Main Topic: The conversation revolves around the importance of seriousness, purpose, and making government cool again, as well as the role of technology in rebuilding trust in institutions and addressing societal challenges.
Key Points:
Catherine Boyle, general partner at Andreessen Horowitz, and the host of the podcast.
Takeaways:
Additional Insights:
Why does seriousness feel radical today? a16z General Partner Katherine Boyle joins The LaBossiere Podcast to explore what it means to build for the national interest—and why that starts with purpose.
Katherine, part of the American Dynamism team at a16z, shares how we got to a place where public service became uncool, how tech can help rebuild trust in government, and why suffering, friction, and responsibility are essential ingredients for growth. From the collapse of civic duty to the rise of meme-driven politics, they dig into the cultural forces shaping America—and the opportunity to reclaim a sense of mission.
They also discuss why Silicon Valley is more idea than place, what journalists and investors have in common, and why being laughed at might be the clearest sign you’re on the right path.
Timecodes:
0:00 - Intro
4:48 The Decline in Public Service
7:47 Making Government Cool Again
10:07 Silicon Valley’s Aversion to National Security
13:15 Positive Sum vs Zero Sum Cultures
16:27 China, Authoritarianism, and Doing Hard Things
19:27 What Makes America Special?
23:03 Silicon Valley and the “Real Economy”
26:28 Investing in Mature Markets
29:08 Vanna White and The Wheel of Fortune
30:27 Journalism and Loneliness
32:52 - Time and Suffering
38:10 - Seriousness and Purpose
41:11 - Is Culture Downstream of Technology?
42:48 - Propaganda and Coolness as a Strategic Asset
44:40 - Florida, Texas, and Regulatory Arbitrage
47:51 - DC, Silicon Valley, and Florida
50:20 - What Should More People Be Thinking About
Resources:
Find Katherine on X: https://x.com/KTmBoyle
Find Alex on X: https://x.com/adlabossiere
Listen to more from The LaBossiere Podcast:
YouTube: https://bit.ly/3QDLQFt
Apple: https://apple.co/478Be6M
Spotify: https://spoti.fi/3sfiFiE
Stay Updated:
Let us know what you think: https://ratethispodcast.com/a16z
Find a16z on X: https://twitter.com/a16z
Find a16z on LinkedIn: https://www.linkedin.com/company/a16z
Subscribe on your favorite podcast app: https://a16z.simplecast.com/
Follow our host: https://x.com/eriktorenberg
Please note that the content here is for informational purposes only; should NOT be taken as legal, business, tax, or investment advice or be used to evaluate any investment or security; and is not directed at any investors or potential investors in any a16z fund. a16z and its affiliates may maintain investments in the companies discussed. For more details please see a16z.com/disclosures.
Stay Updated:
Find a16z on X
Find a16z on LinkedIn
Listen to the a16z Podcast on Spotify
Listen to the a16z Podcast on Apple Podcasts
Follow our host: https://twitter.com/eriktorenberg
Please note that the content here is for informational purposes only; should NOT be taken as legal, business, tax, or investment advice or be used to evaluate any investment or security; and is not directed at any investors or potential investors in any a16z fund. a16z and its affiliates may maintain investments in the companies discussed. For more details please see a16z.com/disclosures.
Hosted by Simplecast, an AdsWizz company. See pcm.adswizz.com for information about our collection and use of personal data for advertising.
Host
Today's episode is a feed draw from the LaBoisier podcast and features A16Z general partner, Catherine Boyle. She's a part of our American Dynamism practice investing in companies that support the national interest across defense, manufacturing, education, and more. In this conversation, Catherine shares why she believes seriousness and purpose are underrated in today's culture, how tech can help rebuild trust in our institutions, and what it means to make government cool again. Let's get into it.
This information is for educational purposes only and is not a recommendation to buy, hold, or sell any investment or financial product. This podcast has been produced by a third party and may include paid promotional advertisements, other company references, and individuals unaffiliated with A16Z. Such advertisements, companies, and individuals are not endorsed by AH Capital Management, LLC, A16Z, or any of its affiliates. Information is from sources deemed reliable on the date of publication, but A16Z does not guarantee its accuracy.
Catherine Boyle
I think a society that completely tries to remove suffering from every part of our existence—and this is something tech has to deal with too, where the whole point of creating tech is to remove friction—we're trying to create this sort of frictionless society. Suffering is innate. It's what gives us character. It's what gives us resilience. If you have a childhood and an adolescence trying to remove any aspect of suffering and human nature from your experience, you do not grow up. You remain a child. It leads to people fumbling around in their 20s, acting as though they're still children. It leads to a society in which we still treat 30-year-olds as though they're kids.
Host
That is Catherine Boyle. She's a general partner at Andreessen Horowitz and co-founder of the firm's American Dynamism practice, which invests in companies supporting the national interest across aerospace, defense, manufacturing, energy, logistics, and critical infrastructure. To me, Catherine is a visionary. She was investing in defense technology before it was socially acceptable, let alone a consensus category, and more importantly, saw Silicon Valley, particularly post-COVID, for what it had become: not a place, but an idea. And that the next generation of great companies would be built outside the physical and ideological confines of the Bay Area.
