Main Topic: The prevalence of insider trading in the stock market and its impact on investors.
Key Points:
Participants:
Takeaways:
Data shows high-level execs often get unusually good returns trading their own companies’ stocks. But regulators say insider trading is hard to prove under current law. For Bloomberg Businessweek, Liam Vaughan explains why insider trading is more widespread than you might think — and why some experts argue the system is fundamentally unfair.
Theme music fades out
Duarte Giraldino
Welcome to In Conversation from Apple News Today. I'm Duarte Giraldino.
Pause
Every weekend, we're taking you deeper into the best journalism on Apple News. You ever get the feeling the stock market is rigged? Like, no matter what you do, heavy hitters are always going to make more money.
Liam Vaughn
Well, some experts say if you're feeling that way, you might be right. Insiders of all kinds consistently outperforming the market. They get out before bad news. They trade before good news.
Duarte Giraldino
That's Liam Vaughn. He's a senior reporter with Bloomberg Businessweek. His latest article is about the prevalence of insider trading.
Liam Vaughn
This is such an open secret, such a baked-in part of the system. I'm not talking about the kind of insider trading that Martha Stewart was convicted of. Those kind of cases involve one person giving someone else a tip, information they're not supposed to know.
Duarte Giraldino
The kind of cases you looked into are different and arguably much more lucrative.
Liam Vaughn
My article's about something that's in some ways more kind of pedestrian, but in other ways potentially more impactful and concerning, which is where executives basically place trades. They don't tell anyone because they don't need to. They just trade themselves or they get their broker to do it.
Duarte Giraldino
And it can be pretty hard to prove the person in question did anything wrong. If anyone comes asking, which they very rarely do, they turn around and say, no, no, no, I was trading because the timing was right or I needed to liquidate my holdings or whatever it is.
Liam Vaughn
So it's the kind of everyday trading by corporate America that I'm writing about. Take this example. You know, in one case, a guy had a 500% return because he placed all these trades before his company made an announcement about a positive set of cancer results and the share price jumped 500%.
Duarte Giraldino
Well, I interviewed him and he talked about the fact that some of that information was already out in the public domain. So he says that he was as surprised by the jump as anyone else.
Liam Vaughn
So let's tackle the big question. Is the stock market rigged, yes or no?
Duarte Giraldino
Vaughn wouldn't give me a clear-cut yes or no, but he did explain why this is important to pay attention to.
Liam Vaughn
The rules say insiders can't trade on material non-public information. But in practice, he argues, one of the biggest open secrets on Wall Street is that this is happening all the time.
Duarte Giraldino
Insider trading is essentially where you are an insider within a corporation. You might be the CEO or some kind of other executive or board member. And you're privy to, you know, information that could potentially move the stock.
Liam Vaughn
It might be that there's some bad news coming down the pike. You might be being investigated by a regulator or it might be good news. You might have a fantastic set of earnings. And insider trading, or at least of the kind that I write about, refers to when insiders will trade on that information to beat the underlying market and to profit.
Duarte Giraldino
And so if you are, you know, someone with a pension plan or if you're someone who just dabbles a bit on the stock market yourself, you know, every time you take the opposite side of a trade against an insider, you're essentially losing money because they know what's about to happen. You don't, and you're taking the wrong end of the bet, so to speak.
Liam Vaughn
How many insiders would you say they are? Can you quantify that number?
Duarte Giraldino
Yeah. So, you know, one of the good things and why this research has been able to be done is that if you are an insider in the US, then you have to file a disclosure every time you trade. And so we know that there's around 82,000 insiders in the US.
Liam Vaughn
How common then is insider trading? I mean, in terms of quantifying it, it's very difficult because so little of it is actually caught.
Duarte Giraldino
What we can say is that if you look at insiders and compare their trading returns versus the rest of the market, they consistently outperform as a group.
Liam Vaughn
So, for example, those 82,000 outperformed the underlying S&P 500 by five percentage points between 2015 and 2020. And if you consider that was actually a very positive period for the stock market, that's considerable outperformance.
Duarte Giraldino
How do they respond when people say, "Hey, is this something fishy? Is this insider trading because you did so much better than anyone else seemed to have been able to do?"
Liam Vaughn
Yeah, I mean they turn around and say, "Wow, I'm as surprised as you are. I only ever trade during the correct times. All my trades are approved by lawyers, and aren't I lucky?" But there's no guarantee that it will keep happening. You know, they certainly don't believe that they've done anything wrong or anything illegal. And to be fair, there's no evidence that they necessarily have. It's just that they've been very, very fortuitous.
