✨ DEBRIEF | Ryan and David unpacking the episode: https://bankless.com/debrief-fragmentation
------ The Ethereum Ecosystem is going through Fragmentation, can we make it more Composable?
We brought on Ethereum researcher Justin Drake to explore this question in detail.
We cover deep topics like Universal Synchronous Composability, Shared Sequencing and Based Rollups. Justin explores the solution for which might be Ethereum’s Hardest Challenge and its roadmap.
------ Listen On Your Favorite Podcast Player: https://bankless.cc/Podcast
------ BANKLESS SPONSOR TOOLS:
🐙KRAKEN | MOST-TRUSTED CRYPTO EXCHANGE https://k.xyz/bankless-pod-q2
🔗CELO | CEL2 COMING SOON https://bankless.cc/Celo
🗣️TOKU | CRYPTO EMPLOYMENT SOLUTION https://bankless.cc/toku
🛞MANTLE | MODULAR LAYER 2 NETWORK https://bankless.cc/Mantle
💸 CRYPTO TAX CALCULATOR | USE CODE BANK30 https://bankless.cc/CTC
------ TIMESTAMPS
00:00 Intro 6:55 Ethereum’s Fragmentation Problem 10:00 The Solution 17:14 Composability Spectrum 23:57 Universal Synchronous Composability 30:32 Composability Features 36:25 Why Composability Matters 43:07 The Roadmap 46:52 What is Shared Sequencing? 1:03:38 A Shared Sequencing Paradigm 1:19:55 Shared Sequencing Solutions 1:30:25 Rollup Design 1:40:15 Based Rollup Roadmap 1:47:02 What’s Next 1:50:51 Timeline 1:53:10 Accessory Technologies 1:58:18 The Role of Blockspace 2:05:28 Outro
------ RESOURCES
Justin Drake https://twitter.com/drakefjustin
Justin Drake Episodes https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=X-4Jn8p2Oeo https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=azjpYTB7PVE https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ycK3AUTdl1w
------ Not financial or tax advice. This channel is strictly educational and is not investment advice or a solicitation to buy or sell any assets or to make any financial decisions. This video is not tax advice. Talk to your accountant. Do your own research.
Disclosure. From time-to-time I may add links in this newsletter to products I use. I may receive commission if you make a purchase through one of these links. Additionally, the Bankless writers hold crypto assets. See our investment disclosures here: https://www.bankless.com/disclosures
No summary for this episode yet.
Welcome to Debrief after our episode with Justin Drake. Fixing fragmentation. What an episode, David. Yeah. I loved it. I personally loved it. There's so many things to talk about. I think maybe I'll just start here for whatever the hell reason, but just like I think many Ethereum people, you and I, whatever category I'm talking about, the you, me, Anthony, Cezanne, the highly convicted Ethereum people, where there was like the rise of Solana and a lot of people were like, you know what? The monolithic blockchain architecture was correct. I'm going to become a Solana. I'm now a Solana person.
They started fading modular. Fading the modular thesis, fading Ethereum, right? Fading the roll-up centric roadmap. And they became like Solana people, right? For whatever tribal. Not just tribal. User experience. You know, I don't think it has to be tribal. I think that the boots on the ground are that in many ways, Solana feels like one unified chain and in many ways Ethereum's roll-up ecosystem doesn't it's like bridge this not just say that that's not reality but just like yeah you know people are like I sold my ETH for Sol here's my Solana NFT for all for the perspective for the perceived nature of these things ETH is dead Solana is the new king yeah and then there's a lot of people like you me Anthony Cezano is like no And maybe we can't articulate why we don't feel like this is a threat or feel like this is a problem because we're not Justin Drake.
And I can't tell you about the nuances of shared sequencing. But a lot of us are just like, it's a problem. Sure, we'll solve it. Present us problem. Eventually, Ethereum will present you with solution. I don't know when. I don't know how. But we will. and that's just some amount of conviction on just like the Ethereum developer mind chair, the mad scientist of Ethereum that Georgios called us, called them the developers and just like, yeah, like, okay, sure. If it's a problem, then we'll fix it. But just like the solutions aggregate to the network. And I also say it's not, it's also not blind faith.
I mean, there are hints of many solutions already. Like, you know, Intense is kind of one category solution. I am aware and have been aware of shared sequencers and their role have not gone in depth. But like that's an emerging field. And like just in general, like there's all of these hints of solutions and the Internet itself being kind of like a case study and asynchronous composability can also work. Now, I will say with the internet, though, it wasn't competing against an internet that had full synchronous composability, right? It was just like, it's asynchronous composability and you got no other options, right?
