Podcast Episode Summary
The podcast episode discusses the topic of pay transparency and its implications for companies. The hosts, joined by Shannon Schiltz and Brandon Cherry from A16Z's People Practices team, explore how companies are reacting to the recent laws requiring employers to post their pay ranges.
Key Points:
Takeaways:
Participants:
Main Topic:
Pay transparency and its implications for companies, including the importance of having a compensation philosophy in place, leveling architecture, and performance management.
With recent landmark legislation being passed around salary transparency, many companies are playing catch up as they interpret and implement changes.
In this episode, members of the a16z People Operations team, Shannon Schiltz and Brandon Cherry explore how companies can best prepare themselves to not just survive, but thrive in this new environment.
Topics Covered:
00:00 - Salary transparency legislation
01:52 - The culture around pay transparency
03:39 - What is the legislation?
07:01 - How are companies reacting?
11:03 - Structuring a compensation philosophy
12:30 - Pay ranges
15:35 - Exceptions to the pay range
18:17 - Leveling staff
22:30 - Ranges and roles and company growth
28:24 - Location based pay
30:05 - What should employees look for when applying for work?
32:19 - Job postings
35:05 - Reviewing compensation ranges
35:42 - At what stage do you hire help?
Stay Updated:
Find a16z on Twitter: https://twitter.com/a16z
Find a16z on LinkedIn: https://www.linkedin.com/company/a16z
Subscribe on your favorite podcast app: https://a16z.simplecast.com/
Follow our host: https://twitter.com/stephsmithio
Please note that the content here is for informational purposes only; should NOT be taken as legal, business, tax, or investment advice or be used to evaluate any investment or security; and is not directed at any investors or potential investors in any a16z fund. a16z and its affiliates may maintain investments in the companies discussed. For more details please see a16z.com/disclosures.
Stay Updated:
Find a16z on X
Find a16z on LinkedIn
Listen to the a16z Podcast on Spotify
Listen to the a16z Podcast on Apple Podcasts
Follow our host: https://twitter.com/eriktorenberg
Please note that the content here is for informational purposes only; should NOT be taken as legal, business, tax, or investment advice or be used to evaluate any investment or security; and is not directed at any investors or potential investors in any a16z fund. a16z and its affiliates may maintain investments in the companies discussed. For more details please see a16z.com/disclosures.
Hosted by Simplecast, an AdsWizz company. See pcm.adswizz.com for information about our collection and use of personal data for advertising.
Host
Starting in 2016, states started enacting laws requiring employers to post their pay ranges. And now at least 10 states require it, amounting to over a quarter of the U.S. labor force covered by salary transparency legislation. With these recent landmark changes, many companies are playing catch-up. So in this episode, we'll explore how companies are reacting, misunderstandings that exist around these nascent laws, and how companies can best prepare themselves to not just survive, but thrive in this new environment.
Today, we're joined by Shannon Schiltz, operating partner leading A16Z's People Practices team, and Brandon Cherry, partner on the same team. Let's get started.
Disclaimer read
So pay transparency. I feel like this is a new-ish concept. Maybe 10 years ago, certainly 20 years ago, pay was not very transparent. You guys have both been working in this industry for a while. Tell me a little bit more about how you've seen that change, maybe that information asymmetry, especially in the last few years.
Shannon Schiltz
It's funny that you say that. I was trying to think of what year pay transparency became a thing. I think in 2010, because that's 13 years ago. It became more of a cultural thing, right? And it became very much a Silicon Valley thing, too – that you should feel confident with what you pay each employee. And if somebody else finds out about it, you should be able to justify it.
Historically, that was generally reserved for government jobs, teachers. You get a master's degree, you get this many more dollars. There was real clarity, and it was structured around achieving this or having that. But in non-government, non-education industries, it was probably a widely known secret that people talked about their compensation. We're going to just bring it to the front so that there's actually insight and rational thinking around how much you're paid and why. That was really powerful for employees.
Host
Yeah, it is powerful. It seems like a no-brainer that should exist, that companies should think critically about how their compensation is structured. But to your point, that's not always the case. Now it may be forcibly the case because there are new laws in some states where they are required, when you post a job, to have transparent ranges. Let's talk about that. What have you seen in terms of some of the legislation or the rules that are now in place that force companies to think a little bit harder about this?
