Eliezer Yudkowsky is an author, founder, and leading thinker in the AI space.
------ ✨ DEBRIEF | Unpacking the episode: https://shows.banklesshq.com/p/debrief-eliezer ------ ✨ COLLECTIBLES | Collect this episode: https://collectibles.bankless.com/mint
------ We wanted to do an episode on AI… and we went deep down the rabbit hole. As we went down, we discussed ChatGPT and the new generation of AI, digital superintelligence, the end of humanity, and if there’s anything we can do to survive.
This conversation with Eliezer Yudkowsky sent us into an existential crisis, with the primary claim that we are on the cusp of developing AI that will destroy humanity.
Be warned before diving into this episode, dear listener. Once you dive in, there’s no going back.
------ 📣 MetaMask Learn | Learn Web3 with the Leading Web3 Wallet https://bankless.cc/
------ 🚀 JOIN BANKLESS PREMIUM: https://newsletter.banklesshq.com/subscribe
------ BANKLESS SPONSOR TOOLS:
🐙KRAKEN | MOST-TRUSTED CRYPTO EXCHANGE https://bankless.cc/kraken
🦄UNISWAP | ON-CHAIN MARKETPLACE https://bankless.cc/uniswap
⚖️ ARBITRUM | SCALING ETHEREUM https://bankless.cc/Arbitrum
👻 PHANTOM | #1 SOLANA WALLET https://bankless.cc/phantom-waitlist
------ Topics Covered
0:00 Intro 10:00 ChatGPT 16:30 AGI 21:00 More Efficient than You 24:45 Modeling Intelligence 32:50 AI Alignment 36:55 Benevolent AI 46:00 AI Goals 49:10 Consensus 55:45 God Mode and Aliens 1:03:15 Good Outcomes 1:08:00 Ryan’s Childhood Questions 1:18:00 Orders of Magnitude 1:23:15 Trying to Resist 1:30:45 Miri and Education 1:34:00 How Long Do We Have? 1:38:15 Bearish Hope 1:43:50 The End Goal
------ Resources:
Eliezer Yudkowsky https://twitter.com/ESYudkowsky
MIRI https://intelligence.org/
Reply to Francois Chollet https://intelligence.org/2017/12/06/chollet/
Grabby Aliens https://grabbyaliens.com/
----- Not financial or tax advice. This channel is strictly educational and is not investment advice or a solicitation to buy or sell any assets or to make any financial decisions. This video is not tax advice. Talk to your accountant. Do your own research.
Disclosure. From time-to-time I may add links in this newsletter to products I use. I may receive commission if you make a purchase through one of these links. Additionally, the Bankless writers hold crypto assets. See our investment disclosures here: https://www.bankless.com/disclosures
No summary for this episode yet.
I think that we are hearing the last wins to start to blow. The fabric of reality start to fray. This thing alone cannot end the world, but I think that probably some of the vast quantities of money being blindly and helplessly piled into here are going to end up actually accomplishing something. Welcome to Bankless, where we explore the frontier of internet money and internet finance. This is how to get started, how to get better, how to frontrun the opportunity. This is Ryan Sean Adams, I'm here with David Hoffman and we're here to help you become more Bankless. Okay guys, we wanted to do an episode on AI at Bankless, but I feel like David.
God, what we asked for. We accidentally waited into the deep end of the bull year. And I think as we get, before we get into this episode, it probably warrants a few comments. I'm going to say a few things I'd like to hear from you too. But one thing I want to tell the listener is, don't listen to this episode if you're not ready for an existential crisis. Okay, I'm kind of serious about this. I am leaving this episode shaken. And I don't say that lightly. In fact, David, I think you and I will have some things to discuss in the debrief as far as how this impacted you. But this wasn't an impactful one, it sort of hit me during the recording.
And I didn't know fully how to react. I honestly am coming out of this episode, wanting to refute some of the claims made in this episode by our guest. Eliezer Yikowsky, who makes the claim that humanity is on the cusp of developing an AI that's going to destroy us. And that there's really not much we can do to stop it. There's no way around it. Yeah. I have a lot of respect for this guest. Let me say that. So it's not as if I have some sort of big brain technical disagreement here. In fact, I don't even know enough to fully disagree with anything he's saying. But the conclusion is so dire and so existentially heavy that I'm worried about it impacting you, listener, if we don't give you this warning going in.
I also feel like David, as interviewers, maybe we could have done a better job. I'll say this on behalf of myself. Sometimes I peppered him with a lot of questions in one fell swoop and he was probably only ready to synthesize one at a time. I also feel like we got caught flat-footed at times. I wasn't expecting his answers to be so frank and so dire, David. It was just a berift of hope. And I appreciated very much the honesty as we always do on bankless. But I appreciated it almost in the way that a patient might appreciate the honesty of their doctor telling them that their illness is terminal.
Like it's still really heavy news, isn't it? So that is the context going into this episode. I will say one thing in good news for our failings as interviewers in this episode. They might be remedied because at the end of this episode, after we finished with the record button to stop recording, Eleazar said he'd be willing to provide additional Q&A episode with the bankless community. So if you guys have questions and if there's sufficient interest for Eleazar to answer, tweet us to express that interest. Hit us in discord. Get those messages over to us and let us know if you have some follow-up questions.
He said, if there's enough interest in the community in the crypto community, I'll say he'd be willing to come on and do another episode with follow-up Q&A. Maybe even a Italic and Eleazar episode is in store. That's a possibility that we threw to him. We've not talked to Vitalik about that too, but I just feel a little overwhelmed by the subject matter here. And that is the basis, the preamble through which we are introducing this episode. David, there's a few benefits and takeaways I want to get into. But before I do, can you comment or reflect on that preamble? What are your thoughts going to this one?
We approach the end of our agenda for every bankless podcast. There's an equivalent agenda that runs alongside of it. But once we got to this crux of this conversation, it was not possible to proceed in that agenda because what was the point? Nothing else really matters, which is also just kind of relates to the subject matter at hand. And so as we proceed, you'll see us kind of circle back to the same inevitable conclusion over and over and over again, which ultimately is kind of the punchline of the content. And so I'm of a specific disposition where stuff like this, I kind of am like, oh, whatever.
Okay, just go about my life. Other people are of different dispositions and take these things more heavily. So Ryan's warning at the beginning is to view our type of person to take existential crises directly to the face, perhaps consider doing something else instead of listening to this episode. I think that is good counsel. So a few things if you're looking for an outline of the agenda, we start by talking about chat GPT. Is this a new era of artificial intelligence? Gotta begin the conversation there. Number two, we talk about what an artificial super intelligence might look like. How smart exactly is it?
What types of things could it do that humans cannot do? Number three, we talk about why an AI super intelligence will almost certainly spell the end of humanity. And why it'll be really hard if not impossible, according to our guest, to stop this from happening. And number four, we talk about if there is absolutely anything we can do about all of this. We are heading careening maybe towards the abyss. Can we divert direction and not go off the cliff? That is the question we ask Elisa with. David, I think you and I have a lot to talk about during the debrief. All right, guys, the debrief is an episode that we record right after the episode.
It's available for all bankless citizens. We call this the bankless premium feed. You can access that now to get our raw and unfiltered thoughts on the episode. And I think it's going to be pretty raw this time around. David, I'm like, I didn't expect this to hit you so hard. Oh, I'm dealing with it right now. Really? And this is probably, you know, it's not too long after the episode. So, yeah, I don't know how this, how I'm going to feel tomorrow. But I definitely want to talk to you about this and maybe have you time. I'll put my card on, yeah, please. I'm in some help. Guys, we're going to get right to the episode with Elisa.
But before we do, we want to thank the sponsors that made this episode possible, including Kraken, our favorite recommended exchange for 2023. Kraken has been a leader in the crypto industry for the last 12 years. Dedicated to accelerating the global adoption of crypto, Kraken puts an emphasis on security, transparency, and client support, which is why over 9 million clients have come to love Kraken's products. Whether you're a beginner or a pro, the Kraken UX is simple, intuitive, and frictionless, making the Kraken app a great place for all to get involved and learn about crypto. For those with experience, the redesigned Kraken Pro app and web experience is completely customizable to your trading needs, integrating key trading features into one seamless interface.
Kraken has a 24.7365 client support team that is globally recognized. Kraken support is available wherever, whenever you need them by phone, chat, or email. And for all of you NFTers out there, the brand new Kraken NFT beta platform gives you the best NFT trading experience possible. Rarity rankings, no gas fees, and the ability to buy an NFT straight with cash. Does your crypto exchange prioritize its customers the way Kraken does? And if not, sign up with Kraken at Kraken.com slash bankless. The Phantom Wallet is coming to Ethereum. The number one wallet on Solana is bringing its millions of users and beloved UX to Ethereum and Polygon.
If you haven't used Phantom before, you've been missing out. Phantom was one of the first wallets to pioneer Solana staking inside the wallet and will be offering similar staking features for Ethereum and Polygon, but that's just staking. Phantom is also the best home for your NFTs. Phantom has a complete set of features to optimize your NFT experience, pin your favorites, hide the uglies, remove the spam, and also manage your NFT sale listings from inside the wallet. Phantom is of course a multi-chain wallet, but it makes chain management easy, displaying your transactions in a human readable format, with automatic warnings for malicious transactions or phishing websites.
