Main Topic: The podcast episode discusses the future of housing and work, with a focus on the startup Flow, founded by Adam Neumann, and its vision for creating an elevated experience for renters and sharing value with them.
Key Points:
Participants:
Takeaways:
Key Quotes:
Key Statistics:
Back in August, after a16z announced our investment into Adam Neumann’s new company, Flow, it felt like almost everyone – whether it was other VCs, founders, or journalists – had something to say.
But the one person that you didn’t hear from was Adam himself.
In this never-before shared footage from a16z’s American Dynamism Summit in Washington DC, Adam Neumann sits down with Marc Andreessen and David Ulevitch, to discuss the opportunities that have emerged from post-pandemic shifts in both work and home, and what Flow is doing to capitalize.
Find the full library of American Dynamism Summit recordings at a16z.com/ad-summit.
Timestamps:
Resources:
Flow’s website: https://www.flow.life/
American Dynamism recordings: https://a16z.com/ad-summit
Stay Updated:
Find us on Twitter: https://twitter.com/a16z
Find us on LinkedIn: https://www.linkedin.com/company/a16z
Subscribe on your favorite podcast app: https://a16z.simplecast.com/
Follow our host: https://twitter.com/stephsmithio
Please note that the content here is for informational purposes only; should NOT be taken as legal, business, tax, or investment advice or be used to evaluate any investment or security; and is not directed at any investors or potential investors in any a16z fund. For more details please see a16z.com/disclosures.
Stay Updated:
Find a16z on X
Find a16z on LinkedIn
Listen to the a16z Podcast on Spotify
Listen to the a16z Podcast on Apple Podcasts
Follow our host: https://twitter.com/eriktorenberg
Please note that the content here is for informational purposes only; should NOT be taken as legal, business, tax, or investment advice or be used to evaluate any investment or security; and is not directed at any investors or potential investors in any a16z fund. a16z and its affiliates may maintain investments in the companies discussed. For more details please see a16z.com/disclosures.
Hosted by Simplecast, an AdsWizz company. See pcm.adswizz.com for information about our collection and use of personal data for advertising.
Host
I just want you to know that it's part of the game to get punched. And the question is not, are you going to get back in the game? The question is, when?
Back in August, after a16z announced our investment into Adam Neumann's new company, Flow, it felt like almost everyone – whether it was other VCs, founders, or journalists – had something to say. But the one person you didn't hear from was Adam himself.
In this never-shared-before footage from our American Dynamism Summit back in November, Adam sits down with a16z co-founder Marc Andreessen and a16z venture general partner David Ulevitch. They start by discussing why Adam chose to step back into the arena, but also why Flow. That leads into the inevitable conversation around how the pandemic fundamentally shifted both work and home, as they touch on a16z's move to the cloud, cities as startups, and ultimately what it might take to disrupt the world's largest asset class. We also get an inside scoop into how Adam is thinking about the four pillars of Flow, from technology to financial services.
Finally, this video was recently published alongside our full library of American Dynamism Summit recordings, which you can find at a16z.com/ad-summit. As a reminder, the content here is for informational purposes only, should not be taken as legal, business, tax, or investment advice, or be used to evaluate any investment or security, and is not directed at any investors or potential investors in any a16z fund. For more details, please see a16z.com/disclosures.
Thank you, gentlemen, for being here. I'm going to just jump right into it. Those of you that have heard Adam and Mark speak know that they have a lot to say, and they're very smart, so we aren't going to waste any time.
Adam, three years ago, you stepped down from your role as CEO of WeWork, one of the most well-known real estate companies ever created. You could have sailed off into the sunset. A lot of founders do that, hang out in the Mediterranean. But you decided to start another company again. You're not naive. You know it's hard. You know that there's a lot of attention on you. So how did you decide that you wanted to chase and build a new, impactful company and chase a big vision and dedicate your time to building? Why get back in the game? Get back in the arena?
Adam Neumann
First of all, thank you for having me. Thank you, Mark. Thank you, David.
When I stepped down three years ago, the first thing I actually did was I took a moment to think of the successes, but also think of the mistakes and the lessons and all the different things that I did and that we did as a team. Even though I was very proud of what we built, I really felt like there was a lot of thinking to do. That was my first thing.
As that was happening, I started building a family office. With my family office, we invested in about 50 venture investments. We did private equity investments. We did liquid market trading. Each one of those things taught me something new that I wasn't aware of before. Liquid markets actually taught me about Wall Street. As I was sitting with the team and we were doing different investing and listening to earning calls, I thought, "Oh, wow, that's what you guys are listening to and that's what's interesting for you." That gave me a perspective that I didn't have before.
When I was sitting with entrepreneurs, as we did our venture investing, the first part when you invest and write the check is a lot of fun. But then comes the part where you're talking to them and listening and they have problems. I got to give advice to these entrepreneurs. They didn't always listen. I thought, "Okay, that's how it feels when an entrepreneur is on the lesson." That taught me a lot and actually made me understand Mark and Ben and venture capital more.
As we're doing all of this, and this is now March 2020, COVID is happening. We were looking at real estate because it's something we care about. We felt that there was going to be an opportunity in multifamily. It was a simple trade: cap rates were at 4.8 and we thought they were going to compress. We saw interest rates and we thought there was an opportunity. So we decided as a family office to go very deep into multifamily. We bought approximately 4,000 apartments.
As we're doing that, I started walking these buildings. Even though initially it was a trade, I started feeling like there was something more that can be done. I started feeling like the residential experience is not what it should be.
