Cryptodollars are the new Eurodollars. What are Eurodollars, though? Well, we get into that in today’s episode with 8-time repeat Bankless guest, Nic Carter. Nic is a partner at Castle Island Ventures, Fidelity alumni, co-founder and board member of Coin Metrics, and a prolific writer of editorials and academic articles alike, Nic is also a believer that the halvening is always priced in, he’s a stablecoin connoisseur, an onchain wizard, and an unlicensed vespa driver.
------ ✨ DEBRIEF | Ryan & David unpacking the episode: https://www.bankless.com/debrief-nic-carter-stablecoins
There’s over $10 trillion dollars worth of Cryptodollars out there and Nic believes that number could grow even bigger. Stablecoins are often called crypto’s killer app, however, Nic thinks we aint seen nothing yet!
----- 🏹 Airdrop Hunter is HERE, join your first HUNT today https://bankless.cc/JoinYourFirstHUNT
------ 📣 a16z Startup School | Apply Before Oct. 20th https://bankless.cc/a16z-startup-school
------ BANKLESS SPONSOR TOOLS:
🐙KRAKEN | MOST-TRUSTED CRYPTO EXCHANGE https://k.xyz/bankless-pod-q4
🦊METAMASK PORTFOLIO | MANAGE YOUR WEB3 EVERYTHING https://bankless.cc/MetaMask
⚖️ ARBITRUM | SCALING ETHEREUM https://bankless.cc/Arbitrum
🗣️TOKU | CRYPTO EMPLOYMENT SOLUTION https://bankless.cc/Toku
🦄UNISWAP | ON-CHAIN MARKETPLACE https://bankless.cc/uniswap
🔗 CELO | CEL2 COMING SOON https://bankless.cc/Celo
------ TIMESTAMPS
0:00 Intro 8:25 Stablecoin Tribe 10:20 The State of Stablecoins in 2023 13:40 Stablecoin’s Product Market Fit 17:16 Stabelcoin Haters 19:00 Growth of the Euro-Dollar Market 21:04 Euro vs. Crypto Dollars 24:30 Federal Reserve History 34:45 Stablecoin Incentives 37:00 Euro-Dollar vs. U.S.-Dollar Backing 43:00 Circle 45:40 PYUSD 46:56 Crypto-Dollars vs. Euro-Dollars 51:15 Why the Rise of Stablecoins? 55:57 Democratic Inclusion of Crypto-Dollarization 59:19 Chart 1:03:05 Tokenized Treasury 1:07:16 Regulatory Idea Maze 1:15:00 Big Banks 1:19:30 Stablecoin Roadmap 1:24:57 Crypto Bullishness 1:28:52 Stablecoin Predictions 1:32:12 Closing & Disclaimers
----- RESOURCES
Nic Carter https://twitter.com/nic__carter
----- Not financial or tax advice. See our investment disclosures here: https://www.bankless.com/disclosures
No summary for this episode yet.
Give us some of your predictions, right? And over the next three to five years, what's going to happen, do you think, in the world of stable coins? Welcome to Bankless, where we explore the frontier of internet money and internet finance. This is how to get started, how to get better, how to front-run the opportunity. This is Ryan Sean Adams, and I'm here with David Hoffman, and we're here to help you become more bankless. Crypto Dollars are the new Euro Dollars. Okay, but what are Euro Dollars? We get into that in today's episode with Nick Carter. There's over $10 trillion of Euro Dollars out there, and our guest today, Nick, says Crypto Dollars are going to be even bigger.
While stable coins are often called Crypto's Killer App, our guest Nick says you ain't seen nothing yet. A few takeaways in today's episode. Number one, why Crypto Dollars are growing even in the bear market. Number two, how Crypto Dollars are playing back the history and evolution of Euro Dollars, and what we can learn from all that. Number three, how the US government policies actually pushing Crypto Dollars off shore. Number four, the road map for stable coins, what's going to happen next. And number five, we conclude with Nick Carter's top predictions for the next five years of Crypto Dollars, including his take on whether Crypto Dollar adoption is going to be good or bad for Ethereum and Bitcoin.
That's a question we had to end with, David, is this good or bad for our bags? Why was this episode significant to you? Why this episode is significant is the same as asking, well, why are Crypto Dollars significant? And of course, using Crypto Dollars as interchangeable with what we know as stable coins. Euro Dollars, therefore, Crypto Dollars, I think we talk about the semantics behind this conversation with Nick. Stable coins, Crypto Dollars, are an immense pillar of this industry. If there's one thing that Crypto has exported, it's Crypto Dollars. That's one of the biggest innovations that we have.
And this is something that we are going to rise in parallel with this technology that puts Crypto one foot in tradfie and one foot in crypto finance. And so I think this is going to be a massive pillar of innovation that we should definitely be tapping into. Because this is the way that all financial networks, bank networks inside of a nation state, all commercial banking layers inside of nation states get woven together by global blockchain infrastructure through Crypto Dollars, through stable coins. So this is one of the big stories of Crypto is we're all coming together as a population. One, global population under the same financial fabric.
And this is the story of Crypto Dollars starting to weave that fabric together first and foremost. And so understanding the growth of this parallel industry that we are creating, we are supporting, I think is very valuable to understanding just overall where Crypto is going as a whole. Yeah, they're going to be a big deal. And it's kind of ironic in that, Crypto was here to kill Fia. No, actually, it's here to export to the world. And also kill at the same time, how do we square these realities? So we talk about that with Nick, a fantastic episode for you. But before we get into that episode, first we disclose, David and I have nothing material to disclose.
In today's episode, there's always a link to our disclosures in the show notes. I own some stable coins, but yeah. Do we own the large supply of stable coins? Would we have to disclose that? I don't think so. Do they go up? We own some stable coins. Anyway, you can see all the disclosures at all times, bankless.com slash disclosures. We're going to get right to this episode. But before we do, we want to thank the sponsors that made this possible, including our number one recommended exchange and our favorite place to exchange crypto dollars for crypto. Kraken, go check them out. Kraken Pro has easily become the best crypto trading platform in the industry.
The place I use to check the charts and the crypto prices, even when I'm not looking to place a trade. On Kraken Pro, you'll have access to advanced charting tools, real-time market data, and lightning fast trade execution. All inside, there's spiffy new modular interface. Kraken's new customizable modular layout. Let's you tailor your trading experience to suit your needs. Pick and choose your favorite modules and place them anywhere you want in your screen. With Kraken Pro, you have that power. Whether you are a seasoned pro, or just starting out, join thousands of traders who trust Kraken Pro for their crypto trading needs.
Visit pro.krakken.com to get started today. Metamask Portfolio is your one-stop shop to navigate the world of DeFi. And now bridging seamlessly across networks doesn't have to be so daunting anymore. With competitive rates and convenient routes, Metamask Portfolio's bridge feature lets you easily move your tokens from chain to chain, using popular layer one and layer two networks. And all you have to do is select the network you want to bridge from and where you want your tokens to go. From there, Metamask vets and curates the different bridging platforms to find the most decentralized, accessible, and reliable bridges for you.
To tap into the hottest opportunities in crypto, you need to be able to plug into a variety of networks and nobody makes that easier than Metamask Portfolio. Instead of searching endlessly through the world of bridge options, click the bridge button on your Metamask extension, or head over to Metamask.io slash Portfolio to get started. Bankless Nation, Nick Carter is a partner at Castle Island Ventures, a Fidelity alumni, co-founder and board member of Coinmetrics, a prolific writer of editorials and academic articles alike. Nick is also a believer that the happening is always priced in. He's a stablecoin connoisseur, an on-chain wizard, an unlicensed Vespa driver, and a great achievement of all, and eight times repeat guests of the Bankless podcast.
Nick, welcome back. Wow, thank you, thank you. I'm trying to, I'm the number, I think two guests on what Bitcoin did. Also apparently number two on Bankless, so. This is correct, yeah. We want to go for more appearances on Bankless than Peter McCormack. So that's the goal, guys. Wait, so you're number two on what Bitcoin did? Who's number one? I think Lyn Alden. Lyn Alden, I think it's number one. Oh, well, well, this is her. She's gonna call it Lyn Alden's correct. You are only succeeded on Bankless by Vitalik Puderin. Oh, she's a 14, so you have some work to do. You guys did one's point blank.
Ask me if I was an Ethereum. And that was episode number two. Oh, no one. That was the first episode. I squirmed under that question. Yeah, you did. You really did. Yeah, I think my answer probably changed over time. Yeah, actually Nick, are you an Ethereum? In all meaningful senses of that term, for sure. Yeah, it's amazing. Let's clip all Nick's answers together across the eight M's. Let's always ask that question at the beginning of every Nick Carter episode. You guys, my most infamous podcast moment ever was on this show. Yes. You guys really screwed me with that one. Yeah. But to the corners, they wrote songs and albums.
