Today we're joined by Ryan Selkis, the Founder and CEO of Messari and an outspoken political advocate for the crypto industry. We explore the current state of Crypto Regulation and how Ryan plans to fight in Washington with the Digital Freedom Alliance.
------ 📣 ASYMETRIX PROTOCOL https://bankless.cc/asymetrix
------ 🚀 Airdrop Alpha is waiting for you on Bankless.com https://bankless.cc/Alpha
------ BANKLESS SPONSOR TOOLS:
🐙KRAKEN | MOST-TRUSTED CRYPTO EXCHANGE https://k.xyz/bankless-pod-q2
🦊METAMASK LEARN | HELPFUL WEB3 RESOURCE https://bankless.cc/MetaMask
⚖️ ARBITRUM | SCALING ETHEREUM https://bankless.cc/Arbitrum
👾STADER LABS | ETHX LIQUID STAKING https://bankless.cc/Stader
🗣️TOKU | CRYPTO EMPLOYMENT SOLUTION https://bankless.cc/Toku
🎮IMMUTABLE | GAMING ECOSYSTEM https://bankless.cc/Immutable
🛞MANTLE | MODULAR LAYER 2 NETWORK https://bankless.cc/Mantle
------ Topics Covered
0:00 Intro 9:34 Does Washington Want to Kill Crypto? 15:45 How the US Affects Global Regulation 27:54 Ryan Selkis Proposal 43:10 What we can learn from SBF 51:20 The Digital Freedom Alliance 59:08 Why we have to Play Politics 1:03:49 What’s Next 1:08:00 Closing and Disclaimers
----- Resources:
Ryan Selkis https://twitter.com/twobitidiot
Join the Digital Freedom Alliance https://joindfa.org/
----- Not financial or tax advice. This channel is strictly educational and is not investment advice or a solicitation to buy or sell any assets or to make any financial decisions. This video is not tax advice. Talk to your accountant. Do your own research.
Disclosure. From time-to-time I may add links in this newsletter to products I use. I may receive commission if you make a purchase through one of these links. Additionally, the Bankless writers hold crypto assets. See our investment disclosures here: https://www.bankless.com/disclosures
No summary for this episode yet.
One thing about Sam Bankman Fried is his understanding of the political system and the political game was unparalleled within the crypto industry. What he did last year was very savvy from a political standpoint. We basically need to do something, but here's the thing. The silver lining, as we know that, but we need to be better as an industry and you need to run a very similar playbook, but with a decentralized base of contributors and a set of honest actors that have been in the trenches four years building or the sole reason that we actually believe in this tech and its potential to be a force for good.
The $100 million fight for crypto in Washington DC, that's what Ryan Silkis, our next guest, feels like we need in order to take this battle to DC and to win. Some questions we had for him in this episode. Can we actually raise $100 million to fight for crypto in DC? What would that even look like? What would we spend this on? Is the US really the place we should fight? I thought crypto was international. Why do we need money in politics to fight this fight anyway? We talk about the window of opportunity to actually get this right. Ryan Silkis thinks we have a very narrow window in which to deploy these funds or else we lose the opportunity.
Then we get to Ryan's proposal for a new organization that he is creating to help win this fight in DC. David, this is the year of regulatory. It's 2023. I feel like that's been a major theme for the year and that's why this episode is important. It's been the year of bad regulatory guidance, bad regulatory oversight. Ryan Silkis wants to make it the year of good regulatory oversight with what he is proposing here with a digital freedom alliance. But before we get into that conversation with Ryan, I want to talk to you about asymmetrics protocol. There's our friends and sponsors at asymmetrics.
If you are familiar with pool together, it's quite like that except with teeth staking. What does asymmetrics do? Is that just 4.5 to 5% staking yield just 2 boring? How does anywhere between 0 and 999% sound? Because that is what you can get with asymmetrics. You put your ether into asymmetrics, it steaks it into LIDA with staked eith, and then it distributes the yield not to you, but to just one lucky winner, which could be you, but it probably won't, but it might, and if it is you, you will get a lot of eith. It's like six eith right now. Six eith to the lucky winner. Exactly. If you want to just really play with your the size of your winnings, again, either zero or quite a lot, this is the place for you.
This is called a prize-linked savings account, so it's like a savings account, except instead of slow and steady yield every once in a while, you get a prize. So there is a link in the show notes to get started with asymmetrics. It's bankless.cc slash asymmetrics, or you can follow the metric or at asymmetrics underscore eith. David, $100 million is pretty ambitious here, but Ryan makes a great case for why we need that much. What do you think of his plan? I think bankless listeners who are going into this episode, I think the imagination that they could strike is like, hey, you know how good SPF was playing at playing the DC game.
He was very good at it. He was a very, very effective. Sadly, he was a fraud. What if SPF was playing the game actually in line with crypto's interests? That is the question that Ryan is presenting to the industry saying, hey, we need to do the thing that SPF was doing, but for the good guys, for us, for our own interests. It's the correct game to play, and we have a very small window of opportunity to play it, and we need to be effective because if we lose the game, unwinding that game, that this game of playing the political fight in DC, it's a one to two year long game. If we lose that game, it is 10 years of repair and going backwards in order to get back to where this industry needs to be.
Ryan makes a very strong case that now is the time and DC is the place. I think that's the imagination I'll leave with listeners is like, man, what if SPF was a good guy in DC and he actually had fought for our interests? How nice would that have been? Ryan's proposing that we do that. Sadly, a year or so late, but regardless, it's the right place to be. I think he makes a great case for that. If you think that doing nothing is a viable strategy, I think you should listen to Ryan's case for why it's not a viable strategy. How doing nothing leads to more SPFs actually stepping in to DC and representing us in ways that we might not want to be represented.
We get into all of that today, a very important episode in 2023 and the current climate that we're in for sure. Guys, we're going to get right to the episode with Ryan Celcus, but before we do, we want to thank the sponsors that made this possible, including Kraken. Our number one recommended crypto exchange. Kraken Pro has easily become the best crypto trading platform in the industry. The place I use to check the charts and the crypto prices, even when I'm not looking to place a trade. On Kraken Pro, you'll have access to advanced charting tools, real-time market data, and lightning fast trade execution.
All inside, there's spiffy new modular interface. Kraken's new customizable modular layout lets you tailor your trading experience to suit your needs. Pick and choose your favorite modules and place them anywhere you want in your screen. With Kraken Pro, you have that power. Whether you are a season pro or just starting out, join thousands of traders who trust Kraken Pro for their crypto trading needs. Visit pro.kraken.com to get started today. mantle is a brand new high-performance Ethereum layer 2 network. Built differently from the other layer twos, you may be familiar with. mantle is a modular layer 2 built on the OP stack, but uses eigenlayers data availability solution instead of the expensive Ethereum layer 1.