To backtrack a little bit: going backwards again to 2019, we're stepping down. Now it's early 2020. As the whole thing is happening, and maybe you wouldn't be surprised, but the phone is not ringing as much as it used to just a few months before. I got a phone call from Mark. We never met. Mark introduces himself: "Hello, I'm Marc Andreessen." I know you are Mark, thank you so much for calling me. We're having a discussion, we're talking about something, but very quickly it turned to Mark asking me, "So Adam, how are you doing?" I told him this and that and this and that. He says to me, "Oh, you're still in that stage."
I said, "Mark, what stage is that?" He goes, "The stage where you believe everything the media says." I said, "Well, I'm not in that stage. I know we built a great company. Of course I don't believe, but you know, they are saying quite a lot of things."
Mark says to me, "Adam, we don't know each other, but let me tell you something about venture capital and high growth companies. The bigger the venture, the bigger the growth, what I'm about to tell you is more true. It's hand-to-hand combat. Anybody who doesn't know that venture is hand-to-hand combat doesn't actually understand or has never done it before. When you fight, once in a while you get punched."
He said, "I guarantee you," because he was very nice, "a lot of our companies use your products, not just in the U.S., but all over the world. I guarantee you that for every mistake you made, there's a hundred things that you did right. I just want you to know that it's part of the game to get punched. The question is not, are you going to get back in the game? The question is, when? Just so you know, you have a friend here that you've never met before, but we've been tracking you. If you ever decide to do anything, then call us."
I'll say one more thing about it, because it was very meaningful. I hung up the phone, and I still remember this. I walked to Rebecca, my wife, and I said, "I just had the most amazing phone call. This guy, Marc Andreessen." I explained to her who Mark is. He called me and basically was very encouraging and gave me a different perspective to look at what just occurred. She thought it was amazing, and I thought it was amazing. Mark, I don't know if I've ever had the chance to actually tell you. It was a meaningful moment for me, and I really appreciate it.
Fast forward now a year and a half. We kept these buildings that we bought. It ended up being a really good trade. Everything that we thought was happening was happening. We started building this brand. It didn't have a name yet, but we started building this business. We saw all this opportunity, which we'll talk about a little bit later. Around February, we spoke again. Mark asked me what's up. I told him what was happening, that we've been developing. By this point the business is over a year old. We've been doing more and more. We started building technology. We bought a company. We did a few different things.
Mark said, "Why don't you come and present it to the team?" We went and we met the team. The first thing I noticed when we all met is that the Andreessen Horowitz team was not like the venture capitalists that I was used to. I had quite a lot of experience with venture capital before. It didn't feel like investors. It actually felt like businessmen, like entrepreneurs. I actually just asked Mark behind the stage, "How many partners do you have that are entrepreneurs?" He said, "20." I got to tell you, that's very different from other businesses.
As we're having the discussion, one of Mark's partners asked me, "Adam, are you raising money?" I said, "I'm not sure. We're going to build this one on our own. One of our lessons was you got to choose your partners really carefully." He said, "Well, maybe you should consider us. Let us look into the business and see if it's interesting. If so, maybe you should consider us."
Then a16z led a very rigorous diligence process. They asked us a lot of questions and learned everything about our business. As we were getting to know Andreessen Horowitz, I realized that these are the kind of partners that I was always looking for, but never really knew that existed.
To answer your question, I was always building it, but building it with a partner was something that only happened because of this team and because of the way I met them. I can just tell you that we had our first board meeting and one minute afterwards, Mark called me and said, "Adam, can I give you some feedback?" I said, "Of course, Mark." He said, "Well, when your team said this and this and this, I don't agree with that. Let me tell you why. Here's the experience I have. Here's what I want to warn you from." I welcome the feedback. I'm so excited to be a partner. I'm excited to be back in the game, not alone, but with the team. We're just getting started. The future has a lot of potential.
Host
That's awesome. I will say, there's a whole bunch of venture capitalists in the room. We are all very happy that WeWork exists so that our portfolio companies are not signing these long-term leases in this dynamic world that we live in, and they get to go into the offices they want to be in in the right cities at the right time.
We're going to talk more about Flow and the new business in a moment. Mark, I want to shift to you. You and I have talked about housing for a long time, long before this investment. It's something you've thought about for a long time. Why is housing important? Why is it particularly relevant? Why is it even a part of American dynamism?
Marc Andreessen
There's a critique of Silicon Valley and the tech industry that, on various states, sometimes I agree with, sometimes I don't. The critique basically says, "Look, you guys have done a great job. Silicon Valley's done a great job over the years at the really unimportant things. Consumer electronics and video games and media and e-commerce. It's all great. It's all fine. It's all good." By the way, we do those things. We're very proud of our efforts in those spaces. We actually think they're very important. But they're basically small slices of GDP.
If you look at the GDP pie chart, the consumer spending pie chart, the things that people spend money on that really matter in their lives, there's basically three really big ones: healthcare, education, and housing. If you look at all the economic statistics by sector, healthcare, education, and housing are basically increasing in terms of cost at a much faster rate than all the others. They're the sectors where the tech industry has had the least impact historically. Of those, the biggest one is housing. Housing is the single biggest thing that most families spend money on.
It's very central from an economic standpoint in the life of the family. There's this very big question: if you own, there are potentially big downsides because you might be stuck in one place where maybe you don't want your family to be for the next 30 years because opportunity shifts around. But if you rent, you don't necessarily build up equity by default with the way that most apartment offerings work. So there are big economic consequences.
