Main Topic: The Little Tech Agenda, a framework designed to ensure that regulation works for both giant tech companies and small startups in the AI industry.
Key Points:
Participants:
Takeaways:
Recommendations:
Who’s speaking up for startups in Washington, D.C.?
In this episode, Matt Perault (Head of AI Policy, a16z) and Collin McCune (Head of Government Affairs, a16z) unpack the “Little Tech Agenda” for AI- why AI rules should regulate harmful use, not model development; how to keep open source open; the roles of the federal government vs states in regulating AI; and how the U.S. can compete globally without shutting out new founders.
Timecodes:
0:00 – Introduction
1:12 – Defining the Little Tech Agenda
4:40 – Challenges for Startups vs. Big Tech
6:37 – Principles of Smart AI Regulation
9:55 – History of AI Policy & Regulatory Fears
19:26 – The Role of Open Source and Global Competition
23:45 – Motivations Behind Policy Approaches
26:40 – Debates on Regulating Use vs. Development
35:15 – Federal vs. State Roles in AI Policy
39:24 – AI Policy and U.S.–China Competition
40:45 – Current Policy Landscape & Action Plans
42:47 – Moratoriums, Preemption, and Political Dynamics
50:00 – Looking Forward: The Future of AI Policy
56:16 – Conclusion & Disclaimers
Resources:
Read the Little Tech Agenda: https://a16z.com/the-little-tech-agenda/
Read ‘Regulate AI Use, Not AI Development : https://a16z.com/regulate-ai-use-not-ai-development/
Read Martin’s article ‘Base AI Policy on Evidence, Not Existential Angst: https://a16z.com/base-ai-policy-on-evidence-not-existential-angst/
Read ‘Setting the Agenda for Global AI Leadership’:
Read ‘The Commerce Clause in the Age of AI”:
Find Matt on X: https://x.com/MattPerault
Find Collin on X: https://x.com/Collin_McCune
Stay Updated:
Find a16z on X
Find a16z on LinkedIn
Listen to the a16z Podcast on Spotify
Listen to the a16z Podcast on Apple Podcasts
Follow our host: https://twitter.com/eriktorenberg
Please note that the content here is for informational purposes only; should NOT be taken as legal, business, tax, or investment advice or be used to evaluate any investment or security; and is not directed at any investors or potential investors in any a16z fund. a16z and its affiliates may maintain investments in the companies discussed. For more details please see a16z.com/disclosures.
Hosted by Simplecast, an AdsWizz company. See pcm.adswizz.com for information about our collection and use of personal data for advertising.
Host
There have been these big institutional players in D.C., in the state capitals for a very long time. There wasn't anyone who was actually advocating on behalf of the startups and entrepreneurs, the smaller builders in space. They're trying to build models that might compete with Microsoft or OpenAI or Meta or Google. For those companies, what are the regulatory frameworks that would actually work for them as opposed to making that competition even more difficult than it already is? Regulate use. Do not regulate development. Somehow it's interpreted as do not regulate. I actually can't think of a single example across the portfolio in which we are arguing for zero regulation.
Who's speaking up for startups in Washington, D.C.? Today, I'm joined by Matt Perault, head of AI policy at A16Z, and Colin McCune, head of government affairs at A16Z, to talk about the Little Tech Agenda, a framework designed to ensure that regulation doesn't just work for the giants, but also for the five-person teams trying to build the next breakthrough. Their approach? Regulate harmful use, not development. We'll cover federal versus state rules, open source, export controls, and what smart preemption could look like. Let's get into it.
Colin, Matt, welcome to the podcast.
Matt Perault
Thanks so much.
Colin McCune
Thanks for having us.
Host
So there's a lot we want to get into around AI policy, but first I want us to take a step back and reflect a little bit. We had publicly announced the Little Tech Agenda July of last year. There's a lot that's happened since. When we first take a step back, Colin, and talk about what is the Little Tech Agenda and how did it come to be at the firm?
Colin McCune
Yeah, I mean, look, a ton of credit to Mark and Ben for having the vision on this. When I first started here, we started advocating on behalf of technology interest, technology policy. What we realized was there have been these big institutional players that have been in D.C., in the state capitals for a very long time. Some of them have done a lot of really good work on behalf of the entire tech community. But there wasn't anyone specific who was actually advocating on behalf of what we call Little Tech, which in my mind are the startups and entrepreneurs, the smaller builders in the space.
Beyond that, we realized they're not always 100% aligned with what's going on with the big tech folks. That's not necessarily always a bad thing or a good thing, but that was the whole impetus of this. How are we going to think about positioning ourselves in D.C. and the state capitals in terms of our advocacy on these issues? And how do we differentiate between the big tech folks who come with their certain degrees of baggage?
Host
From the left and the right.
Colin McCune
From the left and the right, right? And the smallest of the small. So that was really the basic evidence of this.
Matt Perault
For me, it was almost a recruiting vehicle. When it hit in July, I was not yet at the firm. I started in November. When I first read the agenda, it transformed the way that I looked at the rooms that I would sit in where there would be policy conversations. All of a sudden you could see essentially an empty seat and Little Tech's not there. There would be conversations where people would say, "In this proposal, we want to add this disclosure requirement, and then we'll have companies do a little bit more and a little bit more." When you've read the Little Tech Agenda, all of a sudden you start thinking, how is this going to work for all the people who aren't in the room?
