✨ DEBRIEF | Unpacking the Episode: https://shows.banklesshq.com/p/vitalik-buterin-2023-debrief
------ Vitalik Buterin is your friendly neighborhood Ethereum developer, an alfalfa male who thinks we should rename Gas to Mana.
In today’s episode, Vitalik unpacks his recent essay, “What in the Ethereum application ecosystem excites me,” and his thoughts around why crypto villains are getting worse, what Ethereum’s most scalable use case is, why he plans to say ‘Ethereum’ rather than ‘crypto’ in 2023, how Ethereum solves the big bad identity problem, and why he thinks “simple DeFi good, complicated DeFi bad.”
Every episode with Vitalik is a must-listen and this one is no different.
------ 📣 Kraken | The Crypto Exchange for Everyone https://bankless.cc/kraken
------ 🚀 SUBSCRIBE TO NEWSLETTER: https://newsletter.banklesshq.com/?utm_source=banklessshowsyt 🎙️ SUBSCRIBE TO PODCAST: https://availableon.com/bankless
------ BANKLESS SPONSOR TOOLS:
⚖️ ARBITRUM | SCALING ETHEREUM https://bankless.cc/Arbitrum
👯 DESO | DECENTRALIZED SOCIAL BLOCKCHAIN https://bankless.cc/Deso
🦁 BRAVE | THE BROWSER NATIVE WALLET https://bankless.cc/Brave
📡 TRUEFI | CRYPTO FINANCIAL HUB https://bankless.cc/TrueFi
👾 SEQUENCE | ALL-IN-ONE PLATFORM https://bankless.cc/Sequence
⚡️FUEL | THE MODULAR EXECUTION LAYER https://bankless.cc/fuel
------ Topics Covered
0:00 Intro 7:44 Vitalik’s 2022 Crypto Reflections 17:31 Was 2022 More Unusual? 25:58 Esperanto, Linux, & Crypto 34:57 Advice for the Crypto Space 38:31 Permissionless Commons Criticism 45:54 2022 Lessons Learned by Vitalik 52:22 Vitalik’s Recent Blog Post 1:00:00 Why Do We Need Crypto Money? 1:10:29 Where the Opportunity in Crypto is 1:13:52 Identity 1:24:29 DAOs & Governance Innovation 1:31:05 Hybrid Applications 1:36:30 Accelerating the Good Things 1:41:05 Vitalik’s Role in 2023 1:44:48 Action Items & Disclaimers
------ Resources:
Vitalik https://twitter.com/VitalikButerin
What in the Ethereum Application Ecosystem Excites Me - Vitalik https://vitalik.ca/general/2022/12/05/excited.html
Why I’m Less Than Infinitely Hostile to Cryptocurrency - Astral Codex Ten https://astralcodexten.substack.com/p/why-im-less-than-infinitely-hostile
Vitalik’s Other Bankless Appearances https://www.youtube.com/results?search_query=bankless+vitalik
----- Not financial or tax advice. This channel is strictly educational and is not investment advice or a solicitation to buy or sell any assets or to make any financial decisions. This video is not tax advice. Talk to your accountant. Do your own research.
Disclosure. From time-to-time I may add links in this newsletter to products I use. I may receive commission if you make a purchase through one of these links. Additionally, the Bankless writers hold crypto assets. See our investment disclosures here: https://www.bankless.com/disclosures
No summary for this episode yet.
I think it's important to just remember 2022, both not just for the massive failures, but also for the amazing technological and adoption backdrops that we've had. And I think even the first inklings of cryptocurrency and blockchain spaces ability to actually have very significant positive impacts on the world. Welcome to Bankless, where we explore the frontier of internet money and internet finance. This is how to get started, how to get better, and how to front run the opportunity. This is Ryan Sean Adams. I'm here with Dave Hoffman, and we're here to help you become more bankless. Ethereum in 2023.
Best guest to talk about this, Vitalik Buterin on the podcast today. We talk about what in the Ethereum application ecosystem, it's the title of his blog post, what excites Vitalik going into 2023. A lot of optimism dropped in this episode that you got to stay tuned for. Before we get in, first, a little bit of housekeeping for Bankless listeners. We are revamping our sponsor strategy going into the next year, and we're going to be putting a focus more on the sponsors and the projects and the companies that are playing long-term games in crypto. And so we're excited to be building out a strategic relationship with Kraken.
The reason David and I like Kraken is because they're one of the few crypto exchanges that didn't rug us last year, right, David? Yeah. They've also implemented proof of reserves before anyone ever asked them to. So they have been leading the frontier of centralized crypto exchanges that can use cryptography to check themselves. And so implementing proof of reserves before they were asked to just indicates that Jesse and the rest of the Kraken team are here to do good by crypto and to leverage the powers that make crypto awesome. So thank you, Kraken, for sponsoring this. And we're excited to build out a strategic relationship with Kraken in 2023.
A few things to look out for in this episode, as always. Number one, why Vitalik thinks our villains are getting worse. Actually worse every single cycle. This being maybe the worst cycle of villains of all. Number two, why he plans to say Ethereum rather than crypto moving forward in 2023 to describe the industry instead of applications built on top of it. Number three, why he thinks simple DeFi good, complicated DeFi bad. There's a lot of nuance to that take that we get into. Number four, how he thinks Ethereum can actually solve the internet's big bad identity problem. How do you determine who are the bots and who are the humans?
How do you keep identity decentralized? Vitalik's actually bullish that Ethereum has a massive role to play there. And finally, his answer to the question, what is Ethereum's most scalable use case? That's an answer, David. I don't think either you or I expect it. You'll have to stay tuned for that in the episode as well. What should people pay attention to as we dive in here? I think the big question that is the overarching theme about this episode is how proliferated are some of the use cases that many, many people, and definitely us, talk about? For example, DAOs. How much of a Cambrian explosion will there be with DAOs?
How many DeFi apps are there actually going to be? Are there going to be as many DeFi apps as there are websites? Or are there just going to be a few DeFi apps? How many DAOs are there going to be? And this is one of the conversations that we start off this podcast with Vitalik. He gives the example of Esperanto, a esoteric language that was meant to be a universal language for everyone to adopt that would help support global peace. And then also Linux, a fantastic technology with a medium amount of adoption in some specific cases versus the Internet, which is the most adopted piece of technology of all time.
How much of crypto adoption will there be in contrast to these three anchor points? And what can we do to help make crypto be adopted as much as the Internet and not be left to some esoteric hobbyist group who thinks the Esperanto language is cool? And so we talk about this frame of reference in the application layer, in the DAO layer, and the identity layer, and how Ethereum can really change the game and hopefully how we can move the needle in 2023 and look back on 2022 and take some of the lessons of 2022 to make sure that we don't repeat them, right? Look, guys, every episode with Vitalik is a must-listen.
This is certainly no exception. And David, I'm excited to explore some of those topics with you in the debrief as well. That's the show we record after the show for our premium members. And in that, David, I think I want to talk to you about this idea of crypto maybe being a niche versus going mainstream, something like the internet. And also this theme that Vitalik kept coming back to in this episode, which was we actually have a role to play. We can make crypto bigger and better, and we can actually build towards a future where crypto is a technology adopted like the internet and not just some esoteric niche.
So we'll be talking about that in the debrief too. Guys, we're going to get right to our episode with Vitalik. But before we do, we want to tell you about these tools to help you go bankless. The Brave Wallet is your secure multi-chain on-ramp into Web3 and it's built directly into the Brave privacy browser. Gone are the days of managing multiple wallet extensions that put you at risk of phishing, spoofs, and tracking. With the Brave Wallet, you can securely manage your crypto assets across more than 100 different chains, including Ethereum, Layer 2s, Solana, and more, all without downloading risky extensions.
The Brave wallet is easy to set up and removes the headache of jumping between wallets and extensions. It's lightweight, but packed with great features, like built-in token swaps, buying and holding NFTs with a gallery view, and support for hardware wallets. But also much more than that, because Brave is shipping new features every single month with a mission to make Web3 easier to navigate for its over 55 million users. Wallet extensions are a thing of the past, So get started with Brave's Web3 ready browser today and experience a decentralized web seamlessly without all the clutter. You can download the browser at brave.
com slash bankless and click the wallet icon to get started. Sequence is the all-in-one developer platform you need to build Web3 games and applications. For your users, Sequence is a smart wallet and it's the easiest, most intuitive onboarding your users will ever experience. It comes with all the features users need to feel empowered in the Web3 world. Multi-chain support, NFT display, and users can buy SFTs, NFTs, and crypto directly with a credit or debit card. For developers, Sequence is the plug-and-play platform for Web3 games and apps. Their APIs let you bring NFTs, SFTs, and tokens into your game or application.
And a Sequence relayer enables gasless transactions for your users. Sequence already powers some of the best Web3 games like Skyweaver, NFT projects like Cool Cats, and marketplaces like NiftySwap. NiftySwap. And Sequence is compatible with all the EVM chains, including Ethereum, Polygon, Binance Smart Chain, Arbitrum, Optimism, and Avalanche. So go to sequence.xyz.com to start building or speak with the Sequence team today. The reality today is that five corporations control the entire world of social media. They own our names, they restrict our content, they monitor our every move, and their time is up thanks to our sponsor, Deeso.
Deeso is a layer one blockchain built from the ground up to decentralize and scale social networks. With Deeso, you can own your own identity, content, and social graph and take it with you across hundreds of applications already built on the censorship-resistant Deeso blockchain. Deeso's storage advantages make it finally possible to build infinite state applications that can efficiently store and index large amounts of content and data fully on-chain. Deeso also offers multiple crypto-native monetization primitives for developers and creators, including social NFTs, social DAOs, social tokens, and social tipping.
