✨ DEBRIEF ✨ | Ryan & David's Unfiltered Thoughts on the Episode: https://shows.banklesshq.com/p/128-luke-gromen-debrief
Luke Gromen is a macro analyst and founder of Forest for the Trees, a research company which helps investors find the signal. Luke is another one of our big macro brained guests in the same vein as Lyn Alden, Raoul Pal, and Jim Bianco.
On this episode, Luke unpacks how macro got this bad, what the end game looks like, why this is the scariest macro setup Luke has seen in 20+ years, and how to prepare.
The fog of what’s going on is thick, but we're on a quest to find out what in the world is going on. Knowing this is key to understanding the next steps crypto takes. Buckle up.
------ 📣Rhino.Fi | Massive Mystery Airdrop https://bit.ly/3o9trRE
------ 🚀 SUBSCRIBE TO NEWSLETTER: https://newsletter.banklesshq.com/ 🎙️ SUBSCRIBE TO PODCAST: http://podcast.banklesshq.com/
------ BANKLESS SPONSOR TOOLS:
🌱 LENS | ACCESS CODE: WAGMI https://bankless.cc/Lens
🚀 ROCKET POOL | ETH STAKING https://bankless.cc/RocketPool
⚖️ ARBITRUM | SCALING ETHEREUM https://bankless.cc/Arbitrum
🦁 BRAVE | THE BROWSER NATIVE WALLET https://bankless.cc/Brave
🌉 JUNO | BRIDGE FIAT TO LAYER 2 https://bankless.cc/Juno
⚡️ ZKSYNC | THE LAYER 2 SCALING ENDGAME https://bankless.cc/zkSync
------ Topics Covered:
0:00 Intro 6:08 Scariest Macro Setup In 20+ Years 14:15 Why This is the End 22:10 How’d We Get Here 26:45 Bursting Sovereign Debt Bubble 36:45 Fed Data Interpretation 42:42 How the End Game Plays Out 1:01:21 The Affect on The Average Person 1:07:35 U.S. Middle Class vs. Treasury Holders 1:14:58 The Future of Assets & Currencies 1:20:20 What Happens to Energy Commodities? 1:25:40 Equities, Gold, & Crypto 1:31:46 How to Prepare 1:36:50 Closing & Disclaimers
------ Resources:
Luke Gromen https://twitter.com/LukeGromen
Forest Through the Trees https://fftt-treerings.com/
Luke’s Youtube Channel https://www.youtube.com/c/LukeGromenFFTTLLC
Lyn Alden https://youtu.be/XaHuwUDd1C8
Jim Bianco https://youtu.be/VMNmxFzKI64
----- Not financial or tax advice. This channel is strictly educational and is not investment advice or a solicitation to buy or sell any assets or to make any financial decisions. This video is not tax advice. Talk to your accountant. Do your own research.
Disclosure. From time-to-time I may add links in this newsletter to products I use. I may receive commission if you make a purchase through one of these links. Additionally, the Bankless writers hold crypto assets. See our investment disclosures here: https://newsletter.banklesshq.com/p/bankless-disclosures
No summary for this episode yet.
Societal collapse, starvation, violent overthrows of governments. I mean, it is, that's what happens when people don't have enough energy or food. And so if mismanaged, that's where this sort of could all go. And that's what, you know, this all filters into why I think it's, you know, one of the scariest environments we've seen in 27 years. Welcome to Bankless, where we explore the frontier of internet money and internet finance. This is how to get started, how to get better, how to front run the opportunity. This is Ryan Sean Adams, and I'm here with David Hoffman, and we're here to help you become more bankless.
Guys, amazing podcast episode. I hope you've been enjoying our macro episodes because here is yet another as we're trying to understand the landscape in front of us right now. Luke Groman is our podcast guest today. He calls where we are now the scariest macro setup he's ever seen in his career. That's where we start. A few things to take away from this episode. Number one, why is this the scariest macro environment Luke Grohman has ever seen in his career? Number two, what a bursting sovereign debt bubble does to the world, what it does to individuals, why the choice for America is between bailing out the middle class or bailing out the treasury, the asset class.
Number four, the future of all of the asset classes that are investable, including what he thinks about bonds and gold and equities and crypto and energy. And finally, number five, how we get ready. What is the ultimate portfolio to weather this storm? David, this was another fantastic episode. I'm just taking notes because I feel like I'm getting schooled in macro today with all of the content coming our way in Bankless over the last few episodes. Yeah, this is definitely one of the perks of being a podcaster is that like, it's not like I know the answers, but it's my job to go and discover them.
And so when I'm in these podcasts with people like Lynn Alden and Luke, I'm just receiving just the best information possible to answer my own questions. The way that you phrased the start of this, I hope you're enjoying these very dark podcasts about this future. But also at the same time, Luke definitely presented one of the more optimistic outcomes, not guaranteed, but definitely positive outcomes. You said there's a choice between bailing out the American middle class versus treasuries. And that was one of my big takeaways. I'm going to go back and listen to this podcast to go through that again.
The American middle class versus treasury holders. Those two entities are in a tug of war. And while there's certainly a way where both we can split the difference, one of these two sides definitely is going to win versus the other. And obviously, you will understand as a listener that we want the American middle class side to win because the other side of things turns us into the top-down, high-controlled nation-state surveillance state that we don't really want in this world. And so that was what really stuck out to me, where if we can figure out a path out of this extremely chaotic, extremely volatile macro environment that involves increasing wages for the United States middle class, that actually can be really bullish for America as a whole.
I don't know how likely that is, but the fact that Luke sees a path towards that is a light in this very dark time. David, you and I have got to talk more about that during the debrief. And of course, a reminder, we do a debrief episode after the episode for every single podcast. And you can catch the debrief where David and I go over the podcast content, inject our thoughts, inject our comments on it after the episode by becoming a Bankless premium member. We'll include a link in the show notes where you can go do that. Also, we now have video of Bankless podcasts in Spotify. So previously video was only available on YouTube.
Now they are available in Spotify as well. So if you want to go check out Bankless videos on Spotify, go to Spotify, search Bankless, and you can view them there. Guys, we are going to get right to our conversation with Luke Groman. But before we do, we want to thank the sponsors that made this episode possible. Juno is bringing crypto-friendly banking straight into your checking account. With Juno, you can send money from your Juno checking account straight onto a layer two, like Polygon, Optimism, Arbitrum, and they have ZK Sync and StarkNet support on their way. You can skip the ACH wait times, you can skip all the gas fees, and go straight from your checking account to an Ethereum layer two in seconds.
Inside Juno, you can buy and sell crypto with $0 fees, and your Juno checking account comes with a metal mastercard that gives you up to 5% cash back on your spending. Juno is also giving you $10 cash back on your first crypto deposit and $100 when you set up a direct deposit. This ad just writes itself. So go sign up at juno.finance.com. Lens Protocol is an open source tech stack for building decentralized social media applications. It is the new era for social media. We all have toxic relationships with our Web2 apps. We want to break up with them, but we can't. These applications own our digital lives and all the relationships that we've made.
We need to break through to a new paradigm of social networking applications that we control rather than them controlling us. Lens isn't a social media app. It's a protocol to let a thousand Web3 social apps bloom. Lens is a permissionless and transparent social graph that is owned by the user. In crypto, we say not your keys, not your crypto. And on Lens, we say not your keys, not your profile. With Lens, your followers go with you to whatever social media application you want to use. And instead of being trapped by an algorithm chosen by that app, Lens lets you choose the way you want to experience your social media.
Lens is the last social media handle that you'll ever need to create. So in order to get started, there is a secret code word in the show notes. Enter that code word in the Google form linked and you'll be well on your way to entering the world of Web3 social. Zksync is an Ethereum layer 2 network that is pushing the frontier of high performance blockchains that don't compromise on security or decentralization. Zksync has combined the power of zero knowledge rollups in the Ethereum virtual machine, enabling developers to build the greatest Web3 projects possible. Ones we haven't even seen yet.
Crypto needs its killer applications to onboard the world, but crypto killer apps need ZK Sync as a platform to build on first. It's generally accepted that zero-knowledge roll-ups are the conclusion of crypto blockchain scaling technology, and ZK Sync is leading the charge into the final frontier of crypto economics. So if you're a developer who wants to build your app on a future-proof foundation which gives your users the best UX possible, check out ZK Sync's website at zksync.io. And yes, there's also going to be a token, so give them a follow on Twitter too, at ZK Sync. Bankless Nation, we are super excited to introduce you to our next guest.
Luke Groman is a macro analyst. He's the founder of Forest for the Trees, which is a research company that helps investors find a signal right now. And boy, do we need some signal in the midst of all of this mind. He has a big macro brain in the vein of some episodes we've done recently. Lynn Alden, Raoul Paul, Jim Bianco, that sort of individual. And I think, Bankless listener, you can tell we are really on a quest to figure out what in the world is going on with macro, because this is the key to understanding what's going to happen next with crypto. So Luke, thank you so much for helping us out with that agenda.
Welcome to Bankless, my friend. Thank you for having me on, Ryan. It's great to be here. So Luke, we're going to go through this, you know, as simply as we can. High level questions. This is definitely an investor engaged, macro engaged, but primarily crypto audience. So we're going to ask questions here? Like in some of these might be dumb, you know, noob type questions. But we want to go through what's going on in macro right now. First of all, how bad actually is it? Because it seems really bad right now. Then we want to touch on what's going to happen next. Maybe go through this asset by asset.
