✨ DEBRIEF | Unpacking the Episode: https://shows.banklesshq.com/p/debrief-molly-white
After many episodes, we finally brought on a crypto skeptic, Molly White! We brought Molly on to take us out of our crypto bubble, to challenge our assumptions, and to steelman the anti-crypto argument.
Molly White is an engineer, public goods contributor, and an extremely articulate crypto critic. She also runs the web3 skeptic website: https://web3isgoinggreat.com/
In today’s episode, Molly gives us her central claim on why web3 isn’t actually going so great, why she thinks tokens make everything worse, and why—despite acknowledging some of the good—Molly believes crypto is a net negative to the world…and probably will be in the near future.
P.S. Keep in mind, this episode was recorded on October 7, 2022 — way before any of the FTX meltdown occurred this past week.
------ 📣 Earnifi | Check For Your Unclaimed Airdrops, POAPs, & NFTs https://bankless.cc/earnifi
------ 🚀 SUBSCRIBE TO NEWSLETTER: https://newsletter.banklesshq.com/?utm_source=banklessshowsyt 🎙️ SUBSCRIBE TO PODCAST: http://podcast.banklesshq.com/
------ BANKLESS SPONSOR TOOLS:
⚖️ ARBITRUM | SCALING ETHEREUM https://bankless.cc/Arbitrum
❎ ACROSS | BRIDGE TO LAYER 2 https://bankless.cc/Across
🦁 BRAVE | THE BROWSER NATIVE WALLET https://bankless.cc/Brave
🔐 LEDGER | NANO HARDWARE WALLETS https://bankless.cc/Ledger
⚡️FUEL | THE MODULAR EXECUTION LAYER https://bankless.cc/Fuelpod
----- Topics Covered
0:00 Intro 7:35 How Great is Web3 Really Going? 8:10 Headline Selection & Website Goals 12:50 Molly is Anti-Crypto 13:36 Crypto’s Promises 15:36 Are We Early? 17:35 Crypto’s Successes 20:23 Crypto’s Biggest Failures 21:50 Banks 26:22 Education Problem 28:10 The Future of Crypto 33:34 What’s Wrong with the Internet? 35:27 The Money Side of Crypto 37:38 Web2 to Web3 42:23 Starry-Eyed Optimism 54:04 Public Goods 1:02:00 Hyperfinancialization 1:05:55 Show Me Fix It 1:08:34 Environmental Impact 1:13:31 Crypto Idealists 1:16:52 Surveillance & Changing Business Models 1:20:40 Wikipedia 1:25:17 Decentralization 1:26:23 Advice For Crypto People 1:27:44 Closing, Resources, & Disclaimers
------ Resources:
Molly White https://twitter.com/molly0xFFF
web3 is going just great https://twitter.com/web3isgreat
----- Not financial or tax advice. This channel is strictly educational and is not investment advice or a solicitation to buy or sell any assets or to make any financial decisions. This video is not tax advice. Talk to your accountant. Do your own research.
Disclosure. From time-to-time I may add links in this newsletter to products I use. I may receive commission if you make a purchase through one of these links. Additionally, the Bankless writers hold crypto assets. See our investment disclosures here: https://www.bankless.com/disclosures
No summary for this episode yet.
We're still here. Welcome to Bankless, where we explore the frontier of internet money and internet finance. This is how to get started, how to get better, how to front run the opportunity. This is Ryan Sean Adams. I'm here with David Hoffman, and we're here to help you become more bankless. Guys, a crypto skeptic take today. Just some context for the episode you're about to hear. We have Molly White on the episode, the title of which is Web3 is going great. David and I recorded this just over a month ago on October 7th with Molly. It's been in our queue to get it out. We've had a lot of podcasts in queue.
We had it targeted for release today, the day that you are listening to it. So November 14th, I believe you'll be listening to this episode for the first time. Molly did not have the context of the FTX meltdown as we're going into this. So as you are listening to this episode, put yourself in the place of the crypto industry a month ago before the events unfolded for FTX. I'm going to get into some of the claims that Molly makes in this episode, but David, do you want to give us some more context for where we've come since our original episode recording with Molly? Yeah, certainly. During this episode with Molly, we met the person that can critique Web3 the best.
And Molly is a software engineer, a very experienced one. She's also a contributor towards Wikipedia. And so there's some Web3 valence, Web3 ethos valence that she has, like contributing to the open commons of knowledge, knows how to code. And she's somebody that knows the difference. And I think I really appreciated Molly when she made claims that like critiquing the lack of scalability of these systems is like not the right critique or critiquing like the energy of Bitcoin isn't really the best critique. But so her critiques of what she was talking about go straight to the heart of Web3. They are real criticisms.
And so that is the frame of mind that we can go into this. And like Ryan said, we recorded this a month ago. We've just been holding it in the pocket. And then the FTX debacle happened. So we actually are re-recording the intro to this podcast that you are now listening to because we had to update it. And I think just because of this FTX debacle, it's certainly hitting a little harder for me as to how this industry looks to the people that are not yet believers. And I think that is the frame of mind that it will be useful to go into this episode. It's like, damn, sometimes it's pretty hard to justify what we're up to in this industry.
And I think Molly comes and shares that perspective. Well, Molly had a lot of critical takes before the FTX thing actually just happened. So you can imagine what she would add to this. And overall, I do think she is a good skeptic, and we need more of those in the crypto space, of course. So a few things we get into this episode. Molly's central claim, why Web3 is not going so great. This was even prior to FTX. Number two, why she thinks tokens actually make everything worse. Interesting point there. and why despite acknowledging some of the good in crypto and Web3, Molly believes crypto is a net negative for the world and probably will be in the near future.
I think her claims got a little bit stronger after the week's events. Of course, David and I have a debrief after the episode, which we've recorded on October 7th as well. So you can hear our frame of mind. Then if you are a Bankless premium subscriber, you get access to that. I can't even remember everything we said at this point in time, David. but some hot takes post this conversation that I actually want to listen to again and see how well they hold up. We've gone through the portal of this FTX debacle and now the frame of mind is just completely different. And I think it is going to be interesting to see what we said back then, a lifetime ago.
I'm so curious. Anyway, if you want access to the debrief episode, of course, it's on the Bankless Premium podcast. You can upgrade to a premium membership. There's a link in the show notes. Guys, we are going to get right to our episode with Molly. But before we do, we want to thank the sponsors that made this possible. for managing your crypto and NFTs on the go because it connects to your phone with Bluetooth and has a nice big screen for easy transaction readings. Ledger has also upgraded the iconic Ledger Nano S and made the new Ledger Nano S device more DeFi and NFT friendly, making it the perfect hardware wallet for beginners.
Ledger has truly maximized for both ease of use and security. So discover which Ledger device is best suited for your journey by going and visiting shop.ledger.com. The Layer 2 era is upon us. Ethereum's Layer 2 ecosystem is growing every day and we need Layer 2 bridges to be fast and efficient in order to live a Layer 2 life. Across is the fastest, cheapest, and most secure cross-chain bridge. With Across, you don't have to worry about high fees or long wait times. Assets are bridged and available for use almost instantaneously. Across's bridges are powered by UMA's optimistic oracle to securely transfer tokens between Layer 2s and Ethereum.
Across's critical ecosystem infrastructure and Across V2 has just launched. Their new version focuses on higher capital efficiency, Layer 2 to Layer 2 transfers, and a brand new chain with Polygon, all while prioritizing high security and low fees. You can be a part of Across' story by joining their Discord and using Across for all of your Layer 2 transferring needs. So go to across.to to quickly and securely bridge your assets between Ethereum, Optimism, Polygon, Arbitrum, or BOBA networks. Arbitrum One is pioneering the world of secure Ethereum scalability and is continuing to accelerate the Web3 landscape.
Hundreds of projects have already deployed on Arbitrum One, producing flourishing DeFi and NFT ecosystems. With the recent addition of Arbitrum Nova, gaming and social dApps like Reddit are also now calling Arbitrum home. Both Arbitrum One and Nova leverage the security and decentralization of Ethereum and provide a builder experience that's intuitive, familiar, and fully EVM compatible. On Arbitrum, both builders and users will experience faster transaction speeds with significantly lower gas fees. With Arbitrum's recent migration to Arbitrum Nitro, it's also now 10 times faster than before.
