✨ DEBRIEF | Ryan & David unpacking the episode: https://www.bankless.com/debrief-garry-kasparov
----- Chess Legend and Freedom Fighter Garry Kasparov on AI, Geopolitics, and Crypto.
One of the first people to experience machine intelligence in a profound way–greatest chess player in the world when he lost a match to IBM computer program Deep Blue in 1997—since then, humans have never been able to beat machines in a game of chess.
The theme of this episode is Freedom. Garry’s optimism shines through on this topic. With experience in Geopolitics, Artificial Intelligence, and Human Rights, Garry Kasparov might just be the perfect guest to guide us through some very challenging topics that will likely define the rest of this decade, and beyond.
----- 🏹 Airdrop Hunter is HERE, join your first HUNT today https://bankless.cc/JoinYourFirstHUNT
----- 🌐 Layer Zero V2 Launch https://bankless.cc/LayerZeroLabs
------ BANKLESS SPONSOR TOOLS:
🐙KRAKEN | MOST-TRUSTED CRYPTO EXCHANGE https://k.xyz/bankless-pod-q2
🦊METAMASK PORTFOLIO | MANAGE YOUR WEB3 EVERYTHING https://bankless.cc/MetaMask
⚖️ARBITRUM | SCALING ETHEREUM https://bankless.cc/Arbitrum
🔗CELO | CEL2 COMING SOON https://bankless.cc/Celo
🗣️TOKU | CRYPTO EMPLOYMENT SOLUTION https://bankless.cc/Toku
------ TIMESTAMPS
0:00 Intro 9:00 Gary’s Background 20:45 Chess & AI 24:38 e/acc vs. d/acc 28:53 AI & Human History 37:40 Russia & Freedom 49:25 Can Democracy Win? 56:32 Defining Evil 59:31 Garry on Crypto 1:03:00 Leadership 1:08:50 Biggest Threat to Freedom? 1:17:53 Crypto & Human Rights 1:21:01 Garry’s Human Rights Fight 1:29:15 Garry’s Advice 1:33:05 Closing & Disclaimers
------ RESOURCES
Garry Kasparov https://twitter.com/Kasparov63
Human Rights Foundation https://hrf.org/
------ Not financial or tax advice. See our investment disclosures here: https://bankless.com/disclosures
No summary for this episode yet.
What do you think is the biggest threat to freedom right now? Is it China? Is it Russia? And actually, I want to throw a third candidate in there. The United States. I mean, is that a threat to freedom? Welcome to Bankless, where we explore the frontier of internet money and internet finance. This is Ryan Sean Adams. I'm here with David Hoffman. And we are here to help you become more bankless. Guys, we have chess legend and freedom fighter, Gary Kasparov. He talks about AI, geopolitics, and crypto. Gary was one of the first people to experience machine intelligence in a profound way. He was the greatest chess player of all time when he lost his first match to an IBM computer is called Deep Blue, this happened in 1997.
And since then, human beings, that's us, have never been able to beat machines in a game of chess. So naturally, David and I start the conversation there. Number one, what does Gary think about chat GBD, this new era of AI? What is he think about the threats? How about the promises of AI? Then we get to geopolitics. Why did the Soviet Union fail? But we still have totalitarianism in Russia. We talk about that for a while. We also talk about what countries are the biggest threats to freedom. And how do we combat this growing authoritarianism that seems to be sweeping the world? Also, of course, is a crypto podcast.
So we asked him what role crypto has to play in all of this. And finally, we end with his advice for us as we enter the next decades of these tumultuous times. I think the theme of this episode was really freedom. And to me, Gary's optimism was probably the brightest part of this particular episode. David, why was this significant to you? Other than I know, Gary is like one of your all time favorite people made an idol for you or a chess player yourself or not. Yeah, a chess player, which is how this podcast really came to be in the first place. But yeah, it's just like Gary comes from many different walks of life.
Nero skill set in chess that was trounced by a computer, but then also just working around the hard problem of Vladimir Putin and evil out of Russia. Yeah. And he's had so many different walks of life that all only increased in their relevancy as the decades went on. And so he seems to be a person whose skill set and experiences seem to be really attuned to have developed a sense of wisdom about how to navigate them moving forward into the future, which is really the theme of this podcast at large. It was like, the future, oh, future's scary. Gary, tell us about the life lessons that you've had to so that we can absorb some of your knowledge.
I think the biggest thing I got out of this podcast right now is of course, Gary's emphasis on freedom. But really, he made this call to action for more leadership. Because where do we get freedom from? It's from strong leadership. And so maybe just accepting that into listeners' brains as we navigate through these conversations with Gary, this air of leadership that we need to have, strong leadership, good leadership, is something I think that we need to have in order to navigate through these chaotic decades. I think everyone understands that we do have ahead of us. And David, I can't wait to record the debrief with you, which is our episode after the episode.
And I want to talk specifically about how this episode came to be. Because my memory is a little bit foggy, but I think there's a really cool story there. If you are a bankless citizen, you of course, you have access to that right now. It's on the premium RSS feed you get when you subscribe. If you are not yet a citizen, click the link in the show notes and you can find out more about that. All right, guys, we're going to get right to the conversation with Gary. But before we do, we want to thank the sponsors that made this episode possible, including our number one destination to go purchase your freedom coins.
Your freedom assets, like that, that is Kraken. Go create an account. Kraken knows crypto. Kraken's been in the crypto game for over a decade. And as one of the largest and most trusted exchanges in the industry, Kraken is on the journey with all of us to see what crypto can be. Human history is a story of progress. It's part of us, hard-wired. We're designed to seek change everywhere, to improve, to strive. And if anything can be improved, why not finance? Crypto is a financial system designed with the modern world in mind. Instant, permissionless, and 24.7. It's not perfect, and nothing ever will be perfect.
But crypto is a world-changing technology at a time when the world needs it the most. That's the Kraken mission, to accelerate the global adoption of cryptocurrency, so that you and the rest of the world can achieve a financial freedom and inclusion. Head on over to Kraken.com, slash the bank list, to see what crypto can be. Not investment advice, crypto trading, involves risk of loss. Crypto currency services are provided to US and US territory customers by payward ventures to seek PDI doing business as Kraken. Cello is the mobile-first EVM compatible, carbon-negative blockchain, built for the real world.
And now, something big is happening. Introducing the Cello Layer 2. It's a game-changing proposal that's going to bring Cello's rapidly growing ecosystem home to Ethereum. Vitalik has shared his excitement for the Cello Layer 2 on the Cello Forum, so has Ben Jones from Optimism. But why? The Cello Layer 2 will bring huge advantages, like a decentralized sequencer, off-chain data availability, and one block finality. Which is all that mean? Rock solid security, a trustless bridge to Ethereum, and more real-world use cases for Ethereum without compromise. And real-world adoption is happening. Active addresses on Cello have grown over 500% in the last six months.
With the Cello Layer 2, gas fees will stay low, and you can even pay for gas using ERC20 tokens. But Cello is a community-governed protocol. This means that Cello needs you to weigh in and make your voice heard. Join the conversation in the Cello Forum. Follow at CelloOrg on Twitter and visit Cello.org to shape the future of Ethereum. This works. Thanks to a breakthrough technology called ColorTrace from Layer0. Without it, it was impossible to attribute users of a token with a specific issuer. But now we can. USDV is live on Ethereum, Optimism, Arbitrum, and other chains. And it's already available on over 20 exchanges, such as Curve, BitGet, Velodrome, and Stargate.
Start participating in the yield from treasury back stablecoins at bankless.com slash USDV. Bankless Nation, I'm delighted to introduce you to Gary Kasparov, a celebrated chess champion, author, and human rights advocate. Famously, the first human to lose a game of chess to a computer after losing to IBM's deep blue in 1997 making a significant history in AI. Gary also, after standing up to the human rights violation of Vladimir Putin, had to flee Russia during persecution in 2013 and has been an outspoken critic ever since he is also the chairman of the human rights foundation working to promote freedom in countries ruled by authoritarian regimes.
So with experience in relation to geopolitics, artificial intelligence, and human rights, Gary Kasparov might just be the perfect guide to guide us through some very challenging topics that will likely define the rest of the decade and beyond Gary. Welcome to bankless. Thank you for inviting me. Just a few corrections about the introduction. So it's just to clarify two things. This is one is that, yes, it was the first match that a wall champion lost a machine but as for the games, single games or tournament games, machines were on the rise from the late 80s. So I think the first game that machine won against the Grandmaster was 1988.
So it was a process. So there's a say, clearly, you know, the match brought most of attention. And again, for the record, I have to say that the first year, 1996, the first match I won. So that was it. Thank you, that's one for the humans. Yes, yes, yes. So as for AI, it's just, you know, we can talk about it just in the depths, but I mean, deep blue was anything but intelligent and it didn't have to be intelligent because it was just about, you know, brute force. And then, and the reason machines were, and are now superior to humans in all the games is because they made few mistakes. They cannot resolve, you know, all the problems, they cannot calculate, you know, to the end, you know, you cannot exhaust the game of chess that according to Glott Shannon has 46 zeros in the number of legal moves.