Because everyone's already adopted TCP. So maybe there's some different market dynamics there. So yes, I just wanted to add that in addition to it being blind faith, because Ethereum has like fixed all of the problems that have like, like don't bet against Ethereum as the adage, right? Like in addition to that is also there are all of these hints that we can't fully articulate something like Justin Drake can, but that might seem like we were making progress on solutions. This for me, this episode was like, oh, the progress could happen much faster than I thought. and also the insight was ethereum uh main chain would have a role to play as a shared sequencer which is kind of yeah like well i wouldn't even say that that as a a prerequisite for universal shared composability like a single shared sequencer like espresso without using the ethereum layer one still could produce that outcome he justin was just like oh yeah all these all these shared sequencers are realizing that it's the it's the base chain it's the layer one chain that's going to be able to actually do this for the greatest network of bytes.
I don't think I fully understood what a based rollup actually was before, I don't know, the last month or so. It's a rollup that is following the protocol sync thesis. Yeah, and then basically all rollups can become based rollups if they use a shared sequencer that uses Ethereum validators for shared sequencing as well. On that note of having hints of solutions kind of spread around the Ethereum-verse, that's also what I felt like we're in a phase in the market in which everyone listening to that episode has been in crypto for like at least one year if not three plus and so they probably heard the phrase shared sequencing before so like shared sequencing is not new Express has been around since like 2020 2021 and so like there's a lot nothing is really new here I think really the new insight is a little bit more about the order of operations like I was going around and I was asking like a few people on different like roll up teams and Georgios and like Torgal about like, hey, how is Ethereum going to fix its fragmentation?
And I got I got like a fragmented set of answers. And so I ended up at the conclusion of just like, oh, Ethereum will solve this fragmentation problem kind of thing like with market forces. The fragmentation of a layer two is will will die a thousand cuts. Yeah. Like there's not going to be a silver bullet. It's just we're just eventually going to figure it out. And I kind of did come to the conclusion of just like, yo, it's still going to be asynchronous. But if you get a synchronicity inside of two seconds, then you can have like UX tricks take you the rest of the way. That was my previous understanding.
As a result of this episode, I think my understanding is just a little bit more ordered. And I think that's what Justin Drake did for me in this episode where he was like, yes, it will die a thousand cuts and first shared sequencing. And that opens up the door towards the proper ordering of other synchronous technologies. and I think really that's kind of the main insight here is like first shared sequencing and even Georgios on our last podcast that I had with him he was like yeah shared sequencing gets you some composability composability benefits it's not universal composability but it gets you some and then Justin Drake on this is like yeah it also gets you some but it is the platform for the rest of them and that's kind of the new insight that I've had yeah I I think that makes sense.
I, you know, one interesting thing was him calling asynchronous composability cope. He thought that was like that, you know, and it is if you can have synchronous composability, that is everything can kind of like immediately interact with everything else in the same sort of super state, then like, isn't that better? And the answer is quite obviously, yes. I think, you know that is what alternative monolithic chains have kind of pointed out right they very much called uh ethereum's fragmentation and roll-ups cope right and uh you know they not entirely wrong like we i think uh the in defense of the modular thesis that the argument would be like well but it's worth it right like trade-off to remain decentralized and kind of like uh you Low validator requirements is a key for that.
That's how Ethereum defines decentralization. Well, maybe we don't get full synchronous composability, but it's worth it. But Justin Drake, once again, coming to the episode, being like, nah, we can have everything. We can have it all. And here's a path to kind of get us there. Yeah, it's cool from that perspective. Let me ask you, how long do you think it'll take to sort of achieve this? do you think like justin drake's one thing is i don't think it's binary i don't think it's gonna be like oh here's the day uh it's just ethereum's just gonna become a little bit more synchronous day by day by day maybe there are some like big events that happen so it's like oh arbitrum main net and optimism main net they're on the same sequence oh man here's going down yeah um and so like maybe there'll be like days like that like right right now we're watching like uh i think this will happen a bunch like right now we're watching um uh op stack roll-ups like some of the newer op stack roll-ups pivot to celestia for data availability like lyra was the first to go avo is being announced sometime soon um and then we're like the long tail of op stack roll-ups are all going to pivot to celestia because they're paying like you know somewhere between 10 and 50 eth a month for and publishing empty blocks to ethereum yeah so they're pivoting to celestia to get 0.