No way. They wrote all. There's someone wrote a song about it. I didn't listen to it. I miss this part of it. They loved to go in my reply, guys. Love to talk about stars rising. Mm-hmm. It was a cheesy line that has absolutely stood the test of time for you. It was a incredible line. Now I have this burden where I have to keep, like, I don't know, crushing it, whatever it is, whatever star rising is. Yeah, you saw how to always be rising. I have to stop rising. I have to stop, literally, perpetually rise. So I've only started. That's what I have to do now. Well, you know what, this episode will be another example of Nick Carter's start rising.
And we're not talking about, what are we talking about today? Not Bitcoin Maxwellism, we're talking about stablecoins. Yeah, so you're a long introduction of many, many titles. We're going to pull apart one particular tribe, the stablecoin connoisseur. This is the title, the version of Nick that we're bringing onto the show today. All right. I was actually making a list of these people, like stablecoin people I really like. There's like a half dozen, but our numbers are growing. Like people that just love stablecoins. Right. You have the stablecoin tribe. Yeah. Yeah, yeah, yeah. Okay. These are people I really respect on stablecoins.
Peter Johnson, of course, my fellow stablecoin loving VC has vocal, if not more vocal, than me on stablecoins historically. I mean, Solomoni, who has been an innovator in stablecoins. I should definitely shout out the kind of maker die people just like as a general category. And then as far as thinkers are concerned, Antony Lewis, he used to write a great blog, cover it, had some great insights on stablecoins. Luca Prasperi has a great sub stack. He's also builder in stablecoins. JP Koning, I'm sure you guys are familiar with his work. He's sort of on the outside looking in. So I would say more of a cryptocratic, but also really stellar work on stable.
Many rink on cruise, also excellent writing on stable. Austin Campbell, who I think you guys are familiar with, who's like my stablecoin guru. So those are like my stablecoin thinkers where I get all my ideas from basically. Yeah, and the stablecoin tribe has definitely grown in strengths. It's interesting to call it a tribe because usually tribes are reserved for like native layer one assets and some layer two assets, but the stablecoin cohort is definitely growing in strength. And like I said, this is going to be the focus of this episode today. stablecoins have always been in the limelight ever since inception.
It's always been a fascinating topic of discussion, especially as they've gone from just like something new to something core to crypto. But even lately, throughout 2023, it seems to be a particularly shining bright star, if you will. Lately, rising star. Rising star. Yeah, their star of stablecoins continues to rise. So Nick, maybe you could provide us with a little bit of a snapshot of just your perception as to the state of stablecoins in 2023 as it relates to our industry and just global concerns. Yeah, I mean, from the perspective of VC, I think I could just do stablecoins for the next year, stablecoin deals.
And there would be enough there. So on the kind of entrepreneur capital raising allocation side, I see enough there to just feast on. So that's very exciting. But from the outside looking in, you might be thinking, well, hang on, the stablecoin market gap is shrinking. The stablecoin sector is beleaguered. You know, it went from depending on whether you count UST, I don't know if I would count UST. But if you do, it went from 185 bill to 125 bill. So it lost a full 50 bill in market cap. So you might be thinking, okay, well, stablecoins are over. It's all about Fed now. You know, stablecoins are in the past.
But the actual underlying metrics actually look really good. So like you, like actual usage, whether that's transaction count, monthly active or dollar value transmitted on chain. And importantly, it's also decoupled from sort of exchange volumes from the proxies for speculation that we see. I mean, I don't really like that word speculation, but whatever for all the data driven proxies that we see reflecting sort of attention in crypto, whatever that is, those are declining. Stabilcoin usage appears to be basically growing. Stabilcoin volumes themselves like dollar value settled is roughly flat over the last two years, which obviously contrasted with sort of like aggregate prices and crypto is good.
Monthly active's are up. And also more importantly, we see these decoupling from stables just being used to settle with exchanges, you know, just being this liquidity for exchanges or liquidity for DeFi. We see it as now an independent global settlement rail, where a lot of the usage of stables has very little to do with crypto itself. There's kind of like broader like, you know, hot ball of money crypto economy. And depending on your perspective, I mean, you know, some people might say, may not like that, but I think as far as selling crypto to the outside audience, that's a very powerful and important thing.
Because we've never really been able to plausibly claim, hey, there's some actual utility for making blockchain based transactions that is in some way decoupled from the broader speculative casino in crypto. We're starting to see it. Like we're really meaningfully seeing hermitters embracing it, global payment systems, embracing stables, you know, mobile money apps, embracing them. This we see very earnestly, it's very real. It's happening globally, in virtually every jurisdiction. And to me, that's a very exciting thing. We can dig into kind of the numbers a little bit. But yeah, I think we're like, it's a really key moment to gonna sell the value proposition of public blockchain based transactions to the broader public.
Yeah, so I guess a couple thoughts on that, Nick. So you say stablecoin in terms of total value or, you know, a number of billions in stablecoins is actually down, but other usage metrics are up, which is interesting. And I wanna ask what kind of usage metrics are most important. But maybe I guess I'll kind of ask a question about what do you think that stablecoins are cryptos, one of cryptos killer apps, like one of its use cases where it has found product market fit. I was actually just interacting with somebody in traditional finance and we were going on a kind of a little bit of a road trip.
I was driving one of my kids to a sports event. And he was asking about crypto, you have a crypto podcast, like tell me about it, I don't know very much about it. What are the use cases? And I found myself talking a little bit about store value, right? Kind of like think about gold, right? Where did gold's value come from? Mimetic value and what is actually money anyway in all of these things, right? So that's the common store value type case. But the most persuasive use case that popped into my mind and the one that was most compelling was actually the stablecoin use case. It's think of you are an Argentinian and your bank system is failing you, both from an inflationary perspective.
So the local fiat currencies failing you and then the banking system in general has capital controls. So it sets a limit on how much you can actually withdraw and how much commerce you can do and who you can do commerce with and that sort of thing. And so stablecoins in parallel to a store value are a killer use case for someone in an environment like that or take Turkey or take all sorts of emerging economies with less robust banking sectors than we have here in the West. And I found myself relying on that as kind of this is an example of crypto's killer use cases. This is why we are still here.
Do you think that is overselling it or do you think that apart from store value the kind of it's the second product market fit that we can honestly point to and say, hey, this is something that works and is good for the world and is useful. I mean, I think it's the first thing that we've done that has real product market cases, frankly. In 2020 I think I called it, I wrote this white paper I called them crypto dollars and I called it a killer app of crypto. And I mean, the difference is that I think it's very easy unless someone is strongly ideologically disposed against non-bank transactions occurring these people exist and they generally stablecoin haters.
Unless that is their ideological framework, virtually anyone can be made to see the value proposition of stablecoins which is final settlement digitally, instantly cross-border, natively interoperable, natively composable, public ledger, read right access, everybody has access to. I think that is a very clear and compelling story for almost anyone on the planet. The kind of store value digital gold, Bitcoin ether story, that's something that a large fraction of the world's population I think will never acknowledge or understand or truly internalize. That's a much more difficult story. That's one that'll play out over decades.
The utility of stablecoins is apparent today to anybody that's, you know, had to sign a bank wire internationally or anything like that. I have a hard time making a matching there are stablecoin haters. Why would someone hate a stablecoin and does the same individual who hates a stablecoin also not use fiat dollars in their bank account? Do they not pay utility bills or paid taxes? Or what's the take from a stablecoin haters? Is this a group that's more exclusive to crypto and not found outside of crypto circles? No, I mean, these people exist in Washington. There's a cohort of people that think that all transactions should be the purview of the state and thus they should be mediated by banks, which are basically banks for public private partnerships so they're effectively an arm of the state and we see this very clearly this year with the what I call operation choke point 2.
0 where the banks were very clearly deputized for political purposes. And so if you think, if you basically reject the notion of financial privacy or you think only the state itself can create financial privacy, some people do believe that. So if you think transacting financially should be solely a kind of a public concern and not a private concern, you may really disdain stablecoins. These kinds of people tend to also be against fintech broadly and they call stablecoins counterfitting or they'll point to the sketchiness of tether like say that it's a vehicle for money laundering. But yeah, there's like a cohort of people out there that really, really dislike the notion of stablecoins because these are typically private non-bank entities.
They're effectively fintechs that are opening up this brand new transactional space. And so for some people that's totally against the world view as people make sort of unencumbered transactions. One of the things that we say about Bitcoin, Ethereum, DeFi, crypto at large is that they're largely misunderstood by the outside world. And we say the most bullish thing about crypto is to be understood. And I think that can extend to stablecoins. Even though stablecoins kind of straddle old world and new world, old fi and DeFi, there's still something that raises the heckles of people coming from the old world.
