✨ DEBRIEF | Unpacking the Episode: https://shows.banklesshq.com/p/the-cosmos-thesis-debrief
Sunny Agarwal and Zaki Manian are crypto OGs that have been in the Cosmos ecosystem and community from the very beginning. Sunny started the Blockchain at Berkeley, the largest student organization for crypto in the world, and also co-hosts the Epicenter podcast. Zaki is helping ship Cosmos’s IBC, is working on the validator ecosystem, and is also an advisor to the Electric Coin Company, the org behind Zcash and is also a co-founder of Iqlusion.
On today’s episode, Sunny and Zaki share what the Cosmos Thesis is, how Cosmos is similar and different to Ethereum, and what Cosmos’s ATOM 2.0 unlocks for the ecosystem.
Zero to 60 in one episode. This is the Cosmos Thesis.
------ 📣 Galxe | Explore Crypto’s #1 Credential Network https://bankless.cc/Galxe
------ 🚀 SUBSCRIBE TO NEWSLETTER: https://newsletter.banklesshq.com/ 🎙️ SUBSCRIBE TO PODCAST: http://podcast.banklesshq.com/
------ BANKLESS SPONSOR TOOLS:
⚖️ ARBITRUM | SCALING ETHEREUM https://bankless.cc/Arbitrum
❎ ACROSS | BRIDGE TO LAYER 2 https://bankless.cc/Across
🦁 BRAVE | THE BROWSER NATIVE WALLET https://bankless.cc/Brave
💠 NEXO | CRYPTO FINANCIAL HUB https://bankless.cc/Nexo
🔐 LEDGER | NANO HARDWARE WALLETS https://bankless.cc/Ledger
⚡️FUEL | THE MODULAR EXECUTION LAYER https://bankless.cc/Fuelpod
----- Topics Covered
0:00 Intro 8:05 Zaki & Sunny 10:08 The Cosmosverse Conference 18:38 Cosmos’s Central Thesis 23:10 Metaphors & Ethereum vs. Cosmos 29:18 Trade-offs 36:13 Monetary Premium Thoughts 40:18 Osmosis & Power Laws 48:24 Stablecoins on Cosmos 54:13 L2s vs. Cosmos 1:09:11 Cosmos vs. Polkadot 1:14:52 MEV Problems & Solutions 1:23:24 ATOM 2.0 1:32:16 Mesh & Interchain Security 1:41:50 Does ATOM Break Top 10 Tokens? 1:43:43 Will ATOM Flip ETH? 1:44:50 The Future of Cosmos 1:49:03 How to Explore Cosmos 1:50:44 Closing & Disclosures
------ Resources:
Sunny Aggarwal https://twitter.com/sunnya97 Zaki Manian https://twitter.com/zmanian ATOM 2.0 https://forum.cosmos.network/t/proposal-draft-a-new-vision-for-cosmos-hub/7328 The Inevitability of UNIchain https://medium.com/nascent-xyz/the-inevitability-of-unichain-bc600c92c5c4
----- Not financial or tax advice. This channel is strictly educational and is not investment advice or a solicitation to buy or sell any assets or to make any financial decisions. This video is not tax advice. Talk to your accountant. Do your own research.
Disclosure. From time-to-time I may add links in this newsletter to products I use. I may receive commission if you make a purchase through one of these links. Additionally, the Bankless writers hold crypto assets. See our investment disclosures here: https://newsletter.banklesshq.com/p/bankless-disclosures
No summary for this episode yet.
Digital markets in the future will be all markets and I'm building for a future in which digital markets are open source public goods I don't really care about anything else I just view the tools we've built as Cosmos as an essential part of getting there I also think Ethereum largely shares this vision and so feel very aligned with Ethereum But like if we're successful we will have open source digital markets that provide economic coordination for the entire human race Welcome to Bankless where we explore the frontier of internet money and internet finance This is how to get started, how to get better, how to front and run the opportunity This is Ryan Chong Adams, I'm here with David Hoffman and we're here to help you become more bankless Today we are going to explore the Cosmos together This is the Cosmos thesis we brought on Zaki and Sunny We're developers, app developers and long time Cosmos community members to talk about the Cosmos thesis This I think will give you a zero to 60 on Cosmos in 90 minutes I think it's a canonical episode for this community for this ecosystem In fact the guests said as they were leaving this is probably the best Cosmos episode they've ever recorded You remember that?
Maybe the judge after this episode a few things to look out for Number one we talk about the Cosmos thesis itself How it's similar versus how it's different to Ethereum Number two we talk about Ethereum as a tree versus Cosmos as a fungus If that makes no sense to you now, listen to the episode and you'll see what we mean The difference between the fat protocol thesis and the tall app thesis That's another distinction we make And Adam 2.0, a new white paper was just released with new token economics And a whole new Cosmos hub design We talk about the new features and differences in that design We also ask Zaki and Sunny if they think atoms could one day flip ether In terms of total crypto market cap David, there's so much we unpacked in this episode Why are we talking about it?
Cosmos that is and what should listeners look out for as they listen? The Cosmos ecosystem, the Cosmos community, the Cosmos philosophy has always paired nicely with Ethereum While also being different I remember reading the Cosmos white paper in 2018 and really having like an aha moment Like, yo, this is something real that's new And it was specifically about cross chain interoperability And even when I was talking to Sunny at ETC forever ago He said like the Cosmos and Ethereum communities have always been very philosophically aligned And I think when we get into this episode the listeners should really pay attention to The, I think the accepted truth that Cosmos and Ethereum converge At their logical conclusion in their design philosophy at the same place They both believe in the same general outcome of how these ecosystems look like But what they're where they differ is how they get there And the how they get there the Genesis stories for these changes does impact what these things ultimately look like Cosmos started its journey as a network of interconnected sovereign application Chains that weave themselves together later adding a shared security model Ethereum started its journey with the central security model of ether, proof of work A canonical single monolithic chain folding into now the beacon chain And then many chains organize around it We have the app chain model in Cosmos, we have the layer three model in Ethereum We're each going after the same design structures So the listeners should really pay attention to what are the net consequences of a system that emphasized the security first Which is Ethereum and ether the asset first which is Ethereum versus an ecosystem that emphasized the sovereign app chain model first And then added security later what are the net effects of that?
Overall, I'm just, we've used this metaphor in bank listen I used this I've used this in the podcast that if you reroll the dice of the crypto industry over and over and over again You will see something like Ethereum unfold out of that 100% of the time 99.9% of the time And I think that's also true for Cosmos And that is why I think this Cosmos and Ethereum is like two sides of the same coin We will always see these two models and I don't and I think these two models the app chain model The central security model of Ethereum That is what crypto has to offer These are the logical conclusions of crypto design philosophy in my opinion So I think with that context I think the listeners should be pretty well equipped to go into this episode and get completely downloaded as to the whole Cosmos vision The other thing of course to think about as you're listening this episode is where the investment opportunities in Cosmos And David I think I want to talk to you a little bit about that some my thoughts on investment opportunities But we'll save that for the debrief and of course the debrief is available for you who are premium members It's our episode after the episode where we talk about the episode that was So upgrade to premium membership if you want to catch that as well full disclosure going in I own Adam tokens.
It does not represent more than 5% of my holdings We take disclosures very seriously at bankless so we're starting to mention them at the top of every episode There's always a link in the show notes if you want access to see all of our bags Our full disclosures are located there guys we're going to get right to the episode with Zaki and Sunny from Cosmos But before we do we want to thank the sponsors that made this episode possible Arbitram 1 is pioneering the world of secure Ethereum scalability and is continuing to accelerate the Web 3 landscape Hundreds of projects have already deployed on Arbitram 1 producing flourishing DeFi and NFT ecosystems With a recent addition of Arbitram Nova gaming and social apps like Reddit are also now calling Arbitram home Both Arbitram 1 and Nova leverage the security and decentralization of Ethereum and provide a builder experience that's intuitive, familiar and fully EV and compatible On Arbitram both builders and users will experience faster transaction speeds with significantly lower gas fees With Arbitram's recent migration to Arbitram Nitro it's also now 10 times faster than before Visit Arbitram.
io where you can join the community, dive into the developer docs, bridge your assets and start building your first app With Arbitram, experience Web 3 development the way it was meant to be, secure, fast, cheap and friction-free The Layer 2 era is upon us Ethereum's Layer 2 ecosystem is growing every day and we need Layer 2 bridges to be fast and efficient in order to live in Layer 2 life Across is the fastest, cheapest and most secure cross-chain bridge With across you don't have to worry about high fees or long-weight times Assets are bridge and available for use almost instantaneously Across's bridges are powered by UMA's optimistic Oracle to securely transfer tokens between Layer 2's and Ethereum Across is critical ecosystem infrastructure and across V2 has just launched Their new version focuses on higher capital efficiency Layer 2 to Layer 2 transfers and a brand new chain with Polygon all while prioritizing high security and low fees You can be a part of a cross's story by joining their discord and using across for all of your Layer 2 transferring needs So go to across.
io to quickly and securely bridge your assets between Ethereum, Optimism, Polygon, Arbitram or Boba Networks If you've been listening to Bankless you know that we're fans of the modular blockchain thesis The idea that blockchains will separate execution from data availability and consensus, allowing all three to become the best versions of themselves And Fuel has built the fastest modular execution layer in the industry By supporting parallel transaction execution, Fuel unlocks significantly faster throughput for the web free world Fuel also goes beyond the limitations of the EVM with its own Fuel VM, which is more efficient and optimized Opening up the design space for developers and lastly Fuel brings a powerful developer experience With its own domain specific language sway and a supportive tool chain called fork With Fuel you can have the benefits of smart contract languages like Solidity while adopting the improvements made by the rest tooling ecosystem Letting the Fuel development environment go beyond the limitations of the EVM If you want to learn more there's a link in the show notes to see how you can get involved with a Fuel Network Bankless Nation we are talking Cosmos today with two of the best experts we could find in the space Sunny Agarwal is a crypto OG.