5 uh and 0.5 eth per block per month is their cost makes sense there's that's just what we're going to see and it's going to be something like that where like we're going to see and it's going to be more there's going to be an accelerating number of these things as they all do this up to some particular point where like that's how it'll happen some of the big chains like optimism and arbitrum and they're like yeah we're not going to celestia we're staying a roll up um and it'll be something like this for like adopting a shared sequencer is like somebody adopts a shared sequencer. And then somebody else was like, Oh, I'd like to tap, like, I'd like to tap into, to that.
And like, Oh, I, I'd also like to tap into that. Oh, these guys are tapping into that benefits. Like, Oh, I'm also going to do that. And then it'll just like, you know, that, that's that video of the guy dancing in the middle of the field. And then everyone else is the one, he's like dancing solo for like three minutes and he's weird. And then somebody else joins him. And then somebody else runs him. And then, you know, a minute later, like there's a whole crowd of people. It's going to be like that. I think one of my favorite things about this is it's a realization of the dream of the United Chains of Ethereum.
Because I'll tell you where I also felt this, you know, like you could talk about UX, you could talk about liquidity fragmentation, you could talk about having to change from network to network in your wallet. I feel like a lot of that could be changed by like the market, right? Better wallet design, right? If you use the Rabi wallet you just don't even feel it and intent intense right um well like with intense you're not feeling the liquidity pain so much and so the market was was solving that but what it wasn't solving for was kind of the memetic layer and that kind of the narrative layer and the social layer of it it still very much feels like um layer twos are competing hard against one another Like they're not, or it has felt increasingly like that, let me say, the last 18 months.
It hasn't felt like united chains of Ethereum, if that makes sense. Like there was not, as I remember in 2019, 2020, Ethereum had a very clear kind of shared identity of like, if you're an Ethereum user, if you like are building an Ethereum, you have a defined set of Ethereum values, like things that you kind of believe and we're all in sort of the same team. Well, in the roll-up world where we got is a bit of fracturing of that. And it's like, no, there's a polygon people and there's like optimism and arbitrary people. Team purple, team blue, team red. Yeah. Yeah. And like, there's an element of that where it's healthy, but then there's an element where you all want to come together as one like network state, as one digital nation, if you will.
And we lost some of that. And I think the reason we've lost it, we've lost some of that is because of the architecture because there was this lose type of uh you know lose lose or like i take from you from liquidity perspective and you adding you bringing your chain to the ethereum economy that's not necessarily going to add to my chain you're just going to like you might add a little bit but you might take more from me and so i'm hostile to you and my tribe is like this gets rid of a lot of that. I'm not saying there's still going to be healthy competition for execution, for users, but like not as much competition for liquidity.
And if you can come join the network and add your liquidity and bring on a new tranche of users, will you benefit the entire superstructure? That to me is like one of my favorite things about this because I love the network effect type game. I love the win, win, win. Like we all kind of grow together feeling that we had when Ethereum was just one global synchronous state. And let's keep in mind, that's what it was in 2019 and 2020. And every app that added like Aave and Compound, very excited to have Uniswap be maximally successful. Why? Because it benefits their protocol, right? I want that again.
And this is a path to getting that again. and i love that now we have like chain legos so like we had money legos on the ethereum layer one where maker and uniswap and ave and like you know zero x and like i don't know and you know pick your pick your layer one up they were all money legos and there was i remember that old article i wrote i called it um something about like the ethereum superstructure uh but it was it was about defy money legos inside of the layer one because i wrote that in like 2019 before like even any rollups were like alive. And so now this is like the next dimension of that whole entire idea, that concept, which is just like now we have a chain superstructure being built on Ethereum.
And I think the reason why I like this the most, one of the reasons, one of the many reasons is that like the whole Peloton metaphor, whereas this is complete alignment with open source ethos, whereas as something gets more useful, it gets more developer activity, it gets more traction, It becomes even more useful. So it goes back to Andre Santanopoulos' Festival of the Commons, where like right now we have a tragedy of the commons between layer two chains. Like the space between layer twos is neglected. But with this vision, universal composability, it's the opposite. It flips. It inverts. Like adding more chains to Ethereum increases its total unified TPS.