Shannon Schiltz
I think 2016 was the first time the law came out that if you are interviewing a candidate, they can ask for the pay range for the role. You have to be able to, within 24 hours, share with the candidate what the pay range is. I remember when that happened, we worked with a lot of our portfolio companies on thinking through, what is your pay structure? And then it's just been a slow and steady progression around compensation, around equality of compensation.
Brandon Cherry
Brandon and I were talking about this yesterday. The interesting thing is there is this law of pay transparency. If you think about the best practices on how to build a company, the earlier you think about putting a compensation structure in place, the stronger and healthier your company is because you have consistency. Not fairness. Consistency.
Host
My favorite. I love to differentiate there. Can you actually differentiate? What is the difference there that you see?
Brandon Cherry
People will say, "I don't think it's fair that that person is making what they're making." Well, let's dive into what that role is – the scope, the impact, the influence. What is the role? That's what someone's being comped against. When somebody comes and says, "My comp's not fair compared to that person," you should be able to come back and say, "No, for each role, we are benchmarking it against this data, and we target the 50th percentile." That's consistency.
That might mean this role makes $100,000 a year, and this role makes $80,000 a year. But an employee comes talking about fairness. You don't get a lot of people saying, "I don't want a merit increase. That's too much money for what I'm doing." Not many people will say that. What a company needs to have in place are those conditions for success that will enable them to react and respond to pay transparency. If you've got a comp philosophy that tells you how you look at the competitive market, how you position yourself against it, a leveling architecture that clarifies where a role sits in the career progression of any potential job, you can then lean on that to drive a consistent conversation with the backstop of that consistent infrastructure.
Host
Right. It clarifies and codifies how the company thinks about compensation relative to their employees, as opposed to having this black box, ambiguous way in which compensation is set.
Shannon Schiltz
It's a trust thing. It limits cross-employee competition. I'm going to advocate for myself as opposed to in relationship to that person. I'm just going to advocate for myself against what I know the career progression will look like here.
Brandon Cherry
It's interesting because the outcome is actually driving for core infrastructure in your compensation strategy. The outcome is incredibly beneficial to companies. It's just painful to be able to articulate it if you don't have those things in place.
Host
Which many companies, I assume, did not in 2016 when some of these changes started happening. I want to get into how you actually develop that compensation philosophy, the strategy. But before we get there, companies are now having to react to some of these changes in law. I'm curious to hear what you're seeing in terms of the reactions. Are they abiding? Are they struggling to catch up? Are they circumventing the system in different ways? How are you seeing companies react?
Shannon Schiltz
I would say a couple things. One, we've probably never had so many requests for compensation councils, consultants, and "how do I?" So I think people are reacting the right way. They just want to get their arms around it. Then I would say there are multiple ways that people are reacting.
One, some are just saying we're going to be in a wait and see. We're going to see how enforceable these laws are, how much audits are taking place, what becomes of this new law. There are companies that are saying we're not going to do it, so we're not going to post our jobs. Because that's the most visible thing that's come out of it – you have to have a salary range posted with your jobs.
Host
Right.
Shannon Schiltz
And then the third piece is you have companies that are saying, "You could make between $65,000 a year up to $2.5 million a year." Somewhere in there, we're going to pay someone. I would say those are probably the three things that we see companies doing.
Brandon Cherry
Absolutely, those are three choices companies have. There's nuance to it. In some states, there are minimum thresholds and things that people can explore around what the requirements are in different locations. But I think there's just a lot of concern over making sure that not only do they understand how to comply from a regulatory standpoint, but also what does this do to our employee population? Who's going to see this? How is this going to work? And if we do have $60,000 to $2.5 million, are we prepared? Do we have the ability to say, "No, for you, it's $60,000. For other people, it's $2.5 million"? How do you have that conversation?
I think companies are navigating through all of that. For every company, it's going to be very specific to where they're located, the kinds of employee populations they have, how clear and how strong their infrastructure is, and how they feel like they are prepared to have those conversations.
Shannon Schiltz
It goes back to the basics. If you have the structure. For us, it was relatively straightforward. We have the structure here. We could post roles and put a salary range out there. We set it up so we can defend it. The interesting thing that happens, though, is the number of times that somebody sees a job posted and thinks, "That's what I do, but I don't make that." You have to be ready to have those conversations and get your managers ready to have a conversation on why actually this is a level above you and you can progress into it. But that's not where you're at right now. And that's a hard conversation.
