Nothing tests your conviction like a bear market. This is an opportunity to test what you think you know, refine your thesis, and make your bets for the next leg up.
Avichal and Sanjay are long time crypto investors and at VC fund electric capital. What are they betting on during the bear market?
We discuss 5 of the most pressing questions facing crypto investors during the bear market including…
1) L2 tokens - Are L2 tokens they worth something or they just worthless governance tokens?
2) AltL1s…Will the ETH killers make a comeback?
3) Multichain world - Millions of L2 chains or a few big winners?
4) Restaking - big deal or overhyped?
5) What Avichal things are this cycle’s alt-coins.
Episodes like this are an opportunity to sharpen your insights as a crypto investor. Don’t take these ideas as gospel. Wrestle with them. Test them. Make them your own. We’ll have other Bear Market Bets episodes with other perspectives, so this isn’t the last.
------
🚀 Join Ryan & David at Permissionless in September. Bankless Citizens get 30% off. 🚀
https://bankless.cc/GoToPermissionless
------
BANKLESS SPONSOR TOOLS:
🐙KRAKEN | MOST-TRUSTED CRYPTO EXCHANGE
🦊METAMASK PORTFOLIO | TRACK & MANAGE YOUR WEB3 EVERYTHING
⚖️ ARBITRUM | SCALING ETHEREUM
🛞MANTLE | MODULAR LAYER 2 NETWORK
👾POLYGON | VALUE LAYER OF THE INTERNET https://polygon.technology/roadmap
------
Timestamps
0:00 Intro
8:00 L2 Value Capture
15:12 How Rollups Make Money
20:20 Harmful vs. Good MEV
25:00 Transactions Fees & L2s
38:05 Are L2s Valueable?
40:00 Multichain L2s or Few Winners?
43:05 Multichain Applications
49:09 Multichain Friction
59:02 Are NFTs Dead?
1:06:45 Investing in NFTs
1:10:00 RSA’s Worst Fear
1:15:10 Ethereum Killers & Modular/Monolithic Chains
1:19:22 L1s Playing the Monetary Premium Game
1:22:00 RSA vs. Avichal Moneyness Debate
1:24:30 Is Restaking Overhyped? Risky?
1:29:35 Crypto’s Antifragileness & Are We Lost?
1:33:40 Closing & Disclosures
-----
Resources
Avichal Garg
Sanjay Shah
https://twitter.com/sanjaypshah
Read
https://mirror.xyz/electriccap.eth/SD0wT7qSSfis9gLT_Ki1gY6_oTYEqgwcGE0hDw7kMDY
https://www.developerreport.com/developer-report
------
Not financial or tax advice. This channel is strictly educational and is not investment advice or a solicitation to buy or sell any assets or to make any financial decisions. This video is not tax advice. Talk to your accountant. Do your own research.
Disclosure. From time-to-time I may add links in this newsletter to products I use. I may receive commission if you make a purchase through one of these links. Additionally, the Bankless writers hold crypto assets. See our investment disclosures here: https://www.bankless.com/disclosures
No summary for this episode yet.
You can only really generate value as an investor if you have a deeper understanding of what's happening than anybody else. Like effectively, alpha in a market comes from depth of understanding. If you can see the actual value of the thing, and there's a disconnect between perception and reality, right? So if the world thinks something is worth x but it turns out to be worth 2x, and that's a delta between perception and reality. And so what you really have to do as an investor across all of the categories that you mentioned, picks and shovels if you're an early stage equity investor, you know, NFTs themselves, if you're more like an art curator, what you really have to do is understand the thing better than anybody else.
You have to have some perspective on it that says actually reality is different than perception and that's fundamentally what you're betting on. Welcome to Bankless, where we explore the frontier of internet money and internet finance. This is how to get started, how to get better, how to frontrun the opportunity. This is Ryan Sean Adams, and I'm here to help you become more at Bankless. Yep, just me on that episode today, no David, he's off escaping to the mountains. If the AI tech was a little bit better, maybe he'd never miss an episode. I could just beam him in. Unfortunately, we're not there yet.
So I had to take this episode on my own. The topic today is about bear market bets, investor conviction during the bear market. And one thing I'll say at the outset is nothing tests your conviction as an investor like a bear market, in particular a crypto bear market. I think they can be particularly deep and sinister. But if you look at this from the right angle, this is actually an opportunity. It's an opportunity to test what you think you know to refine your thesis, your ideas, and to make your bets for the next leg up at a lower price point. So that is the topic for today. Average hole in Sanjay are long time crypto investors.
They're the guests in today's episode. They're also VCs at electric capital. And I ask them, what ideas are they betting on during this bear market? We discuss five of the most pressing questions, I think that are facing all crypto investors during this bear market, including number one, L2 tokens, these are layer two tokens. Are layer two tokens actually worth anything? Are they just worthless governance tokens? We get into that. Secondly, we talk about alternative layer ones. Will the ETH killers make a comeback this cycle or not? Number three, we talk about what a multi chain world really looks like.
Well, we have millions of layer twos and app chains, or will there be a few big winners? Number four, we talk about restaking. Is restaking a big deal? Is it overhyped? Will it pose an existential risk to Ethereum? And number five, Average hole explains why he thinks NFTs are this cycles altcoins and what he actually means by that. Also toward the end of the episode, I get a quick debate with Average hole on the moniness of ether, ether the asset. He disagrees with me on that. I wish we had some more time for that debate, but we touch it briefly. Perhaps in another episode we can get into it in more detail.
Last thing I'll say before we begin, episodes like this are really an opportunity to sharpen your insights as a crypto investor. So you don't have to take these ideas as gospel. Not everything that these investors say will be right. You of course have to wrestle with the ideas. You have to test them. You have to make them your own. And we'll have other bear market episodes with other perspectives. So this certainly isn't the last word. All right, guys, we're gonna get right to the episode on bear market bets with Average hole and Sanjay from lecture capital. But before we do, we want to thank the sponsors that made this episode possible, including our number one recommended crypto exchange Kraken go creating account.
Kraken Pro has easily become the best crypto trading platform in the industry. The place I use to check the charts and the crypto prices, even when I'm not looking to place a trade. On Kraken Pro, you'll have access to advanced charting tools, real-time market data, and lightning fast trade execution. All inside, there's spiffy new modular interface. Kraken's new customizable modular layout. Let's you tailor your trading experience to suit your needs. You can choose your favorite modules and place them anywhere you want in your screen. With Kraken Pro, you have that power, whether you are a seasoned pro or just starting out, join thousands of traders who trust Kraken Pro for their crypto trading needs.
Visit pro.krakken.com to get started today. Mantle, formerly known as BitDow, is the first Dow-led Web3 ecosystem all built on top of Mantle's first core product, the Mantle network. A brand new high performance Ethereum layer too, built using the OP stack, uses eigenlayers' data availability solution instead of the expensive Ethereum layer one. Not only does this reduce Mantle network's gas fees by 80%, but it also reduces gas fee volatility, providing a more stable foundation for Mantle's applications. The Mantle Treasury is one of the biggest Dow-owned treasuries, which is seeding an ecosystem of projects from all around the Web3 space for Mantle.
Mantle already has subcommunities from around Web3 onboard it, like game seven for Web3 gaming, and buy a bit for TVL and liquidity and on-rounds. So if you want to build on the Mantle network, Mantle is offering a grants program that provides milestone-based funding to promising projects that help expand, secure, and decentralize Mantle. If you want to get started working with the first Dow-led Layer 2 ecosystem, check out Mantle at Mantle.xyz and follow them on Twitter at 0xMantle. Arbitrum is accelerating the Web3 landscape with a suite of secure Ethereum scaling solutions. Hundreds of projects have already deployed onto Arbitrum 1 with a flourishing DeFi and NFT ecosystem.
Arbitrum Nova is quickly becoming a Web3 gaming hub and social apps like Reddit are also calling Arbitrum home. And now, Arbitrum Orbit allows you to use Arbitrum's secure scaling technology to build your own Layer 3, giving you access to interoperable, customizable permissions with dedicated throughput. All of these technologies leverage the security and decentralization of Ethereum and provide a builder experience that's intuitive, familiar, and fully EVM compatible. Faster transaction speeds and significantly lower gas fees. Are you a dev, but you don't know solidity? With Stylus, Arbitrum's upcoming proposal for a programming environment upgrade, developers can write smart contracts in Rust, C, C++, and many more coding languages.
Arbitrum empowers you to explore and build without compromise. Visit Arbitrum.io, where you can join the community, dive into the developer docs, bridge your assets, and start building your first app on Arbitrum. Bankless Nation, I'm super excited to introduce you to our next guest, Avicel Garg and Sanjay Shah. Avicel is the founder of Electric Capital and Sanjay is one of the investors at the VC firm called Electric Capital. You probably know them from their incredible annual crypto developer report. They put out every single year. The most recent, I think, was put out in January. I don't miss this.
Measures all of the dev and dev activity across crypto, Avicel and Sanjay, welcome to Bankless. All right. Thanks Ryan, nice to be here. Guys, I'm excited. I'm excited to do this episode here and now in 2023. Summer of 2023, when we are, I think, most listeners would agree, we are in the bear market. And the reason bear markets are interesting to me is they are this fiery crucible where our investment ideas actually get tested, where we actually have an opportunity to kind of rebuild our ideas from the ground up and place our bets accordingly. So I want to ask a few questions today. I've got five teed up and then maybe some bonus questions if we get some time.
And I think these questions are some of the biggest, most important questions that crypto investors are asking during this bear market. So I want to get your thoughts on this, the thesis that you're sort of rebuilding during the bear market and really get a sense for your conviction, what you're convicted on. Is that sound okay? That sounds great. Actually, and maybe before we get in all that, we can do the standard disclaimer of. Oh, yeah, you did not do that. Go for it. This is not financial advice. You should not listen to anything we have to say, basically about anything. That's great. That's great.