Like, oh, that's the new Wild West. I don't like those kinds of stablecoins. It's fake money printing, et cetera. But I think that comes from a place of lack of understanding of just simple global economics in dollar demand and also history lessons that we've seen play out over time. And Nick, you gave this talk at token 2049, which is a bit of the inspiration for some of the focus here on this episode. I'm wondering if you can kind of run through the parallels of the growth of the Euro dollar market because I think that is just a logical history is rhyming continuation of what we see with the rise of the crypto dollar market.
I think understanding this would allow people to, I think understand that you guys see a crypto dollar as a pretty inevitable and we should embrace them. Yeah, and this is why I called them crypto dollars as a direct callback to Euro dollars. So that was a really clear attempt to make the analogy. We tried to join you with bankless for a while, but we raised the rise of that. No, because stablecoin is, I call it a skew of morphic term because we only have the term stablecoin because we were starting from sort of native crypto. And so then we called the thing a coin and we called it stable as a contrast to sort of like unstable crypto.
But I totally hate the term. I think it scares people. And putting stable in the name is also, I think mistake because occasionally these things will try to discount for like genuine market driven reasons. And so then people will assume that means the whole system is failed. When really it's just the market playing and doing what the market does. Like the deep pegs for a second does that mean the system's a failure because the name presupposes one thing and then it's to, you know, so. For a photo-sworth, if we're gonna go down this one little rabbit hole, I've always appreciated Rai as a stablecoin.
Rai, the thing that fluctuates around a dollar but is free to fluctuate around a dollar and can sometimes be plus 30% negative 30%. That's a stablecoin. And if it's a tokenized dollar, then it's a crypto dollar. Yeah, totally. It's all about expectations management. And it's funny that like central bank is just hate on the stable. So like, oh, these things aren't really stable. It's like, well, but that's not even strictly what we're trying to achieve. We're trying to tokenize a dollar of liability held by some issuer and facilitate trade globally. Like that's what we're trying to do. You know, we don't need this thing religiously pegged to want, they're not even really pegged to a dollar.
I mean, to other friends, since there's a redemption fee, you know, so that implies that it's not actually pegged to a dollar. Does that make sense? But so. Anyway, to dive down into the history, the semantics aside. Yeah, yeah. So, okay, your dollars stablecoins are tokenized your dollars for the most part, right? 75% and a couple percent are crypto backed and then mostly they're issued by offshore issuers. Of course, the element in the room is tether. I don't know what percentage that is. Like it's in the 60s. I think it's very meaningful. The biggest onshore one is circle. But circle is still issued by non bank entity.
Banks in the US are banned, really, from touching stablecoins, which is a huge tragedy and a big scandal, I think. But so. Wait, stablecoins already mean crypto dollars? Crypto dollars, yes. So, stablecoins themselves are mostly tokenized your dollars. They're also very much like your dollars. And, okay, so what's a your dollar? It's very simple. Your dollar is a bank liability that's issued by a bank that is not based in the US. That's really it. And this kind of emerged after World War II when people want to make dollar transactions internationally. And for whatever reason they didn't want to do that in the US.
One reason was they were concerned that the US would sort of arbitrarily freeze the assets for political reasons. So this is why Russia was actually initially one of the entities that was creating your dollars because there was the Cold War. And so they started creating dollar deposits, dollar liabilities in French banks. And I think one of the Josh Younger mentioned this on the Adlots podcast. And one of the first things that did was pay striking workers with those euro dollars. So, you know, they look and feel just like dollars. It's just they are issued by an offshore bank and they may not actually be backed by dollar collateral, which will become problematic later in the story.
Later on, more euro dollars were created because banks on opportunity to pay higher interest rates on those deposits and depositors like that, whereas in the US interest rates were actually capped for a while. So there's this kind of market driven reason the euro dollar market expanded. London became the center of this throughout the kind of the 50s and 60s. In the 70s, the oil shock occurred and the pound sterling stopped being the global reserve in the 50s, actually. And the oil trade began to take place in dollars. And so I'm really accelerating through history here, but what happened was the US started to worry a little bit because they'd been monitoring the euro dollar space.
Initially they didn't know what it was. Then they started to kind of go to Europe and try and figure out what was going on there. And they began to worry that all these dollar liabilities were being created without corresponding dollar assets and without the central banks themselves having access to dollar liquidity. And so the Fed ultimately decided to reconcile that by creating swap lines with these foreign central banks. So then the hierarchy was like local bank issues dollars, they would be able to get emergency dollar liquidity from their central bank. Their central bank would have a relationship with the Fed itself.
What was that kind of a formalization of the relationship between the United States economy and euro dollars? Yeah, I mean, the Fed made the, and really sort of the major Western central banks made the deliberate decision to kind of defend the euro dollar market because they saw that it was kind of getting off sides. And one thing I want to just put a opinion about the existence of the euro dollar market was that it's a, quote unquote, permissionless technology. As in there's no gatekeepers around who can issue a euro dollar, it is just simply an invention of the free market banks to issue dollar liabilities.
And because they're outside of the purview of the United States, there's no gatekeeper to say that. And so it's kind of a natural market demanded phenomenon that occurred throughout many banks across Europe. Is this correct? It's like a gray market almost. Yeah, precisely. So that's exactly it was a market derived phenomenon in response to real market need, which was dollar transactions globally. And then that eventually forced the hand of the Federal Reserve, just like, okay, this is a real market force. We're going to have to align with it rather than compete with it. Yeah, I mean, what they could have done was just deny the importance of the market and not create this dollar equity, which would have caused a financial crisis abroad.
So what they did do over the 60s progressively and then increasingly in the 70s was realize the importance of this market and the value of the market for the US except that they would have a loss of control but trade that for dollar stability globally. And for the fact that all these entities transactions transacting with dollars were buyers of the US debt, they were buyers of the treasuries. And so they basically formalized these relationships, created swap lines, opened up dollar liquidity. I mean, the swap line today is still a politicized thing, like not everyone has that access. It's kind of, if you're an ally of the US, you have pretty good dollar liquidity.
If you're a competitor, you don't. But so with their sort of partner nations, they created these swap lines and came to realize the value of the your dollar market. And today there's more your dollars than our dollar dollars. How much are we talking about, Nick? I mean, over 10 trillion your dollars, for sure. We don't know the exact number and that's another thing that kind of cracks me up. We know the quantity of stable coins to the nearest cent. But we stopped counting the euro dollars. We don't know. Importantly, just to double down on something you just said, there's more euro dollars in existence than actual dollars.
Yeah, I mean, because there's more money in the world outside the US than there is money in the US and the dollars are global reserve. It's 60% of official FX reserves. I think it's like 48% of international trade is booked in dollars. Something like 80% of all FX transactions have the dollars at least one leg. So by virtue of the fact the dollars of global reserve and the world is much bigger than just the US, there's more euro dollars than there are dollars. Is it the euro dollar nomenclature even incorrection and just be called global dollars or non-US dollars? Yeah, I mean, so obviously the creation of the euro dollars preceded the creation of the euro.
So it's something to do with the visa. I don't know, there's some like nomenclature reason, but it does have the funny conclusion that the euro prefix in your dollars just means a currency issued outside of the sort of domicile that currency. So a euro issued abroad would be called a euro euro, which is pretty amusing. Okay, so when we talk about euro dollars and crypto dollars, we're actually kind of talking about the same exact thing except for the fact that crypto dollars just happens on blockchains. Yeah, pretty much. I mean, some crypto dollars are issued in the US, in which case I wouldn't call them a euro dollar, but in the parallel, the obvious parallel is people are creating these things and using them because the original system is restricted in some way.
Like obviously you can't do a smart contract transaction using a bank wire, right? It may be one day you'll be able to. But so you can't get access to this transactional space, which is like a lucrative, important growing market with the legacy fiat system. You had to join the crypto dollar system to engage in crypto type transactions. And also the creation of crypto dollars was a direct reaction to the sort of like inherent politicization of the legacy financial infrastructure. Like the exact precise reason, the first crypto dollars were created, which was really tether, which is the first major one, was because Bitfinex had trouble banking.
And so all they had to do was find one bank that would do business with them. They'll, you know, persuade that bank to custody some dollar assets that they could issue dollar liabilities out of and then the dollar liabilities would freely trade so they could settle up with their clients. As opposed to maintaining bank relationships in every single country where every single one of their clients was domiciled. And if you guys remember back in the day, like Bitfinex is banked in Taiwan and they're getting chased out of there. And then there's a network of banks they were always trying to use. Crypto dollars changed the calculus where you just have to persuade a single bank to hold your dollar assets and reserve and create the liabilities based on those.
