✨ DEBRIEF | Ryan and David unpacking the episode: https://bankless.com/debrief-e-acc-beff-jezos
One guest, two identities. Beff Jezos (Guillaume Verdon) is a founding father of the e/acc movement, a physicist, a quantum researcher, and the founder of an AI startup called Extropic. Beff thinks AI doomers are not only wrong, but they’re taking humanity in the worst possible direction. Growth. Acceleration. Progress. These are the core pillars of the e/acc movement. Instead of slowing down on AI progress, Beff explains why we should be speeding up.
------ 🎧Listen On Your Favorite Podcast Player https://bankless.cc/Podcast
------ BANKLESS SPONSOR TOOLS:
🐙KRAKEN | MOST-TRUSTED CRYPTO EXCHANGE https://k.xyz/bankless-pod-q2
🔗CELO | CEL2 COMING SOON https://bankless.cc/Celo
🗣️TOKU | CRYPTO EMPLOYMENT SOLUTION https://bankless.cc/toku
🛞MANTLE | MODULAR LAYER 2 NETWORK https://bankless.cc/Mantle
💸 CRYPTO TAX CALCULATOR | USE CODE BANK30 https://bankless.cc/CTC
🦄UNISWAP | ON-CHAIN MARKETPLACE https://bankless.cc/uniswap
------ TIMESTAMPS
0:00 Intro 7:15 Why Pseudonym 15:01 The e/acc Pil 31:54 Fume 36:25 Beff’s Beliefs 39:39 Defining e/acc 40:52 The Dangers of AI? 52:05 Why We’re Here & The e/acc Religion? 58:19 Thermodynamics & Life 1:06:16 Maximizing Human Happiness? 1:16:25 Forgetting Society’s Bottom Half 1:23:00 Cancer Also Grows? 1:29:01 AI Regulation 1:33:09 Social Media’s Mistake 1:36:30 AI Bill of Rights 1:38:26 Domesticating AI 1:41:00 Biggest Threats Against e/acc 1:43:43 AI Humans vs. Humans 1:46:09 e/acc vs. Decels…Violence? 1:49:09 Beff’s Thoughts on Crypto 1:54:36 Beff’s Company - Extropic 1:58:18 Closing & Disclaimers
------ RESOURCES
Beff Jezos https://twitter.com/BasedBeffJezos
Guillaume Verdon https://twitter.com/GillVerd
Extropic https://twitter.com/Extropic_AI
AI Safety Podcasts - The Decels Eliezer Yudkowsky https://youtu.be/gA1sNLL6yg4 Connor Leahy https://youtu.be/pMoVsM1EWR0 Paul Christiano https://youtu.be/GyFkWb903aU Nate Sores https://youtu.be/Ymjb3SkElco
------ Not financial or tax advice. This channel is strictly educational and is not investment advice or a solicitation to buy or sell any assets or to make any financial decisions. This video is not tax advice. Talk to your accountant. Do your own research.
See our investment disclosures here: https://www.bankless.com/disclosures
No summary for this episode yet.
what we're advocating for with IAC is sort of freedom of access to compute, freedom of access to AI. We don't want these centralized entities just like a central bank like inflating away your money to control access to advanced AI. We want it in the hands of many because otherwise the centralized parties are going to abuse their power. Welcome to bankless where we explore the frontier of internet money and internet finance. This is Ryan Sean Adams. I'm here with David Hoffman and we are here to help you become more bankless or maybe more IAC in today's episode. We have Beth Jesus. He's the founding father of IAC.
That's effective accelerationism. This is a philosophy that things AI tumors are not only wrong. They're taking humanity in the worst possible direction. The emphasis here is growth acceleration progress. These are the core pillars and instead of slowing down on AI. Beth explains today why we should be speeding up. I think this is a direct answer to an episode that we've recorded over a year ago with Ellie Zarykowski on why we are all doomed and why AI is going to kill us all. It's a debate, I guess, if you listen to those two episodes sequentially. We talk about a few things on today's episode including why AI isn't going to kill us after all according to Beth.
What is IAC? He explains the fundamentals and why IAC is more than just AI. For Beth Jesus, it's an entire philosophy for life. Also, we get into what in the world Homo Techno-Capital Mamedic Accelerationism is. Did I say that right, David? I don't know. Finally, we end with Beth's take on crypto. One thing I enjoyed about this conversation is that I think you could end up at this conversation from a variety of different angles. If you are coming from crypto, you will start to catch a vibe for this. It will sound familiar to you a little bit if you've been paying attention to the AI world for sure.
Also, you can go really far back and just talk about philosophy. If you are a fan of Friedrich Nietzsche, you will find yourself in a familiar place. I've been a big fan of the concept of optimism as a way to achieve strong mental health. Optimists tend to feel better. They tend to be less depressed. They tend to feel like they have more control and agency around their surroundings. If you come from the mental health and psychology background, you will find yourself, I think, resonating with some of the things that Beth Jesus has to say. That's one thing I really just enjoyed about this conversation is that Beth starts from a conversation around base principles, getting really close to the metal, and then expands it, extrapolates it outwards onto a political philosophy that people could align with.
It's worth listening to this episode for that reason alone. David, there's so much more to discuss with you in the debrief, I think. I've got to take some time to really unpack this. Of course, is the episode that we record right after the episode. You're a bankless citizen. You can enjoy that now. All right, let's get right to the episode with Beth, but before we do, we want to thank the sponsors that made this possible, including our number one recommended crypto exchange for 2024. That is crypto accelerator. Definitely a crypto accelerator. Well done, Kraken. Go create an account. Kraken knows crypto.
Kraken's been in the crypto game for over a decade, and as one of the largest and most trusted exchanges in the industry, Kraken is on the journey with all of us to see what crypto can be. Human history is a story of progress. It's part of us, hard-wired. We're designed to seek change everywhere, to improve, to strive, and if anything can be improved, why not finance? crypto is a financial system designed with the modern world in mind. Instant, permissionless, and 24-7. It's not perfect, and nothing ever will be perfect, but crypto is a world-changing technology at a time when the world needs it the most.
