✨ Part I: https://youtu.be/tKjs8bBQ3sk
✨ DEBRIEF | Unpacking the Episode: https://shows.banklesshq.com/p/vitalik-debrief
Vitalik Buterin is a crypto-economic researcher, author of the Ethereum Whitepaper, builder, and philosopher. He also recently published a new book titled, “Proof of Stake: The Making of Ethereum and the Philosophy of Blockchains.”
In his first Bankless appearance post-merge, Vitalik shares his behind-the-scenes perspective on the merge, looking back—what he would’ve done differently, and most importantly—what’s next?
This is a two-part episode that you don’t what to miss! Part one is all about what’s next for Ethereum. And part two covers more of the social/philosophical realm of holistically, what is Ethereum. Further, Vitalik explores his thoughts on artificial intelligence and its relationship to crypto.
------ 📣 Galxe | Explore Crypto’s #1 Credential Network bankless.cc/Galxe
------ 🚀 SUBSCRIBE TO NEWSLETTER: https://newsletter.banklesshq.com/ 🎙️ SUBSCRIBE TO PODCAST: http://podcast.banklesshq.com/
------ BANKLESS SPONSOR TOOLS:
⚖️ ARBITRUM | SCALING ETHEREUM https://bankless.cc/Arbitrum
❎ ACROSS | BRIDGE TO LAYER 2 https://bankless.cc/Across
🦁 BRAVE | THE BROWSER NATIVE WALLET https://bankless.cc/Brave
💠 NEXO | CRYPTO FINANCIAL HUB https://bankless.cc/Nexo
🔐 LEDGER | NANO HARDWARE WALLETS https://bankless.cc/Ledger
⚡️FUEL | THE MODULAR EXECUTION LAYER https://bankless.cc/Fuelpod
----- Topics Covered
0:00 Intro 4:17 Is Ethereum a Network State? 11:09 What is Ethereum Then? 15:02 World Economic Forum & Globalism 20:16 Is Ethereum a DAO? What Are DAOs? 23:55 DAOs & Corporations 26:30 Ethereum’s End State 32:11 A.I. vs. Crypto 35:42 A.I. Ethics 41:50 AGI vs. Ethereum Progress 42:38 Closing & Vitalik Disclaimers
------ Resources:
Vitalik Roadmap Bankless Episode https://youtu.be/b1m_PTVxD-s
Vitalik’s Vlog https://vitalik.ca/
Vitalik’s New Book https://www.amazon.com/Proof-Stake-Ethereum-Philosophy-Blockchains/dp/164421248X/
The Ethereum Roadmap https://twitter.com/vitalikbuterin/status/1466411377107558402
Paths to Single Slot Finality https://notes.ethereum.org/@vbuterin/single_slot_finality
MEV Boost https://www.mevboost.org/
DAOs are not corporations https://vitalik.ca/general/2022/09/20/daos.html
-----
Not financial or tax advice. This channel is strictly educational and is not investment advice or a solicitation to buy or sell any assets or to make any financial decisions. This video is not tax advice. Talk to your accountant. Do your own research.
No summary for this episode yet.
Welcome to Bankless, where we explore the frontier of internet money and internet finance. This is how to get started, how to get better, how to frontrun the opportunity. This is Ryan Sean Adams. I'm your with David Hoffman and we're here to help you become more bankless. Guys, exciting episode for you. This is the sequel. This is part two of What's Next with Vitalik Buterin. We ask What's Next for Ethereum? In today's part two episode, we talk more broadly. What's Next for the world? What's Next for AI in the intersection of crypto? This is the social and philosophical side of Ethereum. We get into the question of what have we created here?
What is Ethereum holistically? Is it like a country, a network state, as Balaji might say, or is it a Dow? If it's a Dow, how should Dow's be governed? Should we use a corporate governance structure? Should we take the learnings from philosophy and political science and apply those things to Dow's? Then we end with the biggest question of all, have never heard Vitalik comment on artificial intelligence in his thoughts, but he gives us those thoughts today. Is AI coming to destroy humanity? We ask him that question. Will there be a peaceful coexistence? What is the intersection between crypto and artificial intelligence?