There are also big social consequences and political consequences. This is something that's been deep in the American character for many decades. This idea that if you have a sense of commitment, if you have a sense that you are actually invested in the place where you live, you are more connected to the society, you're more connected to the culture, and ultimately you're more connected to the political body. There have been long-running policies in the United States to encourage homeownership. It turns out those can be overdone, they can end up with problems. We saw a lot of the problems that came out of that approach in the 2008 financial crisis. Nevertheless, there is a very big, deep, meaningful sense of identity that comes with housing.
Why does this matter from a broad standpoint? Geography is so central to economic opportunity. Take a step back: the role of cities in human society. Cities are a human invention. There were many hundreds of thousands, millions of years where people were running around in clans and tribes, not forming into cities. About 4,000 years ago, cities were basically invented and people started to cluster that way. Why were cities invented? A bunch of reasons, but one of the big ones is there's an economic payoff to being in a city.
If you have a certain level of productivity and you're in a rural environment, you don't have many opportunities to work with other people who are highly productive. If you move to a city, all of a sudden you're surrounded by lots of other people who are highly productive. There's a catalytic effect, a positive feedback loop that forms. Cities are basically the foundation of modern economic growth. Economists call this the agglomeration effect: if you slam people together, you can get a lot of good things out of that.
The story of the West is the story of cities and the creation of all these amazing cities. Over the last 50 years, that trend has gone into hyperdrive. You've had this emergence of what economists call superstar cities: Washington, D.C., New York City, Boston, San Francisco Bay Area, Los Angeles, and internationally, London, Tokyo, Singapore, Paris. These are cities that are irresistible draws for people who are highly ambitious and want to be around a lot of other highly ambitious, highly productive people.
As a result of that superstar city clustering, there's been a bifurcation in the housing market. Those superstar cities become occupied. At some point, people end up with a political agenda and they stop building housing. The places where people want to go and want their kids to go are very difficult to get to. The San Francisco Bay Area is a classic example. San Francisco last year authorized, I think, 6,000 new housing units. That's an absurdly low number relative to the demand for people who want to move there. The places that do not have this kind of clustering agglomeration superstar city effect build plenty of housing, but there's not as much opportunity there.
Heading into COVID, you saw this incredible bifurcation. You saw it in the American economy, and you see it in American politics. You're either in a city, you buy a home, you've got that little commitment, you've got that level of opportunity for you and your family. Or you're in a more rural environment and you're basically stuck. You don't have access to good jobs. Your kids are not going to have high-tech jobs. You're going to have a lower quality of life. This was becoming a very big issue for us because we were basically getting stuck in the geographic confines of Silicon Valley. Our companies were penned in. It was becoming very hard for companies to grow in that area.
Then a horrible tragedy struck that turned out to also be in some ways a miracle in terms of the long-run consequences: COVID. None of us would have hoped that COVID would have happened. It has been a horrible tragedy for many people and broadly for our society. Nevertheless, COVID was a system shock. It caused all big companies to basically instantly move online in a hard cutover in a way that I never imagined was possible. It was also an instant proof that companies really can run, at least for some time, online. No big company actually stopped operating as a consequence of this dramatic shift from in-person to online.
All of a sudden, that opened the door to every CEO, every manager, every entrepreneur, every investor thinking, "Oh, okay, the post-COVID world is not going to be like the pre-COVID world. The post-COVID world is going to be an opportunity to rethink and reinvent how companies are organized. It's going to be an opportunity to reinvent how industries are organized. It's going to be an opportunity to reinvent how geography works, what the role of cities is. It's going to be an opportunity to spread the economic activity from cities much more broadly throughout the country."
Every employer, every company, every CEO here is having some version of this conversation with their own company. We talk about this with our founders all the time. There's a corresponding question that's opened up: how are people going to live? Some people are going to continue living the way that they were. Some people are going to undertake a radical change in how they live, and they'll go remote. All of a sudden, you go remote and you have access to thousands of jobs anytime you want, which is a totally new phenomenon. You now have the opportunity to rethink how families live.
Is it necessary for ambitious kids to leave a place where they grew up in order to have access to first-class economic opportunity? In 2019, the answer to that was frequently yes. Today, maybe not. This is not a zero or 100% thing. It's not a hard cutover. It's not like the whole world goes remote or stays remote. That's not what's happening. But there's this moment in time that we're in right now where we can actually rethink and reinvent how companies are organized and how work happens. We can also reinvent how people live and give people a lot more options.
I think the presumptions that have underlied the whole structure of how the housing market works, how the industry works, and how people live and work are all up for grabs. I think we have about a five-year window as a society to figure out what this means and how to adapt.
Host
That's a good segue to what I want to go into. We have seen work become more dynamic. People now sometimes go into an office some days a week. Sometimes they go in for a couple months and they go to a different office in a different city. WeWork was quite equipped for this kind of dynamic work lifestyle. What are the lessons that you have learned from WeWork that you're going to apply to Flow, or things that maybe you didn't do at WeWork but you thought about that you're going to apply to Flow? Particularly around this changing way people live and work and how people, as we get to rethink the way we organize ourselves and bring ourselves to work and to home.
Adam Neumann
I think you're right. I actually think flexible work is more relevant today than 10 years ago. I think it's a better idea today than it was. The obvious lesson is community.