That's the Kraken mission, to accelerate the global adoption of cryptocurrency, so that you and the rest of the world can achieve a financial freedom and inclusion. Head on over to Kraken.com, slash bankless, to see what crypto can be. Not investment advice, crypto trading involves risk blocks. Cryptocurrency services are provided to US and US territory customers by payward ventures, Eek, PDI, doing business as Kraken. Cello is the mobile first EVM compatible carbon-negative blockchain built for the real world. Driving real-world use cases like mobile payments and mobile defy, and with opera mini-pay as one of the fastest-growing web-free wallets, Cello is seeing a meteoric rise with over 300 million transactions and 1.
5 million monthly active addresses. And now, Cello is looking to come home to Ethereum as a layer 2. Optimism, Polygon, Matterlabs, and Arbitram have all thrown their hats in the ring for the Cello layer 2 to build upon their stacks. Why the competition? The Cello layer 2 will bring huge advantages, like a decentralized sequencer, off-chain data availability, secured by Ethereum validators, and one block finality. What does that all mean for you? With Cello layer 2, gas fees will stay low and you can even pay for gas natively using ERC 20 tokens, sending crypto to phone numbers across wallets using social connect.
But Cello is a community-governed protocol. This means that Cello needs you to weigh in and make your voice hurt. Join the conversation in the Cello forums. Follow Cello on Twitter and visit cello.org to shape the future of Ethereum. Are you launching a token? Is it already live? How are you managing the legal and tax obligations for providing token grants to your team? It's no secret that token management gets complicated. Between learning all the legal language and tax obligations in every country that your team is in, token grant management can feel like an obstacle course, but it doesn't have to.
That's where Toku steps in. Toku provides practical tools to handle token grants, allowing for effective oversight of token distributions and payroll tax compliance for employees, contractors, advisors, and investors. They also handle tax withholdings through their real-time tax calculations that can be done by Toku or integrated into any payroll EOR providers in any jurisdiction. Toku is a trusted provider of protocol labs, dydx foundation, mean of protocol, and many more. Get started for free and make token compensation simple at Toku.com slash bankless. Bankless Station, I'm very excited to introduce our next guest.
This is one guest, but two identities on the podcast today. Beth Jaisos is a founding father of the Effective Accelerationism Movement. This is also known as IAC. You've heard Dave and I talk about IAC before, particularly in contrast to the AI Safety or D cell movement, as someone call it. IAC is a basic philosophy that advocates for the full acceleration into our AI-powered future. This is all gas and no brakes. Beth, welcome to bankless. Well, thanks for having me. Pleasure to meet you, Ryan and David, and excited for the conversation today. Now, I said there were actually two identities, one guest, but two identities.
So, Beth is your online alter ego, but in meat space, your name is your identity, I should say, is Guillaume for known. This is your original identity, your nation's human identity. Yeah, your human name. Let's call it. And you are a physicist, quantum researcher, and the founder of an AI startup called Extropic. So I think we'll be talking more to your Beth persona today, if that's okay, but also, welcome to Guillaume. Same person, but appreciate it. Appreciate it. Yeah, good to hear that. You know, include all of the identities and the intros. Why don't we actually start? Because for some people that may have been a little bit like jarring, right?
So let's start with the decision to use a pseudonym to kickstart the Effective Acceleration as a movement. Why did you use this pseudonym of Beth, Jesus? Like, why not just use your regular old nation state fiat name? I think, you know, at the time, I was, you know, in some secretive teams within a secretive unit of a big tech company. You know, I was as a Google axe in their, you know, secrecy is baseline. I was in particularly secretive team. Can't really talk about what I was doing. People can try to piece it together for my patents and have fun with that. Some leaster eggs in there. But, you know, secrecy was my sort of baseline.
I couldn't necessarily say too many, you know, have too many hot takes that, you know, wouldn't get back to me, right? And where I felt, I don't know if that was like fully true. I mean, I've had some feedback that way, but there was always that sort of, you know, thought that if I said something that would be over the line, it's over, I would jeopardize my career. You know, again, this was like pre-Elon buying Twitter. It feels like a completely different vibe now, which is great. Back then, though, it felt like if you said something, some sort of latent truth or something that you felt, you were even just trying to experiment with, with your ideas and experiment with different point of views.
You can lose your job and get canceled and so on. And so to me, you felt muscled. Yeah, I did. It doesn't have to do with any one particular employer to be fair. I think it was just the general vibe. I think many people felt this way. And I think that's why Ann on accounts were so potent. You're kind of removing the sort of thread vector of reputational counterattacks. People try to shut you down, which of course, now that I am doxed, I no longer have that shield, but I still stand by my values. And that's why I'm here on these podcasts. But at the time, it's funny how giving myself an anonymous account kind of opened up a whole new space of ideas that I didn't even let myself experiment with because I knew I wouldn't even be able to communicate them, right?
So freedom of speech induced freedom of thought for me. And sort of Beth was a sort of experiment in applying my thinking that I've applied to quantum computing, physics-based computing, and AI. Applying that sort of thinking in background to sort of civilization and societal systems and how we organize ourselves in culture. And really, it was supposed to start as a low-stakes experiment, you know, have a couple followers, and just put some ideas out there to see which one's a stick. But it kind of grew and kept compounding. And now we're here, I guess. But that was really nice for me because at the time, I think, I had grown my reputation in my field of study, which was quantum computing.
And it wasn't clear to me if my fans at the time would just wanted a job or something like that. It was kind of the opposite of why most people do an anonymous account, right? Maybe they just want... Well, I think eventually people just want their ideas to be evaluated on their own, right? Regardless of reputation, regardless of your background. For me, it felt like I do the analogy of new game plus when you beat the video game, you want to restart with your knowledge base and maybe some of your gear, but you're restarting the game. And so for me, it was like, can I rebuild a sort of following or reputation from scratch, right?
And uncorrelated fashion. So I would never talk about quantum computing. I'd only talk about AI. And so started it while in Google X and then I ended up leaving that and starting my own company. Now, of course, I'm my own boss more or less. So I have a lot more freedom of speech. But I think overall, people feel freer to say sort of things that were maybe taboo or off limits a couple of years ago. And I think that's healthy for everyone, embracing that sort of variance in the space of thoughts. And so, yeah, I don't know. Well, it also feels to me, I mean, try this on too. Just for my observation, Beth has a different communication style than Guillaume, I think.
