✨ DEBRIEF ✨ | Ryan & David's Unfiltered Thoughts on the Episode https://shows.banklesshq.com/p/117-jim-debrief
----- Jim O’Shaughnessy is a Wall Street legend and the Founder, Chairman, and Co-CIO of O’Shaughnessy Asset Management, which has over $6 billion in assets under management.
Tap in for timeless investing wisdom to last in crypto for the long-haul. We like playing long-term games, and Jim has decades of investing experience. He’s also a lot of fun to listen to.
Since Jim fell into the world of investing, how has the game changed? What’s stayed the same? And most importantly, what does the crypto investor need to know about staying ahead of the curve?
------ 📣 OPOLIS | Sign Up to Get 1000 $WORK and 1000 $BANK https://bankless.cc/Opolis
------ 🚀 SUBSCRIBE TO NEWSLETTER: https://newsletter.banklesshq.com/ 🎙️ SUBSCRIBE TO PODCAST: http://podcast.banklesshq.com/
------ BANKLESS SPONSOR TOOLS:
⚖️ ARBITRUM | SCALED ETHEREUM https://bankless.cc/Arbitrum
❎ ACROSS | BRIDGE TO LAYER 2 https://bankless.cc/Across
🏦 ALTO IRA | TAX-FREE CRYPTO https://bankless.cc/AltoIRA
👻 AAVE V3 | LEND & BORROW CRYPTO https://bankless.cc/aave
⚡️ MAKER DAO | THE DAI STABLECOIN https://bankless.cc/MakerDAO
🦁 BRAVE | THE BROWSER NATIVE WALLET https://bankless.cc/Brave
------ Topics Covered:
0:00 Intro 5:45 Jim O’Shaughnessy 11:30 The investing zeitgeist 17:15 How has the narrative changed? 29:28 Are fundamentals dead? 41:08 Picking the right one 54:44 Investing hacks 1:08:10 The age of social media 1:15:00 Anchoring the crypto space 1:22:08 Psychological hacks 1:29:45 Knowing when to sell 1:36:11 Final thoughts 1:41:38 Conclusions & Disclaimers
------ Resources:
Jim O’Shaughnessy https://twitter.com/jposhaughnessy?s=20&t=h5tIizdYwRmThOJTC-03oQ Devil Takes the Hindmost https://www.amazon.com/Devil-Take-Hindmost-Financial-Speculation/dp/0452281806 Securities Analysis https://www.amazon.com/Security-Analysis-Foreword-Buffett-Editions/dp/0071592539/ref=sr_1_3?keywords=securities+analysis&qid=1651919905&s=books&sprefix=securities%2Cstripbooks%2C107&sr=1-3 The Intelligent Investor https://www.amazon.com/Intelligent-Investor-Definitive-Investing-Essentials/dp/0060555661/ref=sr_1_1?crid=10L16SFDNU20V&keywords=the+individual+investor&qid=1651919926&s=books&sprefix=the+individual+investor%2Cstripbooks%2C97&sr=1-1 The Internet Contrarian https://www.osam.com/pdfs/The_Internet_Contrarian_-_4-22-99.pdf The Simpsons - Sideshow Bob Steps on Rakes https://youtu.be/aRq1Ksh-32g
----- Not financial or tax advice. This channel is strictly educational and is not investment advice or a solicitation to buy or sell any assets or to make any financial decisions. This video is not tax advice. Talk to your accountant. Do your own research.
Disclosure. From time-to-time I may add links in this newsletter to products I use. I may receive commission if you make a purchase through one of these links. Additionally, the Bankless writers hold crypto assets. See our investment disclosures here: https://newsletter.banklesshq.com/p/bankless-disclosures
No summary for this episode yet.
Everyone on this planet is running human OS and if you're running human OS you're gonna fall for this and less you figure out a way to make that impossible. Welcome to bankless where we explore the frontier of internet money and internet finance. This is how to get started how to get better and how to front run the opportunity. This is Ryan Sean Adams I'm here with David Hoffman and we're here to help you become more bankless guys today. We've got a special treat we're talking timeless wisdom for crypto investors. These are the things we need to know. We've got Jim Oshana say who is an expert in investing and comes to us with some fantastic ideas we can implement in crypto a few things you should take away.
Number one you suck at investing and be real with you and Jim makes the case as to why not just you so do I so does everyone. Number two how to short circuit this monkey brain that we're dealing with Jim calls it human OS there are all sorts of traps we can fall into and we need short circuits. And number three some really tactical hacks we got at least ten of them be a dozen actual tips for how you can avoid crypto FOMO and fear uncertainty and doubt and maximize your long term gains David this was at once kind of a very wise and practical episode what were some of your thoughts. Yeah I was completely reminded of this one book that I read called devil takes the hindmost and it was a it was just a book about the history of financial bubbles going as far back as financial bubble bubbles existed.
And the main takeaway that I learned from reading that book was that you know it's there's one common denominator to all markets no matter what asset class no matter what decade no matter what century and that common denominator is human DNA. Like humans perceive value and that's what comes to define markets and so like Jim has seen many markets across many decades and so he has just like wisdom he just has seen a lot of markets and has seen the same patterns play out throughout markets and so well crypto it's a new paradigm it's a new technology we're going to change the world. It's still going it's still operating on what Jim calls human OS and so there are still going to be the same tricks the same traps and the same things to know to make sure that you can actually navigate through markets because crypto is not different is just another market is just the structures different.
Yeah absolutely and that's why this conversation with Jim is so valuable and there's so many things that crypto investors can actually learn from traditional investing because to your point David it ain't changed I mean we're still the same human beings and we're going to make the same mistakes as traditional investors and so he gets right to the heart of it David I'm really excited to record the debrief with you though because there are some other quibbles that we probably have about like some bones to pick. Yeah it's an asset allocation and like whether crypto is a store of value in these sorts of things but guys if you are a premium subscriber of bankless did you know you get an extra podcast that is the recap that we do after all of these episodes where David and I talk about the episode that was if you want to upgrade to a premium member click the link in your show notes and you can unlock that episode on the private RSS feed guys we are going to get right to the conversation with Jim.
But before we do we want to thank the sponsors that made this episode possible if you're trying to grow and preserve your crypto wealth optimizing your taxes is just as lucrative is trying to find the next hidden gem also IRA can help you invest in crypto and tax advantage ways to help you preserve your hard earned money also crypto IRA let's invest more than 150 coins and tokens with all the same tax advantages of an IRA to make it easy to fund your alternative IRA or crypto IRA via your 401k or by contributing directly from your bank account. There is no setup or account fees and it's all you need to do to invest in crypto tax free let me repeat that again you can invest in crypto tax free diversify like the pros and trade without tax headaches open in alto crypto IRA to invest in crypto tax free.
This goes to alto IRA dot com slash bankless that's a L T O IRA dot com slash bankless and start investing in crypto today. The brave browser is the user first browser for the web 3 internet with over 50 million monthly active users control your digital footprint with built-in privacy and ad blocking inside the brave browser you'll find the brave wallet the first secure crypto wallet built natively inside of a web 3 crypto browser. Web 3 is freedom from big tech and wall street more control and better privacy but there's a weak point in web 3 your crypto wallet the brave wall is different brave wall is built natively inside the brave browser no extension required which gives the brave wallet an extra level of security versus other wallets with the brave wallet you can buy store send and swap your crypto assets and can even manage your NFTs and connect to other wallets and defi apps all from the security of the best privacy browser on the market.
Whether you're new to crypto or in season pro it's time to switch to the brave wallet download brave at brave dot com slash bankless and click the wallet icon to get started. Ave is the leading decentralized liquidity protocol and now Ave V3 is here. Ave V3 has powerful new features to enable you to get the most out of defi including isolation mode which allows for many more markets to be launched with more exotic collateral types and also efficiency mode which allows for a higher loan to value ratios and of course portals allowing users to port their auto position across all of the networks that Ave operates on like polygon, phantom, avalanche, arbitrum, optimism and harmony.
The beautiful thing about Ave is that it's completely open source decentralized and governed by its community enabling a truly bankless future for us all. To get your first crypto collateralized loan get started at Ave dot com that's A-A-B-E dot com and also check out the Ave protocol governance forums to see what more than a hundred thousand down members are all robbing about at governance dot Ave dot com. Bankless Nation we are super excited to introduce you to our next guest Jim Oshanasi is a Wall Street legend. He's the founder and chairman and co-CIO of Oshanasi asset management. They've got over six billion assets under management.