So it vastly simplifies the, you know, the ability to transact in crypto. So, you know, the creation of these things was a direct reaction to the kind of very controlled nature of the existing financial system, which is very analogous to your dollars. Right, yeah, very analogous to your dollars, except for the crux of the fact that eventually the Fed, the government, the United States, accepted your dollars and enshrined them formally. We haven't had that moment happen yet in crypto, but this is kind of what we are hoping for and predicting, right? Yeah, so this is the speculative part of my analogy, which is on a go-forward basis, I expect this will eventually occur and the US will realize they've lost control over the crypto dollar market, which they have.
That's been deliberate. They've wanted to lose control. They've wanted to push them abroad. So the reason why this sort of like key catalytic moment hasn't occurred yet is because crypto dollars are not yet systemically useful to the US. So the analysis I would do is if you look at where we are, if you pretend that crypto dollars have a gross trajectory like your dollars, we're in the equivalent of 1967. So if you take the your dollar supply in 67, you inflation adjust it to today, unless my math is wrong, you get to 130 billion, roughly. That's the supply of the stablecoins of the crypto dollars.
So in 67, it wasn't yet fully apparent that your dollars needed to be backstopped. By the US directly. So they were still kind of on the out and out. It was still in the skepticism phase. So basically the crypto dollar supply needs to grow, continue to grow and then make the case to the US that hey, you should actually embrace this thing as opposed to kind of harassing it. But maybe we don't need that. Maybe we don't need that. It just for me selfishly is it kind of the US, for a US individual, it would be nice if the US did do that. But meanwhile, like these things are happily growing and thriving abroad.
Why did the Federal Reserve, US government come to the conclusion that they needed to backstop the euro dollar? What was that conclusion? Because the Nixon shock occurred and this question emerged as to who was going to buy a debt, post gold standard. Then the oil shock happened I think in 73. And there is this huge, huge market all of a sudden for your dollars. And there is a worry that the oil market, that we wouldn't be able to get sufficient oil if we didn't support the US dollar market. So a lot of it had to do with kind of like the petro dollar. So I guess a few housekeeping items here because a lot of this is kind of new information to me or just, you know, it's past I haven't gone down very deeply.
So you're telling me that there are tens of trillions of euro dollars out there and would probably be more accurate to call these like global dollars because they're not all necessarily in Europe. And maybe there's some banker out there who's really angry about the euro dollar meme and just like us wants to change it to global dollar. But that's kind of the reality, right? There are tens of trillions of dollars out there. And by the way, we don't actually have a precise number. Like we don't actually know how much, which coming from crypto, I mean, that feels very weird, right? Shouldn't the central bank be able to run a full node and calculate the supply of their dollars outstanding?
And crypto great. That's how you like crypto. So they don't just your dollar is also physical cash. He's also physical. They don't know how much physical cash is out there. Obviously, there's more dollar cash outside the US than there is in the US also. And it's an unknown amount as well because of course it's not on a global permissionless blockchain. So we got you on the technology side, central bank. But let me just ask a few housekeeping items here. So as bizarre and crazy as that sounds, I want to get into kind of the incentives at play for the creation of this market. So we're calling this kind of a gray market and kind of, you know, it's increasing in legitimacy as the US starts to recognize it.
And it's like, okay, your dollars are here and we can't quell them. Maybe we don't want to. It's not in our interest. Let's talk about the demand side though. Why are dollars so demanded? Why does everyone want dollars? Why is the dollar kind of the better than the euro? Better than the euro. I mean, why aren't they using euros instead? Do you have some sense of that? Because that also informs why crypto dollars might be demanded in the future. Yeah, and this is a good question that I think about a lot because crypto dollars are very unique and that 99% of them reference the dollar, which is just remarkable, which is a much higher percentage penetration than we see dollars in any other domain, especially because crypto is a fully global market.
I mean, a very global market. So I always wonder about that. Like, what is it about crypto that causes the dollar to have these tremendous network effects that's just squashed any other field? What you mean is there's no like euro stablecoin. There's no Canadian dollar stablecoin really that has to. They exist, but nobody wants them. Yeah. I mean, I think this will change to a certain degree. Like probably people will start, they've got your European and you're using crypto and you're using crypto fiat. You're probably using dollars, which is remarkable to me. I think there's like a few reasons why people want dollars.
One is it has, you know, use a dollar to extinguish a tax liability in the US. Obviously that's not that salient in the euro dollar conversation. You also need dollars to purchase US securities. So treasuries, for instance. But the other one would just be kind of the network effects of trade. I mean, you need some currency to denominate trade in, to denominate contracts in. And as the US became the global exporter and just the trade partner for the entire world, post World War II, that was all occurring with dollars. So I think it's just really the network effect. And the liquidity benefits that caused the dollar to be so demanded globally.
And what a powerful network effect. It's turned out to be it seems like. And I guess the question remains over the decades to come how durable that is. Of course, that phases into the crypto story. But I just want to understand euro dollars a little bit more. So what you were saying is it basically the case. So I have dollars in my US bank account, my Wells Fargo account, right? And that is a US dollar that's not a euro dollar. I have FDIC insurance on that account up to 250K. If I have dollars in a bank account in Europe, is that automatically a euro dollar? And then what is it backed by? Like what composes that specific euro dollar?
I think you referenced earlier in this conversation that it's not normally or not necessarily a kind of, there's one dollar for every dollar that I have in a European bank account. So maybe it's backed by something else. What is the actual structure of that dollar that I might have in a bank account in Europe? Is that a true euro dollar? And how is it different than the dollar I might have in my American Wells Fargo account? Yeah, so initially they weren't fungible. So you wouldn't have had FDIC insurance if those dollars were in an offshore bank. But as time went on, the connectivity grew greater.
As US realized they couldn't suffer these deflationary shocks when people thought they'd have dollar liabilities in these banks and they weren't supported by dollar assets. But yeah, initially the banks kind of were offside in the sense that they had non dollar assets that were backing the dollar liabilities. So what I would say they're backed by now is the relationship that ultimately the local central bank has with the Federal Reserve that's sort of the ultimate backing. Anything about your dollars in your bank what they're ultimately backed by is like the Federal Reserve's willingness to create liquidity if there's a crisis.
So like the FDIC thing is kind of like it's kind of symbolic, I would say the FDIC insurance and like we saw this year with a banking crisis. FDIC was kind of irrelevant in a sense, right? Because it didn't support all the unsecured deposits in the banks. So what were your dollar deposits and banks actually supported by was like the FDIC's willingness to create liquidity in a crisis which of course manifested potentially an inflation. But yeah, it's like your dollars in the US are ultimately supported by the fact that there's a central bank that's willing to create dollars and shore up the banks if necessary.
And then it's more diffuse offshore but I would say it's still the strength of that banks relationship but they're a central bank and then the central banks relationship with the FD which is kind of a geopolitical question. So the allies of the US have a tight linkage and the foes of the US were the non-affiliated countries. They've a less tight linkage. So anyone in the US wants to maybe screw or just not bail out and what you're saying is that example was very pressing this year and I feel like we all learn that with Silicon Valley bank where depositors where they would have gotten screwed and there's of course an FDIC limited to 250K per account and of course that was bailed out and all the pausers money was basically guaranteed by the US banking central bank apparatus.
And so you're saying that that relationship would also exist maybe in a foreign bank dependent on the US's desire, political will, monetary will to go commit to a bailout should some sort of event happen. So it's I guess it sounds like it's very different. It's more similar to the dollar I would have in a Wells Fargo account in that it's backed by I guess some full faith and credit of the US banking system type of relationship is a little different than like a USDC or a tether which actually you can kind of like audit yeah I don't know what the latest of tether is but in the case of USDC you get whatever monthly audits you can actually see oh this is backed by 70% treasuries and you know x percent whatever else 30 you know 20% dollars it's kind of composed by a grouping of assets in the case of a crypto dollar or stablecoin and that's that's a little bit different than a euro dollars at the case.