For me, thinking about coming into this role at the firm, the question was, is this a voice? Is this a part of the community I want to advocate for and think about? When you start looking at the policy debate from a perspective of Little Tech and you see how many of the conversations don't include a Little Tech perspective, it was very compelling to think about how can I advocate for this part of the Internet ecosystem.
Host
Right. And Colin, why don't you outline some of the pillars of the Little Tech Agenda or some of the things we focus on the most, and maybe how it differentiates from big tech more broadly?
Colin McCune
From a firm perspective, we're verticalized. We all live and breathe this. That's been very competitive for us on the business side, but I also think it's very competitive on the policy side. Matt leads our AI vertical and our AI policy lead. We have a huge crypto effort. We have a major effort around American dynamism, which is defense procurement reform, something the United States has needed forever. We have colleagues who work on the bio and health team fighting on behalf of FDA reform, everything from PBMs. We're working a lot on fintech-related issues. And then classic tech-related internet entrepreneur issues. There's a lot of tax issues that come along with it, and then the venture-specific things we have to deal with.
But I try to think about this from a basic point of view: if you're a small builder, what are the things that should differentiate you from someone who's a trillion-dollar company with hundreds of thousands of employees? If you're five people in a garage, how are you supposed to be able to comply with the same things that are built for a thousand-person compliance teams? It's just not the same thing. There are categories and categories that Matt and I are dealing with on a regular basis. But that's probably the main pillar: five-person versus trillion-dollar company. Not the same thing.
Matt Perault
It's made my job really hard in certain ways since I started at the firm. The kinds of partners that you want within our portfolio often don't exist. A lot of the companies don't have a general counsel. They don't have a head of policy. They don't have a head of communications. The kinds of people who typically sit at companies thinking all day about what this state is doing in AI policy or what this federal agency is doing in terms of rulemaking — they're not at startups that are just a couple of people and engineers trying really hard to build products.
Those companies face an incredibly daunting challenge. If they're trying to build models that might compete with Microsoft or OpenAI or Meta or Google, that is unbelievably challenging in AI. You have to have data, you have to have compute. There's been a lot written about the cost of AI talent recently. The question that Colin and I talk about all the time is, for those companies, what are the regulatory frameworks that would actually work for them as opposed to making that competition even more difficult than it already is?
Host
One of the principles I've heard you guys hammer home is we want a market that's competitive where startups can compete. We don't want a monopoly. We don't want even oligopolies, a cartel-like system. And that doesn't mean no regulation because that can be destabilizing too. But it means smart regulation that enables that competition in the first place.
Matt Perault
One of the things that's been surprising to me to learn about venture is the time horizon that we operate in. Our funds are 10-year cycles. We're not looking to spike an AI market tomorrow and have a good year or a good six months or a good two years. We're looking to create vibrant, healthy ecosystems that result in long-run benefits for people and long-run financial benefits for our investors and for us. That means having a regulatory environment that facilitates healthy, good, safe products.
If people have scammy, problematic experiences with AI products, if they think AI is bad for democracy, if they think it's corroding their communities, that's not in our financial incentive. That's not good for us. That really animates the core component of the agenda, which is not trying to strip all regulation, but instead focusing on regulation that will actually protect people. We think there are ways to do that without making it harder for startups to compete.
Colin McCune
To Matt's point, I walk into a lot of lawmaker offices. I genuinely say our interests are aligned with the United States of America's interests. The people that we're funding are on the cutting edge. They're the people who are going to build the companies that are going to drive the jobs. They are going to drive the national security components that we need. And they're also going to drive the economy. We want to see them build over a long time horizon. That is exactly how we should be building policy in the United States.
Matt Perault
99.9% of people we talk to think that all we want is no regulation. Despite writing extensively, both of us writing and speaking extensively about the importance of good governance for creating the kind of markets that we want to create. Colin can speak more to it in crypto. I've learned a lot from our crypto practice because the idea there is you really need to separate good actors from bad actors and ensure that you take account for the differences. It's true in AI as well. If we don't have safe AI tools, if there is absolutely no governance, that's not going to create a long-run healthy ecosystem that's going to be good for us and good for people throughout the country.
I actually can't think of a single example across the portfolio in which we are arguing for zero regulation. The core component of our AI policy framework, which was developed before my time, is focused on regulating harmful use, not on regulating development. That sentence — regulate use, do not regulate development — somehow is interpreted as do not regulate. People just omit the part about focusing on regulating harmful use. In our view, that is robust and expansive and leaves lots of room for policymakers to take steps that we think are actually really effective in protecting people.
Regulating use means regulating when people violate consumer protection law, when they use AI to violate consumer protection law, or when they use AI in a way that violates civil rights law at the state and federal level or violating state or federal criminal law. There's an enormous amount of action there for lawmakers to seize on. We really want that to be an active component of the governance agenda that we're proposing. For some reason, it's all passed over and the focus is just on "don't regulate development." I don't exactly understand why that ends up being the case.
Host
Easy headline.
Matt Perault
Easy headline.
Host
So there's been a lot that's happened in AI policy, and I want to get to it. But first, perhaps, Matt, you can trace the evolution a bit over the last few years. I believe there was a time where we were pattern matching with social media regulation a bit. Why don't you trace some of the biggest inflection points, the debates over the last few years, and we'll get to today?