Host
I was going to get into the hard conversations, but let's just talk about that now. Have you started to see that as you started to post roles?
Shannon Schiltz
Oh, absolutely. And it helps us iterate on our process. No process is ever great. I feel like weekly we're like, "Okay, are we checking this? Are we doing this?" And we're iterating on it. Because your future hire is super important, but they're not actually going to be contributing to productivity and output for six to nine months in most situations. So you have to be able to defend it to your current employees. That's the biggest thing that people are missing. Yes, there is this law that you're supposed to post a range, but your biggest asset is your current employee population.
Host
Isn't it true also that not just current employees can see the new jobs, but they can also ask? What is the rule around that? If I, Staff Smith, can go and say, "Hey, I do this job," what specifically can I ask for?
Brandon Cherry
You can ask for your pay range. And that's where your manager should be able to come back to you and say, "Here's the pay range. Here's where you're slotted. This is where you came in. Here's how long you've been in this role. We're seeing the progression. Here's how we think about compensation." You would walk away thinking they've been super thoughtful in how I'm paid.
Host
All right, let's start to think about how companies actually build this, because a lot of companies don't have this in place or are just in the early innings. If you are a company that has, let's say, the California threshold is 15 employees, and all 15 of those employees have been hired in disparate ways, paid in disparate ways, there's no sort of underlying strategy or structure. How do you even go about thinking about how to start setting that up?
Brandon Cherry
The three core tenets are what we've talked about before. You need to be able to articulate your philosophy on compensation. Not everybody is going to be able to compete with a $10 billion in revenue publicly traded company on a cash basis. So you need to own the philosophy that you believe will drive the kinds of outcomes that you want as a company. Your compensation philosophy in terms of how you define your competitive market – companies of your size and scale – and where you position against that competitive market data is really important. That sets the tone for how you think about driving market data through your comp philosophy to determine those ranges.
The other element is your leveling architecture – how you define what it means to be an early career employee versus a seasoned individual contributor versus a first-time manager versus a seasoned leader. Between your philosophy and your leveling architecture and the third-party market data that you use to determine that relationship, you can set your ranges very consistent with what you should be providing to candidates and articulating to current employees when they request.
Host
By the way, on ranges, is there a right answer around how big a range should be? Because it does seem wrong that a role could be $60K up through a couple million. That feels off. But what is a realistic range, and how do you think about what a range is appropriate?
Shannon Schiltz
First of all, it depends on the state, sometimes county and city. The right range is going to be somewhat indicated by the law.
Brandon Cherry
Every level has a range. Market data dictates what your ranges really look like. It's not like you're going to see a $100K difference in every range. Some ranges are compressed, some ranges are larger. If you think about senior leadership, you're not promoting. Your ranges are going to be big because you're going to continue to go through that range. You see it change depending on level, role, market data, all of that stuff.
The basic common construct is that earlier career roles have a narrower range because people are progressing in those roles more quickly. Think of it as an inverted triangle in terms of the width of the range around a target market position. That's an easy rubric, but it's going to change for every role. To Shannon's point, the more senior you are, the likelihood that you'll stay in that role longer is greater. You'll need more flexibility as a company to ensure that people aren't progressing beyond the range. That becomes a problem from a communication perspective. But it's going to change for every role and every function because a manager of finance isn't necessarily going to get paid the same as a manager of engineering. The absolute dollars will be different, but the structure may be very similar. That's where the market data comes in.
Shannon Schiltz
The thing that's interesting about the pay transparency laws is they are only focused on base salary.
Brandon Cherry
That's right.
Shannon Schiltz
Which is actually so funny, and it goes back to when this first came out, a lot of folks' response was, "This feels very government," because that's how they're mostly paid. So it's funny because you would think you would see more companies having these smaller ranges, knowing that they have cash compensation that's still, or bonus potentially that you can move around. You have equity if you're in the tech industry. There are all these different levers that actually don't come into play in what somebody's pay is within an organization. So it's kind of a loophole in a sense. It's just not completely thought out yet.