So in order to experience the social layer of Web3, go to deso.com and claim your username. That's D-E-S-O dot com. Bankless Nation, Vitalik Buterin is on the podcast today. Vitalik is your friendly neighborhood Ethereum developer. He's an alfalfa male who thinks we should rename gas to man. I didn't know that actually. Vitalik, welcome back to Bankless. How are you doing? Thank you so much, guys. It's great to be here. Vitalik, 2022 has been an absolutely crazy year. Disastrous. Yeah. And like the industry is hurting, the community is feeling a lot of pain. I just, maybe just to kick this thing off, can you just give your thoughts and reflections on this?
Like, was this unexpected? What's your assessment of the crypto community after this crazy year we've had? So 2022 has been, I think, a complicated year, right? I think a lot of people are remembering the year for all of the terrible stuff that's happened and within the crypto space for all of the multi-billion dollar blowups. But I think it's also important to remember all of the various positives that the crypto space has seen, right? So the merge, I think, is the most recent one, but the big one, right? This is something that the Ethereum has been waiting for pretty much since its inception, right?
And it's been delayed and complexified and turned out to be more complex than we thought. And lots of things have happened. But, you know, now, finally, as of September 15th, I think it was 0645 UTC, you know, we actually have a proof of stake chain. Right. And, you know, doesn't it just feel good to be able to say like, no, no, not Ethereum is going to reduce its energy consumption by 99.9 percent. but Ethereum has reduced its energy consumption by 99.9%. We're literally talking about going from a level of electricity consumption similar to the entire country of Austria to a level of electricity consumption similar to the entire country of maybe San Marino, maybe Vatican, one of those.
So huge success also from the just protocol security point of view. even a huge success from the usability point of view right so like a lot of people don't realize this but the merge was actually a transaction inclusion time decrease right and this happened for a couple of reasons one of those reasons is actually the easier one to understand which is that you know blocks have thousands of attestations that are coming on top of them and so you have thousands of confirmations happening in parallel and what that basically means is that a few seconds after one single block comes, you have the equivalent of what would in proof of work lanes be considered hundreds of confirmations, right?
Like if you go to etherscan.io slash blocks underscore forked, right? And the most recent forked block was six days ago. In the proof of work era, there would be multiple of these every hour, right? So that's the first reason. The second reason is that because block times now are, instead of being this like very random plus on distribution thing where, you know, sometimes you have a block every two seconds, sometimes you have a block only after a minute. Here we have a block in a nice regular pattern of 12 seconds. And what this means is that on average, you only have to wait six seconds for a transaction to get included, right?
Now, this all sounds theoretical, but just from my own very practical experience, like my experience using Ethereum has just improved massively. It's like, you know, night and day compared to, let's say, yeah, you know, July 2020, before all of this stuff ends before EIP-1559 happens, right? Like, these days, when I send a transaction, I click send, I wait a couple of seconds, and then I see, oh, that transaction got included into one block, and it already has one confirmation. Like, it's not quite competitive with, you know, web to, oh, my God, let's pay $35 million. So the latency is 184 milliseconds instead of 212 milliseconds as standards.
But it's like already good enough to be competitive with say credit card point of sale systems, right? And that's something that I think is really important to appreciate. Like there's been just this massive increase in the usability of the base Ethereum chain that's happened pretty much under our noses. And EIP-1559 was the first half of this. The merge was the second half of this. And the third half of this, of course, is going to be roll-ups that have pre-confirmations, which is coming next year. And later on, we'll talk about how I think 2023 is going to be the year of roll-ups actually hitting stage one of trustlessness, which will mean that Ethereum actually finally is in its scalable era, right?
But before that, so the merge happened and the merge was amazing. 2022 was also the year of ZK EVMs, right? So five years ago, the zeitgeist basically was that, oh, there is this fancy thing called ZK-Synarc technology. And like, maybe theoretically, it could make abstract proofs, and you can turn things into polynomials and like put stuff on top of stuff, and maybe eventually verify an Ethereum block. But like, come on, it's so high overhead, that's going to take like literally four weeks to make a proof, and four years to actually audit the code to do any of that, right? But fast forward to 2022, And we have multiple ZK EVM implementations that are all promising some kind of mainnet launch next year.
Like, this is amazing, right? Like, ZK EVMs have just gone from being a non-existent pipe dream to being the, I think, clear manifesto long-term and possibly even medium-term future of scaling Ethereum. Right? So that's number two. Um, then, you know, on the adoption front, right, sign in with Ethereum has seen massive, you know, gains in adoption. Ethereum, I think, goes in a great position to take advantage of people's desire to explore the various alternative Twitter's, alternative social media platforms, right? So Farcaster, sign into that within Ethereum account. Lens, sign into that within Ethereum account.
And I've used Farcaster and Lens, and they're actually great. Fast forwarding to earlier in the year, I feel like a lot of crypto people have forgotten about this, but it's still super important to remember the invasion of Ukraine in February, right? which is definitely an extremely tragic event overall. But the part of it that is, I think, quite happy is obviously that they succeeded in defending themselves far beyond most people's expectations. But I think cryptocurrency payments actually worked for them when nothing else worked. And, you know, they've actually, starting from that very first tweet that the country's official Twitter account, you know, made on the morning or the day after the invasion, you know, cryptocurrency actually has been a lifeline for the country, a lifeline for a lot of civilians and the people, right?
And, you know, that's just like one example. And then, you know, you have all these various small examples like, you know, continuing adoption happening in places like Latin America, for example. You know, I came to Argentina last year, I came to Argentina this year, and the level of sophistication has improved by a lot, right? And, you know, we've been one of the things I saw, for example, is when I visited just recently, there was a group, I forgot their name, I think it was called either DeFi Latam or something vaguely called like this, right? But this was just a really lovely person from Venezuela.
And he was basically saying like, hey, you know, the FTX situation has helped me realize that DeFi actually is important. And like, I want to help Latin Americans, you know, who need crypto actually interact with crypto in ways that are decentralized and that involve self-custody. And this person actually knew a huge amount about Layer 2 protocols, a huge amount about different forms of self-custody and all of these things. So all of those things are continuing to move forward. Cryptocurrency is continuing to get used for philanthropy a lot. So last year was the year of Crypto Relief India getting its money.
But, you know, this year, Crypto Relief India continued spending some of its money. Also, Bulvi, it's this group that I helped spin up that used some of the money to put money into these more experimental, but potentially much more high payoff options in terms of protecting people now and in the future against viruses. And that's funded amazing stuff like, you know, UV lamps, open source vaccine projects and a whole bunch of things. And like cryptocurrency as a international payment instrument for philanthropy has just been huge there. So I think it's important to just remember 2022, both not just for the massive failures, but also for the amazing technological and adoption backdrops that we've had.
And I think even the first inklings of cryptocurrency and blockchain space's ability to actually have very significant positive impacts on the world. But that's to hear. So. Well, Vitalik, thank you so much for coming into this with your your optimist hat on and just reminding us that sometimes the bad definitely drowns out the good. As someone who's been through multiple market cycles, like every single market cycle has the bad year, right? The down year, right? 2018 was my first one. There was one prior to that. Is 2022 unusual in any respects or is this kind of par for the course of like, yeah, this is this is what happens at the the the last.
the latter half of a bull market. We have a lot of bad stuff. But meanwhile, there is relentless adoption regardless, no matter what year it is. Is 2022 unusual for you in contrast to other years of crypto? I'm trying to compare 2022 against the early to mid bear market periods of the previous cycles. Actually, if you want to show people visuals, one great visual to show right now is the Bitcoin price from 2011 to now. Bitcoin, just because of Ethereum, unfortunately, didn't exist in 2011. But if you look at that, you see the great cycles, right? And you have 2011, and then the really big one at the end of 2013, and then the even bigger one in 2017, and then the super big one in 2021, right?
And see, the very first one at the left, it's like so low that we don't even notice it, right? Like if you just click the log button, wow. So the 2015, right? So if you go down the flat part after the first peak, that's when Ethereum launched, right? So then 2018, that's the flat and the kind of cup and handle after the second bull market. That's when Uniswap was created and started existing for the first time. Now let's look at the flat and slightly decreasing line after the third bubble. That's when the merge happened, and we had multiple ZK EVMs, and we're starting to see serious Layer 2 adoption.
So the post-peak periods are always periods in which there actually are some pretty significant technological progress that is happening. They are periods where often it's easier for people to get back to work because the numbers aren't giving them dopamine hits every six hours anymore. and there are periods where a lot of real work gets done and even periods where the good gets separated from the bad right so one of the other reasons i wanted to make that analogy is that if you go back to 2014 right the uh the ftx of 2014 kind of uh mount gox i actually kind of don't want to even call mount gox the ftx of 2014 because i just feel like the way like mark repellas did a whole did a bunch of horrible stuff but i actually feel like the way that he has handled himself post blow up has actually been kind of honorable like you know he hasn't tried to give himself a yesu juu style uh redemption arc or um you know in what kind of give himself attention on twitter just kind of you know what quiet for a while just diligently worked on helping people get their money back and uh you know working on uh on gox and other and other things right like that's uh it's like our villains are getting lower quality now right That's like Mark.
I think, you know, he is actually like improved in ways that like I just unfortunately, you know, don't expect people like Sue and Kyle to improve even a decade from now. But very much hope I'm wrong, though. I think I'm always happy when people positively outperform my expectations. Right. But the Mt. Gox blow up in 2014, it did feel like an existential crisis for the crypto space. It felt like a huge crisis for Bitcoin. It felt like a huge crisis for legitimacy. It was an invitation for regulators to swarm around the space. And it did have a lot of bad consequences in all kinds of places. And it made a huge number of people very unhappy.
2022, a lot of very similar things are happening, except now we have, I think, a much more interconnected crypto space and we have a lot more sophistication. And so, on the other hand, a lot more fragility and contagion happening. Though I think it's important to remember that in 2014, there was fragility and contagion too, right? Because Mt. Gox, when it collapsed, it was both the thing causing the crypto prices to crash and also the thing that people were used to as being the place where prices moved up and down. And so the market had to basically crash and change where its numbers were coming from at the same time.
