Today on the Pod, we're discussing Why VCs Suck. And who better to answer that question than VCs themselves?
We're joined by Nick Tomaino and Richard Chen of 1Confirmation to discuss the role of VCs in crypto, the outlook on the markets, and how retail should prepare for the next cycle.
------ ✨ DEBRIEF | Unpacking the episode: https://www.bankless.com/debrief-1conf ----- 🏹 Airdrop Hunter is launching TOMORROW https://bankless.cc/HuntersGonnaHunt ------ BANKLESS SPONSOR TOOLS:
🐙KRAKEN | MOST-TRUSTED CRYPTO EXCHANGE https://k.xyz/bankless-pod-q2
🦊METAMASK PORTFOLIO | MANAGE YOUR WEB3 EVERYTHING https://bankless.cc/MetaMask
⚖️ ARBITRUM | SCALING ETHEREUM https://bankless.cc/Arbitrum
🛞MANTLE | MODULAR LAYER 2 NETWORK https://bankless.cc/Mantle
👾POLYGON | VALUE LAYER OF THE INTERNET https://polygon.technology/roadmap
🗣️TOKU | CRYPTO EMPLOYMENT SOLUTION https://bankless.cc/Toku ----- Timestamps
0:00 Intro 6:00 Nick and Richard from 1Conf 7:20 The Price Cycle 11:50 The Signal Cycle 15:55 Tourist vs Purist 20:00 Why Do VCs Suck? 28:15 Raising vs Returning 32:40 How Transparency Shapes Crypto 38:30 VC Report Card 43:45 Holding Retail Accountable 48:30 Advice for Retail 51:15 How to Not Be Exit Liquidity 59:00 Should We End VCs? 1:03:10 How 1Conf Works 1:07:40 Crypto Native VCs 1:12:30 Looking to the Next Cycle 1:17:08 Prediction Markets 1:20:00 Crypto is Ready 1:24:00 Actually Using Crypto 1:28:20 L2s vs Alt L1s
----- Resources
Nick Tomaino https://twitter.com/NTmoney?s=20
Richard Chen https://twitter.com/richardchen39?s=20
1confirmation https://www.1confirmation.com/
Richard's Article https://showerthoughts.substack.com/p/thoughts-on-the-current-crypto-vc
----- Not financial or tax advice. See our investment disclosures here: https://www.bankless.com/disclosures
No summary for this episode yet.
In five years, crypto prices are going to be much higher and crypto products are going to be widely used. But we've been in a video game the past five years where you have these NPCs that are trying to suck us in and kill us. And you have SBF who's shilling mainstream crypto narrative or you have Three Arrows Capital shilling alt L1s. You have Doquan shilling stable coins. You have all of these NPCs. And if you can manage your greed, you can stick to authentic products that are pushing the space forward in new ways, then you're going to be well positioned and you're going to win the game. Welcome to Bankless, where we explore the frontier of internet money and internet finance.
This is how to get started, how to get better, how to frontrun the opportunity. This is Ryan Sean Adams. I'm here with David Hoffman, and we're here to help you become more bankless. the topic today, why VCs suck, with some people who would actually know. We have crypto VCs Nick and Richard from One Confirmation on the episode. You might ask, why would we have VCs on a podcast and then talk about why VCs suck? My answer would be, who better to tell us the shenanigans behind the scenes than actual VCs? The people on the inside. That's right. And I think retail crypto investors and VCs have long had this adversarial relationship.
And this episode gets into the why and how to protect yourself from becoming their exit liquidity. In the final parts of the episode, we talk about the coming bull market. What theme are Nick and Richard most excited about? Are we finally going to build a crypto product that gets used by billions of users? This was just a no BS conversation that I thoroughly enjoyed. David, what was the significance of this episode for you? We'll say this in the intro, but we had Nick and Richard from One Confirmation on two and a half years ago. I think they were some of our first VCs on Bankless way back when in early March 2021.
And that episode was titled Authenticity in Crypto. And it was about a similar subject matter, like how to pierce through narratives. And Richard really took a front and center seat because he was a very early Doom boards analytics wizard before Doom really even blew up into the thing that it is today. And so we were trying to unpack how to pierce through narratives with data, with on-chain data, which is this new tool that we have to navigate the crypto space. And now the crypto industry is two, three years more mature, has two to three years of experience behind it. And there's also been two to three years of adversarial relationships between VCs and retail investors.
And so there's been some shenanigans that have gone on, not just with VCs, but people like hedge funds, like Three Hours Capital and traders. And so I think just going and getting a snapshot halfway through 2023 about how and why these incentives are created that separate retail from both founders and VCs and understanding what are the ingredients that cause this relationship to exist can help equip you, bankless listener, to help navigate this bull market and make sure that when you see some VCs on Twitter that have big prowesses and spin a bunch of narratives, that you actually can start to peer through what they are exactly doing and why they are doing it.
So I think this episode will be helpful for that. Yeah, I can't wait to talk to you more about that during the debrief, which of course is our episode after the episode. Begless citizens can access that now on the premium feed, David. And I forgot. So Richard reminded me of that episode. His was one of the first tweets that actually lit the match for the downfall of SBF. And I have that tweet up. I want to talk to you more about that during the debrief because I remember it well. So we're going to get to the guests in a second. But first, we disclose we had VCs in the podcast. And as with any VC, I think you should expect that they have biases.
A project called Polymarket was mentioned. They're investors. They also mentioned two projects, one called Pimlico, the other called Friends. Both David and I have exposure to both of these, one as angels and the other as Bankless Ventures. We're long-term investors, not journalists. We don't do paid content. A link to all Bankless disclosures is always in the show notes. That's bankless.com slash disclosures. All right, guys, we're going to get right to the episode on why VCs suck. But before we do, we want to thank the sponsors that made this episode possible, including our recommended exchange for 2023, Kraken.
Go set up an account. Kraken Pro has easily become the best crypto trading platform in the industry. The place I use to check the charts and the crypto prices, even when I'm not looking to place a trade. On Kraken Pro, you'll have access to advanced charting tools, real-time market data, and lightning-fast trade execution, all inside their spiffy new modular interface. Kraken's new customizable modular layout lets you tailor your trading experience to suit your needs. Pick and choose your favorite modules and place them anywhere you want in your screen. With Kraken Pro, you have that power. Whether you are a seasoned pro or just starting out, join thousands of traders who trust Kraken Pro for their crypto trading needs.
Visit pro.kraken.com to get started today. Are you a Metamask user? Well, you're listening to Bankless, so of course you are. The wallet you know and love just got a whole lot better. MetaMask Portfolio is the ultimate one-stop shop for all of your crypto needs. It gives you a holistic view of your crypto portfolio across multiple chains and multiple addresses all at once. You can easily view and manage all your coins, tokens, and NFTs in one convenient place just by connecting your wallet. MetaMask Portfolio goes beyond just viewing your portfolio, though. Inside the portfolio, you can do all the incredible money verbs that make DeFi so powerful.
You can buy, swap, bridge, and stake your crypto assets with ease. It's like having a powerful battle station for all your DeFi moves right at your fingertips. So if you're looking to do more in Web3 your way, Metamask Portfolio is the answer. I already know that you have a Metamask wallet, so go check out your Metamask Portfolio. Learn more at metamask.io slash portfolio. Introducing Polygon 2.0, the value layer for the internet. For too long, the limitations of blockchains have held back app development and stifled user adoption. The internet allows anyone to create and exchange information.
What's missing is a value layer that lets anyone exchange, store, and program value. That's where Polygon 2.0 comes in. Polygon Labs has unveiled a series of innovations that will radically alter the Polygon ecosystem and Web3 as a whole. By leveraging groundbreaking ZK innovations, such as Polygon ZK EVM, the next iteration of the best-in-class Plonky 2 proving system, and a first-of-its-kind ZK-powered interoperability layer, Polygon 2.0 will give users and devs unlimited scalability and unified liquidity. Right now, there is a Polygon improvement proposal regarding a potential ZK-powered upgrade of Polygon Proof-of-Stake.