To answer the other question, there are great tools. If this had been rolled out 10 years ago, you would be relying on what Brandon used to do as a compensation consultant – coming in, building it for you, tons of legwork. We even have a company, Pave, where you can go in and work with them and their tool and you can build out your levels. It's much easier to do so. There's a part of me that's like, if it's easier to do and you can do it, and it actually builds a better trust environment, why not go for it?
Host
I think one thing that many companies would be scared of is developing this system. And then, as we talked about, it impacts employees who are already there, not just new employees. Should there ever be exceptions? I feel like this comes up as different managers are talking about top talent. You hear about the 10x engineer. Can a compensation philosophy that's built out well enough – this goes back to your fairness versus consistency – can you build that in where the star players, the Michael Jordan equivalent in a business, can they really fit into something so structured like that?
Shannon Schiltz
They can. The nuance that you're going to have is that, and this goes back to another topic. When I talk to portfolio companies about performance management, the thing I always talk about, and it comes back to compensation a lot of times, especially around equity, is there is a top 10% of your organization that isn't just the best performer, but they're critical.
Host
Single point of failure.
Shannon Schiltz
Single point of failure. Those ranges, they might not fit into a range, but pay transparency says why. Why is this a one-off? And you can justify it. This is where I always go back to the fairness versus consistency. Consistency is consistency. If you define critical talent as being above range, that's being consistent. You have to be classified as that type of individual. This happens in companies all the time – their software architect, their designer, their person that is doing something so incredibly critical that everything stops. As long as you're working it into your overall philosophy, it's still consistent.
Host
Is that about saying these critical people are just above range, or is it actually developing a separate track?
Brandon Cherry
You usually have a philosophy around how you're going to handle your absolute top talent. A lot of times we'll talk about building the ranges. It's not done in a vacuum. Shannon's brought up an incredibly important point. The consistency is really about the design and the process that you use to determine where you sit. The flexibility comes in other tools that the HR ecosystem should have in place – things like performance management, assessment of talent, assessment of candidates. Those are the things that give you the flexibility and the freedom to say, "This person is a single point of failure. The opportunity cost of losing this person and their criticality to this company commands that we have to make sure that we put them in a position to retain them."
The consistency in the application of the data and the design of the compensation infrastructure is incredibly important. The application is where you need to be able to recognize the flexibility that's necessary to grow and run a business.
Host
Once you've designed something, and let's say you do have an existing organization, you're not starting from scratch. What do you do there? Do you level people who are already in the organization?
Shannon Schiltz
There are two things to do. We always try and get companies to do it before they're like 50 employees. This has actually helped us. Pay transparency would be much easier. We've always said to people, the bigger your organization, the harder this project is.
The first thing you do is you have to remove all the humans from the project.
Host
What do you mean by that? The names?
Shannon Schiltz
Yeah, the names, the actual human beings. You build the infrastructure of how many levels are we going to have? What scope? What is it typically? It's years of experience. It's scope. It's impact. It's influence. Freedom to operate.
Brandon Cherry
Freedom to operate.
Shannon Schiltz
These are all the different pieces that you put into a leveling criteria. From there, you build out different levels. You then pull in your market data. You identify who are our peers, what's our market data. Then you go through the process. Once you have all of that structured, you start leveling people just off of the leveling criteria. You always find folks that are either way above range or way below range. Then you can dive into those as almost a talent review.
You're typically not going to take people's compensation away from them. So you might have a conversation with someone saying, "Hey, you're awesome at what you do. We just went through this leveling criteria. You're about $40,000 above where you should be. You're super valuable. I just need you to know you're not going to see an increase for quite some time unless you progress to the next level. I need the world to catch up to your role." Or if you have someone who's well below, you say, "What's our affordability? Can we actually bring people to the minimum of the range that they should be at?"
Host
Are you required to do that?
Shannon Schiltz
You're not required to do it, but it makes it easier to stand behind. That's why I say it's affordability. Not every company can afford to do that. Especially if you're a larger company, there can be a lot of capital required to level a lot of people. But if you find that 80% of your organization is not fitting into your leveling criteria, you're probably not doing your leveling criteria correctly. You're probably going to have a handful that you need to go and address, not 40 or even 20 of your organization being wonky to your criteria.
Host
That's a great point. So you're saying if companies go through this exercise and they're actually seeing that 50% are not following this criteria, there are massive gaps across the company that they should revisit it.
