Episode: #19 June 29, 2020
Hasu is a free-thinker. A truth seeker. A rare voice in crypto. He's not afraid to push back on tribal dogma. He breaks rank with Bitcoiners on some topics and Ethereans on others. Yet he still considers himself a member of both tribes and respects the mysticism (and even dogma) of these deeply social systems.
In the spirit of Satoshi he's pseudonymous. We don't know his actual identity. But we know who he is from his body of writing that has influenced our thinking on many crypto topics.
What does he think about Ethereum?
About crypto banks?
About DeFi?
We covered it all:
Join us next Monday for a fresh episode!
-----
Tools from our sponsors to go bankless:
----- Resources discussed:
----- Episode Actions:
Also...subscribe to Bankless YouTube to watch State of the Nation every Tuesday.
----- Subscribe to podcast on iTunes | Spotify | YouTube | RSS Feed
Leave a review on iTunes
Share the episode with someone you know!
----- Don't stop at the podcast!
Subscribe to the Bankless newsletter program
Watch Bankless shows and tutorials on YouTube
Visit official Bankless website for resources
Follow Bankless on Twitter
Follow Ryan on Twitter
Follow David on Twitter
No summary for this episode yet.
Welcome to Bankless, where we explore the frontier of internet money and internet finance. This is how to get started, how to get better, and how to frontrun the opportunity. This is Ryan Sean Adams, I'm here with David Hoffman, and we're here to help you become more. We have a fantastic show with Hazu. Tell us about it. Hazu is one of the few people that I consider a secular thinker in the crypto space. He's very sober in his thoughts, he thinks clearly, and there have been just, he's produced a ton of content that the most incredible thing that I think about the content that he produces is that we've seen companies make choices based off of the content that Hazu and the content that comes out of uncommon core.
So Hazu, we call him a person that is the M zero of thought, I would say, there's just a lot of memes, a lot of ideas, a lot of concepts that comes out of what Hazu produces. So getting Hazu onto the bankless podcast was an absolute necessity, and he did a great job walking us through how he thinks about the space. We talk a lot about the concept of a blockchain crypto system as kind of like an organism, kind of a cohesion of stakeholders that creates some sort of, that has a body and then also a spirit, right? It has the physical code and the physical people running their nodes, but then it also has like the social contract, right?
It has the implied values of that system and how these things interact and the different ways that they cohere together. You know, it's cool. I think Hazu thinks of himself as a Bitcoin or but also an Ethereum. So this is kind of a good follow up to our Nick Carter conversation because I think both Nick and he think in, they're both free thinkers, as you said, and many of their ideas intersect and complement one another. But what I love about Hazu is he is not afraid to sort of shake things up. So I think he originally maybe came more from the Bitcoin or community or Bitcoin or side of things, but he's not afraid to break rank and write articles like why Bitcoin might not survive a Bitcoin standard.
That was the title of an article he wrote and it was about how crypto banks might sort of infiltrate Bitcoin and break up the decentralized social contract and value system of the network. So he's definitely not afraid to go push back on norms and push back on ideas. And part of the reason I think he can do that is he's actually a pseudo anonymous account. So on Twitter and everywhere he posts, you know, there's no profile shot. We don't actually know who Hazu is. He's got sort of this Rick and Morty with an eye patch avatar everywhere and that's what we know of Hazu. To me, he's like, from Rick and Morty, he's dropping all of this wisdom.
But what's so cool is that, you know, the crypto community is very much a merit-based social economy. So it doesn't matter who he is really, it's, it's, we judge Hazu based on the quality of ideas that he presents and not based on, you know, his reputation or pedigree have no idea who he actually is, but no, he is a fantastic thinker just given what he's written and the way he presents himself. Every conversation that I have with Hazu, I always find immensely valuable and I'm sure you the listener will too. We also talk about common topics such as EIP 1559 and the issue of the growing world of crypto banks and how that influences this crypto industry and what it will look like into the future.
Evergreen topics and coming from a guy who thinks about them a lot. So this is a fantastic interview. Before we get into that interview, let's talk about some bankless things. Both part one and part two of a bankless nation I've written are up and on the bankless website. So you guys should check them out. It's a, it's a two different, two different articles. One kind of goes into the past history of nations. One goes into the future history of digital nations. We talk about these concepts in this episode with Hazu and so I definitely recommend reading those. If you guys don't like to read, but instead you prefer audio content as you are a listener of a podcast, you can go to the bankless YouTube where I read these articles to you and I also scroll through the articles.
So you can read it with me, but I read it aloud, read it right into your ears. So it makes it really easy. And then while you're there, you might as well just subscribe to the bankless YouTube. Yeah, the bankless YouTube is really catching fire these days. We actually just released a new show that we're publishing first on YouTube. It's called State of the Nation where we talk about topical news items that are most relevant to the bankless nation. And we're releasing that on YouTube every Tuesday. We'll also publish it to this podcast stream as well on Wednesdays. So from here on out on Mondays, you're going to be getting a typical edition of the bankless podcast.
And then on Wednesdays on this podcast stream, you can you can listen to State of the Nation. And you can also catch that a day early if you go to YouTube and subscribe to our channel. So to do that, just go to YouTube type in bankless and it'll pop right up. So we are about to dig into the interview. But before we do, we should take a minute and talk about our sponsors. This gives you the ability to run your business without a bank. That is the dream. It is the first ever bankless bank account for entrepreneurs who want to run their business both on crypto and traditional currencies like stablecoins.
So it features a multi-sig wallet. That means you can have team access, not just individual access, which is necessary for a business. So you can implement access controls. You can also earn interest on your crypto using money protocols inside of Maltes like Compound and Ave and others. You can streamline payments as well. Maltes has been featured on bankless for huge fans of the product. They're adding fiat on ramps soon. And as you are listening to this on June 22nd, they are launching a completely revamped app. You've got to check it out. If you're starting a business, want to run a business in crypto, check out Maltes.
co in their revamped app. We're going to be doing a video pretty soon and publishing it on the bankless YouTube channel as well. All right. So you need to go to Maltes.co. That's M-U-L-T-I-S dot.co. And check it out. When you mention bankless, they'll put you ahead of the queue. They'll give you better priority and let you sign up quicker. In this episode with Hazoo, we talk about the influence of exchanges, crypto exchanges, and how they turn into crypto banks. And how that starts to dictate what these chains look like. However, getting value onto these systems doesn't always require a crypto bank.