He's been in the Cosmos ecosystem since the very early days in the community Since the very beginning, he's a man of many hats, he's been all around the space He started the blockchain at Berkeley, a student club, this was the largest student organization for the crypto world at the time And he's also the co-host of the epicenter podcast, Sunny how you doing? I'm doing great, you know just got off of three days of Cosmoverse which is the big causes conference and so in decompression mode right now I understand that both of you guys are recovering from Cosmosverse so hopefully we'll get some of that energy back into this podcast As we go through we also have Zaki Manian, he also wears many hats in the Cosmos and crypto space He's been in the Cosmos ecosystem from the very beginning as well, he helped ship most recently Cosmos's IBC which is an interchain blockchain protocol He's also working on the validator ecosystem, he's been an advisor to the electric coin company You remember Zoku and Zuko and Zekash and he is a co-founder of a staking provider as well Zaki, welcome to Bankless, how you doing?
I'm doing great, Cosmoverse was the best but I'm glad that I flew out of Columbia I was like do I stay in Columbia for DevCon and then I'm so tired I was like I'm gonna leave So this was in Columbia back? Yeah, we did it in many in Columbia Nice, you know Columbia is getting a lot of love this year from the crypto community with DevCon From the crypto community for sure There's actually a Bitcoin cafe like a crypto cafe in Medellin that we got to do some events at I think Bogota is going to be very different but from the experience of Medellin ended up being phenomenal So how was the conference for people that weren't able to attend and also people that are wondering what the Temperature is during the bear market, what was the energy like, what was the vitality like, how many people were there?
Fill us in on what the Cosmosverse conference was like I don't think you could tell that it was a bear market We had like so you know we had this is the second Cosmoverse we had the first one was last year in Lisbon It was like Sandwich in between like Eat Lisbon and the Salona conference and I think there were maybe like 500 or so people there At Cosmoverse this year I think there was about 1500 people so it's like three times bigger while we're in a bear market And like you know last time there was a lot of like overflow traffic coming from the other places It's like here it's like everyone who came here like came for Cosmoverse right and like so yeah it just like shows how much like There's a lot of excitement and like growth and lossy one year even And a little harder to get to than Lisbon Yeah definitely Yeah you couldn't get there you couldn't you know you weren't already there for other stuff or is like yeah I'd say a third or more people were just like okay I'm in town for a for break point and for near con I might as well to Cosmoverse too That was kind of the you know it was all I also like just like again the origin of this conference is like very typical of Cosmos It is like a person named Cryptocito sort of he's a youtuber has a relatively popular YouTube channel about crypto He got interested in Cosmos in early 2021 he started to build up a following in the community Jack Zamplin who is my co-founder another one of my projects called Somalia Finance has another validator business and I was also like a core dev in the ecosystem So Jack and I had been kind of looking for people to help us bring the message of Cosmos to the world And we found that you know Cryptocito was doing a really good job We ended up spot we had taken up there was a marketing Dow that was set up called prop 34 that took money from the Cosmos hub treasury We ended up spending what was remaining in that to sponsor and like give Cryptocito the funds to do Lisbon This time it was like multiple chains so it was the same person now You know held this much larger conference in a much more difficult location he had a staff like 150 people working on it It was sponsored directly from governance proposals for multiple Cosmos chains And you know 1,600 people could throw up there were there were after parties and events every night it did not feel like a bear market at all And people I think and then like the other thing that was really unique about this is there's literally never been a Cosmos conference where anything was announced like really The little chains would announce stuff like ecosystem level announcements had never happened before at a conference And we actually were able to do both the Adam 2.
0 white paper and the announcement of USDC coming natively to Cosmos at our conference David I remember like we talked about at ETC you know I was saying like ETC when we had an interview there I said ETC is my favorite conference And part of it is because you know I don't know I just always feel that ETC has a very community It's the fact that it's a community organized conference rather than foundation organized conference It always had like a more interesting Energy to it to me than even DevCon I like ETC better than DevCon and like every other ecosystem It's always like foundation conferences right Cosmos feels very much like ETC for the same reason It's not a foundation thrown conference it is like friend community member decided to do this Yeah and it's very emblematic of what Cosmos actually is which is a little bit more bottom up than top down orchestrated And so what would you credit the success of this conference while the Cosmosverse was harder to get to in a different part of the world Three times as many people showed up while crypto prices have gone in one third Right so you know one third the amount of capital in the space yet three times the amount of people showed up Where's all this energy in Cosmos coming from what would you guys credit the the vitality the source of vitality here I mean Cosmos has an ecosystem has just grown a lot I think especially you know in the last three or four months I think I think the dy dx sort of announcement of like switching over to Cosmos You know I know the Zocchi was pretty involved with that I think just got a lot of people's attention where you know it's and people like wait Here's this like project that's like been building on a theorem for forever And like you know why did they suddenly decide to like you know make this sort of switch right And so people start to look into like on looking at the reasons that why like dy dx did it and started loading more about you know So the Cosmos thesis is very complex and you know it's like you know when you're switching from a theorem to I don't know avalanche Oh okay cool it's faster yeah it's like no but like you know when you're switching to Cosmos there's like a whole set of like Fundamentally different things that we're doing that like and people took one with the dy dx announcement people started to actually look into that I think a lot of people just got very interested in the feces that we have at Cosmos and that kind of just like snowball like from there over the last few months Before we break down I think the thesis and how this is like really complicated idea of how we're different from a theorem And how we're basically different from the blockchains that most people are probably familiar with The I'll also say it was just like you know we are also basically like what four or five months out from the Terra collapse And Luna was built on top of the Cosmos technology stack it was part of Cosmos it was connected to IVC The anchor carry trade passed through both the Cosmos hub and osmosis in a very large way so we were very economically connected to it It's collapse was almost felt like felt like was a devastating blow to the ecosystem You know almost everybody lost money it was like it was a huge thing And you know and I don't know you know we can we it's certainly if we want to talk about you know how we all feel about the whole UST story But it was it did feel like there was a moment at which there was a bottom there where we kind of felt like you know it was like unclear whether or not Cosmos It was really going to how long it was going to take us to recover And the recovery happened like far more quickly than anyone anticipated And like you know it basically I got I got so much busier in like maybe like two weeks after the Terra collapse And it's just like not slowed down like at all since then Yeah that's really interesting you're right this is this is not long after the Terra collapse Would you guys believe that was just like less than five months ago when that whole thing imploded It's been it's been a wild five months for us Yeah I bet and there's definitely a lot of excitement One thing I you know I've been observing of course in the Cosmos ecosystem is the amount of building that's going on There's also this kind of renewed interest maybe through dydx and others but even in the Ethereum community around app chains Which I'm sure we'll talk about a little bit more And really I think our goal for this episode is you know Dave and I cover a lot in the kind of the Ethereum ecosystem on the podcast So you guys have to teach to Ethereum idiots like what Cosmos is what it's all about I'll say I was involved in the Cosmos ecosystem in the early days and so it's always been a community that's been kind of I've been observing And I've liked and I've appreciated kind of the efforts of but you guys have come a long way as well Cosmos the idea has come a long way and we want to talk about that trajectory I think we also want to talk a little bit about the Terra Luna collapse but let's save that maybe until a little bit later So first let's talk Cosmos the idea and David said this to me before we recorded That you told him sunny Cosmos has been called an idea more than an actual thing Those are your words I think sunny Cosmos being a thing isn't a thing it's more of an idea What do you mean by that?
What is the idea of Cosmos was the central thesis? Sure the central thesis of Cosmos was that you know we are going to see a world of not a few blockchains But many many blockchains most of them being application specific blockchains or appchains And that these block and there's no such thing as a single final settlement layer In the real world there is no final settlement layer We're going to have many many settlement layers and they you know every blockchain is going to be the settlement layer for its own native assets And its own native state and that's what gives it fundamentally sovereignty Role ups and other you know systems they don't have true sovereignty from from the main chain right the main chain is what finally dictates what the spine It's the final arbiter of truth in you know this globalized system while Cosmos is a very you know we're all like localists basically We believe that like hey we're not trying to build the world computer as Ethan Buckman puts it he we're trying to build community computers and let these community computers all talk to each other So yeah that's I know exactly you want to add anything to that?
All I will say is so there's another thing though the sunny and though like the Cosmos thesis really believes which is you know So one of the things we say is that like Cosmos is coming to kill your fat protocol thesis So the fat protocol thesis is that like the way that blockchains will crew value is that you'll build a blockchain it'll you know typically a protocol with the token that token will have a bunch of apps on top of it But because the the infrastructure where in the network affects around it are represented by the token that's where the most valuable crew And the Cosmos thesis has been from the get go that the where the value accrual layer is is the app layer that the like it's the application layer that is the thing that and that the thing that is closest to the users It's the it's the application where we're intent and order flow and everything originates and that's the layer of the system where the value will accrue And we basically purpose built a blockchain stack for people to build the best possible app layers rather than thinking that like hey I built another fat protocol What an analogy that I like to pull to is like you know if you were in the early web in you know in the 1990s you know a lot of people were thinking that the way to bet on the web was a well and copy serve but now with like retrospect we know it was Google and Amazon right the apps are what were sticky and actually had user relationships and the infrastructure layers You know really actually what ended up actually was the biggest acts actually ended up building their own infertile and became actually the biggest infert providers as well they were like AWS but really it is the app developers are the ones who like you know they'll move between infrastructure providers but users are sticky to the applications.
So we want to we want to leave that out there so one ideally you're presenting is rather than fat protocol fat app thesis that be a way to summarize what you just said cosmos is fat app I actually like this term called tall apps because one of the things at least with osmosis what we really believe in is like vertical integration so like you know we build our front end we build our decks modules but we build the chain itself and we just happen to build like the primary wallet for the causes ecosystem. As well but we have this like you know the what we what we actually take a lot of inspiration from is like Apple which is like a very vertically integrated system but that like gives them I think the best UX of any like any product line right and so you know I call these the tall apps right for highly vertically integrated.
