Podcast Episode Summary
The podcast episode features a conversation between Chris Dixon, a founding general partner at A16Z Crypto, and Kevin Rose, the co-founder of Proof Collective and co-founder of Digg. The conversation covers various topics related to Web3, including NFTs, art, AI, and the evolving role of modding, copying, and copyrights on the internet.
Key Points:
Takeaways:
Participants:
Host: Sonal Choksi, host of Web3 with A16Z.
This week, we have a special episode for you, from our newest podcast, "web3 with a16z" . This episode features Chris Dixon – founding general partner of a16z crypto and former entrepreneur himself – and Kevin Rose – the co-founder of Proof Collective, as well as co-founder of Digg, former investor at GV, and longtime entrepreneur and podcaster.
In this wide-ranging hallway-style conversation from web3 with a16z, these two veterans of both web2 and web3 movements go long on tech trends both in web3 and beyond, including NFTs and art; AI; the evolving roles of modding, copying, and copyrights on the internet; tech’s expansion from Silicon Valley to LA and New York; and more. Their discussion is not just a journey through time (long cycles of computing, web2 to web3) and place (LA, SF, NYC), but into "the age of wonders". Are we at the end of (computing) history, or the beginning?
For more on the latest in web3 trends, be sure to subscribe to our podcast “web3 with a16z” (which is hosted by Sonal Choksi, the longtime former showrunner of this show) wherever you listen to your pods.
Stay Updated:
Find a16z on X
Find a16z on LinkedIn
Listen to the a16z Podcast on Spotify
Listen to the a16z Podcast on Apple Podcasts
Follow our host: https://twitter.com/eriktorenberg
Please note that the content here is for informational purposes only; should NOT be taken as legal, business, tax, or investment advice or be used to evaluate any investment or security; and is not directed at any investors or potential investors in any a16z fund. a16z and its affiliates may maintain investments in the companies discussed. For more details please see a16z.com/disclosures.
Hosted by Simplecast, an AdsWizz company. See pcm.adswizz.com for information about our collection and use of personal data for advertising.
Sonal Choksi
This week, we have a special brand new episode for you, courtesy of our newest podcast, Web3 with A16Z, which is hosted by Sonal Choksi, the longtime former showrunner of this podcast. In this wide-ranging hallway-style conversation from Web3 with A16Z, Chris Dixon, founding general partner of A16Z Crypto and former entrepreneur himself, sits down with Kevin Rose, the co-founder of Proof Collective, as well as co-founder of Digg, former investor at GV, and longtime entrepreneur and podcaster. They talk about how, as veterans of Web2, they've come to the Web3 movement and dig into tech trends both in Web3 and beyond, including NFTs and art, AI, the evolving role of modding, copying, and copyrights on the internet, tech's expansion from Silicon Valley to LA and New York, and more. We hope you enjoy this episode. And if you want more on the latest in Web3 trends, be sure to subscribe to our podcast, Web3 with A16Z, wherever you listen to your pods.
Welcome to Web3 with A16Z, a show about building the next generation of the internet from the team at A16Z Crypto. That includes me, your host, Sonal, and also our occasional co-host, Chris Dixon. This week, we were both in Los Angeles where we recorded some more episodes coming your way, including this all new episode, which is a hallway style tour through hot topics involving yet also going beyond crypto, such as art, AI, the evolution of mediums, including blockchains, quantum computing, and other areas. Our guests also do a deep dive on NFTs, communities, debates around CCO and licensing, copyrights on the internet, artists' royalties and more, plus discuss the role of brands.
They also discuss computing cycles and technology, recent past tech history, and the transition from building in Web 2 to Web 3, as both of today's guests were observers and builders through both movements. So we have Chris Dixon, founding general partner at A16Z Crypto and former entrepreneur, in conversation with Kevin Rose, who, among many other things, co-founded the social news site Digg in the early 2000s and is now co-founder of Proof Collective, which launched Moonbirds PFPs and UDAO recently and more. As a reminder, none of the following is investment, business, legal, or tax advice, nor is it directed at any investors or potential investors in any A16Z fund.
Also, please note that any A16Z investments and portfolio companies mentioned are not representative of all A16Z investments. You can see a16z.com slash disclosures for more important information, including a link to a list of our investments. So with that, the conversation begins for the first 10 minutes with how Kevin got to Web3, as well as a setting of Los Angeles since we recorded this in our LA office.
Great. Welcome to this week's edition of Web3 with A16Z. Thanks for being here, Kevin.
Kevin Rose
Yeah, it's great to be here. I'm glad we're doing this in person, too. We're in LA. It's nice.
Chris Dixon
I know. It's nice. It's good. It's good. And you just moved here recently.
Kevin Rose
Yeah, just a couple weeks ago. There's just so much going on in LA right now.
Chris Dixon
Yeah. It's crazy how many founders I hear and talk to that are actually leaving the Bay Area. Or when they're starting something new, they're like, "I'm going to do it in LA first," which is really sad to see happening, but I get the reasons why. I mean, Bay Area was my home.
Kevin Rose
You were there for a decade plus?
Chris Dixon
2000 to 2013. So it was a good chunk. I used to visit a lot from New York, but then I moved in 2013 and now I'm pretty much mostly like New York and LA. I find that those have a more diverse, creative set of people. My kind of pet theory on it is that the Bay went from the pirates to becoming the Navy. It won. And there's sort of Google and Facebook. I find the Web3 thing is a great example where I find much more positive energy towards it in LA and New York than I do in the Bay Area.
Kevin Rose
Yeah, it seems like with such a tech geeky focal point for the Bay Area, once that was won, it was like, "Okay, what other industries are going to be reinvented?" And a lot of them aren't there, right? So it makes sense that media and everything else we all kind of tease is down here. So as the tech gets deployed more deeply in the world, it spreads.
Chris Dixon
I also think, and I had never spent much time in LA before, but the sense I get is it used to be a very kind of monoculture, you know, Hollywood. And at least anecdotally, as you said, a lot of tech people I know who moved here, it just seems like it's much more diverse, similar to New York. I think New York also, my theory is it used to be so dominated by Wall Street and it kind of declined. And it just has many different interesting industries, including tech. It's gotten pretty good in New York.
Kevin Rose
Yeah. I mean, I love that about LA. I remember, do you remember when it was like, "Okay, Snapchat—" oh, no, it was MySpace. MySpace is down there. Like, "Okay, well, it's that one little rogue tech company that's down there." And there were a few little smaller things.
Chris Dixon
Well, and then Facebook crushed them, which was sort of the Silicon Valley narrative. Like once the real tech people came.
Kevin Rose
Right. Exactly. And then we had the same thing with Snapchat being down here. But for some reason, just NFTs and media and a bunch of startups are deciding that the Bay Area, the high rent prices, a lot of the politics that are out there and all of that, they want a little bit more room to breathe and places to raise a family. And LA has a lot of that.
Chris Dixon
Yeah, I used to always think of LA, like 10 years ago, LA startups were kind of like MySpace. Like, maybe they understood culture, but they didn't build a great product. They didn't build great tech. A lot of influencer, you'd always hear these influencer pitches, a celebrity involved, but then the product would be really janky or something.
