Podcast Episode Summary
The podcast episode, hosted by A16Z co-founder Ben Horowitz and Databricks co-founder and CEO Ali Ghodsi, discusses the importance of hiring and firing executives in a company. The conversation revolves around the challenges of scaling a company and the need for effective leadership.
Main Topic: Hiring and Firing Executives
Key Points:
Participants:
Takeaways:
The holy grail of company building is finding product-market fit. But what most people don’t tell you is that once you’ve found it, product-market fit brings its own set of challenges, particularly when it comes to scaling rapidly and hiring the right executives at the right time.
Drawing from their extensive experiences, a16z cofounder Ben Horowitz and Databricks cofounder and CEO Ali Ghodsi sit down to talk about the hardest things about executive hiring and firing, and what is at stake.
They dive into the common reasons an exec fails, why sometimes micromanagement is a good idea, and the difference between someone who has written a playbook and someone who has only run one.
If you’d like to dive even deeper, the Growth team at a16z has spent the last year compiling insights from dozens of leaders at late-stage startups to literally write the book on hiring executives to scale. You can find that book at: http://a16z.com/executive-hiring-playbook
Topics Covered:
Resources:
Read the Executive Hiring: The Key to Scaling in the Growth Stages: http://a16z.com/executive-hiring-playbook
Learn more about Databricks: https://www.databricks.com
Find Ben on Twitter: https://twitter.com/bhorowitz
Find Ali on Twitter: https://twitter.com/alighodsi
Stay Updated:
Find a16z on Twitter: https://twitter.com/a16z
Find a16z on LinkedIn: https://www.linkedin.com/company/a16z
Subscribe on your favorite podcast app: https://a16z.simplecast.com/
Follow our host: https://twitter.com/stephsmithio
Please note that the content here is for informational purposes only; should NOT be taken as legal, business, tax, or investment advice or be used to evaluate any investment or security; and is not directed at any investors or potential investors in any a16z fund. For more details please see a16z.com/disclosures
Stay Updated:
Find a16z on X
Find a16z on LinkedIn
Listen to the a16z Podcast on Spotify
Listen to the a16z Podcast on Apple Podcasts
Follow our host: https://twitter.com/eriktorenberg
Please note that the content here is for informational purposes only; should NOT be taken as legal, business, tax, or investment advice or be used to evaluate any investment or security; and is not directed at any investors or potential investors in any a16z fund. a16z and its affiliates may maintain investments in the companies discussed. For more details please see a16z.com/disclosures.
Hosted by Simplecast, an AdsWizz company. See pcm.adswizz.com for information about our collection and use of personal data for advertising.
Host
If you're giving them a lot of ideas, like more ideas than you're getting out, then that's probably not going to work.
Ben Horowitz
If I have a new executive, I call them every day. When they're new, I call them every day. When do I call them? Do we have a scheduled time? No, I just call them.
Ali Ghodsi
Can you run a playbook or can you write a playbook? So spend the energy, spend the time. This is one of the most important decisions you could ever make as a leader in your company. Spend the energy.
Ben Horowitz
I got to make a decision about am I keeping your peer or am I keeping you. Mistakes are costly. Mistakes take between a year and a half to two years.
Ali Ghodsi
I always find if you give somebody a task and they get super emotional, then they're done.
Ben Horowitz
I think companies quickly form a culture. And fortunately or unfortunately, the more successful they are, they become a little bit arrogant. So companies typically are not super open to massive change.
Ali Ghodsi
You think you're being like objective and factual. What you're really being is emotional, defensive and afraid of the actual truth. And the actual truth when you fire somebody is mistakes were made.
Host
The holy grail of company building is finding product market fit. But what most people don't tell you is that finding product market fit brings its own challenges. All of a sudden, you need to scale really quickly. And scaling really quickly is actually really hard. One of the hardest yet most critical aspects of scaling is finding the right leaders at the right time. And while the growth stage of a company is hard, it doesn't need to feel like things are constantly breaking.
If you're like two people and you find product market fit, you can grow 10 people or something like that in a year. So that'd be like a 5X. But if you're at scale and you try to 5X, I mean, you're going to completely blow up the company. It's pretty rare to see like a big giant corporation that's figured out how to really be a team of small companies, a small business unit. At some point, they're going to reach a level of scale and complexity where like one guy just can't like run everything. And you're going to need to bring in the experts, right? The experts, the technically trained experts, the managers.
The growth team at A16Z has spent the last year culling the hard-earned insights of dozens of leaders across the firm and late-stage startups to literally write the book on hiring executives at scale. You can find that book at A16Z.com slash growth slash executive dash hiring. But in today's podcast, two of those leaders, A16Z co-founder Ben Horowitz and Databricks co-founder and CEO Ali Godsey, sit down to talk about hiring and firing executives. including the most common reason an exec fails, why sometimes micromanagement is actually a good idea, and the difference between someone who has written a playbook and someone who has only run one. Ben also sits on the board of Okta, Databricks, and more, and he's scaled up several organizations in his past, including LoudCloud that went public in 2001. Ali, on the other hand, took over Databricks in 2016 and has since scaled the company to over 5,500 employees.
