✨ DEBRIEF | Ryan & David unpacking the episode: https://www.bankless.com/debrief-vitalik-philosophy
------ This past year there’s been a great societal wide debate: Tech-acceleration (e/acc) vs deacceleration.
Should we continue the path toward AI or are the robots going to kill us? We’ve been hoping Vitalik would weigh in on this debate ever since our episode Elizer Yudkowski —now he has, so what’s Vitalik’s probability of AI doom?
----- 🏹 Airdrop Hunter is HERE, join your first HUNT today https://bankless.cc/JoinYourFirstHUNT
------ BANKLESS SPONSOR TOOLS:
🐙KRAKEN | MOST-TRUSTED CRYPTO EXCHANGE https://k.xyz/bankless-pod-q2
🦊METAMASK PORTFOLIO | MANAGE YOUR WEB3 EVERYTHING https://bankless.cc/MetaMask
⚖️ARBITRUM | SCALING ETHEREUM https://bankless.cc/Arbitrum
👾GMX | V2 IS NOW LIVE https://bankless.cc/GMX
🔗CELO | CEL2 COMING SOON https://bankless.cc/Celo
🦄UNISWAP | ON-CHAIN MARKETPLACE https://bankless.cc/uniswap
------
0:00 Intro 3:50 The Technology Conversation 15:30 The Accelerationist View 30:30 The AI Problem 38:30 8 Year Old Child 44:00 AI Doom 51:00 d/acc 1:08:30 Improving the World 1:16:45 e/acc 1:20:30 Crypto Tribes 1:27:00 Direction and Priorities 1:30:50 Closing Optimism
------ Resources:
Vitalik's Techno-Optimism: https://vitalik.eth.limo/general/2023/11/27/techno_optimism.html
Tweet Thread: https://x.com/VitalikButerin/status/1729251808936362327?s=20
Techno-Optimist Manifesto: https://a16z.com/the-techno-optimist-manifesto/
------ More content is waiting for you on Bankless.com 🚀 https://bankless.cc/YouTubeInfo
No summary for this episode yet.
We are creating financial systems that work without relying on any specific country. We are creating forms of privacy that work without relying on a central actor to hold everyone's information in custody for them. We are creating forms of accounts recovery that don't depend on Google or Twitter having everyone's master keys. That's happening with social recovery while it's send account of through action and ERC-4337. We are creating zero knowledge proof technologies that let people prove that they are trustworthy without revealing any more information about themselves beyond that. We are creating all of these really powerful tools that in a lot of cases are substitutes for more centralized forms of trust.
Welcome to Bankless where we explore the frontier of internet money and internet finance. This is Ryan Sean Adams. I'm here with David Hoffman and we're here to help you become more Bankless. Vitalik Buterin on the episode today. He's sharing his philosophy with us. He calls it D-AC and explains what he means by it in this episode. I think there's really three reasons we wanted to have this conversation on Bankless. The first is this. There has been a society-wide debate on what to do with technology, specifically AI technology. We've got the tech accelerationists as the E-AC community. We've got the tech-de-accelerationists as the EA community.
The debate is whether we should continue on this path forward towards AI the way we've been doing it or if we should stop because maybe the robots are going to come kill us. I know David and I have been hoping to pick Vitalik's brain on this for quite a while. Ever since we had our episode with Ellie Ezer Yudkowski who informed us very politely that we're all going to die. So we asked Vitalik, what's his probability of AI doom? The second reason for this episode is I think the philosophy that Vitalik lays out is something everybody in crypto can line on. It's a way to really unite the tribes.
It can help us explain what we're doing here to the world and why it matters. And more important I think coming out of 2022 when we seem to have lost our way in crypto it reaffirms why we're here. It's a core part of reestablishing our soul and getting the bottom of things. And the third reason we're having this conversation it's Vitalik buterin. Okay that's enough. He's always got interesting things to say. David why was this episode significant to you? I think even more broadly outside of crypto society at large is having a conversation with itself as to how fast it wants to go into the future.
I think there's some parts of society which is concerned about the vanguard of silicon valley and tech innovation moving faster than what society can really as a whole keep up with. And then there's other parts of society who was like guys you solve problems via technology. The acceleration and the speed of technology will help others catch up as well. And this conversation of how fast we want to go collectively as humanity is causing tension in society at large. And well as podcasters what do we do? We try and define the landscape to find the contours of the conversation help people learn the perspectives of other sides.
Discover what is signal versus noise discover what is truth. And so I think when we have clarity on these conversations we can all be in agreement in the direction that we want to go. And I think this is really what Vitalik did with his blog and what we are hoping to do with his podcast is help define the conversation a little bit more so humanity can get on the same page. And so that's why this episode is significant to me. All right guys we're getting it right to the conversation with Vitalik on deac and his philosophy but before we do we want to thank the sponsors that made this episode possible including our number one recommended crypto exchange that's Kraken go create an account.
Kraken knows crypto. Kraken's been in the crypto game for over a decade and as one is the largest and most trusted exchanges in the industry Kraken is on the journey with all of us to see what crypto can be. Human history is a story of progress it's part of us hardwired we're designed to seek change everywhere to improve to strive and if anything can be improved why not finance crypto is a financial system designed with the modern world in mind instant permissionless in 24-7 it's not perfect and nothing ever will be perfect but crypto is a world changing technology at a time when the world needs it the most that's the Kraken mission to accelerate the global adoption of cryptocurrency so that you and the rest of the world can achieve a financial freedom and inclusion head on over to Kraken.
com slash bankless to see what crypto can be not investment advice crypto trading involves risk of loss cryptocurrency services are provided to us and us territory customers by payward ventures eak pvi doing business as Kraken. Metamask portfolio is your one-stop shop to navigate the world of DeFi and now bridging seamlessly across networks doesn't have to be so daunting anymore with competitive rates and convenient routes Metamask portfolio's bridge feature lets you easily move your tokens from chain to chain using popular layer one and layer two networks and all you have to do is select the network you want to bridge from and where you want your tokens to go from there Metamask vets and curates the different bridging platforms to find the most decentralized accessible and reliable bridges for you to tap into the hottest opportunities in crypto you need to be able to plug into a variety of networks and nobody makes that easier than Metamask portfolio instead of searching endlessly through the world of bridge options click the bridge button on your Metamask extension or head over to Metamask.
io slash portfolio to get started you know Uniswap is one of the largest decentralized protocols with over 1.7 trillion dollars of trading volume but Uniswap is becoming so much more Uniswap X is the newest product from Uniswap Labs which aggregates liquidity across the ecosystem to give you the best DeFi trading experience the best part it's gas-free and MEV protected the best prices zero gas and MEV protection all rolled into one app so head over to app.uniswap.org click the gear icon on the swap page and make sure that Uniswap X is toggled on and if zero gas trading on Uniswap wasn't enough for you the Uniswap app is now available on both iOS and Android start swapping seamlessly with products from the most trusted team in DeFi visit app.
uniswap.org to get started today thank the station I'm extremely excited to introduce you to Vitalik buterin you know him as the creator of Ethereum and Ethereum researcher but today he comes to us wearing the hat of philosopher which is I think what we are increasingly need at least in the sector of tech as we're having conversations around the world of technology acceleration as we are approaching new frontiers both inside of crypto and outside of crypto that are defining society at large. Vitalik recently wrote this post my techno optimism which has made the waves in the tech space about what to do about this increasing pace of technology and that is the subject here on today's episode of bankless.
Vitalik welcome back thank you guys it's so good to be here this post that you wrote. Vitalik which you subtitled my own current perspective on the recent debates around techno optimism AI risks and ways to avoid extreme centralization in the 21st century made the rounds inside of crypto and just immediately outside of crypto as well and this has been I think a continuation of a larger conversation that much of the world is having at large with its relationship to the globe's technology sector. So can we set up the conversation and kind of set the table if we will because it's happening society why two camps are forming there's what is known as now recently the accelerationist the pro tech and then the decelerationist the anti tech I'm not sure if anti's fair how would you set the table of this global conversation that's being had.
I mean I'm not even sure if two camps is the right way to describe it because I think what I honestly see yeah and the world and some of the discussions that are a bit happening in the world is like people being confronted with these completely new issues were made by completely yet new people that they are not used to paying attention to with completely new memes and you know weird vocabulary like shogoth and p-dume and timelines and all of these things and like oh well it's almost like an awakening and that for the first time people are actually thinking because like their existing camps don't really tell them how to think right.
