Today’s guest is Brendan Malone. He currently works at Paradigm’s Policy Department. But before that, he focused on crypto policy issues at no other than the Federal Reserve. In this episode, we get deep into answering one, if not the most Bankless questions. What is Money? And what does the answer look like in the Digital Age?
------ ✨ DEBRIEF | Unpacking the episode: https://www.bankless.com/debrief-brendan-malone
------ 🚀 Unlock $1,000+ in Perks with Bankless Citizenship 🚀 https://bankless.cc/GetThePerks
------ 📣 CYFRIN | Smart Contract Audits & Solidity Course https://bankless.cc/cyfrin
------ BANKLESS SPONSOR TOOLS:
🐙KRAKEN | MOST-TRUSTED CRYPTO EXCHANGE https://k.xyz/bankless-pod-q2
🦊METAMASK LEARN | HELPFUL WEB3 RESOURCE https://bankless.cc/MetaMask
⚖️ ARBITRUM | SCALING ETHEREUM https://bankless.cc/Arbitrum
🧠 AMBIRE | SMART CONTRACT WALLET https://bankless.cc/Ambire
🦄UNISWAP | ON-CHAIN MARKETPLACE https://bankless.cc/uniswap
🎮IMMUTABLE | GAMING ECOSYSTEM https://bankless.cc/Immutable
🛞MANTLE | MODULAR LAYER 2 NETWORK https://bankless.cc/Mantle
----- Topics Covered
0:00 Intro 5:40 What is Money? 10:34 The Moneyness Spectrum 16:59 How do Current Forms of Money Rank? 21:03 How Much is a Dollar Worth? 29:16 The Difference between Money and Credit 38:30 Losing Trust in the Dollar 48:29 The Role of a Central Bank 54:14 The Future of Money 1:04:26 Why Now? 1:07:14 New Technology Implications 1:10:40 The Case for Crypto 1:18:55 Closing and Disclaimers
----- Resources:
Brendan Twitter https://twitter.com/brendanpmalone
Read Moneyness In The Digital Age https://policy.paradigm.xyz/writing/moneyness-in-the-digital-age
----- Not financial or tax advice. This channel is strictly educational and is not investment advice or a solicitation to buy or sell any assets or to make any financial decisions. This video is not tax advice. Talk to your accountant. Do your own research.
Disclosure. From time-to-time I may add links in this newsletter to products I use. I may receive commission if you make a purchase through one of these links. Additionally, the Bankless writers hold crypto assets. See our investment disclosures here: https://www.bankless.com/disclosures
No summary for this episode yet.
it's very difficult for me to paint a picture that doesn't involve a lot more time spent online, a lot more time organizing social behavior in digital spaces and having a digital form of money that's decentralized and easily accessible to a lot of people is going to be a precondition to enabling a lot of those future worlds. Welcome to Bankless where we explore the frontier of internet money and internet finance. This is how to get started, how to get better, how to front run the opportunity. This is Ryan Sean Adams. I'm here with David Hoffman and we're here to help you become more bankless.
Guys, this is a canonical bankless episode. All right, we're going to talk about money-ness in the digital age. What does that mean? Money-ness. What is the nature of money? A few things to take away from this episode with Brendan Malone from Paradigm. Number one, what is money? Has it changed at all in the digital age? And what's more, why are people even asking this question? Why are they questioning this thing called money? Number two, we discuss the hierarchy of money and the money-ness spectrum and what that means. Number three, where do crypto assets sit on the money-ness spectrum, eth, bitcoin, stablecoins, how much money-ness do they have?
And how are these assets different than digital dollars in a bank account? And number four, we summarize what all of this means for crypto investing and for the broader world. David, why was this episode significant to you? Everyone, I think, starts their crypto journey asking themselves the question, what is money? Like, that's how you know you're at the top of the crypto rabbit hole. And that's also where this industry started, bitcoin, redefining what money could be. And the people that saw bitcoin as money when it was like 2011, 2012, really early, you know, front-run the opportunity. And this is this is the story of crypto.
Everyone goes down the crypto rabbit hole understanding that, you know, money says it says it's just a meme. It's a shelling point. It's a social construct. And then they go down the crypto rabbit hole from there. And now we are in year 2023. And all of a sudden, more people other than the crypto industry are starting to ask the question, hey, what really is money? And there are a bunch of current events that really have thrown the idea of what's a dollar into question. COVID, the Silicon Valley banking crisis, Russia and the de-platforming of an entire country from the dollar network has posed some very interesting, unique questions as to what is money?
What is a dollar? And can money be something else other than the dollar? These are all questions that I think crypto people have been asking themselves for a very long time in our exploration to make our crypto assets into crypto monies. Now, this question has penetrated beyond the crypto sphere. And so we are revisiting this conversation. Like I said, like Ryan said, a canonical conversation about just something that's very, very deep in the crypto space. Yeah, I think sometimes we forget how just that if you innovate, if you change the nature of money, if you create a better money system, that's the only use case that crypto needs to be worth trillions and trillions of dollars.
Like that is big enough when it comes to impact in the world. That is certainly the foundation of crypto. In fact, David, I think we started talking about moniness on our second episode at bankless. It was literally episode number two. So David, I'm excited to talk to you more about this episode during the debrief. I got lots of thoughts for you, including I want to talk in more detail about the central bank digital currency and some of the things that I'm seeing on the horizon there. So bankless listeners, stay tuned for that. If you're a bankless citizen, of course, you can get access to that right now on the premium RSS feed.
If you're not a citizen, click the link in the show notes that you can upgrade. All right, guys, we're going to get right to our episode on moniness with Brendan. But before we do, we want to thank the sponsors that made this possible, including our number one recommended crypto exchange Kraken. Kraken Pro has easily become the best crypto trading platform in the industry. The place I use to check the charts and the crypto prices, even when I'm not looking to place a trade. On Kraken Pro, you'll have access to advanced charting tools, real-time market data, and lightning fast trade execution.
All inside, there's spiffy new modular interface. Kraken's new customizable modular layout lets you tailor your trading experience to suit your needs. Pick and choose your favorite modules and place them anywhere you want in your screen. With Kraken Pro, you have that power. Whether you are a seasoned pro or just starting out, join thousands of traders who trust Kraken Pro for their crypto trading needs. Visit pro.krakken.com to get started today. For a new high-performance Ethereum layer 2, build differently from the other layer 2s that you may be familiar with. Mantle asks the question, how would you build a layer 2 if you had a technology of 2023?