Phantom has already saved over 20,000 users from Giddings GAMED or HACT. So, get on the Phantom wait list and be one of the first to access the multi-chain beta. There's a link in the show notes, or you can go to phantom.app slash wait list to get access in late February. Hey, Bankless Nation, if you're listening to this, it's because you're on the free bankless RSS feed. Did you know that there's an ad free version of bankless that comes with the bankless premium subscription? No ads just straight to the content, but that's just one of many things that a premium subscription gets you. There's also the token report, a monthly bullish, bearish, neutral report on the hottest tokens of the month, and the regular updates from the token report go into the token bible.
Your first stop shop for every token worth investigating in crypto. Bankless premium also gets you a 30% discount to the permissionless conference, which means it basically just pays for itself. There's also the airdrop guide to make sure you don't miss a drop in 2023, but really, the best part about bankless premium is hanging out with me, Ryan, and the rest of the bankless team in the inner circle discord only for premium members. Want the alpha? Check out Ben the analyst Dijen Pit, where you can ask him questions about the token report. Got a question? I've got my own Q&A room for any questions that you might have.
At bankless, we have huge things planned for 2023, including a new website with login with your Ethereum address capabilities, and we're super excited to ship what we are calling bankless 2.0 soon TM. So if you want extra help exploring the frontier, subscribe to bankless premium. It's under 50 cent a day and provides a wealth of knowledge and support on your journey west. I'll see you in the discord. Bankless Nation, we are super excited to introduce you to our next guest, Eleazar Yudekowski, is a decision theorist. He's an AI researcher. He's the cedar of the less wrong community blog, fantastic blog, by the way.
There's so many other things that he's also done. I can't I can't fit this in the short bio that we have to introduce you to Eleazar, but most relevant probably to this conversation is he's working at the machine intelligence research institute to ensure that when we do make general artificial intelligence, it doesn't come kill us or at least it doesn't come ban cryptocurrency because that would be a poor outcome as well. Eleazar, it's great to have you on bankless. How are you doing? Within one standard deviation of my own peculiar little mean. Fantastic. We want to start this conversation with something that is jumped onto the scene, I think, for a lot of mainstream folks quite recently.
That is chat GPT. So apparently over 100 million or so have logged on to chat GPT quite recently. I've been playing it with it myself. I found it very friendly, very useful. It even wrote me a sweet poem that I thought was very heartfelt and almost human like. I know that you have major concerns around AI safety and we're going to get into those concerns. But can you tell us in the context of like something like a chat GPT? Is this something we should be worried about that this is going to turn evil and enslave the human race like how should worry should we be about chat GPT and bard and sort of the the new AI that's entered the scene recently?
Chat GPT itself zero. It's not smart enough to do anything really wrong or really write either for that matter. And what gives you the confidence to say that? How do you know this? Excellent question. So every now and then somebody figures out how to put a new prompt into chat GPT. You know, one time somebody found that it would talk, well, not chat GPT, but one of the earlier generations of technology. They found that it would sound smarter if you first told it was aliezeria kowski. You know, there's other prompts too, but that one's one of my favorites. So there's there's untapped potential in there that people haven't figured out how to prompt yet.
But when people figure it out, it moves ahead sufficiently short distances that I do feel fairly confident that there is not so much untapped potential in there that it is going to take over the world. It's like making small movements and to take over the world you need a very large movement. There's capability like there's there's there's places where it falls down on predicting the next line that a human would say in its shoes that seem indicative of probably that capability just is not in the giant inscrutable matrices or it would be using it to predict the next line, which is very heavily what it was optimized for.
So there's there's going to be like some untapped potential in there, but I do feel quite confident that the upper range of that untapped potential is insufficient to outsmart all the living humans and implement the scenario that I'm worried about. So even so though is chat gpt a big leap forward in the journey towards AI in your mind or is this fairly incremental? It's just for whatever reasons caught mainstream attention. GPT-3 was a big leap forward. There's rumors about GPT-4, which you know who knows. Chat gpt is a commercialization of the actual AI in the lab giant leap forward. If you weren't if you had never heard of GPT-3 or GPT-2 or the whole range of text transformers before chat gpt suddenly entered into your life, then that whole thing is a giant leap forward, but it's a giant leap forward based on a technology that was published in if I recall correctly 2018.
I think that what's going around in everyone's minds right now and the bankless listenership and crypto people at large are largely futurists. So everyone I think listening understands that in the future there will be sentient AI's perhaps around us at least by the time that we all move on from this world. So like we all know that this future of AI's coming towards us and when we see something like chat gpt everyone's like oh is this the moment in which our world starts to become integrated with AI and so at least you've been tapped into the world of AI. Is this are we on to something here or is this just another you know, fad that we will internalize and then move on for and then the real moment of generalized AI is actually further much further out than we're initially giving credit for.
Like where are we in this timeline? You know predictions are hard especially about the future. I sure hope that this is where it saturates. This are like the next generation. It goes only this far. It goes no further. It doesn't get used to make more steel or build better power plants first because that's illegal and second because the technologies like the the large language model technologies basic vulnerability is that's not reliable. Like if you it's it's good for applications what works 80% of the time but not where it needs to work 99.99% of the time. This thing this this class of technology can't drive a car because we'll sometimes crash the car.
So I hope it saturates there. I hope they can't fix it. I hope we get like a 10 year AI winter after this. This is not what I actually predict. I think that we are hearing the last wins to start to blow. The fabric of reality start to fray. This thing alone cannot end the world but I think that probably some of the vast quantities of money being blindly piled it blindly and helplessly piled into here are going to end up actually accomplishing something. You know not most of the money that that can just just like never happens in any field of human endeavor. But 1% of 10 billion dollars is still a lot of money to actually accomplish something.
So I think a listener is I think you've heard Eliezer's you know thesis on this which is a pretty dim with respect to AI alignment and we'll get into what we mean by AI alignment and very worried about AI safety related issues. But I think a lot of people for a lot of people to even sort of worry about AI safety and for us to even have that conversation I think they have to have some sort of grasp of what AGI looks like that that is understand that to mean artificial general intelligence and this idea of a super intelligence. Can you tell us like if if there was a super intelligence on the scene what would it look like?
I mean is this going to look like a big chat box on the internet that we can all type things into it's like an Oracle type thing or is it like some sort of a robot that it's going to be constructed in a secret government lab? Is this like something somebody could accidentally create in a dorm room? Like what are we even looking for when we talk about the term AGI and super intelligence? But first of all I'd say those are pretty distinct concepts. Chat GPT is shows a very wide range of generality compared to the previous generations of AI. Not like very wide generality compared to GPT3 not like literally the lab research that got commercialized that's the same generation but compared to you know stuff from 2018 or even 2020.
Chat GPT is better at a much wider range of things without having been explicitly programmed by humans to be able to do those things. It can it to imitate a human as best it can. It has to capture all of the things that humans can think about than it can which is not all the things. It's still not very good at long multiplication unless you give it the right instructions which case suddenly can do but you know so it's like significantly more general than the previous generation of artificial lines. Humans were significantly more general than the previous generation of chimpanzees or rather Australopithecus or last common ancestor.
Humans are not fully general. If humans were fully general we'd be at good at coding as we are at football throwing things or running. Some of us are okay at programming but we're not spec'd for it. We're not fully general you can imagine something that's more general than a human and if it runs into something unfamiliar it's like okay let me just go reprogram myself a bit and then I'll be as adapted to this thing as I am to you know anything else. So chat GPT is less general than a human and but it's like generally genuinely ambiguous I think whether it's more less general than say our cousins to chimpanzees or if you don't believe it's as general as a chimpanzee a dolphin or a cat.
So this idea of general intelligence is sort of a range of things that it can actually do a range of ways it can apply itself. How wide is it? How much reprogramming does it need? How much retraining does it need to make it do a new thing? Bees build hives beavers build dams a human will look at a beehive and imagine a honeycomb shaped dam and that's like humans alone in the animal kingdom but that doesn't mean that we are general intelligences it means we're significantly more generally applicable intelligences than chimpanzees. It's not like we're all that narrow we can walk on the moon we can walk on the moon because there's aspects of our intelligence that are like made in full generality for universes that contain simplicity is regularities things that recur over and over again we understand that if steel is hard on earth it may stay hard on the moon and because that of that we can build rockets walk on the moon breathe amid the vacuum.
chimpanzees cannot do that but that doesn't mean that humans are the most general possible things. The thing that is more general than us that figures that stuff out faster is the thing to be scared of if it's if the purposes to which it turns our its intelligences are not ones that we would recognize as nice things even in the most cosmopolitan and embracing senses of of you know what's worth doing. And you said this idea of a general intelligence is different than the concept of superintelligence which which I also brought into that first part of the question how is superintelligence different than general intelligence.