Before we jump in, just a few quick notes. The first is a language warning. You'll also hear Ali refer to super ICs. ICs refer to individual contributors without direct reports. You'll also hear Ben and Ali refer to some of the executives that they've worked with. Mark Craney was Ben's former head of sales at Opsware, while Ron Gabrisco is Databricks' current CRO. All right, let's kick this conversation off with where executive hiring often begins. recognizing the hard truth that you've outgrown someone. As a reminder, the content here is for informational purposes only, should not be taken as legal, business, tax, or investment advice, or be used to evaluate any investment or security, and is not directed at any investors or potential investors in any A16Z fund. Please note that A16Z and its affiliates may also maintain investments in the companies discussed in this podcast. For more details, including a link to our investments, Please see asyncc.com slash disclosures.
How do you know when you've outgrown an existing leader?
Ben Horowitz
It's when you're asking other people, what do you think? But when you're starting to have the thoughts of like, is this the right person or is it not the right person? You're done.
Ali Ghodsi
I always find if you give somebody a task and they get super emotional, then they're done.
Ben Horowitz
Yeah.
Ali Ghodsi
I can't handle anything else. When you can't even process it, somehow it's gotten away from you.
Ben Horowitz
Another one that I find is leverage. If you have somebody who's really doing the job, what you always find as CEO is they're teaching you about how the function should expand, how should it grow. And if you're giving them a lot of ideas, like more ideas than you're getting out, then that's probably not going to work.
Ali Ghodsi
I agree with that, but that's a high bar. If they're still adding value and they work and they make the company better and so on. You might want to keep them. Like that kind of leverage where you're saying like, you know, this person just takes care of that thing and they're so good at it. I'm just trying to like keep up. Can you keep me in the loop of how you even do this thing? I'm learning, I'm taking notes. That's phenomenal. We should strive for that. That's what you, you know, like when you pay a guy all that equity and all that money, that's what you expect, right?
Ben Horowitz
I agree with that. That's what you strive for.
Ali Ghodsi
But then what happens is, turns out they are like that, but they're a terrible communicator or they're an amazing communicator and they're super awesome about it, but they just blab forever. So they'll have like weaknesses. They'll have like big weaknesses.
Ben Horowitz
Yeah, yeah.
Ali Ghodsi
But you always take the weakness against the magnitude of the strength, right?
Ben Horowitz
Yes, exactly. And then the causes for people running out of gas, I always find, are also many. Could be, you know, you promoted them and they continued to do their old job and they never actually figured out what the new job was or the company just outgrew them. or like sometimes there's like actual personal, like they've got a drug problem, they're getting divorced, like something happens and the person you hired and you had for a while isn't that person. And that one is very confusing to me always because you're like, you thought you knew who they were, but they're not that anymore. There's something else.
Ali Ghodsi
I also think confidence is important.
Ben Horowitz
Yeah.
Ali Ghodsi
Once the executive feels like it's not working and they're on the back foot. They spiral.
Ben Horowitz
Yeah, they spiral.
Ali Ghodsi
and it's very hard to actually like turn it around, right?
Ben Horowitz
Yeah. To get back into it.
Ali Ghodsi
Well, and then if they lose the team, it doesn't matter.
Ben Horowitz
The one thing that's always true is if the team doesn't believe in the executive anymore, it doesn't even matter. Like say whatever you want to me, Ali. I still have to fire you because nobody's following you. You're almost better off starting anew somewhere else.
Ali Ghodsi
Yeah, as opposed to wrecking your reputation by continuing here.
Ben Horowitz
When do you give somebody a chance to grow?
Ali Ghodsi
Well, I think, as you said, There has to be a superpower there that you have identified. They can come up with an amazing product, or they're amazing communicators, or they can really get the team to execute. Then the question is, can you just put them in a position where you can accentuate that strength?
Ben Horowitz
And fill in the gaps.
Ali Ghodsi
Yeah, like patch up.
Ben Horowitz
The other thing I'd say is, I think a mistake a lot of companies make is, in engineering and in product and so forth, the knowledge of how your company works is really, really valuable. But in sales and marketing, the knowledge of how other people's companies work is actually the more valuable thing. And so if you take somebody who only knows your company and they have to go learn the world, you're kind of harming everybody in the company because if you're going to pay somebody to do that, go pay somebody who knows the world. Like go buy the knowledge, go buy the acceleration as opposed to, and I don't really care how much potential your internal smart MBA who doesn't have any experience has, the idea that they're going to run worldwide sales for you if you've got a killer product and get that done fast is probably wrong.
Ali Ghodsi
I just think it's because people with the wrong background are trying to figure out the other side. So you typically have tech CEOs and founders who are really good at tech. They're smart. Maybe they have an engineering degree. And like, well, how hard can the sales or marketing be?
Ben Horowitz
Yeah, it turns out very hard.
Ali Ghodsi
You know, if you have somebody who runs out of gas, then do you fire them? Do you level them?
Ben Horowitz
I definitely think that you can put people in new roles and they can succeed in it. There's circumstance, right? so there's i've got an early team and everybody's doing everything in the beginning yeah and people are taking on roles that are eventually going to be bigger than them then there's i hired a high-end vp of marketing gave her gave him a point and a half equity and a big salary i can't level them can i you can i think it's going to be hard to put them in a new role and remove all their equity and it's too hard to take those away. What I have done is, you know, look, it turns out I don't think you're really, like, you don't need to express it this way, but this person is not amazing at running a big team. And, you know, they're really a super IC.