Kevin Rose
Yeah, it's right. Because I remember when, I think it was MySpace that was built on ASP, like Microsoft ASP or whatever. And I remember just being like, "Of course it is." It's funny. So it's definitely changed. I think it's also, as you said, the tech has just matured. You can almost just off the shelf build a good website now. So it just doesn't matter. It doesn't differentiate you the way it did a decade ago.
Chris Dixon
Cool. So you and I, I think, are some of the few Web2 people that are also into Web3 and crypto. I'd love to hear just more about how you got into that.
Kevin Rose
Yeah. Well, I was dabbling in crypto way back in the day, like everyone else. The same classic story of I forgot my wallet. You can look back at those old tweets and you were like how you were buying it sub $100. And of course, it hit $300 and everyone sells. And it's the same story. So that was a lot of fun. That led me to meme coins, like Dogecoin, which I was a pretty active participant in what was going on there.
Chris Dixon
From the beginning?
Kevin Rose
Close to the beginning. So I became friends with the team over there. And I really loved what was going on socially, like the tipping aspect of it, the kind of charity side of things. It was just a fun experiment. All the bots that were created to facilitate tipping. It was performant at the time. There was a lot to love with that culture that was being built. So I always paid attention. When I was at Google Ventures, I led some of our crypto deals. But I always stayed close to what was going on. I saw with my Web2 hat on, I'm like, "There's no way this is going to become mass adopted by consumers in terms of does it pass the 'my mom can send me crypto easily' test." So the user experience wasn't there.
Chris Dixon
The user experience was not there. I mean, to have to copy and paste these massive long wallet addresses. And a lot of the rough edges that need to be sanded down. And quite frankly, a lot of those still exist today.
Kevin Rose
So just curious. But then this Web3 thing started to take root. And I would say DeFi really brought me in. Just rewriting the entire financial stack was really interesting to make it more efficient. So that was the first use case where I was like, "Aha, okay, it's more than just speculation. There's actually real products that are being built here."
Chris Dixon
So this is kind of like the DeFi summer period? Like 2020, Uniswap, Compound, DAI?
Kevin Rose
Exactly. So I just started playing around with all of those and trying out a lot of the crazy degen stuff that was out there and losing some money and just kicking the tires on a bunch of different things. And then I was lucky in that I had minted some of the early CryptoPunks. And it was just like, my buddy was like, "Hey, these are things called CryptoPunks. They're NFTs," or I don't even know if they were calling them NFTs at that point. But it was like, "These little things you can mint on the blockchain." I was like, "Okay, cool. Let me get 10 of them or whatever." So I did that and immediately forgot about it. It was in a wallet called Parity, which was not using the standard mnemonic phrases for restore. So I lost them. Eventually was able to reclaim them. It was a nightmare to get them back. But that was my first introduction to NFTs. Started doing a podcast about crypto during DeFi summer, because that's the way I learn. Having great founders on, I can just pick their brain and it gives me an excuse to sit down one-on-one and really have on all these great people that were building a whole slew of the top projects at the time.
Then NFTs, I had heard about Art Blocks a couple of years back. And I was like, "This is interesting because it's capturing a new form of art, this idea of generative art being captured for the first time." And I've always been kind of a fan of art in general. And I'd seen some generative art displays before the blockchain where you'd go in, you see a computer hooked up, you see something cool on a screen. Some people would buy them, they'd break down, the artist would have to come out and do some repairs or whatever to make these things work long term. So generative art, I believe, has really found its home on the blockchain, largely because traditionally, this was something that required a ton of maintenance and setup. And they were beautiful. You'd see these great interactive displays and all kinds of fun things could be done with them. But it was...
Chris Dixon
We had one in the office once, but it's a really expensive setup.
Kevin Rose
Really expensive. It breaks down. Then you're like, "Okay, how much is it worth? Is the artist still alive? Are they going to come repair it? What's going to happen?" And there's two levers here. One, anyone can create. So it's a universal, P5JS, what they're using for the majority of it. It's a language that anyone can pick up in like a half hour. I was creating some really fun stuff with P5. And then a standardized platform for publishing it. And I was like, "Whoa, this is being captured and solidified into the blockchain for the first time. It's not resource dependent. You don't need to have a special set of hardware, external hardware to make this happen.
You can just display them on your computer." And then lastly, it's this awesome little, like it or not, it's a pull of the slot machine. So people love that idea that when I pull the slot machine handle and I click "Mint," there's that surprise and delight that comes with the reveal. So all those things coming together, great art along with a little surprise and delight. And also just some old school generative artists that have been doing this forever finally came on board and said, "I'm going to start producing really interesting art that you can look back and say, they've had amazing generative careers for the last 20 plus years.
And now they're doing this cemented in the blockchain, proven provenance and scarcity around this drop and all the things that you want out of an NFT." And now it's collectible. And it was clear to me that you see a bunch of other great platforms that emerged where they were doing really creative things that were creating a new medium for art. Artwork can be manipulated based on time of day, stock price, external oracles. It was clear that this was going to be a real durable thing over the long term.
Chris Dixon
Right.
Kevin Rose
And so in seeing that, I was like, "Okay, well let's do another podcast about that and have a lot of these great founders on." So I had all my favorite artists on those first few episodes and started collecting and just saying, "Okay, I'm just going to start buying some of this stuff." Built up a pretty decent portfolio there. And at the time I was at True Ventures. And so I was like, "We need to start backing some of these companies." And so that led us to, I led the round at Art Blocks and Quantum Art. And we probably did another five or six NFT specific investments, some that were fractionalizing art, just some really interesting things there.
And then I was like, "Well, gosh, I'm watching all these people doing really creative things. I'm an entrepreneur. There's a lot of blue ocean here, which you can't say the same for anything else that was going on prior to that. Let's go build. Let's just go and spend a little bit of time." And so my partners at True were like, "Okay, yeah, I mean, this is you. Why don't you go and spend a little bit of time building?" And so that led me to the creation of the Proof Collective Pass. And then that exploded. We sold out immediately. It was a Dutch auction. And that led to eventually Moonbirds and kind of where we are today.
Chris Dixon
Nice. Just curious, when you personally buy an NFT, I kind of think of buying an NFT as a mixture of different motives. So there's the collecting motive. There may be a financial motive, like you think it's going to go up. There's a social aspect to it. You're joining a community. Maybe you're interacting with the artists themselves. Maybe there's a patronage aspect to it. And it's funny because I hear these skeptics, like "You're not really buying the copyright." Of course, that's the same with physical art. You don't get the copyright when you buy it. You're buying a physical thing. And I'll just say for myself, I never was interested in physical art. NFTs seemed obviously much more interesting, and I feel an emotional connection to them. So we're investors in Foundation, which is an artsy kind of NFT site. And I, early on, a couple of years ago, bought a bunch of NFTs there. And what I found, it was sort of the patronage aspect was interesting. I was DMing with the artists. I work in venture capital. I don't normally talk to artists. You and I went to an NFT event a few months ago, and there were all these NFT artists. Again, it's a different experience for me. It's fun for me.
Kevin Rose
Yeah, it's really refreshing, actually. And it's a way to be supportive in an organic way that doesn't feel transactional. Like I'm buying your art. I'm not making a donation. I'm supporting you the way you want me to.