Mantle Network is a modular layer 2, built using the OP staff, but uses eigenlayer's data availability solution instead of the expensive Ethereum layer 1. Not only does this reduce mantle network's gaskies by 80% compared to other layer 2s, but it also reduces gasky volatility, providing a more stable foundation for mantles applications. The mantle treasury is one of the biggest Dow-owned treasuries in Defile, which is seeding an ecosystem of progress from all around the webfree space for mantles. Mantle already has sub-communities from around webfree onboard it to help we growth of mantle like game 7 for webfree gaming or edgey Dow for the world of design.
And buy it for TBL and liquidity and on-mrents. So if you want to build on the Mantle Network, Mantle is offering a grants program that provides milestone-based funding through promising projects that help expand secure and decentralized mantle. If you want to get started working with the first Dow-led Layer 2 ecosystem, check out Mantle at Mantle.com XYZ and follow them on Twitter at 0xMantle. If you haven't experienced the superpowers that a smart contract wall it gives you, check out Ambire. Ambire works with all the EVM chains that are out there. The Layer 2 is like Arbitrum, Optimism, and Polygon, but also the non-ethereum chains like Avalanche and Phantom.
Because of the power of smart contract walls, Ambire lets you pay for gas and stablecoins, meaning you'll never have to spend your precious ETH again. The web app has numerous fiat on-ramps to make it easy to dump your fiat for crypto. And if you like self-custody, but you still want training wheels, you can recover a lost Ambire wallet using an email and password, but without giving the Ambire team any control over your funds. Check it out at ambire.com for the web app experience. But also, the Ambire mobile wallet is coming soon for both iOS and Android. And if you want to be a beta tester, you can sign up at ambire.
com slash app. And since you stayed to the very end of this ad read, you should know that Ambire is air-dropping its wallet token to early users for simply just using the wallet. So if you want to get started with Ambire, all the links that you need are in the chinos. Immutable is at the forefront of Web 3 gaming. On a mission to bring digital ownership to every player, offering the world's best games and game development platform. Immutable lets game builders and players focus on great gaming experiences. So build your next Web 3 game on Easy Mode with Immutable's leading full stack Web 3 gaming platform.
It's built in UX features like the Immutable Passport are designed for games to scale to the next billion players coming to Web 3. With Immutable, players can sign up with an email, pay with a credit card, and experience a frictionless purchase flow inside of games. So, discover your next favorite game and explore a network of 150 games building on Immutable, including such titles as Gossam Change, Guilds of Guardians, Illuvium, Embersword, and Metalcore. So join Web 3's largest ecosystem of games and players. Build, play, and connect at Immutable.com. Thankless Nation. We are super excited to introduce you to Brendan Malone, who works at Paradan, the VC firm, Paradan's policy department.
Prior to working at Paradan, Brendan actually worked in the Believe the Beast at the Federal Reserve. He also focused on policy issues there as it relates to the crypto space. And we are here to talk about a subject that is near and dear to our hearts. I think a subject that really kick-started the bankless podcast, and that is the subject of money and money-ness. So excited to get to that with Brendan today. How are you doing, Brendan? Welcome to Bankless. I'm good. Thanks, guys. I'm just wondering, am I the first fiat defector that you've had on here? Oh, we've had plenty of fiat defectors.
I don't know. In fact, we're all defectors of fiat, aren't we? Do you have a fashion? Well, Brendan, how would you define fiat defector? We've had a lot of flavors of fiat defector. What was yours? Maybe you're the most defector of them all. Yeah, yeah, no, no. That's a great question to kick things off. So I should confess, I am not a fiat minimalist, I guess, as you might say. Do believe in the value of fiat in the overall mosaic of items and instruments that we call money. But do increasingly think that we're in a period of intense change a time where it's really worth asking deep questions about what is money, how might money look in the future, and how can we think about better orienting our systems of social organization around a type of money that works for the digital age that we live in today?
Yeah, maybe we could start there, Brendan, because I think David and I are hoping this could be sort of a canonical episode for people because we're talking about some basic questions here. Most people, I would say, maybe 98% of people out there, particularly those in mainstream outside of crypto, they don't even think about money. I used to be one of those people. I went through my entire life before crypto, not really thinking about the instrument of money. It was something I took for granted without fully understanding what it actually is. Maybe we could start there, Brendan, what is money?
Yeah, so first off, your experience really resonates with me. There's a famous David Foster Wallace quote from a speech he gave where he tells a story of two fish that are swimming around an old fish swims by and says, how's the water boys? And one of the two fish looks at the other one and says, what's water? And the purpose of the illustration is meant to just signify that some of the most obvious important truths that are around us every single day are the hardest ones to see. And I think the kind of experience that most people have with money and how people relate to money is most likely, I think, the best and most resonant example of this type of thing.
Money has evolved over time and we've come to know of it as pieces of paper and as entries in our bank account. But qualitatively, those are two very different things and something that in the wake of Silicon Valley bank and a few of the other bank failures that happened earlier this year, people are starting to wake up to and they're starting to ask deep probing questions about whether or not the assumptions that they had backing their belief in the money that they use were really things that were ironclad and sturdy and kind of all future incarnations of the world. I think what I like about that metaphor the most is that it implies that when you are noticing the water, something's up and I think like when we talk about money, when we talk about money-ness, it's because something's going wrong, you're actually not supposed to talk about money, it's supposed to just work, it's supposed to be in the background, it's supposed to be invisible.
So it's a trend and maybe perhaps as a roadmap to this conversation, why is this question of money-ness arising in the first place? Because this is a question that the crypto industry is built on, but this is a question that we are seeing, tradify, start to ask, especially in the wake of Silicon Valley bank, but really even so that the whole banking crisis wasn't even the first it started with COVID and then Ukraine versus Russia and now Silicon Valley. So I'm wondering what about 2023 makes this question of money-ness so relevant? Yeah, I mean, you hit the nail on the head. I think there's a few trend lines that have been percolating for a while with significant geopolitical changes, China, Russia, COVID being another one, technological change, I'm sure we'll chat about a little bit later.
And I think on top of that, just the crisis in the banking sector, which it has been a bit of a punctuation point on 10 plus years of Federal Reserve monetary policy that led to a lot of cheap money floating throughout the system. And at the beginning of this year, after 10 months or so of interest rate hikes, I think we finally saw the effect of loose monetary policy for 10 plus years in the crash of an institution that was due to liability mismatch and overall insolvency of the liabilities that it issues in the form of money, which are ostensibly supposed to be a safe claim on assets that that institution holds.
And a lot of the money system that we've grown up experiencing and learning about is really built on this system of claims or credit-based claims that institutions give that we hold and that we use, believing that at some point in the future we'll be able to redeem those claims for something that is more like money. So that starts to unpack the actual definition of money. And maybe we can start there again, like first we have the current events of 2023, but we also need to ground those in this idea of money-ness in the first place, right? Money from first principles. So maybe we could start there.