So just to put a visual a metaphor on this whole thing Ethereum as like it's got this one canonical layer one and then we have a proliferation of layer two's there's like five or six real big ones and then like now right now is like a big conversation going on in the Ethereum space was layer three's and this kind of looks like a tree there's like a big central tree trunk. There are like four or five smaller branches but still pretty big that come out of this tree trunk and then they fracture off into like thousands and thousands of smaller branches and twigs that eventually turn into leaves and maybe these leaves can be like the applications that you know capture the energy of the sun for example but it all it all collapses down to a central point a central trunk and that was really the Ethereum beacon chain and each taking at the very very bottom of this whole thing.
The cosmos model is a little more of a of a mesh network I kind of want to say a spider web but even a spider web has kind of like a center point but it still kind of looks like a more flat there's not actually a point in the middle and these things weave together as like a actual metaphor is or like the correct analogy is like a fungus. My cereal network that like pervade the like forests and the earth and do make it so that the trees can actually live right yes that's it that's yeah you have definitely use this metaphor but much better than I have but that's definitely right it's Google searching my cereal network for those that don't have an image in their head as a result of that will definitely help.
And so and so the idea here is that like is it and the cool thing about the my cereal networks is that they're just like res automatically resilient because there is no central focal point can you guys kind of just like lean into this metaphor and help me unpack it a little bit more. So I think one of the big things that we've really believed in in cosmos is that like we do think that like the if there is like a core difference of a vision let's say between like sunny and I and Vitalik is this idea that like. So like we we think and like these I'll try and like quickly unpack the argument like we're like my perception of Vitalik's views and our perception of our views which is okay like Vitalik's view is like monetary premiums are really hard but it's really hard to build like a secure decentralized censorship resistance system without securing it using a monetary perimeter so you have this thing with where you have the the root monetary premium chain which is the beacon.
And then everything descends from that monetary premium chain is secured by the and like reinforces with that monetary premium chain. You know sunny at cosmic versus presented this idea of mesh security where cosmos chains actually off into additional slashing conditions around each other we believe in like ad hoc economic networks forming so so you know. The you know to you know you have these like natural natural trade routes of which the you know USD carry trade was one of them but like you have trade routes between Adam Moses you have a number of large crypto exchanges run their own cosmos changes, including OK X and crypto calm.
So they knew of trade routes between their user bases and other cosmos chains and you see this like at what we are sort of expecting is this like network of value to form between these community computers and if and like some of the ideas that we're exploring now and are sort of in their in our in our vision of the future is to make sure that security and economic security can travel with economic interdependence. But you don't need this like root structure yeah the like an example of this what what it would be chains provide bilateral security agreements with each other so in this option model people have always asked like oh how are you going to get enough security on every individual app chain.
The analogy I like to give it you know I like geopolitical analogies and so for me the example is NATO NATO is a collective of sovereign countries they all have their own governance systems they don't metal in each other's internal politics but they have a security. Security a mesh security system right they if article five says that if any one of the NATO countries gets attacked they all rush to each other's defense and I think the same thing happened will happen with cosmos chains as well and it will be based a lot off what I think what Zaki's point was it will be based a lot off of economic relationships so if you look at so I'll give an example of osmosis and axlar so axlar is you know currently the most popular bridge between you know the area man the cosmos ecosystem.
Osmosis is a deck we osmosis makes up about 70% of axlar's TVL right now while four of the top 10 assets on osmosis are EWBC die in USDC are coming via the axlar bridge so it's like hey we have such high economic relationship with each other. It would suck a lot for osmosis if axlar got like attack if it's like for axlar osmosis got attacked we should be both providing shared security to each other basically right osmo holders should be putting up economic stake backing axlar value as well axlar value axel. So basically by these two systems doing that security with each other they actually have the economic value of both of the market caps combined securing each chain and you can imagine that this scales with more and more chains you know we'll have a network of five chains 10 chains and all the some value of all of the app chains it's going to be you know in this you know it will provide greater or equal security that to like these L1's.
Can we talk about the trade off here which is a trade off I think cosmos has made from the very early days in zaki just alluded to it and sunny I think you also alluded to it and your answer which is sacrificing monetary premium essentially saying that the token at the bottom of a layer one chain does not need to and perhaps should be designed not to a crew monitor. So coming from maybe kind of the Bitcoin space and also now the the Ethereum space obviously for Bitcoin monetary premium is the thing that is the app of Bitcoin right and Ethereum I think the community has most recently more recently adopted monetary premium as part of its security defense force and when we've had Justin Drake and others on the podcast is kind of like maybe less the fat protocol thesis and more kind of the fat money thesis which is the idea that if you can create monetary premium in your base layer asset you essentially get like free security it's like mimetic security for your entire network for the entire tree trunk and all of the chains that are built on top.
And so why not number one and then also secondly how can other layer ones compete against essentially free security gets a chain and an ecosystem with monetary premium. And this is something I think Adams has you know cosmos and Adams being the token of the cosmos hub at least which is just one hub in the mesh network of course is not the thing the cosmos universe is much larger than just one hub but in the in the cosmos hub design it's been kind of sacrifice idea of Adams is not to a crew of monetary premium but it seems like you're giving that up what about this trade off sunny what do you think.
So so about the you know getting the free economic security I actually think that the best security is actually a non rent extractive way of getting free economic security when you're building on top of an L one that has this monetary premium there is actually some you know rent that's being extracted whether it's like you know being forced to pay transaction fees and that token or giving the M.E.V. value to that to that base layer or well with the app chain system you don't and you don't. We use economic relationships to you know natural naturally forming economic relationships to provide that security basis now to your other to the question about like so this might anger some of your listeners but you know I remember I had a tweet a little while ago saying that like hot take the cosmos ecosystem is a bunch of undercover coin Maxi's and I know you replied to that like yes I realized this two years ago.
And for me I actually started building working on cosmos because I wanted to build the app layer for Bitcoin I saw you know I was in I was working on a theorem stuff for a while I saw you know I was at consensus for a little bit and to me the I don't know the monolithic world and model that makes sense and I was like okay wait a second Bitcoin is an app chain maybe we just need to kind of build more app chains and have everything. You know we can build up the app layer for Bitcoin Bitcoin will just remain this simple chain and its only purpose is to you know control the issuance of the Bitcoin system and then Bitcoin will flow off of the Bitcoin BTC will flow off of the Bitcoin chain and be be the main money of the entire cosmos network that we're building you know I guess I'm a little bit less of a Bitcoin Max monetary Maxi as I used to be but you know I'm still you know I would I definitely put myself more in that.
You dabble. Yeah I dabble I don't and but here's there's actually a new project that like kind of came out of hiding a little bit at Cosmoverse which I'm really excited about it's called dabble on it's actually a way of using Bitcoin's like monetary premium security layer to provide security to all the cosmos chains and any proof of stake chain. So what it is is it's a way of checkpointing proof of stake block headers into Bitcoin's proof of work system and you you know augmenting proof of stake security with the proof of work security of Bitcoin and you know you kind of actually get a lot of cool benefits with this you get like you know proof of stake really secure and short time frames fast quality all that not be secure in long time frame to pull long range attacks and all this kind of stuff proof of work not very secure in the short time frames really secure in long time frames and if you actually overlay these systems together you actually get a little bit of the best of both worlds and so I don't know I think Babylon is actually in a little way like bring back that idea of like using the base monetary premium chain and having it provide security to all these chains as well but in this sort of like mesh network paradigm you know it's not it's an auction system it's changed that want to use Babylon can it's not a like a hard requirement before we get to zaki with the same question just one other follow for you sunny so isn't this the problem though when we take something like Bitcoin and we port this to to cosmos is we lose the root economic security of Bitcoin now Bitcoin becomes like a lesser secure Bitcoin the native Bitcoin on the Bitcoin blockchain so native Bitcoin on the Bitcoin blockchain of course is secured by all of the miners right it's it's got Bitcoin level sovereign resistant security guarantees now when we move Bitcoin to cosmos now we have to trust whatever app chain set of validators for our our security of that Bitcoin asset becomes a less secure asset when it's ported on that way because we're not sharing the security isn't this a challenge that you see yeah so you know getting secure bridges to Bitcoin is definitely important focus for you know it's not you know something that we're definitely want to help promote more of right like we are you know we've been trying to help Jeremy Rubin with like getting some of the opc tv stuff and like you know more secure covenants on Bitcoin which will allow for more secure bridges effectively I'm big fan of the drive chains model drive chains is effectively like how you would do IBC for Bitcoin so you know I think what I've what I've learned is that like pushing on Bitcoin development too hard like if you the more you push at it the more it's like kind of pushes back at you and so you know I think that we're building for the long term here and I think that and I think the Bitcoin core developers have like a 10 year 50 year 20 year mindset you know and I think the I think the core primitives that will make Bitcoin be able to securely have the same trust assumptions as IBC will exist within a few years zaki what's your take on this whole monetary premium thing do you think it's much to do about nothing do you think monetary premium actually doesn't matter as much as maybe bank lists and kind of the theorem and Bitcoin community think it does so what I would say is I would I think too many teams who build L ones so like again so one thing that I think is again is sort of important remember about cosmos is cosmos is a 2014 project basically like we started Jay like Jay started it I started hanging out with Jay I've been work we've been talking we've been working on and talking about thinking about cosmos back since then it's gone through many names but basically the court thesis is the same we are very long term builders we we were building the stuff before there was any money in it we'll be building out you know the money goes away like we just it like it's an idea that seems so correct that it just has to be built and the so in that spirit of building for the very long term I really don't believe in building something that so fragile that if you're if you like sort of lose the meme the whole thing collapses right where's like bit you know the problem with and like honestly I admire Ethereum's current monetary premium I think you know I think Vitalik has done if Vitalik Justin Danny have done an extra extraordinary job they don't really always listen to me but you know we saw that with terror a little bit right they lost the meme and the entire system collapsed exactly right so how do you build systems so start by building a system that is secure in the absence of a monetary premium if you happen to also get a monetary premium great you get like this additional security additional value you could you could you could do things differently with but if you don't but if you don't but if you don't happen to have that and you still build a sound system then you know it'll keep going and you know where is like you know you we've seen the flip the other side of it which was also built on our tech which is like what do you what is it look like when you build completely unsound system the minute you lose the meme everything dies which was which was a lot let's your mark this question for later but I think we're on the topic of monetary premium we'll come back to Adam 2.