Chris Dixon
So anyways, that's a long-winded way of saying, I'm curious, what was your kind of feeling when you started collecting and buying these NFTs?
Kevin Rose
Well, I think there's a handful of checkboxes that I look for when I want to collect a piece. First is, am I visually attracted to it? Because there are a lot of friends and flippers and people that just get in for a quick return. And they're just sort of like, "The meme is trending."
Chris Dixon
Yeah, the meme is trending. I'm going to jump in and in 48 hours, whatever, two weeks I'm out.
Kevin Rose
Yeah, exactly. Whereas you're sort of buying it for the decades to come. And the reason I have to be attracted to it is because in a down market, if that thing's chopped in half or by three quarters, I'll still hold onto it because I think it's beautiful. So that's an easy one. I'm drawn into the art. I love it. The second piece is who is the artist behind it. I want them to have one of two spectrums. They either have to be a great promoter in that they have to have the right Twitter presence and carry themselves well on Twitter, or they have to be just weird as shit and just be on the other end of the spectrum, like an XCOPY that doesn't talk to anybody, that tweets out weird stuff. So they have a myth around them or something based on their security.
Chris Dixon
The XCOPY thing is funny because if you DM with him, and you're a collector, he'll get back and he'll chat with you a little bit. And then sometimes you'll ask him a question and he won't get back to me for like three or four weeks. And I'm like, "Ooh, I love that." Like he's setting the hook even deeper. He doesn't care about money. He's super mysterious.
Kevin Rose
So there's something cool about that. The other piece is how often are they releasing new pieces? Are they a machine that's just going to flood the market? Or do they have a great paced cadence about them to where they're thinking about this over the long term? They're not just in it for the quick buck and they're not just doing anything and everything for anyone. So that's another big piece. A couple more pieces. I look at what other prominent tastemakers in the space are collecting that artist. So is there the cosmos of the world? There's probably a dozen or so really well-respected collectors.
I look at their wallets and say, "Are they also collecting this artist?" And then I'll have conversations if they're not and say, "Hey, what do you think of this artist?" And then the last piece of it is, are they doing something new and exciting and novel, or is it just iterative type work? And so, XCOPY was really interesting because what I did is I used the Wayback Machine and I went to his Tumblr account and he was doing this genre of glitch art 10 years ago. And that was way prior to any of this being on the blockchain. And there's so many people that have come in and copied that style, but they have no back catalog.
They just are doing it because it's a hot trend to be a glitch artist right now. And so that was something I was really drawn into. Another great example would be Tyler Hobbs with this QQL drop that he did recently. So Tyler Hobbs is probably best known for the Fidenza series. Fantastic entrepreneur, great coder, decided to do a new drop where you as the collector could use the algorithm to generate as many pieces as you want. And he would give you visual tooling, an interface to tweak some of the parameters of the algorithm. So the way I like to describe it is it's that classic bowling alley with the little kid stoppers on the side.
So the ball is still going to hit some pins and it's not going to go in the gutter, but it's going to produce a decent output. And so you as the collector pick that final one and say, "Okay, I'm ready to mint this one." And then you spend the token, you burn it and you actually get that output. It's really cool because you're picking the output, but then there's the extra additional aspect where if you get someone that is also well-known that is creating the output that has additional value on top of that. So other collectors or other artists have joined and said, "This is the one that I'm minting."
Now you get a combo Tyler Hobbs plus another additional artist that picked that piece. So it's a really fun project.
Chris Dixon
I think one interesting thing is that historically, new technology tends to enable new media. And I think one of the mistakes people make is kind of skeuomorphism. So YouTube comes along, and there's sort of two. There's CBS coming and putting whatever TV show they have on YouTube. And then there's the new native YouTubers, which is the new genre, new form of media. And fast forward, it was the YouTube native stuff that became the most significant and most important. I was seeing the other day that Dude Perfect, it's like three guys who mess around. They have more YouTube followers than all the major sports leagues combined.
Kevin Rose
That's crazy.
Chris Dixon
So, like, who would have thought that in 2005? Everyone just sort of had this skeuomorphic, "Oh, it's going to be football." No, it's going to be three people dunking each other that's been watching video games and all these other kinds of new things. And so I wonder with NFTs if a similar thing will happen and things like generative art and whatever else. I'm sure there'll be a million things that I can't think of that people will come up with that are native to the internet and native probably to NFTs as well, to the fact that NFTs have scarcity, are on a blockchain, have smart contracts involved.
Kevin Rose
Proven provenance.
Chris Dixon
Proven provenance. And then the business model. Because you had sort of native internet things like memes or sort of an internet native media form, but you never had a real business model, which should really add a lot of energy and momentum behind that art. Like now you can make a living this way. It's a lot of side projects.
Kevin Rose
Right. And if you can lean into it, what do you do? You could imagine this really interesting kind of creative renaissance.
Chris Dixon
Well, absolutely. Especially because now the artists are kind of going out and deputizing other artists. It's like this cyclical thing where you're seeing the artist pour money right back into the ecosystem.
Kevin Rose
Oh, that's great.
Chris Dixon
Yeah. I think I saw that in some of the stats on some of these sites. I think they were talking about that, that some high percentage of collectors are also artists. Which seems like a really healthy phenomenon.
Kevin Rose
Absolutely.
Chris Dixon
That's interesting. So let's talk about Moonbirds then. So you decide you're going to go fully in. What was sort of the vision?
Kevin Rose
Yeah. So the idea there was that we created this 1,000 member pass with the Proof Collective Pass. The sort of membership in this artist collective collector club. It was like, if you join this collector club, if you hold one of these passes, you get access to the Discord, all the events, private smaller collaborations that we do with artists. So we're leveraging a lot of our artist relationships. And we have our own products around that too with Grails and some of the other things that we created. And we do about a drop a month to the members. So they get some type of interesting new artist or new artwork almost every month.
So that was a real success in attaching utility to membership, this idea of a token-gated community. And we wanted to do that at scale, a larger scale, with a different mandate to go in and create our own PFP. Because frankly, the Proof Collective is a picture of almost like a credit card turned sideways that says "Proof Collective" on it. Nobody wants to rep that as their Twitter icon. So we were like, "Okay, let's just start with an experiment. Let's see what would happen if we created—" we would pick owls because moonbirds are owls and they're these wise, all-seeing, all-knowing animals. And we went in there and launched this.
And to our surprise, it blew our expectations in secondary volume and it just went absolutely nuts. And I think it was largely because we had already delivered a lot of product on the Proof Collective side. And so people knew if we were going to launch this new thing, it wasn't just going to be someone that puts up a roadmap where things don't get hit. But we're actually product builders in the space. And we had a much bigger vision in mind for what this could be.
Chris Dixon
For those who haven't seen it, it's easy to find. But it's kind of pixelated, retro looking.
Kevin Rose
Yeah, more of the 8-bit style, front facing pixelated owls.
Chris Dixon
And how do you think about that and the owls? And is there kind of a lore around it?