You talked about claims on things that are money, but then it's a little bit self-referential of a definition. How do we actually start the conversation of like money-ness and how society defines what money is? Yeah, for sure. I think as kind of like a priming point, I think about money and money systems as being in a state of equilibrium. And they're complex systems with a lot of legal, technical, psychological structures that build them up. And so there's a lot of ways using that frame to triangulate different definitions or different meanings of money. One way that people kind of commonly frame money is as what it does.
A means of payment, a store of value, and a unit of account. I think those are kind of aspirational and one lens to think about money and what might constitute money. I think the other side that I typically ground my thinking in is this spectrum or hierarchy of different instruments that you can rank in an ordinal manner where at the bottom of the spectrum are effectively just promises or IOUs. And as you move up the spectrum, the IOUs are exchangeable for things that people believe are like the final means of settling a transaction or any obligation that they might have. So inherently in this kind of notion of a spectrum and the notion that at the top of the spectrum there are instruments that people will accept for the discharge of obligations is a need to kind of understand that where you are sitting relatively on the spectrum determines whether or not you will accept something as money or a final means of settlement.
So the way that we see this play out in practice is that most people will accept bank deposits as money or a final means of settlement. If you look at by contrast at the kind of national level how sovereign nations are settling international trade balances, they don't typically accept bank deposits or commercial bank money as that form of money. They'll look to something more like reserves or a higher order form of money in the past this was gold. And in the future it could be something like Bitcoin or Ethereum. Okay, so let's talk about this because I think this is actually I would say an essential mental model for anyone on the crypto journey and on the bank list journey.
I would say this idea that Bren is talking about of a spectrum of moneyness. Okay, so you first established when whenever someone asks you kind of what's the definition of moneyness you hear this sort of this three term kind of definition unit of account me to the exchange and a store of value, right? And so that's one way to define it. I think Bren is absolutely right though this other way to define it as a spectrum of how money something a money can be. How much moneyness a given instrument actually has is maybe a more practical more useful way to define what money is. And so if you imagine the spectrum and we're looking at it on screen right now the spectrum of of moneyness where you have kind of at the top something that is a maximally money.
It is a means of final settlement that is the most money type of instrument. You have at the at the bottom of this spectrum something that is more like credit. And credit of course is a promise to pay whereas you know something that has more moneyness is a means of final settlement. So it has stronger settlement guarantees the more moneyness a given instrument has. And so we've seen at at various stages like in the 1900s. Bren has this depiction in his article. Gold was kind of one of the most probably the most worldwide moneyness instruments. It had the highest degree of moneyness. Whereas a central bank reserves it was kind of somewhere in the middle.
You have bank deposits more at the bottom. Now of course we're in the the world of the 2020s and that has changed. Gold is still up there. It has still strong moneyness but most central bank fiat deposits like most money is actually settled using a central bank type reserves. And they are a higher moneyness instrument than bank deposits. So the money in your Wells Fargo account or securities. And so you often see nation states kind of using the instrument to settle with each other that occupies the most moneyness at a given period of history. And it's interesting to me Bren in that kind of the like this can fluctuate right like the moneyness of a given instrument.
There was one point at time where you know silver might have had a far higher degree of moneyness than even something like gold. And it sort of depends on the society and all of these things. But this is a useful framing of where we are today. And that is again the water that most of us swim in but we don't actually see that's all around us. And as to David's point we only start to notice and ask these questions is something's kind of wrong with the water right. And so that's why we're we're asking these these questions today. So in the 2000s that we occupy now what what's kind of the the spectrum of instruments when it comes to to moneyness like how would something like gold rank how is something like oil rank how is something like tea bills rank how is something like the one or the euro or some other instrument rank in this moneyness spectrum.
Yeah I think it depends a little bit on on the perspective of the person or thing or entity trying to do the ranking. It's a good question though. I mean I think gold tea bills have both experienced some interesting changes over the past five to ten years or so. So I think even quite recently there's been an uptick in the gold holdings of several sovereign nations in particular the nations that are not aligned with the US and the broader G20. So you could like potentially interpret this as a set of concerns that they might have about their ability to use the US dollar either via official reserves held at the New York Fed or via fixed income securities government bonds as like potentially being white potentially being unusable in the future as a means of final settlement for them which is sort of what happened to Russia in the wake of its invasion of Ukraine.
So conceivably there's kind of a point at which some of these different instruments that have been historically used might come back into the fold and some that have been used increasingly over the years might recede a little bit. So it's basically a matter of so Russia or let's say China or something that is less US country that is less US aligned they look at something like the dollar maybe and they see an erosion of settlement assurances when the US Treasury apparatus can simply freeze Russian holdings and Russian bank accounts. And so then they migrate to a money with higher moneyness which according your definition brand it just means stronger final settlement assurances and of course the US you know Janet Yellen and company cannot freeze gold anywhere as long as Russia actually owns sort of the physical gold it cannot be frozen so therefore it has stronger settlement assurances.
So that's very interesting how different money instruments can lose their settlement assurances and thereby lose some aspect of their moneyness over time. Yeah for sure I mean there's kind of a like theory in the international role of the dollar space around the stealth erosion of dollar dominance and there's a lot of contributing factors to that. One of them of course is the increase in the use of economic sanctions as the primary tool of state craft and I think US policymakers are in a difficult position because the international role of the dollar is incredibly valuable to the United States at the same time using that power and effectively not letting the dollar be credibly neutral has an undercutting effect at the I guess in the demand sense of the ability or want of people and nations to hold dollars I think the Russia Ukraine incident was probably the the biggest shifting point over the past five to ten years but there were other moments earlier where the US has gone down this path that has caused people to kind of question whether or not the dollar is that guaranteed international settlement currency that it was for a long time prior.
