The podcast episode features Simon Denny, a global artist inspired by entrepreneurial culture, discussing the intersection of art and technology. The conversation explores how artists have been dealing with technological changes and expressing the visceral feelings of inhabiting new technological moments for a long time.
Simon Denny's practice spans various media and contexts, including installations, paintings, and crypto art. He is interested in the history of art and artists who make for new technologies as they emerge. Denny's work often explores the relationship between art and technology, and he sees himself as an artist who is interested in the cultural and aesthetic aspects of technology.
The conversation touches on various technological milestones, including the emergence of the iPhone, social media, and blockchain. Denny discusses how these technologies have enabled new forms of artistic expression and have changed the way artists create and interact with their audience.
One of the key points discussed is the tension between art and commercialism. Denny argues that pop art proposed the idea that an artist's role is to describe how it feels to occupy the contemporary world, without being an ethical agent. He sees himself as part of this tradition, but also acknowledges the importance of considering the commercial aspects of art.
The conversation also explores the concept of NFTs (non-fungible tokens) and their relationship to art and technology. Denny sees NFTs as a new medium for art, one that combines the cultural asset and the financial container in a way that is unique to blockchain technology.
The episode also delves into the concept of generative art and its relationship to blockchains. Denny argues that generative art is not native to blockchains, but has found its native medium in blockchains. He sees the potential for generative art to become more expressive and dynamic as blockchain technology advances.
Throughout the conversation, Denny emphasizes the importance of understanding the cultural and aesthetic aspects of technology. He encourages artists and art enthusiasts to engage with the digital art world and to learn about the history and context of digital art.
The episode concludes with Denny discussing his current project, which explores the concept of space networks and the way people are imagining building in outer space. He sees this project as a way to explore the intersection of art and technology in a new and exciting way.
Key takeaways from the episode include:
Participants:
Main topic:
Key points:
We know that technology has changed art, and that artists have evolved with every new technology — it’s a tale as old as humanity, moving from cave paintings to computers. Underlying these movements are endless debates around inventing versus remixing; between commercialism and art; between mainstream canon and fringe art; whether we’re living in an artistic monoculture now (the answer may surprise you); and much much more.
So in this new episode featuring Berlin-based contemporary artist Simon Denny -- in conversation with a16z crypto editor in chief Sonal Chokshi -- we discuss all of the above debates. We also cover how artists experimented with the emergence of new technology platforms like the web browser, the iPhone, Instagram and social media; to how generative art found its “native” medium on blockchains, why NFTs; and other art movements.
Denny also thinks of entrepreneurial ideas -- from Peter Thiel's to Chris Dixon's Read Write Own -- as an "aesthetic"; and thinks of technology artifacts (like NSA sketches!) as art -- reflecting all of these in his works across various mediums and contexts. How has technology changed art, and more importantly, how have artists changed with technology? How does art change our place in the world, or span beyond space? It's about optimism, and seeing things anew... all this and more in this episode.
Resources:
Find Denny on Twitter: https://x.com/dennnnnnnnny
Find Sonal on Twitter: https://x.com/smc90
Stay Updated:
Let us know what you think: https://ratethispodcast.com/a16z
Find a16z on Twitter: https://twitter.com/a16z
Find a16z on LinkedIn: https://www.linkedin.com/company/a16z
Subscribe on your favorite podcast app: https://a16z.simplecast.com/
Follow our host: https://twitter.com/stephsmithio
Please note that the content here is for informational purposes only; should NOT be taken as legal, business, tax, or investment advice or be used to evaluate any investment or security; and is not directed at any investors or potential investors in any a16z fund. a16z and its affiliates may maintain investments in the companies discussed. For more details please see a16z.com/disclosures.
Stay Updated:
Find a16z on X
Find a16z on LinkedIn
Listen to the a16z Podcast on Spotify
Listen to the a16z Podcast on Apple Podcasts
Follow our host: https://twitter.com/eriktorenberg
Please note that the content here is for informational purposes only; should NOT be taken as legal, business, tax, or investment advice or be used to evaluate any investment or security; and is not directed at any investors or potential investors in any a16z fund. a16z and its affiliates may maintain investments in the companies discussed. For more details please see a16z.com/disclosures.
Hosted by Simplecast, an AdsWizz company. See pcm.adswizz.com for information about our collection and use of personal data for advertising.
Sonal Choksi
Artists have been dealing with technological changes and expressing the visceral feelings of inhabiting new technological moments for a very long time. As a person who is looking at the history of artists designing for particular mediums, you could do stuff with mobile and social that you couldn't do before.
Simon Denny
I think the notion that Pop Art proposed, that your role as an artist is to describe how it feels to occupy that contemporary world, and you're not an ethical agent. It's just like, I go into the street and I see a giant billboard and it does something to my heart, and that is culture.
Sonal Choksi
When they looked at NFTs for the first time, I think a lot of them saw outsider art.
Simon Denny
One of the interesting things about blockchain as a medium, I think, is that the cultural asset and the financial container is the same thing.
Sonal Choksi
Throughout history, art has helped us make sense of the most exciting and mystifying technology of the day. And simultaneously, technology has constantly rewritten how we express our creativity. Leonardo da Vinci, for example, was influenced by his new understanding of anatomy. Meanwhile, the industrial era was welcomed by images of foreign machines that would forever change society. And cameras, then browsers, then phones gave artists new canvases to create with. Over and over, art and technology have evolved hand in hand. And of course, today is no different. In fact, artists are not just creating work about the blockchain, but also on the blockchain, with Web3 changing the way artists can monetize their work.
This episode, originally published on our sister podcast, Web3 with a16z, features Simon Denny, a global artist inspired by entrepreneurial culture whose cutting-edge work exists where, once again, art and technology collide. Simon's conversation is with longtime a16z podcast host, Sonal Choksi. So if you like this episode, be sure to check out more episodes of Web3 with a16z. In the meantime, I hope you enjoy this episode that itself is at the intersection of art and technology.
Music fades in and out
Welcome to Web3 with a16z, a show about building the next era of the internet from the team at a16z Crypto. We're excited to be back with all new episodes. I'm Sonal, Editor-in-Chief at a16z Crypto, and today's episode is all about how technology has changed art and how artists change with technology, from the emergence of the browser, the iPhone, and social media to generative art and blockchains to NFTs. We also discuss debates that seem to come up in every art and tech shift, including between inventing versus remixing, between commercialism and art, between mainstream canon and outsider art, whether we're living in an artistic monoculture now, and much, much more.
Our special guest is Simon Denny, and we recorded this live in London a few days after we opened our London office, which is fitting since Denny is a global artist based in Berlin, but has shown his work in various countries' biennales, museums, and galleries, including a metaverse landscape solo show called Read, Write, Own at Altman Siegel Gallery in San Francisco last year. As a reminder, none of the following is investment, business, legal, or tax advice. Please see a16z.com slash disclosures for more important information, including a link to a list of our investments.
The first half of our hallway style conversation tours through the evolution of art with technology, and the second half goes deeper into blockchains and art. But we begin briefly with Denny's tech journey and how he thinks of entrepreneurship as an aesthetic.
Discussion begins
Obviously, this is a crypto show, and it's also a technology show. I mean, crypto is all about technology. One of the reasons I'm in this world is it's a very multidisciplinary field. It brings together economics. It brings together philosophy. It brings together networking. It brings together security, cryptography. There are so many layers to crypto.
Simon Denny
Yeah.
Sonal Choksi
And I definitely want to focus in on the art aspect. Tell me a little bit more about your actual practice today, too, and then we'll go back to the evolution.
Simon Denny
At the moment today, I work across lots of different media in lots of different contexts. So I make both installations for museums and art galleries. I paint as well, but I also am very involved in crypto and crypto art. So I design NFT projects. But I guess maybe where I really specialize is I make things that join the museum world with the crypto world. So I'm interested in the history of art and artists who make for new technologies as they emerge to kind of explore what's possible on them that wasn't possible on other platforms from previous.
But I personally got really interested in the people who were making the platforms, the people who were designing the systems, because these were new systems. We were experiencing them. We were feeling different ways, doing different things on them. One of the first times I encountered entrepreneurial culture, for example, that just inspired me unendingly, because it was so different than the attitude of my artist peers that I encountered. They were excited. They were bullish about the future. In my world at the time — I think it's actually different now — but at the time in my art world, it was very common to be incredibly critical and cynical.
Sonal Choksi
Right. Cynicism was the go-to.