So, you know, Beth is a bit more mimetic. Beth is a bit more like in your face. Beth is a bit more rhetoric, I think. And that communication style seems to have meme market fit online, at least. And I think accounts for the growth of the IAC movement so far. Like, I don't know if you were trying that personality on or that persona on. And it's just like a better communication style for the spread of ideas. But that's one observation I have from seeing Beth communicate. Yeah, I mean, like we say, we're on a mission to spread viral optimism, a sort of fuck you optimism, like unapologetic optimism about the future, right?
To fight the sort of pervasive pessimism and doom rhythm. And we will do anything we need to do in order to achieve mimetic fitness, right? Because if the, you know, if it's a sort of viral mimetic vaccine that renders people immune to sort of feeling terrible about the future and being demoralized, we have a responsibility to make it spread, right? And so if in an era of algorithmic information propagation, you can ab test what sort of packaging of your message has highest mimetic fitness. And, you know, usually that's memes. That's, you know, a tone that's sort of brush in your face. That's adversarial.
That's what gets propagated. That's what gets seen an air go, you know, that becomes, you know, that shapes people's priors because they have an information diet that is fed to them by by these algorithms. And so, yeah, I mean, it is a sort of certain communication style. I had sort of experimented with sort of similar fire brand a style in quantum computing back then, you know, I was really trying to push quantum computing towards something like deep learning, differentiable programming, right? So that's what I did at Google with so many team there is bringing sort of deep learning thinking, you know, let gradient descent program for you to to quantum computing.
And that was a sort of similar fight back then, against let's say the complexity theorists that needed hard proofs about everything, every statement rather than just, you know, letting letting letting go and letting the computer figure out how to program for you. And it feels very similar to this sort of battle against the rationalists and the EA's that want to have, you know, axioms and want you to prove that, you know, humanity will be eternal and you guarantee your safety forever. And if you can't prove that, we got to shut everything down, right? Like it's very, very, very, very similar sort of adversaries.
I've been through this drill before. So I bring that sort of sort of baggage to this new fight. So that's so, so Beth, we're already talking about adversaries, the rationalists and the EA. And so I think we need to to tee up this conversation now that we've established who we're talking to. Beth J. Zoes, the one of the founding fathers of effective, effective accelerationism. So let let me just throw some context for bankless listeners. And for you, Beth, as we get in this episode of what we're hoping to achieve in this and the reason for this episode. So about a year ago, like almost a year ago to the day that we are recording, we did an episode with a gentleman by the name of Ellie Ezer Yukowski.
I don't know if you know, at all, or if run across him in your travels. So we thought, David and I thought in our, we're innocent days that we were going to have a nice conversation with Ellie Ezer Yukowski about the interplay between AI and crypto. And it turned out that was not the conversation destiny hadn't store for us. It turned out, we got stuck. Yeah, we got stuck somewhere. And we were going to end that episode in a full-blown existential crisis about this thing. I didn't know as much about as I feel like I know today, but yet I'm still kind of like wondering how much I really know that is AI safety.
And Ellie Ezer offered a compelling argument for basically why we titled the episode, why AI is going to kill a song because that was the distinct impression he left us with. In fact, the entire episode was a dire warning, like halt all AI progress, you know, like right now, you know, go go be with your loved ones, kiss your children goodbye because we're not going to make it and follow that advice. It's never bad advice to go tell the people in your life you love him. And so we're having you on partially, Beth, because you stand on pretty much the opposite side of that argument, I think. And not only do you not think that AI is going to kill us, you think it's going to be great.
Like maybe usher us into a utopia. Okay, so this is not like he was right. In some, you I think are saying Ellie Ezer is dead wrong. In fact, it's the complete opposite. And we should accelerate progress on AI completely across the board. And so a bankless is a technology podcast, but very specific in the crypto community. And I want to give you the chance to explain your side of the argument. I want to give you a chance to pitch effective acceleration as an EAC to the crypto audience. And just like Pellus, that straight up Pellus, like give us the gospel of EAC, Beth. Getting right into it. Yeah, I mean, um, you know, yeah, that that that Yodkowski podcast really, really was, uh, I think to start for you all to get into the sort of, uh, the sort of area.
Did you did it tome across your feed? It definitely did. It definitely did. Um, I think like this sort of, yeah, do mongering or fear mongering has been really nefarious. Like it's really affected people psychologically, right? I mean, but yeah, and yet like, you know, they thought GPT 2 was going to kill us all GPT 3 where GPT 4 4.5 soon. Yeah, we're still here, right? The economy hasn't collapsed. Everything's fine. The crypto bags are still, you know, they're they're doing all right. They're doing all right these days. But these are the last days, maybe, Beth. That's what Ellie used to say is like enjoy the last days.
No, I think that, um, that's the thing about having a system that is, uh, malleable and adaptive, even if you have new technologies that are progressively rolled out, it just morphs and absorbs that capability, uh, and provide it and creates utility out of those those new technological capabilities. And, and really, EAC is about trying to understand where do we come from and where are we going, right? What is the process? What is the process that gave rise to life? What is the process that gave rise to civilization? What is the sort of this weird, you know, clearly something's going on, right?
Like when we were maybe, you know, children, you know, we had like massive computers that were exponentially worse than the ones we're using to converse today. Some things going on, there's a sort of evolutionary process in the space of technologies and the space of ideas. Uh, you know, what is this machine? What is this process that's always, um, uh, morphing and adapting, uh, civilization and the technologies around us and, and really EAC, at first and foremost, is trying to understand this process. How does it work? How did it get us here? Why is it good? And, and then how do we accelerate it?
Right? And, you know, that's what we call, you know, acceleration or, or techno-capital acceleration or more generally homo-techno-capital mimetic acceleration. So it's like all the things, right? Um, essentially, we think that, um, this process of searching over the space of parameters or bits of information and how we organize ourselves culturally in terms of, uh, uh, genetics of humans, in terms of the space of technologies, in terms of how to organize companies, nations, et cetera. It's all one big search process and competition induces a sort of evolutionarily, evolutionary selective pressure on the space of, of all these things.
And that sort of competition breeds fitness that then, uh, benefits us all, right? Like in a sense, like we've tried, we've tried capitalism and freedom versus sort of authoritarianism, uh, uh, or communism, where everything's top-down prescribed prices are essentially controlled. So far free markets have been far more successful at creating wonderful things, such as the technologies we used to chat with today and the system we live in today. And overall, um, such systems where you have many more freedoms, you find much better optima, uh, in terms of, again, technologies we still live your life, um, and just about everything.