Ali Ghodsi
It's very often I see super ICs who went into management and it doesn't need to be on the tech side. You find them in all kinds of roles. They're just so good that eventually they started managing, but actually they're not good people leaders. And, you know, eventually their team is just doing random things and they don't kind of care because they're business super ICing, doing the work of two, three people themselves. In those cases I've been able to take them out and say, hey, look, I'll give you a fancy title. You move over here and do the super IC stuff. And you're extremely valuable because honestly, you're better than most of these people that you used to manage because you're a super IC. But don't try to lead also a team of 200 people because you're actually not leading them.
Ben Horowitz
Yeah. So that's the use case that you think works, that you're switching them back. You're saying, look, you do great work. So we over promoted you to something that you're not good at.
Ali Ghodsi
Yeah.
Ben Horowitz
And let's put you back what you're good at and I'll still pay you a lot of money and give you a good title. But you got to not lie to yourself if you do that, because it's easy to lie to yourself and say, well, this person has some bright strengths, so that way I don't have to fire them. I can just put them in this other thing and overpay them.
Ali Ghodsi
Yeah.
Ben Horowitz
Look, there is a failure mode, which I've seen, which is you move a person to a new role. And then what happens is they start checking out. They're like checked out.
Ali Ghodsi
Whereas they actively disengaged
Ben Horowitz
Well that one is maybe at least you know
Ali Ghodsi
But the person you like who kind of just disengaged and kind of just phoning it in is the hardest one
Ben Horowitz
So I think you have to do a hard thing about hard things And there I think there really no option but to have the conversation. And they know. People don't want to say, look, man, you checked out. It's not working. We tried it. Let's move on. And I have found in those cases, they all like sort of feel ashamed and like, yeah, I know. I know I've been phoning it in.
Ali Ghodsi
Yeah.
Ben Horowitz
Well, that's an important kind of part of it. And it kind of gets to the next thing, which is, okay, how do you have the conversation. And the mistake I see CEOs make is, okay, the way to have the conversation, you know, particularly engineers, is to be correct. Stick to the facts. Stick to the facts. Enumerate them fast. The undisputable facts about why you should be. Why you're wrong. Why you're bad.
Ali Ghodsi
Yeah.
Ben Horowitz
Why you suck. Why you're losing your job. Which is the worst starting point at all, right?
Ali Ghodsi
Yeah.
Ben Horowitz
Ironically, you think you're being like objective and factual. What you're really being is emotional, defensive, and afraid of the actual truth. And the actual truth when you fire somebody is mistakes were made. If you're being objective, it's always partially your fault, usually more than half your fault, if you're honest. And so if you start from a place of the truth, which is kind of what you're talking about, hey, you're not putting in an effort, is always a much better than, let me tell you all the places where you came up short. Like if you start the conversation there, they have no choice but to get very defensive and say, well, I don't agree with that. Like, da-da-da-da. If you really actually thought you were right, you might get squeezed into not actually even finishing the firing. So you kind of have to just start from the place of most honesty. Look, one, this is a done decision. Two, it's my fault too.
Ali Ghodsi
Or like, if you're not ready to fire them, you want to know why their work sucks. Just say, hey, like, here's what I observed. What's going on? That's just the 101, right? It's just a normal 101 where you're like, hey, what's going on with the output of this thing? And, you know, like things happen in those conversations. You find shit out. And it could actually help him. You know, I was talking to an entrepreneur the other day and he's like, you know, he starts hitting on me with the exact thing that you always started. And like, you know, I, you know, I, I'm trying, I'm struggling with, you know, being a CEO, whether I should, you know, I want to be empathetic, but am I tough enough?
And I'm like, who are you talking about firing? You're not being tough enough. And, you know, of course, like there was a super talented guy slacking off and so forth. I said, just start it there. Don't put so much pressure on yourself that you got to go right to firing him. Just find out what's going on with this guy. And, you know, the interesting thing was he has the conversation. You know, he finds out it was a personal life issue. Once the guy admitted it, he was like, you know what? Fuck this person I'm fighting with. I want to work here and go hard. And let that, like literally that conversation solved it.
Just like a little bit of honesty. But to get to that honesty, you have to start by being honest with yourself. And if you don't tell yourself the truth, if you lie to yourself, then there's no way you're going to get the truth out of the other person. There's no way you're going to get to the right answer.
Ben Horowitz
It's this question that you ask executives a lot and this and that, like, have you fired somebody? And why is that an important question?
Ali Ghodsi
I think it's important because if you don't know how to do that, you don't actually know how to get to the truth. And it gets harder and harder. And the bigger the company gets, the more political it gets, the more difficult it gets. You have more regions, more countries, more people, more functions.
Ben Horowitz
and they're professional execs who know how to manage it up.
Ali Ghodsi
Oh, yeah.
Ben Horowitz
Well, and then you take it all personally. This is my company. I built this. Oh, it's all fucked up.
Ali Ghodsi
Exactly.
Ben Horowitz
I don't want to get to that truth.
Ali Ghodsi
Exactly. Just like you don't want to get to the truth about yourself. And the CEOs who can't do that always eventually fail.
Ben Horowitz
I would say for me, you said it. For me, the number one thing I try to do in the conference, if I've decided this is done, we're parting ways, my first question is usually, how do you think it's going?
