✨ DEBRIEF ✨ | Ryan & David's Unfiltered Thoughts on the Episode https://shows.banklesshq.com/p/127-lyn-alden-debrief
Lyn Alden is the Founder of Lyn Alden investment strategy and is a leading expert in macro markets. She focuses on long-term debt cycles and how it’s impacting crypto, fiat, bonds, and equities markets. This is Lyn’s third appearance on Bankless. Each time she’s on, it usually means something is breaking in the macro markets. And something definitely is.
Lyn thoroughly explains everything from whether we’re repeating history to what would turn this recession into a depression to whether or not we’re going to be okay. Don’t worry, Lyn shares her advice on how to be exactly that and more.
Her superpower is to provide clarity during unclear times and this episode is no different.
------ 📣JUNO | Crypto Friendly Banking https://juno.finance/bankless
------ 🚀 SUBSCRIBE TO NEWSLETTER: https://newsletter.banklesshq.com/ 🎙️ SUBSCRIBE TO PODCAST: http://podcast.banklesshq.com/
------ BANKLESS SPONSOR TOOLS:
🚀ROCKET POOL | ETH STAKING https://bankless.cc/RocketPool
⚖️ARBITRUM | SCALING ETHEREUM https://bankless.cc/Arbitrum
❎ACROSS | BRIDGE TO LAYER 2 https://bankless.cc/Across
🦁BRAVE | THE BROWSER NATIVE WALLET https://bankless.cc/Brave
🌴MAKER DAO | DECENTRALIZED LENDING https://bankless.cc/MakerDAO
🔐LEDGER | SECURE STAKING https://bankless.cc/Ledger
------ Topics Covered:
0:00 Intro 6:12 Is this the End? 11:08 Debt Cycle Arc 15:40 The Dollar Milkshake Theory 20:05 Historial Analogs 30:35 How Do We Get Stable? 38:30 Weak Market Links 48:24 Raising Rates 55:03 Deflation & Softer Landings 1:00:19 Fed Meme & Competency 1:07:52 Recession vs. Depression 1:13:06 Markets to Watch 1:18:15 Are We Going to be Okay? 1:22:58 Energy, Food, & Fertilizer Markets 1:29:21 The New Normal 1:36:02 Mental Health 1:38:37 Closing & Disclaimers
------ Resources:
Lyn Alden https://www.lynalden.com/
The Death of the Dollar Dominance https://youtu.be/_Kqcrz3u8rQ Inflation in 2021 https://youtu.be/dyDsQ-XCoNo
Fed Meme https://twitter.com/cobie/status/1542562195573297153
----- Not financial or tax advice. This channel is strictly educational and is not investment advice or a solicitation to buy or sell any assets or to make any financial decisions. This video is not tax advice. Talk to your accountant. Do your own research.
Disclosure. From time-to-time I may add links in this newsletter to products I use. I may receive commission if you make a purchase through one of these links. Additionally, the Bankless writers hold crypto assets. See our investment disclosures here: https://newsletter.banklesshq.com/p/bankless-disclosures
No summary for this episode yet.
a group of elders gets in a room every six weeks and determines what the price of money will be. And it doesn't matter where you are in the country. I mean, this is a country of 330 million people, 50 states, very different markets. And they kind of set the nationwide price and then also because we're the global reserve currency, this has international ramifications. And so I just think that the model itself is kind of antiquated and that as software each the world and as we kind of go through a somewhat inflationary crisis, I think that the shortcomings of that model are kind of being late bear.
Welcome to bankless where we explore the frontier of internet money and internet finance. This is how to get started, how to get better and how to front run the opportunity. This is Ryan Sean Adams. I'm here with David Hoffman and we're here to help you become more bankless. Once again, guys, the bankless journey has veered into macro territory because we got some big questions. These are tumultuous times in macro markets and we brought on Lin Alden who is the perfect person to tell us more about this. And our basic question for Lin, David was, are we going to be okay? And her answer was kind of, it depends.
It's complicated. The big question is how are we going to get out of this? And this is what we asked Lin a few things to look out for in this episode. Number one, what's the checkmate for central banks? What do they come to an end of their capabilities? Number two, why crypto is the only honest market left? Lin makes the case for that. Number three, is this capital R recession going to turn into a capital D depression? And number four, a theme of this episode is what decade are we in? Is this the 1940s, the 1970s? Or oh my god, is it the 1930s? I hope not. Number five, we end with some tips on how to prepare just basic life advice.
What you should do to store your value with your career, even in kind of your family world, David, this is just a great episode for us. I think put a lot of missing pieces together for me in all of the craziness that has been the last three months. Maybe the entirety of this year of 2022 in macro markets, we've had wars, we have inflation, we have a Fed doing all sorts of craziness. Now we have a recession. What's that going to turn into? We get into all of the subjects. Yeah, the fog of war for macro markets, and even crypto markets right now is really, really thick. Everyone's confused multiple people from multiple different parts of the world have stated that this is some of the hardest times, the hardest market sentiment to invest capital.
No one knows how to invest or where to invest. People are just, they feel frozen. They feel like they have paralysis, and that's because the macro markets are so confusing. There are so many different things at play. And so we go through a list of them just with Lyn Alden. We talk about the choices that the Fed has made and the choices that the Fed has left to make, and how there's not really very many tools in the tool belt for their Federal Reserve. So those choices are kind of fixed. And so when we fix that steering wheel, where does that trajectory take us? And then we go into the macro, the external forces, commodity prices, energy prices, food prices, those things are kind of fixed too.
There's not really much influence or choice that we as humans have over these things. And so when we blend all these trajectories together, where do we go? And so that's ultimately where we conclude with this podcast. And then we finish off with, like you said, Lyn's advice. And her advice was grab your bear market buddy, because you know, you need to not go alone into the bear market. And so that's what I'll say now is as you go listen to this, grab your bear market buddy, because you might need it with a friend. Send this to a friend. Guys, in all the chaos that's going on, I think you'll get a rare breath of signal from this episode because Lyn is always clear of thought and help you shape the next decade and your outlook on it.
We're going to get right into the episode with Lyn Alden. But before we do, we want to talk about these awesome tools for going bankless from our sponsors. The layer two era is upon us. Ethereum's layer two ecosystem is growing every day and we need layer two bridges to be fast and efficient in order to live in layer two life. Across is the fastest, cheapest, and most secure cross-chain bridge with a cross you don't have to worry about high fees or long-weight times assets are bridge and available for use almost instantaneously. Across is bridges are powered by UMA's optimistic oracle to securely transfer tokens between layer two's and Ethereum.
Across is critical ecosystem infrastructure and across V2 has just launched. Their new version focuses on higher capital efficiency, layer two to layer two transfers, and a brand new chain with polygon all while prioritizing high security and low fees. You can be a part of a cross's story by joining their discord and using across to all of your layer two transferring needs. So go to across.to quickly and securely bridge your assets between Ethereum, Optimism, Polygon, Arbitrum, or Boba Networks. MakerDow is the OG DeFi protocol. The first DeFi protocol to ever exist even before we call it DeFi, MakerDow produces die, the industry's most battle tested and resilience tablecoin.
Using Maker, you don't need to sell your collateral if you need liquidity. Instead, you can spin up a Maker Vault and use your collateral to mince die directly. With Maker, the power to mince new money is in your hands. And there's something new in the MakerDow ecosystem. Every time a new MakerDow is opened, the owner can claim that po-out, which contributes funds to one tree planted, an organization with ongoing global reforestation efforts. Creating a world where digital participation and the health of our environment can live side-by-side. Soon, Maker will be present on all chains and layer twos, bringing the biggest and best DeFi credit facility to everywhere there is DeFi.
So follow Maker on Twitter, at MakerDow, and learn from the oldest and most resilient Dow in existence. Rocketpool is your decentralized Ethereum-staking protocol. You can stake your ETH in Rocketpool and get our ETH in return, allowing you to stake your ETH and use it in DeFi at the same time. You can get 4% on your ETH by staking it with Rocketpool, but you can get even more by running a node. Rocketpool is the only staking provider that allows anyone to permissionlessly join their network of validating Ethereum nodes. Setting up your Rocketpool node is easier than running a node solo, and you only need 16 ETH to get started.
You get an extra 15% staking commission on the pooled ETH that uses your node to stake. You also get RPL token rewards on top. So if your bullish ETH staking, you can boost your yield by adding your node to the decentralized Rocketpool network, which currently has over 1,000 independent node operators. It's yield farming, but with Ethereum nodes. You can get started at Rocketpool.net, and you can also join the Rocketpool community in their Discord. You can find me hanging out there sometimes in the chat, so I'll see you there. Bankless Station is super excited to introduce Lin Alden. She's back again on Bankless.
Anytime Lin comes on the podcast, you know there's something going on in macro, and today is no exception. Lin is the founder of Lin Alden Investment Strategy. She's a leaning expert in macro markets, focuses on long-term debt cycles, and how that's impacting everyday markets. Of course, a ton to discuss on crypto, on fiat, on bonds, on equities, on whether Jerome Powell is going to steer us off a cliff, or whether we're going to be okay. And so Lin, we want to find out what is going on. My first question to you. First of all, welcome back to Bankless. It's great to have you. And then could you answer the question, is this the end?
Like, are we all going to make it? I think a lot of people are worried, I'm worried myself. What's going on here? Happy to be here. Thanks for having me. I think we can divide it into a couple different time frames. And so in the kind of the big macro scale, I've been using the framework of radio, the long-term debt cycle. And so in that conception, it's the end of something big, right? But of course, the end is a long process. And it can be a decade-long process. So I think that basically, you know, with the long-term debt cycle, every several decades, when you reach a massive amount of debt, when you go down to zero industries, and you have kind of just massive amounts of debt in the system, usually go through some sort of current devaluation and system change, right?