Um, but it's, um, I think, I think it's too broad of a question, like just pill me on eac. Um, I think like let's, let's just, let's go through what, how you feel about humorism and it's just, let's just pick it apart really. Let's just pick it apart. Yeah. Uh, I kind of want to do one more thing for us just to kind of frame this conversation. One of the, um, maybe disarming things about the conversation that we had with Eliezer Yudkowski that maybe like me and Ron just weren't ready for is that Eliezer's arguments were extremely technical. They went down to the basement on like how AI works.
He was using phrases called like gradient descent and, uh, you know, reward mechanisms and it all got like outside of our frame of expertise very quickly because he was like down at the basement level and he was making like this kind of logical argument that like me and Ryan were just like weren't ready to like fully unpack because he got really, really technical. And this, um, this conversation, this eac versus diesel, people can approach this conversation at like varying, uh, like, um, heights, like some people I think, uh, Mark and Drieson wrote the techno optimist manifesto talking about this at a very high level.
And then we went and me and Ryan did a number of episodes about AI safety. And each one of those conversations were like somewhere up and down in the very technical to very philosophical conversation. I'm wondering where you see your innovation with this conversation. You run an AI startup, so you're pretty technical, but you're also, um, just in your response, just now it's a pretty philosophical, directional like approaches. Where would you say you, you would like to innovate in this conversation? Yeah, I mean, whatever you think is more appropriate for your audience, for me, it's always difficult to, to adjust my level of, of, uh, technicality.
I tend to converse pretty technically, you know, I was a theoretical physicist and then now I run an AI startup. Um, usually I have very sort of mathematics first thinking, trying to explain my thinking. And I have to, uh, convert that into, uh, English to some extent. Um, and so, you know, if, if there's any words I say or anything like that that you want to dig in, like, let's dig in. But I would say, I would say the, uh, it is not very technical actually. Um, and that if, if you start digging into his technical knowledge, it's, it's, it's quite, it's actually lacking quite a bit, right? I mean, this sort of, um, you know, this sort of recur, this notion of recursive self-improvement, I guess that, you know, the runaway food, maybe we can, we can address, right?
Like, um, recursive self-improvement is something we've tried in, in machine learning for a very long time. It's called meta learning, right? You, you have a system that learns how to accelerate the learning and you have also architecture search algorithms. The reality is that the, the larger the space over which you search, the exponentially harder things become, it becomes to find the true optimum, right? And so what that means is that if we, task an AI to improve AI, it's, it's, it's, it's exponentially more complicated. Every level of like an AI that improves an AI that improves an AI, you go, right?
Um, and so it's going to take exponentially more compute, uh, and energy, right? Uh, to achieve that optimum, right? And so, in a sense, there's a sort of, there's already a soft cap on compute in terms of the energetic and capital costs of, of compute, and that keeps us safe, right? And it, in, in a sense, like, everything, everything in, in, in, in our civilization, even every life form is trying to fool. Everything is trying to grow, and that is the thesis of, of EAC and, but that, because everything is trying to grow and competing with one another for resources, we yield, we, we get, uh, better optimum, but it also keeps everything in check.
There's not one sort of singleton, you know, a biological, uh, uh, uh, system or one single company or one single nation that takes over the whole system, right? Uh, and because they're, they're, they're, competing with one another. And, and in general, to find sort of, uh, optimum of high fitness, for example, you know, if you're, if you're building a company, a company is almost like, at least in the startup space, you know, at the seed around your, your basic search algorithm, you're searching over the space of technologies and you're burning capital and intellectual compute and, and maybe, uh, actual GPU compute to find sort of, to pinpoint exactly what product you got to build.
That's a couple bits of information, but that's costly. That's a costly thing to find. So every optimum that is high fitness is very costly to find and the more optimal it is, often it's exponentially costlier to find, uh, that optimum. And so that keeps us safe in the sense that I can pretty confidently say we're not just a small edit distance, like this one weird trick, we're like, now we have super AGI that fooms and creates gray goo and takes over the world. Like that's, that's like, very exponentially unlikely, uh, that, that, that, that, that is the case. You can't guarantee it, right? You can't guarantee that there's not one weird hack.
But from what we've seen so far, it's taken billions of years to get where we are now with, uh, life and intelligence as we know it. And it's been a very long sort of process of ex, of, of improvement, uh, to this point. Um, but there should, there won't be a sort of hyperbolic discontinuity in the rate in which things improve. And in general, we, we take the opposite camp like this sort of rate of self improvement of everything is actually really important. And it's what, um, uh, creates, uh, everything we enjoy, uh, and we should, uh, seek to, to, to keep that process growing and scale it, right?
Um, really like systems in nature, uh, either get busy growing or they get busy dying, right? Uh, and so they either secure more resources, secure more free energy and figure out cleverer ways to utilize it in order to, to, to, to, to grow or they try to stagnate, they run out of fuel and then they die. That is it. Everything runs on some type of fuel. Nothing is forever. No bit of information is forever to maintain its coherence. It costs energy because everything wants to decoher. Naturally, everything wants to sort of, you know, it's, it's a constant fight against entropy. And so the, the thesis of IAC is the one golden metric to some extent that measures the progress of the whole system is sort of free energy.
How much energy are we, uh, acquiring and consuming as civilization? Because that's a metric of our progress that can't be gained, right? If you, if you, and, and this will resonate with you guys, but if you measure it in US dollars, that's not, that's not objective scale, right? Uh, you know, uh, that's, that's not a scale that that's a scale that you can, you can play with. You can, uh, you know, and inflate thing, you can have inflation, uh, you can, you can print money and, and, and then it seems like you have some progress, but really, really, you want the other, the wrong way. Whereas something objective like energy is a good metric to measure progress.
And we think that, um, scaling up civilization and, and, and doing so with urgency is how we, uh, ensure it's sort of long term success and existence. Uh, and I think that the, one of the most dangerous things we could do is let this mindset of doom and demoralization, uh, become superstitious, right? If you focus on doom, you focus on, on, on, on dark, darker futures, um, well, first of all, you stop building, you stop helping, having children, you stop hoping for better things in the future, it sort of becomes a self-fulfilling prophecy. And that's how civilizations and empires, uh, die. And, and that will cause massive pain.