Catherine Boyle
I knew something like Anduril was going to be an extraordinary company. Silicon Valley friends, colleagues, people at other venture firms were telling me one, I was an idiot, or worse, I was a fascist. But I do think it just took a long time. If there's greenfield places to build, that's always where people choose to build. But I think it took a long time for people to say, "Wow, there's the capital that can build these categories. There's examples of success." And I think now people are realizing that there are really unique attributes of the moat that you can build in these companies that allow them to scale to extraordinary sizes.
Host
Unsurprisingly, her ability to stand by her most unconventional ideas as an investor comes from an unconventional background. Before becoming an investor in San Francisco, Catherine was a reporter at the Washington Post, bringing with her a deep understanding of D.C. and the fundamental differences between the two coasts, making her a rare bridge between Capitol Hill and Silicon Valley. Perhaps most importantly, she highlights that over the last number of decades, we've seen a decline in public service that's led to a huge talent drain in government and a decay of many of our public institutions that's only now beginning to be addressed by the private sector—broadly making government cool again.
Catherine Boyle
I think it changed in 1973, and it was one of the most favorable things that Nixon did, which was he ended the draft. Heralded by the left and the right as something that was good, but I think symbolically what it said is, you no longer need to serve your country. This is a real crisis for America, that the best and brightest no longer want to serve in government, and that we have a crisis of the bureaucracy. But it has been a multi-decade problem that is finally being addressed.
Host
And maybe above anything, Catherine vouches for seriousness, the maniacal belief in a purpose greater than oneself, and being earnest in pursuing that. In a culture that's been so permeated by irony and critique and snark, it's important to remind ourselves that it's cool to try. That it's important to work hard at things that are important to you and to feel some duty outside yourself to a cause or mission, a god, a country, something bigger than just you.
Catherine Boyle
The American term "seriousness"—when we use it in that context, people think, "Oh, why do you take yourself so seriously?" And what they mean by that is you should have a sense of humor, you should laugh, you should enjoy life. I 100% agree with those things. But the opposite of seriousness is not laughter and humor. The opposite is irony. David Foster Wallace, I think, has the best definition of irony, where he says it's just this pulling apart of anything that is sacred. You pick at it and you nod at it and you pull it apart and you tear it down until there's absolutely nothing left of it.
Host
We spoke about making government cool again, lessons from journalism, authoritarianism and innovation, propaganda, irony and seriousness, and Vanna White, hostess of Wheel of Fortune. This is the La Bossier Podcast.
Sound clip: "We choose to go to the home. We deliver right to the desktop. We're going to reinvent the phone."
Oh, thanks again. Well, thank you so much for doing it.
Catherine Boyle
Yeah, thanks for having me. It's so good to see you.
Host
Likewise. I wanted to start with something that I think would frame a lot of the discussion we're going to have today pretty well, which is the sort of talent shift that we've seen across society over the last number of decades. To start off in 1989, you talk about this a lot. Paul Volcker, the former chairman of the Federal Reserve, referred to the decline in public service as a quiet crisis. American elites no longer felt this duty and social pressure to serve their country. Over decades, different industries become the most attractive and soak up a lot of the talent across society. It was government once, then it was Wall Street, and for the last decade or so, a lot of it's been tech. But what that means is the U.S. government of the 1940s, 50s, and 60s is a far cry from what we see today. We went to the moon and never went back. People point to some time around 1970 when something deeper broke. What happened here? What caused these shifts in the first place?
Catherine Boyle
I actually point to a very specific time, which I get a lot of pushback on. Everyone says something changed in 1971. There's that famous website "WTF happened in 1971?" I think it changed in 1973. It was a bipartisan, one of the most favorable things that Nixon did, which was he ended the draft. I think it was a very symbolic thing. Obviously, it was coming after a very unpopular war, Vietnam. It was heralded by the left and the right as something that was good. But I think symbolically what it said is you no longer need to serve your country. Only the volunteers need to serve their country. That actually led to a bifurcation in society where it used to be that the elites of our society—you didn't have honor, you didn't have dignity if you did not serve your country. So everyone served. That could be through various means, through serving in the military or serving in government. But it was understood that that sort of nobleness comes from serving in duty. That marks the moment where that changed.
Then you had the ripping and roaring of the 80s where it led a lot of people to say, "Okay, I want to work in finance," a lot of that elite class. You have this movement away from, "Okay, we don't have to work in the government. We don't have to serve in the way that historically generations before had." I had observed it, but I didn't realize that it was actually a bipartisan commission of Democrats and Republicans that did a multi-year long study and said in the 90s when it was published, "This is a real crisis for America, that the best and brightest no longer want to serve in government and that we have a crisis of the bureaucracy."
What is interesting is when I talked about that as a huge impetus for starting the American Dynamism practice—who could have predicted we'd be sitting here now talking about Doge, talking about the flip side of that, which is now the best and brightest in Silicon Valley want to go work in government and fix government because they see a pathway to do that. I think we have really come full circle on this conversation. But it has been a multi-decade problem that is finally being addressed.
Host
Let's get into a little bit more of how you fix that root problem. It seems like we're on a good trajectory here, but what are the actual levers? We'll get into how the private sector has been picking up a lot of the slack here and how you're approaching things on that front. But how do you fix the root of the problem ultimately? Government, it seems like it's changing now, but for the longest time it just wasn't the choice of America's best and brightest. What are the levers by which you change that?