Duarte Giraldino
And you do have an advantage if you're an executive, even if you're not trading on inside information. You're still going to know what something means, even if it's in the public domain, better than other people. So that you know, you have to factor in that there is going to be some kind of degree of about performance.
Liam Vaughn
So, Moderna, as you know, it was one of the first companies to come out with the vaccine. Last year, company higher-ups sold hundreds of millions of dollars in Moderna stock. A lot of people were looking at the chief medical officer in particular who changed his stock sales plan just days before his company released big vaccine news.
Duarte Giraldino
Now, Moderna says that the sales were set up well in advance.
Liam Vaughn
Yeah, so the Moderna case is an interesting one, and it's quite typical. And it's why this subject of insider trading has become kind of heated again, which is that you have all these executives at these pharma companies like Moderna, who are sitting on information where they know essentially that their company is about to announce some kind of brilliant set of results from its vaccine, or is about to announce some kind of contract with the government, or something that's going to make the share price pop.
Duarte Giraldino
Then they were in a position to capitalize on that. What the Moderna guy did when he's now left is essentially set up a trading plan so every week for 10 weeks he would sell x amount of shares. But he set it up or it came into being the day after Moderna had announced like an incredible round of results in its vaccine.
Liam Vaughn
And so he made a huge amount of money. He made like four million over a period of 10 weeks. You know, it's interesting to me because on the one hand, you could argue well, this guy contributed to the success of this company that's been involved in this great public good. And Moderna is one of the main vaccines that we're all using to get better. Why shouldn't he benefit from the proceeds of that?
Duarte Giraldino
But other people say, well, you can benefit, but you have to do it in a kind of fair way. And if you're essentially just trading off the back of your knowledge of what's coming down the pike, then that seems unfair.
Liam Vaughn
To be clear, he didn't do anything illegal. He just played the rules as they currently stand. I think it helps highlight there's some problems with the rules.
Duarte Giraldino
Okay, this is probably a good place to talk about the rules because insider trading is hard to prosecute.
Liam Vaughn
Technically, insider trading is not in and of itself a crime. There is no insider trading definitional rule in the US law. Like if you're going to be done for insider trading, you're actually done for fraud.
Duarte Giraldino
What that means is to be charged with insider trading, you have to be charged with fraud under the Securities Exchange Act 1934.
Liam Vaughn
Liam calls this crime as it is written out in the act deceptively difficult to prove.
Duarte Giraldino
That exactly right. Yeah, I approach the story that you have on the one hand all this kind of really fascinating research, which demonstrates how pervasive this type of insider trading is. But then if you look at convictions, they're very, very low. They're at 30-year lows.
Liam Vaughn
Well, why? You know, why is nobody prosecuting this? And so I spoke to a bunch of former SEC folks and former people that are, you know, used to work for the Justice Department. And they all agree that it's just a really, really difficult crime to prosecute.
Duarte Giraldino
One of the reasons for that is exactly as you say, that there's just a lack of evidence. And in order to prosecute somebody for insider trading, you have to demonstrate that they had a criminal intent.
Liam Vaughn
And to do that, you normally rely on an email that says, "Hey, we better get out of this now because something bad about to happen." But in these cases, that doesn't exist.
Duarte Giraldino
But there's other issues as well. It's very easy for an executive at the end of it to say, "No, no, no, it might look like I had information that the company was about to be you know, criminally charged, but I was actually just trading based on my own perception of what's out there already or I was just trading because I just fancied it because it was a Tuesday."
Liam Vaughn
You might be suspicious of that, but to prove a case beyond a reasonable doubt is very hard.
Duarte Giraldino
The numbers show that regulators brought only a handful of enforcement actions for insider trading. The SEC, as I know, wouldn't comment for your story, but you talk to a lot of former government lawyers. Why do they think the feds aren't doing more?
Liam Vaughn
There's a couple of reasons. One, which we've talked about, is that these cases are just really hard to bring. They don't want to spend their time bringing a case that they're ultimately going to lose and it's going to make them look bad.
Duarte Giraldino
But the other thing which was pretty surprising to me is this kind of sense that and maybe it's born of the fact that it's in their interest to say this, but this sense that it's not that bad, like compared to a kind of Bernie Madoff Ponzi scheme where you know, a guy lies about his returns and lots of people lose their life savings or compared to like an accounting fraud like Enron where the company goes under and lots of people lose their jobs and lots of people lose money.