Visit arbitrum.io where you can join the community, dive into the developer docs, bridge your assets, and start building your first app. With Arbitrum, experience Web3 development the way it was meant to be. Secure, fast, cheap, and friction-free. Bankless Nation, we are super excited to introduce you to Molly White today. She's a crypto critic. She's also an experienced software engineer. She's been a longtime Wikipedia editor. We thank her for her Wikipedia service. It's a website I use every day. She also cares very deeply about free and open access to high quality information and things that we definitely value in crypto and at Bankless.
And recently, Molly has been doing a lot of critical speaking about crypto, about this thing called Web3. She covers this in her website. It's called Web3 is Going Just Great. And it chronicles all the headlines of all the grift, hacks, toxicity going on in crypto. Marvelous website. I enjoyed a lot. Molly, welcome to Bankless. Thanks for having me. So this is going to be a fun conversation, I think. And really, we want to get out of our crypto bubbles and hear your perspective during this conversation, Molly. But let's start with this question. So how great is Web3 really going? Well, the title is a little bit sarcastic.
You know, when I first created the site, I was trying to figure out what Web3 even was. And like what was what it was all about and every time i was looking for stuff i kept coming across things where i was like wow this doesn't seem like it's going so great and so that's sort of where the title came from i uh i love it and uh so for for folks that can see we're we're going to share this uh on youtube but if you're listening to this the title is web3 is going just great and the subtitle is and it's definitely not an enormous grift that's pouring lighter fluid on an already smoldering planet. That is the tone.
And I'm looking at a few of the more recent, this is as of October 6th, the headlines like Celsius, they just exposed the names of all their customers and their recent transactions. Of course, bankless listeners will be familiar with Celsius's shenanigans. Also on October 6th, the Binance smart chain just halted. We also have South Korea reportedly freezing 40 million from Do Kwon, Zcash suffering attacks. It's kind of all of the bad news, I would say, in crypto. Molly, give us a sense for some of these headlines, how you select them from an editorial perspective, and what the website itself is trying to accomplish.
So, well, I guess I'll start with what I'm trying to accomplish with the website, which is when I created it back in the fall and winter of last year, you know, crypto was really on a bull run. Prices were at almost all time highs. People were really buying into a lot of the mania. And it felt like a lot of the headlines that I was seeing, even in mainstream media, but also in the crypto press, were around people becoming overnight millionaires and putting a ton of money into crypto and then becoming super wealthy and saving their families because of crypto. And it felt like there was not all that much attention being given to where things were going really poorly.
And even when crypto was on a bull run, there were a lot of examples of things going really, really badly where projects would get hacked or someone would get their wallets would be compromised or some of them were just really bad ideas of projects that people were thinking up that they were like, we're going to do this, but on the blockchain. And so I was kind of hoping to provide sort of the alternate perspective, or at least just like a little bit of balance to some of the reporting to say that like, hey, not everyone is becoming a millionaire overnight. And maybe if you put your retirement money into this, it won't be there in a couple of months.
So that's really the goal is just to say that, like, you know, despite some of the really, you know, the boosterism, there's also a lot to be concerned about. As far as how I select, you know, articles for the site, it mostly has to do with, I mean, any example of something going really poorly, any loss that's over like $100,000 or so, I usually will include. But I also try to really highlight some of the examples where people as individuals are getting hurt. So, So even if a person isn't losing an amount of money that would be significant to an institution, I still will often put it in there if it's really significant to them, just because I think that's also been a pretty big issue where people will put money that they really can't afford to lose into crypto and then something goes wrong.
Did you ever think you'd have this much content, Molly? Yeah, I didn't fully expect it to be like multiple posts a day. Molly, there's a lot of people in crypto. I think Bankless would be a part of this group of people that are perpetually optimistic and perpetually bullish. We can really only see the best of what crypto has to offer. Some might call us the people that are handing out the Kool-Aid, if you will. So this effort is the opposite. It's the anti-Kool-Aid. It's trying to say, hey, there's all these crypto believers that are up only believers and they can't really see the negative side.
And so you're trying to sober us up with this website. Is that kind of the goal? I think so. Although, you know, I think with some of the true believers, you know, the really idealistic folks, there's only so much that can really be done on that. But, you know, I think it is important, regardless of what technology you're interested in, to sort of pay attention to the potential downsides, where people can get hurt if they're using it, you know, the risks that people are being exposed to. And then, you know, I also try to reach some of the people who are still kind of on the fence around crypto and they're trying to decide, you know, is this actually a good place to invest my money?
You know, should I be taking big bets on crypto? Are all of those really sparkling headlines actually true? You know, so I think it's kind of a multifaceted approach. So would you say that you are like anti-crypto or are you just saying, seeing that there's an imbalance in the narrative space and you're trying to counterbalance it? I would say that I am anti-crypto. For what it has been promising, it has not lived up to a lot of those promises. And the promises have been really big lately. I mean, crypto has been around for a while, but the sort of Web3 hype and a lot of the talk around it becoming a really mainstream part of the financial system and even society, you know, those are really big promises.
And so far, the technology doesn't seem to have really lived up to that, nor have a lot of the people who are building in the crypto space. Can we talk about some of those promises, high level, Molly, just to get kind of your framing of it? So from your perspective, what promises do you think crypto has made to the world? What checks has it written? and how many of those checks have been cashed? Which ones are falling short? Well, I mean, like anything, it really depends on who you talk to. So there are some people out there who will say that, you know, crypto is really just for speculation and, you know, that's it, which I would probably say, okay, it has served well as a speculative asset for people who are interested in that type of thing.
But when you start to look at some of the promises that are being made by really big names in the crypto space, by some of the VCs who've been jumping in. It's stuff around becoming a major part of the financial system, in some cases even replacing traditional finance when you get to some of the more extremes. There's a lot of talk around banking the unbanked and fixing the widespread inequality in the financial system, providing services to people who have not had access to them, serving as a better store of value than some stores of value that we have today. I mean, the list kind of goes on depending on who you're talking to.
Becoming a pillar of the web as we know it is a big one with Web3. People talking about blockchains really underpinning every service you use online. And so far, I don't think any of those checks have been cashed. There have been instances where you could argue that Bitcoin or something like that has served as a store of value, assuming that you're willing to take two specific points on the timeline and compare them rather than the highs and the lows or depending on when someone actually needs that store of value. But besides that, it's not replaced web technology, it is not banked the unbanked.
What would you say to the statement just like, it's early. was created in 2009, but also Bitcoin didn't really open up many of the doors that created those narratives, like replacing parts of the internet. That was like more, that came after Ethereum. That was, Ethereum brought that. So Ethereum brought that in like 2015. So like what, we've got like seven years of Ethereum history and most of Ethereum's history and development has really happened in like the last four or five years. So what would you say to the response of just like, yo, we're still trying to figure it out, but the vision is still here.
Like the foundation is still here. Yeah, so that comes up a lot. I think in the tech world, you know, five or 10 years is actually a pretty long time. Things move faster in technology than they do in a lot of other industries, just because of, you know, you don't have to set up a manufacturing plant or something like that, you know, there isn't that sort of upfront cost. And so, you know, I still would have expected a little more by now as far as, you know, becoming a really stable part of technologies that people are using day to day that are actually deployed and like being used by real people.
I also think that, you know, there hasn't been a great explanation of even how we will get to the point where crypto banks the unbanked or, you know, underpins the whole web. There's a lot of people who will say things like, well, once we fix the scaling and the transaction costs and the privacy issues, then it'll be something that everyone uses every day. But that's a big leap to say, well, when we just fix all of those problems, it'll be perfect. Which that's true of a lot of things. Once we fix all of the emissions problems with fossil fuels, then we'll have no climate change problems. But that's actually not possible, right?
At least today, we have no clear way of getting there. So most people aren't seeing things like that. What would you say, Amali, to some of the success that may be? I'm sure you wouldn't argue that there haven't been some successes in crypto, but some of the successes, maybe a few notable things. Of course, the total crypto market cap is over a trillion dollars, right? I know that's price. But if you pick an asset like Bitcoin, for example, for any four or five year period that you've held Bitcoin has appreciated relative to the dollar. And for a Bitcoin advocate, they are not promising no volatility, certainly.