Catherine Boyle
I wrote this piece maybe four or five years ago called "Make Government Cool Again." It was very much about the fact that everything that someone like Elon Musk touches—and I think Elon is singular in this way—turns to gold. It turns cool. Building rockets was seen as the most unsexy thing you could have possibly done when he started SpaceX. I often say in 2000, it was right after September 11th when he started SpaceX. The world was not looking up to the stars. We were looking at a completely different trajectory for America. We just had the largest terrorist attack in American history on our soil. Then two years later, almost exactly two years later, you had the Space Shuttle Columbia disaster. No one was thinking of doing that, and yet he was able to attract people like Tom Mueller, some of the best talent. He created this extraordinary company. I think he's the singular recruiter of talent and capital.
In some ways, what you're seeing now that he's interested in government—and we're seeing it even at a very practical level—some of the smartest people in our ecosystems and our firm, people want to go work and serve their country. We often make problems really dramatic, like the commission: "How are we going to attract great people?" Well, maybe you just need cool people to want to do it. Young people want to work with their friends. They want to work with people they admire. If you make it an attractive proposition of, "Hey, you're going to go work in the government. You're going to get to fix things. You're not going to be bogged down by bureaucracy. It's going to be the same way that Elon's talking about Doge now, which is 20-hour days working with some of the smartest people you've ever met"—that's exciting for the best talent.
There have been so many ideas bandied about of, "Oh, it's a crisis of how much we pay people," which I do think is a problem, but I don't think it's the underlying issue. The underlying issue is it's not seen as an elite profession. I think that's changing now in a way that I couldn't have predicted five years ago when I wrote that.
Host
Another big part of this broader cultural shift and drain from the public sector led to a lot of apathy toward defense and national security in particular, which you talk about in the context of some of your investments in defense tech earlier on. What actually caused that broader cultural aversion to defense in particular? You point to Project Maven at Google as being a wake-up moment for you. But is that coolness? What changed in defense?
Catherine Boyle
There are a variety of reasons why Silicon Valley—and their historic reasons—but I think it gets deeper than what I've talked about in the past. One is that people always used to say, "You can't really understand what you don't see." When I lived in Washington—I know you're originally from Washington—you go on the metro, you see people in their uniforms going to the Pentagon. You are constantly around people who serve their country. You're constantly around the military. It is a normal pattern of life. One of the problems of Silicon Valley is that it is not a normal pattern of life. It is very rare to see someone who was in their military uniform going to work in defense. So that's one part of it—it was just so abstract for a lot of the people who are there.
I also think there's a broader issue that's come up in recent moments where Silicon Valley has this cloistered city-state ecosystem into itself where sometimes people don't even feel connected to the broader issues of the country. I think that's a real problem we don't talk enough about in Silicon Valley that's kind of coming to a head. Why is this ecosystem, which has allowed it to become America's dynamism engine—it is where we are the envy of the world in the fact that we can take young people who are just really good at math and engineering and build these extraordinary companies with risk capital. No one else has that. It's an extraordinary feature of America. But in some ways, the reason why it can do that is because it's so divorced from New York. It's so divorced from D.C. It's so divorced from the other cultural centers of America. Part of that is it's divorced from the issues that Washington cares about. That has been a feature for a long time, but let that fester for decades, and what you see is an ecosystem that has no relationship to the issues of most Americans.
That was where Silicon Valley was headed in 2010, 2011, 2012, where we're only going to focus on the digital world. We're not going to focus on the physical. We certainly aren't going to work in defense because there's this whole other problem where Silicon Valley became elite. A lot of the young people going there were out of the top universities, and defense was a no-no issue. No one would ever want to touch that if you went to Harvard or Princeton or Yale or Stanford. These are not the places that you're going to focus on defense. Defense was seen as an issue that no one would touch. It's low status. The low status aspect of working in government, working in the military—things that shifted over the last couple of decades—I think you're finally seeing that shift back, the pendulum swinging back even harder, where people recognize how important these industries are, how American defense is so essential. But again, it took people like Elon and Palmer making it cool. It also took the wake-up realization of watching a land war in Europe, which many of these young people had never even considered was a possibility.
Host
Another thing you talk about in this context is the fundamental differences between Silicon Valley and Washington, D.C., and that the biggest difference is often cultural. Silicon Valley is this fundamentally positive sum, long-term time horizon place because anyone around you can create the next big thing. Whereas D.C. is zero sum with short time horizons because you're either in power or out of a job. This is a bit more abstract, but do you think government can be made positive sum in any way? If not, how do you reconcile those two coasts?
Catherine Boyle
I don't think you can change the games people are playing. Fundamentally, the incentives are driven by the game. There are things you can do around the edges, but just hearing you say that, I was reflecting—I was just in Washington, D.C., and the hierarchy is so visible in D.C. in the way that it is not visible in Silicon Valley. You can go to the dish in Menlo Park and see some of the most successful people in Silicon Valley just walking around having coffee with young entrepreneurs. When I was back in Washington, D.C. today, there were traffic stops because of different cabinet officials with their motorcades or the VP was going somewhere, with 10 different cars. The president doesn't go anywhere without an entire entourage. The status and the hierarchy of where you are in the pecking order is so ingrained in how Washington works. It has to be. We have to have a clear order of functioning government and know who's in charge. It's become more apparent than ever why that is so important and why we need that security.
