Li Jin is a co-founder and general partner at Variant, a crypto fund investing in Web3 and what Li calls the Ownership Economy. Li is full of massive ideas about the past, present, and future of digital economies.
The core thesis? Next-generation networks grow faster and bigger. The phase we're seeing emerge now with Web3 and crypto is deeply fascinating, with potential to shift power and ownership into the hands of users and creators.
In this new paradigm, everyone is a creator, and everyone is an owner. In addition to her work at Variant, Li is also a painter and an accomplished writer on Substack. After her appearance on the Creator Economy Panel, we knew she had to come back on Bankless to dive deep—this time, into the Ownership Economy.
------ ✨ DEBRIEF ✨ | Ryan & David's Unfiltered Thoughts on the Episode https://shows.banklesshq.com/p/debrief-the-ownership-economy-li
------ 📣 ALTO IRA | THE CRYPTO RETIREMENT ACCOUNT https://bankless.cc/AltoIRA
------ 🚀 SUBSCRIBE TO NEWSLETTER: https://newsletter.banklesshq.com/ 🎙️ SUBSCRIBE TO PODCAST: http://podcast.banklesshq.com/
------ BANKLESS SPONSOR TOOLS:
👀 POLYGON | LAYER 2 DEFI https://bankless.cc/Polygon
❎ ACROSS | BRIDGE TO LAYER 2 https://bankless.cc/Across
🦊 METAMASK | THE CRYPTO WALLET https://bankless.cc/metamask
💳 LEDGER | THE CRYPTO LIFE CARD https://bankless.cc/Ledger
🧙♂️ ALCHEMIX | SELF REPAYING LOANS https://bankless.cc/Alchemix
🦄 UNISWAP | DECENTRALIZED FUNDING https://bankless.cc/UniGrants
------ Topics Covered:
0:00 Intro 6:30 Creator vs Ownership Economy 12:58 Phases of Economies 17:34 The Web3 Renaissance 21:53 Issues with the Early Internet 27:11 Original Sin 35:11 From Attention to Ownership 38:48 Digital Scarcity 47:41 Patronage Plus vs Regulation 52:59 100 True Fans 1:01:17 Programmable Business Models 1:09:17 DAOs & Community Ownership 1:14:48 Comparing Renaissances 1:21:36 Wealth Inequality 1:29:58 What YOU Can Do 1:35:23 What ELSE You Can Do 1:38:54 2022 Predictions 1:42:35 Closing & Disclaimers
------ Resources:
Li on Twitter: https://twitter.com/ljin18?s=20
Li's Newsletter: https://li.substack.com/
The Web3 Renaissance: https://li.substack.com/p/the-web3-renaissance-a-golden-age
100 True Fans: https://li-jin.co/2020/02/19/100-true-fans/
The Creator Economy: https://shows.banklesshq.com/p/-panel-the-creator-economy-jesse
Tweets Mentioned: https://twitter.com/ljin18/status/1434964132042846208 https://twitter.com/ljin18/status/1422928459425271811 https://twitter.com/ljin18/status/1404650885788098562
----- Not financial or tax advice. This channel is strictly educational and is not investment advice or a solicitation to buy or sell any assets or to make any financial decisions. This video is not tax advice. Talk to your accountant. Do your own research.
Disclosure. From time-to-time I may add links in this newsletter to products I use. I may receive commission if you make a purchase through one of these links. Additionally, the Bankless writers hold crypto assets. See our investment disclosures here: https://newsletter.banklesshq.com/p/bankless-disclosures
No summary for this episode yet.
That can be the basis of entirely new types of jobs and income that hadn't existed before online. Welcome to Bankless, where we explore the frontier of internet money and internet finance. This is how to get started, how to get better, and how to front-run the opportunity. This is Ryan Sean Adams. I'm here with David Hoffman, and we're here to help you become more Bankless. Guys, we have a fantastic episode talking about the ownership economy, the creator economy, both of those things. A few things to take a look out for. The first is the creator economy versus the ownership economy. What is the difference between these two terms?
We go through it with Legion. Second, the original sin of the internet. What was that sin? What did it cost us? Third, four things that will actually fix the original sin and usher us into the ownership economy. Number four, the Web 3 Renaissance. What that means? Number five, how crypto can actually fix wealth inequality. Legion gives her opinion on how that could be the case, how we might come up with a fix for some of the wealth inequality issues. Finally, number six, what this means for you, how to set yourself up in the ownership economy, how to be your own boss, how to take advantage of the Web 3 Renaissance that is coming.
All of this unpacked on the show today. David, what were your thoughts on this episode? Gosh, Legion is such a clear, articulate thinker, and she really does a very fantastic job of taking us from the very beginning of this story at the dawn of the internet while the founding people of the internet were really thinking about what happens next now that we have this internet thing, taking us all the way to where we are today, and then also extrapolating into the future about what it means to create content on the internet. I think one of my favorite things about Lee and her interest in the creator economy and the owner economy is that she's very pragmatic.
She wants to see creators and creativity blossom, and that is her goal. Her goal, I don't think, is really to get crypto to take over the world. She sees crypto as a means to an end for what she wants to see in the world, which is inspiring creativity, and everyone being able to be their own boss by unlocking and unleashing their internal creativity kernel that we all have inside of us. She's not like you or me, and we are focused on crypto, and we want crypto to take over the world. She wants creativity to take over the world, and she sees crypto as a viable way to get that done. I think she even hints in this show that she used to be very, very pragmatic about intersecting.
Here, we can use Web2 for this, and we can use Web3 for this, but she said she's recently capitulated and says that it's only Web3 here on out, and it's actually through Web3 that we can fully unleash crypto or, excuse me, fully unleash creativity to its maximum degree in a way that we've never seen before out of humanity. Absolutely. I think that's a great insight. I also think this is almost the sister episode to our episode with Chris Dixon, where we went through five mental models of Web3. I think this is a mental model. The idea of the creator economy, their ownership economy, is a mental model that all bankless listeners should have locked in their brains for 2022, because once you understand this, you start to see different areas you can invest in your time, your money, your skills, your jobs, and the world opens up.
Web3 and crypto really is going to usher a new type of economy. It's going to create a new business model for the internet, and we tap into all of that here. So stay tuned for this episode. As always, like, subscribe, review. If you're watching this on YouTube, make sure you subscribe. Give us a podcast review. If you're listening to this on your podcast player, we're going to get to the episode with Legion. But before we do, we want to thank the sponsors that made this episode possible. Polygon is a theorem's largest and most vibrant scaling solution to date. With millions of monthly users and all of the biggest DeFi apps, the polygon ecosystem has turned into a blossoming metropolis of DeFi activity.
Transactions on polygon are quick and cheap, allowing users the freedom to achieve their DeFi goals, all while being economically anchored to Ethereum. But polygon isn't just the proof of stake side chain. The polygon team is building a suite of scaling solutions, including polygon hermys, miden, nightfall, and zero, all with different design choices in order to be optimized for all possible crypto use cases. If you're a developer who wants to build on the polygon ecosystem, go to the link in the show notes to check out their fantastic documentation. And if you're a user who just wants to experience fast and cheap DeFi, you can bridge over your ETH or other tokens and start playing around with any of the thousands of applications that are available on polygon.
The layer 2 era is upon us. Ethereum's layer 2 ecosystem is growing every day and we need L2 bridges to be fast and efficient in order to live a layer 2 life. A cross is the fastest and cheapest and most secure cross chain bridge. With a cross, you don't have to worry about the long wait times or high fees to get your assets back to the layer 1. Assets are bridge and available for use almost instantaneously. A cross as bridges are powered by UMA's optimistic oracle to securely transfer tokens from layer 2 back to Ethereum. A cross is critical ecosystem infrastructure and ownership is being handed over to the community.
You can be a part of this story of a cross by joining the discord and becoming a co-founder and helping to design the fair, fair launch of a cross. If you want to bridge your assets quickly and securely, go to across.to to bridge your assets between ETH, Optimism, Arbitrum, or Boba Networks. Bankless is proud to be sponsored by Uniswap. Uniswap is a new paradigm in asset exchange infrastructure. Instead of a cumbersome order book system where trades are matched with other humans, Uniswap is an autonomous piece of software on Ethereum that lets you trade any token at the current market price. No human counterparties or centralized intermediaries, just autonomous code on Ethereum.
Input the token you want to sell and receive the token you want to buy. The Uniswap Grants program is accepting applications for grants. Do you have something of value that you think you want to contribute to the Uniswap ecosystem? No matter how big or small your idea is, you can apply for a unique grant at Uniswapgrants.org and help steer Uniswap in the direction that you think it should go. Thank you Uniswap for sponsoring Bankless. At Variant Fund previously worked at A16Z Herthesis, I think the thesis of Variant Fund writ large is that next-generation networks will grow faster and bigger because they are owned and operated by their users.