Not only does this reduce mantle's gas fees by 80% compared to other layer twos, but it also reduces gas fee volatility. mantle has a decentralized sequencer set, eliminating the risk of downtime and censorship on the network. And because mantle implements multi-party computation nodes, layer 1 settlement execution is shortened from 7 days to as low as just 1 or 2. mantle is the first layer 2 built by a DAO and is backed by one of the biggest DAO treasuries in the world. BIT DAO. mantle already has subcommunities from around web 3 onboarded to help the growth of mantle, like game 7 for web 3 gaming or edu DAO for the world of D side and buy bit for tvl liquidity and on ramps.
Check out mantle at mantle.xyz and follow them on twitter at 0x mantle. immutable is at the forefront of web 3 gaming. On a mission to bring digital ownership to every player offering the world's best games and game development platform. immutable lets game builders and players focus on great gaming experiences. So build your next web 3 game on easy mode with immutable's leading full stack web 3 gaming platform. It's built in UX features like the immutable passport are designed for games to scale to the next billion players coming to web 3 with immutable players can sign up with an email pay with a credit card and experience a frictionless purchase flow inside of games.
So discover your next favorite game and explore a network of 150 games building on immutable including such titles as gausen chains guilds of guardians eluvium embersord and metal core. So join web 3's largest ecosystem of games and players build play and connect at immutable.com. Biggest nation I would love to introduce you to Ryan selkes the founder and CEO of msari also an outspoken political advocate for the crypto industry which is in short supply these days and he is here to propose something new for crypto's fight in washington. Ryan welcome back to bankless always get to be here guys are you holding up well.
Ryan are you picking a fight for us a little bit and you know me I feel like I mix it up with different folks on different occasions throughout the years this is your 10 for me within crypto and I would like to think that at this point my staying power and the fact that I'm still around and still have a few friends in the industry means that I've been picking smart fights over the years and I think that this is just the most recent smart fight that is worth fighting down in dc and and a lot of it is damage control and just resetting the narrative post fts collapse in November I think we took a huge hit I think dc move slower and public sentiment move move slower than than crypto does so as focused as people are within the industry on moving forward on building our way out of this and getting to the next milestones and kind of next killer apps and laying the foundation for for you know all the infrastructure improvements that have come out between you know e-scaling and all the roll ups change that have launched we are still in the feeling the after effects of fts from public policy standpoint and we probably will be for some time so there's a couple of ways out of that and I think there is general a general lack of understanding within the crypto community as to how public policy works and in particular like how dc works and what I hope to do you know today is basically talk about some of those misconceptions and and and potentially some of the solutions that I do think are going to require pretty proactive engagement and not just taking a step back and saying you know oh it's fine the the rest of the world will move on and the us will be left behind or you know we're just going to focus on the tech and we don't really need to engage with policymakers I think I think both of those are incorrect and I think you've got a couple of guests on from the regulatory sphere that have said as much but even from a crypto native standpoint I would try to make that argument and maybe first fact from fiction in terms of what's going on and what's going to get us to the other side of this bear market well let's start with the the first fact from fiction question right I think you've basically said and you know this may be a direct quote Ryan Washington wants to kill crypto do you think that's hyperbole or do you think that's that's really the case like is something different about 2023 where Washington has taken this I'm not just going to stifle crypto I we actively want to kill it of course Washington is a complex beast so you can't talk about every faction wanting to kill crypto maybe you're just referring to a specific contingent but tell us about that does Washington want to kill crypto I don't think everybody in the crypto industry deals that way if you're talking about Bitcoin and you're talking about the government's version of crypto then I think there's probably some shades of gray right that the government doesn't necessarily want to or they want at least overtly say that they want to kill those upstarts or those more staff projects they might be focusing on okay how do we make sure that we prevent another situation like FTX how do we ensure we prevent another situation like Tara but for all intents and purposes the folks at matter in DC right now are in the Biden administration of the financial regulators right we've seen what's happened in the past few months with chip.
2.0 and the debanking issues it made companies bad in the industry we've seen this personally you know at the Missouri level in this new entity digital freedom alliance that we're talking to banking and even for pretty plain vanilla organizations that are crypto adjacent that don't actually process transactions that don't actually touch native assets it's still a challenge to get through the compliance process you have for banking on the SEC side I think that that ground has been well-treated what is a security versus a commodity versus a currency you know chair chancellor has his knives out for the industry and that's going to impact basically every asset not named Bitcoin and he's even extended in fact and the SEC is extended to claiming that stable coins are somehow part of their purview and then I think when you when you talk about the other miscellaneous regulators you know whether you're talking about the Fed and Treasury they'll talk about financial stability they'll talk about national security we don't have a lot of friends within the Biden administration right now that's that's just the the ground reality to your point Washington is not all right there are folks on both sides of the aisle there are folks on in different generations not just in terms of age but in terms of experience and kind of like old school new school where they come from politically that are very mixed on crypto and it is fairly split or at least it seems like it's fairly split between what I'd call the ones and the fives right the ones being the Elizabeth Warrens of the world the Brad Schermans of the world that just want to outright kill this and recruit their anti crypto army then there's the fives maybe that's the you know the the time-members the rocona's the the folks that are really good on and and tempered in terms of thinking about how to regulate crypto but the reality is that the vast majority you know 80 plus percent of representatives in Congress are somewhere between two three and four and most of the time there are three because they just don't care and they kind of think that crypto's already dead so I think much like you I mean you guys have done a couple episodes on X-Risk with with AGI right like the the X-Risk with AGI is not that these like AGI's are evil and they they want to squash everything it's that they just don't care like you know we're like ants and there's like there's a little bit of that that you can analogize to in DC which is they see the five bullets like what has happened last year they think this is bullshit we have to fix this and they don't really take the time necessarily to get into the minutiae and the details many of them and and so what may happen if we are not coordinated and and highly engaged in DC the next 12 to 18 months is they're just going to steam roll over some of that nuance and ultimately create structures that are going to be untenable for the industry in the US for years to come and I think we do have a very short window I think the 2024 election is very important and I think the work that we do in kind of resetting the narrative and reestablishing trust and in some cases self-regulating or at least trying to act according to the spirit of existing consumer protection laws is really going to dictate what type of long term outcomes we have in the US we can have a global conversation that's adjacent to that but I think about the US as in the medium term a 2x delta in crypto success you know we have the first second fourth fifth tenth amendment you know on our side we have a pretty libertarian populace we've got the largest tech economy in the world we've got the largest financial markets in the world we've got the reserve currency you know if the US is possible to crypto versus friendly or at least common sense in its approach to crypto you're talking about a 2x in market size one way or the other so I think the risk that Washington kills crypto is not necessarily that it comes down