Bankless listeners, that goes for me too. All right. Don't listen to us about anything. That's basically what our, none of this is financial advice. And beyond. This is not advice. This is not life advice. Don't listen to us. It's not life advice. I don't know what it is. It's another category. It's just a conversation. Hopefully you're entertained by a conversation amongst friends. Yeah. And so a few of the conversation starters then amongst friends. And some of these questions are, I think controversial questions actually, which is among the most interesting. But I'm going to tee these up the first five to give listeners a sneak peek into where we're headed.
All right. The first question I want to ask is about layer two tokens. Are they worthless governance tokens? Is the question. Second question. Want to get into ETH. Will the ETH killers make a comeback? I'll turn to layer ones. Number three, I want to talk about layer two. Are we going to live in a world where there's millions of chains or just a few big winners? Number four, I want to talk about restaking. Is restaking, eigenlayer, all of these things. Is it a big deal or is it overhyped? Is it an existential crisis for Ethereum? And then number five, NFTs, man. They've been down bad recently.
I don't know if you guys have noticed. But are they dead or will they make a comeback? So that's a little agenda item. We've got some surprise bonus questions for you as well. Why don't we start, though, with the big question. I think part of the reason I wanted to have you both in the podcast, the Sanjay Euro. Fantastic blog post about layer two value capture. And let me just frame the question. And you put it nicely at the beginning of your post. The question is, these layer two tokens worth many billions of dollars, double digit billions of dollars. I don't think triple digit billions of dollars.
Are they actually worth anything right now? Or are they just worthless governance tokens? I'll throw it to either one of you. How do you think about this question right now? Yeah, so to me, the way I sort of think about it is it always comes back to cash flows at the end of the day. So you always have to say, OK, let's look at this from a fundamental perspective and where the cash flow is going to come from. And I think that if you really dig deep into layer two's, there are very concrete sources that they can actually generate sustainable cash flows and sustainable profits. And so there is a real and happy to sort of dig deeper into this.
But just based on that idea alone, there is a real fundamental basis for why these tokens should have values based on cash flows. So there's cash flows, just like a company, just like any type of business. These layer two's actually have a product that they're selling. Yeah, well, I would add one thing to that too is, I mean, this is how we model things internally. It's ultimately cash flows. Because if there's no cash flow coming out of the thing, then what is the thing actually worth? And finance in general or investing in general, that's like the great normalizer. It's like, what are the cash flows coming out and what kind of discount rate do I apply to that cash flow?
And then I can start to normalize across things like bonds and stocks and tokens. And so I would add maybe two or three nuances or dimensions to this. So one, just because a thing has cash flow, it doesn't make it a security. And I think this gets into a lot of nitty-gritty about regulatory. But we firmly believe that there are ways to have cash flows coming out of these without necessarily making them secure. Do you hear that, Gary Gansler? I'm going to be listening right now. It gets into how we test. And there's a lot we could go there. But I think it's important people not necessarily can flate cash flow with security.
Those are actually two different things. Second is I think what's really interesting about crypto is the global nature of it. And so the fact that there's so much capital all over the world that would like to be able to invest in cash flow assets or any sort of asset outside of their local fiat regime. And that's actually for most of the world is not possible. Most of the world can't easily access US equities, for example. And so our belief is there's actually a lot of latent demand all over the world for these kinds of assets that are, sort of, they exist outside any singular jurisdiction. Like, ETH doesn't exist only inside the United States.
And that's actually what makes it so compelling, too, from a global perspective, is that there are a lot of people who otherwise would not be able to participate, that can participate. And I think the framing that you had around conviction at the front end is really compelling. And I think one of the things that we have, we personally have not lost conviction on, but I think in the bull market really gets lost in the noise and tends to come back in the bear markets, is that that's fundamentally what this stuff is about. It's about empowering people all over the world to participate in these open systems.
And that's what's so interesting about the L2s is there are actually ways for people to participate all over the world and capture value in that in a way that doesn't make them security, but still has cash flow. Which I think is actually, that's one of the interesting breakthroughs. But by the way, just the cash flow, but not security. Just a brief segue here. So there are other real world assets like this, right? So I, let's say you have property. I own a house, I'm a landlord. Well, that is a cash flow producing asset that's not security. Not to register that thing with the SEC. There are tons of categories in the real world, pre-crypto that actually fit this mold of being a cash flow, but not a security.
How come people are so hung up on this? Yeah, well, it goes to this general problem of like our regulatory frameworks tend to have been designed with certain use cases in mind. This is why you have to be really careful with where the regulation I think. I spent a lot of time on the regulatory side. I think some people know this in conversations with senators and congresspeople and people at the White House and so on. And there are a lot of good people in the ecosystem that spend a lot of time behind the scenes on this stuff. And I think one of the challenges is that you don't want to bake technology solutions into the regulations.
And every now and then every 50 or 100 years, like a new technology comes along and sort of breaks your mental model of what's possible. I think AI and crypto are going to both face this right now because I'll give you one concrete example, right? Like, this stuff doesn't really exist inside a singular jurisdiction. And that creates a whole new dimension of challenges from a regulator's perspective, right? Like, eth is not a thing that exists only in the United States or only in Europe. It exists across jurisdictionally because it lives in the cloud. So anywhere there's a server, this thing can exist.
And I think that creates a whole host of challenges because our entire regulatory framework has been based around the notion of a nation state with physical geographic boundaries and capital controls. And this really starts to break a lot of that. AI is similar in all sorts of ways, right? Like, shouldn't AI pay taxes? Well, it's kind of unclear. And if it pays taxes, like, who does it pay taxes too? Because it can run on any server anywhere. So like, what does that mean? There's a question even makes sense. And this happens every now and then. And I've talked about this in other contexts, but like, to me, crypto, like the idea of this non-jurisdictional coordination mechanism, the last time we really had to face something like this was with the invention of the joint stock corporation, which was like 1650.
It was like, oh, we can put money together and like take risk without it being my personal property at risk and before that, you just set the cottage industry. And so between like 1650 and 1850, we put a lot of regulations in place around how that should work. And it used to basically be that only kings could give you a charter to go start a corporation. And then around 1850, we said, wait a second, that doesn't make any sense. Anybody should be able to start a corporation. And so we created an entirely new regulation that said, oh, here's what it means to register a company. And that unlocked the industrial revolution.
Like the reason railroads could get built is because a bunch of people could pool capital at a scale that wasn't previously possible from one human. And I actually think a lot of crypto and AI, it's like the first time in 150 or 200 years that we've had to face this kind of a problem, which is like, it just breaks our existing model of regulation in a lot of fundamental ways. And so we need to rethink it. I know that's like super high level meta, but like that to me is what makes this so interesting because the properties of this stuff are like truly internet native in a way that I don't think we've ever experienced before.
And that creates a whole host of challenges downstream. One of which is, well, how can you have a cash flow entity that a bunch of people participate in, that I can track, that I know exactly what my cash flow stream is gonna be, but it's not a security. And I think that's one of the side effects of like this new technology. Well, regulatory is gonna be one of the bonus questions we have fantastic to you. I've been told, but there's a lot to unpack there. There's so much to unpack there, but I don't know this exactly comforting that it took us like about 200 years from a joint stock company for joint stock company to get the regulation in order.
I hope Crypto can happen at a faster way of investor. Yeah, all right. We'll get to that too. But okay, so a bull case, I think what you just gave was sort of the bull case for maybe these capital assets that are tokens in general, right? Which is their global, their digital, their cash flow producing assets that aren't security, anyone with an internet connection can own one of these things. So, well, how cool is that, all right? But so there's another piece here though that I wanna get to is just because there is a token out there that can accrue value, doesn't mean it's sort of set up to actually accrue value.
So this idea of cash flows is like, where does the revenue come from for a layer two? Maybe you guys could give us a refresher, Sanjay. You could give us a refresher on how roll ups make money today. How do they actually generate revenue? Yeah, so today roll ups, so in the future, roll ups I think will generate value from sort of two different streams, MEV and transaction fees. Today, roll ups don't actually generate any revenues from MEV because the sequencers are centralized. So optimism, arbitrum, and of course they don't wanna be extractive to their users. So they've decided, hey, we're not going to extract any MEV.
So they've just turned it off basically. Yeah, they just, as a centralized sequencer, they could charge some fees for MEV and for transaction fees, but they've just set it to zero right now, is that correct? For MEV and then, of course, yes, and then of course they are charging transaction fees. And so that's the primary source of revenue today for layer twos. So that's today and in the future, so I think there's a, so let's speak to both sides of those. So for the MEV, that can be turned on in the future. And I think that could be a sizable form of revenue for roll ups. And so in the blog post, they sort of put a little bit of a framing around this.
So they're sort of like good MEV and bad MEV. And good MEV, sort of harmful MEV is anything that's sort of harmful to the user. So let's say a sandwich attack, et cetera. And bad MEV is, yeah, exactly. Thank you for bringing this up. And then sort of bad MEV is, good MEV is something that actually helps the ecosystem. So for example, an arbitrage helps keep prices consistent across different DEXs. And so sort of my view is that as far as MEV, I think the harmful sort of MEV will ultimately be sort of either mitigated or rebated back to users. And sort of like, why do I say that? Well, one, businesses, there's not like a line I have in the post, which is typically businesses don't really gain adoption by screwing their users.
That's not a good strategy. And so I think it's the same way with blockchains. And so there's sort of incentive at every layer of this, whether it's GMAT wallets, whether you're talking about the roll ups themselves, whether you're talking about shared sequinsers. Like, hey, let's figure out a way to get rid of these sandwich attacks. Let's figure out a way to sort of mitigate this harmful sort of form of MEV. And I think right now there's like 12 different projects that are working on trying to do this. And so I think with so many people sort of working on this, I feel fairly good that we're going to figure out a way to sort of combat that.
Okay, so let's break this down a little bit for people and spend some more time on kind of definitions and make sure we've got everyone with us today. So you think that the sources of revenue for roll ups, the way they make money are two form MEV and transaction fees. And then we just went into MEV for a second, defining MEV for a second. This is basically block ordering. There's some value for anyone who is sending a transaction or doing something on chain on one of these layer twos and getting their transaction in first. And it turns out that we can sell that value. And layer twos, indeed, can in the future start selling that value.