Colin McCune
I think we have to play a little bit of history. For me, from a policy and government affairs perspective, this conversation started early 2023. That was the kickoff of the gun. It puttered along and became more and more real over time. But in the fall of 2023, almost exactly two years ago to the day, there was a series of Senate hearings in which some major CEOs from the AI space came and testified. The message that folks heard was, one, we need and want to be regulated, which I think maintains that truth today. That's obviously what Matt and I are working on regularly.
But included in some of that testimony was a lot of speculation about the industry that jumpstarted this whole huge wave of conversation around the rise of Terminator. "Go hug your families because we're going to all be dead in five years." That spooked Capitol Hill. They absolutely freaked out about it. Rightfully so. You have these really important, powerful people who are building this really important, powerful thing, and they're coming in to tell you that everyone's going to die in five years. That's a scary thing for people to hear. And by the way, we want to be regulated.
That starting gun moved us in hyperspeed into this conversation around how do we lock this down? How do we regulate it very, very, very quickly? I think that led to the Biden executive order, which we have publicly denounced in certain categories. That executive order led to a lot of the conversation that we're having in the states, a lot of the bad bills that we've seen come through the states. And I think it also led to a number of federal proposals that we've seen that have not been very well thought through.
People are sitting around thinking, "Was it just some testimony from the CEOs that did this?" The answer to that is no. The effective altruist community for 10 years, backed by large sums of money, were very effective at influencing think tanks and nonprofit organizations in D.C. and the state capitals to push us in a direction where people are very fearful about the technology. That has significantly shaped the conversation that we're having throughout D.C. and the state capitals, and candidly on a global stage. The EU acting, the EU AI Act — we're public on that. There are a lot of very problematic provisions in there. All of this banner of safetyism came from this 10-year head start that these guys have had.
When people are writing articles about the fact that the AI industry is pumping all this money into the system, certainly I'm not suggesting there's not money in the system. We're obviously active on the political and policy side. We're not hiding that. But it is dwarfed by the amount of money that has been spent over a 10-year window. The reason that Matt and I have jobs is because we are playing catch-up. We are here to try and make sure that people understand what is actually going on in this conversation and be a counterforce to this group of people and this ideology that has been here for a long period of time. So that's the briefer on this.
Matt Perault
Companies were ready to consider some policy frameworks that were probably going to be really challenging for the AI sector in the long run. I was at Meta, then Facebook, starting in 2011 and through 2019. After 2016, there was aggressive criticism of tech companies. The general framing was, "You're not being responsible and regulation needs to catch up. Governance of social media is behind where the products are." Whatever you think about that, that was the strong view in the ecosystem — that the lack of governance has allowed problematic things to happen.
When AI was starting to accelerate and you had certain prevailing political interests driving the conversation, companies rushed to the table. It was a group of five, three, five, seven companies who went into the White House and negotiated voluntary commitments. We don't even have to make the argument about the importance of representing Little Tech when you see that there is a set of companies who negotiated an arrangement for what it would look like to build AI at the frontier, with all current developers who weren't those companies and all future startups not represented at the table. That is why we started to think about the value of having more dedicated support around AI policy. Clearly, the views of Little Tech companies aren't represented in the conversation.
Colin McCune
Let me add one thing. It's Mark and Ben's story. They've told it many times. I was in the meeting as well. Everything they've said has been 100% true and accurate. But there was a prevailing view by very powerful people of the previous administration that this was going to be only two or three major companies able to compete in the AI landscape. Because that was the case, they needed to be locked down and put in this incredibly restrictive view from a policy and regulatory perspective. It was going to be this entity that was kind of like an arm of the government. That was the most alarming thing that we had heard from the administration, on top of an incredibly alarming series of events that happened on the crypto side, including wanting to eradicate it off the face of the planet. That all led to the position that we're in now, and certainly Matt's hiring and us building out the team.
Matt Perault
That narrative is clearly the most alarming version of this. But even since I've been in this role, I've heard other versions where people will say, "Don't worry about this framework. It just applies to three or five companies, or it just applies to five to seven companies." I think they mean that to provide comfort to us. But the view of the AI market where there are only a small number of companies building at the frontier — that's not the vision for the market that we have. We want it to be competitive and diverse at the frontier.
The policy ideas that were coming out of the period that Colin's talking about were dramatically different from where they are today in a way that some people have even lost sight of. There were ideas being proposed by not just government, but industry, to require a license to build frontier AI tools and for it to be regulated like nuclear energy. That would be historic for software development.
Host
Unprecedented.
Matt Perault
Yeah. For it to be regulated like nuclear energy with an international level nuclear-style regulatory regime to govern it. We've moved — no matter what you think about the right level of governance — there are not a lot of people now who are saying what we need is a licensing regime where you literally apply for permission from the government to build the tool. But that wasn't that far in the rearview mirror.
Colin McCune
And we're also talking about bans on open source. We're still kicking around that idea at the state level. For us who live and breathe the tech stuff on a daily basis, this sounds insane and crazy. But let me make it a little bit more real. The nuclear policy in the United States has yielded two or three new nuclear power plants in a 50-year period since these organizations have been started. Some people are pro-nuclear, some people are anti-nuclear. I don't want to get into that debate. The point is that was not the intended policy of the United States of America. That was the effect of putting together this agency and what has come from that.
If we do the same thing to AI, had we done the same thing in AI in that period of time, then you don't have the medical advancements. You don't have the breakthroughs. You don't have all of the incredible things that come from this. Beyond that, we lose to China. Full stop. You lose to China, and then our greatest national security threat becomes the one who has the most powerful technology in the world.