Like if you think about the even most recent EAC versus effective altruist debate to kind of give very approximated crude labels to the two camps for example like this is not red versus blue this is not us versus China this is not Europe versus Russia this is not woke versus anti woke right this is basically yeah yeah debate that's happening between two groups of people who I'm even two or three years ago consider themselves to totally be part of the same tribe basically the kind of San Francisco centered like tech forward AI yeah leaning great tribe people who went and in many cases I continue to go to the yeah same dinner parties are in the same social circles and like suddenly there's this issue that has basically pulled them in a varied different directions and like if you're coming at it from the outside then like existing tribal mirrors don't really tell you much about it right because like if you're the type of person who for example thinks that tech people are bad beak and Minok these are rich white male dominated fields that are totally yeah out of touch with the rest of reality then like well guess what like both of these camps have a very large number of people that fit both of those descriptions right and both of those camps have no I think a large number that I do not that also get that also gets underappreciated right like there's a huge international audience for a lot of these AI focused things because similarly to how within the crypto space things like Mino ZK EVMs and ERC4337 are kind of resetting a playing field and giving opportunities to people from you know regions that have it really been historically well represented in a theory I might think a lot of people around the world Mino do also see AI as that kind of opportunity right and then if you're a left leaning person who is very skeptical of corporations and who is like pro governments to put it crudely but most skeptical of governments when that government is being influenced by corporations then like well guess what you know that YIQ and EA camps are both you know doing a lot of influencing governments and there's like lots of money on both sides right and so I think the way that like this conflict really yet is doesn't map to these existing tribal mirrors is like it does give like create this interesting property right and that people actually have to like figure out for the first time like well Mino like what actually is their own perspective on the particular issue and like how do they actually think about this totally new thing that was not even on most people's radars given two years ago right and I think like within crypto it's the same thing right in the sense that I feel like crypto has operated in a bit of this bubble where like there has it really been too much dialogue between like what's happening in this space and some of the discussions like both technological and political that are happening outside of it right and I feel like there is to some degree this kind of extents to which big parts of the space were born in this 2008 era context where I'm you know we're talking about like the second the chance over being on the brink for the second bailout for banks as the big one Genesis block says you know like literally yeah as part of the block body we yeah the discussions around like ending the Fed creating an alternative to central banks and all of these things and a lot of the big discussions in 2023 are just totally not related to that at all right it's like you know I'm sorry but like the I mean like the Israel Gaza situation is not going to be better if there's if those lands were ran on sound money right you know and you know like same with AI you know sorry like sound body is not going to make a like p-dume go down right so and now I mean it is possible to kind of overstate this right I mean I think like for example the with the recent election of Argentina where like I feel so so far totally yeah you know like unqualified to give a kind of like a grand and you know this this is good this is bad perspective on it but what I have noticed for the side from the sidelines that fascinates me is that like Millay is actually talking about economics and like Argentinian people do actually care about economics right and there definitely is an extent to which kind of the U.
S. and the rich countries in general we have I think like Aspology has pointed out moved from caring about the economic access to caring about the cultural access right it's like like the issue that emotionally arouses people in the in the U.S. these days like it's not like pensions and health care and like savings right or at least like that's not what the newspapers report about but in places like Argentina it you know like it still is and there's like a refreshing sort of grounds it in reality aspects to it but like it's so it's like importance to recognize the ongoing importance of that but also at the same time recognize this growing the rapid emergence of these conversations that have just like nothing to do with any of those questions and there's this big question of like how does crypto actually relate to these topics right and I think a lot of people who come into the space come into the space because they have ideals and values and kind of goals and dreams that extend you know like beyond like fairly narrow details of like this is you know like what the structure of the money is going to look like yeah so I think it's important for the space to try to kind of engage in some of those other topics as well right yeah so so I didn't think for a lot of the reasons like I've been thinking about some of these other technological topics as well and one of the things that I noticed especially a yeah you know like this past year in 2023 is that like I have a lot of beliefs about like blockchains of cryptocurrency and see case narks I also have a lot of beliefs about like the important self longevity research I also have my beliefs about geopolitics I also have my beliefs about AI and also have my beliefs about effective altruism but like these sets of beliefs were not really yeah talking to each other enough in a lot of cases right and like asking the question of what really yeah like what is it your actual take on like how crypto fits into this larger picture of the world and like does that prospect do the different parts of that perspective really like actually make sense in the context of the other parts of the perspective right um it's like uh and eat one of the questions that we totally should ask for example is like if AI is so important then like why not drop everything and start working on it right and like I think there are good answers to that question but I like it is a yeah I'm like a question that actually needs to be asked right and so yeah like the so I like I was thinking about a lot of these topics and then of course about a month and a half ago I'm Mark and Jason's a technical optimist manifesto came out and then of course an entire spectrum of replies to the technical optimist manifesto came out and then I started um at least thinking about how I would write this kind of piece and then you know you can act and def connect the deleted a bunch and then finally yeah you know the open AI situation just kind of like blasted basically the exact same topic and focus in a lot of people's minds again um and then so I decided like I'd actually need to like get this uh the documents I'm out there and here we are yeah that that's what uh I very much saw in your post photalic is is kind of like it it accomplished this goal of maybe creating a unified philosophy for crypto in the broader context of the societal conversation and and I want to set that up because you know this year is I think the year that the societal conversation between this acceleration view which you called uh iac which stands for effective accelerationism for folks that are not familiar and this more kind of anti-tech type view um uh effective altruism maybe like to your point of italic well I mean just like just to kind of insert a 10 second parents out of all I think uh just to remember that like as a little less two years ago the main criticism of effective altruism is that these are tech people who believe that like quantitative and technological solution as stuff is the problem to everything and uh you know ignore the non tech the the non-technical and a measurable side of life right um and so fast forward two years later and now like it's just interesting to note that uh you know if they're basically being criticized from the exact opposite direction now right it is fascinating and and there does seem to be like to your point this is all the same tribe that has maybe like in crypto we call this a fork maybe a social fork right where we've got now these accelerationists coming out and saying whoa whoa uh we don't subscribe to kind of some of the anti-tech philosophy of of some in the AI safety movement I I would say that um bankless listeners may be in from you know David myself's perspective or first exposed to this through the AI conversation the AI safety debate so we had an episode back in February of 2023 with Elisir Yikowsky that is like what I would say imprinted on my soul italic okay so like it was basically the first time I was exposed in depth to someone who's very intelligent and had been thinking about a concept for decades now here it was with chat GPT that the AI posed actual existential threat to um to humanity and so we went on a quick side quest a you know uh from our regularly scheduled crypto channel to to explore that a bit and we uncovered that this is not just a a question that um bankless and people in crypto are facing but it's a societal level question and it feels like the rest of societies is you know the the reason David put this into two camps I I realized that there's a lot of you know subtlety and and granularity between the two camps but it's almost like societies being asked to choose right what do you think about technology do you want to pedal to the floor and fully accelerate or do you want to just stop slow it down and just like be cautious and so I I'm wondering of italic if you could give a quick definition for folks that are unfamiliar what is the accelerationist view I think you have a a meme of this that opens your article uh and it says like dangerous behind utopia head that's the accelerationist view for for you know with respect to technology and the anti-tech view is there's safety behind in dystopia head so we're we're journing into this uh you know uh we're journing into this dangerous frontier I guess I would say is the anti-tech view could you just illustrate the the core viewpoints of of both camps to ground us in this episode?