Humans historically throughout history we like discover money we discover like uses and things that can be money and then sometimes it's imparted upon us right like the dollar and humans like even inside of the United States where like you have to use the dollar we also will discover that that's actually the best use of money or else we go to jail like that still counts as discovering it we discover that the dollar still the best thing to use and over time like that always that discovery process can always shift so like like you said right in the in the modern age we have some misaligned countries that have deemed that the dollar is not the best assurances of their wealth because of the ability for the United States dollar network the Federal Reserve the government to cut off Russia and other countries right and so when you open up that door you allow other countries who are maybe less misaligned than Russia to still see that possibility and that's one that's one half of the equation that is really important to define is like the actual politicization and settlement assurances of money and I think this also goes back all the way back into we can start this conversation at like World War II post-World War II United States had all the gold and dollars had backed by gold written on them and then we rugs that in 1971 and so that settlement assurance decade and for the whole world and that like lasted for a while like even though it was not backed by gold since 1971 it still took time for that to like seep into the world but that's only one half of the equation is like the settlement assurance that a dollar is a dollar the other half of the equation is again similarly when we defaulted on the gold window we said they these are no longer backed by dollars we also did something else that I also want to talk about which is we started to lose the assurance that a dollar is a dollar that one dollar is worth one dollar so not only do we have the equation of some countries are going to be cut off from the money network and lose their settlement assurances that their dollars are actually anything but then there's the other half of the equation of inflation and devaluation of a dollar that a dollar is actually not one dollar at least it won't be in the future so Bren can you kind of put these two pieces together they the actual settlement assurances of a dollar and also the value assurances of a dollar and how these all relate in the modern age yeah and I mean I think you can even like trace the erosion of the gold standard to to kind of earlier events like the Bretton Woods agreement which basically kind of said that currencies have to be redeemable into other currencies that are backed by gold so it intermediated the redemption promise of regular fiat currencies that are not the dollar so that the dollar could stay on the gold standard and as long as other currencies were redeemable for dollars dollars could be redeemable for gold and you had inner position of the dollar in the money-ness spectrum before 1971 and everything just kind of blew up I think the other question you ask is sort of what is the value of a dollar and and kind of is that really worth anything today our dollars physical cash is redeemable for it's basically a claim on the balance sheet of the Fed so a dollar gets you a claim on an equivalent amount of the asset side of the Fed's balance sheet well what's on the asset side of the Fed's balance sheet as you said in 1971 we changed from the gold standard when a dollar was a claim on a pile of gold into a system where a dollar is now a claim on a pile of treasury bonds so it's a claim effectively on the future ability of the United States to collect more dollars from people as they pay taxes and like other sources essentially it's like a debt instrument of the U.
S. economy like exactly your faith in kind of the U.S. economy exactly my favorite meme is dollars backed by aircraft carriers and so there's the like kind of U.S.D full node carrier fleet image that I think is in some ways a little bit accurate here because what you have is a claim on this pool of government debt if you believe that that pool of government debt is worth something then you can talk yourself into believing that the money has value and the way the system currently works is you can kind of always create more of those liabilities in the form of money as long as you have the ability to create more of the assets which are government securities and over the past I think 20 years or so the amount of outstanding U.
S. government debt that is I guess in some ways backing all of this money has ballooned and I mean we saw just a few weeks ago there are questions about whether all of it will be paid and whether some of that money will be redeemable in the future in practice no one tries to redeem their dollars for government securities there's no like window at the Fed where you could walk up to and ask for the the equivalent amount of government debt but conceptually that's how it's supposed to work yeah that's the part that I actually have a really hard time wrapping my head around so like when we have we with dollars backed by gold it was very simple and obvious what the money was like if I want gold I go to the federal reserve and I give them one dollar and I get one dollars worth of gold whatever whatever it's backed by and that is just clear as day and then when we remove from the gold standard and we go backed by debt which is denominated in dollars and the government collects dollars to pay the debts which are thought it seems very self referential and which is like both the kind of the point but also the demise can you just help help me and the listeners understand that like self referentiality of a dollar like why is that in what ways is that a feature in what in what ways is that a bug yeah I mean it's a feature in the sense that it gives policy makers tools for controlling the amount of outstanding currency and circulation which has implications for the prices of goods employment and a host of other things that the Fed thinks about when it implements monetary policy in like prior regimes when money was backed by hard assets like gold it was impossible to flexibly or elastically control the amount of money and circulation in order to try to hit other targets like price targets or employment targets like try to do a stimulus check if it's all gold and you're the exact government ain't going to happen unless you find a lot of gold right you know and so you could like think about scenarios and I think this is like effectively what happened where inflows of gold would would would come to the United States be somewhat unexpected or uncontrollable and they would result in subsequent expansions of credit in the United States and changes in economic conditions and so the transition to this more self referential system that's backed by government securities comes with a degree of flexibility that ostensibly lets policy makers more finely tune the amount of credit in an economy in order to get better economic conditions for everyday people of course that you know at some point there are are downside effects of of all of that I think to your earlier question to David I think Brendan's definition of moniness as a means of final settlement sort of explains both the idea like so final settlement to me means both that no third party can kind of freeze the account or or sensor or prevent it and also that a third party can't debase it and so the purchasing power doesn't isn't affected materially by a third party and so that's why I think in times where money money instruments like the dollar are going through debasement or censorship or freezing and they start to lose their credible neutrality and they start to be more political we revert to money that is farther up the moniness spectrum that is more credibly neutral and I by we I mean different nation states because because Brendan you also make the point this why I sort of think the money in this spectrum almost explains everything like it's just explained so much like if you are a nation state you certainly can't trust other nation states if you're engaging in state craft or you have to be selective as far as what your alliances are specifically as we move from a you know us dominated unipolar world to a multi like a bilateral world where we have multiple large powers you sort of you can't put all of your trust eggs in that basket and so at the nation state level you have different needs with respect to moneyness then you might at the individual level right so like a transaction Brendan between you and I right like you don't need to give me gold nuggets like I'll just give you dollars right as that the individual level and that kind of works because we exist in a similar economy and we use a similar unit of exchange but at the nation state level things get much different and this this spectrum as well starts to explain almost a I think a two schools of thought that people have about money which is like the Austrian school of thought the money is a commodity it's based on a barter system that's how sort of arose and kind of like this low trust environment and the David Graber kind of you know debt credit theory of money that that money is sort of a social system well both are kind of represented in the money in a spectrum right and in times of of low trust you sort of revert up to more the commodity money that requires a lot less trust it's not a credit type instrument it's sort of like a gold or like an ether or like a Bitcoin right and then in times of higher trust then you can go down the spectrum more towards credit forms of money and credit of course is a promise to pay it it it's layered so at the bottom of credit there is that final settlement settlement of something either the dollar or gold or some other instrument but in higher trust context you can actually get down to credit and actually credit's not a bad thing I think that's what maybe the the Austrian school of thought don't appreciate or like credit can be a good thing