First, Haseeb Qureshi was a Texas Hold’em poker player. Then Haseeb learned how to code and worked as a software engineer for Airbnb. He went down the crypto rabbithole and is now the managing partner at Dragonfly Capital, as well as an accomplished writer and coder.
He recently published an article titled Blockchains are Cities, expanding on a mental model for understanding the crypto landscape from a high level perspective. We brought Haseeb back onto the Bankless Podcast to dive into this metaphor, which explains how cities (and blockchains) scale.
We also explore the question of the decade: Will we live in a multi-chain world, or will there be “one chain to rule them all”?
------ ✨ DEBRIEF ✨ | Ryan & David's Unfiltered Thoughts on the Episode https://shows.banklesshq.com/p/debrief-haseeb-cities
------ 📣 ALTO IRA | THE CRYPTO RETIREMENT ACCOUNT https://bankless.cc/AltoIRA
------ 🚀 SUBSCRIBE TO NEWSLETTER: https://newsletter.banklesshq.com/ 🎙️ SUBSCRIBE TO PODCAST: http://podcast.banklesshq.com/
------ BANKLESS SPONSOR TOOLS:
👀 POLYGON | LAYER 2 DEFI https://bankless.cc/Polygon
❎ ACROSS | BRIDGE TO LAYER 2 https://bankless.cc/Across
🦊 METAMASK | THE CRYPTO WALLET https://bankless.cc/metamask
💳 LEDGER | THE CRYPTO LIFE CARD https://bankless.cc/Ledger
🧙♂️ ALCHEMIX | SELF REPAYING LOANS https://bankless.cc/Alchemix
🦄 UNISWAP | DECENTRALIZED FUNDING https://bankless.cc/UniGrants
------ Topics Covered:
0:00 Intro 6:00 Haseeb and Context 11:35 Why Cities? 17:15 Limitations & Trust 23:27 Scaling Like Cities 31:15 Who’s Building Vertically? 36:27 Application Specific Chains 45:14 Building More Cities 54:23 Goals, Tradeoffs, and Winners 1:01:20 Cross-Chain Bridges 1:05:59 Cities or Nation States? 1:12:36 Security and Military 1:23:20 Individuals vs Chains 1:30:36 Closing & Disclaimers
------ Resources:
Haseeb on Twitter https://twitter.com/hosseeb?s=20 Dragonfly Capital https://www.dcp.capital/ Blockchains are Cities https://medium.com/dragonfly-research/blockchains-are-cities-564327013f86 Why Decentralization Isn’t As Important As You Think https://haseebq.com/why-decentralization-isnt-as-important-as-you-think/ I’m Worried No One Will Care About Rollups https://medium.com/dragonfly-research/im-worried-nobody-will-care-about-rollups-554bc743d4f1 The ETH2 Metropolis https://newsletter.banklesshq.com/p/defi-in-the-eth2-metropolis-haseeb
----- Not financial or tax advice. This channel is strictly educational and is not investment advice or a solicitation to buy or sell any assets or to make any financial decisions. This video is not tax advice. Talk to your accountant. Do your own research.
Disclosure. From time-to-time I may add links in this newsletter to products I use. I may receive commission if you make a purchase through one of these links. Additionally, the Bankless writers hold crypto assets. See our investment disclosures here: https://newsletter.banklesshq.com/p/bankless-disclosures
No summary for this episode yet.
In every single country, there is one most dominant city, and that city is usually, you know, at least twice as big as the next largest city. In a way, there's almost exactly what we see with LearWonth. Welcome to Bankless, where we explore the frontier of internet money and internet finance. This is how to get started, how to get better, how to front-run the opportunity. This is Ryan Sean Adams. I'm here with David Hoffman, and we're here to help you become more Bankless. I'm really excited about this show. This is on blockchains as cities. We use cities as a metaphor to determine how blockchains scale.
We have Haseed on the podcast, who shows us what this looks like. The big question here for the guest was, are we going to live in a multi-chain world, or will there be one chain to roll them all? Haseed is very much a multi-chain world person. A few things to listen for. Number one, we talk about why networks aren't the right analogy for chains, why cities are. Number two, how blockchains actually scale like cities. Number three, why Ethereum is New York City? Solana is LA. Avalanche is Chicago. Number four, what this means for LearWon investors. Number five, we end with where David and I disagree.
David, what were your thoughts on this episode with Haseed? I mean, you know, Ryan, that I'm a big sucker for metaphors and mental models. That's why I thoroughly enjoyed talking with Haseed today because metaphors are just a shortcut to understanding. I think a lot of newer people who are still trying to wrap their heads around the blockchains space, are you really going to appreciate just understanding the relationships between cities and blockchains and how they relate to each other? I think perhaps understanding, you know, Ethereum's roll up centric roadmap using New York City as a mental model for that.
And then also how Solana is like LA and LA kind of sprawls very horizontally where Ethereum builds up very vertically. I think people are going to really appreciate these these mental models, but also just talking about why blockchains have scalability issues in the first place. We talked about stuff like this at the very in the first half of the show. But then we go into the second half of the show where you and I take apart a little bit of Haseed's mental models where he calls blockchains as cities, but we think blockchains are actually nations. And so we unpack all of these metaphors at some point at the end of the day, all metaphors break down.
And so we really stretch this metaphor these metaphors into their limits. But I think it was just overall super helpful nonetheless. Yeah, and this is worth listening guys, because I do think this is the question of the year, maybe the question of the next few years, maybe the question of the decade remains to be seen, which is multi chain. That means multiple layer ones, or will there be one primary central chain, like an Ethereum, for instance, that provides settlement to many of the other chains. That is the discussion, the debate today and the context as well. Guys, as always, if you're listening with us, thank you very much.
Make sure you like and subscribe wherever you're listening through a podcast subscriber. Make sure you review this podcast. If you liked it, that's how we go top of the charts right after this as well. David and I are recording our debrief where we give our thoughts on the episode with Haseed. I've got a lot of thoughts swirling around. I know David does too. If you are a premium subscriber, premium bankless subscriber, you can tap into your premium feed and listen to that as well. Kind of a bonus episode that comes out every single bankless podcast. We will get right back to the podcast with Haseed.
But before we do, we want to tell you about the sponsors that made this episode possible. If you're going bankless, you need Metamask. This is your tool to unlock the world of DeFi without giving up custody over your private keys. Metamask is both a secure in browser wallet and also a secure bridge for your hardware wallet. You can now trade tokens on any decks or aggregator. Metamask Swap gathers real-time pricing information across all the DeFi exchanges, allowing you to select your best price while getting all the Metamask benefits of self-custody, lower-gas costs, and increased transaction success rates.
Metamask also has a fantastic mobile wallet that I use when I'm out and about, which I use to collect poaps, NFTs, and do all my DeFi things while I'm away from home. If you haven't downloaded Metamask, you've got to try it out. Web 3 wouldn't be the same without it. Download Metamask for desktop and mobile at metamask.io and load up your treasure, ledger, lattice, or keystone hardware wallets so that they too can get into the world of Web 3. Bankless is proud to be sponsored by Uniswap. Uniswap is a new paradigm in asset exchange infrastructure. Instead of a cumbersome order book system where trades are matched with other humans, Uniswap is an autonomous piece of software on Ethereum that lets you trade any token at the current market price.
No human counterparties or centralized intermediaries, just autonomous code on Ethereum. Input the token you want to sell and receive the token you want to buy. The Uniswap grants program is accepting applications for grants. Do you have something of value that you think you want to contribute to the Uniswap ecosystem? No matter how big or small your idea is, you can apply for a unique grant at Uniswapgrants.org and help steer Uniswap in the direction that you think it should go. Thank you Uniswap for sponsoring Bankless. So you've got some money, but how are you going to use it? You want to spend when you know you should be saving.
Never buy a house at this rate. But what if you could spend and save at the same time? For the enlightened kind with inquiring minds, a new world awaits. Set yourself free with completely flexible self-repaying loan technology. Supported on desktop and mobile sees the power of alchemics allowing you to spend and save at the same time. Leverage your wealth without the risk of liquidation. Pick out a loan that repays itself. By using yield from your deposit to pay off your balance, your only debt is time. What was once inconceivable is now within your grasp. Bankless Nation, we are super excited about our next guest, Haseeb Kuresh.
Haseeb is a managing partner at Dragon Fly Capital, which is a cryptocurrency venture fund. A pretty fantastic one. He invests in all aspects of crypto, this entire industry. He's one of those investors who has also had a very successful background in poker, which would be a topic for another podcast. We're not going to get into that today. We've had him on the show before. We're talking about something similar. Subject of cities, how crypto was going to scale, how it was going to evolve in the future, and we've invited him back to talk more about that today. He published a fantastic post using cities as a mental model for blockchains, which we're going to dive into, Haseeb.
Great to have you back on bankless. How are you doing today? I'm doing great. Thanks for having me. Man, it's an exciting time in crypto. Of course, we're trying to figure out this scaling thing. We're wondering if there's a bear market going on. In the backdrop of this, you wrote this post. I think this post is an analogy for probably one of the most important debates in crypto or investment thesis, which is this, are we going to live in a multi-chain world or will there be one chain to rule them all? By multi-chain, of course, I think that means multiple layer ones versus one chain to rule them all is one heavily dominant layer one.