That number could be up outdated Jim. I'm not sure how many you guys have. Yeah, it is outdated. It's like seven and a half billion now. There you go. Keeps going up up only and Jim has decades of investing experience in a world of crypto like podcasts and investing where many of us have mere years. So we are looking at Jim to tell us some timeless investing wisdom something that would last us in crypto for the long haul. I think Jim we want to cover three different things in a few sections. So the first is what's changed with investing throughout your decades of experience. So you know some trends some changes that you've identified maybe different seasons of investing and kind of fundamentals and narrative.
And then secondly what stayed the same that might be actually an even more interesting conversation to have. And then lastly what does all this mean for a crypto investor as most in the bankless audience are like we're kind of getting into crypto now many are young. Many have their first investing experience in crypto and actually don't know investing in the traditional the outside world. So that's what we want to cover is that sound good sounds great. All right, let's start here though first would love to hear a bit about how you learned to invest in your early years. What did that look like for you Jim.
So let me take you back to the paleolithic era before internet where like if you wanted to do something you actually had to go to the library. I could I don't have it handy but I could put up the cover of my first brochure which took like four months to do because I had to physically go to the marble query to take the pictures because I wanted it to look really cool. And then after getting the one I liked I had a design firm and entire design firm try to work it and we can't do that we you know I was telling him what I want it three months later it looks okay but like you do it now one second done.
So when I really started to learn and became passionate and a bit obsessive about investing was in the late 1970s early 1980s. I was a teenager 1979 and then a young guy who got married young and then a young dad so I had people who had to put up with all my craziness so I found a library I used to live in St Paul Minnesota I found a great research library called the James J Hill library where they had literally all the data literally it all of it. What it was was getting it from here to there and you guys probably have never even seen one but they used to have big big spreadsheets paper spreadsheets that were like this long.
And so you could have I can't remember like 18 rows across and 50 rows down and so I started with the Dow because just 30 stocks and I'm you know legendarily lazy so start started there but it was all by hand literally. And so then I got every book that I could find uninvesting and I read all the ones that most people do you know securities analysis by Graham and Dodd the individual investor by Ben Graham himself just on and on and started to build a thesis around investing. Which was that the biggest problem in investing is that people are probably looking at the wrong things and back then again paleolithic era everybody just talked about people right so my I had my aha moment when I was invited finally to the big dinner when my uncles and aunts were in town.
And you had to be a certain age to go to the grown up table and I was so excited because like anyway, so there's 14 of us around the table and my father and my uncle were having this like really intense discussion and fight about IBM and its prospects. And I listened and didn't commits and just kept listening and I just noted it was all just talking about the CEO that was it they were not talking about what its earnings were how much you had to pay for it what its prospects were. And so I finally interject that and I'm like you know uncle John who was more on this than my dad I think that's totally wrong and he's like oh okay well so enlighten me.
And as you know well if you might not know if you're if you're at a mostly Irish families table and there are 14 people there's probably a minimum of 20 opinions and so but it gave me that push that first push right and it's like I think they're wrong but I might be wrong. So let me do let's go to the videotape as the old sportscaster used to say and thus was my first dive into empiricism and now call systematic or quantitative investing. I'm wondering what the context or like zeitgeist was around society and investing at the time because if you're telling me that you had to go to the library and go through like these cumbersome like documents to get an edge to like do your research.
That seems to be that you were doing it if it was hard that you were doing things that other people weren't doing and that reminds me of like the early days of crypto where learning and researching and like valuating things was just there was no consensus about these things. And so there were only people carving their own path was that what it was like and how easy was it for you to like generate your own like understanding and models for how to invest back then. So that's a great question David and it speaks to the zeitgeist of that era every era has its own zeitgeist right and and that era because we were coming off the worst bear market 1970 to through the end of 1974 for stocks since the great depression inflation was rampant sounds familiar.
And like literally so I was like 21 right so all of my contemporaries said you know are you out of your fucking mind why would you be interested in stocks stocks are for widows and or events I mean the real money is in hard assets. So like all of my contemporaries were going into real estate they were going into commodity trading they were investing and trying to figure out how to get into hard assets. So the attitude toward stocks was just grim I mean it was like everyone thought I was crazy to be interested in stocks and like I gave the standard well you know they seem to have done pretty well over the last century so I think that they'll come back.
But the question always also highlights something that anticipates your question on what's changed it was really hard to get good actual data to study and most people did not. If you go back like I was reminiscing with a friend about there used to be a very popular show called Wall Street week with Lewis Ruizer and so I watch the one that they did right after the crash of 1987 I turn my wife and I'm like that world no longer exists. And like it was because everything they were people were still basing their actions on what their broker told them to do and and I use the term specifically broker now we've seen a huge change to registered investment advisors who who like their pitch and everything is very different than a brokers right.
So brokers were there by this why because it's going to go up why because I said so and and basically even like supposedly sophisticated like corporate pension plans they had no idea how their money was being managed in fact the first company I started of Sean C capital management started as a consultant. And it was because I had done a lot of research by this time I finally had computers so made it a little easier and so I had come to the conclusion which I wrote extensively about in my first book invest like the best that you can clone any manager you want it to by not paying attention to what they say but paying attention to what they do what they do is accessible in their portfolio.
So I would take their portfolios put them on a huge database of stocks and suck out the most relevant factors right and it gave us what was at the time called normal portfolios in other words the portfolio had the same characteristics as the manager. And so a the pension finally got to see are they doing what they tell us they do and again spoiler alert most weren't and and secondly are are they the manager adding value through their trading right through their buying and selling throughout the year. We got about three years into that and that's what I decided holy shit I got to become an active manager because the so called clone portfolio was we're killing the managers that they cloned and my my my thesis was that's because like the old Pogo cartoon suggests we we'd met the enemy and it's us.
So that got me involved in the whole human nature stuff and I mean like I've been studying that ever since and it's just so remarkably clear that well our world has dramatically sped up our access to good high quality information. It's the highest it's ever been in my lifetime and things like crypto great example so invented it had it it had a thesis supported by a white paper I like the little razzmatas of it being a anonymous white paper but but it had it already had the part of the defense of the thesis built into that white paper back when I was doing it in a way so so people. Like and this sounds weird but it's true like you might the highest indicator who you might hire as a money manager again you were like a pension guy was who you golfed with and so like that that world I think for the better is is gone.
So there's so so much to unpack there and I think we're like hinting at you know the conversation to come on this podcast but I've already gleaned one learning lesson for us that that is probably timeless and crypto is you have to put in the work that's the edge right because there's a lot of people who are looking at crypto and not putting in the work right now and if you want to make outsized returns now perform them you can't just like watch YouTube videos and just consume bankless do consume bankless. But you also have to put in the work the maybe one of them more timeless lessons that you alluded to that will get you later is also that humans it sounds like they kind of suck at investing like we want to talk about that a little bit.
Sure I think in crypto there's no exception but first yeah you talked about the the the zeitgeist of the era in kind of the 1970s when you entered and I want like you've seen some decades so you've probably seen different zeitgeist different narratives different move. And you know many as I said in the intro many of us in crypto we've been here for years like and when I mean here is investing yeah and we haven't seen decades play out so we haven't experienced the paradigm shifts of different zeitgeist and different narratives and different investing temperaments and I'm wondering what you think about on this topic of how has investing change is kind of like how has the narrative changed across generations like we're growth versus meme versus value.
Investments and what are all of these things one illustration that comes to mind is a chart and I'll show it on screen for people who are watching on YouTube but if you could visualize this for us Jim so it's Tesla versus the market cap of all of these other car companies all right Tesla market cap $1 trillion. Every other single car company combined the market cap of that is less than Tesla it's 0.9 trillion dollars. So that's top line it's not top lines that's market cap that's valuation of these assets but if you look at the gross revenue Tesla is 53 billion dollars in gross revenue and all of the other companies combined it's like 1.
6 trillion right so there's a mismatch here what era are we in Jim how does this even make sense. So great question and let's take a step back and say if you study all the various errors of mostly stock and bond investing but it includes real estate all that kind of stuff. What what happens is that my thesis around markets all markets are that they're complex adaptive systems with feedback loops and that they worked very very well when beliefs of participants are heterogeneous in other words. I may have some Apple stock that I want to sell because I want to help set up a college fund for my grandson you might want to buy something for your children if you have them or anticipating them and both of us are right right in terms of if you're just looking at it from a transaction point of view we're not both right about the price but we're both right about my reason for selling makes a lot of sense your reason for buying makes a lot of sense.