And so we're on a mission to spread sort of optimism that is superstitious in the sense, yes, we can do it. We can build better things. We could build a better future. We can leverage AI to build a better future. We want to cure diseases, to tackle climate change, to unlock nuclear fusion, nuclear energy, massive prosperity. We have all this upside on the table. And the longer we wait, uh, the longer we wait, uh, the lower likelihood we can achieve it. And we, we have urgency to make it happen. And, and that's very similar to a mindset you have in startups in Silicon Valley, right? The most successful startups are very optimistic and, and they believe they can do something that seems like unimaginable at the beginning of the company, but then they do it.
And it just keeps happening, right? And this is sort of superstitious optimism, uh, effect. And that's the sort of mentality we're trying to scale to the world, uh, with YACC. And it's why we think that doomerism and pessimism is, is really dangerous and needs to be fought somewhat aggressively, right? Because, because that is actually the source of doom, not some sort of fictitious, uh, artificial superintelligence from sci-fi. It's not backed by science, right? Um, you know, I've worked on AI for material generation, protein folding, biochemistry, chemistry, all like AI for the physical world.
It's much harder than people think, right? The physical world is really hard. And one of the best, uh, things that designing things in the physical world is life itself, but you could see life itself as a big optimization algorithm that is trying to fume. Every life form is trying to fume. And yet nothing has fumes, right? So that should give you a bit more peace. And you, you, you can breathe, um, and but we're happy to go into any sort of argument, like any sticking points you have about, uh, yes, argument. One thing you've mentioned a couple times is this word fume. Could you define that really quick for people?
Yeah. I mean, you know, well, how, how do you understand fume? Like from your interview with YAD, um, how would you explain it? You know, I think you're using it in a very general sense, which I think, um, I, I wish I appreciate because it kind of, uh, gets down to the bare metal of kind of how life works. Like life is interested in life. Like life is interested in propagating fume in the AI sense is main is mostly talking about that, uh, super intelligence explosion where AI just takes over everything and it solves it's just like this one single event and all of a sudden the whole world is AI and it's run by AI's for AI's, um, trees want to plant more trees, you know, uh, bugs want there to be more bugs and once more ants humans want more humans, uh, and I think this is it's all trying to hit some sort of like, um, uh, point in a curve which like once the ball starts rolling, it starts rolling faster and faster and faster and all of a sudden we have like a population explosion.
Uh, it doesn't matter what kind of life form you are, but like everything is trying to look for that like growth in population. That is something that's fundamental about life. And so you're using it in a general sense where it's just like, hey, any system that any system whatsoever that's propagating is trying to find more energy because that's how it can propagate even more. And this is, this is the playing field that just the universe exists on. And I think that this is how you're using it. It's every, every system and subsystem whether it's a company, a group of people, a culture, uh, like you said, bugs, trees, whatever, um, even nation states, uh, everything is self organizing self adapting.
It's inner workings in order to grow. And by construction, things that are not optimizing themselves to grow, run out of fuel and they fade. And that's it, right? And so if you think about, if you think in the future, which culture, which, um, like if you think of like several nations in the future, which nations will have survived and what culture would they have, right? Well, they would probably have an EAC culture that is literally by construction trying to figure out what is the often way way to organize ourselves in order to grow. And the sort of pessimistic, humoristic, uh, cultures will have faded because they'll have destroyed themselves.
This kind of reminds me by the way of an episode we did with, uh, Robin Hanson about like his theory for obviously, uh, aliens is basically that it's for one, it's too early, but like we will see them and the ones we will see are not the quiet aliens that stick to their home, home planet, not the, the diesel aliens. We'll see the EAC aliens, the grabby aliens that go and they, like consume their solar system, they consume their galaxy, and then there are multi-galaxy, uh, type of, um, like the grabby ones are the ones that are effectively going to fume and win. Yeah. Well, it's the same with like, um, you know, variants of a virus, right?
It's the ones that have higher replicability that you get statistically, right? You don't see like earlier variants that are lower fitness, right? Um, and it's like everything, everything, every bit of information is getting selected for in terms of, does it confer the organism, uh, of which it's part of, uh, an ability to grow, right? Um, like your, your genetics, it's like, does this piece of the genetic code give you higher fitness? Does it, you know, uh, uh, make you have more offspring? And then that piece of code, uh, genetic code is higher likelihood in the future, right? But it's like applying that sort of evolutionary thinking to everything, including culture, including waste organizer companies, including, you can think of, you know, that sort of thinking even applied to crypto, right?
Which, which sort of, uh, uh, coins have the best sort of mimetic, uh, fitness in the long term. Bitcoin maximalism is the Bitcoin fumes. They think Bitcoin is going to fume. Well, I don't know about that. What I do like about Bitcoin is that, uh, it is proof of work. And so it is anchored to sort of physics and energy consumption. And, you know, I'm not necessarily a Bitcoin maximalist, but I am a sort of energy maximalist. I think that is the, the rate metric to, to, to pin things with respect to, yeah. I want to, um, provides the way that I see the structure of this conversation that you have like a very like, um, basement, first principles, uh, grounding in your arguments.
And I thought is like what I would consider like, you know, the very, the depth of where some of this belief structure comes from. Uh, but we've watched, uh, and we've watched a lot of this, um, these conversations permeate throughout like Silicon Valley. And then also make its way into like capital hill, where some of these like very first principle arguments are inspiring or being argued against as like political stances about the direction for society at large. So it kind of goes back to just like, we have some beliefs. We have a structure of thought. Um, it's very, it can't get very technical and granular in their base principle arguments.
But then as this conversation progresses and Ryan's going to take us into the next phase here, it really can inspire like a political belief, uh, like a direction, a proposed direction for humanity. And so this is kind of what you, why Ryan kind of illustrated this is like, you're, you're inspiring like a movement, like a political movement of, um, not necessarily a party because that's too structured, but just like a set of beliefs for how we ought to live as a, uh, as humanity as a species. Is this how, this is how you see it? Yeah. I mean, hopefully, hopefully it does affect, uh, politics, right?