I believe that's what you're saying here. And there are two forms of not the selling of that value, but I guess maybe the effect of blockchain ordering, maybe you can find better words for this. One is there's harmful blockchain ordering. So there's the calling that harmful MEV. And then there's good MEV. And what you're saying, Sanjay, is you think that the harmful MEV will actually be mitigated over time. So that the layer two designers will effectively try to minimize that as much as possible and or rebate it to users. So if you're a user in Metamask, you're creating a transaction. There's some future world where you actually receive some of the proceeds of that transaction in the form of a rebate.
You get kind of your MEV money back. That's what you think will happen to harmful. The good MEV, you think these layer twos will effectively take in the form of revenue under that MEV category. Is that right so far? Would you add to that definition, those definitions? And also, can you give us some examples of harmful versus good MEV? Yeah, so that's exactly right. I think you phrased it really well. So let me give you an example of harmful MEV is like a sandwich attack. So for example, you want to go and you want to buy an asset on a deck. Let's say ether, someone sees your trade incoming. They're going to actually put in in order to trade that asset ahead of you.
And then your order will actually push the price up. And then on the back of that, they'll actually sell what they bought. So they've just made money sort of risk-free. And you as a user, you've actually gotten to execute at a worse price. So that's probably the most sort of common problem in an example of harmful MEV. And then as far as sort of good or beneficial MEV, one example is just arbitrage. So if you have different dexes on a rollup or across rollups, you obviously want prices to be the same or consistent across the different dexes. That's good for users. Liquidations is another example of beneficial MEV.
You want people to get liquidated as soon as possible, which helps the protocol's not a crew bad debt. And so the faster that can happen, the better. And so that's another example of beneficial MEV. One good example is how I see this playing out. There's a new shared sequencer radius that has come out in the last couple months. And they're implementing this thing where they're using encryption to actually block this harmful MEV. So using encryption, nobody can see what your transactions are. And then after some sort of transactions are finalized, then they're actually running an auction to allow people to backrun these transactions.
And so they're essentially blocking the front running of transactions, which allow for the sandwiches, et cetera. And they're running an auction to sort of optimize the backrunning of the transactions, which allow for arbitrage and liquidations, et cetera. So it's sort of in line with sort of this framework that I've laid out. So how does this MEV? We'll talk about transaction fees as the other pocket of revenue in a second. But just for MEV, in general, right now, you said the sequencers are kind of centralized, haven't turned the dials on, so no one's actually charging for this in the future they could.
But how does this get to value in the token? If you're a token holder of something like the arbitrum token or the optimism token or something like that, how do you experience that value? One way in the Ethereum ecosystem that holders experience value is through EIP 1559, the burn effectively, where supply is kind of destroyed. In the world of capital assets, I mentioned the property that I might hold, and I might get a rental income from that. So my asset actually generates income that I can take home. It's not quite a dividend, but it's sort of a dividend, I suppose. Can an arbor optimism or layer two token holder expect to sort of receive this as a share of income or is it burnt or is there some other mechanism that play here to actually link the token itself to this value creation mechanism?
Yeah, I think any of the above, and I think different layer twos are going to experiment with different models. So you could burn it, you could give it as a dividend, you could invest it in retroactive public goods, which, essentially, will then increase the value on protocol further. How I expected to happen in practice is through some sort of like auction mechanism. And so right now you have a centralized sequencer, and so it's sort of up to the goodwill, I guess, of the sequencer to sort of give that back. But I think, and how much to give back, inevitably, I think that once you have certain auctions, just like you have at the proposal layer on Ethereum where builders are actually competing to get proposals to choose or block.
In the same way, I think you'll have people competing to build a block, and then that value will then go back to the protocol, and they can choose what to do with it, what they want. Okay, so you think MEV will be a big source of revenue here. Let's talk about transaction fees, which is the second kind of source of revenue of value creation, value capture here. So how do layer twos today charge transaction fees inside of their ecosystems? I'm gonna pull up a screen just to kind of start this conversation. I believe that was in your blog post. This is Arbitram annualized revenue. If you've never looked at kind of Arbitram from this perspective, I encourage you.
This is the way that investors should and are looking at this. This is, I believe, a set of metrics from May of this year. And this says Arbitram annualized revenue. If you annualize Arbitram's revenue in May of 2023, this isn't a bear market, mind you. We get 115 million in annualized revenue. Revenue being the term for kind of the top line, right? So this is not necessarily profit. We could talk about the costs of the Arbitram business. If that's a capital asset, that's what we wanna call it. But revenue, $115 million, and I believe this is from transaction fees. Can you explain this a little bit, Sanjay?
Yeah, I mean, it's very impressive. Yeah, essentially currently, later to sort of break down their costs into sort of like an L1 cost. So what are they paying to Ethereum for essentially the data availability? And then there's sort of an L2 operational cost, essentially. How much are they, you know, how much is it? Does it cost to actually sort of like operate the chain, et cetera? And then there's like an L2 gas fee. And so, which essentially makes up the transaction fee. So that's how sort of the revenue model works today. I, and it's sort of broken down into these three chunks. I think the way that the, it can be broken down in the future can sort of be different.
Like it doesn't actually have to, you know, be on a menu where here's your L1 cost, here's your L2 operating cost, here's your L2 fee. But I think those basic components are gonna always be baked in there. And are they essentially, it's the way to look at this like a, a layer two is essentially a value added reseller of a layer one block space? Is that what they're doing? Is there, they're basically taking like something like Arbitram or Optimism is basically taking the Ethereum block space and creating another layer of feature functionality value on top of it and then charging for that in the form of transaction fees and then also MEV.
Is that what's going on here? Yeah, I think that's a reasonable way to think about it. I think one of like the sort of like, you know, mental models that I wanted to at least put out there with this is that, you know, I think some people think like, okay, EIP484 for for is coming block space is gonna drastically reduce. And so as a result of that, okay, Arbitram's revenues look great right now, but that's just because L1 data fees are super expensive right now and once L1 data fees plummet, like hey, Arbitram's revenues are gonna, you know, go down the toilet because, you know, maybe they're just making a 10 or 15% margin on top of what the L1 is charging.
And sort of the model that we can get into it that I at least sort of propose here is, hey, that's not actually true because there's actually some block space that's actually valuable on the L2 and they don't actually have to price it at just like a fixed percentage above what the L1 block space is. So as an example, like if you, you know, getting coffee at Starbucks, just cause Starbucks 10 cents to make it, that doesn't mean you're paying 10 cents or 11 cents. You could be paying $5 or $10 for a cup of coffee. And so I think it's gonna essentially be sort of similar in the L2 block space. I think you guys have a pretty famous saying, right, which is block chain cell block space, right?
And I think it's very similar to L2 block space as well. Yeah, I think a lot of people don't understand how later twos actually make money and how much value is created here. And I reach out, I wonder, from your perspective, what this sort of looks like, right? So there are multiple analogs that we could use. Yes, we have said on bankless many times it's a mental model block chain cell blocks. That's the thing that they do just cause it's a simplification. I feel like so many times the crypto investing world to get stuck on narrative value, meme value, and it's helpful to view this as almost like a company, right?
So what is Apple sell? They sell iPhones, right? How do they create value? Well, they take all of these commodity type components and they create an incredible user experience and a phone that you can use and apps that give you value to everyday life and they're able to charge $1,000 per phone, right? It's kind of amazing. And so looking at these layer 2s, almost as kind of like companies, and they're not securities, but maybe from the perspective of there is something that all of them are trying to sell, they're trying to make their block spaces valuable as possible. And to Sanjay's point, they can charge whatever they want for that, whatever the market is willing to pay.
And so that's one model of looking at it. The other way to look at it, though, is as an emerging economy. It's almost like the nation-state type model, right? And if another analog we've used is think of like a province in a nation or like a state in the United States, the state of California. And it is kind of, there's a federal government, that federal government in the L2 world is maybe Ethereum, has its own currency, but then there's a state's economy, the state of California, you can create values. So you're almost valuing it as an emerging economy. It makes sense of this, how do you think of L2s?
Yeah, so two thoughts on this. So I think your second point around thinking of these things as digital countries and states is exactly right. That's very much the conclusion I've come to. We wrote a paper about Ethereum as a digital country a few years ago, and sort of as a little bit of a detour into that for a second, I think that's actually what the, like if you think about what the world wants and kind of what happened after Russia invaded Ukraine and the US flipped on sanctions, what the world kind of realized was that the economy of the world, international trade, commodities trade, pricing, all this stuff runs on US dollars, but ultimately the US can shut you out of that economy if they feel like it.
And that's really scary, right? If you're Turkey, if you're India, if you're Brazil. And so what the world actually wants is a US dollar denominated system, because they don't necessarily want to be beholden to the Chinese government either, and denominate things and see and why, and you're seeing a little bit of a move towards that. And so what the world actually wants is a US dollar denominated system that the US government cannot unilaterally shut them out of. That's effectively credibly neutral and sufficiently decentralized, such that you can get the bad actors but that you can't be shut out unilaterally.
And that's effectively what Ethereum is becoming. And so our sort of like long term view on this is Ethereum is slowly evolving into this third space, which is not the US space, which is not the Chinese space, but is this sort of credibly neutral decentralized space. And I think your analogy of if that's kind of like the federal government, in a sense, or that's the country, then L2 start to behave a little bit like states. And if you think about how a state like California operates and what they're able to do, in effect, why does California have such high taxes? Or why can Apple charge a 30% tax?
It's because they have pricing power. So the general term for this, of it not collapsing to the commodity price of the compute power on the thing, which is I think a thing that a lot of technologists both miss, like they think of these things as purely computational networks, and therefore they don't have pricing power. But there are forms of pricing power that states and companies have, which are really interesting, right? So like for example, California, essentially having a monopoly on useful coastline, on the west coast, like all these beautiful beaches and big sir, and it's just, it's a beautiful place to live, means that real estate is tremendously valuable.