0 and the new economics that were introduced but just really quick Jackie so we can earmark this for for later in the in the episode is Adam 2.0 increasing the potential for monetary premium of atoms in your mind does it make it a better yeah it absolutely is part of the vision that's part of the design it is part of the vision to increase the possibility increase the probability that Adam may have a monetary premium that is cool that's cool that makes me as a as a monetary premium maximalist which I probably am in in addition to a decentralization maximalist it's cool to see the Cosmos community doing that can I give a little example of the best security another like justification of it gold is probably the asset in the work like the one bear asset in the world that has the most monetary premium right now it has a market cap of about 11 trillion dollars the top 10 companies by market cap in the world have a higher market cap than gold combined and so if you go the and that's the option model right it's like oh value comes from real actual like revenue streams and like same way that company you know market caps come from and so if the top 10 companies in the world have a greater market cap than gold why can't the top 10 and options have a greater market cap and security system than a monetary premium basis so your point they're sunny is just it's about like total economic security and that economic security does not need to come from monetary premium it can come from a productive asset that is adding value so like Facebook stock for example and like if you have the top 10 companies then you get a market cap exceeding gold it's interesting so in this mesh network model of security what's stopping one chain from just being way more useful and central than the others and might that chain also be get some network effects and some liquidity will liquidity premiums and so while it all starts off as like a pretty diffuse my cereal network that's very horizontal one chain call osmosis as like the liquidity center of cosmos what's stopping osmosis from kind of just like positioning itself in the very center of everything because everything has to hook into osmosis for liquidity and then while the cosmos idea the cosmos ecosystem never actually created like a beacon chain right and actual this is the center is what's stopping something like osmosis from basically becoming that anyways and what in your answer sunny could you just define what osmosis is for people who are not familiar with the cosmos ecosystem yeah sure so osmosis is a it's a dex option right so it is a you know currently it's an mm based system but you know we're adding more concentrated liquidity style stuff and you know our goal is to build the best dex possible and you know we looked at like other dexes on other ecosystems whether it's unisop or serum and everything's always like constrained with the limitations of the platform it's built on and we had a lot of ideas about how you extra work how like new functionality especially around like privacy and like new things that you we just were so constrained by building on like the like the you know we actually we actually thought about like building it on an EVM and like we like this doesn't actually work the things we're trying to do won't work on here and so you know by having our own chain that we can go you know especially if you want to do a lot of stuff at the privacy layer right you know we need to go be able to change how the cryptography in the code base works while we also go change how the wallets work and like you know you have to have this like full stack control and that's sort of what we did and osmosis was you know so this IBC thing this interblock chain communication protocol that allows cause was changed to talk to each other it it existed for a little while but then osmosis sort of came along and like it was at the first killer app of cosmos right and there will be there are already more I think killer apps coming and by right now it is sort of where the center of user activity and liquidity has aggregated um you'd say it's the first but would you exclude Terra Luna just because it blew up because I was looking like your app a year ago so Terra Luna was pretty good they took a little bit longer to activate IBC so they activated I you know they had you know Terra was had quite a bit of traction but they were using the causes SDK stack and then they acted I activate the I mean I've talked to them about it you know they they're like oh there's no benefit of connecting to the cosmos ecosystem you know where they're on the app and then osmosis came along and they're like oh okay there's something worth connecting to which is why they activated IBC so back to your question about like the you know the how what we're building here is highly organic systems right and that that's a whole premise of cosmos is like you know you let organic systems arise and you let like you know the natural network effects happen and you know natural connections will happen and in any organic system Hayekian system you have power laws right there are things that are it is fundamental to the nature of how Hayekian systems work that there will be power laws and you know obviously as an as an osmosis developer I intend osmosis to be at a certain end of the spectrum on those power laws but you know I think our goal is not to be you know we're not trying to build a hub and spoke system right I think that would defeat the entire point of what we're trying to do with cosmos and we are you know that's why osmosis is contributing heavily to like things like mesh security and like making sure that you know we we we a lot of people that asked us like hey us why aren't you doing how like routing through osmosis right you you know all this you have all this assets flowing through osmosis if someone wanted to send a token from you know regen chain to secret network chain for example you know why aren't we actually we had a we had the opportunity to allow it to have all go flow through osmosis but like that's was just not the vision for how causal works and we like specifically said no no no this like whole system is bad we should everything should be doing point to point routing all chains are the router the hub for their own native assets and so I think that's also kind of why we wanted to build this first option as well was so that you know I our team you know me and Dave and other folks we had spent three years building the core stack of you know building SDK and IBC and at some point we wanted to go build an application and by building the application we can kind of help set how you know be the good actor be the first good at be the good actor that sets the cultural norms for how app change should be built so in that answer is it is the answer yes a chain could become the liquidity focal point of the entire cosmos ecosystem but we will also build surface area and routes around that liquidity center that doesn't like formally instantiate it as a winner even though it might be winning it is not the winner and will never be like locked in there is that a summary of your answer David doesn't just feel like you know swap basically on a theory yes yeah yeah you know you know swap has quite a bit of competition they still make up over 50% of volumes on a theorem but like you know it's still a free and fair market that like you know if you know swap goes down this the area doesn't die right there's so many alternatives that things inflow through as well I think the difference though is that you know swap is largely a platform for ether liquidity more than it is unique liquidity and when there is an absence of a monetary premium asset that's like instantiated or formalized in the cosmos ecosystem perhaps the osmosis token becomes that asset if it is providing its own liquidity to its own asset and the osmosis token is the most liquid asset inside of cosmos and starts to become the money of cosmos I think that's a difference there that's worth worth poking at a little bit because then that does start to like bacon bacon the osmosis token more formally into the broader cosmos ecosystem then you know swap does for the uni token because then the osmosis token starts to fill the role that ether plays in the Ethereum ecosystem what would you think about this yeah so we did do a little bit of that where like osmo is the base liquidity pair of most of these pools but I actually don't think that's going to be a lasting thing because as we move towards more concentrated liquidity and order book style systems I think the ux kind of demands for stable coins to be the you know the quote asset for most of these pairs you know people if they're putting concentrated liquidity positions they want to say hey I want to put it between 90 cents and a dollar ten right not like denominated things in osmos so you know I think with osmosis you know another thing though is like we we're not just the cosmos deck or it depends on what you call cosmos like you know we are funny enough you know we're actually the second biggest dex for dot yeah and it's like so we have a lot of dot coming over we have you know eth and wbtc are the third and fourth most liquid assets on osmosis uh we have um and you know we are working on building up connections to more ecosystems you know our one of our goals is we want to be the place that if you have eth on a theorem and you want avax on avalanche you can the osmosis should be the best place to route it both from a ux perspective and liquidity perspective I don't know if this is true with perspective monetary premiums but I have always seen the cosmos ecosystem that they sort of import different monies into their kind of trade route network rather than build up their own monies maybe maybe thing things are changing with uh with atoms and kind of the new design and that's that's uh being more conducive to monetary premium but importing Bitcoin for example tokenized version of Bitcoin importing eth now more recently importing usdc which has got to be a big boom to the cosmos community zaki do you have any thoughts on this and just in general how big do you think is the move for um circle and usdc to be now supported on cosmos are you kind of a stablecoin maximalist and do you have any issues with this particular stablecoin design that it's a bit more centralized for instance so um inclusion so okay I want to make a couple of points that like just kind of pop the stack a little bit that like all descend really nicely down this so one thing that I think is very different about another thing that's a real difference between cosmos and ethereum is that in cosmos most of the core devs also work on apps versus in ethereum there's like like you go to like uh like um like um like uh what dev connect an Amsterdam and you see this like massive disconnect between like the ethereum core dev community and the ethereum app community in cosmos every single core that like most of the like well-known core devs inside of cosmos and the people who sort of guide and steward the other core devs who don't want to think about apple air concerns almost every one of them has an app so like i have some lia finance i also work on a goryk and a goryk stablecoin called isd i work on the usdc chain uh or the chain the generalized asset issuance chain that usdc is coming on to um you know and i helped close the close the deal in the announcement um and so there's like this whole um uh uh uh which like gives this very different feel uh feeling to the whole ecosystem and also kind of helps solidify this whole oh it's going to be a mesh instead of it's going to be like centralized around one thing because we all have our own apps we all have our own you know and like economic incentives to like make sure that like different coins in the ecosystem all succeed and thrive um and so we're all we're all constantly constructing different routes and trade routes and it does sort of preserve this sort of decentralized nature of the ecosystem so then like go all the way up under the stablecoin thing um so you know in many ways the uh you know the i i would say like the the way the usdc announcement was structured i think was oh we're coming to a lot of chains so it just like sounds like okay we're coming to a lot of chains um but like honestly what i would say is the biggest thing that i have seen from the sort of discussion and conversation with usdc around cosmic but coming to cosmos about coming to so like one of the differences between cosmos right is like on all the other chains except for uh uh polkadot that they're watching on the chain like the apps where the chain is going to be used and the chain where their issuing are the same on the cosmos ecosystem they are issuing on an inner chain secured chain both the understanding that the majority of the usage is going to be on dydx osmosis say protocol like all of these you know agoric all of these things so what i would say is that like one of the things that's been exciting to me has been seeing usdc from go from sort of ignoring the multi-chain world and sort of just like okay we're like we're going to maybe we're going to like we were we're on the like L we're like kind they were kind of affiliated with the fat protocol thesis where they're like we'll go to the fattest protocols will issue usdc there to okay we get it it's all multi-chain we got to like make usdc much more natively multi-chain which is honestly a challenge for a lot of the bridging protocols like i you know when when sunny says you know axor is is the is the biggest bridging osmosis it's almost all stablecoin volume and you know we're bringing usdc natively to cosmos the like most wrapped bridged tokens in general are primarily stablecoins going from where they aren't to where they are and we're much more entering a universe of stablecoin ubiquity like you know essentially now you know if you're building a new l1 and you just build ibc support you're going to get usdc from cosmos from the from the from the from