That's kind of the juxtaposition. That's what we're going to be talking about today. But I want to start with maybe this city's metaphor that we're using. Let's get in the frame of mind. Tell us about cities. What cities have you lived in in the past to see? Where are you living now? What city are you living in now? I'm living right now in San Francisco. Since COVID, I've been floating around a little bit, but San Francisco is usually home-based, which features in the article. It's interesting actually the genesis of this whole metaphor because as you mentioned, I'd written about this metaphor of cities and trying to contextualize blockchain spatially, actually writing about charting and writing about E2.
0. And in many ways, the whole idea of charting is actually very similar in principle to what we think about when we think about a multi-chain world as you have these logically separate mini-blockchains operating alongside each other doing different things, but being able to connect up to each other in some way. And almost every vision of how to scale blockchains is directionally similar. Like layer twos are sort of these mini-blockchains that kind of spin out from layer ones. Other alternative layer ones are so many of them are EVM compatible, so they're literally built on the exact same virtual machine that Ethereum is built on, but they happen to be totally or from validator set or totally different consensus mechanism.
Charting is a similar story, but in E2.0, which I guess we're not allowed to call it that anymore, or whatever. The great future of Ethereum. We'll censor that out. Let's see. Sorry, sorry, sorry. Please, please, please, please. The vision of charting is kind of similar. And what I found in the last year, so I'm an investor, in the last year, I've been chatting with lots of folks who've come into the crypto space, who are brand new, and don't know about any of the prior art for all these conversations that you guys and ourselves have been having, and they just come into this world and they're like, okay, I keep hearing all this stuff about Solana, Solana is the future of crypto, isn't Solana just going to eat everything, and isn't this just like an open and shut story that Ethereum was like MS-DOS, and then like Solana is now Windows 10, and isn't that just how it works.
And I realized that it was very difficult for a lot of folks who are entering into the space to wrap their head around a good mental model of why isn't it that a blockchain that's just faster and can fit more people into it, and fit more transactions into it, why is that not obviously going to win? And in most technologies, that's the case. The thing that's faster and bigger obviously wins. If somebody comes along with a database that is 10 times bigger, 10 times faster, 10 times cheaper than Postgres, it's just going to wipe before everyone's going to be using it in five years. That's just obviously how it works.
And the thing is, I think you and I know, and people who've been in crypto for long enough know that in crypto, that's the wrong way to think about it. It's correct to an extent, but it's not sufficiently, it doesn't sufficiently understand the nuance of why it is that blockchains are what they are. If that were true, then Bitcoin would have been superseded by Bitcoin Cash and by Bitcoin SV and by Litecoin or whatever, right? We know that these things don't happen in things like Bitcoin. Why don't they happen for Ethereum? And that's what led me to coming up with this metaphor and trying to, I use it informally in a lot of conversations with people when I was trying to explain to them why it's not the case that's a lot of just going to eat everything.
Necessarily, it could be that's a lot of it's everything, but it's not obviously going to happen. And that's why I decided, hey, you know what, I should write this thing up because a lot of people seem to find it a very valuable mental model for understanding their ones. And Hiseba, Bangladesh listeners will know that we are just a complete sucker for mental models and just the actual concrete imagery I think will actually allow people to just grapple on to this concept of using cities and geography as a way to understand a blockchain. So let's just go and get started with unpacking this metaphor.
Why are cities a good mental model for understanding blockchain? Just setting the context for the whole rest of the podcast. Why cities? Yeah, so usually when people describe blockchains, the word they use is network. And the place where I want to start is that network is actually the wrong word to use when you're trying to describe a blockchain. And the reason why is that network brings with it a lot of implications about the other kinds of networks to compare blockchains to. So when you think network, you think like the internet, you think like electricity grid, you think like something like telegram or Facebook, you think of traditional types of networks and traditional networks.
When you add another node to the network, you add another server to Facebook, you add another whatever, you can basically scale and network linearly. It's almost this kind of ethereal thing that can grow as a larger, larger cloud over time. But blockchains are not like that. When you try to make a blockchain larger, the larger you make a blockchain, the more expensive it is for that blockchain to get validated. And there's a bound on how large a blockchain can be, right? Even something like Salana, which tries to be extremely sort of scaled vertically by just saying, the nodes that run Salana are going to be super beefy and highly optimized and have 16 GPUs or whatever it is.
Even for this, there's a limit on how big Salana is going to allow its nodes to be, right? It's arbitrarily scalable, the way that Facebook is arbitrarily scalable or Google is arbitrarily scalable. And so the realities that blockchains, unlike traditional networks, are physically constrained. There's only so big that a blockchain can get per unit time. And that's why we have finite block sizes, and that's why we have this fundamental problem of blockchains, that they cannot get arbitrarily big. And that makes blockchains more like cities. Cities are constrained by the land that they're on. They can grow, they can kind of scale out more and more over time, but they can't get arbitrarily big, right?
You can't have a city the size of an entire country. When you do, naturally, what happens if the city gets cut off in a new city starts at some point, and that's just the nature of how cities evolve. And so if you think of blockchains as cities, what is Ethereum? Everyone complains about Ethereum, right? Ethereum is super expensive, it's super slow, it's congested, everything's super old, things never change, like people are like, oh, what happened to, what about TurboGeth, what about E2.0? Nothing ever seems to actually happen around here. Ethereum is Manhattan. It's a super expensive, or New York City more broadly, it's a super expensive city.
It's super old, it's been around forever, and everyone is ignored. Anyone who goes to Manhattan will just complain nonstop about how, you know, the train sucks, and the infrastructure sucks, and the homeless are everywhere. Everything's too expensive, the rents are crazy, nothing can ever seem to get built, but Manhattan is the most happening place on earth. If you want to be a somebody, and you want to be at the epicenter of the financial activity, and the cultural activity in America, the one place per square foot that that is maximized is in Manhattan. And ultimately, if you want to find the richest people in the US, they're in New York.
If you want to find the most culturally influential people in the US, they're in New York, maybe in LA, but let's say New York. And in the same way, if you look on Ethereum, Ethereum has the biggest whales, or all in Ethereum, the most expensive NFTs are all in Ethereum. The biggest DeFi protocols are all in Ethereum. The biggest Dow's are all in Ethereum. Like Manhattan, slash New York, is like Ethereum in that it is the oldest and most robust place. Now, if you want to go start a new DeFi protocol, the same way, if you want to go start a new bank, if you don't have a headquarters in Manhattan, then you're not serious, right?
You're not going to be playing in the biggest games. Yes, I know Manhattan's expensive. Yes, I know that everything's crowded and everything sucks. But like, look, if you're not there, then you're just not going to be playing in the biggest games. And that's also true today on Ethereum. If you're an emerging DeFi protocol, you might say, look, Ethereum is too expensive. I'm going to go here. I'm going to get a roll-up. I'm going to go to another little one. But it's obviously true today that the vast majority of TVL that exists in DeFi is on Ethereum. Now, if you're a newcomer, and you weren't around in the early days, or you're not super wealthy, or you're not one of the rich and famous or part of the intelligentsia, then you might say, look, it's a little late to me to show up on Ethereum.
The fees are already crazy high. There's no room for people like me. I don't have a rent control department. So if I want to strike out, I can't move to New York. It's just too expensive. I got to go find someplace where I can build my career. And for that marginal person, that marginal entrepreneur, that marginal user, they might say, look, this stuff is too expensive for me. Ethereum is for the billionaires. I got to go somewhere else. So the question there is, how do you scale a city when New York is just, there's only so much land, and not that many more people can go there? So broadly speaking, there are three approaches to scaling blockchains.
And in order they are roll-ups, interoperability networks, and other little ones. So I'll go through each of them in turn. Well, can we just pause here before we go through each of those to see? I want to go back to what you said around the physical constraints, right? And make sure that that is hammered home because, you know, what you said is like Facebook, you can just add servers, you could scale, and blockchains, you can't just add servers in scale. Just to ground people on that, particularly those who are new, why are blockchains physically constraining themselves? So I'm not sure that this necessarily might make sense to someone, but like, are they doing this because there's a trade-off?
Are they doing this because our cryptography isn't good enough? Are they doing this because there's some sort of other bandwidth limitation? Like, why are they even constrained in the first place? That's a great question. So the reason why blockchains constrained themselves is not because you can't build a big distributed system that grows arbitrarily big. The reason why is that the core foundational component of what makes blockchains blockchains is the fact that they are trustless. Now, what does it mean to be trustless? I mean, this could be itself an hour long conversation, but part of what it means to be trustless is that you, yourself, don't have to trust any third party in order to verify that the blockchain has been executed correctly.
No one's cheating. No one's making shit up. No one's creating money out of thin air or deciding to change the rules on the fly. Everything is according to the way that the rules were originally set into place when the blockchain was initially created. That's what everyone wants to know. And so, in order for you not to have to trust a third party, you have to be able to run the computation yourself or verify the computation yourself that what has happened in your corner of the world and your blockchain and everything that touches you has been executed correctly. Now, if the blockchain can only be run by a supercomputer because it's so large and it's so big that all the computations in it cannot be compactly executed or verified on consumer hardware.
The kind of thing that you or I could get our hands on and actually run ourselves, then ultimately you have to trust the third party. You have to trust somebody else who is actually going to go run the supercomputer who is actually going to check all the transactions on the blockchain. Now, you might think that look, I'm okay with trusting a third party because whatever, I want to. But the core philosophy behind Ethereum and not every blockchain shares this philosophy. But the core philosophy behind Ethereum is that individuals should be able to check themselves that everything that happened on the blockchain is correct.