Liam Vaughn
You know, the kind of drip-drip of insider trading maybe isn't the worst thing in the world. Yes, every day investors are going to lose a bit of money on every single trade that they're on the other side from, but it's a small amount each time, and it's not going to break the system.
Duarte Giraldino
And so ultimately, there's a kind of sense of envy, I would say, amongst people that used to bring these white-collar cases about that and and and you know, to be fair, amongst some of them, there does seem to almost be like a philosophical sense that, listen, the markets aren't fair, they never have been.
Liam Vaughn
And so the idea of enforcing a rule that kind of is predicated on this kind of notion that the market should be a fair, even playing ground is kind of naive.
Duarte Giraldino
You talk about all these small trades. When you add them all up, how much money are we talking about that's going into the pockets of insiders? I mean, you're talking about billions and billions of dollars.
Liam Vaughn
You know, we're talking about every single company in America is included within these kind of calculations. So, you know, possibly into the trillions of dollars, but, you know, I don't have that figure in there.
Duarte Giraldino
But we are talking billions of dollars. And yet, there are some people who say it's essentially not a big deal that it's in some way good for the market.
Liam Vaughn
That seems so incredibly painfully counterintuitive. I mean, one of the things that again is a consistent theme in my work is that the regulators are really underfunded.
Duarte Giraldino
Ultimately, Wall Street gets bigger, companies get richer, CEOs get better paid, but the regulators stay on that flatline.
Liam Vaughn
The SEC doesn't have enough money to bring all the cases that it wants, doesn't have enough money to buy the technology and the type of computer power that the people that it's chasing have got.
Duarte Giraldino
There's an analogy of a moped chasing a Ferrari, and that is essentially what the SEC and the CFTC have to deal with on a day-to-day basis.
Liam Vaughn
The people that work there are incredibly hardworking and want to do the right job, but ultimately, they can't bring the cases that they want. And so this to me, and I think that's one of the conclusions of the piece, is that ultimately seems to be one of those things that maybe they consider like jaywalking or something. It's like you just kind of let it go because ultimately, either it's too big to take on, you know, like drugs, you know, maybe you're better off just saying we're not going to challenge this so let's just legalize it.
Duarte Giraldino
Or ultimately, they're just focusing on other things.
Liam Vaughn
So I agree, it's incredibly galling to see it and laid out like that. But ultimately, they are limited in what they can do as well.
Duarte Giraldino
You mentioned that there are companies now that track insiders and they sell this information to you or me to anyone who wants to follow the habits and the investing practice of these insiders. TipRanks is one of them. What is TipRanks, how would you explain what it is?
Liam Vaughn
Yeah, so every day, if you go on the SEC's database, it kind of spits out every single trade that corporate America makes in their own stock, but it's like a torrent of data.
Duarte Giraldino
And, you know, even if you were a pretty savvy investor, it's pretty hard for you to wrangle that data and get anything meaningful out of it.
Liam Vaughn
TipRanks what essentially they do is they take that, they strip out a lot of the trades that they believe aren't particularly predictive, and then they come up with a ranking of the top insiders based on their track record over a number of years.
Duarte Giraldino
You know, their kind of win rate and how much they win and their consistency. And you know, that's pretty helpful. It gives you a very good snapshot of who's doing very well consistently over time.
Liam Vaughn
I mean, one of the interesting things I felt about this story is there's a kind of democratization going on. Like if you were to look at things 20 or 30 years ago, the only people that were doing this were the George Soros's of the world, these kind of very savvy hedge funds, and they would hire people to go through the filings and they would be able to sort of factor in what insiders were doing into their information.
Duarte Giraldino
So it's very much like a kind of closed shop, really. But now, TipRanks and others like it are sort of doing that but they're doing it for a much more retail audience, you know, the kind of crypto crowd or the Robin Hood crowd.
Liam Vaughn
That to me looks like the market is saying essentially there is value in tracking the trades of insiders. Whether that's insider trading or not, there's something to be said. They're doing far better than most of us.
Duarte Giraldino
Is that accurate or no?
Liam Vaughn
That's 100% accurate.
Duarte Giraldino
Yeah. And you're right to make the distinction. You know, they don't make a distinction between insiders insider trading and insiders just trading.
Liam Vaughn
But yes, and it's long been understood by Wall Street and is now being understood by everyone else that tracking insiders is definitely a worthwhile activity.
Duarte Giraldino
And if you're able to separate the wheat from the chaff, isolate the trades that are really informative, then yes, there's a lot of money to be made.
Thank you so much, Liam. It was great chatting with you.
Liam Vaughn
Thank you.
Theme music fades in