But again, making few mistakes, even the best of us, the best humans, we are still humans, we are vulnerable and just and, and, you know, we are poised to make mistakes. And, and yeah, you correctly stated that, you know, I left Russian 2013 more than 10 years ago. It's a February, 11 years ago. But one more correction. I have been criticising Vladimir Putin, you know, way before I had to do my part. So, and it's not, you know, it's not being a Monday, Monday quarterback. So, my first article, warning about Putin's threat, dated January 4, 2001, the Wall Street Journal. So again, it's everything is recorded.
Well, Gary, the background that you have, and again, the chess computer conversation, it's a narrow intelligence, right? It's not like the AI that we are experiencing in the year 2023, which is a little bit more general. To me, it's like a canary in the coal mine. And then we also have the, the geopolitics conversation with Russia and also just more broadly at large. There seems to be many different paths that we could go down that are all relevant, things that we've talked about, bank lists and prior episodes, and things that the globe is talking about as a whole. It's just that your history, your background, seems to touch on so many things that have only increased in relevancy as time has gone on.
Computer intelligence has increased in relevancy. The global geopolitics has kind of increased in chaos. So, your background and experience seems to just be very apt for the year 2023, the decade of the 2020s. Would you agree with that reflection? And how has your experience just kind of guided your thoughts as a lot of the events of the globe has unfolded in the last few years? I'm flattered, so this was all the comments. So yes, I can say that to my experience, my knowledge. Those fairly limited, you know, when you just look at all walks of life, it's very relevant these days. So, and what also helped me is that it's my ability to be self-critical and also to recognize the limits of my knowledge.
I know what I know, but it's more important. I know what I don't know. And I know how not to cross the border between those two domains. And yes, geopolitics is important because many of the things I mentioned, so for instance, in my book Winter is Coming, where I've largely been put in and the end of the world must be stopped, published back in 2015. You know, it's tragically came into reality. And many of the things I described in my book Deep Thinking when Machine Intelligence ends and Human Creativity begins in 2017, they also are relevant these days. And as you put it out, so I was the first human who had his job threatened by a machine.
So, and while back in 1997, so I thought it would be a curse. You know, that would follow me for the rest of my life. Now I think it was more like a blessing because I had an experience and it's so relevant now and I can share it. And it's not just to terrorize people's mind, you know, by telling them that's the end of just the end of the world is around the corner, but to the contrary, to tell them that it's not the end of the world. It's something that, you know, we can deal with if we recognize our limitations again. Where our knowledge is limited and where we should rely on machines, but where we are indispensable.
So tons of things that, you know, that's happened in my life, you know, not every time I was happy about it, now are just, you know, help me to create kind of a mosaic that is very useful to analyze the very complex picture of the modern world. In more recent years, we've watched a chat GBT explode onto the scene and really dominate the conversation in society. And this has caused a lot of people's like reactions to chat GBT also be a part of that conversation. We had this episode with Eliezer Yutkowski who's a famously an AI doomer. He's like, oh, AI's going to not just come take our jobs, it's going to come and take over the world and we're all going to die as a result.
And that was very, very shocking. And sobering, I would say. Very sobering, yeah. And we've seen society at large have this conversation with itself about is AI good, is AI bad? What will it do to us? Well, what will it do to society? And we seem to be going through this process of understanding and acceptance about the way AI is going to interact with us. Would you say that society's kind of following the same pattern you went through when you had your reflections about playing chess versus IBM deep blue and or just computers at large? Are we in society at large going through a same process of understanding and reflection about AI that you went through?
Is there similarities there? There are still there it is, but I had a personal experience. And again, in chess, we could see the machines rise to dominance, but also machines and limitations. So it's also accidental that the discolpe of the chess world champion was the kind of send grail for computer experts because for a long time, top scientists believed that chess was the analysis, it's like at a nexus of human creativity intelligence. And this is, you know, that's could be a key to actually reveal the secrets of human intelligence. It goes back to Alfred Binet, the father of IQ test back at the end of the 19th century who was fascinated by chess players, especially those who could play blind chess.
And he wanted to actually to open the brains and just to find out how these magic moves being made. And he was under impression that that's, you know, the shortest cut to the secrets of human intelligence, a general intelligence. And this belief, you know, has been inherited by great minds like Alan Curie and Claude Shannon, Norbert Wiener. So it's a widespread belief that chess is an answer. Again, it's happened on our part of the world, because there are many other versions of chess, like Shogi in Japan and other versions, but the European version of chess, you know, was always like an ultimate test in the eyes of the scientists of human machine encounter.
And its machines kept improving the performance and as I already mentioned by the 80s, we had something, you know, a tangible force. So deep thought, actually, it was the prototype of the blue because it was this team from Carnegie Mellon University that was eventually, you know, went to IBM, IBM purchased the project, but they had the machine that had the first success back in 1998. So in 1989, I faced this computer, played two rapid chess games. It's there again, an hour and a half, 90 minutes for the game. And I won quite handily, so back in 1989. But we could see the progress and I have to say that, you know, we were fascinated, but we didn't even understand, you know, this is how serious the threat was.
Because we already suffered some painful losses in blue chess, five minutes chess, or the rapid chess, 25, 30 minutes chess, but more under impression that it's not just because machines, you know, would be better, you know, eventually would be better than us, but because we had little time. If we had more time, you know, we could think, you know, just avoid some stupid mistakes, not understanding that we have, if we have more time, machine has more time. And it's amazing that, you know, it's many grandmasters made this mistake. I lost two to one of the computer programs in 1994, the rapid chess match.
So, and yeah, and it was two games in London. So then I played again, I beat this computer. But we thought it was, yeah, it's something that, you know, it's good for exercise, you know, it's good for preparation, but it should not, you know, threaten our dominance in classical chess. So that's why the 1997 match was such a big shock. Though I have to say that for me, the first, you know, the first call, you know, was if you may call it the watershed moment, was in 1996, I mentioned I won the match, but I lost game one. So that was the first game where computer could be sitting wall champion in what we call classical chess, six-house chess.
And though I just, I fall back, I won three games, since I won the match, but it's already somewhere in the back of my mind and knew that it's, we are just, you know, we are on, on, on, on the right track. So in 1997, so I had to, you know, I had to think, you know, what would, what would come next to my beloved game. So whether, you know, just we all, we have to do something else, but it's not to play the game, which is doomed. And then I realized that look, it's the machines could do a better job and it would happen. Though we still competed for, I would say about seven years. I played two matches, not, of course, as public sizes, IBM matches back in 2003 against, and after 2003, two matches against German program and against the Israeli program.
It's the preets and the junior, both matches ended as a tie, but I knew the end was near. So I just, it's, it's worth, it was a clear track. So this is, like, right on the wall. And that's why I came up with an idea of advanced chess that was a combination of human and machine. So that's how we can play together to, to, to get the best of two, of two worlds. And, and that, you know, I had time to, to ruminate about my games, my failures, so my accomplishments and also looking at the machines. And I just recognized that while machines would, would keep improving, there's still limitations. And, and again, we can talk in more details about it, but these limitations, I don't believe can be, can be removed, even if machines, you know, could be as powerful as chat GPT.
So there's, even if you talk about AI, because I still think that is, there's a certain elements of, of human nature, right? Creativity that cannot replicate it for a very simple reason. Creativity means that you accept a notion of failure. This is not the way machines work. So machine always looks for, for bottom line. That's the, that's, and again, that, that's all tiny things. What is very important for us to understand that, if you, if you look at the decision making process as a hundred percent and recognizing that there's no perfection of universe, no hundred percent can be achieved, it's, it's about, you know, us finding our spot and, and stomping on our, on our pride and saying, okay, we belong to last few decimal places.
We have to find exactly so where we can add something unique, unique contribution to a machine that will make a combination of human and machine, most, productive. So that's why I think it's the future is, don't you know, machines dominance. The future is us working with, with machines. And, and for those who are just trying to, to use only dark, or dark paint to, to show the future, I mean, my answer is, look, it's, it's not a magic wand, but it's not a terminator. It's not a, a, a free ticket to heaven, but it's not the key to unlock the doors of, of hell. It's, you know, it's, it's, it's human invention.
And, and again, while it could outperform us in, in, in, in many areas, we're still, you know, we still have this theme. It's not a control, but we still occupy a place that I don't think machines can, can take away, take away from us. And, and I, yeah, it's, it's so, it's so tempting, you know, to follow the path of the terminator, movies, and matrixes. But actually, while I was a big fan of the terminator, back in, in the 80s and, and, and early 90s, I still didn't understand why machine wanted to kill people. So, so, so, what for, I mean, I mean, it's some, some in the community, uh, it just basically say as a byproduct of consuming resources, they, they will crush and destroy all of humanity.
So a little less like the terminator of vision and more like a, you know, us squashing an ant because we're, you know, building house or, you know, an ant colony, but I, what, this is why I want to ask the question because you've observed this before when, and deep blue came on the scene, I'm sure people were making comparisons to terminator, right? And they were saying, oh, is this the end our, our humans kind of over? And something similar has happened, I would say, in the last year in terms of the public conversation. But it has felt like this new technology, chat GPT has been sort of a, a, a massive order of magnitude advance.