And then is all of this fixable? And finally, ending with what do we do? You game for that? Sure. Let's do it. All right. Let's talk about this. How bad is it? You called this the scariest macro setup in 20 plus years. Tell us about this. Why did you say that? It is. We've written it numerous times and have been really writing a lot of warnings all year that basically culminating with that view that this, I think, is the scariest macro setup that I've seen in my 27 years in finance. And the reason I wrote that is really a confluence of factors that have either individually, either they haven't been seen in a very long time, or they've never been seen.
And when you put them all together, we've never seen something like this before, certainly in the scale at which it's happening. And so to break each of those down, the first is that this is the first global sovereign debt bubble that we have had in 100 years, really, I think, since the aftermath of World War One, particularly because it is centered in the developing, or excuse me, the developed markets, the advanced economies, not in the emerging markets. So a lot of what we're seeing in US, Japan, Europe has been seen from a sovereign debt perspective in emerging markets since 1980, but not in developed markets for much longer than that.
And the reason for that is, is we had a stock bubble in 2000, policymakers decided rather than letting that play out in a austerity slash deflation type outcome, they kicked the problem upstairs to the banking system via the creation of a housing bubble. That burst, they kicked that problem upstairs to the sovereign level by virtue of effectively backstopping the banking system, bailing out pretty much everything, which is an oversimplification. But that created a sovereign debt bubble. And the problem is once it's at the problems at the sovereign debt level, There's nowhere else to kick that problem upstairs to.
I mean, unless you can find Martians willing to come down and sort of you can kick the problem to Mars, the release valve has to be the currency. They're going to have to print money at some point. So you've got this bursting global sovereign debt bubble, I think, for the first time in 100 years. When you then overlay that with the I think the second big issue is a you have a resource problem. We've been writing about peak cheap energy for quite some time. And that's not to say we're running out of energy. The issue is, is that the marginal barrel of oil keeps getting more expensive to find. And if we didn't have all the debt we had, in particular, the sovereign debt we had, this would be economically problematic, but it would not be economically catastrophic.
The energy is ultimately the true discount rate, nature's true discount rate of economic activity. And a simplified way to think about that is they're implied in the value of every asset on the board, every asset, with the exception of, I think, really two, gold, physical gold, and Bitcoin. There is implied a growing supply of cheap and affordable energy. And what I mean by that, think about it as you have a house in the suburbs. Your house in the suburbs is worth $400,000. The valuation of that $400,000 is based on gasoline being $2, $3, $4 a gallon. If gasoline goes to $10 or $20 a gallon, the $400,000 value of that house gets haircut significantly.
And you can do that to every asset. Some move up, some move down. But the price of bonds, stocks, real estate, all of it implied within it, with the exception of gold and Bitcoin, is a cheap and growing supply of energy or a growing supply of cheap energy. and supplies aren't really growing that much. And they're certainly not getting cheaper. They're getting more expensive to basically stay in one place. For energy to not grow enough is taking more and more expensive energy. And that then brings you to sort of the third leg of this, which is given peak cheap energy and some of these resource scarcity, cheap resource scarcity issues, they are now leading to geopolitical tensions when overlaid with the debt.
And you have seen that obviously in spades since February of this year. And that then also makes it very scary for macro because you can see the Russians weaponizing energy, weaponizing commodities. You can see the Americans weaponizing the dollar. And everybody else in between is getting caught between that rock in the hard place, particularly foreign creditors of the US that are short energy. So that's EU, Japan, China, India, these major economies, they're short dollars, and they're short energy. And if they're short dollars, the financial system collapses. If they're short energy, they have hundreds of millions of citizens starved to death and probably riot before they do.
And we started to see symptoms of that in some smaller places around the world, it's likely going to get a lot worse over the next three to six months on that front. So when you overlay what's happening with the first global spurs in global sovereign debt bubble in 100 years, when you overlay what's happening with peak cheap resources, when you overlay the geopolitical tensions that are, I think, amongst major powers at their highest in probably at least 30 years and probably closer to 40 or 50 years, and then you layer in some other factors such as the Western policymakers, US in particular, they've allowed the system to evolve in a way that the US absolutely needs asset prices to rise to keep the wheels on the cart.
So you've created this pro-cyclical asset price inflation driven economy. And now you overlay these three factors, global sovereign debt bubble bursting, geopolitical, and peak cheap energy that are making it difficult for that to happen. So when you blend all these together, that's why I say we haven't really seen any of these in on their own, either in a very long time or ever, when you blend them all together, it's this that it is, it's the scariest macro environment I've seen in my 27 years in finance. Wow, we recently just did a podcast with Lynn Alden. And we titled this this podcast, is this the end?
And what you said where there is no place to kick this can down the road for. We're at the end of the road to kick this can down the road. Kind of sounds pretty similar. But as we go into the global markets contagion with energy prices, commodity and resources, and all of this fallout, I really want to just emphasize the source of all of this contagion, these issues, which in my mind is the US dollar. And perhaps like why we are at the end and why this is such a big thing to discuss is that the u.s dollar connects absolutely everything and that is this seems to be the focal point of this whole story and so i'm wondering luke why can you just help ground us as to what it means when there is nothing there's no further road to kick the can down the road towards and and what what is the current state of like the u.
s economy the u.s the federal reserve and the dollar is like why is this seemingly like the end of the story of the dollar in its current phase? Can you just really just ground us here? Yeah. So for me, I don't think anything's ever ending. I think it's always a case of what's normal for the spider is chaos for the fly, right? So when I agree that we are quickly getting to the end of the road in terms of where to kick this to, you can either, you're really left with a very binary choice, which is you let the system as it is structured collapse into deflationary chaos. And that is going to be widespread sovereign defaults.
That's going to be commodity price collapse. That's going to be the United States. I mean, when I say sovereign debt collapse, yeah, others will go first, like weeks first. And Europe defaults on sovereign debt, and people think there's going to be some big lag. Oh, well, Europe will go, and then all the capital will flow to America and stock. No, the capital, there is no capital if it defaults there. The contagion will be measured in weeks, if not days. And that deflationary spiral, if the Fed and policymakers continue to stand aside, would be up to and including the United States government defaulting on its entitlement promises to baby boomers.
Hey, mom and dad, I know you were collecting a couple grand a month in social security. It's now 200 a month. And oops, you don't have enough to make ends meet. You don't have enough to buy groceries. You can't make your house payment. Sorry. And it would possibly include once tax receipts fell enough, which wouldn't take very long. It's already happening. the U.S. government defaulting on Treasury bonds. Sorry, Treasury bond holders, we're going to miss this quarter's coupon payment. We're not making it. And now, that's very down the line. I do not think that is going to happen. Right now, we are on that path.
It is a nonlinear path. And if the Fed just continues to stand aside and do nothing, that is where this will go. That is a very, very bad outcome. The dollar goes to the moon in that scenario. But it would be somewhere between here and the moon for the dollar, something very weird would start to happen, which is already starting to happen if you pay attention, which is dollar is 200 on the DXY index, but there's no gasoline at the gasoline, you know, at gas stations. Why am I having to, you know, why are U.S. gas stations running out of gas? Why are grocery stores running out of food when the dollar is strong?
Well, it'd be strong against other currencies, other paper currencies. But the reality is, is the amount of economic dislocation that would take place would be a catastrophic breakdown of global supply chains and widespread shortages around the world. Would it be worse? It would be worse elsewhere? Absolutely. But you would have this strong dollar and widespread global shortages of stuff. So your physical commodities, I think, would be the dollar would be weakening dramatically against physical commodities, even in that strong dollar scenario. So that is leg one of what where where do we go from here?
Leg two is something that's very familiar to anyone that's lived in an emerging market, has invested for long enough in emerging markets, which is the sovereign balance sheet of the West is so bad that ultimately in a fiat currency system, policymakers, they talk tough. They're going to raise rates. They're going to let the dollar go. All of this sort of where I think the mind of the market really is at this point, maybe not quite fully there, but getting there. And then policymakers ultimately have to step back in and grow the balance sheet again to prevent. And this is, I think, the biggest thing that people are missing now versus when they talk about the 70s or the 40s or any other time.
There has been no other time in hundreds of years where the sovereign solvency of the reserve currency issuer is at risk. And so basically, leg two is, is the Fed comes in and begins growing their balance sheet again aggressively to prevent the sovereign insolvency of the United States, of the United States as allies, and in particular, the EU and Japan. And I think we're getting very close to that moment. I think we're probably months away from the Fed having to print money to either renew QE domestically or potentially print dollars and buying euro debt, buying Japanese debt as a way of fighting deflation.
So we are when you say we're coming to the end of the road in terms of where we can kick the can to, I think there is an element of truth to that from the standpoint of sort of this linear path that people have gotten used to seeing. I think the from here, things get very nonlinear. And the question then is, do they get nonlinear inflationary or do they get nonlinear deflationary? And ultimately, really, it comes down, if you're a month-to-month trader, and this applies to crypto, this applies to Bitcoin, this is not a good, between now and when they have to print the money to keep sovereigns solvent, which I think they ultimately will do, they will be probably the, if not the only sovereign in history, one of the only sovereigns in history of the fiat currency that didn't print the money to keep the sovereigns solvent.
solvent by choice. They never choose that, policymakers, that is. So it's, I think, a very high odds shot that the money gets printed to keep Western sovereigns solvent, and in particular, the sponsor of the system, the center of the system, the US and the US dollar. The question is, from here to there, this is where all the money is going to be made, I think, in the second half of this year is how long is from here to there. And I've been surprised year to date that the Fed has, I think they made a policy mistake last year. I think they're, well, let me back up. I don't think they made a policy mistake last year.