It's like, are the ways we, we've been organizing ourselves the ways we've been legislating have been pretty far from optimal. And we should think from a first principle standpoint, you know, what is, how do we organize, uh, sort of a hierarchy of cybernetic control in our civilization? And this is a very deep concept. So how, how do we, you know, in a sense, like, it's very similar to crypto, many layers of a protocol, right? You have sort of, you, you check, you, you, you chunk blocks and then you have different layers that check at different, uh, scales, right? Um, and, and, and base layers have a slower clock rate and the, the, the, the roll up, uh, larger amounts of, of, of, uh, actions or transactions.
Um, it's, it's very similar to having a hierarchy of sort of legislation at the local, you know, provincial or state level and the national level and the international level, right? As you go up the hierarchy, you should have a slower feedback loop and it should be lighter and lighter touch in terms of its, its ability to control things. And I, you know, the goal with EAC is to start a discussion of like, how do, how should we balance things? Because, you know, one side of the aisle wants everyone to be hands off, one side of the aisle wants like absolute total control and the hands of a few.
Uh, and, and both of those things are not optimal, right? There's a spectrum in between and, and we should search over that spectrum. Um, it's, and it's, it's very relevant to the centralization versus decentralization question and crypto, uh, for protocols. I think, I think they're, they're the same question, whether it's in, in politics versus crypto, like, is a system that is, uh, like totally decentralized and greedy, optimal versus one that is centralized versus one that is hierarchical. I, I think it's the, I think it's the ladder and maybe we can, we can get into that. But hopefully that does inspire conversations on Capitol Hill, um, and NDC about, uh, where to take policy and legislation.
Yeah, I think it's really important. I think that this, uh, EAC, um, or do we accelerate or do we do accelerate is, is probably one of the most important conversations that society is, is having. And like, yeah, to me, one question I was going to have for you, Beth, is like, is the act of, is it a philosophy? Is it like a movement? Uh, is this like a social revolution? Is it a religion of some sorts? Is it like this amorphous thing like crypto where it's like a grad bag of all of the above? What's your take on this? I think it's all of the above to some extent, right? I mean, for me, it's, you know, it's almost like religious, like belief, just because it's like, I can get into that.
But, um, you know, and, and for some, it is, um, for some, it's a, you know, it's a community of, of like, mind an individual that are optimistic about the future and trying to help each other and, and, and, and want to build to this better future and collaborate. And, you know, for some, it's sort of, um, a political or ideological movement of how we should legislate things or how we should run things. Um, and for some, it's just, I don't know, inspirational, um, gets them fired up to, to build more. So I very much want to get, um, the ways, like, your take on why this is like a, a religion, how it sort of explains, like, big questions, like, why are we here?
What is the universe? This sort of thing. But before we do, I just got to tie off this, Ellie's or existential crisis type thing. So we talked about fume, we sort of defined it. You think it's very unlikely that, uh, AI's, um, sort of like destroy humanity or, uh, you know, accidentally or, you know, they literally go to, to war with us or, or something like that. Um, but, but I want to maybe ask like, so David said that it was difficult to, to follow the Ellie's, your conversation because it was technical. I actually think it was less that for me, anyway, personally, it was more because the premise was so simple.
We've seen dangerous technologies in the past, uh, anybody, bankless listener, watch the Oppenheimer movie recently. No, the whole movie is about this, like, chain of events where the scientific community discovers some dangerous technology, essentially. And what, like, this chain of events that could lead to global Armageddon and the ending of humanity. And so now we're at the, the precipice of this new discovery, wherein like these times where, oh my god, you can talk to a computer and it's past the Turing test. And it sounds like a real person. And this is amazing. It generates art. Like, we've never seen before.
And we are all wondering whether this is one of those technologies that has the potential to destroy everything. And like, it's very, it's very, you know, seductive, I think, really easier to be like, yeah, imagine if, um, you know, we split an atom with kind of, like everybody could do that in their microwave, let's say. And imagine that was like given that kind of level of power and technology was given to every human being. We democratize it in that way. Well, what would happen? Probably be the end of life as we know it. And so like, I, I still have this base question of Beth of whether AI is like dangerous or not.
Is it similar to nuclear weapons? Is it similar to, um, you know, biological pandemics that somebody could cook up in their basement? Or is it different somehow? Because I feel like a lot of this conversation hinges upon that question. I mean, you were advocating an EAC for, for growth, right? Versus degrowth. And I sort of understand that everybody wants growth over, uh, de, degrowth, deacceleration is my thing. But I think another framing that people like Ellie Ezer might have is its growth versus safety. Like, Beth, you were going all gas. No breaks here. Like, we're worried. What if this technology is dangerous?
What's your take on this? Yeah. So the analogy, I think, you know, if everybody could split the atom in their microwave, we'd have quite quite a bit more energy being produced on the grid. And that would be net positive. I think like, you know, runaway effects of like, if you have a chain reaction that becomes a bomb, of course, that's bad. But obviously, it seems to be like, you know, creating a nuclear weapon is very involved. And not everybody has access to it. And the thing with nuclear weapons is it's pure downside, right? Like the only utility to nuclear weapons is like, you know, damaging your enemy.
And it's like a deterrent, right? Whereas AI, there's huge, huge, huge, huge upside to creating AI and leveraging AI and everything we do gives us intellectual and operational leverage. It helps, you know, create economic value to help solve all our problems. It helps us live better lives. It's going to save lives, right? And medicine, right? It's going to make things cheaper. It's going to help us build cheap housing. It's going to help us, you know, save on legal bills that are, you know, ballooning, right? You're going to have LM lawyers. You're going to have LM doctors. Everybody on the planet is going to have access to some of the best doctors ever.
You're going to have personalized medicine, right? Like, um, the list goes on. Like a lot of our problems that are pain points in our modern society will be solved with cheaper intelligence. And there is an urgency to make that happen similar to how, um, let's say fear mongering about nuclear weapons. I actually kind of killed the nuclear fission energy industry, right? Now it's over-regulated to oblivion. There's so much red tape, like, you know, most of your budget building a nuclear reactor is towards compliance. And, and that's suppressed the advent of, and, and ubiquity of this technology.