top down evenly and says you know I think that might be a little bit of tinfoil hat territory but I think the reality is more likely that they just see the risks here a lot of other big problems that we need to focus on we're going to steamroll over it and then in the process we as an industry will have lost a pretty critical foothold that I think people underestimate in terms of the US's importance in the crypto economy in the medium term and basically what a hostile US would do in having the potential for the market in the next five years if things go the wrong way I just want to capture that last point because this isn't just about the United States I mean some people might be listening to this and being like Ryan crypto like get out of your American bubble man like crypto is a global movement okay yeah America's has the problems right now but America is not the rest of the world but I think you just made the case that the US actually is the hill to die on at least for crypto can you get into that a little bit more can you kind of reinforce that case what why does what happens in the United States matter globally doesn't America just get left behind and crypto innovation moves elsewhere and so we soldier on why why take this fight to Washington so hard I mean I think you have to just be realistic around about where funding comes from around where demand has come from historically and where a good chunk of development is right now and then also which nations have the rule of law and kind of the existing you know societal norms that are going to foster innovation in in an area like crypto and the easiest way to do that is to look just very simply China US Europe rest of world right do you want to be building decentralized technologies behind the great firewall of China and do you think that that ultimately is going to be a healthy market for technologies that decentralized power that decentralized authority and that ultimately empower individuals to make private transactions or own their own data or you know otherwise kind of live live as self sovereigns that's a pretty easy yes or no question I'll leave that to the listener to decide but you know I think that it's so much straightforward another quarter of the world you can break down as European centric and I think Europe is actually an area that we've made some progress from a regulatory standpoint I'm not totally convinced that we're going to love all the solutions that come out of Europe if you think about what's happening with Mika right now there are restrictions on you know how much you can have in self-custody accounts there are going to be disclosure requirements there are already tremendous speech restrictions in the EU whether you're talking about you know just the drama last week with Twitter and the disinformation issues that they have the Ministry of Truth you know as a word and in the EU if you're thinking about the the health of the euro and just like the governance issues that you have in the European union I don't think you want to put all of your eggs in that basket and so then you're basically left with half of the global economy you know 25% of it being the US 25% across the world we should focus on I think Europe and the US I'm an American you guys are American so I kind of feel like the EU is run by technocrats and Mika is already fairly far along so we're just going to have to adapt to that you know kind of post-Mika world in the crypto community the the other half of the world and the the one quarter and one jurisdiction that we can actually control and make an impact is going to be the US and given the US's outsized dominance in financial services and technology the rest of the world will more likely than not follow some of the US regulatory model and the EU regulatory model than they will kind of bootstrap their own and if they do bootstrap their own is it going to be adopted by similar countries or is it more likely that them going their own way like El Salvador is a good example like are they going to create risks for themselves with the IMF with the other kind of global power structures that just dwarf them in size um and I think that's that's uh a pretty hairy question that some emerging economies are going to have to wrap their heads around is you know do we want to gravitate towards the US do we want to gravitate towards the EU do we want to gravitate towards you know China like whose meta rules are are we ultimately going to think about playing by when it comes to international finance and tech and um and I think the it will be the exception not the rule that smaller countries will go their own way um what you'll instead be left with is you know some version of the US crypto rules or some version of the EU crypto rules or the Chinese crypto rules will ultimately be what are what are enacted by large and that that people follow internationally so what we need to do is we need to make sure that the US is the most laws a fair um of those major three markets so that it can be um I think a gravity well or or you know magnet for some of these other developing economies to adopt their models um and ensure that uh that we actually have the ability to build self-custody and and advance some of these um kind of new applications that we've been working on I also want to just grab one other point it also seems like there might be just a small window of opportunity in which to do this and get it done because once legislation is in place it's very difficult to kind of roll back and we're seeing meek is in place China already has its posture on crypto which basically been previously to ban it unless they reverse course uh and now there's the US which is still unwritten the future is still unwritten here but you can't imagine it going five years from now and still like the US hasn't weighed in on this crypto thing right like they're going to have to do something within the next five years so that feels like there is a maybe shrinking window opportunity to get something done and to do it well in the US would you agree with that I think it's a very short window of opportunity sentiment is temporary laws permanent right it is very difficult to get old laws off the books it's difficult to pass legislation it's arguably even more difficult to repeal or alter existing laws um and you just think about how many years we've been talking about hey we need common sense frameworks in the US for crypto um the asset class is swollen to you know over a trillion dollars inside you have hundreds you know over a hundred billion dollars of uh euro dollars that are digitized and traded on chain and there's no federal legislation or really anything that's close to federal legislation right now on crypto that is that is going to come to a head at some point and it's either going to come to a head because the executive branch will seize control and basically do everything in its power to stamp out anything that isn't overtly regulated and doesn't fit within existing you know regulatory norms and which is the default if that decision doesn't happen yeah um and then there's uh bad legislation that would potentially cripple out of the industry so we we really need to thread the needle here in terms of getting good um kind of narrow legislation that can eke out iterative progress um a couple of months ago i i'd written a letter to a number of senators and congressmen just kind of laying out you know fact versus fiction and also you know what do we need to see um in terms of a public policy framework that will help advance the the industry and and and america's interest in in being a dominant player within the crypto market for years to come um and and for me and and i think most others it kind of breaks down into three sub pieces of legislation and one of the problems is everybody's trying to have this you know universal theory of everything for crypto and it's an emerging market that's just not going to happen right now if instead we broke it into three pieces perhaps stablecoins market structure which would basically be how do you handle exchanges and custodians and then how do you handle the assets right so three different um pieces i think we could thread the needle and we could have really positive public policy frameworks in the us that foster innovation that extend the dollar's dominance because you continue to ensure that the us dollar and and us dollar denominated stablecoins with the reserve currency for crypto um and you make sure that you safeguard investors uh and avoid blowups akin to FTX and and many of the other issues that we saw largely international right um and so i think the highest probability legislation that that could be passed in the next couple of years would probably be around how do you regulate stablecoins and how do you regulate exchanges custodians and the like and by the way this is something that you know with the uh dccpa the stab-in-out boseman bill last year there was a lot of noise around this you had the famous debate between you know Eric and uh and sam um that bill i don't think people appreciate like you're always like a few sentences between like a really shitty piece of legislation and like something that can actually be positive positive and workable and uh the issue with the dccpa last year was uh particularly with the the reaction from the