I think they did the right thing by inflating. I think they made a policy mistake by ending the inflation too soon. And so I think we are getting closer and closer to them having to revert back to inflating. But again, that's where all the money is going to be made. The longer they delay, it's not a good environment for basically anything except the dollar. I just want to get a clarifying question. Why are we in this pinch in the first place? We've talked about the contagion that's at risk and the paths forward, but I just really want to ground the listeners. How did we get here in the first place?
What are the factors that have created this very, very unfavorable environment? Human nature and optimism. These cycles repeat over and over. So you go back. When you create a debt-backed system, right, so you go off the gold standard in 71, you create effectively a debt-backed system. And the problem is with a debt-backed system, you can't go through any extended period of deflation without creating a systemic risk. Because if the debt starts to default, the debt is what backs demand for your currency. So basically, if you let the debt defaults go too long, at first, it's good for your currency, and then it turns bad for your currency, right?
There's demand for your currency because the debt's there. But if they default on the debt, then there's no more demand for the currency collapses, right? So you have this debt-backed system that requires, it's like the old metaphor, a shark has to keep swimming or it drowns. Same thing. They have to keep inflating the money supply or the system collapses. So that, number one, is, I think, sort of the overlay of the whole thing. But when I say human nature, look, FDR came out in the middle of the Depression and promised Social Security to everybody. And when you looked at it back then, I'm going to get the ages wrong, but basically it was like, hey, you can collect social security at 62 when the average lifespan was 55, right?
So if you were lucky enough to live seven years past the average lifespan in 1938 or whatever, then the government paid you for a few years before you died. And they've modified it a bit, but in the meantime, the average lifespan has gone from 55 to whatever it is, 75 for men, 82 for women, something like that. At any rate, they've only modified it a bit. The baby boom generation, the retirement generation. So you have these promises that were made that were going, you know, 70 million baby boomers were born from 46 to 64. It stood to reason that 70 million were born, 70 million are going to turn 65 someday.
You had 40, 50, 60 years, where politicians, any sort of sixth grader with a calculator could say, hey, we owe this much money when they get that age. We know this bolus of people are going to reach that age in these years. We should probably restructure these obligations at some point. But politics, and when I say human nature, politics are politics. Entitlements are called a third rail for a reason. You can't touch them. So, hey, it'll happen on somebody else's watch. Well, that watch is here. Then again, tied back to this debt-backed system, you keep bailing out mistakes rather than letting them work themselves out in a deflationary manner.
So, you know, it was sort of it was sort of now we look back, the threats of long term capital, Russia default back in 98, needing to bail that system out or bail those players out. Those were threats to the system, but they were almost adorably cute in terms of how small they were. And now it's just you keep get bigger, bigger, bigger bailouts. And now it is because it's been kicked upstairs to the sovereign debt level. there's nowhere else to kick it up to. So it really becomes a case of this. It really is human nature where you set up the system. It makes a lot of sense up front, but there's very little planning, very little political incentive amongst either the political class or the voters that elect them to change anything until there's a crisis.
And so that's when I say human nature, I think it's really just the human nature of everybody wants something for nothing. And something for nothing is great until the bill shows up. And the bill only shows up every three or four generations with some of the stuff. And unfortunately, here we are. We're in that part of it. And whether you want to call that part of the fourth turning or whatever, that's effectively what we're dealing with. Well, what a time to be alive. We are definitely living in historic times here, Luke. And, you know, I guess the answer to the question of how did we get here is kind of like what you're saying as well, just one step at a time.
It's like one step at a time is the way we've got here. I want to go back to sort of your framework of, you know, how bad is it and why it's bad. And you said three things. Bursting sovereign debt bubble. That's one big reason. Our world is also based on cheap energy. All of our assumptions are based on that. And that's a bad assumption, it turns out, in this new world that we've entered. And then we've got geopolitical tensions. All of these things are related. But let me go back to the bursting sovereign debt bubble, because I'm curious with the language and the terms you used. You said bursting.
And earlier, you talked about default. And it's not clear to me. I think what you're saying is like, no, actually, default is a possibility, but they probably won't default. But you did use this term bursting repeatedly. And when we were talking to Lynn Alden, and keep in mind, Luke, we are simple crypto people trying to understand the macro economy and doing our best. But Lynn Alden kind of compared this current era that we've entered to an era that we've had previously, the 1940s. And that was an era of, obviously, increased government spending, fiscal spending in lots of big ways. And, you know, the way that decade kind of resolved was we had interest rates at like 0%.
But then we had inflation that averaged about 6%. Some years it went as high as 19%. So real returns on treasuries and bonds were negative, like very high in the negative territory. And it seemed like the 1940s and world governments at that time, at least the U.S. did, used inflation as kind of a pressure release valve on all of this. Rather than defaulting, rather than becoming insolvent at the nation state level, you use inflation as the release valve and you let the air out of this balloon slowly rather than having it pop. But you were using the term bursting, which implies that the balloon is actually going to pop.
Can you talk about that? Do you agree with Lynn's take? Or do you think inflation will be like, will there be a slow unwind and an uninflating of this bubble? Or do you actually think we're headed for a burst here? And what does that look like? So to me, I mean, this goes back to my point, what's normal for the spider's chaos for the fly, right? If you are a treasury holder and you lose half of your money on a real basis over a three or four year span because inflation is allowed to run 600 to 2000 basis points above interest rates, that's a burst in my view. That's a crash. You're going to lose half your money in the safest asset on the board, in theory, in the span of a few years.
Um, so I, I think what Lynn's talking about is, is part and parcel to a bursting. Now, do I agree with her? I think there are elements of the seventies of the forties, uh, in the U S the forties, I think are helpful directionally in terms of the last time the United States had debt, the GDP above 100%. It's the last time foreigners were not buying enough treasuries because at that time, basically, the world was destroyed after World War II. This, though, then – so there are some similarities, and I think that lends itself to the you're going to need an extended period of time of significantly negative real rates.
And that's what I said earlier, White. I thought the Fed was making a mistake by tightening prematurely as it looked like they were doing that playbook again last year of, hey, let's inflate away the debt. So that's what you meant by that. That's what I meant by it. It was a policy mistake ending inflation too soon. Yes. They really have to keep inflation up to deflate the balloon. We needed – right. From a – we did a calculation April of 21 that said they needed nominal GDP. The U.S. policymakers needed nominal GDP to run between 15 and 21 percent for five years to get U.S. debt to GDP down to a level from which they could tighten policy without blowing up the system.
And so we said, look, that's what it's going to be. If they tighten too soon, they're going to blow things up. You're going to have a really bad year in the markets if they try to tighten. Halfway through the year, they're trying to tighten. They are tightening. We have the worst decline in stocks and bonds in 50 to 70 years. We've got emerging markets under pressure. We have the dollar skyrocketing. We have home price. U.S. housing sector looks like it's rolling over broadly. So they tighten too soon. They think they're dealing with a dial. It's much more like a switch. The challenge in all of this and using, hey, it's the 40s framework.
And really, it ties back to my point why it's the scariest macro environment in 27 years, in my experience, that there's no really one good metaphor. There are elements of it that are like the 40s. But the challenge is, in the 40s, the U.S. was the only country left standing. We had all the factories. We had all the men. We had all the gold. We were the world's biggest oil producer. Everybody needed us. There were really, you know, emerging geopolitical tensions with the Soviet Union, of course, that got much worse over the next ensuing 30 years. But it was a very different standpoint from that versus now where, you know, U.
S. could just could run the factories full out because they needed to rebuild the world. I mean, U.S. factories and labor rebuilt the world from 46 to call it 65, maybe 60. That's not true. There's too much capacity everywhere, maybe with the exception of the U.S. Um, so that, that element is not true. Uh, you've also got a very big difference in terms of supply chains, right? So after world war two, us made everything. We were the biggest supplier of everything that mattered to the world. Now the United States can't fight a war without China, which is really hard when they're being told that China might be who we fight the next war against.
we're seeing these supply chain problems. That's very different. And so I think that's the other thing that makes this a really challenging period of time where, I mean, quite frankly, there's elements of the 40s, but there's elements of the 80s in Latin America and the 90s in Latin America and 2000s in Latin America that look very similar to the US. Because in the US in the 40s, 50s, 60s, if you look at the wealth discrepancy in the US, for example, it was the lowest it had been. You had a very healthy middle and working classes, very low wealth inequality in the US. And now you have a Latin American wealth inequality.
You have de-industrialized the US in a major way by trade policy. You've racked up the debt. And so there's actually, what we have is a situation where the reserve currency issuer of the world looks much more like Latin America from a fiscal, from a sovereign debt perspective, than it looks like America in the 40s and the 70s. In the 70s, U.S. debt to GDP was very low. You had this growing middle class. Boomers were young, productive, growing their families. And we were still very much not financialized. Now, the US looks like sort of a highly indebted Latin American republic with record wealth inequality and highly financed.
It almost looks like a tax haven, like very financialized economy with a really big and great military, de-industrialized manufacturing sector. And that's when I sort of put all that together, it sort of runs together, But it's it runs together because it I think the running together of it is a manifestation of how you can't just say, hey, it's like the 40s or like in The Wall Street Journal today, the Fed is talking about, well, it's like the 70s again. The balance sheet and the financialization of the U.S. economy are so different than the 70s that if they're running that playbook and they appear to be, they're making a galactically stupid mistake.