Kevin Rose
Yeah, a lot of thought went into it in that we wanted to do a classic 10,000 collection that kind of was pioneered by the CryptoPunks. So the attributes that we designed were specifically built with utility in mind. So different types of attributes will unlock different types of things over time. And one of the things that I wanted to figure out is how you can reward dedication and commitment to a community. And I'd seen a lot of this being done in a whole slew of different ways. One, we're kind of blanket drops to the entire community. And we know that's just a very expensive thing to do. So we introduced another mechanic called nesting.
Chris Dixon
So specifically, what is nesting?
Kevin Rose
Yeah. So once you purchase a Moonbird off the secondary market, you have it in your wallet and it's just sitting there like any other NFT asset. If you go to our website, the Moonbird's website, there's an area that's called nesting. And if you go in there, it shows you once you connect your wallet, the Moonbird's sitting there. You highlight it. You choose, "I'd like to nest it." That disables the transfer function. It still stays in your wallet. You can do a call to the contract to disable it anytime you want, even if our website wasn't up.
Chris Dixon
So this is different than Web 2 and Web 3. The transfer function you're referring to is a smart contract. So the Moonbird is actually a database record, but also a piece of code that exists on the Ethereum blockchain. And so you're actually changing it within the Moonbird itself. This is different conceptually than in Web 2 where you just have the website and the server. You don't have this third thing, the Ethereum blockchain.
Kevin Rose
Right, exactly. So now we have on record when that started. And we can do the math and figure out how long it's been nested for. We can watch for unnesting and re-nesting events. We can watch for it being transferred to different wallets if we want to. There is a transfer function on our website that allows you to transfer from one wallet to another without unnesting it, just so people want to keep their streak, but they're moving to a hardware wallet, things like that. But essentially it's a way to say, "I'm committed to the community, I'm locking this thing up, I'm nested, and now it allows us to enable different nesting tiers and rewards that come with the benefits of locking it up."
So it removes a lot of the supply out of the ecosystem. If you look at just all the top projects, they'll be in the pretty high single-digit amount of available inventory for sale. Ours is, you know, 2% or something like that. So it's quite a bit lower than everyone else. Nesting was a way to say and signal to the world that you're committed to this project over the long term. And so we count down to the second how long it's been nested for. And then you hit different tiers of upgraded nests over time. And then you get different rewards and access based on the tiers that you hit.
Chris Dixon
So it should be proportionate to your kind of time commitment.
Kevin Rose
Exactly. So that's kind of what we're trying to do with the nesting piece of it. And it's worked out quite well. I mean, we threw an event at NFT NYC. And if you had one of the wizard or witch hats on top of your moonbird, you got a private magic show with David Blaine, which was amazing. We had him come and there was like 75 people there and he just blew everyone's minds.
Chris Dixon
Nice. So with respect to NFTs, obviously you're deep in the art space and PFP space. What do you think more broadly, like next five years, like gaming NFTs, redeemable things for physical objects, kind of more traditional collecting? I'm just curious, what else gets you excited around NFTs?
Kevin Rose
Yeah, I think when Instagram drops their minting of NFTs, which is coming soon, that's going to be interesting to see how that plays out. I don't know how they're doing it, but I just worry. Whenever you graft new things on the old, you get weird behavior.
Chris Dixon
No, agreed.
Kevin Rose
But I wonder if there's any depth there. You almost have to forget it's an NFT for a second and think it's a celebrity collectible. They'll sell it in two seconds, especially if there's Apple Pay enabled. I mean, Apple's going to take their 30% cut, which they came out and announced. And I think that's on purpose because they know Instagram's dropping something soon. Would I do Instagram NFTs?
Absolutely not. But I think it unlocks a different generation and a different group of people to NFTs, which I'm excited about because it onboards more users and sets them up with a wallet for the very first time. So that is interesting to me just because it's expanding the pie.
So back to the next five years, I think there's going to be a little bit of a battle around secondary royalties. Some people are starting to sidestep them. This is like the pseudo-swap debate and things.
Chris Dixon
Exactly.
Kevin Rose
Yeah, like there's new marketplaces where you can remove the 5% fees. Just for those who don't know, marketplaces like OpenSea, if you do a secondary transaction, typically five percent of that sale price will go to the original artist. There are new marketplaces that get rid of that feature.
Chris Dixon
Right, exactly.
Kevin Rose
There are a couple ways to approach that. One is that artists are going to fight back, definitely. And there'll be tooling that says yes, you can sidestep us because it's smart contracts and there are ways around it. You could put rappers, you can in theory do it in the smart contract. This is an interesting thing too, and there are reasons people haven't put the royalty in the smart contract, so that you can transfer to your own wallet or to a smart contract system. But I wonder if there might be technical solutions to some of this.
One that I thought was pretty interesting, especially for preexisting collections that have already been minted, is the idea of tracking if things are moving through these networks of no royalties. And if they are, you really can't do anything except the artist can choose not to reward those collections in the future. I think that will start to happen. Also, I believe that with larger mints, additions, things like that, if you're an artist and you're doing a piece of 500 or a larger collection, you'll hold back 20 for yourself or 100 for yourself. And you may have not done that before. But now you have a way to go out and sell those directly on the secondary market.
Chris Dixon
Interesting. Let's talk about CC0. So just to explain, there's a common source of confusion around NFTs. People who don't understand them think you're creating additional scarcity or you're adding a copyright onto something. That's not the case. The mental model I would use is that copyright is a different layer, an independent decision. When you sell an NFT, you're selling a blockchain record, you're selling a proof of ownership. It's in the same way that when you buy a physical painting, you're buying that physical painting, completely separate from the question of whether you own the copyright. Totally separate questions. They don't overlap.
Anyways, there's something called CC0, which is Creative Commons, an organization that standardized a lot of different copyrights. And one thing I want to mention is that we believe that any artist should be able to pick whatever copyright they want. Absolutely, 100%. So this is all about choice. But CC0 is one choice, which says essentially there are no restrictions, that anyone can reproduce this media, create derivative works, sell those derivative works, do anything they want. The image is public domain.
I think – I forgot what license you started Moonbirds on, but you switched it to CC0 a few months ago.
Kevin Rose
Yeah, it was still a restricted license. We could revoke it at any time, but it gave users the commercial rights to go out and monetize. So it's kind of similar to the Bored Apes license.
Chris Dixon
Exactly. That's what we modeled after.
Kevin Rose
And then you went and switched it to CC0.
Chris Dixon
That's right. CC0 Summer really kicked off with a bunch of projects that launched under CC0. I think the hard thing for us is that we stepped on a little bit of a rake in that we announced it without having a conversation with the community first. So I think we could have done a better job on the communication front. Certainly if I had a redo on this announcement, I would have changed a few things.
The thinking there, which got me pretty excited, was that there are two ways as a project, especially as a PFP project. It's all about the game of relevance. One part of it is serving your community. The other is furthering the meme to increase relevance through a whole slew of different things. These can be cultural moments, whether you're the Bored Apes and you put Eminem on stage. They can be through product-driven releases that wow the community. There are a bunch of different ways to stay relevant.
One of the things is that we have finite resources. We have 28 people, and only a handful of them are going out to support ongoing efforts with the community, working on partnerships and all kinds of fun things. But the idea with CC0 is you're saying, okay, if we free up this IP and allow anyone to do anything they want with it, hopefully it will create a lot of derivative projects that have value, that bring more eyeballs on the project and point to that true north, the original project, as being the most important thing, the original asset.