So it's not the end of the world, but it's the end of an era, basically. And I think that's something we're seeing in a number of markets. But, you know, to get let's do more than that, if we focus more on the near-term, we're in a, you know, cyclical downturn. And not all cyclical downturns become recessions, but some subset of them do. And so when we look back over the past, you know, let's say pre-COVID, we had like a 10-year-long, you know, economic expansion in the United States, we still have three cycles within that decade-long period of accelerating growth and then decelerating growth.
And it just that the decelerating growth never became negative growth, and never became an outright recession, even though you had a couple near misses there. And so what we've been in over the past more than a year now is a decelerating growth environment. And then combined with the fact that this one is so inflationary, you know, kind of leading up to that, that this one is becoming more severe and is kind of starting to look like a recession, at least by many indicators. So it does not look like a recession in terms of employment yet, but by most other, especially leading indicators, it does look more recessionary.
And tying this into, you know, crypto, you know, to the extent that I'm here, historically when you look at, you know, the Bitcoin and crypto bull markets, a lot of people tie it to the Bitcoin having, which I think is relevant to some extent, but also actually matches up very, very closely with these economic accelerating and decelerating environments. And so for example, we can use the perching managers index. It's kind of a go to macro indicator for economic acceleration or decelerating. It looks like a sine wave over time. And they average roughly three year cycles. And it just happens that all the Bitcoin bull runs were during these rising PMI environments.
And all of the downward or choppy sideways periods were in declining PMI environments. And of course, that all of crypto kind of goes up and down together, maybe with a little bit of a lag. And a lot of what dictates the PMI environment is also liquidity conditions. And so central banks and kind of dollar liquidity around the world. Generally, you know, one of the big questions was, for example, why is Bitcoin not serving as an inflation hedge? And of course, that would extend to any sort of finite token. Why are these things going down when you ironically have high inflation and fee occurrences?
And there's actually really good charts out there that show, you know, Bitcoin in particular, I use that one because that's what most of the macro people will look at because that's the biggest, most liquid one. And you'll see that, you know, in rising global M2, so rising global money supply year of year, Bitcoin does very well in that environment. And now we're actually in a period where money supply has grown more slowly than it was a year or two ago. And you have multiple central banks mainly of the Fed kind of pushing back and strengthening the dollar compared to many other currencies. And so when you translate all that back into USD denominated global M2 growth, it actually kind of came to a standstill.
So ironically, now that, you know, price inflation is happening with a lag from monetary inflation and some central banks are actually fighting back. It makes more sense is why we're seeing kind of downward price action and a number of assets, including Bitcoin and cryptocurrencies. Lin, you focus on like these long term debt cycles and you're really, really good at placing us in history or at least like talking about what parts of history rhyme with our current phase. So I kind of want to pick your brain as to like where we are in the arc of this long term debt cycle. And for just for added context, we brought you on.
I think our first episode with you was episode 48, January 18th of 2021. And we titled it the death of the dollar dominance. And this was basically a prelude of things to come where the dollar was really just going to lose its place as like the king of, you know, global currencies. And like we've seen events, you know, especially lately, where you kind of see the writing on the wall. And then we had you on in August for episode 76 titled inflation in 2021. This was an inflation really started to pick up, which is one of the things that we kind of predicted with that dollar dominance. We were going to see dollar inflation.
And now here we are in July of 2022. And there's that like gif, that famous internet gif of that truck. And it's hurtling towards the wall. And like you just know it's going to crash. But then it cuts. And then it's going to crash. And then it cuts again, it never actually crashes. But it feels like the question that we're in started with like are we at the end? This feels like with just like extreme inflation, extremely high interest rates. This kind of feels like the last hurrah before we really start to see like the actual just reduction of the dollar dominance. Would you would you agree with this arc and just overall where are we on this arc?
This long arc of the global debt cycle. Yeah. So global debt cycles are kind of correlated to that global reserve status, but not necessarily the same thing. And so in the last kind of long term debt cycle, we did see the transition from UK having global reserve currency United States. One point I've been making for a while is that, you know, now there's really no country large enough to have the only global reserve currency. That was kind of actually anomaly that persistent history. It's not something that necessarily has to repeat over and over again. And then I think we're heading towards a more decentralized type of system.
And I think that was somewhat accelerated by the, you know, the event you've seen in Ukraine, right? So you've Russian initiative war and then the West response by cutting off their foreign exchange reserves. And then you kind of, you know, everyone kind of realizes around the world at the same time that way to second, you know, the money like aspects of these reserves are maybe not as money like as people thought, right? If they can be censored, if they can be confiscated, you know, whether or not you agree with the reason that now gives an incentive to number of countries to be like, wait a minute.
I mean, we're holding liabilities of countries that we're not necessarily fans of, you know, what does that mean? What should we hold instead? And so I do think that we are now we are starting to see, for example, gradual shifting away from treasuries by Russia was obviously early to do it. China's been doing it since 2013. You know, Japan has been a big biotragist, but now they kind of have to protect their own currency. So they're not really buying treasures anywhere either. And you've seen, for example, some of the economic forums Putin is called for kind of, you know, alternative payment systems, you know, cooperation with some of the other peers like between Russia and China or Russian India, for example, India's actually stepped in even though India's more of a, you know, someone of an ally to the West than, you know, compared to China or Russia, they stepped into by massive amounts of Russian crude.
And so I do think we're seeing a little bit more of a multi-polar world emerge rather than a, you know, a unipolar world, you know, just kind of a US dominated global order. I think it's shifting into, you know, kind of a more multi-polar, you know, multiple centers of power. And right now, we actually, the dollar index itself is very strong. That's a large part because it's heavily connected, you know, it's heavily based on the euro and the yen. And Europe's obviously having a very specific energy crisis more so than even the rest of the world. And Japan's doing yield curve control with a very tight cap.
And so basically, it's one of those things where, you know, it's not that the dollar is weakening right now. It's actually quite strong. But the global demand for it, especially among foreign central banks, is drifting towards that more decentralized model. And if anything of the past decade, you've seen a mild uptick and gold usage among central banks because, you know, I was something like Bitcoin or these others, nowhere near big enough or stable enough that for most of them to be interested. And so gold is kind of the, you know, the self-gustodial inflation protected assets that they could turn to if they want to, you know, hold money for a long period of time and not have counter-party risk.
So we have central banks that are definitely following the reducing the dollar dominance playbook. But we have the DXY, the Dixie, which is like the dollar strength index, having like, I think 20 year highs or just really, really strong right now. And so I want to ask you about the dollar milkshake theory, which I'm pretty sure you're familiar with, the idea that before there's a collapse in the dollar, there's a significant strength in the dollar because so many debts are dollar-denominated both inside the United States and outside the United States that even if we are on the precipice of like a total reduction in dollar dominance in the world, first people have to buy dollars to pay back their debts.
And then the big like crash and reset happens. Do you ascribe to the dollar milkshake theory and do you see that as the evidence of what's going on in the macro markets as supporting that theory? So I think that the theory has a lot of merits and I've actually met and discussed and debated with the, you know, the person who proposed that theory, Brent Johnson, you know, my quates is with them. And, you know, when people and macro people debate that theory, you know, the ones that understand it is not so much they disregard this theory, the question is how does that theory end up? And so basically for people that aren't often aware that the point goes that, you know, United States is globals of currency.
That doesn't just mean that central banks hold it. It also means that it's the currency that most offshore debt is denominated in. So if an entity makes a loan to develop in country, either the government or large corporation there, they often don't want to do it in their local currency. They'd rather do it in a, in a harder currency. I mean, that could be dollars, euros, yeah, and things like that. And dollar, of course, is the, is the disproportionate one there. And also it's not even mostly US entities that are necessarily making those loans. Entities in Europe or Japan or China will go out and make dollar-based loans to, you know, a country in Africa or a country in South America.
And so as a result, the world outside of the United States has, according to the bank for international settlement, something like $13 trillion in US denominated debt. Now that's somewhat offset by the fact that the whole world outside of the US has something like $50 trillion in US nominated assets, right? So the US has run these gigantic structural trade deficits. Actually, about, you know, $14 trillion worth of trade deficits over the past, you know, call it 25 years or something like that. And they take those dollars and then they buy US assets. So they buy treasuries when those started to become kind of worse investments.
They shifted by US stocks. They buy US real estate and things like that. They kind of pile it into financial assets. And so when you, basically when it comes down to the dollar milkshake theory, the point is that if there's any sort of disruption in dollar cash flows, the strengths of the dollar goes up dramatically because all that debt represents demand for dollars. And so they have to, basically, they have a short squeeze. They have to buy dollars if they want to cover their own debts or try to service them. Now, where that, that fear, I think, becomes so much self-defeating, is that if the dollar spikes too much, like what we're seeing right now and what we saw back in action in March 2020 during the, you know, kind of the worst of the COVID crash, it starts to cause ironic that US recession, global recession, global liquidity problems, and then those entities start selling US-nominated assets in order to get dollars.
So you start to get problems in the US treasure market, it liquidity problems because the foreign sector stops buying or outright starts selling them in order to get dollars. And so, you know, first it hits other countries, but then it ricochets back into us. And I think that right now we're kind of in that phase, where it's ricocheting back into us. And that's an environment where almost nothing other than dollars does well, including US assets, US stocks, you know, multiple things start selling off. And then of course Bitcoin and crypto is being so volatile and a smaller market, they generally, you know, there's some of the earliest things of the fall they get crushed.
But even things like, you know, equities, real estate, gold, just assets around the world sell off because basically, this unit of account is strengthening so much and causing kind of foreselling. That's interesting. Yeah, it's interesting how interrelated all of these things are, Lin. And you know, you talked about sort of subscribing to Radalio's long-term debt cycles overarching thesis. And I've recently read his book, you know, Principles for dealing with a changing world order, where he kind of looks historically at other empires and kind of the rise and fall of their monetary systems as well.