It increases its total users. It increases its total utility and liquidity, et cetera. And so there's literally no cost to adding more chains to Ethereum. And when that becomes true, when it's not just about lowering the cost, but inverting the cost structure, when that becomes true, just like Ethereum is going to grow so incredibly large. And it's going to be the open, completely permissionless financial platform that we've all envisioned for ourselves here. There are a few things I want to ask you that I didn't fully understand with Drake. We just didn't have time to get caught on very small details because we're trying to express the full idea.
I think we could have gone on for another hour. But this conversation about pre-confirmations, you kept bringing that up. Why is that important? Do you know? Why are pre-confirmations so important? Well, that's kind of like a UX trick, but it's actually more than a trick. A UX trick I'll define as the front end just tells you your transaction went through, even though they don't actually know that it went through. Instantaneously, you could tell a user, hey, transaction's through, but in the background, it's really different. Yeah, you're Gucci. Yeah, in the background, it's still processing, right?
And so that's a UX trick. A pre-conf is a UX trick with assurances. So it's not in the system, but you have an assurance that it's going to get in. And this can be used in a variety of different contexts. I think like heart from across protocol from Uma is using pre comps on or can in the future version of those like intense and cross chain bridges, which is just like I'm going I'm going to tell you your transactions finalized. I'm going to let your UX update as if it is finalized. It's not actually finalized, but if it doesn't finalize, I get slashed by eigen layer or restaking. And so there are systems like this where you can get a cryptographic assurance that this is going to go in.
And there's different ways to provide those assurances. Okay, and then there was this other thing he was talking about, shared sequencing, which we defined that, but also real-time settlement. And then later in the conversation, we didn't spend a lot of time on real-time settlement, but later in the conversation, he talked about a block that could form, like a special interest kind of block of ZK EVMs versus optimistic EVMs. And he was drawing some kind of parallel or difference there and linking that to real-time settlement. And I think maybe his point was like, real-time settlement might be like finality, right?
Whereas optimistic roll-ups have kind of a, you know, seven-day fraud-proof type window. So you don't get kind of like finality, settlement finality immediately. like the confirmation could be like subject to dispute during that seven day window of course with zk evms you don't have that and i think maybe he was saying that that is a reason why zk evms will be could be faster to adopt shared sequencing because they are losing uh right now they're losing in the foot race i mean it's still super early so it's just like it's kind of whatever but they're losing in the traction foot race by some dimensions to optimistic roll-ups.
And therefore, they might adopt shared sequencing sooner. Was that the point you was making? I wasn't really clear on how these things tied together. I don't know if you were. No, I'll have to go back and listen to that part. I think part of that answer just gets because optimistic roll-ups and ZK roll-ups are such a different language. ZK roll-ups inside of the same circuit, right? So ZK seeing hyperchains are one circuit, Polygon supernets are one circuit. They all get the benefits of being ZK and getting very, very near instant finality. And so I think their needs about shared sequencing are different.
They're of a different quality. But I can't see too much more. I don't know. There's so much that this would change, I think, about Ethereum ecosystem and its actors like it as this comes about and again it's not going to happen overnight it's not a switch that's going to flip it's not even a hard fork it's kind of like market forces and other incentives will kind of like push this along as it needs to but it's going to change so much about existing players and where like the attractive investment opportunities are so like if justin drake is right and this is why we do these types of episodes it's because we're trying to figure out what's going to happen and like where we should place our bets right but like if drake is right then what does this mean for bridges they kind of become less important yeah he also implied well no it depends on it depends on the type of bridge so let's let's parse that part apart right so there are um lock lock and mint bridges which i totally think you're right those are like those are going away um but across bridges are like an intent based bridges so across isn't even a bridge is like an intent system on one side and a tent system on the other.
And then market makers go between those two ports. So it's like a port. So across is like multiple ports of different chains. Market makers, all these, the swarms of MEV bots kind of like in between. Yeah. Yeah, across was an intent filler before we had the word intent. This is why I actually really respect Harden. I kind of don't class that as a bridge, but like I suppose it's like a sub-bridge. But yeah, when I was more- It's a bridge from the perception of the user. I was more talking about bridges. I was more talking about like the typical mint type of bridge and all of the multi-sequence.
Lock and mint bridges are boo-boo. Those are fundamentally boo-boo. Those are going away. But even the super bridges that are out there. What's a super bridge? Well, the bridges that basically become development platforms. I'm trying to think of an example off the top of my head. Oh, like Layer 0? Yeah, like a Layer 0. What happens to a Layer 0 in this world? Messaging bridge? Layer 0, I think, has always been meant for more messaging. So basically the asset bridges are going to have, like the pure asset transfer bridges are going to maybe have a hard time, but the message passing intense based bridges maybe not.