sure um so the way that I would think about the yeah effective um accelerationist perspective is basically uh like it's all about recognizing the invisible graveyard right um the yeah invisible graveyard is a phrase that I think either Alex tabrock or someone else came up with in the context of uh talking about the harm that the uh FDA causes in the US just by yeah delaying the extents to which it approves certain drugs right basically yeah that if a life-saving medicine gets delayed even by a month because of uh regulatory hurdles then like that's something that can easily kill tens of thousands of people and uh if you do the math then the uh amount of people killed by these things potentially goes way higher and if you kind of zoom out even a bit more broadly like in the meme there right you have a utopia ahead and then behind you you have a bear and the biggest bear of the wall is uh probably aging right which is uh you know a condition that kills a um you know about about 60 million like literally a year world war two scale a number of people every year and if technology doesn't massively accelerate the base cases that literally all of us are including everyone listening to this podcast right now is going to die right and uh the gains that come from uh technology are just massive right like if you just think about the difference between the kind of life that we have now and the yeah life that we have um a thousand years ago or even 50 years ago there's just a whole number of both measurable and immeasurable things that have massively improved and like the these improvements are incredibly large and the these improvements can even overshadow some of the worst things that happen and even if you can blame some of those things on technology right so like if you look at the chart for example right like we can understand what some of those dips are right um so like for example if you um look there's like a whole bunch of correlated dips in the 1910s and obviously that's world war one in the case where there's a double dip the second dip is the Spanish flu um by the way bankless listeners had a life expectancy chart over the past 120 years or so yeah and it has uh think about eight lines for various countries you know US Europe Asia um so there's some dips in the 1910s where there's double dips it's uh uh where we're one in Spanish flu in the uh 1940s there's uh dips which is obviously world war two then China's got a dip in 1960 which has to greatly forward and so there's like very visible disasters um along here but if you just zoom out even a bit they yeah all of these um dips ultimately are overshadowed by just like the incredibly large gains from medical technology right and so grow like growth in technology does a lot and even growth in wealth does a lot for example right because if you imagine a world where everyone is wealthy then like that say world where if you suddenly have to like leave your home and pack up and go to another country then like you're not going to starve you're going to like basically walk into a much more stable situation than you what otherwise right and so there's just all of these big positives that come from technological gains and there's like an unrelenting history of thousands of years of uh technology repeatedly doing good despite lots and lots of people um you know excreaching and complaining that things could end up going in the opposite direction right so that's the acceleration is case um here the um anti-tech case I think it's important to separate the kind of old school anti-tech case versus the AI tumor case more specifically right um so the old school anti-tech case it's one that I admittedly am you know like on balance very uh not sympathetic to and you know like I've written about this in the article but I think if I had to illustrate kind of the the really uh biggest and most important like the strongest parts of that case um obviously yeah the environments and climate change are a really big aspect of this right so there's this chart of how temperatures are suddenly rising in a way that's like totally yeah unprecedented in any um you know historical natural situation except possibly for like you know like asteroids that like fell um you know like many tens of millions of years years ago or something similar right yep there's uh there's the graph right it just uh over the last century and a half it's just convertical there's graphs of a species extinction that are pretty bad there's graphs of like even like populations of particular animals that are pretty bad there's um and then another um a kind of aspect of this that starts uh you know like bleeding into the AI discussion is like the possibility of a technology getting this used by authoritarian governments um but I feel like even like that's not a risk of super intelligent AI but that is a I mean super intelligent AI would make the risk worse but that even is a risk of like present AI and like present day surveillance technology um then there is just a fact that like easier communication um creates greater economies of scale and that creates greater centralization which creates opportunities for political conflict of a yes scale that uh totally yeah did not exist before so you could try to make that argument though I think at the same time like again just kind would be a pretty yeah big counter argument to that right this is uh you know the guy who uh genocide it about as many people as Hitler back in the 13th century but then for some reason it's like totally socially acceptable to sing songs about him today um but Jane Jane this kind is like oh my god yeah so there's uh but let's uh the yeah um and then I think um on the climate side like my uh my counter arguments to that case is basically that like there have been there is a history of lots of uh specific environmental issues that once they became bad we actually did get together and solve them and uh you know improvements in air quality in cities are a big one right like I yeah I remember seeing the tail end of this myself and the first time I visited in uh Beijing back in 2014 just remember how incredibly smoggy it is and like that aspect of China like improved massively and very visibly over the yeah um you know like six years that I went to to visit over and over again um since then um so and then you know there's like ozone and like some reforestation and some areas and so forth right so like that would be the counter to the counter um but then the anti-tech argument that is more compelling to me personally is like this what the the like very specific one about super intelligent AI right and super intelligent AI to me is uh like one something that one way to think about it is to think about it as being something that's in the category of technology so like think about it as being the same kind of thing as smartphones the internet contraception the printing press the wheel guns um um like the steam engine and these are technologies that in many cases really were socially disruptive and in many cases definitely did um you know harm people who depended on the incumbents but at the same time like if you just look at it from the uh I have long term history and you realize that um you know there's massive good that came out of most of them um I mean guns are I think more controversial right because like like military technology is the one branch of technology where like it's uh I think much less clear that like improvements are good um though I mean actually even there right there's an interesting argument that some historians make that guns are sort of more democratizing than the previous wave of military technology which was Bose which uh you know required like 10 years of training to be able to use well and so I kind of enabled um more centralized forms of government but uh you know even even still right like military technology is like the other big exception in general right but uh you aside from military technology like on average technology is bit crazy good and so if you think of AI's being technology then like your first instinct is going to be AI's going to be crazy good and like maybe you would worry about AI military applications right but if you instead think about AI as not creating a tool but as creating a new type of mind and creating a new type of mind that is far more intelligent and powerful than the human mind then like this puts us in a totally different category right like uh if you think about humans right humans have been able to take over and utterly dominate the world and even um accidentally genocide all kinds of species of animals um just in in most cases was like a milk without even intended or even realizing that that's what we're doing and humans got into this position of power entirely because of mineral our minds right like our minds enabled us to create uh tools technology better work together collectively and uh cooperate and do all of these things and then now imagine an AI that beats humans on that exact same metric right by a factor of uh mineral like a ten thousand right then the question is like well what's going to happen to humans and the big risk here is that um comes from this um argument of uh that I call um well two arguments right one argument is the difficulty of alignment and the second argument is instrumental convergence um so the difficulty of alignment is basically the difficulty of uh like just making a thing that has the same kinds of goals that we have and this is like a surprisingly hard problem that we just have no idea how to do right and like there have been um you know like plenty of these myths and legends in history that kind of talk about the alignment problem right so like there's um you know King Midas who um you know like famously yeah got the touch that turned everything into gold and then uh of course uh you know he ended up dying of starvation um then there was uh I forget who but the yeah Greek um you know like a mythical figure who wished for immortality but forgot to wish for eternal youth right and so there's like the problem that if you don't perfectly specify what you want then like there's lots of uh ways for that to be yeah just like slightly satisfied in a slightly different way do you guys remember that uh I think it was an Ed Grail and Poe short story called like the monkey's paw or something like this where uh the character receives a monkey's paw that that gives him three wishes and so he would wish for things like one of his wishes was um you know his uh his um he wished for money uh and what ended up happening is the monkey's paw granted the wish but his son died later that day in a tragic factory accident and so he received some proceeds from the workers compensation policy like that's how the wishes were fulfilled it reminds me of that as well.