And so you kind of wonder if this is sort of part of the fall of the US as a monetary leader. And I think you're indicating that, well, you know, before that happens completely, there might be an erosion, right? And there might be some, you know, some pluralism in terms of the monetary instruments use. But I'm curious if you could kind of ground us with any historical analogs here. So is this like, is this like something that happened in the 1700s? Should we go back to other, you know, our history of other empires? Or even, I've heard so many people talk about this as the 1940s. Maybe that's a good analog, you know, or others have talked about the inflation of the 1970s.
Some people, when you start using the recession word, people immediately think back to 2008, which was in most listeners, I guess every listener's lifetime, who's probably listening to this. And it also feels like, hey, if things get really bad, if the recession, the R word turns into the D word, are we entering a 1930s type time range? So are there any historical analogs for this that come to mind for you? Or is this just the 2020s? It's completely independent thing and brand new. So it's a good question. I mean, I think that that that quote that is either correctly or falsely attributed to Mark Twain is really applicable.
And I've used it a number of times, which is history repeats. I mean, history has a repeat, but it does rhyme. And so analogs, I think are actually really useful. But of course, there's no perfect analog. And if you go back far enough, technology's totally different. And so basically the 2020s, you know, are their own thing. But we still learn from periods of history. You know, I think that the base is to understand different analogs so that one can then see how they're different from that. If they don't study history at all, they're completely blindsided. They think it's all unprecedented, whereas actually there were rather similar environments.
And so I think we can divide that into two parts. One is the, you know, you mentioned Dalio's principles of, you know, the focusing on that global reserve and rising and falling empires. And then that's different from maybe this current macro environment, even I think they're related. So in that book, what one thing he does, he actually he'll he'll take an empire and he kind of goes back in history. So there's, you know, kind of the called the Chinese one, United States one, the UK, you know, the Netherlands, he goes back in time, maybe 500 years or so, and he tracks these, these handful of empires.
And he, he grade them on multiple scales, right? So there's like, they're, you know, their education, their military power, their economic size, there was, you know, their global reserve currency status, basically the acceptance of their currency by, you know, their, their various trading partners and other countries around the world. And there are some that are more league leading and lagging than others. So education, for example, is a rather leading one where that starts to rise before many of the others and then starts to fall before many of the others. Whereas the other ones, you know, because of never effects and momentum that is, you know, takes a long time to turn around, those are more lagging.
And so global reserve currency is actually one of the most lagging ones where all those other things come into place first and then their currency gets wildly accepted. And then even as some of those other ones start to clearly deteriorate, the global reserve currency is kind of the last one to roll over because there is still so much never effect and usage for it that it's, you know, it's the, it's the incumbent. It's very hard to displace until all the other pieces are there. And so, Dallio often points to China as kind of the rising power compared to United States, which is many ways compared to, you know, United States was the rising power compared to the UK.
I think that there is some accuracy to that. But I mean, I don't think that, you know, transit into, you know, 20 years from now, we're all using the you want, right? I think that's, that's not what that means. I think that ultimately we're going to, is again, a more bipolar type of world, you know, maybe a tri-polar world, what have you want to call it, but not this kind of uni-polar world. I mean, after World War II, which is maybe the closest analog because that was the rise of the United States over the over the 90 kingdom, you know, most of the world was devastated, and that stage was kind of like almost untouched, right?
And so we were rebuilding our allies. We were helping rebuild some of our enemies. I mean, we, you know, we had kind of the last intact manufacturing base. And that was kind of a, you know, becoming like a hyper power status, which is, which is pretty rare in history. And so, I, you know, outside of something like that happening, I think that the the era we're going into somewhat more decentralized, somewhat, you know, different poles. And just you have the relative diminishment of the United States. I mean, we have something like what four or five percent of the population at our maximum height.
We were like two thirds of global currency reserves. And that's kind of inherently unstable system. It's kind of it's hard to maintain that level of dominance. And I think we're naturally drifting towards where is the population centered? Where are these different sources of power? And so I do think that we're headed in that direction. And then tying it into historical analogues in other areas, like what is, what is this inflation similar to? What is this economic environment similar to? I have been using the 40s of the closest comparison. And the reason I've been doing that is so when people think of inflation, they often think of the 70s, right?
So they just go, that's the, that's the one they think of. But the environment was quite different and the causes of inflation were quite different. The one similarity, I think, was the shortage of energy. But outside of that, most of the money supply growth in the 70s was you had a demographic boom. You know, the baby boomers were entering their home buying years. You had a lot of bank lending happening. And so when commercial banks make loans that increases the broad money supply. And then of course, on top of that, you had some fiscal problems. But the deficits were actually much smaller. And a lot of that broad money supply was happening because of the banks.
You also had pretty low debt as a percentage of GDP. And so Paul Volkl, for example, the head of the Fed at the time could raise rates to double digits to try to, you know, kind of purposely put the US in a recession, stabilize the dollar for international creditors and go from there, right? So I think it's both the causes and solutions to inflation were quite different than what we're seeing today. And actually, I think a closer analog is the 40s, which was, you know, you didn't have a lot of bank lending. You didn't have a lot of demographic expansion. But you had, you know, after the 30s, actually, let's go back to the 30s.
So you had this, you know, obviously in 1929 crash, you had a decade-long depression. And you had rising populism, you know, both between countries and within countries. And that took different forms. I mean, obviously in Europe, you know, you had the rise of Nazism. And that obviously contributed to global conflict. You also had populism in the United States, multiple other countries because of that tough economic environment. And then eventually, when you ran into the 40s, and you started to get that conflict happening and you worked out a lot of leverage in the system, you had, you know, huge fiscal expenditures, right?
Because a lot of it was to fight the war and to kind of rebuild things after that period of, you know, stagnation and populism. And so the inflation that we saw in the 40s was very fiscally driven. It wasn't bank lending driven. It's very fiscally driven. So you had a sharp increase in the money supply. And you had very high public debt to GDP, which means that the central bank couldn't raise rates to double-digit because you'd bankrupt the federal government. And so they just held rates low anyway, despite significant inflation. And you had this, you know, this huge fiscal driven inflation. And I think that, you know, what we've seen over the past, you know, call it 15 years has kind of been a replay of that where we had that doesn't a crash.
In many ways, you know, I have a whole bunch of charts out there that show it's very similar to 29 crash in terms of it being a private debt bubble that unfolded. And then, you know, throughout the whole 2010s, we had what in many ways was a mild depression. I mean, emerging markets, basically they had, you know, almost no, you know, except for China and a couple others, most of them had no dollar-dynamited GDP growth over a very long stretch of time. I mean, look at the stock markets. They've gone sideways in dollar terms for 10, 15 years. You know, many of them have not had, you know, kind of substantially new highs in dollar terms, even in the United States and elsewhere, you had unusually slow GDP growth.
You had rising populism intentions in the United States and Europe and many other countries. And so, you know, going into this, we're very, very leveraged. And then we have, you know, the pandemic and we have, you know, this very leveraged system hit by an external catalyst. And so we have something that looks like wartime finance and response, you know, trillions and trillions of dollars printed, ends up being a very inflationary, as one would expect. And so I think that in many ways, the 2020s are resembling the 1940s, but then there are some differences. So in the 40s, going back to Ray Dallas conception, the United States was a rising power.
We were running trade surpluses. Now we look more like the UK looked in the 40s were structural trade deficits. We're kind of the incumbent power where we're more deindustrialized due to kind of shipping our supply chains overseas. And so there are a bunch of differences, I think, but I think that people should be familiar with the 40s. If they want to have a decent macro framework here. So is there a vague way where this plays out like the 1940s, except the US is the UK, something to that effect. Well, I think in terms of the UK had a diminishing share of global GDP in that time. And I think that that that clips out for the US somewhat similarly.
In all of my kind of 1940s comparisons, I have, you know, obviously the first thing people think of is like, wait a minute, world war. And I'm like, I'm not saying that's going to happen. I was like not making the kinetic comparison. Unfortunately, that that's gotten more direct with, you know, obviously recent recent events where you have more kind of, you know, kinetic conflict happening. But I do think that this is a time where, you know, we go through transitions. And right now it's Europe, I think that's most at risk for a lot of things. But I do think that the United States, I mean, you're probably at the end of this decade is going to have less of a unipolar grip on global financial markets than it had, you know, going into this decade.
I think that there's more catalyst for countries like Russia and China, and then even countries like India to develop just alternative systems and alternatives towards a value. Having a more decentralized money system definitely seems to fit into the theme that we've been seeing. There's less globalization going on. Our supply chains have broken. People are moving manufacturing like to be more domestic and also kind of more or less fits into the crypto side of things. It's like, yeah, we also like our money to be internet based and not based in any one particular geographic region. And so it's really helpful just say, like kind of take these like decade and almost century long time frames just to really place us into history.
But also at the same time, Lynn, like the markets seem, the fog of war around markets seem so thick right now. Like we are not looking five, 10 years long investing horizons. People are looking at like, what is the Fed going to do next week? So I want to zoom in here and start to get a little bit granular as to like how we get out of this like that we're in a dis equilibrium right now. Everyone understands that whatever the financial or economic state of the world is is not normal right now. And we would like it to go back to being normal. Whatever normal is we're probably going to be it's probably going to be a new normal.
But that's fine. So long as it's stable. And so my question to you is like we have a few paths ahead of us. How do we get to like a stable path? What does that stable path look like? What is this new equilibrium? So we have like the feds going to raise interest rates or lower them. So like what are the paths ahead that the fed have? Like what are the reasonable outcomes that the feds choices are going to make in the next like three, six, 12 months. So my expectation for you know several months now is that the feds going to raise rates until it breaks something. And I think we're kind of entering the phase where things are starting to break.
Nothing's kind of broken so much they have to pause now. But I think that you know basically they were late to respond. And now I think that they're kind of making another mistake which is responding super aggressively too late when they've already kind of missed their window. So you know we already have you know economic decelerating activity and then they're tightening into that which is actually historically very unusual. And you know they're basically because their credibility is on the line you know drone pals like this is on the line where you know they have a long-term 2% inflation target and they're looking at like 8.