Host
I think the early concern on open source was that we would be somehow giving it to China, but then we've seen with DeepSeek, et cetera, that they just have it anyways.
Colin McCune
Exactly. The idea that we could lock this down — Mark and Ben have talked about this. I think they've debunked that a number of times.
Host
Just to understand, for the previous administration, what was their calculus? Was it that they were true believers in the fears? Was it that there was some sort of political benefit to having the views that they had, especially on the crypto side? I don't understand what is the constituency for an anti-crypto stance. How do you make sense of the players or the intentions or motivation?
Colin McCune
That's a really hard one to answer. I'm not sure I can pretend to be completely in their minds. I think there are a couple of different competing forces. One is, what are the constituencies that support that administration? What are the constituencies that support that side of the aisle? Over the last 10 to 15 years, there has been a very heavy focus on consumer safety, which is a very important thing. We're obviously in alignment on that. Everyone should be in alignment. You have to protect consumers. You have to protect the American public. But I think a lot of that conversation has been weaponized. It is a big-time moneymaker. A lot of these groups either get backing from very wealthy special interests or they are small-dollar fundraising off of quick hits like, "AI is coming for your jobs. Donate five dollars and we'll make sure that we take care of this in Washington for you." It's a pretty easy manipulation tactic.
The other thing here is that personnel is policy. A lot of the individuals that were in very senior decision-making roles within that White House and that administration came from this consumer protection background. That was a constituency. They were put in this position to come after private enterprise. That was the goal. There's this whole idea among some of those folks that Senator Warren has proposed many times: if you're not going after and getting people in the private sector on a regular basis, then you're not working hard enough.
The third thing is we're at this very weird moment where being a builder and being in private enterprise is a bad thing to some policymakers. You're not doing good because you're earning a profit. They certainly won't say that, but the activities and the things that they're doing are 100% aligned with that type of idea. So I think that's the basic crux of it.
Matt Perault
I think the things that motivated that approach were done in good faith. As you alluded to earlier, there are a lot of people who believe that social media is poorly regulated and that because policymakers were asleep at the wheel, we woke up at some point in the 2014 to 2018 period and realized that we had technology that we thought was actually not good for our society. Whether or not you think that's true, that has been a widely held view. It's a held view on the right and on the left. It's a bipartisan view.
When this new technology came on the scene, this was a do-over opportunity for policymakers. We can get this right when we didn't get the last thing right. I understand that motivation. It makes a lot of sense. The thing that we strongly feel is the set of policy ideas that came out of that good faith belief were not the right policy ideas to either protect consumers or lead to a competitive AI market. Many of the politicians who were pushing concepts that would have really put a stranglehold on AI startups and would have led to more monopolization of a market that already tends toward monopoly because of the high barriers to entry — those politicians three years before had been talking about how problematic it was that there wasn't more competition in social media. Then all of a sudden they're behind a licensing regime, which is not pro-competitive. It typically is the opposite.
The disagreement is less with the core feeling that we want to protect people from harmful uses of this technology and more with the policy concepts that came out of that feeling, which we think would have been disruptive in a problematic way to the future of the AI market.
Host
Anecdotally, it seemed from afar that some of the concerns early on were almost to match social media — around disinformation or even DEI concerns, people trying to make sure the models were incompatible with the speech regime at the time. Then it shifted to, "Wait, no, is there more existential concerns around jobs or is AI like nukes in the sense of people doing harm or AI itself doing harm?" It seemed to escalate a bit, maybe aligned with that testimony you alluded to.
Matt Perault
I experienced it as feeling like the goalposts always move. One of the things that I started asking people when I was really trying to settle into this "regulate use, not development" policy position is: what do we miss? If we regulate use primarily using existing law, what are the things that we miss?
And I haven't gotten very many clear answers to that. Like you can't do illegal things in the universe and you also can't use AI to do illegal things. And typically when people list out the set of things that they're most concerned about with AI, they're typically things that are covered by existing law. Probably not exclusively, but primarily. So that at least seems like a good starting point.
Some of the other issues that I think are understandably ones that we should be concerned about have a range of different considerations associated with them. Like if you're concerned about misinformation or speech that you think might not be true or might be problematic, there are significant constraints on the government's ability to regulate that. The First Amendment imposes pretty stringent restrictions. And I think for very good reason, because you don't want the government to dictate the speech preferences or policies of private speech platforms for the most part.
So those issues might be concerns, but they're not necessarily areas where you want the government to step in and take strong action. I think there are things that we should probably do as a society to try to address those issues, but government regulation maybe isn't the primary one. And again, in most of the things that people are most concerned about—real use of the technology for clear, cognizable, real-world harm—existing law typically covers it.
Colin McCune
I have a theory on this. I think everything that Matt just said is spot on. But then you're kind of sitting around scratching your head, like, okay, well if use covers it and there hasn't been a very incredibly fair rebuttal on why use is not enough in terms of focus on the policy regulatory side, what's the answer?