Simon Denny
Yeah. And I get that culture. I kind of love that culture. It's sort of like indie rock or something like that. But then I encountered all these incredible optimists. And I was like, wow, this is a force that I can't understand culturally.
Sonal Choksi
Oh, that's fascinating. I never thought about that you're coming from a cynical, kind of default cynical art world and then being like totally inspired by the optimism. Because I feel like those of us in Silicon Valley take that for granted.
Simon Denny
Yeah, I guess I'm really attracted to value systems aesthetically because I'm an artist and I think visually and culturally that I don't know everything about and I don't completely understand. So I started to go to technology conferences. And the first thing that I did is I went to a prominent conference in Munich called DLD. And I made an artwork about DLD in 2013, a one-year history of the conference a year later. I made a maze that people would walk through in this museum space just down the road from the conference where there was a graphic panel for every talk panel, basically.
Sonal Choksi
Interesting.
Simon Denny
So you would look at pull quotes that I'd pulled out from the entire conference and encounter things that Jack Dorsey was saying, the things that the founder of Wikipedia was saying, Pavel Durov was saying — interesting entrepreneurs that they were able to gather there and the things they were saying about the world. And it was kind of overwhelming.
Sonal Choksi
Sounds really immersive too.
Simon Denny
It was super immersive, but very digital. I also leaned into the design interfaces that were contemporary at the time, which look really ancient now, which is really interesting too, because it was like iOS when it was skeuomorphism. So it was like all of these bookshelves as stages, as whatever digital buttons. And that was the kind of graphic language I used. It was like cartoon font that looks very strange. But it gave this overall sense of this really vibrant community, which I hadn't really encountered before as an artist. Again, the art world's a little different in terms of culture. And that was one of the first times that I was like, wow, this is incredible. There are people here who are really optimistic, super excited about the future. Yes, they're critical thinkers as well, but they really want to build something. And that was the first time I encountered that culture.
Sonal Choksi
Tell me a little bit about how you actually came as an artist to the technology world.
Simon Denny
I grew up in New Zealand. I went to university at the University of Auckland to first study art. That was the thing that I fell in love with as a painter when I was younger. New Zealand's amazing, but it's also very small and quite remote. And I learned about how big the contemporary art world was, which made me want to go study in Germany. Germany is a really special country for contemporary art. Every little town has a major contemporary art museum, which is really unusual. In the post-war period, it's been a really important place for lots of different artists internationally to do museum shows early. There's also an incredible education system there. So I went to art school then in Frankfurt at this very special school called the Städelschule in the mid-2000s. And at that time, the director of the school was also the director of the Venice Biennale. And all the teachers that I was learning from there were these international artists that I saw on the cover of all the magazines that I was reading. So it was a really exciting hub of international practice.
And there I got super interested in the history of technology and art. Because I moved there in 2007, the year the iPhone came out. I moved with a laptop, didn't have an iPhone because it was a brand new, very expensive thing. But we were all just starting to use social media like Web2 in a really interesting way. And of course, because I moved away from all my friends and family, that was one of the things that really kept me connected. Laptop I used for education, watching movies, but also keeping on top of friends in a really intense way. And so a bunch of artists that were studying at that time got really interested in this new wave of technological stuff that was enabling a different type of engagement.
Sonal Choksi
And Berlin's, for those who don't know Germany, it's like Berlin's, I guess, a place where a lot of contemporary artists live and work.
Simon Denny
And there were this little hub of people that were really interested in the history of contemporary art, the history of art made for digital platforms like web art from the 1990s, which is a very interesting specialist field. So when browsers came about, when the World Wide Web started, when people started using Mosaic and Netscape, there were artists designing for that as a specific medium.
Sonal Choksi
Yes. I want to go back to how when you were in art school, you and your cohort came across the iPhone for the first time. You don't necessarily immediately think viscerally about the iPhone as a creative medium, the way one thinks about caves for cave painting or paper for drawing or canvas for painting or LED lights for certain kind of electronic art installations at mass scale or whatever, neon. It's funny that you mentioned that because it's just sort of like this little tiny device. It's a computing device. So can you tell me a little bit about how you and your cohort at the time experienced the advent of the iPhone as the moment that tipped into your interest in the intersection of technology and art?
Simon Denny
I think it was a conflation of a few different things that I was really compelled by when the iPhone came out. One was the really strong marketing component to that. I think I was particularly impressed by that. The Steve Jobs moment was very compelling.
Sonal Choksi
The narrative part of it?
Simon Denny
The narrative part of that. The way that Steve and other entrepreneurs around him at the time seemed to be offering a really cohesive vision of the world. But also the aesthetics. There was a kind of a design hegemony that got installed. But also as a person who was looking at the history of artists designing for particular mediums, you could do stuff with mobile and social that you couldn't do before. Artists had been making amazing artworks for browsers. There's an incredible history of that. They'd even been making artworks that dealt with the culture of companies. There was an amazing browser-based group in the 90s who were called eToy. And eToy was a real company.
Sonal Choksi
Right, I remember that actually.
Simon Denny
They started before eToys, but they tended to be quite antagonistic. A lot of browser-based work from the 90s came from artists who were really resistant to the commercial aspects of the internet. They were really anti-commerce. They were curious about the internet for just communication.
Sonal Choksi
Exactly.
Simon Denny
And I think they really idealized moments where it was a more collective experience and the commercial part seemed to be a difficult thing. But eToy, I think, was an amazing collective because they were completely anonymous and they basically ended up coordinating a DDoS attack on eToys, the real company.
Sonal Choksi
That's like activist art in some ways.
Simon Denny
Exactly. Activist art was really close to that browser-based work. Now, me and my cohort were less anti. I'd come up already through a commercial art world that was offline. I really valued the work that commercial agents were doing to make the work known. And I didn't have a problem with that. And I think a lot of the people who were using social media early were also okay with the idea of promoting themselves. So we were less against. We designed things that didn't necessarily have this kind of anti-commercial message.
Sonal Choksi
There's always been this long history and tension, as you obviously know, with artists and the commercial aspect. Andy Warhol is the most obvious example that comes to mind for that. And it's interesting because we'll get to how this may play out with the NFT world. You talked about the early days of Web2. Browser-based art is maybe the moment in your age and demographic. Web1, browser-based, Web2, some of the Instagram, social and mobile.
Simon Denny
One of the greatest examples, I think, of people making artwork for social media plus mobile was this work that a friend of mine, Amalia Ullman, did a little bit later, like in the early 2010s. And this is when Instagram was really the medium that everybody was using in the art world, at least in our art world. And we were all posting our exhibition photos on there, posting selfies of ourselves, whatever. But she was using it in a different way where she really occupied this proto-influencer idiom. She started taking photos of her and then gradually over time, her image changed. It was less kind of art world girl, more kind of basic, quote unquote, looking person. Her makeup was more extreme. Her body became more extreme. And then at one point, she was announcing that she was going to have surgery on her body.
Sonal Choksi
Whoa.
Simon Denny
And then we as a community of artists that knew her were like, wow, Amalia's really changed. This is really super difficult. And then she had these incredible pre and post things of an operation or whatever. And then it came out that it was all a performance. And we were all completely duped by the whole thing. It was really, really believable. And again, it used all of these emergent properties of that medium to really do something that said something about the way that the world was going.
Sonal Choksi
Yes, that sounds like performance art. I actually think I heard about this.
Simon Denny
Right, exactly. And speaking of the specific properties of that medium, you also mentioned the word proto-influencer, which I think is very interesting because obviously there is this element of influencers today on Instagram and beyond in social media and influencer culture. So this is sort of pre that sort of phase.
Sonal Choksi
Emergent with it, I would say.
Simon Denny
Emergent with it, okay. And I think this is what artists are good at doing. They're good at seeing emergent properties that are happening both in visual conventions, like how photos are looking, because that was another thing. Visually there was a particular style to these images that came from the hardware, came from the way that the phone looked, came from the lighting that was common in a bedroom or whatever. All of this also was a kind of an aesthetic layer to it.
Sonal Choksi
It was also constrained by the technology at the time.
Simon Denny
Yeah, exactly. And all of those things come together to make a particular medium possible, including the network, which I think is also interesting if we're thinking in the future about NFTs.
Sonal Choksi
When you say the network, do you mean the network as in the community around her or the network of her followers and her social graph? Or what do you mean by network?