Galactically. I mean, they are going – it's like, well, we want to fly to L.A. Okay, well, fly east, southeast around Australia to get to L.A. Like, well, no, you can just go west and be there in five hours. No, no, no. We're going to go 28 hours around the planet to get to L.A. And we don't have enough gasoline to even make it to frigging Africa. That's that's the the that's that's the game plan the Fed's effectively running. So, you know, good luck to them. That's why I say I think, look, we have this period of time where they think they can do this. They can't that they think they can. And they're trying to convince markets and markets are still somewhat convinced they can.
sometime in the next two to three to four months, markets can go, oh, shit, they can't do it. The plane's out of gas. We're halfway over the Atlantic. We're not even in Africa, let alone the extra 25 hours of flying we have to do to get to Africa or to get to LA around the world. And now what? And that's when they're going to call the Fed and the Fed's going to be the, sort of to continue the metaphor, the in-air tanker, the in-flight tanker, refuel the jet, and then they can make it. Well, that's going to be Fed balance sheet expansion. But between here and there, being a passenger on that jet is going to be pretty scary.
Luke, in a different show, you talked about how the Fed only pays attention to certain kind of metrics and it ignores other kinds of data, other kinds of metrics. Like it's a backwards looking institution. It doesn't really look to forwards very much. I'd love it if you could expand on the data that the Fed is interpreting and how that data is impacting its decision making. And then also the data that the Fed is ignoring or just leaving on the table that we can take a look at and inform us for what the future of the U.S. economy might turn into. A mistake I have consistently made is giving the Fed more credit than they deserve.
And that is not to say they are stupid. I don't think they're stupid people individually, but I think they are a political institution. I think they're a political institution in a normal time. And when I say normal time, non-war time. So I think they are a, I'll put it in practical terms. The playbook is very clear. The IMF wrote about it. When you get that the GDP is high as US debt, the GDP was after COVID, you need to inflate for years. That's it. You need to run significantly negative real interest rates for five to 10 years. That's what they did in the 40s. They went from 110% to 50% over five years by negative real rates of 600 to 2,000 basis points, like we talked about earlier.
That's a playbook. That's it. That's what they need to do. The problem is that they are – and if they were an independent institution, that's what they would have done. That's absolutely what they would have done. That's what they had to do. But they're not an independent institution. That's one of the great myths that's still held by some because you could see it. Inflation began applying political pressure to the Biden administration. Nobody cared about all this. Hey, they were all in for the stimulus early on. You're growing money supply. How did you possibly think growing the money supply 25%, 30%, 40% over a couple years wasn't going to lead to inflation?
They're not stupid. So I think they went into this saying, we're hoping we can sort of inflate this away and no one will notice. And the problem is, is people started to notice. Republicans cynically made a big deal about it for the Biden administration. It became a political problem for the Biden administration. And all of a sudden they care about inflation. So now they need to fight inflation, but it's the wrong playbook. And so I think the Fed is... Do you think they're pretending to fight inflation and not actually doing it? Like back to maybe they're actually like a lot smarter than we think.
I think they would love to do that. I think that's what this whole transitory ruse was. I think that I think that was a period of time where they were doing that. Now, if you look at what's happening, credit markets, if you look at what's happening in housing, if you look what's happening, stocks, you learn to me, Bitcoin, what's happened to Bitcoin is telling you they're no longer just they're no longer just pretending it's happening. You know, you take Bitcoin from 70,000 to 20,000. To me, that's just the advance. That's the last functioning smoke detector saying, guys, liquidity is gone. And people say, ah, you know, there's on FinTwit, right?
Oh, look, Bitcoin's down 70 to 20. You suckers. And without fail, the last several years, every time that's happened, like it's like, wait for it. Three, two, one. Oh, God, stocks down. Oh, God, bonds are down. Oh, save us, Fed, save us. Right. So there's I think we are when you look at what's happening in credit markets, you know, when you look at what's happened in the Treasury market in the I mean, it's what's it's incredible what the Treasury market has done year to date, even allowing for the inflation we had earlier on. how bad the treasury market has performed, given that we're heading into a recession, we're heading toward a recession.
Are we in one? Are we not? We're going to have two quarters of negative real GDP growth. There's some argument. Whether we think we're in one or not, we're heading toward one. And yet treasuries are down, worst treasury performance in 50, 60, 70 years. It's really incredible. Now, they bounced recently, but- Well, why is that incredible? Give the dumb crypto people some context. Oh, it's incredible because historically, the first thing you do as the US GDP starts to go negative is you buy long-dated treasuries. Because they're the safety asset. I get a fleet of safety. They're the safety asset.
They're the safety asset. And so, yes, there's been inflation, but there's this balance of payments dynamic where foreigners own so many treasuries now, they're not buying enough of them. And in fact, the stronger the dollar gets, the more treasuries they will sell to get dollars to try to keep their heads above water. And then just this dynamic of the structural size of U.S. deficits, right, of, you know, the Fed is in theory starting to sell treasuries. foreigners with the dollar where it is are selling treasuries. A treasury is selling treasuries. Who's the buyer? It's got to be mom and pop.
Well, mom and pop don't have the balance sheet. The banks have been big buyers. They don't really have the balance sheet. Some of that's regulatory, but there's a supply demand imbalance that is fundamental there. There are some cyclical moves within that, like we've seen in the last, call it two, three weeks where long dated treasuries have been bid. They probably stay bid for a bit longer, But if the Fed stands aside, the supply side of the treasury market will get so much bigger as the U.S. heads into a full fledged. Everyone agrees we're in a recession or a financial crisis. Then you're going to see treasury yields rise, in my view, in a recession, in a crash.
And that's that's something we haven't seen in the U.S. in a long, long time. I don't know when the last time we saw that, but you see it all the time in places like Turkey and Argentina and Mexico in the 80s and 90s and Southeast Asia in the 90s. It's a balance of payments problem. So Luke, we're going to take this asset by asset in just a second. But before we do, while we're on the subject of how bad is it, can you just fast forward us to how you think the end game will play out here? So you've indicated that this has elements of the 1940s, has elements of the 1970s, also has elements of Latin America in the 1980s.
So I think you're making the case that the 2020s are going to be their own thing. You also said that you expect inflation for years once the Fed, maybe all of the other institutions, come to grips with reality. What we're going to have to do is inflate, maybe for five to 10 years, is what you said. Can you just fast forward us to kind of the endgame here? What is the endgame? So what does this decade look like in the highest level macro perspective? Fast forward it and play it out. Yeah, so the end game is a Fed balance sheet that is exponentially bigger than it is today. And it's filled with not just U.
S. treasuries and mortgage backs, but it's also going to be filled with, in my view, foreign sovereign debt, probably a lot of European debt, Japanese debt, because they're the sponsor of the system. If they want to prevent their allies from collapsing, they're going to have to do that. I think we're going to go through a span of significantly negative real interest rates. And there's some flexibility around that, maybe. The way to think about that is we can have a 10-year period of negative 6% real rates, and that would probably work, maybe. But again, the debt is so much higher than it was.
The U.S. economy is so much more financialized than it was. the problem with that playbook is you've got to convince somebody to be the sucker at the card table, somebody be the idiot holding treasuries for 10 straight years at negative 6% real rates. And we had six months of negative 6% real rates, and you started to see problems, political problems with inflation, treasuries sell off, because the problem for the Fed is you You can't, the debt is so high, they can't sustain a rise of interest rates in response to that inflation. They have to keep real rates significantly negative. So to me, the negative 6% for 10-year real rate playbook, that was a baseline, base case, I think, pre-COVID, maybe in the immediate aftermath of COVID.
That is now a Hail Mary. I don't think that that's more likely. I think where we're quickly going to get to is particularly given this Fed policy mistake of not continuing to just inflate because they're trying to deflate for a bit. That makes it much more likely that what we instead see is a U.S. version of Israel in the early 80s. And this is not a well-known playbook or episode I've found in macro. So Israeli, right? Israel is a very developed, highly educated nation. Lots of high-tech products, et cetera. They had 100% to 400% inflation for three, four years in the early 80s. And the sovereign debt problem was gone like that.
After three, four years, central bank raises rates up to whatever they raise up to. They stop inflating. They cut deficits. Boom. And you move on. And I think increasingly the odds of a 40 scenario where, hey, we're just going to keep real rates negative 600 to negative 2000 basis points for six years. I think that was still on the I think that was still on the on the on the menu of palatable or plausible economically mathematically possible options as of mid to late last year. The second the Fed started tightening and the dollar started rising, I think those are now off the table. I think what we're now going to the end game is going to be a whoosh down in risk assets for a few weeks.
we've sort of had the bleed down year to date, but I think we'll get a whoosh down and then the Fed coming back. And then we're going to go through this period of time where I think you're going to have extremely high inflation in the US for two, three years. And at the end of that two, three year period of time of extremely high inflation. And when I say extremely high inflation, I think you could probably see it 30 to 100% inflation at the CPI level in the US for two, three years. And I think the Fed will be saying, oh, it's only 10 to 12 and we're working on it. But at the end of it, U.S. debt to GDP will be 60, 70 percent.