And I'm wondering if you still at, at its core, if you've had time to mess around with chat GPT, if you still see it as, yes, I'm still seeing deep blue here. It's still doing the brute force. It's still not a human. I, it was interesting, Gary, I just asked while we were having this conversation, can chat GPT play chess well? So according to chat GPT, I asked chat GPT this question. It says, I can analyze chess positions and chess moves, but my capabilities are not on par with specialized chess engines like stockfish or alpha zero. And then I asked it to answer the same question, but as Gary Kasparov, and it said, this is what you would say.
While chat GPT demonstrates a remarkable ability to process and generate language, its skills in chess are not comparable to those of a grandmaster or a specialized chat engine. I don't know if that's something that you would say, but this kind of intelligence, the ability to have a conversation with the computer, this feels so new to us. Yeah, I mean, look, I, probably everything depends on the angle of observation. This is the glasses half empty or half full. So that's the, actually, I view it from the other side. I think it's phenomenal. Because I think that machines will unleash more of human creativity.
Because so many things can be done by machines if we know how to balance it. So we can start inventing things because this is this is some of the wild dreams that can be reached. So they're within our reach. I mean, when we look at machines, so there's so many mysteries of nature, whether it's in deep oceans or in outer space, that we cannot unlock without computers. So while I'm not holding a crystal ball and not pretending we're not strong enough to tell you everything will be perfect in the future, I think that again, it's a new challenge, but as ever a challenge, it has threats, the risks, but I think the benefits, the benefits could be phenomenal.
So we just have to stop debating whether it's a mortal threat to us or not. Look, people have been debating about machines threat to our civilization for quite a long time. So it says it's the year after the Luddites in the UK, so two hundred years ago. And I can tell you, you know what, who made actually the first speech against the machines, against, again, that we talked about, you know, this is the primitive machines that, you know, that could remove many people, you know, from their workplace. Back in 1812, it was the maintenance feature of Lord Byron in British Parliament. Yeah, very eloquently arguing that machines that could throw so many people into poverty.
Of course, it's a stretch. But still I think, you know, it's just, you know, certain things, you know, we should probably, you can't abandon this discussion, but I don't think we should give too much emphasis. It's called progress. And progress, you know, brings various things, you know, yes, it's always easy to talk about destruction, because it's much easier to create nuclear bond and nuclear reactor. So yes, and of course, first thing we think, oh, that's what happens, you know, the machines won't go after us. I see, you know, just getting totally different angle. It's fantastic, you know, so now time, you know, so many things we can do because a lot of war, you know, this is the, the, the Roth War can go to the machines.
So it's just that tell people that is, if machines can do your work, so probably you can see another bug machine, but about the work you're doing. So we're presently watching Silicon Valley have a very similar conversation about itself and its relationship to AI. Mark Andreessen recently wrote this very long blog post talking all about accelerationism and how we need to, you know, accelerate technology because that is where we get, you know, wealth generation and we, you know, the rising tide lift all boats. The alternative side of this, we saw open AI have this drama where a board, which was more decelerationist, try and steer the ship of open AI in a decelerationist way, which led to all of that drama that we saw recently.
Fatalic Buterin just put out a blog post talking about his flavor of this, where he is a fan of this thing called defensive acceleration, where he promotes defensive technology. And it's all about just like perceptions of the future and our relationship with technology. Have you been tapped into these conversations and do you have like a stance on accelerationism and technology as it relates to these conversations? Look, you know, I follow up these conversations, you know, I believe I have some to say. And my view is again, you can say whatever you want, but it's happening. So it's just, yeah, you can talk about defensive, but some people will do the other, the other opposite.
So it's the, it's the, it's, this technology, you know, reveal fuel potential. It offers great opportunities, you know, just for individuals. You don't need, you know, billions of dollars of investment and secret plans and locations like Los Alamos, you know, it's just to have Manhattan Project. You have one or a few individuals that could, you know, literally change the world. Is it dangerous? Yes, it is dangerous, but it could be beneficial. So I'm, you know, I'm impossible optimized by nature. I just believe that, you know, it's the, we have new tools and these new tools can help us to, to upgrade our knowledge.
You know, again, going back to the, to the mistress of our planet. So this is, I think it says the knowledge of, of the old oceans, it's under five percent. I mean, four percent of just, it just, imagine this is this, we don't know our planet. So it is, how about, you know, finding out what relief and how about, you know, improving our knowledge on the outer space. So there's so many things happening, you know, this is the, I think this, this, a couple of months ago, so there was a first successful attack, again, that's the right. So those are things are just, you know, part of the, of this development.
And just ignoring the fact that so many great things happening now, you know, is, you know, we're generally improving the leading standard. So we're, we're as leading longer. So it's the, and we're, again, with our ability to, to invent things that, you know, will weigh beyond our reach. And concentrating on the dangers, again, I think it's just, you know, it's, it makes this discussion, A, I don't think it's, it's not practical. And B, again, it's, it's like, you know, standing against the wind, you know, that's spitting against the wind. So it's, as we say, oh, let's, you know, let's make sure that we understand exactly how it works.
You know, the Europeans are, the big progress are very much concerned about, you know, the, the, the machines, you know, the, the black box. So we have, we need GDPR, we need all the regulations. My question is in business, do we care about, you know, understanding of the machine or about the bottom line? So what, what, what, what do you prefer? And also, you can impose all regulations, but the world is not run by, you know, by one world government. And if you know, you have regulations here, here in America or in Europe, China doesn't care, Putin doesn't care. So that's, so that's why I can wish, we should recognize that our limitations, our ability to, to control the progress.
We can monitor it. But the idea that we can, we can put it under control, bureaucratic control. So this is, it could be only defensive. It could, you should stop here. No, it doesn't. So this is, since you know, it's one individual can actually make history. So I think we should, you know, it's instead of trying to stay on the way of this, of this flood, we should, I think, open of all floodgates. I'm, I'm experienced. Okay. So, so, so Gary, opening the floodgates, and if this is our future, and if it's kind of unstoppable, it, you know, maybe there is the, the glass half full view, and we should be optimistic about this.
But it also means that many listeners, including maybe, you know, podcasts, interviews like David and myself, and crypto investors like David and myself, we might be out of a job soon, or we might have to find a different line of work because chat GPT might be able to do it better than us. And so as, as someone who's been in that position before, where, you know, suddenly a machine can play chess better than all of the human beings, was chess any different for you after deep blue, or like, give us some guidance, because I feel like you've been playing, you know, 20 years ahead of the rest of society.
Again, let's, let's us examine human history. So let's look at the last couple of hundred years. So where we had machines in the reading, in all walks of life. So the society of the 18th century was agricultural. So the 19th century, we saw the replacement of human labor, the machines getting in. So by the end of the 19th century, you know, 20th century, the big, the developed countries, they had a very different balance, proportion of all urban population versus countryside. So today, how many people doing agricultural America can both present? And so then we had, this is the manufacturing era.
So we had this industrial era. So what's happened with these blue color jobs? This is again, it says, no, the problem is that now, machines are spreading wild color jobs. And the difference is that unlike countryside folks are the 18th century or 19th century folks, you know, from big factories, I mean, white color jobs, you know, are just typically taken by people who have their Twitter accounts. Yeah, and who have access to mass media. So social media. So it's, and that's why we are so concerned. It's a natural process. So I'm not, I don't know the sound callus, but yes, it's just, you know, if this job, you know, just is, it's no longer, you know, offers you a chance to compete with the machine.
So move on. So now, as for chess, there's a slightly different because chess is a game that is a sport. And we're still watching track and field. But, you know, we say bold or just, you know, the best, you know, athletes, they cannot compete with, with, with, you know, the Ferrari with any car. So, so the same is here. So it's, yes, we know that chess engine now will beat any grandmaster. It's on, chess engine on, on, on, on, on, on this on this device is stronger than the blue. So again, it's a little bit unpleasant. It's actually, you know, I, I can't, to be honest, you know, I've got me, I'm not very happy about it, but, again, just, you know, change the angle of the race.
When I played carpal 30, 35 years ago or so, everything we did on stage, it was like, you know, the, the, it's a magic, something, you know, that happened in the temple. So even if we made mistakes, grandmasters who followed the game and just made commentaries, they were, they were scared, you know, they were shy to criticize because there are two, you know, high priests, you know, just, you know, these in the temple of, of case of the goddess of chess. And you can't, you know, you, you, me, me, me said, maybe it's an accuracy, but you can't go after, you know, after their ability to, to, to provide us miracles today.
Every amateur, you know, having access to computer screen, can I say, oh, Magnus Carlson made a blunder and one billion people. So again, as a, as a former World chess champion, I don't feel very comfortable about it, but imagine how many more people are watching chess. Now we have a chess popularity that beat all the records. Why? One of reasons because people actually can learn, they just see how they, they, they feel that they, they understand what's happening. They're following the game. They don't need, you know, Gary Gaspard or Yassassero one already commented to tell them what's happening.