6% official inflation levels higher if you look at a number of important categories. And so it's understandable that with employment so low and and industry it's so high that they're going to try to fight it. The problem is that the source of inflation is largely outside of their control. So a lot of the inflation happened not because of Fed actions but because of fiscal actions. And number two they can't really do anything about the supply side right. So the lack you know the lack of energy the lack of certain commodities things like that. And if anything's if you tighten too much you can ironically make it harder for for many companies to bring on new supply.
And so I think that they have a very limited tool set but nonetheless in order to preserve their own kind of just legacy and kind of purpose they're trying to use the tools they have. And I think they're going to basically use them until it gets messy enough because they can't create new supply but one thing they can do is try to suppress demand. And that can potentially lower prices but then ironically that comes at the cost of a recession. And you know kind of checkmate for a central bank is when they have high inflation but for one reason or another they cannot raise industries. And so for example in the 1940s and United States you're fighting a total war you have 130% you know federal debt to GDP of running massive deficits.
And the Treasury Department just says look you know we're not going to lose this war so you're not going to raise industries and you just can't you just can't do it. And so that that was an example where they just said look you know inflation is running hop but we're going to cap yields anyway. So at one point the 40s you had 19% year of year inflation and they still didn't raise rates because they just they just couldn't and it wouldn't even really mattered because the source of inflation was a decision to you know print a lot of money build a lot of stuff and fight the Nazis and things like that right.
So it's it's a different type of inflation than what you see in say the 70s. And I think that right now there's a number of central banks that are essentially checkmated where there's you know too much debt in some of their areas like for example it Italy has 150% debt to GDP. Japan has 250% public debt to GDP. And so you know they can't support 5, 6, 7, 8, 10% it just rates. And so their central banks the ECB in the bank in Japan are basically saying look we just can't raise rates right now. So you know we're just going to hold rates low despite the fact that this is happening. The Fed has a little bit more leeway and so there is still in the phase where they're at least trying to you know raise rates from a very low level to try to combat it.
But again I think that runs into the whole dollar milkshade thing we discussed earlier where if the Fed is kind of an outlier compared to a number of other developed countries and you see a dollar strengthened too much then you ironically have foreign entities sell treasuries and start causing you know problems in US capital markets and the US economy. And I think that ultimately forces the Fed to probably stop tightening by next year even if inflation is still kind of running hot or is quick to bounce back as soon as they do. So I think I think kind of the the new normal for this decade is probably going to be this kind of cyclical inflation where that you know it can go away for periods of time but then it's quick to return once the conditions are right for it.
And I think that you know in many ways the past few decades have been unusually disinflationary in the sense that you know we basically had more money supply growth but lower inflation than you'd expect for that money supply growth because we had a lot of levers we could pull to prevent wages from rising and to kind of push that inflation elsewhere. And as a large part due to globalization right so we'd kind of you know we'd push a lot of our manufacturing to cheaper places in the world so that you know we basically had that big offset. And when you combine that with more law and technology and things like that we had a rather you know disinflationary period of time and I think that we've kind of run out of rope for that path both are just geopolitical reasons and just kind of populism reasons and then just due to due to you know kind of the natural limits of how much you can do that I think we're now kind of in a process where we don't really have that ability to push inflation elsewhere and so money supply growth more readily results in inflation for us going forward in in developed markets and then in addition commodity cycles kind of go through these kind of 10 to 20 year cycles where it takes years and years to bring on these big commodity resources and so you have this period where you know prices are low nobody wants to invest eventually you kind of work through the existing supply start to get price increases I start to get inflation and then a lot of new capital comes in and builds up all this new supply events you overbuild that takes many years and then that's you know the high prices end up being their own cure for high prices they bring a lot of capital and then you have oversupply at a period of lower prices and I think the past you know call it 10 to 15 years we've been in this commodity disinflationary cycle over supply and I think that that's mostly behind us now so I think that you know going forward the next you know call it 5 10 15 years I think we are it just inherently more inflationary environment because we're not oversupplied with energy and most commodities and we don't have those offshoring disinflationary levers that we had so in some way this not that this is highly inflationary although it is it's actually that the past decade was highly disinflationary is unusually disinflationary we had unusually strong levers to offset some of our monetary growth and we don't have those levers anymore so I think there's going to be more correlation between money supply and inflation but of course for the lag.
I want to get just a little bit more clarity on what you mean by the Fed is going to raise interest rates until something breaks and when you said that my mind immediately went to the crypto markets which are like things a lot of things broke in crypto in the last month we have like three O's capital got liquidated that had contagion and Voyager like Celsius is underwater a bunch of just like smaller crypto banks are are going under like block fives distressed so if we're looking at the crypto industry as like a litmus test like well a lot of things just broken crypto however crypto is still very very small so if we're taking this to the larger financial market and you're saying that the Fed is going to raise rates until the larger financial market starts to break like what's an example of something breaking in the financial market is there any like weak link that sticks out to you that's going to go first I would say treasure market or credit markets for example you know one of my macro friends Luke Roman describes you know Bitcoin and crypto as last functioning fire alarm meaning it's one of the last free markets and so it kind of it's kind of the clear in the coal mine it responds quicker to change in liquidity than other markets that are larger and more managed right so so the fact they've seen so much carnage among all this leverage and all these things wiping out I think is a precursor what we're seeing you know to lesser extent in macro markets because there's no you know the central bank is not going to rush in and do anything with crypto it's all of that is just on its own it's it's going to survive or die in its own based on the merits of the of the projects and so if if you I guess analogues are good here so if you go back to 2018 right so so the last time the Fed was raising rates they were raising them through 2017 you had a strong economic environment you had you know kind of the incoming fiscal stimulus because they did tax cuts that were not you know offset but any sort of you know other spending cuts elsewhere so they basically is putting more money into the economy and you had a rising economic environment but again this this generally goes through cycles and so by the time you got into late 2018 you know you were kind of out of stimulus and you were kind of slowly rolling over in terms of economic activity you're starting to get slower growth and the Fed was hiking rates and Jerome Powell described it as being on autopilot he's like we're just going to keep doing this we're going to keep producing our balance sheet we're going to keep hiking rates and eventually credit markets broke and by credit markets I mean that you know corporate bonds basically corporate you know corporations have need for refinancing their debt you know issuing debt to do operations things like that and especially in the weaker markets the you know the the non-investment grader the junk bond markets that market completely froze for like six weeks nobody was able to issue debt because the the yields were messed up the market was liquid nobody wanted to you know no one no one in that environment was like you know I don't want to buy right now junk bonds right so the whole market froze and so a lot of people saw on the surface at the S&P 500 went down 20% which was of course a notable event I mean it's a pretty big correction but that's not why the Fed jumped in they jumped in because they saw credit markets which are much more tied to the economy and much more tied to corporate solvency and liquidity totally break and so you know they had to basically pause and say you know you know we're going to be data dependent we're not going to autopilot we're going to you know start adjusting a couple months later they were already kind of trimming their rates a little bit this was all pre-COVID this was in 2019 and then you had the repo rate spike that's another thing that broke so interbank overnight lending markets broke the Federal Reserve had to come in and reliquify those so they'd end their balance sheet reduction ahead of schedule and start expanding their balance sheet and then by March 2020 when you were full on in COVID you had a massive crash you had a dollar spike the milkshake theorist playing out you had foreign sectors selling treasuries so the Federal Reserve had to come in and buy treasuries to reliquify the market so you have the treasurer market break so those are examples of things in financial markets breaking that are you know closely tied to the functioning of the US economy that the Fed is basically forced to jump into and some of those things like the treasurer market or the repo market are something that is you know if they break the Fed will literally have an emergency meeting and fix it in like hours or days right that those are those are like the core of the system you know credit markets you know they those can break for weeks and then the Fed will be like okay we have to figure out what's going on here whereas like something like crypto markets are so on the periphery that you know they can break and the Fed will just keep tightening until one of those closer markets starts to break and as I as we're having this recording treasurer market illiquity it is getting pretty problematic so it's pretty volatile market is pretty illiquid so we're starting to see signs of stress in the treasurer market it's not completely broken like we saw in March 2020 but it is getting quite messy and we're also seeing rising spreads in corporate bond markets so we're starting to see more stress in those markets and neither of those markets have gone to like outright breakage but they are getting weaker and I think pointing to the fact that you know the markets are going to realize that by next year maybe even before then the Fed's probably going to find it harder hard to continue tightening regards to what the inflation numbers are showing us this is so fascinating by the way Lynn and to bankless listeners I can't believe this content is free all right this is the beauty of podcasts all right so like in previous decades in normal people would have no access to this level of analysis and this kind of information much harder to prepare and the the kind of analysis that we're getting Lynn is just helping me think which with much more clarity about the rest of the 2020 so you know thank you for everything you do and it's so cool that like with the internet age that we're living and all of this is it is free anyone can listen to this but Lynn there's a that's also just jumping that's also why the analogs can be tricky right so if you're looking back in the 40s and they're essentially doing what's called financial pressure they're holding industries below the inflation rate you know people didn't have ready access people couldn't rattle off what's the inflation rate what are interest rates you know they would they would check their like weekly newspaper if they were into the markets but you know basically the information traveled very slowly and a lot of what was happening it was only known in hindsight as we de dissected what happened throughout the whole banking system who was buying what how is this being managed whereas now in the age of information you know people are updating each other like memes on the internet about what's happening real time and spreading that out we have a meme here that we want to talk to you about but like is this also why things seem to be happening so fast like it feels like we're we're living through like decades in the course of years and in the whip lash that we've seen lately has felt like we've lived through several big you know decades just in the past three or four years do you think that's ties into the thesis of like things will actually happen at an accelerated rate with the highs and the lows and everything from here on out I think partially that said I think that there's there's two things one is that things when things start to get break you know basically when they're at the end of a long-term death cycle you have to kind of a phase change in the way the system works you get more volatility and more whip lash so that's number one we kind of saw some of the things in the 20s 30s and 40s but number two yeah I do think that the spread of information means that markets can adjust a lot quicker and so you get a lot of kind of wild action and that's actually I mean that's part of why those crypto banks had so much problems you know even the ones that weren't outright insolvent they had bigger bank runs than than most banks would ever experience because all that money can move faster and you know this is kind of the whole point of the space and so you had bigger bank runs and and more liquidity problems and it all just kind of becomes contagious right away.