crypto community people were looking at a draft piece of legislation that was still getting uh the fine-tooth comb and people were arguing about the words um and and trying to make sure that they were technically accurate that the spirit of what the the legislators were trying to do was consistent with the actual letter of the law that was written and and and and basically um change the the several sentences that would make a good market structure bill a good stablecoin you know uh kind of legislation um would make it work without crippling defy or pushing every single crypto asset through the scc or or or or something similar and um and we didn't get there for numerous reasons not the least of which was you know the the offensive november and ft axis collapse i think through cold water on on uh any forward progress that we had there but i do think that there were more pieces of that legislation their core pieces of a couple of other pieces of legislation have been sponsored by tom emmer um and uh and and uh chair mcennery and and vaccine waters i think i have good stablecoin legislation these things aren't that far away but some of the splits that we see um it takes time energy and attention to actually close those gaps and that's what i think is working against us right now is peat you know generally speaking um i think the the democrats are okay with the status quo because they feel like gary gensler and the financial regulators are clamping down on the industry and making sure that it can no longer do any harm um but some of the more forward thinking legislators are trying to say we would like to actually come to a compromise here we'd like to set some clear guidelines and we would also like to ensure that we're not just delegating public policy that's going to have a long-term economic impact to one man that's temporarily heading a regulatory agency and grabbing as much power as he possibly can um so you know to come full circle one of the reasons that i'm spending more time and i'm sure we'll talk more about this yeah maybe it's a segue but one of the reasons i'm spending more time kind of formally on on public policy is how do we call attention uh to some of this overreach in a constructive way and then how do we you know advance our own narrative so it's not just the crypto community you know uh whining about getting regulated after all of the sins of 2022 um that's just not going to play in dc it's not going to play in europe so i can't play it anywhere i think everybody recognizes that a redux of 2022 in a future market cycle is um not a scenario that global policy makers are you know going to allow and they will deputize anyone that they believe is going to prevent it then right now that's chair gansler that's uh chair vio groenberg from the fd icidu a certain extent to choke point um and and a couple of the other regulators so our only hope right now um to actually make some forward progress between now in 2024 election is a bipartisan stablecoin or market structure bill um that solves some of these jurisdictional issues or um some changes and you know in many cases generation change in dc and in the next um 2024 election so um it's a long time to wait uh by by crypto standards uh to feel like we're in a holding counter so i used to take consolation in that uh the idea that it's not as impossible to ban crypto you only ban your citizens from uh from accessing crypto and if america was going to just shoot itself in the foot and ban crypto then so be it uh but i now i now take the perspective that uh america banning crypto is the fight uh because of america uh if america leaves by example and does great legislation and great leadership and we as the crypto industry get to advocate for ourselves inside of capital hill inside of washington then the downstream net effects of that are are significant uh if it if we win this fight we win 10 15 20 other fights across the globe and so i think i what you're saying Ryan is that it behooves the crypto industry to make the full court press here and now inside of washington and i think what you're also saying is like not only is the battleground the correct battleground to fight america but also the time is now uh this is not something that we can choose to wait on uh the vultures are circling decisions are going to be made in the next two years around the those three things that you outlined market structure stablecoins and uh the nature of assets and so what you're saying is like the hey this is the this is the moment for the crypto industry to make a full court press because like you said laws tend to go one way they they get approved and then they don't get pulled back uh and so my my question to you is like well okay great i think we at least part of the crypto industry would would accept this and that's why we have things like coin center and blockchain association and all the other crypto advocacy advocacy groups in capital hill so what are what are you proposing that's different well what are you coming to the table with that is unique from all the other efforts that we've already had in this crypto industry great question so i think a lot of these other organizations are doing great work and they will be the first ones to say where there gaps in the market today um so taking a step back and then i'll drill down into what we're doing with uh digital freedom alliance this new 501 c4 that that we just started um in order to win over the next 18 months hold the line advance some positive narratives of the industry potentially advance some positive legislation and continue to elect more pro crypto and then we can progress what we're going to need is around a hundred million dollars of total spent right for that campaign a hundred million yeah um and i think we're probably about a third of the way funded to that because if you think about the annual well i mean if you think about the annual budgets of not the organization i'm talking about i'm talking about the the top down right the top down approach right so if you think about the operating budgets for coin center for the crypto council for innovation for blockchain association um if you think about the in-house policy spend and lobbying um that's that's be going on at some of the corporates and you just kind of tally all that effort it's probably around you a 30 to 40 million dollars and last year you know that's not that big a difference year over year if you take out FTX right so kind of the status quo is intact so the thing yeah just to to drive that point home the crypto industry spends about 30 to 40 million dollars in advocacy in capital hills what you're saying collectively i i i would say lash you know post-destructure bill i think yeah we we got up to that level so last year i'd say that's about the right number i think this year is probably similar um and um the way that that breaks down ideally that hundred million you have the status quo with the trade associations and the advocacy groups that are just doing like the shoe leather lobbying right there they're meeting with members are trying to educate members um about what is defy what is self cost how does the tech work why are these things important how does this already fit in some cases into the current you know public policy framework and regulatory framework and um it really historically has been i'd say 90 plus percents education and advocacy right and i think that's really important because you're talking about a novel tech and you're talking about you know why should you care about this why is it important for american competitiveness why is this good for consumers um and and basically you're painting the picture of okay what does the world look like in five ten years if we can allow these technologies to thrive but also safeguard consumers and individuals and what does it look like if we just push everything offshore which is kind of the current direction so that's basically like education advocacy and kind of tech 101 um and when you say education advocacy you're talking about education to political leaders to regulators this is not made like educate to lawmakers specifically exactly two to lawmakers to vote to folks in in Washington DC another prime that is emerged um that sun on socket bucket of what the trade associations or groups like point center will do is litigation finance and this is essentially just like holding the line and challenging some of the overreach that we've seen from the financial regulators right you can probably put another ten to fifteen million dollars in that bucket but some of the cases like ripples own case are orders of magnitude more expensive than that but there's probably about you know half dozen do a dozen cases you know all of which are going to cost you know probably on average about a million dollars because they're smaller scale um just to to actually hold the line and and and check the overreach of some of these regulators and and you know basically call balls and structure or or try to avoid negative precedence just because people aren't paying attention right so a good example would be the why he case with with coin base and all the briefs that you saw from friendly entities and and from some of the pro bono work that came in from different groups to actually challenge some of the claims that the regulators were