This is called the Uniswap Economy. Web 3, as you can imagine, crypto, as you can imagine, has a huge role to play here. She's also a writer on substack, fantastic writer. By the way, in a hobbyist painter, Legion, welcome back to Bankless. It's great to have you on again. Thank you so much for having me, guys. It's a delight to be here. I think last time you were on a panel and we enjoyed that panel so much. We're like, we've got to bring Lee back to talk about the ownership economy in more depth, the creator economy. Actually, I want to ask you that question. Do you like the term creator economy or ownership economy better when you define this thing?
I think those two things are actually slightly distinct. They're overlapping. It's like a Venn diagram. There's creator economy, non-ownership economy version. There's creator economy, ownership economy, overlap, and then there's other ownership economy stuff that is outside of the creator economy. Well, I like that. Could you get into the detail there? So creator economy, I'm imagining is, well, yeah, why don't you describe the Venn diagram source? Yeah, sure. So the creator economy is really this economy that exists online marked by this proliferation of individual content creators who are uploading user generated content and monetizing that in a host of different ways.
Essentially, ever since, for as long as the internet has existed, there have been creators on the internet ranging from people starting blogs and posting on forums to today, you know, posting on YouTube making podcasts like we are right now. And the way that people have monetized their independent creations have varied over the years. It really used to be banner ads and then programmatic advertising. And in the last couple of years, I think the resurgence or the increased attention the creator economy has gotten has really been around the potential for direct monetization of one's audience spanning from writing a subscription newsletter to starting a Patreon to starting, you know, any sort of like direct fan monetization type of business.
And so the creator economy has been around for I would say like over a decade. And it's gone through multiple phases in its history, which we talked about on the panel with Cooper and Jesse. And I think we're right now in the third phase of the creator economy, which is that they regard themselves as independent businesses in and of themselves in their own right. They used to be people who helped other businesses to grow by selling sponsorship placements or doing advertising on behalf of other brands. But today, I think the mental shift that a lot of creators have made is that they think of themselves as businesses and brands as individuals as personas.
And where that starts to overlap with the idea of the ownership economy, which is the idea that all next generation internet products and services are going to be owned by their users. And go through the progressive decentralization playbook is that I think there's really this convergence where there has been the broad recognition that creators have been responsible for creating a lot of the value on the web to internet that have not really been the beneficiaries of that value creation. And said it's gone to the owners of the platforms that they're working on. So a creator on YouTube or create on Facebook, etc.
They are earning income on the side for sure. And they can find external ways to monetize their audience. But they haven't been owners of the underlying platforms that they're posting content on and actually contributing value to. And that comes in the form of economic ownership as well as any sort of governance rights. And so we're really seeing this overlap in this flourishing of the creator economy and ownership economy today. Where and people are having the conversation of well, creators should actually be owning more of the value that they create. They should be the beneficiaries of the value creation that they're doing and they should become just as other users in the community owners of these platforms too.
So the creator economy then obviously predates crypto but was maybe uniquely enabled by the internet. We'll get into that. But is the ownership economy is that sort of a product of crypto? And how does this term web 3 do you think relate is our web 3 in the ownership economy part of the same? You know, would you buck it? The ownership economy under web 3? Do you think it's its own thing following its own path and trajectory that's just related somehow? Yeah, we have this internal debate all the time among the variant team as to what all of these different terms mean crypto web 3 ownership economy.
How do we diff them and where are the boundaries? I think frankly, like it's still such a nascent area of technology that no one can really say conclusively what is one thing versus another and the terms have sort of taken on lives of their own. My personal feeling and the way that I personally define them is I think the ownership economy is actually a bigger like umbrella phenomenon in which users and participants of platforms are becoming owners. And there was a web 2 version of the ownership economy in which companies were trying to utilize traditional equity and legal structures in order to give ownership to their users.
That was like the weak form of the ownership economy and the strong form of the ownership economy is enabled by crypto and tokens which represent ownership. And then as for web 3, I think most people are using it synonymously with crypto, but I think the ownership economy is bigger than all of that. Lee in order to fully explain the creator economy and the ownership economy, we're going to take a second to go all the way back to the dawn of the internet. But before we do that, can you just explain or illustrate the arc that I think exists with the trend of the creator economy? You already illustrated a little bit where creators used to create for others and now they are creating for themselves.
And then you also think there's another phase coming. Can you just summarize the trend of the creator economy, kind of where it started and where it's going and what the general arc what it arcs into over time? Absolutely. So I described the creator economy in terms of different phases and the evolution of the phases that we've gone through over the past decade or so. So creator economy 1.0, which was the very the dawn of the creator economy, I think of as existing as long as the internet has existed. So initially people were uploading content online, they were doing so on their own independent websites or blogs that they set up.
And then as the social network started to come out, people also utilized those for content creation. So in those days, I would consider everyone to have been a content creator as long as they were posting content, but it was very nascent in terms of the economy piece of the content creation. So there were creators that left so an economy actually happening. Creator economy 2.0 I think was really the burgeoning economy around people who built up fame and influence on all of those channels. So gradually, you had people who accumulated audiences by posting content on the internet and they were kind of like digitally native celebrities.
And this influential class, who we typically refer to now as the creator class, then began to receive monetization, usually in the form of advertising or brand sponsorships. So they monetized the eyeballs and the reach that they got from their total audience. And that was a game that really rewarded reach and scale. And now we've shifted, I think just in the last couple of years or so, to the phase that we're in now, which is creator economy 3.0, which is this phase in which creators are no longer just conduits for selling other people's products and plugging other people's businesses and brands.
But instead are regarding themselves as the brand as the business and they are trying to monetize their own persona in different ways. And they're doing so increasingly by using lots of different tools and platforms that have flourished in the last couple of years, all really based on direct monetization of their super fans. So that's that's the phase where I now creator economy 3.0, which is creators as their own independent businesses. I think NFTs actually, I would bucket under that third phase of it's another tool in the toolkit that creators are using today for direct monetization of fans where I see this all going in the future is eventually the next phase of the creator economy will be the dissolution of boundaries between who is a creator versus who is an audience member.
And so it becomes much less clearly delineated the creator versus the fan. And instead it moves towards this world in which creators co-create with their audience and they're all part of a community that is helping to drive value back to the collective output that they put out. And in that world, I think everyone is compensated with a reward proportional to how much value they drove to the community. And I call that evolution from the creator economy to the community economy. And that is really the supercharged version of the creator economy and where we go. That's really cool. From from the individual creators to entire communities and creators co-creating with their fans and fans creating with the creators as well.
It's super interesting. And I think that that definitely dovetails into the ownership economy as well because that provides maybe the underlying alignment or incentive mechanism. But like I don't want to we jump ahead of ourselves yet because this has almost been like a tease so far of everything we're going to unpack in this episode. I think I want to go back to a post that you wrote recently. Fantastic post called the Web 3 Renaissance Golden Age for content. And let's go back as David was saying to like the founding of the internet. And there was this essay I believe in 1996. I guess this was a little bit after you know the the internet came on board.
But this famous essay from Bill Gates entitled people have probably heard this phrase content is king right. You've heard that mean propagated around. And Bill Gates said at that time in that essay one of the exciting things about the internet is that anyone with a PC in a modem can publish whatever content they create from the for the internet to thrive content providers must be paid for their work the long term prospects are good. But I expect a lot of disappointment in the short term you go in your post on to unpack that. But can you really put us back in the shoes of Bill Gates when he wrote that in 1996.
What did he see in the internet at that point in time. And why did he expect this disappointment in the short term are we still kind of living in that disappointment. Talk us through that. Sure. So firstly I would say when this article was published it was very very early days of the internet. This was 1996. I think globally there were like 30 million users total on the internet. Today it's like three and a half billion. So at the time it was less than one percent of the world population. So this was very very early days. Also I would just say that at the time I was five or six years old. And so I was not an active internet user.
I was probably playing with Barbies or something. And so a lot of what I know about that era is not from my first hand experience of using the internet, but rather from reading and talking to friends who are older than me. More mature than me. But regardless. So I think putting ourselves into the shoes of Bill Gates in that era, the internet was really nascent. It was nascent in terms of user adoption, not to mention the revenue element of what existed in terms of businesses on the internet. At that point in time people really regarded the internet as this kind of like toy or interesting novelty, but didn't really see a viable place for businesses to get built.