Simon Denny
I think there are a few different layers to the network thing. The performance, if you categorize it as a performance piece, happened first to her friends that knew her because the strangeness of experiencing that change was the thing that made the effect. But that network of friends also had a second order network of people that knew of her. So this classic social network kind of social graph world spread out into it. But also the hardware, the technological layer of the network, where you couldn't have these distributed performative moments without iPhones, without satellites, without cables. So it's really quite a lot of things coming together in this network, I think.
Sonal Choksi
Interesting. So then, Simon, on that note, what are some of the other milestones for your experience in evolution as an artist in the technological moments?
Simon Denny
Artists have been dealing with technological changes and expressing the visceral feelings of inhabiting new technological moments for a very long time. Surrealism and Dada as an early 20th century moment that dealt a lot with the changes both in advertising language and mediums around communication. Surrealism really leaned into the illustrative aspect of that. But Dada and stuff, artists like Picabia and people making images of machines, of post-industrial revolution kind of worlds. A lot of early modernism is depicting machinic worlds.
When you then jump to the post-war period in the 1960s and 70s, you started to have groups of artists around pop art and neo-pop dealing again with their language of advertising and ambivalence called commercial culture. Artists like Robert Rauschenberg, who was a kind of proto-pop artist, working with people in collectives like EAT, the Experiments in Art and Technology, which happened in dialogue with Bell Labs at the time.
Sonal Choksi
Oh, I didn't know about that. Tell me a little bit more about that.
Simon Denny
I'm not an expert, but there was this really amazing moment where these very prominent people were in dialogue with people in Bell Labs. And so they made experimental, technologically enabled sculptures. There was one Rauschenberg piece that I'm thinking of — I don't know if it was made with EAT or not — but it was like a bed of mud that was bubbling that then had a sensory component on it as well. Really amazing kind of machine and object-based work, but also a lot of theater-based experiments and performances, which were also done with early computer systems.
There were also people being given, for example, early Portapaks, which was the first video equipment by Sony. So Sony was really involved in donating to artist groups. And there was an artist group that was in New York that was really adjacent to the Whole Earth Catalog and the Stewart Brand world.
Sonal Choksi
Yes.
Simon Denny
There was another magazine called Radical Software, which was produced at the time as well. And Radical Software was run by an early artist corporation called Raindance Corporation. They incorporated themselves. And they had a space in New York where several Portapaks were that artists could come and use. They would make footage. They would bring the footage back. And then they would make artist libraries that you could pull as stock footage and make montages from. So that was also a really interesting early moment that inspired me a lot. And out of that group came early experiments in broadcast television and cable network television. There was an amazing collective called Top Value Television, and they produced one of the most amazing artist-made documentaries that was then screened on cable television at the time, looking at Madison Avenue and advertising producers, but also a Nixon convention. They went and made a kind of political documentary. And then, of course, there are more famous examples like Warhol Television and cable networks.
Sonal Choksi
When you said that the example of the early stock library type of idea that people could take and that you said that inspired your work, what really stuck in my mind about that is that's like an analog version of remix culture.
Simon Denny
Absolutely.
Sonal Choksi
And so tell me about how it inspired your work specifically.
Simon Denny
Well, I'm a bit of a historian, and I actually made a show here in London in 2012 at the Institute of Contemporary Art, the ICA, where I managed to convince the broadcasting network who were changing over from analog broadcasting to digital to give us one of the old analog broadcasting machines. And I dumped that in the middle of the Institute for Contemporary Art and put all of these libraries of old network videos made by people like Raindance Corporation and their peers around in a video library where people could watch them. And one of the things that I found in an archive of theirs was a way of categorizing different types of tapes. They made early data versions representing what was being made in those libraries. So I found those resonant with what people were doing on YouTube, what other artist peers of mine were making, which were kind of remixed things and appropriated things.
A bunch of my work is very liberal with ownership. I believe that one doesn't invent something. I believe that one finds things and combines them with things. So I prefer the notion of a value add than a kind of invention. So I don't believe that you can invent things. This is why I think movements like Pop Art were so profound, because the direct appropriative touch of making an image of a Campbell's soup can and claiming that as an original thing, recontextualizing it, was one of the biggest things. And I think sampling culture and all of that stuff builds on the back of that assumption.
Sonal Choksi
I find that so personally fascinating, too. So we talked about some of the pre-influences in the technological side. Let's talk about some of the post-influences, post-iPhone. Are there any other technological moments?
Simon Denny
Yeah. So I think the next big moment in the mid-2010s — I was lucky enough to do the Venice Biennale Pavilion for New Zealand. The Venice Biennale is kind of like the biggest art show in the world, and there are country-by-country pavilions. So I got to do New Zealand. It was 2013-14 I was working on it, and 2015 I presented it. I was interested in the WikiLeaks moment at that time. Artists like Trevor Paglen were involved in those communities, so I was sort of peripherally aware of those groups around transparency and stuff like that. When they released all these documents, I found the clip art on the DoD and internal NSA documents. I found them really aesthetically surprising.
Sonal Choksi
Wow.
Simon Denny
They were these very playful images that were representing kind of very serious things.
Sonal Choksi
That's so interesting. I never thought about that.
Simon Denny
You had literally like a magic card standing in for a big offensive that was looking in on everybody's privacy or whatever. But I was so interested that I really wanted to find some concrete example of who was making those images. Who were those artists? And I found this one guy's LinkedIn page, this guy called David Darchicourt. And David Darchicourt was self-proclaimed on his LinkedIn — this is, again, social media art in a way — he claimed that he was the creative director of the NSA for the 20 years preceding the leaks. And he had a really big Adobe platform portfolio of his work on it as well.
So he had designs he'd done for the NSA: slip mats, mouse pads, training posters, all these things. And I made copies of all of them. I made giant interpretations of his work. I changed medium from them. So I made sculptures out of things that were diagrams. And I situated them in this library right in the middle of Venice next to the Doge's Palace, which was designed by Sansovino, this very important architect there. And that is a very ornate room that has images of druids and wizards and all these fantasy things that went into Tintoretto and all these artists that were working in that period.
And I put his work alongside their work. And there were these crazy synergies: bearded men, strange books. Fantasy imagery that was throughout the NSA material in clip art form was very close and resonant with these Renaissance images.
And also, I guess the key thing was it was a performative piece because Darchicourt didn't know that I did this work.
Sonal Choksi
I was about to ask you if he knew and if you talked to him.
Simon Denny
So it was all appropriated. And the only moment that he found out that that happened was when the Guardian called him on the opening day and said, hey, did you know there's a bunch of stuff with your work?
Sonal Choksi
Why did he react, by the way?
Simon Denny
Oh, I think he was a little confused. He's like, what is this guy doing with this? It was really important to him at the time. And this came out in the Guardian article too, when the Guardian spoke to him. It was really important that he was attributed, which he was. His phone number was on there, just like it was on the web. That was part of my gesture. And I think he found it really interesting, of course, as the gesture was a little bit like performing something like what the NSA was performing on all of us, but on artistic work. And I think that was, again, complicated by the fact that I was from New Zealand. This is US culture in a certain sense. So I think there were a lot of really interesting tensions around ownership.
Sonal Choksi
Right. And it's funny because the technological underpinnings are fascinating to me because you said briefly that in a way him putting that he was a creative director for the NSA on his LinkedIn profile is almost performance art.
Simon Denny
Exactly.
Sonal Choksi
And then the other point is that these materials you're talking about, these artifacts, were leaked online.
Simon Denny
Yeah. And I think this brings up the kind of art networks that preserve and take care of culture. I think they take care of things that are otherwise not seen and not cared for. So I really like to act in that domain. But of course, that's a sort of object-based medium in itself. You want to go into a room in a museum and you want to have a rich experience in there. Translating browser-based work into a projector in a room doesn't always work so well.
Sonal Choksi
Did you create it for the Biennale?
Simon Denny
I created it for the Biennale. The way that it works is you get commissioned. You can kind of do whatever you like. You work with a curator. The government of the country sponsors that and then the Biennale acts as a sort of presenter in a way.
Sonal Choksi
Were there any other technology milestones on the way to crypto and blockchain art?
Simon Denny
I'll say one more. So I mentioned this piece that I made where I was looking at entrepreneurs through DLD, through going and hanging out at conferences. That was really inspiring aesthetically and everything for me.
Sonal Choksi
That's so funny to hear about entrepreneurship as an aesthetic.