making in that case so that it didn't create or precedent and push us further in the direction of okay this is tech that should you know be treated as you know securities issuance technology and and everything should kind of fall in the scc's bucket right this is just like the the trench warfare of court battles the tornado cash versus o-fac court cases come to mind as well exactly so I'd say collectively this is probably like half the battle the other half is camping finance which I'll talk about a minute but of that you call it fifty million there is I think one really important gap in the market which is in messaging message testing paid advertisements you know just general campaigning for crypto and changing our negatives from like nine to one in the mainstream media or in DC maybe to three to one or two to one right so just getting more of the pro crypto voices out there muting some of the most outrageous you know fun inducing claims that we we see on a day-to-day basis about how you know crypto is used for all these illicit activities or you know only people people have only lost their shirts with this tech it's not really good for anything it hasn't really hit you know any you know mainstream scale we need to counter some of those narratives and have actually pulled like you know pulling data and message testing that is going to help advance our narrative with those right audiences and then just saturate them with it part of it is stories like research driven pro crypto messaging that we first research and then broadcast to the right people exactly and it's it's you know talking points for kind of mainstream media surrogates it's actually just understanding like what language works with policymakers whether they're a one or a four whether they're democrat or republican and and and making sure that we stick to some type of campaign message right you always hear political campaign campaigns talk about staying on message uh an advocacy organization like digital freedom alliance which is this is all we're going to be doing is messaging coordination grassroots engagement and helping tell the story of crypto and then saturate um DC with that story everything that we're doing right now has to be about staying on message as if you think about crypto as like the candidate right the crypto campaign needs to stay on message and we need to talk about american competitiveness we need to talk about tech innovation and what that is done for our economy you know long-term we need to talk about the threats to the dollar and to our international dominance of financial services if we push this technology offshore and and you know kind of three to five kind of bulleted messages that are going to resonate on both sides of the aisle and we're actually going to be able to make a positive impact um and we also need to turn this into a campaign issue so out of the the messaging focused advocacy groups i'd say we're lacking that right now um in terms of like a single group that's going to coordinate you know shouting to the megaphone and and and really kind of nailing messages that work um point center does a great job of this with a very narrow set of issues so privacy software developer rights the um the case for bitcoin and and you know generally are following uh a pretty disciplined approach towards protecting constitutional rights of crypto users in the US i think about coin center almost like the night's watch right to use the game of thrones comparison right they're at the wall defending some of the big constitutional issues where any encroachment over that line is breaking some law or some norm and they're the first line of defense in terms of calling that out and and actually actively fighting that in in in the courts we don't really have in organization right now that's focused on like the fight for kings landing which is really like the muck of of dc and and and the political campaigning that i think is required um to make anti crypto policy politically damaging for our biggest opponents or their allies and to make pro crypto advocacy something that is going to be rewarded at the ballot box right so there's one side of the wall a messaging campaign that goes around that um and then on the other side we're talking about actual hard money that's going to go into electing pro crypto politicians so out of that hundred million dollar general campaign that um that we're talking about about 50 million is going to messaging advocacy lobbying litigation finance where you're you're just you're you're fighting and you're making the case for crypto with the existing incumbents the other half has to do with uh electoral politics right so how do we advance more pro crypto candidates through primaries how do we elect more pro crypto dems more pro crypto republicans in both chambers of congress and then ultimately how do you um make the crypto voting block very loud so that it will be perceived as politically damaging to be on the wrong side of this issue uh if you're uh if you're Elizabeth Warren or one of her close allies um that's where i think super packs and and pack funding comes in which is the direct contributions that are being made to campaigns or the indirect contributions that are going to um different groups that are generally aligned uh for or against a political candidate in a race and that ultimately you know kind of is responsible for the tv ads the print ads and and you know every dollar that's going into um fighting in the trenches and some of these swing states or some of these you know key key districts or key races um that uh that you know are going to be within you know five points uh come come November of 2024 learning about crypto is hard until now introducing metamask learn an open educational platform about crypto web3 self-custody wallet management and all the other topics needed to onboard people into this crazy world of crypto metamask learn is an interactive platform with each lesson offering a simulation for the task at hand giving you actual practical experience for navigating web3 the purpose of metamask learn is to teach people the basics of self-custody and wallet security in a safe environment and while metamask learn always takes the time to define web3 specific vocabulary it is still a jargon free experience for the crypto curious user friendly not scary metamask learn is available in ten languages with more to be added soon and it's meant to cater to a global web3 audience so are you tired of having to explain crypto concepts to your friends go to learn dot metamask.
io and add metamask learn to your guides to get onboarded into the world of web3 hiring people worldwide paying them in crypto providing them access to benefits it all so complex but it doesn't have to be complying with labor laws payroll rules tax obligations and crypto regulations in every country that you employ someone is difficult time consuming manual and costly and it's drawing more and more attention from regulators and governments but there is good news toku is here toku is the first to employment and compensation platform for the crypto industry that makes this easy toku helps you hire employees or contractors and pay them in fiat or crypto legally, compliantly and with all the taxes handled in over a hundred different jurisdictions so whether you're an early stage company with just a team of two or you're an enterprise with 200 toku has a solution that meets your needs toku is already working with the leading companies in the space protocol labs Hedera get coin and many more so transform your employment and token payroll operations with toku you can reach out to toku at toku.
com slash bankless or click the link in the show notes introducing eth ex from stator eth ex is a liquid staking token designed to maximize rewards all while securing a theory with stator you can run in a theory node with just for eth an 85% lower capital requirement versus the 32 eth required for solo stake with stators for eth nodes you can get a 35% average higher yield since you charge fees to those who use your node to stake their eth by running a node with stator the eth ex staking derivative token can get minted on your validators and can flow into the world of defa which stator is actively building integrations and partnerships into to increase the utility of eth ex stator allows for both permission and permissionless nodes to join the network maximizing its potential scalability for eth ex while preserving the values of decentralization and openness behind its liquid staking token go to stator labs.
com slash eth and sign up to get access to the stator staking protocol. Arbitram 1 is pioneering the world of secure ethereum scalability and is continuing to accelerate the web 3 landscape hundreds of projects have already deployed on Arbitram 1 producing flourishing defi and NFT ecosystems with a recent addition of Arbitram Nova gaming and social daps like reddit are also now calling both Arbitram 1 and Nova leverage the security and decentralization of ethereum and provide a builder experience that's intuitive familiar and fully evian compatible on Arbitram both builders and users will experience faster transaction speeds with significantly lower gas fees with Arbitram's recent migration to Arbitram Nitro it's also now 10 times faster than before visit arbitram.