And that's where Monolith comes in. Coming soon on Monolith is an on ramp into your Monolith smart contract wallet directly from your bank account. So you don't need to pass through any sort of crypto exchange crypto bank to get your value on into Ethereum. Monolith for those that don't know is a smart contract wallet that also connects to a crypto visa card. You can go to the store, swipe your visa card as you normally do. And instead of pulling out dollars from your bank account, it pulls out die from your smart contract wallet. So this is a way to live a bankless life without having it impact you and your daily living with your friends and family.
And you don't have to be that weird person that only has crypto money and no real money. So it wraps your Ethereum address in a visa card. And visa is accepted basically all over the world. And you still get to have access to your die earning that interest rate in DeFi at the same time. So check them out at monolith.xyz to get your bankless visa card today. All right guys, let's go ahead and get right into the interview with. Hey everyone, we are excited to have hasu with us hasu is a crypto researcher. He is also a writer. He's read a ton of stuff. You've probably already read. If not, his ideas are likely embedded in your subconscious as they are in mind.
Hasu is fantastic to have you today. We're really excited about this. Yeah, same. I'm really excited to be here guys. Okay, so when I was looking at the volume of writing that you've done over the years since I don't know 2017 2018 when you started to really get active in crypto and publishing, I was just overwhelmed. Like there are a lot of even your earlier ideas that I feel like are embedded in my own subconscious. But I want to ask you this question, you know, maybe it's not your most popular article, but what's your favorite article that you've written so far? Well, first of all, first off, that's what you said is probably the biggest compliment that you could give to to me.
You know, I just, I just love to write stuff where people say, or that becomes basically part of this. What everyone believes, right? It's, I don't know how to put it here, but. And because I'm I myself and I'm influenced by by some writers very strongly and it's just we talked about this a little bit before the show started, but I feel like it's it's worth repeating here, but we all have these. These kind of people who influenced our own thinking in a very strong way. And for me, for example, he's he's not the most popular guy or like he doesn't tweet very much and so on, but a lot of my thinking, for example, is strongly influenced by reading Paul Storzer's blog.
Truth coin.org, I believe. And so a lot of times when I write something that and I actively wonder, okay, where does this particular thought of mine originate? Then it's like there's like a 25% chance or something that I first set the thought while reading his blog or picking up something that he said. And a bunch more people like that. So James Press, which is someone who was probably almost at the same level as Paul, for me, just in terms of when he says something, then I listen so intently because just historically there's such a large chance that when they say something, then it becomes like it it permanently orders my my thinking.
That's so funny because so off to check out Paul, I've read some of James's stuff off to check out Paul a bit more to because I feel like you're probably in that category for me, at least personally. And Nick, Nick Carter, whom we had a couple episodes ago is probably another one who's in that camp for me too, but like it's it's very cool how the crypto social like contract or the social layer. I guess I should say sort of works because it very much it's it's sort of a just a free open thinking society, especially among among some of some crypto thinkers who haven't descended into weird, you know, maximalist kind of like narrow minded paths.
And each of us kind of build on what another says and sort of take an idea, you know, further and it really develops this incredibly rich social layer that I haven't personally seen anywhere else, I don't know if it exists anywhere, I haven't personally seen it. Yeah, and even even when it comes to maximalism, that's it's so fascinating to observe like in every aspect of this complex or these complex social dynamics that we have in the crypto community, there's always something to analyze and to draw an interesting takeaways from in my opinion. The way that just the kind of tribalism works in crypto, I mean we've talked about this like so many times before, but they are very strong parallels to religious movements and when I realized that it really transcended the debate for me and it made me bullish on a whole other level about cryptocurrency when I realized how religious the movement is.
And I'm generally surprised by how few people get this still or still see the religious aspects of crypto as a negative because for me it it's so massive like even though I don't participate in these kind of religious rituals and the way that I guess others do, but just as an observer I look at them and I find it incredibly positive for the future. If you have a movement that's that has ambitious goals and changing how the world works and they're then having this kind of religious structure is just and religious further is just fantastic. Alright so so that I'm glad you bring that up because so David and I were just talking about this yesterday on the the first state of the nation episode that we released and we're talking talking about whether crypto is more similar to a religion or a nation state and David I think you made the comment that well you know to you Bitcoin feels a bit more on the religion side whereas maybe it's more nation state that both sort of one.
What's your take on some of the nation state is crypto this way. Yeah I read your article actually but it was good so the way correct me for wrong about the way that you do collect the main criteria that unified for the nation state was that it provides physical protection for its people is correct. Or not even a nation state but just a nation at large right. So the whole idea was to expand the model of a nation into the groups of organizational schemes that have come throughout history and religion would be one of the original schemes of a nation that one of the core features of it is that it offers protection for its own constituents.
Yeah yeah I'm kind of buying to the I guess you would you could say like it's the Sabo Saboian way of thinking about this or also Harari it's they both kind of have a very similar attitude about this but so those above the state or the nation state and religions are both social technologies or social technology. Social institutions that are that humans invent to increase their ability to cooperate with one another beyond the the confines of their small trusted social group so it's it's always about scaling the ability to trust one another and as a result you can you can cooperate with one another.
And when the they both operate in like in slightly different ways so the punishment or like the way that I would say this this data is it is. Where you would combine it with some kind of legal system so you impose some rules that are if the rules are paid it's beneficial for everyone it's just like social contract in that sense right. Like you can't kill me or I can't kill you but in return I'm sure that you won't kill me and we enforce these rules by whether by by physical punishment in the case of the state but in the case of religion via some. Yeah I guess some kind of more arcane threat right so it's it's the punishment in the afterlife or it's the fall from grace I don't know what to call it but in both in both it's it's also the.
The threat of being rejected from your community but that that that aside so so they are both social technologies. And to scale our ability to cooperate with one another by removing trust from the equation and I don't think that there's I don't think there's a difference between like Bitcoin and a theorem there. To me they I think even in the future I think it's already happening but the just this distinction between religion and the nations that even in the in the physical world is just going to disappear so. The state can be a religion and the religion can be a state and then there are other movements that have sort of the attributes of both a little bit so.
I just think that the soil the soil distinction between them is going to disappear and Bitcoin and a theorem definitely have attributes of both. I want to bring it back to the original question so the Bitcoin to me is more of a religious nation although it is also like a nation state but a theorem to me is also more closer to a nation state but it is also a can has its religious components do you recognize that distinction. I guess I guess not really so I mean when you would say it's more like a religion that that would imply to me that the properties are very strongly reliant on social norms because that's what religion mostly does it creates or it the rules in a religious movement are applied by us the strong enforcement of social norms and values.