They just look at the screen, a machine knows everything. So it's, it, there's always a balance, there's always a balance and, and as long as the balance is positive, and in my view, it's just in popularity of chess is more important than her feelings of some players. So we are on the right track. I, are you satisfied? Or just sure, I'm not sure, or you're, you're even more now, more, more concerned. I am, I am for myself, I'm satisfied. I mean, to the point of like this being like the industrial revolution, there's no chance, Gary, I would change what I do now with the life of kind of a, you know, a farmer, I would not be very good at that skill set, you know, in the 1700s or something like that.
So I, I see a lot of the benefits, although it does feel like we're entering a new era, a chaotic time at, you know, the next, the decades to come as an era of change. And that always makes, I think, people feel uncomfortable, including myself, like we just don't know what to expect. How is the world around is going to change? Like I'm feeling comfortable now, but will I feel that way in, you know, 10 years? So it's probably a fear of the unknown that is a kind of natural, and I think that's part of the climate right now. How old are you? I'm 38. David, how old are you? I'm 30. I'm six. And I was, and I was born in the Soviet Union.
You know, it's this on the other side that are important. Right. And you know, what was the biggest challenge in the country where I was born raised is everything was the same. You know, this is, there was no change. People were plumbering for change. So yes, change is challenging. But it's necessary. And, and yeah, we have to cope with that. So I'm, yeah, 60, I still feel and I'm rather one because I know I'm willing to accept the change. So I'm willing, not just accept, I know it's happening. And by the way, it says, this is the way to improve lives, you know, of ordinary people, of, you know, of big conglomerates.
So we have different challenges. You know, this is, 100 years ago, nobody cared about climate change. 50 years ago, nobody cared about climate change. So we have new challenges. So what is the new challenge? Let's think how we can handle it. So, and, and while you know, we have this the rise of the machines. So just let's use the terminator, terminator, terminology. So I think that we just have to recognize that, you know, this is, it's, it's may, you know, it's also maybe it makes sense of signals that we just have to do some scales. Because as the, I'm, again, I'm willing to be asked of exploration.
And we stop exploring. I think this one of the problems, you know, of the, of the baby boomers, it was that it was a first generation in, in, in history of civilization that never experienced any danger of, you know, extermination or hunger. So this is, and they got the place. And, you know, it's, you know, I grew up in, in, in, in Soviet Union, but in the 60s, late 60s, I was six, seven, and I was a voracious reader. And I had all this back essence, you know, but exploring, you know, Mars, Vinero, so this is, yeah, Ben Venos, so I use the Russian, Russian name for the planet. So it's the, and I was, and so this in, in 1966, you know, that says, this, this, this, you go back to this as the, yeah, the first start for X.
So this is, they talked about, you know, the plasma engines in 1996. So what do we got? You know, this is crazy for swaps, it's in 1996. So it's season, it's a very, we, I think we just need to concentrate too much on, on, on just other things, get great, fantastic. We made phenomenal improvements, you know, in healthcare, you know, in its, remedying our social yields. But, you know, at the expense of exploration. So the last man walked on the, on the, on the moon, you know, what, you said, seven, and in 1972. So it's this is, people believe it would be Mars, you know, in the 80s. Yeah, so, so I think it's time now to actually start concentrating on exploration, because that's, that's what made us successful.
And then when, you know, when people talk about flying to Mars, this is, it's far as I look, you know, our chances of exploring Mars are just much better than Columbus, because, you know, it's, at least we have the map, we know where we're heading. We know exactly the distance. So let's start, you know, upgrading our challenges, because we have such powerful allies as computers. When I've been reading your book, Gary, the winter is coming, the one, the focuses on Russia, of course, you get the sense that there's a lot of talk about just like, there's a humanist angle to it. Humans have this creativity, they desire to express, they have frontiers, they would love to explore.
And when you suppress that ability, like, eventually that that brews and that eventually explodes is if it's contained for too long. And I think this is something that, you know, me and Ryan here on Banclist do try to get across on the podcast is we are a species of explorers. We are, we are looking for new frontiers. Something that I really got out of your book was in the first few chapters where you discuss, when the Soviet Union collapse in 1991, the West perceived this future of when Western liberal values coming to permeate through the communist block. Now democracy would flourish, the massive Russian market would enter the fold, it would spawn a new era of human liberty.
But then 10 years later, Vladimir Putin would take over leadership of Russia, a position that he still has 20 years later to this day. Russia has invaded Georgia, Crimea, and more recently Ukraine for the second time. And so we go back to the thing that you were saying, like, you felt behind the Iron Curtain, which was like, everyone was clamoring for change. And then we had this window of time in which, oh, like, we get to invoke change behind the Iron Curtain. Yet now we look forward to where we are today. And there's another dictator that has been leading Russia and it's doing the same thing that it did before the Iron Curtain fell, which is invade its neighboring countries.
What went wrong? Why? Why did we revert back to a time in which we were trying to end? Why didn't democracy flourish? Yeah, yes, you reminded me and the audience about this great moments of 1991, 1991, 92, the it's actually 89 of the collapse of World War, you know, the opening of the era, the end of the empire, so the emergence of new states out of the Soviet Union. And I remember that the best-selling book in 1992 was Francis Fukuyama, the end of history. And I have to admit, I also believe that the future will be bright. Of course, it's over, you know, the Soviet Union gone. So this is this, let's turn Russia into wild east.
So this is the land of opportunities. Yeah, I think we made few mistakes. One of them is, yes, we haven't recognized the simple fact that evil doesn't die. It can be buried in the rubble of Burnwall for a while. The moment we lose our vigilance, the moment we become complacent, it sprouts out. But also the most important thing, though, I don't want just to pretend that there was no blame on the Russian side, on us in Russia, that we just, I was 28 when it happened. So that's probably, I know I was engaged in some political activities, but still I was a kid. But I think the burden of leadership wasn't the United States.
And America had to come out with a plan. Because when you have the end of history, not a history, but the end of chapter in history, you have to come up with a new plan. So why the free world was successful in the Cold War? It's not just because, you know, it's, it had better system. Yes, of course, it's economically, it's, it's based on freedom. So, but it also had a plan. The strategy designed by human, by, by, by, Truman, the inspiration back in 1946, 1947, that has been followed with some modifications by, by, by, by both Democrats and Republicans, by presidents. For 40 years, America followed a plan.
It was not, it was a bumpy road, but it was a plan. So to stop communism, and eventually to demonstrate the advantages of the, of the free system, of the free world. In 1991, 1992, we needed to come up with a new plan. So just two, two, you know, just, um, throw a picture of, of this bright future. So what's, and what's next? One of the challenges for me, that's, that's, that's, that was not answered, was the United Nations. The United Nations was designed as, as a best vehicle to prevent the next war, which, you know, you may, compare it to a freezer, you know, the freeze conflicts. In 1991, we were at the unique moment in history where America was powerful enough to start solving problems.
So that's why you did new organization. That's what I, let's say, I'm a canco, legal democracy. So it's the, um, and again, many other things that we, it could be addressed, but I think, you know, we just, you know, we, the, we as a, we, the free world lost the sense of urgency. And going back to my child, child experience and teenage experience back in the Soviet Union, I remember that everybody knew America was there, like immobile object. So it's hate or laugh, but it was America. Whoever is in the White House, America is there. Yes, it could move a little bit left, right, but it was there.
Today, we live in a world where America as a factor, it's America. It depends who's in the White House. You know, it's well like a pendulum. And of course, you know, just by losing this, this immobile object that could hold the world. So we have a lot of back up created. And who, who feels the vacuum? Putin, Xi Jinping, Al Qaeda, ISIS, Iran and, uh, I told us, his beloved mass, Maduro's, Chavez, whatever. So this, it's easy. Because again, we, they have a plan. They're ones very simple graph. So that's what, whatever, they're opportunists. The advantage of, I use chess language now, the advantage of dictatorship or democracy is practical.
They can always, you know, grab, you know, something that is, is, is available because they don't have problems with their parliament, you know, debate, free press. It's just, I decide, period, we move. What is the advantage of democracy strategy? Continuity. We needed the plan. And we, we see that, you know, it's every time we compete, we'll be there. So this is the free world is always advantageous when it comes to innovations, when it comes to new ideas. So there's those who are panicking now. Look at China. So yeah, look at China. China gave us virus, America. Answer was a vaccine. And China couldn't even develop a problem vaccine, though they had six months head start or not on the college.
So we, we still see that, you know, the freedom is it is, it is indispensable component of, of, of, of success. Whether it's a business success or social success. But it's just, you know, it's, it's an advantage that we don't know how to use. And you know, we, we definitely know, reach the point where we need this change. So look, you know, you are 38, I'm 16, but, you know, I don't feel that I'm, you know, I can dictate the, your generation or the younger or, or, or, or, or, or, or younger kids, how to leave. But if we are, we live in a country, what next year is that the choice will be between, you know, two guys that, you know, 160 or more years also combined.
And definitely not in the best for, for various reasons. Not in the best conditions to, to, to be leaders of the free world. So this is, we need change. So that's why going back to this. We, we, we have to actually come up with new, new concepts for development. That's why exploration, exploration is so important, because it is so much energy now in the world that is just, you know, just that doesn't go anywhere. So that's why I want us to fly to Mars. By the way, it's not just about flying to Mars. It's not just about, you know, just having, you know, boots of our, of our space explorers, you know, stepping on the red dust of the planet.