Yeah now I mean I think um one kind of rebuttal to this that like lots of people make and uh that I've made is that like if you think about if you just interact with um you know like existing AIs like even chat gpt is just a little bit like these are not um you know hyper autistic robots that have no idea how to understand like context and uh unexpressed intentions and subtext right I'm like uh like gpt will totally be understand that uh you know if a human says I want anything I touch the turns of gold here um you know it has an exception in mind for things like food and water and medicine right um but they're ill well like this by itself doesn't save us and it gets a little bit more tricky to sort of explain why right but I bug I can try um basically yeah I mean the best analogy unfortunately is kind of like looking at some of the previous generation of AI that we've had like remember back in the mid 2010s when people were starting to work with deep learning AIs for the first time and they were starting to get like kind of good at making pretty pictures and there is like a thing that you can do where you can run the model forwards and if you run the model forwards you pass in an image and it tells you like is this thing a cat or is this thing a dog but then you can also run the model backwards right and you can pass in the input that like I want to uh the ultimate essence of a dog like I want the thing that really is gonna be a hundred percent dog it's gonna maximize the extent to which this classifier is gonna tell me that this thing is definitely a dog it's not something else and then you run it through and it generates the image that maximizes that and it turns out that what you get is totally not a dog right what you get is like some insanely crazy contraption that definitely like has doggy aesthetics but it's also got it I mean like maybe 12 eyes maybe 48 eyes maybe there's like a whole bunch of dogs that have merged the bodies is just like looks like some totally crazy thing and getting visuals of a kaleidoscope of a dog right exactly right and like this is the thing that like maximizes the dog parameter right and I think another example is like us humans have sort of hacked evolution in the same way right so like if you think about what evolution is evolution is like this agent that uh has a goal right and its goal is to like maximize the reproductive fitness so you know survival times how many children you have of whatever agents it's operating on in their environments right and in order to fulfill the subjective evolution gave humans a lot of desires right like there is the desire to have um food the desire to have delicious food right and uh like what what is delicious and what isn't delicious while those are things that we're fine tuned based on like what is nutritious in the in the natural environment right and then there's the yeah there's a lot of desires associated with reproduction there's um no desires associated with survival and all kinds of things right but then look at how modern humans have uh dealt with these desires right and one is we've created a lot of food that's like hyper optimized for deliciousness that in a lot of cases doesn't do well at all on nutritional value right um we have invented at least like five separate different types of technology that let people have sex without getting pregnant right we've uh um invented all kinds of things that like satisfy the proxies that evolution has created in our minds for evolution's goals but that do not actually satisfy evolution's goals at all right and um you know the results of this is that like lots of people are eating unhealthy food and there's uh increasingly a yeah deep population crisis with lots of countries having fertility rates that are below one right and so it's uh now one thing you might ask is like well surely you know like we as humans know that we are not following the goals of mother nature and the answer is yes we know very well that we're not following the goals of one nature but guess what we are humans our goal like the in maximizing reproductive fitness is the goal that mother nature had that it is not the goal and we know that mother nature was not able to perfectly sort of copy its goal into us but we don't care we we have our goals and we follow what our goals are right and so we're in the case of AI what might happen is like we tell the AI um you know like azalex treatment would say so like um you know like bring more love and peace into the world um and then the AI would discover that like okay here's a bunch of things that look like love and peace and uh these are things that we would all recognize as being love and peace but then at some point it would discover like wait if i create this 47-dimensional squiggly that looks in this particular way then like it's going to be even better at max like satisfying its own internal conception of uh you know like the love and peace which is going to be slightly off because anything is uh that is created by any finite process is going to be slightly off and uh this 47-dimensional squiggly is going to look incredibly lovely and peaceful to the AI but it's like nothing that any of us would recognize as being um love and peace in any sense right and then we go and tell the AI bring more love and peace into the world and then the AI just kills all of us in our places that's all with 47-dimensional squigglys right um so this is kind of the AI safety case right i mean this is uh basically the same as i you know what i remember um elizor yadkowski yeah i told you guys and it's the same thing as what a lot of people have said um so this is like one of my yeah points of concern regarding AI but and in my post i also talked about two other points of concern regarding AI um where one of them is just this question of like well even if everything goes well um like is this actually a world that we would want to live in right and it turns out that like if you examine the sci-fi worlds that people have tried to come up with that that show um you know humans and bots living in harmony then like either the world is like insanely unrealistic and it's just unstable and it's just obviously going to collapse into AI's dominated together thing in in like in in another one to 10 years or it's like a world that actually really feels quite deeply unsatisfying from and like most people's perspectives today right like we're basically talking about a world where i'm you know we've become we all become pets of the yeah superbot and uh a kind of human agency doesn't really play any part in uh you know determining which way the universe goes from there and by the way of italic for for those that that maybe doubt that um a bunch of machines or bunch of computers could actually rest control over humanity i when i was reading your article at you know i was in kind of a serious mood and i was drinking some coffee i literally spat out my coffee laughing at this uh this turn of phrase you used you said this to see why the machines could rest control over humanity imagine that you are legally a literal slave of an eight-year-old child if you could talk with that child for long enough time do you think you could convince the child to sign a piece of paper setting you free i've not run this experiment but my instinctive answer is a strong yes and so all in all humans becoming pets seems like an attractor that is very hard to escape i was just visually visualizing in my mind trying to convince an eight-year-old uh child to to set me free and what that process would would look like and that's kind of what we're dealing with when we're dealing with a super intelligence it's uh to to to them we would be that eight-year-old child it would have probably no trouble convincing us uh to do whatever it wants to fulfill whatever outcome uh and and set of goals that it had yeah and then the other thing to keep in mind is um that like to the extent that there is any notion of competition in this uh world of the future like whoever really gives up control of the reins to the AI is going to outperform the people that don't because uh you know like that's what happens in chess that's what happens in go that's uh you know just what eventually yeah happens anywhere right um so that and then the third risk that i yeah um outlined is basically yeah you know essentialization and surveillance right and this isn't even just a risk of super intelligent AI it's a risk of like basically AI of the type that exists already and this is um actually in some cases situations that happen already right um so uh one of the things that's been happening in russia for the yeah past while actually yeah even uh quite a bit before the recent war started is that uh you'd have uh uh protests right and uh the unfortunately yeah i mean oh the authoritarians discovered this one weird trick which is you let the protest happen and you uh you know you send the police out and uh you know like you do the usual pro uh you know like protest versus police thing a little bit but like you don't aim to crush it right then and there but you have the cameras out and then you identify who all of the key people in the protest are and then at some point later at 2 a.
m. they get a knock on the door and uh uh you know like repeated and uh rinse uh about a hundred times and uh five years later suddenly you have uh like basically yeah almost no one left to lead the protests right and meanwhile every other single country is like oh this is a normal functioning you know society who's expressing their desires and they are free to express their desires exactly yeah it's like much less visible which makes it kind of much more difficult to coordinate against it's and uh um you know it makes it much more difficult to um even create outrage against it internationally um it's uh yeah i mean it's a big problem i mean i think it's uh like a big part of the yeah reason why yeah like it feels like protests against others here in regimes have been getting less and less effective for the past while um and uh like if you just extrapolate this trend even further then the risk um basically is that uh like there isn't a place to hide anymore right like there isn't a place where any kind of uh credible opposition movement to a yeah government could even start because as soon as it starts the surveillance can detect it um and uh um you know you don't even need uh like physical police at some point the yeah AI soldiers could just uh I mean i could go and shut it down and uh this gets even worse when we think about wars uh because uh like the need to get the population on your side has historically like actually been a pretty significant break um at least slowing down uh people's desires uh to uh go to war but then if your entire army is a bunch of uh robots then like you know the dictator gets drunk at 10 p.
m they yeah see someone being mean to them on twitter at 11 p.m and uh the drones um you know start uh flying and raiding hellfire on other countries before midnight right um and so this what kind of natural check and balance that comes from the facts that like what are ultimately there are decentralized humans that have to be doing the executing and if you try to do something really terrible then like those humans are going to be demoralized and uh you know like they're going to be much worse uh they're going to be much worse willing to um go along with your plans and uh even if they do lots of them we're going to leak every single detail of uh your plans uh uh to the CIA or to whoever your opposition is which is uh actually yet another thing that uh you know fortunately yeah it did happen in Russia like once uh you know like you have uh AI armies like all all of those checks the balances go away right um and so this is my other big um concern about AI like basically is this sort of you know the ultimate centralization from which uh at some point uh there might not actually be an escape um so that so those three cases are my yeah kind of big uh you know a condotive caution on artificial superintelligence in particular and how it's like pretty unique and pretty different from all the other other technology is that we've uh dealt with over the past uh like 10 millennium.
Okay David Talley so so David's gonna did I come and summarize this in a in a moment so we're tracking our our journey so far through this then then we we want to kind of introduce your your philosophy here and what you think the counter is and how that applies to crypto but I have one follow-up question that uh to you specifically that's been kind of burning in me since uh Ellie user uh podcast back in February and that is what do you think like so we we talked about three different uh AI risk scenarios the first is doom basically we all die the second is we become pets and I'm like at this stage it's better than one that's not so bad and then the third is totalitarianism but I want to go back to the first because that that's been giving me like an existential crisis all year what's your personal take on this I I know you've got a spectrum in your article on on what you called earlier the probability of doom the p-dume ratio what's what's your p-dume ratio and uh and why I'm just curious how at where you weigh in yeah uh so the uh number I gave in my tweet thread is 0.