io where you can join the community dive into the developer docs bridge your assets and start building your first app with Arbitram experience web 3 development the way it was meant to be secure fast cheap and friction free so Ryan I'm not super tapped into the world of politics and lobbying and fighting on capital hill but I feel like everything that you said is more or less like a known science to the outside of the crypto industry I think maybe inside the crypto industry we're like it doesn't matter so global movement will get there eventually don't worry about the the milieu of capital hill fights but we've already passed that part in the conversation where we've established that now is the time in Washington DC is the place but this is like a known science right we're not inventing anything new here this is what other industries do I think perhaps what you're suggesting is like oh we're doing a great job and more narrow efforts to to fight the fight for crypto but I think you're just saying hey let's zoom out let's get bigger and let's be more strategic with how we advocate for our industry and copy the the strategies that other industries have employed for the for decades is that is that a fair summary one thing about sandbankment freed is his political under his understanding of the political system and the political game was unparalleled within the crypto industry what he did last year was very savvy from a political standpoint we basically need to do something but here's the thing the silver lining as we know that but we need to be better as an industry and you need to run a very similar playbook but with a decentralized based of contributors and a set of honest actors that have been in the trenches four years building or the sole reason that we actually believe in this tech and his potential to be forced for good who could that be who could that be Ryan okay so sbf totally got it right oh we got we got three of them on the call so well okay well I I don't know that's that's ambitious for me I but like okay sbf was playing the right game and he was maybe one of the first people in crypto to actually start playing that game and by the way people who didn't understand this game like zoom out and they look at oh my god how fast how far he got so fast right it's like amazing what you can do if you play the game and you play it well and you're saying that we need better honest good actors rather than sending our worst to dc sbf a literal fraudster we need to send the right people to dc we need to have good leadership here also we need to keep it decentralized and accountable as well but that is the exact the game that he played we need to play a similar game that's what you're saying I think so I mean he had he had all of the wrongs of that campaign but we can't do it the same way that that he went about it obviously right I mean I think the crypto brand is pretty tarnished from a lot of folks that are not true believers of the tech within dc you know he gave money to so many people and he put so many people in a bad place politically or he made them look silly or you know he the the one rule I think we should learn as an industry is don't embarrass your friends in dc and he he just was a nuclear bomb that went off in dc based on the amount of time that he was spending there with members with staff everybody well he but we think about it as like he embarrassed us which is true but he also embarrassed a lot of folks in dc and I think led folks that we were making progress with to clam up and and so part of part of the job that we need to do as an ecosystem and again going back to the messaging is we need to advance some of the true narratives of crypto not the woke shibboleths or whatever he called them you know when when he thought he was off the record basically him just blowing smoke to to key members in both parties when he was meeting with them but we need to actually narrow in on like what are the true bipartisan messages that we just need to focus on and like show the impact of and just brow beat the dc establishment into understanding over the course of the next 18 months and I think the narrative development there is very often understated because we have a decentralized community so okay who is going to elect like one spoken representative for this entire like decentralized community you know why would we play the dc game when we can just opt out and build in all these different pockets let ripple fight their case let coin base fight their cases let whoever kind of you know going to you know fights their individual battle and we'll just engage in trench warfare from all these different corners of the industry the the reality is that we have some overarching messages as a community that whether you're a stablecoin issue or whether you're a bitcoin maximalist whether you're diehard ethereum fan like these kind of core um truths I think are things that we can rally around and that we can win a lot of swing voters in dc over right so the proliferation of stablecoins being number one the kind of individual economic empowerment um of you know previously disenfranchised or you know underpants or creative classes like those are pretty powerful narratives because you're talking about positively impacting the livelihoods of uh you know different different individuals in in different uh up and coming parts of the economy and you're talking about american competitive competitive as long term um and then the last is just a rule of law right so I think we lost some of the moral high ground when it comes to use cases and the case for crypto and like this is going to change the world last year just because that's what happens when you go from a bowl to a bare cycle but one thing that we really have right now is the constitution and the rule of law on our side and some of the overreature we've seen from the regulatory state is so egregious that we just need to be able to wrap those stories uh in a tight narrative and actually uh saturate dc with some of these stories and help people understand even what the issue is that we're fighting against because a lot of I think a lot of members and a lot of their staffs just don't understand um what's going on with debanking what's going on with um the SEC's you know kind of double speak when it comes to regulation and uh and the fact that it essentially amounts to a shadow band in the industry so um if we can focus on kind of the three pro crypto you know kind of positive messages and then the three combating kind of opposition narrative you know kind of counter messages that's I think all we can do to hold the line for the next 18 months and then give the folks that are at the trade associations that are actually actively lobbying in dc and that are going to be running campaigns give them the air cover to operate and you know kind of help move the incumbents and some of the newcomers to congress in the right direction this this marketing piece I think is going to be important not just from like a single entity but um hopefully some of the research that we put out is going to help folks like you is going to help folks when they're meeting with members is going to help folks when they're on mainstream media outlets uh triangulate on the things that they know have a 30 point net favorable uh rating when it comes to talking points right so maybe we don't want to say hey any one of the world should be able to use crypto um regardless of whether they're they're they're on the sanctions list like that's not a smart narrative right sure I love some of the libertarians in the industry not a smart narrative but if you want to talk about the dollars dominance um and the benefits of a uh US dollar denominated stablecoin versus the you know Chinese digital you want from a competitive uh competitive to standpoint or from a uscbdc from a surveillance standpoint you know that's a pretty good narrative to rally around and say yeah they're pretty common sense solutions here or this close you know tell your members that you would like to see stablecoin legislation tell your members you'd like to see market structure structure you know regulation so that we can feel safe and secure when we're using Coinbase or Kraken or Gemini or another US regulated entity if we get it right this could be very powerful this is the reason uh you know dc listened to sbf and not someone uh like Eric Voorhees even though we wish he would listen to an Eric Voorhees sometimes you have to kind of massage the message here and so I want to make sure that the people here the punchline because this is so so you and the digital freedom alliance the DFA this is a new organization that you're helping to form are raising between hundred million dollars or above to 125 million dollars I believe that's kind of the range that feels like a lot of money maybe but I don't know how compares to other organizations doing this you're raising that in order to put this structure in place and do things that the coin centers and the blockchain associations aren't doing they're they're kind of manning the wall they're the nights watch but there's all sorts of political activity that we need to have that we need to coordinate around if we actually want to win during this very narrow window of opportunity so what do you what do you call this thing Ryan is this like a is this like a pack is this like a super pack uh and by the way are we trying to influence lawmakers here are we doing kind of the pack game of like you know we're running commercials to voters and we're talking about like the virtues of crypto and and we have kind of talking points around that like so anyway I want to make sure you kind of nail the point of what you're actually doing because this is beyond talk this is not you just standing up here and getting on the bankless podcast and saying hey guys we need to do more stuff you're actually organizing it you got the you got the outlet so what are you going to do with a hundred million dollars i'm not going to do anything with a hundred million dollars so that the digital freedom of lights is going to raise probably about five to ten of that right and and are the ability to um actually execute against the roadmap that we have in the messaging side we can do a lot with five million or so uh and then it scales up from there and basically the the the variance is how much um messaging and how many you know kind of paid campaigns are we able to run um and how many different kind of areas are we able to move swing voters in DC and and kind of move sentiment and kind of mainstream media outlets um it's it's just it's a marketing machine right dollars and equals you know some outcome on the other side of that from a brand and a favorable standpoint the hundred to hundred twenty five million i think is what it costs to run like this multi-faceted campaign so dfa i think is