If approved, Polygon Proof-of-Stake would become a Layer 2 ZK-EVM Validium. So make your voice heard on this proposal by joining the Polygon Discord today. You have a chance to help the Polygon community give the internet the value layer it deserves. Bankless Nation, we are excited to introduce you once again to Richard Chen and Nick Tomaino. They are GPs at One Confirmation, a crypto-focused VC fund that's definitely seen a thing or two. If you're a dune board connoisseur, you might know Richard from his work on the many dune boards that he's created. We use them on the weekly roll-ups all of the time, and we've had Nick and Richard back on the show.
I think the last time was March 2021 during the heat of the bull run, and that was hot. Now we're bringing them back full circle to talk about maybe everything we learned or didn't learn. Richard, Nick, it's great to have you back. How are you doing? I'm great. How are you guys? Good. Fantastic. Good. I think I'm good. Actually, I was just talking to David about this recently, and I feel like we are entering the Goldilocks zone of kind of the cycle. So let me just kind of like define that for you guys and see if it resonates or what you think, what part of the cycle we're in. My favorite part of the cycle is when we get through all of the dumpage and kind of like all of the pain.
And we're out on the other side of that and we're heads down building. And you see kind of the fundamentals starting to stack up and kind of no market reaction to those fundamentals. But the builders are building and it's still quiet. So the market hasn't yet gotten stupid. And the tourists have left. The settlers are here. and we're in kind of this like quiet phase of growth. And I feel like that's what August of 2023 is for me. And I don't know, it's just a feeling. What do you guys think? What part of the cycle are we in? Does any of that resonate to you? What do you think, Nick? A little bit, yeah.
I mean, it's always hard. Timing is always hard for me. I mean, that's part of why we started One Confirmation as a venture fund because I have a really high degree of conviction that in five years, you know, crypto is going to be broadly used in the world and crypto prices are going to be much higher and crypto products are going to be widely used. But it's hard to time things. So one of the things I've been thinking about, I feel like we're playing a video game. I think a lot of crypto people, this may resonate with. It's like we've been in a video game the past five years where you have these NPCs that are trying to suck us in and kill us.
Right. And you have SBF who's shilling, you know, mainstream crypto narrative or you have three arrows capital showing alt L ones. You have Doquan showing stable coins. You have all of these NPCs that are trying to suck us in and kill us. And if you can manage your greed, you can stick to authentic products that are pushing the space forward in new ways, then you're going to be well positioned and you're going to win the game. So that's more the feeling I have. And I don't know if all of the NPCs of this cycle are necessarily dead. Most of them are gone and have blown up. which is a good thing.
But I don't know. There's a few still out there. You have to wait until they all die, Nick? Or can we just move on and just realize we're just going to stack some NPCs every cycle? No, I mean, I don't know. It depends how big of a bad guy they are, and sometimes it's hard to know. But I do think you're right. But a lot of these NPCs have been fleshed out, and there is a lot of great stuff happening. And it's not happening on a mainstream level where everyone's paying attention, and that does tend to be a good time to lean in. Richard, what do you think about the cycle? I mean, do you resonate?
If we're playing a video game, what video game are we playing, and what part of the cycle are we in? Well, with the cycle, I'm not a trader myself. So like it's I really can't time markets and know, you know, when the next bull market is going to start if we've bottomed or anything. I mean, the game I always compare crypto to is like RuneScape. Like this was really true when back in 2020, like yield farming started. And there's like so many parallels between like item things you do in RuneScape and things you do in crypto. and there's definitely a strong subculture community in crypto with RuneScape and of course you have bad guys that try to like the the I think the long term in crypto it's important to be lindy and just like survive and like don't fly too close to the sun and feel like you're invincible and like use leverage and blow up you know fall for really aggressive marketing and like people who try to play God on Twitter, just, you know, stay level-headed and don't be too greedy.
I think one part of the cycle that you guys might be more tapped into more than like the price cycle would be the signal cycle. Like Ryan said, like we're in this, I totally resonate with what Ryan's saying. We're in this like Goldilocks zone, Goldilocks era of crypto, where if you were going to leave, you would have left by now. and also the NPCs that Nick was talking about are all like in jail or have fled. And so we're in this like NPC free zone where all the homies are hanging out on crypto Twitter and we're all kind of just like in this calm before the storm. And I'm wondering how that relates, how this Goldilocks era of crypto also relates to the signal that you guys are seeing in startups and what they are building on and what they are focusing on.
And so, like Nick, you said like five-year time horizons, you start to have a pretty strong confidence. And that's what startups are building for. And the noise cycle of startups is also a cycle that exists inside the crypto space. Like people are building things in the top of the bull market that are kind of just make no sense, but only make no sense in hindsight. Where would you see, how would you describe maybe the last two years of noise to signal ratio in the startup landscape? and how do you see where we are now? Nick, I'll throw that one to you. Well, there's always a lot more noise. And this is not necessarily a bad thing.
It's one of the beneficial things about crypto. But there's more noise in a bull market, of course, which begets more noise, which begets more noise, and things go crazy and get too overextended. And so that's happened now five or so times that I've seen since I've been in crypto where you have these extreme bull markets. And during those extreme bull markets, I mean, what we see is a lot of builders, right? But a lot of the builders are only there because of the money and because of the attention. And they don't really understand crypto deeply. We talk about this idea of, we try to invest in things that are at the intersection of purist and tourist.
So the purist is the person that's steeped in historical knowledge and context on the history of the thing, the product. The tourist is someone that doesn't give a shit about all that. They just want to build something that resonates with users. And so in kind of a bull market, you see tourists. And the tourists can look really, especially from a founder perspective, these tourists can look really good on paper. They've worked at Facebook or Google or whatever. They have really compelling resumes. They talk a really good game. But they don't get the history. They don't get the context. They don't get crypto deeply.
um so you know those those came out a lot in the past two years um and what we try to find again is the intersection of purists and tourists and i think now the builders you see more purists right and being too purist also isn't great right because you're never going to connect with a mainstream audience so now i think you know we're seeing a lot of purists which we'd rather we tend to skew a little purists, maybe too much so in some cases. But really, in terms of the signal now, it's a lot of purist founders that really appreciate and understand crypto and are building things for a crypto native audience.
And in those times, what we want to do is make sure that those types of founders have a little Taurus in them, right? Because again, I think to really win big in crypto, you need to be at the intersection of purists and Taurus. And I would argue that's what Ethereum has. That's what Coinbase has. That's what OpenSea has. And those are what we found to be the best investments. That's a really interesting mental model. So the intersection between tourists and purists. By the way, that wasn't original for me. The creator of this idea is a designer who passed away um in the past uh year and a half his name's virgil abloh and he's a very famous um designer that worked for louis vuitton and a bunch of big uh designer brands he had a brand named off-white as well and he that was his mental model that he applied to how he designs clothing and furniture and things like that and i um i got to meet him once um and i basically watched all his youtube content and everything.
And I kind of found that and I was like, wow, that's exactly kind of how we think about crypto investing. So in 2021, you know, kind of peak of the cycle, you saw a lot of tourist types of founders and you wish they would maybe skew a bit more purist, right? And now 2023, where we only have kind of the tourists have left. So we only have what we call in Big List, the settlers, and these would be sort of the purists. And now you're looking for kind of founders and builders who are purists because they're still here. Obviously, everyone who's still here is probably a purist at some level, but they have a bit of tourists in them in that they're not just building for the existing crypto audience.
They're building for like the next cohort that we want to bring into crypto. Is that sort of what you're saying, Nick? Exactly. Exactly. Richard, what would you add to that? What's, you know, what about that mental model speaks to you? Yeah, the terminology I like to use is missionary versus mercenary. And I think a lot of mistakes that VCs made during the bull market is they saw a lot of founders who have really polished resumes. Like they went to Stanford, worked at Google, Facebook, were like a founding engineer at a startup. And then now there's going to be a great executor in crypto. And what ended up happening is like when crypto prices dropped 90 percent, I think the people who are the most talented are also the first people to bail and pivot to AI or something else because they have a lot of opportunities.