And therefore, that they do not need to rely on any third parties outside of the kind of things you could run on your own consumer hardware without relying on AWS, without relying on the government, without relying on anyone intermediating between yourself and the blockchain. Go ahead. So, blockchains are physically constrained because they are attempting to keep the cost of verification low while also scaling the amount of transaction throughput. So, that's the key there is keeping the cost of verification low. And that's why they can't just like expand indefinitely. That's why they are more like cities because they have some borders.
They have some limitations. They have a set of square miles that they've allocated for themselves and they can't really expand beyond that. Exactly. That's exactly right. And the way that I've thought that a useful way to understand this is that if we want to just scale up a Web2 database, like a Facebook database, we can just arbitrarily add more CPUs, more GPUs, more memory, and it doesn't really matter because generally we're adding that physical hardware into the same spaces as all the other physical hardware. Like Facebook only has so many databases. Google only has so many databases. There's a handful of them, you know, five, I don't know, five to 10-ish.
In blockchains and when we want to have things be trustless, we have an arbitrary number of databases that all need to maintain consensus. They all need to sync up with each other. And so in a Web2 world, when you add hardware to a database because it's centralized, you just linearly add capacity, just resources. But in a blockchain world, because all these locations of these databases are spread around the world, when you add a new computer to the network, when you add a new node to the network, you will on net actually slow down the network. So it's the in Web2, when you add resources, it speeds it up, and Web3, when you add resources, it actually slows it down.
And the way that it slows it down, just to unpack that a little bit more, is that some blockchains accept a certain level of speed with how much data they allow the network to handle. And some networks want to throttle themselves back so that any computer, any reasonable computer that was made in the last five to 10 years, can keep up with the chain. And then other blockchains say like, oh, we only want computers that have been made in the last two years and also are super powerful. We only want those to be able to keep up with the chain. And so it's an inversion. In Web2, when you add network resources, you speed up databases.
But in Web3, when you add network resources, you slow them down because you need to make sure that every single individual is able to keep up with the chain. And the tolerance for how many individuals can keep up with the chain is a spectrum that different blockchains can tinker with as they see fit. Do you want to add anything to that metaphor? No, I think you nailed it. So I think the intuition that most people should be walking away with is that look, different blockchains have different ideas about what that threshold ought to be. How much is it okay to say that this is the kind of hardware or the kind of cost that you need to actually verify the blockchain yourself?
If you're Binance Marchain, then that cost is very, very high. It's very difficult to run a note for Binance Marchain on any kind of consumer hardware. For Solana, it's maybe, you know, similarly quite expensive, but maybe a little bit cheaper than Binance Marchain. And as you go further down the chains with respect to their intrinsic performance requirements, those things get cheaper and cheaper. And charting throws a whole other curveball into this whole story because charting kind of makes a story a little bit more complex. I think it's probably beyond the scope of this particular conversation, because it applies in general even across individual charts about, okay, even within the context of one chart, how big is that chart going to be that you can actually verify it on your own consumer hardware?
Okay. Well, so now let's return to our thread, Hasey, and where you're going. The question of how do you scale up a New York City? How do you scale up, you know, generalize it any city? What are the different paths? You mentioned three of those. And maybe you could reiterate those. And then we could dive into them one by one. Yeah. So if Ethereum is New York, and Ethereum is too crowded, how do we scale up New York? And the three approaches within blockchain land are first roll-ups, second interoperability networks, and third would be other layer ones. So let's start with roll-ups. Roll-ups are the, well, so if you take it to the city analogy, right?
Let's say you're in New York, and you know, it's, I don't know, maybe you're 1900, and you're like, okay, New York is full. Everyone is here, rents are super high, everything sucks. How do we get more people into the city? Because there are a lot of people who want to live here. And the answer, of course, in urban planning, is build up. So start building taller and taller buildings until you culminate in skyscrapers. And skyscrapers are obviously, you know, they're marvel of engineering. They're incredibly complex to actually build and get them to where we are today with skyscraper technology.
But the fundamental thing that skyscrapers do is they allow more people to fit into the same city with the same kind of underlying land because the fact is if you build up, yes, exactly the same footprint on the underlying land. Now putting more people into a city is a beautiful goal. But when you have skyscrapers, when you have a city full of skyscrapers, the reality is that, so one, although a lot of people have managed now to be able to move into the city because they can live up above the underlying ground, each person who enters into the city through the skyscraper, they require less overall land, but they still tax the underlying resources of the land to some degree.
If you have people living on the ground floor and then you add another layer on top. Great, you now have a two-story building and new people come into that two-story building. The overall utilization of the city has increased much less than it would be if you had to add more, you know, those people on the ground floor, but it's increased somewhat. It's increased very, very slightly. And as you keep adding more and more layers, you can add people more and more cheaply. But the experience of those people, if I come in and live in a skyscraper in Manhattan, it's maybe nice because we've added a lot of extra rooms, there's a lot of vacancies, rents can go down now that we've added more land, or not more land, but more rooms, rather.
But the downside of living in a skyscraper, of course, is that if you live in a skyscraper, and I live in a skyscraper, and I want to come see you, I have to go down my skyscraper, get on the ground floor, go hail a taxi, get across town, pay the tolls along the way, and come to your skyscraper and go up all the flights of your stairs to go find you. And by the way, in New York, it takes like one hour to go like three miles. That's right. It's a huge pain in the ass, right? We do not get to escape the fundamental constraints of the city we live in if you and I live in different skyscrapers, which we most likely will, if there are going to be a lot of different skyscrapers in the city.
So now what's the blockchain equivalent of that? It's roll-ups. You know, Vitalik has claimed that roll-ups are the future of Ethereum scaling, right? We now have this full capitulation and destroyer of Ethereum, I want to say 2.0. The future of Ethereum that post-sharding Ethereum is not going to have native execution on its charts. It's instead going to be a roll-up centric view of how Ethereum is going to scale. And so what that means is that these roll-ups, so roll-ups, I mean, I can't probably be on the scope of this to exactly describe the mechanics of roll-ups, but long story short, they are scaling solutions.
They're like kind of mini baby blockchains that emerge from the underlying blockchain with the security properties of that underlying blockchain. They sort of obey the institutions and the trust properties of that underlying blockchain. In the same way, if you live in a skyscraper in Manhattan, you might have some rules for living in the building, but you're still fundamentally living in Manhattan. All the rules of Manhattan apply to you. And all the trust model, all the taxes, all the whatever. You're still a member of Manhattan just because you live in a skyscraper. You might have extra rules on top of it, but you fundamentally still live in the same city.
The same thing applies in a roll-up. A roll-up extends out from a layer one. Everyone who lives in that roll-up has the same trust guarantees as the underlying layer one that they're operating on, which in this case would be Ethereum. But things are a lot cheaper, things are faster, things are more scalable. Now, they're not infinitely cheaper or infinitely faster. And there's some non-roll-up designs like Volition or Volidium that might have very, very, very high scalability properties. For most roll-ups, it's a very significant factor increases like 10X or 20X or something like that. But it's not 1,000X or 2,000X or anything like that for most of the roll-up designs that exist today.
So all that is to say, roll-ups have the same issue that I just described in a skyscraper. If we're in a roll-up, if I'm in a roll-up and you're in a roll-up and we're not in the same roll-up, then if I want to transact with you, I have to exit from my roll-up, go down to layer one, transfer across layer one, and then go up into your roll-up to go and transact with you. Now, there are other solutions like Crossring Bridges. You can imagine, you know, there's maybe, you know, got to like the, you know, those... Sky Bridges? You have the Sky Bridges? Yeah, Sky Bridges, yeah, that's what they're called.
You can imagine like some Sky Bridge-type things, type contraptions. But, you know, if you want to move an enormous amount of stuff across the Sky Bridges, maybe you can't do it, right? Like, it's somewhat complicated with these Cross Bridges. These Cross Chain Bridges, they can't bridge exactly everything. There are some things that can't be bridged. Some of the Sky Bridges... Some of the Sky Bridges look a bit more like tightrope, right? Exactly, exactly. Exactly, exactly. It's not quite... It's a very narrow Sky Bridge, at least today, and I think there's some fundamental reasons why those Sky Bridges have to be narrow, because of liquidity that's needed for the different assets that you might want to bridge on each layer, too.
But at the end of the day, Sky Skippers are great. They're a huge improvement on what you can build inside of a city. But Sky Skippers are not themselves... If you think about it, like, okay, we've got Sky Skippers now in big cities. But not everybody lives in Manhattan or New York, even though we have a lot of Sky Skippers, right? There is only so much you can get in cheapness from living in a Sky Skipper in New York, right? Like, fundamentally, living in a Sky Skipper in New York is never going to be cheaper than living in, you know, just some random town in Virginia. And that's a fundamental property of the fact that you have to be taking up space in Manhattan.
There is some externality for you being there that is imposed by your presence in the city. And if you want to get to the place where basically you're paying, you know, some small town in Virginia type rent, or let's say, you know, some new layer one type fees, which can be, you know, in the fractions of a cent, you're never going to get that on a roll-up. It doesn't matter how beautiful or how well designed the roll-up is going to be, or at least, you know, to a first approximation. If it's truly a roll-up, and it actually is posting transaction data on-chain, which all roll-ups do, then you're never going to get it to be that cheap compared to an underlying layer one transaction.