1 so um you know 10% chance uh super intelligent AI is gonna kill us all um and I think the reason for this is like I see both sides of the arguments right like I see the yeah sort of quote doomer argument which uh basically yeah is uh essentially what I've already outlined to you guys and then I think uh if I had to give the counter doomer arguments I would basically say something like uh you know look at the kinds of ayes that we have now like there was kinds of ayes are not even goal seekers they basically yeah are things that you know like put on human costumes and sort of play out roles of the uh type that uh you know to uh of like whatever a type they sort of pattern match themselves into thinking that they're in at at that particular moment right like I chech epitit does not act like something that maximizes any particular objective um and like if you uh tell it to make the world more doggie like it's not going to do anything that looks like um you know maximize the assets of dog right it's uh going to um you know just uh do like give you a five paragraph essay that's like a pretty normal and human thing that like expresses like what might it mean to make the world a more doggie place and uh it's a sort of thing that's like pretty yeah inoffensive and like it looks like pretty fine right um so basically yeah if you just compare um you know the specific scenarios that um eight people are people worrying about AI yeah feared what happened with AI at current level of capabilities and then you compare that to like the actual thing that AI at current levels of capabilities does and like it's always quite different right and one thing I'm happy about is that I feel like the yeah the level of um like harm from deepfakes in particular so far has been much lower than what I think most people expected and even what I expected at current levels of capabilities right like if you explain to someone from from back in 2015 what the current level of capabilities of AI making deepfakes is like they're probably going to tell you like whoa like we can't trust anything that people say anymore like this is going to totally break elections and it's going to lead to all kinds of horrible consequences and like some bad stuff has happened but like the reality is much less than that fear right which is like interesting and uh surprising and like it uh I mean to some extent it shows the yeah I feel the um adaptability of mankind's to some extent it shows that mankind is less evil than some people fear um but and then of course the doom or what sort of counter by saying wow guess what like with uh super intelligence neither of those two things even matter uh because the AI is going to be doing all the work um but like it does still feel true that sort of the way that things keep progressing do sort of uh going different directions uh then um what uh you know like people's existing world worst fears have been and in ways that sometimes feel like we're going further and further away from the kinds of you know a hyper optimizer is that people are afraid of um so that's the case against um and uh well you know if I had to like again counter the counter I would say well that's LLM's and it's in looking very possible that like LLM's basically tap out at some level of capability and uh you know like GPT4 and like a little bit better than GPT4 is like basically what we're going to get um but then there's going to be some next technology which like could be combining LLM's and curening like you know it could be something else and uh like we don't even know what what what property is that next level of technology is going to have and so it's like a big wash out right um and so I think like there is a big problem uh chance that the AI doom problem is just like it it turns out that it was never that big a problem to begin with there is like a big chance that it is a really big problem and within that chance there's a really big chance that it is a really big problem but um you know with uh awareness and hard work we will be able to um deal with that and uh you know like make sure that we don't actually yeah get demified right so that's where sort of the I think the balance comes in right but like it's important to keep in mind that like a 10% probability of doom is still a big deal right so like for example like one analogy for this is like 10% is like I think greater by somewhere between a factor of one and three I forget like but it's like that like only a little bit greater than the probability that um any of us is going to die from a non biological cause um and so if you think about like the accident or something like this like car accident homicide suicide like any nasty thing that's not disease um then like if you think about the amount of just like care and effort and thought that you personally put into your physical safety and the amount of like care and concern that you expect I mean like governments to put into your physical safety with things like police then like roughly that level of care is a reasonable level of care to have about you know the possibility that something really bad is going to happen out of AI right and obviously like and that doesn't mean like overturn the entire world to suddenly care about this problem but it does definitely mean care about the problem more than we do today.
Arbitram is the leading Ethereum scaling solution that is home to hundreds of decentralized applications Arbitram's technology allows you to interact with Ethereum at scale with low fees and faster transactions Arbitram has the leading DeFi ecosystem, strong infrastructure options, flourishing NFTs and is quickly becoming the Web3 gaming hub. Explore the ecosystem at portal.arbitram.io. Are you looking to permissionlessly launch your own Arbitram orbit chain? Arbitram orbit allows anyone to utilize Arbitram's secure scaling technology to build your own orbit chain giving you access to interoperable customizable permissions with dedicated throughput whether you're a developer an enterprise or a user Arbitram orbit lets you take your project to new heights.
All of these technologies leverage the security and decentralization of Ethereum. Experience Web3 development the way it was always meant to be secure, fast, cheap and friction-free. Visit Arbitram.io and get your journey started in one of the largest Ethereum communities. Selow is the mobile first EVM compatible carbon negative blockchain built for the real world and now something big is happening. Introducing the Selow Layer 2. It's a game-changing proposal that's going to bring Selow's rapidly growing ecosystem home to Ethereum. Vitalik has shared his excitement for the Selow Layer 2 on the Selow forum, so has Ben Jones from Optimism.
But why? The Selow Layer 2 will bring huge advantages, like a decentralized sequencer, off-chain data availability, and one block finality. Which is all that mean? Rock solid security, a trustless bridge to Ethereum, and more real world use cases for Ethereum without compromise. And real world adoption is happening. Active addresses on Selow have grown over 500% in the last six months. With the Selow Layer 2, gas fees will stay low and you can even pay for gas using ERC20 tokens. But, Selow is a community-governed protocol. This means that Selow needs you to weigh in and make your voice heard.
Join the conversation in the Selow forum. Follow at Seloworg on Twitter and visit Selow.org to shape the future of Ethereum. Introducing GMX, the deepest on-chain futures market to trade Bitcoin, Ethereum, and leading altcoins. GMX is a permissionless decentralized exchange that offers perpetual futures and spot trading. Lightning fast trade execution and competitive pricing, with the security and self-custody of a decentralized exchange. GMX is live now, with V2 bringing new optimizations to on-chain leverage trading. And even more than an improved trading experience, GMX will reward you for just participating.
All GMX users can easily set up a referral link, and with $12 million of arbitrage grants being distributed as incentives, and over $150 billion in trading volume today, all settled on-chain. GMX is leading the charge in terms of opportunities for defy liquidity providers. The future is on-chain with your waltz, with your trades, and with your money in your own hands. Try it out now at app.gmx.io. So, if it's time I want to kick this tool and throw us all the way back to the start of this conversation, we just went down like this AI rabbit hole to talk about the potential risks of acceleration, which is one of these camps that has kind of emerged and thought as our society is having this conversation.
The risks of going forward in time and accelerating our progress with technology, and you've labeled like, well, AI is this exceptional case that we need to consider the circumstances of some other examples are like climate change. There seems to be a correlation with the increased risk of climate change in the quickening of technology, and this is the decelerationist camp, if you will, and then the accelerationist camp, which I think you have said that you more are more resonant with, says that, well, there are as technology advances, we find these occurrences in history, these wars, these increased capabilities to cause harm, but by and large, they are completely drowned out by all the other focuses, all the other developments of technology.
We've kind of set the stage for these different constructs of thought, and like all extremes, they're all relatively blunt, if you will, if you just only focus yourself in one school of thought, it's a blunt tool for the job, and as we progress forward in your article and in your thought, we start to get a little bit more nuanced, a little bit more, we don't have to be so blunt in our thought about the direction of society, we can pick and choose components from different schools of thought and put them all together. We understand that AI has risks, we understand that we have to solve climate change, we understand that technology presents new risks, yet nonetheless technology also helps us navigate those risks all the same.
So rather than having to pick an extreme, pick a tribe, if you will, a school of thought and be shoehorned in there, how would you propose, we think about all of these different things that we've put together here, if we're talking about a unified idea of thought, how would we have a framework for understanding, if we are going to go forward with technology, what is the correct path, the more optimistic, more precise path that we can maximize the good, because really all of these conversations are all about how do we maximize human welfare and well-being at the end of the day? How would you proceed in this conversation from here?
Yeah, so I think this is where the idea of DEAC that I came up with in the post really comes out of, right? So AC is obviously acceleration and DE is intentionally standing for primarily for defense, but also for decentralization and democratization. And so the idea of this philosophy is to basically look at the offense versus defense balance of the world, right? So basically look at how easy it is to do things that are like harm or go against the goals of other people versus how easy it is to protect yourself or if you're a community against that. And think of that as something that is and has always been shaped by technology, but also something that can be shaped by future choices in technology and to really focus on building defensive technology and especially, and I think this is the angle that is really naturally appeals to people in Ethereum and people listening to this.
Defense of technology is that work by improving defense in the abstract without kind of coming with a built-in or a built-in enforcer that decides what is good and what is bad across the entire world or across an entire ecosystem, right? You would say phrase differently, defensiveness as a platform or just a technology platform that allows defensive technologies to emerge. The word platform is interesting, right? Because I feel like this is one of those sort of sometimes VC buzzwords that means a lot of different things. The part of platform that appeals to me is like this idea that a lot of this is going to create involve creating common infrastructure and both defensive infrastructure and even common infrastructure that enables building many kinds of defensive infrastructure.
The part of platforms that I'm kind of wants that cautious to me against embracing that word is that a lot of things in the modern world that call themselves platforms are things that do contain this centralized actor that controls the thing and that plays this role of I'm not deciding who's good and who's bad, right? Like we talk about Facebook being a platform, I'm an open AI being a platform, Twitter being a platform, and like all of these things have centralized actors that run in control of them. They have centralized forms of moderation. They have not centralization on all kinds of levels and this is one of those things that creates a lot of problems, right?