On top of everything that Mark just said, and I'm not going to repeat any of it, that's the data that pushed us into being as interested as we were in this category. On top of all of that, I think a lot of people argued. Howard Schultz used to say Starbucks is the third place. I remember once having an argument with him. I told him WeWork is the third place. He said Starbucks is the third place. I think the first place turned out to be the third place. I think the home is the most important thing. I think COVID taught us that. You can take your work into your home, but you can't take your home into your work. That's affecting a lot of change.
To put a little numbers behind what Mark is saying: 70% of 35-year-olds and youngers are currently renters. They don't actually buy. This number is not because of the interest rates that have been going up over the past six to 10 months. This is a number from 12 months ago. We believe that number is only going to grow. So 70% are renters. You said it's a big piece of their spend. It's about a third of their total wallet. You have this huge asset class, largest in the world. 70% of its users are renters. It's a third of their spend. Yet they're not getting an experience that is actually up to par. Not to talk about the financial. You mentioned, Mark, that they're not creating any equity. When you put those two things together, you see a real challenge.
What it's going to do, and we're already seeing it, is people are starting to work where they live and not just live where they work. You're starting to see these movements between cities. Without becoming too political, but we're in the heart of politics, maybe some of the results in midterms now showed Democrats that were actually traveling to new cities and moving to different places. A lot of things are shifting. The way we live has an opportunity right now to change. If we weren't clear about it before how important the home is, everybody is reminded. A great home and a great experience, an elevated experience, is more important than ever before. Work has to accommodate.
Mark and I actually see the world a little differently about whether every company is going to be a remote company or in-person company. But the answer is obviously hybrid of the two. As you think through how am I going to solve work and how am I going to solve the future of the way people live, what I see is an opportunity to really affect that change. It's exciting that we're in D.C. because this is one of the places where opportunities like this become a reality.
Marc Andreessen
If I could put a point on something that Adam said. There's Richard Florida that analyzes these things. He talks about what he calls the creative class. It's the sort of upper middle class. It's us, it's our kids. Highly educated kids who are going to go into a knowledge or creative profession of some kind, working at a keyboard as opposed to doing some form of manual labor or manufacturing. This is not most of the economy, but this is the upper middle class, in many ways the cultural vanguard for the country. They define a lot of the trends.
There's this experience that I'm sure a lot of us have had, and a lot of younger people we know have had in the last 20, 25 years. You grew up at home, you then go to college, you spend your time at college for more years. You're on this campus environment. Everybody knows college is kind of education, it's kind of adult daycare. It's got all the food and entertainment. It's this whole contained environment. It's a social environment. It's a dating environment. You're putatively an adult, but you're living in a dorm and there's an older adult down the hall who's taking care of you. You're not really fully an adult.
50 years ago, you'd leave that environment and you'd go to work in an office. You'd buy a starter house and you'd be on your traditional American middle class path. Over the last 20, 25 years, it became very common to have this idea of the corporate campus. Google really crystallized that in the culture. This idea that a company's facility where everybody came every day was going to be a continuation of the college campus experience. That led to this perk bonanza. You'd go to this campus and it's gourmet food 24 hours a day. They'll do your dry cleaning and they'll walk your dog. There are swimming pools. By the way, these campuses still exist. They're all 100% converting all the tennis courts to pickleball courts, because that's what everybody's doing.
The theory was: if we can get people, especially these young people, inculcate them, keep them in this kind of college campus environment, then they'll basically work more. We'll get more out of them because they'll be here more often. It was everything up to not usually including the actual bed, although sometimes people would sleep under their desk like Elon Musk, but everything short of that. As a consequence, young adults stayed in this corporate campus environment. They had this incredible community. They had this incredible environment with all these friends, co-workers, colleagues, teammates, other people who work at the same company. They're going to lunch, going to dinner, doing the whole thing. By the way, it turns out it's just like the college campus: it's the dating pool. If you work for the Google campus or the Facebook campus, you're probably going to date somebody who also is there because you're there all the time together.
Then you drop COVID into that model and you just detonate it. That's what's happened. All of a sudden, the experience of a kid going through that is, "Nope, you don't get that. What you get is you get to sit in your studio apartment right in front of your laptop. Good luck." You're cut off from everything else. You've got DoorDash and you've got Tinder. That's your life. That is not the same thing.
To Adam's point, a lot of these companies now are thinking, "Okay, we're going to have people come back in the office two days a week, three days a week, or we're going to have them come back in shifts." But the spirit is that Elvis has left the building for these kinds of environments. This is not the way that most companies are going to operate. All of a sudden, the focus on where you live, the focus on whether you are literally by yourself, whether you have roommates, whether you're in a small complex or a big complex, whether you have any sense of connection whatsoever, whether you know who your neighbors are.
Most people historically have lived in apartments. I don't think they generally would even know who the neighbors are. The guy next door is just the guy next door. You'd feel no connection. There would be no overlap where you lived and the people you worked with. There was no point. You didn't worry about whether there were other people who you worked with who were in your same apartment complex because you were seeing them at work all day. Do you have anything in common with the people you're in the building with?
And so there's this sort of whole model that an entire generation grew up with that has all of a sudden been detonated. I don't know, it may be radical. I think the idea of sitting in the apartment in front of the screen with DoorDash and Tinder is not a good life. And so that opens the door for reinvention. We know it's not a good life.
Adam Neumann
Because even in the office, you gave Google as an example. Google was inspiration for us at WeWork. Our point was, why can't small businesses have this great campus, have this great energy? And that was the beginning. I remember when we tried to sell Google, I would be like, "Can we take some of your stuff?" They're like, "You can't take our stuff." Or "Google, we invented this." We ended up taking some of their staff, quite a lot actually.