it's a way to scale society so long as you have trust but when you have corruption and that starts to erode the trust of the instrument well then credit can turn sort of bad and then people naturally revert up the chain of moneyness to that means of final settlement to kind of closer to the bare metal I'm wondering if you could you know reflect on on some of that you know how much is explained by this money is spectrum am I am I reading too much into it yeah I mean I like personally think I kind of believe that it's good for us to have both sides of the spectrum and as long as you believe that states are a kind of useful way to organize society and have people doing things working for the common good uh you know I think there's probably going to be the existence of some credit based official monies at the same time like having other higher order forms of money available and free to use for when there is more uncertainty or more ambiguity has just one very specific use case but also as a like a check on uh you know democratic use of power and authority I think you know in a lot of ways the idea of the dollar is credibly neutral reflects American values around freedom and self-sovereignty and the less the dollar kind of behaves that way uh there's some down stream effects for just the nature of the country the United States and sort of whether or not it's operating in a way that's kind of aligned with the founding principles and I think to the extent that higher order forms of money are more closely aligned to some of those principles of kind of censorship resistance freedom from authoritarianism uh yeah having a set of instruments that are available for people to use as uh better forms of digital commodity monies is a good thing I also think it's kind of to sort of go to your point about uh contrasting individuals and nation states I almost think about this in terms of concentric circles where even from the perspective of a single nation state that might be the largest circle in a series of concentric circles whether or not you believe in certain principles of money is going to depend on what your reference point is to the smaller circles within so if you imagine the United States occupying like the largest ring uh you can think of like Iran occupying the next ring and you can think of an individual person in Iran representing the the smallest circle in this set of three circles for the United States it's going to want to have some ability to control what the Iranian state does as kind of geopolitical grand strategy and the use of money as a means of economic state craft at the same time it's going to want to have more free censorship resistant money for the Iranian people who might be trying to look for ways to engage in just normal behavior and avoid a regime that the United States might not be aligned with so even from the perspective of a nation state like the US how it might think about money and promoting different types of money is going to be different depending on who the the person is uh kind of at the end of this this uh set of circles i really appreciate the the trust model for money um back when we had back when we used gold it was in a society in a world uh in a phase of of humanity where we just had less credit and trust and i think when truck when credit is high on the moneyness spectrum it's actually indicative of a high trust environment like that's actually like the kpi that we are going for that's like that's what what we want although i do see that well once you get to a high credit environment a high trust environment it's also dubious because then you will allow for distrustful people to enter into a trusted space and kind of ruin it for the rest of us um but but i i i see like at gold as actually in the background and some sort of credit as money is actually the place where the most economic activity is happening um and it's only when uh something like gold needs to arise as the only form is the dominant form of money is is because we are in a distrustful environment uh there's something like very holy about having gold in your hand there's that meme that like possession is nine tenths of the law and then also uh since gold is gold like the economic security of gold is is written in explosions of stars like you're not going to be able to reproduce that like you can reproduce a dollar and so like that is the most trustless form of money in your hand possible like gold in your hand is the most trustless high assurances form of money but it's also not what we want to have a society based around right because we want trust we want trust at we want as much trust as possible and so Brendan i'm hoping we can move forward into the modern age of 2020 because since since covid there has been not so many great um things happening to the trust around the dollar starting with covid and then we have russia and china and then silicon valley bank in that order so far the 2020 has been a bad year for the dollar um so maybe we can unpack like the the story of the dollar this decade and and how it's kind of lost its position in the world um or maybe currently losing its position in the in the world and then we can go into the world of crypto money after that yeah overall there's just been an erosion of state capacity in general where i mean in the 60s and 70s the place you wanted to go if you were the top engineer graduating from caltech was to like a us government lab or to nasa and i think there's just been a broader shift in public trust and the value that the public places on public institutions and so like one narrative here is just i think around the experience that most people have had with monetary policy and uh the current posture of the fed which is to basically be a par maxi by everything when there's a crisis and uh deal with bigger systemic issues that might be affecting the system as a whole uh as something it for a later day so for uh silicon valley bank and like the kind of entire system that we have i think there was a presumption that people could trust that banks were not engaging in risky business and bank regulators were there to make sure that if they were consumers were protected and when svb went down individual users were made whole it kind of system was dealt with in a way that uh led people to not lose significant amounts of money but a lot of people i think are you know rightfully asking the questions whether we should have been able to get to that place in the first place and you know do we need to have a system that relies on emergency actions uh to make people whole instead of one that is architected so that those emergency actions are never necessary in the first place and when you have uh i'm kind of going back to our sort of previous thread on uh low trust environments making a stronger case for higher order forms of money when you have a low trust environment and uh primary monetary instruments are a promise for an institution like a bank and you have relatively little ability as an individual to verify that those promises are credible uh there there's just an overall scenario that uh creates a lot of complications for individual people and when you kind of light a torch and get rid of the entire uh foundational belief that lets everyone kind of willfully ignore the fact that a commercial bank deposit is credit to a bank and credit exposure for an individual to a bank uh you know you you start really opening their eyes and and uh getting to the the point where you can ask some really interesting questions about the future of money and if there's a way better design a system that is uh inherently lower in uh it's baseline requirement for trust I think the conversation of the um bank failures that we saw recently in 2023 the the four banks that that went under there's a good conversation to be had about like okay the safety of our money system in our banks um but but the other half of the conversation is the federal reserves reaction to it or the FDIC specifically's uh reaction to it where all the sudden like banks M2 the monetary supply uh money goes into the banks and then the banks 10 exit and like lend it out as credit and then some banks uh irresponsible ones go under and then the FDIC insured every single dollar that was ever uh deposited into that bank which really warps distorts what actually money actually is if these banks which all with all of their loans and all of their credit lens uh gets uh covered one to one it really uh distorts how people think about their banks and so Brenda maybe we could just like I don't know though guys like so I'm it what's interesting is I I feel like what the FDIC did is actually they said oh yeah that credit money that you know S S V B dollar that you thought that that you thought you had okay we're actually going to change that to a higher order of money where it's basically FDI insured S V B dollars and so if you have your money in in Silicon Valley bank you're you're happy about that so didn't the FDIC essentially do its job like so what what are you saying the implications are there David like aren't they there to make sure that Silicon Valley bank dollar holders have their money restored and didn't they accomplish that task by saying hey it's actually we'll give you better settlement assurances like they're there to preserve the settlement assurances I think of um yes savers in their bank account basically so yeah they they distorted the nature of money by turning credit into money like pure alchemy they snap their fingers Jesus turns water into wine and the federal reserves turns credit into money right and and so like use individuals that have that that credit owed to them are happy yes but the broader system is like yo that you just turned not my money into my into more money and so the system is distorted as a whole right branded the fundamental question is like is it because you know this is not like a clearly choreographed and firmly legally enshrined policy change so like overnight turn the broader set of commercial bank money into effectively government