I think we're experiencing this pattern on the crypto side too. We're having a very spirited debate on the crypto side about how to regulate tokens and how you launch a token in the United States as a security or as a commodity. This is an age-old debate that's plagued traditional securities laws for years, but certainly also the crypto industry. What we have found is that there are a number of people who have entered this debate who are actually trying to get at the underlying securities laws. They want to reform securities laws, not reform crypto laws that involve securities. And this is their only venue by which they can enter that conversation, because there's no will from Congress or from policymakers to go and overhaul the securities laws right now. It's just not there. But what is moving is crypto. So people are now trying to enter this debate saying, "Oh, we should relook at this." And I'm like, well, this doesn't have anything to do with it. We shouldn't be entering this conversation. Yet they're still pushing, and that's kind of muddying the water.
I think a very similar thing is actually happening on the AI side. There are a number of members of Congress that feel like, "Well, we missed it on the '96 Telecom Act. We didn't do good enough around then. So we need to rewrite the wrongs through the venue of an AI policy conversation." Because if you think about it, assuming that use doesn't go far enough for someone—and this is the same conversation we're having in California right now or in Colorado right now—if uses does not go far enough, okay, well then it would be really simple if you could have a privacy conversation around this, if you could have an online content moderation conversation, an algorithmic bias conversation around it. You could do all of that, wedge it through AI, and then assuming AI is actually going to be the thing that we all think it's going to be, now you've put basically a regulatory funnel on the other side. You've put a mesh screen where everything has to run through AI and therefore it runs through this regulatory proposal you put together.
Matt Perault
The thing that I've really been wrestling with in the last few weeks is whether those kinds of regimes are actually helpful in addressing the harm that they purport to want to address. Colorado is a really good example. There are all these bills that have been introduced at the state level. Colorado is the only one that's passed so far. It's set up this regime where you basically have to decide: are you doing a high-risk use of AI or a low-risk use of AI? This would be for startups that don't have a general counsel, don't have a head of policy, can't hire an outside law firm to figure it out. High-risk, low-risk. And then if you're high-risk, you have to do a bunch of stuff—usually impact assessments, sometimes audit your technology—to try to anticipate whether there's going to be bias in your model in some form. Maybe an impact assessment helps you figure that out a little bit, but it's probably not going to eliminate bias entirely. It certainly isn't going to end racism in our society.
Colorado's governor and attorney general have put pressure on the legislature to roll back this law because they think it's going to be problematic for AI in Colorado. There was just a special session there to consider various different alternatives. One of the alternatives that was introduced proposed codifying that the use of AI to violate Colorado's anti-discrimination statute is illegal. That's consistent with the "regulate harmful use" framing that we've talked about. Instead of having this amorphous process where maybe you address bias in some form, maybe you don't, this goes straight at it. If someone uses AI in a way that violates anti-discrimination law, that could be prosecuted. The attorney general could enforce. I still don't understand why that approach is somehow less compelling than this complex administrative paperwork approach.
I think it's kind of the reason that Colin's describing, which is that people want a different bite at the apple of bias. But it's not clear to me that it's actually the best way to effectuate the outcomes that you want, as opposed to just criminalizing or creating civil penalties for the harm that you can see clearly.
Colin McCune
It's also, in policymaking and bill writing, really, really easy to come up with bad ideas. It's easy, right? Because they're not well thought through. The first thing comes to your head, someone publishes a paper on something, here we go. It takes real hard work to get something that actually works. And then it's even harder to actually go through a political and policy negotiation with a diverse set of stakeholders and actually land the plane on something.
Matt Perault
Yeah, I think that's part of the reason that people think that we are anti-governance. Because when we were ramping up our policy apparatus, these were the ideas in the ecosystem: licensing, nuclear-style regulation, flops-based threshold disclosures, really complicated transparency regimes, impact assessments, audits—a bunch of ideas that we think are not going to help protect people and are going to make it really hard for low-resource startups. So we've been trying to say, "No, no, no, don't do that." And so that sounds like deregulate. But for whatever reason, it's been hard so far to shift toward, "Here's another set of ideas that we think would be compelling and actually protect people and create stronger markets."
Host
Right now, we don't see terrorists or criminals being aided 1000x with AI in performing terrorism or crime. When I ask people, "What are you truly scared about? Give me a concrete scenario," people will be like, "Oh, what about bioterrorism?" or "What about cybersecurity theft?" We seem very far away from that. Is there any amount of development in the next few years, any amount of breakthroughs, where you might say, "Oh, maybe use isn't enough"? Or do we think that that will always be the case?
Matt Perault
I think it's conceivable. And I think we've been open about that. We think existing law is a good place to start. It's probably not where we end. Martin Casado, one of our general partners, wrote a great piece on marginal risk in AI, basically saying that when there's incremental additional risk, we should look for policy to address that risk. So the situation you're describing might be that.
I think what you're getting at is a really important question about potential significant harms that we don't yet contemplate. We get asked often about our "regulate use, not regulate development" framework: "Are you just saying that we should address issues after they occur?" I understand why that's a concern. There might be future harms. Wouldn't it be nice if we could prevent them in advance? But that is how our legal system is designed. Typically, when you talk to people about ways that you could try to address potential criminal activity or other legal violations ex ante before they occur, that's really scary to people.
What if we just learned a lot of information about you and then predicted the likelihood that you might do something unlawful in the future? And if we think it's exceeded a certain threshold, then we're going to take action against you before you've done it so that we can prevent future crime. You're laughing because it's laughable. We don't want a kind of ex-ante surveillance, both because it feels invasive and because it often is ineffective. We might run some test that shows that you're likely to be predisposed to some kind of criminal activity, but we don't know until you've done it that you've done it. So I think that kind of approach is motivated by a really valid concern and a valid desire to prevent harm. But the regulatory framework probably won't do that. It probably won't have the effect of preventing harm. And there are all these costs associated with it, mainly from our perspective, inhibiting startup activity.