But that same serendipity feeling that you feel when you go into an office and connect—that belongs in a home in a funny way, way more than it ever belonged in an office. When you think of these apartment buildings, it is a little sad. It's sad that there's an apartment building with 400 apartments, maybe 600 or 700 people, with a swimming pool, a kitchen, a gym, and all these amenities. If anybody here has ever been in a multifamily building, you do this amazing tour. They show you all these amenity spaces. You never see anyone there. You then move into the building and you—not everyone, but a lot of people—live their life that Marc is describing. And that's sad because I don't think human connection thrives.
I'm so happy we're here face to face. COVID was obviously a horrible thing, but also a miracle at the same time. It's a miracle that we're all here face to face because this connection is so much more meaningful. And why don't people deserve that in the home? I go back to that number: a third of their wallet spend. As Americans, we used to spend on anything—if it's two percent of our wallet spend, one percent of our wallet spend, many companies that you guys invest in make it all branded. It's always an uplifting experience. If someone doesn't do a good enough experience, the next person comes and elevates it. And yet in residential—and we can talk about why—it never happened. Because it never happened, and because it's so difficult to disrupt, it actually didn't occur. What ends up happening is that renter is not getting a good deal, neither the experience nor the financial transaction. And again, that renter is the majority of the young adults.
Marc Andreessen
Yeah, I think COVID was the first time a lot of people, especially under the age of 40 or 50, first time they ever got to know their neighbors. They never had to. Their proxy for community was probably the workplace. And like you said, we're never going back to that. Whatever our new normal is, it's not the old.
Adam Neumann
It's an American thing that they never had to. In other countries where I grew up in Israel, there's no such thing. You don't know your neighbors? When you don't have salt, you go to your neighbor's door. You knock on the door. They don't answer. You open the door. It's locked. You know where the key is. You open it up. You go and you take the salt. You never bring it back. Then they go back. There's no salt. Oh, Adam took it. And it's this community. Here we call the police.
Marc Andreessen
Police.
Adam Neumann
Yeah. They come in four hours. It depends. Or San Francisco, maybe never.
Marc Andreessen
You guys said that. I didn't say anything.
Adam Neumann
Okay. But the point is that it's such a natural thing for people living together to connect. And yet we live in a world where even when people are in the same building, they don't talk to each other in the elevator. When I came to the United States and used to say hello to everyone in the elevator, people thought I was weird. And I thought it was weird that you wouldn't say hello. Wouldn't you want to know who is living there?
There are a lot of different ideas that we have. But the simple one is: when people tour a building, the leasing agent tells you about all the amenities. I would like the listing agent—who's not even going to be called a listing agent—to introduce you to a few residents who actually like living there. Let them tell you why this is a great building and if it's a fit for you or not. That tiny little thing I just said is so small. And the fact that it doesn't exist—a lot of people ask me, "Adam, how come this didn't exist before?" It doesn't exist, in my opinion, because buildings are full anyway. There's a shortage of supply.
You spoke a little bit about zoning. The numbers vary, but between three to five million apartments and single-family homes are missing right now in the U.S., and that number grows by hundreds of thousands of units a year. There's a shortage of supply, there's an over-demand, and no one really needed to do it. Because the landlords didn't need to do it, it didn't happen.
When you think of proptech companies and technology—I was talking to Steve Case before about proptech and all the different innovations. When you think, "Why haven't people solved this problem before?" Most proptech companies come in and solve a point solution. They have this one solution, but then they need to take that solution, convince the landlords who are not even interested in buying anything because they're making money anyway, go to these old ERP systems, connect to the back of these systems, then get the users. It's very difficult, which is why the way we want to tackle it is actually vertical. I almost think it's the only way.
Host
Excellent. We're going to come back to that—the vertical software stack for proptech and Flow—in a minute. But Mark, you know, we came out, Ben had a big blog post about how we've moved our headquarters to the cloud. We have decoupled the geography of the firm. So I guess the first question is two parts. Talk a little bit about the thinking about moving to the cloud. Why did we do it? And then talk about how it's gone.
Marc Andreessen
Yeah. And then I'll keep you honest if I agree.
Host
Yeah.
Marc Andreessen
This has been very dramatic. For every employer, every company, this has been dramatic. We've had our version of it. For us, it's been very dramatic. We made a very deliberate decision when we started our firm in 2009 that we were really deeply going to invest in the office, and in particular in one office. We were kind of semi-notorious in the industry for only ever having one office. The office was in Menlo Park, California. This is actually controversial even in the Bay Area because there were lots of startups that were actually in San Francisco. Lots of the younger people who worked for us lived up in San Francisco. And we said, "Sorry." Every year everybody was like, "We got to put up an office in San Francisco." And we're like, "Nope, single office. Everybody's going to be in the office."
The reason for that was we wanted the beehive effect. We wanted people when they walk in—both the people who work for us, but also the people who are visiting us—to really feel like they were tapping into energy. They were seeing lots of other interesting people. This was the kind of environment and the kinds of people they'd want to be around. So we put a really big emphasis on that. We were in there every day, all day, working together. The whole thing you get from a high-functioning office environment.