The Fed can take rates back to 10. They can cut fiscal deficits because tax receipts will be high enough. And then they normalize policy and we move on. And, you know, Treasury holders, thank you for your donation to restoring U.S. fiscal solvency after COVID. We appreciate it. You got paid every dime you were owed, but you went from buying steak with it to buying, you know, crickets with it. So, So, you know, congratulations. This is quite the picture you're painting. And of course, one difference between Israel in the 1980s and the U.S. now is Israel did not have the global reserve currency at the time.
And that's exactly right. That's part of why I say it's so scary is there is – the U.S. is a way bigger economy. It's not the global reserve currency issue. So it touches, to your point, it touches everything. And so that whoosh down, that's DXY to the moon. That is everything else down, including treasuries, probably. I mean, like I said, you probably get a little bit of a treasury bid for an intervening period of time. But I think we're going to see a period like we saw in March 2020, where treasuries are bid, treasuries are bid. And then all of a sudden, it got bad enough and treasuries are sold.
This is interesting, though, Luke. So the other piece here is like you were talking about finding the sucker to buy treasuries, right? And so when the US realizes that that will be the new problem, I wonder how jealous it gets. And you start to recall kind of FDR's, you know, executive orders from the 1930s, banning US citizens from purchasing gold, right? And that is a similar kind of energy of like, hey, we need you to buy bonds, and we need you to buy treasuries to support your national economy. You can't have these other store of value assets. Do you think, is that part of your end game scenario that you're modeling out that the US gets kind of desperate and maybe some of these, what we would now think of as authoritarian, totalitarian measures come down the pike?
That's the incredible thing about it is if there's this phrase, and I wish I knew who quoted it, but it's wisdom is seeing things for what they are, right? So wisdom is seeing things for what they are. In 2014, the SEC passed a rule for money market funds. It offered, it provided for money market funds to be gated in times of crisis, which means you can't get your money, right? If there's a crisis and they're going to break the buck, you can't get your money. But it exempted something called government money market funds. So basically, by regulation, the US government began shifting dollars that were in the money market fund sector, which are enormous, they're measured in the trillions, out of private dollar assets, which finance corporations, and it finances foreign government.
I mean, anyone that was issuing commercial paper in the money market sector, saw their interest rates rise, LIBOR rose. And instead, you saw the shift of funds out of private dollar assets into U.S. Treasury T Bill money market funds, government money market funds. And that's so that is a FDR. When I say wisdom is seeing things for what they are, that was a regulatory measure designed to shift demand away from private dollar assets to U.S. government dollar assets. That is a a polite version of what fdr did it's a it's it's very similar to what argentina did in the early 2000s they were incenting um they were incenting um the private uh pensions and banks to buy government debt because they had a problem similarly 2014 high quality liquid asset regulations for the u.
s banking sector incented them to hold greater amounts of u.s treasury bonds as regulatory capital, gave them a break. Same dynamic. It's sort of a classic emerging market balance of payments problem. It's a version of what FDR did vis-a-vis gold, which was a monetary asset at the time. It's private property now. So my point is that this has been happening in slow motion, if you watch. The draconian version of this, I think, is less seizing gold. I mean, I think you certainly could see, you've seen some regulatory threats, I think, on Bitcoin. I mean, could it be something like, so regulatory threat on Bitcoin, Luke.
So could it be something like you can't actually hold Bitcoin in your own self-custodied wallet? You have to hold it on an exchange if you want Bitcoin. And that way, do you think it would go this far? I think they would do more of the pipes. I think they would do more of the on and off ramps, right? Is just say, hey, we want to, you know, we can see the on and off ramps out of, you know, from your bank to Coinbase. And we know what you have, and we're going to take whatever, we're going to tax it at 40, 50%, and put it in treasuries or something like that. Or there's some good ways it can happen too, right?
If they actually mandate, hey, any funds, you know, stable coins all have to own 100% UST bills. That's another way you could do it. But there's, It's like when they asked Willie Sutton, why do you rob banks? That's where the money is. He said, that's where the money is. So the same thing you could do is, look, there's whatever, $30 trillion in US retirement assets. Why confiscate gold or Bitcoin, which in aggregate are what in the US? A trillion? Two trillion? You could literally get $3 trillion right off the bat by saying every single, in order to maintain the tax-deferred status of U.S. retirement accounts, it must own 20% U.
S. Treasury bonds. There's $6 trillion right there. Boom. And that's where I think you could see that go. But here's the catch. They're probably thinking in these terms already. The problem is, remember what I said before, they need stocks to rise just to make the ends meet on the fiscal situation, right? So Alan Greenspan said in 2015 that – Capital gains tax? Is this why – What's that? Capital gains tax. It's not just capital gains. So net capital gains plus taxable IRA distributions alone are 200% of the annual growth in personal consumption expenditures of the United States, which PCE is about two thirds of GDP.
So that's basically U.S. consumer spending mathematically cannot grow unless stocks are rising. And if consumer spending is not growing at two thirds to 70% of GDP, GDP is not really growing. So the problem with diverting money out of stocks into treasuries and these retirement accounts to try to, you know, is you're going to take six trillion out of stocks, put it in treasuries. Well, great. Now you're going to have mandated selling in stocks as stocks come down. You thought you needed six trillion. The deficits are going to rise as stocks fall. You can see that clear as day, that correlation in the government data, because the US economy is going to head into recession.
Deficits always rise in recessions on the counter cyclical payments. So you can try to force Americans to pay more for their own stuff, to pay more for their own deficits. But if you do it by getting them to sell stocks, whatever deficit level you thought you needed to fund, it's going to be in order to magnitude higher deficit because the economy weakens. So you saw this play out in real time with Obamacare. So Obamacare, it's funny, is in 2014, the Wall Street Journal said part of what they're doing Obamacare for is to raise health care costs, to force Americans to pay more for their own care, to lower U.
S. deficits. And then that was like the only time it was ever about a deficit issue. This was right at the same time that we talked about the money market fund example. We talked about the bank example of, hey, U.S. money funds or money funds, banks, they need to buy more treasuries to help deficit. Well, U.S. consumers contribution to that deficit reduction exercise was Obamacare. Hey, your Obamacare premiums go up huge. Wall Street Journal says it's partly about deficit reduction and it worked 14, 15. You saw deficits come down. Problem is, is U.S. consumer spending came down, too. And that led to a – because all of a sudden, they're paying more for their care, right?
Something they were getting for free, they now had to pay for. And that consumer dollar that was going to a car or a boat or plastic crap at Target or Walmart wasn't getting bought. And what ended up happening in 2016 is U.S. deficits as a percent of GDP in response to these deficit reduction and financing exercises actually started going up because – That was what you meant when one of my goals in this conversation was to ask you what you meant by the U.S. stock market effectively is the U.S. economy. You tweeted that out recently. The stock market is the U.S. economy. That's what you meant.
That's what I mean. And critically, like that net capital gain plus taxable IRA being 200% of the annual growth in PCE, that's just net cap gain and taxable IRA distributions. That does not include any of the stock comp, right? So you go out to the West Coast and everyone's buying all these big houses because they're either selling options and buying the house or they're using it as collateral. Like stock comp, executive stock comp is taxed as ordinary income, and it's not broken out really anywhere cleanly how big a deal that is. But you can play bigger than a breadbasket of how big a deal it is when you look at the percentage of taxes paid by individual by tax bracket.
So if you say the top 5%, IRS data shows that top 5% of US taxpayers pay 60, 6-0% of the individual income taxes, that's 30% of total US income taxes. Now, top 5% of taxpayers in the US are making, I want to say, I don't know what the, it's a couple hundred thousand dollars a year. And particularly the higher up you go, the top 1%, these are people that are, they're not working hourly. It's not like these are people that are making $20,000 an hour expressly in wages. They are, they're making their, you know, a couple hundred grand in cash comp. And then the rest of it is coming as incentive comp.
And all that incentive comp is subject to the stock market and the stock market year over year. And their marginal consumption is a function in part of that wealth effect. The wealth effect probably declines as you get further out there. You're worth, you know, $2 billion. dollars. It's not like you care if you're only worth a billion and a half, but you're worth $10 million and you're only worth, you know, 700, you know, one in three quarters or one and a half. That's that might change your or excuse me, your five to seven, seven million that might start to change some of the marginal consumption patterns and on down.
So there's that's when I say, hey, the stock market is the economy. It's not about when you look at it in the absolute. No, it's a relatively small percent, but so many economists, analysts, writers make this mistake. It's all about what happens on the margin when you are highly indebted. If we were running an equity-based low debt system like we had in the 70s, so what? Stocks go down, so what? But because the leverage is so high on the margin, stocks go down, consumption goes down. Consumption goes down when you're as levered as the entire system is, system unwinds fast and non-linearly. And that's why I say the stock market is the economy.
It's the economy on the margin, and on the margin is all that matters in highly indebted systems. RocketPool is your friendly, decentralized Ethereum staking protocol. You can stake your ETH with RocketPool and get our ETH in return, allowing you to stake your ETH and use it in DeFi at the same time. You can get 4% on your ETH by staking it with RocketPool, but you can get even more by running a node. Rocket Pool is the only staking provider that allows anyone to permissionlessly join their network of validating nodes. Running a Rocket Pool node is easier to set up than running a solo node, and you only need 16 ETH to get started.
Why would you do this? You get an extra 15% staking commission on the pooled ETH, so your APY is boosted. So if you're bullish ETH staking, you can increase your APY and get some extra tokens by adding your node to the decentralized Rocket Pool network, which currently has over 1,000 independent validators. It's yield farming, but with Ethereum nodes. You can get started at rocketpool.net and also join the RocketPool community in their Discord. You can find me hanging out there sometimes in the chat, so I'll see you there. which gives Brave Browser an extra level of security versus other wallets.