Simon Denny
Yeah, I love it. And so this is the thing I leaned into the Berlin of that time as well. And I made a series of works about young startups. So, for example, I took a Wired roundup, like top 10 startups in Berlin, and I made almost like a deal toy meets a gaming computer meets a kind of piece that might go in a trade fair booth or something like that. And I would make these pop art inspired sculptures that were celebrating the culture of entrepreneurship. That was something that I ended up culminating in a big show that I did also in 2015 at MoMA PS1, which was called The Innovator's Dilemma.
Sonal Choksi
Like named after Clayton Christensen's famous book.
Simon Denny
Exactly. The Christensen book.
Where it brought together a bunch of different projects that I was doing in general about entrepreneurship. I made something about South Korean entrepreneurship. I made a big project about Samsung during those years as well, which looked at their turn to be more global in the 1990s.
Sonal Choksi
Right.
Simon Denny
I also did a really big round of work based on Peter Thiel. It was inspired by a moment in New Zealand where it was realized that Thiel was a citizen. And I made a big group of artworks that were based on board gaming and the language of gaming, which mapped out ideological narratives that came from Peter's world, which is very, very influential in entrepreneurship. So I did a show that was at a small gallery in Auckland, in New Zealand, not a kind of big space. But Peter ended up coming there. He ended up seeing the show. We ended up getting in touch after that when he was still based in San Francisco. And that was, again, this really interesting moment of bringing the way that certain ideas were received in a local space with something that was very influential in the business world and the technology world.
I also made artworks about Kim.com, who is this German Finnish entrepreneur who built a platform called Mega Upload, which was one of the most used piracy networks for downloading Hollywood content. He was sued by the U.S. government, I think in 2013, 2012 even maybe. And there was a massive bust on his home, which was a collaboration between the New Zealand Armed Forces and Police Network and the U.S. And they tried to extradite him ever since. Of course, we did a cover story on Kim.com at Wired. That cover story I was very inspired by at the time and also because he was based in New Zealand. And the whole bust went down in this very glamorous property in Auckland. I have to say he's still living in New Zealand. They never managed to actually successfully extradite him. And he made other platforms since.
Sonal Choksi
I was also watching all of my content on his platform actually at the time.
Simon Denny
There was another thing. Living in Germany, you couldn't get Netflix at the time.
Sonal Choksi
Yeah, we were all pirates at some point in our career, especially if you grew up at any point in the 90s and onward. It was all pre-Netflix. That was the only way to get things. Remember burning CDs?
Simon Denny
Oh, of course I remember burning CDs.
Sonal Choksi
Exactly. "You wouldn't download a car," you know.
Simon Denny
Well, now I look back on it as a creator. And there's a big difference when you talked about how you were doing literal appropriation art in the case of that NSA artist. That's a specific performative type of thing. It's a gesture.
Sonal Choksi
It's a gesture.
Simon Denny
Exactly. Now I'm mortified as a creator at how I treated other creators' works when I realized that we just burn CDs, pass them to our friends.
Sonal Choksi
This is a Web 2 question as well, right? A little bit. Because it's also about what is promotion, what is popularity, what is attention value worth and where do you monetize that. Burning CDs is a proto expression of that problem, right?
You've mentioned a few times actually this tension between art and commercialism and I want to go back to it. It's quite fascinating. There's a thread in your work. You seem very inspired by advertising culture.
Simon Denny
Oh my God, yes, yeah.
Sonal Choksi
And a lot of people would argue advertising is not art.
Simon Denny
Yeah.
Sonal Choksi
So clearly you fall in this other camp.
Simon Denny
Yeah. Tell me more about that. I mean, I think it's also not so unusual within the art worlds that I occupy. But essentially, pop art is a really great example because everybody's heard of Warhol. But there are many practices that came in the wake of that big idea and also the scale that he was able to bring to that big idea. I think the notion that pop art proposed that your role as an artist is to describe how it feels to occupy that contemporary world. You're not an ethical agent. It's just like I go into the street and I see a giant billboard and it does something to my heart. And that is culture, right? That is the claim of pop art.
Sonal Choksi
But one thing I do have to ask you about on the advertising and also globalization. So two themes here.
Simon Denny
Yeah.
Sonal Choksi
I think back to when I used to go to India and I'd see Bollywood posters, which is its own aesthetic.
Simon Denny
Hand-painted often.
Sonal Choksi
Totally. That actually is a dying art now. But it was an incredible thing to see that art form, especially in my parents' tiny village.
Simon Denny
Incredible.
Sonal Choksi
It's this pop of color and this kind of almost desert landscape.
Simon Denny
And glamour as well. It's very glamorous.
Sonal Choksi
Exactly, exactly. I edited one of my friends. She's also an author, Virginia Postrel. She wrote a book called *Glamour*, which actually, it's funny you said the word glamour because it has certain specific connotations to it, which I think is great.
Simon Denny
Right, right.
Sonal Choksi
But I do have to ask you, Simon, do you think there's also this kind of monoculture that's happening because of that globalization and in that aesthetic? Because I feel, especially in the case of pixel art, that there was a point when everyone got a little too digitally influenced and everything started looking like the 8-bit thing. And I got very bored of that as well.
Simon Denny
Yeah, yeah.
Sonal Choksi
And so I just wonder if you think there's this sort of homogenization happening as well in the aesthetic.
Simon Denny
Yeah, I guess this is a narrative that comes up from time to time. I mean, it's not only in art that it comes up, right?
Sonal Choksi
Right.
Simon Denny
I mean, Netflix culture is a great example.
Sonal Choksi
Netflix culture is a great example, too.
Simon Denny
But I think people bring it up politically, which is the most charged context for it.
Sonal Choksi
Oh, yeah, yeah, totally.
Simon Denny
There are these conversations about how homogenous things are becoming because of the speed of travel, the ease of travel, these kinds of things. But I don't really believe that that will ever make a true homogenization. And my understanding of the way that cultures have emerged is they always emerge in hybridization. There is no such thing. Again, this is an originality question. There's no such thing as a true original flavor of X or Y. There's no first anything. And there's only kind of encounters. And I tend to think I'm sort of an encounters maximalist or something like that.
Sonal Choksi
I like that. An encounters maximalist.
Simon Denny
I mean, that's something I literally just coined.
Sonal Choksi
I love it. We're inventing things on the podcast. That's how we go.
Simon Denny
But I tend to think that more hybridization is always positive. And I don't believe that this true homogenization really ever happens. There are trends and moments where certain boringnesses settle into a market or whatever, where a lot of people try and do that thing. And yes, I get very bored about that very quickly. Boring homogenous stuff is boring and homogenous. And I think the way that NFTs stratified very quickly in 2021 into particular genres bored the hell out of me. I mean, this is true in the art world as well as the NFT art world. Expensive things are considered to be important. But on the edges of those things, I could tell you 10 examples of things that did incredible stuff with the kernels of things that went into those strata, but then did something truly amazing on the side of it. At the fringes, at the side of those movements, there is always something where somebody is mixing that with something that's never been seen before. That's great. And then that makes something new. And I think that's a very old story.
I also think globalization is a much older story than is often assumed colloquially. Cultures have been mixing across Eurasia, for example, for a very long time.
Sonal Choksi
Oh, totally. I love that you pointed out that this kind of intermixing has been happening for eons. That's great.
Simon Denny
There are many examples across the history of art and culture of things that happen on the fringe of those environments that are a little harder to see at the time, that certain enthusiasts get really excited about around them as they happen, but don't scale in the same way, don't reach the same price points, don't enter the same museum collections, that are then later looked back on and seen as things that happened there that were just super exciting.
Sonal Choksi
That's fascinating. When I think of even the outsider art movement, and this is a very literal interpretation of fringe, and I know what you mean as fringe is more nuanced than that, but I have a piece by Howard Finster.
Simon Denny
Oh, interesting.
Sonal Choksi
It's one of his dinosaurs. It's a little cardboard cutout dinosaur on a little platform.
Simon Denny
Wow.
Sonal Choksi
And he's handwritten in Sharpie, all these biblical verses, like fire and brimstone. And it's really fascinating because he was an ex-minister. And to me, that's an encounter between Christian faith and thinking combined with this encounter with evolution and what it means. Because it's so bizarre to have biblical verses on a dinosaur.
Simon Denny
That's incredible. It's so great. Oh my God, I want one.
Sonal Choksi
Oh, yeah.
Simon Denny
I think what's really interesting about outsider art in general as a category is that I think a lot of people that came from the art world that I've been talking about up until now, the world that kind of circles around museums and art fairs and galleries, when they looked at NFTs for the first time, I think a lot of them saw outsider art. Because it was people who were not trained in the art tradition, who were given a certain technological stack, who were then able to create and promote and sell whatever work. And that opened up to a whole lot of creators that were definitely not schooled in the canons. And then lots of super interesting weird stuff happened on the side of those, which I personally found as a wealth of compelling examples of emergent culture. And then they became their own kind of homogenizations and canon buildings within that sub-community around NFTs. And those things I found often a little less interesting.