Ali Ghodsi
Yeah.
Ben Horowitz
And, you know, 50% of the cases will say it's not going well. It's not. From then, it's much easier to, you know, take it to the next. Like, it's not working. And so we've tried it for a while. We've tried all kinds of things. It's just not working.
Ali Ghodsi
I found that if you can get a person to start it there, instead of saying, hey, here are the things you're doing wrong, or I don't like this, just start with, like, is it working? And if they're not there, then I think step number one is just to get them there to realize that, look, it's not working. Like, marketing is not doing a great job, or sales is not, or, like, engineering is not humming, and we're missing the SLAs. There's outages left and right. And, yeah, it's lots of people involved. It's not just, you know, your department.
Ben Horowitz
Well, phrasing is important. It's not working. How's it going? How are you doing? Like, because as soon as it gets personal, that's when the defensive people have to put up their guard.
Ali Ghodsi
Yeah, and I'll pull it out and I'll say, look, we're having outages left and right. This is going to be a really hard problem to fix. And you've been at it for six months. We've been at it for six, 12 months. In fact, it's increasing. If anything, it's getting harder. And I know it's not just engineering. It's like other departments, sales is promising things. and customers are doing things. But in any department, you could have this conversation. They'll kind of eventually say, yeah, but it's hard, man. It's like, it's tough. Like it's left and right outages. We don't have the right people. I'm not getting any help from sales. I'm not this and this and that. Then you've gotten them to a place where like, look, I think we can bring in someone that can actually fix this. Navigate our organization.
Ben Horowitz
Yeah, someone who can bring in the right people or someone that has dealt with nasty, nasty outages like this or someone who can actually sell to these really, really big conglomerates. Wouldn't that be the right thing for the company.
Ali Ghodsi
So I try to like abstract this away from them. So it's not about you. It's just what's best for this company. Once we've accomplished this, I've actually seen many execs get to that point. Then they kind of turn to me and then they say, they actually will say, okay, I get it. But what about me? Like my career or my path? Then it's like, okay, that's a separate thing. We're going to take care of you.
Ben Horowitz
Actually, you bring up a really good point, which a lot of CEOs don't do this. And it's so important that when you talk about your expectation for an executive, it's not what you and your people can do. It's what you and your people can do in the context of the organization. And that means working with your peers so effectively that you get what you need.
Ali Ghodsi
Yeah.
Ben Horowitz
And if you can't do that, then I got to make a decision about, am I keeping your peer? Am I keeping you? Because that is the requirement. And I think that a lot of CEOs get themselves into trouble because they give executives a pass on that. Oh, no, that's my job to make you guys work together.
Ali Ghodsi
This is a great point. Like, you're in legal, and so, yeah, but the sales team is like, they're giving away liability and indemnification and so on. I mean, what can I do? Like, there's nothing I can do. Or you see the execs doing that, right? But it's really, no, no, no, no. The right leader, trust me, the right head of legal that comes in here will not tolerate that. They will actually pick up the phone and tell the salesperson, hey, here's the framework I've been using. We're going to have an escalation if it's like indemnification above this limit, if it's a liability of this sort, this is what's going to happen. and they kind of push the whole organization in direction. Whereas the leaders that aren't making the cut, they kind of just, you know...
Ben Horowitz
They let it fester till it explodes.
Ali Ghodsi
Yeah, it's fester. The organization gets abused and they can't actually achieve anything and they're in that position. And then they say, look, it's not my fault. Look at these other departments. They're the ones doing it to me. That's when you know that, no, with the right leader there, the right leader will not let these other departments do that. So when you get them all the way there and they go, okay, what about me? like, what's your philosophy on the package, the, you know, references, Reed Hastings in his book, which I argued with him about after he wrote it, said like they sent an email at Netflix saying like, we fired this guy. How do you think about all that?
Ben Horowitz
Yeah, I disagree with that. I think from then on, it's you owe them. You're the one that made the mistake of hiring them to be as generous as possible within reason. You have a company to run, you have fiduciary duty. But as much as you can, if you squint, and in the big scheme of things, it's not going to hurt the company. It doesn't really matter. Be as generous as you can possibly be, both in terms of taking care of them compensation-wise, but more importantly, I think, being there for them psychologically, finding them the next job, being a reference for them, helping them as much as possible.
I think that goes a long way. And actually, you'd be surprised. You can have great relationship with these folks for many, many years to come. Put it on your CV as long as you like. Who cares? And if you need a reference, I'm here. And then on the compensation, as generous as you can be, but there's fairness and there's equity and there's fiduciary duty and so on. But I found you can be more generous and people are very, very stingy in these kinds of situations. And there's a couple of things about that. One is if you are kind of more supportive and generous and you know you're gonna have a relationship afterwards, it's easier to fire the next one because it wasn't like a dramatic horrible like event.
And then, you know, my old friend, Bill Campbell, used to say, he'd be like, Ben, you have to take his job. you do not have to take his dignity. That is not necessary. And I think that that just goes a long way also for the people who are still in the company.
Ali Ghodsi
Yeah, they see how you treat them.
Ben Horowitz
Yeah, absolutely.
Ali Ghodsi
And no matter how bad an executive is, they have some supporters. They have some people who like them.