Arvantrum is an Ethereum layer two scaling solution that is going to completely change how we use DeFi and NFTs some of the coolest new NFT collections have chosen Arvantrum as their home while DeFi protocols continue to see increased liquidity and usage you can now bridge straight into Arvantrum from more than 10 different exchanges including finance FTX who will be in crypto.com once on Arvantrum you'll enjoy fast transactions with cheap fees allowing you to explore new frontiers of the crypto universe new to Arvantrum for a limited time you can get Arvantrum NFTs designed by the famous artist Ratwell and Sue Goi for joining the Arvantrum Odyssey the Odyssey is an eight-week long event where you complete on-chain activities and receive a free NFT as a reward find out more by visiting the discord at discord.
gg slash Arvantrum you can also bridge your assets to Arvantrum at bridge.arvantrum.io and access all of Arvantrum's apps at portal.arvantrum.1 in order to experience DeFi and NFTs the way it was always meant to be fast cheap secure and friction-free the Brave browser is the user first browser for the web3 internet with over 60 million monthly active users and inside the Brave browser you'll find the Brave wallet the secure multi-chain crypto wallet built right into the browser web3 is freedom from big tech and Wall Street more control and better privacy but there's a weak point in web3 your crypto wallet and most crypto wallets are browser extensions which can easily be spoofed but the Brave wallet is different no extensions are required which gives Brave browser an extra level of security versus other wallets Brave wallet is your secure passport for the possibilities of web3 and supports multiple chains including Ethereum and Salana you can even buy crypto directly inside the wallet with ramp and of course you can store send and swap your crypto assets manage your NFTs and connect to other wallets and DeFi apps so whether you're new to crypto or you're a seasoned pro it's time to ditch those risky extensions and it's time to switch to the Brave wallet download Brave at brave.
com slash bankless and click the wallet icon to get started there is a brand new staking feature in the ledger live app two day we all like staking the assets that were bullish on and now you can stake seven different coins inside the ledger live app Cosmos, Polkadot, Tron, Algarirans, Tezos, Salana and of course Ethereum with ledger live you can take money from your bank account buy your most bullish crypto asset and stake that asset to its network all inside the ledger live app through a partnership with figment ledger also lets you choose which validator you want to stake your assets with and ledger is running its own validating notes offering a convenient way to participate in network validation and it even comes with slashing insurance ledger live is truly becoming the battle station for the bankless world so go download ledger live if you have a ledger already you probably already have it and get started securely staking your crypto assets so this is fantastic and to your earlier point about about the Fed is like one takeaway I had well listening to you Lynn is the Fed doesn't care about equities right now it definitely doesn't care about your crypto asset prices doesn't care at all but when things start breaking credit markets closer to treasuries that's when they're going to start but one thing that I can't quite square in many of the macro people we've heard from and talk to lately lately is this so Dan Moorehead from Pentera Capital put out a memo recently and you called the recent actions of the Fed the rate raises like you know 0.
5% increase or something like this and what are we at now Lynn is it like 1.5% 1.7 1.5% and we just had a 75 basis point increase which was the biggest in you know something like so the biggest into in in 25 years the biggest in a long time you called that aggressive but Dan Moorehead in his you know in his commentary was like that's not aggressive what we need to be doing is 5% like or higher we like that's that's how much catch up we have to do because the Fed hadn't been doing anything since the signals were there of like a year ago let's say summer of 2021 we should have been doing more the Fed should have been doing more and so rates have to increase to like 4 or 5% maybe higher and so I hear that sentiment from some macro people and then I also hear like the other it seems like you know unsolvable force meets immovable object sort of thing like at 5% the US's interest rate payments have got to be absolutely crazy and like to your point about breaking like what has broken in the world economy at at 5% levels god knows god knows what crypto prices look like what stock prices look like and what credit markets look like and how does the the US actually services debt and pay its debt this is something I can't quite square can you can you help bring some insight here how is it possible that we need to raise rates to 5% why are some macro people saying that why are others saying like you can't possibly raise rates to 5% because if you do the US won't be able to service its its debt yeah it's a good question I think that I think that actually comes back to why studying periods of history so useful and so back in in 2020 I started writing about the inflation that was likely to come from from this increase in the money supply and also expecting that interest rates would be slow to rise in response to that high inflation basically to have a large and normal gap between inflation and interest rates and that's actually what we've seen I mean that the Fed is you know even though they they just had you know they're their first certified basis rate hike in a long time there's still the furthest behind inflation they've ever been since 1951 since basically the end of the whole 1940s inflationary period and so basically the basically further behind inflation that they have ever been since the last long-term debt cycle ended right so and I think that's why historical analogues are important because if anyone was using the you know the the 2000s modeled inflationary environment or the the 1970s inflationary environment they have expected higher interest rates in response to that higher inflation whereas if I think you're looking at the amount of debt in the system and you're looking at kind of the low threshold of interest rates where things start to break you would more readily expect that policymakers would have no choice but to have you know basically have an inability to close that gap and I think that that's what we're seeing playing out and it's normal for macro people to to be wrestling with this with this viewpoint because it's such a it's not something that happened in their lifetimes and so really you have to go back to history books and you have to kind of look at bottlenecks in the system and start trying to judge what break what is the order of which things break because as you point out if you go up to 5% interest rates that sounds responsible that's like you know we should have positive real rates I mean if we have high inflation we have to raise rates that that makes sense for a lot of people but as you point out that breaks basically everything so you know not just stock market going down but housing market breaks probably the foreign sector has to rapidly start selling treasures treasure market goes completely liquid like it did in March 2020 and then what do you do there right so it's like it just you know the whole system kind of seizes up and I think that's a function of the fact that you know for 40 years now we've had lowered lower interest rates all the way down to zero and in some cases negative in some countries and that's resulted in higher and higher debt relative to GDP and that debt is only serviceable with low rates and I think that that is what defines a long-term death cycle that's why it's different than a normal deleverting event because there's so much debt the system that it if ever delivers normally the whole system breaks and so given the choice between massive you know bumpy deflationary collapse or printing money that historically the result in printing money which can take the form of holding interest rates below inflation for quite a long period of time and so in the 1940s for example inflation average 6 percent it's spike decided 19 percent and the Fed held rates it roughly 0 percent and they basically just said you know we're not going to default so this is interest rates and we're seeing that right now in Japan where you know they're above their inflation target but they're holding rates zero and they're capping their 10-year bond at 0.
25 percent with yield curve control they're basically printing money into inflationary spike because they're like our debt our public debt is 250 percent debt to GDP so we're not going to raise rates to positive real levels anytime soon and we're seeing a similar thing in Europe they're basically saying look Italy's got a hundred percent debt to GDP they're not going to have positive or rates they basically bond holders are going to default in one or two ways if they raise rates they're going to default normally right so Italy's just going to be unable to service debt or you just everyone's going to take a haircut and you know Italy's not going to default normally but they're going to basically default in real terms when you keep saying default in real terms right so what we're talking about is inflation is really the pressure release valve here right that's how we have in the in the long term debt cycle we have we have pump this like this balloon maximally full and now it's going to pop but the way we can like deflate it slowly is through inflation that's kind of seeping out the sides and is that why we're seeing that with like the yen and the euro why they're at like you know 20-year lows relative to the to the dollar is because we're starting to see kind of inflation deflate this this debt pressure that's been building up I think that's what we're seeing but it won't be a pleasant process and so basically in a normal de-leveraging cycle the amount of debt in the system comes down whereas in a long term debt cycle basically endgame type of scenario there's so much debt in the system that it it can't come down without collapsing everything and so instead you have the denominator go up which is money supply right so you have debt compared to GDP nominal GDP and compared to money supply go down not because there's tons of de-leveraging but because there's inflation of the underlying unit that that debt it's nominated in and you know that's one it's a very messy environment and it's so rare in developed markets I mean this happens all the time in emerging markets it hasn't happened in our lifetimes in developed countries and that's why this is so challenging to navigate and it usually involves financial oppression because if you're inflating away the currency people want to get out of the currency so then they often try to block the exits and say well you know you can't buy like in the United States when they went through this period they they made it illegal to own gold literally for if you own a benign yellow medal you could get up to 10 years in prison which is you know kind of insane by today's standards and so basically it's it's one of those things it's kind of intellectually offensive that they say okay well this is you took out this debt this is what you owe but when push comes the shove that's that's essentially what happens in history where they they kind of inflated away and you know there's there's weight there's snares where it can happen slower than others and there's ways that can happen more spectacularly and more kind of terribly and that partially comes down to what's happening in the real world right so for example the fact that Europe is now energy insecure kind of makes that more of an emergency for them whereas you know Japan and into the United States is a little bit less of an outright emergency and might happen more gradually for example whereas some areas are more an emergency status and then of course that's even more so for some of these periphery countries like Sri Lanka for example that's like being completely unable to get fuel because they have kind of fewer resources in general so their whole reserve systems messed up and so I do think that we are in an environment where a lot of debts will be inflated away and that can mean different things depending on the order of events that happen right so it could be a spectacular blow up or it could be like the 1940s financial pressure scenario where it drags out over a decade and you know everybody kind of takes a haircut is there any softer landing if it happens to all developed countries at once it seems like all the central banks are in a similar scenario and if it happens to everyone is is that a softer landing than if like it's only happening in a few small pockets I think that still remains to be seen because the challenge there is that even though it's happening to every country once it's not happening to every person in those countries equally right so for example right now in the United States consumer sentiment you know the University of Michigan does a consumer sentiment survey nationwide and they it's actually got their lowest ever reading yeah here it was last month in June since they started doing it yeah like 70 years ago right it's just it's never been lower it basically the it only got almost as low during the the bottom of the subprime crisis and very briefly at the end of the 70s early 80s when they had massive inflation and Volcker was trying to put the economy into recession to fight it which is kind of similar to now but basically it's it's the worst ever reading and that's a large part because you know the average wage went up like 6% official inflation went up 8.