And that's how you get these scalability benefits. But Bitcoin is just as much a technical protocol where rules are enforced by a network of computers that reject each other's messages if they don't follow certain what if they don't follow the correct protocol. And we have just as strict as an enforcement there and in some ways the enforcement in Bitcoin is arguably even stricter right. Because in Bitcoin the the Bitcoin communities more strongly believes in this. So that everyone should be able to validate the blockchain and we should reject the idea of weak subjectivity so there should be no subjectivity at all and what is the heaviest chain.
Whereas in in Ethereum the human community believes that hey it's okay we can use checkpointing for validation and it is okay if there's if an attack up takes over a proof of state network then we can just fork them out on the social air. So I feel like the then enforcement is more strict and more physical is the Bitcoin so in that sense in that sense it might be like Ethereum might even have some of these more religious aspects or more social aspects if you create religion with social enforcement. That's that's really interesting that you say that has you know one take on this and maybe part of the reason why David feels like Bitcoin has a bit more religious aspects to it and further about it is just it does feel like there is a richness in Bitcoin that in the social layer in sort of these enforced norms.
That isn't yet present in Ethereum though Ethereum is kind of is kind of getting there right there there's some very clear things in Bitcoin that you have to sort of subscribe to to be you know part to be a Bitcoiner right and there's even you call the maximalists or you've written articles about the intolerant minority people who go around and they they enforce these norms you know through sort of purity tests. So and so is not a real Bitcoiner if if he was he he wouldn't say XYZ right no but but possibly that's just because Bitcoin has been around for twice as long. You know so Ted you know 10 years ish and in Ethereum Ted 5 and it's still kind of working itself out so I think that maybe a closer comparison would be to check out Bitcoin in 2015 versus Ethereum today where it's just starting to establish its norms but.
On the topic of kind of these the social coordination systems as a religion right I find it very interesting that when people talk about their religious affiliation they might say I'm a Christian or I'm a Muslim or I'm a Hindu right they put a name to it we do the same crypto i'm a Bitcoiner I'm an Ethereum and I guess my question to you is the same question I asked as Nick are you a Bitcoiner and are you an Ethereum hot so do you identify. Yeah sure I would say I'm both for me I would say mostly I at Nixon of you and I I was nodding along when he said so I think you asked you for a definition of what it means to be a kind of Ethereum first.
It's the most Nick Carter thing to do. It's very it's I also agree with what it's what he said that it's it's easier to define what a Bitcoiner is because they're. Like the the the values of what that means are much more defined but I also agree with what you said earlier that the values of what it means to be. Material also becoming more strongly defined over time and it's mostly it's mostly a process of removal. So you start with a community that has a lot of different beliefs but those beliefs are not heard very strongly and then eventually it converges it converges on on the much smaller set of much stronger heard beliefs.
At least that's what it seems like to me and then people were like at some of these fringe views they find themselves pushed out eventually. So yeah any kind of movement I think tends towards the more extreme versions of what it previously believed over time. Do you think those extreme like people in those extreme versions that the maximalists are useful for these predator religions. Oh yeah I mean this goes back to what we talked about a few minutes ago with just the kind of religious further how how I think how value but I think it is in one example would be. One example would be in terms of what I made my my the article that I wrote before the one on EP one fifth of mine about custodial banking.
So this is in my opinion a great example of how it's not enough that you have a protocol a technical protocol that can enforce a particular set of of rules automatically because the the number of rules that you can enforce with a blockchain is actually quite limited. And it's not nearly enough to build a system that can become a global form of money that is very valuable and exist in a very adversarial environment you need to pair this with. With social norms as well look at gold gold is gold is a physical element and you can't alter the shape of the physical element but everything that is built on this base layer of gold and settlement asset is entirely shaped and molded by humans and it's extremely valuable in the sense.
So the same is true for Bitcoin you can you can have you can have a very robust base layer but if people are not using the base layer but using any kind of system that is built on top of it then. That's not something that that's a not something that the base layer can control and be it can it can push the entire system in a state where the roots of the base layer that they don't even matter anymore so if everyone's everyone's transacting only on on higher layers then whoever controls these higher layers they control the entire rules of the system. So that that chose to me why the social norms are so so important as well if you want to build a system like that.
So how's it in my article the nation article I made some sort of claim that the protocol of the systems are their DNA right and as these systems grow if you take if you take the lens that these systems are organisms as these systems grow the DNA of the protocol the specific details of how their specific code works. This defines what they look like at maturity you know as DNA does like as an organism grows up it determines with the shape and structure of said organism and I think what you just said and and something I think we want to get into in this episode is the the DNA of a particular protocol if it doesn't retain its the sovereignty over its own soul right if it doesn't control what it looks like at maturity then there are layers of.
So on top of the protocol that can perhaps capture and control the soul of the system and redefine what it means to use use the system itself and to make this in more concrete terms so i'm not speaking in generalities. This is the conversation of of crypto banks right where the cryptocurrencies have a soul a structure of belief systems and values that are instantiated in the code in the DNA. But if everyone is using these crypto systems via a proxy like a crypto bank that may or may not thwart or corrupt the soul the spirit of the bottom the spirit of the system and so I kind of want to get your take on on a that perspective but then also lead into the conversation of what the future of crypto banks are and how they are going to impact the spirit of these systems.
So I think it's I agree with the take that the code the code of these protocols is the DNA. But I would say it's part of the DNA because you're part of the DNA also rests in the social contract and the social contract is not the same as the protocol itself so they. The social contract is to me is really the layer zero of any of these systems and then on top of the social contract sits the protocol and the protocol is expressed by code but the protocol can only enforce part of the social contract. So it can, for example, enforce that I'm not allowed to print money from thin air I can only spend a coin that I have that someone that either I have mind or that that someone has sent to me with a valid signature.
But then there are things that are not possible to enforce with the protocol and those are also important parts of the DNA. So, for example, the fact that we should use or we should validate our our own transactions are that we should use when possible. We don't use intermediate forms of payment and custody for our kids or we should hold our own keys. So those are not like how would you enforce those things by the protocol you can't. This this has to be all done through social norms that are also they don't talk about the social contract and that's where I think the. Whether more the I guess whether more strongly minded and vocal people and in both communities are very important because they do the same as the protocol does they and socially enforce particular routes that are important for the long term survival of the protocol does it make sense.