So there's this book that was written recently that talks about this concept of weaponized interdependence and basically this idea that the type of technology that we've been building for the past 20 years. And when I say we, like I do mean, you know, the centralized world, like this is the place where the decentralized world gets to pat itself on the back and say, like, yeah, no, we're actually better than that, is that the technology has been networks technology and it's been it's network technology that creates centralized choke points where the creator of the technology has ongoing power over the users, right?
Like if you think about just going back to the year 1970 and let's say, yeah, like, look, pick, you know, like a random country that has powerful technology that we don't trust. Actually, let's just like not say anything bad about anyone in the physical world. Let's say you have like more door, right? Like let's say, yeah, you know, like you have literal more door and it just like pops up in the middle of the Atlantic and it turns out that that's what Atlantis was the whole time and it's the technological superpower, right? And imagine you're in the 1970s and you're buying cars and forks and knives and all kinds of things that are made in more door.
And we ask a thought experiment of like, what is the worst that the more doorians can do to you? And I think probably the worst that they could do is one, they could do false advertising, they could create things that look like they satisfy certain properties, but actually like way underperform on durability or on safety, for example, right? And like that is bad. The probably, yeah, the most evil thing that they could do is like what we call the razor blade model, right? Like basically, yeah, sell you devices, but then if those devices end up kind of depending on these sort of attachment parts that have to constantly get renewed and it turns out that more door is the only vendor of those.
So like that's the closest that you could that more door could do to like real to like really getting power over you just by being a vendor, right? Otherwise, it's like even if you're like very, you know, you know, like anti-z, yeah, more door and you have a, yeah, you know, cell run must die, yeah, you know, like poster on your wall and, you know, like you go around wearing, you know, free service on gold t shirts, like more door can't really do much to hurt you, right? But then fast forward to 2020, right? In 2020, we have network technology. And if more door builds smartphones and you use a smartphone from more door, well, the smartphone can spy on you.
If you use internet platforms from more door, those platforms can censor some political viewpoints and promote other political viewpoints, right? And it's going to tell you that like, hey, yeah, you know, this free service on gold thing is like actually, yeah, a bunch of terrorists and, and, you know, nobody's allowed to support them anymore. It can affect, you know, the domestic politics of other countries. It can add any particular moments, just like flip a switch and take, like, take away the technology from any subset of its users, right? And so the amount of power that you have over users by being the producer in a central in at least if you're building this kind of centralized network technology has just gone way up now compared to what it was in 1977, right?
And so the, yeah, like that's the aspect of platforms that actually, yeah, it's one of the things that this is even reacting to, right? It's even one of the things that the, yeah, I think crypto spaces really, yeah, reacting to, right? And so the goal here is to build defensive technologies that are not like that, right? Defensive technologies that do not assume that like they are being built in America and they're and they are going to be good because everyone in the world agrees that America is good, right? Because, you know, unfortunately, this kind of consensus does not exist in the world, right?
And like what we want to do is we want to build technologies where people can trust them, even if they have different opinions on what's good and what's bad. And these are technologies where there exist a lot of really interesting examples of already, right? So I, yes, split defensive technology into four different parts, right? Where I like the first split is the split between the world of bits and the world of atoms, right? And in the world of atoms, you have defense against big things and defense against small things and defense against small things is, of course, bio defense. And then in the world of bits, we have what I call cyber defense, which is like defense against things where if you look at them hard enough, it's obvious that they're attackers.
And then what I call info defense. And this was like a very specific distinction that I think other people haven't quite made in the same way that basically is about defending against things where there is much less consensus about who the attackers are, right? And the big example here is what we call misinformation, right? Like people don't want to be misinformed. People want to know the truth and not know false things. But a lot of the sort of quote anti misinformation ideas that have been proposed by the, you know, the mainstream world or I know what we might call the centralized world, they all involve there being a particular actor who understands what's right and what's wrong and basically forces that perspective across an entire ecosystem, right?
And so the question is like, well, can we build tools that actually avoid having that central point of like deciding what's good and what's bad for everyone? And so in the case of like the world of atoms, this is kind of somewhat easier. So I yet like in the world for macro, for example, I talk about building resilient physical infrastructure. I'm so, you know, even like the facts that we have solar panels and the fact that we have such amazing batteries now is like amazingly good, right? And if every household had those kinds of things, then like the amount of disruption that would happen to people's lives even as a result of, you know, cyber war or even regular war, which is what already be significantly lower, right?
If we had much more distributed agriculture than like that would improve things even more, right? So there's things that are just like obviously defensive without having to like come with an opinion attached of like who is the one that you're trusting to do the defending for you. And then in the bio space, like there's vaccines, there's other kinds of prophylactic things that boost your immune system. There's like, and then like I, yeah, basically talk about how there's like this entire set of things that we can do that we totally are not putting enough resources into right now that could totally create a much more airborne pandemic resistance world, where we have much less COVID, much less one COVID and even much less, you know, colds and flurs and where lots of diseases would basically stop before they even start because there are zero would it would end up even being less than one in this kind of world, but we just need more funding and more efforts to actually make this work this some happen.
And then in the world of bits, this is where crypto stuff really starts coming in somewhat, right? So like one of the things that I began this whole episode with is like asking the question, well, you know, crypto needs to also think about some of these issues that people are really, yeah, thinking a lot about in 2023 and what is the way that crypto is plays it to some of those concerns and like here it is, right? Like basically, yeah, we want to create a world that has a much more digital hardness baked into it by default and where digital attacks become much harder and digital defense becomes much easier, right?
And what's interesting about like the cryptocurrency and blockchain space is that it's great at doing that without relying on a single centralized party, right? So, you know, we are creating financial systems that work without relying on any specific country. We are creating forms of privacy that work without relying on a central actor to like hold the information, everyone's information in custody for them. We are creating forms of accounts recovery that don't depend on, you know, Google or Twitter having everyone's master keys. So that's happening with social recovery while it's in account of through action and ERC-4337.
We are creating zero knowledge proof technologies that let people prove that they are trustworthy without revealing any more information about themselves beyond that, right? So we're creating all of these really powerful tools that in a lot of cases are substitutes for more centralized forms of trust and one of the arguments that I make in that section is basically that like one of the reasons why the internet has become more centralized and a less free place over the last 15 years is basically because like there are threats and the easiest and laziest responses to threats that you could implement are responses that involve centralization, right?
Like require everyone to have a Google account to sign in and like that's your anti-symbol mechanism, right? And the the question is like, well, how can we actually bring privacy back? How can we actually bring, you know, the ability for unknowns to participate in the internet back? How can we actually let people do all of the things that they need to do without creating these mechanisms where like if you're in one of the, you know, quote, good countries, then you're trusted. But if you're in, you know, like one of the untrusted countries, then like you're screwed, right? And like these are things that actually happen, right?
Like, I mean, I love community notes, for example, and I talked about community notes very positively, but I remember there was this one thing about it that at least when I checked a couple of months ago, in order to join community notes, you needed to have a phone number from a quote trusted carrier. And I remember seeing a tweet from someone in India, basically saying like, hey guys, you just made like one of the major carriers and carriers in India that serves hundreds of millions of people untrusted. And like there's this big population that's like 5% of the world that's like locked out of being a community notes participant.
And like you can see how those kinds of problems just naturally come out of this centralized perspective on trust. And so if we can create like better and decentralized alternatives, then like this ends up really solving that kind of problem as well, right? So that's cyber defense, right? Basically, all of the yes stuff that we've been working on in terms of, you know, creating more decentralized and more robust financial systems in terms of grading these zero knowledge proof systems don't let us, you know, prove that we're good guys without revealing any other information that let us prove computations like all these things, they make a much more defense favoring world.
And so it's amazing that our space has been accelerating these technologies so much, right? And so that's kind of the core of the, yeah, you know, the way in which crypto fits into the yeah, deactivation. I'm getting a notion, Vitalik of Daniel Schmoktenberger and his metacrisis concepts where we have the increasing capabilities, increasing capacities of technology to do stuff good or bad doesn't really matter just stuff generally, neutrally. And some of that stuff sometimes ends up as like bad outcomes or just problems that need to be solved. And the concern here is that when technology is the introduces new problems to society that society just comes up with centralized solutions to that problem or corporations and entrepreneurs can just move quickly and solve problems before human humanity can come together to coordinate on a mutually assured platform.
I'm mutually assured defensive technology to answer this. And I think what I'm hearing from you is that well, certain elements of cryptography, coordination, via theorem not allows for a solution space to emerge that isn't merely just, you know, some large company slapping on that that patch onto society at large by say, hey, here's our solution. It seems to be like a, you know, the what you are illustrating here is like there is a middle ground between the chaotic production of highly capacity technology and just like centralized companies solving that that problem space. Is that a fair illustration?