And here, this year, we had the double whammy of obviously first Luna coming back down to Earth and Terra going back down to somewhere much, much lower than Earth. and six months later, obviously, FTX blowing up and then a month after that, I think BlockFi is in bankruptcy or something like that now, right? So it's definitely echoes of a similar situation. But at the same time, I don't want to all be rosy about it because I think the other thing that's important to remember now that I think will make 2022 harder to recover from than 2014 is that I think a community having this very high variance and both high excitement and high turnoff approach to existing is something that's a very good strategy when you're trying to increase adoption from 0.
1% to 10%. But it's a terrible strategy when you're trying to increase adoption from 10% to 70%, right? I think this is a criticism I would have made of Bitcoin maximalism sometime ago too, right? That if you're just a small community, then if you say incredibly over the top things about how the U.S. government is the primary source of all evil in the world and money printing is the reason why, you know, we have some kind of military status dystopia instead of, you know, Switzerland, like happy land for everyone. then it's you know you're going to turn off a lot of people who clearly kind of see through those attitudes and realize that there's a lot more complicated stuff going on in the world but at the same time there is going to be some portion of the population that like really believes in the thing you believe or is really receptive to the thing you believe and they're attracted to the passion with which you say it and so they're going to you know wants to come along with you And, you know, being in this kind of siege mentality where they are one of the few brave soldiers pushing forward the future, even if, you know, huge portions of the mainstream world and the Paul Krugmans and the Elizabeth Warrens and all those characters are, you know, rabidly against them.
Like, there is a group of people to whom that like being in that position of the siege narrative really appeals to them. Right. But that's how you get from 0.1 percent to 10 percent. And crypto is no longer in the stage of getting from 0.1% to 10%. I think there have been adoption charts and estimates that people have attempted to make. And in some countries, ownership of cryptocurrency is literally at the 10% of the population level. So now the space is at the level of trying to get from 10% to 70%. And that requires different strategies. And strategy is where, you know, this really crazy stuff that keeps losing people $5 billion keeps happening are like the exact opposite of what the space wants and needs to do.
Right. So, yeah, you know, I wanted to give the message of optimism, but also give this kind of important message that there is a lot of work that needs to be done. And, you know, the status quo, even if it's a status quo that's like kind of secretly exciting and fun for a lot of us, like that's, you know, not the sort of thing that we want crypto to continue to be four years from now if we actually want it to succeed. Is it possible we just get stuck in that niche of that zero to 10%? We never, I mean, I know it's possible, but do you think that's like a high probability outcome? It's a good question.
Back in, I think, 2011 or 12, one of the earliest articles that I wrote for Bitcoin Weekly, it was called something like Bitcoin, Esperanto, Linux, or the Internet. Basically comparing Bitcoin to three different things that started off as being these very idealistic movements to replace the existing system with a totally different and much better system. Right. So Esperanto was this constructed language invented by Ludwig Zamenhof in the late 19th century. The goal basically being to create a language which is easier to learn because it has much simpler and more regular spelling and grammar. And it's the theory was that everyone would learn Esperanto in addition to their national language and everyone could speak Esperanto with each other.
And that would be the path to world peace. right and esperanto ended up not really succeeding right it's this uh fairly niche interest community at this point and you know there are speakers but it's like enthusiasts that are just uh you know in it as a hobby like even more much more than a pragmatic communication tool or an actual attempts to make world peace at this point right and which is like sad you know i personally love uh like i never learned esperanto super deeply but uh you know So it's a really cool language. I think the world probably would have been better if it got much more adopted.
What's cool about it, by the way, just to nerd out for just a second, is it a combo of kind of like, is it some sort of Latin derivative? This is really based from scratch. They built a new language from the ground up, so it's different. Esperanto is interesting. I have this combination of very positive and critical views of it. I think the critical view is basically that it's a language that strove to be universal, but actually ended up being like very European specific. So like, for example, the way that you make a plural in Esperanto is you add a J and a J is pronounced J, right? So kind of like how in Eastern European languages or in German, right?
Uh, so if you want to say something, if you want to, uh, I think what, like try and think of like a good, good examples for nouns in Esperanto. This is like, I think homo is a, is like a person and homoi is people. Um, let me just, uh, uh, check that quickly. Um, but, and then you have like the N, which is an, which is the accusative case, right? The accusative case is like the same, like, you know, how in English you, like, if you're doing something, you say, I am doing something. If someone's doing something to you, you say, someone's doing something to me. So I is the nominative and me as the accusative.
So a lot of European languages have that for nouns and as well as pronouns. And Esperanto has that for nouns as well. So it has a lot of these very European specific features, but at the same time, the good is that it is extremely regular. So it's even things like, so like English, for example, right? Like you have words like who, what, where, when, why. And then you have like, well, that, because, therefore, at that time, right? So, or if you want like the negative, then you have no one, never, for no reason, right? And like you have this kind of two by two table that's really complicated. In Esperanto, it's like a really it's an incredibly clean system where like I think it's like the first half of the word is like, do you mean which do you mean?
Do you mean that? Do you mean no one? And then the second half of the word is like referring to a person or referring to a time or referring to a place. So it's got a lot of regularity in the grammar. It's got a lot of regularity in the spelling. Right. So English has a lot of these, you know, really dumb spelling rules and you have to memorize, you know, memorize spellings of a lot of words really thoroughly, including the word thoroughly, which like makes totally no sense. But I guess that's the point, right? Even if you design the most perfect language from a technical perspective, that's not how you actually get adoption for language, right?
So there's like the theoretical perfection. Right. So this is the analogy, right? It has all these beautiful technical properties, but the adoption roadmap basically went nowhere, right? And instead, like English had too much of a network effect. And, you know, especially post-World War II, where pretty much every major country except for the United States got turned into ruins. You know, that I think set English on a path to dominance. And I don't really think anything else is in a position to challenge it now, right? So that's Esperanto. Now, Linux is an interesting middle case, right? So Linux is interesting because it's kind of succeeded and it kind of has not succeeded, right?
So Linux is this open source operating system. So it's an alternative to things like Mac and Windows. So I'm speaking right now through a computer that is running a Linux distribution. But Linux has had this interesting mixture of success and failure. So Linux on the desktop is mostly a failure. So it is a product that is continuing to be developed, and it is very usable, and I use it, and I think it's great. But it just doesn't quite appeal to the majority of people, right? But on the other hand, Linux has become this really important backend thing. So Android, for example, which a lot of phones use, runs on the Linux kernel.
A huge portion of all the servers run on Linux. A huge portion of developers, including people who write the Ethereum codebase. Not all, but a very significant portion. They run Linux on their computers because Linux is just very developer-friendly, right? So there's a lot of specific communities and specific applications in which Linux is very entrenched. And then there's this permanent dream of Linux as an open-source operating system becoming this thing that really takes over for everyone. But that just ends up never quite succeeding, right? And then the third is the internet, and the internet has just obviously completely taken over everything.
And so my question back in 2011 is, is Bitcoin going to look more like Esperanto, more like Linux, or more like the internet? And I kind of was willing to accept all three possibilities as being likely, and I wasn't sure yet. I think today cryptocurrency is way past being Esperanto. right um but uh but the question is like how linuxy is it going to be or how internetty is it going to be and i don't know i mean it's very possible that it's going to be in the middle right so like it's very possible that when just one example in developed countries it's going to be like linux on the desktop but in the developing world it's gonna become like ubiquitous it's very possible that in both worlds, it's going to be something that's organized or concentrated around a few particular industries that we are like, say, yeah, reversibility of credit card transactions and other things just like totally makes no sense.
And cryptocurrency is the best thing that works. It might just be something that people have as a store of value without really using day to day. And when a big crisis comes, it just becomes suddenly really important for people and people appreciated, right? Or it's possible that, you know, the next, basically all of the infrastructure of the next wave of technology is going to be built around Linux, or sorry, built around cryptocurrency, right? Hopefully cryptocurrency and Linux. That would be more the Web3, that last piece is the Web3 meme. Yeah. So which one is it going to be? I don't know.
And I mean, I am a definite optimist on this. I think which one it's going to turn out to be depends crucially on how hard we try and what we try to do. Interesting. So you actually think that we have a lot of agency over the outcome of whether or not crypto actually replaces the internet or just provides a few very useful applications? I think absolutely. I think it's actually really important for good people in the Ethereum space to recognize that they have agency and exercise it. Because I think if good people act passive, then the things that take over just are going to be, you know, the drama queens of the world, right?
And like, I think we as people trying to build actually meaningful things, you know, have a responsibility to work hard to drown out the drama queens. And that's a challenge. And I think sometimes we do worse, sometimes we do better. But, you know, we got to try. That is a challenge, Vitalik. But that like I'm almost tempted to turn this into like give us some personal advice here. Like, how do we do that? All right. So I'm leaving partially 2022 again, feeling embarrassed that I'm in crypto. Oh, you have a crypto podcast at your next. How's that going? How's that going for you? And, you know, mainstream people outside sort of the normies, the people who are in the 90 percent, not the 10 percent.
they're looking at this industry and being like, what is this just run by a bunch of kind of clowns and scammers? Like, where are the adults? I thought you guys, you preach crypto values, and then I see all of this. And so I'm feeling a little down at the end of 2022, but also reflective in terms of like, what could we have done better? What lessons can we learn? Do we need to like, I mean, I know we've talked before about like how you call out, you know, scammers and kind of the social layer and you can veer too far to one extreme or another. But yeah, what are your thoughts, advice for us in general?