I think of these people as like they're like priests right almost in kind of religious context they're like the the core devs of the the meme layer of the social layer. And they are important and the weird thing about it is sometimes I see Bitcoin maximalists on that side of things I think Jesus is bizarre like you guys are not responding to like logic and reason and yet at the same time. It kind of makes me bullish on Bitcoin right it's this weird dichotomy because that level of religious a fervor implies that there is a strong social contract around some of these things and ultimately it's that social contract that secures the Bitcoin network.
And that's also why I see like I get bullish when things like you know the parody multi sick hack there was an EIP to release funds there right but that never went through that sort of shot down by the Ethereum social contract that to me is is bullish for Ethereum maintaining its minimum necessary insurance policy we're not going to. You know do another doubt and intervene in the protocol at all and that's also why I don't really get worried about the move from ETH 1 to ETH 2 because the same social contract like from Ethereum's inception is going to be preserved you're moving the spirit but you know you're you're moving to a new body but the spirit is the same right so.
I'm not as concerned as as some people are for like what if what if the ETH 2 technology doesn't work out of the gate well it's fine we saw this the social contract which hasn't been disrupted will fired up again and we'll keep moving on the social contract I don't know what your take is on that but that's where what I was thinking as you're saying that has you. I actually have an important thought on this I think so it's it's true that that the social contract I mean you can move you can you can retain your soul if you will move to a different body and that's all good but I think it's like the same community made one mistake with the transition from ETH 1 to ETH 2 and that is increasing all like introducing double issuance there.
Because it creates so the way it works is when Ethereum 2 launches it has its own it's its own issuance and there are two tokens until the two systems eventually emerge but it's it's unclear how long that's going to take and could well be could well take five years or longer. And what this does is it creates an incentive for Ethereum 1 to stay as its own network and split off from Ethereum 2 because the moment that Ethereum 1 and 2 merge there is this supply shock where all the coins that have accumulated in Ethereum 2 suddenly become merged with the coins that are in Ethereum 1. And I see this as a very big oversight and I was very surprised to hear this because you you create these disincentives in the community against merging the two together and I think I think that would be I think this will become a become a bigger issue when it's actually time to merge those and the issue gets larger longer than the merging takes.
Yeah so one question I I've been thinking I've seen a debate in the Ethereum community on this is so so you're right so ETH when ETH 1 when ETH 2 fires up there's going to be additional issuance right so there's ETH 1 issuance plus ETH 2 issuance and it's going to increase total issuance of ether on an annual basis by you know maybe half a percent maybe a percent or so. And some have advocated that well we should decrease the block reward on ETH 1 to compensate for the additional issuance in ETH 2 so there's not like additional net issuance. But the other counter to that is any you know you only get a few rubs of the genie bottle right and any change that you make to the issuance policy it's human intervention quote unquote so it's hurting the credible neutrality of Ethereum by changing issuance.
What side do you follow on with that do you think that in the transition to ETH 2 do you think that ETH 1 should reduce its issuance to compensate or do you think that the net impact on the credible neutrality of the issuance of Ethereum would be impacted from that and that would be a net negative. I'm not even sure that you could prevent this bad outcome by lowering the issuance of ETH 1 because in either case you still have the supply shock when you actually merge the two together so I think it's more result of having this launch in stages. But at the same time I'm not really sure how you would do it better can you do it in a way where the two systems are I mean I mean I think I guess you could you could solve the problem by making it possible to trans to transact both ways right so you have a B direction a transfer between ETH 1 and ETH 2 and the way that I see it then there's no 0 to 1 supply shock.
There's only where any kind of coin that is created on ETH 2 can immediately affect the coin supply on ETH 1 so it's more like it's more like like boiling a frog very slowly compared to throwing it into hot water at which point it's just going to jump out again. I think that that is probably how I would have done it so I don't see the question of should be lower issuance of ETH 1 should be not lower it I don't see that as central. So we want to pause the interview and tell you about two more of our sponsors the first is ramp what's holding crypto back getting fiat into the crypto system in order to get fiat into a defy application you have to create an account with an exchange.
You have to wire funds that's the same thing that's holding your defy app back users drop off off in the sign up process because they don't have crypto so what you're doing is you're limiting your market to the hardcore crypto people but with ramp that no longer has to be the case ramp is it delightfully easy fiat on ramp it lets first time crypto users get ETH die USD see this takes five minutes or less this reduces the drop out rate so you can build products for the real world. It's free for developers it takes 10 minutes to implement you can 100x your addressable market size if you have a defy app so this is the ultimate growth hack what you need to do is go to ramp.
network to check it out that's r-a-m-p.network to check it out see how easy this is and when you mention bankless they will on ramp the first 100k in US dollars for free so make sure you go to ramp mention bankless and get that set up today. It's a defy protocol that you just have to check out it is a borrowing and lending protocol on a theorem but with a few more tricks and tools than than what you may be used to. So you can put assets inside of it and supply assets and then get your interest rate based off of those assets and then you can also borrow those assets but the cool thing is you can borrow assets at a fixed interest rate which is a really important money lego in order to expand what the ethereum nation can really offer the world around it.
Having a fixed interest rate where you can borrow assets and not have that interest rate change under your feet is it going to be a crucial feature for enabling more tools coming out of the ethereum economy. In addition to that there's also a tokens which are tokens that represent the underlying collateral but has that interest rate baked into it. Abe is climbing the leaderboards of the value locked in defy about two cross 100 million locked they currently at 98.3 million so they are just absolutely crushing it. Developers you can check out their flash loan protocol which can really help the UX of your application.
A flash loan is when you borrow assets from the protocol without any collateral so long as you pay back that those assets in the same transaction. And this can help your users move their positions of their move their debt positions either a compound debt position or a maker dowval position. It allows you to swap out collateral instantaneously in one transaction which really allows for a lot more which really is going to be a blessing for your users and their UX. I want to circle back around and finish a thought that we were talking about a second ago. You said that the DNA of a protocol isn't completely instantiated in the code itself but it's also part of the social contract the social contract system also has the DNA of the protocol.
But I think a case can be made where that's actually a weakness right because the whole point of the system is to relegate to code as much as possible. And so if there is a social contract in Bitcoin of you know run your own node hold hold your own keys you know do all these things it the reason why those are rallying cries in Bitcoin is because the Bitcoin protocol is not comprehensive enough or strong enough to build that into the base layer right. And so as a result the I see the social contract as compensation for the weaknesses of the code and so we have to actually rely on you know crypto banks to do our services for us.