In his article he outlines that right now the internet is predominantly used by businesses to drive purchases offline. So you kind of give a teaser a look at like your offerings and wares. And then hopefully some of those users go offline and purchase your magazine or your book or your content thing. It's kind of the internet is a static catalog idea. It's not really dynamic. You don't really interact with it so much. Yeah, exactly. It wasn't it wasn't dynamic at the time. And at the time, yeah, there were very few options for actually collecting payments or monetizing users directly. Advertising was also really early.
He states in the article that advertising might be promising in the future, but today the total amount of advertising revenue that's being collected on the internet is nearly zero. And so this is this is really the basis for why he predicted a lot of short term pain in terms of content creators online was because it there was just very little there. There was very little users. There was very little monetization happening. And so he he had this optimistic view of well, the internet is really powerful hypothetically because it's permissionless and anyone can go online and post content and the barriers to entry are much lower.
And I think that has proven out to be true. Like we have had this flourishing of content creation on the internet. Everyone can become a creator. But the second part of his prediction was was that there would be there was it was challenging to actually make money from being a content creator on the internet. And I think that was true up until we saw the web two platforms and the aggregators who obviously were very profitable and did make money from the content creation that they facilitated. But that revenue ultimately a large portion of it did not actually end up in the hands of the individual content creators.
So Bill Gates the disappointment that he predicted he wasn't predicting the frustration that we often talk about today with web two platforms. His predicted disappointment was coming just from the fact that there was no internet. There was no money flowing through the internet in the early days of the internet. There was just as as Ryan and you said, so you know static pages just to disseminate information. There was no passing of credit card information or not not even to mention cryptocurrency. So like being a content producer in the early days just had it was only intrinsic. There was no ex any extrinsic value flows.
This is all correct. Yeah, that is my understanding from what I read is like at the time there was basically like two types of businesses that actually worked on the internet. One was e-commerce. Amazon got certain 1994 and the way that they accepted payments usually was someone mailing them a check and then getting mail the product. So e-commerce was happening. So physical products. And then there was porn. And then beyond that there was basically nothing else. People were very reticent in those days to enter their credit card information onto a web page. And it was also very difficult on the supply side for publishers or web page creators to even accept credit card payments.
And so direct payment was really not a thing advertisers had not yet moved online. And so the whole landscape of revenues online was just very very early. So from the perspective of this early days of the internet, the web two platforms, Facebook, YouTube, etc. was probably actually viewed as probably a very good thing that if they could have seen that on the horizon because these things these platforms made it very easy for content creators or easier for content creators to actually monetize themselves in the first place. Would you agree with that statement? I would agree with that statement.
I think that in the early days of these web two aggregators or platforms, they were viewed in a much more positive light, both from the consumer perspective as well as from the supply side perspective of the content creator. So on the consumer perspective, I think their early days of the internet were marked by this belief that like the internet is this really overwhelming place. And it's a wash in this like sea of all sorts of different types of content. And like as a user, I can't make sense of it. There's like headlines from the New York Times at that period of time where people are calling the internet this overwhelming sea of websites that like can't possibly be navigated.
Search also by the way was really early in these days. And so I think on the consumer side, like the aggregators played a really important role in helping consumers to make sense of all of that information, putting into one place, having an algorithm that ranked it and surfaced up what was most interesting and help users to basically sift through everything that was out there. And then on the content creator side, I think in the early days, the challenge was like, okay, I've published my blog online now what? Like how do I actually get connected to audiences and users? There's not really, there's no Google yet.
Search engines don't really exist. The internet had all of these like closed ecosystems like AOL and MSN. How do you actually get connected to end consumer? That was really difficult too. Letterland, you know, the difficulty in those days of like setting up your own website and getting your own server. So I think the dawn of the web two platforms was actually a really positive thing. It was regarded as really enabling the vision that Bill Gates set out, which was facilitating this flourishing of content creation and making it possible for people to reach the people who would connect with their content.
I'm really blown away by this. You said, you know, 1996 Bill Gates concerned in the content of his king article is that there's not enough, there's not a business model for content creators. Like he saw the potential, but he's like, there's no way for them to make money. There's no way for individuals to find them as probably the more, one of the more elder millennials on this podcast, I do remember when Facebook actually came to my university. I was like, it was the coolest freaking thing ever. Like Facebook is here. Okay. Now we have a way to like socially connect with our friends and peers.
This was like a revolution of revolution in the internet, right? It's like all of the the Microsoft's in the world. They were kind of the the old guard of computing, but like the Facebook's and Google, this was the revolution. This was giving creators an aggregation point, a connection point to their audience creating a business model for them. And it's so funny how quickly that happened, right? So you chart like 10 years from 1996 to 2006 and then you have the beginnings of Facebook and you have Google and you have an underlying business model of the web. But something from that point on, a little bit after maybe like turn towards a dark path, right?
And now the Googles in the Facebook's of the world aren't necessarily perceived as our friends. I'm wondering if you could talk about this because this isn't your article as well Lee, the original sin of the internet. I think this is a term from Mark Andreessen if I'm not mistaken. Can you tell us about the original sin of the internet and why that led to the outcomes that we have today and maybe the business model that the internet operates on today? Yeah, sure. So the term the phrase the original sin of the internet, it's from the spireside chat that took place a couple of years ago between Mark Andreessen and Katie Hahn who are two of the general partners at A16Z.
I think they were talking at one of their crypto regulatory summits about crypto and the future of the internet. And Mark was talking about his experience building net scape and the early days of the internet. And he calls the fact that browsers did not incorporate payments natively into the browser. He calls this the original sin of the internet. And he said that this they tried to do this but conversations with banks and credit card companies didn't go anywhere. And so they sort of gave up on embedding payments directly into the browser. And this is the original sin. He says because it's created all of these downstream problems that we have today that stem from the fact that advertising then became the prevalent business model online because it didn't require payments.
And because of advertising you have issues around privacy and data collection and the misalignment of incentives between all of these content platforms and what users actually want to see. And so the way that he frames it is it stems really from the fact that the internet didn't have this native ability to transfer value. And I think it was a really interesting conversation. And he goes into a few implications for you know what could have happened otherwise. If payments had been built into the browser he talks about how there might have been this parallel transaction system outside of the hands of a few centralized gatekeepers.
He talks about how it would have been you could have had aligned incentives between the platforms and their users. And then he also talks about how maybe the internet economy would actually be much bigger if there had been this direct payments model instead of just advertising. And I think when I when I probe into all of these points through the lens of the creator economy I do think that things would have turned out really differently had there been payments from day one. Because essentially like the trajectory that we took with the creator economy where in as you recall like in phase two of the creator economy everyone was basically acting as a conduit to sell other types of products and to shell other brands and help other companies advertise their their wares.
Like I think that really skewed a lot of the incentives of content creators themselves. They had to grow their audience to be as big as possible so that they could actually monetize a larger extent. They had to make their content really aspirational and make people feel like they were lacking something in order to drum up the desire to purchase. And yeah they had to go for reach and skill. And in order to get that you kind of have to create kind of like vanilla surface level mass appeal content versus niche in depth like passion driven content. And I think you see that across the internet where it's impacted the incentives of these content creators and as we know incentives drive everything.
And so you have social networks that are full of content that is really mass surface level shallow aspirational results in people feeling bad about their lives and what they have. And a lack of real expert driven or passion driven type of content creation. I find this part of the conversation fascinating because it's an interesting thought experiment to go back towards the dawn of the internet and talk about if we had only included payments natively in the browser. What could have been what what utopia did we accidentally miss by not integrating that in the early days of the internet. But I'm wondering if we might actually accidentally be being naive about other problems we might have also missed because if we had incorporated native payments into the browser I'm not technical enough to understand how this might have worked.
But my worry that I have is that if we had just done that well then we might have actually set up intermediaries payment intermediaries that we actually couldn't really predict today because it didn't happen. And so my question to you is is the native payment of the internet is that have could that have even been possible without crypto or is crypto really the secret sauce that unlocks the truly native internet payment means that actually does allow the creator economy to fully unpack. And so do you think that we actually did as a society accidentally miss a grand utopia or do you think really it needed to be crypto at the end of the day regardless?
Yeah it's really hard to explore the counterfactuals since they never actually happen but there were I mean there were definitely a number of attempts to facilitate transactions over the internet. There was a protocol that a bunch of different companies and browser companies were also working on called set protocol secure electronic transaction which was this protocol for securing credit or debit card payments over the internet and they needed to partner with a whole bunch of stakeholders merchants issuing banks credit card companies all of the browsers etc and so they never really got any traction but regardless of that like I think hypothetically I'm not entirely sure if we could have bypassed the web to internet if we had just only built in payments into the browser.