Colin McCune
Mark once told me his joke: a man goes to the government because he has this big problem. Now he gets a lot of regulation. Now he has two problems.
Host
Okay, let's talk about the state of AI policy today. There's a lot that's happened in the last few months with the moratorium, the action plan. What are some of the things that we're excited about right now? What are some of the things we're less excited about? Give us a breakdown of where we're at right now.
Matt Perault
Given what Colin described about where things were a couple years ago, it's great to see the federal government—certainly the executive branch, but not just the executive branch, I think this is in Congress across both aisles—being supportive of frameworks that we think are much better for little tech. Trying to identify areas where regulatory burden outweighs value and where we can right-size regulation to make it easier for AI startups. As Colin said, support for open source. We were in a really different place on that a couple years ago. Now it seems like there's much more consensus. And again, it was across the end of the last administration and the current administration around the value of open source for competition and innovation.
The National AI Action Plan also had great stuff in it about thinking through the balance between the federal government and state governments, which is something that we've done a lot of thinking about. There's an important role for each. But we think the federal government should really lead regulation of development of AI. States should police harmful conduct within their borders. I think there's stuff in the action plan that would try to ensure those respective roles.
There's also a lot of stuff in the action plan that wasn't really talked about much—it wasn't the headline-grabbing stuff—that I thought was incredibly compelling in terms of trying to create a future for AI that just works better for more people. A really good example is the stuff on worker retraining that focused on different programs that could help workers if they're displaced as a result of AI, as well as monitoring AI markets and labor markets to make sure that we understand when there are significant labor disruptions. I think it gets at a point that you were alluding to a couple of minutes ago about what happens when there's something really disruptive in the future.
Can you predict with certainty that there won't be this crazy disruptive thing? No, we can't. There might be significant labor disruption. Others at the firm have talked extensively about how typically there are worries about labor disruptions when there's new technology introduced. Typically, there are increases in productivity that end up being good for labor overall. We think that's the direction of travel, but you never know. We can't predict it with certainty. So I think it's a really strong step to try to monitor labor markets to see what the disruption might look like so that we're set up to take strong policy action in the future.
Colin McCune
Can I just say one thing about the AI action plan? I don't want to juxtapose this to what we saw under the Biden administration, which was an incredible amount of activity, and an incredible amount of activity under the Trump administration. But look, I view these executive orders and these plans that come out from an administration as very, very important. Some of them have true policy. They direct the agencies to do things, to come out with reports, and then take on rulemakings and things like that.
But from an AI action plan perspective, for me, it was so significant because I think it turned the conversation on its head. Before it was, "We have to only focus on safety with a splash of innovation." And now it is, "We understand how important this is from a national security perspective. We understand how important this is from an economic perspective. We need to make sure that we win while keeping people safe." That dynamic and that shift of rhetoric is incredibly important. Because what that does is it signals to the rest of the world, it signals to other governments that this is the position of the United States and will be the position for the next three and a half years. And this is the position of the United States to the Congress. So when the Congress is looking at potentially taking up pieces of legislation or taking actions or even committee hearings—which for the broad base of what we're talking about are fairly insignificant—all of that is kept in mind. So now the conversation has shifted significantly, and that is really, really important.
Host
Speaking of winning, Colin, I'm curious for our thoughts on AI policy vis-a-vis China, whether it's export controls or any other issues we care about.
Colin McCune
First and foremost, we have to win. I think that is the main thrust of a lot of what we're doing here and a lot of the way that we think about this from a firm perspective. First is making sure that the founders and the builders can build appropriately with appropriate safeguards and an appropriate regulatory structure. The second is how do we win and make sure that America is the place where AI is the most functional and foundational vis-a-vis China.
There has been a long conversation about the diffusion rule that came out from the Biden administration, specifically on export controls. Many panned that proposal. A lot of people suggested it was probably too restrictive, that it wasn't the right way to think about things. We have spent most of our time—Matt leading this effort—specifically focused on how we are regulating the underlying models and how we are regulating the use of these models, rather than specifically on the export control piece.
What I will say, though, is that some of the proposals that came out from the Biden administration, some of the proposals that we've seen at the state level, and some of the proposals that we've seen at the congressional level that dealt with export controls on models themselves are very concerning. We're still having this conversation. There is a policy set that has been kicked around for a while called the Outbound Investment Policy, which is basically how much U.S. money from the private sector is flowing into Chinese companies. Very noble, laudable, super supportive of that concept. We are a very America-first sort of organization here. We're investing primarily in American companies and American founders. So we're very supportive of it.
But when you edge into the idea that we might inadvertently ban U.S. open-source models from being able to be exported across the country—by definition of open source, there are no walls around these types of things—that's one of the areas that we've been very, very focused on. Obviously, it's very important to make sure that we don't have these very powerful U.S.-made technologies in the hands of our Chinese counterparts in the PLA and the CCP using this against us. But I also think that we need to make sure that we're not extending too far and limiting the power of open source technologies to be able to be the platform around the world.