And then like everybody else in March of 2020, we shut that down and we went completely online. Like everybody else, we were shocked that we were able to continue to run the firm, basically keep everything going over Zoom and Slack. So off and away we went. We had an incremental process. The two weeks to crush the curve turned into two months, turned into two years. Like everybody else, we're trying to figure out how long this is going to last. We start doing polls of our employees. Six months in, some people were like, "I can't wait to get back to the office." Some people were like, "I don't know." Twelve months, the numbers moved. Eighteen months, the numbers moved. Then we had one poll where it was basically 100% of the young parents were like, "If you guys want to go back to the office, good luck. We're getting different jobs. I get to spend time with my kids. I get to be here in the morning. I get to be here at night. By the way, I'm working from home 12 hours a day. I'm more productive than ever. But I am not going to do the two or three hour daily commute from South San Jose or from San Francisco or from the East Bay to go to Menlo Park. I'm just not going to do it anymore."
That perked our ears up. And then the other conversation we had was about what's going to happen to our companies and to our industry. It's certainly not the case that all of our companies are going fully remote. We actually have quite a few companies that have elected to stay very office-centric, which is a very interesting counter-programming thing that some people are doing now. But generally speaking, our companies were indicating that they were going to become more flexible and they were going to really start to spread out. The industry felt like it was going to expand. We were seeing a lot of founders who were frustrated being in the Bay Area basically leave over this period. They went to other places and started companies.
So we basically decided we can't be in the business of partnering with people who are building the future if we're not living in the future ourselves. We said we'll just do a hard reset. We'll become remote-centric or virtual-centric. We still have our office because it's on a long-term lease, so we converted it to hoteling. I just signed off yesterday on converting my former office into apparently the new lounge. I'm very excited to visit the new hangout space. We're going to keep offices basically as places for people to go when they need a place to work, for teams to be able to meet together. We're also letting our founders use our offices more, which is actually helping them figure out how to adapt through this.
And then we're going to expand—the WeWork model being ahead of its time. We're going to have more smaller offices and more locations. We've opened formally in LA, Menlo, SF, Miami, New York, New York 2, New York 3. I think that's it for the moment. We'll have more in the future. We're an investment operation, not a product company, so we don't have assembly lines or software production. We have a simpler version of the problem, but we're letting our teams decide how to distribute. Some teams want to be in person. Some teams want to be remote.
The way the firm runs now is we run the firm remote—all the formal meetings are on Zoom. Everything is kind of equalized that way. But the teams are free to cluster whenever they want. We have a very big focus on two things: one is off-sites. Every team is expected to get together on a frequent basis, and we really invest in that. And then a lot more travel. My steady state is going to be traveling at four times the number of days that I used to travel. All of a sudden, it's even higher impact than it used to be to actually show up someplace and be there in person.
For us, it feels like a real broadening out of what a firm like ours is capable of doing. It feels like a way to accommodate scale, because we definitely felt bottlenecked where we were. I think to Adam's point, we're feeling our way through it. I talk to a lot of big company CEOs. I think they're all in an intermediate state. They're all in some hybrid state where they have a lot of vestiges of the old model because they've got the offices they've got and the employees that live in certain places, but they also know that they can't go back to the way things used to be. They've all got some hybrid remote virtual thing. It's usually a two or three day a week thing. It's not working really well. They've got this big question: do they also hire remote employees? Because if they do, then it brings up the issue to the current employees: why can't they become remote? And then they basically all have to reinvent all the communication flows, all the management systems.
And then they've got this fundamental question for their people, especially all the new hires. We're going to be on five years in here pretty quick. There's an entire generation of kids coming out of school that are going to go to work for these companies. They're going to have a different set of both expectations and issues. I think we're still at the beginning of the change. I think we're three years into probably a 10-year process. The level of reinvention is going to be quite staggering from here.
Host
I think that's right. I think we've managed through it very well. We actually materialize where we need to and have a lot more face time. I mean, I see you all the time outside the office. I think we get much more concentrated, focused time together to actually be productive. The hallway track is okay at the office, but it's a little bit superficial. "How was your weekend? What did you do?" When you go to an off-site, it's just much more focused and conscientious about what is important to us, what went well, what are we not doing, what do we want to be doing. My takeaway is that when we are together, it actually is way more productive. Not that I don't care about your weekend. I do care. But it's not as important as talking about the next 10 years of the firm.
Marc Andreessen
Yeah, I call this the barbell. Because everybody always asks, "What about the water cooler moments?" And I'm like, "God, I hated the water cooler moments." To have to stand there and talk about the football game—I can't. Tom Brady seems like a wonderful guy. I can't do this anymore. It's very deflating.
Host
It's very deflating.
Adam Neumann
I'm going to have to push back on my partners a little bit.
Host
Okay, go ahead.
Adam Neumann
For an investing firm, I accept. And I already said you guys are not just investors. You're partners to a businessman and entrepreneur, and it's factual. I strongly feel—and Mark asked what's important about this conference, and said it's important to think a little bit how the future is going to look—just an opinion. I've been in a few offices. I strongly feel that the serendipitous connections—the water cooler is boring. When you're building a company and it's getting exciting and a new idea is coming and the whole team was supposed to go home and it's 8 p.m. and everybody told their husbands, their wives, and their kids we'll be there in 30 minutes.
And then someone went to the bathroom, sorry for the example, and comes back and is like, "I have it." And they say this thing that solves the entire problem. And everybody gets so excited. And before you know it, it's 2 a.m. And we just moved the business forward, not by a week, but by a year. And now it's 2 a.m. It's very late. Everyone's sleeping already. "Well, let's go out and grab a drink." And now everybody's hanging out. And before you know it, you just had one of those nights that's this moment in the life of a business that you look back and say, "I know that day when it all changed."