And then maybe we can talk about lessons for the entire community. So just to kind of start slowly moving into the blog post we wanted to talk about a bit, we'll start with the first eight words of it, right? So the title. I intentionally said what in the Ethereum application ecosystem excites me instead of what in the crypto space excites me. This is an experiment I've been trying, right? Basically, yeah, like using the word crypto less and using the word Ethereum more. And this is like a subtle thing. I mean, it's still an early stage experiment. So I'm not entirely sure what all of the consequences of emphasizing Ethereum in particular much more would be.
But the theory here, so first of all, it's not maximalist, right? So it's not saying like, you know, focus on Ethereum to the exclusion of everything else. It's more saying we are not going to implicitly ally with you just because you are a cryptocurrency by default, right? The problem with the crypto space is that the crypto space is an ungovernable commons that has no barrier to entry, right? So if you remember, you know, the basics of, you know, Eleanor Ostrom's theory of the commons and what commons create tragedies of the commons and what commons can be governed. One of the basic ingredients for commons to be governed is gatekeeping, right?
Like you have to actually be able to, you know, say, you know, this is us and this is not us. And actually be able to have some level of enforcement or filtering in the thing that is us. With the crypto space, the only qualification to be able to call yourself part of the crypto space and not have people complain is to just somehow use cryptography and to have some kind of change data structure somewhere. Those are literally the qualifications. You don't even need decentralization. I forget. Has IOTA even gotten rid of their coordinator yet? I forget now. The answer is no. Right. XRP, right? Like, you know, they're still completely centralized.
And but, you know, at the same time, they are on coin market cap and, you know, still, I think, haven't apologized for writing documents into the to the U.S. government, basically saying that they should be favored over Bitcoin and Ethereum because Bitcoin and Ethereum are China controlled. so so vitality when you have a permissionless commons you're saying the role of gatekeeper is essential and that role is essentially a kind of a social layer type role let me let me throw the criticism at you that you might expect to see you probably won't expect to hear that now but like earlier this year you would have would have expected to hear that if you talk about the ethereum ecosystem well that makes you an ethereum maximalist okay and crypto is much broader than Ethereum and we live in a multi-chain world here.
And you're just pumping your bags. You're just pumping your bags and decentralized values can exist outside of Ethereum or the so-called crypto values can exist. So stop limiting yourselves to Ethereum. That was kind of the jujitsu move some pulled whenever you start trying to redefine the boundaries and start to do a little bit of gatekeeping. Okay. So this is a good point. So here is my analogy. So suppose that you have an American politician who goes on CNN and he says, you know, here is a package of policies. Here are some things that I want to deregulate. Here are some things that I want to subsidize.
And here are some things that I want to encourage. And the combination of these ideas is needed to reinvigorate American prosperity into the 21st century. if you hear someone saying this from the perspective of a non-american does that sound america maximalist no well right yeah no it doesn't right um like it does it does get a little bit complicated right because like like there is definitely a like i think a real effect where there's like some americans that sort of act like the non-america world doesn't exist but i think like just uh you know this the sentence that i just said like you know it is totally innocuous right um the difference though is that uh being people are frequently born into america and then that's just like not actually their choice whereas when you come into the crypto space you're kind of like a blank slate and you get to choose your chain or tribe that you align with so i think that's the main biggest difference there that is true um though i think uh oh no i feel like the whole like i've even seen immigrants to america uh like but be on both sides of the you know, we love American prosperity discourse.
But I think, you know, even still, like sometimes like, oh, look, the point that I want to make about Ethereum, right, is that I think that there should be a way to talk about Ethereum that doesn't implicitly, you know, lend credence to the, you know, the Lunas and the XRPs and the IOTAs and the Bitcoin Satoshi's visions of the world, But that still does leave room for kind of valuing the good and the honorable things that are happening in other ecosystems. Right. So, like, I'm happy to say that, you know, I think the Cosmos ecosystem, for example, I, you know, I deeply respect it because it is one of the few that's actually trying a very different region of design space.
And, you know, they have this vision of, you know, a larger number of blockchains. Each of those blockchains has a small number of validators. They use these protocols to talk to each other. And they give up on shared security, but they give up on tight coupling, but they have modularity. And, you know, here's their arguments for why this might be a good idea. And, like, I really respect the fact that, you know, they have a technical vision. They push a technical vision first. They, in my view, have not been pump and dumpy. You know, they have not done any, they have not bought any stadiums. They, you know, have not put the face of their founder up on cylinders all over San Francisco.
So, look, that's something I respect. You know, the Zcash ecosystem, I think I've talked about them consistently many times. You know, Bitcoin, I value the self-custody ethos and the decentralization ethos. And I think that's one that we have a lot to learn from. Right. So the thing that I'm getting at is that I think there should be a way to like both talk about Ethereum and even talk about Ethereum, like non-Ethereum projects that we still think are contributing to good, but in a way where like we're not extending alliance to everyone by default. And so this is like, this is one of the things that I'm in the process of thinking through, right?
Like basically, what exactly is the right formula for doing that? Like if you think about things from that perspective, right? Like in 2022, what's the worst thing that happened in Ethereum land? I would say probably like, see, this also depends on how you define Ethereum land because NFTs, Bored Apes, for example, right? Some people would point to that and say, look, celebrity endorsements, kind of pump and dump NFT. where's the nft well that was an erc 721 on what on ethereum so is ethereum ecosystem question mark i don't know uh maybe something like that i would point to i think if bored apes are the worst thing that happened in ethereum in 2022 that's really doing okay yeah i agree with that too yeah okay um what's what's the worst thing that happened in cosmos in 2022 i don't oh oh except for tara I mean, do you consider Terran Luna Cosmos?
Yes. Yes, you do. That is true. That is a, yeah. That's why these boundaries are so difficult. Right. It's a good point, right? See, this is why I'm kind of intentionally hedging this as a kind of thought in progress, right? Because I think like ultimately there definitely is a trade-off between being permissionless in the good sense and being permissionless in the sense of like letting literally anyone who wants to come in and borrow your social credibility, which is the type of permissionless us that we don't want. And there's probably some kind of balance to draw between those. Well, so that's actually an interesting case to unpack because like, I feel like no one blames Cosmos, the ecosystem at all for the Terra collapse by the nature of the app chain model.
Everything's kind of like compartmentalized, right? And so while there is composability risks as in the value of UST that got spread across the chains and Cosmos all went to zero, So no one really blames Cosmos as a whole for that by the nature of how app chains come together. Perhaps one of the worst things to answer after I've thought about the question, what's the worst thing that happened in the Ethereum ecosystem? I'm pretty sure the Wonderland drama, which was kind of Ethereum's microcosm of Terra. It was an algorithmic stablecoin. Stablecoin went to zero. Turns out Xerox Sifu was the ex-Quadringa perpetual fraudster scammer person.
uh that did happen on ethereum in ethereum defi uh and so like that that was on our chain that was inside of our borders this is true but i guess the saving grace is like the ethereum influencer elite never treated daniela sesta with risk with the slightest dose of respect right yeah yeah he uh i i fought with him for sure yeah and i'm pretty sure even like the cosmos most influential elite. Did they ever treat Tara with that much deep respect? I actually don't know. I don't think so. I don't remember any instance of this. Right. So Vitalik, one of the main reasons to bring you on the show today is because of a recent fantastic blog post.
I want to connect these conversations that we've had to this blog post first with this first question. One of the things that I've been personally thinking about is, and as a result of your blog posts is one of the main euphoric statements that like I echoed and many people in crypto in 2021 echoed is like, there's going to be a Cambrian explosion of DAOs. There will be so many DeFi apps, NFTs and NFT projects for absolutely everyone. And then and that was like, OK, this is Web3 is replacing the Internet. We have this Internet thing and where it's going to completely be replaced by Web3. So earlier we were having this conversation.
It's like, all right, is crypto Esperanto, Linux or the Internet? And you're like, well, definitely not Esperanto, hopefully more than Linux, perhaps as big as the Internet, but TBD. And then when I was reading some of the components of your blog post, which is, like you said, titled, What Applications in Ethereum That I Believe In, I was thinking like, oh, maybe actually in the DeFi landscape, there's only a handful of very strong, very useful DeFi applications. things like exchange DEXs like Uniswap and SushiSwap, things like borrowing and lending services like Aave. And then, you know, beyond that, a few more, but not too much more after that.
And then also there's a conversation on DAOs. Are there going to be a Cambrian explosion of DAOs where me and my group chat form a DAO? And so does like every other group chat in the world form a DAO? We have all these bajillion DAOs out there, DAOs for every single stated purpose that exists? Or is decentralization much more surgically applied to a few more use cases? And so these are some of the lessons that I'm thinking of. And this is going to think, I think, be an overarching theme for the rest of this podcast. But before we drive into specifically your article, I just want to ask you as a whole, what lessons do you think we learned as an industry in 2022, now that we are in December looking backwards?
Like what lessons did you personally learn, Vitalik? And what lessons do you think we should all make explicit here on this podcast so that we can know to not do them again in 2023 and beyond. Yeah, I think the big takeaway is that I think the crypto space is at its most honorable only insofar as it actually takes its own core principles seriously. So like, I mean, well, what those core principles are should be pretty obvious, right? It's, you know, decentralization, openness, self-custody, being transparent with people, right? And those are all values that FTX did the exact opposite of pretty much since the beginning, right?
And those are, I would say, even values that Terra violated to some extent. I mean, I think Terra is a more complicated case because Terra was a hybrid of a mechanism that was open and transparent, but it was just bad with a mechanism that the rescue fund, which was completely opaque. But that was FTX, I think, definitely, you know, the exact opposite of openness and trustlessness. A lot of the applications that grew a lot, but then ended up completely failing, They probably tried too hard to integrate with the mainstream and doing that by compromising toward the mainstream ways of doing things.