Ben Horowitz
Yeah, and it's nuanced. They're two sides to the coin.
Ali Ghodsi
Yeah, and that executive is going to talk to them and it's going to matter how you treat them.
Ben Horowitz
We start at the end of the process. You got to fire the guy. Let's talk about bringing them in and how do we stop them from getting fired
Ali Ghodsi
So if you bring in a new exec, how do you help ensure their success? Because the failure rate on that is pretty high.
Ben Horowitz
It's almost always retrospectively, people call it fit. But fit isn't entirely determined by the hire. It's what happens after you hire them. So how do you think about solving that?
Ali Ghodsi
I actually literally give them the article that you published. It's on micromanagement by Ben Horowitz, where you battle Mark Andreessen, who says, you know, you have to delegate and you have to respect the people and you hire them and they do the job, you stay away and you say, no, you got to micromanage them. So I actually give them that article and I just tell them, this is what we're going to do next.
Ben Horowitz
He called it micromanagement. I call it training.
Ali Ghodsi
Okay, training.
Ben Horowitz
Because I think it's an expectation thing.
Ali Ghodsi
Because the thing is if you start micromanaging a person that new in your organization or training them as you call that some people might be offended Hey I don like this What am I getting into This is a new relationship And you going to be breathing down my neck like this 24 Like, I'm not sure this is like a good thing for me. They get freaked out. This article kind of says, hey, it's just a transitor thing. It's a normal thing. Everybody here went through it. We're going to do it here too. So that kind of just sets the stage. So they don't feel like they're being singled out. And in fact, some people might be like, hey, you're actually not that bad even. Like, after reading that article, I thought you were going to be all over the...
Ben Horowitz
Right, right, right. You set the expectation very high.
Ali Ghodsi
Exactly, exactly. And then I think stay as close as you can to them. Weekly one-on-one and so on. That's not going to cut it. You know, you got to call them every day. If I have a new executive, I call them every day. When they're new, I call them every day. When do I call them? Do we have a scheduled time? No, I just call them. A lot of times they'll notice I'm just shooting the shit. I'm not even really actually. I don't have really an agenda. But it's beginning to know each other so we can build up trust and understand.
Ben Horowitz
Yeah, and context. And we're sharing so much that's shared in those. and after a couple months, you're going to feel much more like, okay, I know this person. You know, I've had so many interactions with him. I really know Ali. Like, I know how he thinks and all his weaknesses and strengths. I think the kind of point that you make is really fundamentally important because what I always get from CEOs is they're like, well, how do I manage a CFO? I don't know how to set up a proper control structure or whatever it is that a CFO does. Like, how do I manage these guys who are doing jobs that I've never done? and you kind of hit on it, which is they may know their function. They better know their function better than you. But they don't know Databricks better than you. Like nobody knows Databricks better than you. And you've made every flip and hire, every good and bad architectural decision in the product you're aware of, every customer that blew up you know about. Like you know the comprehensive history of the place and then you know all the people and what they're good at and what they're not good at and so forth. and somebody coming from the outside doesn't have any of that.
Ali Ghodsi
Exactly. They know zero.
Ben Horowitz
Exactly. You're like a large language model trained on trillions of trillions of text documents. You don't even know what you know.
Ali Ghodsi
Yeah, you know many, many years of everything, every little detail, all the context, why, how it went wrong, how it went right, what to do, what to not do. And that, having watched executives fail, that's the number one thing they fail on is they don't have the context. So they'll come in and in the first three months, they'll start working on whatever made sense at their last company. And they're like, well, you hired me for what I did there, right? Because that's where I came from. And then everybody who works for them and everyone around them says, wow, Ali, he paid this guy all this money, giant equity package, and he came in and he did nothing.
And then once the team goes that, that's it. It's over right there. And so you have to guard against that by giving them the context. And that daily conversation, by the way, that is essential. And it doesn't have to go for five years. It goes maybe 30 days. And sometimes a conversation can be just, hey, what are you going to do tomorrow? And what I always find, if you ask an executive what they're going to do tomorrow and they're new, they'll always say at least one thing that makes no fucking sense at all. And so you just could not do that.
Ben Horowitz
By the way, that's a great thing that you want to do tomorrow.
Ali Ghodsi
Yeah.
Ben Horowitz
We have huge fire right here. Like it's going to burn up the whole house.
Ali Ghodsi
Yeah.
Ben Horowitz
Why don't you help us put out this fire instead of that thing? And by the way, if you put out the fire, everybody's going to consider you're a hero because that thing was on fire before you got here.
Ali Ghodsi
But then like I don't even know where is that, which floor is it, what fire is that? I didn't even hear it.
Ben Horowitz
Oh, you don't know? This is the biggest dumpster fire we've had here. You know, it's on the third floor. Go there and look.
Ali Ghodsi
Oh, and tell me more about it.
Ben Horowitz
Oh, here, let me tell you the history of how that happened.
Ali Ghodsi
Yeah, and let me tell you exactly how to fix it because that one I know. I just haven't had the time to do it. That gets them off to the right start. And then also kind of that's how I always find you teach somebody the organization because they go, oh, well, I'm going to go work on this. and they're like, oh, well, you need to talk to Ed because Ed knows all about that. Oh, I didn't even know who Ed was. But why Ed? He's not C-level or Chucky. He's just a random dude.