That special piece cannot happen on Zoom. I think human potential is in the cloud, I believe it, but human interaction is happening right here. If you look 10 years forward, the companies that are going to make the effort now to be face-to-face—now we can describe what face-to-face is, there are many ways to do it—but the companies that are actually going to do the face-to-face, I think when we look back five years, maybe even 10, are going to be the winners. Obviously, I agree that the huge ones who don't know what to do with themselves, that's an opportunity for incumbents to come. But when I'm thinking of startups and new businesses, even strong new businesses, with my team, we're fighting for that face-to-face time. Every time we're together, the excuse of having this event brought a few of us together and three things came up about the business as we're thinking about just what we're going to talk about. I think that's priceless.
Now, take that because we agree that the office is a challenge. Bring that back into your home. You're back in that multifamily building. Why not have those connections there? Why shouldn't you meet there? It makes a lot more sense for me, by the way—I'll meet my wife or my husband in the apartment building when I go downstairs to the pool than I do in the office. So both of those things work really well. From a business point of view, I can do business there also. And then maybe there should be a co-space. There should be an office. And maybe enterprises are going to look—if enterprises need to do culture, and if culture is not going to be in the office anymore, then maybe there's a new hybrid that has to do with the home put together with an office space.
I'll give one more thought. I think the fact that you guys have seven offices is the future. I do think it's smaller offices and centers. But it's going to be very hard for me to be convinced that not bringing people together and not having human connection is in our nature. I don't think we're built to look at the screen. I think that one day when we're all much, much older and we're on our deathbed and we're looking at ourselves and we have that moment of realization and we say, "How much time in my life did I spend with my loved ones and with people I really care about? And how much time of my life did I spend in front of a screen?" If that answer, if you're in front of a screen, is too big, I am not sure how we're going to feel that second before it's all over.
Marc Andreessen
I think we would all agree. You have to know what inning you're in, what time it is in your company. There are definitely moments that matter where you all want to be in a room working together. We do that. We would agree with that for sure.
Host
So actually, let's talk about that. Adam, you've kept a lot about Flow close to the vest. Give us a little bit about the vision. You've given us a little hint throughout your answers here. But what are you really hoping to build with Flow?
Adam Neumann
I actually thought, because we were talking so much, that I was going to keep it under my vest one more day.
Host
Oh yeah, well.
Adam Neumann
I thought I was going to get away with it. Well, first of all, I'll say a reason about keeping it under our vest. It's not that we've actually been keeping it under our vest. It's that one of the many lessons that we learned from the past is talk is cheap. We just want to build. It's a heavy lift, and we just want to get to work, so we had no reason to say anything. I met a nice person here earlier today who I think said something about me when he was talking before, and I said, "That's not true what you said." He goes, "But that's what the media said." And I was like, "Well, I never spoke." That's right. The media has never mischaracterized him either, so it's amazing. He then told me, he said, "I'm not sure I buy into Flow." I said, "Well, I never spoke about that either."
In a very simple way, we want to create an elevated experience for the resident. And we want to find a way to share with the resident a portion of the value that they create. I'll give that a moment. We want to elevate their experience. We talked about the buildings. We talked about everything that's happening. I don't think it's an easy job. I think it's very hard, but I do think the bar is low. You just make a little more connections. You just make it a little bit more real. You pay attention to the people running it. You maintain it the right way. You leverage technology to actually make things work. Instead of using nine apps, you use one. You do simple things and you elevate the experience.
But then the more complicated part is you find a way to share a portion of the value with the resident itself. And that's the vision. Because we said that it's a majority of the young adults, and because Mark said that that's how people—a few numbers behind that. For 80 years, owning a home used to be the way that the majority of us created equity. 60% of Americans today, on average, their equity is in the home. That is the majority of equity. So if we're correct and 70% are renters and that number is only going to go up, where are they going to create equity? If they're going to be renters for 10 years, 20 years—when you go into these apartment buildings, and it's true about single family, but for today we'll talk about apartments—if you're going to go into these multifamily buildings and you're going to have this disconnected experience that you just said, but you're not only going to be there for two years and then get married and move to a home, you're going to be there for 20. That sounds soul crushing. Therefore, you have to solve both of the sides.
Can I ask myself the next question? Sure. "Adam, how are you going to solve both of the sides? That sounds really good, but what are you actually going to do?" Great question. Thank you. Thank you for that great question.
Well, we have four pillars as we're looking at the business today. We have the first one, which is a branded technology-first management company that actually runs the buildings. We have an asset management or real estate fund or real estate company that actually owns the buildings. Something cool about our new business: we actually own buildings together already. One of the biggest words that Mark and Ben used, as I said before, was alignment. Alignment, alignment, alignment. So for perfect alignment, we contributed into this business at least as much as Andreessen Horowitz contributed into this business. I'm very excited about it and it's amazing to feel like that.
Then we have a financial services company. So number one: management company, branded technology first. Number two: real estate asset management, a company that can buy real estate and asset manage real estate. Number three: financial services. And the fourth pillar is this mechanism that's going to take some of the value and share it with the value creators.
What we get so excited about the vision of Flow and the business of Flow is that it's actually a flywheel. If we can actually create a better experience in the building, then the building performs better and makes a higher NOI. If the building makes a higher NOI, then we'll be able to raise more money and buy more buildings. If we buy more buildings, then we'll be able to run more buildings and have more users in those buildings. And those users are going to start using our financial services.
The reason they're going to use the financial services: the first thing you do in buildings is you charge rent every month, and that's 35% of their total wallet. So that payments company that's charging your rent already has a real relationship with the user. If that financial services company is going to do what we want it to do and create services that are actually meaningful—we think of it as financial wellness—and give services that are actually meaningful, then that again is going to drive more users.