It's, it's about, it's about the process. Because what we know is that the process of exploration has unexpected turns. I bet you that something will happen, maybe in one of the asteroids on the way to Mars will discover something that will help us to solve climate problem. And it's statistically, something will happen. It was not just Columbus to cross that landing. It's about so many things happen. You know, they have to develop new, new instruments, you know, this is better sheep, you know, it's, it's exploration always has its cost. By the way, it's quite risky, but, but it also has side effects.
And by the side effects are becoming more important. So that's why it's very important for us to, to secure the perimeter of the free world. That's why I think we need more decisive response to Putin's, Xi Jinping's and I at all. But it's not just, you know, using force, but it's also just offering future. And I think that's a fundamental problem. The free world failed to, to, to, to, to present the vision of the future. We talk too much about this, you know, the, the darkness that is just, that is, it's, it's, it's inevitable. You know, that's why I want to change the conversation. It's all about darkness.
It's about optimism. Look, that's what we invented. We haven't changed it in our fantastic. So let's see how we can use it to improve our lives and to get to other planets for us. Are you launching a token? Is it already live? How are you managing the legal and tax for providing token awards for your team? Toku simplifies everything about managing token grant compensation and you can get started with them for free. You'll have access to top notch legal and tax support to handle the distribution and management of tokens for your team. Toku caters to every step in the process from user friendly legal templates for granting tokens to tracking vesting periods and calculating with holding taxes.
Toku understands every grant structure token purchase agreements restricted token awards restricted token units token options and all the other ones. Toku is already simplifying this today for leaving companies like Protocol Labs, DUIDX Foundation, Mina Foundation and many more. You can learn more about how Toku can help you streamline your token management and get started for free. Visit Toku at Toku.com slash bankless or click the link in the description below. Arbitram is the leading Ethereum scaling solution that is home to hundreds of decentralized applications. Arbitram's technology allows you to interact with Ethereum at scale with low fees and faster transactions.
Arbitram has the leading defy ecosystem, strong infrastructure options, flourishing NFTs and is quickly becoming the Web3 gaming hub. Explore the ecosystem at portal.arbitram.io. Are you looking to permissionlessly launch your own Arbitram orbit chain? Arbitram orbit allows anyone to utilize Arbitram's secure scaling technology to build your own orbit chain, giving you access to interoperable, customizable permissions with dedicated throughput. Whether you're a developer, an enterprise or user, Arbitram orbit lets you take your project to new heights. All of these technologies leverage the security and decentralization of Ethereum.
Experience Web3 development the way it was always meant to be. Secure, fast, cheap and friction free. Visit Arbitram.io and get your journey started in one of the largest Ethereum communities. The equilibrium that you illustrate, that I perceive that you illustrate between evil that grabs versus long-term democracy that plays a long-term game. Strategy versus tactics. To me, that's a difference of short-term versus long-term. Democracy is playing the longest-term game at the cost of short-term clarity. What is democracy's next moves? That's a little bit more foggy. But with dictatorships and with evil, the next step is obvious.
Like you said, it grabs. There's an equilibrium there that settles between these two forces that doesn't allow one to really ever trump the other. As democracy looks into the longest of terms, it creates room for evil to execute some tactics. You are such an advocate for human rights, of course. But what do you think in the fullness of time that goal actually looks like? Can democracy quote-unquote win? Can we actually stamp out evil or is evil something that we are just destined to live with until the end of time? How do we discover a more suitable equilibrium between these two things? Look, as I said, evil doesn't die.
So we know that evil always comes back because it's human nature. You have good and evil. So I think what is very important for us to actually identify is this absolute evil. Because there's no absolute good. So I'm a big fan of Lord of the Rings and generally the fan disciples. And Lord of the Rings is a great story where you have absolute evil. But on the good side, you have many quarreling factions. And the normal circumstances, they don't like each other, sometimes they fight each other. Yeah, also worse for instance. And even humans, they have tons of disagreements. But facing absolute evil, they had to unite.
And the same is in this world. So yeah, we will have tons of disagreements. And there will be various forms of evil. But right now we're facing out of a challenge. Vladimir Putin, Ayatollah. So this is the access of evil that is not just that exists somewhere. It has been actively threatening our way of life. And we have to fight back. Days, we will not go into see any feast in Ukraine or in the Middle East before the regime change in Moscow and Tehran. And it says that again, it's it's going back to the to the 30s and the 40s. And it's not, you know, it's not accidental that Roosevelt and Churchill back in in January 1943.
Just when again, it's it was not an easy moment. I just remind you that 1943, the battle of Stalingrad was not yet over. It was January. It ended in the beginning of February. The German German student banks of all get all the way to the to the short Atlantic. Japan was still running strong. And Italy was still in the war. And they set unconditional surrender. And so that's leadership. Unconditional surrender because they knew that with facing absolute evil, we have to act. So and you know, they understood that they had to deal with Stalin, which was also terrible evil. But at that time, we had no other choice.
So then it was another against his three dozen and Hitler was gone. Then we had Stalin. We had Soviet Communism threat. But again, it's just one challenge at a time. Today, unlike in the four days, the free will has all the wrong advantage economically, you know, in innovation, politically or militarily. And what we're missing, political will and also visual of the future and recognition that, you know, there's there are values. There are values that, you know, you cannot compromise with. And we always, we have not, not real leadership, but more like a managers. So this is people that are willing to take responsibility for the future.
That's the dose of great leaders of the past. They made big decisions and nobody knew whether decisions would be going the right or wrong. But you know, I, in 2015, I had a speech in Berlin. It's for Aspen, Aspen, Germany. Aspen is in Germany. And I titled the speech four words. So the idea was that, you know, it's saying very little, you know, the leader, true leader can change the world. And of course, first thing people remember about four words is it's infamous Nell Chamberlain's back coming back from, from Munich, Munich, deal with Hitler. So saying peace for all time. That's bad news. But we had other things, tear down this wall.
That's Ronald Reagan or Jeff Kennedy, Irvina and Berliner. So this is, and kind of anecdotal, that's the truly response to the Pentagon's analysis that West Berlin cannot be defended, defended back in 1948, West Stalin located the city. So we shall stay period. So it's, there was what a science of leadership. And again, this is Harry Truman phase, Joseph Stalin, JFK phase, I mean, Soviet Union in 1962, 63 years. Trust me, much more formidable enemy than than Putin's, Putin's army today. And Ronald Reagan, again, still faces Soviet Union, called it evil empire. So they was a sign of leadership because these great leaders believe new values.
This is important. Yeah, I watched many times, actually, I watched a lot of it. It's the first televised debate between Kennedy and Nixon. I mean, even set aside the fact that it was very civilized, you know, vice president and senator, you know, what's the most striking about this debate back in 1960? It was debate, debate was about means, not about hence. So this is that state. They, they agree. They just, they, they knew America was there. They, they, they, similar visual world future, very different means how we should get there. But today, we live in a world where just, you know, people in America or in Europe debate, debate the ends.
So this is we don't, we don't, we still questioning despite obvious facts that the free world offers better conditions. As I said, you know, let's look at that, that, that, even healthcare. And look at many other things that, you know, where we easily beat the competition on the other side. But we still don't recognize that it's how, how, you know, valuable is the freedom because so many things we take for granted. You know, I always, you know, just arguing with some friends here. So say, look, guys, you know, you're right. Pointing out at, at, at, at social use of America. Yes, you have police brutality, but it's a problem in America.
I come from the world, I grew up in what it was and still is a system. So, so we just have to recognize that, you know, the free world offers phenomenal opportunities for individuals. And again, I, I think that the future is, is, it's to revealing this more potential of human creativity, human resolve that is, is yet being untouched. I think part of the, the challenge with all of this, Gary, is like, there's not consensus on what evil is anymore, at least in, in some of the culture. And I, I want to ask you, you, you've used the term evil and you've talked about absolute evil. And I think you'll find many bankless listeners will find common cause with you, you, you bringing Lord of the Rings into the picture.
I'm sure that we have many fans, many, many readers of those books. And in Lord of the Rings, the depiction of evil is this littlest eye on a tower that was constantly surveilling everything. So, you know, this world of a complete global surveillance and this world of dominance where the darkness would kind of spread out from Mordor and, you know, conquer the kingdoms of elves and the kingdoms of men and dwarves like to sort of one by one. And then you had the, the free lands of middle earth kind of trying to resist this. And so I, I'm wondering, is that what you mean when you say evil? Is that your depiction?
Is it this idea of authoritarianism? And, of course, there are many different blends of, of good. Let's call it. But, and they look different, but it is, is good freedom, essentially, is that the free peoples of earth? How do you see evil? How do you define it? No, it's the, yeah, it's, it's a very good description of, of, of, of, of this, a lot of the rings. Thank you. I am a fan, Gary. I love the rings. Thank you. Yeah, you know, I can tell me that's, it's, it's nearly 30 years ago. So I was asking Russian radio just after the college of the Soviet Union. And the book was literally unknown.