Sonal Choksi
Yes, I totally agree. I'm about to ask you about blockchains and NFTs in just one more minute. I'm also trying to think of when outsider art becomes establishment in other ways.
Simon Denny
Henry Darger is a very canonical example.
Sonal Choksi
It's a very strange hierarchy that gets established, especially with the use of the term "outsider." It also kind of brands somebody as not legible and includes them in the canon, but as an outsider. These tensions are very strange. It's about academy versus not, and certain people who are able to say that's important and that's not, and value and where money lies, and all these other things that are really interesting around culture.
Okay, great. Let's talk now about blockchains and crypto art. So you mentioned all these technological milestones on your way to your evolution as an artist. Tell me about how you came to blockchain art.
Simon Denny
Yeah. So, if you're muddling around in Berlin, in the communities that are building new products and new companies in the early mid-2010s, you come across Bitcoin. And the more I dug into Bitcoin culture, the more fascinated I was. As somebody who's looking for new, inspiring narratives, this notion of sovereign free money, I then started to pay attention to people who were advocating around exit versus voice and also self-sovereignty. I read *The Sovereign Individual* as a book. And then, of course, in Berlin, you heard about Ethereum as it emerged because the Ethereum Foundation was getting set up and started there.
So for the 2016 Berlin Biennale, I made my first big piece about crypto. And that was three different fictional trade fair booths based on three different entrepreneurs that were looking at three different narratives that were emerging from blockchain. One of them was Blythe Masters. So Blythe Masters was coming from the banking world. She came out of securities in the 1990s. And she made this company at the time called Digital Asset. I made a big installation about her. I made a big installation about Balaji and about 21 before it was changed or whatever. And then I made a big one about Ethereum and Vitalik. And it was like those three narratives I was looking at at the same time. I made little postage stamps that I worked on with the German postal service. Because I thought postage stamps were both expressions of sovereignty, they were also design objects, and they were also a kind of currency, a parallel currency.
Sonal Choksi
That's also, by the way, fascinating about postal stamps. They are an expression of sovereignty, but they're also ways to get out. They move objects around the world.
Simon Denny
Exactly. They're infrastructure. It's so fascinating.
Sonal Choksi
Right, exactly.
Simon Denny
So I thought they were the perfect sculptural form for work about this emergent network.
Sonal Choksi
So far, you described how you were using blockchain and crypto as inspiration for your art, the subject matter of your art. But now blockchain is a medium. Let's talk about that.
Simon Denny
Yeah, so there were a few people at that time who were starting to design web-based art, like browser art that I described earlier, or Web 2 art, that was based on coding on emergent blockchains. There was a project called Ascribe, which was actually something Vitalik worked on as well at the time, which was an early system that tried to put artworks and link them to the Bitcoin network. There was a conference in 2014 at 7 on 7 that Rhizome did, which was connected to the New Museum, where they pair an artist with a technologist.
Sonal Choksi
Okay.
Simon Denny
And at the time, they designed something based on colored coin, which was essentially an NFT. And then I started to learn about other projects. I learned about Terra Zero, which was a really interesting project, a group that were proposing to make trees own themselves as entities.
Sonal Choksi
Trees own themselves?
Simon Denny
Yeah, exactly.
Sonal Choksi
Wow.
Simon Denny
They were like, look, if you can do a blockchain system based on Ethereum, if you can have smart contracts, then why not give the sovereignty of ownership to the trees? Why not have a commercial forest own the produce of its own work? I was fascinated by that. So I curated a little show in 2018 at a space in Berlin called the Schinkel Pavilion. And that was about artists that were doing these experiments. So also included in that was CryptoKitties.
Sonal Choksi
Okay.
Simon Denny
So I don't know if you remember this, but Christie's did a weird little collaboration with ConsenSys.
Sonal Choksi
Oh, yes.
Simon Denny
Where they sold a hardware wallet with a specially designed CryptoKitty on it.
Sonal Choksi
Right, right.
Simon Denny
Gile Twardowski, who was the guy who invented the visual aspect of the CryptoKitties project, not the mechanics, but the actual cats, made a special one and they sold it as a hardware wallet, which was also specially designed in an auction. And it was big news in the New York Times. And so I included that in the show. I included Terra Zero, this forest project in the show. I included other artists like Kia Kreutler, who was also working around Gnosis at the time, doing interesting designs for that. And the whole show was set up. The curatorial premise was also based on blockchains because I didn't want to decide everybody in the show. I asked somebody else to choose two things and then they would choose two things. And then we did a transparent publishing of all of the decision makers on the wall as a curatorial protocol.
Sonal Choksi
So you turned curation, the act and art of curation itself, into a form of art that actually also showed the process behind the outcomes.
Simon Denny
Exactly. Transparency, networks, all of these things that are so important to blockchain. Decentralized decision making. And so, yeah, we had this protocol that we designed where everybody knew who picked them for being in the show and I wasn't making all the decisions. And that show was called *Proof of Work*, but that was way before NFTs were a thing.
Sonal Choksi
Yes. And before we talk more about NFTs, what do you think is unique about blockchains as a medium for art?
Simon Denny
One of the interesting things about blockchain as a medium, I think, is that the cultural asset and the financial container is the same thing.
Sonal Choksi
Yeah.
Simon Denny
That's sort of true in art in a way. But literally as an NFT, those things are much more structurally combined. And Web 2 art, art designed for social networks, they're also networked objects. They're connected to other things. And settlement is immediate. One of the things that artists got really, really excited about with the emergence of blockchain art, and this is really going into the NFT moment now, but the idea that you could have settlement immediately on sale and that you wouldn't have to have an intermediary because galleries and whatever, it's a very complicated system.
Sonal Choksi
Yes.
Simon Denny
So the simplicity and the directness of that was really attractive, but also this notion of resale royalties. The idea that you would sell something on a secondary market and immediately the original creator would receive some compensation for that. That's been something that the art world's been dreaming about since the 70s. There's a conceptual art piece by a very famous curator, Seth Siegelaub, that he did in the early 1970s called *The Artist's Contract*.
Sonal Choksi
So let's talk about NFTs specifically. We've obviously been dancing around that this entire conversation. But I think crypto art is bigger than just NFTs, to be clear.
Simon Denny
Agreed.
Sonal Choksi
And blockchains as a medium is bigger than just NFTs.
Simon Denny
Agreed.
Sonal Choksi
So we agree on that. But let's talk about NFT specifically, because that's the thing that really captured the mainstream attention and actually maybe even catapulted crypto into much more mainstream awareness. And to be clear, I mean this well beyond the financialization aspects. I'm talking about as an artistic thing. This includes multiple auction houses doing NFT auctions, participating in it. Multiple people who only came to crypto for the first time and set up a wallet in order to buy NFTs. Who knew? Of course, we knew that culture would be the thing that brings people to technology. I mean, retroactively, it looks logical, but I don't think that was a given.
Simon Denny
Oh, interesting. Tell me why.
Sonal Choksi
Well, I don't know. I mean, I think the moment that changed for me from knowing about a small group of people messing around with blockchains, making art with it, to the post-Beeple auction moment. I guess that's maybe the...
Simon Denny
Beeple is the right thing. Pre-Beeple and post-Beeple.
Sonal Choksi
Right, exactly. Pre-Beeple and post-Beeple. And that was also in cohorts with the auction houses. I mean, Beeple was not an unknown entity before that auction, but he was known in the graphic arts world. He was a very, very well known figure there. But then with the signal from the blue chip art world, from those auction houses, I think those are the things that created that change in awareness.
Simon Denny
Yeah, say more like why you think it wasn't a given that this would happen.
Sonal Choksi
Well, if I think back to Web 2, for example, I don't think culture was the thing that brought that into mainstream awareness and usage. I mean, unless you count sociality as a layer of culture, which I guess one could, and I guess I do in a way, but it's not high culture. You didn't learn about Facebook or MySpace because of an exponent art. Whereas I think a lot of people's mainstream adoption and understanding of Web 3 came around that moment, which was associated with art and an artist. Web 1 also didn't happen like that. You didn't hear about the internet because you heard of some artist piece being made by an artist.