If you were in Washington, you know where you are in the pecking order constantly. The staff sits back. You know who's important. Everyone in Congress wears a pin because they are important in Washington. That does not exist in Silicon Valley. In fact, it's the opposite. Everyone wears the exact same outfit. Everyone dresses down, wants to blend in. There's this view that we can read between the lines of who's really important, but no one's ever going to throw that in your face because the next big thing could be just around the horizon and we're all playing for the next big change. I don't know that we can ever change those systems. But what I do think is Washington can learn a lot more about how Silicon Valley functions, and Silicon Valley can learn a lot more about how Washington functions. This is the first time where you're seeing so many venture firms, so many executives really taking the time to understand how Washington functions.
The inauguration, seeing all of the CEOs of America's most important tech companies lined up there—I think it shows that there has been this coming together of Silicon Valley and D.C. again. Going back into my archive, when I was writing about these things, I would have never foreseen that this would have ever happened. To me, I'm shell shocked that you saw all of the CEOs at church, sitting in St. John's behind the president at the inauguration. I'm just like, "Is this real?" There's something that has happened where the merging of Washington and our tech ecosystem—I don't even want to say Silicon Valley, it's America's tech ecosystem—is finally working together with the government. That is such a good thing for this country.
Host
Maybe it's Silicon Valley the idea rather than Silicon Valley the place, in a lot of ways.
Catherine Boyle
Yeah.
Host
To go from nationally to more broadly geopolitical, this is a high-level big question. On the topic of China, it seems like there are basically two camps with respect to them and technology. On one hand, you have a pretty valid criticism of China—without infantilizing them in any way or their ability to take anything from zero to one—which is essentially through the act of their IP theft against the US. You might argue that an authoritarian system actually chokes a society's individual agency necessary for doing anything hard or pulling off anything new. But on the other hand, things like the Apollo or Manhattan Projects or any of these huge engineering feats were these top-down mandates. To be crystal clear, I'm pro-democracy to the alternative, but is an authoritarian system actually net better if your only goal is to build hard things? How do you think about that trade-off within the system that we thrive in and do well in, but has those intrinsic trade-offs?
Catherine Boyle
I think the counter to your narrative would be if SpaceX hadn't existed. But your point on whether an authoritarian top-down focus is necessary to do hard things—yes, but we can now build it in a company with a singular founder like Elon Musk. I do think there is a third path there. It's shown by the fact that SpaceX is the most valuable company in America, but it does take a once-in-a-generation leader. That leadership, whether it's political leadership or leadership in a company, takes someone who is maniacally focused on the details and does have what you could call authoritarian control. The way Elon runs his companies, he is in the weeds of every engineering decision. That is not a typical HBS "this is how we run companies" sort of CEO. This is someone who is very, very in the weeds and understands that he is the leader of that company.
Palmer has actually talked a lot about what you just said—that we are in some ways behind because the CCP can control all of its best talent and direct them. You have to be working on this. That actually puts us on the back foot when America can't recruit the right engineers to work on important companies. But Palmer was saying that in 2017 when there was one defense company, or there were one or two—it was Shield AI, Anduril, there were a handful of companies actually working on this. Yes, SpaceX, but SpaceX hadn't gone as deeply into defense or working on some of the things they're working on now. I actually think it's extraordinary the path that America has taken, that these companies have taken, where eight years later, you now have a whole Silicon Valley ecosystem dedicated to national security and defense that didn't exist before. In some ways, I think that's a favorable showing of capitalism, where if you make things cool, if you make them interesting, if you have great leaders, make the category sexy, a lot of young talent will flock there without being told by a dictator, "You have to go work on this issue."
Host
I think this is a really good segue to talking about the country as a whole. I think the most brilliant part of what you've done with the American Dynamism practice is that instead of underwriting a category, like you might at a regular venture fund, you decided to underwrite a nation. If nothing else, it's clear that for its entire existence, America has been a pretty bad thing to bet against. I think sometimes you reference Alexis de Tocqueville, this 19th century French sociologist and political scientist, who says boldness of the enterprise is the key to the country's success. Culturally, geopolitically, spiritually, even structurally, what do you think makes this place so special?
Catherine Boyle
What makes America so special? If we go back to even this election, and the conversations happening now between tech and the mandate that the government has, there is this important thing that JD Vance—who I think understands the fusion between tech and government better than anyone—says: "America is a nation. We are not just an idea." I very much believe that as well. This is a place. It has a history. It has a culture. It's a fusion of some of the most extraordinary ideas that have ever existed in terms of liberal democracy, but also understanding that there is a culture to what makes America great, while coupling it with extraordinary freedom, liberalism, and capitalism that just does not exist anywhere else. I think you have the fusion.
I would argue that we are a Judeo-Christian nation. That is our history. There is so much about the ideas of helping thy neighbor, the family as an institution being in many ways—and throughout our era until very recently, I would say—just as important as the state. The federalist model, where we have states competing against each other, where there's this federal authority but also state authority that manages a lot of the local issues. We are such a unique political country in terms of our politics and the way the country is structured. It is so unique and different than any other country. Add to that the fact that we have this extreme drive that has existed—and Tocqueville writes about it better than anyone—this extreme drive to constantly improve and constantly tame the land, make things more abundant, that is unlike any other people in the world.