They had a special program, you know, that said, it's the, it's the, it's in 30 minutes. You had to, to tell to the teenagers something about the book. And I think that more of the rings. I had, in 30 minutes, I should, I should explain. And actually, this is the, you know, and 30 years ago, I had come up with, you know, one idea, just, you know, what's the main idea? And I said, I use the ideas, absolute power, corrupts absolutely. For me, it was more about the, the, the, the ring, the ring of power. So this is, it's the, it's no one can resist, even the good cannot resist, can't resist, can't resist, absolute power.
So that's, that's the idea that I presented. So that's this, this, the, and again, of course, the coalition, but, but again, even this coalition that, that fought absolute evil had to destroy the weapon of evil because absolute power is, is, is, is, so absolute power is the central evil in, in, it's the absolute, absolute power, you know, this is, if you have absolute power, there's, there's uncontrolled, yes, it, it, that's what we, that's what I believe, you know, it, um, it always, you know, serves the evil at the end. But because it's absolute power means that, you know, it will infringe our freedom.
So I'm, I'm great believer in the individual freedom. So that's why anything that stands on the way of us, you know, of our self-expression, of our ability to leave our lives, according to our beliefs, and leaving the world, well, you know, we're all equal before the law. So that's, that's, that's freedom. And that's what power somehow will, will always conflict things that have described. It's, it's fascinating because I, I think very much the reason that David and I came to this kind of, you know, industry and started this podcast was in pursuit of, of, uh, the, the seethos of freedom, really.
And like, you know, quite famously in, in, uh, cryptocurrency circles, the, the great enemy is really, uh, centralization, concentration of power and sort of that the savior technology is individual freedom in the form of, uh, encryption. You can own your own private keys, you can own your own assets, you know, Bitcoin, you throw all of these things. And so I think there's a lot of common cause with, with what you're saying and, uh, what, uh, many of our listeners probably believe. Oh, yeah, absolutely. I think it's, it's, it's, uh, it's for me, the, the, the Bitcoin and all, all the crypto currents as a concept is a very important step towards the same direction.
So it's the, again, thanks to the technology, thanks to computers. I mean, they say, and, uh, and for those who say that, oh, uh, cryptocurrency, you know, can help bad guys to, it's money laundering. That's almost popular argument. My answer is, yeah, they're mind-wondering about it just before give Bitcoin. From the moment we invented money, there was a money laundering. It's just, you know, it's, it's there. But who could do that? Only guys with power. So let's, again, it says, it's the, the banks, let's tell me, Swins, Luxembourg, Lichtenstein, these banks, you know, have been collecting funds from all over the world and this, and they offered this kind of protection and mind-wondering in instruments.
So this is not all of them. They did it all of that, but again, people always money always had a way to, to, um, make secret transactions. Now, this opportunity is presented to the masses. So you can do it. Yeah, again, as we already had it, you know, just this conversation, there's just a few times. So we're last hour. It's nothing comes for free. This is definitely the price to pay. And I've no doubt that this is the, there are zeros downsides. But again, let's compare the, again, look at the balance. Uh, yes, this is the, it's the, there are problems with with cryptocurrency, let's say Bitcoin, but we know exactly how many Bitcoin's can be printed.
And we know that this, this, this, this, this is a limited amount because we have a math on our side. Do you know how much money the feds can print? I don't know. We don't know. They know. Do you know what is the, what is the overall, when you look at it, what was the overall debt in the world now? Because you have so many financial instruments that are murky. I mean, they, even the guys were trading, trading them, I'm not sure they know exactly what this date. So we're talking about overall debt, you know, probably, you know, just it's 20, 30 times the size of the global GDP. You're talking about quadrillions now because there's so many debts are just, you know, they, it's, it's the cross pollinated.
And this is, and we still have to rely on a currency called US dollars and we have zero control of, of, of, of, of the way this currency being devalued. As we speak, you know, this is something is probably happening. And so I don't like, again, I understand we have to live in this well, but why not to use the power of technology, the power of science, the power of, you know, this global communication to fight back. And to guarantee that you know, there's what I heard on this world. So it would be protected by the law of mathematics, not by the good wheel of, of, of, of, of, of feds. Part of the ethos of this industry comes from the fact that we can leverage math and cryptography to have maximum, like freedom is a word that we frequently use.
But since we're talking about leadership so much in this podcast, I think we can, I can reorient the conversation in that lens as well, where it gives us individual tools to give us a platform to all be individual leaders, when we can, you know, own our own assets, manage our own finances, control our own identity. These are some of the topics that we talk about in crypto. These are all tools to become the best leaders individually that, that we can be. And it's one of the psychological elements that I think has always drawn me into this space. And also since we're talking about Lord of the Rings too, I think like one of the reasons why Frodo is the protagonist in that story is that he was, he was the least dangerous because he was the hobbit.
But he was also the one that was corrupted the least by the ring. And so he was the leader in the, in that respect that he resisted the temptations of, of power the most. And Gary, as you were talking about the, the fall of Russia and the opportunity that we had that we did not take, you accounted it to a lack of leadership. And then you also, you also talked about, or at least a lack of having a plan. And you also have mentioned the lack of leadership that we feel in this day and age, at least in America. It's something that I feel our, our political system is not elevating the best leaders that could be, could be elevated.
Is that a core fundamental problem that you see that needs to be addressed in this day and age for humanity to improve? Like we don't have a supply of strong leaders that we once did. Yes, thinking about a lot of the rings. So just, we should remember that even Frodo had a problem of resisting the temptation. And we needed evil actually to push. So it's this, we need to go David, we need to go. It's a, it's, it's, it's, it's, this is a very important question. And it's, it's a, some say it's a chicken attack because you know, this, do we have leaders because, you know, the people want them or we have, you know, just, it's, we have leaders and they, they, they, they show the way to people.
So, but I think that it's, it's, it's, it's, it's, naturally we have the population that looks for more for security safety, more just for other things, you know, strong leadership is not required. So this is because with, but back to that, now you are called who was over, why do we need strong leadership? So let's, you know, we can, we can just do other things. So this is the leaders. They do something else. Now we, we, we reached for you where, you know, it's the, I think the problem of the political leadership, let's talk about this country. That is, again, we can look at Europe, but let's look at this country.
I think a political system does work anymore. Just for a simple reason, you know, any political system needs, you know, you need some, um, uh, uh, call it, it's not just ridiculation. It says, you have to rebuild it. You have to adjust, let's say, you have a, we haven't found, we haven't found in principles. Thanks to founding fathers. So that says this, but you have to adjust them to the demand of the time. So this is, and there's always a crisis, you know, and, and sometimes you can solve the crisis, you know, but political means. Sometimes you know, it ends up, you know, tragically, but it's not necessary as a civil war.
So this is God forbid, but, but let's remember what's happened before a civil war, you know, the American political system had to undergo dramatic change. So it's always too, too, too, too, too, too, too, too part of the system. Man, you know, then we had a collapse of the Democrats for thousands and, and all the Democrats, and then you had a collapse of the weak party into no nothing, but a familiar, you know, nothing. There is an immigrant and so on. And Republicans. So in the phase four elections of, of, of, of, of, fateful elections on 1916 or 1860. So we had four candidates. So when you look today at American political map, and we understand, you know, it's the, they know two parties.
This is, this is, you can, we'd meet at least four candidates to represent, you know, sizable chunks of American society, at least four. The problem is, you know, since he has only two parties, and it totally dominate everything, the control everything, mostly grassroots. So that's why you cannot get through. So you end up with one candidate, because, you know, it's it's, it's because the party wants, you know, just wants to call, to, to, to, to, to, to, to, hold firm control of the, of the process. And very often, you know, this is those who are no easier and those are just more radical, they, they, see the momentum.
So it's this, again, it's this, you just look at current American political, a, a situation. So you have, you know, this is very likely of a criminal, like we just in the moment, age on one side, and if somebody who just has to retire some time ago, so will be on the other side. So, uh, but why? Because, because political system doesn't function well, it doesn't reflect the, the, the, the, um, the, um, the different trends, because we're so in the debates. We are talking about the, going back to what, what, yeah, we spent more than now and now, we don't know what the future, you do believe that these two candidates, if you have to shoot between, they can actually talk about the future, they have an idea about the future.
I said, I, I know I disqualified myself, though, I think about the future, and I believe I have, I'm much better qualified to, to debate future than, than, than, than, than, this, this, this, to, to, to, to, to, to individuals. But we need, we need, you know, all the different, you know, um, um, framework of the political debate. And again, it says it's, that's always crisis. It's where, where the, where the political system is behind, is behind the demand of time. And, uh, I think it will, it will work out. Democracy just always, you know, this is, it's so, it's so, uh, um, correctly mechanism, but the press will pay might be high.
The, the price we pay might be high. Um, yeah, Gary, I, I want to ask you a question, maybe, if, if we've established, uh, you know, freedom is a, is kind of a, a great good, we're still on this topic of, of geopolitics. And as you look at all of the geopolitical, uh, chess players, what do you think is the biggest threat to freedom right now? Is it China? Is it, is it Russia? And actually, I, I want to throw a third candidate in there. The United States. I mean, is that a threat to freedom? Uh, Germany didn't start out as Nazi Germany. What, what's your take on this? Um, no, let's, let's separate United States with, with, with, with Russian China.