So that's the majority of markets market environments and in those kind of market environments markets are amazing they they clear and you run into trouble when you when you hit on one of these crazes okay. And what happens is those feedback loops speed up and they create what I call information waterfalls and what are they information waterfalls are are just a fire hose of information hitting your perception field but with all the same story all the same story. And so what you see over time is that investors expectations move from heterogeneous to homogeneity in other words everyone's thinking the same thing what most people don't quite understand is this is the way it has always worked.
I mean you go back to the south sea trading company in Isaac Newton losing his entire fortune in it and the reason for that was what I just described every but they got the information a lot slower but they still got it and they he got hit was so many oh my god south sea is going to make everyone a millionaire everyone a millionaire everyone a millionaire. And and so if you if you looked at the chart of the south sea company it looks like the Nasdaq prior to the crash the dot bomb crash and then afterwards so so so this chart pattern basically you see it everywhere were craze or what like a mine virus takes over so it starts back there.
You know fast forward to the United States where the biggest market so there's a lot of examples here railroad stocks I mean people who think that like Tesla is over valued go back and look at how they valued some of these railroad stocks I mean they were totally insane. And yet people kept believing the story they were telling themselves right I am smart because this brand new technology is going to be revolutionary there's a really important lesson if you're if the object of investors desire is an innovation and a technology that's when they get super super whipped up about saying it's still early.
And you know I could give you a million examples but I'll give you three so RCA radio came out right so you got to remember before radio like you listen to other people talk that was it so radio comes out and everyone is like holy shit this is amazing so they ran RCA's radio corporation America stock up to a price that was priced not only for perfection but for deification. And when the when the ultimate reckoning came and we'll get to that part later that's the not fun part but RCA never went higher than that price of 1929 Warner Brothers the movie company they would have 600% in one year why talkies.
And so our human reaction to these new technologies seems very predictable we get super excited about it and by the way it's not wrong that we're super excited about it because we're often right about the ultimate thing right like this is this bad boy is rewiring our minds right now and it's very powerful and it's very cool but. Jim is holding up a cell phone for the podcast but so you know rinse repeat and and every era has an idea right that becomes dominant as well so back then it was all the tech right and it's hard to it's kind of funny to think about tech is radio and talking pictures but this is how far we've come.
But another narrative like the one discussed earlier is like stocks will never go up again you know bonds will never go down you know and that's just it easy if you if you take the time to do a little bit of homework. You can see that like we all think that we're we're different than other generations no we're not we know more but there's still so much more we have to learn and and so many lack the humility of understanding how little they really know and that's why like one of the things that I base all my stuff on is evidence right. Right directionally more times than not i'm right that's about as good as I can get for you directionally more times than not i'm right well that's quite an edge and and so it also has the ability to negate as to mean stocks so this is one where people you'll like after this comes out you'll get lots of angry comments and that is because.
The evidence suggests that price follows narrow or sorry narrative follows price not the other way around. And so obviously the from the stock market the good example is the meme stocks right and that all these people with their diamond hands and all that kind of stuff and like I was talking to another guy's a writer on my agent he's been an investor as long as I haven't you know. He's like so what do you think in the whole you know AMC thing and i'm like well I said I feel really bad because there's a lot of earnest people and I really do mean this young people especially a lot of earnest young people who want to learn about how to invest which I think which I'm massively in favor of being manipulated because you know the chat rooms right.
Wall Street that's and all that kind of stuff. If you don't understand that there weren't probably a dozen employees of some of the biggest hedge funds in there under assume names you need to maybe splash some water in your face in the old days that was called painting the tape. So William harryman who was a railroad barrened but was also a really good stock speculator a syndicate which is what they used to call people in the 20s that were poured money together to try to manipulate the bark of essentially. Came to him and they said to to harryman can you get the stock I can't remember the name of this company but can you get the stock of XYZ which was then at 100 can you get that 120 that's where we really want to sell and harryman goes no way he goes on the other hand I can move it to 200 and you can sell it on the way down he intuitively understood that a 20% move doesn't ignite anyone's passion or imagination.
100% move back then did and so the whole diamond hands thing all of that that was a highly manipulated market and there were people from those hedge funds who wanted to punish each other playing a very different game and and the narrative just writes itself David first Goliath. Like so stories work really well in explaining what happened right if you if you want to explain what will happen I think it's a lot harder to do but if that that one was just so juicy and so I guess the takeaway that I would offer your listeners and watchers is if you get enticed by a story don't say oh that's just a story and that's being manipulated go back to your original point do some homework.
Say okay this story seems to be here and now that I know what that old guy that they had on their podcast said I'm going to look into like whose benefits and and who doesn't and you know the simple rule is follow the money and like when you do that it you might become a little bit disillusioned so that's that's what I guess I would say about that. Thankless listeners there's so there's two lessons that we just heard there that I think is incredibly relevant and implicable to everyone who's doing anything in crypto which is this narrative follows the price not the other way around okay so when you're looking at narrative investing in all of these assets that that are pumping based on the narrative realize that the price influences these things something we can come back to and also let's not be naive painting the tape as Jim is calling it happens all of the time in crypto.
It just happens with a youtuber who's talking about a specific cryptocurrency or a Twitter thread or an anon who is you know is is pumping their bags and in various ways so let's not be naive to these facts but Jim I do want to go back to this Tesla thing just for just for a second because what's super weird about this is like you know people went to a business school or like the traditional investing sort of things how do you value a stock well it's price to earnings ratio right and that's how you value a stock and so but like we see the price to earnings about it. All of these car companies exceeding Tesla and yet Tesla is in order of magnitude higher in terms of value and I'm asking you about this like our fundamentals dead or is this just another narrative that we've told ourselves right now and by by the way this is this is true in stocks and equities of course but we also see this playing out in in the crypto world where there are assets in crypto we might say look at look at these look at these revenue inflows from it.
Look how much cash is being generated from this particular DeFi protocol or this particular asset but that seems very disconnected from the reality of the market caps of these things and what's actually going up in price is this just an error that we're in where fundamentals don't matter and you think we'll reset to the meme. So let me preface it by saying I can only speak to my personal experience in markets and it additionally studying prior markets before I was a rap so it's different this time right that's that's the that's the call that's the the thing that gets people really excited. My thesis is that as long as human beings price securities or crypto or whatever asset class this is ubiquitous to and it's applicable to all asset classes as long as human beings determine ultimately their price.
You're always going to have situations like this week I have seen it personally just so many times that you know you get this when you see a pattern endlessly throughout your career your intuition gets very imbued with understanding that pattern and so just give you several examples in the late nineteen sixties one of the most speculative decades for stocks since the twenties. They had a thing called the nifty 50 the nifty 50 were 50 stocks that essentially serious or apparently serious minded analysts said by a minute price because these 50 stocks are going to like always rule well the consensus stocks yep and you know I don't even have to be terribly bright to go to the end of this story.
They got absolutely hammered in the correction and bear market actual bear market of nineteen seventy three seventy four flash forward to oil when oil was crazy in the in the late seventies early eighties everybody was buying every oil stock that they could do you know multiples be damned oil because we were running out of it every magazine was screaming peak oil we're going to run out of oil. Twenty years the world is going to be completely without oil right and so like I went I didn't exercise I went through what was then called the pink sheets which were stocks that didn't weren't worth enough to get listed on an exchange and in under a week.
I had highlighted all of the stocks that were trading under a buck right so under one dollar in under a week there was not a single one trading under a dollar okay so guess what happened after that. They realized that maybe those predictions that the pessimistic journalists like to spread were maybe wrong and then of course let's come up to the granddaddy of all similar things to what we're seeing right now was the dot com craze and you've got to understand and this is so difficult to understand theoretically. I'll give you a good example though in in April of nineteen ninety nine I wrote a piece that's still available somewhere online called the internet contrary and in this piece I said when the crash comes eighty five percent of these companies are going to be carried out feet first they're going to die they're going to go away and then I used Amazon as an example of a company that I thought was a winner.