Yeah, I mean, I think like the really important piece of this is basically creating these technologies that kind of improve the baseline defensiveness of the world while at the same time allowing the world to remain and, you know, it could be even more of a pluralistic place, right? So avoiding the usual trap where, you know, you basically have danger all the way up until one group just takes over everything and imposes it's well on everyone else. So Vitalik, you know, what you're proposing here is maybe a philosophical framework for where we're crypto fits, right? And the reason I really like this is because it seems to be like kind of a big tent and it's something that I personally resonate with.
So you're basically saying you don't have to pick the effective accelerationist, you know, the techno utopian version of the world. You don't have to pick the techno fob's vision of the world and kind of the Luddite Dumerism picture either. This is a third way and you're calling this defensive or decentralized, the deconstant for all sorts of different things or democracy or differential accelerationism. So this is D-AC basically. And crypto fits under the defensive technology in kind of the cyber type of use case. And it feels very much like what you're advocating for is technologies that increase and enhance human freedom.
And so this can also be a bulwark against maybe your AI risk scenario of a probability three that, you know, the AI brings about totalitarian technologies and now we have this defense, you know, it gets it. And the other thing I would say is it seems like it's a very broad tent. It's like who can't get behind some good old-fashioned defense, right? We're not talking about something that could destroy the world. We're just talking about regular individuals and societies being able to defend against something that can destroy the world. And I want you maybe to talk about this as a philosophical framework.
Like obviously people in crypto are hearing this. I'm sure they resonate. Oh, you're telling me that there's a, you know, a way to express, you know, my beliefs about crypto and this defensive and freedom enhancing and decentralized technology called D-AC. Like, sign me up. There's also, I think, some other camps that could listen to this and be interested. So you've got this section in your essay saying, is D-AC compatible with your existing philosophy? If you're an effective altruist, this is a rebranding of the idea. If you're a libertarian, there's something here for you. If you're a pluralist, if you're a public health advocate, I'm wondering if you talk to the specific camps here and the value that they might find in subscribing to the D-AC belief.
Of course, yeah, I know you're not, you're pushing it. You're not trying to necessarily convert people, but in order to explain it, maybe, can you talk about the winds for these various camps? Sure. I mean, any specific camp you want me to start with? I would love you to start with the libertarians, actually, because I think we have more than a few listening, maybe. Sure. I mean, I think the best way to think about this is it's a pathway to, like, basically, preserve mental equilibrium going into a much more technologically advanced 21st century. And I think the challenge that D-AC is looking at is basically that there are lots of technologies, including technologies that are being developed by governments or by corporations that are increasingly working with governments.
There was that recent A-16Z post that was talking pretty enthusiastically about American dynamism in defense, which, of course, means a military attack. And basically looking at, like, how do we create a world that with the rule, all of these changes and through all of these pressures, doesn't just kind of maneuver itself into being this incredibly, yes, centralized place where you've basically, yeah, got these probably, yeah, to somewhere between one to four of these sort of big super states worldwide that are in full control of their tech ecosystems. And, like, regular people basically have no option except for being stuck inside of one of these with no other real options for getting out of that equilibrium.
And so we can talk about the possibility that we'll have much more offensive AI in the hands of governments. You can also just look at existing trends in how the internet is not going the way that a lot of us hoped. The concept of internet anonymity, for example, which was like a big hope of people, I think, like 10 or 20 years ago, but then the internet is obviously becoming an increasingly difficult place to actually be anonymous. And a lot of the reason why is definitely just all of these mineral cybersecurity issues and people just kind of naturally grappling for, you know, the centralized solutions for those problems because they're the easy ones.
And Diak basically tries to ask the question of like, well, there are threats. And you can go after a threat either by hunting down all the wolves or by putting armor on the sheep. Right. And putting armor on the sheep is like philosophically much better if you can do that. Right. Because the problem with hunting down all the wolves is like, well, we have the wolves are some of us. And like, we have to agree on who the wolves are. And like, there is a risk that, you know, the government's going to decide one day that you're one of the wolves. Right. And the ones don't want to be hunted. Exactly.
And if, you know, like we, yeah, instead say like, let's make it with the world a more defense favoring place by default, then like, that is something that is much harder to, you know, like twist into a narrative for like why, yeah, like governments should just like go after all kinds of all kinds of people that they don't like. Okay. So. So Diak has some wins for libertarians here. How about the solar punks? How about the Kevin O'Walky region type community who are very oriented on, you know, collective action and human coordination? Are there, are there wins in Diak for that community? Absolutely.
I mean, I think solar punk again is, I think, a school that values human flourishing and values cooperation. It's also values decentralization as well. I think, you know, ultimately there is, you know, a punk in solar punk. It's not, you know, like solar monolith, right. And I think a lot of people in that camp are concerned about like the resilience of the, yeah, of the world going forward, our ability to survive different kinds of risks. And are probably very cognizant of the fact that like all kinds of centralized actors, including both corporations and governments can be a yeah, big problem in making a lot of those risks larger.
And what Diak basically, yeah, says, is it says like here is a set of tools that we can use to like just cut down on a lot of those risks just across the board and make the the world one that is like much more friendly to human flourishing without having to construct any of those kinds of monoliths, right. So like if you think about the idea of like, let's say the bio defense side of this, right, we can basically make a world that is much more protected against diseases, natural and artificial pandemics, all kinds of things natively just by having cleaner air. And this is, I mean, it's a much more natural solution, and it's a, you know, it's a yes, it's a solution to that problem that really, yeah, avoids some of the downsides of, you know, like things like walk downs that we've seen, which, you know, can be justified if there's enough of a health risk in a particular situation, but which also are just kind of massive, you know, like forced changes in the way that people just like live their regular lives with their with their families and, you know, if they're regular relationships and their work.
And so it's something that like it's an approach that allows us to be yet in in harmony with each other. I would also, I'm even say, yeah, in harmony with nature, because I think defense includes protecting the environment absolutely. It's, you know, an approach that leverages local communities instead of trying to put power into these kind of big super states that decide, you know, like what is good and what is bad on behalf of like the entire world or on behalf of much larger groups of people. It's a, yeah, world that really, yeah, empowers local coordination much more. And so I think there's a lot of technology is within the idea from umbrella, especially if you look at the, yeah, kind of info defense category that we didn't go too much into that like really talks about improving social technology that I can really, yeah, make society of both more defended against attacks and much more of the kind of society that has the kinds of relationships that solar punks would want us to have.
The D can also stand for a democratic and yeah, we didn't have a chance to delve into that. But okay, so we got the libertarians. We got some wins in D Act for libertarians. We got some wins for the solar punks. Let's talk about the original group that we started this entire episode with, which is on the one side is someone like Mark Andreessen, who is an EAC. He's effective accelerationism, full throttle, pedal to the metal, let's just do technology. And the other side is, you know, somebody who's maybe in the EA community, the effective altruist community. So can you get, can you get Mark Andreessen on board with, with Deac?
And can you get Elisir Yukowski on board with Deac? Could they, could they both agree about this one, you know, like narrow subset of technology accelerationism, do you think? I mean, the post got retweeted by, you know, Mark Andreessen and by AI not kill everyone is a meme. Yeah, yeah, you know, it's a pretty successful already. And I think the really big piece of it here is that I think for the EAC side, the thing that it brings that a lot of the previous philosophies don't bring is, I mean, one is there's just optimism about technology in general, but then there also is an alternate path forward, right?
So the message is not just pause. The message is like, we proceed. And here are some alternative routes for how to proceed differently. And so if you are a builder, then like your, like the perspective does not kind of frame you as being an incorrigible enemy, right? Like you can continue being a builder. And there's plenty of amazing roles for builders that do really great things within the, yeah, within the Deac context. And the final stage of Deac being successful, like if we imagine going out to the year 3000, like really does look like a, you know, like post singularity, yeah, you know, like Kardashian type to like super advanced technological society of exactly the type that, yeah, can shreds humanist people have been dreaming about.
And for people who are in the AI safety camp, I mean, the concept of differential technology development is something that a lot of effective altruists have actually been already been talking about, right? So I included a link to one of those posts. But I think the thing that it adds is this kind of emphasis on a more democratic political approach. And like this probably is one of the big areas that, you know, like effective altruists do get criticized for, right? And like sometimes the criticism is, you know, like unfounded because like if you put, you know, the governments in charge of like distributed public health funding, then like realistically, it's going to be rich people, countries, governments, and like, you know, you're going to like national governments have a huge track record of like not even caring about what's going on in Africa, whereas effective altruists like actually already have put a lot of money in, right?