Lock and mint bridges going away. Yeah, generalized messaging. Layer 0 is a generalized messaging bridge. But even I don't know if it's highly optimized for being an intent bridge. How does it change also market dynamics when you have asynchronous composability. You don't have to have, sorry, synchronous composability. And you don't have to approach every single chain and say, from a biz dev perspective, and be like, hey, do you want this? We've got this new, and there's an agreement. Drake talked about backroom deals. He's the example of Chainlink. But there's tons of this. When we're doing due diligence for somebody who's kind of entering and they've got this new a service that they want to provide, you know, chains.
And the question is always go to market. Well, how are you going to convince these chains to adopt your product, go through the work effort or pay the cost, right? When you dissolve the borders, then pretty immediately, like you could have an Oracle service that is in use across all of the chains, couldn't you? And by decreasing that barrier to entry and go to market business development costs, how do you change the competitive landscape? does chain link suddenly have a whole bunch of competitors that can start to do something uh like with you know with you know and you spin up other oracle services i'm just saying like yeah the board the borders when you dissolve borders things happen and landscapes change and i don't i can't necessarily predict how they'll change i just think if drake is right it has some pretty big implications for a good kind of change and a good kind of chaos in this space, I would say.
Yeah, I definitely think that's right. I think there's a general shift towards a de-monopolizing of the Layer 2 space. And so the Chainlink, for example, has a monopoly on oracles and DeFi oracles. If you're going to be a Layer 2 chain, a DeFi Layer 2 chain, you need Chainlink oracles. But if everyone can just tap into Layer 1 Chainlink oracles on their Layer 2, then that monopoly is kind of like broken it's like easier to be a new player in the field um what was i gonna say i was gonna say something um well i got some something else i'm thinking about it what what while you're thinking about that so like what's your what's your take on incentives for chains to adopt shared sequencing now so we we talked about that with drake that's you know some people have said that's a a reason why chains want it's basically the reasons we we talked about is they don't want to give up their MEV.
That's revenue. And when you think about that, it's not like a greedy, arbitral, you know, optimism labs, like centralized entity. It's also the token holders. If you hold some ARB token, you're just like, yeah, but how does this accrue value? And like, you're going to give away my rights to potential MEV fees? Like, no, don't do that. Don't do that. And so there's some, maybe some forces that would inhibit their incentive to put decentralized sequencers in place. But Drake says, well, but like if everybody does it and like if there's so much liquidity benefit and composability benefit that you can make it make up for that loss of revenue.
And by the way, MEV is going to kind of go away anyway. This is, yeah, what's your take on that? Yeah, I could spit out a bunch of those like gut takes, but they would be pretty like unfounded. the vibe that he was giving was that like especially with that one innovation that he named from espresso which is just like yo espresso is going to be able to segment rewards and so arbitrage is going to retain its share of the pie and and like you know all chains are going to pro rata be able to retain their share of the pie and then also he was saying just like uh well that was always one of my understandings that i've heard from other people say it's like why would anyone adopt a shared sequencer when sequencer is where they get their money and then his answer is like it's actually not where they get the money.
It's actually just MEV. Yeah, I don't know. I think that's going to be a very big topic of discussion because all of this ultimately boils down to economics. We're talking about trade between chains, trade between economic zones, trade between states. And all the states, we're trying to make trade deals, right? And imagine that's going to take a while. That's going to be the thing that probably slows us down the most, I'd say. I think I really appreciated his, almost in the same breath where he was talking about COPE, asynchronous composability is kind of COPE. He was also just, I think a little earlier, talking about just thank you to other chain ecosystems, particularly he named Solana for pushing Ethereum in this direction, right?
I can think of the competition that Solana has recently given Ethereum ethereum has kind of woken the uh ethereum community up to two things two big innovations i think were important and previously underlooked one is like parallelized virtual machines like somewhere along the the road map ethereum forgot that that's important didn't like innovate very much never never really accounted for in the first place right i mean well do you remember Yeah, it just didn't do any innovation on its EVM and didn't really. The EVM has never been touted as like a highly advanced piece of software. No, and do you remember there were at one time, like 2018 or so, 19, there was EF initiatives to do like eWASM.