So there's nothing that's intrinsically motivating them to stick around in crypto if they could succeed just as well in AI. I think I really saw this a lot with the Solana ecosystem. So I think a lot of VCs made the mistake of like, there's so much talent of developers going to Solana. But from talking to like a lot of these so-called blue chip teams in Solana, it just felt like a lot of mercenary founders that weren't going to stick around when crypto prices crashed. And, you know, fast forward like two years after the all L1, like the peak of the L1 cycle, like we're seeing a lot of big name Solana projects like wind down or pivot.
so I have one other thing to add is like while Silicon Valley archetype founders might be like the worst type of founders to back in bull markets I think they're probably some of the best type of founders to back in bear markets because this is just kind of speaking in generalization like Silicon Valley type founders are generally better executors than kind of your random open source indie hacker from like someplace else in the world. So, you know, in a bear market, when there's sort of an emerging category, say like account abstraction, I think the Silicon Valley founders that do have the conviction to build in the bear market are just going to out-execute, you know, all of their wallet competitors, other projects building in the AA space as one example.
So the same founder archetype can provide two totally different signals to you depending on when you meet them in the market cycle? Yeah, more or less. There's probably more to talk about with respect to kind of investing at this part of the cycle and different founders and teams, but also I'm very interested in themes, right? Because a big question I think for crypto right now is, hey, crypto, are you guys going to stay a niche or are you actually going to expand to like billions of users? And that has always been sort of the promise. Maybe we'll talk about that later. But before we do, I want to talk about this a thing that Richard was talking about for a minute.
It's like mistakes VCs make. So VCs, it turns out, make mistakes. And I think I've seen you, Nick, be actually one of the most critical voices about VCs, specifically in crypto that I've seen, which is interesting because obviously you guys are also VCs, right? So this is VCs talking about why VCs suck. I'll read out a few tweets. All right. Venture capital is the dumb money in crypto. This from January of this year. That was a Nick tweet. NPC VCs are a vibe. So calling VCs NPCs as well. Good at raising money from hollow institutions and deploying it to hot trends. Never distributed cash to LPs.
You go on, but I'll flip to another tweet. Venture capital is the fakest industry on the planet. In what other industry can you be objectively bad at your job, but create narratives that make you appear great to the outside world for years. All right. So some harsh critiques. And before we get into this discussion of like maybe why VCs suck, let me frame this because I bet there are a lot of Bankless listeners out there. And obviously, you know, we don't skew VC. We have VCs that listen to our podcast. But this is basically like we're all crypto investors on the journey, right, in Bankless. So we're talking to like what people might call a bunch of retail users or actually actual crypto users, some of those crypto natives, some of those settlers who stayed.
And they were hearing me read those tweets and they were like probably, you know, standing up and clapping, like standing ovation, like go get them, Nick. Right. Like there's this battle or this dichotomy in crypto that I think is unique. It doesn't so much exist in other venture capital. Right. Because the markets take longer to go public. It does exist to some extent, but not like crypto, where it's sort of like, yeah, the VCs are going to dump on retail. They're going to like invest in an asset, take a position early. Well, unaccredited investors don't get access to it, and then they're going to wait for it to release a token, and then they're going to dump their bags on you.
And this has played out over and over and over again. So I think a lot of bankless listeners are probably standing up and cheering you on. And yet, I think there's some subtlety here, because you guys are obviously VCs. So I imagine you think you're doing the right thing here. But let's talk about this. Why do VCs suck? Why do you seem to hate VCs, Nick? Well, I obviously like some VCs, right? I don't hate all VCs or anything like that. But I do really dislike venture capital culture, particularly in Silicon Valley. And there's a few reasons why. The main one is just the lack of transparency on performance.
So in If you're an NBA shooting guard, right, you are objectively measured on your performance, right? Points per game. How many points did you score in a game? If you're a boxer, you're objectively measured on what's your win-loss record. And venture capital doesn't have that. You know, there is a metric, right, which is distributions to paid-in capital, right? You take LP money and then you return it. And the job of a VC is to make good investments and generate a high distribution to paid capital, DPI. But it's not talked about publicly. So that aspect of venture capital culture, and it's not just crypto, it's broad, I think really I don't like it.
And I don't think it's optimal for people, for the masses, right? It's almost more like an industry like politics, right? Where you're competing on perception rather than how good you are at your actual job. And so that's what leads to things like, you know, thread boys on Twitter or, you know, these massive. What's a thread boy? Oh, I think it explains itself. Yeah. Is that somebody there just publishes a bunch of threads for narrative's sake? And it's not – yeah, what's the implication there? No, you know exactly what it is. I'm sure most of your listeners do. So you have people that are competing for perception to be perceived as really smart or to be perceived as having a lot of money or something like that.
When that shit doesn't really matter. It's not part of the job. The job is to be a good investor and return funds. So I would really love to see a culture where just like, again, NBA, people are talking about DPI and IRR and these metrics that really matter that behind the scenes, the LPs in these funds care about and are looking at. But that's not what's happening now. And I think that's a big part of why, you know, people, I think a lot of people, your listeners and others can sense this and why there is this negative sentiment towards VCs because it does feel very fake. You have these people, you know, shilling fake narratives and, you know, trying to generate a lot of attention when that's actually not the name of the game.
So that's the first thing. The second thing is, and this isn't unique to venture, but there's a lot of greed in crypto, right? Everyone is greedy. That's human nature. But I think in crypto VC as well, there's a lot of short term greed focus. And what I specifically mean by this is you guys know this, probably most of your listeners do also, but as a venture fund, you make money two ways, right? You make it with management fees, and that's just an annual fee that you collect on funds raised, and you make it in carry. And that's a fee at the end when you return the money plus some. You get usually 20% of that, right?
So typical fees for venture is 2 and 20. So Nick, that means if you have a $100 million fund, right, and we're talking management fees of 2%, then $2 million just for having the fund in existence goes to kind of management fees. That's the one part of it. Agnostic of performance. Agnostic of performance. Yep. And then the 20% is the performance kind of bonus. Exactly. Exactly. And so because of these incentive structures, most people are just trying to raise as much money as possible. Right. So the example I like to use is you could have a 50 million dollar fund that is 20 X at the end of 10 years.
Right. That's one of that'd be one of the best venture funds of all time. And in that case, you'll make 200 million. right you'll make uh roughly um you know 190 million my math is right on uh carry and 10 million on management fees and your lps are very happy exactly so that's that's one example the other example is you could have a billion dollar fund um and you're gonna make two and you could lose everything theoretically at the end of the fund, not return anything. And you could still make 200 million. You're collecting a 2% management fee annually. So that's the reason that you see these massive funds, right?
Because it's, it's, you know, if you're just looking at it from a pure, pure, you know, how much money you're going to make perspective. It's the rational thing to do is just to raise as much as possible in a bull market. And so that's why you see so much, you know, capital and so many people that have no business raising billion dollar funds that have them. But doesn't that problem get fixed, Nick? Because if I'm not returning capital to my LPs and they're not going to give me capital the next go around when I try to raise the next fund. But ventures along that'll play out over a 10 year period so you're not 13 years old you're 10 years or more right so you're not um that you know there's there's there's a long feedback cycle for venture to know if you're good or not um so so that's that's a problem right the reason this is a problem this explains ftx right FTX you have prestige brand name funds that are giving FTX hundreds of millions of dollars right why well because they have massive funds they need to deploy it and what they see as big opportunities and they don't do their homework and actually look at what's really going on they look at it as a surface level and say oh SPF is a great executor right he is getting all this media attention.