Brave Wallet is your secure passport for the possibilities of Web3 and supports multiple chains, including Ethereum and Solana. You can even buy crypto directly inside the wallet with Ramp. And of course, you can store, send, and swap your crypto assets, manage your NFTs, and connect to other wallets and DeFi apps. So whether you're new to crypto or you're a seasoned pro, it's time to ditch those risky extensions and it's time to switch to the Brave Wallet. Download Brave at brave.com slash bankless and click the wallet icon to get started. Arbitrum is an Ethereum layer 2 scaling solution that is going to completely change how we use DeFi and NFTs.
Some of the coolest new NFT collections have chosen Arbitrum as their home, while DeFi protocols continue to see increased liquidity and usage. You can now bridge straight into Arbitrum for more than 10 different exchanges, including Binance, FTX, Huobi, and Crypto.com. Once on Arbitrum, you'll enjoy fast transactions with cheap fees, allowing you to explore new frontiers of the crypto universe. New to Arbitrum, for a limited time, you can get Arbitrum NFTs designed by the famous artists Ratwell and Sugoi. for joining the Arbitrum Odyssey. The Odyssey is an eight-week long event where you complete on-chain activities and receive a free NFT as a reward.
Find out more by visiting the Discord at discord.gg slash arbitrum. You can also bridge your assets to Arbitrum at bridge.arbitrum.io and access all of Arbitrum's apps at portal.arbitrum.one in order to experience DeFi and NFTs the way it was always meant to be, fast, cheap, secure, and fiction-free. So what is this era going to mean for the average worker in the United States economy. The WTO worker, $40,000 to $100,000 yearly income. We're going to have a period of, you've already said, like five to 10 years of sustained inflation. That seems crazy to me. I'm sure crazy to most people. I don't know anyone in the United States has lived through that.
And then also when we have this depressed stock market, which we just talked about, which is a part of so much of people's consumption. Well, if that's depressed, that's also going to impact the economy. So but what do you how would you illustrate the next five to 10 years for just like the average worker with like their grocery bills, their rent prices, their their ability to produce an income? Can you paint that picture for us? Yeah, I increasingly think it's one of two outcomes, depending on which faction in Washington and more broadly globally wins. um the happy ending is um basically we go through this span of high inflation there is a recognition of the extreme national security vulnerability of the united states as it relates to producing our own stuff vis-a-vis china in particular but others as well and we go through a massive period of reinvestment in U.
S. industrial infrastructure, reshoring broadly. Basically, the United States says, okay, we're going to implement a version of Chinese industrial policy with U.S. characteristics. And in that case, inflation goes crazy. Real rates are massively negative. The working and middle classes win huge because wages, you just basically, The wagers are going to go up and up and up until you find basically the offer side, right? So until you start having Wall Street salesmen saying, I'm hanging it up because I can make more money being a plumber, that's what happens there. The U.S. comes out way ahead because of the natural endowment that we have.
And that's a really good outcome. That's a very weak dollar, really bad for bonds. that's really good for risk assets broadly, home prices, gold, Bitcoin. It's very inflationary. That's the happy ending. The unhappy ending is sort of the – I'm going to try to be diplomatic here. You can kind of tell which side I'm rooting for, I guess. sort of the, those that think, hey, we need a strong dollar and the treasury market must be preserved in real terms at all costs. That is a really good outcome for, you know, basically, hey, we must crash the US economy to make sure treasury holders are kept whole on a real basis to preserve the dollar's role in the global financial system and to preserve the treasury's role as primary reserve asset.
And you can see this from people like William Dudley and his op-eds at the New York Fed, from Larry Summers, some of these series of actors that have been in Washington for the last 40, 50 years, sort of the Rubin, Robert Rubin, Clinton type financial people. In that world, Washington wins huge. U.S. military-industrial complex probably does okay. China ultimately quickly surpasses the United States in economic importance and geopolitical power. Europe probably comes unhinged. Japan probably comes unhinged. The U.S. middle and working classes probably suffer greatly and end up with some version of a permanent version of universal basic income, which starts to veer into, you know, issues of control.
Hey, if you don't, you know, if you don't do this or do that, then we'll haircut your UBI payment for you that month. And that's just not a great, You know, as a father, that's not a great sort of outcome. That's not something I get excited, a world I get excited about for my kids to live in, as opposed to the former. So I think those are your two sort of, it's basically really, again, to your point, Ryan, earlier, the dollar connecting to everything. what do we want to be? The first scenario, we go back to be in America, basically. In the second scenario, we go back to sort of America with the asterisk, which is we're going to be in the business of exporting dollars and exporting treasuries.
And then we're basically going to be sort of a giant tax, you know, tax haven, a la, you know, Panama, with a lot more, you know, corn and soybeans and a bigger military. And I just, you know, I think I'd rather be America than America asterisk. But I think those are your two, I think those are your two sort of options are most, those are the two, you know, polar ends of where this goes. I wouldn't say that there's only one or the other. I think that you can probably blend shades of the two. But I think that's sort of your range of outcomes based, again, on what do we want to do? Do we want to preserve American exceptionalism, American power by investing in America?
Or do we just want to keep the dollar treasury system as is or try to? I don't know that it'll work in the long run, but I think those are sort of where we're going. after talking with linaldin and also you thus far in this conversation it was surprising to hear that there's actually like a positive outcome for like the u.s middle class that involves a definancialization of a very over financialized economy that's us that's us and allowing for strong wage growth in like real terms to to be a possible future uh so So that's cool if that is on the table. It seems to be like it's the United States middle class versus treasury holders.
Like that seems to be the correct tug of war. Is that a good way to put this? It's absolutely the right tug of war, the right way to frame it. It's something we wrote about a couple of years ago now where I said for basically from 80, 80, basically as soon as Paul Volcker got into office, when he did what he did, he began subjugating the U.S. middle and working classes in deference to the U.S. Treasury holders. And that was great for Wall Street. It was great for Washington. It was not great for the U.S. middle and working classes. When you look at trade deals like NAFTA, when you look at trade deals like the WTO, those were basically just extensions of what Volcker did in terms of subjugating the U.
S. middle and working classes in deference to U.S. treasury holders. And for the U.S. to really win, it needs to do the opposite. It needs to subjugate treasury holders in real terms to the U.S. middle and working classes. And I think ultimately, in real terms for U.S. wages, I think wages will probably not quite keep up with inflation over time in that period, when you look at the histories of inflation, right, first wages exceeded, and then they, you know, then they don't. The evening out that people typically leave out is, is you've got a whole lot of fixed rate debt, right? The average American worker has a lot of fixed rate debt.
And that's why I say, I think ultimately, this is gonna be very inflationary very quickly is, is no one's gonna want to hold a mortgage paper, no one's gonna hold mortgage paper yielding for if inflation is 15 to 20. That's terrible for the mortgage holder. It's great for the mortgage owner, right? If your wages, you know, if your food bill is going up 20 and your wages are going up 12 to 15, it sort of stinks, except if you've got a 4% mortgage, you're picking up 800 basis points a year, right? If your wages are up 12 and your mortgage is a 4% coupon, You're picking up 800 basis points in real terms against your mortgage every year, even as you're losing 300 to 800 basis points against your food bill and your gasoline bill.
And so I think to the extent that, again, it allows a de-levering sovereign and household balance sheets, there's this fixed debt component that people tend to leave out because they don't think about it in terms of, you know, again, they always go back to the 70s if you're in the United States. And oh, it just killed us in inflation. Well, U.S. debt to GDP was 25, 30 percent. People didn't you know, the average mortgage in the 70s was was way lower than it was now. So there's this I think when you think about real wage gains for the middle and working class under that scenario. Yes, it probably is maybe a little bit of a gain early on a push and then eventually they're behind.
But there's this cushion in terms of the fixed rate debt that I think tends to not be considered. Now, it goes back to our question. Who is the sucker at the card table holding that debt as you're inflating it away? And the answer is going to be the Fed's balance sheet. And that's why I say I think where this goes, where this endgame is, is the Fed's balance sheet is an order of magnitude larger than where it sits today. And the question is, what's the path between here and there? To keep going on this whole tug of war, the American middle class versus treasury holders, you stated two possible outcomes.
We revitalize America or it's America with an asterisk. My mind when you said that went to, well, that sounds like China, where you have this behavior dependent UBI that comes from a highly surveilled state where there's a lot of top down control and like less freedoms and forcing funneling, you know, the capital of the United States into these treasuries so that, so that the treasury side can, can come out. Okay. Versus, uh, you know, reinvigorating like the American dream, strong middle-class, like high production, high manufacturing. Uh, and obviously like now when you, when you said like, I, uh, I, that obviously it's obvious which one you're rooting for.
I'm also like, I'm also rooting for the same won, I'm pretty damn sure. How strong are the political forces to have the America with the asterisk? Like how strong is that side of the fight? That's the status quo. So it's pretty strong. Now, with that said, it was a lot stronger pre-COVID. And the reason I say that is I've been talking about these issues for a long time. And pre-COVID, I sort of got a lot of yeah, yeah, yeah, yeah, yeah. Particularly from people tied to Washington, right? Or even people on Wall Street. Yeah, yeah, yeah, yeah, yeah. But then when New York and when Washington couldn't get supplies, when the response to COVID is we need a bunch of masks, and China said, hey, yeah, hold on, we'll get you your masks after we have ours all taken care of.