Ben Horowitz
Yeah.
Ali Ghodsi
Who you would never know about.
Ben Horowitz
Yeah.
Ali Ghodsi
Unless I told you. And you would waste months trying to figure out what Ed knew.
Ben Horowitz
Yeah.
Ali Ghodsi
And so that kind of thing, that's what people miss.
Ben Horowitz
And Andy Grove used to call it task-relevant maturity.
Ali Ghodsi
Yes.
Ben Horowitz
Which is a classic Andy- Complicated phrase.
Ali Ghodsi
Complicated, but if you dig into it, that's exactly what it is.
Ben Horowitz
Yeah.
Ali Ghodsi
Which is, oh, yeah, you're a great sales exec. I don't need to train you how to do that, but I need to train you the tasks that are relevant to us until you're mature on them, and then we don't have to talk every day. And that's really what the micromanagement means.
Ben Horowitz
Hey, let me go back to, you said something really, really important. I actually think this is extremely important. I actually think when you hire a new exec, they come in and usually the organization is also, it's not just you.
Ali Ghodsi
Yeah.
Ben Horowitz
Everybody's looking. Who is this new guy or gal?
Ali Ghodsi
Oh, yeah, everybody's looking.
Ben Horowitz
Everybody's looking, right? Because I know he paid them a lot of money. Who is this? And I don't make that much money. You're sizing them up. You're looking up and down. I'm like, you know, what are they doing here? What are they going to do here? I think it's super important, like getting that first win. And it's got to be in the first two to four weeks.
Ali Ghodsi
Quickly.
Ben Horowitz
Yeah. Get that quick win.
Ali Ghodsi
And similarly, if it's like a big trip up and fall and, you know, big splash, you know, people are like, oh, my God.
Ben Horowitz
Yeah.
Ali Ghodsi
You know, who is this person? You know, what do you think?
Host
And they all will talk to each other. And once it's socialized, yes, it's a very rare bird that will back off the position they took during that socialization. People are watching that first success. Quick first success is important, which then means don't do eight things.
Ali Ghodsi
Yeah, right.
Host
Do the thing. Do the one simple win here. Let's get them. And it's your job as a manager to say, look, hand that on a silver platter to them. It's still going to be hard. Trust me. New company, new people, everything is different. Get them to get that first win. I once had an executive who came and he had read like the Stephen Covey, Seven Habits of Highly Effective People. And he's like, "Well, what I'm going to do is first I'm going to seek to understand and then be understood. And I'm going to spend like a month just talking to everybody." I was like, "You're going to be fired in a month. I'll help you understand."
Ali Ghodsi
So I've actually found that for new people, they come in, especially the ambitious ones. They come in like, "I have so much to add here. I don't know where to start, but we have these eight things we have to fix. I'm going to fix X, Y, Z, A, B, C." And that's when you got to stop them.
Host
Which one is the most important?
Ali Ghodsi
Yeah, let's get one win here. We're focused on one win.
Host
Yeah, one win this week, another win next week.
Ali Ghodsi
Exactly. And then on the daily call, remind them, "Hey, how's that going? That dumpster fire on third floor. Did you put it out?"
Host
Exactly, exactly. So what's the impact of a new executive on an organization and its culture? And what do you want it to be and what do you not want it to be?
Ali Ghodsi
Well, I think companies quickly form a culture. Fortunately or unfortunately, the more successful they are, they become a little bit arrogant. Companies are typically not super open to massive change. Companies don't like someone coming from outside and saying, "This is amateur hour. We're going to do things quite differently. And I'm going to show you because I come from this really big company over there. And I'm going to show you how we did it over there." And then they're name-dropping that company in every other sentence. And you can see people like, "Don't want to hear about Amazon anymore. And don't bring that... This is not Amazon. This is not Google, okay?"
The first thing is, honestly speaking, just fit in. Just become part of the team. Get those quick wins that we mentioned earlier. Once you've been here and people respect you, only once you really rock it, you can start saying that, "Look, this process that we have, it's taking eight days. I think there's a way we could shorten it to four days. Or I think we could actually, if we tried this thing, we could improve our hiring and engineering. Do we want to do maybe a business review on the biggest deals every quarter? Do we want to try that out?" So I think you have to become part of the organism and you have to succeed in it to change it. I think it's very hard otherwise from the outside.
Host
Let's say you need a pretty sharp cultural change. And you guys did at Databricks early on where you were very engineering-centric, I'll just say. And then you needed a sales organization. And you brought in a sales leader and you could have, as CEO, stopped him from bringing what was like a large dose of enterprise software culture into what was a more academic, technology-oriented culture. So how did you stop the company from just rejecting? Because that was so different.
Ali Ghodsi
Look, I think that, like I said earlier, companies get arrogant and they don't want to change. One thing that really helps you is failure.
Host
Yeah.
Ali Ghodsi
You guys weren't selling enough. It humbles you. And you realize, "I need help. I need a helping hand. I'm drowning here." We had huge success in 2015, and we had done a great job with the open source software. It was an awesome company, but we had problems with the revenue. And it was clear that the product-led growth, PLG, that we believed in, we called it Zero Touch at that time, was not working. People couldn't just build it and they come. They weren't swiping their credit cards left and right and paying us. And we could not do a deal that was bigger than 20 or 30K. It was just impossible. So we needed a big change. And I think one important thing is that insight, the CEO has to embrace it. I knew we had a problem. We had not been able, me included, to fix the problem. And so in 2016, we knew that the shift has to happen.