Simon Denny
No, I agree. I totally agree with you. You've said multiple times in this conversation that culture emerges. And so what do you think about this moment made this the time? Like, why now?
Sonal Choksi
Well, I mean, auction houses are always looking for new things, new markets. They've constantly done that. Before the 1970s and 80s, they didn't sell contemporary art, for example. They only sold old masters. So moving into new areas is kind of a textbook thing. But then DeFi Summer came and there was all this liquidity created in the ecosystem from people who had been successful, which then they started to filter into these cultural assets. And I think that was what built up to the crypto.
Simon Denny
Yes, but why the art? Because it could have also funneled that liquidity into something else.
Sonal Choksi
You know, I can't answer that question. But I think people want to buy art that supports the cultures that they believe in. It's about identity and belonging.
Simon Denny
Yeah, exactly.
Sonal Choksi
And affiliation. And people who'd been excited by what was possible within the DeFi world, within the crypto world in general, saw an emergent cultural package that kind of embodied the value of that. And they were like, "OK, I believe in this culturally." And I think that mostly really happened around PFPs.
Simon Denny
Yes, profile pic type art.
Sonal Choksi
Profile pic type art, like CryptoKitties and CryptoPunks. Artistically, it's a really interesting mechanism. You sell something initially to a large community. A bunch of people hold the same thing. And then that also moves around in networks. It changes ownership, owner to owner. And with that, the community grows. The people who have touched that asset. And that means that a large group of people are suddenly almost fractal participators in one cultural moment.
Simon Denny
Totally.
Sonal Choksi
In one cultural asset.
Simon Denny
You know what I mean? Yes, exactly. They're designed to participate in networks where the provenance is important.
Sonal Choksi
Yes.
Simon Denny
Where it came from, where it's going to is important. Tracing these relationships as a part of the medium is what's so super interesting about that.
Sonal Choksi
It's fascinating. And the networks themselves are in the cloud.
Simon Denny
Or blockchain. One of our colleagues, Tim Roughgarden, calls blockchains "computers in the sky."
Sonal Choksi
Yeah. Because they operate without any central authority, accessible to all. You talked earlier about coming from New Zealand.
Simon Denny
Yeah.
Sonal Choksi
And this idea of the borders and the inspiration for you being almost global by default. This is that exact example, the portability of the asset. It's not just that. It's the portability of your humanity, your identity, who you are, your network. Or even belonging in a network, regardless of border, place, location, into a different kind of identity online.
Simon Denny
Yeah. And I mean, there's a more human side to this argument as well. The Donna Haraway notion of the community of kin, but it's that within a digitally designed artwork network.
Sonal Choksi
I mean, that's so beautiful. Say more about community of kin.
Simon Denny
Well, one of the cool things that I found in art school was that me and this one other person loved this one artwork by this one artist. And we found a passion in there that meant we were compatible across all sorts of different things.
Sonal Choksi
Oh my God, you're so right. One of my absolute favorite artists is this New Orleans artist named Rebecca Rebouche.
Simon Denny
I'm a big fan of her work.
Sonal Choksi
Very fantasy. She has a lot of portals.
Simon Denny
Yeah.
Sonal Choksi
I love that type of thing. And I collect a lot of her pieces.
Simon Denny
Oh, interesting.
Sonal Choksi
And so I went to her art patron dinner, and I've been to multiple shows of hers. And I feel like the community that comes around the art, these are people I've never met before. I have no history, no demographic in common. It's an instant affiliation and true connection.
Simon Denny
Yeah, exactly. Because what better proxy for understanding that kind of like-mindedness than having that same shared love?
Sonal Choksi
Oh my God, I totally agree.
Simon Denny
It's a really precise cultural signal. There's also another artwork that I want to mention here that is maybe less known and is working differently than many NFTs in terms of dynamics. It's a project by Sarah Friend, which I actually showed in another curated show that I did later on called *Proof of Stake*. And that was all about ownership in particular. And she did this piece called *Life Forms*, which were designed on Polygon, but the NFTs were designed to only live if they were transferred. And so they had a time life programmed into them where if they stayed in one wallet longer than three months, they would completely self-destruct.
Sonal Choksi
I don't know if you've heard of this, but OG Crystals.
Simon Denny
Oh, yeah, sure.
Sonal Choksi
And the artist is Michael Jew. And he did it with Daniel Griever-Rochko. Anyway, what's really fascinating about it is that the NFT, to your point, has to be transferred in order to exist. With Sarah Friend's *Life Forms*.
Simon Denny
I love that it's called *Life Forms*.
Sonal Choksi
This was really interesting on the coral reef diversity side, where every time you transfer this NFT, the properties of other things in that person's collection inhabit it. It's like an organism.
Simon Denny
Yeah.
Sonal Choksi
Inhabit that NFT. So what happens is, for instance, if you own MiBits, then that NFT, the crystal, the form it expresses will have this 3D, cubic element to the coral. To respond to that shape.
Simon Denny
Exactly. And it evolves.
Sonal Choksi
And so the art itself evolves as it gets transferred, which I think is so fascinating. I have goosebumps talking about this.
Simon Denny
I know, yeah. Because that is the essence of truly being native to the medium. Because it's not just taking something and applying it to blockchains. It's taking the inherent nature of blockchains and evolving that with the art. It's just incredible to me.
Sonal Choksi
Yeah, I agree. And the online-offline connection is also still really important. Even the virtual is so physical, because screens are real, pixels are real. Networks are made of atoms as well as bits. And the recent body of work that I made was actually named a little bit close to this book from Chris. So I made oil paintings of other people's metaverse property tokens.
Simon Denny
Ah, so you made the digital physical.
Sonal Choksi
Yeah, in a way. Because I thought about territory, I thought about community, I thought about history. And I thought about the fact that these tokens, when I looked at something like Decentraland or Sandbox, these very popular crypto-based metaverses, when I looked at the ownership tokens for owning a piece of property in those worlds, I saw a grid that looked to me like mid-century painting because it's a grid. These projects, if you buy a token, you get an NFT that looks like a part of the map of the project. But I was thinking, "Oh, that's so interesting because it looks so much like mid-century painting." And then I was like, "Oh, wouldn't that be funny to paint that actually?" And then I was like, "That would be a landscape painting of a piece of property in the metaverse. That's so weird." And then I was like, "What is landscape painting?" And that again goes back to my background. I grew up in New Zealand. The first thing we learned about is colonial landscape painting. And I was like, "Oh my God, when I see these NFTs, this gridded system, it's like modernism is being projected onto the metaverse."
Simon Denny
That's fascinating. So it's taking an old modernist trope and putting it onto the metaverse.
Sonal Choksi
But it was important for me to underline the networked element as well. So while there were paintings of somebody else's property, I included two QR codes on the side of each painting. And the first one links to the original property. So you can look at the property that the painting is of. Because that's interesting as well about metaverse interfaces. It's already gone through a few rounds of UX. So the painting is often an early version of a landscape, and then you have a link to what the real one looks like now. But then I designed an NFT that looks like an ownership card that you would get in Monopoly for owning a piece of property and tells you who owns that piece right now. And it links you to the person that owns that piece, but it's also permissionless. So it's a painting, which is permissionless, of a property that you don't own, that then you have another piece of ownership property that always links you to the person who currently owns it.
Simon Denny
It's so fascinating exploring the nature of ownership. So this is the exhibition you debuted in San Francisco. Why did you title it *Read Write Own*?
Sonal Choksi
Well, I was really interested in what are good descriptions of what's different about networks. And when I read about Chris's book coming out, and *Read Write Own* was kind of underlined as a way to summarize Web 1, Web 2, and Web 3 was the title of the book. It resonated with also the design on the cover. It was a little square in the middle and a kind of landscape-like object around it. And I was like, "Oh my God, this is what I've been painting. I've been painting the difference of ownership in Web 2 and Web 3 and how these things layer up." Also, ownership is something that's really important in art. It always has been important. And so people owning properties, people owning images of other properties, again, these notions around landscape. When you paint a landscape, it doesn't mean you own it.
It's a picture of something you often don't own. The other thing that's fascinating to me about what you're saying is this idea of ownership and what you're doing with the paintings in your exhibit for *Read, Write, Owned*. It's this idea that we ourselves are transient humans and the ways we put our stamps on the world. Sometimes the only thing that endures is art. Whether physical or emotional, the things we leave behind.
Simon Denny
Yeah. And it's funny because I used to be a huge fan of Christo and Jean-Claude.
Sonal Choksi
Oh, yeah, sure.