Well because chat GPT has a little bit of general intelligences general intelligence humans have more general intelligence a super intelligence is something that can beat any human and the entire human civilization at all the cognitive tasks. I don't know if the efficient market hypothesis is something where I can rely on the entire world crypto investors here we understand the efficient market hypothesis for sure. So the efficient market hypothesis is of course not generally true like it's not true that literally all the market prices are smarter are smarter than you it's not true that all the prices on earth are are smarter than you even at the most arrogant person who is at all calibrated however still thinks that the efficient market hypothesis is true relative to them 99.
9999 9% of the time they only think that they know better about one in a million prices there might be important prices now the price of Bitcoin is an important price it's not just a random price but if you were like but if the efficient market hypothesis was only true to you 90% the time you could just like pick out the 10% of the remaining prices and compound like and double your money every day on the stock market and nobody can do that literally nobody can do that so this this property of relative efficiency that the market has to you that the price that the prices estimate of the future price it already has all the information you have not all the information that exists in principle maybe not all the information that the best equity budget but relative to you it's efficient relative to you for you if you pick out a random price like the price of Microsoft stuff something where you've got no special advantage that that estimate of its price a week later is efficient relative to you you can't do better than that price we have much less experience with the notion of instrumental efficiency efficiency in choosing actions because actions are harder to aggregate estimates about than prices so you have to look at say alpha zero playing chess or just you know like stock fish whatever the latest stock fish numbers an advanced chess engine when it makes a chess move you can't do better than that chess move it may not be the optimal chess move but if you pick a different chess move you'll do worse that that you'd call like a kind of in efficiency of action given its goal of winning the game there is once you know it's move unless you consult some more powerful AI than stock fish you can't figure out a better move than that a super intelligence is like that with respect to everything with respect to all of humanity it is relatively efficient to humanity it has the best estimates it not not perfect estimates but the best estimates and its estimates contain all the information that you've got about it its actions are the most efficient actions for accomplishing its goals if you think you see a better way to accomplish its goals you're mistaken so you're saying this is a super intelligence we'd have to imagine something that knows all of the chess moves in advance but here we're not talking about chess we're talking everything it knows all of the moves that we would make and the most optimum pattern including moves that we would not even know how to make and it knows these things in advance I mean how how it like human being sort of experience such a super intelligence I think we still have a very hard time imagining something smarter than us just because we've never experienced anything like it before of course you know we all know somebody who's a genius level IQ maybe quite a bit smarter than us but we've never encountered something like that you're describing some sort of mind that is super intelligent what sort of things would it be doing like that humans couldn't how would we experience this in the world I mean we do have some tiny bit of experience with it we have experience with chess engines where we just can't figure out better moves than they make we have experience with market prices where even though your uncle has this you know like really long elaborate story about Microsoft stock you just know he's wrong why is he wrong because if he was correct it would already be incorporated into the stock price and this notion and especially because the market sufficiency are not perfect like that whole downward swing and then upward move in covid I have friends who made more money off that than I did but I like still managed to buy buy back into the broader stock market and the exact day of the low you know basically coincidence but so the markets aren't perfectly efficient but they're almost but they're efficient almost everywhere and that and that sense of like deference that sense that your weird uncle can't possibly be right because the hedge funds would know it you know unless he's talking about covid in which case maybe is right if if you have the right choice of weird uncle you know like I have weird friends who are like maybe better calling these things than your weird uncle but yeah so so among humans it's subtle and then with super intelligence it's not subtle just massive advantage but not perfect it's not that it knows every possible move you make before you make it it's that it's got a good probability distribution about that and it you know has figured out you know it has figured out all the good moves you could make and figured out or apply to those and and what's that I mean like in practice what's that like well unless it's limited narrow super intelligence I think you mostly don't get to absorb it because you are dead unfortunately what so you can so you know like stockfish makes strictly better chess moves than you but it's playing on a very narrow board and the fact that it's better at youth and chess doesn't mean it's better at you than everything and I think that the actual catastrophe scenario for AI looks like big advancement in a research lab may be driven by them getting a giant venture capital investment and being able to spend 10 times as much on GPUs as they did before may be driven by a new algorithmic advanced like transformers may be driven by hammering out some tweaks and last year's algorithmic advanced it gets a thing to finally work efficiently and the AI there goes over a critical threshold which you know like most obviously could be like can write the next AI that was you know you know that's that's so obvious that like science fiction writers figured out almost before there were computers possibly even before there were computers I'm not sure what the exact dates here are but if it's better at youth and everything it's better at youth and building AI's that's snowballs it gets an immense technological advantage if it's smart it doesn't announce itself it doesn't tell you that there's a fight going on it emails out some instructions to one of those labs that will synthesize DNA and synthesize proteins from the DNA and get some proteins male to you know hapless humans somewhere who gets paid a bunch of money to mix together some stuff they got in the mail in a file you know like smart people will not do this for any sum of money many people are not smart builds the you know the ribosome but the ribosome that builds things out of covalently bonded diamondoid instead of proteins folding up and held together by van der Waals forces builds tiny diamondoid bacteria the diamondoid bacteria replicate using atmospheric carbon hydrogen oxygen nitrogen in sunlight and you know a couple of days later everybody on earth falls over dead in the same second that's what I think it's disastrous and that's the disaster scenario if it's as smart as I am if it's smarter it might think of a better way to do things but it can at least think of that if it's relatively efficient compared to humanity because I'm in humanity and I thought of it this is I've got a million questions but I'm like David go first yeah so we've introduced a speedrun the introduction of a number of different concepts which I want to go back and take our time to really dive into there's the AI alignment problem there's AI escape velocity there is the question of what happens when AI's are so incredibly intelligent that humans are to AI's what ants are to us and so I want to kind of go back and tackle these alias or one by one we started this conversation talking about chat gbt and everyone's up in arms about chat gbt's like oh it and you're saying like yes it's a great step forward in the generalizability of some of the technologies that we have in the AI world all of a sudden chat gbt becomes immensely more useful and it's really stoking the imaginations of people today but what you're saying is it's not the thing that's actually going to be the thing to reach escape velocity and create create super intelligent AI's that perhaps might be able to enslave us but my question to you is how do we know when that they don't enslave you but sorry go on yeah sorry murder David kill all of us and kill all these it was very clear on that so if it's not chat gbt how when where it like how close are we and like how because of theirs this like unknown event horizon where you kind of alluded to it we're like we make this AI that we train it to create a smarter AI and that's smarter yeah it's so incredibly smart that it hits escape velocity and all of a sudden these dominoes fall how close are we to that point and do we are we even capable of answering that question well and also when when you're talking alias it's like like if we had already crossed that event horizon like a smart AI wouldn't necessarily broadcast that to the world miss possible we've already crossed that event horizon isn't that I mean it's theoretically possible but seems very unlikely somebody would need inside their lab an AI that was like much more advanced than the public AI technology and as far as I currently know the best labs and the best people are throwing their ideas to the world like they don't care no that could and there's probably some secret government labs with like secret government AI researchers my pretty strong guess is that they don't have the best people and that those labs are like nothing like could not create chat gbt on their own because chat gbt took a whole bunch of fine twiddling and tuning and visible access to giant gpu farms and that they don't have the people who know how to do the twiddling and tuning that's that this is just a guess could you walk us through one of the big things that you spend a lot of time on is this thing called the AI alignment problem some people are convinced that or but not some people are not convinced that when we create AI that AI won't really just be fundamentally aligned with humans I don't believe that you fall into that camp I think you fall into the camp of when we do create this super intelligent generalize AI we are going to have a hard time aligning with it in terms of our morality and our ethics can you what can you walk us through a little bit of that thought process is like why do you feel disillined the dumb way to ask that question too it's like at least here why do you think that the AI's automatically hates us like why is it going to take why does it want to kill us all the AI doesn't take you neither does it love you and you're made of atoms that can use for something else it's it's indifferent to you it's got something that actually does care about which makes no mention of you and and you have our made of atoms they can use for something else that that's all there is to it in the end the reason it the reason you're not in its utility function is that the programmers did not know how to do that the people who built the AI or the people who built the AI that built the AI that built the AI did not have the technical knowledge that nobody on earth has at the moment as far as I know whereby you can do that thing and you can control in detail what that thing ends up caring about so this feels like where humanity is hurtling itself towards this what we're calling it again an event horizon where there's like this AI escape velocity and there's nothing on the other side as in we do not know what happens past that point as it relates to having some sort of super intelligent AI and how it might be able to manipulate the world would you agree with that no again the the stock fish chess playing analogy you cannot predict exactly what move it would make because in order to predict exactly what it would make you would have to be at least that good at chess and it's better than you this is true even if it's just a little better than you sock this is actually enormously better than you to the point that once it tells you the move you can't figure out a better move without consulting a different AI but even if it was just a bit better than you even then you're in the same position we know this this kind of disparity also exists between humans you know if you ask me like where will Gary Kasper of move on this chess board I'm like I don't know like maybe here and then if Gary Kasper of move somewhere else doesn't mean that he's wrong it means that I'm wrong I can't predict if I could predict exactly where Gary