And it was still a give and take. I was myself a little bit like, "Do I want to really?" So to my CRO's credit that first year, I told him, "We're still going to do a lot of the PLG. Because PLG is still our future. But we're going to also do the thing that you're going to bring in that you know really, really well. But don't forget PLG, it's super important." It wasn't until he then went at it for one year. And at the end of that year, suddenly half of our revenue was enterprise. It was very clear. He's right. This PLG thing is just overrated for the kind of business we have and the kind of market we are in. Then I embraced that change. And we put up a gong that we would hit when we closed the deal. And in fact, I embraced it and the engineers loved it so much that they would steal it and they would go hit the gong. I would say, "Hey, guys, you can't do that. This is when we close a big deal." And they'd say, "Well, this is a big deal. We just developed software." It's like, "Yeah, yeah, but you're eroding the whole thing, hitting that thing every 10 minutes just because you're happy."
So we had a great thing. And then at all hands, we really tried to embrace the culture change. For the first time, at all hands, 50% of the time we're going to look at sales deals that we did. And we're going to have the salesperson present how they did. And we kind of motivated both sides. We said that, "Look, we're doing transformational change with software. That's going to change the world. But these organizations are not ready to accept data and AI. The people that are going to help us get that software into the doors there for the large enterprises are the sales folks. So let's embrace it."
Host
When executives come in and they are good, sometimes they'll want to bring like a small piece of culture that is just incompatible. And I think that can be very insidious if you're not careful. There are certain things that you believe in as a company that you've kind of drilled into everybody. And if you bring in an executive who doesn't want to do it and you don't make them assimilate, then you basically destroy that whole piece of things. And I remember when I was at Opsware, we had been through so much. I was just like, "Look, maybe nobody gets rich on this thing, but nobody's going to have a bad work experience here."
I was very hard on that. And I was like, "Everybody's getting a performance review. I don't care. You're writing your reviews." And Cranny comes in and he was like, "Man, fuck you. I don't need to write reviews." So he didn't write the review. And I just withheld all the raises, equity ups, everything for his organization. I was like, "Everybody else in the company got their equity and their money." He's like, "Why has my team got nothing?" I was like, "You haven't written your reviews." And the interesting thing about it, to his credit, his reviews were the best reviews.
Ali Ghodsi
Well, they're competitive, right?
Host
Yeah, very competitive. They're competitive people. So look, I hired an amazing CRO, came in, Ron, right? And took us from zero to billions. But one of the things I heard them say in one of the meetings was they're like, "Damn it, it's SPD." I was like, "What's SPD?" They said, "No, no, nothing. I didn't say anything." And I started thinking, what is SPD? Oh, sales prevention department. I was like, "What the hell is that?" And so, well, the whole company sales prevention department, they're trying to prevent us from doing our job of closing these deals. Engineering can't build the features. And I said, "Hey, I had zero tolerance for that." I went to Ron. I went to all the people. I said, "Don't ever use that phrase here. It's zero tolerance here." Because you get into the big companies, they form cultures like this, where the different departments hate each other more than they hate the enemy. So they end up fighting with each other. I said, "No, we're a small company. We're working together." And to their credit, they said, "No, no, no, 100%. I'm not going to use that phrase." It's like, "No, no, we're all in it together."
Ali Ghodsi
We touched on this a little bit, but what are the most common ways that a new leader fails? One is too much. This is not the right way to do things. Too much destructive. And we're going to have too much copy-pasting what they saw in the previous company. But actually the copy-paste is also an interesting thing in the hiring, because this is where people also make mistakes. They're like, "Well, do I really have to hire an enterprise software guy to run my enterprise software?" Yes. Because whoever you're hiring is going to copy-paste to some degree. You need that. You're buying the domain expertise. You're buying the stuff that you don't know. So if you go and hire an enterprise sales guy who's selling Google AdWords, he's 100% going to fail.
I think when you hire someone, you want them to have seen or done the thing that you need now. And this is, I think, how a lot of people fail or how you hire a lot of wrong people. You need to figure out sales. You hire a guy who's been closing $10 billion for some big company. And he's so good, he managed 10,000 salespeople. And you have 10 salespeople. You're like, "That's great." That's not going to work. Really make sure that they've seen the scale you're at, and they've done that phase.
Host
And really did it. Yeah. Not were around the ball.
Ali Ghodsi
Yeah, exactly. But had the ball. Exactly. And then there's the people that are like, "This person is perfect. Perfect culture match. I think they're great. They can come in and do this. But we have about 500 salespeople, and this person has done 100. Have they ever done 500?" "No, well, once they used to work three years in a company that had 40,000 salespeople." Yeah, that's not going to translate to the challenges you have right now at this particular stage. So there's a difference between just running the existing programs in a large company and creating the programs. Almost like an organizational founder is the way I kind of think about it.
Host
Right. Yeah, like the person who works at a company isn't the person who built the company. And the person who works in an organization is not the one who built it. They really do need to have built it.