Sometimes people cite the Mona Lisa as an example. You can reproduce the image all you want, and in fact, reproducing it makes it more iconic. And if anything, it increases the value of the original.
Kevin Rose
I mean, this is true of all kind of artwork.
Chris Dixon
Right, exactly.
Kevin Rose
Well, you can go out and buy a very first edition, an early edition, first print of Sherlock Holmes. A major movie studio took it, remade it into a movie because it was public domain. And it increased the value of that original work. It's pointing back to that original piece.
Chris Dixon
This is generally how things work in the physical world. And you and people like you and I and NFT folks assume that we believe that's a similar logic in the digital world. I think it's important to note that this isn't something that everyone should adopt. There are going to be a lot of artists that say, I want to retain the rights to my work. I had a great chat with Eric from Art Blocks about this, the founder, and he was like, "Crummy Squiggles. I don't want to see that being used as a hate symbol or anything else. I want to hold on to this."
Actually, I really got to say, I do like a lot of what you all did at Andreessen around those new licenses that you released. Because I thought that was something we were thinking about. Is there a license that says, "Okay, go do very creative things with this. But no hate speech. And carve out two or three things that certainly no one wants as part of their project and launch it under that license." I wish you had had that license a few weeks before I went out with CC0.
Yeah, just for people that don't know, we put out a thing called the "Can't Be Evil" license. We can link to it. It's on GitHub. The license itself is public domain, so we encourage people to fork it and change it. But we went out and created a standardized set of licenses that would give the creator a choice of different menu options. You could be CC0. You could reserve all the rights. But the goal of the related license is to make it simple and standardized and permanent.
One thing concerned people have had is, "What if I go and build a business on the Moonbird? And what if you then pull the rug under me by saying I can't do it?" So we wanted to come up with a license that would survive M&A and other kinds of things. And then one thing we put in as an option was the revocability over hate speech. Again, it's an option. All of these things are options, just to be clear. The creator should have more options. And I think it's always good to have standardization and clarity for both the creators and the collectors.
Kevin Rose
I mean, obviously, we're all anti-hate speech. But could you have unintentional consequences of these clauses? We'll see how it plays out.
Chris Dixon
Yeah.
Kevin Rose
I like the little matrix you put up there showing all the pros and cons of each one. They were really thoughtfully done. It was funny, XCOPY did a tweet where he said something along the lines of, "All those hate groups out there looking for those CC0 projects." How many hate groups are out there? It would be funny to think that some extremist group out there in the middle of nowhere is like, "Okay, let's check the license. Okay, this one's CC0. Yeah, we're going to go with that one."
Chris Dixon
That's fair. While I'm in the middle of doing all these awful things, I'm going to check the copy of your paper. "Why am I building this nuclear weapon on the side here? Let's check to make sure we're compliant."
Kevin Rose
Fair enough. And like, what is hate? That would be an extreme case. Maybe there's something more disorganized that's not great and they're using this squiggle on the book cover. I don't know. But that's a good point.
Chris Dixon
Yeah, but on the CC0 front, it's a choose your own adventure. You really have to pick it.
Kevin Rose
I think a lot of the stuff that is just straight duplicate, just straight clones. We've seen Moonbirds that are turned the other direction instead of facing the right way, they're facing left. Or Moonbirds with a couple zeros in them or whatever. And those are just like... What was the big CryptoPunk thing where they flipped?
Chris Dixon
Oh yeah, there was another CryptoPunk one.
Kevin Rose
And those are just, we laugh at them and we know that long-term... I mean, the flip side is Doge was a fork of Bitcoin.
Chris Dixon
Right, exactly.
Kevin Rose
And so if you fork it, you've got to add something. It's either technical or cultural. Doge added the cultural twist. Otherwise, it's just spam and it falls away. And I actually don't hate them. If it creates another little mini press cycle and a few people pick it up, God bless. But it's cooler if they do more than just flip it. They actually have their own new set of memes.
Chris Dixon
Well, those are the ones that are going to be durable and lead to bigger and better things, which I think we're pretty excited about. There was this great blog post about how low-fidelity NFTs allow for more derivative creativity. I think of it like, what if you had a Moonbird that interoperated between two different games? We're seeing that happen. 3D Moonbirds are being built. And one of the cool things is because it's low fidelity, because it's pixelated, you can imagine one game embodying it in their art style. It's sort of unopinionated about the art style. Someone else embodies it in a cell-shaded rendering, and someone else in some hyper-realistic rendering. And by making it CC0, you're just saying, "Hey, go back to the games industry, remixing, modding."
I always think about, have you read *Masters of Doom*?
Kevin Rose
No, I haven't.
Chris Dixon
Oh, it's a great book. It's about Carmack and Romero, and they created Doom. They invented multiplayer gaming. But I would actually argue the even cooler thing they did was two other things: shareware gaming and modding. He actually included a C compiler in there to mod it. It was like "ModMe," right? That was revolutionary. And I think of modding. If I go to places like Steam, it's the Wild West, it's creative, it's cool, people are modding. And I think it will be a similar thing here with media. That's what you're encouraging. You're saying CC0, mod me, make games, fork it, make parodies, let the internet do its thing.
Kevin Rose
Right, exactly. And if you're doing it right, most of the mods want to always respect the original. We saw with 3D Moonbirds and some other projects that are creating higher fidelity versions of what we have. They say, "Hey, if you own the original, come and prove it off your wallet and you can get this minted for free or next to nothing." Because why wouldn't you want that community happy? If you're doing something based off of that community, you want to make sure that community is happy, so you always do right by them. It's really accelerating the inevitable. Everything's going CC0 whether we like it or not. It's only a matter of time.
Chris Dixon
The way I think about the internet is a copy machine. It's going to copy stuff. And you can either build a business model that's aligned with that or you can fight it and eventually probably lose. In my mind, video games are at the frontier. They're the one form of media that gets this. As an example, streaming. Nintendo fought it for a long time because they're like, "It's copyrighted. You can't just stream my stuff." And eventually they realized, like everyone in gaming has realized, that the benefit of the increased attention outweighs the copyright infringement.
Kevin Rose
Exactly.
Chris Dixon
And I think it's going to be the same logic for all visual media and probably for music. All forms of media, maybe outside of long-form movies, but all the other kinds of internet-native media forms, I would expect to follow the same logic.
Kevin Rose
You're fighting for attention.
Chris Dixon
Exactly. And there are two alternatives to this model. One is to say, "We're going to hold all the rights back for us, and we're going to go and build our own characters." For us being the company. We're going to build our own characters, our own worlds, our own everything. We'll hold that, and that's how value will accrue to these NFTs. That's very much a Gary Vaynerchuk VeeFriends model where he holds back all the IP. But just today he announced that some of his plushy toys are going to be in Toys "R" Us. So that's one path. And that's not in our core DNA. We're not going to go out and build video games. That's just not who we are.