And that's why roll-ups are themselves probably not the end of the story on scaling. Every city eventually, as it grows, has Sky Skippers, but Sky Skippers are not themselves alone enough to say, okay, great, everyone's going to live in one city, and that's the end of the story. Okay. And that's why we have to explore other solutions. So this is the building-up approach. This is what you would consider just to classify, which, you know, chains you would consider doing this Ethereum, you would say, is doing this building-up method. Any blockchain, maybe that's taking this modular blockchain design type of method where they're scaling up with roll-ups, like maybe a near or a tezos is probably taking this approach.
Are there any others that come to mind? I think those are the main ones. And the reality, of course, is that the one that needs it most desperately is Ethereum, because right now, you know, it's almost like the year is 1850, and New York is the one city that's starting to, you know, push up against the boundaries, but almost everything else is still frontier. And as a result, you know, when prices are still cheap, and people are building new housing every single day, and like things are growing, and cities are on the rise, there's not a lot of need to start figuring out how to build Sky Skippers.
It's only the demand for Sky Skippers, I mean, you can sort of see this, right? Like Plasma, which was the first layer two that was seriously considered for Ethereum, that was going to scale kind of general computation, Plasma was first, or I'm sorry, Plasma originally was not general computation, but eventually there were designs for general computation. Plasma was first announced and explored in 2017, when Ethereum started getting congestion. And of course, almost every other blockchain today is not seriously facing congestion, except, you know, maybe in times of, you know, total turmoil, like what we saw, you know, a couple last weekend during the market downturn.
But generally speaking, most of these blockchains have tons of headroom, so there's not actually a burning need the way there is for Ethereum today to build vertically, at least not yet. One thing I really appreciate about this metaphor is a couple things. The subway system in New York, his debut kind of talks about the New York infrastructure, but coming from Seattle, the level of degree of New York's public transportation infrastructure is just astounding to me. And well, and it's got this fantastic, just mesh network of subways connecting, you know, skyscraper to skyscraper, and that feels like the Ethereum L1, where you're not supposed to be in the subways are not where you live, like that's not where you spend your time, you just are there while you are going from more desirable place to more desirable place.
The more desirable place is being the buildings, the ones that are building up vertically, and even though, like, you know, you can build a pretty damn tall building with a ton of apartment units in it, but at some point you approach physics, where we cannot build an infinitely tall skyscraper. We can innovate, but at some point the laws of physics get in our way. And so that to me is like what a roll up centric roadmap looks like. We have all of these machines that are faring people and their stuff from skyscraper to skyscraper, and then the skyscrapers have built up to the match the demand as much as they can of the people that want to live in Manhattan and are willing to pay to live in Manhattan.
And that's how we get scale. And so we have these very, very vertical skyscrapers that are being coordinated by the roots of the city, which are the subways, which are like the faring of value between roll up to roll up. That's kind of how I think of Ethereum in this city metaphor. I think that's absolutely right. I think in a post-sharing universe that if we do actually see this roll up centric roadmap be delivered, that's what Ethereum is going to look like. Now, the big thing, of course, about that vision, if you imagine a vision of a city where basically everyone either is in a skyscraper or they're in a subway, it sounds like a slightly dystopian vision of a city.
And I think part of the reason why you're actually seeing so much demand for some other approach beyond just, okay, we're all in shards and then we move in between these roll ups, is that it's very complex because you don't have the composability that right now, right now, Ethereum is basically one of these old-timey cities where you just walk down the street and there's courses where old ladies selling their wares and there's a park over here and you can walk around the park and there's an ice skating rink over there. It has a kind of dynamism that comes from composability. And in this post-roll up world, one of the things that you give up by having a world where it's all these vertical skyscrapers and a subway system that connects them is you give up that composability that is defining characteristic of Ethereum today.
So obviously within a skyscraper, everything's composable because, you know, you can say, oh, great, you know, this floor has the gym and has the swimming pool and has this thing. But in the vibrancy that we get from cities, unless we see something like where there's one super dominant roll up or maybe two super dominant roll ups, within which the composability is enough. So there's one giant sort of snow globe that is kind of one mega roll up and there's almost like an entire city embedded in that in that in that roll up. It's too early to say it's too early to really know, but I think it's one of the reasons one of the weaknesses, I'd say, of this vision of blockchains is that lack of composability.
Okay, well, let's move to the second approach for blockchain scalability, which you teased and you mentioned. So this is interoperability network. So this is kind of the cosmos polka dot type of approach where you have this internet of change, this network of chains and they're all linked in some way. Can you talk about that approach to scalability and the pros and cons that you see. Yeah, so if you take, okay, so let's take for granted that skyscrapers are coming, but let's see what other ways are there to scale New York aside from skyscrapers. Now, one approach that is one of the classic approaches to scaling blockchains.
I mean, this has been going on since, you know, 2017, 2016 is this idea of let's create an internet of blockchain so that other blockchains can help scale the sort of the excess the overage from Ethereum. And this was the original vision behind polka dot and cosmos and increasingly what you see today is that the way that polka dot and cosmos have kind of oriented themselves is that instead of really focusing on, okay, let's connect up Ethereum to a bunch of other chains. What they really focus on is let's create a network of blockchains that all obey the same kind of SDK that have the same kind of underlying sort of infrastructure and underlying guts.
And you can really easily spin up a new blockchain that only does one thing. These are often called application specific blockchains. So you can imagine that someday make it out could have its own blockchain or compound can have its own blockchain. In fact, compound was talking about this with, uh, uh, gateway, I think, yeah, compound cash. Oh, no, that was the, yeah, right. Yep. Yep. Sorry. We're just going to be on top of gateway. Cash cash would be the native. So there are many, many applications that have contemplated the idea of creating their own blockchains and becoming these application specific blockchains that connect back to Ethereum.
Now, the vision, and this is only, you know, you talk to the folks at cosmos or the folks at polka dot, they'll tell you is that, you know, the idea that you're going to have one big super city that's going to encompass everything. That's just never going to work. That's not going to scale. That's not how, it's not how modern distributed systems are built. They're built with lots of individual systems that talk to each other asynchronously, right? And so you will have, according to these people, you will have a lot of small blockchains that do one thing and that talks to each other over some interface, whether that be through the polka dot relay chain, whether that be through the cosmos, cosmos hub or through osmosis or whatever, through, through IBC.
And you're going to have lots of individual chains that do only one thing. And that's how smart contracts are going to scale. Some things will live in Ethereum. Sure. If you really need to be in the metropolis, sure fine, be in the metropolis. But lots and lots of industries are going to take place in these small applications specific chains. The way that today, most applications on the internet, they don't take place in common servers, right? You go to CNN.com and they run their own server. And you go to AT&T.com or you go to Apple.com and they run their own server. And everyone has their own machine.
That's the vision of application specific blockchains. Now, the equivalent analogy that I give in the city's metaphor is that applications specific blockchains are kind of like factory towns. Or they're kind of like sort of a town that's just just as one thing. So you can imagine a town that's like just, you know, just has outlet stores and nothing else. And there's maybe a gas station or a town that's like, you know, just a mining town. And everyone here is mining or everyone here is like, you know, there's an oil rig and everyone here works for that oil rig. And the town exists only to do one thing.
And it's not a generalized, you know, cosmopolitan place, the way that we think about a place like Ethereum. So if this is the right mental model for these types of chains, then what I argue is that, look, I think it's very likely that we will see some application specific blockchains. The application specific blockchains that we see today are pretty small though, right? So, you know, one example of it is something like osmosis. Osmosis is a cosmos SDK based chain that only does one thing. It's just a big, basically, it's basically equivalent of balancer. It's a big, giant balancer thing that exists on Cosmos SDK, connects to other cosmos chains across this big highway system.
That is the cosmos, cosmos, you know, IPC routing system. It only does one thing and it does it pretty well, you know, it's pretty good at being this kind of cosmos balancer thing. But that's it. It's not, you know, there's not a whole universe of things happening on top of osmosis. It only does one thing. And it's likely that things like this will exist. But I don't think it's likely that this is going to be the lion's share of activity. And if you sort of think about the city's metaphor, it drives you in the same direction. There are, you know, towns that only just, you know, mile everyone works for some oil rig.
Well, there are towns that like everyone here works for this one office of this one company that happens to have a factory nearby. But they are not the lion's share of where people live. They're not the lion's share of where economic activity happens. They're not the lion's share of economic innovation. They're important. They're a part of the landscape. But it's very clear that cities are really important. Cities is where almost everything happens because of the fact that they're these tightly connected, very dynamic, very interconnected places. And those interconnections is what creates innovation, economic opportunity.
And, you know, if you live on osmosis and all you can do is trade, you know, one different, you know, cosmos based token for another, that's useful. But there's not a lot of creativity that's going to merge out of cosmos. And it's very clear. The reason why cities and, you know, later on blockchains become so valuable is because of all the innovation that's occurred on top of them. And that's why I think, although these, you know, sort of application specific blockchains exist, they are not going to be the most important part of the scaling story. So you are bullish metropolis and bearish, like, you know, one factory towns.
I mean, bearish is a strong word, right? It's sort of relative to the price. If you look, I mean, if you look today at the landscape of layer ones, or sorry, the landscape of public blockchains, you can see, you know, look at the top 100. There aren't that many applications, there are blockchains there, which it's kind of like the market is telling you that they don't really value the application specific blockchains very highly. And I roughly disagree with it. I'm not saying that I think osmosis is going to do badly from where it's sitting or these other application specific blockchains are going to do badly from where they're sitting.