Brandon Cherry
When you look at the basics of leveling, software engineers levels – I think there's typically six or seven individual contributors, five to six individual contributors. What it might mean is that you pulled the levels and the data and you built out four levels. You grabbed the data and went one, two, three, four. Maybe the way that you've actually structured and hired is you have a level one, which is entry level, and then you don't hire that level two, you hire a level three. So you might go back and just have to play with, "We're not going to use all six levels." That's where it's validating the type of talent you're hiring.
It's so important to remove people from the conversation because it drives an org design and org development conversation as opposed to "let's build a role around this person that holds a little bit of finance, a little bit of HR, and maybe touches on legal occasionally." That's not a scalable role. That's a Frankenstein role. What you really want to do is make sure that you're building the roles and defining the levels in a way that's consistent with how you are going to scale as a company.
Shannon Schiltz
To Brandon's point, then you can start to break your four levels into five if you think that's appropriate. Or in a seven-level structure, you only have a couple of roles at the early stage and a bunch of roles at the top, individual contributor, technical talent, because you've got a strong leader already in place that fills those gaps.
Brandon Cherry
That concept of putting market data against the leveling and having a clear conversation with your leaders is really important to be agnostic of the people in the roles. You don't want to design roles and levels around existing employees. You want to design it about what's going to enable the company to scale and grow at the pace that is necessary.
Host
Real quick, just because you mentioned it, there are Frankenstein roles out there, especially early on, where people are doing a little bit of everything. What do you do with that if people are in those roles?
Shannon Schiltz
A company starts that way. Then as a company progresses, you actually do need people. As you grow as an organization, people have to become very specialized in what they do. Using executives as an example is the easiest one. When you're a small company, you might have a VP of product and a VP of HR. As you grow to be like a 5,000-person company, you're probably going to have a chief product officer. You might have a CHRO. Then you can have VPs, SVPs, EVPs. It really goes with the scale and the type of people you need to hire. You start seeing the layering taking place.
Host
If you are rolling this out to the company, how transparent should you be? How much information are you revealing to each individual, but also to the company, revealing how you're thinking about this or even the fact that you're pursuing a really robust structure? And also some of those difficult conversations. What do you do when someone is just really unhappy with where they fall in that new structure? They come and say, "There's no way I'm at the bottom of this range." I'm sure you get that a lot too, where people have a different perception around their value, maybe even the scope of their role and what they add to a company.
Brandon Cherry
From my perspective, the success of rolling this out is not about... you have to look at all your stakeholders – your candidates, your employees. It's really about the success of how you enable your managers and HRBPs, if you've got them, to have these conversations. From a required transparency, you're going to have to provide a range, and you should always have a really clear understanding of who's going to see what. You want to do audits before you roll this out. You want to make sure you know where people fit in those ranges and that you've empowered the HR team and managers and leaders to be prepared and potentially be proactive in their conversations.
Host
Is there a good way to have that conversation, though? If someone just misunderstands or just disagrees with where they sit in that structure?
Brandon Cherry
It's a hard conversation. A lot of times when that comes up, you bring in your HR business partner, you bring in the manager, and you have an employee. You walk them through why the role's leveled where it's leveled. You walk them through why they're leveled where they're leveled. It can be performance-based. It could be tenure. It could be years of experience. There are all these different things. Sometimes the fact of the matter is we might agree to disagree. It happens all the time that people are like, "You don't understand. I'm doing this, this, this, and this." And it's totally understood, but this is the role you're in. This is what you're being compensated for.
Shannon Schiltz
In a way, it's great because those conversations were probably already happening in terms of someone saying, "I should get paid more." Instead of companies just being like, "I guess the person who complains the most" –
Host
The squeaky wheel.
Shannon Schiltz
– gets paid the most. In this case, they really have to sit down and say, "Are they correct? How does this compare to the philosophy that we spent weeks, months building up that we are willing to stand behind?" The hidden gem here is that ultimately these laws are forcing companies to put the kind of infrastructure in place that a manager can use as the backstop. The leveling, the career progression, performance management. It becomes less about compensation. That's the leading topic. But it's really the richer infrastructure that you've wrapped around your compensation strategy that supports that conversation and drives to that consistent conversation that managers can have across their team or across the company.
I will go back to one other thing that I think is super important. I've been doing HR for a long time, so this is not just A16Z related. When a person comes and says that they're unhappy about their compensation, it's not a compensation person that comes in and has the conversation.