HODL has been an adage for that community from the very beginning. They are promising that it will hold up to the dollar, which is going through kind of a debasing type of experience. And Bitcoin is not. So something like that. But we could also take decentralized finance and we see a use case like stable coins, which are like borderless dollars. There's over 100 billion in stable coins out there. The Ethereum network itself did about the value transfer of the Visa network last year. Uniswap, a smart contract protocol born, what, three, four years ago, did over a trillion in value, kind of this permissionless open ecosystem.
system, what would you say to some of those successes? Do you just think that they're just kind of niche and not significant compared to the promises, the checks that were written? Or do you think that there could be something early that might manifest later and you're still holding out hope? I mean, I think a lot of the successes of crypto are a little bit hard to measure, I think. You know, things like market cap are really hard to measure in crypto where things can be double counted pretty easily and tokens are often being overinflated. So I have a healthy amount of skepticism when it comes to things like market cap.
You know, I think that there are people using crypto. I think that's sort of hard to argue. But as far as the use cases that are being promised and the idea that stablecoins are a better option in some cases, or for things other than trying to get into the crypto ecosystem, I think that's a little bit hard to argue. I also don't know if stablecoins on the whole have been purely successful. There have been a lot of issues with stablecoins, there are a lot of questions around a lot of remaining stable coins. You're probably referring to Luna and Terra as one of those, quote unquote, stable coin failures that happened earlier this year.
I'm curious, from your perspective, as you've watched crypto more closely over the last year or two, what are some of the most colossal failures that you've seen? What's kind of the the biggest evidence to support your points? Well, I think Terra Luna is a pretty good example. Not only the collapse of that specific coin, but also all of the sort of ripple effects that it had throughout crypto where other projects were using the anchor protocol or had exposure to Terra. I think the failures of some of the other institutions like Celsius, that's been pretty spectacular. You know, people having a lot of money locked up in Celsius and who truly believed that it was like a safe place to put their money and it was better than banks in some situations.
So I think that's another really good example. And then, you know, some of the huge hacks that have been happening lately, especially when it comes to crypto bridges. You know, I feel like every time I read something about a blockchain bridge, it's because like 100 plus million dollars were just exploited. There have been a couple of those. So yeah, I think those are probably my top three. I think we definitely as an industry should take responsibility and ownership over why people in the outside part of the world are considering these things like DeFi and Web3, right? Celsius, in hindsight, was a bank.
And this guy, Alex Mashinsky wore this like shirt that said like, you know, let's bring down the banks. And it was like it had DeFi on the back end, but it was like a centralized institution that took customers deposits. And as an industry, we kind of just like let it go on because nothing really bad was happening. But nothing bad does happen when prices go up, right? It's always when prices go down. And then there's also like kind of the issue, the definitional issue of all of these cross-chain bridges, which are used multi-sigs, which is kind of like a bank with some limitations, but not enough limitations, right?
So as an industry, we do have this like definition problem where we don't actually know how to label these things because they are new, they are like net new to the world. And so as a result, we get it. It's labeled like crypto. It's what crypto is. It's what DeFi is. It's what Web three is. Even though like these things have gotten like blurred and honestly like bastardized, some of the pure crypto native products that are supposed to not do these things. What do you what do you think when you hear this? Well, I would say that I wouldn't call them a bank because I think that's actually what got a lot of people really drawn into Celsius is that they were told that Celsius was a bank.
And when they read that, they were like, great, my money is safe. You know, if you put money into a bank in the United States and the bank suddenly explodes, you don't lose all your money. Right. It's insured by the FDIC. And I think people thought that they were getting those kinds of protections with Celsius and especially with Voyager, which had actually sort of implied that they were protected by the same FDIC insurance. And so like when you say bank, people get a really specific idea in their head that is not what crypto, you know, what Celsius and Voyager and other sort of centralized exchanges are providing.
I think from a terminology perspective, when we talk about bank on bank lists, which is what the show is called, like we're trying to go self-sovereign without banks. What David was referring to is there's kind of a, when we say bank, we have sort of a negative connotation in it. And not applying this to outside of crypto, although we do often apply it to financial institutions that are banks outside of crypto, but crypto banks themselves. When David says banks, he means that there is a hidden trust vector there, that it is a siloed institution that doesn't have transparency, where you're actually depending on a set of individuals.
In this case, Alex Mashinsky, who you had to trust. And so David was using it in a, well, it turned out to be a bank in that a lot of people thought what they were doing was self-sovereign. And I just deposit here and, you know, it's transparent. It's fully open the way decentralized finance is. What it turned out is they were depositing funds into a closed bank that Alex Mashinsky could like deploy however he wanted with his group of executives and withdraw funds. So it implies this trust vector. But I think I take your wider point, that is, a lot of these, and we've been critical of this as well, a lot of these interest accounts, whether it's an anchor or whether it's in Celsius, are marketed as if they are risk-free to retail in the terminology of bank, which people think of as FDIC, insured, this thing is completely safe, and they're certainly not those things.
Yeah. And I think there were sort of people in both camps in the Celsius instance. You know, I've read a lot of the letters that people sent to the judge in the bankruptcy case. And there were some people who absolutely believed it was like a bank in the sense of like stability and, you know, you're not going to lose access to your funds. There were also definitely people who thought it was more of a self-sovereign thing. And there was one person I remember who wrote in and said that because USDC made all of these guarantees around being tradable one for one with a US dollar, how is it possible that her money was locked up in something like Celsius?
And it's like she almost didn't realize there was an intermediary there that was controlling her money. So I think it's, yeah, I think it maybe goes both ways. Do you think that that makes this more of an education problem than it is really like a structural Web3 crypto problem? I think every I think there's always an education problem in finance and technology, actually. You know, crypto especially is really you can get in the weeds really fast. And, you know, even with the project that I run, you know, I find people who follow the project and who are clearly like pretty interested in crypto, either because they like it or they don't.
But, you know, who have a fairly decent knowledge of it, who also sort of misunderstand things. You know, I've had I posted about the Celsius disclosure of all their customer names the other day. And someone was like, wow, so much for DeFi. And it's like, well, no, Celsius isn't DeFi. You know, but those are a lot of to a lot of people that's like they have no idea what that means. Can I just say, can I just pause and say I very much appreciate that you're getting to that level of detail, even with the critiques, because many crypto critics do not do that. I think, you know, in addition to all of the grifters and scammers we see in the crypto community, I think there are many crypto critics who sort of don't actually take the time to understand what they're criticizing.
and I've read countless articles after the Celsius implosion about how this was an example of DeFi and look how broken DeFi is. And I just wanted to go to the reporter and say, hey, this is not DeFi at all. Like, don't throw us in with those people. Like, this is not what this industry is about. In fact, nothing was transparent or decentralized about this entire operation. And so there's that element as well. But I definitely appreciate the work you're doing here. I guess one high-level comment I'd say, Molly, is I think you'll find that many people in crypto, David and myself, and I think a lot of Bankless listeners included, will look at all of the events that you just mentioned.
The scams, the grifters, the Celsius, the irresponsibility of BlockFi, the three arrows capital, like margin craziness shenanigans, the Luna Terra, Doquan, you know, die must die. Ronin sidechain, wormhole sidechain. All of it. We can go down the list. You'll find many of us have been calling these things out the entire time. And also after the fact, also emphasize how this does not represent crypto values. It's not what our community and our industry stands for. So we kind of stand, I think, in support with you on that. But one difference, I think, and I want to get some clarity is, as David mentioned, he called us perma bulls, right, at the outset of the show.
And that's because like, it doesn't mean that prices won't go down and think you can't, you know, it doesn't mean that you won't lose 90% in a certain cycle. But we are bullish over the long run, over the 5 to 10 to 20 year time cycle, that this entire thing that is being built in crypto is not only going to appreciate in price, that aside, but it's actually going to be good for the world. It's going to be a net benefit. It's going to actually help humanity in ways that are not the same, but are similar to the level of the internet. This is another wave of the internet, if you will. And so we are long term, even though we see all the scams and the grift, we think crypto is a net positive for the world, not a net negative.
But I'm wondering if you disagree with that. So we talked about like, you know, current state, even some in crypto might argue that's been a net negative so far, but they're still in crypto because, and I would argue that's still net positive so far. But that aside, some people would say it's net negative, but they're still in crypto still building because they think we are building a brighter, better future. Do you think that this possibility even exists? Or do you think, are you kind of thinking that crypto is a net negative, not only now in its current form, but into the future as well? Like it's never going to be worth more than all of the effort and all of the grift and all of the negative externalities that have been pushed out by it.
What are your thoughts on this? Yeah, so I don't have strong hopes, I guess, for the future of crypto. But, you know, I would say that anything is possible. And, you know, I've said this before that, you know, my goal with the work that I'm doing is not to be able to look back, you know, 10 or 15 years from now and be like, ha, I was right. Crypto had no purpose. Nobody's using it. There are no blockchains in existence or whatever. To be able to say that, my goal is really to try to make sure that the web is a better place for the people who are using it. Which, you know, and if that means that in five years, you know, 10 years, all the problems are fixed.