I just don't think they're going to be the lion's share of where value is created in public blockchains. Okay. So when we look around the distribution of cities in the United States or the world at large, we see many, many cities of the type like Manhattan, like LA, like Seattle, like Chicago, but I'm trying to think of a like company town or mining town that I know the name of and I don't really know the name of one. So perhaps like the distribution. And if we want to take like physical real estate land geography, I think that would equate to block space. And really what do blockchains do blockchains sell blocks.
There's not that much physical real estate that is claimed by the world of specific like one use case cities like a mining town. And so perhaps if we extrapolate out to the end game of whatever this crypto industry morphs into perhaps application specific blockchains only take up a relatively minor portion of the total block space demand. Would you agree with all that? Yes, not just that they're going to take up a relatively small amount of total demand. The demand that they're going to be competing for is going to be valued less highly, which is, which is an important distinction right you can imagine that actually a lot of the US has taken up by like wind farms and you know, things that take up a lot of space, but that space is not in high contention.
No one is fighting for that space in the same way. The trades on osmosis are really cheap and they're really cheap because not a lot of other people are trying to do things on osmosis other than just trade on osmosis. But if osmosis lived on Ethereum or on Terra or on some other, you know, blockchain that had more contention for that same underlying land that underlying block space that underlying resource, then you would see things be more expensive. Yes, like metropolis space per square mile per square foot is much more valuable than like some rural geography right from a real estate perspective.
And like I think you have to go back to why people choose to live in the city that they choose to live in. There are many factors quality of life, you know culture would if they enjoy culture all sorts of things, but also economic opportunity is a is a massive driver of where individuals choose to locate like where are the jobs where the good jobs right. And I think that's another driver that that probably comes into play you're not going to find the same type of job in a small rural town as you are in Manhattan or LA or some other metropolis and that factors in. So let's talk about the third path then because there are three paths here.
What is the third path here? This is more cities has seen what are you talking about more cities we could just build more of these things. Turns out you know when when New York got full or I guess it was originally Boston in the history of America when the first city gets full people know what to do. And the answer is you go build a new freaking city and the history of cities is obviously that there is not just one city in every single country. There are many cities and interestingly what you often see is that the cities tend to be far away from each other and they tend to become very different from each other.
And so you know the two major cities in the US are New York and LA and LA is really far from New York. It's literally the absolute opposite as far as you could possibly get from New York and it's really different the culture of LA is completely different than New York. Now when you build a new city the first thing about building a new city is that there's a lot of stuff you have to do all over again. It's a lot of redundancy right when you start a new city you have to start with building a bunch of basic infrastructure. You have to go in you have to build you know there needs to be plumbing there needs to be roads there needs to be a police station there needs to be all sorts of kind of bazaars.
Exactly you need basic infrastructure in order for people to actually be able to live there. Like if there are no schools if there is no you know fire stations if there's no any of the stuff then people are not going to want to move to this new city. So initially when you first start a new city there's a lot of just you know infrastructure plumbing redundant work that needs to be done that you don't need to do when you're building a skyscraper and you don't need to do when you're building a you know like a factory town or like a wind farm or whatever. And so initially it might look that building a new city actually seems really wasteful we already we already have great hospitals and great police stations and great roads in Manhattan why are we doing all this all over again.
But the advantage of building all that infrastructure over again is that you are not burdened by this sort of technical debt let's call it or like the bad decisions that were made by those older cities and that's why you often see when you have older cities that eventually get too big and someone goes and starts. The newer city is much faster it's much cleaner it's more efficient it's better it's laid out more intelligently whereas the older city kind of you know it's a sort of process of accretion and things going to get bolted on and everything's like it's got this complicated story of like why is it that the train doesn't go here and like it goes does this crazy loop de loop before it can go to this other thing it's like look it's so hard to explain it's something happened like 70 years ago and like blah blah blah something about World War two like whatever just deal with it.
And when you sort of new city it's a blank slate you can do everything over again from first principles and with the tools of kind of modern civil engineering and science and whatever. And so when you when you see the equivalent of new cities in blockchains those are that's what new their ones are that's what all these new emerging their ones are we New York was full and so we decided to create L.A. To create Boston we decided to create you know Chicago and and Houston and all these other cities and now you know to my point about infrastructure one thing that you notice with all these new their ones especially when they're new is that a lot of infrastructure is missing.
So it's like okay where the block explores why can't I see the smart contract code on chain you know why why are the RPC endpoints so so crappy why isn't there you know a good either scan or good to analytics or a good you know good security tooling or good you know developer experience all this stuff needs to get rebuilt for these. And you know some of them can can kind of piggyback on theory with the use of yeah but but even still there's a lot of infrastructure that that is missing no matter how similar you make it to to the original city and but the advantage of building a whole new city is that you get to start over with institutions.
The institutions of New York are very conservative in a lot of ways because New York is old very stalwart city has been around for a very long time is built on you know this global finance this this you know this incredible pedigree that comes with being. You know descended from New York something with London something with all these very legendary massive cities. When you start a new city you can kind of say look we don't need to be what New York is we can be more nimble we can have different values we can have different perspectives we can value different things we can be governed differently right one of the things that you notice about California versus New York is that the way in which laws are laid out that govern California very different than what goes on in New York and so.
The way that I like in these cities and I have these very specific analogies I'm sure we'll go back and forth on but I compare Solana to L.A. And the reason why I compare Solana to L.A. is that Solana is like this look you know Solana went as far west as you can go right Solana said look New York those guys over in the east goes that cares so much about decentralization they're so you know up their own asses constantly talking about how nation's data tax blah blah blah but I look fundamentally I know what people want what people want is they want entertainment. They want fast key transactions they want everything you know straight you know fed down the tube of their TVs that's what people really want and I'm going to give it to them I'm going to go to the most beautiful you know the most beautiful and sunniest place in the world exactly is manicured place where all the you know the people who want their 10 minutes of fame they can come up to Solana everything's cheap everything's fast and like we're for the builders right that's a world about and if you want to be a gaming project and have tea project but we are we are the best place for you.
Everything is cheap and fast and we're going to sit down with you are going to help you help you make it happen and for those people who are not too fixated on decentralization and they don't think that that's the be all and all for a lot of them they say like great that's an awesome vision I love that vision and it's almost as polar opposite as you can get within the within the scope of all the you know the kind of big dominant ones Solana is kind of as far as you can get from from Ethereum and in many ways you can also see it within New York. Within New York or sorry within crypto the the two biggest layer one blockchains are Ethereum and Solana in the same way the two biggest cities in the US are New York and L.
A. Now I keep going down the list and giving more examples I can stop there I can keep going. So I was just going to bring that up yeah so you list off some other cities and some other blockchains that you think resemble block blockings that resemble certain cities and so I think that's just a fantastic game so let's keep on going with that. Sure sure so the the next on the list that I put on there is avalanche is not literally the next blockchain and market cap it's the one that I think is worth putting in this list. So avalanche the way that you can that I like to announce avalanches avalanches like Chicago so Chicago is the third largest city in the US and of course Chicago you know it kind of has this it is sort of a financing city like New York.
It doesn't have quite all the same kind of cultural sophistication that New York has but it's an aggressive city it's a fast growing city it's a newer city and it's one that is ultimately it's made a name for itself by being really really good at what it does. And in the same way I think avalanches kind of this finance oriented up in commerce very aggressive it's it has this kind of very brusque identity but it's look we're going to be the next generation of Wall Street we're going to take the we're going to take the wind out of the sales of Ethereum and be the future of what you know Wall Street wants to do.
You know it's a little cold in Chicago say way it's you know avalanche obviously is a snowy game and they like to use a lot of cold metaphors so I felt like it was very appropriate to to brand them as Chicago and then the the the the next one I put on that list is San Francisco. There is actually not one of the one of the largest cities actually they're pretty far down the list actually but in terms of cultural significance I think it's pretty obvious that San Francisco is enormous in terms of its cultural roadmap or so it's impact on the overall culture and on the overall country by GDP and the same thing is true in many ways for near near is actually pretty low on the list of total TVL chains at least right now.
But you can obviously see in terms of price it's it's moved dramatically or especially over the last couple months and and near I now just San Francisco where near is this near actually very much embraces this ethereum 2.0 vision is that you know look near we are you know charting before a theorem can ever get to charting we are the decentralization maximalist we're the idealist about what technology can accomplish you know we're a bunch of like X Google and XM SQL engineers we're trying to build this next generation of tech. And we're true believers in that decentralization vision it's not there yet we're on our way and I kind of analogize that to like okay you guys are trying to build the future it's very you know idealistic much in the way of San Francisco so those are the blockchains that I do into the post but you know it's a it's a game that we can we can take further if if if it makes sense to yeah I want to know what the random town Virginia which blockchain that is a seed.
Ryan took that one personally. Oh shit I didn't realize I live in a random town Virginia. Okay but no offense taken yeah I totally get it but what can I ask you a question right because this this is interesting a lot of people frame different chains and bankless has we have in the past as taking a completely different trade offs. But I think you're saying a little bit like yeah and that's the point these cities are making different trade offs right you're saying LA is going to completely different direction in New York. But what they're all after is sort of the same fundamental things they want population growth they want economic growth they want you know prosperity they want more more citizens I suppose more GDP for their city so they're all competing.