It's their manager, it's the HR business partner. And when you start asking questions and you start pulling away the layers of the onion, just like I say, no one leaves for comp. No one ever leaves for comp. If you actually really dive in and you start talking about why someone is leveled at this level and your manager can say, "Here's the things you have to do to get to the next level because this is career progression and it's all about leveling," all of a sudden you hear, "Well, I don't get feedback. I don't know how I'm performing. I just know that I don't feel I'm paid the way my peers are paid."
So all of a sudden it's really about the person wanting to know how they develop. They want to know how they progress. And so it's a much richer conversation. But I bring this up because it's not a compensation person that comes in and has that discussion. It's typically something other than just comp that is bugging the employee that they're bringing to your attention.
Host
Yeah.
Shannon Schiltz
And if it is a compensation conversation, you've probably missed an opportunity because you've devolved down to the ones and zeros. You haven't actually engaged in a richer conversation around the things that you're going to do. And there can be mistakes. There are times in which we're like, "Oh, crap." Right. Or the markets move faster than the survey data has. All of a sudden you're like, "Holy shit."
Host
Right. Exactly.
Shannon Schiltz
Yeah. Exactly. And in those cases, you dive into it and you figure out, like, what should we be doing here? Who all is impacted? How do we address this? And it happens with new technology, right? New technology comes out, people who have experience with it. Everyone always wants the market data, and it's, well, the market data is always six to 12 months lagging.
Host
Right, and it's like, this has only been out for six months. It's still behind.
Shannon Schiltz
And so then it's, okay, we've done this enough times. What you need to do is take what you have and pay a premium, right? And so it's having those discussions versus it all being driven by data. That's the only thing I don't like. I feel like when something becomes a law, everyone's like, "What's the data?" Right. Actually, there's a whole philosophy behind it. And it's the application of that data that really matters.
Brandon Cherry
Maybe one other aspect that is emerging, you mentioned like new technology, is location-based pay. Remote work is rolling out. Many companies have already adopted it. Some are flip-flopping, going back. But the idea still stands where I think many more companies are hiring across borders, whether that's state borders or international borders. And there's all of these new implications of that, one of them being location-based pay. Should someone in New York get paid more than someone in Ohio? This goes back to the philosophy, though. It goes back to what a company's philosophy is. And I think it becomes really hard. This is why the conversations are so important.
Because, for instance, a company can decide to do location-based pay. So their employees in San Francisco and New York are going to make more than somebody who's sitting in Cincinnati.
Shannon Schiltz
Yeah.
Brandon Cherry
Or they can say, "We're going to pay everyone San Francisco-based." Or they're going to say, "We're going to do the national average."
Shannon Schiltz
Yeah.
Brandon Cherry
It doesn't matter where you're located. And so all of a sudden, when an employee comes to you and says, "My friend who works at X is making Y, and I'm doing the same thing, and I'm making this amount." It's like, and we've been saying this for years. Like, it's never apples to apples, right? You have to understand what the comp philosophy. I mean, how many times? I get phone calls all the time. "I'm negotiating an offer. Can you help me? What am I worth?" I'm like, "Well."
Host
To who?
Brandon Cherry
To who? Yeah, but actually. "What's their comp philosophy? Where do they pay their executives?" And people get so frustrated with me. And I'm like, "I don't know what you're worth for that company. I don't know where you fit in."
Shannon Schiltz
Yeah.
Brandon Cherry
And that's the most important thing.
Host
That's actually such a great point, though, because so far we've talked mostly from the company side. But just for the people who might be listening who are on the talent side, who are looking to get hired, like how do they even start thinking about that? Where should they start painting a picture? Is it looking at whatever market data they can get? Is it looking at the open jobs?
Shannon Schiltz
I actually don't think it's market data. Like at the end of the day, pay transparency is a law that we'll see where it goes.
Host
Yeah.
Shannon Schiltz
At the end of the day, if you are applying to a company, you should understand the programs within the company. You should take the time to understand from the manager how they think about compensation. You should take the time from a manager to understand how they do performance management because those are the things. And then you figure out how you fit in there. And there is absolutely nothing wrong with asking someone, "Can you share where you benchmark and who you consider your peers?" That's a really healthy conversation. At the end of the day, you're either going to take the offer or you're not.