on one side of the wall one of the missing ingredients uh maybe the missing ingredient from an education advocacy standpoint coin center and dfa are kind of like yin and yang i'd say coin center is very focused on the constitutional issues whereas we want to focus on the messaging issues that are actually going to change public sentiment and dc sentiment all the other trade associations are responsible for lobbying and thinking about what are legislate uh what are let us legislative solutions that are going to work that are going to get some bipartisan support and then potentially get enacted into law they're also the ones that are engaging directly with with regulators through rulemaking and helping them understand how crypto confidancy existing you know regulatory structures in the meantime before we have clear legislative guidance the other fifty percent of that so the other fifty plus you know 75 million that's where the pack and the super pack fund and come in and that's the electoral finance side of this equation um what i have said is i want to spend time on this only because i've already spent time on this the last two years basically ever since the infrastructure bill as you know i've been more outspoken i spent more time with these policy groups and so i know the executives and their policy teams uh pretty well what i'm trying to wake other executives and investors up to in the industry is the need to make this investment and to basically like two to three x the investment that we currently have which is the first comment that we made about thirty to forty million and where we need to be which is closer to a hundred hundred twenty five million a good chunk of that is going to come on the political giving side actually supporting financially the pro crypto members of congress that have been very good in the issues they've dug deep we want them to be holding pen on new legislation because they just understand it technically and we have faith that they're going to get the balance right engaging in primaries is going to be the work of some of the super packs and some of the other electoral politics uh focused organizations that we have and um the goal there is to basically look at if it's a swing district who's going to be the better candidate in the general election if it's a forty point democratic district who's going to be the best democrat that we can get through that primary if it's a forty point republican district same thing who's the best republican we can get through that primary on these issues and that's just a ground gain that i think is not something that can be developed in house that any of the crypto companies but we do have some good political operatives that are running those pack and super pack operations that can help us both recruit and then elect uh great like pro crypto voices as as generation change in congress takes hold just to give you an example last cycle we elected out of the open primaries that one of the industries primary super packs was was focused on um well we want basically seventeen for eighteen in terms of pro crypto candidates you know there's four hundred thirty some members of congress so to actually move the needle you're going to need to do that every two years for the next decade and then you ultimately win over time just by having a more educated um digital native base of members that is going to handle i think a good chunk of our long term challenges but in the meantime we have to make sure that we get some pretty important districts and some pretty important senate seats swinging in the right direction because if we have blockers at important committee chairs um or important you know kind of senior members of either the senator congress that are going to slow down any legislative proposals that come across their desk just because they are so far in the one category that they're you know they're not salvageable um for for our intents um then we need to you know figure out if there are candidates that are better suited for for us as an industry you know how do we how do we help support them um and by and large i think the strategy today has been support incumbents work with incumbents and their staffs educate incumbents and their staffs educate the regulators and and you know tell the right story and the areas that we fall in flat are in actually financially supporting them and then arming them with data and research that can that can kind of help them make the case uh as they're going out and they're and they're stumping for for this is one of the key key prongs of their campaigns um last thing i'll say on this point is um the reason that this hundred million dollar number is so important again it's not to put you know kind of money in our organization i think we're probably five to ten of that on the 50% education advocacy side along with all the other existing groups that we have but i think a problem that uh many executives and investors in the industry make is they don't want to play an electoral politics for whatever reason right they they think it's not a good use of time could use of money they don't want to feel like they're getting you know that it just it feels untoward uh to to good chunk of the community especially the the libertarian strain that got into crypto particularly to opt out of politics and i understand that but if we don't get over that then what you have is a situation where all of those groups whether it's digital freedom alliance it's coin center it's um it's the blockchain association it's cci they're going into a meeting and they're having a really good session with members and their staffs and those members and staff come out all raw raw and then they look at their watch and say well i have to go meet with the the bankers association because of fundraising launches yep and so you know you're basically throwing an alley you but then there's there's there's there's no follow through guys i mean this is what we've done in crypto i mean this is what they say in dc it's true if you're not at the table you're on the menu and crypto kind of sat back and we basically let somebody who is more ambitious represent our industry in dc and that person's name was sbf and look what he did and so if we don't fill that vacuum with something like it's not it unfortunately i wish this was the case it's not an option to just smell out of the game and not play you have to play the game you're forced to play this game so if we're in a position where we're forced to play the game let's do it well we can maintain our ethics we can maintain our values but we've got to play this game well so okay now also if you do it right you don't have to do it in the future yes yes and it's much more expensive to do the cleanup work as we're seeing it is post sbf one one thing just to make this like super tangible because i know a hundred million is a big number it sounds like it's kind of out of left field but there is some science behind it but if we want to just do like back in napkin um what is the return on that investment if you will right i think about this as an insurance policy right because if you're not at the table you're on the menu and regulatory risk is probably the greatest risk that we have as an industry right now in us right um it's going to be hard to envision another kind of boom cycle in the us where crypto is is thriving here under the current construct that we have in the current situation that we're in with the SEC um and his jurisdictional issues the FDIC and kind of banking regulators it's it's hard to see a catalyst there so i go back to the very first thing that i said which is this is important because i think a pro crypto us is a 2x in market cap right that's the quick and dirty right like i think everything thrives the infrastructure the use cases the consumer adoption and then yes the price of some of these assets but if you think that there's a 10% chance that that hundred million dollars will move the needle for a pro crypto us versus a more hostile us after 2024 that's the only thousand x there is in the market right it's the only thousand x there is in a market 10% expected value of a trillion dollars a hundred billion dollars a hundred billion is a thousand times more than a hundred million right it's you're saying it's good for our bags if we are interested in financial upside we would fight this fight if we are primarily interested in number go up this is a high value opportunity here here's the issue that i think we're confronting this year i think it's good for everybody this year and i think last year it was good for sound yeah that was what so many of us were kind of fighting behind the scenes in these smoke filled rooms or whatever other bullshit you know people love you to be people don't smoke and that service anyway yeah for for for trying to you know coordinating some of these conversations well we were trying to do is we were trying to slow down Sam who was running kind of unilaterally and and and trying to just go ahead advocate for his his own efforts and we were trying to make sure that there was a good group of folks that were actually engaged with the policy makers that were writing some of these bills and that were at the table and and felt like you know all of these diverse interests in the industry were well represented that ultimately you know maybe it was moving the right direction maybe not but it fell apart because FTX fell apart and so now we're kind of back to square one where can we get the honest brokers in the industry the people that have been here for years the people that didn't just pump and dump on their followers the folks that actually believe that triple entry accounting to be as boring as as that is right like but triple entry accounting is such a profound technical innovation in an era of declining institutional trust that this is worth protecting at all costs right and and and I think that has to be at least a quarter if not half of the focus for any serious executive or investor in the industry right now because the the cost of getting it wrong long term is so damaging and and just stunts our potential to such an extraordinary degree that we just can't afford to risk it so I think I've been enthused by my conversations with other founders with with with other investors but it's a tough market right it's tough to make this pitching into a declining market and it's tough to feel like we're trying to like squeeze blood from a stone but I think the stakes are high the time is now and if we can get through the other side of this bear market and we can have these hard conversations now and move the needle and be the like the very best that we are from a narrative and from an ethics perspective then I think we can get through the other side of this and and you'll see a much stronger vibrant ecosystem emerging the other side both in the U.