That, I think, hit Washington in particular in a way where even the most dogmatic politician, hey, strong dollar, good, strong dollar, good. What's good for the dollar is good for America. In the same way that what's good for GM is good for America was once true, and what's good for US Steel is good for America was once true. There was this huge contingent in Washington, hey, what's good for the dollar is good for America. Well, you can have masks or you can have strong dollar, what do you want? And I think post COVID, that pushed a notable contingent of people that had not really thought that hard about it beyond what's good for the dollar is good for America toward a little bit of a more nuanced position of understanding how vulnerable U.
S. supply chains had become by virtue of this status quo system. So there is a – the status quo system is still very powerful, very well entrenched. They tend to be older, though, versus I think this growing recognition of, hey, we're vulnerable from a national security perspective. I mean, the Defense Department is very much on board with this and have been for years of, listen, borrowing money from China to build weapons to face down China is not a good idea. It's not a sustainable strategy. So I think there's a lot in the defense and intelligence establishments in the United States that get this.
And I think there's a lot of sort of your middle ground politicians either became aware of the issue after COVID or switched over to sort of that DOD and intelligence side in the aftermath of COVID. But there's still a lot of institutional dogma, et cetera, around this. and so it is still very much a toss-up. And so Luke, we talked about kind of how bad is it and the end game scenarios and the possibilities of fixing this. And also we talked about like what happens next. I wanna zoom down into some assets and kind of burn through these real quick. Like, so talk about like currencies, talk about a little bit more about bonds and equities and energy as well, even though we've touched on some of these, but let's drill down and give this an asset lens here.
So in either of those two paths, maybe in the Treasury's path, the dollar retains its global reserve supremacy. But what do you think in these two paths, these two scenarios, what happens to the dollar in this environment? And then also just take us through really quickly other currencies, euro, yen, yuan, ruble. What happens to all of these currencies in the future we're headed towards? I think it depends on which choice, how quickly the Fed, you know, basically until the Fed relents and starts putting the world on its balance sheet, you're going to have dollar up against, I think, everything except the ruble over time.
And you may see the euro collapse. You may see the yen collapse, in which case the dollar goes towards infinity, theoretically, because basically the DXY index is basically the dollar against the euro and the yen, right? So, you know, it's sort of ironic. Hey, the dollar's up. It's so strong. This is so good for America. Well, it's the DXY, just a stupid index to look at right now. It's getting it's getting it's getting less stupid. It's getting less stupid because you are finally seeing the energy shortages impact emerging markets as well. For, you know, February, March into April, it was a bit of a stupid index because it's basically, hey, your allies in Europe and Japan are collapsing.
yay, we're winning. Well, not really. You're putting a bullet in your two most important allies. That's not good for America. And you could see it, right? The Brazilian real was rising against the dollar. The ruble rising against the dollar. It was a little silly then. I don't think it's as silly now. Now you're seeing weakness. It's much more broad-based weakness. So I think it is giving us an idea. But I think it's the right direction increasingly now as it continues to strengthen. The challenge is that it's basically indicating an energy crisis. It's indicating what was really a global energy crisis.
Europe is now in a twin deficit position. Japan's in a twin deficit position. All else equal, those currencies and those nations will collapse unless either the Fed comes in and starts buying their debt for them, weakening the dollar, strengthening the other pairs. Or they say, I'm sorry, USA, we're short energy. We have to take care of our people. People are going to starve. People are going to die. Pick up the phone. Yeah, hey, Vladimir? Yeah, sorry, we need gas. Will you sell us gas in yen if you're Japan? That's where this is going. And so when you think about this, okay to pass. As long as the Fed stands aside, dollar is going to win.
And everything else is going to lose. I think the dollar will continue to fall against ruble, though, because ruble is effectively gas based at the gas backed at this point. And the dollar is going to fall against gas in my view, the dollar is going to fall against oil in my view. That's, that's, that's the easy answer. And then the flip side, I think is also true. When the Fed is forced to finally sort of come in, come back to the markets, I think dollar loses against virtually everything. I think there's probably, and we may be starting to be in it now, an intervening period of weeks, maybe a month or two, where the dollar also rises against oil and gas and against the ruble and other commodities.
I think we may be in that period right now. But ultimately, it can't last long because once oil gets low enough, biggest marginal producer of oil in the world is the US and it's high cost oil. And you get oil too low and the US is going to start shutting down shale wells because they're very much on off depending on break evens. And then you're just gonna be seeding leverage right back to Putin. So it really is a very binary outlook as it relates to commodities. As long as the Fed is not buying enough treasuries to finance a sufficient amount of US deficits, the dollar is going to go up against virtually everything, except for oil and gas.
And by virtue of that, I think against the ruble and vice versa. When they are, then I think the dollar weakens against virtually everything. And we saw this play out in the lead up to 2020, the immediate lead up, dollar was up, everything else basically down. once the Fed started buying enough US Treasuries from April 20 through May 21, the dollar fell against virtually everything. And then once the Fed started tightening again, the dollar has risen against virtually everything. So I think it's a very binary, this ties into my point of, hey, the Fed, it's not a dial, it's a switch. USA economy on, USA economy off.
When USA economy is off, there's a dollar shortage, dollar's going to go up. And when a US economy is on, then, And hey, party on Wayne, party on Garth. Okay, so all of these currencies are now getting kind of repriced for this new reality. We already talked about what happens to bonds in this world. Your prediction is they absolutely die, right? Not going to do so well for the next, you know, in this paradigm shift. Yeah, and we'll come back to equities in a minute. But you've been talking a lot about energy commodities. And it seems like even for the ruble, it's basically like the ruble is being priced as if it's gas, as if it's an energy commodity.
What happens to energy commodities, oil, natural gas in this environment? I think energy is in a secular uptrend, again, because of this peak cheap energy. You need higher energy prices to get the supplies, the incremental supplies to continue to maintain the debt that is out there. I mean, you need to expend energy to generate economic activity to support the debt that exists. And if you don't have that energy, the debt is going to default. You're not going to generate the economic surplus needed to pay, you know, just to keep floating the debt. And so you're in this weird period of time where whether you look at it, when you look at it geologically, you need higher energy prices.
If you don't get higher energy prices, you're going to have very big economic problems. And so for me, it speaks to two things, depending on your view. If you're just sort of cash buy and hold investor, I think energy is going to be fine. If you're a trader, I think we're talking about a continuation of just mind boggling volatility in energy markets. And we're starting to see that, right? When you see down 10% days in crude oil, I mean, crude oil is a $2 trillion, $3 trillion a year commodity. Down 10% in a day, it's just mind-boggling volatility. But that's what you're going to get in this combination of high debt, peak cheap energy world, where once you start over-tightening in terms of policy, you're going to be, okay, oh, God, I have to sell my oil.
Once you sell it too far, now you're going to have oil shortages very quickly. Because again, U.S. shale, world's biggest marginal producer, the legacy wells decline. In the U.S., in the four biggest basins in the U.S., the legacy wells decline 5% per month. So if you just stop producing in the U.S., U.S. oil production, the four big basins, is going to fall at least 30%, 40% in a year. So you're going to take 30%, 40% of the biggest marginal producer out of the market, and maybe more if you get prices too low. So there's this, the energy market, like I said, for the cash investor, I think remains very fundamentally driven.
I think volatility is going to be very, very high in the intervening time based on those dynamics. Luke, you gave a quote that I really, really resonated with, and that was energy is the interest is nature's interest rate. And I'm wondering if you could explain what that means and connect that to all of the developing markets, emerging markets that are out there in the world. And kind of something that I'm a little bit fearful of is that a lot of all of this demand for energy, especially especially as Europe goes into a winter, gets sucked out of the market and leaves a lot of emerging markets hanging, not able to afford energy.
Can you just explain these dynamics that you see ahead of us? Yeah. I mean, there are pictures. It could be very catastrophic for emerging markets. Very catastrophic. It could be very catastrophic for Europe. We've been writing for the last three, four months that the playbook Europe is running is basically the same playbook Germany ran after World War I in Weimar, Germany, which was the French came in and seized Ruhr Valley coal stores as a part of the war reparations. And the Germans said, oops, we don't have energy. Let's just print money. And you look at what's happening now. The Europeans are blindly saying, hell, yeah, you know, bad Putin will do without his gas.
Or Putin's now saying, OK, fine. You want to sanction my you want to you want to take my FX reserves. Great. I'm going to make you pay in another currency or you're not going to get the gas. and what are they talking about doing? They're talking about printing money to keep peripheral spreads close to the center. You print money without energy, you're gonna hyperinflate the currency. And that's in Europe, that's in a developed market. That's a potentially pleasant outcome. You talk about places like Sri Lanka at the other far end of the sort of the very weakest of the weak emerging markets, societal collapse, starvation, violent overthrows of governments.
I mean, that's what happens when people don't have enough energy or food. And so if mismanaged, that's where this sort of could all go. And that's what, you know, this all filters into why I think it's, you know, one of the scariest environments we've seen in 27 years. Everything in this type of environment goes back down on Maslow's hierarchy of needs. And people are just talking about like, you know, food, shelter and energy, right? And that's kind of what you need at the base level. let's just finish this up with the asset lens equities where do they go over this decade I mean they're traditionally risk-on assets aren't they what what do you think they'll do in this kind of environment over this decade I think they go way higher because ultimately I think this I think the decade of the 20s is going to be about when you look back it's going to be about western sovereign governments' solvency being maintained nominally by their respective central banks.