I think that is perhaps a little bit unrealistic and the reason why I say that is if we look at the state of the internet today it is much easier to accept payments on the internet like any sort of publisher or content creator or person who sets up any website can much more easily accept payments now credit card penetration is also really high in the US so let's just say like it is actually very easy now to facilitate transactions online and yet we still have all the problems of the internet that we're facing now we still have all these like walled garden platforms that control a bunch of user data that we can't pour out of we still have content creators who are going for scale and reach and so I think like the internet evolved in the way that it did for a number of different reasons not just the business model I think like it needed to be aggregated because it was a huge wild west of all of this type of content as mentioned like end creators were craving aggregation so I think the aggregators needed to emerge whether like the aggregators whether a different monetization model for the aggregators would have changed the type of content that they surface or changed the way that they built their algorithms I think that is a possibility but I still think we would have had the centralized businesses that emerged during the last decade because frankly that was what consumer behavior gravitated to and so could we have just leap frog from internet 1.
0 to web 3 I think that's a little bit naive yeah it's it's definitely hard hard to know and to go back you kind of factually is almost impossible they were in the early days there were a ton of benefits to you I guess this this economy that we created including onboarding so many people at very low cost and distributing it to a wide audience we often talk about kind of the aggregators as sort of the evil ones and I think that that story has been told many times on bankless but I'm super curious about what you just were talking about with the creators that have arisen in this in this type of internet era you know that quote show me the incentive and I'll show you the outcome right and it strikes me that creators today it's very much is mass produced right it's like they're all competing for these little bits of attention that people find on the internet and so we get mass produced somewhat shallow creators all competing for attention this kind of a perverse incentive system in that it's not necessarily the the best or the smartest content that gets rewarded it's kind of the lowest common denominator type content my favorite example is like you ever see in people people who like crypto shows will see you ever see your favorite crypto youtuber and like the goofy faces they make in thumbnails it's always like this like like like like this like I'm I'm screen capping that well we will now for this one so it's like it's that's perfect example and why do they do it it's because the system the algorithm in place is encended towards you know attention right and so they have to make this goofy surprised face in order to get clicks the other outcome of this too is like creators don't really own anything is the aggregators that own everything and so like a bankless youtube channel like we don't own it youtube could to platform us at any time like we don't own our our Twitter presence we can't export that file there's all sorts of weird things outcomes that have come as a result of this and that's why I want to get to like the second piece of what you wrote because I think what you are talking about is a transition that is happening in the creator economy and to the fabric of the internet from this business model that is solely based on attention this attention economy that we have right now to something that we were talking about earlier which is the ownership economy and the ownership is not just for creators that's a piece of it but it also strikes me for community members and you outlined four different ways we get from the attention economy to the ownership economy I'm wondering if we could go through these four right now Lee so sound good yeah that sounds good to me I'm gonna so throw these out there and kind of list them and then we'll strike them off one by one so the first way we get from the attention economy to the ownership economy you talk about the introduction of digital scarcity all right digital scarcity it's like NFTs as an example of that that's number one the second is patronage so that's supporting creators actually becoming investment and not just this act of altruism the patronage plus is what patronage plus okay yeah and we'll get into what that means the third is new economic models these are programmatic programmable economic models and the fourth is this idea of dows and community ownership so one two three and four we'll go through them all let's let's start with that first one okay and this is where maybe crypto enters the story a bit more the introduction of digital scarcity how does that take us from the attention economy to the ownership economy Lee right so up till when the blockchain was introduced and crypto there was no scarcity in terms of digital content like everything could be reproduced there was no concept of the original or the canonical version of a piece of digital content and that really undermines the ability for creators to be able to sell things sell digital goods and content if there is no scarcity if everything can be reproduced this is why we got a ton of pirating in the early internet days when you know people just trying to transpose the offline monetization model to online and sell like CDs on the internet or movies on the internet like that the marginal cost of reproducing that is zero and people could just therefore pirate it copy and paste it and download it to their own computers and so the the fact that the blockchain enables there to be scarcity dynamics introduced to the internet is really powerful for creators because all of a sudden that means you shift from selling this fake version of scarcity there's a lot of like faux scarcity products I I bugged them as faux scarcity because they're trying to like create scarcity but like the forces of the internet are just trying to undermine that so like a faux scarcity model would be pay world content or creating or they would proxy for scarcity with their time they would sell their time i.
e. through consulting offering one on one consulting or doing personalized cameo videos or something like that because because time is the only scarce thing that you have to sell on the internet and so we move from that world where they are very limited in terms of how they can monetize to being able to sell scarce digital goods or NFTs and tokens social tokens and so when you have scarcity that introduces supplier power in this case the suppliers are the creators and so they're able to monetize through this new economy of scarce goods in a way that was never possible before and this you know ties into a piece that I wrote a couple of years ago around the 100 true fans thesis and how you could make a living off of far fewer fans than you needed to before if you could manage to monetize them to a greater extent there's a few things to unpack there i want to come back to the 100 true fans these listen your your idea there but before we do so you use this term faux scarcity okay and this is what some critics think NFTs really are is like right click savable faux scarce things but you're saying that NFTs and actually like the digital properties of NFTs are actually the thing that's real scarcity on the internet how can you make that claim like how do you defend against people who are like that's also faux scarcity I mean anybody can mint an NFT and I can right click save what what's what's your feedback there well I think this is it gets quite philosophical in terms of what's real and what's not I think real is in this case we're talking about things around which their social consensus and so for NFTs there is a digital record of ownership on chain that everyone can agree is the canonical version of that piece of content whereas faux scarcity is I think a world in which there is no social consensus around which version is the original or edition number one two three etc and instead people are trying to proxy for scarcity by imposing yeah paywalls that you hit upon and have to unlock with a credit card or saying that there's only going to be a hundred versions of the sold for an ebook or whatever but you know in reality they could generate many more and there wouldn't be a way to tell whether yours was one of the original I think this same energy comes out of Bitcoiners who are very proud about how easy it is to audit the Bitcoin supply that's one of the features of the Bitcoin blockchain is it's super easy to run your own node and it's super easy to audit who owns what Bitcoin's and that same energy can apply be applied to NFTs the nature of an NFT when it's minted on Ethereum or any other smart contract blockchain comes with a very very specific address that cannot be duplicated or replicated or faked and and so then Lee it's going to what you're saying where there is some sort of social agreement as to what is the real NFT but as soon as that social agreement happens it's extremely easy to verify which is the real NFT because if I I have a crypto punk on my wall and I can absolutely verify with complete ease that I own the real crypto punk to that even though somebody could take that same JPEG minted brand new NFT and have a same NFT have a new JPEG but I have the real one because it's as simple as copying and pacing a string of of letters into you know something like ether scan and verifying it and so that's something that could not have been brought about before crypto just the ease of verifying the true ownership and so sure while there is plenty of foe scarcity with NFTs we can spin up new infinite new numbers of NFTs that doesn't dilute just like how we can fork Bitcoin 10,000 times that doesn't actually dilute the value of actual Bitcoin so I wanted to add that color in there would you add anything?