He's, you know, working with regulators. He's, he's such a good executor. That was, that was the narrative from these funds that gave hundreds of millions to, to SBF and it's soulless greed, right? It's, they have these massive funds, they have huge management fees. And, and they invest in projects that, that make no sense that are either, you know, an aptos or a SUI or something like that, or an FTX. So, so either it's, you know, one of the worst frauds history or it's a um you know a token that um they then dump on retail to to your point um so that's i guess that was long-winded uh richard probably has other thoughts but those are two reasons why um i take issue with a lot of what i see in uh venture capital today yeah richard what do you want to add here yeah i guess on the topic of perception of vcs do you guys remember back in 2021 there was that like spreadsheet uh floating around on crypto twitter of ranking all like the vcs by tiers like oh yeah vaguely i can't remember what the purpose of that especially i think it was around the time of the sushi treasury diversification and then like and like there are all these like vcs like proposing themselves like hey we should uh buy some sushi tokens at a discount like the funniest thing about this spreadsheet is like you know looking back in hindsight two years later is like on every single ranking like alameda three arrows were like always at the top of the list um and like it's like pretty true that like there's a very strong inverse relationship between like who's killing it on crypto twitter and like what their performance like what's actually going on behind the scenes and it's almost like like if you're killing it on twitter it's because you have something bad you want to hide uh so you try to create this narrative that other people think that you're still good when you're trying to mask some shitty stuff that you're doing um so like another thing that happened during the bull market is um you had all these trading shops uh that were starting to invest in like private deals and they probably could like not give two shits about like what the founder is building but like as soon as the founder mentions the word token like they're just like in immediately and it's clear because they want to get into the private sale and then dump as soon as the token's live and there's no lockup.
So with that said, not all VCs are created equal. And a lot of founders mistakenly went with these trading shops when they were fundraising the bull market because it was the easiest money to raise. You could go to Three Arrows, have a 30-minute call, almost no due diligence, as long as you say the word token. And that's the easiest way to fundraise. uh but you know if you're thinking long term obviously that money comes with strings attached and you know a lot of those founders have uh left the space uh because they learned the hard way of you know getting dumped on by their quote-unquote vcs i i know dave is going to jump in with something but can i just say i am loving this real talk all right this is so refreshing to my soul um yes these are the games that are being played aren't they and i want to try and unpack why crypto is conducive to these games.
Like there are some ingredients and really to understand the dynamics about why these things are the way that they are, why the incentive structures are the way that they are, why there's this negative relationship between VC and retail. Because I think we can, the more that we diagnose this stuff, the more we can actually be like, navigate it and understand it. And so I think we're doing a great job and I want to continue it because I think there's one more part of this conversation And Nick, you alluded to it with your Threadboy comment. So much of crypto lives in the future because so much of it is perceived.
It's like we can imagine a crypto future. We can all think about what this might be like in the future. But a lot of crypto is left to be built. And so that leaves a void there for imaginative Threadboys, perhaps, to fill it with something. And I think that's another component as to like why there is this weird toxic relationship between VCs who are quote unquote getting in early at cheap discounts and then the actual manifestation of things in market reality, which is the public markets, which is where retail plays in. So Nick, maybe you can kind of like carry this conversation forward. What are the void of reality in crypto?
Why is it so strong? Like why does crypto allow for some of this stuff to manifest? Well, it's part of what makes it so fun, right? And what makes us all love it and live it every day. It's like everything is happening in the open. Everything's open source. The culture of crypto does tend to be very transparent, where people are talking about stuff online, people are seeing things on chain. um and that's why there's a kind of a culture clash right you have like venture capital which lacks a lot of transparency and you have crypto which actually does tend to be very transparent right and i always i always think like the reason you know it was not um regulators it was not the media that took down ftx right it was crypto it was the crypto community it was actually Richard's tweet on October 13th was one of the things that really kicked it off.
It was a whole bunch of other people as well, obviously. Richard, what did you tweet? Oh, it's about the DCCPA bill. Basically, SPF was lobbying behind the scenes to get the DCCPA bill passed. You whistleblowed it. I was the guy who whistleblowed it. Oh, my God. That's what happened. I'm recalling. Okay, so I saw that tweet. No one talks about this, by the way. Oh, my God. You know why? It's because that whole period of time is a blur. David, that's the tweet I actually saw. It was Richard. Yeah, you messaged me asking for my- And I messaged you about it, Richard. And I was like, are you serious?
So the bill was called DCCPA, right? Digital Commodities Currency Protection House or something like that. Yes. This is what led us to invite SBF and Eric Borges. Yes, it was. So Richard shot out this flare. A whole bunch of people across crypto Twitter, and as far as I knew, were saying that, hey, this bill is okay for crypto. Yeah, it's got some compromises, but like, it's all gonna be okay. And then you shot out this flare and you said, this is not okay. They're talking about banning DeFi front ends in the United States, requiring like AML KYC type of rules, money transmitter laws to apply to DeFi front ends.
That's not okay. And you said something to the effect of like, an SBF is behind this. So I was like, what? That's not squaring with what I'm hearing. And then there was some debate. I think I participated in one of the tweet threads with SBF where he was kind of defending, we were attacking that. That led to a conversation with SBF and Eric Voorhees on the Bankless podcast, a whole debate about this. And it kind of blew up from there. I've forgotten that you were the source of that, Richard. Oh, yeah, it's pretty cool. And again, that's what's great about crypto is like just, you know, some random dude can tweet something, get it out in the open and the community reacts and it leads to a month later, FTX was dead.
It's really crazy. And I think, you know, if in an industry, in a different industry that wasn't as transparent and open, you know, FTX would have gone on to be the JP Morgan of the industry. Right. And we don't know the true history of like how JP Morgan got to be that. But my guess is there's some shady shit there that the public doesn't know about. Right. So to answer your question, this is kind of a tangent, David, I guess. But I mean, the reason why you have so much wild shit happening in crypto and anyone can tweet anything. And it's a really cool, fun thing as well, because the culture of crypto is very, very open and transparent.
But the problem is, you know, everyone has their own bias. There's extreme greed. There's extreme bias. And, you know, what I always say is I don't think it's a problem to be biased if you're biased and right. Right. But the problem is there's a lot of people that are biased and badly wrong and loud about it. And that's where, you know, problems can arise from. But yeah, the kind of open nature of crypto culture, which you guys are obviously very well aware of and also have contributed a great deal to, is one of the best things about it. If you had to give a sweeping grade to crypto VCs as a whole, good ones lumped in with the bad ones and the mid ones in there too, how would you audit crypto VCs?
um maybe like a c oof okay all right why what's what's the main mark what's the main uh curse that crypto vc well i just think i i think what what i've talked about i think it's greed um and i think particularly when it comes to like hurting retail right um like you have a lot of these coins that give 50% plus of their allocation to team investors and then dump on retail. And this is something that I can't believe it's not more talked about, right? But the token distribution is something that everyone investing in a token should be well aware of. Right. So like what's Bitcoin? What percentage of the coin did Satoshi give to team and investors?
Zero, of course. Zero. What was Ethereum? Do you guys know Ethereum? Twelve and a half. I think it was not. That's close. I think it was like 9.9% in terms of team, investors, early developers. Do you know Solana's? It's like 50 something. 62. 62%. Not great. It gets worse than that, I'm sure. I mean, you know, Isn't this also partly a founder project issue as well? As in the founders create a deal that is highly conducive to VCs and the founders VCs have like, okay, you build this project and you give me a large share in it. I'll promote it and then we'll dump on retail, which in like a perfect Harmony world, it would be a three-way partnership between project VC and retail where everyone feels good at the end of it.
But there's like founders can also be severely culpable about this too. A hundred percent. And again, this speaks to the culture clash between venture, Silicon Valley venture capital and crypto, right? Because in traditional Silicon Valley venture capital, founders see the VCs as like the kingmakers, right? So famously, there's massive products that people believe were king made because the VC gave one of them $100 million and not the other or something like that. And so I think a lot of the traditional Silicon Valley founders see these VCs as king makers. And that's why they're willing to do these deals when the truth in crypto is that's not the case at all.