Over the same types of resources and the same metrics and yes of course they are all making different trade offs would you agree with that these these cities are all making different trade offs but they're all after the same thing. Yes to an extent right so the classic way that the multi chain story has often been betrayed or portrayed is that it's a zero some battle and the zero some battle is basically that. Who's going to be the dominant blockchain and whoever picked the right trade offs is ultimately the one that's going to be dominant right that's the traditional network effects model of blockchains that there's going to be one that's the right one and everyone else is basically going to die off or be a ghost town.
And the vision that I'm painting here is a different vision it's a vision that look New York and LA obviously in some sense computer where people because some people decide whether to live in New York or whether to live in LA. But when you see that there's a lot of you know when you see out outflows today not you know 100 years ago but today from New York or from LA it's actually not that common that people from LA go to New York. But the people from New York go to LA that's usually actually not what happens what happens is that people in New York go to other places in New York or you know they go to get or they go to Jersey or city or whatever and same thing in California if you don't like LA you go to San Diego you know you go to some other place in California.
And the reason why is that ultimately I think what is going to end up happening in blockchains this is kind of the prediction the underlying prediction of this model is that the different places in the trade off spectrum. Actually are going to attract mostly different people the vent diagram there's some people who are going to be look I just want to be in the best city and if New York's the best city is the most happening city I'm going to go there and if it's LA I'm going to go there and like I don't really care about the underlying culture or the underlying values the underlying whatever. But a lot of people are going to find that the cities are so different they house such different applications such different kinds of people such different use cases that actually it's like look if if I want to be you know playing games.
Then I'm going to be on salon either way and if I don't use a lot I'm going to choose some other thing that's going to make a similar set of tradeoffs I'm never going to be going on a theory to play games it's just not the place for games. And in the same way like look if I want to go be an actor maybe actor is not a good example since they both have acting but you know let's say that I want to you know be in. Hollywood is more the Hollywood yeah okay I guess Hollywood is if I want to if I want to make movies right like I mean obviously there's there's there's there's you know the sort of play acting or like a Broadway which is in New York but if you want to be in movies there is one place to be and that's LA and if you are not in LA and you're not making movies like you're just you know what are you doing like it's just the wrong place to be.
And I think in that sense you will find that as blockchains as these emerging little ones grow the prediction from this model is that one they will become more distinct from each other. Initially when they all start they're all kind of the same right because they all just a big pile of roads and a police station and you know whatever it's all just you know it's a block explorer and then a you know a Twitter account that's like talking about how great it is but eventually and you've already seen this. The communities are getting more and more different they're becoming more and more. Very agitated over time and as they do that they're going to track different communities different industries different kinds of developers different kinds of applications and if that happens then the substitute ability of these cities for each other will go down over time.
And you won't say okay I don't like a theory and therefore I'm going to go move over to near what you will say instead is that like hey near is like really good for. I don't know decentralized social media or you know some other thing that is not the thing that a theory is dominantly used for and vice versa. Do you think there will be some power law winners here. Yes I do and I think again this is another prediction of this city's model which is why I like it because it predicts a lot of things simultaneously. What it predicts is that look when you look at cities you do observe a power law. In every single country there is one most dominant city and that city is usually at least twice as big as the next largest city.
Almost always very rare there are two cities that are almost exactly the same size and you see that in the U.S. right in the U.S. New York is like some like eight million people and then L.A. is like three point something million people New York is almost twice as big as L.A. and you see in and it falls down and then there is one point something Chicago is maybe two million and then Houston is like one point five million or something I don't know exactly the numbers is something in this ballpark. In a way is almost exactly what we see with their ones with their ones we see that a theory is huge and then after that so on is pretty big and then we see these other ones that are somewhat small and then it really falls off a cliff after you start going further down the list right but it looks like the power law distribution looks very similar to what we see with respect to cities.
And so you know to count if you take the holistic view of this model the reason why I like this model so much is that it almost perfectly describes what we actually see. What we actually see in terms of layer one blockchains their utility or sorry I should say their utilization their prices and their value is that. Matt you know the cities the big cities are we're almost all the values right so like the theory on salana near avalanche terror etc all those cities are hugely valuable but concentrate mostly in the theory and then it kind of falls it goes down a curve after that and if you go further further down the list of cities those cities are not valuable at all they're very very small.
Right second is that when it comes to roll ups or or you know the the skyscrapers skyscrapers are important we're seeing lots and lots of investment in the skyscrapers as you would expect as it is growing really large but you know the largest skyscraper which today is our term has way less economic activity inside of it than L.A. Which is maybe not surprising if this analogy is correct and then third is that the application specific blockchains which are the factory towns like you know something like osmosis are tiny compared to all this other stuff going on within layer ones and there to their tiny blip in the overall economic picture of what's going on on public blockchains.
And see you make a you're going through some of the predictions that you concretely write out in your in your paper which is basically what we are going through right now in this podcast but there's one prediction that we haven't touched on yet and that's the very very last one which is that cross chain bridges will be extremely valuable can you unpack this element of your thought and mental model here why why are bridges so valuable. So this one this one I think doesn't follow directly from the analogy but I think it's it's one that's not a far leap from the analogy so crossing bridges are basically ways that you can connect up between two chains or two cities or you know even two skyscrapers that matter and in a world where the distance between those two blockchains is very large and very treacherous what what you actually have seen in order for us to get the massive sprawling infrastructure that we have in the U.
S. there was an enormous investment into a highway system. And the highway system that was you know built by the government is obviously very very valuable before we had that you know we had roads and railroads and railroads of course were extremely valuable so those valuable businesses in the world before you know the you know the basically the highway system was built and totally made public and transportation across the U.S. became much cheaper and of course before that it was canals and canals were extremely valuable and you know because they were effectively the choke point for a huge amount of commerce.
And in the same way if there's any good analogy if you've drawn here you know transportation is one of the most one of the largest industries in every developed economy and transportation in the realm of public blockchains is basically bridges it's how you connect assets and even potentially you know smart contract execution from one chain to another chain if you're going to see more and more distribution across the landscape in crypto across different ones and their twos and applications blockchains then the connective tissue that connects up all the stuff is going to be very very valuable in the way the railroads are valuable in the way that canals were valuable so that's it's again it's not a direct consequence of this but it's a prediction that I think is probably going to I think probably going to come true.
The layer two era is upon us Ethereum's layer two ecosystem is growing every day and we need L2 bridges to be fast and efficient in order to live a layer two life across is the fastest and cheapest and most secure cross chain bridge with across you don't have to worry about the long wait times or high fees to get your assets back to the layer one assets are bridge and available for use almost instantaneously across this bridges are powered by UMA's optimistic Oracle to securely transfer tokens from layer two back to Ethereum across is critical ecosystem infrastructure and ownership is being handed over to the community you can be a part of the story of across by joining the discord and becoming a co founder and helping to design the fair fair launch of across if you want to bridge your assets quickly and securely go to across dot t o to bridge your assets between Arbitram or boba networks.
Polygon is Ethereum's largest and most vibrant scaling solution to date with millions of monthly users and all of the biggest DeFi apps the polygon ecosystem has turned into a blossoming metropolis of DeFi activity transactions on polygon are quick and cheap allowing users the freedom to achieve their DeFi goals all while being economically anchored to Ethereum. But polygon isn't just the proof of stake side chain the polygon team is building a suite of scaling solutions including polygon hermys miden nightfall and zero all with different design choices in order to be optimized for all possible crypto use cases if you're a developer who wants to build on the polygon ecosystem go to the link in the show notes to check out their fantastic documentation and if you're a user who just wants to experience fast and cheap DeFi you can bridge over your eith or other tokens and start playing around with any of the thousands of applications that are available on polygon.
Living a bankless life requires taking control of your own private keys not your keys not your crypto that's why so many in the bankless nation already have their ledger hardware wallet but the ledger ecosystem is much more than just a secure hardware wallet ledger is the combination of the ledger hardware wallet the ledger live app and soon the CL crypto life card powered by ledger the CL card powered by ledger is a crypto debit card with powerful features like an instant exchange to fiat where crypto assets are only sold at the moment that you swipe your card and also credit from crypto collateral.
Where you can collateralize your crypto assets in order to get a higher credit limit would be able to manage your CL card powered by ledger inside the ledger live app right next to all the DeFi apps and services that you're already used to using making the ledger live app your one stop shop for all of your financial needs go to ledger.com grab a ledger and download ledger live to get all of your DeFi applications all in one place. There's a ton of residents that Ryan and I have had with these mental models but there's also a few tweaks that we want to make so we want to dive into how we would tweak these these ideas and concepts to the way that we see this playing out it's mostly the same as it's 80% the same.
But instead of cities we've seen blockchains crypto economic networks as nations nation states not necessarily cities and the reason why we we think that we see blockchains to be cities especially ones that take the modular approach is that to us the L2 the roll ups take the take the role of of cities where the Ethereum L1 takes the role of like the federal. The federal government right the coordinating body behind all the cities and that's why you can drive from New York to L.A. without ever going through a security checkpoint you don't actually ever have to cross a border you can cross state borders but like no one's there checking in on you saying like hey can I see your documentation.
And this the way that this this works is that because every single city which I'm and we're kind of learning the lines between cities and states here. Every single state slash city is all abiding by the same central protocol and that is the Ethereum L1 and so you're saying the same citizenship that you have inside of you know L.A. is the same citizenship that you have inside of New York. And you you mentioned earlier about how Boston was actually like the epicenter of the United States and then also we have Washington DC where like literally everything is decided but let's go ahead with and just a you know to discount all the ways that this metaphor breaks down when we make it extremely concrete we'll just assume that the epicenter United States was New York because it kind of is.