Yeah I agree with that completely and and the reason why your like canonical crypto punk or whatever has value is because people acknowledge that it is the real version they can inspect you know ether scan and see that this was minted by the original creator or whatever and there's consensus around that and that just had never before existed prior to crypto there was no consensus over which version was real like a few downloaded from iTunes was this the real one or did you pirate it off of you know some torrenting service or whatever another way that I um I'm starting to describe this as um using the analogy from economics is crypto introduces a digital goods economy when there had historically only existed a digital services economy so in the real world we have both goods and services that go into the entire GDP um over time over the decades America has shifted to more of a services economy wherein more people are employed in services versus goods manufacturing but goods still represent a huge portion of GDP something like 40% and the distinction that economists place between what is a good versus what is a service is that a good is something that is tangible that you can return um you can exchange you can resell to other people um you have property rights um with goods versus that's not the case with services and so moving that to the internet um version so historically uh I think a lot of a lot of internet based businesses and creators have had to monetize things as services when they would actually be more naturally monetized as goods but because there were no property rights they had to actually create a service around it so an example of this would be software as a service instead of selling software as a license it moved to the SAS model because that was actually the like the more feasible monetization model same with all types of content like we've all shifted towards streaming content versus buying content and downloading it because there are no digital property rights prior to crypto um and so historically it's been really challenging for there to be a digital goods economy it's primarily things as a service and like content as a service movies as a service music as a service streaming um and what's exciting is now there can be a digital goods economy because if there are now digital property rights and so the implication of that if we go back to the real world is that there can be that can be the basis of entirely new types of jobs and income that hadn't existed before online and I think the topic of digital scarcity internet native digital scarcity just leads right into what we were hinting at earlier with patronage plus because I think you need digital scarcity in order to have that plus side of patronage plus can you elaborate on patronage plus and how digital scarcity is involved absolutely so everyone's familiar with the idea of patronage is this for as long as there have been artists like it's really just the concept of you want to support someone you feel affinity for this person um you want to contribute and financially support them um and this has been a model online for a while in the creator economy there's tipping you can um go to any sort of live streaming app there's digital gifts that you can buy them um or you can subscribe to someone's patreon and support them um but the underlying motivation has always been altruism um fans don't really get all that much in return for tipping someone besides maybe a shout out or they get to unlock some extra piece of content but really I think the primary motivation behind patronage is um a softer type of motivation it's altruism it's the desire for status it's the ability to stay like I you know I really care about this person and I'm a better fan than you um but the plus in patronage plus really refers to the fact that there is a tangible benefit to the fan from supporting the creator and that takes the form of um a financial benefit potentially if the thing that the fan decides to purchase let's say an NFT um appreciates in price and the fan is able to benefit from that price appreciation so you go from this world in which the motivation for um supporting a creator economically goes from altruism to this actually like self-beneficial rationale and I think when you move um from one motivation and introduce this new motivation it actually dramatically increases the potential number of people in the world who would actually support creators not that many people are willing to just donate out of altruistic purposes but everyone is interested in making more money or mostly everyone in the world is interested in making more money it's funny to think of that as like a scalability technology right it's kind of the difference between like if there were only nonprofits versus you know the corporation right nonprofits can scale but they have some limitations and a corporation I mean our world is composed of all sorts of for-profit capital formations right it's kind of the difference between nonprofit and something that is for-profit yes exactly I want to take this opportunity to jump down a quick rabbit hole here because when you're talking about uh you like uh fans get to purchase an NFT or maybe some sort of token that loosely resembles some sort of vehicle for upside this is when uh we get into the conversation of right SEC regulations and this is the conversation I think that we're currently having in the crypto space uh with our frustration at some of the securities regulation such as in the United States but also abroad where some sort of creator just being doing their creative stuff expressing their creativity issue some sort of token and then that might just accidentally be a security because it has the potential of upside in it um Lee can you kind of just unpack um the difficulties of uh really unleashing the full potential of the creator economy and uh the securities regulations that uh hinder it hmm so I would definitely say that I'm not a securities law expert um so my understanding is today in the offline world a lot of the creative work that people do treat as investments are not actually regulated as securities so things that we would buy like collectibles or um merge at a concert or even paintings those are not securities I think where it does start to come into question is um when people are expecting to receive a portion of revenues on maybe like an ongoing basis or they're marketed in terms of you can expect to return in the future um and in that case uh I think it potentially could get classified as a security um which would mean that you know investors uh who purchased these things would have to be accredited um or they have to be registered with the SEC and I think that would just be um yeah tremendously challenging for the entire space and limit participation to a very small tam of consumers um so I'm I'm really like of the camp that I think we should increase opportunities for as many people as possible to build wealth and to um participate in the ownership of assets that will appreciate and value that is the whole um reason for the ownership economy thesis and so I I really hope that we can still treat all of these content creator products these digital um the digital content as akin to merge or collectibles we tease this a little bit um but why don't why don't we dive into it in the topic of patronage plus still so um there's this idea that all you need is a thousand true fans uh to kind of you know spin up a business or or kind of become a become a creator but you have a thesis that maybe you need far fewer than that maybe in order of magnitude less so maybe a hundred true fans can you explain that concept and how that relates to patronage plus absolutely so my piece called a hundred true fans was published I think in 2019 or so very much inspired by reading Kevin Kelly's original a thousand true fans post which he published almost I think more than 10 years ago um so Kevin Kelly's piece he he was a wired editor and he was writing this um I think in 2009 about how the internet is going to be really great for content creators because it means that you don't need to be a mass famous celebrity you actually just need a thousand true fans in order to make a living because he was doing some back up the envelope math if you could get a thousand fans who pay you ten dollars per month um and cut out the middleman which the internet enables you to do then you could actually make a full-time living just being a creator with that small fan base um and I really loved that idea and I took a step further in order of magnitude further and said actually all you need is a hundred true fans because if you can have a hundred people say paying you a thousand dollars per year um then you can make a full-time living off of that and earn you know a hundred thousand dollars and the recipe to do this I outlined was um comprised of giving fans more than than just appealing to their altruism it really needed to be about fan benefit rather than creator benefit and so creators needed to give them content or community that they were unable to find elsewhere um appeal to fans desire for status and feeling special um like fans were willing to pay those kinds of amounts for results or transformation like there were all these different components that I listed out of the a hundred true fans playbook but at the time NFTs had not really taken off and so I put this thesis out there and when NFTs took off I I was like oh my god this is this is what enables a hundred true fans for many many more creators because the powerful thing about what's possible with NFTs is that um you can basically like segment all of your fan base fans are very heterogeneous like when we look at our follower number I think that number is actually quite meaningless and instead we should think of them as fan segments where you have the super fans the casual fans and then the I forgot what I called it like it's like active fan and then passive fan um and there's going to be a segment of people who are willing to pay a lot who are willing to really pay anything and are really price and sensitive as long as it gets them a closer relationship with this person that they have a ton of affinity for and so NFTs enable that kind of price discrimination and being able to charge up to the fans full willingness to pay and therefore enables um much more powerful monetization of super fans.
So there's a number of dynamics in the web to world that I think really getting the way of that 100 true fans model I think the most obvious one that comes to mind is that Spotify for example treats all streams by all users equally and so you know one stream um from one person is going to read net some artist uh one tenth of a penny uh and Spotify doesn't differentiate between a casual fan that is just listening to a song via Spotify radio versus a hardcore fan that only listens to the same band day in day out and is willing to die for that that band that they really really love. Spotify doesn't enable any sort of segregation with this sort of behavior uh and so what you're saying is that in this whole patrons plus model we actually have ways of allowing fans to express a one thousand dollar a year or ten thousand dollar a year interest in a specific creator and allow that that one particular fan to differentiate themselves from somebody that is just randomly stumbling stumbling upon another artist through like you know a radio mix or some sort of you know random uh curation algorithm that we see all the way throughout web too uh am I onto something here?
Yeah I think you hit the nail on the head the way that I usually describe it is like fans are very heterogeneous and they all have like different willingness as to pay you can like maybe plot it out and sort of envision there's like spikes in the curve of how much they're willing to pay for something and existing web two business models that are advertising based or um I guess even subscription based business models that basically just charge a flat price what they do is they flatten that entire variation and so instead of charging everyone up to their full willingness to pay and said everyone is monetize the same as each other um every eyeball is fungible every play is fungible um and what you have as a result of that is the inability to charge these super fans but also on the super fan side the inability to express your fandom in a way that would distinguish you from other people out there so it's not only leaving money on the table from the behalf of the of the creator but it's also leaving creativity on the table as well the creator could have created more had they had a more viable monetization path than just whatever Spotify does which is you know using the least common denominator of what people will pay yeah exactly uh the example an example that comes to mind which I think really paints the picture for this is um a company that I invested in or we invested in a variant called sound which is a music NFT platform um when I checked with them a while ago they had just launched and they had done seven drops so far with pretty small indie artists honestly and they had all sold out immediately in under a minute um and the revenue of that each of like that these seven artists collectively generated was equivalent to the streaming revenue that would have been earned if they had gotten 21 million streams 21 million streams for seven artists is like mega famous level that was not the case for the initial artist that launch on sound um but because they were selling NFTs and this you know was denominated in ETH and the sale prices were relatively high or yeah I think it was like a collectibles level of um price point um as a result of that like they didn't need to be super famous in order to be able to monetize effectively and not only that the example you just gave is that the the artist actually gets to know who those fans are especially when we talk about using this through a crypto platform where you can go look at the address that holds your NFT whereas Spotify you don't get the email addresses of your listeners uh you just it's a black box but with NFTs and with you know traceable uh transparent blockchains you actually as an artist have a direct connection towards who the hell is it paying you $10,000 for your song or whatever uh and so that identity aspect is I think also very very empowering towards the creators yeah that's definitely true I think there's a lot of potential there we still obviously lack a lot of the infrastructure to make use of that sure uh identity in terms of being able to message and reach out to them and tie it to uh you know their public profiles that might be out there but I agree that there is a lot of potential there if you're going bankless you need Metamask this is your tool to unlock the world of DeFi without giving up custody over your private keys Metamask is both a secure in browser wallet and also a secure bridge for your hardware wallet you can now trade tokens on any decks or aggregator Metamask swap gathers real time pricing information across all the DeFi exchanges allowing you to select your best price while getting all the Metamask benefits of self-custody lower-gas costs and increased transaction success rates Metamask also has a fantastic mobile wallet that I use when I'm out and about which I used to collect poaps NFTs and do all my DeFi things wrong away from home if you haven't downloaded Metamask you gotta try it out Web 3 wouldn't be the same without it download Metamask for desktop and mobile at metamask.