the our chain like seamlessly and permissionlessly which you could never do before so these things are like i think the circle announcement was kind of underplayed as exactly how as a big deal it is because like literally what they were to saying like the literal logical implementation of of usdc coming on to cosmos is now usdc is available to any l1 builder who implements the interblock chain communication protocol and they get usdc for free i think that is the big deal and i i like the idea of usdc on cosmos more than say something like some kind of a bitcoin because usdc itself is is already a centralized it's an io you for a dollar in a bank account owned by coinbase right it's not supposed to provide sovereign grade security it's not a crypto native money at all and so putting that on cosmos just seems to make sense you're not really sacrificing any of the any of the security or any of the kind of the sovereignty of the money because it's just already a dollar it's a digital dollar but okay so i'm going to lay out another question i guess i have for you guys and this is again maybe from a dumb you know a theorem kool-aid drinker a point of view and you guys tell me you're out wrong yeah okay so layer two's versus cosmos let's talk about that so yes the future is multi chain what people don't necessarily understand is that there are kind of two multi chain visions i think at play right not to say that both won't coexist i'm sure they absolutely will coexist but one is kind of a cosmos multi chain vision and the other is maybe an ethereum multi chain vision and let me lay out the the ethereum kind of multi chain vision because i understand that a little bit more but the basic idea is all of the chains settle back and use the security of ethereum right and so yes the ethereum ecosystem or universe if you will will have app chains and yes app chains are a force cosmos is absolutely right in its thesis about this that app chains are going to be a big deal i think you guys have led the way in probably the ethereum community is like oh yeah we get it now like we understand app chains big deal yes but the way that the ethereum community is doing app chains is basically like as part of maybe call it a layer three it's part of kind of a roll up so you've got arbitrum and there any trust strategy we just had the folks from zk sync on the on the podcast last week or a couple weeks ago at the time of record at the time of people will listen to this and that episode was about essentially spinning up app chains inside of what they call the layer two which just means basically settled down to ethereum at the root at the end of the day so secured by ethereum and the benefit of this oh you guys are going to emphasize the cost but let me tell you what the benefit is of this i see is you get ethereum's level of security or something close to it with maybe a few minor trade-offs without having to pay for it right so if you spin up your own sovereign chain there is a military there is a security force the police in the military you have to fund and those are called the validators of the system they secure the chain for you if you are on a ethereum you settle down to ethereum you benefit from ethereum's economic security you don't have to pay your own military and police force and so that has both economic advantages it seems like you get to preserve much of the sovereignty though you guys maybe will disagree and say well it's not completely your own your own kind of sovereignty in that app chain but you get those benefits and then you're kind of tapped into the ethereum network in the ethereum community cross-chain bridging becomes much more secure you get a lot of benefits from from that path so contrast that if you will with the cosmos app chain model and yeah tell me tell me where the the ethereum strategy breaks down uh well we have a name for that system it's called empires and colonies and we are building for sovereign systems um and i was like you want to start yeah okay so that was the very memeable um of the put down i'll do the a little bit more so okay so first point is i don't think like like i i i think that the you know part of the goal of you know part of like the dialogue between ethereum and cosmos which i think most people in ethereum don't really realize this but the style log has been going on since like 2014 one of the co-founders of cosmos was like an early geth contributor and geth geth uh uh person like we have been these have been existence systems that inform each other and honestly we've been trying to get convince ethereum to like move towards something like what the current vision is for a very long time we've been like okay guys like yes like we get it but like you got to understand the app chain thing like that has to like be part of the vision and like it's taken a long time because like they went down this like sharding uh uh uh uh uh uh off ramp and i was like what are you doing i don't know that off ramp and the plasma off ramp and like those like come on off ramp it's like plasma sharding it took them so long to like be like single-stop finality appchains okay cool so they kind of actually did a little bit and they came around to the cosmos vision yeah i you know i i was i hung out with the toddler for like a week earlier this year and i'm like you've i finally convinced you it's taken seven years but i finally convinced you so i i was so that you know there's a there is a friendliness always to the the ethereum community we are we are we i've always been each other as brothers and in many ways like i think the mission of the cosmos i if that world that like you're describing of the ethereum the idea of cosmos will have succeeded and that that's why we're all here so that's first of what we're most now i i'll just go to like what is the specific sort of technical reason is in my mind a blockchain is three things it's an execution environment it's a data availability system and it's a system of bridges ethereum is trying to say hey basically we want to build one of all of this like there's like one canonical place you bridge to where you have where you post your fraud truths where you post your your your your your your zero knowledge proofs we will provide one data availability where called dank sharding and then you can investigate all the execution environments that you want the cosmos vision is bridge wherever you want we have iBC you can go anywhere you can bridge anywhere iBC can it can can enable you to bridge anywhere post your your zero knowledge proofs and your your fraud truths and everything wherever you want you know celestial is kind of part of the cosmos family it is a data availability focused app chain enabling a like a a a roll-up type ecosystem and you can post your stuff there and then we've given you a free toolkit for building execution environments and so the differences between the ethereum environment ecosystem right now is one for the most part the execution environment toolkits are not free which is which is i think a big reason of you know why do you IDX for instance came to cosmos and why other chains have come to cosmos is there is an advantage to being like hey wait the execution environment is not the product of some company that like ray is like bill you know hundred you know multi-billion dollar valuations it's lucky with that is that is that like um tenderment is that kind of the cosmos yes tenderment is just free it's open source out of the box it's our open source Apache 2 licensed public goods got it you know collaborated on by many different people where there's many different experts all over the ecosystem who sit in chats with each other and just like work on it in debug it every day um march of it is funded by the atom holders but it's like again we use the atom fundraiser we use the speculation speculative energy around atom to like build this public good for everyone um so that was that was that was so that's that i think is the biggest thing it's actually just the best framework for this like i mean you know if you have compound if you know Robert Lesnar tweeted a couple weeks a couple months ago he's like you know compound chain tried to build an app chain on you but i think they just chose the wrong stack they chose substrate and spent a year being their head against the walls and gave up and and that Robert Lesnar said like hey i actually think if we chose the cosmos SDK as the stack to do this on i think this could have worked and um you know part of from a builder perspective i think there's actually just like one of the big things is we could just build faster with the cosmos SDK then we could with the rollups right like built so in rollups today you kind of have like two model two real frameworks right now it's either everyone's building these like EVM compatible systems but like i mentioned you know the stuff we're trying to do it doesn't work on the EVM we need we need a custom uh framework for that who building optimistic rollups or zk rollups for really custom state machines is actually really hard probably the closest you know the closest thing right now is kairo from from the startware team and you know it's really impressive what they've been able to do but i mean i'll say that writing a dex of the complexity of what we're trying of osmosis trying to write this in this new programming thing called kairo that's like very cutting edge you know it's it's like trying to write in like you know not even see it's like a proto-c like it's like versus you know the stuff that we can do and like go and rossam just like build faster and i think build the applications and build the ux framework so i guess like you know maybe one one thing is how to compare a lot of this stuff is the ethereum ecosystem and cosmos yes maybe they're moving towards the same place right now with the same end goal the ethereum ecosystem decided to spend a lot of time focusing on you know the things like duck said like the like the fraud proofs and validity proofs the data availability stuff while i think the cosmos ecosystem has focused much more at a higher level layer of the stack at the you know the state machine stuff i think the cosmosam vm is probably the best designed vm all of crypto because how it does interchain composability um i the the the cross chain composability that we have in cosmos is way more advanced than anything else you know other ecosystem yeah you can bridge tokens right in cosmos we can have like dows on one chain like do transactions on another chain like that's like so and i think maybe part of that comes from the you know like zaki mentioned that all the core devs of cosmos are app developers as well and so that's kind of informs the decision and priorities that that that that we do and so that's sort of one of the trade off then no we will eventually have fraud proofs and validity proofs and all that stuff for cosmos SDK chains as well but we're just like we're gonna build a better ux and like app features first i think this is very much what the what the difference is this cosmos is starting like app down and and ethereum is almost starting from what kind of like um base protocol up a bit more and so i yeah i think a big part of your answer was hey the cosmos SDK is just bad ass if you're trying to build a chain and like there's nothing comparable in the ethereum community yet i know we've we've heard the optimism team talk about um you know a bedrock which is kind of their version of creating kind of a uh almost like a word press for chains we just kind of you stand them out and these would be roll ups but layer two out of the box yeah layer two out of the box but it's not it's certainly not there yet what's interesting i think i'll take is that you know roll ups like to talk about how much how like secure they are and stuff compared to like but if you go to l2b.
com you can see the actual security database we know it yeah i would say the ibc system right now is actually more secure than any of the most of the roll ups in practice today well we also had um vitalicon who is like wondering if we'll ever get to a place in optimistic roll ups at least where where fraud proofs um actually work because we're not we're not there yet right um although i will say zk evm's are looking pretty pretty good from a tech perspective and uh from from from from that side of things but yeah it's it's very interesting i guess one comment i want to make and then just a quick question is it does seem like because all of the cosmos core developers are also app developers um app chain developers that probably from put on your app chain hat you guys are just willing to use whatever technology app chain technology is best right and right now that seems to be cosmos for you but like if there was a way to do kind of cosmos uh plus settling on ethereum you might decide to migrate your app there it's just not been the best approach uh today right the cosmos community has as provided the best app chain tools the brave wallet is your secure multi chain on ramp into webfree and it's built directly into the brave privacy browser gone are the days of managing multiple wallet extensions that put you at risk of fishing spoofs and tracking with the brave wallet you can securely manage your crypto assets across more than a hundred different chains including ethereum layer two's salana and more all without downloading risky extensions the brave wallet is easy to set up and removes the headache of jumping between wallets and extensions it's lightweight but packed with great features like built-in token swaps buying and holding NFTs with a gallery view and support for hardware wallets but also much more than that because brave is shipping new features every single month with a mission to make webfree easier to navigate for its over 55 million users wall extensions are the thing in the past so get started with brave's webfree ready browser today and experience a decentralized web seamlessly without all the clutter download the browser at brave.