And like this wasn't parallelized EVM, but this was the EF doing something. It was still advancing the EVM. Right, so that, and we talked about that almost at length on Bankless, I feel like, recently. And Ethereum kind of was pushed into that by a competitor. But then also, solving fragmentation and not settling for asynchronous composability, but going full synchronous composability. And Solana has pushed the Ethereum roadmap in that direction as well. So he was saying, thank you, Solana? Yeah, what's your take on that? And where do the monolithic chains end up if everything Drake says comes to fruition?
So one thing I think that I think is happening is my gut take, my intuition, is that when every single layer two chain joins together in the unified synchronous composability, like layer two mesh network that is being built on top of Ethereum, like, yeah, the EVM is single threaded, sure. And so every single layer two chain is a single threaded chain because if they're using the EVM, then it's a single thread. Every layer two is a thread. And so if we have a hundred layer twos shared sequencing with each other, we have a hundred threads being computed against by market makers, by intent fillers, by shared sequencers, by the Ethereum layer one validators.
And so we actually have like a hundred threaded CPU layer two on top of Ethereum being collapsed down into a packet that goes down onto the Ethereum layer one. And so like, we can talk about like, yeah, so like, you know, the EVM is single threaded. It's so low performance. But like, what is Ethereum supposed to be? It's supposed to be a world global virtual computer. And so like a chain is the thread. A single chain is a single thread. Sure, but what you can do is get like quadratic threading, like where you have the- Where you can have multi-threaded layer twos. the single thread that you're talking about then is a multi-thread single thread chains you know what i mean right for sure but just like anything that's a modular blockchain is like oh we're multi-threaded and you don't need layer twos because we have multi-threading it's like well yeah but like go zoom out one more order of magnitude well zoom out go out one more dimension and yeah you have like a like you have different chains which all represent their different throughputs all represented different order flows they're different traffic uh and really it's just like a shared sequencer isn't a sequencer a part of a computer isn't that like a technical component like a sequencing the traffic of of like flops or whatever bits i don't know i need to brush up like a like a service bus or something um yeah bus yeah serial bus serial bus isn't there something like this yeah i don't know what it does yeah you see the metaphor i'm trying to make it make happen, right?
Yeah, I definitely see that. I mean, this goes back to kind of like, I think Mike from Blockworks, who's talked about all of these chains sort of are starting to collapse on the same design. I think there's elements of that that are right. But like, I kind of wonder if you're a monolithic chain, I guess more my idea, my thesis is, at some point, if you're, say, Solana, and you're building this excellence in terms of execution, right? Like, I know I've said this here recently, but I think it's a very realistic possibility. You should build up all of the state, this excellence, incredible execution.
And then you're just like, I'm just going to join this network. Sounds great. I get to keep all my state. I get to keep all my users. And then I get to tap into this massive liquidity source, which is the entire Ethereum economy, and shared sequence that. And then you effectively become some version of an Ethereum layer two. You may not be a roll-up because you're not necessarily doing DA on Ethereum. You might like do that somewhere else, but you definitely become connected. So I just, I think all of the other alternative layer ones will also be like gravitationally pulled into this super network as well.
And I don't even know that that fragmentation will persist. We might be able to get this so we're completely borderless or very close to that, even across other chain ecosystems. I don't know. What's your take on that? I think we will see the writing on the wall for that to happen when we see ghost chain layer twos join into a shared sequencer set and the ghost chain layer two actually starts to get more activity just because it's proximate to the activity. Right. Like one of the reasons why like building in crypto, building in Ethereum specifically is so fast is because you build an app on the Ethereum layer one and you are just so proximate to a bajillion users and like billions of dollars.
And so you actually it's actually relatively easy to get user acquisition in TVL just because you're so close to everyone. And so if we start to see ghost chain layer twos that are not part of a shared sequencer set and then they say, all right, we're going to join in on the Peloton. Let me like just bike over here and join in the herd. and all of a sudden you get more users and you get more TVL and you get more economic activity, that's the evidence. The market provides evidence. Sure, but the interesting thing about what you're saying is you have to be a ghost chain. You have to be kind of desperate in order to do that.
If you're doing well on your own, you're not a ghost chain. You have users and your token price is going up. You're probably not going to do that. I mean, a ghost chain by comparatively to the Peloton. Yeah. Yeah. Yeah. Anything else from that episode stick out for you? No. I mean, I'm, let me, I'll tell you after go back and re-listen to it. Yeah. Same here. It's a, it's one I'm going to have to re-listen to. All right guys. Thank you for being citizens. This has been The Debrief.