Main Topic: This episode of Apple News Today discusses various news stories, including the UN's report on climate change, the Taliban's military victories in Afghanistan, the FDA's handling of medical device safety, an animal rights case in New York, and a free speech case involving a giant inflatable rat.
Key Points:
Participants:
Takeaways:
The Food and Drug Administration is supposed to ensure that medical devices used by the public are safe and effective. ProPublica investigates why the agency allowed a heart pump that didn’t meet federal standards to be implanted in thousands of patients.
The United Nations calls its new report on climate change “a code red for humanity.” CNN has key takeaways.
The Wall Street Journal looks at the Taliban’s mission to capture cities in Afghanistan as the U.S. withdraws.
National Geographic explores how animal-rights advocates are fighting for animal personhood, and what it could mean for creatures in captivity.
NPR describes why a large inflatable rat created to protest at labor disputes gained free-speech rights.
Duarte Gialdino
Good morning. It's Monday, August 9th. I'm Duarte Gialdino. And I'm Shamita Basu.
Shamita Basu
This is Apple News Today. Each morning, hear about some of the most fascinating stories in the news and how the world's best journalists are covering them.
Duarte Gialdino
A code red for humanity. That's how the U.N. Secretary General is describing its new report on climate change.
Shamita Basu
The group that prepared this report calls it the most comprehensive report on the state of the climate crisis.
Duarte Gialdino
It's placing the blame squarely on greenhouse gas emissions caused by humans.
Shamita Basu
The report paints a picture of more extremes. Drought, flooding, heat. And it suggests that some changes are irreversible, even if we drastically curb our emissions.
Duarte Gialdino
This document is thousands of pages long. More than 200 scientists from around the world weighed in.
Shamita Basu
You can find the best write-ups of what's in this report throughout the day on the Apple News app.
Duarte Gialdino
The Taliban is winning major military victories. Now that U.S. combat troops are no longer in the country, the Taliban is consolidating power in Afghanistan.
Shamita Basu
On Sunday, it seized the key city of Kunduz in northern Afghanistan.
Duarte Gialdino
As The Wall Street Journal explains, the Taliban has been targeting that city for years.
Shamita Basu
The Taliban has also taken control of several other capitals of Afghan provinces in recent days.
Duarte Gialdino
The journal says a number of Afghan and Western officials worry Taliban advances could lead to a collapse of the Afghan government in the fall.
Shamita Basu
Kabul is relatively stable, but other major cities are vulnerable. Except for the ones who are protecting the U.S. embassy and a few other American assets in Kabul.
Duarte Gialdino
U.S. troops have left the country, and things could get harder for the Afghan government.
Shamita Basu
American airstrikes launched from bases outside Afghanistan. They're set to end later this month.
Duarte Gialdino
Over the weekend, the U.S. Embassy in Kabul put out two statements.
Shamita Basu
One said Afghan forces have the training and equipment to prevail.
Duarte Gialdino
Another advised American citizens in Afghanistan to leave on the earliest available flight.
Shamita Basu
Part of the Food and Drug Administration's job is to make sure that medical devices are safe and effective.
Duarte Gialdino
But recent reporting from ProPublica shows that when the FDA identifies issues with a particular device, the agency often relies on manufacturers to fix the problem on their own.
Shamita Basu
And when a company doesn't do that, it can have deadly consequences.
Duarte Gialdino
That's what happened recently with a type of heart pump that's been implanted in thousands of people.
Shamita Basu
We spoke to reporter Neil Betty at ProPublica.
Neil Betty
The Heartware Ventricular Assist Device is a heart support device. It's meant to be implanted actually directly on your heart. Surgeons core out a hole from the bottom of your heart to put the pump into that hole.
Duarte Gialdino
So it's a very invasive surgery, and it's there to help patients with very severe heart failure who need artificial assistance to have blood pumped throughout their body.
Neil Betty
From the start, the FDA was identifying issues like faulty batteries or short-circuiting near static electricity.
Shamita Basu
People who had these pumps were getting injured and dying.
Duarte Gialdino
And in 2014, the FDA issued one of its most serious citations. A warning letter where they said, this device doesn't meet federal standards. We are labeling it adulterated.
Neil Betty
And you have 15 days to fix these problems or we can take regulatory action.
Shamita Basu
15 days came and passed. They didn't take any regulatory action, the device stayed on the market.
Neil Betty
The FDA did not use some of its most powerful tools.
Duarte Gialdino
The FDA says it can take enforcement action if companies are no longer fixing problems.
Neil Betty
They can seize products. They can order an injunction. They can do a mandatory recall.
Shamita Basu
They took none of those actions in this case.
Neil Betty
And experts have told me they rarely take those actions in general for the entire industry.