backed central bank money uh it was done as emergency action for a small bank but you does sort of beg the question would this apply to every bank are we in a system where we have like sort of Schrodinger's uh central bank money where all of the money in your commercial bank is simultaneously a liability of that commercial bank but in some effect guaranteed implicitly by the government and if that's the case isn't isn't what biology was worried about we're like every all of the credit that was issued by banks they're all all the banks are going to fail and that credit is going to be with the snap of the fingers of the federal reserve turned into money isn't that more or less what biology was saying with his whole Bitcoin to a million uh meme yeah yeah I think that that's kind of the core premise and there's like a question of whether you were to like sort of overnight narrow bank the entire banking system uh if you could do that and ensure that all of the commercial banks stayed narrow banked so they weren't able to go like further uh in a fractionalized way off of that kind of initial expansion of harder money then conceivably the kind of like hyper inflation uh effects wouldn't necessarily happen that way but it is I think easier to conceptualize his argument is just one of sort of what sorts of emergent phenomena are possible as we think about a pretty fundamental change to the nature of money banking and the role of the state uh overnight or over the weekend well I feel like that's what that's totally what the government uh basically said is your dollars are backed it doesn't matter how much you have an account in any bank in the US they didn't write you know in it's not legal right they they didn't kind of craft a bill passed this through legislation but it is part of the social contract now and by making that part of the social contract they prevented a wider spread bank run bank failure but like implicitly all m2 there's money commercial a deposited money just became a kind of like federal reserve based money didn't it I feel like that's what happened so if that's what everyone thinks I mean that's why I'm I did it rush out to like pull all of my money from Wells Fargo and like you know turn it into crypto um I just do that more slowly um but like I I didn't do that overnight because I was fargo man yeah exactly and by the way Wells Fargo is one of those banks which is also on the you know top 10 too big to fail um you know a bank list so so that makes me feel uh nice and secure but like that that does beg the question is like what's the downside of this isn't this what the FDIC isn't this what you know kind of the treasure in the fed in this what they're supposed to do is in times of stress they're supposed to restore confidence and oh yeah that credit money is is essentially um you know has stronger settlement assurances and we'll come in and and uh make it so are there are there bad effects to this David you were talking about systemic effects to this are there um dangers of doing this or is this what they should be doing the first place yeah I mean this is the big uh like meta debate among fed watchers now uh Gina smell like from the New York Times just wrote a book called limitless about the feds increasing role over the past 15 years as a crisis fighter so like sort of traditionally think of the fed as being responsible for uh monetary conditions in the form of employment and prices but there's also a you know an argument that the fed and the kind of broader crisis fighting apparatus in the United States is really best suited for dealing with liquidity problems dealing with problems where people have uh assets that are effectively credit and they need cash today and the place that's kind of best suited to deliver the high order form of government-backed money whenever it's needed is the central bank and they can take illiquid kind of more credit-based assets turn them into cash today and break the the system not in the the kind of sense that it's broken but arrest kind of any further spirals and saw this with covid where one of the first things the the fed did uh in 2020 was roll out a like bunch of facilities that just accepted assets and gave cash um and you know that there's a longer debate that will probably have over like multiple decades of whether or not dealing with short-term pain in the form of crises is worth the longer term effects of creating a system where losses aren't deeply internalized by the actors that incur them and you know sometimes uh those are actors that are doing like bad or or reckless things but other times that those are just individual people and we've collectively and socially made a decision that it's better uh to not have to deal with the effects of crises but we've also kind of blown out the the discipline side side of the equation.
This is very interesting this idea of like you socialized losses right because I found myself personally it's like when a deposit deposits their money to a bank account should um they uh be undertaking the risk of bank management basically and I feel like myself personally I'm much more comfortable with um that loss being socialized then with like equity holder bank equity holders getting a bailout right and socializing that loss right and that's just me personally other people might feel different and there might be some underlying systemic um moral hazards that occur as a result of this maybe it is a better system if we all have to like think very carefully before we put our money in a bank account as to the management and trust worthiness of this um particular bank account but when you broaden that and you look outside of the US and you think about the US being a the global reserve currency where um you know other countries essentially store their wealth in the dollar and you think about those countries uh taking the socialized losses of the United States economy and the mistakes that that we're making that becomes pretty unpalatable right and so like I would not be I would not want to be in a position where I am um a different nation state with my own kind of you know sovereignty and I am responsible for the mistakes of um the fiscal policy of the US government or for like you know bailing out um uh yeah the generation of of baby boomers maybe uh for instance or whatever you know political decision the US makes right and so that starts to arose uh erode the credibility of of the dollar for other nation states so this idea of socializing losses is is very interesting and I think that is effectively what when you have the reserve uh currency you can sort of socialize the losses or the or the mistakes that your country is making to the rest of the world as long as they are holding those dollars that's kind of the game that that maybe the US is playing and other countries other nation states can effectively opt out of that game at any point in time by what by purchasing non-US based assets maybe that's what they're starting to do yeah I mean there I think there are there's a lot of theories on on this right now and and like a lot of questions whether large nation states are are gaping into crypto and I don't know that we have uh like good evidence that that's happening but there's there's certainly uh like directionally some anecdotal evidence that some countries are thinking more critically about their dollar exposure for a variety of these reasons learning about crypto is hard until now introducing metamask learn an open educational platform about crypto web3 self-custody wallet management and all the other topics needed to onboard people into this crazy world of crypto metamask learn is an interactive platform with each lesson offering a simulation for the task at hand giving you actual practical experience for navigating web3 the purpose of metamask learn is to teach people the basics of self-custody and wallet security in a safe environment and while metamask learn always takes the time to define web3 specific vocabulary it is still a jargon free experience for the crypto curious user friendly not scary metamask learn is available in 10 languages with more to be added soon and it's meant to cater to a global web3 audience so are you tired of having to explain crypto concepts to your friends go to learn dot metamask.
io and add metamask learn to your guides to get onboarded into the world you know uniswap it's the world's largest decentralized exchange with over 1.4 trillion dollars in trading volume you know this because we talk about it endlessly on bakeless it's uniswap but uniswap is becoming so much more uniswap labs just released the uniswap mobile wallet for iOS the newest easiest way to trade tokens on the go with a uniswap wallet you can easily create or import a new wallet buy crypto on any available exchange with your debit card with extremely low fiat-honorant fees and you can seamlessly swap on main net polygon arbitragem and optimism on the uniswap mobile wallet you can store and display your beautiful NFTs and you can also explore web3 with the in-app search features market leaderboards and price charts or use wallet connect to connect to any web3 application so you can now go directly to defy with the uniswap mobile wallet safe simple custody from the most trusted team and defy download the uniswap wallet today on iOS there's a link in the show notes Arbitram 1 is pioneering the world of secure ethereum scalability and is continuing to accelerate the web3 landscape hundreds of projects have already deployed on Arbitram 1 producing flourishing defy and NFT ecosystems with a recent addition of Arbitram Nova gaming and social apps like Reddit are also now calling Arbitram Home both Arbitram 1 and Nova leverage the security and decentralization of Ethereum and provide a builder experience that's intuitive familiar and fully EVM compatible on Arbitram both builders and users will experience faster transaction speeds with significantly lower gas fees with Arbitram's recent migration to Arbitram Nitro it's also now 10 times faster than before visit arbitram.