com slash bankless and click the wall icon to get started and all of my years in crypto i've never been hacked scammed or lost money to a thief and a lot of that credit goes to my ledger hardware wallet the ledger nano x and the ledger nano s plus hardware wallets allow users like you and me to secure and manage all of our crypto assets and our NFTs all with the security of storing users private keys offline and out of rage from hackers the ledger nano x is the perfect hardware wallet for managing your crypto and NFTs on the go because it connects to your phone with bluetooth and has a nice big screen for easy transaction ledger has also upgraded the iconic ledger nano s and made the new ledger nano s device more defy and NFT friendly making it the perfect hardware wallet for beginners ledger has truly maximized for both ease of use and security so discover which ledger devices best suited for your journey by going and visiting shop dot ledger dot com next so is your financial hub for all your crypto needs next so let's you buy crypto instantly with your credit or debit card or via bank transfer they also have an awesome advanced trading platform called nexo pro that pays you rewards when you swap crypto assets and nexo also lets you earn interest on your crypto in bitcoin eth or other assets and they also give you an instant crypto line of credit with as low as 0% APR and they also give you access to a crypto backed master card of course earning you more crypto when you use it so enhance your financial life with nexo who ensures all credit lines are over collateralized with insurance on all custodial assets nexo the right place for your crypto so click the link in the show notes to join over five million users who are getting the most out of their crypto i'm one question though and this is a throwback maybe to to two two two thousand eighteen two thousand seventeen two thousand eighteen and this was i remember at the time there were two big interoperability chains because this was the narrative it was uh polka dot and it was cosmos um and you just we're talking about a failed attempt from the compound team to actually build something in and substrate that you know the polka dot tech has cosmos won that war do you think cosmos versus polka dot is cosmos ahead and i'm asking for you obviously you're probably gonna say yes because you're on team cosmos but like give me some i objective reasons for why you think that's true um yeah okay so we could talk about a little bit about i mean we have many friends at parity in the in the polka dot community uh i bc two polka dot is also being built by a team called composable finance another exciting thing just talking about all the zk progress is zk i bc has gone from being like maybe it's like five years away to like maybe it's like a year away um there's like a lot of exciting teams that have have kind of come in and started building the the building box of zk i bc which would potentially allow for much more interoperability so just like kind of talk about all those things but then like like you get to the heart of your question polka dot versus cosmos which model is winning um dot market cap wise dot is winning but okay so like you know you heard in the same sentence it like basically the same presentation from circle usdc is launching in polka dot it's launching before it's launching on cosmos absolutely true does polka dot have an app that's going to mint a billion dollars of usdc on it now right we have dydx like when usdc goes live on on on uh on uh uh uh cosmos the floor mint is a billion dollars just to move the dydx user base from starkware to with two two cosmos this is the like i mean that that's like it's a very hard number it's a very hard metric but it's like like this is what happens when you bring the best apps to your ecosystem and you don't collect rent from your app developers you you build an ecosystem into which of collaboration in which they can thrive and we can thrive you get the best apps and then as assets and stuff move to the ecosystem you you get these like exponentials of scale that like are not possible uh you know well what's interesting about that is it feels like polka dot has maybe done the strategy where they've tried to split the difference between ethereum and cosmos and because they've been in the middle like the middle just hasn't held right whereas like ethereum is just like yeah the middle doesn't hold and so ethereum is just like hey we're um we're an empire i guess i don't think particularly think they're an evil empire but in in an empire in the last like they're not vitally not evil no one would say that but like there's some randix traction there's all sorts of things right i get that and it's not nearly it says it's i don't consider it nearly as adversely selective as polka dot you are getting these enormous network effects from it well we so you have that and it's like it's kind of like a the united states right and all of the chains are sort of states within the united states there's a federalist kind of like notion to it but you know confederacy of states as well and then you got cosmos on the other side which is just like anarchy almost it's not anarchy but it's almost like hey any any city state can spin up we'll we'll do a network if it's yeah advantageous we'll do sparta and Athens we'll make an alliance but maybe we won't maybe we'll go to war but maybe we will and like it's like it's very loose but there's no rent collection paid to the kind of the cosmos hub then you have polka dot which kind of tried to split the difference here where they tried to have kind of the you know the sovereignty of all of these chain experiments but then they asked the chains to pay rent economically back back to dot holders right you have to rent out your um parachain in the polka dot network right and it just seems like that model has not picked up from an economic perspective and this is why very much right now in crypto maybe this has always been the case i've i just see these two sides there's a theorem on one side and there's cosmos on the other and these are the two kind of parallel ideas that are playing out in crypto before us in 2022 we've used this metaphor before Ryan is the one that put this into my brain is that uh nature has made a crab like 10 15 20 different times throughout history and these crabs are unrelated to each other like on the evolutionary line and that's just because the crab is a good strategy and some of the lines i've been using on this like metaphor is that if you reroll the dice over and over and over again about how the crypto industry forms you'll get a theorem every single time and it also i think goes to show with Ryan was just saying you'll also get cosmos it is the central security model of a theorem versus the app chain model of cosmos and that is like the whole thing maybe big corners will be like oh and there's also the proof of work money uh strategy as well maybe that but maybe that's also true but uh my opinion is that type of app chain okay sure that's an app chain right uh so it's it's one of these two flavors maybe maybe it's a 50 50 split maybe it's an 80 20 split but it's definitely not 100 zero i definitely will take that into account i want to um talk about mev i want to go down the mev rabbit hole a little bit uh because i think that will also help uh illustrate the incentive for apps to be their own app chain uh sunny can you talk about the mev model of a theorem and like we can use uniswap as an example dan ellipsor just put out a fantastic article talking about uh uniswap and all of the money it makes as revenue versus the money it leaks to the ecosystem and just like real just a speedrun that article roughly one third of the economic energy that goes through uniswap is collect captured by uh liquidity providers the actual like service providers of uniswap about one third goes to gas payments to transact on uniswap and one more third goes to mev payments front running back running like arbitrage opportunities so there's this application on on a theorem called uniswap and of all the costs it takes users to use uniswap about one third of that cost goes to profits for liquidity providers one third goes to gas payments which goes to ether holders and one third goes to mev bots which are mev bots and so the claim here is that there's a leaking a lot of value anytime you use uniswap so sunny can you talk about this in like the cosmos perspective and how cosmos and app chains uh solve some of these problems some of these mev problems and are a less leaky ship when it comes to uh value capture and value accrual for apps yeah sure um yeah you know dance uh that was just like uh proposal hey we should build like a unique chain and i'm like yeah we we did it's called osmosis uh and then notice nascent is a major investment in osmosis uh but so the uh yeah so uh anitoli from salana had a you know how to tweet a couple of months ago at this point but he basically you know he also doesn't believe in the monetary premium uh thesis right and he actually said that like i i don't think there's more i don't know about the monetary premium stuff it's a little bit too hand wavy for me but the value of l ones is the mev that they capture and like you said exactly that like you know uniswap is leaking that mev value to the user to to to the base layer of uh of a therium right for osmosis you know for as a vertically integrated chain there's sort of three sources of revenue right i could see it we have our applet revenue which is like you know it's a dex of training fees and all that kind of stuff um there's your transaction fee revenue but my take is actually that transaction fee revenue should never be a meaningful source of revenue uh this is sort of my like concern with the whole eip 1559 like sound ultra sound money like thesis is that like in any world in which the transaction fee okay why is what what are you paying for with transaction fees you're paying for like block space of a bft compute system and the point is that like you know i think that bft block space and bft compute systems is going to be cheap in the long run because there's going to be so many chains and you know they're going to have a lot of uh you know as more you even in the ethereum model as more uh usage moves on to the rollups the demand for base layer of block space will go down massively and like users are not going to pay in any world world if if transaction fees are too low it's not a meaningful source of revenue if they're too high users are not going to use it and you know ethereum had this like kind of like you know at this like two-year period like last starting two years ago of like oh okay you know there was high enough there's really high fees but users were still using it because there was no real alternatives right but i don't know if that like is a especially with rollups and app chains and all this new stuff coming out i don't know if that i don't know if users are going to be willing to pay hundreds of dollars again for transactions uh so and then we kind of see this you know that's why a lot of stuff markets have moved to other chains you know NFTs are very popular on you know Solana for example right or games that moved off of like completely move off of the ethereum mainchain altogether um so yeah the third the third source of revenue is the MEV capture right and so i suppose since we actually started with uh so before we were building a Dex we actually were just like building like MEV mitigation strategies and so we were working on something called threshold decryption um which is a way of encrypting the mempool entirely and so that way and only decrypting and executing after blocks have been finalized and committed and so you know the model that we we follow at osmosis is mitigate bad MEV internalize good MEV so how where do we draw this distinction bad MEV is the type of MEV when you are doing actions based off of other people's transactions right because the mempool is public you can read others transactions and you could you know sandwich them you could you know generalize front run them copy their strategies you know all this stuff which is like not cool fundamentally that's a privacy breach and like it is a bug that the mempools are not encrypted right now so that's why we focus on building threshold decryption so that the mempools are encrypted but now there's still some types of MEV that remain right and I call these like I don't know if good MEV is the right word but they're not the it's not extractive MEV you're not extracting it from anyone else so examples would be arming prices on osmosis relative to centralized exchanges or even arming prices within osmosis pools you know there are circular routes through pools arming those together or there's um there's you know the Mars protocol is launching a lending platform on osmosis quite soon so you know triggering liquidations is another sort of you know good MEV and all of these are good things you know you want your pools to be arb you want liquidations to be happening fast but there is value in being the person to do that right and so how do we internalize good MEV and bring that as protocol revenue uh we're working very closely with a team called skip who's helping us you know instead of letting this stuff be like you know I call them like I call you know then them be run by these off-chain validator cartels let right you know I would say like flashbox not being part of the core protocol it makes it so like you know it's sort of it ends up having to be a little bit profit maximizing when if the core the beauty of appchains is because your chain hat understands the semantics of the application built on top of it it can be opinionated about how it orders transactions or and it can do things to actually promote social good right it could be like you know we are going to make sure uh you know you can't just rug liquidity we're going to make sure all trades happen first before liquidity removals happen and like so that way you know liquidity can't get rug from under you or or we can like detect sandwiches and like you know be like oh this is an invalid transaction order we're going to move these transactions around so it's not a sandwich anymore um and like you can do things like that right to help continue to mitigate that bad mv and then on the good mv you know we can run automatic on-chain our bots where like you know we calculate our our cycles and we run an on-chain arbor that happens at the end of every block and captures that our revenue it and gives it to osmos takers or we could uh hack what we're going to do is have a top of the block auction but in the protocol itself so instead of relying on off-chain system the in protocol you can bid to say hey I want to be the first transaction in the block and that way you can be the one to do all the arbes and you know liquidations and stuff and doing it in protocols important because then the protocol can decide how the revenue gets shared right in if you do it off-chain you know the revenue goes to like only the validators and you know maybe we have to rely on them altruistic like you know maybe we'll see a market where validators have to end up starts sharing all the revenue with with their delegators right but in if you do it in protocol we can say oh we want some of this mv revenue to go to all takers we want some of it to go to the community pool we want to give some of it as a kickback to users like we can like choose what to do with that mv revenue which is I think a very important property yeah I think that's definitely the strength of the the app chain model um you know as we as we move kind of this conversation to from from comparisons to a theorem and from the cosmos thesis uh to the world of the new atom 2.