And then if we are able to take this value-creating mechanism and share with our residents a portion of the value, it's going to make them feel ownership. It's not just ownership like "I feel like I'm part of something." It's "I actually own part of something." The word ownership is a very complicated word, especially in this place. But if there's perceived value, and if that value appreciates over time, then I feel like I'm part of a community.
A very funny example that we like to give: if you're in your apartment building and you're a renter and your toilet gets clogged, you call the super. If you're in your own apartment and you bought it and you own it and your toilet gets clogged, you take the plunger. That's the difference between feeling like you own something versus just feeling like you're renting. From being transactional to actually being part of a community. Our vision is to bring it all together.
Just one more example to put it into numbers. Average churn in multifamily in this country is 50%. It means a user stays on average for two years. If the user now enjoys their experience more and feels like they have a portion of the value and chooses to stay a little longer, and that average churn goes down from 50% to 40%, without getting too deep into the numbers, the NOI of the building will go up by approximately 5%. That increases the returns of the building for those LPs, for the investors, by 500 basis points. In real estate, that's an unheard of number. By tackling this challenge vertically is what Flow is planning to do. And as I said, we're just getting started.
Host
Excellent. I'm going to wrap this up with a sort of combo question for both of you. Are there any model cities that are sort of doing this right from a regulatory standpoint, from a building standpoint, from a community neighborhood standpoint? And then part two is sort of: what role does government have to play in facilitating and improving either home building, home ownership, and all these components?
Marc Andreessen
Well, look, cities were startups at one point, right? There are incredible stories if you go back far enough, like the creation of cities like Los Angeles or Washington, D.C., for that matter. In the 20th century, at least in the West, that kind of went out of fashion. It became sort of an intractable thing to try to do. There were some entrepreneurs who thought hard about it and gave shots at it. Walt Disney had a whole vision. The Disney company to this day has these planned communities that kind of come from that. Walt Disney actually had this thing called Epcot—the Experimental Prototype City of Tomorrow. You can see it in the museum in San Francisco. If you go to the museum, you can see it.
Host
Oh, is that right?
Okay, yeah. The whole thing. Well, I think they still have the Epcot. The part of Epcot that got built, I think, is still in Florida. So you can go visit, I think, the remnants of Epcot. So this was like sort of futurism from the 60s, kind of in Disney's. He passed away, and he wasn't able to fully develop Epcot, but he was kind of reaching in this direction towards the end of his career.
Marc Andreessen
And then, you know, there are other examples in the U.S. It's probably, what is it, Irvine, you know, took a big swing at this and actually has been very successful. And then, Venice, Abbot Kinney, sort of created the Venice Canal, a planned community. So there are various ideas like this. It's been a long time since somebody's really taken a hard swing. So basically what you have are legacy systems. You've got this sort of entrenched, complicated power system, local homeowners. It almost seems deterministic that if a city becomes successful, the local homeowner political base devotes itself to preventing the construction of new housing. It seems like a real trap.
Adam Neumann
I'll add to what Marc is saying. If a city was a business and it's an old business that's 30 years old, you'd say forget that business. We're going to start a new one. We're going to fund it and take over. The problem with cities is they're built. To go into a city now and change something simple—most of the city is concrete and roads where cars are driving. There are so many new solutions. Anybody who knows New York City saw what happened when Uber got bigger. The yellow taxis started disappearing. The medallions that used to cost a million three suddenly dropped. It is a very challenging thing to reimagine a city when it's already built.
There are things you can do. When you look at these buildings as single-standing villages—a building with 400 apartments—we can reimagine what happens inside of it. But reimagining a city is a big undertaking. One of the only places actually doing it is Saudi Arabia. I know some team members were just there. They're actually going for it. So there are places in the world right now where people are trying to build new cities. It's very innovative and impressive.
As for how government can help: there are technology companies and construction companies right now. There's a construction company called Icon that's using technology. The government is going to need to partner with them at some point because they have found ways to build a home in four days that used to take a year and a half. As we do more of those things, through innovative technologies, we'll be able to build fast enough to give people the courage to build a new city. But going into the old ones is very hard.
A crazy idea: office space now, with everything happening in office. Can you convert some of these dead offices into new ideas? You could think about that. I think the role of government has always been very important for this country. For us at Flow, this is another lesson from the past. We used to think we had to own everything. I think the category is so big that the only way we're going to achieve anything is through partnership—partnership with government, partnership with current players, and partnership with new players that are going to come. I think it's the only way to solve this problem.
I'll finish by saying that I actually think the housing crisis we described might be one of the biggest challenges the U.S. is facing today. The reason it's hard to understand is because if you really want to get it, it's five to ten years down the road. The problem with housing takes five to ten years. Marc, I agree with your assumption that we have about five years to do something really big about it. All I can tell you is I think we have the right team to give it a shot.
Host
Excellent. Well, thank you both for being here. This was a great discussion.
Marc Andreessen
Thank you.
Adam Neumann
Thanks, everybody.
Host
Thank you. As a reminder, this conversation was part of A16Z's American Dynamism Summit in Washington, D.C. You can find the full library of videos from the event in November by going to a16z.com/ad-summit. Thanks for listening to the A16Z podcast. If you like this episode, don't forget to subscribe, leave a review, or tell a friend. We also recently launched on YouTube at youtube.com/a16z_video, where you'll find exclusive video content. We'll see you next time.