When people decided to move out of New York New York was settled in like the 1650 something and then we made the Constitution of the United States like almost a hundred years later and the Constitution of the United States set the rules for how people can freely migrate across all the states across all the cities or perhaps across all the roll ups and so where Ethereum the L1 has like this EVM the the central guiding protocol that allows for all. These different cities to sync up on their central notes right and so all of these states collapse down to the central the federal res the federal government and so we are all of these cities or in states inside of the United States of America all abide by the same central protocol which is the Ethereum L1 and that makes interstate highways free of free for trades free trade between states like you don't actually have to pay taxes.
But to go trade between states not not to the federal reserve and you also have all of the same rights that you do when you go from state to state and city to city and this starts to that breaks down when you go across a border and so like we all will have. The United States of America be the United States and then like Solana can be Canada and you actually have there's friction going across the border like you actually aren't guaranteed to have it like be able to pass through that and while users can freely consider themselves like a citizen of any single L1 and all of them simultaneously assets are the things that are actually have prominence right if you an asset is born on Ethereum.
Then if you want to migrate that using a cross chain bridge a multi-sig bridge going from United States to Canada United States and Mexico or to Europe you actually have to ask permission and you need to go through a permission bridge and that is the difference between a multi-sig bridge where you have a set of signers which is how you cross across blockchains versus a roll L2 roll up cryptographic bridge which has as far as my understanding goes much more bandwidth. So you have to allow for things on the L1 to pass up to the L2 and so there's friction between these borders and that's because Canada abides by some certain set of raw of laws it is a particular protocol and America abides by a certain set of laws that is its protocol and these laws are asynchronous and so you so you have to actually go to a nation state and some nation states have really good partnerships perhaps like it's actually way easier to go from Ethereum to avalanche because they are abide by a very common set of principles the EVM and that's why transportation across things like United States to Canada are actually relatively easy because we actually have shared culture but going from the United States to some like country like Iraq gets a lot harder because we do not have shared protocols shared laws we operate on different rules.
How do you feel about this tweaking of the metaphor? How has this landed with you? So I like it and I think by kind of zooming out a level and kind of saying like okay we're actually let's pull everything up one kind of level of size you end up at an interesting place whereas you were talking about you can start contextualizing the relationships between layer ones as I like your analogy of like well yes you're absolutely right. There is more interoperability much easier between avalanche and Ethereum because they share this common language of the EVM which is kind of similar to like how Canada the US share common culture and common legal norms although it gets like I'm I think at the same time though it is a little bit early to start calling alliances between layer one blockchains because I think we we don't actually really know how it's going to play out right like I think it's it's it's sort of like you know it's the year is still.
The year is still like you know 1790 and you know France maybe just help us out a little bit but it's a kind of like okay well I don't really know what you want to do with us now that you got us out of this war. And I kind of feel like that's a little bit of how the L ones are looking at each other today is that look everyone starts friendly because they're like what's the point of not being friendly but as competition ramps up we may see slightly less friendliness over time it's it's hard to say. But yeah I think your analogy also works very well and capture some other elements of how the the different ones relate to each other.
The other I guess question I have about I'm kind of the the multi chain world in the multi chain idea and like we can get a bit more concrete we don't have to stay with the city's analogy although I do think nation states maybe. implies this better is the topic of security so you know all of these cities all of these chains let's say have to fund their own security budget their own military right and this is this is more than like a police force this is an actual military because you know police forces mostly for enforcing the law. In a population you know your city a military you're actually fighting external forces right so like you know the US might have to fight another country or something or some other country might have to attack the US right you have to defend against that as a nation state.
And that it seems like is the primary cost of running a layer one running a blockchain is security cost and you pay for it in one of two ways either pay for it via issuance so you mint new tokens and those assets are worth something the layer one assets. Or you fund it through transaction fees and the minting of new tokens the transaction fees they either go to the military in the form of miners or they go into the military in form of like validators right in all blockchains basically work this way so you have a security budget. And so I guess the question for me or what i've struggled with with the multi chain thesis is how is a layer one going to compete against a layer two.
When the layer two doesn't actually have to fund itself so the nice thing about being a layer two is you kind of get the military for free right so like you're just again if layer ones are nation states you're in the US you know and a layer two is a city like San Francisco or L.A. The nice thing is New York City L.A. they don't need their own militaries they just depend on Washington DC and the federal government right and but if you are spinning up your own country you have to have a sizable military I think not necessarily to take on the US but to build your network effect because I think there is a.
There is an idea here and i'm wondering if you agree with this idea that applications and users will go to the highest security blockchain that will be the chain that wins so the chain that has the highest security will eventually be the dominant chain and that may or may not be true but that I think is an underpinning of this thesis and if that's the case then yeah I mean basically change that become money they're underlying assets become a monetary asset of. Some sort they're able to create the highest security budget they will attract the power law the vast majority of all of the value and other chains won't and it particularly because those other chains will have to compete against layer two is that pay nothing for security.
What do you think of that how does security budget factor into the multi chain thesis that you have to see. Yeah so there are a lot of things there and I want to make sure I get to every component of them to to forge my answer so the first thing is. I I think okay the country metaphor here I think gets a little bit treacherous because if we actually want to play out the metaphor then it's like okay well ones the US who's China who's Germany I think it's it starts getting. Yeah it starts getting politically messy that's one of the reason why I like the city analogy that it's more politically neutral or at least less charge when we start like assigning.
But second is I do think they're actually some important disanalogies between nation states and cities right so cities still do have what we might call a security budget right you need a police force you need a fire station you need. There are certain services that must be administered by the municipality in order for a city to function correctly right there are public goods that must be administered by each city and security just one such public good right it's the it's kind of the most principle public good in in a blockchain. The question that you laid out there is look if I am choosing a city to live in am I not going to choose the city that has the best police force isn't that just obvious because if I go to another city there's a marginally higher chance that like I get robbed or that I get killed or that I get whatever.
And the answer is well obviously not right if you if you frame it in those terms or the question is OK look what should I live in the country that has the highest you know military per capita which actually I don't know if the US has a highest military for capital let's say for instance that it doesn't let's say there's some smaller country somewhere that has even more forces per capita right. It's like OK well I know I wouldn't choose where I want to live based on that I might go live in Switzerland because Switzerland is just really nice and like it's good enough for me and I you know Switzerland hasn't invaded in a very long time and if it's going to be invaded in time soon I can leave and you know find somewhere else to go live the reality is that that's that's just demonstrably not how people choose where they live now there are certain people who are making their choices based on security right there are certain people who are saying look I am going to live in New York because I want to make sure that like my real my assets are protected by the most ironclad you know legal framework possible for protecting people's assets right a lot of people do that a lot of financial assets are look I'm only going to be in New York banks and I am not going to entrust myself into any other jurisprudence I'm not going to have money in in Hong Kong or in Singapore or in Germany because I never know what those governments might do but I know what you know New York is going to do New York is not going to steal my money.
And that that you know set of case law is so ironclad that I can trust it in that same way some people are going to say look I'm only going to be on a theorem because I don't trust anywhere else not to eventually fuck up and that's why I'm going to choose a theorem and nothing else there are some people who will make that choice. But one obviously the people who do that are probably going to be the very very wealthy so you know it's the whales and the kind of billionaires and the kind of crypto elite who are going to be saying I'm only going to choose a theorem because I don't trust Salana or Avalanche not to have faults or not to you know to actually be able to survive a nation state level attack etc etc.
It's the first thing very few people are making their choices based on that criteria second you can sort of see it by people's reveal preferences is that there are more users on Binance Marching and then there are an ethereum you know ostensibly there are if you certainly aggregate all the other lay one blockchains there definitely more users on all the other lay one blockchains and there are an ethereum. If you combine them all right it does not seem to be the case that people are measuring the security budget of Ethereum how many people do you know who have asked you can you please describe to me the difference between the security budget of Ethereum or security budget of Salana.
I have never heard anyone ever ask me that question that is not how people are determining what blockchains they're going to use. So now there are important considerations about how long is this blockchains been around how robust is it how you know how likely is it to be bug free those are all things people very much care about but the security budget and this is something that I have written about actually a bunch of times I wrote a piece I can't remember I think we may have spoken about a right a long time ago called why decentralization isn't as important as you think. And in that in that piece I talk about this decentralization S curve and the S curve basically describes that when you are not very decentralized and you have very little security budget increasing the security budget that you're spending doesn't matter very much because if somebody wants to go and like you know if you're Robston right let's say or like I don't know cheap.
You guys know cheap. Is that another test net of some sort. It's like it's like a it's like a real test net but it's a real money you can go buy it it trades on like some random shit coin exchange. It was actually made by George hot it's it's kind of cool but basically it was like it's like the Kassama for for Ethereum right yeah value laden real main net. So if you go on cheap and you want to go do a 51% attack against cheap it's pretty easy it's not that hard if you marginally increase the proof of work on cheap. It's not going to change that anybody who really wants to and wants to go spend you know $10,000 or I don't know how much it costs to take it take it over.
You can just go do it right it's not that hard so increasing the spend does basically nothing. But at a certain point you'll hit this curve where now so okay now it's $100,000 an hour. If you increase enough now you start climbing up this escurve where the amount of extra security spend is really materially changing the number of people who would need to court or you can single handedly coordinate to take over your blockchain right. And so you start climbing this escurve and really having an impact on the effective censorship resistance of this chain and decentralization of this chain but then eventually you're going to hit this point of declining returns.