What I just said, none of it actually makes sense. It's all dichotomies. We're an idea in terms of all these ideas that were fused together at the founding of our country, but we're also a nation of people. We have a Judeo-Christian ethos, but at the same time, we have this ruthless capitalism that leads to the flourishing of companies. These are all contradictions, but they are contradictions that make this country extremely beautiful. I feel like I could write a book about what makes this country so extraordinary.
The reason why American Dynamism is underwriting a country—which I love that you said that—and underwriting the ethos of America and not underwriting a type of software, is because the problems that matter to most people in America change over time. If you set up a practice that is constantly focused on what are the biggest issues that technology can serve the American people on, they're going to change. They're going to change because of who's in power. They're going to change because of what the country deems to be its most important issues. But I also think there's always going to be problems to fix, and technology can always serve those efforts.
Host
Totally. I think something really interesting you've tapped into through the American Dynamism practice is that there's been this larger movement. We were just talking about Silicon Valley becoming an idea rather than a place, maybe accelerated by COVID. Out of this B2B SaaS bubble of Silicon Valley and into the rest of the country, this is reflected in the industries you're investing in—things like education, public safety, and advanced manufacturing—as well as the actual geographies these companies are being built in. I think as of 18 months after launching the practice, you hadn't invested in anything in San Francisco at that point.
Catherine Boyle
We have now, by the way. I personally have two investments in San Francisco now. So it's not totally over. Not by a long shot.
Host
There's a more consensus understanding now that most of our technological progress has happened in software over the last couple decades. But what kicked off this movement into the "real economy" and the rest of the country? What was the catalyst for that explosion?
Catherine Boyle
I don't take as hard of a line as some people who invest in this category that SaaS is bad or that software isn't interesting. In some ways, the best companies in our portfolio are a fusion of hardware and software. Software, to use Marc Andreessen's term, is magic. It is eating the world. It is everywhere. The big thing that has changed is that software is also now supporting government. Part of the reason why it took so long is because you can't be what you can't see. If you haven't seen any success stories—venture capitalists are the most mimetic people—why would you invest in categories where there haven't been successes?
Host
So it took a long time for Palantir. It took a very, very long time for Palantir to show that it was worth working with government. It took a very, very long time for SpaceX to get to the point where reusability excited investors. I remember when SpaceX went out for a round and they were talking about Starlink, and this was 2018 or 2019. The number of investors that were like, "Starlink is never going to happen, or it's going to take forever, and they think it's going to happen so fast." And look at where we are now. The story of Silicon Valley is people doubting Elon, and it's like, never doubt Elon. He always does what he says he's going to do.
Catherine Boyle
But I do think it just took a long time. If there's white space and greenfield places to build, that's always where people choose to build. It took a long time for people to say, "Wow, there's the capital that can build these categories. There's examples of success in SpaceX, Tesla, Anduril. There's examples of people who can get through the defense valley of death, to use your term, the real economy." It is hard to compete with incumbents. Now people are realizing that there are really unique attributes of the moat you can build in these companies that allow you to scale to extraordinary sizes. That is fueling this moment where limited partners and investors are saying, "This is a real category of innovation, and it's going to be with us for a long time. We've done all the things in the digital world, or there's less white space there because we've been working on that for 15, 20 years. Now let's go bring this fusion of hardware and software together to a lot of categories that have been ignored."
Host
Let's dig into that a little bit. Something interesting about the kind of investing you do here is that a lot of it is retrofitting, rebuilding, or supercharging legacy industries. But the industries themselves aren't set to 100x over the next 10 years. The usual VC calculus seems like, if you're investing early in social networking or e-commerce or mobile, those markets themselves are going to 100x over the next 10 years. How do you think about the size of outcomes here, but how long it actually takes for these types of companies to reach scale and compound?
Catherine Boyle
This is going to sound like such a cop-out answer, but I think venture capitalists are very bad at predicting TAM. We are so bad at it, we shouldn't even have the TAM conversation when we talk about companies. Maybe it's early-stage investor privilege that I get to say that, but it's almost comical how bad we are at this. I have a theory of why we're so bad at this.
I don't think the Harvard Business School case study method of building a spreadsheet, going to work at Goldman Sachs, looking at comps of other companies that existed 20 years ago to predict TAM is an exercise we should be doing if we're trying to predict the future. If you actually believe that technology and software is this magical thing that can create new markets, how does a company built in 1980 that has reached a certain terminal value predict what's going to happen in the next 20 years? We use that methodology stolen from banking. That's what investment bankers do. We say, "This is the best proxy we can do." We look at financial models and say, "This is how big a company is going to get," knowing full well it is not at all going to predict the future. It's a tool. But when people sit down and actually talk about it, it's a tool, but it actually leads us astray from our actual instincts about where things are going.
So I don't really try to predict TAM. I'm not going to say I know better than an Elon Musk or a Palmer Luckey. When people were looking at Anduril in the early rounds, the expected size of what Anduril could become was comical, the conversations people were having back in the day and where the company is now. If I've learned anything, and it's been humbling, in the last 10 years of investing, it's never to think that something is just going to stop growing. Never to think that a company is in a small market and therefore we shouldn't invest in it. It is so obvious to me now that this is the thing we are the worst at as investors: predicting how big something can be in the future.
Host
I want to shift gears totally for a second and talk about your background. Before becoming an investor, you worked as a writer at the Washington Post and left right after Bezos bought the paper in 2014. You wrote such eclectic stories. You wrote everything from museum finance to performance art and the longtime hostess of Wheel of Fortune. Great profile.