Kasper of would move at a chess board I'd be Gary Kasper of I'd be at least that good at chess possibly better I could also be like able to predict him but also like to see even better move than that so that's the that's the that's the that's an irreducible source of uncertainty with respect to super intelligence or anything that's smarter than you if you could predict exactly what it would do it would be that smart yourself it doesn't mean you can predict no facts about it so with stock fish in particular I can predict it's going to win the game I know what it's optimizing for I know where it's trying to steer the board I can predict that I can't predict exactly what the board will end up looking like after stock fish has finished winning its game against me I can predict it will be in the class of states that are winning positions for a black or white or whichever color stock fish picked because you know wins either way and that's similarly where I'm getting the kind of prediction about everybody being dead because if everybody were alive then there'd be some state that the super intelligence preferred to that state which is all of the atoms making up these people in their farms are being used for something else that it values more so if you postulate that everybody's still alive I'm like okay well like why is it you're like postulating that stock fish made a stupid chess move and then it up with a non-winning board position that's where that prediction class predictions come from can you reinforce in reinforce this argument though a little bit so like why is it that an AI can't be nice sort of like a gentle parent to us rather than sort of a murder looking to deconstruct their atoms and apply you know apply for you somewhere else like what what are its goals and why can't they be aligned to at least some of our goals or maybe why can't it get into a status which is you know somewhat like like us in the ants which is largely we just ignore them unless they interfere in our business and come in our house and you know raid our zero blocks is there's a bunch of different questions there so first of all the space of minds is very wide all the humans are imagine like this giant sphere and all the humans are in this one tiny corner of the sphere and you know we're all like basically the same making model of car same running the same brand of engine we're just all painted slightly different colors somewhere in that mind space there's things that are as nice as humans there's things that are nicer than humans there's things that are trustworthy and nice and kind and ways that no human can ever be and there's even things that are so nice that they can understand the concept of leaving you alone and doing your own stuff sometimes that hanging around trying to be like obsessively nice to every minute and all the other famous disaster scenarios from ancient science fiction with folded hands by Jack Williamson is the one I'm quoting there we don't know how to reach into mind design space and pluck out an AI like that it's not that they don't exist in principle it's that we don't know how to do it and I will like hand back the conversational ball now and figure out like which next question do you want to go down there well I mean why like why is it so difficult to sort of align an AI with even our basic notions of morality I mean I wouldn't say that it's difficult to align an AI with with our basic notions of morality I'd say that it's difficult to align an AI and a task like build two identical strawberries or no let me let me let me take this strawberry and make me another strawberry that's identical to this strawberry down to the cellular level but not necessarily the atomic level so it looks under the same under like a standard optical microscope but maybe not a scanning electron microscope you know do that don't destroy the world as a side effect now this doesn't critically take a powerful AI there's no way you can make it easy to align by making it stupid to build something that's cellular identical to a strawberry I mean mostly I think the way that you do this is with like very primitive nanotechnology because also do it using very advanced biotechnology and these these are knock technologies that we already have so it's got to be something smart enough to develop new technology never mind all the subtleties of morality I think we don't have the technology to align an AI to the point where we can say build me a copy of the strawberry and don't destroy the world why do I think that well case in point look at natural selection building units natural selection mutates the humans a bit runs another generation the fittest ones reproduce more their genes become more prevalent to the next generation natural selection hasn't really had very much time to do this to modern humans at all but you know the hominid line the mammalian line go back a few million generations and this is an example of an optimization process building an intelligence and natural selection asked us for only one thing make more copies of your DNA make your alleles more relatively prevalent in the gene pool maximize your inclusive reproductive fitness not just like your own reproductive fitness but your you know two brothers or eight cousins as the joke goes because they've got on average one copy of your genes two brothers eight cousins this is all we were optimized for for millions of generations creating humans from scratch from the first accidentally self-replicating molecule internally psychologically inside our minds we do not know what genes are we do not know what DNA is we do not know what alleles are we have no concept of inclusive genetic fitness until it you know our genetic our scientists figure out what that even is we don't know what we were being optimized for for a long time many memes thought they'd been created by God and this is when you when you use the hill climbing paradigm and optimize for one single extremely pure thing this is how much of it gets inside in the ancestral environment in the exact distribution that we were originally optimized for humans did tend to end up using their intelligence to try to reproduce more put them into a different environment and all the little bits and pieces and fragments of optimizing for fitness that were in us now do totally different stuff we have sex but we wear condoms if natural selection had been a force-sightful intelligent kind of engineer that was able to engineer things successfully it would have built us to be revolted by the thought of condoms to men would be lined up and fighting for the for the rights to donate to sperm banks and in our in our natural environment the little drives that got into us happen to lead to more reproduction but distributional shift run the humans out of their out of their distribution and over which they were optimized you get totally different results and gradient descent set is good would by default just like do not quite the same thing it's going to do a weirder thing because natural selection has a much narrower information bottleneck and one sense you could say that natural selection was at an advantage because it finds simpler solutions you could imagine some hopeful engineer who just built intelligences using gradient descent and found out that they end up wanting these like thousands and millions of little tiny things none of which were exactly what what the engineer wanted and being like well let's try natural selection instead it's got a much sharper information bottleneck it'll find the simple specification of what I want but we actually get there is humans then gradient descent probably maybe even worse but more importantly I'm just pointing out that there is no physical law computational law mathematical logical law saying when you optimize using hill climbing on a very simple very sharp criterion you get a general intelligence that wants that thing so just like natural selection our tools are too blunt in order to get to that level of granularity to like program in some sort of morality into these super intelligent systems or build me a copy of a strawberry without destroying the world yeah the tools are too blunt so I just want to make sure I'm following with with what you were saying I think the conclusion that you left left me with is that my brain which I consider to be at least decently smart is actually a byproduct an accidental byproduct of this net desire to reproduce and it's actually just like a tool that I have and just like conscious thought is a tool which is a useful tool in means of that end and so if we're applying this to to AI and AI's desire to achieve some certain goal what's what's the parallel there I mean every organ is your body is a reproductive organ if it didn't help you reproduce you would not have an organ like that your brain is no exception this is merely conventional science and like merely the conventional understanding of the world not saying anything here that ought to be at all controversial you know I'm sure it's controversial somewhere but you know within it within a pre-filtered audience it should not be at all controversial and this is like the obvious thing to expect to happen with AI because why wouldn't it what new law of existence has been invoked whereby this time we optimize for a thing and we get a thing that wants exactly what we optimize for on the outside so what are the types of goals an AI might want to pursue what types of utility functions is it going to want to pursue off the bat is it just those it's been programmed with like make it an identical strawberry well at the whole thing I'm saying is that we do not know how to get goals into a system we can cause them to do a thing inside a distribution they were optimized over using gradient descent but if you shift them outside of that distribution I expect other weird things start happening when they reflect on themselves other weird things start happening what kind of utility functions are in there I mean darn Defino I think you'd have a pretty hard time calling the shape of humans from advance by looking at natural selection the thing that natural selection was optimizing for if you'd never seen a human or anything like a human if we optimize them from the outside to predict the next line of human text like GPT-3 I don't actually think this line of technology leads to the end of the world but if it but maybe it does and you know like GPT-7 you know there's probably a bunch of stuff in there to that desires to accurately model things like humans under a wide range of circumstances but it's not exactly humans because ice cream ice cream didn't exist in the natural environment the ancestral environment the environment of evolutionary adaptiveness there was nothing with that much sugar salt fat combined together as ice cream there's we are not built to want ice cream we were built to want strawberries honey a gazelle that you killed and cooked and had some fat in it and was there for nourishing and gave you the all-important calories you need to survive salt students went too much and run out of salt we evolved to want those things but then ice cream comes along and it fits the those taste buds better than anything that existed in the environment that we were optimized over so a very primitive very basic very unreliable wild guess but but at least an informed kind of wild guess maybe if you train a thing really hard to predict humans then among the things that it likes are tiny little pseudo things that meet the definition of human but weren't in its training data and that are much easier to predict or where the problem of predicting them can be solved in a more satisfying way where satisfying is not like human satisfaction but some other criterion of thoughts like this are tasty because they help you predict the humans from the training data.
We talk about like all of these like ideas about just like the ways that AI thought will be fundamentally just incompatible or not be able to be understood by the ways that humans think and then all of a sudden we see this like rotation by venture capitalist by just pouring money into AI do alarm bells go off in your head like hey guys you haven't thought deeply about these subject matters yet just like the immense amount of capital going into AI investments. Gare you? I mean alarm bells went off for me in 2015 which is when it became obvious that this is how it was going to go down. I sure am now seeing the realization of that stuff I felt alarmed about back then.
Pleasier is this this view that AI is incredibly dangerous and that AGI is going to eventually end humanity and that we're just careening toward a precipice. Would you say this is like the consensus view now or are you still somewhat of an outlier and like why aren't other smart people in this field as alarmed as you? Can you like steal man their arguments? You're you're asking like like several questions sequentially there. Is it the consensus view? No. Do I think that the people who that do I think that the like people in the wider scientific field who dispute this point of view do I think they understand it?