6% you know food at home went up 12% high protein foods went up 14% gasoline went up 50% and so you know basically even though unemployment's low people in general are miserable and it doesn't it doesn't affect everyone equally so someone has resources someone has a lot of fixed rate debt you know if their income is unaffected if they you know have all the needs met they're in pretty good shape whereas if someone's kind of struggling that's where you're going to go rising populism rising social discontent and that can make you know a soft landing is not soft for everyone and then you can get kind of you know fluctuating changes in leadership of that country and you know just basically I think the United States and Europe in particular among developed countries are pretty vulnerable to just kind of shifts in in political winds around back and forth to get whiplash and what the people want from their politicians because they're in kind of an impossible scenario I want to set up a scenario that I think we are all about to run into you know go speaking in the frame of mind of you know history doesn't repeat but it does rhyme but it's also very different and one of the reasons why it's different is from technology and we already talked about how like this the speed of information especially memes being passed around on the internet is part of that technology people just like understand things better and faster these days and I also want to bring up the something that's stuck out to me lately is that you know the federal reserve is led by the the the elder generation the boomers of the world meanwhile there's this like this growing younger cohort on like crypto twitter that is surprisingly like well versed in like money and economics and finance for what they would be in their in previous eras and so there was a meme that was circling around on on crypto twitter Lynn that I want to get your take on and Ryan is gonna gonna share it here in a sec the the bank list weekly roll up we talked about this meme at the end of the show so if you listen to the roll up you'll you'll know it's coming so this is a meme that progresses quarter by quarter so we start in q1 2021 and every single quarter has Jerome Powell's face and his quote he's quoting in q1 2021 quantitative easing won't cause inflation and then in q2 2021 we go some inflation but it's transitory q3 okay high inflation but it's peaking q4 2021 okay inflation but maybe not transitory but job market very strong wage growth very strong and then q1 2022 okay we need to hike aggressively to curb inflation but no worries economy very strong soft landing definitely possible q2 2022 and this is like you know it's circled red because this is where we are currently negative growth in q1 but no no recession risk q3 2022 okay recession coming but you're not gonna lose your home q4 2022 okay you you may lose your home but you're not gonna starve to death q1 2023 you may die but at least you'll go to heaven and so like part of this is this like technology that is passing around like these memes that by the way I love his face like how it transitions like at the end these memes that are very well understood by like younger generations and it's commentary it's like social commentary as to the performance and the knowledge of the federal reserve so Lin when you take a look at this meme is it as that first is it as dire as it may as the meme makes it out to be and and second is the Fed like how would you rate the actions of the Fed is the Fed like a competent institution right now so I mean dire I think depends on where you are right so if you're if you're in Sri Lanka it is pretty dire even if you're in Europe it's pretty dire maybe less dire depending on where you are in the United States or where you are in Japan or where you are in certain countries maybe less dire so I you know you'll die if you go to heaven it's not on my macro forecast thankfully but you know I think that but I get the meme it basically one of the things I've been analyzing is the question of what does the Fed understand that they're not saying versus what do they not understand that that's actually kind of an interesting question right because you know prior to this whole covid fiasco and the money printing and the financial pressure and the inflation you know black rock with with a former Fed official released a report saying in the next downturn because that's so high because the trades are so low we're going to have to print a lot of money and do probably do helicopter money so probably fiscal stimulus combined with that but that could be someone inflationary so they're going to have to hold the interest rates low for period of time despite that so you can have to have kind of coordination and then the big challenge becomes how to not have inflation get too high and out of control so like the whole roadmap was there I mean they they saw basically everything and there are a number of analysts like like me and others they were you know we we had been reading things like that and we've been at doing our own kind of similar research and saying that's that's that's basically the problem and so when it starts to play out in real time you know central banks never come out and say look the sovereign debts too high so we just have to hold rates low and financial pressure everything I mean they never to say that they never say we have to inflate the debt away so they have to use euthanisms they have to kind of phrase it in different ways and so the question then becomes what do they know that they they just have to phrase differently or kind of you know kind of push the can down the road and kind of mislead people versus you know what do they actually just that they honestly think that they that they can solve it or that they you know that they think they're doing the right thing and so you know for a while the Fed and other central banks were saying it's transitory when a lot of us knew that it wasn't or at least not nearly as transitory as they as they think it will be and so I do think that the Fed and other central banks are facing a competence you know chronic crisis here where their tools have always been kind of lagging indicators right so they're they're not very good at forecasting if you look at the Fed's track record of forecasting basically what they do they never predict a recession because that you know they they're kind of inherently political organization right so so predicting a recession is kind of inherently political statement in some ways even even if it's not it just it just comes off that way so they never predict a recession and what they do basically no matter if things are high or low they kind of point back to everything is going to go back to 2% that that's all they do they they basically draw a line forever it is now to 2% inflation and like you know 2% GDP real GDP growth and like 2.
5% illustrates and they just are always kind of going back and trying to point towards that medium and they don't really have a good track record and I think that that's all kind of being marked a market or being kind of um realized now because now they're facing this kind of more endgame type of scenario the super high debt level combined with inflation which is just not something that their tools are well equipped to handle and something that they contributed over decades to getting us here that they don't really have the tools to get us out of and so I do think that are you know in countries around the world especially these developed markets that have these super high debt levels so you're up to pan United States like I wouldn't want their job because it's an impossible job and you either have to like lie or you know like you have to be stupid or kind of look stupid and it's just it's inherently challenging environment to be in right so I think that they face a credibility crisis and it's not it's partially because they contributed to it but it's also partially because their predecessors contributed to it and that's just inherently rough place to be and I think that the model itself is old right I think that you know if you ask most people are price controls a good thing like should the government set prices of things most people say no um whereas like it you know in the United States we've had price controls on money since 1913 right we control the price of money a busy a group of elders gets in a room every six weeks and determines what the price of money will be and it doesn't matter where you are in the country I mean this is a country of 330 million people 50 states very different markets and they kind of set the nationwide price and then also because we're the global reserve currency this has international ramifications and it's literally because a group of people in a room are determining that that that price and so I just think this the model itself is kind of antiquated and that as software each the world and as we kind of go through a somewhat inflationary crisis I think that the shortcomings of that model are kind of being laid bare that is why of course in crypto we were looking to immutable algorithms to control our monetary policy as a way out and maybe as the the institutional trust in the central banks around the world erode in this decade as we expect they will maybe that becomes an increasing reason to turn to crypto of course that is the bulk case but I want to ask you uh another thing that this meme was conveying I think towards the end with the uh well maybe we'll dive at least we'll go to heaven part which is like kind of this grim humor but but also a concern that I've heard David articulate I've thought about it in the back of my head as well which is one decade we haven't talked about Lynn is the decade of the 1930s and the R for recession can turn into a D for depression and we have the populism we have um you know kind of like the commodity prices that the global instability the political instability um the like this could turn grim very quickly you haven't mentioned the 1930s as as a possibility but what do you think about that is is there some remote chance of course there's always a chance but do you think it's likely maybe or do you think it's a probability worth considering that this R could turn to a D depression and we get a decade or maybe less than a decade of of some sort of really big uh calamitous dip in the economy that is worldwide in nature and does affect the US does affect the developing world as well as the developed world I think that's possible it would take a different form and so the 1930s were pretty disinflationary decade and that's because you had the popping of a private debt bubble and so you had busy underutilization of existing capacity so you had commodity oversupply you had low economic output and then the economy had a tough time kind of bouncing back and responding to that whereas I think that to the extent that we run into a calamity of this decade and I think we're seeing kind of early signs of one uh due to energy crisis um I think it'd be more of an inflationary type of depression right I think that that basically you know if I look at the bottlenecks of what could make this decade really really bad it's you know partially what's happening with the money system but it's more so what's happening with the real movement of essential goods right so it's really about can people get the energy they need uh and energy is kind of the master resource that affects everything else and so if you look back in history you know even though individual countries can kind of reduce their energy use the world almost never reduces its energy use because like you know there's so much developing uh you know kind of countries around the world there's still people that need a lot more energy and I'll even the countries and developed markets that have been able to kind of flatten their energy use it's a large part because they shipped some of the most energy and tons intensive production to those developing countries so they kind of got off their balance sheet and out of mind even though they're still actually benefiting from that higher energy consumption and the only times where global energy usage went down year of year uh one was you know a kind of a three year period in the in the early 1980s which was basically when when Volker basically put the the you know kind of US into a severe recession you had a Latin American debt crisis you had a big dollar spike and you had this kind of just really rough uh global macro environment for for a few years so that was number one that was basically that was actually the last time that consumer sentiment was anywhere near this low was that period right so that was a terrible period for almost everyone the other one was the global financial crisis you had one year of you know less energy uses than the year prior and then the third instance was 2020 the whole COVID crash uh and at basically you know economic lockdowns and shut ins and reduced air travel and things like that and so generally reductions in energy consumption are associated with the worst economic environments in modern history right and the whole kind of post world war two era um I don't have data for energy consumption during the 30s but it would not have been pretty um possibly worse and so I think that that's one of the