And the social contract is like the force against this reminding people about why we are here reminding people about what our values should be. But I think it would be more scalable and more sustainable if we didn't actually have to rely on the social contract and the values of these systems were completely part of the DNA of the protocol. And so any I see any and the metaphor we use Ryan Ryan use is a priest right like a priest of the system a somebody that people go to for insight and leadership. But we saw in the hey day of the church that the priest just claimed that they were the messengers of God when really they were just some dudes who were capturing like the audience of their local region and then extorting them for their whatever you know their Sunday donations right.
And and priest would like lie and say like only I can speak to God that's why you guys have to listen to me. And I can kind of see that similar role of Bitcoin banks right where they say you don't have to actually speak to the Bitcoin blockchain you can just speak to me when instead it's a capturing and coercive system and I see that as a weakness of the Bitcoin blockchain. And so Ethereum tries and fixes these problems with things like smart contract wallets or or you know sharding and all these things that allow for maximal decentralization it's taking away the role of religion and trust and just having to have these these priest leaders remind ourselves what the values of the system are because the values of the system are more closely baked in.
How do you feel about that take. I think I think we're conflating two issues there so the first is in my opinion the social contract is always center and it the protocol can't take the role of the social contract because the social I mean the so if there's no social contract for example against or that that says what the protocol should do. Then just it should it would be trivial to just change the protocol and they ever change the social contract but that's not how it works so there needs to be. There must be a community of people who strongly believe in the same values and the same things that the protocol should do and that's that's the whole way that we uphold.
So basically the values of the protocol that's why we all converge on the same rules that because we all believe in the same things that the protocol should do. So that's why I think the protocol is always is always an implementation of the social contract that brings us to the second part. So if you have a social contract and you have a protocol to implement it then the question is how well can the protocol implement the social contract. And the better it can implement it the more the more robust it probably is because let's say you have this yeah you have a social contract and it has two rules and you can enforce only one of those with the protocol and the other you have to enforce via social norms.
Social norms are much more malleable than the protocol that's why we invented these protocols in the first place because otherwise we could just do it. And so the question really is how well can the how well can the protocol implement the social contract in a way that is not malleable. That's where that's where I see the big strength of Ethereum because if the protocol is more expressive than the wish or the optimistic goal would be that we can automate or enforce more of the roots of the social contract via these kind of automated means of the protocol and we don't have to enforce them as much socially.
So yeah that's that's I think that mirrors exactly what you said about Bitcoin Bitcoin banks or Bitcoin being on a path to scale via custodial banks to a much larger degree maybe than Ethereum although that's totally up in the air. But I definitely see the advantage of having non custodial smart contracts take the roles of custodial banks so yeah that is definitely or that pretty much summarizes why or what I like so much about Ethereum in relation to Bitcoin. I just say, so that is the entire thesis for the bankless podcast like that's that's why we are on this quest to go bankless because you know we believe and I think that the you know members of the community crypto community believe some of them anyway that the social contract of Bitcoin is peer to peer right you know a peer to peer cash system was the title of the Bitcoin white paper right.
And like peer to peer means bankless right it's it's not trusting a central intermediary so David's point of like one of the problems with Bitcoin is that it requires that the members in Bitcoin kind of observe this social norms so like at once a year we all like withdraw all of our private keys from the exchanges to make sure that they have them right. That's an example of of that being preserved in more flimsy way and the Ethereum approach is basically like don't have crypto banks at all have transparent open money protocols DeFi protocols essentially where you can always see the balance of your crypto so their balance sheets are are completely transparent to you and you maintain custody of your funds.
So you can withdraw at any time as well so you don't have to get into these fractional reserve areas and I think you do believe that because you read this fantastic article you know why Bitcoin might not survive the Bitcoin standard. I wonder if that raised some eyebrows in the part part of the Bitcoin or community but can you talk about that a bit more we want to spend some time on that so why is it bad if Bitcoin custodial banks essentially start to become the main way that users interact with Bitcoin the asset and even with Bitcoin the network. Yeah, I feel like so I feel like Hasey like you know there's some Bitcoin or so you think it's great right Nick Carter might be among them.
That like custodial crypto banks doing the majority of transactions on Bitcoin that's a future that is appealing what do you think about that is there a problem with that vision. I mean so Nick is a realist and a pragmatist and I would call myself into that field as well so there's not really a way around the emergence of Bitcoin banks or just banks in general that hold Bitcoin and offer financial services for Bitcoin users. But the big risk in my opinion is that that eventually everything just happens everything happens on on this custodial banking layers and then you lose this you then you lose all the advantages that made Bitcoin special in the first place so the Bitcoin Bitcoin can enforce a different social contract and a non Bitcoin system could because the rules are enforced by the protocol.
But when the users don't use the protocol anymore then the system is vulnerable to the one in the exact same way that the traditional financial system is because then you you you still use a protocol but it's a different protocol it's a protocol that is subject to the loss and regulations of wherever it operates. So some people argue against that as long as you can withdraw to the base layer still and basically like let's say one country shuts down all the Bitcoin banks and then everyone would panic and they would withdraw their money to hold their own keys and continue to operate on the base layer.
This is not possible because once Bitcoin has grown to the size where let's say I don't know 15 even even just 50 to 100 million people use Bitcoin via banks if those people all wanted to withdraw their coins to the base layer then it's it's already not possible because it's just the capacity of the system doesn't allow for it. So you lose this optionality you have this optionality decay of freedom pretty much where the users become locked into the higher systems because there are now too many users to withdraw to the lower level. I see that as a big big problem and it doesn't just exist when the fees are too high and like I said there are too many users and they can't always draw to the base layer but you also have the opposite way so the fees are maybe too low on the base layer and it's the system is just that the base layer is very insecure then one way to one way to still transfer money and hold funds safely is just be holding the same amount of BTC on the bank ledger.
So the bank ledger would then effectively replace the Bitcoin the ledger of the Bitcoin base layer. So in my mind and maybe this is my Ethereum religiousness coming out but the logical conclusion is what the Ethereum blockchain is trying to achieve where an expressive base layer allows for individual banking services and for individuals to truly be their own bank. Am I right in concluding that that is the next logical step or am I missing something? No I mean that's that's why I like Ethereum I think it's it's I like the the other approach of doing it or taking a bit more risks with the base layer but at the for the potentially benefit of having more trustless additional layers because it's already clear that the base layer itself is not going to cut it for any kind of larger scale adoption we have today.