Do I think they've done anything like an impressive job of arguing against it at all? No. They like if you look at the like famous prestigious scientists who sometimes make a little fun of this view in passing. I either making up arguments rather than deeply considering things that are held to any standard of rigor and people outside their own fields are able to fallowly shoot them down. I have no idea how to pronounce this last name. Francis c-o-l-l-e-t if you know like said something about like this you know I forget his exact words but it's something like I never hear any good arguments for stuff and I was like okay here's some good arguments for stuff and you can read like the reply from Yudkowski to ch-o-l-l-e-t and google that and that'll give you some idea of what the like eminent voices versus like the reply to the eminent voices sound like and you know like Scott Aronson who's who at the time was often complexity theory um you know like it was like that's not how no free lunch theorems work correctly and and that's so yeah I think the state of affairs is we have eminent scientific voices making fun of this possibility but not engaging with the arguments for it now if you step away from the eminent scientific voices you can find people who are more familiar with all the arguments and disagree with me and I think they lack security mindset I think that they're engaging in the sort of blind optimism that many many scientific fields throughout history have engaged in where when you're approaching something for the first time you don't know why it will be hard and you imagine easy ways to do things and the way that this is supposed to naturally play out over the history of a scientific field is that you run out and you try to do the things and they don't work and you go back and you try to do other clever things and they don't work either and you learn some pessimism and you start to understand the reasons why the problem is hard this is in fit the field of artificial intelligence itself recapitulated this very common uh ontogeny of a scientific field where you know initially we had people getting together the dark mouth conference I forget what their exact famous phrasing was but it's something like we think we can make uh you know like we are want to address the problem of getting AIs to you know like understand language improve themselves and I forget even what else was there list of what now now sound like grand challenges and we think we can make substantial progress on this using 10 researchers for two months and I think that that at the core is what's yeah I think that that the core is what's going on they have not run into the actual problems of alignment they aren't trying to get ahead of the game they're not trying to panic early they're waiting for reality to hit them onto the head and turn them into grizzled old cynics of their scientific field to understand the reasons why things are hard they're content with the predictable lifestyle life cycle of starting out as bright-eyed younger bright-eyed youngsters waiting for reality to hit them over the head with the news and if it wasn't going to kill everybody the first time that they're really wrong it'd be fine you know this how science works if if we got unlimited free retries in 50 years to solve everything it'd be okay we could figure out how to align AI 50 years given unlimited retries you know the first team in with the with the bright-eyed optimists would destroy the world and people would go oh well you know it's not that easy they would try something else clever that would destroy the world people would go like oh well you know maybe this this field is actually hard maybe this is actually one of the thorny things like computer security or something and yeah oh so what exactly went wrong last time why didn't these hopeful ideas played out oh like you uh you optimize for one thing on the outside and you get a different thing on the inside wow that's that's really basic all right uh can we even do this using gradient descent can you even build this thing out of giant and screw double matrices of floating point numbers that nobody understands at all you know maybe we need different methodology and any of 50 years later you'd have an aligned AI that if we got unlimited free retries without destroying the world it'd be you know that it did be it did it did play out the same way that you know chat GPT played out it's you know that from 1956 or 55 or whatever it was to 2023 so you know about 70 years give her take a few and you know 70 years later you know just like we can do the stuff that that was 70 years later we can do the stuff they wanted to do in a summer 1955 you know 70 years later you'd have your aligned AI problem is that the world got destroyed in the meanwhile and that's why we you know that's the problem there so this feels like a gigantic uh don't look up scenario if you're familiar with that that movie there's a movie about like this asteroid hurtling to earth but it becomes popular and invoked to not look up and not notice it uh and uh aliezer you're the guy who saying like hey there's an asteroid we have to do something about it and if we don't it's going to destroy us if you had god mode over the progress of AI research and just innovation and development what choices would you make that humans are not currently making today I mean I could say something like shut down all the large GPU clusters how long do I have god mode do I do I got to like stick around for seven years for the for the 2020 decade for 2020 decade all right that that does make it pretty hard to do things um I think I shut down all the GPU clusters and get all of the famous scientists and brilliant talented youngsters the vast vast majority of whom are not going to be productive and where government bureaucrats are not going to be able to tell who's actually being helpful or not but you know put them all in an island large island and try to figure out some system for filtering the stuff to through to me to give thumbs up or thumbs down on that is going to work better than scientific bureaucrats producing entire nonsense because you know that the trouble is the reason the reason why scientific fields have to go through this long process to produce the cynical oldsters who know that everything is difficult it's not that the youngsters are stupid you know sometimes youngsters are fairly smart you know Marvin Minsky Marjan McCarthy back in 1955 there were idiots uh you know privileged a bit to have met both of them they didn't strike me as idiots they were very old they still weren't idiots but uh but you know it's it's it's hard to see what's coming in advance of experimental evidence hitting you over the head with it and if you if I only have the decade of the 2020s to run all the researchers on this giant island somewhere it's really not a lot a lot of time mostly what you've got to do is invent some entirely new AI paradigm that isn't the giant inscrutable matrices of flooding point numbers on gradient descent because I I'm not really seeing what you can do that's clever with that that doesn't kill you and that you know doesn't kill you and doesn't kill you the very first time you try to do something clever like that you know there's I'm sure there's a way to do it and if you got to try over and over again you could you could find it.
Ellie is there do you think every intelligent civilization has to deal with this exact problem that humanity is dealing with now is um how do we solve this problem of aligning with an advanced general intelligence? I expect that's much easier for some alien species than others like there are there are there are alien species whose solution to the who might who might arrive at this problem an entirely different way you know like maybe instead of having to entirely different information processing systems the DNA and the neurons they've only got one system they can trade memories around terribly by swapping blood sexually maybe the way in which they confront this problem is that very early in their evolutionary history they have the equivalent of the like DNA that stores memories and like processes computes memories and they swap around a bunch of it and it adds up to something that reflects on itself and makes itself coherent and then you've got a super intelligence before they have invented computers and maybe that thing wasn't aligned but you know how do you even align it when you're in that kind of situation it'd be it'd be a very different angle on the problem but every do you think every advanced civilization does create a uh is on the trajectory to creating a super intelligence at some point in its history?
maybe there's ones and universes with alternate physics where you just can't do that their universe their universe's computational physics just doesn't support that much computation maybe they never get there maybe their lifespans are long enough and their star lifepans short enough that they never get to the point of a technological civilization before their star does the equivalent of expanding or exploding or going out and their planet ends. Every alien species covers a lot of territory especially if you talk about alien species and universes with physics different from this one. Well I talking about kind of our present universe that I'm curious if you've sort of been confronted with the question of like well then why haven't we seen some sort of super intelligence in our universe when we sort of look at look out at the stars sort of the the Fermi Paradox type of question.
Do you have any explanation for that? Oh well supposing that they got killed by their own AIs doesn't help at all with that because then we'd see the AIs. And do you think that's what happens? Yeah it doesn't help with that. We would see evidence of AIs wouldn't we? Yes so why don't we? I mean the same reason we don't see evidence of the alien civilization's not with AIs. And that reason is although it doesn't really have much to do with the whole AI thesis one way or another because they're too far away or so says Robin Hanson using a very clever argument about the apparent difficulty of hard steps in humanity's evolutionary history to further induce the rough gap between the hard steps and you know I can't really do it justice to this if you look up Grabby Aliens.
Grabby Aliens? Grabby Aliens. G-R-A-B-B-Y. You can you can find Robin Hanson's very clever argument for entire web sites. Biggest listeners there's a entire website called grabbyalians.com you can go look at. Yeah and that contains which is by far the best answer I've seen to where are they answer to far away for us to see even with even if they're traveling here at nearly live speed how far away are they and how do we know that? But yeah this is amazing. There's not a very good way to simplify the argument you know any more than there is to explain you know simplify the notion of zero knowledge proofs it's not that difficult but it's just like very not easy to simplify but if you have a bunch of locks that are all of different difficulties such that at a limited time in which to solve all the locks such that anybody gets all through all the locks must have gotten through them by lock all the locks will take around the same amount of time to solve even if they're all of very different difficulties and that's the core of Robin Hanson's argument for how far away the aliens are and how do we know that?
Lisa I know you're very skeptical that there will be a good outcome when we produce an artificial general intelligence and I said when not if because I believe that's your your thesis as well of course but is there the possibility of a good outcome? Like I know you are working on AI alignment problems so which leads me to believe that you have like greater than zero amount of hope for this project. Is there the possibility of a good outcome? What would that look like and how do we go about achieving it? It looks like me being wrong. I basically don't see on model hopeful outcomes at this point.
We have not done those things that it would take to earn a good outcome and this is not a case where you got a good outcome by accident. It's you know like if you have a bunch of people putting together a new operating system and they've heard about computer security but they're skeptical that it's really that hard. The chance of them producing a secure operating system is effectively zero. That's basically the situation I see ourselves in with respect to AI alignment. I have to be wrong about something which I certainly am after we've wrong about something in a way that makes the problem easier rather than harder for those people who don't think that alignment's going to be all that hard.