Well I mean the banks asset they're like portfolio of mortgages and loans of small business et cetera that like that's like the actual assets that supports it but that is not necessarily dollar denominated so the sort of like liquidity provided last resort would still be the Fed but the Fed will rather the US may not feel that they owe anything to the foreign holders of your dollars. So I think this is actually something people talk about a little bit like well there's all these dollars that overseas like in particular in countries that we're not friendly with right and there may be in kind of the near future the situation where which emerges where we have a global financial crisis again and the Fed ends up being at odds with the kind of national security apparatus of the US because the Fed's motive will be to shore up the dollar system and provide that liquidity even if it helps our adversaries right so like you're not talking about American savers who are potentially dealing with loss they're saying you're talking about total foreigners that we may not feel like we owe anything to so the kind of natsack portion of the government might be like well why an earth would we bail out like people abroad that you know like what do we owe them whereas the Fed their motive is well actually our job is just to like ensure the sanctity of the dollar globally even if the dollar was created in a foreign bank so this is actually like a debate that will be had in the coming years is to what extent should we support the global euro dollar system that's a very interesting question right because when you look at it through that political lens you sort of wonder what's what's the safer asset a euro dollar in a European bank account or a USDC did omination of USDC which is basically an US bank account at the end of the day and it almost feels like under a certain lens like you could easily say USDC is the safer asset relative to a euro dollar what do you think of that well it's also with USDC specifically I'd feel really good about it because well it's kind of an interesting thing that's maybe not the best example because you bet no offense to my friends at circle you're as a USDC holder my analysis is you're an unsecured creditor of circle so it's kind of like your creditor of circle it's like you bought a bond that they issued and you get zero coupon for that so you know what would you have to be paid to be a unsecured credit of circle for me it's probably more than zero but that's what you that's a USDC holder is it getting paid we'll take a better example would be like paypal's PYUSD so that's issued under the New York Trust License and I don't want to be mean to any given stablecoin here I love them equally they're all my children but PYUSD is a good example because it's issued in New York New York Trust License bankrupts your the regulator is very clear about that and they do monthly out of stations they're very clear about what the assets backing that are treasuries reverse repos some cash probably and they're very clear about what your assurances are as a holder of that you compare that to let's say the users of the ordinary paypal product and JP Coney wrote a growth blog making this exact clear contrast the holders of the dollar liabilities issued by paypal in their conventional product have none of those assurances in fact there's a higher maturity it's not just short dated treasuries or cash there's some exotic stuff in there they're not as transparent with the disclosures because they don't have to be and you don't have a priority in a bankrupt serial equitation situation so because of the way that crypto stablecoin regulation is being treated in the US at least the crypto dollar holders of PYUSD are in a far better position than the dollar holders of ordinary paypal issuance and by the way Nick for people who haven't kept up with this PYUSD is a new paypal stablecoin that just was started being issued I believe this summer it doesn't have a lot of traction yet but you're you're saying actually the you know the settlement guarantees let's call them a PYUSD are actually pretty strong yeah the overall assurances you have from being a user in that system I mean look there's a freezing seas function as most fiat backstables have stable tics yeah yes and there's a weekend dig into why you probably should have that um but uh yeah the assurances the system because of the weird contingency that it's a crypto dollar are far far greater than the assurances you have being a ordinary user paypal and not all stablecoins are like that they're not all I should have New York with New York trust license obviously the biggest stablecoins big questions around them other stablecoins in the US there's an array of strategies issuing strategies somewhere state-by-state MTLs somewhere out issue out of trust um but on on kind of a go-forward basis my general stable would be I'd be far more comfortable being a stablecoin holder than I would be a um you know citizen some foreign nation with a dollar account in their bank account so I have one last question about um the euro dollar so and that that's with respect to how it grows and how it's issued is it basically just a function of demand so I'm very familiar with how stablecoins grow and stablecoins grow when the market demands or stablecoins right so if there's more demand for USDC then it can just you know more there's more USDC uh liabilities uh in the account and they can issue more USDC and it just kind of ratchets up with with demand uh do do euro dollars work the same way are they just kind of like they could mint infinite I suppose as to the extent that the demand is there well I mean the bank solvents is ultimately the question so if they're over issuing dollars and then there's a run on the bank um you know the bank itself runs in a trouble and could potentially go bust so it's the same constraint applies would be a capital ratio liquidity ratio so they'll be able to issue dollars to measure it with like whatever the local regulatory requirements are but ultimately it would be a function of the demand to hold dollars in that bank and then so do you think crypto dollars could be a competitor to euro dollars in the future and start to take some of that market share well I think they are a force for your dollar creation basically um but also crypto dollars don't have to be issued by a bank I mean we see non-bank issuance of crypto dollars um so it could well be the case that the banks are kind of cut out of this process whereby you have a crypto dollar issuer you have some custodian that holds treasuries for them and uh some intermediary that helps with the liquidity and there's no bank involved at all um so basically I think crypto dollars are the new euro dollars they could also be a creative two-year dollar sector generally but yeah I see them as basically the new euro dollars I want to talk about some of the drivers behind the rising star of crypto dollars like why why is it gaining momentum uh not few things in 2023 have actually um rose in popularity rose in utility rose in interest stablecoins is definitely one of them but why um because you mentioned you alluded to earlier Nick that it's actually decoupled from uh exchange volumes so there are new net new buyers of stablecoins there are net new transactors in stablecoins who are these people what what are the sectors of the world the of oh the sectors of industry in parts of the globe that are um like leaning into the crypto dollar world yeah and i'll caveat this by saying that we see monthly active and weekly active users increasing for stables the volumes as far as i can tell are flat but obviously relative to crypto that's good flat is up in this day and age flat's up and um this the total supply of stables is contracting but so that means velocity is increasing so we're doing more with less in terms of monetary base um i would love to know you know who all these people are and it's very circumstantial you have to put the puzzle together so based on all the pieces you know i'll identify a few kind of categories so one is cross-border payments remittances right and i think so we all we see the legacy remittance providers getting into the stablecoin space so that's a thing that's happening like moneygram is getting into it um but you also see new crypto native remittors engaging in stablecoin transactions to satisfy the kind of cross-border leg and these are just new names that are emerging um a lot of these remittors will be using crypto dollars without their users knowing about it so this is kind of like utility scale b2b2c type mechanics so that's certainly a category uh they may not be holding a big float because that this is more kind of like for payments but we certainly see that another cohort is stablecoin uh or you know like fintechs banking as a service companies e-money mobile money companies that are giving their users access to the dollar uh whether it's for transactional access or just to hold the dollar and maybe uh an interest-bearing mechanic like a tokenized treasury type thing this we see mostly outside the US right like obviously we're very well served from a fintech neo bank perspective in the US but in e-mcc this and uh there's a bunch of new names emerging there and i think within a year or two we'll see you know massive massive companies built here um and a lot of these we've talked to like a castle island we've talked to like two dozen of these firms in the last couple of months uh a lot of them their metrics are just skyrocketing as users become more comfortable with this or as users become more attuned to the risk of their local fiat's um you know like we've seen banking crisis around the world the hotspots i see everybody knows latam is a hotspot for this that's probably the number one place the um you know there's a combination of like latent amounts of wealth there there's a um you know obviously a flow of remittance in and out and there's in depending on the country there might be very unstable or weak fiat system you've even seen dollarization episodes in latam and there's also a very tech savvy like you know mobile first user base so i think that's why you see such high penetration in latam um the other hotspots we see are eastern europe uh again like very technically savvy populations um and uh history of kind of like unstable currencies unstable governance we see this in africa we're investors and i think the largest crypto brokerage in africa yellow card the main thing people do with them is make cross border stablecoin transactions and of course the dirty secret of all this is that it's a lot of it is on tether on tron specifically so you know we we joke about it but tether tron is like the number one crypto application that anyone has ever come up with which is pretty amusing um and then you see a lot of usage in uh in southeisia as well um so it's kind of like you really put the picture together right i'd love to know just bring it from like at the on chain data what's going on but of course you there's only so much you can piece out of that so we have to go kind of bottom up arbitrum is accelerating the web3 landscape with a suite of secure ethereum scaling solutions hundreds of projects have already deployed on arbitrum one with flourishing defi and nft ecosystems arbitrum nova is quickly becoming a web 3 gaming hub and social data like reddit are also calling arbitrum home and now arbitrum orbit allows you to use arbitrum secure scaling technology to build your own layer three giving you access to interoperable customizable permissions with dedicated throughput whether you're a developer enterprise or user arbitrum orbit lets you take your project to new heights all of these technologies leverage the security and decentralization of ethereum and provide a builder experience that's intuitive familiar and fully evm compatible faster transaction speeds and significantly lower capacities so visit arbitrum.