Catherine Boyle
That was a good profile. That was a really fun one to do.
Host
Actually, can we go off on a tangent there?
Catherine Boyle
Of course.
Host
I took a guy who had spent many years covering the war in Iraq with me as my photographer for three days to Las Vegas to cover Vanna White, the hostess of Wheel of Fortune. He said to me maybe halfway through, "This is the weirdest, one of the strangest. I don't want to say it was the hardest, but this is weirder to me than being dropped in a war zone." I'm like, "Yeah, it's kooky." It was a strange moment to go back in time. There are these obsessives who love this game show. I love the game show. I grew up watching it with my grandparents. Wheel of Fortune is still on the air. Vanna White's still kicking. It was the only job she's ever had, and yet no one had really ever talked to her. So I did this story on her. The memories of actually reporting that story and going with someone who had spent a long time in a war zone was really, really funny.
Catherine Boyle
It's funny. I've heard you get asked this question a lot: what did journalism teach you about investing? I am really curious, is there anything that journalism taught you that is difficult or impossible to learn otherwise that transfers really well to investing?
Host
Gosh, that's a good question. What it taught me, as I reflect on why it wasn't a hard transition for me, is that journalism is an innately lonely profession. It is a very lonely profession in the same way that investing is lonely. Even though you're on a team—I was on a great team at the Washington Post and I'm on a great team now at Andreessen Horowitz—at the end of the day, it is your name on that investment. It is your byline on that story. If you were wrong, it is very public failure. You have to stand by it. The thing it taught me at a young age, because I started reporting when I was 24, is that you have to wake up every day, put your name on something, and deal with the consequences of putting your name very publicly on something.
That was as Twitter was really emerging. There was a point in my career where I had a lot of people completely tearing down my stories. Every time I would publish a story, I would just think, "Okay, now the trolls are going to come after me." You have to build a very thick skin, but you also have to feel very strong about your convictions and where the world is headed. That is what makes great investors. If you haven't learned how to stand out in the crowd, or stand out from the crowd alone, and really stand by something you believe in and be torn down publicly for it, it is very difficult to do that when we're attaching big numbers to it.
In some ways, I'm very grateful that I started in journalism because it's small stakes. If I'm wrong about a story or if I get a fact wrong or if a source is upset at me and they're yelling at me, it builds this sort of thick skin. It was not hard for me to make a transition where when I knew something like Anduril was going to be an extraordinary company, and Silicon Valley friends, colleagues, people at other venture firms were telling me I was an idiot or worse, I was a fascist, that didn't hit as hard as I think it would have hit had I never worked at an investment bank and always had air cover. If I had gone the traditional route, I think I would have backed off my beliefs a lot quicker if I hadn't built that muscle at the Washington Post.
Catherine Boyle
Okay, shifting gears one more time. There's this really great quote from a profile Max Mayer did of you in Arena Magazine that goes, "If 'live, laugh, love' was the bland life maxim of Gen X, then Boyle's reply is 'time, purpose, suffering.'" I want to dig into some of the belief system you held long before it was politically correct or consensus. Why don't we start with the first in that trio, which is time. We often forget it, but the most famous of America's founding fathers were in their early 20s and 30s at the founding of this country. Today, it seems like the average age of accomplishment has gone up. The hallmarks of adulthood—when you get your first job, when you move out of your parents' place, when you get married, buy a house, have kids, let alone found a country—have all gone up drastically, particularly if you're more educated. Why did this happen?
Host
I think there are a lot of reasons why it happened, but I can talk to you about why I think time is so important and why it's always been on my mind. A very personal story: my father was 55 years old when I was born, and he was in the hospital when I was born. He was in heart failure. So I was always as a kid obsessed with the fact that the earlier you're exposed to death, the more you realize how precious life is and how fast it goes. Thankfully, he survived, and he died almost 20 years ago now, but I had a lot of extra time with him. I was always aware that every moment counted.
It's related to the third one you said, which is suffering. A society that completely tries to remove suffering from every part of our existence—and this is something tech has to deal with too, where the whole point of creating tech is to remove friction, and we're trying to create this frictionless society, and our legal system is trying to remove any kind of suffering from society—suffering is innate. It's what gives us character. It's what gives us resilience. The huge part of time that is related to that is if you have a childhood and an adolescence where the parenting model and the schooling model, the education system, is trying to remove any aspect of suffering and human nature from your experience, you do not grow up. You remain a child.
You can talk to anyone who's been in business for a long time, any industry. When I talk to government agencies, everyone is dealing with the exact same thing: the young people coming out of universities, in many cases, have not grown up. They haven't had friction in their lives. They haven't had suffering. They've had an entire system around them that has told them that suffering is weird. So they act younger than the 22-year-olds who had served their country in some way. They do not have the resilience to cope with the modern world. I do think there is an importance of suffering that we've tried to eradicate from daily life. When we've done that, it has led to this lack of resilience. When you're talking about the importance of time, it leads to people just fumbling around in their twenties, acting as though they're still children. It leads to a society in which we still treat 30-year-olds as if they're kids, versus the people who should be getting married, having families, and becoming fully functioning members of society.