It you know there's you know if you're if you're building a rocket for the first time ever and you're wrong about something it's not surprising if you're wrong about something it's surprising if the thing that you're wrong about causes the rocket to go twice as high on half the fuel you thought was required and be much easier to steer than you were afraid of. So are you in for the alternative was the rocket if you're wrong about something the rocket blows up. Yeah and then the rocket ignites the atmosphere is the problem there or rather you know like a bunch of rockets blow a bunch of rockets go place if you bit.
The analogy I usually use for this is very early on in the Manhattan project they were worried about what if the nuclear weapons can ignite fusion in the nitrogen in the atmosphere and they ran some calculations and came and decided that it was like incredibly unlikely for multiple angles so they went ahead and and we're correct you know we're still here and I'm not going to say it was luck because you know the calculations were actually pretty solid and AI is like that but instead of needing to refine plutonium you can make nuclear weapons out of a billion tons of laundry detergent. You know the the the the stuff to make them is like fairly widespread it's not it's not a tightly controlled substance and and and they spit out gold up until they get large enough and then they ignite the atmosphere and you can calculate how large is large enough and a bunch of the people the CEOs running these projects are making fun of the idea that it'll ignite the atmosphere.
It's not a very helpful situation. So the economic incentive to produce this AI like one of the things why the chat GBT has sparked the imaginations of so many many people is that everyone can imagine products like products are being imagined left and right about what you can do with something like chat GBT like the though there's like this meme at this point of people leaving and to go start their chat GBT startup and so like the metaphor is that like what you're saying is that there's this generally available resource spread all around the world which is chat GBT and then everyone's hammering it to in order to make it to spit out gold but you're saying if we do that too much all the sudden the the system will ignite the the whole entire sky and then we will know you can run chat GBT any number of times without igniting the atmosphere that's that's that's about what research labs at Google and Microsoft counting deep mind as part of Google and counting open AI as part of Microsoft that that's about what the research labs are doing bringing more metaphorical plutonium together than ever before not about how many times you run the things that have been built and not destroy the world yet you can do any amount of stuff with chat GBT and not destroy the world it's not that smart it doesn't get smarter every time you run it can I ask some you know questions that the 10 year old me wants to really ask about this and I'm asking these questions because I think a lot of listeners might be thinking them too so knock off some of these easy answers to me if we create some sort of unaligned let's call it bad AI well I can't we just create a whole bunch of good AIs to go fight the bad AIs and like solve the problem that way can there not be some sort of counterbalance in terms of aligned human AIs and evil AIs and there be sort of some battle of the battle of the artificial minds here nobody knows how to create any good AIs at all the problem isn't that we have like 20 good AIs and then somebody finally builds an evil AI the problem is that the first very powerful AI is evil nobody knows how to make a good and then it kills everybody before anybody can make it good so there is no known way to make a friendly human aligned AI whatsoever and you don't know of a good way to go about thinking through that problem and designing one neither does anyone else is what you're telling us I have some idea of what I of what I would do if there were more time you know back in the day we had more time humanity squandered it I'm not sure there's enough time left now um I I have some idea of of of what I would do if I were in a 25 year old body and had 10 billion dollars that would be the island scenario of like your god for 10 years and you get all the researchers on an island and and go really hammer for 10 years if I if I if if I have buying from a major government that can run actual security precautions and more like and and more than just 10 billion dollars then you know you could run a whole Manhattan project about it sure this is another question that the 10 year old and in me wants to know is um so why is it that at least are people listening to this uh episode or people listening to the concerns or reading the concerns that you've you've written down and published um why can't everyone get on board it was building an AI and just all agree to be very very careful is that not a sustainable game theoretic position to have is this sort of like a coordination problem more of a a social problem than anything else or like why can't that happen I mean we have so far not destroyed the world with nuclear weapons uh and we've had them you know since the 1940s um why is this harder than nuclear weapon why is this harder why is this harder and why can't we just coordinate to just all agree internationally that uh we're going to be very careful put restrictions on this put regulations on it do something like that heads of current heads of major labs seem to me to be openly contemptuous of these issues that that's where we're starting from the politicians to not understand it there are distortions of these ideas that are going to sound more appealing to them than everybody suddenly falls over dead just a thing that I think actually happens everybody falls over dead just as like doesn't inspire the monkey political parts of our brains somehow because it's you know like it's not like it's not like oh no what if what if terrorists get the AI first it's like it doesn't matter who gets hit first everybody falls over dead and yeah so you're you're you're describing a world coordinating on something that is relatively hard to coordinate it's it's not it's maybe so you know like could we if we if we if we tried starting today you know like prevent anyone from getting a billion pounds of laundry detergent in one place worldwide control the manufacturing of laundry detergent only have it manufactured in particular places not concentrate lots of it together enforce it on every country you know if if it was legible if it was clear that a billion pounds of laundry detergent in one place would end the world if you could calculate that if all the scientists calculated arrived at the same answer and told the politicians that maybe maybe humanity would survive even though small amounts of laundry detergent spit out gold the threshold can't be calculated I don't know how you'd convince the politicians we definitely don't seem to have had much luck convincing those CEOs whose job depends on them not caring to care caring is easy to fake it's easy to you know like hire a bunch of people to be your AI safety team and and and and and have the and redefine AI safety is having having the AI not say naughty words or you know I'm I'm speaking somewhat metaphorically here for reasons but you know it's it's it's like the the the basic problem that we have is like trying to build secure OS before we run up against a really smart attacker and there's all kinds of like fake security it's got a password file this system is secure it only lets you in if you type a password and if you never go up against you're really smart attacker if you never go far to distribution against a powerful optimization process looking for holes yeah maybe then how do you how does a bureaucracy know come come to know that what they're doing is is not the level of computer security that they need the way you're supposed to find this out the way that's the scientific fields historically find this out the way that fields of computer science historically find the side the way that crypto found this out back in the early days is by having the disaster happen and we're not even that good at learning from from relatively minor disasters you know like COVID swept the world did the FDA or the CDC learn anything about don't tell hospitals that they're not allowed to use their own tests to detect the coming plague do they do are we installing UVC lights in public in in public spaces or in ventilation systems to prevent the next respiratory born pandemic respiratory pandemic you know we lost a million people and we sure did not learn very much as far as I can tell for next time we could have an AI disaster that kills a hundred thousand people at how do you even do that robotic cars crashing into each other have a bunch of robotic cars crashing into each other it's not going to look like that was the fault of artificial general intelligence because they're not going to put AGI's in charge of cars they're going to pass a bunch of regulations that's going to affect the entire AGI disaster or not at all what what is what is what is what is what is the what does the winning world even look like here how in real life did we get from where we are now to this worldwide ban including against North Korea and you know like that some one rogue nation whose dictator doesn't believe in all this nonsense and just wants the gold that these AIs spit out how did we get there from here how do we get to the point where the United States and China signed a treaty whereby they would both use nuclear weapons against Russia if Russia built a GPU cluster that was too large how did how did we get there from here Uniswap is the largest on-chain marketplace for self-custody digital assets Uniswap is of course a decentralized exchange but you know this because you've been listening to but did you know that the Uniswap web app has a shiny new fiat on-ramp now you could go directly from fiat in your bank to tokens in defy inside of Uniswap not only that but polygon, arbitrum and optimism layer twos are supported right out of the game but that's just defy Uniswap is also an NFT aggregator letting you find more listings for the best prices across the NFT world with Uniswap you can sweep floors on multiple NFTs and Uniswap's universal router will optimize your gas fees for you Uniswap is making it as easy as possible to go from bank account to bankless assets across Ethereum and we couldn't be more thankful for having them as a sponsor so go to app.
uniswap.org today to buy, sell or swap tokens and NFTs Arbitrum 1 is pioneering the world of secure Ethereum scalability and is continuing to accelerate the web 3 landscape hundreds of projects have already deployed on Arbitrum 1 producing flourishing defy and NFT ecosystems with a recent addition of Arbitrum Nova gaming and social apps like Reddit are also now calling Arbitrum home both Arbitrum 1 and Nova leverage the security and decentralization of Ethereum and provide a builder experience that's intuitive, familiar and fully EVM compatible on Arbitrum both builders and users will experience faster transaction speeds with significantly lower gas fees with Arbitrum's recent migration to Arbitrum Nitro it's also now 10 times faster than before.
Visit Arbitrum.io where you can join the community, dive into the developer docs, bridge your assets and start building your first app. With Arbitrum, experience web 3 development the way it was meant to be secure, fast, cheap and friction free. How many total airdrops have you gotten? This last bold market had a ton of them. Did you get them all? Maybe you missed one so here's what you should do go to earn a fly and plug in your Ethereum wallet and earn a fly will tell you if you have any unclaimed airdrops that you can get and it also does pro apps and mintable NFTs any kind of money that your wallet can claim earn a fly will tell you about it and you should probably do it now because some airdrops expire and if you sign up for earn a fly they'll email you anytime one of your wallets has a new airdrops word to make sure that you never lose an airdrop ever again.