io and load up your treasure ledger lattice or keystone hardware wallets so that they too can get into the world of Web 3 living a bankless life requires taking control of your own private keys not your keys not your crypto that's why so many in the bankless nation already have their ledger hardware wallet but the ledger ecosystem is much more than just a secure hardware wallet ledger is the combination of the ledger hardware wallet the ledger live app and soon the CL crypto life card powered by ledger the CL card powered by ledger is a crypto debit card with powerful features like an instant exchange to fiat where crypto assets are only sold at the moment that you've swiped your card and also credit from crypto collateral where you can collateralize your crypto assets in order to get a higher credit limit you'll be able to manage your CL card powered by ledger inside the ledger live app right next to all the DeFi apps and services that you're already used to using making it the ledger live app your one stop shop for all of your financial needs go to ledger.
com grab a ledger and download ledger live to get all of your DeFi applications all in one place so you've got some money and you want to spend you me shopping now bro when you should you save it you'll never buy a house at this rate but what if you could spend and save at the same time for the enlightened kind with inquiring minds a new world awaits set yourself free with completely flexible self-repaying alone technology supported on desktop and mobile sees the power of alchemists allowing you to spend and save at the same time leverage your wealth without the risk of liquidation pick out alone that repays itself what was once inconceivable is now within your grasp are you winning some okay so this is such an interesting conversation because what we're actually talking about here is ripping out the guts the business model the internet and replacing it with an entirely new engine and when people hear the example you gave of sound in these these artists selling you some of them will dismiss and say oh that's just like the NFT bubble where they got lucky or something like this but I think what what we're doing right here lean the way you've laid it out is it's like very methodical like you can see exactly how we're going to cross this chasm from the attention economy to the ownership economy and we've only gone down I guess two of the trigger points right so the first is just by way of recap we've got this new digital good product so crypto invented digital goods and we can now sell them on the internet the second with patronage plus is all supporting people who are supporting creators they actually become investors so your fans become investors that's the second now let's get to the third so this is new programmable economic models that sounds like a bit of a mouthful but tell us what you mean by that how is this going to transition us from the attention economy to the ownership economy right so this this third point gets to be a little bit more future-facing and I would say it doesn't quite yet exist but where I think we'll get there and I think a lot of people are building in this direction so what I meant by new programmable business models is essentially like today a lot of content creation is collaborative all sort of content that we create draws upon past information sources or inspirations that have led us to create the thing that we're creating and yet none of that revenue is flowing back to all of the sources of inspiration all of the people who perhaps contribute to piece of work and so you can imagine that eventually in in the future once more of our content creation moves on chain and all work becomes tokenized that people can draw on this universal content library to mix and match and remix in order to put together whatever they're putting together and by attributing it back to this universal content library perhaps all of those different contributors to that piece of content could also be economically rewarded for their contributions so you're starting to see I think this is like a pretty futuristic idea that a few writers have have talked about you're starting to see I think like hints of this being implemented when you look at the splits feature on a few different NFT platforms so an example of this is like on mirror writers are actually splitting the revenue that they get automated in an automated way between really like any one of their choosing but usually people who collaborated to a piece or proofread it or edited it or whatever and then I think on foundation as well as a creator you can split the revenue that you earn from NFTs as well as secondary sales with other addresses and so the vision that I was really laying out here is this world in which everyone becomes linked both in terms of content creation as well as the economic reward for how they're being compensated for that it's fascinating shared reward so with the mirror with the mere platform for example if we you myself and David we co-authored a piece together right and we listed that and somebody bought it for you know say three eth and we were all you know splitting into third to third to third we'd all received the proceeds from that that's something that's the ability to partake and share in some of the upside of these digital product products in new economic ways and probably to program them in all sorts of interesting ways in DeFi is just super nascent that hasn't fully been tapped into yet yeah I agree and I think this is this is really powerful because this behavior has been or this kind of like splitting a revenue and taking the value that you get and giving a portion of that to all of the influences and contributors this has been a pain point in the web to internet for a while I hear from youtube creators that it's challenging to you know sit down every month calculate like their ad sense revenue on a video and calculate like how much should be split to every single person who collaborated with them on that video and that just compounds over time because you're earning revenue on a continuous basis and yet the platform really treats it as like a one channel one creator one revenue account model and then there's definitely like a huge trust component to trusting that the person who has the login credentials to that channel and that ad sense account is going to actually properly split it with you and represent accurately like what they earned and so yeah I think there's there's lots of issues around revenue sharing and attribution today that I'm hopeful blockchain can be part of the solution for okay let's talk about the fourth one and I think we sort of alluded to this when we were talking about some creator starting to co-create with their communities with their fan base and the fourth one is dows and community ownership so talk about that how's that going to usher us into the ownership economy from the attention economy right so this is really the the future of the creator economy as I mentioned is the community economy it's this world in which we shift from creators creating content at their fans or for their fans to a world in which they're co-creating with each other and everyone is driving value back to the community in some way that could be you know commenting on their posts retweeting things amplifying their content leading like marketing efforts or whatever it might be I think everyone in a creator's community is actually driving value in some way but they're just not getting compensated for that work and so this fourth point was really around moving to this community ownership model in which everyone becomes part owner of the community that they're in and their membership state can be tokenized and represented on chain we're seeing this with dows where every member of a dow is actually part owner of the dow itself and stands to benefit from all of the revenue and the value that they create I think creators are going to implement this model with their fans and with each other and drive value back to this community treasury and share it with all the people who created value for them that's fascinating are you seeing any examples of this like you know our story around the the bank list dow has been somewhat of an example where you know we we just sort of you know seated this idea of some people in the bank list community kind of starting a dow and now they're off and Dave and I barely participate right we're not active participants in terms of the day-to-day governance but with this this vision of like let's go make the world bankless now this dow has spun up which originated as you know fans of the bankless podcast and the newsletter and they're creating all sorts of things like their own podcasts their own like educational centers there's like a bankless university spinning up and the communities doing this completely on their own and it provides David and I a way to kind of scale the bankless movement and start the vision and let the community take it away so we've certainly seen that are there other examples that you can point to around communities co-creating with their fans that you like yeah absolutely so yeah I think bank list out is actually a really great example of this kind of community driven content creation model I think there's other experiments that are running that are really fascinating Kyle Chica who is a I think New Yorker writer started a publication about NFTs and he crowdfunded that by selling NFTs and AirDrop tokens back to those crowd funders and the idea is that the crowd funders would then have a stake in the publication and have an incentive to help with content creation or amplification of what gets published I think even something like Nounstow could be thought of as a creator community ownership sort of organization wherein all of the values being driven back to this community treasury everyone who has bought in is able to determine what that treasury is going to be used for they could use it on different initiatives to support ecosystem to publicize the work that they're doing etc and then I would also point to this musician who recently has done a lot of really successful NFT drops his name is Daniel Allen he is a really active participant in the web 3 community he's a music artist I think a couple of things to note about him he raised a crowd fund on Mir a few months ago in which he raised something like over a hundred thousand dollars in ETH through selling NFTs the plan is to then AirDrop tokens to all of those NFT holders he's also done a lot of music NFT drops in in recent weeks and so all those who are going to also have tokens representing their membership stake in this DAO and then going forward you could imagine that everyone who has ownership in his community is going to be that much more incentivized to contribute to his success potentially create content themselves and rise up as creators in that community so I think we're really early days but I think this like community driven model is what I see as the future because otherwise we are recreating this world in which creators are essentially the new platforms and fans are the people who are creating value but not benefiting from their contributions and instead I think the realistic state of the world is that everyone is contributing in their own ways to the success of all the projects they're involved in and all of the projects that they patronize and they should have ownership in that I want to integrate all of these different components that we've been talking about in this new creator economy web three world we have significantly lower barriers towards creating with coming with increasing financial rewards to creating and we also have a changing creative process where it's no it's no longer just the creator towards the fan but it's a it's a buy conversation where the creator create something the fans then also create and respond to that and then it's an iterative conversation of creation between the creator and the fans so when we when you put this all together what what comes out of this what is the resulting impact upon society are we getting a boom of art and creativity is this the road map for a brand new renaissance of human creativity what is the what is