io where you can join the community dive into the developer docs bridge your assets and start building your first app with arbitrum experience web3 development the way it was always meant to be secure fast cheap and friction free sell-o is the mobile first evm compatible carbon negative blockchain built for the real world and now something big is happening introducing the sell-o layer two it's a game-changing proposal that's going to bring sell-os rapidly growing ecosystem home to ethereum vitalic has shared its excitement for the sell-o on the sell-o forum so has been jones from optimism but why the sell-o layer two will bring huge advantages like a decentralized sequencer off-chain data availability and one block finality which is all that mean rock solid security a trustless bridge to ethereum and more real world use cases for ethereum without compromise and real world adoption is happening active addresses on sell-o have grown over 500% in the last six months with the sell-o layer two gas fees will stay low and you can even pay for gas using erc20 tokens but sell-o is a community governed protocol this means that sell-o needs you to weigh in and make your voice heard join the conversation in the sell-o forum follow at sell-o org on twitter and visit sell-o org to shape the future of ethereum we were joking earlier about we call them euro dollars but they're really global dollars they maybe just the memes started in europe but really it's a global phenomenon but maybe that's just because europe is more financialized and more banked than the rest of the world so they got to this phenomenon first is it accurate to say that crypto dollars stablecoins are a democratizing force for access to what we call euro dollars that blockchains have helped like the the non-Europe non united states parts of the world actually penetrate into the crypto dollar market is it's a democratizing force that's being brought to play here yeah and people talk about like financial inclusion and talked about it for years in crypto and like sometimes it's just total red herring façade like a justification for what we're trying to doing but like it's very real and so like my prediction here is actually if you actually look at it the euro is becoming less and less influential because Europe is fading in many ways my prediction is the dollar actually kind of re entrances their dominance in the coming years and I think crypto is a big part of that I think you'll see this kind of spontaneous crypto dollarization occur and I thought this would happen it back in 2020 I started talking about it in a podcast many series I wrote my little white paper about it I thought you would see crypto dollarization episodes and like in certain hotspots you have seen this definitely like in Venezuela it's absolutely the case that crypto dollarization has occurred with a certain portion of of the population but I basically think there's going to be many fewer fiat in the next kind of 20 years or so and I it's not that I think like Bitcoin is going to kill them or anything it's the dollar will kill them right like the dollar will be forcibly important to these countries and local government authority will not have the tools to stop this and if these countries are democracies it will be politically unpopular to try and inhibit this right it won't make sense at a certain point so I think you'll see a lot more countries kind of submit to dollarization if their local population becomes too fed up with the kind of fiat mismanagement but you know as far as taking giving people access to dollars that they never had before like oh and a lot of these countries are just elites have access to dollar accounts and the way that they get that is they literally fly to the US with cash they deposit the cash in Bank of America for some reason Bank of America is very common with like Venezuelans for instance and so that's like obviously not something ordinary people can do but now that you have fiat liquidity whether it's p to p basis like Binance p to p or with these exchanges that are pretty well established and basically every country on the planet all the tools are there and you know high quality wallets crypto wallets the work or fintechs that can kind of intermediate this if you don't want to bother with key management all the pieces are there for this to occur so as the world gets smaller as blockchains tear down these kind of geographic barriers you will see I'm certain episodes of crypto dollarization and basically we're going to see the dollar be this kind of apex predator that predates on all these weaker fiat currencies so I might have been early in this prediction but I kind of stand by it I still think it's going to happen yeah and I'm going to put something up on screen here this is a slide from your recent talk at Missouri which is just got three lines on it too that we're going to focus on one is the supply of USDT tether of course and one is the supply of USDC circle and these lines largely move in parallel with each other with USD and the lead right up until recently right up until a few months into 2023 when they just massively diverge and USDT grows to basically new highs that it's never seen before in the crypto world and then USDC from about almost 50 billion down to below 30 billion just with the context of we just that we just had in this conversation Nick and the demand for crypto dollars outside United States well what is the signal that we get from this slide white why is this slide significant yeah I think it's one of the most important charts that I've put together I tweeted that and people like this is an interesting this is not an interesting chart like I found it interesting I found it interesting so this shows the disparate rate sensitivity of the two major stable coins and this tells us so much it tells us so much it tells us that USDC holders are rate sensitive of course USDC holders are a lot of them are US based firms I wanted to make crypto transactions if you were to plot the crypto yields the kind of native crypto yield that there's not one but there is a collection of crypto yields against the trad by yields the crossover would have happened in late 22 early 23 and that's kind of the moment when USDC supply started to draw down this is just like how sovereign currencies work by the way if there are two similar nations two similar currencies and one of them pays a very high yield one of them pays a low yield capital will flow into the high yielding one it sucks it in and out of the low yielding one so it's the exact same thing happening here like crypto land stopped paying a high yield I mean we can talk about the yields and crypto some of them were illusory whatever fiat land started paying a high yield in fact it's gone up since this it's astronomically high right in the US so USDC holders all of a sudden had this massive opportunity cost where they're getting paid zero to hold this stable and the crypto opportunities weren't as good and it wasn't difficult for them to move back into fiat and put their money in treasuries right and earn the now 535 basis points me okay so this is kind of what is this is the main thing that's responsible for the sell off and stable coins is the fact that stable coins pay zero yield it's like a savings account in the bank to pay you nothing you're not gonna keep your funds in that bank actually this happened to me just last week I pulled all my funds out of my credit union because they're paying 20 basis points on my cash which would take you less so meanwhile tether is rallying it's an all time high tether also pays zero yield so what's going on like there's something substantially different between tether and USDC or leases or perception and I think it's that tether holders are more remote from the US and they don't necessarily have the ability to go from crypto dollars to fiat dollars because that's more difficult for them because they're either unable to are unwilling they're able to tolerate the opportunity cost much better than a USDC holder was so I find it fascinating I think it tells us a lot about the different user bases I think it tells us the USDT holders are holding it because they want to be as far away from the US as possible and whereas USDC holders we know are like they're much more proximate to the US it's actually much more fascinating when you explain it that way and on first glimpse I looked at it and said okay so tether up USDC down right maybe that's because of regulatory crackdown or something or you know maybe that's because tether is just winning some sort of a narrative war but you know the way you explain it I should think sheds a lot more light into it and I also wonder about kind of a product that this seems to imply that would be highly demanded by the entire global market including US users of USDC and that is the idea of tokenized treasures because then you could actually get that fed fund rate on top of your your stablecoin and have kind of the benefit there does this chart also imply that that demand could be sucked up by an ERC 20 or some sort of form of a tokenized treasury where you're getting that fed fund rate yield on top of your dollar yeah I mean that's one of my big hypotheses for this year you know you look at the eth to stake deeth transition and defy where stake deeth derivatives became a very dominant form of collateral I think the exact same will happen with stables it won't be a full replacement we won't go from all of the tether's 86 billion of tether's to 86 billion of interest bearing stablecoins but I think it'll be a very meaningful share because 550 basis points or 500 basis points of opportunity cost is very real so we're seeing dozens of these emerge all kind of different approaches the commonalities a lot of them are issued offshore so they're finding jurisdictions that are willing to have a interest bearing stablecoin or tokenized treasury list in foreign jurisdictions because of course it'd be very hard to do it if not impossible in the US so technologically there's no reason we can't do this it's just not that difficult to you know pass on some of the yield and I think users are a little bit fed up of these firms the stablecoin issuers internalizing all of their yield I mean that's kind of ridiculous you know at the people at this point know that tether they have what 50 employees they make four billion dollars a year roughly from the treasury and asset portfolio they're sitting on they pass on and none of that are you saying 50 employees generate you say four billion a year yeah so I think tether is the most profitable per employee business on the planet at this point and I mean stupid look they have the golden goose they have the liquidity everywhere that's fine some percentage of their clients will be fed up with that and they'll move to unless tether themselves turns on the yields bigot you'll see this competitive dynamic emerge just the same way that banks are now competing with money market mutual funds or certain banks that are now passing on a lot more interest as interest rates of risen you'll see this competitive dynamic emerge where newer issuers some newer issuers that are willing to pass on a good portion of that yield will will do very well at the expense of the incumbents the difficult thing for us dc is they probably can't do this in the us at least not on chain they're trying to get around this by passing on they're not calling it a yield they're they're calling a reward they're passing on some of the underlying yield from us dc via coinbase and things like that the security regulations that prevent them yeah and for sure like the scc even thinks b usd which is a non-interest bearing stable as a security under their very strange reading of the research they might think pokemon cards are security here lately nick so you know who knows if it's tokenized it's got to be a security right they think everything's a security but it certainly doesn't help your case if you're playing you're paying an explicit yield to the holder so us and look we talked a lot of startups that were trying to do this in the us but us issuers will basically not be able to do this this will be another force i've been talking about the offshoring of balance sheet from the us to other places and to other x us it should stable this will be another force that accelerates that too this is fascinating i mean you've got you know maybe near the end of this episode we can kind of lay