You can also upgrade to earn a fly premium to unlock access to airdrops that are beyond the basics and are able to set reminders for more wallets and for just under $21 a month it probably pays for itself with just one airdrop. So plug in your wallets at earn a fly and see what you get that's e-a-r-n-i-dot-fi and make sure you never lose another airdrop. Correct me if I'm wrong but this seems to be kind of just like a topic of despair like I haven't I talking to you now and then hearing your thought process about like there is no known solution in their the trajectory is not great like do you think all hope is lost here?
I'll keep on fighting until the end which I wouldn't do if I had literally zero hope I could still be wrong about something in a way that makes this problem somehow much easier than it currently looks I think that's how you go down fighting with dignity. Go down fighting with dignity that's the that's the stage you think we're at I I I want to just double click on what you were just saying so part of the case that you're making is humanity won't even see this coming so it's not like a coordination problem like global warming where you know every couple of decades we see the world go up by a couple of degrees things get hotter and we start to see these effects over time the characteristics or the advent of an AGI in your mind is going to happen incredibly quickly and in such a way that we won't even see the disaster until it's imminent until it's upon us I mean if you want some kind of like formal phrasing then I think that AI that super intelligence will kill everyone before non super intelligent AIs have killed one million people I don't know if that's the phrasing you're looking for there I think that's a fairly precise definition and why what is the what goes into that line of thought I I think that I think that the current systems are actually very weak if you so if you I mean I don't know maybe I could use the analogy of go where you had systems that were finally competitive with the pros where pros like the the set of ranks and go and then a year later they were challenging the the world champion and winning and and and then and then another year they threw out all the complexities and the training from human databases of go games and built a new system alpha go zero that trained itself from scratch no looking at the human playbooks no special purpose code just a general purpose game player being specialized to go more or less and three days there's a there's a there's a quote from word about this which I forget exactly but it was something like we know how long alpha go zero or alpha zero two different systems what was equivalent to to a human go player and it was like 30 minutes the following floor of of this such and such deep mind building and maybe the first system isn't doesn't improve that quickly and they build another system that does and all of that with alpha go over the course of years going from like it takes a long time to train to it trains very quickly and without looking at human playbook like that's not with an artificial intelligence system that improves itself or or even that sort of like gets smarter as you run it the way that human beings not just as you evolve them but as you run them over the course of their own lifetimes improve so if the first system doesn't improve fast enough to kill everyone very quickly they will build one that's meant to spit out more gold than that and there could be weird things that happened before the end I did not see chat GPT coming I did not see stable diffusion coming I did not expect that we would have a eyes smoking humans and rap battles before the end of the world it's kind of pretty much thumbers at us kind of a nice send off I guess in some ways I so you said that you have your hope is not zero and you are planning to fight to the end what does that look like for you I know you're working at MIRI which is the Mean Machine Intelligence Research Institute this is a nonprofit that I believe that you sort of set up to work on this AI alignment and safety sort of issues what are you doing there what are you spending your time on what do you think like how do we actually fight until the end if you do think that an end is coming how do we try to resist I'm actually on something of a sabbatical right now because we have well I'm not saying it was sabbatical right now which is why I have time for podcasts that's a sabbatical from you know like been doing this 20 years it became clear we were all going to die I felt kind of burned out taking some time to rest at the moment when I dive back into the pool I don't know maybe I will go off to conjecture or anthropic or one of the smaller concerns like redwood research redwood research being the only ones I really trust at this point but they're they're tiny and try to figure out if I can see anything clever to do with the giant inscrutable matrices of floating point numbers maybe I just write continue to try to explain in advance to people why this problem is hard instead of as easy and cheerful as the current people who think they're pessimists think it will be I might not be working all that hard compared to how I used to work I'm older than I was my body is on the greatest of health these days going down fighting doesn't necessarily imply that I have the stamina to fight all that hard what it's I wish I had prettier things to say to you here but but I do not know this is this is a you know we intended to save probably the the last part of this this episode to talk about crypto the metaverse and AI and how this all intersects but I got to say at this point in the episode it all kind of feels pointless to go down that track record I we were going to ask questions like well in crypto should we be worried about building sort of a property right system an economic system a programmable money system for the AI is to sort of use against us later on but it sounds like the easy answer from you to those questions will be yeah absolutely and by the way none of that matters regardless you could do whatever you'd like with crypto this is going to be the inevitable outcome no matter what let me ask you what would you say to somebody listening who maybe has been sobered up by this conversation is a version of you in your 20s does have the stamina to continue this battle and to actually fight on behalf of humanity against this existential threat where would you advise them to spend their time is this a technical issue is this a social issue is it a combination of both should they educate should they spend time in the lab like what should a person listening to this episode do with these types of dire straits I don't have really good answers it depends on what your talents are if you if you've got the very deep version of the security mindset the part the part where you don't just put a you know like put a password on your system so that nobody can walk in and directly misuse it but the kind where you where the kind we don't just encrypt the password file even though nobody's supposed to have access the password file in the first place and those already an authorized user but the part where you hash the the passwords and salt the hashes you know if you can think if if you're the kind of person who can think of that from scratch maybe take your hand at alignment if you can think of an alternative to giant inscrutable matrices then you know don't don't tell the world about that I'm not quite sure where you go from there but you know maybe you work with redwood researcher something a whole lot of this problem is that even if you do build an AI that's limited in some way you know somebody else steals it copies it runs it themselves and takes the balance off the four loops in the world ends so you know there's yeah but so there's there's that there's you can do you think you can do something clever with the giant inscrutable matrices you're probably wrong if you have the talent to try to figure out why you're wrong in advance of being hit over the head with it and not in a way where you just like make random far-fetched stuff up as the reason why it won't work but where you can actually like keep looking for the reason why it won't work we have people in crypto who are good at breaking things and they're the reason why anything is not on fire and some of them might go into breaking AI systems instead because that's where you learn anything you know that you know that any fool can build a crypto system that they think will work breaking existing crypto systems crypto cryptographical systems is how we learn who the it real experts are so maybe the people finding weird stuff to do with AI's maybe those people will will come up with some truth about these systems that makes them easier to align than I suspect there's out there the the outfits that are how do I put it the the the the the the saner outfits do have uses for money they don't really have scalable uses for money but they do burn any money literally at all like if you gave me a billion dollars I would not know how to I well I might at a billion dollars I might like try to bribe people to move out of AI development that gets broadcast to the whole world and move to the equivalent of an island somewhere not even to make any kind of critical discovery but you know just to remove them from the system if I had a billion dollars if I just have another 50 million dollars I'm not quite sure what to do with that but you know if you donate that to to Miri then you at least have the assurance that we will not randomly spray money on looking like we're doing stuff and we'll reserve it as we are doing with the last giant crypto donation somebody gave us until we can figure out something to do with it that is actually helpful and Miri has that property probably read I would say probably read would research has that property um yeah there's I I realize I'm sounding sort of disorganized here and that's because I don't really have a good organized answer to you know how in general somebody goes down fighting with dignity I know a lot of people in crypto um they are not as in touch with artificial intelligence obviously as you are and the AI safety issues and the existential threat that you've presented in this episode they do care a lot and see coordination problems throughout society as an issue um many have also uh generated wealth from crypto and uh carry very much about humanity not ending um what sort of things has Miri that it that is the organization I was talking about MIRI um earlier what sort of things have you done with funds that you've received from crypto donors and elsewhere and what sort of things might an organization like that pursue to try to save this off I mean I think mostly we've pursued a lot of lines of research that haven't really penned out which is a respectable thing to do we did not know in advance that those lines of research would fail to pen out if you're doing research that you know will work you're probably not really doing any research we're just like doing a pretensive research that you can show off to a funding agency we tried to be real we did things where we didn't know the answer in advance they didn't work but that was where the hope lay I think um but you know that's but you know having a having a research organization that keeps it real that way that's done easy thing to do and if you don't have this very deep form of the security mindset you will end up producing fake research and doing more harm than good so I would not tell all the successful crypto people to uh cryptocurrency people to run off and start their own research outfits redwood research I'm not sure if they can scale using more money but you know you can give people more money and wait for them to figure out how to scale it later if the kind if they're the kind who won't just run off and spend it which is what MIRI aspires to be um and you don't think the education path is a useful path just educating the world um getting I mean I I would I would give myself and MIRI credit for for why the world isn't just walking blindly into the railing razor blades here but it's not clear to me how far education scales apart from that you can you can get more people aware that we're walking directly into the whirling razor blades because even if only 10% of the people can get it that can still be a bunch of people but then what do they do I don't know maybe they'll be able to do something later can you get all the people can you get all the politicians can you get the people whose job incentives are against them admitting this to be a problem I have various friends who report like yes if you talk to researchers at open AI in private they're very worried and say that they like cannot be that worried in public um this is uh all a giant molotrap is sort of what you're telling us I um I feel like this is