But I said in the essay but Amazon when this happens is going to go down ninety five percent in price. That's exactly what happened a year later but here's what's interesting and this is the better part of this story in my opinion. I wrote that right based on just data what did I do next I started an internet company. You should have been shorting Amazon did you do any exactly exactly but but what I want it what I want to underline here because it's so hard if you haven't experienced it yourself it's so hard to learn from the example my example. You our world back then was so monoma maniacal about the internet is going to replace everything.
So don't ever invest in a bricks and mortar company they're dead they're dead don't have anything to do with anything and every every example every lunch you were at even with people you didn't know. Hey did you see that new store that you don't even have to buy shoes anymore they you'll put your foot on this thing it'll transmitted over the internet and that shoes will come right to you. And so like everybody had this fever right and not unlike I think Newton and back in the day much slower back then of course you know. But that's another part that's changed the ability for these cycles to to speed up and play on themselves creates these emotionally because these are not intellectual thoughts because remember I had written a piece based on empirical fundamentals that said.
Dead and it has to be right and and so but I was so taken up in this idea of the internet that I started a company net called net folio which interestingly enough O'Shaunt will see asset management now has basically what I was trying to do back then we call it canvas that allows us to individualize people's portfolios but the point is that that came and the price. Plunged and suddenly there are all sorts of narratives and this is where the understanding of human beings and by the way me to you to anyone who is running human OS unless we have aliens among us like men in black suggests. My guess is everyone on this planet is running human OS and if you're running human OS you're going to fall for this unless you figure out a way to make that impossible and so the what's going to happen in crypto I have no idea I have no idea but I can tell you that it seems to me that on the plus side.
They tried to kill crypto so often and it hasn't died that's a really interesting sign to me because like back in nineteen thirty whatever FDR decided yeah the gold standard. Foco broke man so they passed and eating and they literally went house to house with guns give us your gold and we're going to pay you thirty five bucks and we're now going to fix the price of gold and you know that was that we don't live in that kind of world anymore but so so what I believe will happen is that as crypto evolves as the various protocols of the blockchain evolve there will be early on. Many many different competing things to your test example right and and they each one of those various coins or protocols is going to have what I call true believers true believers and this is very uncharitable of me but they're brain dead.
They have replaced the thought process with a set of talking points which like look at the most fundamentalist religion in the world and these guys Trump those guys all day long because like because like if you if you are ignoring against the one true faith man it's lucky that we don't have auto defa which is burning at the stake anymore because they kill all the heretics that's how passionate. They believe but that gets shipped away at and when you start getting a bit of a history which is happening now by the way when you start getting a bit of a history over okay did that work or did that not work right and and people become a little less committed more people come online that like listen to the the proselytizer on behalf of that particular coin or protocol but they are not immediately brain lost there.
They're a little more skeptical and then the whole thing is eventually washes out let's stay with cars in 1900 there were over 200 car companies in America. 200 and by the way about 15% of them were making you guessed it electric cars and so they were all competing they were all doing this and then the big three one and now it's the big one. So about the question do fundamentals no longer matter yeah they still matter and but it's going to be a little bit like the famous conversation between Hemingway and Fitzgerald when when one asked the other you know how did you go bankrupt and it was. Slowly at first and then suddenly and that's what your price patterns are going to look like so you're going to you're going to be popular and it'll run up and that'll get people excited to buy some more and then the people who want to get rid of their holdings will you know go down and then all the way down and you know so that that's that is an outcome that you really do need to consider.
For your particular passion whatever that might be but as I said crypto has a lot of interesting things in in its favor and it's inability to be killed I think is one of the strongest ones. The lesson here of course is that there are dangers when it comes to just consensus in communities where like if everyone is believing the same thing the opportunity of being the the contrarian and that is perhaps strong but Jim I want to present the devil's argument because there are plenty of times where an examples where the having consensus about something kind of feels like well we all see the same thing and we're all early.
And I mean there was consensus amongst you know the early Bitcoiners if you saw Bitcoin between 29 2009 and 2013 all like all the crazy like libertarians who saw Bitcoin that early had consensus about it and that was before it was $100 and the other trap that I'm seeing is that when we talk about just like these communities that have the same like the thought leaders of every single community have like the same lines and the same tropes about how we're all early we're all in on this thing. That seems to be normal in crypto for every single asset like every single asset has its tribe and you talked about the mind virus right don't get infected by the mind virus well literally the Bitcoiners will use the phrase like you get infected by the Bitcoin mind virus and you never you can never like you know get it out you just are compelled by the Bitcoin vision.
And Ryan and I talk about this in frequently on the weekly roll up where like crypto is a one way street like once you learn about crypto you can't go back like every everyone has consensus about crypto and then there are different tribes and different communities in crypto some with varying degrees of like tribalism and toxicity some will objectively like lean into these strategies in order to get people on their on their ship others will use more like pragmatic strategies like talking about fundamentals that's what I like to think that we do. But like in crypto there are no there is no absence of tribes and so therefore there is no absence of just complete consensus inside of communities that this is the next big thing and like the thing is that I think some what at least one of these communities is going to be right and many of these communities are going to be wrong but some will be right probably over the long term and so I'm wondering if you have just any thoughts or wisdom about how to navigate just like the timing of when these communities decide that they're right or not.
Because again if you were 20 2009 to 2013 Bitcoin you were super right and there was consensus among that those communities and I think that perhaps there's evidence to say that some communities in today's crypto are also going to be like the 2009 to 2013 Bitcoiners if they are right about the right thing. Like yes consensus global consensus is like a big like red siren we should be totally scared of that when everyone believes the same thing but also aren't there enough examples to illustrate that well I mean if we picked the right one then we are right right. Yeah so that's it if you take in any logic courses there's a thing called the planted axiom a planted axiom an axiom by its definition is obviously true.
Okay so you don't have to argue about it when you plant an axiom that means you're saying something is obviously true that is not obviously true. And so like if you study logic a little bit you can see if you can get away with planting an axiom right which is the planted axiom here is that those early guys were right and they were totally right and look at all the money they made. Okay that factually that's true right but when you need to you need to do a much deeper dive on that and some good metaphors are wars right so everybody thinks that god is on their side. Everybody thinks that they are fighting the righteous cause everybody thinks that you know we are the one true faith we are the one true belief we have access to the truth that others don't have that's why this inner tribal rivalries often get so violent in the old days thank god it's mostly just people flaming people on Twitter.
But like in the old days you killed them you literally killed them because they did not adhere to your belief that was the definition of a heretic somebody who was like no fuck you or an apostate even worse an apostate with somebody who used to believe but then leaves the tribe because of his or her insights about what's going on with the tribe. The second thing you need to think about is that and this is a little harder to be honest but I've always been a big fan of alternate histories right and if you can run enough alternate histories you can see all the times when that original tribe wasn't the winner.
And trying to like getting back to my definition of markets all markets crypto markets included complex adaptive systems complex adaptive systems are very different than simple systems complex adaptive system all of the innovation and emergence comes from the bottom not from the top. So if you get people like the idiots in Washington I don't care what party you support if you can be all the way over here on the left or all the way over here on the right you're wrong and like the your your members of a cult and a mind virus and you know you shout at each other all day and it's ludicrous because the one thing they share is this belief that there is a top down system that will work.
And we can rule the world this way if we just do it you know this way if you're on the left or if we just do it this way if you're on the right they're both wrong emergent systems which are why things got the way they got right we weren't in a complex adaptive system society is one. If you have like a couple of things that are also defining of that particular society or system if you have a rule of law and you have the basic freedom for people to do whatever they want well guess what type of country goes to the top of the league table in inventions in material wealth in in in extending rights that would have been thought of as privileges long ago that type of system.
And so the thing that I would also add is there is a I mean it's just like this is now we're going to get into why we're so hard to like figure out and why I opted to just time myself to the mast because I realized that I was going to be just as dumb as everybody else because I'm running human OS. So so my friend Annie Duke writes about this really well and and she calls this process resulting in other words let's say you don't think about an underlying process at all you don't look at fundamentals at all you don't you know you you might just be at a party and like your friend shows you this cool coin and you just go and buy it i've heard that many many times all the time all the time right so here's the part that really screws with your head.
So you do that you're at a party a friend tells you about this new coin you buy it it goes up you immediately say I made a great decision no and my friends genius and my friend exactly thank you for adding that and and so what you've done is you have created a thought process in your mind. That is so difficult to reverse and the only way it gets reversed is when you get wiped out because what you're doing is you're saying okay cause a friend genius tells me to buy ship coin a result I make I made 200% you know in in a month genius genius good good way to do it no I'm reminded of Pavlov's dogs right now exactly.