And as a result, there's this like source of income, which they effectively have a monopoly on, which allows them to do a lot of other things. Or there's brand value, right? Like why do people pay for, you know, an eight dollar cup of coffee, right? Why do they go to blue bottle or whatever? Yeah, it tastes better, but like part of it is the experience, part of it is the brand, part of it is the ethos, you're holding the cup, you're being seen by other people. So there are these like emotional motivators, or there are network effects, right? And so like Silicon Valley is a network effect around capital, which has been written about many, many times.
Entrepreneurs will generally relocate to where they can get great capital. And there's so much tribal knowledge about how to build companies in Silicon Valley that it's not a surprise that sort of that network effect continues to perpetuate. Crypto being a really interesting counter example we could talk about. And if you look at the L2s, they kind of have all of these, right? There are network effects in terms of like D5, all being on arbitrum right now. Or there are technical modes, right? Like actually building an iPhone is really hard. And so you look at something like StarCware and that you might argue that that's a real technical mode.
There's just not that many people that could build a ZK based system or ZK sync. You look at brand effects. And so like if all the cool kids are in one place for the NFTs, then like that's where all the NFTs will be. That's where the creators will wanna be. So they're gonna be these different forms of pricing power that these networks have on top of the L1 that's gonna allow them to have some spread there, I think. And I actually really, I hadn't heard somebody talk about it as a state on top of the federal government, but I think that's a great analogy. And I think states like California or New York or Washington DC where you have this combination of like network effects because of the industries that are there, the company towns is effectively the brand value.
It's like if you wanna do anything in government, you have to be in DC, like that's where the network is, that's where the flow is. And that gives them pricing power. And I think L2s will behave very similarly. That's super fascinating. And just maybe to extend this a little bit further, this line of thought because what you're saying kind of brought some thoughts up in my mind. So I think what you're saying is that layer 2s are a bit more like California than they are like Apple. But where that, I think that mental model falls apart for people is there's no way right now to invest in California tokens.
Like how would I even, how would I invest in the California economy, right? Yeah. Well, if you had a token that represented that or some sort of asset that represented that, it would probably be the value of California's tax base, I guess. Well, there's another example. Yeah, go ahead. Like Alaska, right? So you get an oil rebate. So like the state has all this oil revenue coming in and they just refund it via tax revenue back to the city. Right, yeah. Like I wonder if there was some sort of a composed asset that gave you an index of all of California's property assets, let's say, for instance.
And then also the S&P5, like the number of public trade companies that were all based in California, something like that, that could almost give you a proxy for what an investment in California would look like. But we don't really have that at the state level or even at the nation state level. So I guess the best proxy for investing in the United States is probably buying the S&P or something. There's not a NASDAQ or something like that, right? But you sure wouldn't want to buy the dollar. But so maybe that's what we're saying. You guys are saying these L2 tokens are. They're effectively, they're an investment in this emerging network state.
Let's call it. And just like if you live in California and they're not providing the services, it's not worth it, network effects aren't worth it. You can defect and you can move to Texas, for example. Well, all of the different layer twos are competitive with one another. And they have to provide the network effect, the services or the population, the applications on top will kind of defect. I think the analog kind of holds. So is this making sense? Or are we stretching the metaphor too far? Well, it's a little bit stretched in. I mean, it's one of the things that's generally tricky about technology, early stage technology is like we have to reason through analogy and schemorphically.
Like if you remember the original iPhone apps, we're all kind of like leather and paper. And it's because that's like how we were used to when it came to touch. And so we're like, well, if it's a flat screen, let's make it look like paper and leather, but that just like doesn't make any sense actually. So I think it is a little bit stretched, but I think analogs are still illustrative. They can still teach you things. So I do think there's a lot too that. I think the idea that there are network effects, the idea that there is a notion of brand, there's community, there's cultural alignment. And so like by choosing to live in San Francisco, you're making sort of like a cultural statement about your values as much as you are physically where you choose to live.
So I think a lot of those drivers will exist in altos as well. And then I think you're pointing around, what is the ease of switching? Given that all of these things are EVM right now on top of Ethereum. And the ease of sort of moving things around, I think at least in the early days, it's sort of like if I could effectively pick up and move to Nevada or Texas or Florida without having to uproot my entire family and like, you know, would I do that? I think a lot of people would actually consider doing that. So like lowering the difference I guess here with the altos is like the switching cost is significantly lowered as the infrastructure gets better and better.
Like I can just use optimism or arbitrum as an end user or if I as a developer can just move my code because it's all EVM and it basically works the same way everywhere. Then the switching costs are significantly lower than they are in the physical world. So to answer this first question and the question I think people, investors are rightly asking during the bear market are layer two tokens valuable. You guys are saying, hell yeah, they're valuable. Just look at the kind of the on-chain revenue profile and in fact, for those saying that like it's impossible to value different crypto assets, I think you guys are saying you can actually value this as a capital asset and forecast revenue and profit over time and plug in the numbers and excel a spreadsheet and it'll give you the valuations that we're saying here.
That's, well, one caveat there is I think everybody should do their own math on this and figure out whether or not that is actually true but the general statement I think definitely holds which is you can absolutely make an assertion here that there can be cash flow coming out of this thing. There is some sort of pricing power. You can figure out what your assumptions might be for that with a call star for running the network and there's certainly a spreadsheet model that you could produce here that would produce like positive cash flow out to token holders over some period of time. That doesn't necessarily make it a great investment.
That doesn't necessarily mean that people should do it. It's extremely risky. But that's roughly, that's generally how we think about these things is like, you know, if there isn't ultimately going to be cash flow coming out of it, the market and the long term will not value the thing. Anything to add to it. The only thing I'd add is I think they'll be valuable but the ones that will be the most valuable are the ones that can generate sort of like a unique state that cannot easily, you cannot easily just move to another roll up and get it. So if you think of, you know, if you have a roll up that's sort of like the DeFi hub, let's say the New York of L2s, right?
You can't just go to Texas or you just can't go to Chicago and sort of get that same liquidity, et cetera. And so any of the roll ups I can actually build this sort of unique state that cannot easily be replicated are going to be the most valuable. Well, then I think that brings me to the second question that I highlighted early, which is another question for the bear market right now where everyone's trying to test their thesis. Forecast the future of L2s for us, there are two paths and you know, I'll give them to you in their most exaggerated forms that we can discuss the one side of the spectrum versus the other.
There could be a world where we live in with millions of different chains and layer 2s or there could be a world we live in where there are a few winners with kind of big network of facts, right? So which of those is the most likely outcome? Like one is a world where we might have tons of app chains. There aren't any really, like too many generalized chains. I don't know if you could put some more color on that, but the other is a world where there's a few big mega chains that kind of win like DeFi and FT use cases, they all sort of accrue to a couple of mega chains. We're sort of seeing that I think on the main chain layer one side of things, we'll get into that discussion next.
So what do you think? Millions of L2s or a few big winners, Vichel, what do you think about this? Yeah, this is actually probably one of the things I've most changed my mind on over the last two years. You know, I mistakenly assumed there would be some sort of power law the way I think the L1s will have a power law where ethos really big, maybe the Cosmos ecosystem can be big, Solana might be big and you're gonna have a long tail. And I mistakenly assumed that the L2s will work that way and the sort of belief I've come to is actually there're gonna be millions of L2s. There will be a relatively small number of generalized ones that are permissionless and open, but what I think optimism really did by open sourcing the OP stack was they made it really easy for people to spin up their own instance of optimism while still being a part of the ecosystem.
So you look at things like base and as a result, I think what you're gonna get is not just the truly open permissionless ones, you'll get everything from that to ecosystem chain. So I think there are probably gonna be things that are like an NFT ecosystem chain. So to use sun jasonology, maybe that's like the LA of Ethereum, right? And there will be like the KYC chain. We have to KYC to get in. Maybe base wants to do that with Coinbase. Yeah, I'm not implying anything. I don't have any inside information or everything, but you could certainly imagine Coinbase taking that killer asset that they have with 100 million KYC to count and saying, hey, you can actually trade in a KYC way here and that looks like TradFied New York.
And so you'll get sort of these ecosystem ones all the way out to the other extreme of like the only user of that L2 is a specific application. So you essentially get an app chain, like the Cosmos style, you know, like I have a game and I want to control the sequinsers and I want to have those be hyper centralized to lower gas fees and I just want interoperability with Ethel1 and so I'm using all the same standards, like the same NFT standards. But I actually want to control it. And I think you'll get the full spectrum there. And so if you believe there could be millions of applications then certainly all of a sudden you end up with millions of app chains.
Well, let's maybe test that assumption. Millions of applications. What are all these applications going to be? I somewhat wonder now, I guess this is a reflection in the bear market. It felt like during the bull market, we didn't have, we had too many apps not enough block space, right? Like blocks, you know, chain fees were incredibly high. Now it feels like we're moving towards the opposite world. We have all this black space, but we don't have enough apps to actually use it. Are you like, why do you think we're going to have all of these applications? Why millions of chains? How come every, like, how come all of these applications need their own chain?
Well, I think there's sort of a couple of things to pull on there. So, you know, one, it's sort of more abstractly, it's interesting when you look at the history of available computational power, whether that's CPU or RAM or hard drive space, whatever, it just gets sucked up. Like as soon as you make it available, some developer finds a way to use it. So it's like the infamous Bill Gates quote that like 64K RAM is enough for everybody, and you just don't need more than that. And here we really said that. Yeah, something out of, I don't know what the exact quote was, we should look it up in the late 80s.
And it's probably misattributed in some form. I'm sure these are very smart guys. So he probably meant it in a different context or something. But the observation is like, you know, my, like how much faster are computers today? And like how much slower do they feel than the 1990s? There's a great video that was circulating a couple of weeks ago. This is about like Windows NT or Windows 3.1. And you look at like the boot times and like how quickly apps come up and it's instant and it's like slower today, even though computers are 10 million times more powerful. And so there's still like this property of computational markets, which is like as soon as you give developers some computational resource, somebody will find a way to use it and break through somehow.