S. and then internationally as other markets strapped off of us. Really quick Ryan just to throw some quick questions at you what are the just like the near term next steps like what what's happening in the next week what month two months to get the DFA up and running the digital freedom alliance and then also throw a throw a question at the end for this how much harder is this now that SBF was playing this playbook a year or two ahead of us and then blew that strategy up and now we have to like do that same strategy but now there's like the the shadow of SBF in Capitol Hill like how much harder is this now as a result of that so I'll throw those two questions at you.
Well I mean I think step one is you know the same strategy but the complete opposite right so you know what we're not trying to do this you know behind the scenes you know I'm putting bullseye in my forehead and you know come and and talking to you guys and and being pre-vocal about what we're working on so it's hidden in plain sight but I think the reason that we should be a little bit more transparent is that's what the industry is based on and that's ultimately the only way that we're going to get to the other side of of this FTX drama remember that court case is coming up so we're going to have a whole other cycle where like that is going to be top of mind for folks and if we don't have a very strong counter narrative that includes just a massive slug of entrepreneurs that are you know ready to be like you know articulate really powerful surrogates for the industry that can tell some of these positive stories that can tell you know policymakers the way that they are approaching the industry is in good faith and in the right way and in keeping with some of our existing laws and norms then you know we're going to be able to I think get some of the results that we want but the from a DFA standpoint you know we've got some world class you know colleagues that I'm working with on us on this campaign the messaging strategy that go to market the research both polling, foyer requests, freedom of information requests you know opposition research and then the storytelling kind of masters that are going to help you know packages and digest that's going to be accessible for people that might not otherwise have time given all their competing priorities in DC to fully digest you know what's going on with layer 2s and you know what's what's the new hot NFT project like none of that really matters we have to abstract all that away and and kind of just be a focus on some of these some of these core that's great I mean no question we need to do this work so to to summarize all this Ryan your message today is a crypto needs to get going on this right now this is the the time is really now we're spending maybe 30 million a year collectively on the crypto policy machine and we need to three to four x that investment across the industry so we need to get to between 100 and 125 million you are starting this digital freedom alliance which is going to be a 501 c4 advocacy group and what that's going to do is it's going to occupy this niche of helping to fight the flood helping to tell a story that propagates across both policy makers and mainstream and maybe that costs something like five million dollars of that 100 to 125 million dollars but that will allow us to scale and amplify the rest of the investment that we put on this space and maybe that takes the form in the future of other packs us getting more active in campaigns but we really need sort of a narrative machine in order to propagate the right messages and honestly to coordinate on them if we don't do this by the way the next sbf comes in and makes like pumps pumps their own instead of pumping the values that we want expressed across crypto so that is what you're here to tell us and that is the work that you're going to do in this space particularly setting up the digital freedom alliance and then also making the call for us to triple our investment in this crypto policy space and being a leader in this space as well not the not the only leader but a group of leaders that can push this forward did i get that right i think you nailed it i'd say you know i uh didn't have scone with customer funds so i don't have as much personal capital to deploy at this as other folks in previous cycles so it has to be decentralized right and i think if we can pass the hat around what i would say is an action item from from this of the episode is you go to join dfda.
org if you want to learn more about what we're working on and then you want to find ways to get involved the first bit of fundraising that i'm doing is for that first five million we'll ultimately open it up for public contributions in the next couple of months but if you want to subscribe for updates we've got a sub stack they can subscribe to on the join dfda.org websites and if you're an executive in the in the industry and you or your company would like to contribute to this hundred million dollar campaign and you're just flying blind and you don't even know where to start what i've volunteered is that if you're ready to spend serious time and and money i will pick up the phone and try to help orient you towards which groups need this capital the most right so i think we need to continue funding cci blockchain association coin center i can make the case for like why the digital freedom alliance is a really important prong of that side of the equation and then i think we also need to make sure that those that have done really well in the last couple of cycles are funding the pack and super pack efforts so that we actually make long term and medium term change in congress that that is going to set us up for long term success and not just this perpetual firefighting we've been doing last year or so that's great Ryan we'll we'll end it there and we'll leave a link in the show notes it's been awesome to have you on thank you so much thank you for doing this too apparently we need it thank you guys i just want to say one last thing as we close guys we'll include a link in the show notes to join df a dot org and let me just say uh Ryan has been in the space for 10 years all right and there's a certain lindie effect that we talk about often about um protocols i think lindie effect also applies to individuals as well people who've been through multiple cycles without stealing anyone's funds without screwing people over like by being honest actors and i think we are um we we have swung a little bit too far on the pendulum of not trusting anybody right now in 2023 the crypto industry okay and that's understandable look what we went through in 2022 well just scam artists screwing the space over no wonder we have trust issues collectively but let me say let's not air too far on the other side and and and come to the conclusion that there are no leaders and we can't trust anyone in this space there have been people that have developed a reputation been through multiple cycles and are trying to do the right thing and i think ryan selkis is one of those people i'm really excited to uh to to to to support join df a and uh for the work that we're doing it's sorely needed if we don't fill the gap here somebody else will and i'd like to see ryan and some of the other leaders brine armstrong is one of them uh you know i know the folks at kraken lots of good folks that are still here pushing this work forward so don't get disinvolved in politics okay like we got to involve ourselves if if we're going to take this fight to dc and uh you propagate the values that that we talk so much about that was my my sermon rather than disclaimers he got that but let me end with disclaimers of course none of this has been financial advice it's not really political advice we're just figuring this stuff out as we go guys but eth is risky so as defi you could definitely lose what you put in we are headed west though this is the frontier it's not for everyone but we're glad you're with us on the bankless journey thanks a lot