And then it really starts leveling off right if I told you hey you know what I think a theorem should spend you know a billion dollars more per year on a security budget. Would that materially change your desire to use a theory. No of course not right like you would probably wouldn't even know you didn't even know to ask the question of hey should the theorem be spending more on its security budget. You're not even thinking about it right you you know that a theorem is safely past the point where it needs to be worrying about how much it's spending on its security budget. And if I told you that hey a theorem is likely to lose 10% of its security spend next year you would say okay whatever like that's probably fine because you know that it's safely passed that rise in the escurve.
And so for that reason the thing that really matters is that most of these later on blockchains pass that really high ascension in the escurve and further marginal decentralization or increased security spend doesn't matter that much right if all that you know if you had your massage or you know the FBI or you know these other really concentrated actors coming together and saying you know what we're going to go break a theorem. There's a good chance that they could even do that to a theorem today. And if you know a group of scriptkitties or you know one of these you know hacker groups came together and said I want to go break a theory where I want to go break avalanche they might not be able to do it today.
And so they both actually are not that different in their material respects with respect to how secure they are now I mean you can argue at the margin whether or not that's true of avalanche whether or not that's true of a theory whether that's true of tasos or whatever my point is that it's definitely not a question of whichever one is the most secure is the one that everyone's going to use because it's not even the criteria people using today. Do you think I want to get back I want to get back to that because I think the first two points you you made are good but do you think that that still holds true if we assume users are no longer individual people but they're actually actually change because that effectively is what the Ethereum roadmap and the modular blockchain thesis is like pushing towards it's like no users aren't going to be using main chain actually other chains are going to be purchasing the block space of main chain and so the argument would be will security actually really matters maybe not for individual users you don't care like I'll use coin base all the time I have assets on coin base like whatever I don't you know but if they're planning their entire economy and their entire future they have to have the most secure chain in order to route themselves in order to have those settlement guarantees does that change the calculus at all.
And to elaborate on that the more security a federal government has the stronger military a federal government has in the world of blockchains when we extend this metaphor blockchains you are literally making more space for more cities because you can fit more roll ups. And so again it's not it's asking a question a question to users like yo like do you want to go to the most secure chain they don't really care they just want to go to where the fun is they want to pick their favorite city that vibes with their culture the most but when it comes to a nation or a blockchain house house your level of security is determined how many cities you can fit inside of your protocol how many cities you can fit inside of your nation.
So it's a it's a interesting question and I think I get your point is that chains are going to be in some sense they can aggregate the preferences of their users more effectively than users could maybe individually and it might it might be that look when you're big and giant you're just going to be more risk of us and you're going to be more conservative the way the governments are tend to be more conservative than maybe users individually are. That being said I mean again we can it one is I think it's very clearly security is not the only thing that chains care about right they also care about composability they care about you know economic value they care about also I mean one thing that a lot of chains are can and do.
Uh concern themselves with is you know what is the what is the trajectory of this chain am I attaching myself to a rising country or a falling country and the people want to bet on winners they want to bet on and there's more returns in many ways to betting on somebody who's rising that on somebody who's flat or somebody who's falling. Um the prediction that almost falls out of the suggestion you guys are making is that look US is the biggest country got the biggest military right so wouldn't be the case that every single other country on in the world would become basically a satellite state of the US.
And the answer demonstrably is no like it's just not the case that every single country in the world is a satellite state of the US because there are many other things that matter besides your military might. And I think that I mean that again this is where the analogy breaks down because there's obviously so many more variables in geopolitics than just your military. But I think what we'll find is that it's likely also true in in blockchains and it's also a matter of when it's not just a matter of this will eventually happen when a theorem that achieves its you know eventual roadmap. There's also a question of like okay well how friggin long is it going to take because I'm ready to go today I'm like an entrepreneur I'm here ready to build.
I have users who are not sitting around waiting for this eventual utopian vision of charting and blah blah blah and I think all this stuff is clearly path dependent because if security is not the only thing that matters which I think we can all agree it's not the only thing that matters might matter a lot but it's definitely not the only one. If these other things matter and they can be delivered faster by these other architectures these other chains then I think it is very path dependent how all the stuff ends up evolving. I think one kind of interesting you know implication of this whether we see layer one chance of cities or whether we see them as as countries as as nation states like if we look at the world today both of those things do break down like do turn into power law distributions right as far as like GDP.
As far as like you know economic power that sort of thing like there are generally power law winners at one given epoch in history and there are other you know smaller nation states as well. And so maybe we're also arriving to a similar conclusion whether it's nation states or cities exactly okay so how bullish are you then on non layer non Ethereum chains right now has seen do you think that this is where the bulk of the growth and the value will be had for investors moving forward. I'm quite bullish I don't know about the bulk of I mean that's a very strong that's a very strong phrase I don't know if I'd say that the bulk of value is going to come from these emerging layer ones but I do think it's the case and I'm not making a bold prediction that's already happened obviously so I'm a little late to the party but I was I was also here if you if you I think you and I talked about this briefly I wrote a piece back in I think it was the summer called I'm worried no one's going to care about roll ups.
And in that piece basically one of the I think one of the lines I put out of it actually was a line but basically I said you know the one of the reasons why I'm worried about these emerging roll ups being this huge story and people thought oh skyscrapers are going to be the biggest thing and everyone's going to live in a skyscraper which you know today is obviously not the case even in the world is that most people don't live in skyscrapers. And the reason one of the reasons why I was concerned about the stories that these emerging layer ones can move so much faster than the roll ups it's so much easier to just go build a new city than it is to like go perfect skyscraper technology and in fact I was worried that look these guys like they can iterate if there's a bug in a roll up game over potentially you lose all the money right it's extremely careful engineering if the skyscraper falls down lots of bad shit and like no more skyscrapers for a long time really that's that's how bad it's going to be.
But with emerging layer one if something goes wrong that's cool just fork it fix it you know if you need if you have a down fork situation that's fine right you're still in your infancy it's all good everyone's calling stuff beta software even though no one's treating it as beta software it's all good you can you can do that really easily you have the flexibility. Whereas with with literally you don't have that and furthermore from the perspective of the user most users who are entering blockchain city they're just here you know they're here to train enough tease they're here to like liquidity mine they have no idea what's going on they have no idea what any of the arguments that we've been you know going on about for the last three or four years and so when they show up and they see a cheap chain there's like hey this skyscraper is really expensive this other one is really cheap and both of them you know have you know Ponzi schemes on them great I'll go I'll go on this one which is where cheaper.
And from the perspective of a user the best layer two is a new layer one so that and you know that that was a concern that I was voicing back in the summer and I think the so far that's turned out to be the case is that the most vibrant happening places in crypto today are probably these emerging layer ones and the layer two are still relatively anemic in their in their growth. I see if you had to this is the closer question for the podcast okay what's your favorite city to live in. In the in the real world or in crypto I'll let you figure that one out okay my favorite city live in I would actually say New York although I don't live in New York I think New York is probably my favorite city it just happens that at Dragonfly we do so much work with Asia that living in New York would just be absolutely respect to time zones.
But New York particularly in I'll say not in the winter non winter New York I'd say it's probably my favorite city and maybe that betrays something about my my views about a theory on is that I think a theory is amazing except when it's congested then it sucks. I also heard winter and hopefully we're not in a in a crypto winter right now see do you have any thoughts on that yeah I mean I was just I was just asked to see the day from somebody who is like a reporter type and when I told him is that look. You know that's like are we in a winter do we know when how do you know and the answer is like look you know when you see it like the point where everyone's asking the question of where are we in a winter the answer is yes that's what David says it's like I you know I'm not convinced we're in a bear market but he's like if you're asking that question then we're in a bear market because it's a bear market is about sentiment.
Exactly bear market is when you look around and ask people are we guys are we still is anyone excited that's how you know is like when you're looking around looking for trying to get people hyped up that's okay yeah you're not there anymore you're not you're not going to work anymore this is great has seen this has been super helpful thanks for coming on bankless again and just talking about cities and I really like this analogy I do think you know geography cities social structures all of these things are helpful very helpful for understanding blockchains and thanks for laying out the multi chain thesis today totally there's a lot of fun action items for you bankless listeners of course we'll have a few links to resources in the show now it's the first is read his piece we've been talking about today blockchains our cities is the name of it if you want to throw back go all the way back to summer I think of 2020 yet summer 2020 when we last had his seat on where we talked about defying the E2 metropolis it's another cities analogy to describe starting and how scalability would emerge on a theorem so those are some resources for you of course as always risk and disclaimers guys all the stuff is risky everything we've been talking about none of it has been financial advice eat this risky defy is risky so all of those cities and chains out there you can definitely lose what you put in but we are headed west this is the frontier it's not for everyone but we're glad you're with us on the bankless journey thanks a lot hey we hope you enjoyed the video if you did head over to bankless HQ right now to develop your crypto investing skills and learn how to free yourself from banks and gain your financial independence we recommend joining our daily newsletter podcasts and community as a bankless premium subscriber to get the most out of your bankless experience you'll get access to our market analysis our alpha leaks and exclusive content and even the bankless token for airdrops raffles and unlocks if you're interested in crypto the bankless community is where you want to be click the link in the description to become a bankless premium subscriber today also don't forget to subscribe to the channel for in-depth interviews with industry leaders ask me anything and weekly roll ups where we summarize the week in crypto and other fantastic content thanks everyone for watching and being on the journey as we build out the bankless nation