And so you're just sort of perpetually sucking up all the available capacity. And so I suspect that will be the case here. If I had to guess what is the initial set of use cases there, I think it's probably going to be games. And I think often you see that in a lot of early platforms. And, you know, in some sense, DeFi and NFT are games. They're actually just real world, real money games being played across the entire internet. Rather than being played in like some executable that you run on your computer, it's being played on Discord and Telegram and Twitter. And in the real world at events, and like that they're just games that we're playing, they're social games that we're playing.
So I'm almost collapsing down to the idea of like how much of real life is actually a game. I don't know, I just like, it's all a game that we're all playing kind of thousand, thousand percent. It's some alien simulator somewhere. Yeah. Well, that's a, that's a part of the question too. But no, I mean, if you look at like a lot of primate behavior, I mean, this is the thing too, is right? Like look at the world's richest man, Bernard Arnold, right? He runs LVMH. Like what does that guy do? That guy is basically like makes money by selling you a $300 leather item for $3,000 because you're playing a social game.
Like what you're doing is converting capital capital into social capital. And it turns out billions of humans want to play that game. And that's just a totally socially constructed game that all these people need to play. And hence, this is the richest man in the world. But it's hard, I think for a lot of engineers and a lot of tried fight like rational, you know, you like look at finance analysis or economic analysis and like the center actor and all of that is always like a rational adult, you know? That's like somebody who only behaves 100% rational. But that's like a disconnect with reality.
That's just like not how things work in reality. And so like we're all playing game. That's like 80% of life is playing games. I mean, I just wanted to hone in on that because if anyone hears of each of listening to this and it's like, well, just games, so well, that's kind of a small use case. You're talking about like hundreds of billions. It's like, no, like expand your definition of what a game actually is. You know, a game can kind of encompass everything. It can be all of the use cases. Like, you know, what is buying, you know, property being a real estate agent in Manhattan is that is that is that a game to acquire more and more kind of real estate tokens?
I also find that like the best training I've had for crypto is actually playing video games. I've talked to many crypto investors who said something like similar. So like just playing RPG games and, you know, RTS games, all of these things as they were growing up. I mean, like now what do we do as crypto investors? Well, we just try to level up and collect coins like that. Okay, that's true. That's the thousand percent correct. Sanjay, what do you think about this question? Millions of L2s are big winners. Yeah, so I think to think about that question, you first have to maybe like drill down into what do you get by being on sort of a general purpose chain versus like what is the advantage of being on a specific L2?
And so when you're on a general purpose chain, like arbitrum optimism, you get that asynchronous composability. That's like key, especially for DeFi. But there are actually like really big advantages to being on an app specific chain. You lose the interoperability. Well, not like total interoperability, but you lose sort of that asynchronous composability. Yeah. Well, you do get like per block composabilities where you lose the two. Yeah, exactly. Flashline. Yeah, you retain interoperability. Yeah, but you get like a bunch of customizability. You get sort of like if you don't want your fee markets to be intertwined with the fee markets of all these other chains, you get that sort of isolation.
And then you also get some level of protection from like what the L2 would do. So like if you're an app on arbitrum, for example, and an arbitrum does some governance thing, that you just think is like a terrible decision, you're kind of stuck because you're an arbitrum. Now like you're your dapp on arbitrum. Whereas if you're sort of like this app specific chain, you can actually then say, hey, you know, I don't really agree with this. Like maybe I'm going to move to optimism, right? And so you get a lot more flexibility that way. So there are these like, I think clear sort of orthogonal trade offs.
And I think some lend itself to like the asynchronous composability means that there will be a set, especially like DeFi, that will be on the general purpose roll up. And then there will be a lot of app specific L2s because I do think that there are some clear advantages that a good mix of both is sort of what I would think. One pushback against the millions of chains idea here is that maybe there's some UX power law here, network effect, right? And I'm just looking at today's world. And today's world, if you're on arbitrum, you want to get to polygon or optimism or something like that. There's a work involves, right?
Like go a bridge and then you're somewhere else and like the experience is different, instead of applications, like it very much feels like moving like to a new neighborhood, a new town. I mean, there's some friction in the UX. Do you think all of it that gets abstracted away in the millions of chains? Because it feels like it would almost have to. The security issues, the UX issues would have to be abstracted away from the user in order for millions of chains to actually work. Yeah, I think that's a great point. I think the UX today is really tough for users. But I mean, already you can see sort of the buddings of how this would get abstracted away.
You have a lot of stuff around shared sequencers, which would help increase interoperability. You've seen the polygon 2.0 vision that was laid out recently. You've seen the ZK stack recently vision by ZK sync, which allows for a lot more interoperability. So already I think we're getting sort of maybe a little snippet or a little preview of how some of these things might get resolved. And I think over time I do think that they will get significantly better. OK, but to push back on that, though, what those look like is a bunch of architectures for different superchains. And still, if I'm going to go from polygon to arbitrum, it feels like that could be an argument more for a world with a small number of big winners that all kind of make the UX very good inside of their stack.
But it becomes very difficult if you're moving from polygon 2.0 to an optimism or some other stack. Yeah, well, I think it depends on standards. So if there are some standards that are set across different chains, and I think you could have similar interoperability across different changes, as long as two chains are sort of speaking the same language. And that's how right now we have all these chains that are all sort of like speaking different languages, I would say. And if you look at sort of how the internet works, right? Everybody's on this like sort of TCBIP protocol. And so I do think that there could be a world in which these sort of superchains can also interoperate with each other.
And the shared sequinsers are sort of independent of these superchains. That's sort of just a separate concept for multiple chains that are all speaking different languages can kind of go there and sort of interoperate. Yeah, I know a couple of things. A couple of threads to pull on. So yeah, I think folks like Espresso building shared sequinsers, I think there's IBC as a bridge tech and messaging tech. Like I think a lot of the infrastructure significantly reduces the friction to sort of moving between different things. And it becomes effectively standard. And so then you can sort of move assets around.
I think there's a lot of work to do on the user experience. This is something we talk about a lot internally. And we've tweeted about and written about is like, this is probably the big bottleneck now. It's actually the thing like at this point, if I think about going back to your highest order question about conviction, what is the thing that I worry about the most? Like why won't crypto work? Like why will the L2s not work? Well, with Ethereum not become this third digital country and so on and so on. I think the biggest risk is actually user experience, which is like so many people can get exposed to this technology because everybody has a phone.
There's now five billion phones in the world that if the guardrails aren't in place yet and there's too much friction and people come in and they just lose their wallet keys or like, you know, something bad happens that you could actually poison the well. And so I actually like being able to get to a billion people overnight is as much a curse as a gift. And so I actually think if crypto were to not succeed, like what's the bear case overall for all of this stuff, just not working, I think it's actually the UX burns people. Like it's so like our ability to get people to try this thing is so far ahead of our ability to build good user experiences right now that we could actually burn a lot of people.
And so I actually, it's funny. Like I basically have the opposite. I have like the inverse concern as you run, which is like, I don't worry that the UX is going to like prevent people from doing it. I actually think it's like too easy to get into the into the flow of this stuff. And then you can get caught and you can lose your assets. And then that just burns you and then you don't want to touch this stuff. And then we kind of have to cycle out an entire seven or 10 years of people to like forget the pain of having lost their money because the UX was bad. Well, I mean, case in point is 2022, wasn't it?
I would argue a lot of people used centralized lending platforms because I wasn't supposed to defy it because the UX is better. It was easier to use Celsius or BlockFi, you know, than it was maybe to go get your Metamask and do a bankless wallet and go use something like like Ave or Compound. And so and now what's that generation they're paying for it? And they some of them have left crypto with a very bad taste in their mouth as a result. Yeah, that's right. Or you look at NFTs and like I think fortunately NFTs did not get big enough this cycle. I think there's a chance that they get really big in the next cycle and they come back.
But my concern would be that if like it's too easy to get into the NFT world and it's too easy for money to flow in there that actually people will get burnt before we have the guard rules in place, which is the other side of UX. Like it has to basically it has to be easy to use this stuff. But we also have to put like the safety measures in place so that people can't just lose all their money and lose the private keys and need a password recovery and you need like you need to have ways where to be decentralized that the centralized guys can't just like be opaque about what they're doing and take a bunch of risk and lose all your money.
There's just like I actually worry about the other side of it is if it's too easy to use, a lot of people may may just get burned. So there's like there's a there's a really difficult tension here. Like you want this stuff to be easy to use, but in very particular ways and still let people protect themselves. And I actually think if if this stuff becomes a little too easy to use that that people may just get burned like it. I kind of I kind of like the sort of contrarian take I have a little bit is like I kind of hope we have a long bear market because the longer what's like the like like three years right we're already eight months into it.
But the reason is that like if you start to your point right if you look at the quality of experiences that are being produced today like every six to 12 months like the user experiences get better and better and it gets easier and easier to use this stuff without totally burning yourself. So like Coinbase's MPC mobile wall is like actually pretty good or like institutional custody is way better than it was even 18 months ago. You have companies like Fortify. And so I think if we give people like another 18 months or 24 months to actually make these experiences good and safe, then we have a shot at not burning people and poisoning the well.
So I'm actually kind of like I kind of secretly hope that like we just have this like sideways burn for like another two years so that like we can build really good experience. So that when I mean you look at chat GPT it went zero to a hundred million people basically overnight like in 30 days right and so like I'm not I'm not at all worried about whether or not people show up here because there's so much utility and so I just want it to be like really good and easy and safe when people actually show up when we go to like as investors selfishly I mean valuations are a bit lower than they were before right so it's kind of a nice time.
It's always be skeptical of anything if he says so that's fair point. Metamask has something new introducing Metamask Portfolio. Metamask Portfolio is the best way to view your crypto portfolio from a holistic level. See everything across all the chains all at once. In your portfolio Metamask will report the aggregate value of all the assets in your Metamask wallets and even the other wallets you import to but Metamask Portfolio isn't just a passive portfolio viewer it is a place to do all of the money verbs that make defy so powerful you can buy swap bridge and stake your crypto assets. So not only is Metamask the easiest place to see your wallets in aggregate but it's also a powerful battle station for all of your defy moves.