Ali Ghodsi
Yes. Like the ride along. Otherwise that's a copy-paste. The people that are just purely blatantly trying to copy-paste, like literally, they weren't a huge organization. They were one of the cogs and they just saw that big cog and they're just saying, "Look, we need exactly a wheel that big and we need to copy-paste it over here." And it's like, "Yeah, but we don't even need it. We can't even fit a wheel that big in here."
Host
Can he run a playbook or can he write a playbook?
Ali Ghodsi
Yes. And writing the playbook. And it's amazing when you actually interview for that. Like, "Okay, tell me what you did at your last company exactly. How was it built? How was it constructed? Okay, now imagine like you're here. How would you write this playbook?" That'll screw people up if they've not done it, right? Like if they only saw it, it's a very tough question for them. By the way, that's how we found Ron was on that question. The way he answered that question for us, even though he came from a company we'd never heard of selling a product that didn't make any sense, that's how he got into the Databricks interview process. And he was like the most left field candidate, but he ended up being the best candidate.
Host
You know, I remember there was a question we had for him, which was, "I need to invest in sales enablement," is what he said. "And I teach people to sell this product." And we said, "Well, we don't have time for that. We're a very fast growing company and we want to get to these targets and so on. We don't have time for enablement. We're going to grow so fast. We're going to hire so many people that there's like just no resources." Because we thought he's a big company guy. He's going to come in and bring in all these different processes. And he said, "Okay, if you want to grow that fast, then I need to do way more sales enablement than I said."
Ali Ghodsi
Wait, that didn't make any sense.
Host
And I said, "No, because we have all these new people you want to hire. They're clueless. They're going to show up here at the elevator and they're just going to look around and say, 'What am I selling here?' We've got to enable them. So we've got to double down even more on enablement. Double that budget." And if you had hired a guy who had only knew how to read a playbook, he would have agreed with you. 100%.
Ali Ghodsi
So do the five whys. Just keep asking. "Okay, so why do you do that? Why do you do enablement? Who runs enablement? What kind of enablement? Okay, what did I do there?" And just keep asking them why. And the people in the interview process that kind of tap out, they're like, "Oh, that's a good question. I don't know the answer. I've got to go figure it out." Like, you can see that it's very surface level. They've kind of seen it somewhere. And now they're trying to copy-paste it over here. They're probably not going to be able to build it. Whereas builders really can tell you, "Oh, then where do we start? How many hours do we have?" Yeah, it's like, exactly. Then, there's like a depth. He's done enablement 15 ways. And then, keep going deep, deep, deep. Don't put up with surface level answers or just one-shot answer questions. Go many, many, many levels deep. That's where you can see how deep they are in the subject area.
Host
All right, closing thoughts.
Ali Ghodsi
All right.
Host
Any other kind of final thoughts on hiring, integrating, firing executives, dealing with executives?
Ali Ghodsi
Start early, your searches. Any search for a person has a trade-off. The trade-off between quality of the person and how fast we get them, right? So like, yeah, if I take forever, I can find the best person. Or I can quickly close the search immediately and find someone that's going to be a terrible person. And mistakes are costly. I say mistakes take between a year and a half to two years. Takes you six months, jury's out. Nobody wants to fire someone within six months of hiring someone, right? So you're taking six months. Then you need to have this conversation. You need to reach an agreement.
You need to figure out what it is. You need to procrastinate because you want to have the conversation. You need to ask a hundred people whether should I or should I not. Then once you've let the person go, now you have to start a new search. Guess what? The second time, you're more nervous. Now you don't trust yourself and your own instincts because you screwed up last time. Now you hire a new person. Okay, you hired the new person. You finally trust yourself. Now you got to ramp the new person to get them back in. Okay, you lost two years. So then how do you avoid that mistake? Start early so that you can kiss a lot of frogs and do a lot of homework, back doors, to really make sure that you're nailing it.
Host
Yeah, that makes a lot of sense. I would say the other thing, particularly for new CEOs, is how do you know what's good? What's a good head of sales? What's a good CFO? Well, the best way to know is actually to talk to a bunch of CFOs. Ask them how they know what's good. What's the difference between a good CFO and a great CFO? How do you know that? How do you interview for that? All those kinds of things, that knowledge, you only get from interviewing candidates. A lot. And if you start early and you're not even filling the position, then you can ask them whatever you want.
Ali Ghodsi
Exactly. And that ends up being basically the script to figure out what it is.
Host
That's a great point. I've seen CEOs who say, "I'm going to have my assistant do the backdoor checks, reference checks. I don't have time for the executive recruiting meeting this week. I'm delegating this. But once we get to the final stages, I'm going to pick." If you're new and you don't really know what a great CFO or CRO or VP of engineering looks like, you should be immersed in yourself, spending all the time interviewing everyone, doing backdoors on everyone, doing dinners with people you can't get.
Ali Ghodsi
Well, is your assistant going to say to the back door, "Is this the best CFO that you've ever seen? Oh, he's not. Who is it? Oh, can you give me her number?" Exactly. They're never going to do that. Spend the energy, spend the time. This is one of the most important decisions you could ever make as a leader in your company. Spend the energy. You can't be spending too much time on this.
Host
Thanks for listening to the A16Z Podcast. If you liked this episode, don't forget to subscribe, leave a review, or tell a friend. We also recently launched on YouTube at youtube.com slash a16z underscore video, where you'll find exclusive video content. We'll see you next time.