Crypto, of course, being a decentralized technology, AI being one that centralizes. Are we in for the cage match of the decade of the next century? Maybe that's ahead. Vitalik, as well, thinks AI could be coming sooner than he previously thought. I think this is after a trip to Silicon Valley and talking to some experts, so a lot of content to unpack. Of course, this is a second part of a two-part conversation with Vitalik. If you want last week's part one, go back on the RSS feed and you can download that you should see that. Guys, of course, we're just going to get right to the conversation with Vitalik, but first a moment to talk about some of these fantastic sponsors that make the show possible.
If you've been listening to banklists, you know that we're fans of the modular blockchain thesis. The idea that blockchains will separate execution from data availability and consensus, allowing all three to become the best versions of themselves. And Fuel has built the fastest modular execution layer in the industry. By supporting parallel transaction execution, Fuel unlocks significantly faster throughput for the web free world. Fuel also goes beyond the limitations of the EVM, with its own Fuel VM, which is more efficient and optimized, opening up the design space for developers. And lastly, Fuel brings a powerful developer experience with its own domain-specific language sway, and a supportive tool chain called fork.
With Fuel, you can have the benefits of smart contract languages like Solidity while adopting the improvements made by the REST tool and ecosystem, letting the Fuel development and wiring go beyond the limitations of the EVM. If you want to learn more, there's a link in the show notes to see how you can get involved with a Fuel Network. And all of my years in crypto, I've never been hacked, scammed, or lost money to a thief, and a lot of that credit goes to my Ledger hardware wallet. The Ledger Nano X and the Ledger Nano S Plus hardware wallets allow users, like you and me, to secure and manage all of our crypto assets and our NFTs, all with the security of storing users' private keys offline and out of rage from hackers.
The Ledger Nano X is the perfect hardware wallet for managing your crypto and NFTs on the go, because it connects your phone with Bluetooth and has a nice big screen for easy transaction readings. It also upgraded the iconic Ledger Nano S and made the new Ledger Nano S device more defy and NFT friendly, making it the perfect hardware wallet for beginners. Ledger has truly maximized for both ease of use and security, so discover which Ledger device is best suited for your journey by going and visiting shop.ledger.com. Nexto is your financial hub for all your crypto needs. Nexto lets you buy crypto instantly with your credit or debit card or via bank transfer.
They also have an awesome advanced trading platform called Nexo Pro that pays you rewards when you swap crypto assets. And nexto also lets you earn interest on your crypto in Bitcoin, ETH or other assets. And they also give you an instant crypto line of credit with as low as 0% APR. And they also give you access to a crypto backed master card of course earning you more crypto when you use it. So enhance your financial life with Nexo, who ensures all credit lines are over collateralized with insurance on all custodial assets. Nexto, the right place for your crypto. So click the link in the show notes to join over 5 million users who are getting the most out of their crypto.
Well, as we move from kind of the technical layer, I want to talk about maybe a bit more of the social layer and moving from engineering to some of the softer sciences like philosophy and maybe political science here. And I think one question that we're left with Ethereum is, okay, what is this thing that we have built so far? There is this notion, I know you're familiar with it, of the network stake. The network state, rather. And this is a concept most recently put forward by Bology. He was on the podcast as well recently. And we asked Bology, who's been long time in crypto, of course, from very beginnings.
Do you think that the network state is kind of the main thing that the crypto project is focused on? And his answer was, yes, absolutely. That's what we are doing. Money is just a subset of the network state. I'm curious your perspective on this, Vitalik, and I know you have thoughts. But let's talk about Ethereum first. Do you think Ethereum is an example of a Bology and network state or a network state of some other conceptual framework? I would say no. I think Ethereum has a very important role to play in network states. But I would say Ethereum is a bit of a higher layer thing. And the reason why I would say that is that at this point in the Ethereum community has grown very big, very diverse, very pluralist in a lot of ways.
And one of the things that that means that it sacrifices is definitely an assumption of alignment on a lot of issues that people really care about, especially on non-crypto-related topics. If you look at Bitcoin 10 years ago, or even Ethereum 8 years ago, and you asked a question of what do you think the right federal minimum wage is, or what's your view on how healthcare should be provided, or what's your perspective on immigration, or who's right in some geopolitical situation? 10 years ago, you would have gotten a lot more alignment, and I think these days you're going to get less alignment on those kinds of issues.