So go check out your Metamask Portfolio because it's waiting for you to open it up. Check it out at portfolio dot Metamask dot IO. Introducing polygon 2.0 the value layer for the internet for too long the limitations of blockchains have held back app development and stifled user adoption. The internet allows anyone to create an exchange information what's missing is a value layer that lets anyone exchange store and program value. That's where polygon 2.0 comes in polygon labs has unveiled a series of innovations that will radically alter the polygon ecosystem and Web3 as a whole. By leveraging groundbreaking ZK innovations such as polygon ZK EVM the next iteration of the best in class plonky to proving system and a first of its kind ZK powered interoperability layer polygon 2.
0 will give users and devs unlimited scalability and unified liquidity. Right now there is a polygon improvement proposal regarding a potential ZK powered upgrade of polygon proof of stake. If approved polygon proof of stake would become a layer to ZK EVM validity. So make your voice heard on this proposal by joining the polygon discord today. You have a chance to help the polygon community give the internet the value layer it deserves. Since you brought it up a virtual NFTs and burning people our NFTs dead is the question here and I think a lot of people are wondering in the bear market and I think your answer this is probably no because I snuck a look at one of your your tweets prior to recording this episode and eventually said this NFTs are this cycles altcoins.
We're seeing liquidity flea and rotate out as the excess comes to an end just as with ICOs the ADIQ belief is actually right just too early. Ethereum, Solana, Layer 2s, Define, Stablecoins all came out of the excesses of the ICO boom it just took a few more years. NFTs are this cycles altcoins so I think you're saying they're not dead you're bullish. Get into that a little bit more. Why are NFTs I guess maybe underhyped at this point in time are oversold? Yeah they and it's not a comment about any particular NFT collection or anything like that it's more the concept of NFTs which it goes back to this idea of if you look at LVMH you look at Nike you look at Rolex like a lot of the world is about non-fungible items right like your purse or your watch or your shoes and they're special to you because they're imbued with value because you as a human imbue emotion into these physical objects and so if you look at just you know like 20 years ago there were these graphs that used to circulate that was like hey here's how little time is spent on newspapers but look at all the ad dollars on newspapers and here's how much look at all this time being spent on the internet and look at how little money is being spent on online ads and you're like okay well that just has to reconcile like over the next decade that's just gonna fix itself the ad dollars are gonna go where where the people are and I kind of look at digital goods the same way just like look look at us right now it's like you don't know what pants I'm wearing you don't know what shoes I'm wearing you don't know what watch I have on I just like even know if you guys are wearing pants to be honest so you know like why why would you spend $500 on shoes or $1,000 on shoes or you know $500 on pants it like the whole like yes there's gonna be some segment of those people that appreciate the craftsmanship like that menswear guy on twitter that somehow is like always in my feed right like that guy is gonna continue to buy great clothing no matter what but a lot of people do it the bulk of people out argue do it because of the social signaling and NFTs are it turns out way more effective at accomplishing that end goal so the internet the internet flex is much more important than the real life flex than thousand percent and and it's not only is it more important but it's it's actually from a utilitarian perspective it's more efficient so so think about the math here right like let's say you're gonna buy a two hundred thousand dollar uh patek grand complications and it's on your wrist how many people are gonna see it on your wrist like maybe 10,000 people over the life of you home having that watch are gonna see it and spot it and say oh that's a two hundred thousand dollar watch and so that's effectively twenty dollar CPA like per conversion of person that sees it and now you get their social capital now it's a very particular group of people and you might want that group's approval but it's effectively twenty dollar CPA if instead you buy and spend two hundred thousand dollars on digital items whether that's skins and fortnight or NFTs on your twitter profile pfp's or whatever else um a million people could see it on your twitter profile no problem right you have one tweet that goes viral and and a million people will see that tweet and they see your picture so it's effectively 20 cents in impression uh so it's literally a hundred x more efficient to accrue social capital using digital goods versus physical goods and one of the really interesting properties with with digital markets tends to be that because of the friction being lowered so significantly relative to physical the market sizes tend to be much much much larger um and so you know if you look at um take uber versus taxis right like the big knock against uber at the series a was well if the entire taxi industry is only worth ten billion how could you possibly be worth more than ten billion and here we are and you have uber and lift and dd and grab and like all these companies all over the world that an aggregate are worth more than a hundred billion um and so my opinion actually is that if you think LVMH and Nike and Rolex and you know these are Tiffany like these are monster brands in the offline world that actually by opening up brand and opening up luxury and opening up social signaling digitally like that could actually be 10x bigger um and so what we now have is like shared infrastructure to be able to do that and so like every game is going to use NFTs because it's just better to use them it's just like interoperable with every game now so you can recruit other people to come in um every brand is going to do NFT drops because it's actually a hundred percent gross margin like Nike just minted 20 million dollars for doing like some digital and then they did this fortnite thing where you can like see Nike apparel and and fortnite LVMH is going to do this it's just like lower cost of production of the item and people still willing willing to pay whatever they pay for it because the brand value um and you now have a direct pipe to your fans so like Nike or LVMH or Tiffany know who their biggest fans are their most loyal fan base because they're seeing them and have a direct pipe to them they can actually talk to them directly and there's now an advertising network that gets built on the back of that right so I can look on chain and I can figure out exactly which people are actually the super fans of Nike or the super fans of Rolex and if I want to do a collab or if I want to try to recruit those people instead of me going to Facebook and paying the ad network to acquire another mobile app install for a game or for for a key type of customer I can just incentivize that customer I can just say hey look if you show up and you prove to me that you've spent this much money on these types of goods or that you've spent you know you bought 10 pairs of Nike goods or you spend a much of time in roblox and you can cryptographically prove that to me I'll just give you something in my in my ecosystem I'll just give you a free digital good worth the thousand dollars and now you're actually paying the end user um to come user thing so you start playing this out and so it's not just like that it's more utilitarian at a as a starting point but like the interoperability and then the network that you build around everybody doing this on top of one standard and one network itself creates five to tenx more value in my opinion until like the downstream effect of this is just like all of this digital good spending I think just moves digital over the next 10 to 20 years and the beneficiaries is the whole ecosystem actually because you can now build a network effect around all these people doing it on top of one standard you don't think we've burnt out too many people in 2022 with kind of the the UX mistakes of buying an NFT you thought was going to moon and then the you know the company or the centralized product kind of exit scams you or the like the asset that you thought was going to go to the moon you decreases 99% in value you don't think we burnt people out now it goes it's very very to in my mind I was having this conversation with the friend of mine over the weekend and that's what spark that tweet was it the realization was that's basically how I see us were right if you go back to the ICO boom of 2017 or all of these ideas like DeFi is going to be awesome and you're going to be able to do real world assets on chain and like we'll have stable coins and they'll be super fast and settle quickly and like we'll have L2s and we had all these ideas and they were basically directionally correct like all the ideas were right but it really taps into that human psychology there's this adage to make bill gates to sort of offset my my bill gates for the origin of bill I mean yes there so we got to suck this right but yeah to inflate is he go a little bit um he has this quote that's like you know people dramatically underestimate what's possible in two years or sorry dramatically overestimate what's possible in two years and dramatically underestimate what's possible in 10 years and that's kind of what happened here right like over the last two years everybody dramatically overestimated what would happen with NFTs and it just it takes a decade to build a brand it takes a decade to build a real community but I think we're going to look back in 10 years and there's going to be a some really big winners that come out of this cycle um or or even earlier you look at something like crypto punks um and and it takes 10 years to have that Lindy kick in um but I think the next wave of stuff might actually be the wave of stuff that works because it it's sort of from the ground up uses NFT infrastructure in the right ways and does the right things and incentivizes the right behavior having learned from just this graveyard of mistakes that have been made over the last two to three years in NFTs this is where the art maybe the science don't know which you lean on more in your investing uh it comes in though is because of the things that you mentioned let's say somebody's bullish on the category of NFTs and what you mentioned I mean there's a hundred different uh startup ideas there and you know thousands of different assets that you could purchase and so many of them will end up in the in the graveyard because there there are so many different ways this NFTs space could emerge so let's say I'm bullish NFTs right okay so what do I go buy do I go buy the zookey collection do I go buy an index of the top you know 25 NFTs right now do I go invest in in picks and shovel infrastructure do I go look at um maybe this goes with you know established brands like the Nike to the world this comes from the established brands leaking to NFTs so do I look at their assets or or companies that are making like where do I do all of the above so how do you distill that I'm bullish on NFTs into navigating the idea of maze of what specifically to invest in because you don't want to end up in the graveyard do you yeah so obviously not financial advice and so kind of without saying here's what people should do or go do I think there's a meta framework for this which is you can only really generate value as an investor if you have a deeper understanding of what's happening than anybody else like effectively alpha in a market comes from depth of understanding if you can see the actual value of the thing and there's a disconnect between perception and reality right so if the world thinks something is worth x but it turns out to be worth 2x and there's that that's a delta between perception and reality and so what you really have to do is an investor across all of the categories that you mentioned picks and shovels if you're an early stage equity investor um you know NFTs themselves if you're more like an art curator what you really have to do is understand the thing better than anybody else you have to have some perspective on it that says actually reality is different than perception and that's fundamentally what you're betting on and there are a million different ways to do that like art curators and collectors you know can be wildly successful people who you know invest in picks and shovels can be wildly successful people who you know maybe you say hey I think there are certain brands that are really going to benefit from this and so like I should just go buy stock like public stock and companies and you know you looked at if if you really understood AI five or seven years ago maybe you just bought up a bunch of Nvidia when it was you know down big time and and that's how you sort of played that market so there are a lot of different ways to do it um but I think the crux of it is like you have to more deeply understand what's happening in some subsector than anybody else and be able to identify that delta between perception and if you don't your bitch is better off with an index or something like this like or just or just finding the place in the world where you do have that you know like there are a lot of ways to make money right and it's it's one of the things that we've had to learn um just as early stage investors is like or you know Stan Druckenmiller is a public market investor Warren Buffett they sort of have their own versions of this and you know it's I think Stan calls it a fat pitch like really the way you make money is like you find a thing where you're like I'm pretty sure I understand that better than anybody else and it's just such a good setup it's it's kind of like