Crypto is amazing. Everyone's using it. You know, I've got my wallet and I'm paying for my groceries with crypto or whatever it might be. That's fine. Like, if it's better and fixed, that's great. But, you know, in the same vein, if five or 10 years from now, people aren't getting scammed and, you know, they're not losing all their money and these things aren't blowing up every other day. because crypto turned out not to have any promise, that's also fine. You know, I just want to sort of make sure that everything is moving in a better direction. So, you know, broadly speaking, I don't have strong hopes for crypto.
You know, I think that for, you know, I would need to see pretty strong evidence that the technology has a lot of promise for the applications that it's being, I guess advertised for. And I haven't seen that yet. I haven't seen really compelling use cases of it yet that aren't doing things like, you know, basically taking advantage of the lack of regulation. But, you know, that's also something that can change, right? Like if someone finally comes up with that one Web3 project, it's like, dang, that is actually better than the alternative and, you know, is providing a useful service and isn't just taking advantage of the fact that it's being poorly regulated, then yeah, I'm like, I'm open to changing my views.
I'm not, I'm not, you know, totally stuck in the mud here, but I don't share your permable, I guess, perspective. That's probably pretty clear. Well, from a values perspective, you mentioned one thing, you want the web, you want to see the web be in a better place for those who are using it. So So maybe you are a maximalist, you're bullish on the web as a technology. And that seems to, I'm guessing here, Molly, because we don't know each other well yet, but like, I'm guessing your contribution to Wikipedia, contribution to kind of open source tools as an engineer, as a developer are all based on that belief.
I'm curious your perspective on like, is there anything wrong with the internet today? Do you think? Like, what are the problems with the internet? Like, what would you solve if you could wave a magic wand? Yeah, I mean, I've gone into this a little bit before in some of my writing where I actually share a lot of the same goals as a lot of the people who are working on Web3 projects. You know, people will talk about the extreme levels of surveillance that are happening on the web, the capture of the web by just a few small companies, you know, the lack of access to web projects and even to the internet in general.
You know, I think there's a lot of issues with the web that Web3 advocates talk about that I also really care about, you know, the really crazy way that platforms are being governed these days. You know, I would actually point to those same things. The difference is that I sort of don't see crypto as a great solution to those problems. You know, I tend to feel that problems with the web are really they tend to come down to problems with like society and the way that these communities are being built. And it's really tough to sort of fix a really societal problem with just a technology. you know I think that it's going to take something like societal sort of change and regulatory change on the web to really help with a lot of those issues and crypto I worry tends to go in sometimes the opposite direction with really sort of hyper financializing a lot of things and sort of taking trying to take sort of the side route to fixing those things without actually addressing a lot of the underlying issue.
And so you have common ground with the stated problems that the Web3 community might say about the existing internet. How about the stated problems with the money system? Because there's almost like two sides of crypto. There's kind of like tech, Web3 crypto, and then there's also like money crypto, which is like central banks are broken. Banks in general are kind of broken. They're inefficient. You can't program against them. They're not open. And so we have this thing called a non-sovereign store of value. And we have other primitives that we can create. And we want programmable money and we want a bankless money system.
Are you sympathetic to some of the problems that they point to? Or yeah, what are your thoughts on the money side of crypto? Yeah, I mean, so the money side of crypto is definitely further out of my area of expertise, I would say. I come from sort of a software background, not an econ background or a policy background. But, you know, I think that, again, a lot of people in crypto are identifying serious issues with banking. You know, there's a lot of issues with access to banking. There's high fees. It's slow. You know, there's all sorts of stuff. But I think also they tend to sometimes ignore the reasons for some of those issues.
You know, like a lot of the slowness is coming from regulatory intervention, for example. And so, you know, it's like you can make a faster system that's completely unregulated, but you also end up with a lot of the chaos that we've been seeing in crypto where, you know, your funds are gone, they're gone, and there's no, you know, recourse there or, you know, pick your example. So, you know, again, I think there are issues there. I think there are improvements that could definitely be made in the financial system. You know, some of the slowness, for example, does not need to exist. We live in a world where, you know, banks probably don't need to be on a nine to five schedule or, you know, other financial systems.
But, you know, I also sort of question crypto's ability to just sort of circumvent those issues and end up in a better state rather than address the issues themselves. So putting on my crypto optimist, crypto apologist hat, which fits very nicely, by the way, there's two sides of this crypto conversation. There's the web conversation, whereas our platforms are owned by some tech elites and they dictate what we say and they don't make us feel very empowered. And then there's also the banking situation, which it kind of feels like there's There's just these banking elites and they just like use our money as a way to generate revenue for themselves and not pass it back to the consumer and not really enable the consumer very well.
And I think the crypto take is that we've had these Web2 apps, Facebook, Twitter, Instagram, and their trajectory doesn't feel good for most people. Like their trajectory is bad. Facebook's causing civil wars. I don't know if that's the Web3 take. I think that may be the general take, but... Yeah, that's a general take, right? But the Web3 take is that there's kind of no fixing Web2. There's no way to hit the reverse button on Web2 and like, oh, that didn't work. Let's go back and go in a different route. And it's kind of the same take that we have with banking because of regulation. These regulations have entrenched winners in the banking system that has calcified the banking system.
And I think the Web3 take might even extend that to like the political system is like the political system is entrenched and not changing. And so while so many crypto people like talk about, look, we got all these use cases we got, we're going to fix the banks, we're going to fix the Web2 platforms, we're going to fix like social organization systems. It's like it's because we see like the trend of, you know, what the current state of the Internet is, is heading towards a dead end. And we also feel that with finance and we also feel that with politics and like social cohesion. And so like while crypto is coming in and not really necessarily like fixing things right off the bat, what we are kind of doing is we're like taking the cage and we're like rattling it and like, hey, we need to like shake some things up real quick.
And yeah, we're going to like break some stuff. But that's kind of what we need to go backwards to then progress forwards again into the future. How do you feel about this take? Well, I have said that one thing I think crypto does succeed in doing very well is highlighting issues that need to be addressed, whether it's with traditional finance, the web, whatever you want to call it. I think it has really made people more aware of issues in banking, which most people probably don't think a whole lot about. But now that people are focusing on crypto, I think they sort of do think about those things more.
Same with the web. But, you know, I think it's also, I sort of question the idea that the web is unfixably broken, that society, banking, politics are unfixably broken, because those are not things that really just go away. You know, like, it sort of depends how you define web two. But, like, if you talk about going from web two to web three, and you say that web two is unfixably broken and Web3 might be a path forward, a lot of Web3 relies on the current web that we have today. So depending on how you're defining Web2, I guess, like I don't really see how that follows. You could definitely, if you're defining Web2 as like large platform companies that are really controlling social media or something like that, then you could definitely make an argument for those going away in some form and being replaced with something else.
But if you're talking about Web2 as just sort of the web that we use today, like websites are still going to exist with Web3. You know, there's still going to be just sort of the underpinnings of the web. And so, you know, I don't really know how you can say that the web is intractably broken and should be replaced with something else unless you're talking about like kind of getting rid of the whole thing, which is definitely not what Web3 is trying to do. I think we're mainly focusing on our social media platforms, our web platforms, like the big ones that, you know, it used to be when I would go onto the internet, there would be like 20 websites that I would visit.
And now it's like three. Twitter, Facebook, Instagram, Amazon. So if that's sort of the way you're approaching it, then I sort of see what you're saying. Those things are really broken and we should replace them with Web3 or something like that. But by the same vein, if that's a possible way forward, why can't we say that those things are unfixably broken? Let's replace them with something else. Social communities with a better governance model, regulations that prevent companies from forming those enormous monopolies, federated social media, things like that. So one take on crypto for this is because what's really interesting, Molly, is that we see so many of the same problems that you do, right?
And crypto is saying, hey, we're trying to build something to fix some of these things. And at times, many times, I would say crypto is overly ambitious in its promises. And I don't think that token incentives don't help this, right? Because it incentivizes projects and founders to over-promise and then undeliver, right? And yet there is something here that I think is fresh and kind of different because crypto at its best can, we hope that it does, offer a different kind of governance model, if you will, at the root. But it's similar to me to, I know we've made this comparison in the past on Bankless, but like a constitution, right?