The final point that I'd make here is that we ultimately have a decision to make as the U.S.: do we want people using U.S. products across the world, which helps for a whole bunch of different reasons—certainly on soft power from a national security perspective—or do we want people to use Chinese products? The more that we lock down American products, the more the Chinese will enter those markets and take a land grab in that space.
Host
When you get into what happened with the moratorium and the fallout that ensued, I think this one is a bit complicated. There was a perception about the moratorium when it came out that it would have prohibited all state law from existing for a 10-year window. Obviously, that's a long period of time. I'm not sure we would necessarily completely agree with that policy stance.
Colin McCune
That, from our point of view, is a misinterpretation for a whole bunch of different reasons of what the language actually said. But sometimes in D.C., a lot of times in D.C., perception is reality. And that kind of took hold.
But I also think there are strong competing forces, as we've discussed, from the doomer crowd or the safety crowd that were very, very anti, that had used all of their tentacles that they've spread out over the last decade to try to move in and kill this. I think they also were successful in leveraging some other industries to come in and also move forward to try to kill this thing.
By virtue of the vehicle—the underlying procedural vehicle, this reconciliation package that it was moving in—it was a partisan exercise. It was going to be Republicans on Democrats, and that was that. There was nothing, even a prominent AI policy that was going to be dropped in a reconciliation package, that was ever going to drag Democrat votes over because it was such a big Christmas tree style thing that had all kinds of tax reform positions, et cetera. If you're in one of those situations, the margins on the votes become very, very small. So all it took was one or two Republican senators hitching their wagon to some of these ideas that were out there to tank this thing.
Look, I think that's going to be a situation that you're going to fight in any sort of political policy legislative outcome or any sort of issue that you're going to be running within the Congress. But more so than anything, and we heard this repeatedly from a whole bunch of different people, and this is what we've also experienced: the industry was just not organized well enough. And that's not just the industry. It's also the people who care about this thing that aren't actually industry stakeholders. The stakeholders who were pro some level of moratorium or some level of preemption were just not organized. I think that was both an eye-opening moment and an important moment.
What we have done in the preceding three or four months since this thing has gone down is we've taken a long, hard look at what we need to do collectively from a coalition to be able to be in a better position next time we're there. So what does that look like? First and foremost, it comes with writing, doing podcasts, talking about these things, talking about the details of what's actually in these proposals and what it actually means for states and the federal government, to make sure that we're fighting through the FUD that's coming through because it's always going to be there. There's misrepresentation all over the field.
The second piece is let's all get on the same page, which I think we've worked very hard to do. Where we can find alignment, I think we've found that alignment between big, medium, and little. And then the third and probably the most important is: what are we doing on the political advocacy side to make sure that we have the appropriate tools to be able to push forward in a way that ensures that America can use the lead and that we don't lose out on this race to China? That's part of the reason that we have recently announced our donation to Leading the Future PAC, which will have several different entities underneath it, which I think is designed to be that political center of gravity in the space. That will fight at the federal level and the state and local level. So we're happy to be a part of it, and we expect there will be others that join this common cause fight on the AI side.
Host
If we could wave a wand, what would we like to be done at the state level versus the federal level? How should we think about that interplay compared to where we're at now?
Matt Perault
I think the helpful answer here comes from the Constitution. The Constitution actually lays out a role for the federal government and a role for state governments. The federal government takes the lead in interstate commerce. So governing a national AI market and governing AI development, we think, is primarily Congress's role. Sometimes when people say that, I think what other people hear for some reason is "states should do nothing." We have tried very hard to be deliberate in not saying that and making clear that states have an incredibly important role to play in policing harmful conduct within their jurisdictions.
Criminal law is a perfect example. There is some criminal law at the federal level, but the bulk of criminal law is at the state level. When you think about routine crimes, if you are going to prosecute a perpetrator, it's likely that would occur under state law. So to the extent we want to take account of local activity where there's criminal conduct involved and we want to make sure that the laws are robust enough to protect people from that activity, that's going to be primarily state law.
Oddly enough, as Colin is describing, this isn't the delineation that we've started out with. There are a lot of state laws that have taken the approach of, "Congress hasn't acted, so we have a responsibility to act." And that's true to some extent. States can act within their constitutional lane. Some of what states have done have gone outside that lane. We actually just this week released a post on potential dormant commerce clause concerns associated with state laws. The basic idea is that there's a constitutional test that says that states cannot excessively burden out-of-state commerce when that greatly exceeds the in-state local benefits. Courts actually weigh this. There's a balancing test: do the harms or costs to out-of-state activity significantly outweigh the benefits on the local side?
We think that for at least some of the proposals that have been introduced, it's likely that the benefits are somewhat diminished relative to what the proponents think they are, and that the costs are significant. The cost of a developer in Washington state complying with a law that's in California or a law that's in New York is going to be significant. Our hope is not that the dormant commerce clause ends up serving as a function that makes it hard for states to enact laws, but actually just serves as a guidepost for states around the kinds of laws that they might actually introduce. I think it pushes in the direction that's consistent with our agenda, which is to take an active role in legislating and enforcing laws that are focused on harmful use.
Host
Looking at the next six months to a year, what are the issues that we're most focused on or that we think are going to be playing a role in the conversation?
Colin McCune
I think it's first and foremost some level of federal preemption. And I want to be very specific about this. Again, to Matt's point, we're not talking about preempting all state law. We're talking about making sure that we have a federal framework specifically for this model regulation and hopefully how the models can be used.