The other path is to say, "Okay, the users own that, but they then have to figure out how to monetize it on their own." And this idea, I believe it's a flawed one, to think that there are going to be these licensing deals that happen to the individual. The reality is that most people are never going to get any licensing deals, unless you have an ultra rare Bored Ape or something else. Because if you're a big brand and you want to play well with this ecosystem, you go out and buy an NFT because you have the budget. It's what we've seen today. When you see Tiffany's or Budweiser or any of these big brands that play in the world of NFTs, they don't actually license anyone else's IP. They go out and buy one of the NFTs because why would they spend marketing dollars on something that they don't own?
So this is a chance for them to go out. We've already seen and are talking to brands that are okay with it being CC0. They want to go out and they still see the value in buying and holding one of the NFTs because it's theirs and it's provable by the blockchain. The beautiful thing about this is it's actually very Web3 native because it says the source of truth is not the trademark office. It's not a centralized organization. The source of truth of who owns this is looking on the blockchain and saying, "Where does this point to?" That's a pretty powerful thing to think about and embrace.
I find with the Web3 concepts, for a lot of the behaviors, you have to kind of invert things. This is what throws people off. Same with copyright. The copyright is the right to sue. It's a scarcity mentality. And the internet really is much more about this abundance mentality of, "My ownership is not the right to sue. I'm not stopping something. But I am receiving additional things like airdrops, like invitations." I think we're just at the very beginning stages of that.
To give you an example, I think a very common thing that will happen in the future is unrelated parties—a brand, a restaurant, my sports team—will do airdrops to existing NFT communities. Because at some point, that community, the fact that you own that thing is partly you own it, and that's important in and of itself. But partly it's this incredible opt-in data source. It says all these things about you. If I'm not related to Moonbirds, but I'm having an event for early tech adopters in L.A., wouldn't I want to give a free pass to the Moonbirds community as an example?
I also think it's the way the internet should have done ad targeting. The wrong way to do ad targeting, which is where we are today, is all of this surveillance, tracking my phone. The right way to do advertising is let people choose what to make public and then give them offers or awards accordingly.
Kevin Rose
And you can choose your audience. You can say, "Hey, I'm really trying to target women here. Let me go to the World of Women project." There are a bunch of these different projects that have really passionate communities behind them. If that community is about health, we have one subset of Moonbirds from Tokyo. You can go and find out exactly which holders are part of that, what we call the subparliament. "Parliaments" is also a term for a gathering of birds, oddly enough. They've started to create these subparliaments, and you can target them in a non-evil way and provide value back to them.
Chris Dixon
That's cool. There's a lot of talk in the NFT world of creating the next Disney. Do you think at some point there will be a significant media activity around Moonbirds?
Kevin Rose
A lot of it's up to the community. We're definitely not video game producers or filmmakers, but we have a lot of community members that dabble in that world. That's the beauty of the CC0 model. We're saying, "Hey, take these assets, let us support you." That can be via grants from the actual DAO to go out and build on our behalf. A lot of you are probably better at this than we are.
There's another piece where this DAO will be equipped with an NFT treasury as well. It kicked off with 2 million USD worth of ETH. Then we're transferring some of the Moonbirds that we have from our company wallet. They can use those for collaborations, for any way they see fit. It's also a piece of art. If the art increases over time, they could choose to sell it for more ETH to roll funds back into the DAO. We have 35% of ongoing royalties going back into the DAO, so there's continued support and a treasury building.
Chris Dixon
These are the secondary sale royalties.
Kevin Rose
Secondary sales. That's very cool. So you want to make sure it's a bottom-up thing that comes from the community. Maybe you support them with money. We're the scaffolding. We're the structure for it. We're going to continue building the tooling and everything, but we're going to let them do the heavy lifting on that side. That's not to say we're not going to do a ton of things on the BD side. We can go do partnerships with sneaker companies and different big brands and do that all day long. But again, we're leveraging a third party for that, albeit a big brand.
Chris Dixon
I think it's really smart. I think there are things that are well done by a crowd and things that aren't. Maybe someday BD will be well done by a crowd. But today, most of these partners expect a more traditional interface of legal contracts, lunches, all that kind of stuff.
Kevin Rose
Right, exactly. Whereas demand signal seems like a no-brainer that it should come from the crowd. And today, very much of it doesn't. Creative things feel like they should come from the crowd. A big job of ours is we will have someone raise their hand and say, "I'm a 3D animator that does X, Y, and Z. I work on some very big brands. But I lack this skill. I can't do this." So it's connecting those dots, bringing them together in the community and saying, "Okay, now that you're connected, you've brainstormed, you put together a template of what you want to do. Let's go fund you at the DAO level."
Chris Dixon
So yesterday you had an announcement. Can you tell us about that?
Kevin Rose
Yeah. The DAO announcement, it's something we let people know was coming. But DAOs are always really tricky. People either have no idea what they are, or they've interacted in a DAO and it was a really poor experience and it hasn't worked, or they have interacted with some of the best DAOs out there and sing their praises. So you have to do a little bit of education and bring people up to speed on what it's for.
When we launch this DAO, it's not just about "Here, take the keys." It's about "Here's a new seat at the table for you as a community. Here's some funds to go do amazing things. But let us throw on some professional rigor on top of this in terms of project management, in terms of helping you vet the ideas." When we launch our DAO, you'll see if a proposal that's come through has the green light from us. It's not to say if it gets a yellow light or a red light it can't get approved, because ultimately that'll be up to the DAO. But it at least lets them know we've taken a look at it. We've had a conversation directly with the founding team. We think this is a solid idea. We think it has a high likelihood of completion.
It's kind of like the Kickstarter model. We've all backed some stuff that hasn't worked and we've backed some stuff that's been amazing. I have this amazing pepper grinder, by the way, from Kickstarter.
Chris Dixon
You know which one I'm talking about?
Kevin Rose
I don't.
Chris Dixon
Oh, it's... I'm going to send you one. It is the coolest thing I've ever had.
Kevin Rose
Oh, I got to get that. I was a personal angel investor in Kickstarter. I was into it from the early on and still am. I've mostly backed books. You'd like this if you haven't seen it. It's these European designers who have taken all of Newton and Euclid and all these classic books and done them in a cool modern way. It's just stuff that would never exist. What publisher would publish that? But it turns out there are a thousand people on the internet willing to fund it.
The other Kickstarter story is we invested in Oculus. What the community was good at was the demand signal. I wouldn't have known in 2013 that there were that many people excited about VR. But it's very hard for a community because they don't have the resources to do the tech diligence. They're just not positioned to do it. You have to have a bunch of PhDs and probably get in person and do a bunch of stuff.
Anyway, as an aside, I always thought it would be cool to figure out a model to combine those things. Because it's ridiculous to me—you did venture capital—that we're sitting there trying to predict what the community wants when you could just go out and ask them. But on the flip side, we're pretty good at diligencing the supply side of things. Anyway, it sounds like you're kind of developing a DAO model that tries to get the best of both worlds. What you're doing is combining the best of what the centralized part can do and what the decentralized part can do.
Yeah. I like what you said, though. I've always been interested in things like prediction markets. I think it's ridiculous, the idea. And actually, a lot of our investments now in Web3 stuff is around media and movies. We've got a few in the movie area, and the idea is to harness the wisdom of the crowds. I think there are so many areas in the world. I do think there's a role for expertise, like diligence in technology. There are people that know more about computer science than other people in the crowd. But anything that's demand signal, I think it should not be done. Demand signal and also creative.