And eventually, you just get to the point where you realize there was just no point in having a blockchain left. So one of the examples of this might be the supply chain blockchain trial. trial. I think it was ASX or one of those groups that did it and it just shut down recently. There's just a lot of these enterprise blockchain projects that have quietly shut down over the last couple of years. And even the blockchain enterprise projects that were not shutting down, they generally went into the direction of, hey, how about we're going to be more public chain now? That's a trend that I feel like we've been talking about for a few years already.
um so what kinds of things have succeeded right so uniswap has succeeded rye has succeeded um die um you know in the middle of a very complicated governance discussion wish it success uh you know the ethereum base layer succeeded ens succeeded right smart contract wallets, rising. Account abstraction, rising. Privacy technology, I think it's obviously hit a speed bump with the various legal issues, but that's, I think, something that is going to continue and is going to pick up again next year and over the next couple of years. So there's just a lot of different things that like actually are blockchain-y and open and decentralized and trusted that basically survived the whole situation completely unscathed, right?
And it's the centralized stuff where everyone is wondering like, you know, hey, am I ever going to get my money back, right? And this, like, there's actually different ways of having this perspective, right? So like, the more crypto negative way of having this perspective would be to say that Like, oh, crypto was more honorable when it understood that it was like a very niche gray market thing, kind of like the Pirate Bay. And it just tried to be that. But then the speculators came in and tried to turn it into something much, much bigger than what it was supposed to be. And that's where all of the biggest, biggest harms are coming from.
Right. So like that's a view that you definitely hear from a certain tribe of like more crypto negative people. But in some ways, that's basically saying the same thing. Right. Right. So, you know, whether you believe the more crypto positive kind of like slant on that or the more crypto negative slants on that, like the core idea that the parts of the crypto space that are honorable are the parts of the crypto space that actually try to stay true to its values, I think is something that there is a very broad agreement on. And that's the thing that I want to double down on. Yeah, agreed. And yeah, the things that did stay true to those decentralization values are still left standing at the end of 2022.
So let's talk about this, because you wrote this post, what in the Ethereum application ecosystem excites me, and you broke it into kind of five different categories, money, DeFi, identity, DAOs, and hybrid applications. and I know you picked these five for a reason. So let's talk about each. And it's actually interesting because that you put money is the first because I think maybe it was, a lot of what you're saying, I think the last time you came into Bankless Podcast or maybe a couple of times ago, Vitalik was like, hey, money is one use case and that's cool, but I'd love to expand outside of money.
And yet money is the very first use case. So could you talk about this? Is this a proven thing? What do you see in the money use case that's actually exciting in Ethereum? No, you make a good point. So I think there has been this contradiction in the Ethereum space almost since the beginning between a vibe that wants to try to be more than just money, in part because it wants to try to be more than just Bitcoin, versus the reality that's just obvious from the outside of the space, which is that cryptocurrency as currency just is far more proven than all of the more speculative stuff. I actually think, though, that the two perspectives are more compatible than it might seem.
And the reason why they're more compatible than it might seem is because of the application category that I spent the least time on in this post is DeFi, right? Like, I think the vibe that I was reacting to when, for example, I made that presentation in Paris about a year and a half ago was one where there was not too much attention on money, a huge amount of attention on all kinds of incredibly complicated DeFi things, and then a tiny amount of attention on, you know, non-money and identity and social stuff, right? And my view on DeFi that we'll get into in this post is basically that I think simple DeFi good, complicated DeFi bad, right?
Like by far the most important applications in the DeFi space in terms of actually being able to provide value to people are just incredibly simple stuff like, for example, stable coins, right? Like stablecoins are DeFi. They do involve significant financial engineering, especially if they are something like DAI or RAI that tries to work without centralized external collateral. But they provide a service that's very simple and dumb to the point where you don't even realize that it's DeFi. But they are DeFi at the same time. Uniswap is DeFi, but it's just so simple. And we've had it for like five years now.
right um prediction markets are defy but we've had them for five years like generally i think defy that we've had had for four years is uh generally a better kind of defy the defy that emerged in the last two years is my general take right and you're not saying that that's just because of how old they are you're talking about there's a certain uh kind of product that came out of the early cohort of DeFi that new DeFi is fundamentally just different from. It's not about the time, right? Exactly. I think, well, it's a product of the time, but it's not about the time, right? It's a product of the time because the applications that emerged in the more old school period were applications that really cared about providing like this specific forms of utility that are very clear to people and in this like very abstract way where they're clear even if you're not part of the ecosystem already whereas the newer stuff it's like oh well we're gonna build a thing and you can liquidity farm it and it looks like you can maybe get 11.
4 percent apr interest and you know hush hush we're not going to talk too much about whether or not the 11.4 percent APR is sustainable. So it just, the newer stuff basically tends to be more often justified by like short-term evidence of what it does. And that's a very bad epistemology in the DeFi space because it's just so easy to get short-term good performance by sacrificing long-term performance, right? Whereas the categories of applications that existed for four years, like if they did not have long-term value people would have forgotten about them by now so that although i would say like honestly four years ago even the ponzi's were more honorable like what do you remember you know you know there were some pretty sophisticated games four years ago right where uh you know there were these uh experiments where people would like stick their money in and then the first person to take their money out would lose some percentage and though you'd have to hold your coins in the system for longer than everyone else or you'd have these games where if you're the last person to touch the thing before no one touches it for 12 hours you get a special reward and like it was just actually fun it was like it was like transparent the ponzi was transparent everyone knew what they were doing rather than this fakery well yeah so the game i'm pretty sure you're referring to is called just game just dot game i think they'd actually migrated to tron because justin sun paid them to but it was very explicitly like this is a ponzi it was a ponzi game but huge emphasis on the word game it was a casino game that would be a great and awesome and fun casino game and it made no intentions on promising any sort of outcome if you lost and i think that's what you're talking about vitalik is like it was more honorable in the sense that like no no one is like if you partake partake in it like that's on you if you lost money exactly whereas the new stuff it's like there's a lot of obfuscation like there's often even layers of obfuscation going on like there is obfuscation uh trying to against vcs obfuscation against regulators obfuscation against uh token holders against early participants and late participants and sometimes it's this kind of layered game where like oh everyone understands that this thing refers to this thing and you know you have these arguments about like well why it has to be this way but then the problem with that with doing things in that way is that it basically creates no way to distinguish uh bits or no way for good projects to distinguish themselves from things where the thing that they're obfuscating is that their entire project disappearance scheme.
And the good side of what emerged in 2021 basically turned out to be unsustainable and ended up just kind of slowly offering lower and lower rates over time. And the bad side of what launched in 2021 just ended up blowing up completely. So in both cases, it was over-optimistic in terms of what it promised, but some of it degraded gracefully and some of it degraded very not gracefully. And so what I want to go back to is just more doubling down on and refining the kind of fewer but really important ingredients that we have already known for quite a few years are actually really valuable and important to people.
So you are still bullish on simple DeFi, complicated DeFi, not so much. Can we go back to kind of the money for a second? And just maybe from somebody who's outside the crypto industry's perspective, like why are you why are you still excited about the money use case in general like why do we need crypto money vitalik like digital money uh a central bank digital currency could do that right we could we could scale out what um paypal is doing or you know um some other kind of aren't you just talking about digital money why why is this crypto money uh different or important well Well, I personally have used like cryptocurrency as money huge numbers of times over this year.
Right. And like for me, the use case basically is like medium scale investments and charity donations. Right. Like, you know, just sending a couple hundred thousand dollars to some charity that's giving money to poor people or supporting health care in Africa or somewhere somewhere like that. Just like quickly routing money to medical organizations that are based in all kinds of countries. These are investing in startups. These are all cases where cryptocurrency is actually significantly more efficient than the existing banking system. And like, I don't think that it's temporary. Like, I think that there's structural reasons why cryptocurrency is better at surviving as a frictionless international thing than fiat traditional banking systems do, right?
And so I think it's actually an open question whether or not CBDC is even – will be able to compete against that in that same way, right? Like if, you know, China launches a DCEP and does a really good job of it, then like that could easily get a lot of adoption in China. But would people be willing to use it in Vietnam or Singapore? I don't know. Right. So whereas cryptocurrency is a thing that actually has like this very international reach already even today. Right. So that's one thing. Um, and that's just to be, it's kind of in a way trying to fulfill a very similar goal as the Esperanto language, which is like, you know, F every single nation state currency, uh, because of the borders.
Uh, but let's make a brand new currency and everyone can use that instead. Exactly. Right. Like for a, uh, from the point of view of a country, uh, government, um, having 10% of your national economy suddenly be carried out in cryptocurrency is much less scary than 10% of your economy suddenly being carried out in US dollars, right? Because in the second case, the US government has power over you. In the first case, it doesn't. So there definitely is this structural aspect where because of its neutrality, cryptocurrency has an advantage that fiat currencies cannot have, right? And like, there are countries that have a reputation for neutrality.
But the problem is that all the countries that have a reputation for neutrality don't have scale. Once a country has scale, it starts to have interests. If they have neutrality, they get eaten up by the countries that don't have neutrality because the countries that don't have neutrality have the larger armies. Exactly. Right. Or potentially just like the larger economy is and the larger will to kind of bully them into going along with the local bloc. I mean, these are things that happen all the time. Certainly. Right. But that's just me, right? So like I interact with lots of people around the world, but I, you know, I'm still ultimately a well-connected rich country person.
But then if you go out away from that and you go to, you know, all kinds of places in Latin America, Africa, Middle East, Southeast Asia and those kinds of places, like there the financial system is often not even well-connected to rich country financial systems, right? Like often enough, cryptocurrency just is by far the easiest way to send money home to people's families. Cryptocurrency can be even the easiest way to make payments. It could be the easiest way to save money that is much more guaranteed to not drop by a factor of two every year for pretty much forever. There are a lot of places where existing fiat currencies are very unstable and existing fiat financial systems are very unconnected and where the banking system doesn't necessarily even want to connect it.
basically because there's just almost no incentive for them to. So those are the kinds of places where I think cryptocurrency just has clearer use cases even today and where I expect it's more valuable to succeed in the long term and where if you go to the places and you go to the meetups and you talk to the people, the culture there just feels much more genuine and more real. It's not talking about these kinds of issues. Theoretically, it's, you know, you have people saying like, hey, I'm from this country. And in my country, there actually was a hyperinflation. And because I was able to put money into Bitcoin and ETH, I was actually able to protect my savings.
