Travis didn't want to sell or IPO, so that's why they did it in part. Ideology, why? Because sometimes they're far left within an organization and they want to attack that organization. Compromise, well, that's interesting. That's often, sometimes the journo will have something on somebody and they'll say, "I won't print this if you give something else." That's not an economic transaction, but that's a very dastardly thing. So it's like, yeah, don't talk to journos.
What happens is the NYT or WaPo or whatever, they'll message you and they'll put on their nicest kind of thing. They're taught to flatter and sympathize in the email. You know what it's exactly like? Our SDRs, our sales development guys, our sales guys. They send out emails that are really crafted, cold email, blah, blah, blah things, to make the sale. And it's a completely calculated thing. Go and look at, I don't know, Mark Craney stuff on sales. If you need a filter and analogy to understand the journos, the journos are sending you sales emails. The difference is they're scam sales emails.
It's like a Nigerian or whatever. It's like a scammer email. So at least when we're doing enterprise sales, maybe it's an aggressive sale at times or whatever, but the product has to work. They can cancel subscription or whatever. It's not, "Ha, you bought the product. Now we got malware on your property. You're going to destroy your company." That's actually what the journal sales email is like. So there's an analogy you can only go so far.
And the point being that the ego part, M-I-C-E, just like the CIA, the bureau chief, people will do it to get their name in the press. They'll do it because they think, "Oh, it'll work for me. I'll be the one. I can charm them." Everybody has to learn this lesson somehow.
I do want to call out that there are some, you know, we named some of them, but there's some other new media folks who are Substackers, et cetera, who are doing journalism, but are not the same journal.
Balaji Srinivasan
Okay, okay, so all right. So now let me get to a very, very, very important point. Many words have been corrupted in a certain way. So when I say journalism, I mean blue journalism. Because if you were to ask some journo, "Is Ben Shapiro a journalist?" They'd say, "No, of course not." If you ask them, "Is Nate Silver still a journalist? Is Glenn Greenwald still a journalist?"
Erik Torenberg
Barry Weiss.
Balaji Srinivasan
Yeah. No, they're just running a blog. Obviously, NYT is Silver's blog. In the same way Free Press is Barry Weiss's outlet. So this is a very important point. Let's say that Zuck competes with TikTok. Zuck would never say TikTok's not doing technology.
Erik Torenberg
Right.
Balaji Srinivasan
Yeah. That's Chinese technology versus American technology, but they're still recognizing they're playing the same sport. You might say they're like, it's under the Communist Party surveillance, whatever. You can make all those points and argue all that. And Trump is flipped on whatever. Leaving that aside, the point is that you wouldn't say they're not doing technology just because they're adversarial. They are doing technology. They're just doing it on the Chinese side.
Erik Torenberg
Right.
Balaji Srinivasan
Versus the blue journalist will actually deny that Substack is journalism, that Ben Shapiro is journalism. Because even if Ben Shapiro has millions more followers than they do and a much larger audience and so on and so forth, even if he's smarter than they are in many ways and like a better company, certainly he's better than their opinion editors and so on. And the Substackers are doing original reporting. What they say, when they say journalism, they mean he's not in the club.
So remember the social network thing with the blue and the red? Once you think about it as a network, where the borders are fuzzy, but no less real for being fuzzy. A network of blues. So like Glenn Greenwald is on the boundary of that. Seymour Hersh maybe arguably is on the boundary because on Substack and so forth. Like Barry Weiss arguably is on the boundary in some ways because she was formerly in the club and so forth. So it's a little bit like being an MD or a JD where you have a formal state license. To be a blue journo is to have an informal state license. Why is it informal? Because if they were formally state licensed, they could say that it's a state-controlled press.
Erik Torenberg
Yeah.
Balaji Srinivasan
So instead, what they get is a White House press pass. It's a press-controlled state. The point about that is that once you see that it's a network, it's a club, that's when you realize, oh, don't talk to blue journalists is actually really what I'm saying.
Erik Torenberg
Yeah.
Balaji Srinivasan
And when I say tech journalist doesn't count either, which is tech journalists, like TechCrunch is on, that word has been. The problem is words have been tortured to mean the opposite of what they mean.
Erik Torenberg
Yeah, it's anti-tech journalists. Like science.