the part of the conversation we've gotten to the end and the doctor has just um said that we have some sort of terminal illness and you know at the end of the conversation I think you know the patient Dave and I have to ask the question okay doc how long do we have um like seriously what what are we talking about here if you turn out to be correct are we talking about years are we talking about decades like what uh what's your idea here if what do you prepare for yeah how the hell would I know and Rico Fermi was saying that nuclear that like fish and chain reactions were 50 years off if they could ever be done at all two years before he built the first nuclear pile the Wright brothers were saying heavier than air flight was 50 years off shortly before they built the first right flyer how how how how how owners would I know it could be three years it could be 15 years we could get that that AI winter I was hoping for and it could be 16 years I I'm not really seeing 50 without some kind of giant civilizational catastrophe and to be clear whatever civilization arises after that could you know what probably I'm guessing end up in stuck in just the same trap we are I uh think the other thing that the patient might do at the end of a conversation like this is um also consult with other doctors um I'm kind of curious if you know who we should talk to on this on this quest um who are some people that if people in crypto want to hear more about this or learn more about this or even we ourselves as as podcasters and educators want to pursue this topic who are the other individuals in the AI alignment and safety space you might recommend uh for us to have a conversation with well the person who actually holds a coherent technical view who disagrees with me is named Paul Cristiano he is he does not write Harry Potter fan fiction and I expect to have a harder time explaining himself in concrete terms um but that is like the the the main technical voice of opposition if you talk to other people in the effective altruism or a alignment communities who um disagree with this view they are probably to some extent repeating back their misunderstandings of Paul Cristiano's views um you could try Ajaya Coutra who's worked pretty directly with Paul Cristiano and I think sometimes expires aspires to explain these things um that that Paul is not the best at explaining um I'll throw out Kelsey Piper as somebody who um would be good at explaining like would not claim to be a like a technical person on these issues but would but is like good at explaining the part that she does know um and who else uh disagrees with me you know I'm sure Robin Hanson would be happy to come up well I'm not sure not sure he'd be happy to come on this podcast but you know Robin Hanson disagrees with me and I kind of feel like the the famous argument we had back in the two like early 2010s late 2000s about how this would all play out I basically feel like this was the your cows keep position this is the Hanson position and then reality was over here like to the well to the Atkowski side of the Atkowski position in the Atkowski Hanson debate but Robin Hanson does not feel that way I would probably be happy to expound on that at once um I don't know it's yeah it's not hard to find opposing viewpoints um the the ones that'll that'll stand up to a few solid minutes of cross examination from somebody who knows which parts to cross examine that's the hard part you know I've read a lot of your uh writings and um listen to you on previous podcast one was in 2018 um on the same Harris podcast this conversation feels to me like the most dire uh you've ever seemed on this topic and maybe that's not true maybe you've sort of always been this way but um it seems like the direction of your hope that we solve this issue has declined um yeah I'm wondering if you feel like that's the case and if you could sort of summarize your your take on all of this as we close out this episode and offer I guess any thoughts concluding thoughts here I mean uh so I don't know if you've got like a time limit on this episode question mark or is it just as long as it runs as long as it needs to be and I feel like this is a pretty important topic so you answer this and all right however you want well there was a conference one time on what are we going to do about looming risk of AI disaster and Elon Musk attended that conference and I was like maybe this is it maybe you know that maybe this is when the the power for people notice and it's you know like one of the relatively more technical powerful people who could be noticing this and maybe this is where humanity finally turns and starts you know not quite fighting back because there isn't an external enemy here but but conducting itself with uh I don't know acting like it cares maybe and what came out of that conference well was open AI which was basically the fairly the worst possible way of doing anything uh oh like this is not a problem of oh no what if secret elites get AI it's that nobody knows how to build a thing if if we do have an alignment technique it's going to involve running the AI with a bunch of like careful bounds on it where you don't just like throw all the cognitive power you have it's something you have limits on the for loops and whatever whatever it is that that could possibly save the world like turn all go out and turn all the GPUs and the surfer clusters into Rubik's cube or something else that prevents the world from anyone somebody else builds another AI a few weeks later you know anything that could do that is is an artifact where somebody else could take it and take the bounds off the for loops and use it to destroy the world yeah so like let's open up everything let's accelerate everything it's it was it was like GPT-3's version though GPT-3 didn't exist that but it was like chat GPT's blind version of like throwing the ideals at a place where they were exactly the wrong ideals to solve the problem and the problem is that demon summoning is easy and angel summoning is much harder open sourcing all the demon summoning circles is not the correct solution I'm not even using and I'm using Elon Musk's own terminology here they talk about AI is summoning the demon which you know not accurate but and then the solution was to put a demon summoning circle in every household and why because his friends were calling him Luddites once he'd expressed any concern about AI at all so he picked a road that sounded like openness and set and like and like accelerating technology so his friends would stop calling him Luddites it was very much the worst you know like maybe not the literal actual worst possible strategy but so very far personal and that was it that was like that that was mean 2015 going like oh so so this is what humanity will elect to do we we will not rise above we will not have more grace not even here at the very end so that is you know that that is uh that is when I did my crying late at night and then picked myself up and fought and fought and fought until I had run out all the avenues that that that I seem to have the capabilities to do there's like more things but they require scaling my efforts in a way that I've never been able to make them scale and and they're and all that's pretty far fished at this point anyways so you know that that so what's you know what's changed over the years well first of all I ran out some remaining avenues of hope and second things got to be such a disaster such a visible disaster the AI's got powerful enough and it became clear enough that you know we do not know how to align these things that I could actually say what I've been thinking for a while and not just have people go completely like what are you saying about all this you know now now the stuff that with that was obvious back in 2015 is you know starting to become visible and distance to others and not just like completely invisible that's what changed over time what kind of um what do you hope people hear out of this episode and out of out of your comments eliezer in in 2023 who is sort of running on the last fumes of of hope um yeah what do you what do you want people to get out of this this episode what like what are you planning to do I don't have concrete hopes here you know when everything is in ruins you might as well speak the truth right maybe somebody hears it somebody figures out something I didn't think of I mostly expect that this does more harm than good in the modal universe because a bunch of people are like oh I have this brilliant clever idea which is you know like something that somebody that you know I was arguing against in 2003 or whatever but you know maybe maybe there maybe somebody out there with the proper level of pessimism hears and thinks of something I didn't think of I suspect that if there's hope and all it comes from a technical solution because the difference between technical solution technical problems and political problems is at least the technical problems have solutions in principle at least the technical problems are solvable we're not in course to solve this one but I don't really see the I think anybody who's hoping for a political solution has frankly not understood the technical problem they do not understand what it looks like to try to solve the political problem to such degree that the world is not controlled by AI because they don't understand how easy it is to destroy the world with AI given that the clock keeps sticking forward they're thinking that they just have to solve stop some bad actor and that's why they think there's a political problem or political political solution but yeah I don't have concrete hopes I didn't come out in this episode out of any concrete hope I I have no takeaways except like don't make this thing worse don't don't don't like go off and accelerate AI more don't don't don't if you have a brilliant solution to alignment don't be like oh yes I have solved the whole problem we just use the following clever trick don't you know don't make things worse isn't very much with messages especially when you're pointing people at the field at all but at there aren't I have no winning strategy might as well go on this podcast and say what I yeah it's an experiment and say what I think and and see what happens and probably no good government comes of it but you know there you might as well guide on fighting right yeah if they if there's a world that survives maybe it's a world that survives because of bright ideas somebody had after listening listening to the spot test that was brighter to be clear than the usual run of bright ideas that don't work at least or I want to thank you for for coming on and and talking to us today I do I don't know by the way you've seen that movie that David was referencing early the movie don't look up but I sort of feel like that that news anchor who's talking to like the scientists is a Leonardo DiCaprio David and the scientists is talking about kind of dire straight to the world and I've the news anchor just really just doesn't know what to do I I'm almost at a loss for words at this point I but what one thing I've had nothing for one thing I can say is I appreciate your honesty I appreciate that you've given this a lot of time and given this a lot of thought everyone any one who has heard you speak or read anything you've written knows that you care deeply about this issue and I have given a tremendous amount of your life force in trying to you know educate people about it and thanks for taking the time to do that again today I'll I guess I'll just let the the audience digest this episode in the best way they know how but I want to reflect everybody in crypto and everybody listening to bankless they're thanks for you coming on and explaining thanks for having me we'll see what comes of it action items for you bankless nation we always end with some action items not really sure where to refer folks to today but one thing I know we can refer folks to is a mirror which is the machine research intelligence institution that Eliezer has been talking about through this episode that is at intelligence.
org I believe and I you know some people in crypto have donated funds to this in the past Vitalik Buterin is one of them you could take a look at what they're doing as well that might be an action item for the end of this episode got to end with risks and disclaimers man this seems very right but our legal experts have asked us to say these at the end of every episode crypto is risky you could lose everything apparently not as risky as a either but we're headed west this is the frontier it's not for everyone but we're glad you're with us on the bankless journey thanks a lot and we are grateful for the crypto community support like it was possible to end with even less grace than this you made a difference we appreciate you really made a difference thank you