If you're trying to replace kings and dictators and emperors, what do you do? 1700s United States. You have to create a governance framework. You have to write a protocol. You have to put in some new legal code that gets social consensus, that balances out power, and is more credibly neutral. And at its best, that's what we see the hints of in technologies like Ethereum. It's credibly neutral. It's censorship resistant. It's peer-to-peer. It's decentralized. Anybody with an internet connection has the ability to open up a bank account, essentially. All they need is a private key, and it's theirs, right?
And this is a hopeful substrate. I personally don't know, Molly, if we'll ever get to the level of like replacing Facebook, right? Like I remember the early days in crypto, it's like people, my early days in crypto, people are talking about, let's just put Uber on a blockchain, right? And it'll be better Uber and the world will be magic. And of course, like it doesn't work this way at all. But there is hope. And we've seen some evidence, I think, at least us crypto bulls have, us perma, you know, optimists and evangelists, that what we are able to do is instantiate some of our values of decentralization, of credit neutrality in the base layer protocol.
And something that David and I often say on Bankless is if they adopt crypto protocols, they adopt crypto values. Like it's a new type of constitution. And this isn't to say that we shouldn't continue to try in our existing nation state governance frameworks to fix things and reform things, right? It's like, encourage people to buy crypto and vote. Like, you should still vote. You still need to participate actively in your democracy. This is not kind of a, like, you know, I'm sure you've heard sort of the Bitcoin tribe, Bitcoin maximalist tribe of a little bit like, we're going to buy a bunker and the world's going to, like, be destroyed.
And like, that is one subset of crypto that at Bankless, David and I do not resonate with at all. Let's try to fix the problems in our existing governments. But also, we have this other approach that is exploring a new frontier in the digital landscape. It just feels so much, Molly, like there's something there. And I guess I'm curious twofold. My question here is, one is, do you think that there might be something there? Or do you just think, look, you're starry-eyed dreamers, it's not going to work? And then secondly, if it's not this, Molly, like, what is it? Because to be honest, I don't have a lot of hope in our existing political system.
I mean, like, we've tried these things, our existing frameworks, our existing companies, Silicon Valley, like, what's going to shake the banks up? Unless it's some external startup technology that's like, hey, we can out-compete you. Hayden Adams can create a decentralized exchange with a $60,000 grant that can beat the NASDAQ in like five to 10 years, right? 10,000. I don't know what the range is. Some people have told me 10,000, 60,000, 120,000, some range. There were maybe multiple grants, David. Regardless, what do you think about this idea, Molly? Yeah, so I think I probably share some of your starry-eyed optimism around substrates when it comes to the web, right?
I think that a lot of what has been enabled by crypto has been enabled thanks to the web. Someone has an internet connection, they have access to the web and to building communities there and to organizing without needing to be within physical proximity to people and, you know, to participating in systems that are built in various ways that will allow them to do really powerful things. And I really do share that underlying system of thought. And, you know, decentralization is possible on the web without crypto. You know, there are ways of building, you know, collaborative governance systems on the web.
Um, you know, I like the sort of positive things that crypto is trying to do, but I also try to acknowledge some of the really negative things that I think threaten a lot of its future. You know, when we talk about governance in crypto, for example, so far, a lot of the government structures have operated around the token based model where you really your power in that project is completely, you know, correlated to how much money you've put into that project, which I think is the wrong direction for us to be going. these really pay to play models where if you don't have the capital, you can't even participate.
And if you don't have a ton of capital, you can't have an impact on a project. And so I started doing some research, you know, because I was reading about a lot of these DAOs that were set up in that way. And I was like, boy, that seems bad. And so I was trying to do a lot of research into, you know, okay, so how are other projects, you know, clearly, there are people in crypto who agree that that's not a great way of doing things. I don't think a lot of people think that's the optimal way of doing things. So I started, you know, doing a lot of research into so okay, so how are projects trying to solve this problem?
And things got worse when I started looking at that, you know, when I was looking at ways that projects were trying to do, you know, one person, one vote, that type of thing, it got really scary as far as privacy and some of the sort of sacrifices that you had to make in order to do those types of things. So, you know, I sort of worry about those types of, you know, trying to basically predicate everything on crypto because you start with an obvious governance model that has serious problems and you start trying to circumvent those problems and things just get worse and worse and worse is what it seems like to me.
You know, my thought is to build systems where you're not immediately fighting against the token based model. you know when you talk about how to replace banks you know and the the best way to do that is to out-compete them with you know some startup that's doing things in a really genius way you know that seems sort of to be really leaning into the sort of capitalist model that we're already stuck with at this point and saying okay the only solution to capitalism is hyper capitalism and you know just gotta compete and you know let the free market decide and then we can overthrow the banks or whatever.
And again, that seems like the wrong direction. I feel like financializing everything, making everything that people are doing into this really hypercapitalized, financialized transaction feels antisocial and detrimental to society, to community, to the web. So yeah, I think I'm starry-eyed about the future of the web. I am not starry-eyed about the future of crypto? One of the stories that crypto proponents will like to bring up is the story of Uber. Uber tried to issue equity to all of its Uber drivers, but they just couldn't for a variety of reasons. There was too much overhead. The regulations for doing this were too ridiculous.
They just couldn't figure out a way of transferring equity from company to contributor, to the drivers. And then this like airdrop meta happened where Uniswap airdropped like 30% of its token supply straight to users, previous users, previous contributors to the protocol. And they did it with like the snap of the fingers. And so we like to use this example as like a contrast between like the previous systems, the systems without private keys, because there was private keys that specifically enabled this. We had this Ethereum address, So you could just like as a destination to deposit a symbol of equity, a symbol of ownership, a symbol of power to the users.
And so, yes, one take is that, yes, this is kind of like hyper financialization. We're creating more financial assets and providing them to more and more people. But also at the same time, like the paradigm that we came from wasn't really able to support a large diffusion of capital and power to a wide number of individuals. Like and to us, this is like just a huge success story. When you hear that story, what do you hear? I mean, that Uber wasn't able to do it doesn't seem all that compelling to me. There are plenty of examples of co-ops that function pretty well. So I guess I don't know a lot about the Uber story, but it does seem like we probably don't need crypto to make that happen.
We might need better changes to basically the financial and regulatory framework to make that smoother. But co-ops do exist and mutual organizations have been operating for a really long time. The Brave Wallet is your secure multi-chain on-ramp into Web3 and is built directly into the Brave privacy browser. Gone are the days of managing multiple wallet extensions that put you at risk of phishing, spoofs, and tracking. With the Brave Wallet, you can securely manage your crypto assets across more than 100 different chains, including Ethereum, Layer 2s, Solana, and more, all without downloading risky extensions.
The Brave Wallet is easy to set up and removes the headache of jumping between wallets and extensions. It's lightweight but packed with great features, like built-in token swaps, buying and holding NFTs with a gallery view, and support for hardware wallets. But also much more than that, because Brave is shipping new features every single month with a mission to make Web3 easier to navigate for its over 55 million users. Wallet extensions are a thing of the past. So get started with Brave's Web3 ready browser today and experience a decentralized web seamlessly without all the clutter. You can download the browser at brave.
com slash bankless and click the wallet icon to get started. If you've been listening to Bankless, you know that we're fans of the modular blockchain thesis. The idea that blockchains will separate execution from data availability and consensus, allowing all three to become the best versions of themselves. And Fuel has built the fastest modular execution layer in the industry. By supporting parallel transaction execution, Fuel unlocks significantly faster throughput for the Web3 world. Fuel also goes beyond the limitations of the EVM with its own FuelVM, which is more efficient and optimized, opening up the design space for developers.
And lastly, Fuel brings a powerful developer experience with its own domain-specific language, Sway, and a supportive toolchain called Fork. With Fuel, you can have the benefits of smart contract languages like Solidity while adopting the improvements made by the Rust tooling ecosystem. letting the fuel development environment go beyond the limitations of the EVM. If you want to learn more, there's a link in the show notes to see how you can get involved with a fuel network. What about this idea, Molly, I know you've come back a few times to this idea of hyper-capitalism and being kind of a negative, right?
And like, you know, plutocratic token votes. And we certainly agree with your point and take your point about that. What about this idea of public goods that we're creating? I mean, the Internet protocols, the adoption of protocols like TCPIP and other layers of the Internet stack, they're not owned by anyone specifically, right? They're kind of a public good for all of humanity. Open source code works very much the same way. Wikipedia, for goodness sakes, this is like open source public good for the world. I don't know. You're in the inner beast of Wikipedia, so you might have a different opinion on that, more informed opinion on that.