And like, these are actual experiences that you regularly hear from people there, right? And I think a culture that is animated by those kinds of goals is just much healthier than a country where the like the thing that it's animated by is like, oh, look, you know, I have a $36,000 monkey and that's my pass to get into some kind of elite New York City nightclub. It's like, if I were to go to a New York City nightclub, I'd almost want to see what would I want out of a New York City nightclub? One is that I would want it to open at 4am instead of closing at 4am. Because I think people who have the discipline to wake up in the morning are possibly more interesting.
I would want to possibly exclude people who have a monkey that costs more than $30,000. Or, you know, pretty much the exact opposite of what the New York City monkey scene is doing right now, right? So that's – you're just not going to get a great culture when you have people that just don't have problems for themselves personally that cryptocurrency can solve other than getting rich off of other people's problems, right? And so the cryptocurrency communities that are best, I think, are the ones that are not in that position. And developing world is one example. And then I think another good example is developed world, but the more activist scene or certain industries that get deplatformed by banks and payment systems all the time and those kinds of things.
So those kinds of places are the places where I actually expect the most interesting work to happen over time. And those are the places that are, in a lot of cases, using blockchains and cryptocurrency already. And I think the main challenge there is that today, a lot of the time, people are using cryptocurrency by interacting with Binance accounts. And it would be ideal if these people had more decentralized options available to them, too. And that's one of the reasons why I'm really excited about the social recovery wallet and smart contract wallet and account abstraction ecosystem. You know, why I'm excited about Layer 2 technology to bring fees down and excited about privacy technology and all these other things.
Arbitrum One is pioneering the world of secure Ethereum scalability and is continuing to accelerate the Web3 landscape. Hundreds of projects have already deployed on Arbitrum One, producing flourishing DeFi and NFT ecosystems. With the recent addition of Arbitrum Nova, gaming and social dApps like Reddit are also now calling Arbitrum home. Both Arbitrum One and Nova leverage the security and decentralization of Ethereum and provide a builder experience that's intuitive, familiar, and fully EVM compatible. On Arbitrum, both builders and users will experience faster transaction speeds with significantly lower gas fees.
With Arbitrum's recent migration to Arbitrum Nitro, it's also now 10 times faster than before. Visit Arbitrum.io where you can join the community, dive into the developer docs, bridge your assets, and start building your first dApp. With Arbitrum, experience Web3 development the way it was meant to be. Secure, fast, cheap, and friction-free. TrueFi is DeFi's largest credit protocol, connecting global lenders with institutional-grade lending opportunities. TrueFi has completed over $1.7 billion in originations and paid out nearly $35 million to lenders, proving that DeFi is ready to take its next big leap into the $8 trillion credit market.
TrueFi gives lenders like you access to sustainable, high-yield opportunities backed by real-world investments, usually reserved for high-net-worth individuals. At the same time, fund managers use TrueFi's financial infrastructure to bring their portfolios on-chain, benefiting from the global liquidity, cost savings, and transparency of DeFi. TrueFi is a decentralized financial utility. The protocol is owned and governed by the TrueFi DAO, and TrueFi is here to bring DeFi into the golden age, bridging the power and access of crypto with institutional-grade lending opportunities and portfolio tooling.
Explore the diverse financial opportunities available on TrueFi or launch your own portfolio at truefi.io. If you've been listening to Bankless, you know that we're fans of the modular blockchain thesis. The idea that blockchains will separate execution from data availability and consensus, allowing all three to become the best versions of themselves. And Fuel has built the fastest modular execution layer in the industry. By supporting parallel transaction execution, Fuel unlocks significantly faster throughput for the Web3 world. Fuel also goes beyond the limitations of the EVM with its own FuelVM, which is more efficient and optimized, opening up the design space for developers.
And lastly, Fuel brings a powerful developer experience with its own domain-specific language, Sway, and a supportive toolchain called Fork. With Fuel, you can have the benefits of smart contract languages like Solidity while adopting the improvements made by the Rust tooling ecosystem, letting the Fuel development environment go beyond the limitations of the EVM. If you want to learn more, there's a link in the show notes to see how you can get involved with the Fuel network. I want to hop back over to the DeFi conversation before we tie a bow on the money and DeFi conversations and move on to the identity conversations.
But on the DeFi conversation, to me, we're in this limbo period where we don't really know if there's going to be a Cambrian explosion of DAOs, a brand new wave of DeFi apps. And one of the things that Ryan and I would previously communicate on the Bankless podcast is that, you know, the application layer, the DeFi layer is always kind of the frontier there. While there's not that many, there's not that much room for layer ones and layer twos out there. Like there can't be there can't be as many blockchains as there are applications. There will naturally be more applications than there are blockchains.
And like kind of a large part of the wealth generation of the protocol layer is not like completely over, but it's we've gone through that adoption wave. Like Ethereum is half a trillion dollars or maybe a quarter trillion dollars. And so like one of the things we've communicated is that like the application layer is where a lot of the wealth is left to create. There's a lot of wealth creation on the application layer. And so maybe you were too late to explore the rise of the protocols, but the rise of the applications will never stop coming, right? There will always be new applications on the frontier to explore.
And that is where, that's why some of the concentration of wealth in Ethereum I don't think is the biggest problem because the application layer is this natural diffusing mechanism because new DeFi apps, new tokens, tokens go up and down, and a new place to establish wealth. But if I'm now kind of considering that there's actually fewer DeFi applications than there really needs to be, and instead of there needing to be thousands and thousands of DeFi apps, there really only needs to be like 10 or 15 to really be comprehensive. Now I'm starting to worry that there is less churn and there is less opportunity out there.
Do you have any thoughts or reflections on this? There's definitely less low-hanging fruit out there, right? And I think that's important to just recognize. And I think there's a huge amount of opportunity, right? Like if you can make a wallet that a billion people use, that's a huge opportunity. If you can make a stable coin that can actually survive, you know, anything up to and including a US dollar hyperinflation and, you know, doge forbid the US dollar hyperinflation actually ends up happening, then, you know, that's a huge opportunity as well. If you can, you know, create something that can actually, you know, be a lifeline for everyone going through that situation.
If you can get sign in with Ethereum to work and you can like unseat Facebook and, you know, Google and Twitter as the kind of login overlords of the internet, that itself is a huge opportunity, right? And there are still huge things that are left on claims that still can be built, but they're harder to build, right? Like you can't just build, you know, obfuscated casinos and get people to throw $13 million in and just have a fairly quick path to victory. So that's the place where I think the space is in now. And I think the people that are going to be more successful are the people that are actually willing to put that kind of hard work in.
Next on your list of applications that you believe in is identity. And there's a line in your article that I'd really like to pull out where you say, for a long time, I have been bullish on blockchain identity, but bearish on blockchain identity platforms. Can you unpack the difference between those two things? What's the difference between blockchain identity versus an identity platform? Sure. So identity is a complicated term that refers to a whole bunch of different ideas, right? So the concept of authentication, just proving that the identity that you are using to sign a particular message, to post a particular message, to send a transaction is the same identity that you registered at some point before, right?
Even if it's totally pseudonymous, like even if it's a PHP public key, that is part of identity. Attestations. I attest that David Hoffman and Ryan Sean Adams are both participants in this thing called Bankless. That's part of identity. The government of Canada attests that I, Vitalik Kabutarin, am a citizen. That's part of identity. identity, domain names or .eth names like Vitalik.eth, also parts of identity, proof of personhood, proving that I'm a unique human and this is the only account that belongs to me in the system. That's part of identity, right? Identity is this very nebulous bubble term that refers to all of these things.
And sometimes when people say they need an identity solution, they might be referring to any one of those or any combination of them. And those problems are very different problems and they're problems that have very different properties. Like they have, for example, very different properties in terms of the level of centralization they might require in terms of the level, the extents to which the problems are social, the extents to which you can make a solution that works for a small number of people that doesn't grow beyond that small number of people. And these are all actual use cases and they're all specific needs that people have.
But the problem is that for the last decade, I've also noticed this very abstract blockchain identity discourse, where there were people that have been intentionally trying to create identity platforms. They're people who tried to create identity blockchains. And I'm, by default, and have been and still am very not bullish on a lot of those, right? Because basically, they just have the mindset of starting from the point of view of identity as an abstraction, as opposed to starting from the point of view of a concrete set of use cases that people care about, regardless of whether or not they can later narrativize those use cases into being part of some grander space that they can call identity, right?
It's like meme first as opposed to problem first. And problem first is the approach that I think is more viable there. And I think it's more viable everywhere. And I think Ethereum is the place where identity solutions in the sense of solutions to all of these specific problems that I identified are happening and are pretty rapidly growing. I think part of your answer is that identity isn't something that you can go headfirst at. You can't make an identity app. You can't have an identity startup. Identity is something that is emergent. It is something that is naturally composed from many different sources of inputs that may or may not be able to interoperate with each other.
Is that a fair assessment? Yep. I mean, it almost has to be like a byproduct of the thing that you're building, right? Like in a certain way, like why is there sign on with Google or sign on with Facebook? It's not because they started with the identity solution, but it's because Google made Gmail just so damn valuable and its app ecosystem. And so everyone has a Gmail account and now you can use that to sign in. And I'm just wondering how you think identity solutions, again, we could have the Esperanto problem for just a microcosm of identity where we create all these great identity solutions.