And I think that's an inevitable part of the ecosystem growing. And it's also a healthy thing, right? Like Glenn loves to use the phrase facilitating cooperation across difference. And to me, facilitating cooperation across differences, definitely part of what both middle blockchains and a lot of the equipment on blockchains is going to be about. One thing, probably just a very concrete example, just to kind of dive very briefly into the weeds before we dive back out of what I'm talking about, is the whole ENS-brandly situation, right? Like that was something where people within the Ethereum ecosystem who are passionate Ethereum and who have done ethnames, we know they did have very different perspectives on that situation that they care deeply about.
And I think it's a testament to if the Ethereum ecosystem and even to ENS itself, that we were able to navigate that, and even navigate like pretty close to a 50-50 split, I think, in the ENS DAO's decision of whether or not Brandly should be fired, right? Without that really turning into like a big scale, that breaks Ethereum all together. But to refresh people with the Brandly situation, Brandly had some controversial comments. What was it at the time that a subset of the Ethereum community disagreed vehemently with? And, yeah, any other light on that for folks that weren't familiar with the current event does it happen in Ethereum world?
Yeah, I mean, like, he basically has kind of traditional religious views on topics like minohomasectuality and those kinds of topics that are, I mean, definitely extremely out of step with, especially people who have a more left-wing ethos. And what was the outcome? So the outcome was that there were a lot of calls to basically fire Brandly or cancel him for various meanings of that term. And I think he did end up getting pushed out of true names, LTD, the company, but there was a vote to try to push him out of the ENS DAO, and I think that vote ended up failing. So, you know, Brandly is part of Ethereum lands, and there are people in some kind of sub-Ilands of Ethereum who do not really interact with him or once interact with him, and then there are some people who do, right?
And he did, you're right in that. He did not get kicked out of the DAO, or he did not lose a lot of his delegation, but he did kind of be removed socially. He had much less presence on Twitter, people listened to him a lot less. And so while the formal DAO did not remove his power, he did, like, kind of socially take a few, get knocked down a few rungs, if you will. So there was some sort of, like, hybrid outcome to this. Absolutely, yeah. And, I mean, the crypto space, I think, has, you know, obviously, continue to intersect with geopolitics more and more. The other big example of that was obviously the whole Ukraine situation this year.
And there, I think, I mean, I personally am not aware of, like, Ethereum community. I actually, no, maybe, yeah, maybe within the era gone team, which is Russian. There's definitely more people who have, like, takes that vehemently disagree with my position. And I mean, I guess your position on that issue, but, and there has been some even Twitter drama on that. But more and more of these do crop up and more and more of these wall crop up. But I guess my view there is that, you know, like, I have views on each one of these issues. And we have views on each one of these issues. And I don't think that, like, our role as participants in the Ethereum ecosystem should cause us to shy away from expressing our views on, on some of those topics, because, I mean, those topics are very important.
I think some of what you're saying, Vitalik, is that Ethereum is almost, like, too credibly neutral to become a Blagian network state. Like, it doesn't have strong enough opinions. It's kind of like asking the internet to become a network state. Well, what is the internet? It's a whole bunch of tribes coming together to interact. So, but, but maybe so if Ethereum itself is not a network state and can't become one, it doesn't have a social fabric that has enough, you know, coherence, I suppose, around a particular set of values other than being decentralized and being credibly neutral itself. Then, is Ethereum a substrate for spawning other network states on top of?
I think absolutely. And I think Ethereum, like, it absolutely is still a, yeah, both a substrate and a home for a lot of different sub-communities that do have these much more detailed and opinionated visions of the kind of world that they want to see. And, like, I do think that Ethereum to some extent does sort of structurally have some opinions in the sense of, like, if you're a person that really does believe in the world economic foreem vision of a casual society, then, like, there's just much less for you that Ethereum can offer, right? So I do think that, you know, there is some extent to which Ethereum as a thing has values baked into it and there are values that are shared by, like, that are much more shared by the Ethereum community than by the world as a whole, right?
But the, I think, the right level to try to make some of these more opinionated visions come to life is by things, like sub-communities that are close to Ethereum and that are even proud of their alignments with Ethereum, but they do sort of recognize their distinction from Ethereum itself and so that do sort of both give permission to people for people to still be Ethereum, but at the same time, not what, not liking their vision, and also by doing so, kind of give themselves the freedom to, like, really have these stronger moral commitments without, you know, fear of kind of offending people by speaking for Ethereum as a whole, right?