And it's caused us to have to go to all sorts of wars all over the place for, for energy, right? So, so, so this mind virus of anti-nuclear was actually, uh, net detrimental. And we're, we're kind of like, waltzing into a similar scenario with AI. If we over-regulated in the room, we're not going to see the massive upsides to it. Um, I don't, I, I think that what's dangerous with AI, and we're very transparent about this, uh, you know, AI is, information is power, intelligence allows you to extract more utility out of less information. And so it is, it is, give, it confers you power, right? And if you have a big, uh, delta, big difference between the capabilities of centralized entities and that of the people in terms of AI, then you have the opportunity for sort of AI-assisted tyranny.
And to us, that's the highest existential risk, because there's a very strong prior that if you give all the power to centralize party, it becomes corrupt, and then it abuses that power and oppresses people and causes mass suffering. And to us, like putting AI, which yes, it will make AI, whoever has advanced AI in their hands will become formidable. But if everybody is, you know, not equally formidable, but, you know, in a similar range, then no one party is going to have too much power of the other and, and, and going to dominate, completely dominate the other, right? It's just sort of adversarily equilibrium.
And that is sort of what we're advocating for with EAC is sort of freedom of access to compute, freedom of access to AI, right? We don't want these centralized entities, just like a central bank, like inflating away your money to control access to advanced AI. We want it in the hands of many, because otherwise, you know, the centralized parties are going to abuse their power. And so, to me, I think that, you know, yes, AI is potent. If you only focus on tail risks, you can convince yourself to kill anything in the womb. But there's also massive upside that shouldn't be discounted, and there's not enough, we don't talk enough about the massive upside we're leaving on the table.
And the reality is that most likely what will happen is that some nations or, or some cultures will, will embrace AI, some will want to ban AI. Those that ban AI are going to be left behind and massively disadvantaged. And those that embrace it are going to be economically prosperous, will outgrow those that have banned it. And so you want to be in the fork, right? Just similar to the crypto fork. You want to be in the cultural fork that embraces AI and integrates it into their lives, into society, and leverages it to become formidable and grow, right? And they're always forward to, you know, leverage AI and merge with it.
I mean, we're already, you know, we're using like smart watches and smartphones and Apple Vision Pro, you know, is going viral. We're already augmenting ourselves, the notion of human, you know, of a human individual is getting sort of diluted or eroded. We already leverage exogenous sources of intelligence, right? We use Google search, proplexity, whatnot all day every day. And I think that just focusing on like, oh no, humans will be left behind. It's like, no, but like the notion of human will drift and compass a human and maybe they're, they're fleet of AI's that, that do, do their bidding.
And then you become of this sort of formidable being. And that's the sort of awesome future we want to have where your quasi immortal, you have like, you know, AI customizing your, your, your, your, your biology, and you have sort of AI augmentations in every way possible. And, and, and I think that sort of optimistic future, we got to paint the picture of that future, rather than painting the picture of the doomer future, we're like, AI takes over, which again, I don't know how it would do that if, if there's other powerful AI's keeping it at check from, from parties that aren't necessarily aligned with that party.
And again, I, I don't believe in sort of fast takeoff in AI. I think it's not well founded. And so like if, if you don't necessarily think that, you know, the likelihood of this fully existential doom is high from like just pure ASI, then, then the biggest threat vector becomes sort of authoritarianism sort of censorship, right? If, if you only have AI in the hands of a few and they use it for information control and cultural control, then they can basically sigh up you and control you, right? And, and that is very dangerous because if only a few parties that are, you know, government, back cartel, control, all M's and they become our sources of truth, then they control you.
And they can like use that to consolidate their control and consolidate their power. And now we live in a sort of dark age where we don't have open access to knowledge, we don't have open access to compute and we can't, we can't fight this sort of top down control with AI with our own AI's that would help us filter and counter sort of this psychological manipulation. And so that's the dark future we're trying to avoid. So getting AI in the hands of many and to every org and accelerating makes it very hard to sort of send acceleration is a hedge against sort of top down control and maybe a centralized party taking over killing variants, killing like you can only, you know, use AI this way and taking control of the whole technology because that that would be the bad future we're trying to avoid.
Anyways, so we, we kind of have our own existential risks, right? Like we think like authoritarianism and centralized control is sort of that's the that's the bad scenario. It's based on like data from history, right? There's a lot of bad things that have happened historically when that happens versus sort of sci-fi-based priors of like I read too many books on the Terminator, I read too many 90s sci-fi books about nanotechnology. And you know, I think like AI is going to figure out how to, you know, turn us into Gregoo, which not plausible. So basically you think like P Doom is kind of like a failed kind of calculation.
What we should be doing is P utopia, right? And then also like the risk on the wrist side, it's like probability of totalitarianism. So like let's let's do that calculation too. Yeah, P 1984, right? P 1984. Okay, so, so I think we're starting to understand the contours of YAC and like where you're coming from. So it's pro-growth. It's definitely tecto-optimism, right? I certainly love the picture you're painting about kind of like the possibilities here. It's much more cheering optimistic than sort of the the AI Doomer takes that I've heard so far. I want to get back to kind of the ways YAC is like a religion to you.
And I don't want to interpret too much into that. I'm sure there are many ways that it's not like a religion, but talk about kind of the basement level because I know you are, you know, I have been as a physicist and you know, throughout childhood, I've heard other conversations with you. You've been always in search for like what's the the basement level of this whole experience that we're having right now in the universe and like why does all of this matter? What conclusions have you come to? And how does that relate to YAC? Maybe how does YAC even explain some of these things? Yeah, I mean, it's it's been a journey throughout life to try to understand or place in the universe, right?
That led me to theoretical physics, trying to understand the very small, the quantum mechanical and the very big, the cosmos. So I was a quantum cosmologist at some point. I also worked on sort of black hole physics, which are kind of the edges, different edge of the universe, right? And there I was trying to understand, you know, where do we come from? Where are we here? By looking at sort of the very big and the very small, and I kind of missed the middle part, right? And in a sense, after some time, I realized that a lot of the beauty and complexity and good things in the world came from sort of emergence and self-organization.