0 economics that were released um having gone through that paper there are a few things that that stuck out to me and I'm going to try my attempt at at summarizing um but you guys uh go in there and and um let me know what the what the main thrust of these changes are it seems like before atoms from an economic perspective the token economics for an investor anyways weren't really great kind of sucked at least did not a crew monetary premium and zaki you're you're going thumbs down can you talk about like why did why didn't thumbs down in agreement right yes thumbs down thumbs down in agreement yeah I know right so why did they suck before I mean like this was a big part of our presentation at cosmic verse my presentation specifically you know it was like look um you can think of what atom was foremost in the first iteration was a prototype of a proof of state check right we kind of you know we would say that from our point of view that pro our argument is that before the cosmic sub launch there was no live proof of state chain that had really taken proof of state economically seriously and done it in like a rigorous way from like the computer science level all the way to the economics level we we I believe that the cosmos was the first gene to do this um so but it was a prototype of what does proof of state look like how can it be done in a rigorous way like all of these things um but it was only a prototype and like the best way I would describe it is also is we have an app chain thesis what the hell is the app of the cosmos hub uh it doesn't appear to have an app so we were kind of the uh uh you know and so you know the uh you know both Ethan and I talked about this and this was a bit a big theme both you know the last week of our lives and like the proceeding like nine months of pulling all these ideas together um has been about you know okay we would like to go out and we would like to say one we want to make Adam a better ecosystem asset but part of that but it inherent to that idea is we must create an app for the cosmos hub why don't I know what you kind of take your other takeaways for the paper because I'm curious in real time get it like what you what you took away from it um and then but I could talk a little bit about but yes so like issuance is changing we are moving towards you know not this exponential inflation we think that helps defying the ecosystem we think it makes Adam closer to a monetary uh a monetary asset like all of those things and we think those things are good okay well first do I give this to let let's camp on that because as a as a um monetary maximalist you'll know that the first thing I noticed in this paper was um hey the monetary policy has changed how this is interesting and I you know I I almost wondered in the back of my mind if it's like if the Ethereum community kind of capitulated and being like a cosmos these app chain guys were right they were right all along right we're going to do more app chains in Ethereum I almost saw maybe some recognition from the cosmos community that huh this this ultrasound money thing hmm maybe we want our Adam token to actually exhibit some characteristics of of money and have a a better issuance policy that's kind of what I saw but maybe that's my bias reading of the thing and so what I saw is previously I think um issuance for Adam token holders was that between like seven and twenty percent per year that was the rate of issuance in the market it's adaptive to the amount that's state so we are going to stake rate of sixty seven percent um uh because of you know we want to keep the make it very expensive to attack to like hat for there to be enough liquid atom to accumulate to actually attack the network right um uh and you know so you know we had so basically you know what pulls atoms away from being there are like what's on centralized exchanges that the centralized exchanges themselves are not staking um and then all of the atoms that are out there uh in LP pools all of that stuff um uh you know that pushes the staking rate down the uh inflation rate goes up to compensate so um right so like since osmo so we had dropped to about seven percent inflation um uh uh new atom issuance and then since kind of osmosis launch of the IVC ecosystem top uh we've been averaging about nine nish percent in this PID loop um but and that has translated into a staking APY for atoms of about you know 19 20 percent gotcha and now what are the changes there seem to be almost two phases of these changes like a transition phase and then almost a steady state and the first phase issuance actually increases I believe but then in the second phase it kind of like tapers off and it's going to decrease to like one percent okay explain that yeah there's there's a bunch of complicated moving pieces and the issuance thing a big part of the framework around issuance though is that uh osmosis taking a very different approach to liquid staking then let's say ethereum has where I would say ethereum fought tooth and nail to make it as hard as possible for like liquid staking to emerge and it emerged anyways because the economics are so compelling um the cosmos ecosystem has been taking approach of hey we want to make sure that there are just a large variety of liquid staking providers and so that there's competition and so you don't have a situation where alighto like entity becomes like super dominant um but we think on the whole like like liquid staking staking derivative assets are actually really important to the security budget of the system um so and the logic there is it allows people to stack their yield so rather than saying atom holders like we're going to try and like print so many atoms that we compensate you for the opportunity cost of everything else you could do with atom we're saying liquid stake your atom take your liquid staked out of go do all the other things that you could do in defod go use the app ecosystem with your liquid staked out of and have it still contribute to the security budget of the cosmos so um so that that so the first thesis is so there's like um probably about like six liquid staking protocols launching or in the midst of launching on topic in the cosmos ecosystem right now um so there's like there's a lot of activity around that so we're sort of projecting in the future saying hey we think this over the next three years we expect these protocols will succeed uh my team at occlusion um has been working has has been working really like one of our big contributions of the occlusion team uh to the uh to the paper has been that we spent the last like 18 months making changes to the like default cosmos staking module to improve the ux of liquid staking so all of that stuff so that's happening so staking yield starts to fall uh starts to fall on like a yearly basis in this now the issuance goes up but that is issuance to the community treasury it is it is because you know a lot of chains have had this idea of having like the on chain down being able to have funds and funds we started the cosmos hub out with a very small amount uh where there's only about uh half a percent of of new issuance goes into the and so like we have about you know ten million dollars I think of token of value in our in our uh uh community pool whereas you know some other L ones have like a third of their market cap um in in the community pool um to like fund new things and one of the things that we're saying is in this new app vision to execute on that app vision you need working capital like we're gonna have to go and do business development we're gonna have to onboard chains this interchange security thing like there's gonna be a lot of stuff that needs to be done that wasn't really conceived of in the original cosmos hub but like you know if you hold atoms you're gonna be a voter on what those funds are being do so like the extent to which is delutive I think is a little overplayed because and then we're saying after this three year period there's not gonna be any more new funding going into the community pool there's not into the launching treasury um there's uh and then we're gonna drop the staking yield basically to about one percent that makes sense okay so that's the economic change for atoms and um lower staking yield is kind of like like lower issuance is the eventual outcome that'll take some years to play out and you also mentioned liquid staking which I noticed in the paper making that kind of a first class citizen I would say in the cosmos ecosystem and the way it's liquid stake is probably it's not a first class citizen in the theorem it's just it's kind of an app that a third party creates and then I also noticed like you're you're posing the question zaki of like what is the app of the cosmos hub itself and is the app of the cosmos hub not interchange security isn't it like isn't that the thing that's supposed or so to talk talk about this and this I think uh is is sort of the idea that um you can call on atom validators cosmos hub validators to also secure your app chain if you want is this the case is what interchange security means yeah so I'll contrast why don't we talk about two terms one is mesh security the other was it interchange security okay technical primitives are very similar are basically this almost identical between them they're about you know translating staking information from and slashing information from one chain to another chain so like if you fault on one chain you get slashed on another chain um let's call interchange security but like you're the version in which you replicate the hub validator set um okay so when we started with this interchange security thing I was like the biggest skeptic that we would find anyone who cared about it I was like anyone who's really serious about building an app will like want to be their own sovereign chain why would anybody else want to do this like and then we found we found like an enormous amount of uh of uh uh customer demand for for interchange security that like uh or like we called them consumer chains um so chains that consume security from the hub we found so much demand for and I'm like what like it was like a shock to me but I've understood now in in in the in in the past like what are the what are the things that interchange security is offering that people get uh that is like appealing to people one category of thing is there are very high value users like usdc for instance um who want to be able to like launch be strongly affiliated with the developer community core the exchanges the custodians the the the community around Adam um and like do not want to think about tokenomics they just like don't want to like that's like just not something that they would like really at all want to do um and so that's like one really strong use case which is like really powerful use cases that recruit value to the whole ecosystem and recruit value to the cosmos hub um but like don't want to think about their own tokenomics at all other things are hey we are building something that's like actually very security sensitive like liquid-staking where if like you have a major liquid-staking provider and it gets taken over it like cat there's like a cascading effect on the security of every other chain that is is is like running on top of their liquid-staking protocol so those chains have also wanted to affiliate um more closely with the cosmos hub um and then there's the sense of hey I want to build a build like and really target just like the network effects around Adam the wideholder base all that stuff these are three team uh uh uh themes that we see popping up over and over again and frankly this has given this like again has finally given us a sense of what is the purpose of the cosmos hub which is to enable these things to succeed that is cool um I guess another thing I noticed was um something that you guys are doing with mev on uh can I add one more thing about the hub yeah yeah go ahead how it relates in the mesh security vision so um I taught a class on Switzerland in uh at UC Berkeley it's my favorite country in the world you taught a class on Switzerland on the subject of Switzerland yeah yeah yeah eight lectures talked about history politics economics like everything in all my website very neutral country yes so you know how did Switzerland become it's one of the richest countries in the world right uh and there's many things that that went into that right I think the role of its credible neutrality that it's played throughout history was very important one thing that people maybe don't realize is that uh Switzerland you know it's it's neutral but it actually had one of the best militaries in the world and even till today it actually is one of the best militaries in the world but from like you know the period of like 1200 until like Napoleon basically they were like Europe's mercenaries they were the best most like respected military in all of Europe but because they were neutral they acted as mercenaries and went and like defended whoever would pay for them and I see the role of the causes hub to be this credibly credibly neutral system that is a we will you pay it for security and you get this like amazing economic security from it so that's where I see the military for hire military for hire it's like you know you don't want to have to come up with your own military well you know uh you can you you can you can pay the causes hub and you'll and that that's the role I feel that it plays in this mesh security vision so the idea here is that app chains maybe at Genesis don't do this because they're at Genesis but then their product market fit happens their utility is proven out their value increases and then they can start to go hey you know what we can afford security and so then they start to tap into this like credibly neutral army uh which thing can secure them I was one of the other direction well I will I'll just say to one one of the things that is like really cool and I think unique about our vision of shared security is we have specced out the whole system to the extent where you can seamlessly like just through like the standard kind of upgrading application upgrading process that we use in cosmos both join interchange security without disrupting your iBC connections or anything or leave interchange security so you know communities are still giving the given the it's not like they've like if they if they like find the hub excessively value extractive for the security that it provides it's very it'll be very possible to leave it'll be possible to go join someone else's shared security environment too or like be your own sovereign app chain and so like again this is like a long-term commitment we're creating market forces and cosmos that ensure that this is a pluralist environment and that way we are not creating any sort of artificial rent secret like the hub has to really provide its value otherwise we'll provide value otherwise no one will do this because that MEV has been like MEV censorship all of these things hugely relevant the Ethereum community so so we've we've heard a little bit about what does MEV look like in the pure app chain thesis but one of the things that we you know i've talked a lot about with the MEV we have flashbots teams we also have some very good MEV teams inside of of cosmos skip and mechatek who are you know doing also like building you know businesses around MEV in the cosmos and one of the things that we've been talking about most one of the things that like is built into it is again we don't think transaction fees will ever be high like we don't think transaction fees will be a mean a meaningful amount of revenue but you know in a world where there's like atom usdc other assets that are major fiat or on ramps between cosmos into the cosmos ecosystem at least one hop of every economic sort of loop or economic activity will frequently start within what say called the atom economic zone the interchange secured area of atom will probably be a place where a lot of economic activity originates and the ability to sort of arbitrage that so statistical arbitrage is not sandwiching or anything but just knowing hey someone is minted a whole bunch of usdc and we see them issuing an IVC packet that kind of information is likely to be valuable that block space is likely to be valuable so one of the things that we're proposing in the in the in the hub 2.