So, like, I would love to see multiple Ethereum network states, I would, I think within the network state concept, like, there is a lot of room for the, like, some kind of concept of kind of coordinating layers between network states in general, right? Like, I do think that once there are multiple network states, there are going to have some they are going to have some common interests that just have to do with the fact that they're all network states, I think there might even be value in co-locating some of them beside each other, for example, so that, you know, they can interact with each other, but without literally being part of the exact same at surf and, you know, sort of the high levels of alignment that come out of something like that.
And I think if the RMS can be part of the alignment layer, but there is probably also room for other kinds of alignment layers between the different network states as well. So, you know, and it'll be interesting, I think, you know, we'll see how that whole vision is going to evolve. I mean, I think just basically saying that network states are something that should be free to be more opinionated as something that's probably even going to just create a better world because we'll get more interesting visions that we'll try to use the concepts to be able to do more. When we talk about the world economic forum and Ethereum, we're comparing like the value systems of these two like polls, right?
But I think it's fair to say that the world economic forum is very like opinionated and it's very like political and Ethereum is designed to be this credibly neutral platform. And I think perhaps it's a fair take to say that the reason why we can't really find much room on Ethereum for the world economic forum is due to that difference, right? Like we can't really find a way to include the WEF's values on our credibly neutral social settlement layer. There's just like not room for them to appear. And so when we talk about other network states or other political systems that do find good ways to inhabit space on Ethereum, and maybe there's more than one, maybe there's a number of them.
That's true. They are able to do that because they are more aligned with the value found in Ethereum or they fit inside of it a little bit better. And so Ethereum as a system of supporting many, many network states does come to actually like proliferate its values upon the world by supporting many, many other network states that fit on top of Ethereum, that fit well inside of Ethereum's structure. And so Ethereum kind of becomes like the meta structure that allows for many, many network states to proliferate. And I think what you're saying with like co-locating network states may be both in physical territory, but also two network states that are just like very similar are also going to be able to cooperate with each other work well together and grow stronger because of that cooperation.
And so I'm wondering if like where, if you see this kind of like trajectory for things and network states being built on Ethereum where if we're going to get a proliferation of many, many network states, some of them we're going to be able to fit better than others and the ones that fit better than others are able to adapt with each other better than others. And then this is kind of this snowball that carries us into this belagian network state future that I think he is very, very hopeful for. Is that a fair take for the future? I'd say so. Yeah, I mean, I think it's, I mean, it's definitely true that some ideology is fit better into both Ethereum and the network state world than others.
I mean, the world economic forum is an interesting case, right, because like there is the world economic forum as an actual thing and then there's the world economic forum as like the thing that Twitter and Twitter mythologize it into. And I, I mean, I get, I always get the feeling that like I haven't been to the forum myself, but you know, I get talked to like people who have participated in it and like and you know, there are very diverse people and there's definitely people that like just wants to create infrastructure for schools and developing countries. But so, you know, it is a forum and ultimately a forum like internet forums are like places where discussion happens, but at the same time forums like the R Bitcoin forum, you know, they do tends to like I skew toward particular ideologies as well.
So we always, you know, there's always a balance between those two tendencies. And I mean, I think there's definitely the some aspect like the concept of globalism, right, like that, that's an interesting one. Like I don't know if you saw there was that Twitter poll I made where I basically asked people how they identify me. And one of the questions was am I a globalist and do you like globalism? And there were people who said they like globalism and I'm a globalist and there's people who say they don't like globalism and I'm not a globalist. And this is because there's like actually two different meanings of the term globalism.
Like one is this sort of, you know, cosmopolitan vibe of like someone has the same moral value of whether they're from the United States or Canada or Uganda. And, you know, I'm going to be open to treating any of those people as my brother. And then there is globalism as in one world government. And like I'm obviously a fan of the first and not a fan of the second. And I think a lot of people are fans of the first and not fans of the second. But they still, like they just disagree on the semantic question of which one of those two of the world, the word globalist belongs to. And you know, even within the world, the world economic forum, I think there's definitely people who are very ideologically inclined toward the second.