So we know that like we I think we have to take a holistic view let's just imagine so Bitcoin and Ethereum both have a hundred million active users. So how how does the system look at that size and if in Bitcoin the base layer plays only a very small role in serving these users then what does it really like what does having this very strict and very robust base layer even give you it does not automatically mean that the whole stack is robust. So I think it's it's a good approach to take or it's possible to take some trade-offs with the robustness of the base layer and allow for more expressiveness for example just to buy you the ability to extend more of that trust to higher layers.
So what do crypto banks look like when there you know hundreds and hundreds of thousands of users of these systems right and and a lot of these users are using these systems through crypto banks like do it what what they're because there's a lot of political significance to large crypto banks right like if Coinbase and Gemini go from just being an exchange to being a financial services in you know institutions. There they are domicile and physical nations they have a ton of data is it fair to say that these crypto banks at maturity when they have you know millions of users that they start to kind of look like the web to carcassians but in the in the crypto web three world.
And then what if that is true like what what's the relationship that these systems are going to have with nation states like how is a nation state going to perceive these these you know new financial institutions. I think that look exactly like the banks were today so we would just rebuild the existing financial system. So I don't think it matters very much that what the what the base layers do at that point so you have the banks that work like banks do today and and then they settle amongst each other every once a day or something. So I mean that that seems to be what the end state of the Bitcoin vision is even you know saffodine in his book the Bitcoin standard talks about the settlement layer Bitcoin being used by you know maybe a thousand banks and maybe maybe that's maybe that's generous.
I guess my question is is that a better world like it is was that the point of the the white paper in 2009 to create a new banking system that's based on you know a asset with 21 million in scarcity. We know where we are going at and it's I don't like people read so much into Bitcoin and the Bitcoin white paper and so Toshi never promised that Bitcoin would be a system that could be used by billions of people and could do other things that kind of that can fulfill all these promises that the Bitcoin community invented on top of them eventually. I'm not so sure that it is realistic that in like the next 50 years that we can fulfill even 20% of these promises you know Bitcoin and Ethereum by extension they might do a lot of good for the world but I mean they might not they might not be everything that is that is promised right it's not like they could support billions of users probably either.
And I love them could. So the DeFi version of a crypto bank is more or less make or down right where it is a crypto bank but it is a protocol is a crypto bank protocol and like the governance over these systems is defined by an asset that's tradable on the free market. And it largely offers a lot of the same services that we would expect a crypto bank to to offer right so credit and then savings and then you know using many different types of collateral and I expect there just to be even more financial services based on top of make or down into the future. And you wrote this art of this fantastic article which I hope everyone who is listening to this will read or has read called the future of money could be discretionary and so when we talk about how you know crypto banks real crypto banks you know physical crypto banks are kind of just you know the same boss new boss same as the old boss.
Do you see like make or down and protocols like make or down as the viable solution for these for actually bringing in a world that we are kind of hoping to imagine that is no new and sci fi and perhaps more fair and equitable. I wouldn't read too much yet into maker. I think it serves one aspect which is fully collateralized collateralized loans but it does not yet serve or it does not serve custody and it does not does not serve payments. So these would be I would see I would see those as the three big main things that banks do so banks give credit or create credit or monetize debt and they do payments and they do custody and only one of them is currently a self by maker but maker is the super interesting project in my opinion.
So your article the future of money could be discretionary it illustrates that you know discretion discretionaryness is also subjectivity right and part of in my opinion part of the DNA of all these systems Bitcoin and Ethereum. They're they're supposed to do their best to remove subjectivity out of the protocol right and and the the Zabo idea is that you know any amount of subjectivity is a weakness when it comes to scaling these systems out to their to their maximal degree. At the same time maker doubt is a protocol and when you know submit collateral there is no credit scoring there is no you know utility bills there is no government ID so to some degree subjectivity has been removed but to what degree do you think that like the subjective governance over the parameters of maker doubt is a hindrance on its ability to scale.
Yeah that's a that's a very good question so I think for a system like maker it's it's a kind of it's a tight walk because of course the system is more available to to borrow us the more types of collateral you can use for example so. Including we were type of collateral that is like like let's say used to see whether it's really an issue that that sits in a regulated environment. Whereas for the holders for the holders it could be better that if the type of collateral is more trustless so you can have these two streams going up against each other but of course they would also like liquidity so.
You kind of need to balance these different interests against each other but I'd also like looking back at that article I I kind of mixed up to interest that could have been maybe two articles because it mixes up basically a discretionary or like a flexible money supply and a system that that is controlled by. Well basically by humans or not by by algorithms and it I think it made a very strong point that you can have systems with a flexible money supply like maker so it is that it is possible to to target the price stable money for example. Because I feel like that's not really something that the crypto community a large policing so they think like price targeting is always a scam or something or it's always something that requires.
I'm not really sure what they think but in general that just the benefit of price stability is doesn't get a lot of credit whereas I think. When you say they think it's like fragile well also the target of the price itself requires some sort of subjective opinion as to what that target actually is right like so the CPI for them for the federal reserve is a human generated metric that we have decided is valuable at targeting that's a great point yeah exactly. So I think they don't they look at the entire stack of what it takes to make a flexible money or price targeting money and they think it can be abused in too many ways and that might be true.
But the more we learn about automating the kind of steps that it takes to keep a money price stable I think the more interesting these ideas become and that's that's where I gave the basically that's where I showed how you can keep a money price stable entirely by implementing positive and negative interest rates so. That that part of the article was was actually picked up by JP Konig was a finance blogger someone that I I love to read and he he turned this into a smaller article about how central banks should. Or like how people should not be afraid of negative interest rates because they're not necessarily something unnatural or anything because if you look at if you look at derivatives exchanges today like.
They're a bit or a bit makes or fdx the only way that their. The perpetual swap contracts track the spot price is via these continuous funding payments so you always have one side of the market paying the other that encourages more people to go along or to go short. And that is the exact same thing that happens if you have a money that you want to make price stable so you also set a target and then you just continually rebalance the supply like the demand to go along those are the holders of the money so the holders of die for example and the demand to go short those are the borrowers people draw die against collateral so they are the short side.