Catherine Boyle
Okay, let's skip ahead to suffering for a second, because this is super interesting. You talk about friction in the context of technology. It seems like common hardships like the draft and even childbirth used to bond society, and removing them can exacerbate this broader crisis of meaning. We'll probably have synthetic wombs in some amount of time. The question is this: if technology is by definition something that reduces suffering, and less suffering makes us less resilient, doesn't technology necessarily make us less resilient as individuals? And if so, can we supplement that at all?
Host
Not necessarily. Technology should make life more abundant. It should give us more resources. It should make life easier in many ways. But contrast that with the most important technology company in America, which is SpaceX. What does Elon talk about? He talks about grinding 20 hours, sleeping on the factory floor, pushing so that we can bring humanity to Mars. They're two sides of the same coin. We can remove friction from certain parts of our lives, but we have to have a culture that demands that we continue to reach our purpose, that demands that we continue to work, that demands that we continue to build.
That's actually the real problem. It's not technology in and of itself. It's that when you remove all friction from life, when you tell people that suffering is bad, when you tell people that there's no meaning to life—which is a whole other portion of this, this ironic culture of "Why are we even here? What are we doing? Why does it even matter?"—that has been driving American elite culture since the 70s. That is the huge problem. You can have abundance and you can have purpose and you can have drive, but you have to have a culture that celebrates that. You have to have leaders and celebrate leaders like the Palmers and the Elons who are constantly pushing humanity forward.
Catherine Boyle
We move from time to suffering, but to come back to purpose for a quick second. There's a belief you hold that seriousness, this maniacal belief in a project greater than oneself, is something we lost admiration for. I think you're a pretty serious person. There's this cool anecdote that when you were at the Post, you insisted on using the front door even though the side door was closer to the Metro. You went to the newsroom every Sunday because nobody else was there, because you thought it was a quiet place to write. Why have we lost our admiration of seriousness? Maybe it gets back toward that topic of irony you were talking about.
Host
I'm glad you pointed that out. When the American term "seriousness" is used in that context, people think, "Why do you take yourself so seriously?" What they mean is you should have a sense of humor, you should laugh, you should enjoy life. I 100% agree with those things. But the opposite of seriousness is not laughter and humor. The opposite is irony. David Foster Wallace has the best definition of irony, where he says it's just this pulling apart of anything that is sacred. You pick at it, you gnaw at it, you pull it apart, you tear it down until there's absolutely nothing left of it. I always get this image of art critics: someone puts forward this great beautiful piece of something, and you just pick at it and gnaw at it and completely deconstruct everything good about the thing. That is irony. That is the sort of driving voice in many cases.
When I look at what is the dominant force of the internet, what is the dominant voice on the internet, it's not earnestness. I think it's coming back to earnestness, thankfully, and we're seeing changes with X. But for a long time, it was snark. It was this snarky, "I'm too cool for school" sort of vibe. That is not how you achieve great things. How you achieve great things is earnestness. It is seriousness. It is understanding your purpose. It is believing so much in this thing that you were put on this earth to do. I've talked about how you know you're headed towards seriousness of purpose when people are laughing at you. When your entire ecosystem, bathed in this snark and irony, is just saying, "That's absurd," you should feel like you're sort of Pollyanna-ish and too optimistic. You should feel that tension. If you feel that tension, you know you've stumbled upon this purpose and the seriousness that is important to do any sort of great thing.
Founders are a microcosm of that. If you talk to any great founder, you hear how they were laughed at in the earliest stages. They're not laughed at in the end. Sometimes they are, actually. But they're not laughed at when they've become successful, because we admire successful people. In those early days, people will ruthlessly gnaw apart a founder. I think that is because the people on the outside are deeply ironic, and the founder is the serious archetype.
Catherine Boyle
Okay, let's talk about media for a second. In interviews you've given, I always notice you referring to movies and TV shows a lot when answering questions. You talk about Mad Men a lot. You talk about The Departed, 1917. Do you think culture is downstream of technology? Is technology downstream of culture? Or is it self-referential? What do you think?
Host
For a very long time, America's exporting city was Los Angeles. When I was watching the fires in this visceral way, I was thinking, "This is America's cultural city." But I do think we're now seeing that a lot of American culture, particularly meme culture, which I think is driving more of the universe, is downstream of technology, and particularly the tech industry. That's why tech is being so demonized, partially because of that. Tech is now controlling a lot of the films we watch. Do people go to the theater anymore? No, they go to Netflix. All of our cultural elements are now downstream of what the algorithm and what tech tells us we should be doing. There's this concentration of power that's interesting.
But I do think the art we create is the best representation of who we are. It is somewhat circular, but it can also deeply impact a generation. We have to be very careful about the art we ingest into ourselves and be very careful about how we question memes, how we question the messages given to us. If we imbibe too much of them, I think it does lead the culture astray.
Catherine Boyle
This is an interesting follow-through. It seems like a basic truth we're getting at is that something being cool can play a really big role in something being successful, attracting talent. Companies and funds play into this. It helps attract talent, get access to investment or capital. If coolness is a strategic asset, should the government do marketing? Is propaganda, if we can use that word neutrally, actually in the national interest?