a heads I win tails I win you know it's like no matter what happens like you're gonna do great um and there are enough such opportunities in the world that you don't have to be like funneling into stuff it's actually like patience patience is a virtue here yeah and all investing I'll tell you my worst fear and maybe this should be every investors worst fear though is you see what you just saw let's say you see the opportunity in crypto right and then and then within that you see the opportunity in NFTs you guess what you us we people listening this may be among the 1% less than 1% of people who see the opportunities uh in NFTs the NFT category in the world doesn't my worst fear as an investor is I see that opportunity and I make all the bad best net category and lose all my money or I don't make the return right so it's like you imagine NFTs are big we all kind of make that prediction but then you you make a series of bad choices in the NFT segment and you don't end up uh accruing the rewards of that you end up losing anyway is there a way to prevent that from a meta perspective as an investor I think you have to I actually think probably most people should not be looking at NFTs or early stage crypto as an investment I think if you look at it as an investment like you're probably going to lose this is why like a Warren Buffett or or you know Vanguard people will tell you to just buy the index because it turns out most people are not good investors um it's a really hard thing and and and speaking well like if everybody were a great investor especially with really high risk highly volatile assets then everybody would everybody would be rich right like that and it turns out it's really hard to make money doing these things and so actually I think most people should not be looking at this as an investment buy for the art like buy for the community buy it because it brings you joy um size those things so that like if you lose a little bit of money because you bought the art and you supported some artists that you really believe in then you don't feel bad about it you're like well the whole point was to support like I'm I um I'm subscribed to like some patreon's and it's like I've forgotten how much it is but it's just because they're like these people creating great content I'm just like yeah five bucks a month let me just chip in and I don't think about it right um that's I think the right lines that most most people should have on it um and if somebody does want to become an investor I think it it one of the things you have to learn is that discipline of like how do you size your positions appropriately how do you not take undue risk like rule number one is don't blow up um and if you if you're taking so much risk that you're gonna implode then like you won't be here and that's again it's not financial advice like I actually think most people should not investing in this stuff I think most people should not be trying to think of it as an investment um because you're probably gonna lose your money um but if you're gonna go down that path size it appropriately and it goes back to this idea of like what do you like great startups and great early stage investing and great early market intuition and I think you know NFTs are very early market it's based on some secret like you have to understand something that's true that other people haven't figured out that's true and if you don't know what that secret is then like you don't know the secret and if you don't know that insight then you probably shouldn't be investing like the the um poker equivalent of that is like if you're if you look around the table you don't know who the sucker is then you're the sucker right like that's the poker equivalent and so you better you better understand the market better than anybody else and have some deep insight and in order to be able to invest and make money I think the other component right into your question is when do you invest in these things so you know we're sort of very early into NFTs and as an individual investor you could I mean I understand it's like it's a crapshoot at this point like what's like it are all these NFTs can they you know are I gonna pick the right NFTs or not but you could wait you know a few years and then maybe what emerges is sort of like a blue chip layer of sort of NFTs like if you just think about cryptos in general right like you as an investor on the sideline you can say well I'm an investor like Bitcoin and ETH and like those can be like my holdings and so like maybe in like three or four years the equivalent will emerge in NFTs so maybe the answer is you you just hold off for some amount of time until some sort of reliable index or this is also this is also a good observation to like if a lot of times people really underestimate the size of the market and so if things work out the market will likely be 10x to 100x bigger than then you could have imagined and again it goes back to this idea of patience it's like buying Bitcoin in 2012 was easy holding on for 10 years was hard right like the patience is the hard part or a lot of times when you see a lot of activity happening like not investing is the hard part until you really have conviction on thing and I suspect if this stuff works the markets are going to be much much much larger it's just like the internet nobody could have imagined you go back to your 2000 and you're like hey in 20 years all of the world's largest companies are going to be internet companies would have been sort of unthinkable like Apple is going to be a $3 trillion company when Steve Jobs comes back in the late 90s and it's like a failing enterprise that's going to go bankrupt like these are just like unthinkable statements right so patience I think is like the key thing and patience oriented towards how do you understand more deeply what's happening with the user with the business with the market than anybody else and only then should you really be thinking about investing and I think that's usually the failing like most people don't actually deeply understand the things that they're investing in and therefore they end up losing money because they just don't deeply understand what what actually makes money in the space speaking of patience and testing conviction I think the the alternative the the non-aetherian layer one community is definitely going through that right now right this kind of he's like slana the cosmos token avalanche these sorts of things that had a massive run up and now some of them are kind of in existential crisis mode down bad as we would say in crypto and this brings kind of another question I wanted to ask you guys is the future do you think there will be a contender for aetherians thrown in the future will the aetherian killers make a comeback as they have in previous cycles and what about this broader question of a modular versus monolithic chains bankless listeners will know of course aetherian has taken the the modular route with scaling via layer two's there are other ecosystems that have taken kind of a modular route they're a little bit different maybe cosmos is sort of one of those more modular and then there's this question of monolithic chains of which you know slana has maybe most famously gone in that direction so what do you think about all of these questions alternative layer ones eith killers are we going to have you you said that layer ones are more more of a network effect game than layer two's you sure about that so let's dig into this a virtual what do you think um so okay so zooming back on modular versus monolithic you know I think um sundry touched on this earlier the fundamental tradeoff is do you want real-time composability or not like intra block composability and the L1's like slana give you this property and sort of you know as soon as you start moving to l2s and you start fragmenting liquidity and execution you lose that now you retain interoperability and so there are a lot of use cases that are you know you need the interoperability but you don't need real-time composability but I think a lot of monolithic people would argue that that that real-time composability is like the one of the killer features of these blockchain architectures and so why would you give that up you should really lean into that and then the fundamental tradeoff you have to make is around decentralization and so you know like the monolithic argument which I I actually do think is compelling for certain kinds of use cases is can you be sufficiently decentralized to still be decentralized and censorship resistant um even at state level attack kind of um censorship resistant while retaining composability and that's like that's an interesting design exercise like in your design of blockchain that does that and I think that that's compelling because I think there are use cases that will want that set of tradeoffs um and so I think it's really good from an ecosystem perspective for both of these things to exist and and the search space to include both and I think if you step back even even to like hundred thousand foot view I mean like part of the idea here right like the whole reason this space was invented um in the first place was that um centralization is not healthy and if we only end up with if we end up with only ethereum I think we have failed as a space because that's not resilient at the ecosystem level like Ethereum can be resilient but what if there are like critical day zero issues with like clients or with the EVM or you know like um you know I just I worry that if we don't have multiple approaches that we're not actually as an ecosystem being resilient and I think that um if we think of it as a non-zero thing which is like well they can both be successful they can both be a hundred X bigger than they are today I think that's the right mindset on it so I'm a huge fan of everybody trying to do both of these things or like the fact that salana doesn't do EVM I think that's awesome like I think that's actually really important um to have a totally different technology tree that we're exploring to like use a use a video game term right like I think that's really really important for this space to survive and be thriving 10 years from now um and I don't think of them as like I don't think of salana as an eth color I think they both coexist and they just solve different problems with different ecosystems and I think that's awesome um and so our our approach has been they make different technical trade-offs applications and ecosystems will emerge they take advantage of those different trade-offs and they should both coexist um and they'll just solve different problems and they can both be they can both be ridiculously successful ecosystems and coexist one thesis that bankless has had for for a while then I'm wondering your take on whether you agree or disagree with this actually is um that if you are a layer one you're sort of competing at the the money game basically where you want need your asset to a true monetary premium um which is basically like selling block space isn't enough if all of your alternative competitors are also selling valuable block space in creating revenue that way and it also valued as a money because if your value doesn't money just the um the kind of the network of fact game the liquidity game the economic security game is tilted so much in your favor that you you end up winning anyway what do you think about that do you think uh layer ones are all playing for the bitcoin ether more recently game of monetary premium or do you disagree with that yeah I disagree with that and I'm curious what's on Jay thinks but yeah I disagree with that and and you know without experiment here is like well if you look at amazon's market cap like what percentage of amazon's market cap is due to AWS um or what percentage of microsoft's market cap like if azure were standalone business what would that be worth and I think it turns out that computational networks are extremely valuable um at scale like if all of Wall Street and you know all of tradfi were running on one platform um that was 100% interoperable with each other so every bank could immediately calculate how much leverage they have and you know you could know exactly who owns which uh mortgages and mortgage back securities and that were all on one platform that platform would be tremendously valuable now there's this this actually goes back I think to the l2 question which is like what kind of pricing power does that else l1 need to have on top that platform existing in one place and I think if you think of it like a country there are real network effects and there's real brand value and there's real you know the ability for a new application to launch and acquire a bunch of customers because the infrastructure exists there right there's accounting tools and NPC wallets and um you know distribution platforms for people to find users like those things are real network effects that create pricing power and so I think these things if they're able to be successful will be computational networks with pricing power on top of it like I don't think they collapse to zero because I think network effects give you pricing power the same way that apple or facebook have it so I don't think you have to have you don't have to become based money like I don't think you have to compete with the US dollar I don't think you have to compete with bitcoin all in is pricing power above the cost of running the network and and that can you know that that looks a little bit more like a company right like apple has pricing power or facebook has power because of the network effects and I think that's actually how these things will will eventually operate and then you'll have cash flow coming off of them like I think these things will extract some premium on top of the cost of running the the computation and the cost of the block space and um that the token holders can benefit from that would you value the bitcoin network and uh the bitcoin asset based on cash flow or do you ascribe a kind of a monetary premium to that is that like a special case