And just by implementing this you can create a price stability without any discretion so that's so that's that was basically the first part that could have been abstracted out of the article but it also looks at what maker can maybe learn from. Well, I guess both what central banks can learn from from maker, but also what maker can learn from existing monetary policy options of central banks. And if you just look at yeah. Oh, well, if you just look at what. Oh, good. And we find that they use the exact same options that central banks are also using so they can use open market operations so they can they can print.
They can print maker for example and buy back die from the market to burn it so that's one thing that they can do. They can they can print die and then they can buy either to back the die so they those would be one way to remove die from the market and one way to push die onto the market so those are those are two options and I think like I'm not 100% sure but I believe those are also two things that maker has done in the past when it was under less scrutiny than it is today and nowadays. I think they really don't want to be labeled the bank so I guess they stay away from that for now. But the other is a very underrated option so what maker does is it allows more types of collateral and it changes basically the the worthiness of this collateral as well.
It can say how how much money can be borrowed against this form of collateral based on its implied volatility usually. And that is that is one option that that is super key to the central banking system or to the banking system that we have today but that most people never talk about is the collateral policy of central banks. So the central banks also control the amount of credit in the economy very strongly by allowing and disallowing a different forms of collateral that banks can accept to give credit. So what's interesting to me about that article in particular so you talked about this convergence between you know stablecoin and DeFi and central banking right you said within the next five years we'll see a major central bank higher stablecoin designer and a stablecoin system higher famous central bank economist right so there's this convergence and it does feel to me like even giving you what you said there's sort of a fork in the road for maker.
It can either go in the direction of removing some subjectivity right and going in the direction of something that's more algorithmic in terms of a stabilizing price but there's some trade offs there maybe usability is a trade off because you have to get into you know negative negative interest rates for for the money and people aren't used to that they might not like that there's usability trade off. And then on the other the other fork and like side of the fork is they could become a bit more central bank like and start and the inevitable conclusion of that is you know play that out and you're doing open market operations like the Fed basically.
So I mean do you see it as a fork in the road for these DeFi protocols they either become like a bit more protocol like through their governance process or they become a bit more like a like a traditional. I'm not sure if I see it as a fork in the road I it's so the one reason my makers I think it's super attractive to central bankers and to economists is is the reason that it crypto is such an amazing microcosm for monetary experiments and just monetary policy options. So if you work at a central bank today and like you have learned you have you have learned all these different ways that you can potentially manipulate basically monetary policy to get one outcome on the other in terms of achieving your mandate then these are all conjecture really like we don't have a ton of ways to test these.
But like if if I was working there then it would be super fascinating to me to go into a space where I can actually implement and test these things in a free market environment where people like willingly adopt a coin and then you have competition of the best ways to manage that currency. I just think that that's probably one of the most fun things that you can do. But at the same time, central bankers are very aware of the kind of negative influence you could say that a lack of political independence from governments creates. So there is a branch in monetary economics that is called algorithmic central banking so that there is not something that crypto invented because I mean central bankers would also like to make less like some of these rules that they would like to invent rules.
Sort of like automatic trigger so when when that happens to certain key parameters in the economy, then we do this policy and then when the policy is such an effect it stops so on so these are just algorithms and the problem the problem for some central banks is that they can't credibly commit to these algorithms because they always they the answer sort of tight to the political or they are tied and depend on the political moods of whoever's in charge in the country and and also, you know, the what the actual people think about their policy. So I see crypto as a really interesting way to experiment with commitment devices.
So a commitment device is just you you commit to a something that allows you to commit to a certain algorithm or certain policy and then stick with it. And then you can credibly say I can't change this my hands are tied so a smart contract without an admin key would be one way to do this. That's why I don't necessarily see it as a fucking road but I see it as more of a convergence so the two the two will become one where I think crypto will attract a lot of central bankers. Because of the experiments that can be run here just because of how well their knowledge applies but then what crypto does for central banking is like popularizing commitment devices and removing the ability for governments and the tyranny of the masses to influence central bank policy.
How's it getting your perspective on bankless has been super valuable and before we let you go we need to talk about of course EIP one five five nine. And if I could challenge you in in a way can I get you to in a concise way and the most concise way as possible wrap up and summarize the significance and impact of EIP one five five nine upon the Ethereum nation. Like what if you had to boil it down in its most simplistic form how does it materially impact the Ethereum nation. No it's very hard to be concise about this because of how central this kind of this changes to Ethereum it touches on so many different things and that's just that's just the nature of how central the block size of the block space sorry market is for any blockchain.
EIP one five five nine is it's just small handful of lines of code but it's it's implications would be pretty big so for me personally I mean everyone sees a different thing in it but I see four I see four benefits of the proposal so the first is it it implements or creates a better UX for users when interacting with the block space market. So the way that works right now is everyone submits a transaction together with a bit for inclusion and that bit is the transaction fee but the problem is you don't know you don't know how much is actually needed to get into a block. So because minus just include everyone's transactions basically they just perpetually fill blocks with transactions and then hash them to to search for the golden ones but you don't know how much others are going to bid so you always like if you want to get in perfectly you're probably going to bid more than the people already bid and then others see that and bid even higher and.
It's just like this these these kind of models are quite first price options and they are. They are quite inefficient in terms of translating like they actually the actual preference of users to get into a block. And to pay and paying like a reasonable amount of money and the way that yep you want five five nine changes this is it implements a a fixed price sale so a fixed price sale is when you go to Amazon and you see an item and that has a certain price and you can just decide to buy it or not and that's what one of five nine will do also so you could you would just decide on the spot if you want to get in or not and the way that it the way that it does this is by implementing a new type of fee so instead of one fee there would be two types of fees and the first is called the base fee and the second is called tip the base fee is set by the protocol and is burned so it does not go to minus and the second is the tip tip goes to minus and in the next step we have two we don't have the single rigid block size cap anymore but we actually two block size cap so we have the we have the target block size which is 10 million gas and then we have the new maximum block size which is twice the amount so it's it's 20 million gas.
And blocks and no long blocks no longer have to be 10 million they can also exceed the the the previous maximum so they can be higher than 10 million for a period of time so it can be if minus one they can mine up to 20 million. And guesswork of blocks blocks blocks of gas sorry but it's only possible for a short period of time because if you look back to what we talked about with maker and how you govern stability or how you can basically price target a money and how this is very similar to derivatives exchanges and the way that they get price stability of perpetual swap against this spot the spot price of an asset they do this with these kind of continuous funding payments and EIP 159 is actually not that different from that because you also have a target so you have a block size an average block size that you want to target which is 10 million gas and then you have this you have this payment for transactions.