Simon Denny
Big fan, because I love landscape art. You would think it's so inane, like you're putting plastic to cover trees. How is this art? But I love this idea that humanity is conquering nature in a way that's not extractive. It's actually beautifying it and showing our presence. There's something extremely exquisite about it.
Sonal Choksi
Which I'm bringing up because it resonates with what you're describing with the *Read, Write, Own* exhibit you did.
Simon Denny
Well, exactly. I mean, Christo and Jean-Claude, for those who haven't heard of them, they basically, as a giant sculptural gesture, would wrap significant things. For example, the Bundestag in Berlin, that was a really big one.
Sonal Choksi
That's right.
Simon Denny
They just did in Paris. Well, actually, one of them obviously died, but the spouse is still alive. Yes, and they just did the wrapping of the Arc de Triomphe.
Sonal Choksi
Exactly. So often symbolic things, but also whole islands. Surrounding the Florida Keys.
Simon Denny
Yeah, and it makes a monumental gesture, but it's also at the same time a light touch. You occupy it and then you unoccupy it.
Sonal Choksi
Exactly. And it kind of comes back. It's ephemeral.
Simon Denny
But it's light touch, but it's so heavy in the moment that it's there. And by the way, logistically, incredibly difficult.
Sonal Choksi
Oh my gosh, yeah. They're like massive engineering projects, actually.
Simon Denny
And I bring that up because it is an example of how art is engineering. And you're describing a lot of technology as art, as art is engineering.
Sonal Choksi
Yeah, absolutely. And I think that's exactly what art does really well. That's what NFT art is doing really well for blockchain networks and other types of crypto art as well, like TerraZero that we design. The notion of being able to give ownership to trees over their own sovereign space. These kinds of things are only possible because technologists have architected a certain platform or a certain environment.
Simon Denny
Yes. So let's do some quick lightning round style wrap up. But first, there are a couple of recurring themes. Let's pick them up and bring them back full circle.
Sonal Choksi
Yeah.
Simon Denny
So one is, you've talked a lot about commerce and the relationship to commerce. What do you think about this in the context of NFTs and art? What would you say beyond obviously the valuation aspect?
Sonal Choksi
Yeah. Well, one of the things about NFTs and art is that the financial container is the same as the artistic container. One of the knock-on effects that has happened because of that is that often value is accrued completely to price. I think that is not necessarily the case for all culture. There's a term like "priceless." Often you talk about priceless cultural works. But also there's this notion that something cheap can also be something valuable. And I think that's harder to express in the current technological stack of NFTs.
Simon Denny
What do you think the opportunity is to build that?
Sonal Choksi
Well, I think that there should be another layer of accruing and showing value in NFT projects that is not about how much they cost. I'm thinking about something that could be a curatorial infrastructure for giving different signals that aren't only expressed in how expensive something is. Of course, expensive things that are in museums are important culturally and valuable in that way as well. Part of the price of them being so expensive is about how much people love this culture. But you can make something experimental that might not sell at first, or that might not be expressed as something expensive at first, that will later be cherished and really valuable. There's this notion of the avant-garde, which is really important to modernism, where you can have a small group of people doing an experimental thing that is really unpopular and very hard to understand at the time, that then later gets interpreted and valued in a different way. I think that's a little bit missing from the NFT art world, where financial success is the only expression of cultural value. It's not that I want to divorce that completely.
Simon Denny
No, you can't.
Sonal Choksi
I just think that it needs to be more complex than that.
Simon Denny
I would say multidimensional. Because if you think about all these properties, there's community, there's belonging, there's expression, there's the aesthetic, there's the technological underpinnings. There are so many different dimensions you can assess something on. There's reputation. I totally agree that there needs to be more dimensions on that. One example that I think is really fascinating here: I co-edited a piece by Kai Sheffield, who works at Visa. He wrote a very thoughtful piece on fantasy Hollywood and this idea that you can essentially create characters that can be represented by NFTs.
Sonal Choksi
Oh, wow.
Simon Denny
And essentially create a whole set of storytelling around these characters. So the idea is that NFTs are characters.
Sonal Choksi
Yeah.
Simon Denny
And the other point is it's really about who gets to make—this is a recurring theme in what you've been talking about.
Sonal Choksi
Yeah.
Simon Denny
Who gets to make these characters? Because right now it's centralized Disney, or a certain type of artist.
Sonal Choksi
The IP world, right?
Simon Denny
Yes, exactly. So this idea that you can actually share and create this IP. But the real idea here is that NFTs in that sense represent community, belonging, character creation, collaboration, and a community of storytelling.
Sonal Choksi
Yeah. And it's funny because I was debating this with Bob Iger a couple months after we did our podcast together with Chris Dixon. He kind of brought up, "Is it really possible to tell really good stories in a decentralized way?" And I was like, "It's funny you say that because you acquired Lucasfilm." We talk about Star Wars, this franchise that was created by one person. After that, many people took over and extended the canon and did different things with the stories. But there's actually a pre-story that no one talks about, which is that Star Wars itself is oral myth and storytelling that's been propagated over centuries.
Simon Denny
Right.
Sonal Choksi
Based on these hero story archetypes.
Simon Denny
Exactly, the Campbellian myths and the archetypes, the Jungian ideas. And that bubbled up into what became Star Wars, which now has become a canon, and then that went beyond canon, and then we went back to a new canon. It's continuing.
Sonal Choksi
And so if you think about the NFT aspect, this is very empowering for people and you could add value that way. This relates back to my pop art thing and also the best parts of NFT art, which is this permissionless thing that I was leaning into with my canvases. This notion that you can take something that has a powerful effect in the world, like a Campbell's soup can, that has a cultural effect that you live in and live with, and you can work with that and make expressions of your own. That's kind of what Andy Warhol did, in a way. And there was no kickback to Heinz. But in a way, there was an attention kickback, or a kind of valuation, a branding kickback maybe, because it's the notion of the Campbell's soup can.
Simon Denny
Totally, totally.
Sonal Choksi
But I think there could be a more nuanced ecosystem around defining where value is added in that exchange.
Simon Denny
That's right. I do want to ask you a question about where you think generative art and blockchains intersect.
Sonal Choksi
I think we get to a bit of a problem here with term definitions as well. Because I understand the broader definition of a generative piece is where you set up a protocol, you put something through a protocol, and it has a series of outputs. And those outputs are artworks.
Simon Denny
That's right.
Sonal Choksi
But I think generative art now has come to mean, colloquially, a particular aesthetic. It's not about the process.
Simon Denny
Oh, you're right.
Sonal Choksi
It's rather about, "Oh, this looks sort of like an abstract shape. It has a gradient to it."
Simon Denny
Yeah, you're right. I find that trope, unfortunately, a little dull because this is where the homogenization question comes in and it actually starts to get really boring. But the notion of artists setting up protocols and having outputs and that being a methodology, that I find super interesting.
Sonal Choksi
I agree. I would say there are three layers. One is the generative as you actually have a beginning of something and it sets up a protocol and it creates a certain output. There's a dynamic nature. The OG Crystals project that evolves is by definition generative. And a lot of PFP projects are also generative by definition, even though that's maybe not what you think of as generative art, because this is a by-necessity thing as well. If you want to make a collection of a thousand things, you're not going to design every single one from scratch the same way. You make up a protocol and then it produces a thousand of those. That, I would argue, is a different definition because this comes to the debate between customization and configuration. There is something that's truly generative where it's unknown what the output is going to be.
Simon Denny
Yeah, right.
Sonal Choksi
Some of the PFP projects fall in this category. Not all, but some of them, just to be even more nuanced. It's actually, in that case, more that you have a set of attributes that you're just applying. Like CryptoCoven, each of those witches, they have a very thoughtful approach. They've actually written some beautiful pieces on how they thought about the properties that would manifest as different people minted the witches and how they sort of constrain them. That's another aspect of that. And then there's a third part, which you're saying you're kind of bored by, and I don't disagree to some extent, which is this aesthetic where now this is all what generative art looks like. I personally do love that aesthetic, I have to say.
Simon Denny
There's nothing wrong with the aesthetic.
Sonal Choksi
No, no, I agree.
Simon Denny
I agree.
Sonal Choksi
But there's Zancan and there are really interesting people who are doing very interesting riffs on it.
Simon Denny
Those are the people that emerge to the bubble. And Helena Sarin, I love her work.
Sonal Choksi
Yeah. There are a lot of artists whose work bubbles up in that sense and they bring a certain element to it. But like Sol LeWitt—
Simon Denny
Yeah, sure, exactly. How would you connect him into this movement?