yes a special case a special case I think that the the the reason that bitcoin is a special case is that it's it behaves a little bit more like a commodity right so it's a fixed supply like the idea is for it to move slowly and not evolve rather than a computational network that needs to sort of evolve as a platform to acquire keep acquiring developers like bitcoin is ordinals is kind of an elegant hack um but it's not a developer platform um that's to really not what bitcoin is designed for bitcoin is designed to be more or less static and evolve very very slowly so I think it behaves a lot more like a base money or a lot more like a like a gold or commodity so I think you just have to value that differently but I think that's a special case like I think you comparing bitcoin against Ethereum um or you know these other computational networks I think it's sort of it doesn't really lean into what makes bitcoin special and unique that's fascinating I I feel like we could have an entire podcast just kind of debating that or getting into that discussion a little bit more I tend to think that the lines are a bit more blurry here between like money versus um pricing power of you know network effect and they may in at the end of the day be one in the same but um yeah it's you know definitely maybe maybe one way to put it is like you know I think there's this very um binary person people have which is like either you have a monetary premium or you're going to collapse to the price to the price of the running the computational network and I think this is actually a legacy of sort of um early bitcoin maximalism like circa 2015 and there are some papers that were circulating around that time that people basically framed Ethereum as that and they're like we're like look if you don't have a monetary premium you're you're token will just collapse to the price of running the network because it's a computational commodity but I think there's this thing in the middle which is if you have cash flow and you have pricing power due to network effects then you don't have to be base money to get a monetary premium and you're not going to collapse to the price of of running the computational network and I think the open question is how significant is that does that mean that you get a 15% margin on top of it does that mean you can charge 2x what it costs you to run it can you you know like where on that spectrum are you I think is the open question I think if Ethereum is a great proof point for this actually I think I agree with that like there's a spectrum of of moneyness and um mimetic value and um I do think that's more complicated to say something is competing as money or it's not it's you know reality probably all assets are competing as a money I mean you just think of S&P 500 in stock is that competing as a uh store of value well sort of is sort of is my property sort of is as well um I want one last question for you and then we'll kind of draw this to a close um so restaking let's get to that really quick is it a big deal or is this overhyped we've had some panels lately lately about the uh the existential uh I guess uh threat of staking and some of the theorem researchers actually think restaking poses some existential threats in the same way that MEV is but let's take those um issues separately so first of all restaking is it a big deal or is it overhyped at this point and then what do you think about the existential risk to underlying blockchains that um that have restaking on top of them um yeah I mean I think I think restaking is is a big deal right because it's it's really hard to bootstrap a trust network that's it's just one of the hardest things there is to do um and we've we've just seen that that lots of chains have difficulty doing that and so if you can take the existing trust of a theorem and um and reuse that I think that's a big deal now I maybe have sort of a a little bit of a nuanced opinion here which is that roll ups um so I think maybe what we'll play out is I think there's this sort of envisioning of like thousands of protocols maybe using these restaking layers and I think that it may not actually play out like that but I think it may be a few really big important protocols using these restaking layers so as opposed to thousands of chains being restaked it might be like 12 really important ones and so like what are the things that could really benefit from restaking um a decentralized sequencing layer a DA layer bridging so there's a few like really really core use cases and if you think about these use cases they're massive right like a scalable DA layer that's a massive use case a scalable sequencer layer that can basically support you know thousands of roll ups that's a huge use case so I'm sort of I'm super bullish on restaking as a means to provide decentralization decentralization beyond Ethereum to the broader ecosystem do I think it's going to um and it's going to be massively impactful do I think there's going to be thousands of protocols running on these restaking layers that I probably think will not happen and we should call out we're we're investors in eigenlayer and espresso so the premiere restaking protocol and the premiere shared sequencer protocol just again back to this idea of like don't listen to VCs like VCs VCs we're going to talk their book and so you know always keep that in mind well I imagine you guys are also investors at some level in Ethereum which brings up the question of um existential risk to Ethereum for staking of each one what do you think of of that I know you listen to the the recent panel that was great I can drink and yeah and Tam and yeah it was really really good that was a great conversation um and as you rum did a great job too and I think yeah you know kind of two thoughts I agree with Sanjay you know I think it's it's really probably a handful of use cases that are really critical for restaking um you know there's a question of do those start to get so large that you know that they start to post some sort of existential risk to Ethereum like you know from that shared security cross the answer is maybe I mean it's kind of like TBD I think it kind of goes back to you know people tend to think either people tend to have these sort of binary approaches to thinking about this stuff and I think there's like a messy middle a lot of times and so I think there's a world where restaking gets big enough that it's interesting and useful but not so big that it's essentially a threat um I also think that ecosystems tend to be pretty resilient and so I suspect if it starts to get into that kind of like existential risk territory um we'll figure it out like the Ethereum ecosystem has been remarkably resilient about these kinds of existential risks and like fixing them um and so I have a lot of faith in in generally the ecosystem and the researchers and the developers and the community to sort of evolve and figure it out and so we start getting to that point I suspect there will be you know like I think um camera if it was just under Tim but somebody was talking about like how would the protocol need to evolve to account for this potentially and so you know that might be a solution or there may be things that um that you could do um kind of at the protocol level above Ethereum protocol so I think um if you look at liquid staking tokens um you know people talk about existential risk if it's all sort of going through one protocol and I think there there are simple ways to mitigate that right there's multiple protocols and you move your eth between multiple protocols um or you do some self-staking right I think there are ways to like mitigate that and there's enough well-informed actors kind of at that base layer that basically the right things will happen so um it feels to me like an inevitability and if we get into sort of existential territory if we if we're truly it's so successful and so useful that you get into existential territory I suspect the ecosystem will figure it out and for bank listeners if you're you're newer here in crypto we tend to get an existential risk every six months or so that we think it's going to be the downfall of Ethereum or crypto in general yeah and uh you were still here we're still here well that's that's the thing is that's why I have so much faith in the community it's just like it's turned out there so many places where it could have died for the last six years or you know if you look at Bitcoin 12 years and it keeps going and so it's it's giving me a lot of faith in the people the developer community like it's just so amazing that people figure it out and solve the problems when we do something else I think you have to understand it at a deep level in order to understand the space is that crypto is much more anti fragile than I think the the layman or the person looking at it from above things I remember someone once told me that the reason they're not investing in Bitcoin is because software has bugs I'm a software engineer and so what are the chances there's going to be some bug that expands the supply of Bitcoin to like you know hundreds of millions rather than 21 million right what's interesting about this is as you dig in deeper you realize well that's actually not what secures the the Bitcoin network it's actually a social protocol like there's a layer zero here that would just fork that out and would continue running and so if that's a reason not to invest I think that's a mistaken reason but you see that the surface level well guys this has been so much fun I want to close this out with a question related to the mood in crypto right now and this is a tweet I put out and I don't know if you agree with it or disagree and I'm not entirely sure how I feel about it but I'll give you a sense for the mood here crypto feels lost right now all right that idea crypto is lost right now and how can it find its way was the question I posed do you think which crypto is lost this 2023 bear market and if you do how can it find its way out of each all what do you think no I think we know exactly what to do just like L ones need to scale we need L2s to work we need like modular blockchains to work we need stablecoins and defi like you know there's 120 billion dollars to stablecoins and 40 billion sitting in tv all and eath protocols that's about the 20th largest bank in the United States which is very real you know I tweeted a while ago that eBay at IPO was doing about 340 million dollars of GMV NFTs do more than that today but what you started is what gross merchandise volume so like total value of the goods that they'd sold so eBay 96 wanted IPO'd had done about 340 million you know Bitcoin ordinals probably do more than that today in the depths of the bear market and so like sentiment is very very low and so it feels it can feel bad but when I look at the numbers it's just it's actually it's like working I mean it's amazing if you go back to 2017 there's all of this stuff that was theoretical like hey one day Ethereum is going to move to proof of stake and and you know we'll have L2s and we'll have stablecoins we'll have defi and like we'll have these brands coming in and like we might have an ETF and like all this stuff and it was all theoretical ZK you know ZK Bruce will work one day and like you know all this stuff NPC will happen one day and like we'll have institutional custody and like yada yada right and then like governments will be pro crypto and all of that stuff was theoretical and basically five or six years later it's basically all true which just goes back to this adage of like people way overestimate what's possible in two years and they dramatically underestimate what's possible in 10 years and so like roughly halfway through that 10-year cycle we're like basically where you'd expect which is all the tech is now real it's now it's just a question of like how quickly does it get to people so I definitely feel like it's a we're down on sentiment but like on fundamentals it's I've never been more optimistic it's just like everything that was vaporware five years ago is actually real now yeah I actually on Twitter saw this video it was like with Jeff Bezos and he was talking about the 2000 dot com bus and it was like you know I think don't call me in the numbers but I think it was like Amazon stock went from like 131 to 6 but then he was there like sitting looking at his metrics and I was like everything was up right and it was like scratching his head yeah and you know it's the same thing I mean he's just look at the tremendous progress that's happened in crypto like just even on the ZK side right it was like a year ago nobody thought like the ZK chains were like four years away and now we have ZK chains and you know we have now frameworks for ZK interoperability and the OP stack and so we just have so much progress that's been made that at least for me it's hard to be bearish long term people don't understand how fundamentally different this bear market is then 2019 in 2020 where I would argue we had much more of an existential where's our market fit type of conversation than we have now guys this has been a lot of fun I think we got to the answer this question of what you guys are convicted on by exploring these different questions and in your thesis so for each so thank you so much for joining us on bank lists it's been a lot of fun thanks we're having us thanks Ryan action items for you bank list nation there's a post that we refer to in the episodes called understanding roll up value accrual written by one of our guests Sanjay also could you to read the lecture capital developer report they put this out every year it's always fantastic read the builders keep building folks that's what the the bottom line of that developer report is it continues to go up risks and disclaimers got to end with this another time I need to tell you none of this has been financial advice never is on bank lists crypto is risky you could lose what you put in but we are headed west this is the frontier it's not for everyone but we're glad you're with us on the bank list journey thanks a lot you