VCs aren't king makers, right? Look at the top three cryptocurrencies, right? Which makes up about 70% of the total market cap of cryptocurrencies. Bitcoin, ETH, and Tether, they didn't raise venture capital, right? There's the idea that VCs are kingmakers in crypto, I think is not accurate. And so that I think is it. But that's the reason that a lot of these founders, I think, do these deals. Would you say it's accurate that retail never had a voice in Silicon Valley Web2 startup founder VC relationships because they were stuck behind the walls of public listings on the NASDAQ and stock exchanges?
and so now there's this conflict because for the first time in crypto retail actually does have a voice and all these players that you know founders and vcs that existed before crypto are now having to deal with this new variable which are the voices of retail who are ultimately the buyers of these tokens and that's where a source of the conflict comes from for the first time in crypto retail actually has a voice and it can make demands and produce market pressures would you say that's a conclusion of this yeah not not just a voice but i mean retail is a direct competitor with the vcs right um so certainly um there's the users uh of these products are owners and have a loud voice and also are direct competitors so i think you know i gave i gave a c grade um i'm obviously biased because we're doing as well because we're doing things a certain way but we the way we uh you know run a venture fund is to really act like users first and foremost um and to be aligned with um you know the users um of products because we are users ourselves um and so we generally aren't participating in any of these big um you know pre-sales and you know we we have made exceptions um which i'm sure people will call out um like world coin is the one that people like to call out the most um but so we do make exceptions but i mean even world coin um do you know how much world coin obviously gets a ton of shit do you know the supply 20 25 25 so um it's not close to you know some of these others can i i want to come back to that idea in a little bit because uh you know another mental model unlock i think for us um You know, the first was like an intersection between purists and tourists.
Another is this idea I've heard you guys talk about the idea of a user capital versus venture capital and how you want to be more on the kind of the user capital side of things, which is like actually using the tools and being kind of informed at that level. I think that's important. But before we do, still on this topic of like VC sharks versus retail. All right. One second. I don't want to let retail completely off the hook here. Okay. And here's kind of why. so the um the expected value the ev game that you're talking about where like founder and vc conspire in kind of a dark room and like they're going to release this token and they construct a narrative and they you know push it out on the world and um they sell it to kind of hapless vc i i want to say yeah like that's the story here except except that that play has been played so many freaking times.
And it seems like retail never learns. And so the reason they keep running the playback is because it works every damn time. And I want it to stop working. I want retail to wake up and be like, huh, why am I buying the latest Threadboy shill of this new token? And guess what? They're going to do it again next cycle. And we know they're going to do it again next cycle. And that's why venture capitalists and founders come up with these new tokens and these new pushes where they keep 50% because it works. It's because they see a high expected value return. If it stopped working, then it would no longer be profitable.
First of all, let me just say, I'm totally, I totally, I know we're slamming VCs here and like as well, we should, we're slamming nerves. What role does retail play in this, in actually being smart? Should we expect them to be smarter than this? Or is this just what retail is? You're right. I mean, you're 100% right. And I think the great thing about a free market is that you can get hurt and then hopefully learn. And I do think as time has gone on, people are getting smarter, but obviously not as smart as quickly as we'd hope. And I think you're absolutely right. It's going to happen again. And, you know, more new people will get hurt.
But I think that the overall trend is probably a good one in terms of learning and people getting smarter. um but i do think vcs you know the ones that are raising the money there is a responsibility as well and the answer oh you know these people retail needs to smarten up um it's it feels like a weak one to me um but that's my my approach and again they're free to do what they want what do you think about this convo i mean like to be honest like retail all they can do is like dollar cost average into ETH. And then like the dirty secret of that is if you were to DCA into ETH, like you would outperform the vast majority of VC funds.
Wait, really? This is, this is, yeah, this is like looking at like VC performance data. Oh. And like the cool thing about institutional LPs is like they like survey like 150 or so funds and then they create cohorts of like fund performance data so it's uh broken down by vintage so like if you were started in 2017 18 19 so on so forth and then you see like the quartile so like what the return is for the top quartile uh the second quartile third fourth and also the top performing fund um and it's really fascinating like going through that data then benchmarking that to dca into bitcoin or ease um and like quite quite honestly, like a lot of retail, like if you were just disciplined and patient and DCA'd into ETH, you would have done pretty well.
Yeah, that's a good point. The other thing, Ryan, you went hard on retail. There's also a lot of smart retail out there that the SEC deemed not smart enough to invest in a startup, but they participated in the Ethereum ICO, right? and outperformed the best brand name venture funds, right? So there's a lot of smart retail out there too. But I do think, of course, there's a lot of dumb retail that needs to learn also. Yeah, I totally agree. And what better way to learn than crypto markets? Ideally, you're learning on a smaller amount and you're learning young. I mean, I'm just trying to get, And I think we have many smart, getting smarter retail investors listening to the Bankless podcast, right?
And so certainly we encourage responsible behavior, dollar cost averaging into assets that you have fundamental conviction on. I'm wondering if we could kind of summarize, because you guys see behind the scenes at the, let's call them the VC games, right? The VC shenanigans that are going on. I'm trying to draw out kind of a list of things that retail investors can really look out for or be cautious of. So one is, you've mentioned it earlier, the thread boys, the kind of like the narrative VCs are always like, you know, pumping the narrative. And I think we've seen many main characters kind of like be written out of the show in the 2022 cycle.
And that's a red flag. And so bankless listener, I hope you heard that. Watch out for that. Watch out for that kind of token populism out there. I just want to add to that I call it a counter signal it's like when I think the people with the deepest conviction in crypto often aren't loud about their conviction I think being really loud about your conviction is actually should be recognized by the public as a counter signal where you don't actually have that conviction you're trying to convince others and especially when you see projects in crypto that are you know, consistently trying to get validation from institutions or celebrities.
It's like the thing that comes to mind for me was like the FTX Bahamas conference, right? Where he had Bill Clinton and Tom Brady and, you know, people like that. It's like, that's a counter signal. That actually, to me, signals that a lack of conviction about what you're actually doing. um so that that should be one of the big lessons and i hope it is of uh the you know the last bull market yeah marvelously well put counter signal that means run in the other direction don't just avoid just it means run in the other direction um yeah the the archetype of the uh driver who drives the big big hummer but they've got a small pp yeah yeah and all of these i mean crypto is a mark a microcosm for life right i think there's so many lessons within crypto that uh apply to you know everything in life yeah well you know that's the quality content bankless subscribers subscribe to me thanks for that analogy david psychological projection man it's called compensation the the other piece here is uh token distribution right so you said that that can be a red flag and so one thing i don't think enough um crypto investors look at is like you know, kind of total market cap, right?
So they look at liquid market cap, you know, instead of like total. Fully diluted. Yes. Thank you for the words, Richard. Fully diluted market cap, which is what they should be looking at in this market. And, you know, maybe you could say a few more words about distribution. Like, what does a good distribution like look like? Is there a threshold where it's a certain number and that's like, that should be a red flag for anyone in retail? Or like, what are your further takes on distribution here? Oh, yeah. I mean, maybe we could talk about the market structure bill that just passed through the committees in the House, where they kind of specifically outline like, what's the threshold for a token to be a commodity, not a security.
And there's things like no individual or entity can own more than 20% of the fully diluted supply. no one can have more than 20 voting power um there's things about like uh developers uh like having how much control do developers have over the project um so like the good thing about the bill is like for the first time there's like very tangible like metrics for when is a project considered sufficiently decentralized that it's a commodity um versus like still seeing more as like a like insider VC founder type token. Wow. So I actually, you know, I knew that bill was in progress, but it sounds like you're familiar with kind of the details of it.
So could we take a quick side quest here? So what is that bill that you're talking about? And you're saying there's some concrete definition of the difference between a commodity and a security and it goes to actually define, you know, your token supply in the hands of a small group versus, you know, distributed. give us some more context here. Yeah, it's called the FIT Act. It's basically the market structure bill that concretely settles the turf war between the SEC and the CFTC and just defines what's a security, what's a commodity, when can a security become a commodity when the network is decentralized.
um so it it kind of outlines all of this like regulatory clarity that you know we as the industry has been asking for over the last few years and by the way under that under that bill as written richard i don't know if you've looked at like um besides bitcoin and ether and you know like you know stable coins that kind of thing what other token assets actually fall under the definition of kind of a commodity per that bill uh i mean well i have to look at like different tokens and like see what their current distribution is but like you know quite a lot of tokens um uh i think it's still unclear like whether or not existing tokens will get grandfathered in um i mean the build is still like very much like a work in progress and like the final draft is may like that goes through the house might be very different than like what the text is uh right now i think just to really nail this point home what we're really talking about are like a legitimacy threshold for centralized ownership of a token creation event.