key things to look at is if we do have serious trouble getting the energy we need uh that's where you can get really bad you know she's like humanitarian outcomes and it doesn't affect everyone equally it affects it depends on where you are uh physically what resources you have available to to you um and I so that's that's the thing like if if there's an economic then the key step at night it's about energy security energy distribution uh and then all these kind of other things come come later so so the the money system all that is really bad but at the end of the day it comes down to chemigate energy cheme heater homes in the winter can we you know get food on the table right because even you know a lot of fertilizers are made from natural gas right and so if natural gas you know like in Europe it just looks like a wiremark chart that making fertilizer in Europe is going to look like a wiremark chart right so basically it really comes down to whether or not we have abundant energy I want to hear what you think about uh the fertilizer and food topic but before before we get that I just really want to double down on this whole energy conversation uh oil a bear of oil sides first decline in price in the last like two weeks in a while and like I think hey like if we take a trailing average of like ten five for ten ten years oil and gas is still really highly priced currently but at least it's coming down in the last two weeks so that's like one very cautious note of optimism to be had there if that continues to trend downwards I think that's a big relief as an energy prices gas prices food prices start to come down but question question for you is is oil really at the center of this or like what is if we're if we're saying the energy uh is at like the center of whether or not we go into a depression or recession or it's just uh or it's just a pullback what what charts are we looking at what what are the energy prices how do we measure this whole thing so oil natural gas would be the two biggest coal uh and nuclear and other things like that are also are also big ones and so you know basically if you look at oils more fun oils more fungible than natural gas so oil is is pretty easy to transport around the world uh and so you can get kind of dislocations in price but it's generally pretty similar prices around the world uh and so Brent crude and and west Texas intermediate crude you know there could be brief anomalies where they differ but for the most part they're rather similar prices and you know uh right now we saw a dip in oil uses but we have to keep in mind that the US strategic petroleum reserve so the oil that the government controls they're actively selling oil once in the market to try to suppress prices that they can't do forever for obviously so they only have so much um we also China's been under lockdowns for you know a large part of the spring and even now basically they have they have an usually low jet fuel usage and car usage because they have you know kind of essentially suppress their economic activity so the two biggest countries in the world are either increasing supply or suppressing demand for oil um and so I think that I I would you know any sort of dips I think that you know you have periods of time we're get ahead of itself people bid up the price and then you have kind of you know pullback you have demand destruction uh you have recession type environment I would be slow to celebrate those pullbacks because I think that the underlying supply constraints are still there um and so I think that those can bounce back quickly or if they keep going down it's a sign of basically depression spaces sign of recession happening um natural gas is a less fungible energy source because it's much harder to transport if you want to transport internationally you need LNG right so you either need to you know transport over land with pipeline usually uh those take years and years to build a very expensive or if you want to transport it by C you need LNG which means you need these multi-billion dollar facilities to cool it you know there's this whole technical process to you know basically liquefy it transport it and then unliquify it and it's there's kind of a firm amount of LNG capacity that we have because these are multi-billion dollar facilities that we we don't just switch on overnight and we don't just have flexibility for people in that familiar what's LNG liquefy natural gas right so it's natural gas that we put into liquid form uh and cool it and so that's so basically the result of what I'm saying is that because natural gas is is more cost at a transport relative to the value of the product we have much different prices around the world for natural gas compared to oil that is pretty unified and so right now for example European natural gas prices are absolutely through the roof there are multiple times higher than you see in the United States or Canada because they have an energy crisis they get a lot of their natural gas from Russia so that's obviously a geopolitical problem right now but actually that was already happening before the war they were just we're having limitations there and their ability to get natural gas overseas is much more limited than their ability to get oil from overseas because the the capacity to transport natural gas is much more limited and takes a lot more money and time to get that capacity online in order for say Canada to ship over natural gas to Europe or the United States to ship over natural gas to Europe and so I think the two markets to watch one is just global oil prices but then two natural gas prices especially in specific regions and then also I mean as a fallback you know a I mean AZ uses coal quite heavily because they don't have a lot of oil and gas deposits so they use a lot of coal uh despite the fact that it's dirtier in most ways and rocks you're starting to see in Europe that some of those markets are falling back on on coal basically due to emergency conditions that basically they've you know they they have not built new nuclear facilities uh they're at their limits in terms of natural gas that whole market's breaking uh and they can only get so much oil and so they have a fallback on on coal and so I think that basically looking at these big you know markets are some of the underlying things for for kind of near term intermediate term energy usage.
So here's what I'm concerned about um the first half of this podcast we were talking about how the federal reserves hand is more or less forced with its tools it's it's it's steering wheel has one of those things in it that's locked so it can't really steer it's out of options the global markets for oil we're already broken with supply chains so that kind of is is a fixed thing as in so we can't really fix that it's not it's not fixable uh we're already like maxed out as far as I can tell from the limited information that I've gathered maybe you can help clarify we're already maxed out with how much gasoline we can pump out of the ground or how much energy that we can produce so that option is fixed as well we don't really have much choice there it sounds like we have a little bit of ammo left in our reserves that we're selling into the market to help supply uh to reduce the price but I mean that runs out so as soon as we're done shooting that ammo then we're then we're kind of stuck there it seems to me we don't have very many choices and our future is already set and well for better or for worse maybe that future is actually you know the clear sky somehow we make it out of this okay you know maybe it's not maybe it's a capital D depression but either way arch we don't have any choices and if you're telling me that we don't have any choices that makes me scared uh and I don't really have a question I kind of just want to hug like do we do we have any good where are the clear skies here are there any or are we kind of effed so I think as we go deeper into this day I mean there are ways to bring more energy online uh just not overnight right so you know partly is if you're an oil company or an investor in a potential oil company um you know there are quick oil sources you can bring online like shale where maybe you're willing to ramp that up a little bit um but in other hand there are like oil projects you could do offshore that take seven years to pay back and you don't know what the market's gonna look like uh you don't know what governments are gonna do you don't know what technology is gonna look like and so you're hesitant to do those and and you know right now I feel like at oil pricing markets they kind of like the Fed they they still kind of think this is transitory they're like oh we're going to go back to normal and like oil prices not going to be that high so if you're if you're planning on putting three billion dollars into like offshore development you're like well maybe I shouldn't and I think that basically the the more kind of pain this this goes on um the more incentive eventually you you start to get of both governments and corporations like no no we have to go get that oil this is like an emergency and this this is not going away right so I think there are still levers to pull in terms of bringing new supply online uh and then building LNG so that for example you know relatively cheap American LNG could then kind of arbitrage some of the super expensive natural gas in Europe and kind of arbitrage and spread out those prices a little bit so there's there's kind of natural things that over time should begin addressing this and I think their concerns come if one is you have kind of say governments make wrong decisions and either try to suppress new production or or control production and then mismanage it right I think that that those are risks they're basically you can kind of like snatch defeat from the jaws of victory where you're kind of maybe started to come to solution than you managed to mess that up um and also it's one of those things where if you're on the periphery if you're if you're in a poor nation or if you're in a poor segment of society it's like you're you're kind of last in line in order to get this resolution so I think for a lot of people it isn't really tough time to be in um but I think over time that this can be fixed and you know the the fed's purpose right now like I said before they can't do supply but they can try to suppress demand so they're kind of trying to take discretionary demand off the market they're basically saying look if you're going to go on a frivolous vacation maybe you shouldn't right so maybe maybe you know curtail your optional usage so that the more central usage gets used right so that that's kind of what that's the lever that they're pulling and I think that over the longer run the only way we truly get out of this towards you know constructive disinflation growth again is to get more energy supply and distribution online and then that can also I mean you know China's building nuclear plants um there's a you know there's all sorts of technologies you look long enough in the future deep geothermal certain types of renewable resources um you know I think that there are long range ways to address this and it just there's there's intermediate things and there's longer range things and it just that's why I think this is going to be a challenging decade because these are not things we can snap our fingers and just get you know long duration of oil projects and gas projects and L and D terminals online tomorrow what would it be unprecedented in the same way that the United States government like put a permanent bid on vaccines before they were developed and just just footed the bill for that would it be unprecedented for them to do something similar with energy markets where they hey we need investment into our infrastructure we promise to buy oil like this many boils of barrel barrels of oil at this price for the next four years to give some sort of like security onto this investment by by the private sector would that be unprecedented that would be kind of like the 40s right so the 40s they said look here's this war we're gonna do we're gonna be a permanent bid for like industrialized building industrial facilities making war machines and you know you're gonna you're gonna get paid right so that's kind of what we did also they did the same things they said okay we need aluminum we're gonna build aluminum like that's just we're gonna throw public money to building aluminum right so base you had a very inflationary decade but they actually had a lot of real-world goods and services they came from that and so that actually that actually helped make it that inflation not permanent right so you brought on you know new resources because of that so if you had some sort of policy where they said look we we are going to you know incentivize new production as quickly as possible and longer term as possible I do think that would be one of the more productive uses of public capital I mean if you're gonna if your choices are either throw you know billions of dollars towards towards corporations for fearless purposes or throw billions of dollars towards energy development I would take that latter one every day of the week right so that's not the worst use of incentives or public capital and basically if you know if the U.