out nick carders a crypto dollar predictions but you know one of your predictions early in this episode seem to be that that crypto dollars will maybe surpass at some point your own dollars right which would be you know quite the in a second prediction of you know the coming of a tokenized treasury would be maybe another prediction that i'm hearing you make but a lot of this depends as we start to talk about kind of what the us wants and on on actual us banking regulatory apparatus and what's in kind of the best interest of the united states and it it feels like they're kind of split brain on this a little you know maybe schizophrenic or they have different there's different factions that want different things and i'm wondering if you could walk us through the the regulatory idea maze here and kind of the incentives at play and maybe we can pull in parallels from the euro dollar market it seems like probably maybe you would know much more but probably in the 50s and 60s with the emergence of the euro dollar the us regulatory apparatus would have squashed it maybe if they could they did like they don't necessarily like things that are outside of their jurisdiction and control but they were content to kind of let it grow and then it became so big and they found some wins there with petro dollar and other things exporting you know us monetary might monetary supremacy that eventually they just brought it into the fold right maybe begrudgingly at first but they saw enough benefit saw enough wins to kind of bring it into the fold what is the current us posture towards um crypto dollars right now aka stable coins is we they've been interchangeable to this episode but crypto dollars um and how do you think it'll play out like what are the wins for the us and what are the things that they might might not like about um crypto dollars yeah and this was kind of my subject to my talk of mean that which is basically the conclusion of all that was it's kind of up to them it can be really good for the us american interests or it can be kind of less good and it really depends on whether they want to fold them in in braces sector or whether they want to push it away um so it could well be more hostile to us interests if they push stables away um if a few things happen like if uh stables start to be issued against crypto collateral as opposed to dollars then that wouldn't be good as far as the crypto dollar sector being a buyer of the us debt because instead crypto dollars would be buying ether and potentially bitcoin and that's what the us wants that's one thing the us wants is they want buyers of treasuries basically yes they theory yes they don't seem to care very much the stat that I have is crypto dollars is overall would be the 16th largest sovereign holder of us debt more than already 16th yeah so more than Mexico more than Saudi Arabia more than Germany you you say that like quote the government they don't they don't care but they're naive right i naive or there's some overriding concern so one concern is the loss of control similar to your dollars and um i think what they don't understand is if they were to cultivate a network of issuers here in the us they would still be able to exert meaningful control i mean it's not like your ability to um project power you know through sanctions enforcement or to pursue law enforcement objectives that doesn't go away with the stablecoin you can still ask the issuer to carry out your will and the stablecoins themselves listen to law enforcement i mean even tether does right they tether is frozen more addresses in usdc i believe so what they should want is accountable issuers that are willing to listen to courts and listen to treasury if they want to pursue some kind of political objective um but of course stablecoins are less accountable than ordinary transactions that are happening fully within the banking sector because they're cash like transactions these are p to p so i think that's one thing they don't like um you know i'd say a lot often if cash was invented today would be illegal this is like the reinvention of cash and so it's not surprising they don't like it even if it can be frozen a distance unlike cash the other thing they are worried about is quote unquote financial stability so it's very ironic us regulators think stablecoins and crypto like helped to bring down some of the banks that failed early this year i don't buy that in fact i think the banks were pretty much taken out behind the woodshed and shot and that's being pinned on crypto so i think it's pretty much the opposite but uh what they worry about is like oh what if you know tether redeemed all of their outstanding liabilities in one day and they had to sell off their entire treasury portfolio wouldn't this cause yields a spike um the obvious point there is like stablecoins just encrypted all is still very small relative to like treasury liquidity austin cam will wrote a good blog post on this and a csonario today where that's a threat also i don't think it's very likely that all of the tether is will be redeemed all at once in fact everything we've seen about tether is that it's incredibly sticky like people don't want to redeem their tethers they want to keep holding them and they may not be able to redeem them frankly so that's the other worry they have so it's a loss of control they're concerned about and then i think this pretextual concern about financial stability so with all that in mind like what we've actually seen this year is every tool in the toolbook the us has to kind of suppress and quash the stablecoin sector they've used so in January they denied the custodial application the federal reserve did to get access to the master account which is basically the core of the fed that meant the custodial couldn't issue their own stablecoin which they were trying to do with a bank charter that's on the signal to anybody else that was trying to get a bank chartered issue stablecoin which in my opinion would be the best way to do it uh through a chartered bank not just uh with the state by state money transmission license in march that you know we had this crisis with the banks silvergate and signature um silvergate choose to voluntarily liquidate signature were shuttered unfairly in my opinion they both ran this fiat clearing infrastructure which was very useful for a stablecoin liquidity sound and signal respectively uh what they allowed was 24-7 liquidity uh for the creation redemption of stablecoins the process of winding down those banks and having their assets sold off in that process send and signet were not included in the sales which violates the FDIC's mandate to maximize the value of those sales so this is a huge scandal in my opinion it's really a huge huge deal this is like key infrastructure that should have been sold to someone to keep these networks running and the government didn't allow that to happen so they're basically selectively destroyed a key piece of crypto infrastructure which was very useful for stablecoins that's a huge deal um also in January all of the major federal um bank regulators wrote a letter saying yeah we think stablecoins are risky don't touch them in August they wrote another letter the Fed did saying yeah look if you want to do stablecoin self as a bank you can do it but uh you have to ask us permission and get a letter so basically they're saying you can't do it um so everything um they've done to date has been an effort to kind of discourage stablecoin activity in the US specifically with banks and that's I think a big part of the reason why we see the stablecoins going offshore it's frankly nick been kind of bizarre behavior because what they are in effect doing is they're they're trying to slow it down in the US but they are in effect as long as the demand is there we saw this play out with your dollars they're just actually just driving it offshore and they might even be driving it towards a different asset as you said well if they're not going to allow dollar backed stablecoins then how about uh an eth backed stablecoin or a crypto another crypto asset backed stablecoin um so it's frankly been kind of bizarre behavior and I'm wondering what you think about this kind of um not a conspiracy theory take but just sort of an influence type take which is um how about the big banks it seems like they might have um a lot of sway in uh in Washington in DC and they're tied up in at some level with the kind of the central banking apparatus um what about when they get a product to sell maybe maybe the approach makes some logical a sense if some of the larger banks are just trying to slow down almost like these neo proto banks like called coin base or circle the like proto banks slow them down until they have a product that they can sell it's it was very interesting to me that JP Morgan for for instance they have a private blockchain like not a lot of people are aware of this called it was formerly called corn it's called something else now and they're doing things yeah on it and they're doing things on their private network and there's an actual JP Morgan chain I could imagine that they would want to issue that as an ERC 20 on public networks and take some of this global market that you're talking about and they haven't been able to yet and I I'm wondering if it's just because well I'm wondering if the tide could change if there are enough winds for traditional Wall Street or the big banks to kind of push this uh you know down the throats of of regulators who might be resistant what do you think of that theory yeah it's a great question I think generally open interoperable networks um probably are not not good for the banks and banks as an industry especially now the rates are high so in theory banking is more profitable they probably wouldn't like the um competitive dynamic where a bunch of quasi banks were able to emerge all of a sudden very quickly the banks certainly benefit from the status quo whereby it's very expensive to charter new bank if not impossible like post financial crisis Dodd Frank made it very very hard to create new bank so the rate of bank chartering became effectively nil after that the form of regulatory capture it's it's a very unfortunate situation um and it reduced the competitiveness of the banking sector in my opinion so the banks themselves um I think some newer like smaller banks would want to hitch their horse towards a crypto space and become stablecoin issuers and compete well that's what silvergate and signature we're trying to do is to be like crypto focus banks that's what custodial was trying to do um you know so the states want to charter these things there's newer banks that want to do this they want to distinguish themselves by doing crypto the big banks I think the status quo works for them however there's also the asset managers like B&Y melon has clearly had crypto ambitions for some time blackrock is active they work with circle you know they actually administer some of these assets they would like to issue an ETF we there's a whole laundry list of asset managers that seek to benefit from crypto we don't know fidelity is active there Franklin Templeton has a tokenized treasury product right so from the asset manager side I think there's certainly the will there one problem is this obscure accounting rule I say be one twenty one which means that if if you are a bank you have to take a capital charge against any crypto asset they are holding even if it's on behalf of your customers which is a kind of a ridiculous interpretation of of how how it works so that holds any bank back from sort of like touching crypto meaningfully so I think you kind of have to disaggregate the institutional environment a little bit um I think it's heterogeneous basically I think the large banks don't have a lot to gain from public blockchains I think certain asset managers have something to gain from it and I think smaller banks that want to win win market share certainly have a lot to gain from it and it's them that have been really harshly stymied here the the conversation of stablecoins is always in my mind an innovation on two fronts one is the trad world innovation and this is just like legal work making sure your buttoned up making sure you're accepted um and then maybe some like BD stuff some some trap stuff and then there's actual like raw stablecoin innovation on the crypto side of things um and that's where I want to ask you about next nick about like with