In plain English, Western governments are broke. They're pretending for the moment like they're solvent. They're not. Central banks are going to print the money to keep them solvent, and that's going to be really good for equities over the course of this decade. Now, anytime they come out like they are over the last six to nine months, 12 months, and say, oh, we're going to tighten, it's not going to be good for equities. And we're seeing that. But unless central banks in the West, unless the US Fed is willing to stand aside and let the Fed, the ECB, the BOJ stand aside and let the US, Europe, and Japan default on their debt, which I don't think is going to happen, then I think they're going to print the money.
And as they print that money, it's going to be really good for equities from beginning to end of the 20s. gold now, another different store of value commodity, let's call it. This is a tweet you put out recently, Luke, which I liked. If gold was a useless pet rock, Western G7 policymakers wouldn't be putting capital controls on it. Is this kind of emperor with no clothes? Gold is actually a store of value asset. Where does gold go? And then lastly, we'll get to crypto, but first gold. Gold for me is the once in future neutral reserve asset. It's been moving back into the system as a neutral reserve asset led by the quote unquote rogues gallery of China and Russia and primarily those two.
The Europeans have always liked gold. They continue to like gold. So I think ultimately gold has been gaining share slowly from treasuries as a primary reserve asset. I think by the end of the 2020s, gold regains a lot of share from treasuries as a primary reserve asset. And when you look at the relative sizes of those markets, it implies gold being multiples higher over the course of this decade so that it can be big enough to serve as a reserve asset again. And so I think gold is probably a double or triple from here over the next 10 years. Okay, so how about crypto now? So you could group crypto in that store of value asset category like gold.
Others group it, and it seems like the market is recently into kind of the risk asset category. And you'd expect with all of the nominal issuance, money printing, inflation going on, you'd expect something like Bitcoin to perform better than it has recently. I'm wondering if you think that could turn around. There's also this quote I think many have attributed to you, Luke, which I really like is, crypto is the last functioning fire alarm. Talk about that too, if you would. What's the story on crypto this decade? For me, I really focus just on Bitcoin. And so for me, Bitcoin is the last functioning smoke alarm.
And the reason I like Bitcoin so much is that proof of work dynamic versus proof of stake, because to me, proof of stake is effectively just a fiat system. And proof of work is much more gold-like. It's basically a tie to energy. I look at Bitcoin and I look at gold as energy proxies. It takes a lot of energy to mine and store gold. It takes a lot of energy to mine and warehouse cold store Bitcoin. There's an energy component to that. And so I think ultimately Bitcoin will trade more like an energy proxy store of value, neutral reserve asset for the people. I agree it has not. It is not traded as a store of value, neutral reserve asset for the people relative to treasury bonds, gold stocks, et cetera, on the way down here.
It has, I think, traded as a neutral reserve asset relative to everything else in crypto on the way down here, which has been somewhat typical in down cycles in crypto over the last several years. Bitcoin outperforms on the way down and has underperformed on the way up. It'll be interesting this time to see, given some of what's happened, have there been people converted to Bitcoin only from some of these others by this down cycle? Who knows? But to me, Bitcoin is basically the last functioning smoke detector in terms of liquidity metrics. And I think will come to be seen as a neutral reserve asset, which is ultimately neutral reserve asset is just an energy proxy.
It ties back to what we talked about before, negative real interest rates, energy scarcity. You need a neutral reserve asset that preserves your purchasing power and energy or else you're screwed. You're screwed like Europe, you're screwed like Japan, you're screwed like Sri Lanka. You need energy. And for a long time, dollars equaled energy. US Treasuries equaled energy. And that's part of this sovereign debt bubble bursting is this belief that sovereign debt will hold its purchasing power in real terms. I think that has begun being – that's when I say it's bursting. The bursting is ultimately this unwavering belief that sovereign debt and in particular treasuries are good stores of value on a real basis.
They have been for a long time. They can't be anymore if governments are not going to nominally default on the debt. So, Luke, how should we position our portfolios going into what seems to be a very thick fog of war, very uncertain decade with a lot of volatility? keeping in mind that listeners of this podcast are likely 50% or greater of their portfolios or in all in crypto assets. So what are the general rules of thumb that we should consider when we construct our portfolios to finish off this decade? So I think it may be the most instructive chart to answer that question. There's a chart that I've highlighted a number of times in our work.
It was put together by a friend of mine, Dan Oliver at Mermican Capital. And it's tremendous chart, what it shows is the price of gold in Weimar German marks, and then the month-over-month performance of gold in Weimar German marks. And so from, call it, 1918 to 1923, literally, the currency hyperinflates to zero against gold. Gold goes from whatever, 20 marks to 20 Reichsmarks to a trillion Reichsmarks over a five-year span. However, and a lot of people would say, oh, I want to borrow as much money as I can and own gold. The challenge that I think a year ago people didn't appreciate, I think today they appreciate a lot more in the crypto world, is that chart showed that four or five or six different times in that span of that hyperinflation, one of the great ones of all time, you lost all of your money if you were levered long gold in REX marks.
because inexplicably, people actually believed the equivalent of, well, the Reichsmark is going to do QT. They're going to sell. They're actually going to go into austerity. And people multiple times sold gold to buy Reichsmarks as the currency was going to zero. So the point is that I think the key is to be unlevered. If you're levered, this whole process is so political. I can't tell you whether the Fed can come out tomorrow and grow the balance sheet. Something could break. Fed will be outgrown tomorrow. And then it's going to be or they could be weaponizing this against Russia. There may have been a decision made behind closed doors is we want oil at 40.
And we don't care if the Dow goes to 10,000. We don't care if the if Nasdaq crashes. We don't care if Bitcoin goes to zero, you know, goes back to 20 bucks. Oil has to be 40. Anything else that breaks, it doesn't matter. I don't think they can do that. But if they try that and you're levered, you're going to lose everything. You are going to get carried out on your shield. And I think, like I said, a year ago, people like now, now I think people see it. If you were levered long crypto over the last six to 12 months, your capital is gone. And so I think rule number one is stay unlevered or very low leverage.
And then for me, I like holding a lot of cash. We've been talking about building cash with our clients. If you're a high risk month to month guy, we've been talking about being mostly in cash for several months because it's just such a political dynamic. So to me, my portfolio, I like to call it the Jacob Fugger portfolio, richest man in history, 25% cash, 25% gold, 25% stocks, 25% real estate. And then you just adjust based on what moves the cash gives the optionality. To me, when I think about gold, I lump Bitcoin in there with gold. And then it's a personal situation of, hey, you want 25% Bitcoin?
Great. You want 5% Bitcoin of that 25? You want one? It depends on your situation, your comfort with understanding it. And then you adjust based on what happens. But I think having the cash for optionality, but most important is being unlevered because this is such a political process, number one. And number two, the debt is so high. The volatility has been high. It's going to keep being high in my view. I'm reminded of this fund that lost all of their money, completely blew up by shorting Luna into the ground, which is a lesson in volatility. You can be right over the long term, but the volatility will chew you up on leverage in whatever time frame that you're in.
Luke, one last perspective I want to get from you. The gist that I've gotten is that over the 10 plus year time horizon, we're super bullish. We can be bullish on perhaps equities and crypto and gold. but it's this next one to three to five years of just like volatility and chop that we need to get through to get to that point. Would that be a fair assessment? Yeah, I think, I think it's a very fair assessment. I think it's a lot shorter than two to five years of chop, but I, but yeah, I think we've got chop over the next six to 12 months. And then I think it's, you know, we're going to know for sure, but it's that you've got to live through that chop.
Otherwise you're not going to, you're not going to have anything to invest on the other side of your two lever. Cool. Luke, thank you so much for joining us and helping us think through these tumultuous times, see through the fog of war, as David mentioned earlier. We really appreciate it. Thanks for having me on. It's great being here. Bankless Nation, a few follow-ups, of course. Go listen to those thoughts from Luke at the end. No leverage. Holding cash, which is somewhat ironic because we just spent most of the podcast disparaging the dollar, but that is wise in these economic times. action items for you.
We will include a link to the chart that Luke mentioned. We'll make sure to get that link from him post-show. Also, make sure you subscribe to Forest Through the Trees, the newsletter. We will include a link in the show notes there. Luke also has his own YouTube channel. So if you are on YouTube watching this right now, go ahead on over to Luke's YouTube channel and click subscribe as well. Some fantastic content there. And as always, last action item for you. We've got a lot of macro stuff still coming your way and a lot in the archives recently with Lynn Alden, Jim Bianco, and others. We'll include links to some of the key shows there.
As always, none of this has been financial advice. Crypto is risky, but wait, the entire world is risky now. You can definitely lose what you put in, but we are headed west. Hey, we hope you enjoyed the video. If you did, head over to Bankless HQ right now to develop your crypto investing skills and learn how to free yourself from banks and gain your financial independence. We recommend joining our daily newsletter, podcast, and community as a Bankless Premium subscriber to get the most out of your Bankless experience. You'll get access to our market analysis, our alpha leaks, and exclusive content, and even the Bankless token for airdrops, raffles, and unlocks.
If you're interested in crypto, the Bankless community is where you want to be. Click the link in the description to become a Bankless Premium subscriber today. Also, don't forget to subscribe to the channel for in-depth interviews with industry leaders, ask me anythings, and weekly roll-ups where we summarize The Week in Crypto and other fantastic content. Thanks everyone for watching and being on the journey as we build out the Bankless Nation.