We're like, hey, world, come use it. And the world's like, we don't care. We'll just use English. It's fine. How do you think identity actually happens as an export from the crypto world? Like practically, how does this bottom-up emergent thing manifest? I think you had it exactly right in that whatever the thing is that gets the network effect has to get the network effect for some other reason first. One example that I think is good to zero in on is Ethereum wallets versus PGP keys. PGP keys have for a long time been the number one cypherpunk meme. We have a cypherpunk world when everyone has a PGP key and when people could use this PGP keys to sign and encrypt messages to each other.
And that's been around since what, like the early 90s? Yeah. People tried really hard to have key signing parties and attest to each other and have PGP encrypted email and even have all kinds of apps to make it easier. And all of these different overlay layers. But just none of them have really worked well. And what has worked well? Well, guess what? We have Ethereum accounts now. And what is an Ethereum account? Well, it's a private and public key pair. And so now guess what? You can sign into stuff with an Ethereum key. You can encrypt stuff to people's Ethereum keys with a tiny bit of extra work, right?
And so you just get all of this immediate benefit that's only possible because you already have a user base of billions of people that have Ethereum wallets, which they got originally for basically financial reasons, right? Because they wanted to hold cryptocurrency or do DeFi stuff and occasionally NFT stuff with it. So one question I have about this model, I think it requires a significant amount of standardization across attestations, on specifically the attestation side of things. Like Vitalik attests that Ryan and David do this bankless thing uh the uh country of canada attests that ryan was once a citizen there sorry for doxing you ryan uh america attests that i'm a citizen of america uh spotify attests that i'm a huge fan of the sheepdogs how do we do these things need to be the same standards or how do we make this uh the identity of all these different attestations all composed together so that we have like my identity rather than just like a bunch of disparate systems that don't really talk to each other?
I think standards will emerge over time, right? Like the Pope protocol exists and lots of people use it. And Pope, I think has so far been more successful within the Ethereum ecosystem than anything that calls itself an attestation protocol, right? Like they've, you know, actually gone out there. They have the network effect. Lots of people have Popes. I have dozens of Popes and the thing works and the thing is continuing to grow. So that's just one example of something that I think is succeeding. I think there's definitely room for a couple of other things to succeed as well. And then at some point, they're going to grow to the point where they have to talk to each other.
And at some point, they're probably going to agree on aligning cryptographic standards or something like that. And, you know, hopefully we'll get to something reasonably sane. Why is identity in the crypto space? It's a huge conversation. We all, everyone comes into crypto and they kind of get this vague semblance of an idea that like something about crypto has to do with identity. Then they learn about like, oh, my Ethereum address can represent me. But why is this better than my nation state identity? What is lacking in nation state identities that Ethereum or private key identities really brings to the table?
Like, why is this not a meme and why is this actually a good product? I mean, it solves problems that people actually have, right? Like people, I think, obviously wants to have an identity in the sense of like just wanting to have an identifier, like a username that other people can use to talk to each other. Crypto, in addition to being a useful set of products, is an ecosystem and a community. and people in that community want to talk to each other. So it serves that need too. People, I think, wants to be able to do stuff on the internet without that stuff being dependent on Google or Facebook or Twitter, being able to do whatever they want with their accounts or even just seeing all of the actions that they're taking.
so there's this like clear value that i think speaks to things that people in the in the crypto space want to do and even to dreams that people outside of the crypto space have have had for a long time right like this is um you know making the internet more decentralized in a way that i think a lot of people have wanted to for like decades at this point and so i think it's a in a great place to actually get that kind of adoption I think one of the one things that really excites people about identity and crypto and, you know, really Ethereum sign this whole like sign in with Ethereum movement is that it's actually really easy to envision login with Facebook, login with Google, login with MetaMask or Rainbow Wallet or something.
Is that is that the goal that we're looking for? Is that like when you said like the decentralization of the Internet? Is that one of the parts of the Internet that we can actually decentralize with Ethereum? Is that like the explicit vision that you kind of have? I think absolutely. Okay. All right. Well, Bankless Nation, you got your work cut out for you. I think actually, I think on an identity, this is going to be seen as a big win for nation states. Well, there's a portion of nation states who are a little bit like, don't step into the money thing. We have that covered. I mean, what kind of nation state doesn't want the bot problem mitigated on the internet and to help identify who the humans are and who the robots.
And by the way, the nation's day answer to this is a social security number and a driver's license that you have to like and like a selfie. Come on. That is not internet native at all. So there's some low hanging fruit here if we can do this. But let's talk about DAOs for a minute, Vitalik. So we think about DAOs, the use case. You said you're still bullish on them. Are DAOs going to replace corporations? Is there something less that they will do? Why are you still excited about DAOs as an application and what function do you think they can fulfill? Yeah, so ironically enough, I think DAOs are well set to replace a lot of things other than corporations, right?
Like corporations are actually one of the forms that I kind of specified that DAOs are less likely to be able to replace. And the reason for that is that I think corporations benefit from the ability to pivot and ability to pivot is like almost the inherent opposite of a certain type of decentralization that people really want. But also corporations are not, they are big enough that they can afford to set up like more regular infrastructure, like legal infrastructure and security infrastructure and so forth. And so they don't really benefit well from the other architecture, which is like, hey, let's just not bother with that stuff and have a multi-sig of seven people, right?
So my view is basically that there's two architectures that make sense. One of those architectures is like, let's quickly spin up a multisig of seven people. And the other architecture is, let's think really hard and create something that's very credible and neutral, very able to resist all kinds of takeover attacks and use it to run really important stuff that we want to last for many decades, right? Whether that's ENS or whether that's a stable coin or something like proof of humanity or something like Kleros. Like, let's figure out how to make that extremely robust, right? So that's something where I think a DAO makes a lot of sense.
And then the multi-sig of seven people use cases are use cases where I think something that you could call a DAO makes a lot of sense, right? But it's like a DAO where you're not really emphasizing the smart contract logic. you're emphasizing more the decentralization of just like very open and spontaneous collaboration patterns that can be very agile between fairly small groups of people. And the smart contract side of things is actually pretty minimal, right? So those are the two architectures that I'm more bullish on. Architectures that try to do something else I'm less bullish on, right? So like things So like the original DAO trying to be a DAO that is a VC fund, the more time goes on, the more I think, yeah, actually, that doesn't really make a huge amount of sense.
In those kinds of cases, you're getting the disadvantages of decentralization, which are that you move slower and that you open up things that other people in a competitive environment can use against you. But you're not really getting too many benefits from decentralization either. So if you want to do that kind of VC fund, you just spin up a VC fund, right? Whereas a DAO for MakerDAO or a DAO for Proof of Humanity or a DAO for ENS, that's something where that kind of value makes sense. And then a DAO in the sense of a group of five or seven people that just wants to quickly collaborate without bothering with a legal entity.
That's also something that makes a lot of sense. And do you think, Vitalik, there's going to be some innovation in the governance structure of DAOs? Or do you think we've basically discovered all possible governance that could work with DAOs? I think we need innovation. So this gets into one of the other topics I've been really big on over the last year, which is non-financialized governance, like governance that can resist attacks from, say, 51% of the token holders or the token holders getting bribed or those kinds of situations. And I even argue that it's the financial use cases where definancialized governance is the most important.
Like if you look at a stablecoin, for example, like MakerDAO, it has, I think, what were the stats? I think I had them in the post. $7.8 billion of collateral. But the market cap of the Maker token itself is like somewhere around $500 million. dollars right and so if maker tail really was governed by maker holders in an unrestricted way then you could just go and buy up half the maker tokens and then use that to manipulate the oracles and you could steal a huge portion of all the collateral and that would just be a really big and profitable multi-billion dollar attack right now the reason why that hasn't happened to maker down specifically is because maker holdings are fairly concentrated and there's like maybe a dozen people that have more than half the total supply.
And it just so happens that those dozen people are kind of fairly aligned on the vision and they're either honest or at least they have enough other interests that would be really hurt if they did something like that. But in the long term, that's not the sort of thing that you really want to rely on. And so I think it's obvious that if you want a stablecoin that scales, the collateral has to exceed the market cap of the profit-taking token and probably by even more than 17x. But if you want to do that, you have to have some kind of governance that's not financialized or some kind of governance where there's some kind of intentional friction or speed bump that prevents MKR holders or the token holders of the system from being able to quickly implement whatever gold they want and take over the system.
As you're talking about all of this, I just want to remind listeners to a bankless mental model that's at least helped me think through this. And this is like from games like Civilization that maybe some of you have played where you have this concept of as you're leveling up your civilization, you have like a tech tree, right? And you have to learn the basics of like mathematics before many generations later in the tech tree, you can build nuclear reactors with your civilization or launch someone to the moon. Like you need your math before you get your physics, before you get your nuclear reactors.
And the question people have outside of crypto is like, okay, cool, you've been talking about this forever. how come you haven't done it? Well, think about the tech tree, right? You sort of need the money DeFi use case in order to build the network effect for identity to be valuable. And then once you have identity, you can start to tweak governance because some of the non-financial governance cases that you just mentioned really aren't very possible without identity and knowing who's a human who's not on chain. And so this is all kind of a big Ethereum tech tree that we're kind of building out in parallel.
That's what this reminds me of anyway, which lends me to kind of the last piece of what you wrote, Vitalik, this category for hybrid applications. What are hybrid applications? Can you just like tease that out for us for a minute? Hybrid applications are applications that are not entirely on-chain, but that benefit from being connected to a chain, right? So basically think of it as centralized services that use the chain and commitments published to a chain as a way to constrain their behavior and keep the system honest. So the nice thing about hybrid applications is that they, I mean, obviously scalability challenges basically don't exist with them, right?
Like as long as you can make, you know, ZK-SNARKs that are powerful enough, you can make some of these applications already. So scalability challenges don't exist. Privacy challenges are a lot smaller, especially if you can trust the provider. And sometimes even if you can't trust the provider even. And the deployments challenges are much simpler because in a lot of these cases, it's not even something that requires changing the workflow of the user. It's like purely an overlay that runs on the side and only people who want to interact with you overly have to, right? So probably the simplest example of this actually is making centralized exchanges safer with proof of solvency protocols, right?