io where you can join the community dive into the developer docs bridge your assets and start building your first app with Arbitram experience web3 development the way it was meant to be secure fast cheap and friction free so let's turn this conversation to the world of digital money the frontier of digital uh moneyness and so there's a line in your article that stood out to me Brendan that says maybe it's time to replace credit worthiness with collateral worthiness and i'm wondering if you just unpack that statement and overall just juxtapose this digital financial system that is being built uh versus the entrenched fiat system which kind of seems to be a little shaky yeah i mean that you know that uh that line in particular is a bit of a cheeky reference to like a few writers uh who've like written more publicly about the nature of moneyness in the financial plumbing context um you know and kind of in in the context of shadow banking and broader activities that really large institutions and and countries are doing in the the space of uh of money markets and uh the original reference is referring to a an article written by Nathan tankus looking at the situation that happened with credit swiss and uh you know kind of effectively the one of the like sort of big problems in money markets is that you have a lot of large institutions that end up holding securities like uh government securities or uh mortgage back securities and at different points in time particularly in times of crisis they need to figure out whether those promises to pay are uh like actually worth something and measuring the economic value of some of these credit based instruments is very difficult in normal times it's incredibly difficult in in times of crisis how do you figure out what uh mortgage back security is worth you can't just like walk out on the street and kind of ask someone to buy your mortgage back security especially when like an entire market might be on fire and and full of dysfunction and so there's uh like a kind of a I think point at which you can make a very strong case that having assets that are not IOUs or promises that are uh tradable and and kind of readily priceable is incredibly valuable and I think you have that with with crypto which which you can hold uh you know like in a self-custody manner free of of credit risk or credit exposure to an institution and uh you can also like readily price it so you get some of the same kind of benefits of moving up uh the money-ness spectrum that you would going from cash or something else to gold but you don't have to deal with some of the more like kind of cumbersome features that come with something like gold can we talk about the money-ness spectrum as it applies to the digital age and I'm wondering if maybe we can we can pull up um the same chart we've been using the the spectrum and now um talk about some of the various um digital instruments but let's um let's first start by saying it it is probably increasingly obvious which almost goes without saying to everyone that is listening to this that um humanity has squarely entered the digital age okay like um this is the internet age our financial instruments aren't going to manifest physically and while we have things like nuggets of gold and you know gold bars these are sort of vestiges of the past as is you cash money right um I was growing up at a paper route you know you got paid and kind of you know cash cash money basically door to door and I'd have to come collecting every weekend this is a thing of the past this is a thing that is is quite uh quaint um by today's standards and uh we are no longer going to have um there there's a phasing out process of actual cash of physical bills so we have entered the digital age and uh in the digital age when we have these digital instruments there's a spectrum of money-ness for each um type of instrument so I it's very interesting by the way last week um Gary Gensler came out and said we already have digital money there's no need for crypto we are it's it's called digital dollars in your bank account right I want to say but Gary those digital dollars in my bank account do not have the same settlement assurances as some of my crypto assets do so let's look at this chart and apply kind of the the digital money to it uh at the one end of the spectrum on the credit side of the spectrum we have bank deposits that's the digital dollars that Gary Gensler is talking about and we already have digital money right um that is very far on the the the credit side of the money-ness spectrum a little bit to the left of that we have stable coins in your chart here a little bit to the left of that we have reserves that have more money-ness and all the way to on the money-ness spectrum we have assets like bitcoin and ether that are not credit they are almost like gold in these uh economic systems they have the strongest settlement assurances bread and i'm wondering if you could kind of comment on this spectrum here and why you place these assets in these various locations yeah i first started thinking about this when i joined the fed in i think it was 2016 and this is like a very different time when the entire us government was a lot more open to engaging with crypto companies and one of the first projects i worked on when i started was a bit of an industry stock take and um in some ways a little bit of crystal wall gazing we we set out to meet with as many companies as we could and crypto companies you're talking about crypto companies um and hypothesize what the emergence of blockchains meant for payments clearing and settlement systems and our remit was to try to think about how to make the payment system and the the broader set of financial infrastructures used for transferring assets safer and more efficient and some of that was a kind of constant in the moment game of looking at the current landscape and then there was also a set of projects related to kind of thinking more deeply about what the future evolution of our financial architecture looks like and what that means for some of the things that we we kind of care about and i think the kind of first round of industry outreach we did we met with probably 30 or so companies and talked to them about the projects that they were working on in the like crypto and blockchain space and almost everyone at the time said the exact same thing which was that they needed a native form of money a native dollar effectively that they could integrate with these systems in order to settle transactions and make payments and for me that was a bridge into this broader notion that a lot of the systems that we have for transferring value and exchanging things as a value require a form of money inherent to them that let you make payments and exchange obligations and as you look like kind of low down on the money spectrum to things like bank deposits these are very digital obviously but they're also very narrowly constrained so they are it fundamentally a promise of the bank but also exist mostly on a narrow set of databases that the bank runs they don't have a lot of like functional use for a broad set of applications that you can imagine being the case for other financial instruments and this was really the like first foray that I had into thinking kind of more deeply about what the digital age looks like what kind of use cases are going to be coming about and emerging from this wave of innovation and what types of monetary instruments might be useful to have in an emerging digital ecosystem and what might those look like stable coins really became the I think like first most prominent one largely because I think they're the easy way to get something that is functionally similar to a central bank digital currency without dealing with any of the thorny questions about you know like CBDC that has created a like very particular landscape and political economy that is supercharged and full of a lot of interesting and heated debates but fundamentally if we're going to be spending more of our time in digital environments engaging with open digital ecosystems we need forms of money that are native to those environments and that can function seamlessly in them without needing to rely on third parties to gatekeep or approve entry and exit to them.
Going back to the current events of the 2020s decade again COVID, Russia, Silicon Valley bank failures, inflation, etc. What tailwinds are the big tailwinds that you see for the crypto monies, the big coins in the ethers out there or all the other aspiring crypto monies. Why is now, why is this decade the right decade for crypto monies to emerge? What void are the are we feeling here? Yeah, I mean it depends on the specific cryptocurrency and questions. I think the maybe just crypto assets as an archetype, not an expensive one. Yeah, yeah, I mean I think having a digitally native form of money that is censorship resistant is a super powerful use case going to be increasingly so.
So I think the transactional ability on a like payment side is one. I think having an asset that is durable, that is supply controlled is another one which gets at the question of whether a dollar is always worth a dollar. We know that one Bitcoin is always worth a Bitcoin and that is mathematically true and will always be true. You can think about fluctuations against the dollar but that is like a separate set of considerations and a separate set of use cases. Going another step further, I think there's just the platform angle which is that when you have assets that are built on top of platforms that allow for a lot of different potential uses and use cases, you have what functions almost like a digital form of oil that can be the necessary commodity to kind of grease the wheels of a ton of possible use cases.