And so I think, Richard, why you brought this up is that this bill is actually putting in a number, a ratio of distributed to privately owned, like publicly held versus privately held, that is actually going to give a legal thumbs up, as in if you give away at least this much of your network, you are legitimate from the eyes of this bill, from this nation state that perhaps Congress approves. i don't know if you know what those numbers are richard but um you know ryan asked you the question like what what are the red flags and then you you bring up this this bill who's literally trying to draw a line in the sand as like what's a red flag versus what's not a red flag do you do you know the numbers off the top of your head i think it's like 20 percent uh 20 percent i mean does that feel right to you um yeah reasonably so um i mean like it's still like very much a draft of work in progress.
So all these exact terminologies are still being negotiated. What else? I would say, yeah, it's hard to define exactly what the number should be. But to me, anything over 30% should be a major red flag to retail investors. And part of being an investor is you have rules, but you can break them. And so even that, I would say, you know, you can break that rule if there's a really strong reason to. But generally, I think that's a good rule to have. Thank you. and start building your first app with Arbitrum. Experience Web3 development the way it was always meant to be, secure, fast, cheap, and friction-free.
Hiring people worldwide, paying them in crypto, providing them access to benefits, it all is so complex, but it doesn't have to be. Complying with labor laws, payroll rules, tax obligations, and crypto regulations in every country that you employ someone is difficult, time-consuming, manual, and costly, and it's drawing more and more attention from regulators and governments. But there is good news. Toku is here. Toku is the first employment and compensation platform for the crypto industry that makes this easy. Toku helps you hire employees or contractors and pay them in fiat or crypto legally, compliantly, and with all the taxes handled in over a hundred different jurisdictions.
So whether you're an early stage company with just a team of two, or you're an enterprise with 200, Toku has a solution that meets your needs. Toku is already working with the leading companies in the space, Protocol Labs, Hedera, Gitcoin, and many more. So transform your employment and token payroll operations with Toku. You can reach out to Toku at toku.com slash bankless or click the link in the show notes. Mantle, formerly known as BitDAO, is the first DAO-led Web3 ecosystem, all built on top of Mantle's first core product, the Mantle Network, a brand new high-performance Ethereum Layer 2 built using the OP stack, but uses Eigenlayer's data availability solution instead of the expensive Ethereum Layer 1.
Not only does this reduce Mantle Network's gas fees by 80%, but it also reduces gas fee volatility, providing a more stable foundation for Mantle's applications. The Mantle Treasury is one of the biggest DAO-owned treasuries, which is seeding an ecosystem of projects from all around the Web3 space for Mantle. Mantle already has sub-communities from around Web3 onboarded, like Game7 for Web3 gaming, and Bybit for TVL and liquidity and on-ramps. So if you want to build on the Mantle network, Mantle is offering a grants program that provides milestone-based funding to promising projects that help expand, secure, and decentralize Mantle.
If you want to get started working with the first DAO-led Layer 2 ecosystem, check out Mantle at Mantle.xyz and follow them on Twitter at 0xMantle. Part of this gets into accredited investor laws, and then other parts of this just get into pools of capital that are very informed about founder risk in particular markets and making bets that way. I remember there was a narrative once upon a time. This is hearkening back to the 2016-2017 Ethereum ICO days that there's no more need for VCs. Everybody can be a VC. It hasn't quite played out like that. And a lot of people called BS on that from the very beginning.
But what's your take on this? Eliminating the idea of VCs. Do we not need it in a fully democratized finance type of world? No, we obviously don't think that because we are them. I mean, when we launched One Confirmation in 2017 as one of the first crypto venture funds, that was kind of – we were able to raise money because we were saying there's this huge ICO boom happening. we think it's mostly bullshit. We're not really participating. But there are really good founders that are thinking long term about building useful products. And so I think, you know, a good VC in crypto is making non obvious bets in early stage products that may not exist otherwise.
Like that's what venture capital if you look at the you know, the history of venture capital, The early VCs were kind of the renegades that were crazy and investing in wild ideas that wouldn't have gotten funded otherwise. And also being a good partner to the founders after your backing. So working closely and helping them with whatever they need. And to me, that's what a good VC is. And I think there still is a need for that. Um, like you, you could raise an ICO and get, um, you know, a thousand people that have a small skin in the game. Um, but then none of them are really helping you. Um, and none of the, none of them are really, and really, you know, if you, this is a totally different direction, but if you look at DAOs, um, you know, a big problem with DAOs is you have, you know, these DAOs that have a lot of participants, but no one that's really focused on driving the thing.
And so I think a good VC is someone that has a large ownership and actually skin in the game and cares about helping. Um, so, and I, I do think they're, you know, founder, there's a need for that still. Um, I think there's way too much capital and a lot of VCs that don't do that, but, um, but I think there are, you know, a number of them that all that do that. And, and that's, that's helpful for crypto. If a VC can fund a product that maybe doesn't have a token, so it isn't getting the love on crypto Twitter or whatever, but is actually bringing millions of new people to crypto, I think that's a net positive for both crypto and the world.
That's what we try to do. Yeah, I think that's a pretty clear articulation as to why even in the absence of investor accreditation laws, you will still have venture capitalists because some venture capitalists will, A, like you said, have enough skin in the game and also the skills and means to actually meaningfully move the needle for a startup, move for actually truly help a founder. And if you just bought a token on Uniswap and it's half a percent to 5% of your total portfolio, maybe you just don't feel that same sort of skin in the game if you're a retail investor with $1,000 to $10,000 invested.
But then, Nick, that kind of brings me to what I want to unpack with one confirmation. So we've talked about the archetype for a toxic negative crypto VC. And we've talked about the game that they play to make their returns, which are perhaps the illegitimate, like I said, toxic games. But what games does OneConfirmation play? How does OneConf actually win the deal for VCs, for a startup where inside of the startup landscape, you have a litany of other VCs in this space who they could take the checks from? What's your pitch for why they would take OneConfirmation's check? And what does OneConfirmation, what game do you guys play in contrast to all the toxic VCs out there?
Yeah, I'd say one thing that differentiates us from other VCs the most is we make very few concentrated investments. And as a result of having a small portfolio, we're able to spend a lot of time with founders post-investment. And like, say a founder wants to chat about something, like I can hop on a call in five minutes and like have a conversation with them, just kind of walking through like ideas with them. And like one thing that we do really well is for like new founders that want to work with us, we ask them to like reference check our existing founders. and ask them, rank all the investors on your cap table.
Where would you rank one confirmation? And not only that for our existing portfolio, but also, this is funny, actually one founder did this to us recently where he wanted to chat with projects that didn't work out, that failed. Because oftentimes when the project is not going well, then the VC-founder relationship truly gets tested. And even in the cases where the project ended up not working out, like we still had a very good relationship with the founder. And like, those are also good reference checks to have, like not, not just the curated references that like, you know, every VC will provide, but also kind of the spicier ones where the project didn't succeed, but you want to see if the VC behaved badly and did stuff.
So what does it take for you to be on the good side of one of your guys' startups? Like what, what are the things that you think you can really help them with? I guess for me personally, like building Dune dashboards, that's like, that's a really obvious one. And like founders always like appreciate it when like the product goes live, they deploy their contract on mainnet and then like a day later, like a Dune dashboard exists and it's like tracking all their top KPIs. Obviously, you know, making intros to like potential customers. We're like, both Nick and I were big like users of like all these crypto products so just like something as simple as using the product and like offering feedback is like you'd be surprised by the number of vcs who don't do that like like one example they're busy writing threads yeah exactly um yeah like one example that comes to mind is like when we invest in super rare like we just like interviewed uh the top super artists and collectors like ask them like what are your feedback on the product what are things that could be better and then like compiled like a google docs sheet and then sent it to the super founders and like something as simple as that was like super valuable to the founders when maybe they couldn't as candidly ask like their users um like their honest opinion of the product that actually sounds like you're doing labor which is interesting because vc is of course on the labor to capital spectrum it's capital but it sounds like what you're doing is just like well we'll actually like do some actual lift work some labor for our portfolio uh portfolio companies yeah which i think is like back to the original points like it's only possible when you have a small concentrated portfolio and like you're making you know at most a dozen investments a year a dozen new investments a year um and like you see vcs there are a lot of vcs that like spray and pray and we'll just like write uh over 100 checks like 0.