Exactly and like we're listen we are domesticated primates I know people don't like to hear that but that's who you are and like you can program people the same way you can program dogs and and like the it happens and the challenge there is there's a concept that can break you free of that and it's called base rates what is a base rate a base rate is okay I did I use this process to generate my body. And so how often did I win and as you go forward in time your base rate gets longer and longer this is a big reason why I'm a big believer in testing historically because you can get massive base rates right and and when you do that you suddenly realize oh buying that shit coin at that cocktail party was really really stupid maybe I should have a process that is repeatable giving example and by the way everybody is guilty of this me to you guys all of our listeners we're all guilty if we're a human being because that's the way human OS runs we haven't had an upgrade to human OS in a long long time and unless you are very skilled at metaprogramming it's gonna be hard for me.
You have an upgrade so you put up a chart it's 1968 and you show for the last five years if you had just bought the stocks with the highest gain in sales right so their sales went up the highest over the previous five years right and then you looked at the results like to smoke everything else like they were 28% per year first like the market was at 10 right and then if you really want to add some symmetry let's add what happened to the ones that had declines in sales like nothing tea bills right and people are looking at this and they they're looking at it and they're thinking well that's a process not enough time right because first off does that make intuitive sense that you're gonna buy the stock that just doubles it sales keeping everything else equal I don't know could what I would be driven to is huh that's an interesting idea let's test it and that's what I did test it all the way back to 1927 that was a highly anomalous cherry picked period where that actually happened you look at the long period of consistently buying the stocks that whose sales go up the most return is less than tea bills so so there are just so many mine traps and other traps waiting for we gullible naive humans to fall into them you ever see the Simpsons episode where the crusty the clown everywhere he turns he steps on a rake and it's shown from up here to the rake and he's just surrounded by rakes we're a little bit surrounded by rakes and and I do not advocate that people beat themselves up over making mistakes like everyone makes mistakes I made a shit ton of mistakes over my career so rather than like beat yourself up over that mistake learn from it say oh you know what maybe maybe he's right maybe if I could start building out my own ideas about why this particular coin or this particular blockchain or this particular process is gonna work better you'll at least keep your mind in that keeping the mind open zone what we often do again all of us including me we often go looking for it's called motivated reasoning when I want to buy crypto because I want to get rich really fast my reasoning is motivated by that and I only go looking for reasons why I'm gonna get rich by buying crypto right and I block out or reinterpret all of the reasons that are out there that are legitimate reasons for why that might not happen and when you add in the research on how unreliable our memories are it's a perfect storm man it's like our memories the brain thinks is doing us a kindness and what it does is it upgrades our memories to make them consistent with what we believe now and we don't make us feel good exactly and and so like if you if we swung the camera over here you'd see boxes and boxes and boxes of journals that I've been keeping since I was 18 years old and when you do that you you realize that well I would never be that dumb and then you go back to like 1989 and read what you wrote and I was shit I was that dumb this is so great Jim this is like exactly I think what we need to hear and I just want to you know link this because all of the terms you're using we using in crypto right now and we we can identify all the patterns you talk about you talk about survival ship bias you know there's also this term that crypto often uses of like FOMO if you're missing out right and so many crypto investors get caught up in the FOMO of whatever whatever narrative is is popular also many fall into the trap of becoming breakable becoming brain dead maximalists where they only have one view of the world they can't escape it but I think the bottom line is this like some things have changed in investing right and you have different errors and different zeitgeists and and narratives that are popular but actually more has stayed the same and the thing that stayed the same is we're all still a bunch of monkeys with human OS and like a question to you listeners like would you let a monkey handle your investing decisions because if you're making them that's what you're doing effectively and so you've begun to provide a glimpse for us Jim of kind of the way out maybe these are like quantitative methods right you know I think what we're looking for is some some practical tips on how we short circuit human OS if we're if we're ready to come to terms with the fact that we're all kind of shit at investing right now the crypto included we might have some good ideas from time to time but like we're not really good at control rolling all of the cognitive human psychology biases we have well what are some hacks what are some tricks that we can learn to actually short circuit and create some process creates some guard will rails in place so we don't screw it up and one that you mentioned that seemed super practical is like the base rate method where you're like doing active logs of what you're doing and over a long enough time frame you can actually go back in time and see the mistakes you made where you were right where you were right you could go into that a little bit another method that we advocate often on bank lists is just like dollar cost average in you know if there's an asset that you think is going to appreciate in the long run and you you know you slept on it you thought about it you've done your research you done your deep dive like you don't necessarily have to buy all in now you can just dollar cost average in over time and that's kind of a human psych trick that that works for many listeners but how can we get out of this how do we short circuit human OS and not screw this whole crypto opportunity up yeah so that's a that is a the ongoing and eternal question and what I have come to believe is that there is no one you know external strategy that works for everybody right so so my solution of being an entirely acquired right it negates all of my emotions because I obviously I built the model right but once I built the model then I set the research team on improving the model right because you're always going to be able to improve no model is always right right again what I said the beginning directionally over you know seemingly a majority of day of time right so that was my solution right my solution was I know like I'm wise in the socratic sense of knowing how little I know and I'm very willing to admit that and I'm very willing to admit that I would probably fall into every one of these behavioral traps just like everybody else and so I have that little bit of wisdom and so what I'm going to do is I'm going to use empirical evidence and I'm going to arbitrage human nature okay other people might just say you know I just I can't do that well there's all sorts of what I call interrupt methodologies that can work with people I have a good friend who's a trader in Europe and he's he's a he's kind of an intuitive trader and what he does which I which is very effective for him is like when the market starts going against him he literally closes his workstation down he keeps up he keeps running close at his office he puts him on and he goes he lives in Vienna if you ever been there it's a beautiful city so he goes for a five mile run in Vienna and like what he stumbled on to is when we allow for these cool down periods the emotions are like oh I like this this is nice the weather is nice it feels good to run and what happens is the brain resets and and the emotions get calm down and and like if you want to really whip people up just keep going at it right you must believe you're going with the maximalist way and all that kind of stuff if you if more of your style is deep breath got to think about this I feel like really compelled to do this I know that I have this huge fear of missing out yeah I'm going to go for a run another way that I have found that is like really work for some younger people that I work with is to to write it out that I have been a passionate believer in writing your ideas out forever because it just it's almost magical a first off when you have to write it out when you have to get it out of your head and into the world on a piece of paper or you can I find using your actual hand writing works best and there's some studies that show that it engages different parts of the brain up but write it out what you're going to find really quickly let's say you think coin a is got is still going to be the winner right and and you're sitting there and you're talking to your your significant other or your friends or whatever and you're making the arguments and they're like countering and you know it's a conversation if you do this part instead of that part sit down and say I'm going to write why my thesis for coin a is right and then you're going to start writing what you're often going to find is that you have no reasonably good argument for why coin a is going to win and you teach yourself it's a great way to give yourself feedback on your own thoughts because if you can't build a cogent understandable argument for why you believe what you believe and by the way this is a ubiquitous process you can do this for anything doesn't have to be just crypto it can be whatever if you can't write it out or after you've written it out you read it you go what dumbass wrote this this is bullshit right um that way you've interrupted yourself and you're like oh I guess coin a isn't going to be the winner another thing that could happen and sometimes happen by the way the first one happens more frequently than the one I'm about to describe is you write out your thesis it's pretty compelling so then you're running to the trap of the curse of knowledge so if you've got a if you've got a very compelling thesis um and let's say you're pretty smart and this is the really I mean I love the irony of this the smarter you are the better you can convince other people and yourself of your argument so it's just like oh my god so if that happens you still got to go on to the next the next stage you have now written down a cohesive thesis that is compelling for why coin a is going to work find somebody that knows nothing about crypto and have them read it and then listen to the questions that they ask you what you're going to find I've never yet uh worked on these mentoring things with these some of the younger people I work with but one guy came close um the questions that you're they're going to ask you are going to change what you think about point a point b or point c right because you're going to realize you're going to take your notes and again this is back to your initial assessment uh Ryan it was like do the homework well this is homework and so third part of the process you take your compelling thing have them read about it they're going to ask you questions you write those questions down and then you redraft your essay does it get stronger or does it get weaker and so the whole point here is less important about how compelling your thesis is you could still be raw right nothing's 100 percent ever and nothing ever is certain we live probably we live we're deterministic zero to a hundred thinkers who happen to occupy a probabilistic world and generally that leads to hilarity or tragedy so but what you're doing here is you are giving yourself a chance to slow down and letting your deeper thinking part of your mind get involved that's the real secret here by by taking the time to write it out all of that guess what goes away fomo you're no longer like i got to do this now like these are the sad part about this is there's a guy Edward Bellamy who was a real asshole he was Freud's uh nephew or cousin or something anyway he's the guy who was the master of propaganda and of course he changed his name to public relations much nicer sounding uh that there are a lot of of these techniques that are like automatic that just hack into your base code of being a human another book i would recommend for your listeners and what and people watching is a book called influence by a guy by the name of childini he also has a pretty cool website if you prefer to learn by watching him talk about it but what he's good about is is showing you no no no man those are routines let's you know we always compare the brain to whatever the latest technology is i love that i mean like back when steam engines were it everyone compared the brain to a steam engine and then you know it was whatever the the current new technology was and so now we're all saying well the brain is just like a computer it's not really but it's it's it's convenient right so there are ways to hack in to those those subroutines running in your brain silently um that just take you over and so a lot of duplicitous people do that and this slows that down and it kills for the most part i haven't i haven't yet worked with somebody who said who actually did this who actually said you know jim that was bullshit and at the end of it i felt even more phomo because i was doing this ridiculous exercise of yours and then finally um would be the kind of okay i i think the crypto is going to win and i think that um that the blockchain is going to win and permissionless protocols and all that kind of stuff i think that's going to win they're finally building indexes of all of the various coins and and stuff like that by one of those and and so that makes it a lot easier on you because indexes are really momentum funds in disguise right because as back to tesla tesla keeps getting to be a bigger part of the snp 500 so these innocent investors who think that their passive investing are actually investing in a mutual fund that is based on momentum because they have to reallocate the cap waiting as tesla grows and they have no idea that they have in their snp 500 fund a huge position in tesla and that tesla could shit the bed and they could go very very wrong however it's the it's the cleanest way for somebody who doesn't want to make it kind of like their life submission um and to participate and um if you get it wrong well then it's better than trying to speculate in all the coins like because if the index fund goes to zero it means we were wrong right we we got that wrong and something happened whether it was the u.