I believe a lot of creative stuff is... My theory, for example, on this, and this maybe relates to Moonbirds, is storytelling. Are there people that are great at coming up with stories? Of course. There are great writers. But I also bet you that there are a million people who have one great story in them. Maybe they don't have 100, but maybe they have one. And right now their stories are not surfacing. I think AI is going to help that a ton. I think AI is very exciting. Technology typically democratizes things. Crypto and Web3 are doing it through new incentive systems and AI through new capabilities. You could make a movie maybe. I think they're really close to having text to video now, not just text to image synthesis. I think AI is going to completely change the NFT game.
Chris Dixon
Yeah, it's interesting.
Kevin Rose
I feel that there are a lot of people out there that are wildly creative, but cannot put pen to paper or mouse to pixel. But their brains work in that creative way. So now they're prompt engineers.
Chris Dixon
They're prompt engineers. And it's not just prompt engineers in that if I say, "Give me a horse with a red hat," that's not art. But it's almost like you'll track the amount of prompt interaction. You'll say this person spent... This was a piece of art that was created with 1,500 different prompts that went into it, where there'll be refinement that's done. I think the refinement piece is going to be really interesting.
Kevin Rose
Yeah. I had Dolly access. It's an amazing technology, mind-blowing what they've done. Dolly and the other kind of stable diffusion and all of this. But I found myself personally after a few days kind of running out of things. And it's probably just because of my own lack of creativity.
Chris Dixon
I think it's the limitations of the tool.
Kevin Rose
But maybe you need something that's helping you refine the prompts and suggest things. I'm not saying it's not amazing tech, but more just to your point that it's not the end of it. There's a whole ton more you can do on the prompt side.
Chris Dixon
Yeah, it's early days there. I'm thinking five, ten years from now, it's just going to be a killer app. And for me as a collector, speaking to our earlier conversation about what you collect, I've gone back and bought early AI NFTs. They look horrible. But you'll look at that and be like, "Look how bad that AI was." Have you seen, if you go back on YouTube, this is really cool. I think it was 1975, the first computer graphics was a hand.
Kevin Rose
Oh, interesting.
Chris Dixon
Have you ever seen this? It looks like... What's it called? Battlezone. It's like green lines, vector graphics. It's the same kind of thing. So you think that these will be kind of interesting, iconic early collectibles.
Kevin Rose
Yeah, I mean, Robbie brought some of the early GAN stuff that they were doing out of NVIDIA on SuperRare. It's really cool with the image synthesis stuff. I actually started an AI company, whatever it was, 15 years ago, and have followed the space for a long time. I don't think anyone you talked to in the past would have had generating artistic images at the top of their list of things that would be automated.
Chris Dixon
Well, mostly analysis, right? That's how people thought of computing. Medicine for sure. Or you break down a computer program. Turns out they're farther ahead in generating images and movies than they are in analyzing computer programs. It's just not what you would have expected.
Kevin Rose
Do you think there's going to be a tipping point here really soon? I feel like things are accelerating. Is that just me because I'm getting excited about art, or are we seeing that in general?
Chris Dixon
On the AI specifically, I think it's accelerating. And by the way, a separate thing which I believe is that if you go back and look, as you were there and as I was, to the last kind of major computer cycle—mobile, social, cloud—you had these three trends. People thought it was buzzwords and overblown. It turned out to be underrated. The three trends reinforced each other. Social networks were the killer app of mobile phones, but mobile phones allowed them to go from the desktop, from 100 million people to 5 billion people. And cloud is what enabled those systems to run. You couldn't have a billion people interacting without cloud.
Kevin Rose
Right.
Chris Dixon
So my mental model is you had three exponential processes in and of themselves, but then they combined and created a hyper-exponential process. I would argue it's crypto, which is going to create a new architecture for incentive systems, and AI. The third is usually an interface. You could say AR, VR, maybe IoT, embedded devices and cars—that takes you from 5 billion to 200 billion. Within each of these areas, AI alone is going at an exponential rate. The algorithms are getting better. All the smartest people at Google are working on this. The distributed systems are getting better. You can count how many neurons are in these neural networks, and it's going up. It's like a Moore's Law type thing.
Kevin Rose
And specific chips, like the tensors.
Chris Dixon
Exactly. Purpose-built chips. It's happening at every level. A lot of it is also how you shard the problem across multiple machines. There's a ton of smart people doing that. These models like GPT-4—they've just taken it and added another 10,000 machines.
Kevin Rose
Right. And yet Ethereum's still at 30 transactions a second. We've got to catch up.
Chris Dixon
Well, the other thing I'll throw out there—this is a favorite topic of mine—is that if you go back since World War II, computing cycles tend to happen every 10 to 15 years. Advent of computing in 1945, then mainframes, mini computers, PCs, internet, mobile. The iPhone was 2007. So we're 15 years into this one. You've seen these early eruptions. The AI stuff is amazing, but it hasn't been deployed broadly yet. It's still in demos. I feel like there's a building crescendo. A lot of people are underestimating it. It's all going to come together and reinforce. Then you add in stuff I don't really understand, like biology and quantum computing.
Kevin Rose
Quantum seems like an amazing experiment but with very little practical application.
Chris Dixon
On the quantum side, it's not an area I focus on personally, but I have friends who do. My understanding is it's following a Moore's Law-ish trajectory. I see it more from the cryptography side. Some people on our team work on post-quantum cryptography. All cryptography on the internet—both in crypto and when you talk to your bank—is based on an old principle from Euclid. It's fast to multiply prime numbers together but takes a long time to go from the composite to the pieces. Quantum computing allows you to go back really quickly, so all of that falls apart. People like Dan Benet, who works with us and is a professor at Stanford, have developed new forms of cryptography resistant to quantum computers.
Kevin Rose
Because it all depends on which curves you use. You have to really diligence it.
Chris Dixon
The smart people I know think quantum computers are coming. They exist and are getting better, but it's about 20 years away. The plan is to do a kind of Y2K-type upgrade. We'll have to get together, hire consultants. The wild card is maybe somebody already has this stuff—the NSA or China. Anyway, there are two ways to look at the world today. One is what you see on Twitter: everything is the end of history, computing is mature, a lot of negative tech stuff. The other is that we live in an age of wonders, where computing is finally getting over its toddler phase and all this incredible stuff is about to happen. I feel like the next 10 or 15 years, that's going to happen. I'm pretty excited about it.
Kevin Rose
What year did you start Digg?
Chris Dixon
2004.
Kevin Rose
Oh, so you were in the very beginning. That phase was really cool—the primitive development.
Chris Dixon
For sure. Ajax happened. We could update websites without leaving the page. That was huge. Before that, you were hitting reload on a static thing. I remember it was called the port 80 trick. Now people don't even know what Ajax is. It's baked into React and everything else.
Kevin Rose
I call it primitive development. I remember the beginning of Web 2 when tagging was a new idea. Delicious did that. It sounds crazy now. There were hints of it, like social networking. Default to public—all the design patterns. You had that phase, which is the best phase because it's creative. Then you had the execution phase with the Zuckerbergs. Then the cloning phase, where everyone copied everyone else. Finally, for the first time, the community pushed back. Remember when Instagram rolled out features that were clones of TikTok, and the community said, "No, we don't want you to change it." I was like, "Yes." They're finally squashing the straight copying.