S. said look if if prices go below X we will expand our strategic petroleum reserve to pay you X so you have you have no kind of downside risk over the next five years from producing oil you know I think that that what I mean that probably you'd have periods of problem in the future you might have oversupply at some point right you probably that that's kind of the history of public arrangements where they solve one problem they create another but I do think that is one of the solutions here but I think this is overall it's just going to be a very challenging decade I think different countries are going to handle it differently I think some of them might try to do things like that other times I think the private sector can wake up and and you know if you kind of get out of their way that they can go and do that and it's of course it's a very challenging balance because during this period of commodity oversupply that's when a lot of people develop some of these environmental goals that they then are stuck because now you have an actual crisis and you're kind of you're balancing between the environmental goals you were kind of planning for and then being hit in the face by the real world and I think that that's it just I think a lot of people are kind of adjusting and kind of navigating that in the way that they see it really quick question before we kind of just summarize everything food or excuse me energy oil these like energy markets are at this epicenter of everything but then like downstream of that immediately becomes food can you just kind of paint the picture of what is the state of fertilizer markets and just food markets and if there's any just like you know contagion risk there so there are so I mean the subset of fertilizers are made using natural gas right so energy is is a key input not just in in driving to work but also in you know making food and then even once the food is made in terms of transporting it and packaging it and getting it to where it needs to be all that is very energy intensive process and so generally when you have price spikes and energy that translates into price spikes and food which of course is one of the most bad types of inflation because it's a essential good and it hurts impoverished people the most because they spend the largest percentage of their income on necessities like food and fuel and then it's compounded by the fact I mean so rush is the biggest fertilizer exporter first of all and so there's obviously you know we think of Russia as an oil exporter but they're actually that you know they're the second biggest oil exporter they're the biggest natural gas exporter they're the biggest fertilizer exporter they're a big exporter of nickel which is an important metal for batteries and things like that so all the a lot of the renewables that people want to do they they have sources there so they're you know given the fact of the largest land mass it's not shocking that they're basically the the most important commodity market and so that obviously has some geopolitical implications but either way you know basically so Russia's a big fertilizer exporter they're also a big wheat exporter Ukraine's a big wheat exporter and so I know that Ukraine's like you know harvest has obviously been disrupted from this you have kind of you've had kind of wheat problems and if like actually a wheat chart there is a sign of good there so you had this huge spike during the run up to the war but it's actually given back a lot of those war related gains because I think that that might be cooling off to some extent but over the very long run I think the key thing to focus on is fertilizer because if if natural gas prices stay high that means fertilizer prices are likely to stay high which transfers into higher food prices and like I said transporting it now again you do have a supply response over time and so for example one of the world's largest fertilizer producers nutrient is expanding their production they were kind of on the fence for that for a number of years where they always had the option to maybe expand it and you know now they're kind of accelerating some of their expansion efforts because they get you know the market has given them the signal yes we need all this new production and so I think that over time you can get responses to that but it just you know commodity cycles tend to tend to be rather persistent they tend to last you know five to ten years on the upside and five to ten or more years on the downside because a lot of these projects do take years to bring online and so I think that that is the big challenge right now is that you have so much to end the system increased money supply so much now we have real world constraints on energy and fertilizer and things like that and so I think we're going to have a period of you know high inflation interest rates below inflation and to the extent that it's either bad or terrible part it really comes down to the real world right so so can we get the energy can we get the fertilizer can we get that who's going to get it and I think that's the situation we find ourselves in so Lynn you've dropped so much fantastic information for us and I feel like I have much more peace on the possibilities and the you know different outcomes of the 2020s you know particularly on the macro side than I did coming into this I guess as we conclude you know two big questions one is could you just give us a summary of what this new normal looks like yet again I know you're alluding to it earlier and then secondly want to leave the listener with some action items what do we do so I think the message has been clear from this episode for travelers into the 2020s of which we are all on that journey you know steady and in time and space we are entering the 2020s there is going to be a new normal we cannot expect a world of the 1990s or the early 2000s or the 2010s the 2020s are going to be different there's going to be a new normal there's going to be an adjustment we should get prepared for that and so first what does this new normal look like can you summarize that I know you mentioned cyclical inflation that's going to be an ever constant thing you also mentioned commodities going up because we are undersupplied on commodities is are those the chief characteristics of the new normal are there others how do you summarize that I think that's a good way to put it I think that you know we can describe the recent normal which is basically 90s the 2000s and the 2010s which was we had try to open up to the world we had the Soviet Union collapse and all you know those states opened up to the world so we had this big pool of labor that was able to connect to develop markets and so we had decades of geographic arbitrage where we could offshore things is very disinflationary force and it resulted in this period of abundance where you know you you can always go to the market there's you know everything you can ever want any color and and pretty cheap and that's kind of the environment we've been in and I think that we've kind of exhausted quite a bit of that where we've now we've tapped into that labor you know China is now a rising you know geopolitical power obviously there's tension in the Russia now so you basically I think we've gone from this unipolar world that was opening up and that was becoming more efficient in their connected I think now we're going into a multi-polar world a more contentious world and you know we that we've have to restore some things and the basically we no longer have the capacity to push inflation and push you know kind of lower capital elsewhere at the same time we've you know we went through long period where we under invested in commodities that this had to happen in history I mean the 1970s another contributor to why we had so much inflation is US oil production peaked in 1970 structurally after like a century going up and rolled over you know all the way until the 2000s when we you know started doing shale right so we had became more reliant on those external sources the Middle East and that's that that's along with money supply growth that's part of why we had such inflationary decades there's always the combination of commodities and then whatever whatever's happening with the money situation and so I think going forward because of how high debts are because of how kind of tight our energy situation is and because of how we've lost some of the dissipationary levers I think we're going to have a more constrained world for a while I think then that could take the form of inflation and there are other periods where you can get dissipation but then scarcity and in recession and and basically the shortages right and I think that those can manifest in different ways and different severities depending on where you are and I you know navigating this is obviously challenging I mean that that's something we're all trying to figure out I think that there's practical things people can do like you know corporations are very lean manufacturing oriented they want to have low inventory they wanted to just a time delivery and I think it's kind of up to households to have you know stockpiles if they can basically to not rely on that everything's going to be there for you all the time right when you need it with no interruptions right so I think that that people have to become a little bit more self-sufficient a little bit a little bit more ready for periods of disruptions and challenges and then number two you know I think people approach their portfolios differently I mean I take a rather diversified approach I have cash I have equities you know focused on kind of like a energy equities cash flow producing pipelines things like that I mean I have a diverse set of equities I have some gold of that Bitcoin people know that and I kind of just I diversify a number of different assets that I analyze to be important for the next decade and of course people have different expertise and they'll find different things that they want to invest in or different things that they want to exclude but I do think it's important to be somewhat diversified because you can have big shocks I mean as we saw crypto just completely went down dramatically if someone was 100% in crypto their net worth is down you know 70 80% or more whereas you know if they were like 100% cash over the past couple years they just got you know their their net worth of nowhere went down in real terms why everything else went up for a long period of time and so I generally have a mix of multiple assets but I think a lot of it's also just you know cultivating yourself having you know trying to build relevant skills that's trying to you know basically make your life as a result in this possible because I think there's there is kind of challenges ahead of us and the one area that still could be disinflationary is actually ironically white collar labor right so we've we spent the past a couple decades you know kind of offshoring blue collar labor and now with with remote work it becomes super easy to hire any competent person around the world and that I think that actually kind of can result in disinflation for for a lot of white collar jobs so I think that the basically people have to just I think cultivate diverse skill sets be as valuable as possible and and be diversified and and basically have resiliency in your own life this is all fantastic inside and I think this this this key of self-reliance is going to be important in the 2020s you have to get out there and learn how to do things because the old methods will not work and even even questions of like where do you store your value and to your point lens like you know people used to store their value in you know savings account in the bank maybe maybe now in the 2020s you want to store the minimum necessary that you need for some time horizon to pay bills and such and then with the other value that you want to store look at this diversified set of assets including of course crypto and other things one last question on that because you touched kind of career and you've touched it kind of storing value but one piece that I think might might be shaking people a little bit is their mental health actually and I know that your your focus is really like macro but there is a psychological element to investing into macro as well do you have any words for people in this volatility on kind of mental health and how we should prepare in that way well I guess people don't want their macro advisor to give me health advice but I mean I think exercising and eating healthy is really important I actually it's funny one of my earliest articles I wrote like a 9,000 word article on kind of fitness and healthy living because you know I I've always kind of been into fitness and I used to do martial arts I used to be like a assistant instructor for martial arts and it's kind of a big theme for me and so I think it's people should not underestimate the importance of exercising and shape you know kind of you know trying to eat like whole foods you know as much as they can get back to fundamentals get back to fundamentals yeah and then yeah I mean developing strong relationships with those around you either online or offline because we're we're social animals and you know we need to go to interact with our tribe or our group and other groups and and so I think that mental health is an important thing and I think especially in this environment where people hate each other so much there's rising populism due to extreme wealth concentration due to changes in the money and breakdown of money systems and things like that I think it's important for for people to at least try to be have gratitude for what they have and and be as constructive as possible to those around them and I think it's also it's it's an environment where you know we talked about before about how information travels super fast that also means bad information travels fast basically we have a flood of information both accurate information false information and people have to be really discerning and like look for sources and like kind of not always just kind of focus on whatever they would have reinforced what they already think but then you know seek out information that they disagree with so that they can then learn from it and then you know basically then come to a more informed conclusion and that's that's from multiple different subjects and so I think that that's and that's part of self-reliance is basically having your own information filter so that you were not getting in a bubble and that you were getting out there basically trying to understand the world how it works and I think that's just it's a really really challenging environment because it you know kind of breaks a lot of bubbles I think that people have been in for for decades in in various countries such a good way to end it baked listeners hope you were taking notes we started with macro thoughts macro advice we end with life advice which is always fantastic in which you can expect on a bankless podcast Lynn thank you so much for enlightening us on what's going on in the world and the 2020s this has been super valuable we appreciate it happy to be here thanks for having me action items guys of course we will include a link to Lynn's fantastic newsletter and website at linaldin.
com make sure you subscribe to that sign up via email also we have a number of previous podcasts with Lynn David was mentioning them earlier in the episode will include a link to all of those episodes in the show notes also stay tuned for more macro stuff on bankless more coming up with Luke Gromman and Travis Kling and others risk and disclaimers as always we have to end with this none of this has been financial advice maybe some life advice sprinkled in but crypto is risky all this stuff is risky definitely lose what you put in but we are headed west this is the frontier it's not for everyone but we're glad you're with us on the bankless journey thanks a lot hey we hope you enjoyed the video if you did head over to bankless HQ right now to develop your crypto investing skills and learn how to free yourself from banks and gain your financial independence we recommend it joining our daily newsletter podcast and community as a bankless premium subscriber to get the most out of your bankless experience you'll get access to our market analysis our alpha leaks and exclusive content and even the bankless token for airdrops raffles and unlocks if you're interested in crypto the bankless community is where you want to be click the link in the description to become a bankless premium subscriber today also don't forget to subscribe to the channel for in-depth interviews with industry leaders ask me any things and weekly rollups where we summarize the week in crypto and other fantastic content thanks everyone for watching and being on the journey as we build out the bankless nation