s. government outlawing crypto or whatever there was some exogenous external exogenous event that blew the whole thing up um so those those i would offer as as as ways to at least think about it it's it's really good it's really good advice you have i just want to um you know plus one one of those in particular and then talk about a few others and then ask you a question actually um so i just want to plus one the right out your strategy and everything that Jim said is a hundred percent true you know bankless as a newsletter it's effectively what we do in podcasts too we are basically like you know talking about our our strategy and ideas the the one i think add that uh we might have we have the benefit of the internet now is you could publish it to social media and then everyone in the world can tell you all of the flaws of your idea in fact they'd be happy to tell you the flaws of your idea let me guarantee you will find haters on anything you post in social media so it's even developing a social media presence developing a a blog that's well read that can be a way to you get that feedback cycle a little bit tighter um also i want to plus one on the on the go for a jog another a strategy is like look if you're listening to bankless you're probably checking crypto prices like half a dozen times a day okay i know that because more than that david's like david's like uh you know how many times do you have to pump those up he's checking right now he's checking out he's checked three times since we started the podcast i think go for a jog also stop the amount of times you check crypto prices all right it's like what new has happened what what's the market telling you like if you believe in this asset class for the long term do you need to check it ten times a day now what if you checked it once a week yeah how would that change how you're thinking about things go ahead jim that's a great those are both uh plus one great you know i i started moving all of our my work to social media like when i saw that because i owe a lot of my success to the traditional media right i was on cmbc all the time i got written up in the journal and all the various things which was really great and i am credibly grateful that at that point in the cycle i was able to you know have that advantage but i i study these things and i started to see that everything was moving to social media and and so that's when i got active on twitter even though i got an account earlier um that's a great idea so let me just endorse that idea because man if you can if you can you know strap on your armor uh it's it's it's it's going to be very helpful but uh the the the checking prices so there is a thing called hyperbolic discounting and i know we need i and i'm guilty of this yeah it's a term of art what it really means is it's you're shortening your time horizon without knowing you're doing it every time you check the price of crypto or anything like 10 times a day what your brain is saying is oh we need to pay attention to these short probably very meaningless moves up and down and when you become a hyperbolic discounter you are you pull triggers way too fast and almost always to your detriment so like another idea that i have been planning with which i think it's now getting some pretty good support which is this idea i always say arbitrage human nature well there's this other thing about temporal arbitrage right what's temporal arbitrage it's basically like i'm just going to this this particular algorithm that i've developed does it pretty well i'm just going to let it keep running right and you get a massive advantage over people who are running around like what's crypto now what's crypto now what's it doing what's it doing i you know like literally if you've walked into my office one we were still at when we were still in the office we've moved to have worked from anywhere but all you would hear is Bach you wouldn't see a tv you wouldn't see at Bloomberg i didn't have any of that shit in my office arbitrage is an ethereum layer 2 scaling solution that's going to completely change how we use defi and NFTs over 300 projects have already deployed to arbitrage and a defi and NFT ecosystems are growing rapidly some of the coolest and newest NFT collections have chosen arbitrage as their home all the wild defire protocols continue to see increased usage and liquidity using arbitrage has never been easier especially with the ability to deposit directly into arbitrage through all the exchanges including Binance, FTX, Quoby and Crypto.
com once inside you'll notice arbitrage increases ethereum's speed by orders of magnitude for a fraction of the cost of the average gas fee if you're a developer who wants low gas fees and instant transactions for your users visit arbitrage.io slash developer to start building your dap on arbitrage if you're a degenerate many of your favorite daps on ethereum are already on arbitrum with many moving over every day go to bridge.arbitrum.io now to start bridging over your eth and other tokens in order to experience defi and NFTs in the way it was always meant to be fast cheap secure and friction free the layer 2 era is upon us ethereum's layer 2 ecosystem is growing every day and we need bridges to be fast and efficient in order to live a layer 2 life across the fastest cheapest and most secure cross chain bridge with across you don't have to worry about the long wait times or high fees to get your assets to the chain of your choice access or bridge and available for use almost instantaneously across bridges are powered by uma's optimistic oracle to securely transfer tokens from layer 2 back to ethereum a token proposal is being deliberated as we speak across forum where community members will decide on the token distribution you can have your part of across the story by joining the discord and becoming a co-founder and helping to design the fair fair launch of across if you want to bridge your assets quickly and securely go to across.
io to bridge your assets between ethereum optimism arbitrum or boba networks maker doubt is the OG D5 protocol the maker doubt produces die the industry's most battle tested and resilient stable point using maker you don't need to sell your collateral if you need liquidity instead you can spin up a maker vault and use your collateral to mint die with maker the power to mint new money is in your hands the maker protocol is extremely hardened and operated by one of the most experienced douse in existence they've been here since the beginning they've seen it all and so you can mint die with the assurance that your collateral is saved soon maker will be present on all chains and altos so minting die can take place on oasis.