But then there's I think also people who are much more inclined toward the first and don't care about the second. And I think as a kind of global, you know, you could call it sort of alternative liberal in with you using the word liberal liberal in the lower case sense movement. There's an opportunity to try to like really split those two and to like basically show people that like some notion of a global brotherhood, you know, it doesn't actually require a global political centralization, but I think these are all fascinating things. And like obviously why why even the social science side of this crypto movement is maybe in some ways more interesting than the technology side.
But you know, you're talking about the semantics of words words like globalism and how that's changed. I also think the semantics behind words in crypto have changed. So take the word dow. That used to mean something different than what it means today. And I would even say a year ago it meant something different than it does today. You wrote a post which I read yesterday I was quite fascinated with. And the title of that post was dowels are not corporations. And I think you were responding to a new kind of concept or I guess thing that's been invoked recently, which is the idea that all dowels that we have on a theorem and other crypto networks should get their shit together a bit more should get a bit more organized should nail down a structure and should start to resemble more corporate governance.
I think you push back on that claim and you think that some dowels maybe are fit for corporate governance, but others are should be more public, should be more inspired by the political scientists and the political science that we have and maybe that's the lens of a theorem. We'll start there back to what is this thing called the theorem is a theorem a dow and like what actually are dow should they be managed corporately or are there new governance systems that were unlocking here. It's a good question. I mean, I think we haven't really even fully defines the term dow as some of the examples and that post go into right like there's this sort of vague notion among a lot of people that a dow still should be this kind of logically centralized singleton where money goes into one place and there's a global vote on every funny decision.
And that's clearly just a bad model and it's a model that probably doesn't even give people what they want out of the house. And then there's this alternative architecture that's a kind of inspired by what Ukraine Dow is doing where you have the core that makes these decisions, but then you have pods and pods have a much higher level of autonomy and that seems like something that actually really gives people more of what they want out of decentralization. So and like obviously Ukraine's that was not the only one like there's also Vida Dow, which was doing life extension research. There's all of the various dow's that are trying to like run long term pieces of infrastructure.
So you know reflex there for a rye maker for a maker Dow, Claire Rose, then optimism which we're finding in all of these things. So I hope that we're going to learn a lot from these examples. I hope that a couple of years from now, we're going to have like some much better models of what a good Dow looks like and you know, once we once we learn from them, then you know, would the yeah, Ethereum foundation be able to become a Dow based on that kind of bottle? You know, we'll see. I guess that that was one of those things that's also been a dream from close to the beginning. And then, you know, optimism, obviously, yeah, very down controlled like what other dow's we're going to see within the Ethereum ecosystem and we'll see, but it'll be interesting.
Why why why why don't dow's just all operate with the corporate governance structure? I mean, there is the argument, Vitalik that we have baked out corporate governance over the last, you know, 200 years. We've made it pretty efficient. There's a CEO, there's an executive team. There's a board of advisors. There are these governors that that keep them in check. These are called shareholders and it works pretty well like all of the products that we experience in our in our modern world were brought to you by corporation, right? Somebody on the S&P 500 went and created this. And so these these joint stock ownership companies that the corporate structure works pretty well isn't a Dow just trying to mirror that or is there something different here?
That's a good question. I think there's two arguments that I have against that line of thinking, right? Well, one of the well, I mean, actually three arguments right in the post like one of them is that some things require censorship resistance and corporations are not good at censorship resistance. And another one is that corporations are good at building products, but they're less good at providing infrastructure. Right? So like, for example, social media companies have completely failed at satisfying people's desire for some notion that like the the content decisions that they're making are fair, right?
And that's the sort of thing that Dow's might actually be better at than educational or corporate forms of corporate governance. And then a third one is this the fact that like while actually corporations are designed around the idea that they're second order organizations and they can appeal to a first order courts when something goes wrong, right? Like you can 51% attack a company, right? And like potentially 51% of the shareholders could try to vote to kick out the other 49 ones, but that is explicitly illegal. And the mechanism that enforces that is itself a, you know, the ultimately the government that enforces shareholder laws, right?
And so if we're going to build a Dow, then the Dow has to include all of that functionality that's normally provided by nation states by itself. And to, you know, corporate governance is not good at doing that, but political science like that's exactly the sort of stuff that it studies. Yeah, that's, it's definitely fascinating to see how that evolves. Maybe let's switch back to Ethereum for a minute and kind of the end game. I guess if, you know, using as simple words as possible, Vitalik, how would you describe Ethereum's end state like at the end of this long road map, the theme of this episode, I think has been what's next at the end of all of these things that we've talked about so far of what's next, what does Ethereum look like and what does it deliver for the world?