Balaji Srinivasan
Yeah, it's anti-tech journalists, right? Exactly. Like science got tortured to mean masks don't work before they do. So you actually have to have some prefix or something, which is like science in the form of independent replication, not procedure citation.
Erik Torenberg
We're trying to coin new media, something new. That's right.
Balaji Srinivasan
And another example of this is democracy. Like for the Democrats, it means California is a one-party state. Here, let me show you this just to show you. So Democrats and communists have both built one-party states. So here is Newsom taking lessons from Xi, and he's explaining how— This is an amazing visual, right? Where total Democrat Party control. Democrats and communists have both built one-party states. This is more than just a one-liner. It's a deep point. Just like when they said science and they turned it into the opposite of science, which was masks don't work before they do. Just like they said media or they said journalism and they turned it into opposite journalism, which is basically, it's not neutral reporting on anything.
It's reporting on the enemies of blues and protecting blues. Here, they turned democracy into opposite democracy where they destroyed competitive multi-party elections. In California, elections are held, but the party always wins. Exactly like China. Democrats destroyed democracy in California. Deep point. This is why things got so bad there. Because with no Republican check, with no multi-party competition, this is when the California train of $100 billion, this is when the graft really got underway, the homeless industrial complex explosion, because there was no accountability at government level for all the Democrat abuses.
They built a one-party state and started looting it, just like the communists did, but I repeat myself.
When a Republican is elected, that's a threat to democracy. But when a Democrat surveils or sanctions or deplatforms or unbanks, that's just democracy. Now, the thing is, to be fair, it is true that many Republicans in response to this have started to build Florida, especially, into their own one-party states. So the problem is that you have Democrats, Republicans, and communists that have all created basically one-party states where the only democracy then is going to be the right to exit. To vote with your feet.
Erik Torenberg
Go ahead.
Balaji Srinivasan
That's the perfect place to wrap this episode in terms of it gets to the network state. The network state. Now you can vote with your feet and go to California or go to Florida or go to wherever.
Erik Torenberg
That's right.
Balaji Srinivasan
And we want to combine these because Starbase shows that you can combine all threes. And I'll end with just two things. So essentially, this is a really important point. We reclaim free speech. We need to reclaim democracy. We cannot give up on democracy. Democracy is actually, first of all, that's an important interpretation where I just said it was not an abundance, but a deficit of democracy that resulted in California's downfall because the Democrats built a one-party state, destroyed all multi-party competition, they gerrymandered it, and that's how they started all the looting, the hundreds of billions of dollars in looting.
But we can have a rebirth of democracy, and maybe we can do our next talk. Democracy is creating startup cities. Why? They voted, people voted with their feet to move to Starbase. They voted with their wallet to build up Starbase. And then finally, they incorporated Starbase by voting with their ballot. That's the future of democracy. Not a two-party system with the illusion of choice, but a thousand-city system with the reality of choice. 97% for Elon, right? This is essentially a precursor to what's coming next, where you vote with your feet, your wallet, and your ballot at the same time. And that's the only way that you can vote against the Democrats or the communists.
The only remaining vote is that vote. That's where the true vote is. And what we need to do is reduce the barrier to exit to give everybody that practical franchise. Reduce lock-in, make it possible for people to actually have choice over the government that rules them.
And this is also, of course, basically we need to become the largest funders in the world of media, of democracy, of science. And we actually mean it in the uncorrupted versions because I actually do believe in those things unironically. I do believe in media, in books, in writing, and all this kind of stuff. As I said, remember, we're a fork of the East Coast.
Erik Torenberg
Yeah.
Balaji Srinivasan
We're a fork of that assessment. So we basically, with technology, we can have a new birth of media, science, democracy, equality on the internet, because that's what the internet is. It's a peer-to-peer network. We're all equal on the internet. And truth is everybody's property. It is not Sulzberger's property. It's cryptography.
Erik Torenberg
That's a great place to wrap. Balaji, always a pleasure. Thank you so much for coming on the podcast.
Balaji Srinivasan
Thanks.
End of interview
Announcer
Thanks for listening to the a16z podcast. If you enjoyed the episode, let us know by leaving a review at rate this podcast dot com slash a16z. We've got more great conversations coming your way. See you next time.