This payment for transactions which is the base fee which the protocol can control and the higher like the larger the blocks are the higher the base fee goes and that eventually creates a downward pressure on the size of the blocks so if you mine one block then that's that's let's say 20 million gas then the base would increase if you mine another would increase further and so on so it always increase relative to what it was before. And so the base fee would just continue to go up and then eventually when there are no more transactions that are willing to pay the price then maybe we can mine smaller blocks again and when you mine blocks below 10 million gas that's when the block size that's when the base fee starts to go down starts to normalize.
And the fact that we always target 10 million gas but there's 20 million of capacity that is what ensures the fixed price say because there is always extra capacity available it's just that it is the base fee that governs how frequently the how frequently the access capacity is used that makes sense. Because there's always extra capacity you can always be sure that you get in at the fixed price if you want to. I mean, that's like a very thorough explanation of EIP 1559 I don't know that I've heard such a thorough explanation right so it's clear that you have dug deeply into it one of the implications I think in your article he's one of my takeaways was the burning of the part of ether in these transactions actually makes the Ethereum to monetary policy.
You know that that was a huge takeaway for me I guess now you dove into this so deeply what's your takeaway on the implications for investors like are did it make you more or less bullish on the asset. I see 1559 as super positive for a theorem like if I am super in favor of it being implemented after I reviewed it so I think it's very hard to disentangle the how how well the different benefits we only touched on one of them right so we touched on the better UX for transactions but there's also we briefly touched on the other one so we now target an average block size rather than a fixed block size and that allows more flexibility in the block size but without creating an additional burden for people who want to validate which is very important.
But then there's also the benefit of better security and preventing economic abstraction and it's it's very hard to say how much each of those were impact the price of ether or just the market sentiment just looking at I guess looking at at at how the Ethereum community talks about the proposal so very few people talk about the fixed price sale which is which is probably my favorite part and very like a lot of people talk about the secured why not even about the security aspect I guess that's also this so what for me is like it's a security benefit most people just see it's okay the monetary policy of it is going to improve because you now have this because the base fees burned and it's the base fees 99% or something of all the fees that I'm going to do.
I'm going to be paid because the base fees burn that's created deflation every pressure on the ether coin supply and that's I guess that that is the main benefit that I read when I read about like other articles on ERP one of five of nine. But I think that it's really the synthesis of all these benefits that that is very very beneficial. It was awesome to get you to take a look at EIP 1559 thank you for doing it thank you for all of your work in the space. So you've written a fantastic body of knowledge I think both David and I consider you one of the the free thinkers that kind of bridges multiple communities and honestly talks common sense and rationality to each of them and is not afraid to push back on the religious conjecture.
You know another piece I'll just mention was a piece you wrote will include in the show notes about your future projections of Bitcoin's security that was I think you wrote with that with James pet press which and that was another you know instrumental. It's an article article for me in understanding Bitcoin into the future and transaction security went once issuance runs out so guys we will include many of Hossu's articles in the show notes so you have access to that at the ready. I've got to ask you one last question before we go so you have chosen an anonymous student anonymous identity online and it is this Morty with an eye patch from Rick and Morty so I have assumed all of this time that you are a Rick and Morty fan are you indeed sir a Rick and Morty fan.
Why do you pick the Morty with the eye patch I guess he's my he's my favorite character from the show my I mean my favorite episode is the Rick Lentus mix up which is I think it's season three. It's a great. It's a great. Just the way that it has these different layers and different story lines that all pay off in the end in a really nice way. Yeah that's I think that's one of the best episodes in TV period right and of course it prominently features even Morty. You've got me hungry for some Rick and Morty I think I might do some bench tonight actually have to get caught up on season four I've got like two more episodes left and yeah it's a great show does feels like it does keep getting better but I'm waiting for their like it's it's always you know sci fi something right when are they going to do the sci fi crypto have they touched on anything with respect to like money in some of these sci fi civilizations I don't think I've seen that yet.
They did once they they had one episode where the empire invaded earth and I'm not sure what what haven't exactly but someone I think Rick hacked into their computer. Rick made the money of the system worth one of something to worth zero of something and then everyone's everyone started blowing blowing like shooting themselves. Rick was dead. That was definitely a jack at Fiat money at least I read it that way. Yeah I recall that now now that you guys are mentioning I worry that they'll do an episode on like crypto and you know Rick will find some way to like beat the Bitcoin blockchain and destroy mutability.
We'll send the wrong message. On the one hand I on one hand it's always nice when show us include references to Bitcoin. I've never really read it at the same time. Yeah it's never really satisfying. When it actually happens. Yeah it always makes the show like if you like to show previously it just makes it look. Yeah absolutely well Hasey this has been fantastic. We appreciate you being here thanks thanks for everything you do. Oh thanks for having me guys. Alright guys this has been Hasey I hope you enjoyed this episode. Some action items I think guys a real big action item is to check out some of Hasey's body of work.
We will include some of our favorite articles in the action items. So that's number one. Number two is go check out the episode that we did on ether scarcity. That talks about 1559 why we're also bullish on this change in ether's monetary policy. That's really what it is. We'll include that as the second action item. And third David I haven't checked in the last week or two. How are we doing on the five star reviews sir. Hey we're doing pretty good but we still want to do better. I think we have 60 or so five star reviews. So if you guys could push that up into the 70s and 80s. We are still not showing up when you type in crypto or Bitcoin or Ethereum into the iTunes podcast search.
And so those five star reviews are how we get there. So thank you for those that have given us those five star reviews. And if you are yet to do so please do that. It really really helps us reach more ears reach a bigger bankless audience. Cool. And last announcement is actually David you and I started a video podcast. Well a video cast are publishing on YouTube we're also publishing on this stream as well. Can you tell folks about that. Yeah we are doing the state of the nation every Tuesday. So you guys can actually look at the charts look at the data look at the tweets that we are talking about.
So if you guys are into video content if you guys are on YouTube you can find the state of the nation on the bankless YouTube. And then it will also be released as a podcast version on the stream as well because why not. But really the substance is the video that is on YouTube. All right guys that's it from us risk and disclaimers crypto is risky folks DeFi is risky we talked about EIP 1559. That could cause some risk to you could lose what you put in this is crypto we are headed west though this is the frontier. It's not for everyone but we are glad you are with us on the bankless journey thanks a lot.