But this idea is not just that we are creating kind of like new corporations and LLCs and tokenized private capital entities, but we are creating new public substrate. So, for example, now with Ethereum, as I said earlier, anybody all over the world, let's imagine for a minute that some element of the DeFi optimists are right. And there is this DeFi banking system on Ethereum. Well, what that would mean, and it's good. It's like comparable to maybe better than the kind of banking system you might get in the West, in the developed West, right? Or something like this, even though I think the West's banking system kind of sucks in lots of ways.
But let's say it's that. Well, now what have you done? As a public good, you have somebody in India, Africa, all over the world. All they need is an internet connection. They have the ability to spin up and access a bank account. How would they get access to these sort of financial tools? They don't have to pay anything in order to do this. There are gas fees and this sort of thing. This is the scalability conversation. We're trying to fervently and feverishly make those gas fees go down. But the idea would be they just spin up an account. And just like they have a keyboard, they have an internet connection, they're plugged in to this communication network.
Well, they could be plugged into this ownership network, this property rights system that is crypto native. No one can tell them not. At some level, I guess I'm saying is there is a lens where you could look at crypto and focus on all of like the perverse incentives that happen when money gets injected into the system. But maybe are you missing the public good side of what we're also creating here, which is like, I mean, Uniswap, anyone can use Uniswap. It's a, you know, anyone can spin up an ERC-20 and create their own business. Anyone has access to a stable coin from any part of the world. What about this side of crypto seems much less capitalist and much more public goods?
Yeah, so this kind of gets into what I touched on earlier, where a lot of the arguments for crypto and Web3, you end up in discussions where it's like, okay, but what if we fix all the problems and then everyone has access to this perfect banking system? And it's like, yeah, I want that too. Let's fix all the problems and have a perfect banking system, which is great. But I have not yet seen how we're going to just fix all the problems. You know, I think that creating open source software, creating networks that everyone has access to, those are great things. I think, you know, public goods are far more important than we tend to treat them as a society.
But I don't think that solely because something is a public good that it is also going to be the future of society. I mean, like there's a lot of open source software out there that's wonderful, but I don't think it's going to overtake the banking system. And I don't think it's, you know, the the the, you know, makes the developers all perfect and wonderful people. So, you know, I think that I think that creating a public good is definitely a good thing. But I don't know if it is the argument for why something should exist. So, Molly, your comment is kind of like, yeah, cool, Ryan, show me first.
Right. Like that system doesn't really exist. I don't need to see it, you know, deployed and working and wonderful. I just need a plausible path from where we are today to where we are in 10, 15 years when this utopia has been achieved. And nothing about Uniswap and a MetaMask wallet and a protocol like Maker or Aave or Compound, nothing about these tools that exist today kind of show a glimpse to you of what that future could be. Do you still think these things are too niche? No. So it's not to say that there aren't crypto projects that are doing cool things. I think decentralized networks in general are interesting and cool.
And I think there are crypto projects that are providing value to people that are helping people. The thing that I don't, the thing that I really try to make clear is that it is the negative sides of things that I see as being almost intractable, potentially intractable, and sort of not offsetting, or rather offsetting the good that a lot of these projects are trying to do. And so, you know, when we talk about things like, you know, removing the money from the system because money is having such a negative impact. I don't see how that's possible with crypto because crypto is predicated on being, you know, the only way you really maintain a network when you get down to it, a decentralized network with crypto, you know, the way that that happens is by paying people with money and, you know, requiring money to use the system.
So, you know, there have been people who have been like, well, what if we just ignore the tokens, ignore the crypto tokens, we'll just look at Web3. It's like, how are you going to use Web3 without the token? How are you going to use the Ethereum network if you don't have any ETH? I think you can't just separate things like that and say, well, ignore all the bad stuff for a second. What about the good stuff? This is why it's a net negative to you in your mind because you're like, hey, Bangla Skies, the negatives are a 10 in terms of minus 10 for the world. bad, all of these things. And you do acknowledge the positive, but maybe that's just a two, right?
And so you got a negative 10 versus a plus two, and you still get negative eight. It's a net negative for the world. And you see that even if crypto is more successful, it's always going to be kind of net negative because you are seeing these sort of harmful types of incentive structures and influences and like core, I guess, like core grift and scam inside of the system. Is this right? Yeah. I mean, if you just look at the history of crypto, you know, as crypto has become more successful, more mainstream, more widely adopted, the grift and the scam and the harm that it has done has also grown enormously.
You'd say proportionally. It's just like... At least, I would say. And so, you know, if that pattern suddenly stops and like, okay, we fix all the grift and the scam and the, you know, the issues with, you know, people evading regulations and blah, blah, blah, you know, fix all of that. And we just keep the good stuff. Great. I think that's great. You know, it's like what I said at the beginning. You know, if we fix all the problems and we end up with only the good stuff, you know, I'm not going to still be here waving my flag about how crypto is the worst thing in the world. But I don't see the credible way that we can get to that future state where all the bad stuff just magically disappears and these wonderful utopian visions continue to persist.
On the note of the hyper-financialization of society, the way that I try and reframe this and the worry here is that like, cool, we have this new primitive as the ERC-20 token. We also have NFTs and now people can mint all these tokens and they can go everywhere and they can inject their way into society. And a lot of people are worried about this because there's many aspects of society that perhaps finance should like stay out of, perhaps money should stay out of. The way that I try and reframe this is that, yes, there's the line we are a hyper financializing like culture. But also I try and flip it around and I say we're actually injecting culture into our finance.
We can't have one without the other. So you're putting finance into culture, but you're also putting taking culture and you're all actually culture is corrupting finance. And I'm using corrupting in like a good way. And so people are saying, I guess, like we're hyper financializing our culture and finance is coming into corrupt culture for the bad. But I would like to say, like, actually, you're allowing culture to become expressed in these financial assets. And I think we really saw this in, which was the bull market of 2021 when NFTs, while there are many like, you know, JPEGs that are collectibles and they're kind of Ponzi schemes and they're kind of just like, sweet, you're buying this like picture of a monkey for a quarter million dollars.
It makes no sense. While that money could have definitely have gone to better uses. There's also artists that are making real neat art that are tokenizing their art with NFTs and selling those NFTs on the internet because art collectors want to collect those things. And so we are financing new culture. We're financing new art that I don't think we could have done in a web two way, not without like Apple taking a 30% cut on the iOS store or, you know, Facebook or Instagram wanting a slice of it. And so this era, this part is like, yes, we are putting finance into art in ways that make some people uncomfortable, but we're also economically, we're making a lot more art economically viable by the creation of NFTs.
And while it is definitely not the dominant use case of NFTs, a lot of it's like the monkey JPEG speculation, it is a real part that is actually putting food on the table for a lot of new artists. What would you say to this reframing of the NFT financialization side of things? Yeah. I mean, so I wrote a whole essay about sort of the idea of NFTs enabling digital art and empowering artists. And I can go into it if you want, but it's also kind of a long rant. I don't necessarily think that it was the crypto itself that specifically enabled artists to be paid. You know, the new idea with NFTs is sort of this idea of like digital scarcity, where people are assigning value to digital art in a similar sort of frame of mind as they do to physical paintings and things like that, right?
But, you know, you can do that without crypto. You know, you could digitally sign a piece of artwork and upload it somewhere and then people could check it and see that I own, you know, some piece of artwork. And you can incredibly do that. It's really the sort of cultural change that people were willing to assign enormous amounts of value to NFTs associated with digital art that has helped artists. And it has. Again, I will acknowledge that there are artists who have benefited from NFTs. But it was really the speculative bubble around NFTs that has enabled artists to get paid. if there had been a speculative bubble around you know pgp signed pieces of artwork you know it could have been the same thing do i think it's necessarily likely that that would have emerged no but i also don't think that it's really crypto it's the speculative side of things that sort of made that possible i feel like the maybe the the thought on that or pushback on that molly is you know in the same way you're saying basically hey everything you guys are saying sounds great but show me because it's not happening yet.