Brandon Cherry
Right.
Shannon Schiltz
And I would say take the time to understand role clarity. A job description is helpful, but really have that manager, that person articulate, like, "Where do you fit into this? How am I going to succeed in this role? What does success look like?" to Jen's point, around performance management. Then you've wrapped a lot of information around this opportunity, and you understand that, yes, they may only pay you $75,000 in base for this role and this other company is offering $80,000, but you understand why in terms of how the role fits or maybe how they're using equity or other elements of the compensation strategy that they have in place.
Brandon Cherry
So the pay transparency is helpful, but it's just a small fraction of the conversation for all the reasons that Shannon just mentioned.
Host
Yeah, and to your point about compensation, like no one quits for compensation, ideally you're also not choosing jobs solely for compensation.
Brandon Cherry
You would have a lot.
Host
Yeah, exactly.
Brandon Cherry
Yeah, and you're like, "Oh, wow."
Host
Yeah, we're both like, yeah.
Shannon Schiltz
Well, and it's one of those things that, I say this to my kids all the time. I'm always parenting and HR-ing at the same time. But it's like, how valuable are you to the company you're going to? What you do, your role. And so it's one of those things that, you know what, at one company, being a designer might be super, super important. If you go to another company, maybe design's not as important. So again, it goes back to the philosophy per company.
Host
Well, we talked about how different companies are responding. But also, one thing we didn't talk about, or kind of like the companies may not realize that even an employee posting about their open position on LinkedIn, like that's technically a job posting. That's a job posting. And so is the easiest way really just to stay out of certain states if companies don't either know how to or want to comply?
Shannon Schiltz
So I don't think it's come far enough to understand like what is the cost to not, right? But I think, and maybe we're just like being too hopeful. It's a law that could have a lot of different ramifications on doing business in different states. At the end of the day, there's a really easy way to get in front of it, which is just build the infrastructure. Just do the work. Just do the work. And it's hard work, but it's important work. If you meet the strictest standards, you're generally going to be in a pretty strong position.
Host
And what are the strictest standards? Is that just posting the pay range?
Shannon Schiltz
Actually, I think the stricter standards come from how many employees you have more than anything. It's all kind of the same laws. Now, there's some states that are saying that they're going to require reporting, but some of these states are like two years behind in a lot of what they're enforcing. So that's why I say the law is TBD. The fines are TBD.
Brandon Cherry
Right.
Shannon Schiltz
But it's easier to get in front of it and build it the right way, because then you can turn it on so easily. But to your point earlier, also, it's not just to comply with the law. It's actually beneficial for companies if they set this up. It makes their jobs easier.
Brandon Cherry
Companies go through an evolution, right? When they first start and it's a founder with an idea, they have to do everything they can do to get the right talent to get to the right next point in time to raise money or to release a product. So, look, your first couple of hires, it's going to be a negotiation. And to your point, all of a sudden you get to maybe 8, 10 employees and you're like, "Oh, I have to make this make sense now," right? And that's where some of these states that are saying it, one or two employees, it would be really hard. I just don't even know that that's what someone should be focused on at that point of building a company.
Well, you have to post a job, level four engineer. What does that mean? Mid-career, individual career engineer. But you find someone that you said, "Listen, on the roadmap, this is someone that we probably wouldn't have hired for another 12 months. But why wouldn't we strike while the iron's hot? It doesn't significantly change how we're thinking about the next 12 months. Let's get this person in." And all of a sudden they're quote unquote above the posted range, you've got to think through like re-leveling the job and all those kinds of things. But ultimately you're not going to slow down your hiring process in the first eight or ten employees because you're now going to go through six weeks to figure out how to reset this job. You need to be able to react and respond because again we talked about opportunity cost. It's staring you right in the face in your first 18, 24 months as a company.
Host
Yeah, and if we are thinking about scaling, I mean some of these companies may not make it to 200, 2,000 employees. But like for the ones that do, how often maybe should they be revisiting this? Is this like a one and done? If you do it right, then you're good?
Shannon Schiltz
You're always refreshing. You're always refreshing it. Like I think probably every 18 months, 12 to 18 months. It's like material change, right? If you go through it, if you raise a round, it's probably worthwhile to make sure your ranges are consistent with sort of the new scope and scale that you are as a company. If you've got really hot jobs where the market's moving really quickly, you might even look, you wouldn't necessarily react to it, but you might look at it every six months and say, "Listen, this is something we want to make sure we keep a pulse on."