I think that's going to be so, so critical because we can't, just like any other technology, no technology can live under a 50-state patchwork. And that's been the biggest issue that we've been fighting over the last year and a half or so.
I think there are some other policy sets that I think will be handled beyond that that can kick into workforce training. I think there's some literacy things that should be coming up. Obviously, there's a huge robust conversation around data centers and energy that I think will be really, really important. But above all, I think most of our time and energy will be focused on trying to have some level of federal standard here to try and drive the dividing line between the federal and state government, which I think Matt has already done a ton of great work on.
Matt Perault
Yeah, I think this is just a super exciting policy moment for AI. There's the last couple of years where I think there are a bunch of ideas that have been proposed. And for the reasons that we've discussed, we think those ideas fall short, both in terms of protecting consumers and in terms of ensuring that there's a robust startup ecosystem. Most of those laws, I think, have actually not succeeded in passing. So like, there were a number of laws introduced at the state level in this past year's legislative sessions that we thought had a strong likelihood of passing, and I think to date, none of them have passed.
Colin has also been building out the expertise and skill set and capacity on his team. We just hired Kevin McKinley to lead our work in state policy, and I think he will help us to take a real affirmative position in the legislative sessions ahead on what might actually be AI policy that's good for startups. So instead of being in the position of saying no, because we're sort of starting late and kind of with one hand behind our back, I think we're in a position to really actually try to articulate and advance a proactive agenda in AI that's compelling.
I think Colin hit the main parts of it: ensuring proper roles for the federal and state governments, focusing on regulating harmful use, not development. And there are specific things that you can do there in terms of increasing capacity and enforcement agencies, making clear that AI is not a defense to claims brought on under existing criminal or civil law. And technical training, I think, for government officials to make sure that they can identify and prosecute cases where AI is used in a harmful way.
And then all this infrastructure and talent stuff that Colin is describing: worker retraining, AI literacy. We've also given some thought to the idea that has been articulated by a number of lawmakers and was in the National AI Action Plan of creating a central resource housed in the federal government. And you could also do it in state governments as well that lower some of the barriers to entry for startups—compute costs and data access. And we think that's really compelling in terms of ensuring that startups can compete. And that idea, like many of these, is bipartisan. It's been supported by the current administration. It was supported by leading Democrats over the last couple of years. So that's the kind of thing that we are hoping that when we have the room and position to really advocate for an affirmative agenda, that we'll get some traction in policy circles.
Colin McCune
We're not always in 100% alignment with other people in the industry. And I think that that's big, medium, little. Across the board, there are other consumer advocacy groups that obviously feel differently about these things. I think for the most part, the industry is generally aligned on some level of a federal standard here. And understanding that the thing that won't work is a 50-state patchwork. I think that's super important because I think for the first time, you actually have this sort of alignment there. And if you have that sort of alignment, that's momentum that you can use to actually push things over the finish line and get something done.
And I think, look, also the Trump administration, to their credit, has also been incredibly supportive of this idea too.
Matt Perault
That's an incredibly important point. One criticism, usually raised in sort of an implicit criticism sort of way, is: "Hey, you're the little guys, but often you align with the big guys. So aren't you just in favor of a deregulatory agenda that works for big tech?" And one of the things that I think is really extraordinary about the little tech agenda is it's really nonpartisan and it doesn't take a position on big versus little. It basically says, here's the agenda. And when you agree with us, we'll support you. And when you disagree with us, we'll oppose you. And that's not party line. It's not big versus little.
So I think what we saw over the phase that Colin was referring to, kind of initially in the recent set of AI policy, was a phase of divergence between big and little. Licensing regime, bigs were sort of pushing it. Little was concerned about it. Then there was a period of convergence. And I think actually if you look at the National AI Action Plan comments across a range of different providers, as Colin's saying, a lot of them had some core similarities. So lots of large companies have advocated for federal preemption. We don't oppose that just because big companies are advocating for it. We think that's good for startups.
I think it's possible. I'm curious—Colin really understands this in a way that I don't, like how the political chips will fall. I think it's possible we're in a period of some divergence. And one thing that we hear repeatedly, which is sort of funny, is people will bring us stuff and they'll say, "Industry agrees with this. So we expect you to agree. You can't disagree." And we say, "The big parts of the industry have agreed, but sometimes we agree with them, but sometimes we have different views." And so when we disagree, it's not because we're trying to blow up a policy process or make it difficult for lawmakers who are trying to move something forward. It's because when we're looking at it, we're looking at it through this particular lens. And I think I hope it's not the case, but I think there might be more fracturing in the months ahead.
Colin McCune
Yeah, I agree with you on that. And by "people," he means lawmakers, just to be specific.
Host
Yes. That's a great place to wrap. Colin, Matt, thanks so much for coming on the podcast.
Matt Perault
Thanks very much.
The views expressed here are those of the individual AH Capital Management, LLC ("a16z") personnel quoted and are not the views of a16z or its affiliates. Certain information contained in here has been obtained from third-party sources, including from portfolio companies of funds managed by a16z. While taken from sources believed to be reliable, a16z has not independently verified such information and makes no representations about the enduring accuracy of the information or its appropriateness for a given situation. This content is provided for informational purposes only, and is not directed at any investors or potential investors in any a16z fund. Please note that a16z and its affiliates may also maintain investments in the companies discussed in this podcast. For more details, including a link to our investments, please see a16z.com forward slash disclosures.