I feel like optimists in crypto could say the same thing to the existing system. Sure, the existing banking system could be better. Sure, it could serve underserved populations. Sure, artists could create a PGP signed piece of art and actually earn an income, but that's not happening. So existing system, show us. Meanwhile, while you're trying to show us we're going to be building stuff over here to actually make these possibilities happen what would you say to that kind of pushback yeah i mean so i think the the thing about the nfts is that you know a lot of people will say like well we hate the speculative bubble we like that it's helping artists and my point is that you know helping artists was not i don't know how possible that is without the speculative bubble right um and so i think that that's really something that's key to focus on when it comes to NFTs.
As far as the sort of general argument around like, show me, fix it. You know, I think that that's a very reasonable point. I think there are serious issues with the existing system that we have today. But I also don't see the, you know, externalities of crypto adding to that very much. You know what I mean? Like by saying we're going to replace it with this other system, I would hope that that system would be better than the current system, not worse. And so, you know, although I appreciate that people are working towards creating a better system, you know, if they're doing it in a way that I think is actually net negative and is harmful to people, I think that's important to say.
You know, I think there's a lot of talk in crypto around like, just let us build, you know, would you shut up, Molly, and let us build? You know, I get that a lot. And it's like, I get it. I love that people want to just build stuff, but we've also got decades of history of tech companies just building stuff and then going, whoops, guess we accidentally started civil wars, or guess there's this huge issue with radicalization online that we just completely ignored. And so I think that pointing out the issues when people are talking about revolutionizing something with technology is critical, regardless of the end state.
I think it will either help to empower the Web3 end state in what I imagine would be your best case scenario, or it will help us avoid ending up with a system that is worse than what we're already dealing with today. Actually, so my take on that is we definitely do not want you to shut up, Molly. We want you to keep speaking. So here's my hidden agenda in this is actually like you seem so smart and knowledgeable about things that even many people inside of crypto who are buying monkey JPEGs have no idea about that. Like my hidden agenda is actually to recruit you internally. Like we want all of the good skeptics, you know, as a selfish builder side of things, who's optimistic about this community, what we're doing.
We want them internal to help us fix things. uh and uh yeah so keep up the the good work even if you decide to always hate crypto please uh keep us honest we definitely appreciate that um let me ask you yeah no i was not accusing you of being one of the shut up and let us build people but it is a very common refrain let me ask you because i know you've also been been been critical of um uh you know energy consumption um particularly on the Bitcoin Ethereum side of things. One example where I feel like, and I want you to keep me honest here, crypto has made tremendous strides is recently with Ethereum.
So, you know, forever it said, we're going to move to proof of stake. It's coming. It's anytime, like soon. Well, they actually did it. Six months. Yeah, six months away. They actually did it. It actually happened in September. And all of that energy use, I think you'd probably be, you know, harness the same kind of criticisms you've always had against Bitcoin. But this is an example where Ethereum, a major network, a major contributor to this problem in your eyes, has actually improved. Would you give crypto any points for that? Absolutely. Yeah. I mean, I think it's great that they pulled off the merge and that the environmental impact has been mitigated to an enormous extent.
You know, I think that's great. You know, I've always tried to keep my criticism of crypto as far as the environmental impact goes um somewhat tempered just because i think there can be sort of a tendency to over focus on that in the sort of critical side of things where you know there was a lot of people they're like it's burning down the rainforest it's terrible and that was sort of the only argument which um you know it is terrible that you know the ethereum emissions were horrifying so were the current bitcoin ones um but that has never sort of been my only issue with it. And so, you know, I think I was always very careful sort of before the Ethereum merged to sort of not focus on that quite too much because people would end up sort of shifting the discussion towards, okay, so how do we fix the environmental issue?
Which, you know, seems to me like a somewhat solvable problem. So same thing with things like scalability, you know, or gas fees. Well, maybe not gas fees quite as much, but scalability where it's like people are like, oh my God, you know, it's so unscalable, it's never going to scale. And it's like, well, there are a lot of things that we're never going to scale that have scaled actually pretty well, like the web, you know, we never thought we were going to be able to stream video or, you know, record something like this, but we're doing it now. You know, so I think it's sort of important to look at, okay, so what is an issue with crypto that exists today that is like fundamental to the structure of it and the way that it has been designed and imagined?
And then what if it's, which part of it is like, well, we just need a little bit of time for the software engineers to, you know, make it a little bit more scalable or whatever it might be. And I sort of see the environmental impact as more of the second, where, you know, we've known for a long time that there are alternatives to proof of work that people have been using. You know, it's not like Ethereum invented proof of stake when they did the merge. So it always sort of struck me as like a solvable problem. I don't know if the Bitcoin one is a solvable problem but that's not for a technological reason yeah i do appreciate the the fact that we're having a crypto skeptic on that uh is saying that the energy and scaling things are actually not the things to be skeptical about uh i listened to your episode with uh jason kalkanis and uh one of the one of the arguments you guys were talking about was like the bitcoin energy consumption and i thought that you guys actually completely nailed it uh the and it's it's rare to actually see like crypto outside uh crypto skeptics crypto outsiders i don't know if you accept that label or not or whatever but just like uh say like it's it's what one part about the energy consumption is its current amount of energy consumption but it's also the mechanism itself that if bitcoin does achieve what many of the bitcoiners wanted to achieve then the energy consumption also like rides along on those coattails uh in a negative sense and and and so uh i just wanted to to give you give you props for being able to like identify unique crypto parts to be to be skeptical about rather than just like the easy ones, which is like all gas fees and energy consumption.
Molly, I want to ask about like your personality, like disposition, would you call it consider yourself like a pessimist or an optimist or somewhere in the middle? I definitely sort of trend towards the cynical on a lot of things, especially really specific things. But I think generally speaking, I'm an optimist. I describe myself as starry-eyed about the web. I do think that there's a lot there that could be wonderful. I'm mostly cynical about how things are today. Sure. Sure. But yeah, I guess probably somewhere sort of in the middle. Okay. And so me and Ryan, we consider ourselves crypto natives.
We use this metaphor, crypto tourists. There's people who come in during the bull markets and then they leave. Then there's crypto settlers. And like we talked about earlier, kind of permabulls. Crypto has baked itself into a part of my identity at this point. And so if crypto doesn't do the things... In a healthy way, David? Not necessarily. Just checking. But if crypto doesn't do the things that I think it does and it starts to do the things that you think it does, part of my identity gets crushed a little bit. And so when you look at people like me, people like me and Ryan, who are just like, we're in crypto to see this most idealistic vision built out or die trying.
What do you see when you see this type of crypto character? When you look over the fence and see all these crypto idealists who just are so crypto pilled that they can't think about anything else. What's your take on what we're up to? What our deal is? I mean, I think there's always risk in taking a stance that is so strong that you're not willing to change it. You know, I think I think I mean, and I think that's just broadly true outside of crypto and technology even. You know, I think it's important to be sort of open to evaluating new evidence as it comes in. You know, so I think being bullish on something sort of despite all evidence to the contrary is not always a great thing.
But I think being idealistic about something is fine. You know, I think it's good for there to be idealists out there. You know, I'm idealistic about a lot of things. So, you know, I think it sort of depends exactly where you draw that line. That was a very friendly way of saying, David, get some help. I'm aware. I'm aware of my fault. Well, I think a lot of people look at me and they think of me as bearish against all odds and unwilling to change my position and that this is a huge part of my identity, which I guess I might give off that perception because I run a website about this. Yeah, it hasn't been my perception in this conversation.
It's like, we've been, honestly, can I say something? So Bankless has been on a quest for a while to find good crypto critics and it's eluded us. Like, honestly, I feel like this is a genuine quest we've been on. And this is one of the first conversations. I think the other one, David, that comes to mind is our conversation with Rowan Gray. I was going to say Dimitri Kofinas. Dimitri Kofinas, yeah, but Rowan Gray. And then Molly, I would count you as maybe the second or maybe the third good crypto skeptic that we've actually talked to. So for whatever that's worth to you, we appreciate it. But one other thing, I guess, in all of this, you've gone back several times to kind of like, it's not about necessarily the current use cases.
You accept the fact that crypto could clean up its act with respect to energy. It could actually scale transactions. Maybe there'll be some great DeFi use cases that work for a citizen in a country in Africa and actually start to bank the unbanked. You accept these possibilities. But you have this fundamental issue with the business model of crypto. This idea of like tokenizing everything, this idea of like financializing and incentivizing things through kind of money. I want to push back on that idea, too. And this is kind of an idea that is certainly probably core to Web3 and also crypto. And it's articulated, I think, in some ways by VCs like Chris Dixon and Andreessen Horowitz and also at Bankless.