Like if you have exchanges that actually, you know, publish commitments to say the, all of their user liabilities, that's, and then they have assets on chain and by having assets on chain, they're proving that they actually have the assets that match the user liabilities. Like that is an example of an application that does use the chain and even uses cryptocurrency, but it is also a centralized application. And that application could keep the workflow of being a centralized application, but still get a lot of benefits from being hooked into and kind of being shackled by the decentralized system.
Games are another example, right? You can have game servers that post the state to chain using zero knowledge proofs. And that basically binds them to actually follow the rules that they committed to. The Dark Forest game, right, is probably one example of this. Voting, yeah, I mentioned as an example. And there's many different kinds of voting, even going all the way down to something as simple as like Twitter polls, for example, right? Like you could imagine a blockchain-based Twitter like Farcaster, say, an Ethereum-based Twitter like Farcaster, make a poll where you use one of these fancy voting mechanisms to vote in the poll.
And the voting is totally private. The voting is even coercion resistant. And that's also hooked into popes. And so you can limit the poll to a certain group of people. right but then well forecaster is like i guess not quite a hybrid application because forecaster is aiming to be a decentralized system but you know you could imagine something kind of centralized like also plug those kinds of components in right and so you get kind of the efficiency of centralization and the robustness benefits of decentralization at the same time right so i think there's a really huge number of applications in this category like on some level almost anything can be improved by requiring it to submit routes to chain and requiring it to be open about when it changes its rules, right?
And that's just something that you can just like go and add on. And, you know, it might not have benefits at first, but it might have benefits that appear years down the line. And just the cost of doing it is in the long run so low that I think there's a bunch of applications where it makes sense. Yeah, I actually haven't really spent too much time thinking about this, but this is actually really kind of mind blowing in the sense that it's actually doing some of the things that we're already doing in other parts of the Ethereum landscape. Like what do layer twos do? They post data to the Ethereum layer one that forces the layer two to play by the rules, right?
And this is kind of the same model for what you're saying. You can see so many other use cases. What is proof of reserves? It's a centralized company that's not really changing much else about this business, but it's posting data to a public blockchain that allows people to check on itself. And so you're just saying that the general purpose utility of centralized companies, centralized teams, centralized projects, whatever, can just publicly post data to a chain that allows humans to check on whether or not that company or team or whatever is doing the thing that they originally committed to doing.
And really, what is the original ethos of a blockchain to begin with? The whole idea of a chain, a blockchain, is to like check on human folly, right? Make sure that humans are not being bad and being able to verify that. And I think the flexibility that this model offers, which is just like, hey, you have a centralized company that requires human trust. Well, you can prove that trust with a blockchain is like probably I think the most broad utility, broad way to provide blockchain assurances to the world that I can really think of. Yep, absolutely. That's their goal. So the broader question, I think really the reason how that will actually end up is just like at some point, the companies that do this just have a competitive advantage versus the ones that don't.
That's like perhaps like the capitalism market forces argument for why this will happen. But I want to kind of zoom back into the near term and also go into one of the last sections in your article, Vitalik, which is how do we get there? And then a quote from your article I want to read is that the Luna market cap got over to $30 billion, while stable coins that were striving for robustness and simplicity are often ignored for years. Non-financial applications often have no hope of earning $30 billion because they do not have a token at all. But it is these applications that will be the most valuable for the ecosystem in the long term, and that will bring the most lasting value to both their users and those who build and support them.
This paints this picture that all these flashy scams like the Lunas, the Wonderlands, FTX will always get more attention and more adoption than like these boring, hardened, basic primitives that like crypto so desperately needs. And so this kind of lends itself italics like one of my existential crises I've been having recently is that like crypto might actually not be good in the short term because it takes longer for these hardened real protocols to get built out. Meanwhile, we can generate like 10,000 APY Ponzi's along the way for three bull markets in a row. Do you think that this illustration of crypto is true?
And how do you how do you suggest that we accelerate the good things that we can take and show our moms? This is where we get back to one of my points a bit earlier. We have to recognize our own agency. I think all just needs to work much harder at both doing all that we can to help those applications and doing less that we can to help applications that even if they look shiny in the moment are not actually all that meaningful long-term. You know, just being willing to get excited about stuff other than making huge amounts of money. You know, organizations in the space can do much more to explicitly support some of those projects, right?
Like, even just, you know, giving grant like a few million dollars worth of grants to people who are honestly trying like trying to make wallets that properly solve the self-custody problem right like these are try to get to the point where like the uh how hard you have to work to get uh to get funding as a wallet developer is like at least comes close to approaching how um how easy it was if you were just running a DeFi project. It's just also just like talking about the, some of the problems that these projects are solving and why it's, why it's so important to solve them. I think it's the best that we can do for now is a combination of all of those things.
Another important thing that I think is important for the space to do is like continue the conversation with regulators. and not just in the United States, but regulators around the world, right? I think it's important to get out the message that what we as the Ethereum space want is not even necessarily a regulatory environment that's friendly to everyone, but a regulatory environment that satisfies the requirements of being maximum friendly to like say people building account abstraction wallets or working on zero knowledge proof protocols, but without being friendly to Duke One, right? And like, what does that even look like?
It's another one of the conversations that I think is worth having and trying to figure out, right? Because I think at this point, the, you know, well, the political appetite to make an environment that's friendly to Duke One is like definitely close to zero at this point, right? And so I think it's important to kind of take the lead in the conversation of like how to be friendly to people making account abstraction wallets specifically without being friendly to Dookwon. And that's a more difficult one. And that's definitely something that I'll keep thinking about too. Yeah, I completely agree.
By the way, I'd love to see a Vitalik regulatory post sometime on Vitalik.ca. I think that would be a cool post. Vitalik, thanks a lot. We appreciate you coming on and talking about all these things. Maybe just sort of final question on a little bit of a personal note. I'm just curious for you. So we are ending 2022, entering 2023. It's been a big year, certainly for Ethereum, a lot to be excited about at the end of 2022, shipping the merge, all of these things. But what do you see your role in crypto as, as we move into 2023 and beyond? You know, the old office space. what is it that you'd say that you would that you do here uh vitalik like what's what's kind of your role how would you describe yourself i i feel like the answer is still some of everything right like i think now that might change over time you know that but it might be other things too right but for now um you know it's uh definitely some combination of like increasingly trying to help projects that I like that are building good applications succeed and, you know, helping to explore and understand the application space better.
You know, still a lot of important Ethereum protocol stuff better and, you know, participating in the discussion on like scaling, trying to kind of push the EVM in a good trajectory. So it gets, you know, functionality that people want without getting the complexity that people don't want. trying to, I guess, continue to interact and connect with the various Ethereum communities around the world. I've made it a goal next year to spend some time visiting places that I have historically not spent much time visiting. I mean, that was my goal for this year too, right? And I did end up spending months in Latin America, but next year, other places too.
So that's, Right now, definitely some of everything and some of just letting other good people continue doing great work. And I guess helping the Ethereum ecosystem move over to being this very stable and self-supporting thing that just keeps going forward on its own. Are you really trying to turn gas into mana? Is that really a thing? It's a good question. I was going to ask, what do you think the odds of your ability to do this is? I have thought about this, right? And I think the one place where we could do that is in the context of multi-dimensional EIP-1559, right? The system proposal where instead of having just one gas limit, we have one limit for computation and then one for data and one for maybe storage operations.
One of the dimensions could just be called mana. And I think that would be cool and fun. I like Ethereum being fun. But if it's going to be anywhere, that would be the place where it is. But we'll see. That's awesome. Wait, was there a World of Warcraft? Was mana a thing in World of Warcraft? I don't remember my wild days. Yeah, yeah. Mana is the primary limited resource for anyone using magic. This was the game all along. Vitalik wanted to create mana in this decentralized ecosystem, all the way back to his nerfed World of Warcraft character. It's come full circle. Indeed. like you know you have ethereum you have soulbound tokens uh we're getting closer vitalik this is a diablo maxi podcast by the way yeah it's true it's true you gotta confess still still blizzard though uh same company used to be so blizzard uh vitalik thanks a lot we really appreciate it yeah no thank you guys too it's been great action items for you bankless Nation, another fantastic Vitalik podcast.
We've got a few more in the queue. We'll throw, sorry, a few more from the archive. We'll throw links to those in the show notes. Also, you got to read what in the Ethereum application ecosystem excites me by Vitalik. We'll include a link in the show notes. There's also another article I want to draw some attention to. It's an article that was posted earlier by the time you listened to this last week from Astral Codex 10. It's called Why I'm less than infinitely hostile to cryptocurrency. Why I'm less than infinitely hostile to cryptocurrency. I think a great article from an outsider's perspective, looking into the space and very rational as to which use cases have succeeded.
So go read those. And that's it. Gotta end with this. As always, none of this has been financial advice. It never is on Bankless, of course. ethereum is risky you could lose what you put in but we're headed west this is the frontier it's not for everyone but we're glad you're with us on the bankless journey thanks a lot hey we hope you enjoyed the video if you did head over to bankless hq right now to develop your crypto investing skills and learn how to free yourself from banks and gain your financial independence we recommend joining our daily newsletter podcast and community as a bankless premium subscriber to get the most out of your Bankless experience.
You'll get access to our market analysis, our alpha leaks, and exclusive content, and even the Bankless token for airdrops, raffles, and unlocks. If you're interested in crypto, the Bankless community is where you want to be. Click the link in the description to become a Bankless premium subscriber today. Also, don't forget to subscribe to the channel for in-depth interviews with industry leaders, ask me anythings, and weekly roll-ups where we summarize the week in crypto and other fantastic content. Thanks everyone for watching and being on the journey as we build out the Bankless Nation.