the new frontiers of stablecoin innovation there's topics here like on chain tea bills which against kind of strutles both um but then there's new form factors for stablecoins which are a little bit more crypto native but overall if we talk about just like stablecoins and uh road map if you wear if you will like Ethereum has got a roadmap salon has got a roadmap if there's a perceived stablecoin road map about like you know things to squeeze juice out of what what what do you focus on what what was there left to squeeze here wow there's so much juice to squeeze man um it's very exciting like we'll see altos that are stablecoin focus L1s that are stablecoin focused we will see like aggregators for stablecoins to emerge especially a stablecoin liquidity becomes very fragmented so you see like the one inch for stablecoins the cow swap for stablecoins on the stablecoin issue inside you'll see interest paying stables you'll see crypto backstables especially now the eth has this positive carry now kind of for the first time in some ways it's possible to have a robust eth back stablecoin is synthetic usd um that's all very exciting then on the sort of like financial rails you'll see more efficient ways to stitch together via rails and stable rails to create an alternative to the correspondent banking system which is highly highly efficient at moving money so you see like global Venmo's global PayPal's emerge when they just weren't able to do that before um so yeah and then you'll see like more sophisticated especially offshore like fintechs that are fully powered by stables on the backend custodial semi custodial um so I mean total Cambrian explosion is what we're seeing and the amount of like the quality of entrepreneurs and the number of startups I'm seeing is very very significant as I said I could just do stablecoin related deals for the next year probably and that would be it yeah so we we we started off this conversation saying like oh yeah stablecoins kind of cryptos killer app right I think what you're calling for is like yes and we're just getting started you ain't see nothing yet that that kind of seems like what you're saying yeah I mean it's remarkable actually like how in some ways like or the stablecoin experience has been like the stable ones that exist don't give us great assurances like I'd love to see better transparency also in the accounting like I'd like to see real-time proof of assets as opposed to monthly out of stations which I don't like um uh so the I would like to see much more concrete property rights carved out um so I would like all issuers to find a way to make the assets bankrupts your remote held for the benefit of holders as opposed to being an unsecured creditor that's a bad thing um so there's a lot of legal and contractual innovations to occur there and then stablecoins are still pretty siloed they are not fully integrated into the financial system in the US or abroad one interesting thing that it's making them more proximate is the emergence of rapidly settling payments on the fiat side so if you want to go from fiat to crypto to fiat for let's say an end-to-end remittance that you want to send you know from the US to whatever the Philippines the historical issue was that there was a settlement risk on the fiat side so it was always the fiat like of the transaction there was a problem but as these newer payment systems emerge um that settle very quickly on the fiat side now you can do that whole transaction in maybe in seconds as opposed to having the issuer trying to take on some risk where like ACH might be reversible after some number of days a credit card payment might be reversible like this chargeback risk so one interesting thing that's going to make stablecoins better and more useful is fiat transactions getting better and more useful so as fiat transactions approach the settlement speed of stables that makes the whole system more functional if that makes sense right yeah so the the properties the underlying strengths of one fiat network impacts how strong the stablecoin network can be if you want to go end-to-end right from fiat via crypto to fiat the fiat leg on the ingress side needs to be fast settling otherwise the entity that's intermediating the transaction is taking on a whole lot of risk and it's one of the weird ironies we think the US financial system is really good it actually relative to many many others including developing world financial systems it's very very bad because there's a lot of settlement risk in the US financial system typically and actually as we see more real-time payment systems emerge even fed now potentially believe it or not that will actually make the experience of going from fiat to stables back to fiat much much better so that's a weird thing that's been holding us back is actually the fiat side that sucks fed now is bullish for crypto very interesting interpretation yeah so I want to ask you for the crypto natives who've been hanging out this entire episode who are who are excited about you know crypto dollars in the potential but you know they might have the question okay so how about our crypto native assets what does this do for our bags Nick is the adoption of there's there's always since we've been talking about stablecoins and crypto dollars there's always been kind of two sides of the coin here you know some have made the argument that crypto dollars are actually parasitic to the value of ether and bitcoin because they represent sort of a monetary demand that's expressed in dollars rather than in you know crypto native asset and others have said no adoption is good more addresses and more people's you know in more use cases and more gas fees and all of these things what do you think so if this vision comes true and we get crypto dollars you know rising to scale of of the euro dollar market is that going to be good for crypto native assets like bitcoin and ether it depends on whether you lean into the change or whether you reject it so I think I wrote a blog post for you for your newsletter like some years ago like saying I think crypto if yeah was parasitic at the time at the time I think I've been saying it was so I think the real question is how quickly are you able to internalize this reality like one of the charts I showed on one of my talks showed that something like 70 80% of all dollar value settling on blockchains is now happening in dollars as opposed to bitcoin or ether or other L ones and when I wrote my first white paper in 2020 was 30% I already thought that was a big deal and now it's like 70 80% so it's a huge deal now so it's a kind of a challenge I posed to the protocol engineers can you make your blockchain such that it benefits from the existence of settling non native assets the eth folks I've said this before I think did a good job because eth tokens are able to extract some of the value from the transactions happening in fiat via fees and like the burn mechanism things like that bitcoin is still more up in the air because well there aren't really a lot of crypto dollars settling on bitcoin but potentially it could be a force driving up fees if that were to become a domicile for crypto dollars but it would also be it would eliminate the medium of exchange value prop bitcoin not maybe not eliminated but challenge it and this is a big argument I've been having with the bitcoin or it's like is bitcoin being a medium of exchange and bridge currency an absolutely inherent part of the bitcoin thesis if it is that's challenged by the emergence of stablecoins for sure however if you can position your blockchain such that stablecoins represent a revenue opportunity for the blockchain itself then you can certainly benefit from it so I don't think it's a bad thing for crypto that we're settling a ton of dollars like that's usage that's economic very real world economic usage that seems like a great thing but the question is can you position yourself to benefit from it I think you'll see a lot of these L ones so to realize this and so to try and position themselves to be like the stablecoin domicile of choice like we certainly see this with like the dollars of the world so long as like leaning into this heavily if I think tons of not really care what kind of transactions you're doing so maybe this is for the like newer smaller L ones I want to distinguish themselves in some way but yeah it's kind of like up to you really whether you benefit from this trend because it's very real and I think intensifying yeah it'll be fascinating to see what L2s do with it as well I mean your base is a fan fascinating experiment you know with with kind of a coin base who is obviously very friendly with USDC in circle and now having their own layer 2 there's going to be a lot of innovation here Nick a final question for you you've been kind of an oracle of crypto dollars and stablecoins for a while you know long long predicting that their star would rise is that the fourth time we've used that this episode I'm not sure but so give us some of your predictions right and over the next three to five years what's going to happen do you think in the world of crypto dollars okay so first of all I think the US dollars can remain the main unit of account I think the interest bearing cohort of stable is it's less than 1% I think it'll be at least 25% within two to three years so I think that'll be a huge huge shift that's large growth I think Tether will eventually realize this and probably be forced to create their own competing product USDC will not be able to directly maybe they'll be able to indirectly so the way they're currently doing it I also do think crypto collateralized starting with ETH collateral would also moving on towards Bitcoin collateral those will become a meaningful sector at least 10% of supply and I of course I think total supply is going to grow dramatically I like completely plausible to me we'll see 500 billion dollars worth of stables within three four years right so and I think stablecoin market cap might actually overtake ETH or market cap yeah I think so yeah I certainly see that I think stables will ultimately flip in the kind of crypto native assets I mean it's interesting going to yeah yeah sure wow sure like what's the supply of all stocks and then what's the supply of all dollars it's actually probably pretty close it's actually probably pretty close yeah I think they're equity public equity my market cap but you know Bitcoin and Ether are like you know they're just a subset of that so yeah I think crypto dollars will ultimately exceed the L1 equity tokens rather one thing I think is that the rise of crypto collateralized stables will push down ETH yields because that'll be a big consumer of ETH staking and it also pushed down the yield from basis trade on ETH and Bitcoin because basically stablecoins themselves will be doing this carry trade you think the the issuance and minting of stablecoins will use Ether staking as one of its assets yeah yeah I mean so look at these synthetic stables like ETH in a good example where they're long ETH staked ETH and they're also short ETH futures both of those have a positive carry as you see billions and billions of this type of stable created it'll push down both of those yields I think the other big prediction is other jurisdictions will embrace US dollar stables this is clearly already happening and then I think longer term it'll take you a some time to realize this but they'll see the benefit and themselves fold stablecoins in and eventually even give stablecoin issuers you know closer access to the central bank directly so I think eventually you'll see that make sure term Nick US laws do you think that will be pro stablecoin do you see that happening in the next one to two to three years certainly not before the election maybe if the Senate but you know becomes Republican then maybe we'll see that but not with this current Senate we go Nick Carter thank you so much clearly you are bullish crypto dollars and maybe we never call them stablecoins again this has been an absolute pleasure we appreciate it thanks guys it's been great bankless nation got to end with risks and disclaimers of course crypto is risky but crypto dollars on the other hand no volatility there you just got to make sure you know what backs them you could definitely lose what you put in but we are headed west this is the frontier it's not for everyone but we're glad you're with us on the bankless journey thanks a lot you