0 white paper is that like one of the again applications on the hub is this walk space market that any chain in the ecosystem whether it's interchange secured or not can opt into participating with and say we're actually going to package a product that is like a better product than like what skip and mechatek could build right now which is guaranteed the guaranteed ability to like have a transaction at the top of the block across many blocks over some continuous period of time and that the hub is a natural place to like hold this auction and execute so right now cosmos the atom token is coming in at 23 on coin get the total coin market cap and it's kind of behind some tokens that I'd never really would expect it to be behind a lot of tokens are sadly behind ripple light light coin is the one that comes to mind it's right before it at 22 it doesn't make any sense to me because it's like coin all it's got is Lindy do you guys envision that atom actually enters the top 10 crypto assets in the future as some given amount of time um if that doesn't happen atom I will not be have satisfied like I will consider that like the work that I've been doing will not have been a success like there is it like like I like I believe that this that this that's this work that went into atom 2.
0 has created a top 10 ask like when executed creates a top 10 asset and if the market doesn't agree with me you know and like there's as a as an entrepreneur it's like you go out you bring your best ideas to the market the market punches you in the face um and so we'll see um but uh yeah that's what we're trying that that is I would say that is up explicitly michael in this out of 2.0 sending any thoughts um yeah I admit I'm not as focused on the atom side of things I believe I know I focus on the cosmos level at the vision and then you know I'm very focused very focused on the cosmos vision and then very focused on the osmosis chain um we're trying to build osmosis we're trying to build the decentralized version of Binance Binance is a top 10 asset and gospel will be one day too Zachi the ethereum ecosystem and community like largely on on the page of like yeah we're going to flip bitcoin one day uh do you think cosmos is is there a part of cosmos that's like atom is going to flip eth one day um like okay so I'll just give you where by feel like I can always tell you by feel it's I can't I have become really probably more despondent about bitcoin's long term future than I ever have been um I own more eats today than I've ever owned in the past I own much more atom but I own more eat than I've ever owned before I'm own more eat than bitcoin um uh I think ethereum is doing a great job uh and like deserves is like the better representative of the cryptocurrency community the values that I believe in and I feel more aligned with ethereum than in the past um and so I'm not I don't I'm not building with this with like oh I have to flip eat I want to I need to flip all of the shit that is between me bars loaded to that there's a lot of it guys this has been a lot of fun I really feel like um listeners at the end of this episode will uh understand the cosmos ecosystem so much more including uh how it's going to evolve in the future and uh what's so interesting to me is these two communities ethereum and cosmos is like you see ethereum veering towards cosmos right getting more into app change this sort of thing you also see in places cosmos veering more towards uh ethereum at least with atoms and kind of monetary policy improvements and you know it's uh interesting to see these two communities one thing I've respected out of both is uh they are both the community of builders like you guys are just cosmos is building a lot and it's hard to be bearish on builder activity when you get 1500 people at a conference in a bear market and you know they're there because they think they're building something cool uh that is special and that is certainly something to watch so uh we're definitely watching it at bankless I guess last question for you both so let's fast forward you know five years into the future ten years into the future um where do you think cosmos ends up what does crypto look like and what does the cosmos ecosystem look like maybe five years into the future ten years from the future just any point in time where you feel like the vision is fulfilled zaki over to you um in so okay so I mean my my expectation is that by the time the vision is fulfilled most people who use crypto currency based technologies will kind of not really know whether or not they're using a cosmos thing and ethereum thing and so on a thing and hopefully what I want is them just to use the use a thing where they're where they are not being exploited where there's not being front ready where they're part where we're digital mark okay so like this this comes down to the question I think which you know uh I have a good way of articulating now digital markets in the future will be all markets and I'm building for a future in which digital markets are open source public goods that's like flat out what I've tried to accomplish I don't really care about anything else I just view the tools we've built as cosmos as an essential part of getting there I also think ethereum largely shares this vision um and so feel very aligned with ethereum but like so if we're successful we will have open source digital markets that provide economic coordination for the entire human race um and it like works it's you know and no one is exploiting or extracting residency because you can't um and that is the world that like is that is the utopia open source digital markets that's socky's utopia what's your sonny mine is for long you know like I mentioned I've always I really love organic hyacchia systems and part of that I think that like build rebuilding the infrastructures of society away from these like very top down organized systems to like bottom up localized localized localized systems where you know people make bilateral treaties multilateral treaties build communities and organized you know it's you know it's it's it's mesh is all the way up right and I really believe in ideas like web of trust based systems um you know I started working on one of the reasons I started working on cosmos was I just thought that you know I really wanted to work on proof of stake and I you know I was working on that you know I saw that I thought the cosmos team was the most like uh you know most fathers along on proof of stake actually and so and I know they weren't uh and so now that like you know as of last month or two weeks ago over 50% of market cap is running on proof of stake I'm like that's awesome but now what's like the next thing I think there's like I think this things we can do even better than proof of stake I really believe there's like a world where we can build like a web of trust based consensus protocol that will actually be even more decentralized than proof of stake um and I think there's like a lot of like I don't know I just want to keep tearing down like centralized or even you know high levels of communication required systems and build more organic mesh systems so I think this we use the metaphor of exploring the frontier quite frequently and the cosmos name actually is very conducive to this so say a listener is listen to this and they're they're on board and they want to go explore the cosmos uh in Ethereum we have like Metamask you've got to have Metamask uh what's the toolkit for people that need they what what's the toolkit that they need to be equipped with to go explore the cosmos first what's what's like the Metamask of Cosmos or just like what are the tools that listeners should probably start with in order to go explore cosmos um you should go get a Kepler wallet which is actually built by our team uh but you you know go on decentralized exchange by Adam which is the you know entry point into cosmos today you iBC it to osmosis do a swap for a token called stars you iBC it to stargaze and go buy your first bad kids NFT that's your that's you know that's your onboarding path that's your to-do list cool yeah and like I think if you just look at that okay you've got like an NFT app an onboarding place uh uh uh uh uh uh uh uh uh dex and just use that experience and say hey is this how do how different does this feel it from Ethereum but then go look at how much you spent on gas and we're getting that we're getting it better right now each of those steps require as a click and you know uh our uh at least on osmosis our view is that every click loses half of our users and so we're working on a lot of the tooling to like make that entire process feel like one click guys what what we'll do is uh after the show before this is actually published so by the time you're listening to this bankless listener we will have a little tutorial for everything sunny just said that we can link to on the bankless uh website so uh you could see sunny and zaki's ideas and how to get started with cosmos and start exploring the cosmos guys this has been a lot of fun thank you so much for joining us thank you action items for you bankless listeners the first is we'll include a link to the cosmos two dot o atom two dot o white paper check that out also referenced was the inevitability of unishane in article by dan ellitzer and of course we'll include a link that i just mentioned to that tactic on how to get started with cosmos and this is for zaki and and sunny if you guys are willing a thing that we've been doing is having our guests actually read out our outro of risten disclaimers crypto is risky you can lose what you put it in but we're heading west to the frontier it isn't for everyone but you're we're glad you're with us on the bankless journey hey we hope you enjoyed the video if you did head over to bankless hq right now to develop your crypto investing skills and learn how to free yourself from banks and gain your financial independence we recommend joining our daily newsletter podcast and community as a bankless premium subscriber to get the most out of your bankless experience you'll get access to our market analysis our alpha leaks and exclusive content and even the bankless token for airdrops raffles and unlocks if you're interested in crypto the bankless community is where you want to be click the link in the description to become a bankless premium subscriber today also don't forget to subscribe to the channel for in-depth interviews with industry leaders ask me any things and weekly rollups where we summarize the week in crypto and other fantastic content thanks everyone for watching and being on the journey as we build out the bankless nation