Host
I guess final question is, we're talking about these smaller companies who at the beginning is just like the founders trying to figure this out, piece together data from Pave or somewhere else. And at what point is it really the time where you should be bringing in someone like yourselves to figure this out?
Brandon Cherry
In my opinion, your early stage, you have to get stuff done, right? And then you get to, I would say, you know, we have early stage companies. We have our venture, which is A, B, C rounds, right? And then we have growth. And I would say it's typically once they're getting a good infusion of money and they're going to start scaling on hiring that it's like, this is a great time. It doesn't have to be complex. Put something in place so that you're being consistent.
Shannon Schiltz
Yeah.
Brandon Cherry
We hear companies say, "Well, this feels very limiting." And the ranges aren't necessarily rules. They're guideposts. And more importantly, they surface the trade-off decisions that you make as a company along the way. And instead of just making decisions without understanding the consequences of those decisions, your compensation infrastructure, your ranges, your leveling criteria all give you an idea of when you're making...
Shannon Schiltz
Guiding principles.
Brandon Cherry
Guiding principles, that's right. To get you to where you should be. And then you can say, "Okay, we choose to do this. We need to make sure that we understand why. And then we're good with that because this is a key hire where we have looked for this role for 12 months and have not been able to fill it, and now we're going to."
And I would say even more importantly, I would say it's less "we've looked for this role for 12 months." It's like this new technology came swooping in, and we actually found someone that knows how to do it. It's like you don't want someone who's just everyone's negotiating and you're paying whatever somebody negotiates because there's a lot of bias around that.
Shannon Schiltz
Right.
Brandon Cherry
But there are going to be points in time, like never in a million years did I think that we would see how the market was increasing as it was pre-2022, second half of 2022, you never had to move your ranges. Your midpoint might move. We were in a constant progression of you have to move your ranges almost every year because the market was dictating it. So it's being flexible. Again, guiding principles, not laws.
One of the biggest red flags is if you find yourself, I call it vapor lock. I don't know what the right term is, but like spinning on should the range be plus or minus 7% or 5%, and you're a 30-person company. That's not a good use of time.
Shannon Schiltz
It's not a good use of time.
Brandon Cherry
And it's great to see that kind of passion around that conversation. But if you spend 10 weeks trying to figure out exactly how your ranges should be built and you're a 20-person company, you should know that it's likely going to change in about 18 months.
Shannon Schiltz
Yeah.
Brandon Cherry
You're going to be right back at it.
Shannon Schiltz
Again, the guiding principles point and also the evolution point, it's important to have a way in which you define those things. But recognizing that that range will change or your learning architecture will change. Or the types of programs. You might roll a bonus plan at some point on top and you don't need to move the base salary ranges as much because you've got the performance management infrastructure. So it's a multivariable equation, and it's also important to balance the time that you dedicate to this process with sort of the return on that investment.
Host
Totally. So final question is, what's my range? No, I'm kidding.
Brandon Cherry
Well, 60 to 2.5.
Shannon Schiltz
Yeah.
Brandon Cherry
I can confirm I'm somewhere in that range.
Host
That's awesome.
Shannon Schiltz
Well, we're doing our job.
Host
Yeah. Well, this was awesome. I think it'll help a lot of companies who are trying to figure this out for the first time, maybe in their company trajectory. And so do you want to leave any sort of parting thoughts?
Brandon Cherry
My parting thought is that Shannon and I have dedicated a large portion of our careers to this. And so I can easily kill an hour talking about this. We block everybody. This is therapy. We have a two-hour session where we just talk about compensation and what's going on.
No, I think my parting words are like, look, it is a new law. I wouldn't over-rotate on it. Go back to the basics of building a company. At some point, it might become even more heightened. If you're building the company the right way, it should be very easy to follow the requirements and just realize that compensation iterates and iterates. And we have a whole people practices team here at the firm that can help people think this through. Always help, I mean, in the ecosystem, we love helping companies think through how to build companies the right way. So we're always available.
Shannon Schiltz
Right.
Host
Yeah. Great. Well, thank you so much.
Shannon Schiltz
Thank you for having us.
Brandon Cherry
Thank you.