The threat comes from the countries that, uh, are fighting our way of life. And, and, uh, it's, it's not no longer just access to evil. It's, it's, it's much larger coalition. Uh, obviously, uh, Russia, China, uh, playing Gleening Roll, you have, you're, you're in an other tallest, uh, you have North Korea, you have Venezuela, uh, here, uh, and we have many others that might follow. So, and of course you have, you know, the, uh, quasi-state institutions, uh, like, you know, he's Bola, for instance, and terrorist groups. Um, he, he, somehow we can look at this at the global map today, Jubilee, Google map as chess game.
It's black and white. Again, this, this, this, it doesn't mean that, you know, the forces on, on our side, they are just, you know, the perfect, they're far from being perfect. But again, that's the, that's democracy. Speaking about America, it's another end in quest for perfection. But again, you, you know, that American history, America always answered challenges. Maybe later than, than that we wanted it, but still, you know, always had inner strengths to, to address the challenges, even the most, even the most, um, uh, uh, uh, evil ones. So, uh, unlike most of other countries, because when you look at the European history, the, there was a much bumper road than America.
So, uh, so every country went through the process of, you know, reconsidering its past and also recognizing that nothing was perfect, but it's going back to what I said already a few times today, balance. So, are we doing better today than, than 50 years ago? 100 years? Of course. Just, you know, just, just look, look, look at this. That's overall environment. So it's, we, you know, we're 100 years ago, one in America, exactly 100 years ago. So the, there was the, uh, universal suffrage. Though we still knew that, yeah, you know, in theory, it was a suffrage, but until mid-60s, consider a part of the population in America, um, technically had the rights, but couldn't exercise them.
So have it made progress from the moment when the, uh, civil rights, um, uh, uh, uh, uh, uh, uh, was introduced? Yes, of course. It's just, again, is it perfect? No, but if you compare America to the rest of even the, the, the developed world, the, the democracies, it's, it's still the first country in the world, trust me. So when you look at the, you're still very bullish on America, and it's, uh, ability to be bullish. I'm bullish. I'm, look, it's, this is, dollar is, is, is a very weak currency. It's the strongest because others are so weak. America, America is still, it's probably not because it's perfect, but because others, you know, have more problems.
So this is, yeah, it's, that's, that's, trust me. As you look around the world and you recognize it, this is a, that's why people are trying to get to America. Why you have so many people trying to get to America. So this is, yes, because America offers opportunities far from being perfect. But we leave it, we don't leave, you know, in the world that, you know, it's come close to perfection. And I don't think we should measure America or just, uh, um, uh, or compare America to some kind of heavenly standards. We live on earth. And this, this is the earth's full of sins. And what do you think?
So, um, you are bullish on, uh, America's ability to resist the ring of power, not collapse to, to sort of authoritarianism and it's, actually, it's, it's challenging now. Yeah, it is. And I, I want to ask you why you think, uh, the America, um, the experiment of America has sustained, you know, the, the freedoms it has as long as it has. Is it, is it something unique about the protocol that we set up, that this constitution, the freedoms, the way it was founded. Is it something cultural? What, what do you think? I think I think it's, again, it's, that's probably requires a second podcast. Oh, we're open to that, Gary.
So many times to discuss it. No, I think it's important. America, you know, it's the, it's the country that was built not on the blood and soil. So that's it's, it was more like an idea. So, and, and it gradually developed in, in, in, in society, that, uh, that believed in equality before the law. So the United Kingdom was closed, but it's still, you know, the state, it's, as every European country, even the UK had history that that sometimes had a negative effect. Because when you look at the ancient history or just medieval times, yeah, I always feel a little discomfort that you know it's written by those who won.
So that's why, and America doesn't have this kind of historical liability. It's just, you know, it was from Pocahonta to Joe Biden, so it's just a puzzle straight line, so it's just, so we can argue about, you know, about our evaluations, we don't argue about the facts. So we just, so unlike in Europe, very often, we're not so sure. So there's certain advantages that America had from the very beginning, and up to now it was always, you know, resisting against, against challenges that could come from radicals. The problem is now, I think it's just, this is too many several generations already lived in the world of great comfort.
And I think just, yeah, taking it for granted, it's always dangerous. And that's why, you know, we have, we have extreme positions. The democracy is in danger when it's attacked from both sides. It's not, it's a very important remember. You cannot destroy the most from one side. You need two antagonists that, why do I need each other? So this is, who is the best fundraiser for AOC, Donald Trump? And vice versa. This is it. This is, we should remember that. So in Germany, when people say Hitler won the Lexus, no, he hasn't won the Lexus. The best result Nazi had in November, 1932 was just also the 7%.
But the common is made nearly 16. So which man that more than half of German population rejected democracy as an institution. So, and then you just, you already had, you know, just, it's the, it's a past to, to, to, to, to dictatorship. Whether it's going to one side or another. So it's what's happening now, America is just, it's, it's, it's the aggressive, aggressive attacks on various foundations, you know, on one side of liberal freedom, another one of the market economy. But you, but they need each other and that's, and the center has been decimated. So I still believe the center will, will, will recover.
But again, it's a problem, you know, the reason Joe Biden was elected in 2020 is, you know, because he represents a hope or normal thing. Because, again, not perfect choice, but, but clearly, you know, people wanted just to find some kind of a balance. Look at Donald Trump and potentially at Bernie Sanders plus. So, but now we need, we need to move on. So that's why again, this is the, if you follow my article. So I, I argue that, you know, Joe Biden should, you know, recognize that he's placing his to depends on, on, on carrying the torch and passing it to the right person. So I, my suggestion is that he should, you know, step down at one point, get just, and nominate Lloyd Austin as the, as, I think, the most capable member of the cabinet to, to, to, to continue, which, by the way, will solve the problem with Donald Trump.
So that's the, this, this, who cannot beat edge, even generic Democrat, but still tragically can be Joe Biden. So again, it's, it's, it's, there's so many things, you know, that that can happen. And I, I think that the changes is inevitable. That's why I'm not sure that, you know, we, we will see this, this horrible choice, you know, between Biden and Trump, you know, back in November, a year from now in November. But there's a risk, there's a risk. And we have all, we have all to work on it. So that's why I hope Nikki Haley can beat Trump. Oh, I'm, looks, looks, it's a long shot. So let's, let's say now.
So, but, but the American system proved to be resilient. But we, we reached a point where the conflict in the society is, this is between radical factions, the society is too deep. And majority in the center, which again, could the center right, center left, I mean, doesn't have a strong leadership to actually to fight. That's why I think the political system that caused us this problem has to be redesigned. Gary, from our perspective inside of the crypto industry, crypto is becoming an increasing conversation in at least pockets of the political sphere. You're seeing candidates on both sides of the aisle come up with their crypto policy and trying to get some sort of support around the crypto industry.
And then you have like the Warren and Biden camp who are kind of like anti crypto. I know that at times crypto as an industry Bitcoin property rights from crypto has entered into the world of human rights across many of the authoritarian regimes that we find across the world. And you're exposed to a lot of the stories coming out of the human rights foundation, you know, that do and do not have crypto in them. I'm wondering if there are any stories that do have crypto in them from the human rights foundation that you can share because me and Ryan, we're kind of inundated. We have like tunnel vision about like tribal warfare and crypto and SPF and FTX.
And sometimes we forget to zoom out and look at crypto through the human rights lens. Are there any stories that you can share about how crypto has improved people's lives across the globe to fight authoritarian regimes? Oh, I, and the story. So again, I suggest we do a separate podcast on that because the problem is I'm not sure with whether I could reveal some of the stories for a simple reason. For instance, you know, support for some of the underground women organizations of Afghanistan. So there's many things that are happening. So as this, well, that's that's we couldn't do that crypto.
Again, for those who are saying money laundering. So I mean, they think about people who are trying to fight dictators in Russia and Belarus and in Venezuela, of course, Afghanistan, even around. So this thing crypto is a chance. It doesn't solve all the problems, but it offers new opportunities. So that's the that's yeah, it's it's it's it's it's it's could there weapon, you know, by by bad guys by the governments to actually attack our democracy. Yeah, absolutely. But you know, it's balance in our favor because I think you know, it offers millions of people a chance to fight back and just you know, to defy government in in in financial sphere.
Because very often government can win the battle by simply not cutting all all the funding was crypto. Good luck. So getting into the specifics of stories I understand can and can be like, you know, there are are worse to be fought here. But we're like, what about the properties of crypto? Would you say is advantageous to people who are fighting against oppression and totalitarianism? Oh, well, there's no look, you know, this is they they have to function. For instance, yes, they have the the schools for girls. So this is you have to pay somehow. This is again, there's so many things so many small projects, you know, in that health individuals.
Again, this is it doesn't I doubt very much you can fund a revolution on that. But you can fund so many small projects, you know, the civil society projects. That help, you know, just to keep the the the the the the the flickers of the flag. So this is just this not to let let let it to be to be just to extinguished by by by the totalitarian machine. So what are your efforts currently working on in the human rights foundation at large? Like where there there's a lot of places to advocate for human rights. Where are your energies being focused on today? Human rights foundation is I don't know, you know, whether your audience is familiar.