And that's this idea of the, but wait, the internet has a hidden business model already. And I know one of your core concerns that you mentioned earlier in our conversation is like surveillance. We are surveyed on the internet. Every single swipe, every single tap, every single click is logged in a database, even kind of the movement, the location you're in, it's all logged in a database. In the US, this takes the form of capitalist surveillance. And the reason is, I think you'd probably agree with this, is advertising. Advertising is the business model of the internet. That's been the business model of Web 1.
It's been the business model of Web 2. And it's incented this surveillance apparatus that fortunately, not yet in the US, has been used by the state, but it's certainly used by large tech companies to prey on citizens. This has caused some political instability as a result of this business model. And talk about Cambridge Analytica and Facebook and all of those things going on. And so the idea of crypto is it doesn't replace advertising as the business model, but it adds a different one, this idea of ownership, right? So you can own a specific piece of the internet and maybe pay as you go. It disincents or starts to disrupt the whole business model of advertising of the internet.
And so I guess maybe pushing back on this idea that financializing everything and tokenizing everything is bad, there seems to be a problem with the existing business model of the internet in that this is surveilling everything. It's preying on us in a way that is unhealthy. Do you see this problem? And is there any other way out besides the Web3 ownership, adding a different layer in the capitalist system to the internet, changing up the business models? Is there any way out of this? So I would disagree that the advertising model of the internet is endemic to the internet in the way that the token model is endemic to crypto.
You know, there exist sites on the internet today that don't advertise to you. Wikipedia is a good example of one. You know, that exists. There is no advertising on Wikipedia. And so it's, I think, not correct to argue that, you know, in order to succeed on the web, you need to be advertising to customers or surveilling your users. I agree that it's not the dominant form of business on the web. Obviously, I think everyone would agree that advertising is clearly the way that people tend to get to monetize their websites and things like that. But it's not fundamental in the same way. Can I ask, just because we're on the subject of Wikipedia, what's it like to contribute to Wikipedia?
I imagine this is kind of like a messy process. And there's probably so many things Tao governance could learn from the nature of contribution to something like Wikipedia. But what's a day in the life? What kind of things have you done there? How does this thing actually work? I think people have lost their wonder for Wikipedia. But I remember the early days of Wikipedia. It's just mind-blowing that people would come together for free and write a freaking encyclopedia that is just an incredible resource for humanity. So tell us about that. I think Wikipedia is sort of partly what keeps me so idealistic about the web, because like Wikipedia is one of those things that should not function, right?
Like you look at it, you're like, how is that possible that people are just doing that for fun? They're not being paid. You know, they're not experts or academics, but it works, right? You know, and so that's sort of one thing that tries, it sort of tempers a lot of my cynicism around things where it's like, that could not possibly work. It's like, well, it kind of does. But yeah, I mean, I think as far as like a day in the life, it is a very messy process, especially on more popular pages or pages that themselves are controversial in some way. But it's sometimes kind of meditative in the quieter parts of Wikipedia.
You know, if you find some random article on some really niche subject and you want to just like do a deep dive, that's pretty fun. I enjoy that a lot. But yeah, I mean, I enjoy, I think, all parts of it. The arguments sometimes are a little bit more than I would like to put up with. What motivates you? What motivates you to contribute? What motivates the average Wikipedia contributor to actually do the work? Because it's not tokens. There's no token. How could you possibly be motivated? Yeah. They've actually tried to do research on this because I just like, nobody really knows. I think there's sort of this weird subset of people who just love doing stuff like that.
It's like the sort of born encyclopedist or like the born archivist almost who just get a lot of joy out of collating data and making it accessible to people. For me, a lot of it has to do with just a really strong belief that knowledge should be available to people as widely as possible without being stuck in expensive volumes of encyclopedias or behind academic paywalls or behind news paywalls increasingly. I think creating that resource is societally incredibly important. But I think there's a really broad range of reasons that people edit. that some people like in sort of a token-based model, they like to see their edit count go up.
That just makes them happy inside. They can't spend those edits anywhere, but yeah, it's like a cloud thing. But I think probably most people are just motivated by the end results. That is very fundamental. So spreading knowledge to the entire world and believing that that is an important thing to do, Molly, that's what keeps you contributing. Famously though, Wikipedia is blocked in many different countries around the world, right? I'm not sure that it gets through to China across the Great Firewall. There are other locations where it doesn't get to either. How important in your mind is getting access to Wikipedia, a knowledge base like Wikipedia, to these places where it's currently censored?
Would you rate that as very important? I would say it is. Yeah, I mean, it's impactful to be able to have access to that kind of knowledge. And I would say that the attempts to block it have been somewhat unsuccessful. I think a lot of people get around the Great Firewall to access Wikipedia. You know, Russia recently tried to block it. And, you know, is it via VPN or how did they how did they do this? Yeah, to some extent, it's largely via VPN. But or, you know, people will log on via Tor or things like that. But, you know, I think that as a community, we sort of do what we can to enable people in those situations to access Wikipedia in various ways.
There have been attempts to, you know, create offline versions that could be distributed or to, you know, enable people to circumvent those, you know, firewalls to the extent that we can. Do you think that anything you've seen in crypto has a role to play in making things like Wikipedia more censorship resistant? I'm thinking projects maybe like IPFS, which is sort of a distributed file storage system. Projects even like ENS, which is a decentralized DNS system. So you can go to kind of like a website URL and access it. Have you seen anything there that is interesting? These are less talked about, I think, in crypto because it's not a JPEG token that could be pumped.
But yeah, what are your thoughts around this? Yeah, I mean, I think the general decentralization idea is really interesting and important and has been far before crypto and probably will continue to be. Again, I don't always feel like crypto is necessary for decentralized storage, but I do think that attempts to make it available through crypto are interesting. IPFS, Filecoin, some of those projects are really interesting. So far we haven't seen it. Molly, this has been a lot of fun. I guess last question for you, because as I said at the outset, David and I want to get outside of our kind of crypto bubble, and maybe bankless listeners who want to do that as well.
Do you have any advice for people in general in crypto, people that you've seen that are a bit maybe, you know, too much, drinking too much of the Kool-Aid, a bit too starry-eyed, a bit too naive? Do you have any advice for them on how to break outside of their kind of information bubble? What would you say? Yeah, I mean, I think just being open to alternate perspectives is important. You know, like I try not to read all anti-crypto stuff all the time. You know, I listen to podcasts like this one or to, you know, I read crypto media a lot. And I think that is really key to having a fairly healthy perspective on things.
You know, I think there are really, I think, I think there are probably more good crypto critics than maybe you do who are doing really, really interesting work. And, you know, I think I would just encourage people to try to just try it. You know, they're not boring to listen to. They're not trying to sell you anything. Well, maybe we'll get a few names from you after the show, Molly, and other crypto critics we can bring on. This has been a really fun conversation. And thank you for joining us. I hope you didn't feel like you were going behind enemy lines on today's episode, but I appreciate you coming on of crypto podcasts.
Yeah, thanks, Molly. Yeah, I was happy to do it. Action items for you, Bankless Nation. Of course, break outside of your information bubbles. You're probably listening to the Bankless podcast. Maybe it's time to also put a non-crypto podcast in your rotation. Should we say that, David? Nah. Cross that out. Never mind. That's not an action item. Not after you're done listening to the five Bankless podcasts. The action item for you is to check out Molly's website. It's called Web3isGoingGreat at Web3isGoingGreat.com. you'll see a compilation of things that aren't going so well in crypto if you ever need to be reminded and of course guys risks and disclaimers should include as always none of this has been financial advice crypto is definitely risky so is eth so is bitcoin so is defi you could lose what you put in if you need to be reminded of that go to molly's website but we are headed west this is the frontier it's not for everyone but we're glad you're with us on the bankless journey thanks a lot.
Hey, we hope you enjoyed the video. If you did head over to Bankless HQ right now to develop your crypto investing skills and learn how to free yourself from banks and gain your financial independence. We recommend joining our daily newsletter, podcast and community as a Bankless Premium subscriber to get the most out of your Bankless experience. You'll get access to our market analysis, our alpha leaks and exclusive content and even the Bankless token for airdrops, raffles, and unlocks. If you're interested in crypto, the Bankless community is where you want to be. Click the link in the description to become a Bankless premium subscriber today.
Also, don't forget to subscribe to the channel for in-depth interviews with industry leaders, ask me anythings, and weekly roll-ups where we summarize the week in crypto and other fantastic content. Thanks everyone for watching and being on the journey as we build out the Bankless nation.