Hmm, I think well, Ethereum's ethos from the beginning, right, I think has been to insist on a few particular values, but otherwise not have its own picture of like what specific things it brings to the world, but we have that up to the ecosystem and lots of different groups to create their own vision. And I think just having a well-functioning global cryptocurrency is a huge amount of value by itself, like it's especially valuable to what people outside of the first world. And in places like Latin America, Africa, Eastern Europe, and other central Asia and other places that have a harder time with the existing financial system.
Ethereum being the substrate for dows and mechanisms that do other things. So identity is one of the biggest examples, like can we create some kind of more decentralized model of identity and really start with what some of the tools that the Ethereum ecosystem has already, whether it's accounts and hopefully soon social recovery wallets and ENS and things like popes and try to really optimize that and do what we can to build it into something that's really good at providing what people want out of an identity system. Like what would it be, being a base layer for dows in general, like, I mean, network states are, yeah, just talked about those for 10 or 15 minutes, but like what would it actually mean for Ethereum to be a base layer for things like that?
Things like proof of humanity would be, yeah, would have always been one of my favorite applications. Other kinds of censorship resistant applications, some other kinds of like credibly neutral and decentralized applications like, you know, could we actually do the whole blockchain based on social media thing and try to create social media platforms that are like more credibly neutral and fair in some way? So like I don't think there is one vision for what Ethereum could do. I think there's many different visions and I think once Ethereum manages to solve its a scaling problem is it's going to be in a much better place to help be the substrate that allows all of those visions to happen.
Arbitram 1 is pioneering the world of secure Ethereum scalability and is continuing to accelerate the Web 3 landscape. Hundreds of projects have already deployed on Arbitram 1 producing flourishing, DeFi and NFT ecosystems. With a recent addition of Arbitram Nova, gaming and social apps like Reddit are also now calling Arbitram Home. Both Arbitram 1 and Nova leverage the security and decentralization of Ethereum and provide a builder experience that's intuitive, familiar and fully EVM compatible. On Arbitram both builders and users will experience faster transaction speeds with significantly lower gas fees.
With Arbitram's recent migration to Arbitram Nitro, it's also now 10 times faster than before. Visit Arbitram.io where you can join the community, dive into the developer docs, bridge your assets and start building your first app. With Arbitram, experience Web 3 development the way it was meant to be, secure, fast, cheap and friction-free. The Brave Wallet is your secure, multi-chain on-ramp into Web 3 and is built directly into the Brave privacy browser. Gone are the days of managing multiple wallet extensions that put you at risk of phishing, spooch, and tracking. With the Brave Wallet, you can securely manage your crypto assets across more than 100 different chains, including Ethereum, Layer 2, Solana, and more, all without downloading risky extensions.
The Brave Wallet is easy to set up and removes the headache of jumping between wallets and extensions. It's lightweight but packed with great features like built-in token swaps, buying and holding NFTs with a gallery view, and support for hardware wallets. But also much more than that, because Brave is shipping new features every single month, with a mission to make Web 3 easier to navigate for its over 55 million users. Wall extensions are the thing in the past. So get started with Brave's Web 3 ready browser today and experience a decentralized web seamlessly without all the clutter. Download the browser at brave.
com slash bankless and click the Wallet icon to get started. The Layer 2 era is upon us. Ethereum's Layer 2 ecosystem is growing every day and we need Layer 2 bridges to be fast and efficient in order to live in Layer 2 life. A cross is the fastest, cheapest, and most secure cross-chain bridge. With a cross, you don't have to worry about high fees or long-waid times assets are bridge and available for use almost instantaneously. A cross's bridges are powered by UMA's optimistic oracle to securely transfer tokens between Layer 2's and Ethereum. This is critical ecosystem infrastructure and across V2 has just launched.
Their new version focuses on higher capital efficiency, Layer 2 to Layer 2 transfers, and a brand new chain with Polygon all while prioritizing high security and low fees. You can be a part of a cross's story by joining their discord and using a cross for all of your Layer 2 transferring needs. So go to across.to to quickly and securely bridge your assets between Ethereum, Optimism, Polygon, Arbitrum, or Boba Networks. I love that part of the answer to the question of what's next for Ethereum is question work. We don't actually know. It's up to you. What's on the other side? It's like a two-year-old adventure.