So it's the organization that has been created by tall Thorhausen back in 2005. And I I joined the organization in 2009. So as a member of the board, the first president in Chairman of the board was Vatel Havel. It's one of my great heroes, you know, the Czech dissident and the first president of in the of Czechoslovakia, three of communism and then following, you know, the collapse of Czech and Czechoslovakia and Czech Republic and Slovakia, so president of Slovakia, or president of Czech Republic, sorry. And and when he passed away, so Thor and and and the rest of the board suggested that I would be chairman.
So I chair the organization for 11 years now. And the idea of the organization was very much to actually to have the first time evidence. Not, you know, the conference, you know, violation of human rights. It's happened here. It's about stories. It's just it's it's one like a show. You have people who will testify first hand, what's happened to them in Russian Belarus, in Zimbabwe, God knows where it is from Nicaragua on on the west to to to North Korean and on the far east. And if if an individual who was subject to this prosecution could do it on his own or her own. So then you had people close to him or her.
So that's the sometimes we even had the activists who have been killed by the by the regime. And then we had, you know, the relatives or friends who spoke spoke for them. So that's that's that's that's constantly very successful because it helped us to actually to to move beyond Norway. Originally, it was also freedom forum. Now it's it's it's a trademark of that that is being used in New York in in Taipei in in in Johannesburg in in Costa Rica. God knows where just around the world. So and and it's the it's probably the most lucrative dissident event because it was also very flashy. It's very it's high class.
So it's very important to demonstrate that the people who gather in Oslo and other theaters, they are not just respected. They are they they represent, you know, most important values of our society. And also it creates a sense of family. So many dissidents, so many human rights activists who came from countries around the world, they they left this event, you know, energized because they could see that they were not alone. Creating the sense of loneliness is one of the dictators most powerful weapons. You are against the country. You are against people. And now the dictator because everybody wants me to stay power.
And who are you? You know, just you have a bunch of, you know, just uh uh um squadrails, you know, you how can you challenge me? They understand. We are a majority. So that's that's that's what you know what to help the organization to to to grow and and we you know, we keep moving on. So that's as this is by by having more events. But uh lately, you know, we had a new organization that actually goes very much inspired by by Humans Foundation. And I was one of the founders who is Massie Elena Judd from Iran and Leopold Love is Robin as well. Well Liberty Congress. That we just had our founding Congress in Lithuania a few weeks ago.
And Mass Elena Judd she was like the president. So uh and uh that's more like a aggressive entity because it's it's about political change. It's about it's a structure that has, you know, this is this leadership, you know, Massie the president. I was president. Leopold is the executive secretary. So it and we have people from all over the world electing their representatives regions that you know, that's that's again, creating a network. So the idea of of of of while the British Congress was dictators getting united. This is the dictators' interaction. You look at all of them working together.
Iran sending drones to Russia. China is definitely now sitting behind but but but but pulling all the strings North Korea. I guess it's probably Chinese shells also moved to Russia. So they all work together. So why why don't we? So this is this this. This is the key now. We have to get together and we have to use the power of of of of of mass media. They have the power of technology. So that's why we will always look for for crypto. We will look for modern communications because we believe this is the way to be dictators. Yes, they could it they could be successful temporarily because they have more resources but we have numbers on our side.
So that's why again, I could see this how we can bring this this this projects together and and and to fight. So as also freedom for being humanized foundation working on more mechanologists is presenting the at glorifying the cause of of of of human rights fight. But while the British Congress basically carrying the fight back to dictators. Yeah, I mean, that's fantastic and certainly crypto is an ally of that. You know, we feel very much that what we're doing here is if this is a freedom technology for the world. And we think that we've talked about that the whole context of this discussion has been about, you know, technical change.
And we are entering we're we're moving from the analog into the digital. And it is therefore essential that we have a bill of digital rights as well. And I think the right to encryption, the right to own your own private keys, the right to own your own crypto is part of that and and is common cause with the human rights foundation, what you guys are doing. I'm curious like in the day to day of the human rights foundation, though, Gary's like, what is the most effective way to push for human freedoms? Is it is it education? Is it interfacing with with world governments like your dollar for dollar?
What's the the most effective spend in the space to get to propagate human rights? Look, it's education is very important. You know, we just, you know, it's the projects like freedom academy, so by just, you know, educating people, by the way, also educating them on crypto, educating them with using, you know, modern technology, also helping them to protect their devices. That's again, it says, just, you know, it gets attacked. So this is making sure that, you know, you can identify better Pegasus is sitting on their phone or not. So or how to protect your computer. So that says, again, those are small things, but are very important to people who are under constant pressure from depressive, from oppressive regimes.
And also they, they, they're, there's certain, you know, crucial moments will have to campaign, put in pressure on the world governments because somebody is arrested or just even worse. So I also just to keep, you know, to keep this momentum because there's so many compromises made by the free world with dictators, because you need oil, you need gas, you need that. And this is, and look, Jamakashoggi last performance, last last speech was at also for the forum. So we, we, we, we funded the movie called The Visiting. So there's the story about, about, about this tragic, the tragic story about this, this heinous crime.
And we guess we are pointing out that still, you know, it's the, the cause for justice has been announced. And so many things happening in the world now, that's worried, and the, the geopolitics, reality, is standing on the way of human values. We believe that, you know, that's, this is the human rights should be given priority. And it's not just lip service, as, as President Biden said, you know, this is democracy versus autocracy. Fine, perfect. So show me again, put here, put here, you know, you're, you're your money next to you, what your words are. And that's, that's, that's what believe it's our, it's, it's our, it's our mission to make sure that, you know, even if we cannot succeed today, but we'll still, you know, push the, the, the governments of the free world to the right things, sometimes even at the expense or immediate economic benefits.
Well, it's fantastic work. And we'll certainly put some links, links in the show notes, their Gary, where folks can get involved and find out a little bit more. And as we wrap this up, you've been, you know, we've explored so many topics today. And from touching on AI and, you know, geopolitics, I want to get back to sort of one thing. So our listeners in crypto, they kind of skew younger, right? And I think we've all felt going to the 2020s. I mean, it started with COVID, didn't it? It has felt so tumultuous. It has felt so chaotic. It has felt so disorienting. And I'm wondering if you could offer us some words of wisdom as we close.
So like as we look into the future, I think you have a very optimistic outlook for humanity. Can you lend us some of that optimism? Why are you optimistic? What parting advice would you have for us to weather the decades ahead that might be full of all sorts of changes, some of which might be very uncomfortable? Yeah. I was very comfortable. I lost my mother to COVID. The Christmas day on 2020. She was in Moscow and I couldn't, I couldn't see her because I was out of the country. So there's a price to pay. But, you know, one of the lessons I learned from my mother, you know, when I was rising to the global fame is that it's not just about winning.
Of course you have to win the game to climb to the top of the ladder. But it's about making a difference. And as long as you feel that you can make a contribution, make a difference, you win a small difference, you're relevant. So that's what keeps me going. I think I'm still going to make a difference. Even just we talk now. I share my experience. That's my contribution. I'm not sure I'm right to never say I'm saying to the Congress. I believe that many things I said, maybe not be tested by time. They were not age well. But it's very important that we debate. And we try to make the difference always to move the needle.
So I'm a good scholar of history. I read many books and I analyzed it and I saw that this is the freedom always wins. It's the darkest moments in history. Don't just think about 1940. This is the moment where everything was lost. The Britain just was standing in Nazi Germany. But by the Stalin was Hitler's ally. America was dominated by this debate about its isolationism. America first, the original American first. So just try to take America away from the global stage. Japan was just taking already part of China and dominating the nation. So you had an Italy, of course, you don't just had three hands in Mediterranean and North Africa.
So look, that everything was lost. Still. So that's why again, we have to respect our history and we have to recognize the value of freedom and we have to be guardians of freedom. And it could come and meet many different forms. One thing is that this freedom and democracy related to freedom, they don't offer all the solutions. It's just they are challenging. But again, this is the, you know, this Don Quixote, the freedom sancho is the greatest gift that nature I would bestow to a man. So that's the book I read and that's the that's a foregoer that I believe is a guarantee of success. Though success doesn't mean that you succeed, I succeed, he succeeds.
Oh, we all succeed. No, there's a cost. And this is we cannot be all with us. The win, win, it's not the way the the history works. But the balance, the balance is the most important. I think the balance will be always in our favor because we're on the side of freedom. What a fantastic way to end freedom always wins and crypto certainly is a journey and a technology in pursuit of that. Gary, it's been fantastic to have you on Bayclas. Thank you so much for spending this time. Thank you so much. Until next time. The conversations. Yeah, we've got a few other conversations. Freedom requires. You know, we appreciate you.
Thanks so much. Thank you. Thank you. Thank you. Thanks Gary. Risen Disclaimers, of course, none of this has been financial advice. I don't think we dispelled any advice that could even resemble financial advice on today's episode. Gotta let you know crypto is risky. So is AI. Man, so are the next couple of decades. I hope we make it. You could lose what you put in though. We are head and west. This is a frontier. It's not for everyone, but we're glad you're with us on the bankless journey. As always, thanks a lot.