I also wrote in my piece a little bit about the potential for AI agents that are going out and conducting things for us on the internet needing to have access to a digital form of money that is native to the environment that they live in. I haven't seen any specific implementations of this yet but I would feel a lot more comfortable giving in LLM trained on my own personal data access to a wallet with a fixed amount of crypto in it rather than just giving it carte blanche access to my bank account and everything else. It's interesting as we unpack the definition of money-ness, I think we all everyone understands the inevitability of AI coming down the pipeline and all of a sudden AI's get an opinion too.
They don't need to even be sentient or conscious, this isn't even a conversation about that. It's just about being economic agents in the world of finance which money suits them better. First of all, you know they're going to prefer digital, right? And then you know they're going to prefer digital and programmable as a second. So we know that. Maybe the ultimate hedge against AI existential risk is their ultimate aversion to physical cash and gold. At some point when they get rid of all of us we'll just have to exit to the paper and gold. We'll be back to cash. We'll be using gold as a form of money-ness that the AI overlords can't censor us from using.
I think it's really really well. There's two forces moving us towards digital money and digital finance. There's the gaping hole that the current fiat system is creating for better or worse choices by the money managers of the world. And we've already talked about that again, like COVID, inflation, Silicon Valley Bank, Russia, the politicization of the dollar, the decay of the dollar, all that stuff, like that. All of that, Tradworld is creating demand for digital finance, new world money. And then there's also just other innovations out there, other frontier technologies that are producing new use cases that specifically only crypto monies can truly enable or just can enable far better than our old system.
And so it's just a nice way to frame this conversation. Man, it just feels so inevitable. I mean, that's what I feel. Do you feel the inevitability Brendan? Yeah, for sure. I mean, if you look at the average time spent in front of a screen over the past 10 years, it's like, I've always gone up every year. People are increasingly spending more and more time online. We knocked the word metaverse as being a little cringe sometimes, but the fact that boomers and other people like so quickly, we're able to hear the word metaverse, understand what it meant, and then like start making jokes about it, tells me that there was a deep, like unsatiated latent demand for having a way to talk about this idea of like digital worlds that people are going to be living in.
There was like immediate product market fit of the term metaverse, like the day it started becoming popular. And whether or not people truly believe that it's going to be a thing, then we admit it's almost let me just say it's almost like gold and fiat kind of had a baby. Because remember this point we were making earlier about you said, Brendan, the dollar is, you know, your favorite meme of the dollar is that settlement assurances it's backed by aircraft carriers, right? And you see that kind of like and the aircraft carriers are obviously backed by American taxpayers, which are backed by the US economy, right?
So the aircraft carriers are just power projection of the US economy is one way of thinking. Well, an asset like ether is kind of like power projection of the Ethereum economy and its block space sales, essentially, right? It's so it and the way Ethereum sort of taxes everyone in the Ethereum economy is through transaction fees and in the future probably MEV ordering type fees. There's almost like it's not fiat in terms of supply, but it is backed by an economy, isn't it? Like a almost not a nation state economy, but like a blockchain decentralized economy and its power will scale so long as economic activity increases and the economy of Ethereum continues to increase.
So it's it's almost a little bit like not like fiat. I hate to say that somebody's going to take this quote out of context and say, Ryan just said Ethereum is fiat, but there is something that parallels kind of the nation state, right? And yeah, I'm wondering if maybe I'm like, what would you say to that kind of analog that I just laid out? Is there something similar here? And for me, that's actually bullish. I don't know what you guys would say, but yeah, grab onto something for me here. Yeah, I mean, like one of the reasons why the US is a kind of seen as a symbol of economic growth and innovation is all of these preconditions that the nation has enabled that allows other things to be built on top of it.
So it's things like a legal system. It's a highly educated workforce. It's technology investment. All of these things create like a platform, which is a country on which things can be built. And the more things that are built there, the more clustering and agglomeration effects you have, which make it even more valuable to build future stuff. And I do think at some point, L1s, there's kind of a parallel to the nation state at the L1 level where like kind of having a platform that enables the creation of rules and other use cases and generates network effects is kind of a helpful frame for thinking about the future growth.
And there's also the kind of like cross, cross country or cross L1 comparison where you can sort of think about the purchasing power parity of Ethereum versus another L1 where like what you can do and how you can transact on the network is in some ways like a function of what it costs to do that from a block space perspective, which is like a relative price compared to to another network. So like transacting on something like Solano, which might be incredibly cheap, is on some level comparable to the idea that like different countries have cheaper labor costs or cheaper manufacturing costs. And there's kind of opportunities to are across those for different use cases.
I really like the idea of like the hybridization of the fiat and hard money worlds in the world of crypto. And it just kind of fits the pattern of technology converging different components into the same system. So we have like the triple point asset thesis about Ether. It's a commodity is a security and it is a shit, whether you hold on, what's my own. Actually, don't say it's security. I would restate that. Yes, big time commodity capital asset and commodity capital asset and store value store value store value store value. Yeah, security. That's a great way to put that. Like Ether, the triple point asset thesis, it's a commodity and a capital asset and a store of value.
Right. And so to me, it's not just like we're not compromising like, hey, we have fiat properties and hard money properties. It's actually we have the best of nation state economics. And then we also have the best of hard money Austrian economics. So we have the strengths of both. You have these strengths of the Ethereum economy and the assurances of gold of supply changes of algorithmic monetary policy. And so like to me, the the hybridization that you're talking about Ryan is actually bullish just says it because it seems such like a logical conclusion of where money in finance goes. Yeah, I totally agree.
And I think I think the the mental model and of course, you know, Bankless is trying to understand the asset space. We've been on a quest to try to understand what is this? What is this crypto thing? But the best mental model I've seen and I subscribe to for understanding at least layer ones Bitcoin, ethos, a lot of all of these things is like it's like investing in an emerging economy. It's kind of what you're doing, right? The monetary asset and almost the stock market of an emerging economy. It's sort of what we're doing here. And I hope Bankless listener, you understood the lesson of what money actually is here.
Money. There is a spectrum of moneyness. All the way on one of the spectrum is credit, a promise to pay. That is kind of weak in its form of moneyness. And on the other side of the spectrum, the maximally money type of instruments are a means of final settlement. So I hope you bring that lens with you when you're evaluating crypto and evaluating all of the digital money instruments. They're about to hit us in the 2020s and beyond. Brendan, thank you so much for joining us today. This has been very helpful. Thanks, guys. Bankless listeners, we will leave you with one action item, which is read Brendan's fantastic article.
It's called Moneyness in the digital age. We'll include a link in the show notes for you to access that. As always, risk and disclaimers got to let you know none of this has been financial advice. Crypto is risky. You could lose what you put in, but we are headed west. This is the frontier. It's not for everyone, but we're glad you're with us on the bankless journey. Thanks a lot.