app zaryon zapper or any other d5 protocol that you use follow maker on twitter at maker doubt and learn from the oldest and most resilient down existence. So Jim I think something that the crypto industry is really really missing that would make this whole thing a lot easier this whole thing being being able to be sober about our thoughts removing emotion from investing and looking for the for the long term is that there's so many competing ways to value crypto assets like and no one really knows how to do it there's the like different tribes will give you their version for evaluating crypto assets and it will always favor their particular crypto asset right there is there is there is no consensus on valuation models and I think I think when you were getting into the world of investing with stocks I think perhaps that was about a similar context as in there was no general consensus with how to value equities maybe you can correct my memory because I wasn't around back then but something that we're really missing in the crypto space is like of an anchor to all ground ourselves in about how to measure the valuations of these things because it's all there are no fundamentals there are no fundamentals it's all in our heads no one can agree what are the metals even mean right so is this is this is this an important point that we're missing in the industry that we should really work on so Ryan's interjection there is is hit it on the head that there there are no fundamentals that like you can you can't move over the fundamentals of companies right to crypto right because I used to use a joke meme that was essentially crypto CEO needs to raise prices so so the I have in my thinking about crypto I think that the the the best way to to approach crypto is to use momentum filters right that's the wisdom of crowds and you know a quick and dirty you wanted another way for people to kind of approach this is momentum has a solid history going back my book what works on Wall Street takes it back to the early 1920s other books the data is really sketchy and so I'm low to like recommend them but momentum is essentially wisdom of crowds it it's not always right of course but it's right a lot more often than it's wrong and and so I don't know that that would be a valuation approach but it would certainly be an an external way to say I'm not going to listen to the story as to why coin A or coin B is better I'm just going to look at the momentum which ones winning the most adherence and which one are people buying the most of I think the other thing about crypto that I always I I always just like tried to get my head around this because in the early days of crypto I'm an early adopter I love listening to people with no ideas and because you know there's a lot of great ideas out there but you know the early days as you guys said it was mostly the sovereign individual types the you know anarchist libertarians and and and they were making the case that it was a store of value right what is what what are currencies well in in in an ideal form a currency is meant to be a store of value that doesn't change a lot right so inflation screws that up you know other other exogenous events screws that up but then you got to look at okay another way you can say store of value is is this going to be the most acceptable thing like could I go anywhere and trade the crypto that I have on my phone for something I want right I want to go I don't know I want to go on a riverboat tour of the Nile and can I go and will they take my crypto so I always try to get my head around that because it didn't seem especially by its price action it seemed like a perfectly designed speculative asset um and not a store of value so I think I don't know um I don't know if it'll ever turn into store of value um I think that you know that would be one way I would kind of think about the fundamental side of things and that would kind of be along the lines of okay so if we're thinking of this as a store of value then it becomes applicable to say how many people will take this as payment how many people are willing to accept it in terms of a worker you know we have a new mayor here in New York and he was went on and on about who's going to take part of his paycheck and in Bitcoin the mayor of Miami who I've had on my podcast like he's Mr.
Bitcoin um and and so that would be the way I would try to understand the adoption rate so that could that could be kind of a fundamental thing right so if suddenly a country or a bunch of companies or a bunch of investors say yeah we'll all accept fill in the blank right as legal tender that's probably going to be the winner and so keeping an eye on you know what's getting accepted the most what has the most adherence what has all that kind of stuff I guess and those are quasi fundamental things right because in stocks are so much easier right it's company A they make X dollars there's always going to be that crazy stock like Tesla with it has it's a what I call a cult stock and I don't mean that as any disrespect on Elon Musk I think it's hysterical watching the potatoes who hate him and the people who love him I really I just think he's a very interesting guy and I think that like I try to divorce the person from the achievements and like that guy can land rockets on platforms in the middle of the ocean I don't know how you don't respect that and and so like so you get that kind of cultish thing and absent that though most stocks are like based on you know people saying yeah no I'm not going to pay a hundred times for every dollar of earnings and or they you know see the light and it's funny because they all collectively see the light at the same time so I guess that's kind of a bad answer but it's because I really haven't been able to like come up with a way of systematizing a way for us to look at crypto the way we look at investing I think increasingly Jim we might find ways ways to do that in the future and what we do like have to all be cognizant of this man this asset class is just so young right but the the depth of data available for public networks like Bitcoin or Ethereum in terms of like amount of addresses that are like bank accounts that are holding Bitcoin essentially or holding ETH you know how much these addresses actually move Bitcoin or ETH right and how many of them are holding what's the time horizon there's so much data I feel like that could be plugged into quantitative models and the future to help us predict some of this stuff um like I do want to go back to kind of those those tactics for a minute because um I was like also getting really excited about some of the advice you had me you mentioned momentum funds or or momentum filters right and you said one of those is an index I think that's another takeaway for people is like hey use crypto indexes and there are crypto indexes that capture the total crypto market cap right now uh and or also capture like segments like decentralized finance that you can look at and purchase and some of these index will hold up better than others um another like I guess a grab big of strategies that I want to run by you Jim and see if this resonates with kind of your experiences um uh one thing that David has mentioned in the past is that he does like there's so much opportunity I feel like crypto is all of the behavioral uh traps that you find in the regular you know stock market and such you you find in crypto only it's like it's 10x it's on it's on freaking steroids because there will be that guy at a party who just made like a hundred x on some NFT that he purchased right and you're going to think immediately when you hear that story that you can replicate that strategy and that here's the next uh you know asset or token or NFT that you can buy to to replicate that strategy but one thing that I learned from david's what he does with the portion of support folio is he creates like a a d gen portion like a degenerate portion where he's like this is the portion I'm serious about and that's going to be like I don't know david what is it like 90 90 percent or whatever but you're going to take this 10 percent and you're going to get it out of your system right and do sort of the the more d gen activity the scratch the itch portfolio scratch the itch portfolio that's it that's a that's a great way to do it um yeah that's not crazy no not at all not at all because it's a yeah that's actually a really good psychological act um and I love the degenerate um because you're just calling it what it is right and and so it it scratch the isch is good too because if you can scratch the itch you don't feel the need to go all in on that scratch right uh so I think that having what I would call play money right um that you're actually putting in the market that is like that that can solve a lot of folio that can solve a lot of that other stuff we used to keep a um portfolio at my first company which honestly capital management uh that was the what we call the eat uh drink be marrying because tomorrow you die so it was all the vice stocks right so it was filamoras it was all the alcohol makers the pharmaceutical companies hospital stocks funeral homes that kind of stuff it killed it I mean it was like always and again it's taking advantage of we humans you know I mean come on if you let's say you want to die it right and and the you walk into the kitchen and there's a brownie there I could tell you the brownie always wins and again that's back to the time horizon and the way you you discipline yourself right you think yourself okay I'm gonna lose whatever 20 pounds and you walk into the kitchen there's a beautiful brownie that someone's just made and you're like I can just have this because I'll go back to the diet after this right and you kind of never do so the warning that I would have on the degenerate portfolio is you are at risk of like inevitably you're gonna hit a really great strength of wins in the degenerate portfolio and you are gonna pause and think I should this this should be the 90% over here and and and the other one should be the 10% and again human OS man that we're all the same we're all think that so as long as like if you lock it in that it's got can't be any more than 10 you rebalance out of it and take some of those gains and and just do put it on automated right so every quarter you gotta you gotta add to it if you've had losses bring it back up to 10% of your portfolio or more importantly let's say it doubled and in that quarter and you're now 20% degenerate sell it down to 10% again that helps you do that David do you do that yeah that part's hard see well listen man I mean like one of the greatest investors in the world Sir John Teppleton like what he used to do was really interesting so like if he if he was worried that the markets were getting really frothy and everything he would put good till cancel orders in on stocks that he really liked except let's say that that stock when he put that good till cancer cancel order in was trading at a hundred bucks he put in order to buy it at 30 dollars and just leave it right and they ask him why do you do that and he's like because if that stock ever got to 30 there is no way in hell I would have the emotional ability to call in a by order at 30 and when you think about that that's genius so he was self-aware enough to understand that he's not gonna have the willpower and he's making that decision when everything's great right and and so he puts those in and like I talked to somebody who knew him and it's like that's where he made like the biggest killings ever was when when that happened it's Jim it's just such a good freaking idea and this happens all of the time in crypto okay so like one one thing I recall is you know Ethan Bitcoin price in March of 2020 right and so we were hanging out and that you know I don't know Ethan was like the 200s or the 100s or whatever it actually dropped down to like eighty dollars at one point in time and eighty dollars going down to like double digit for an asset that I fundamentally believe in with all of my freaking heart like the fundamentals are strong incredibly excited about holding this thing for like 10 years but in the moments when covid was happening and you hit a spike down to eighty dollar each you're like oh my god what's happening it's all over and you get had I had double digit buys in an order book at that time would have snapped up eat the cheapest is probably ever going to be for the rest of my life and didn't do it it's the order book hack it's so good let me ask you one