5 percent of the fund each like into each company. And obviously when you have that big of a portfolio, now I have trouble managing, I don't know, 30 different names and imagine having to manage 100, 200 different companies and what's going on. So those are kind of the telltale signs that founders could use if a VC's just like LARPing about being a value add or do they actually have the resources for it? One thing I'm continually blown away by is the, The amount of VCs who aren't actually crypto users, like DeFi users, right? And this was even worse previously, but it's still kind of bad now.
It's just like they've never actually run an Ethereum node. They don't have custody of some of their own personal assets on an actual bankless wallet. They barely know how to use Metamask. They don't do much with like Uniswap or any of the kind of the DeFi protocols out there. And yet these are the VCs that are, you know, deploying cash and like investing in these products. That never ceases to amaze me. And I actually think there's a lesson for our listeners here and for retailers here. Spend less time reading threads and absorbing narratives and spend more time using products. that will already put you ahead of a lot of the VCs deploying capital in the game.
And that will help teach you what's real and what's not. What's a narrative, what's a story, and what's an actual product that has some functional utility. Probably need to use some airdrops too. Yeah. Yeah. And that's a big, that's really the core thesis of what we do, right? We only make, as Richard said, a concentrated number, four to six investments a year, call it. And we're only investing in products that we understand deeply from a user perspective. And that's my crypto journey. I mean, how I got involved in Coinbase, so I was one of the first 100 users of Coinbase. I was trying to, back in 2012, I was trying to buy Bitcoin.
I was living in Portland, Maine. And back then, to do that, you had to go to an ATM, take out cash, money gram it over to Mount Gox. And it was just a bad UX. And I saw Brian launched Coinbase on Hacker News. And it just solved a very simple problem for me, like buy Bitcoin with a bank account online. So that's how we invested in OpenSea. We were buying CryptoKitties on the CryptoKitties website, and they were charging 5%. And what's the true value of an NFT, right? It's true ownership, and you should be able to trade it on many different venues for cheaper. And then we used OpenSea early, and then we invested.
So we're very much product first and really only investing in products that we understand deeply from a user perspective. And that actually allows us to do what I personally feel is like the most important role of a VC. VCs talk about, you know, all the different value add, you know, whether it's hiring or, you know, whatever it is. And some of them oversell it. Some of them really deliver on that. I mean, Richard, like, has built many different products for actual portfolio founders. So I think we've done a good job there. But at the end of the day, I think the truth is, and I know this from my own personal experience, the most important thing an investor and a founder can do is instill belief in that founder.
And that's what I feel like we're now in a positive position to do because we've had success in the past. We've seen a lot. We know what works, what doesn't. And just being there as a positive light to a founder and help them instill belief can do wonders to a founder's success. So that's really what we try to do as well. And it's kind of this maybe soft, not super tangible thing, but I do really think it's the truth. And again, I know that from my own personal experience. When I got investors in my fund that I really respected, that really helped propel my belief in what I was doing. And I think that is a really important thing that any investor can do.
And I think it's hard to do that if you don't really understand the product and have conviction on the product and the market. So that's kind of, that's what really, we really focus on. And I've personally focused on more recently as well. It's something you don't really realize early on. At least I didn't in starting one confirmation, but you can, and I've, I've been guilty of this too. um, you know, project your own insecurities on a founder and bring like negativity to them, um, which doesn't help at all. Right. That's, that's a net negative. And so really doing anything you can to not do that and be kind of a positive light and, and project a belief, um, is I think really, uh, really important role of an investor.
Yeah. It's, uh, you know, forget the work of, uh, being a founder is very, very, very, very freaking difficult uh for sure and shout out to all the builders and founders out there who are making making crypto what what it is and what it should be and you mentioned nick this idea of kind of product first uh and i want to broaden this out so we talked about um you know like uh what we did wrong in in 2022 and some of the lessons learned we talked about why vc suck and how to do it well i feel like uh we need to now think about preparing for the next cycle or the next wave of adoption or the next wave of building, whatever we want to call it.
And the truth is crypto still hasn't gotten to a billion people yet, a billion users. And isn't that why we're here? Isn't that the promise of crypto? And so I want to ask you guys what themes that you're looking at, like going into 2023 to onboard the next cohort of crypto users. Like where are you looking for the alpha? Where are the 1 billion users going to actually come from? Nick, I saw a tweet from you that said this, crypto native products that will reach 1 billion users in the next 10 years. And you said prediction markets, DAO tools, on-chain messengers, decentralized social media, decentralized identity.
I feel like we haven't really seen much uptick in any of those things yet. And I'm wondering, is that your answer for where the next billion comes from? It's one of those categories? Or do you think it's something else? Why don't we start with you, Nick? I think that's where I have the highest conviction, right? The beautiful thing about crypto is there's a million different projects being worked on, and we don't really know. It's really hard to predict what is going to really hit, right? I mean, we nailed NFTs. I don't think many did, right? And for a long time, most in crypto, I think were too big brained for NFTs, right?
And they were focused on, you know, the deep tech or the DeFi or something, and really dismissed NFTs, even though there was a small community that was using it. uh you know the products they were you know dismissed as either dgen or stupid or something i just thought they were jpegs like jpegs right click save jpegs at first honestly yeah so that was obviously a surprising one and nfts um arguably have gone more mainstream than anything um so far um so we very much look for products that are serving a small niche of really passionate users that have, you know, mainstream potential that that's what we do as kind of early stage VCs.
And yeah, I mean, if I had to pick one right now, I would say prediction markets. I think prediction markets, they capture the essence of crypto, right, which crypto is all about speculation and memes. If you had to right now, define, and I think it's going to be much more than that but still in 2023 if you had to define the the essence of crypto i think it's it's speculation and memes and i think prediction markets bring speculation and memes to more people it's not just about shitcoin speculation it's about speculation on um whether the room temperature superconductor paper is real or whether uh trump is going to be the republican nominee or whatever.
The submarine, the recent story of the submarine, that brought in like a million dollars of volume inside of like two or three days to polymarket. Yep. Yep. So I really like prediction markets as a use case. I think it has a lot of the features that really requires a mainstream use case. I mean, one of the things that I think is unappreciated about prediction markets is it could also be a new business model for creators. So I think one of the big reasons NFTs broke out, right, is they made it easy for any creator to make money. And I think soon we're going to see create your own market type products that allow like any influencer to basically create their own market and then make fees off that.
So I think prediction markets, if I were to pick one right now would be the category that i pick can i ask you on that really quick nick because the prediction so so much about kind of investing is timing right and so it's like um you know eventually um the idea of a food delivery service uh worked uh internet food delivery service but but it wasn't webvan back in like you know 1999 or 2000 or whenever that was right it was it was something later it was like an uber manifestation of this um prediction markets have been a crypto use case for like ever one of the first uh ethereum icos was auger uh i'm sure you guys remember that right which is what was it a you know decentralized prediction market why now like so why have the um the previous attempts at prediction markets in crypto failed and like why is the timing right now in your mind yeah and and again i'm not sure it is but um you know we We've been watching this space closely from the beginning.
I mean, we invested in Augur. We participated in early Augur markets. We were investors in Vale, which was a more centralized version of a prediction market that didn't end up working. And, I mean, prediction markets are tough because there's a regulatory component that makes it hard, particularly in the U.S., for centralized companies to operate and offer the service to U.S. consumers. And Augur tried it in a decentralized way. But as you guys know, there's often a tradeoff between a decentralization and UX. So Augur went decentralized, wasn't able to get a great UX. Vail went more centralized, couldn't figure out how to operate a centralized business within the regulatory framework.
and look i think you need to tip your hat your your cap to shane and polymarket because they've kind of grinded through dealt with um some challenges in terms of regulatory but have figured out a way to offer a product outside the u.s um and really you know gain gain traction so you know the the honest answer is i don't know for sure that the time is right But it just feels like the way things are going with everyone is becoming an investor, the trend, the way that regulation is going, more people coming online globally, memes going more viral. There's just a lot of indications that it could be a good time to build a prediction market business.