Vitalik, before we close this out, finally, Danny Ryan came on the podcast earlier this week and he told us that you had some thoughts on AI, artificial intelligence that is Vitalik. Do you have any hot takes on AI? Are you worried about... Since we're on the topic of what's next. Are you worried about AI and society? Are AI's next-essential threat to humanity? Do you see any intersection with crypto? Give us any hot takes. What I really want to know out of this is AI's are not going to have bank accounts, but AI's can totally manage private keys. What intersection does this apply? Did we just create a substrate for AI's to gain control over the human race?
It's over now. Yeah. When I was visiting the Bay Area as part of my trip to SPC, I also visited and talked to a bunch of various AI people, like people from Anthropic and OpenAI and some of the big AI firms and just general AI boosters in this space. I was surprised by the fast timelines that a lot of them have. Like going in, I think my timelines were more that we're going to get something like the singularity by sometime around 2075, and when I gave this a number to people, they're like, oh, wow, you're crazy. How can you possibly think AI's going to be that slow? Wow. A lot of them are literally expecting human level AI before the end of this decade and the singularity.
Yeah. I mean, these are obviously inside of us and my default instinct is to be a skeptical, but I think it's important that's the question of like, well, what if they're right and what if over the next decade or two AI basically ends up eating the world? And then the question that we have to think about is like, what is the role that crypto has to play in an AI-dominated world, right? Like, you know, our structure is that kind of insist on the idea that humans are the only kind of significant actor in the space, like are those going to survive an AI transition? Like what would an AI even look like?
Could crypto be a part of somehow democratically governing the AI's that come out? Would crypto be something that could help coordinate like some alternative AI projects so that the whole AI transition doesn't lead to just massive centralization in one or two companies? I mean, I don't know, but I think it's important for anyone to be thinking about the future of crypto as a space to also have the question in mind of how does AI play into this and what would a young merger of, well, not a merger, but what would the interplay between crypto and AI look like? I don't yet perfectly know the answer to this question, but I just think it's a really important question that we need to be very serious in thinking about.
Do you have any thoughts on like AI ethics and making sure that we embed, you know, human-oriented ethics into AI as very early so that we don't get an advanced general intelligence that kind of runs away from us? I mean, Nick Bolster has talked about this in his books, Elon Musk, and others wondering if you've looked at that angle of things. It's a very good question. So actually, the people in the Bay Area that have fast timelines, they're also more optimistic about AI safety and an AI alignment than they have been before. The way to explain the reason why is because a lot of the very doom and gloomy AI alignment theory, it basically implicitly assumes that AI's would be grown by essentially playing real-time strategy games against each other.
Right, like if you think of something like Alpha Zero was grown, right? You know, it's able to learn to play a game by playing against itself billions of times, and then it just becomes really good to go, and you just like take that model and you translate it to optimizing it, manipulating the natural world as a whole. And with that kind of a growth path, it's easy to see why that AI would be totally just unaware of and not able to be aligned with human values, right? Because the AI grew and developed its patterns of thinking without any interaction with humans. The AI's path to becoming intelligent would not even be the same path that humans don't wear.
There's this complicated interplay of cooperation and competition, and there's even a big argument to be made that human intelligence basically evolved as a result of by humans having to play political games against each other, right? And AI's would just be a completely different concept. And so, or there would be born and raised in a completely different way, right? And so maybe the whole, like would the AI just turn the universe into paper, collapse to be able to calculate a little faster thing here is like a really excellent question to ask. But the AI's that we're seeing today, they're AI's that are grown by basically learning patterns of human behavior.
And it's basically repeatedly attempting to pattern match the situation that they're in to the human behavior that's been repeated the greatest number of times in a context that's similar to that pattern. And so the AI's that emerged out of that kind of learning process just are going to be AI's that are sort of more naturally human by default. It also means that we're going to have slower take-off because like there is a natural divide between being able to get to human-level intelligence and surpassing it. Because human-level intelligence, like you can get to human-level intelligence if you're just a really good pattern matching engine that learns from all the humans.
