Podcast Episode Summary
The A6D&T podcast episode discusses the emerging model of gaming called Play-to-Earn (P2E), where players can earn real money by playing games. The main topic is Axie Infinity, a popular P2E game that has made over $3 billion in sales since its launch in 2018. The episode features an interview with Jeff Zerlin, co-founder of Sky Mavis, the company behind Axie Infinity, and Gabby Dizon, co-founder of Yield Guild Games (YGG), a P2E gaming guild.
Key Points:
Takeaways:
Participants:
Main Topic: Play-to-Earn (P2E) gaming model and Axie Infinity.
Zoran Basich
Welcome to the A16Z podcast. I'm Zoran. Today we're talking about an emerging model of gaming called play-to-earn, where players can make actual money based on the time and effort they put into a game. This isn't about streaming revenue for top players or esports, but about day-to-day gameplay. Play-to-earn is part of broader trends—the changing relationship between players and platforms, new incentives for participants in blockchain-based networks, and the new internet era known as Web3.
The top play-to-earn game is Axie Infinity, operated by Sky Mavis, a Vietnam-based company. Players acquire unique digital pets called Axies, battle other teams, and these NFT Axies can be created and sold using the game's currency, SLP, which can be converted to traditional currency. Think of it as Pokémon on the blockchain with a built-in social network and an actual economy, including companies that help players get started by loaning them money.
Since launching in March 2018, Axie Infinity has made over $3 billion in sales, with much of its early growth in the Philippines. Remember, none of this should be taken as investment advice. Please visit A16Z.com/disclosures for more information.
Our guests today are Jeff Zirlin, co-founder of Sky Mavis; Gabby Dizon, co-founder of Yield Guild Games, a play-to-earn gaming guild; and Arianna Simpson, A16Z crypto general partner. They discuss the tech trends enabling play-to-earn, its early adoption, community role, challenges like onboarding and scalability, and the model's economic sustainability. They also explore what play-to-earn says about the future of work.
Jeff Zirlin
The play-to-earn concept took about four years to develop. Many original Axie community members and founders came from the CryptoKitties community, where we saw that producing NFTs needed to relate to work and effort to prevent hyperinflation. Initially, we had experience points for breeding Axies, which players wanted to trade. We tokenized them, and players created a liquidity pool on Uniswap. This let us calculate an expected hourly wage for playing Axie. In January 2020, we saw the intersection of NFTs and DeFi, which we called play-to-earn.
Gabby Dizon
I joined Axie in late 2018 as a player. During the lockdown, Filipinos discovered Axie as an escape from economic hardship. These weren't crypto enthusiasts but people who needed income. I started Yield Guild Games to scale access through a scholarship program, providing Axies to those who couldn't afford them, initially in the Philippines, then across Southeast Asia, India, Latin America, and beyond. We invest in assets and inform communities about games where they can participate and earn without upfront costs.
Zoran Basich
What made the Philippines a growth spot for Axie?
Jeff Zirlin
The Philippines has a culture that loves mobile games, high crypto literacy, and a communal culture where trends spread quickly. Filipinos were early adopters of platforms like Facebook. These factors helped Axie break out, though it's only about nine months ahead of other emerging markets. This suggests a broader movement where value creators share in the upside, a core Web3 belief.
Arianna Simpson
The transition is about removing middlemen like app stores and game publishers who take 50%+ revenue. Axie shares value with the community, driving traction without extraction. This is an unstoppable movement, sharing value with creators and users.
Zoran Basich
How sustainable is this economic model?
Jeff Zirlin
Axie is currently growth-dependent, like an emerging market. Long-term, it needs players engaged for fun or trading, not just earnings. As Axie becomes a social network, more value exchanges emerge. We've framed Axie as both a game and a social network since the start.
Arianna Simpson
Managing capital and token supply in these metaverses is complex. Having diverse player motivations—fun, coaching, financial gain—keeps the ecosystem robust, similar to real-world economies.
Zoran Basich
How do capital flows balance between the economy and fiat?
Jeff Zirlin
Only 4% of Axies are for sale, showing emotional connection beyond money. People stay engaged for opportunities, social networks, and fun. The economy is balanced as we grow, but long-term sustainability requires keeping the community and game enjoyable.
Arianna Simpson
The community's shared economic and cultural alignment is key. Early adopters transfer their ideals to newcomers, fostering enthusiasm and referrals. Community-driven onboarding educates and integrates new users effectively.
Zoran Basich
How does this model's portability affect competition?
Jeff Zirlin
Axie is more than a game; it's a nation with shared culture, economy, and social ties. Uprooting such a community is hard, as seen in real-world Axie meetups and Discord activity. The network effect deepens as more people own Axies and land, making migration unlikely.
Arianna Simpson
Web3 communities are opt-in with shared ownership and incentives. People stay because they choose to, building culture and value together. This alignment makes communities resilient.
Zoran Basich
How are user behaviors and participation evolving?
Gabby Dizon
We help players transition from gamers to investors. Initially, they earn to cover bills, but as they gain excess income, they invest in Axies for others or buy land. This mindset shift is crucial for sustainability.
Jeff Zirlin
Challenges include onboarding complexity. We're developing a tutorial with free starter Axies to lower entry barriers. Partnerships improve payment processes, and community support enhances onboarding.
Arianna Simpson
Community replaces middlemen like Facebook and Google, onboarding users organically. This approach turns users into individuals creating content and earning, transforming daily active users into engaged participants.
Zoran Basich
What future jobs might emerge from this model?
Jeff Zirlin
Axie's ecosystem may see roles like competitive battlers, collectors, scholarship managers, farmers, content creators, and politicians. These roles mirror real-world professions, showing the model's potential beyond gaming.
Arianna Simpson
The future might blend work and play, using crypto in virtual worlds for various tasks, not just gaming. This could redefine work in the metaverse.
Zoran Basich
How does gaming impact crypto adoption?
Jeff Zirlin
Gaming offers a friendly onboarding to crypto, making it approachable. Players start with a game, gain a wallet, and explore more Web3 products, driving broader adoption.
Arianna Simpson
Users don't need to understand blockchain; they just need to see the benefits. Gaming provides a clear, fun entry point, encouraging deeper crypto exploration over time.
Zoran Basich
Thanks to Jeff, Gabby, and Arianna for joining us today.
Jeff Zirlin
Thanks.
Gabby Dizon
Thanks.
Arianna Simpson
Thanks, Oren.