Host
Certainly. I think there should be a chief marketing officer of America. That would be a dream job. That would be so much fun. But I think we also have that in our leaders. You can point to the recent election of President Trump. So much of it is that he understands meme culture. So much of it is that he is a meme himself, and he is a vibe. There are a lot of people who've talked about the vibe shift, the vibe election, the meme election. These are things that are now obvious. To really do anything—whether it's found a company, run for office, start a business, anything you want to do—you really have to understand vibes, memes, culture, and how they play through the digital world. There's this universe of "touch grass" or "the internet is not real life." People used to say Twitter is not real life. Yes, it is. They are now merging. You have to understand all of the aspects of how aesthetics and vibes are going to affect the message you bring. 100%, countries do propaganda, obviously. But I think it would be really fun to have an office of memes, which I would love. That would be an amazing job.
Catherine Boyle
As a closing thought here, it seems like this resurgence of federalism you were talking about before, and state-by-state competition for residents post-COVID, is real. The product of geography is sort of becoming higher variance. You were a part of that movement. You left California for Florida. What do you think has made Florida and Texas so successful in that shift? If you were governor, what would you be doing to compete right now?
Host
That's a good question. You've rightly pointed out that Florida is a political project. Some in the industry have said it's going to be the tech ecosystem to compete. I think these are 30-year projects, not three-year projects. But Florida is inherently a political experiment. A lot of the reasons why people have moved are policy reasons, not necessarily related to industries here. There's a geographical reason also why people move to Florida. But there's a political focus that's really interesting.
If I'm being honest about why I moved to Florida, one, I'm from here. I love the culture of Florida. It's a very different state. We're in South Florida, but go north of Orlando and it is a completely different culture. It's an agricultural state. Part of the reason why Florida is so politically powerful right now is because when Jeb Bush was governor in the 90s, he started this program called Bright Futures Scholarships. He encouraged any top student in Florida to get paid to go to any state university they wanted to go to in Florida. A lot of the brightest students in my graduating class didn't leave the state. They took money from not only a full scholarship, but they literally made money going to school. They got paid thousands of dollars every semester to do whatever they wanted to. That meant that a lot of great talent decided to stay in the state.
What's very interesting about the top universities in Florida is that a lot of the wealth and industry is in South Florida, but the best universities are in the northern part of the state, the agricultural part. You have this really interesting meshing of cultures. If you're a person who grew up in Miami, maybe you come from a family of Cuban immigrants, and you go to University of Florida, you're now interfacing with people who live on farms. Then you go back to Miami and you have this understanding of the culture that I don't think you get in different states in the same way. That's why we're seeing now how many people in this administration are coming from Florida. It's a very politically powerful state. Texas has a similar sort of energy where a lot of people stay in the state. There are a lot more reasons to move to a state that has enterprise but also has really favorable policies to business. It has sort of opted out of the elite system. People who moved to Florida in the last few years, people who moved to Texas, have inherently opted themselves and their families out of a system they don't necessarily want to be a part of anymore.
Catherine Boyle
You've sort of seen all sides of this. Granted, this is home for you, but you left Florida for D.C., you left D.C. for Silicon Valley, and you saw both of those places for what they were, but you decided to come back. A lot of people ask you what D.C. can learn from Silicon Valley or vice versa. But what do you think Silicon Valley and D.C. can learn from Florida?
Host
That's such a great question. I left Florida for the great reason I think a lot of young people leave: I wanted to spread my wings. I had a wonderful childhood, but I wanted to spread my wings. My obsession was politics. I was going to go to Washington. If you were going to work in politics, you needed to go to D.C. Then I got a little bit disillusioned and saw that a lot of the things I would have loved to see enacted couldn't exist inside of how Washington functions. That led me to Silicon Valley. There is this story of disillusionment and waking up and becoming an adult.
What D.C. and Silicon Valley can learn from Florida is that Florida is such a diverse state. I don't mean that in the DEI way we talk about it. There are so many different ecosystems of people who actually have a lot in common. South Florida is one of the most family-friendly places where you can build a life, build a home. Miami has more foreign-born people than any other city in America. You have people who've moved from New York. I always joke that just north of Miami is the sixth borough of New York. Then you get to Orlando, which used to be orange groves, and now it's Disney World, the cultural center for children.
Then you get just north of that and you get to this incredible farm, southern history. It's all in one place. Because people have to interact with each other due to how the university systems work, or if you want to stay in Florida, you kind of have to interact with all of America in Florida in a way that if you're living in San Francisco or New York City, you don't necessarily have to. There's a lot we can learn from that interaction. You learn from your neighbors. You learn from your people. But Florida also still has this incredible optimism. It's still the frontier. It feels new in a way that a lot of other places don't.
That's what excites me most about it.
Catherine Boyle
I know we're coming up on time. I have one more question for you. It's the same one I ask at the end of every interview: what should more people be thinking about?
More people should be thinking about their calling. It goes back to this question of purpose. It is something that I do think we have to spend a lot of time reflecting on, praying on, meditating on, whatever it is. Why am I here? What am I supposed to be doing? We have such a limited amount of time. Time is the most important asset.
I do think that reflection on why you have been sent here, this unique reason why you are on this earth — it's not to consume our phones. It's clearly not all those things. But what it is is something that I think takes deep reflection. The earlier you start reflecting on it, the more fulfillment in life you will have.
Catherine, that's all I got for you. Thank you so much for doing this.
Host
Thank you so much. So good seeing you.
End of interview
Thanks for listening to the A16Z podcast. If you enjoyed the episode, let us know by leaving a review at ratethispodcast.com slash A16Z. We've got more great conversations coming your way. See you next time.