the long term impact of all of these new paradigm shifts that are seemingly all happening at once I'm really optimistic about the future of the creator economy I titled the blog post the web three renaissance so clearly I think that where do for this period in which many more creators can flourish and make a living and many more fans can also benefit from the contributions that they're making so I think we go from the state of the world that we're in today wherein there's about 50 million creators in total and the entire market size of the creator economy is estimated to be something like a hundred billion to a world in which everyone is earning some income and ownership through their contributions to the internet so everyone becomes a part creator like I think literally every single person who uses the internet is a creator in their own unique ways I think what changes in the future is that they're able to financially benefit from that so I very much see like yeah another renaissance on the horizon that will be enabled from that I think people might think that I'm quite optimistic and maybe too optimistic or utopian but I really do think all of the foundational elements are there and it's really up to us and all of the builders in the ecosystem to make that version of reality this is not the first time that a guest on bankless has predicted a renaissance one of our general communities favorite previous episodes is episode 63 the crypto renaissance and a historian Josh Rosenthal takes us through the argument about how the the technologies that are specifically enabling enabling crypto are the same iterative iterations of technologies that enable the original renaissance so taking it taking it on taking it for granted that a renaissance does actually come do you have an opinion as to the magnitude of such a renaissance in comparison to the last one that happened in the 1400s are we thinking smaller than that one equal to that one greater than that one it's a ridiculous question but I want to ask it into anyways well actually I think this is the third renaissance people often talk about the new deal as the second renaissance the new deal in the post-abression yeah exactly in the US that has been informally dubbed as the second renaissance because that was a period in which the government essentially paid the salaries of a bunch of artists and creators to go out there and create art for the public or create documentaries and write books etc so sometimes that is described as the second renaissance so if that if that is the second renaissance then we're headed for a third and I think it's going to be bigger than the prior two combined because this is now reaching internet scale this is happening online versus the prior two internets were bounded to IRL they were scoped geographically they had geographical boundaries very few people could actually participate in terms of patronizing artists in the first one and then in the second one it was like you know tax revenue being fed into supporting artists as part of like a government plan and now I think we're moving into with this third renaissance the difference is that everyone is able to participate as both a content creator as well as a patron patron plus and so like I think it'll truly be internet scale a renaissance at the scale of the internet is something to be optimistically bullish on if ever I've heard it no one's ever accused us david of not being optimistically bullish that was so however ubiquitous podcast goes we now that we've kind of uncovered your your mental model for the creator economy and the ownership economy I'm wondering if you could take us through some implications here maybe in some of your recent tweets that we picked out and we really liked the first is something you tweeted the passion economy is the what the ownership economy is the how what do you mean by that yes so the passion economy thesis which I spearheaded when I was working at a 16 z a few years ago and started writing about a few years ago is this idea that new platforms and tools could help people to earn an income from their individuality the idea was monetizing individuality by leveraging their creative skills or their non-commonitized knowledge and packaging that into different products and services that you could sell online what I meant by this tweet the passion economy is the what the ownership economy is the how is that I think the ultimate vision for for me and for a lot of folks in the space is we still very much want to realize a world in which people are able to do what they love for a living and achieve financial stability through doing that but the how of how we accomplish that is rather than just giving people income in bits and pieces here and there from these platforms that they're contributing to instead they become the owners of the underlying internet products and services so I think by giving people ownership that really turbo turbo charges how financially empowered they are and so the ownership economy is the how of how we actually realize the vision of a passion economy you also said this the biggest opportunity of our time is to reconfigure the relationship between capital and labor to reconfigure the relationship between capital and labor what do you mean by that and how does that relate to our discussion that was quite a controversial one yeah so what I meant by that is so economists divide up the the share of national income into income that is derived from labor i.
e. working like wages salaries tips whatever versus income that is earned from capital i.e. things that you own that earn a return for you this could be factories or real estate whatever it might be capital income and the trend over time in developed economies has been that the capital share of income is growing and the the labor share of income is shrinking and what that means is that people who have existing resources existing capital are just getting wealthier and earning more versus the people who are working further living and so the implication of that is exacerbated income inequality because that means if if you have more to start with you'll actually be able to outpace and earn more than the people who are just working with their time for wages and so what I meant by this tweet the biggest opportunity of our time is to reconfigure the relationship between capital and labor is I think that that dynamic is just fundamentally broken a world in which what people have is a bigger contributor to their wealth than what they have to actually contribute with their energy and effort I think that for boats really badly for our society and just puts us on a path to even more extreme income inequality and income inequality that'll be exacerbated through multiple generations too and so what I hope to see is that we basically make them one in the same people who are contributing labor are able to earn capital through that effort through that work and so people it becomes indistinguishable that relationship between labor and capital and I think that is the vision of crypto by the way is that people can not just buy ownership of potentially valuable assets with their money that they can actually earn them by participating in these new projects and networks why is this country virtually because anytime you talk about capital and labor those two words have actually become quite touchy inside yes so I mean Marx wrote a lot about the relationship between capital and labor and how capital owners and laborers were stuck in this perennial struggle this power struggle where capital owners people who like own factories and all of the means of production they could exert that ownership and get laborers to essentially bend to their will and to work on their terms because the laborers only had their labor to sell they didn't they couldn't make the end product on their own and so this idea of class struggle between capital and labor and like his prediction was that ultimately like labor was going to overthrow capital and we were going to have this classless society I think the words capital and labor are just kind of like hot button words now because a lot of people assume that I'm talking about like class struggle and class warfare and abolishing capital period but instead I think what I'm describing is something that is net new and hasn't been possible before there's a frequent conversation in the crypto space about whether or not crypto fixes wealth inequality wealth inequality being perhaps the biggest problem of our current time at least definitely up there in the top three or so I'd say and let's say the answer to this question definitely should be nuanced crypto does not solve the current state of wealth inequality at least in my opinion there's in we are not redistributing wealth there's nothing about Bitcoin or nothing about the spinning up new L ones that fix wealth inequality old capital can just buy the new capital and retain their capital but I think how crypto does solve quote unquote solve wealth inequality is that it generates platforms that are balanced that don't tilt towards what you are talking about where capital gets more capital faster than labor gets more capital and I think one of the reasons why people like you and me are are so bullish about crypto is that it actually starts to really blur the lines between what labor and capital actually are and so we are actually starting to integrate these things and so while we cannot we're crypto is not going to have some sort of Jubilee where the ledgers are wiped clean and wealth is redistributed it's still it's not going to fix the current levels of wealth distribution it can prevent them from getting any worse and maybe if you're even more optimistic than that it can actually start to reorient and rebalance the distribute the discrepancy between labor and capital do you have any thoughts on that I have many many thoughts this is a big part of the reason why I became a full-time crypto investor before before October of last year I had sort of been investing both in web 2 and web 3 businesses and sort of straddling both worlds and I made the decision to go full-time crypto because I felt like this technology evolution presented the biggest opportunity in my lifetime to help address income inequality and so I wanted to bet my career in this direction because I was frustrated by frankly by the platforms and services that were being created in web 2 that to me represented kind of incremental band-aid solutions on the current problem like on the margins they were helping creators become slightly more empowered or you know export a portion of their fans to an email list or whatever but it was very marginal and I wanted to harness a much more powerful tool set for this mission so what drew me originally to crypto was this potential to create more fairness in the world and to mitigate income inequality and so to go back to your question around like does crypto solve income inequality I agree it's a really complicated question and I think the answer is really up to us to shape the devil is in the details in terms of how we actually implement these token distributions and how we design all of these networks it's up to founders to decide how much of their token networks go to the community versus goes to investors and the team it's up to founders decide whether their token supplies inflate over time and create the potential for newcomers to benefit versus tilting it towards the early adopters and so I think a lot of this is within our control that's the wonderful thing but I think for the first time ever we have this new and powerful tool set to actually reconfigure the relationship between labor and capital that's incredible if we could pull that one off you know this crypto certainly gives surface area to to far more people and provide surface area to far more opportunities and maybe this is kind of the last week we brought in that that kind of links to what you're just saying Lee which is if you are a creator first company you tweeted this your cap tables should reflect that seems like that's kind of what you're saying if you're really a creator first company then creators should own part of your equity part of your capital is that what you're saying?