last hack here because this is something I have I've trouble with personally okay so how do you not get to attach to your assets so when I make mistakes I think in investing it's actually not that I don't hold long that I don't hold long enough is that I hold too long and I'm like oh you know what like I want to hold this a little bit longer because I because I believe it how do you know when to sell how do you make sure you don't get attached to your assets so not now we're pushing into you'll understand why I made such a study of human nature and and the way we are so it it's literally there's a great old Wall Street sign which is a stock doesn't know you own it and and the idea is that we anthropomorphize our stocks and we like people naming their cars are their boats right oh that's Betty and you know whatever and it's just human nature do that right and so like I train myself to be completely dispassionate like if you ask me right now what are your biggest winners in your equity portfolio I have no idea none and I do know they're underlying factors I do know what portfolio I bought them in right but because I automated it I automated the cell process too and I guess we'll go back to talking about David's de gen portfolio if you can automate the process and whatever it doesn't have to be just the generic it can be your overall portfolio it's like you know what just to keep it easy let's say my net worth is a hundred thousand dollars and I'm a passionate believer in Bitcoin and so I'm going to put half my portfolio this is not an investment recommendation people just let's underline that but so you're such a believer you put 50% in that and 50% in other stuff right stocks whatever whatever that other stuff is and you just continually rebalance when you do that bringing it back to 50 50 right when you do that you're forced to sell when your conviction is the highest in that Bitcoin is going to rule the world right and you're forced to buy when your conviction is that it's lowest right because so time a 50 50 a year later Bitcoin 70% of the portfolio the other stuff is 30% you're forced to sell back to 50 50 man that's hard because every part of your emotional being is going to say well this is different right it's finally cut on it's finally you know fill in the blank right and you're going to have all your reasons and they're going to sound really good to you but then on the other hand right Bitcoin like you said had you simply had those double digit orders in the book like you would have never had the guts to pull the gun then right but when it's in the book it's done for you so the other way right all of a sudden stocks are 70% of your portfolio Bitcoin is 30% and you're like well at least stocks have fundamental at least these companies are actually earning money and I guess you know it's maybe else should just probably lead Bitcoin at 30 because you know I'm you know and your reasons will sound equally valid by the way to yourself so that's the way I would do it like so I'll give you an example in 1999 we ran a mutual fund which was a small to bid cap growth fund and it was like my most aggressive strategies right and so 99 was a vintage year for rampant speculation and that fund got rebalanced every six months and there were several stocks in the fund that on the rebalance had already gone up 600% from January to June but they still qualified and I was I still remember this like it were yesterday my trader came in and he's like we are going to override this right this boom this went up 600% and it's got to go down it's just like there's no way it's going to keep going up and I'm like no we're not going to override it we're going to follow the model and you know at the end of the year it's up 1,300% from the first buy in January and then same trader this is what's so fun same guy walks into my office and he goes that was right man it's probably good for another 1000% and the stock no longer fit in the model and I'm like no sorry man you're selling it what you know and so having this built in rebalance I mean like that works in a lot of asset classes and it's just dispassionate right it's just like yeah okay whatever is right for you right and by the way I'm using 50 50 simply because it's easy to illustrate if I'm giving you investment advice in all of your listeners don't put 50% of your portfolio into any speculative asset okay and I think that that Bitcoin still can still counts as a speculative speculative asset but you know other people make the same mistake and you know penny stocks or whatever and and the other bit of advice is you tend to do things like that because you want to get rich quick and what does that bring us back to brings us back to hyperbolic discounting and how that always ends up having cost you a ton of money slow and steady which to other people might see this guy's a reckless look he's got like he's got all this crypto and everything but within your your intellectual framework you might think of it as boring right but it works I think I think that's honestly it's the bankless philosophy of sort of like get rich slowly but like we're doing it in crypto right and so there's there's so many in crypto that want to play the short term games but if you play the long term game that can be your edge Jim this has been so much fun we've got a lot of insights and I feel like I want to summarize this at the very end but last question for you do you have anything like just in part any any final thoughts so again the listener was listening today maybe they're the bulk of their experience in investing comes from like kind of a crypto world and that's how they learn things and so it's like if somebody dropped you into a foreign country where you don't speak the language you just kind of learn it as you go you're missing a lot of the fundamentals of how does the grammar work and how are things spelled so I feel like people listening are probably missing some key pieces of of how to invest in this behavioral short circuiting is probably one of them do you have any just parting thoughts for us anything else we should keep in mind as we're going on this investing journey into crypto and other lands sure um thanks for having me first um so I guess what I would say is like maybe one of the wisest lines I've ever seen in my life is this too shall pass and when you think that way you the losses that you take and you will take losses uh become less painful uh and the gains that you take and hopefully you will take gains um are excite you a lot less in terms of um you know look at what a stud and what a genius I am um and the other parting thought would be read as much as you can like in history and look at what happens to people who there's a great quote from one of the ancient Greeks which is whom the gods would destroy they first make great and and when they make them great they get filled with hubris and they get filled with I am the greatest individual that has ever lived and we all tell ourselves these stories we're all confabulating unreliable narrators and again me included and that's just the way human OS works and we have this incredible desire for certainty and like there is nothing certain in the world other than death and taxes right and you know like if we go into anarchy maybe just death so so I mean like there's precious little that that is um that ultimately important right and and so the other thing I would say is like I love people who like people who really get obsessed about investing it's great because it's never ending it's a wonderfully it's the Olympics of investing of business right because you got a you got to understand a bunch of different things you got to understand human behavior but like leave room and go with what resonates with you and by that I mean um everybody's different you got to find the right process the right thing that you can vibe with and just like keep learning just keep learning listen to your podcast read books do as many things of those things for yourself education that you can because in the real world you got to teach yourself like everybody gets oh well but I studied finance at you know Wharton I don't care it doesn't matter short one futures contract with your own money and you'll have more experience than the Wharton guy that freshly minted and I don't mean to pick on Wharton all business schools right so lessons are hard and and unless you can understand that this happens to everybody you know me you everyone else every successful person you're looking at right every single one of them has a bunch of failures and what made them different they got back up and when they got back up they looked and went oh I really fucked up what can I learn from this and then they just keep going and so and and just don't fall in love you you talked about maximalists like not a good look because it's just like oh man just think about it in terms of a religion and if you're a maximalist you would be the one holding the torch wanting to burn that heretic who you've got type of mistake you don't really want to do that because there is no one true faith or one true method or one true anything find what's right for you um and then like if you're passionate maybe you'll make it a career maybe you'll have a podcast on it that's great if you're not learn as much as you can and then like automate and let that work for you that you know I wish I could give you uh better parts of wisdom but that's what I got for you now I think it's fantastic Jim and you've given us a lot of wisdom ending with that a stay humble and keep leveling up at the same time uh Jim this has been a lot of fun thanks for joining us oh thanks for having me was a lot of fun hey guys I just want to stop and just do a quick recap of that episode because I feel like there's so much many pearls of wisdom and I'm just going to sum it up for us here uh number one Jim was talking about narrative following price not the other way around take that into your crypto journeys also putting in the work that's the real edge here you got to put in the work uh human suck at investing we all have these monkey brains with human os think about that when you're making your investment decisions and this I'm just going to rattle off some tactics to put in your bag on how to short circuit human os number one Jim was talking about writing out your strategy then publishing it maybe on social media what get get gets written gets clarified also dollar cost averaging in number two we talked about that uh next time you want a photo go for a jog instead clear your mind okay also maybe only check the price once a day or once a week slim down in your price checking because every time you check price that shortens your time horizon you're time you look into block folio and coin gecko you're shortening your psychological time horizon uh also using momentum of filters one of those is an index where you can capture upside opportunity logging your ideas uh creating a degen portion of your portfolio that's David's idea that Jim seems to like as well setting your buys on the order book now okay and maybe also your cells because you have to continually rebalance I don't know how many that was but it's at least uh over close to a dozen of practical tips to help you guys survive in crypto and uh once again this has been Jim we appreciate you joining us today had a lot of fun thanks risk disclaimers guys of course none of this has been financial advice crypto is risky you could lose what you put in but we are headed west this is the frontier it's not for everyone but we're glad you're with us on the bankless journey thanks a lot cheers hey we hope you enjoyed the video if you did head over to bankless hq right now to develop your crypto investing skills and learn how to free yourself from banks and gain your financial independence we recommend it joining our daily newsletter podcast and community as a bankless premium subscriber to get the most out of your bankless experience you'll get access to our market analysis our alpha leaks and exclusive content and even the bankless token for air drops raffles and unlocks if you're interested in crypto the bankless community is where you want to be click the link in the description to become a bankless premium subscriber today also don't forget to subscribe to the channel for in-depth interviews with industry leaders ask me any things and weekly roll ups where we summarize the week in crypto and other fantastic content thanks everyone for watching and being on the journey as we build out the bankless nation