One of the takes that I've been giving out recently is that a lot of the underlying infrastructure of crypto is ready. It is effectively done. There's still plenty of domains, part of this deep tech stack that CryptoWeb3 is built on that definitely we can improve. but I don't think that there are any applications that are not accessible to the crypto tech stack because of how I feel like finished some of our protocols are maybe we're like one to two years out for this really being true and I'm wondering if that take resonates with you as in our protocols data availability layer two speed and latency and UX all of these things like cross-chain composability could definitely get improved but it's on the horizon and I'm just wondering about your take about this take nick and richard like i think that uh the full spectrum of user applications is going to be available to crypto to web3 like basically now ish one to two years like where our protocols are ready to support whatever app that we can develop and i'm wondering if that resonates with you richard how do you feel about that yeah i mean i agree with that i actually have a pretty similar hot take uh we're actually we're recording this uh august 2023 so like right now at least in the vc world like there's just so much money that's being poured into new infra projects and i think the reason is because um there aren't really net new users in crypto and like people just want to bury their head in the sand and like punt the question of like how are we going to get users and adoption down the road so meanwhile no one wants to do the hard thing no one wants to do the hard thing about getting users so meanwhile just build infra and then kind of punt that question later but the problem is then you become one of 50 different infra providers that an application can build on so like we as a fund we generally skew more like consumer application heavy because like i think in the next bull run or two like that's where the next million billion users are going to come from some killer app um nick talks about prediction markets um one thing i've been thinking a lot about is web3 messaging so um you know historically like wallets have been the gatekeeper the front end to crypto is like whenever you want to do some crypto interaction you have to go through a wallet first but like if you think about it like if you look at like your transaction history on etherscan like almost all of those were probably triggered because a friend told you to go mint this nft or like go do this action so So what if you have messaging, the social layer as the product, and the wallet becomes the feature, not the product?
I think that is one potential area where the next wave of crypto users that onboard won't have the bias of existing wallet products, but onboard through a messaging app that just has the wallet built in as a feature, not the product. Do you think part of the reason for that prediction is that we're making progress on account abstraction and Layer 2s, gasless or very low fee block space, that kind of thing? Is that why? Why now? Yeah, I think AA is like a big unlocker. You know, like account abstraction is an idea we've been really bullish on for a long time. We actually invested in one of the first AA wallets called Ethereum back in 2019, which they ended up pivoting to Hop Protocol.
But I think with like 4337 going live, the entry point contract going live on mainnet March of this year, I think that 4337, the spec, is specifically what makes the timing now different and better for account abstraction. And we've actually made a bet. We invested in a founder. His name is Christoph. He's actually one of the co-authors of 4337, which is really cool. And he went from co-authoring the spec to now building Pimlico, which is a company that's building out the bundlers and paymasters for account abstraction. so since you guys are users first what do you guys do when you guys are going to go do and make a transaction on ethereum or a layer two what kind of activities do you guys like to do what's your not maybe not the dgen activity but if you guys are users how often do you see yourself or what activities you guys see yourself doing the most inside of crypto i guess for me it's minting nfts like for example with the the base l2 launch uh yesterday like uh i minted like dk motions nft uh and it was cool uh i mean i'm a big fan of dk motions art so it's cool that it was one of the first nfts on base nick what about you um lately i'm more i'm increasingly excited by non-financial activity.
So, um, Farcaster is one. Um, I use Farcaster quite a bit. I, um, I really liked the community they have. Um, and they recently added a ENS, which I thought was cool. So I, you know, added my ENS name and, um, you know, made some posts on Farcaster. messaging is another one i mean i'm increasingly using uh crypto like on-chain messengers so uh converse is one that um that i use pretty regularly um have you guys used any on-chain messaging products no um so xm i've used like ether scan yes the ether scan chat yeah xmtp is a uh is a protocol that is pretty cool and by the way we're actually not investors in that one.
So we're not just showing our bag, but they built kind of an on-chain messaging protocol that a bunch of products have used. And so one of the cool things about like Converse and Coinbase Wallet has it as well, is you can write a message. You can connect your wallet, write a message to someone. Say someone owns an ENS name that you want, you could message them. And the message persists across the different messaging applications, which is kind of like a crypto-native behavior that I think is pretty cool. We all know juggling Telegram and – Discord and email. WhatsApp and everything else. So that's an example.
Another one is we recently invested in a messenger called Friends, which is taking a different approach. But that's an area that I'm increasingly excited about. I do think it's likely that a speculation-related application is going to be the next breakout, something like prediction markets. But we're also closer than ever to kind of these non-speculation-related use cases. Nick, the non-speculation stuff. Is that Web3? Is that what we're talking about? I haven't heard you guys say the term Web3 this entire episode. Web3 is like a made-up Silicon Valley. That's what Silicon Valley VCs love using the term Web3.
And then crypto natives just use crypto. Yeah. But I mean, we're effectively talking about some of that, right? Decentralized social networks and crypto connections. Yeah, truthfully, it's like Web3 was a made-up term to appeal to people in Silicon Valley that looked at crypto and said, oh, that's scammy. That's degen or something. So it was basically, I don't know, I don't love the term. It's like digital assets versus cryptocurrencies. Yeah, yeah. I will say there was a conversation I had with my father sometime in like 2019 where he was like, crypto, y'all really need a rebrand because crypto is such a, he's a, dad's a boomer, of course, like crypto is just such a negative connotation word.
And then as soon as Web3 came around, I was like, oh, okay, great, we did it. And then we kind of ruined it. Well, guys, this has been a lot of fun. So thank you for guiding us to the world. I think bankless listeners should come away with this with a lot of lessons. I guess one last question I have to ask you. So L2s, let's talk about this. L2s versus alternative layer ones. You guys have any hot takes? I know that's not the app layer, this is infrastructure, but what are you betting on? I would say my on-chain, again, we let products guide us. And L2s have been really hot from a narrative perspective.
And I've tried a bunch of them to try them and stuff like that. But the vast majority of my activity is still on Ethereum. Layer one. Layer one, exactly. And so we haven't done a ton in the L2 space. I mean, a lot of them were, again, these kind of big VC rounds that we generally don't participate in. It's a super hot narrative that I generally like it, right? Because it's good for Ethereum overall. Our largest position as a fund is still ETH. But in terms of just activity, I'm still mostly on mainnet, and we haven't done a ton. We've done some, right? Like Hop, I think, is a great product that bridges assets from mainnet to L2s.
And I've used Hop quite a bit, again, just to experiment. But there's no product yet on an L2 that I'm using consistently. I'm curious. What about you guys? well on layer 2 nft minting is the main activity yeah really cheap nft minting yeah yeah and then there are some layer 2 native defi apps which i've touched maybe a few times yeah i think both dave and i probably ski pretty bullish on layer 2s overall how about you richard i have one hot take i have for l2s i think a lot of projects will launch their own roll up on the OP stack because there's a better argument for having a token rather than kind of this pseudo equity governance fee token is like you're building your own chain and you have a token that secures the sequencer and kind of manages the L2.
So I think we'll probably see a lot of app specific roll-ups in the next year or two. That is a thesis that you and I share, Richard, and if i said anything more bullish about the op stack would be like the fifth time this week well guys thank you so much for joining us on bankless has been a lot of fun yeah great to see you guys hope you enjoyed that episode one action item for you today uh richard actually wrote a fantastic post on the current vc landscape we'll include that in the show notes we're not done slamming vcs of course go uh go read up on that some more risks and disclaimers gotta end with this as always crypto is risky you lose what you put in but we are headed west this is the frontier it's not for everyone but we're glad you're with us on the bankless journey thanks a lot