Sonal Choksi
Well, Sol LeWitt is this mid-century artist who basically designed instructions. When you bought an art piece of his, you bought the right to perform the instruction, or even the right to employ somebody to perform the instruction. So it's kind of an algorithm that you buy, which is really amazing. These are for wall drawings in the case of Sol LeWitt. And coincidentally, they look like what we think of as generative art. It's great, blocky aesthetic.
Simon Denny
Yeah, it's based on vectors and gradients and lines and patterns. So it has this abstract element that reminds us of what we think of as generative art now. But Sol LeWitt to me, the interesting part is—I'm going to say something maybe controversial here.
Sonal Choksi
Love it.
Simon Denny
The notion of buying the idea is the thing that I like about Sol LeWitt. The way they look on the wall, I mean, fine.
Sonal Choksi
I'm with you.
Simon Denny
Oh my God. I'm 100% with you, Simon. In fact, this is a great example where I think, as a collector, I'm very careful to watch myself for if I'm falling for the idea of the thing versus the actual visceral response of the thing. Sometimes I have to hold myself back. Because intellectually, and definitely that's a component of my decision making, I have to intellectually respond to it—the visual language, the symbolism, the lore. But at the same time, I have to have a visceral response inside that I feel something, and a visual response that I really want to look at it every day. That's incredible and very difficult to capture.
It's very difficult to capture, but that's the holy grail of the art experience. But I do think some projects in the academic, conceptual art moment, which came up in the mid-century in the 60s and 70s, were explicitly anti-visual. The work didn't exist. You were only moved by the pure idea. That was a kind of aesthetic notion that came up around conceptualism. The earliest example of that that has been interestingly revisited in NFTs is Yves Klein and this moment of the invisible artwork. He made a piece that was made in French. Basically, it was one of the first motions in the late 50s where people bought something that was actually invisible and you were only buying the aura as a kind of genre. Interestingly, an artist, Mitchell Chan, revisited that in 2017 prior to the protocols that became NFTs. He designed an immaterial artwork that was also based on that notion as a history. Because what felt like at the time you were buying when you bought an NFT was very ephemeral. That work, for example, I love. Even though there's no visual necessarily associated with it, I'm as moved by it as I am by a very visceral painting. Sometimes just the idea is the thing that moves you.
Sonal Choksi
Yes. There's also this thing that happens with early technologies where people are limited. They think they don't see the expressivity that's possible. So they almost go for the most reductionist way of interpreting that piece and thinking about it. To bring it back to generative art today, I think we're going to see a lot more very interesting things happen. And one thing I will say from a technological perspective, I ask everybody this question because I'm obsessed with generative art.
Simon Denny
Oh, interesting.
Sonal Choksi
Again, for a very long time.
Simon Denny
Yeah.
Sonal Choksi
Which is: what is unique about blockchains? Generative art is not native to blockchains as a medium.
Simon Denny
Right, yeah.
Sonal Choksi
But it seems like it's found its native medium in blockchains. One of the technological answers I heard from one of the people on our team, Michael Blau, and a couple of other people made this observation: at the end of the day, it was so compute intensive to unfurl the code and the package and the storage involved. So there's something really great about having this executable on chain that lets you unfurl these things visually. I think it'll be really fascinating to see as the technological constraints get lifted and we advance blockchain performance, scalability, everything. What will then become possible when you can unfurl things on chain?
Simon Denny
Totally.
Sonal Choksi
So I think we're going to see a lot more expressivity at that point. One of the generative projects that I really love that I think falls under your categories as well of defining it is Terraforms by Math Castles. I think that is a project which really does all of those things. It plays with history as well because of this ASCII component. It plays with complexity because of this territory component. Also, this notion that you have this metaverse of terraforms that you can invert and participate in on different levels. All of that is pushing the medium of generative art beyond just an output of an algorithm that is really boring.
Simon Denny
So last question for you. Another recurring theme, especially with your own history, just come full circle with where we started. You have traveled from this legacy to digital art world. What are some of the things, if you were to tell people on the legacy side about the digital side, and then vice versa, for the digital world trying to understand the legacy world, what would you say as a person who travels between both of those worlds?
Sonal Choksi
I think about it a lot because I do exactly that. I value those communities as much as each other. I think they're both really compelling places to be and to care about culture and to make things and to learn about things and to collect things. So I would say, speaking to a legacy person about the digital art world, take the time to get to know somebody who's passionate about what is going on there. Don't start with the *New York Times* or whatever. Don't just look at what you see first and come with your priors and biases. Embrace the learning curve that is the exciting moment of getting to know somebody's passion and why they think this project is interesting and that project is boring.
Simon Denny
And what would you say specifically about crypto and blockchain art to that same person?
Sonal Choksi
Well, one of the challenges I've always had with addressing the legacy art world with crypto and blockchain art is that people in the legacy world hear the word "crypto," hear the word "blockchain," and think, A, too complex. "I'm not part of that community. I don't understand the technology. Therefore, it's too much work to engage." And two, they also have a whiff of scandal around it or a swindle. To a lot of art world people, that's a red flag for bullshit. So they just don't want to see that. So I would also say this is a little avant-garde community that has its own aesthetic dimensions. Yes, there's a learning curve to understanding it. But honestly, in the art world, there's always a bit of a learning curve. You have to study art for several years to really get into histories of the avant-garde. That's a rewarding process. People stay there because they love that. They love to get into those complicated discourses and histories. So there are actually a lot of rewards for legacy art people if they would take the jump.
Simon Denny
And then what would you say on the flip side for both the digital artists understanding the legacy world, and then specifically for crypto?
Sonal Choksi
Yeah. So digital artists understanding the legacy world, I think there's a lot more continuity there than they might imagine. I think that often around these worlds, the notion of new things has a high premium. Understanding histories that actually have played into those is kind of undervalued. So I would say to those people, and I actually often do this, "Oh, you're really interested in this artist that made this kind of digital artwork? Here's this legacy art person who you've probably never heard of, who did something like Sol LeWitt or whatever, that resonates with exactly that gesture." They're often really charmed by that. And by the way, you're not saying that in a pedantic way of, "Oh, that happened before." It's more, understand some of the previous movements because it might inform and inspire you.
Simon Denny
Yeah, I'm a pedagogue sometimes too, so I have to watch my tone.
Sonal Choksi
But the situation is more like, "You love this, you'll also love this." Clusters of interest.
Simon Denny
Exactly. It's like an Amazon recommendation. And that's about sharing passion again. That's a beautiful thing.
Sonal Choksi
And then on the crypto-specific side, what would you say to that group, not just digital, thinking about the legacy art world?
Simon Denny
Well, I would do a more nuanced version of the same thing where I say, "Oh, you're interested in the history of networked artworks based on this particular asset form. There's this amazing group of people that were making things for cable networks in the 90s. Isn't that incredible? Look at this Port-a-Pak art that was created around this thing." Again, it's about encouraging and getting the infectiousness of the love that comes at the core of those projects.
Sonal Choksi
Well, I think that's a beautiful note to end on, Simon.
Simon Denny
Yes. This has been a fun conversation. And I'm so excited to see more of your work. The next thing I'm doing is building a big project about space. I'm looking at the kind of space networks and the way that people are imagining building in outer space. I'm building an augmented reality work that is based on a sculpture of a megastructure that will hang in the Auckland Art Gallery in New Zealand, but will hopefully travel in the future as well. That is actually based on the work of a company as well.
Sonal Choksi
I love it because it's going all the way from the outer worlds, the inner worlds, to external space worlds.
Simon Denny
Exactly. And technological paradigms enabling new types of culture and worlds. It's a totally different kind of world building.
Sonal Choksi
Exactly. Thank you so much for joining this episode of *Web3 with a16z*.
Simon Denny
Thank you very much. I've been a long time listener, first time caller, I guess.
Sonal Choksi
Thank you. Yes. Thank you so much.
Closing music fades in
Thank you for listening to *Web3 with a16z*. You can find show notes with links to resources, books, or papers discussed, transcripts, and more at a16zcrypto.com. This episode was produced and edited by Sonal Choksi. That's me. The episode was technically edited by our audio editor, Justin Golden. Credit also to Moonshot Design for the art, and all thanks to support from a16z Crypto. To follow more of our work and get updates, resources from us and from others, be sure to subscribe to our Web3 weekly newsletter. You can find it on our website at a16zcrypto.com. Thank you for listening and for subscribing. Let's go.