But at the same time, once effective altruism starts going away from putting money into obviously good, but we just might disagree on how good things and into kind of manipulating like big political objects, then like you start really needing to care much more about legitimacy. And to me, I feel like both of the big effective altruist related, you know, like fails, if you can call them over the last two years, what right where one is the opening-eye situation and the other is FTX. FTX, I mean, to me, they both have to do with under-rating legitimacy, right? Like SPF was clearly, I mean, he had all kinds of massive problems, but one of them is definitely that he just overrated the extents to which he could become a massively negative value actor just by, like, delegitimizing the ideas that he deeply cared about, right?
And then on the open-eye side, like basically what we saw was we saw a seemingly earnest and well-intentioned effort to kind of create a kind of clamps on open-eye open- the open-eye effort that could try to kind of reduce its potential to become super harmful by creating this board that could push things in the other direction, but the problem is like it tried to do all of this through a completely undemocratic and unaccountable board of five people that saw no need to even try to explain its actions to the wider public, right? And then what happened was like, well, it fired Sam Altman and then basically within three days, well, it was like in some ways like a pretty unprecedented political fail because what happened was the employees of the company, who are probably, you know, like capitalists, delivery and leaning, just like tech software types in a lot of cases, formed an impromptu union to side with the billionaire CEO against the board, right?
Like, that's like a pretty big fail if you think about it that way, right? Like, congrats, you got software engineers to unionize, except they're standing behind the billionaire. And, you know, if, and so I think the thing that like deac ideas can really bring here is basically bringing back some of these concerns about legitimacy and like understanding that, you know, you're not just spending money points, but you're also spending social capital points and like, you really need to take that seriously. And like, bringing that in in a way that's not just sort of an adjunct, but that is a really core part of the philosophy, right?
Like, it's a core part of the deac philosophy that we are trying to create a world that is more defense favoring from anyone's perspective, regardless of whether or not you agree with any specific actor that is going to be, yeah, that would enforce like its own idea of who the wolves are and who the wolves are not, right? The last group to ask you about here on kind of compatible philosophy that's near and dear to our hearts is how about the crypto tribes? So we have big coiners, we have theetherians, we have people are into Salana and Cosmos and there's a lot of tribalism. Do you think something like deac, we can all stack hands on something like deac and say, hey, these are a common set of core values, defensive decentralization technology that that we all agree on.
Yeah, we have our differences with respect to implementation, but can we all unite behind something like deac, is it that wide of a tent to bring the crypto tribes together? I think it absolutely could be and I think this is one of the most places where I think it's it's good to give a positive shout out to like some of the positive aspects of the bit of the Bitcoin community, which is that like they're definitely is a strong sub community and there that cares about non blockchain decentralization tech, right? Like there's big coiners who really support things like Noster, there's big coiners who support tour and you know things like internet freedom tech, there's big coiners who have supported more secure operating systems, there's and then there's aetherian people who have also supported like all kinds of things in each of those categories as well, right?
And so I think the idea of viewing the blockchain world as being one part of this somewhat larger thing, which is a decentralization favoring vision of cybersecurity and then seeing that itself as being one picture in a broader vision of, you know, decentralization, friendly, like pushing the offense defense balance strongly toward defense is something that if you're in people and in Bitcoin people and a lot of people as well can absolutely get behind. But talk, I'd like to throw a different candidate for what the D means for in deac. Mine might be directional acceleration. I thought you were going to say David.
That can be a different topic with the Dave Dow. But so to me, there's like the tribal debates between decelerationism and accelerationism or effective altruism and accelerationism. And when there is these tribal debates, usually the weaknesses inside of one tribe never really get addressed by that tribe because they only ever really argue in relation to a different tribe. The way I hear this blog post and hear you speaking about is like, hey, we're going to move forward in scientific progress. We're going to have technology that has higher capacities. And now it's really just a matter of picking our direction, our priorities, and where we want to go and what technologies we want to prioritize first.
Because I think generally most people accept the technology has helped the world over the grand over the grand arc of time. And now it's really more about choosing which direction we go in. Rather than blindly saying, yes, it's forward. It's more about saying, yes, forward and over here in this particular direction. How would you feel about directional accelerationism? Yeah. I mean, I think with the caveat that it's totally possible to create a directional acceleration story that I totally disagree with. But you know, as long as we, we still have to debate in which direction. Exactly. As long as we understand which direction is, I mean, you think, yes, absolutely.
Vitalik, as we maybe conclude this episode, you've given us a fantastic tour of this whole debate, this societal debate in this context and crypto and a great definition of deac, which is I think it's just a fantastic philosophy that I think Bangladesh listeners will probably take some time to mull over. But your article concludes with this. It includes with some optimism for human potential here. You say, human beings are deeply good. And I got to confess, like in my darkest moments, of course, I sometimes doubt whether that is actually true. And if you look at, you know, even crypto in 2022, I feel like we all came out of that collectively as an industry pretty beat up, pretty doubtful that human beings are deeply good.
But you say this, I love technology because technology expands human potential. We are the brightest star. 10,000 years ago, we could build some hand tools, change which plants grow on a small patch of land and build basic houses. Today, we can build 800 meter tall towers, store the entirety of recorded human knowledge and device that we can hold in our hands, communicate instantly across the globe, double our lifespan and live happy and fulfilling lives without fear of our best friends regularly dropping dead of disease. Zooming out, we have come quite a ways. Haven't we? What grounds your belief that human beings are deeply good, Vitellic?
I mean, I think just like what other thing even remotely compares to us, right? This is the question to ask, right? You know, the universe is a very lifeless and unforgiving place, right? Where we've had, you know, like first nine billion, seven to nine billion years of the just stars and planets crashing into each other and randomly creating supernovas that would just completely wipe away everything within a light years without thinking about it. And then we had four billion years of life, but life that was very nasty, very brutish, very short, and that basically involved the milic predators constantly running around and eating prey and everyone being on the brink of the dropping dead of disease and starvation.
And, you know, there is not a single example of a cat that modifies its eating behavior because of a principled stand that killing mice is wrong, right? Like that is just not a thing that happens. Whereas with humans, there are plenty of humans that have written entire screeds on why this is the case and that have made like huge personal sacrifices to protect the people or animals or plants that they care about. And I think to the extent that this happens, it's incredibly amazing and incredibly beautiful. And I think if humanity continues on a positive trajectory, then the amount of good that we can do just multiplies even further exponentially from there, right?
Like in the 21st century, I think there is a big chance that we're finally going to turn the corner on factory-farmed animals. And probably the biggest moral catastrophe that you still can blame my humans for is something that we will actually end up moving beyond. And then to, you know, one billion gears from now, the sun is scheduled to get bright, get so bright that life on earth is not going to be possible anymore, right? And, you know, does the sun think about the moral consequences of this act that it's going to make? Well, no, it does not, right? But humans, well, what can we do? Well, you know, we can sprinkle, you know, a calcium carbonite or sulfur into the air and compensate and reduce the amount of light that reaches the surface.
We can, you know, build giant mirrors in space to reflect the light. We can go and terraform Mars. We can do all kinds of things. And so if, you know, the beauty of earthly life, life is still going to shine two billion years from now, it will be because of us, right? And so I think we carry the torch of this just enormous potential that is unparalleled in any other thing in the universe that we currently have evidence of the existence of. And it's our job to do a good job of carrying that torch and carry the torch forward. What a fantastic way to end it. I think that's what the the deac movement it sounds like is all about.
And I, you know, I could say, a bank list is certainly part of that movement. And I'm hopeful with crypto, we can help carry that torch further. So I'll leave maybe bank list listeners with this line from your article. We are the brightest star. There's a lot of good that can come from ongoing human progress into the stars and beyond. But there are big forks in the road. And we need to choose carefully accelerate, but accelerate carefully and well. Vitalik Buren, thank you so much for joining us today. Some action items for you, bank list nation, link to the tweet thread that we discussed today.
My techno optimism, that's a Vitalik's article, we'll include a link to that. And also the article itself, wrist and disclaimers, of course, crypto is risky. So is philosophy. So is technology. So many. Yeah, I think so. You could definitely lose what you put in, but we are headed west. This is the frontier. It's not for everyone, but we're glad you're with us on the bank list journey. Thanks a lot.