But moving beyond human-level intelligence requires you to like actually come up with things yourself. So it's still a step higher, basically, right? So we have more time. The AI's are more likely to be human-like. We're more likely to see multiple AI's instead of one single AI dominating everything. So all of those things paint a more optimistic picture. And also the work that's been happening in AI alignment now, like it's less theoretical and it's more practical. Like it's trying to say, how do we take the AI's that we're building today? And how do we try to make them be as aligned as possible?
And that's a path that seems to be like, so are we starting to make more headway? So I mean, obviously, we still have very big problems. I think very big problems from the risk of the AI's that take over being unaligned. And I would say also a political centralization risk from bad versions of AI alignment theory being used to justify an idea that AI risk means that AI's have to be in a lab. We're only a couple of large corporations run by self-appointed ethical hyperists should be the only ones that have access to the capabilities. And if people who build the most powerful AI's end up having that kind of mindset, then what would that mean for the political structure of the world?
That's kind of like a secondary AI risk that I think is also worth thinking about, especially in the near term, because the AI's that we have today, they're more than a decade away from paper-collipping risk. But if we enter a world where the US and Chinese governments can make deepfix, but no one else can, then in some ways that's worse than a world where everyone can make deepfix, because it just gives, it just sort of unbalances the balance of power toward two particular organizations. So I think that stuff is also stuff that's probably worth thinking about, and it's definitely been more on my mind than it has been six months ago, but we'll see.
That's interesting. I'm wondering if you vibe it all with Peter Teals' take, where AI is kind of a centralizing technology, whereas crypto is a technology of decentralization, and almost like a defense of a bulwark against the centralizing functions of AI. Does anything in that idea resonate with you? I mean, that's an idea that I've repeated myself multiple times, right? I think the question is like, how do we take that from sort of the world of theory and the world of abstractly thinking about AI and crypto as sort of ideologies for the world and into the young question of like, well, what concretely can crypto do to try to mitigate the chance that AI leads to centralizing everything?
Which is faster or further along in its roadmap? Ethereum or generalized AI? That's a good question. It depends on how far you like how far you want to go. I do still expect that we are going to get Ethereum fully finishing its vision before we'll get to a human-level AI, but even close to human-level AI, that's going to start to make our world look very different. This is a fantastic bear market content for us on the AI side of things. I think actually we want to explore this a bit further. I'm curious from your perspective, is there anyone in the AI field that we should be talking to on bankless is we're looking at this I will think about this and if I find names, I will send them to you.
Fantastic. Beautiful. Metallic. It has been a pleasure talking to you about what is next for Ethereum. We didn't say that at the outset, but congratulations to you, to us, the entire Ethereum community for this major milestone and getting to this point. Congratulations to you too. It's all been a great journey. Bankless Nation. We've got some action items for you. Lots in the show notes today. Number one is Proof of Stake, which is the book that Metallic has come out with. This is, I think, Metallic, I correct me if I'm wrong, but a lot of your blog posts only in book form, which makes it more accessible for people.
Is that correct? Yes. Also some links to the posts that we talked about today, the paths to single slot finality, Dows are not corporations on Vitalik's website, and what does Vitalik think about network states will also include a link to the MEV boost website, where you can see all of the builders and relayers in production as always got to end with risks and disclaimers. Crypto is risky. Luna is risky. Luna is extremely risky, but to be honest, Ethereum is risky too. You could lose what you put in, but we're headed west. This is the frontier. This technically, it's the London hard fork, but it's still the frontier.
It's not for everyone, but we're glad you're with us on the bank. This bank was journey. Thanks a lot. Hey, we hope you enjoyed the video. If you did, head over to bankless HQ right now to develop your crypto investing skills and learn how to free yourself from banks and gain your financial independence. We recommend joining our daily newsletter, podcast, and community as a bankless premium subscriber to get the most out of your bankless experience. You'll get access to our market analysis, our alpha leaks, and exclusive content, and even the bankless token for airdrops, raffles, and unlocks.
If you're interested in crypto, the bankless community is where you want to be. Click the link in the description to become a bankless premium subscriber today. Also, don't forget to subscribe to the channel for in-depth interviews with industry leaders, ask me any things and weekly rollups where we summarize the week in crypto and other fantastic content. Thanks everyone for watching and being on the journey as we build out the bankless nation.