precisely precisely basically if if you're a founder and you're beating the drum of creator empowerment and being creator first the number one most powerful way to do that is through giving creators ownership and ownership decomposes into both economic rights as well as governance rights but at the end of the day giving ownership over to creators is the most impactful way to actually enable and empower creators and it's interesting that in this tweet I said your cap tables should reflect that I've now obviously pivoted my focus to token tables and I think this also applies if you replace cap table with token table I think the challenge with cap tables is that they're heavily regulated as under the current legal framework and a lot of founders were kind of really limited in terms of what they could actually do with their equity and how many people could own their equity and how many creators on their platforms they could actually distribute that too and so I think tokens are this more powerful tool through which to actually distribute ownership to many many people it is funny and sad how regulation can actually exacerbate wealth inequality very very much what we're seeing with the credit investor laws and you know another topic for another day but this is maybe my favorite part of the conversation where we get to turn a little bit of the theory into practice and talk about what someone the average person listening to this can actually do with this information to better their lives and to put themselves in the in the flow of this new trend this ownership economy creator economy trend and it strikes me that right now crypto has too many speculators maybe like we we have too many speculators in proportion to the amount of creators and entrepreneurs that we have and I think there are massive opportunities for creators and entrepreneurs in the future that are completely left untapped at this point in time right so we've talked enough in crypto circles about all the opportunities for speculators but I love how this conversation really positions the value proposition towards somebody who's trying to create something new and earn income from their community somebody who has a who has a community and can create a fantastic community and some of these digital projects products so let's talk about this and get actionable what is your recommendation for someone who wants to plug into the creator economy or the ownership economy today what sorts of things should they do in order to find themselves at the at the center of this renaissance rather than at the fringes or kind of out in the cold there are so many different ways to participate it's almost like too many ideas to list but I'll just bucket them and quickly suggest a few options so I think for anyone who finds themselves with a special skill or creative talent the my number one answer is to actually try and participate in the ecosystem as a creator to try one's hand at being a creator this is what I did when I started being an investor in the ecosystem is I actually started creating content on the internet and if you know even if you're not that successful as a creator it definitely helps to cultivate a lot of empathy with other creators out there so that brings me to my second point which is to engage in the ecosystem by supporting creators and supporting creators can take a lot of different forms it can be financial support like buy stuff from creators buy their NFTs buy their tokens like join their discord join their dows but if you know if someone is financially limited I think there's other ways to show support as well you can use your social capital to help amplify their work and help them get recognition and there's also ways to help educate and bring more creators into the web3 ecosystem I actually think this is a huge opportunity for anyone who wants to get involved in the creator economy is to learn about different crypto platforms and projects and help actually walk creators through the process of getting started there and so and then I would say lastly is to either build a creator focused company or to support them as an investor or user there's so many amazing projects that are getting started today all across the creator economy and ownership economy there's new music NFT platforms new visual NFT platforms new tooling platforms that help creators to give their social tokens more utility and so you could work for those companies help contribute to them or help start something new that you don't see up there the a lot of people come into this industry and they take one look at it and they say well I can't code so there's nothing I can do what would you say to these people I would say to those people that there are a lot more jobs that are in demand in web3 outside of coding and recently I published a tweet storm about this topic this exact topic the first tweet was like seven steps to get into web3 for non-technical people and so there's a number of really sought-after skills just to list a few of them one is community building I think every single one of my portfolio companies is hiring for a skilled community manager someone who's able to manage socials connect different people in the ecosystem drama of excitement this is like a really like in demand scarce there's there's very little great candidates who are in the ecosystem and everyone is hungry to hire for this position I think people are also really hungry for folks to engage in governance to propose like new governance proposals to engage in the forums to drive some of these protocols and projects forward I think there's also a new job that hadn't existed before in the form of working on tokenomics a lot of these projects are still in their early days in terms of running the progressive decentralization playbook and are looking for guidance and support in terms of determining who gets the air drop and like what's the criteria for that and how to design their tokenomics so that is definitely an opening and then I would just also say that like all of the other like you know traditional non-technical rules that had existed startups still exist in web3 so design project management like being the glue person in some of these communities like just managing like follow ups and getting everyone to move forward and agree on a set of action items that is so valuable um product management like a ton of web3 projects are now looking for mass adoption and to reach like normal consumers and so usability and design really matters and so skilled web2 product managers are really in demand so anyway so there's a huge gamut of different um jobs out there for people who want to help build the the creator economy in web3 we started off this podcast with this very prescient quote from Bill Gates saying content is king and I would just like to double down on that because no matter how awesome web3 is you need to have good content and I think this new creator economy this ownership economy it's really meant to be able to amplify one's skills that producing content more than it is to be able to just you know put money in the hands of everyone and I think what I'm particularly bullish about with the future of crypto future web3 the future of the creator economy is that everyone has some sort of kernel of creativity inside of them and it's up to the social social structures the platforms that we use to really unlock and unleash the creativity that's inside of of everyone so that's what I'm bullish about for the future of the passion economy Lee let me ask you this uh this closing question um so we're recording this at the start of 2022 and I think last year was a fantastic year for the creator economy and the ownership economy just the uh the surge of NFT interest we saw alone was enough to to make it an incredible year what do you think 2022 is going to bring for us is this going to be a big year for the ownership economy and then like what do you what do you must looking forward to in the in this year and then the years ahead I think that it is going to be another banner year for the creator economy I mean I think every year is that is the case because the creator economy is just on a tear and in general I think the backdrop of this is that there there's a generational shift in how people are thinking about work and how they want to earn income and more people are gravitating towards being able to be autonomous and independent and doing the things that they want to do more flexibly and that's driving huge adoption of the creator economy across the board and so I don't think we're going to see any slowdown in that because that is an underlying human motivation that is prevalent all around the world in terms of like specific themes and predictions for 2022 as it pertains to maybe some specific areas that I'll be focused on in the creator economy I think I think more creators are going to explore uh web three native ways to monetize and add that to their toolkit hunter walk had a really great post about creators being multi-squeue like most creators are multi-squeue they monetize through a variety of different business models and different types of products I think this will be the year where a lot of creators go from watching and waiting to actually participating and jumping in and so what that means is um a bunch of new NFT platforms as well that cater to different types of NFTs and different formats of digital content so whereas last year was really all about um collections and really revolved around visual art um and that happened on open sea and foundation and super rare I think this year we're going to see more musicians participate in NFTs so there's a bunch of different music NFT platforms that have emerged like catalog and sound and arpeggio and there's communities like water and music and song camp um and I think photo NFTs are going to be another big trend this year where photographers are able to be more successful with their work um and that's happening I mean that's happening on foundation but that's also happening on new platforms like quantum and then I think um this is also going to be a year of experiments for web three social which is really a foundational element for the creator economy because it determines how well or how successfully creators are going to be able to connect to audiences and vice versa so I think we'll see more social experiences that are built with an eye towards exposing people exposing users to stuff that's happening on chain that they might not be aware of um that is interesting to them and so a project that I'm keeping my eye on in this regard is called context which is this NFT focused kind of social network or social feed um there's another interesting one called backdrop which is really focused on dows and what people are doing inside of dows um but yeah web three social is a theme that I think is really fascinating too absolutely so much to be built so much to look forward to up only for the creator economy is what Legion is predicting uh in the years to come thank you so much for spending time with us this has been absolutely fascinating and I know the bankless communities absolutely gonna love it and we appreciate you spending the time thank you so much for having me really love the conversation action items for you today bankless community the first is a panel that we talked about earlier it's called what is the creator economy Legion was on that panel so it was uh Jesse Walden one of her partners at variant fund go check that out it's a great download on what the creator economy is as well also subscribe to Legion sub stack uh you could find that in the show notes we'll link to that also we'll link to her post about 100 true fans we looked that up for you and uh go click that link and read that post risk disclaimers guys as always this stuff is risky crypto is always risky so is it so is Bitcoin so is the creator economy you could definitely lose what you put in but we are headed west this is the frontier it's not for everyone but we're glad you're with us on the bankless journey thanks a lot hey we hope you enjoyed the video if you did head over to bankless hq right now to develop your crypto investing skills and learn how to free yourself from banks and gain your financial independence we recommend joining our daily newsletter podcast and community as a bankless premium subscriber to get the most out of your bankless you'll get access to our market analysis our alpha leaks and exclusive content and even the bankless token for airdrops raffles and unlocks if you're interested in crypto the bankless community is where you want to be click the link in the description to become a bankless premium subscriber today also don't forget to subscribe to the channel for in-depth interviews with industry leaders ask me any things and weekly rollups where we summarize the week in crypto and other fantastic content thanks everyone for watching and being on the journey as we build out the bankless nation