Chris Dixon
It was nice about that era. That's what I was asking about the year. At that point, the internet was still out of fashion as a business. It self-filtered for people who actually liked it. It created a culture around it.
Kevin Rose
You were on the West Coast then.
Chris Dixon
That's right. I was on the East Coast. I kind of regret it. I didn't get to see the West Coast side. The East Coast had literally 20 people. We'd go to meetups. The West Coast was bigger. When we'd get together, there were parties. I remember when Arrington had meetups at his house. I remember when I first saw TechCrunch. It was exactly what you're describing. You get together with a friend, talk about it, and it felt like a new movement. Then someone wrote it down, and it was a different moment. Someone who's clearly an enthusiast is writing in an excited voice about this new stuff.
Kevin Rose
I 100% remember the first time I heard the words "Web 2." I was building Digg, a few months in. Jason Calacanis called me up. He said, "Hey, I run Weblogs, Inc. We have Engadget. We noticed you're sending us traffic. Would you want to come join?" I said, "We're building this thing." He goes, "Well, you're very Web 2." I thought it was a software upgrade I hadn't applied. I literally thought I hadn't applied a patch to one of my servers. Because we were hard-racking our own servers back then. There was no cloud. I said, "Oh, shit, I haven't upgraded the web."
Chris Dixon
That's funny. I think it was O'Reilly. There were these conferences. It kind of started that way. Jump a tail.
Kevin Rose
Exactly. Then you had all these head fakes, which Web3 could potentially make real. Things like mashups. That was composability—what if web services were like Lego bricks and you could recombine them? That was happening a bit prior, too. Remember Dogpile?
Chris Dixon
I don't think I know that one.
Kevin Rose
Dogpile was the first search engine to combine results from four different search engines on one interface. AltaVista, Yahoo, a few others. Technically, they could have kept doing that. But at some point, the business model pushed people to silo. "You have to stay on my site so I can put ads on there."
Chris Dixon
You're one of the few people who have been in Web 2 and Web 3. How do you think about Web3 product development?
Kevin Rose
It's definitely changed. Maybe it's because I'm getting older, but Web 2 was all about coming up with the best formula for locking in eyeballs for as long as possible. Somewhat in a very evil way.
Chris Dixon
Yeah, that is what it is.
Kevin Rose
Web3 is very much about setting the stage for the meme. How do you further the meme? I don't mean a flash in the pan that's funny for 24 hours. It's building cultural moments that have lasting impact. If you become big enough and establish yourself as unique and novel, you flip from a project that requires constant maintenance to something that requires no external dependencies. CryptoPunks is in that genre. Dogecoin is in that genre. They were industry firsts. They started hundreds or thousands of collections spawned from that original idea. When you think about building, we're all looking for that thing where we'll be the front and center Wikipedia entry, solidifying us in a place where we flip to not needing external dependencies.
Back to product development: in Web 2, you could launch something, go away for six or eight months, come back with another iteration, and that was okay. This space is so wide open and blue ocean that you're rewarded for being a little crazy and chaotic. The best projects solidify themselves by being first in something. What made CryptoPunks or Bored Apes what they are today is not going to make Moonbirds a household name. We can't copy their playbook. We have to go about it in a different way. The cool thing is there's so much that can be done with the programmable nature of the blockchain. Very few people are competent in doing it well.
That's why I got back in. Now's the time to take a lot of these learnings and bring them into Web3.
Chris Dixon
Great. Another question about the difference between now and then: as you're building your company, how is it different than before?
Kevin Rose
A lot is the same. A lot has changed in terms of the infrastructure you need on the back end. It's more challenging, as always, to hire great engineers, especially around the security required for smart contracts.
Chris Dixon
You think it's more challenging than Web 2?
Kevin Rose
Yeah, 100%. In Web 2, once Rails hit and a few other frameworks like Django took off, it became really easy to hire engineers. Boot camps cranked them out. Pre-web framework, you had to build the whole thing. It was hard to scale. I remember who wrote Memcache? We were on the bleeding edge because we needed to cache. MySQL wouldn't do too many writes at once. A dig was a write to a database. It was a nightmare. A lot of those problems have been solved. The problems today are largely around finding competent smart contract engineers. Thankfully, we acquired the Divergence team, who's been awesome. I'd say there's more flexibility in what's accepted and what can be done. It's a very exciting time for entrepreneurs. It's not like the app world, which is so crowded. There are so many broken pieces of Web3 that require people to figure out problems like wallet hacks and UI/UX issues that expect you to be an engineer to use.
Chris Dixon
What about team building? How are you doing it differently this time?
Kevin Rose
We've grown fast. When we hire, it's a combination of pedigree and background, but also an inherent love for Web3. I don't want an engineer just because they're a senior engineer at Google. That's not interesting to me. If they have that and on nights and weekends for the last six months they've been writing smart contracts, that's exciting. Our team is composed of a slew of different people. I have engineers who are Art Blocks artists who have done drops. The Divergence team has done multiple art-related drops. I hired a product manager from Coinbase. He was frustrated because all they were doing was hiring ex-Instagram folks to build the Coinbase NFT product. They had no experience in Web3. He said, "I own a Moonbird." That was part of the interview process. He said, "You don't understand. I'm really deep in this." I said, "That's the type of person I want to hire." The mistake a lot of companies are making is throwing Web2 talent at Web3 problems. Unless you're in there kicking the tires and playing with this stuff, you'll try to shoehorn something in and do what you've always done in Web2. It's just not going to work for this crowd.
Chris Dixon
Interesting. We used to have a rule on our crypto fund that you had to live through a crypto winter. That was our proxy for saying you actually believe. If you live through a winter, it made no financial sense, so you must have done it because you believed. At some point, we relaxed that because some people were too young. There are many paths to get into something. But I do think an important strength in good Web3 companies and funds is this kind of true believer, people deep in the space. You have critics who list the various issues. Do you see that as an opportunity or as a core deficiency?
Kevin Rose
You want to hire people attracted to the fact that there's a lot of design space. They want to be creative and have impact. For me, it's a chance to reexamine and reboot the entire incentive model around the web. It rightly aligns power back in the hands of the consumer and gives them a way to participate in networks where value accrues to them versus a Fortune 500. That's a radically new model, and I want to play a part in it.
Chris Dixon
Nice. Thanks for having me on. I appreciate it.
Kevin Rose
Thanks for being here.
Sonal Choksi
Thank you for listening to Web3 with a16z. You can find show notes with links to resources, books, or papers discussed, transcripts, and more at a16zcrypto.com. This episode was produced and edited by Sonal Choksi. That's me. The episode was technically edited by our audio editor, Justin Golden, with 7 Morris. Credit also to Moonshot Design for the art, and all thanks to support from a16z Crypto. To follow more of our work and get updates, resources from us, and from others, be sure to subscribe to our Web3 weekly newsletter. You can find it on our website at a16zcrypto.com. Thank you for listening and for subscribing. Let's fucking go. Thank you.