Duarte Gialdino
The heart wear pump was implanted into more than 19,000 patients, and most had this device put into their chests after the FDA found the pump did not meet federal standards.
Shamita Basu
By the end of last year the agency had gotten reports of more than 3 deaths. These are deaths that may have been related to the heart wear pump.
Neil Betty
Patients knew there were risks associated with the pump. These are very sick patients, and it's not normal to need a device in your heart.
Duarte Gialdino
But the patients I spoke to, even the ones who were grateful for the device, had no idea these problems had been recorded, reported, had been cited by FDA inspectors for years.
Shamita Basu
The company behind the pump halted sales in June.
Neil Betty
But about 4,000 patients still have this device inside of them, and getting rid of it isn't really an option for most of them.
Duarte Gialdino
The FDA and Medtronic don't recommend any of the last patients remove their device unless it's medically necessary, because the surgery is so risky, and they believe the risks of the surgery outweigh the risks of the device.
Shamita Basu
And so these patients are stuck waiting to see what happens.
Duarte Gialdino
Should a smart, social animal be forced to lead a solitary life? That's the question at the heart of a legal case that's made its way to the highest court in New York State.
Shamita Basu
An animal civil rights organization is fighting for an elephant, ironically her name is Happy, to be granted legal personhood.
Duarte Gialdino
National Geographic has this reporting and makes the point that the U.S. is far behind other countries when it comes to recognizing the rights of animals.
Shamita Basu
First, let's talk about what it means to have legal personhood. It's not the same thing as being considered a citizen.
Duarte Gialdino
It's not like Happy the Elephant is going to be on the hook for taxes or be able to vote.
Shamita Basu
The idea is, does Happy have rights? Here in the U.S., our laws consider corporations legal persons, but not animals.
Duarte Gialdino
Nat Geo runs through a few animal rights cases in other countries.
Shamita Basu
There was a famous recent case involving an elephant in a zoo in Pakistan.
Duarte Gialdino
After this elephant's mate died, he spent the next eight years living alone.
Shamita Basu
A lawyer petitioned to have a court intervene, saying this elephant deserves a healthy environment.
Duarte Gialdino
The judge agreed and ordered him to be sent to a sanctuary with other elephants.
Shamita Basu
A similar case came up in Argentina in 2016.
Duarte Gialdino
A court there ruled a chimpanzee named Cecilia who been living in a zoo should be recognized as a legal person with fundamental rights.
Shamita Basu
And things turned out well for Cecilia. She's been living in a sanctuary ever since.
Duarte Gialdino
Over the years, as research has shown many animals are smarter and more emotional than we previously thought, several countries ended up passing laws that recognize animals as sentient beings with rights.
Shamita Basu
So what does this all mean for Happy and her court case in New York?
Duarte Gialdino
Nat Geo spoke with Stephen Wise. He's the president of the Non-Human Rights Project.
Stephen Wise
That's the organization that's arguing on Happy's behalf.
Shamita Basu
Wise says he's hoping the court will side with them in order that Happy get transferred to a sanctuary.
Duarte Gialdino
That'll help lay the legal groundwork for other solitary zoo elephants to gain the right to be sent to sanctuaries too.
Shamita Basu
You ever been out shopping and notice an inflatable 12-foot rat outside of a business?
Duarte Gialdino
It's not a cute rat like the one from Pixar's Ratatouille. No, this guy is ugly. It's raising its claws and baring its teeth.
Shamita Basu
They call him Scabby. Unions set up this giant airfield rat in front of businesses they disagree with.
Duarte Gialdino
And just recently, Scabby was at the center of a free speech case.
Shamita Basu
NPR explains how this happened.
Duarte Gialdino
See, sometimes a labor union would put Scabby outside of a business to draw attention to an ongoing dispute they have with that establishment.
Shamita Basu
But other times, Scabby has been used to shame a company just for working with a business that the union has an issue with.
Duarte Gialdino
You know, shaming them by association.
Shamita Basu
Those retail store owners argued that unfairly hurt their businesses.
Duarte Gialdino
This all came to a head recently when the National Labor Relations Board said it would review this issue.
Shamita Basu
The board ultimately sided with unions.
Duarte Gialdino
Board members said Scabby was a form of protected free speech.
Shamita Basu
Now, this decision could be appealed, and if that happens, one union leader promises to vigorously defend the rat and everything it represents.
Duarte Gialdino
He said, we'll always fight for Scabby.
Shamita Basu
You can find all these stories and more in the Apple News app.
Duarte Gialdino
And while you're in the app, keep listening to hear narrated articles from our News Plus partners.
Shamita Basu
We'll talk with you again tomorrow.