Basically, instead of looking at quantum physics or what is called general relativity, so gravity, which are the mostly physics of the very small and the very big, I need to look at thermodynamics, the physics of the middle were out of equilibrium thermodynamics, the physics of life, the physics of self-organizing complex systems, because that's what created us, that's what created a lot of civilization, technologies we see today, and that's what induces this sort of selective pressure on the space of everything. And that sort of principle is very deep. And so, you know, having gone through theoretical physics, and eventually discovered that sort of complexity and self-organization is where a lot of the answers are, that's what led me to sort of look at EOC, a sort of like, hey, like thermodynamics helped create, well, it explains why we have life at all, right, how do we get here, it explains evolution, it's upstream evolution, it's upstream of, you know, market pressures, selective pressures, it's kind of like this generalized law that creates everything we know, right, that is relevant to us in our day-to-day life, right, like what is Andromeda going to do in like two billion years, not that relevant day, right, what is, you know, so, so, so I think like, to me, EOC is almost religion, because it's like, okay, we are part of this process, the self-adaptive process of, you know, life, memes, information, technologies, civilization, and this whole system seeks to grow.
We are a very special phase of matter that is very unlikely in our universe, and we have a sort of responsibility to cherish it and allow it to grow in order to be robust to sort of erasure or fluctuations, right, like an asteroid, right, and so, you know, it's very elonian in the sense of like, you know, it has very high inner product with the quest to increase the scope and scale of civilization, consciousness. Is it elonian? Is that like, of drives? I just made that up, but the point is we're very aligned with that, with that mission, and it gives you crazy amount of purpose day-to-day, like what is the point of a religion?
A religion is like, for a lot of people practically, it is a cultural heuristic that if it has stuck around for a long time, it has been post-elected for in terms of conferring its adherence, like, a sort of advantage, right, because by construction, it has grown, it has propagated this far, this long, right, and so, it's like ways to live your life. It's like prescriptions, right, to me, they're like cultural parameters similar to how, like, you have in a neural net, you spend a lot of time training and finding the optimal parameters, and then you run inference, you just run at the optimal parameters.
To me, religions are like pre-trained models of how to live your life, right? They're like, prescribed parameters, and then you can just run inference. You think EAC kind of like prescribes how to live your life. Actually, it gives you some meaning. It's basically, basically, the meaning is growth. The meaning is propagation. The meaning is like pushing humanity to the stars, to the frontier. These are some of the meanings you drive from this. So, to me, EAC is more like the meta-learner or the optimizer, right? We're not prescribing any one particular way to live your life. It's like, but any sort of prescription that you may posit will be what we're saying is it's going to be post-selected for according to this sort of fitness function.
So, you should select for subcultures that give you an advantage in this growth, right? If you want to be part of the future. But really, it's a search process for what yields higher growth, and it's always, always changing. It's not one way to live your life right now. There's not one set of optimal policy parameters that you can just run forever. It's like, let's collectively figure out the heuristics of how to organize ourselves and how to live our lives, how to run the world, such that we grow sustainably, fall-tolerantly towards, yes, a galactic civilization. Beth, one set of dots that may not have been connected for folks.
I sort of connected them a little bit as you were speaking, but because I've heard you speak in the past, and I've read many of your articles where you've written things like this on your Twitter timeline. How does thermodynamics explain life? Why is that an underlying process in the universe that is relevant to what we're talking about? Pro-AI growth? Yeah, that's a really deep question. And to me, I've made it quite a career pivot. I went from being someone in quantum computing, so trying to harness quantum mechanics of the world to make computing devices and make computing devices that understand the quantum mechanical world around us, that is what I did in quantum machine learning.
Now, after the realization that the most interesting part is in the middle, it's in thermodynamics. Now, I'm doing thermodynamic computing where I'm harnessing out of equilibrium thermodynamics to engineer self-organizing devices that are kind of lifelike, but they do machine learning as a thermodynamic physical process. But once you understand these principles enough to engineer systems that enact them, you start seeing that pattern everywhere. And I wrote the EAC Physics manifesto at the same time as I found it in my company. So for me, it's just because my mind is swimming in it. But yeah, why does life, why did thermodynamics give rise to life?
I'm an aderent of a theory by Jeremy Inglin, former MIT professor. If you want to read his book, every life is on fire. And his lectures are great on this. But essentially, what you can show, it's just from the laws of probability, really, and it's a generalized notion of the second law of thermodynamics, where it shows that paths, if you think of your trajectory across time, of you have a certain system, you have states over time, and you have a trajectory, trajectories that have dissipated more heat along the trajectory are exponentially more likely from the laws of physics. That's pretty nuts.
And so there's theorems, they're complicated names, but check out the work by Jeremy Inglin on the thermodynamic dissipative adaptation. Basically, it posits that systems in nature, or really any system, any system that is in the physical world, will self-adapt in order to maximize the dissipation of for energy. So that includes figuring out how to capture more for energy to dissipate it. So life-like systems are always adapting, how can I secure more fuel? How can I use it more efficiently? So I could budge in my fuel to get more fuel and keep growing. And you get, as a byproduct, you get evolution because systems that have adapted their genetics in order to replicate more, well, if you replicate more, you burn more fuel as a whole system.
And so you're more likely. So human complexity exists to burn a fuel faster for the universe to. The whole civilization is a fancy fire, right? But we're a very clever fire. We're like an energy seeking fire, right? But yeah, that is what gave rise to us. Is it correct to define life if we're used, if this is like the idea that life is whatever system finds a way to dissipate more heat, and that, and so part of that definition, like you said, it includes collecting energy. So like reversing entropy. First, like creating order, creating systems, creating structure, in order to produce more heat exhaust, which is, and that is what life is.
That is what all thermodynamic systems are. But life is like a very special version of that. People are out of that. I think, yeah, I think people are trying to, well, you know, is a virus life, right? You know, is, is it on the spectrum? Is it AI that, you know, it's always adapting its architecture to be of economic utility to us? And if it's of high economic utility, then we run it on GPUs, we give it budget to, and we burn heat to keep it alive, right? Is it alive? Right? So I think like we can't even, it's hard to define intelligence formally, it's hard to define life formally. And so I'm just like, what's the base layer?
It's just thermodynamics and probability and information, right? I used to work in theoretical physics where we're trying to understand the theory of everything, everything in the universe through the lens of information theory. It was the it from bit or it from cubit school thought, right? It's it's it's seeing the whole universe as a big computer, right? And so sort of I see a lot of civilization as a big thermodynamic computer in a sense. So the universe is kind of like sharing humanity on and the complexity of life on and particularly like I guess the civilization that we built, because like we've become really, really good at like burning energy.
Yes. Yes, like the universe is on our side and we've been doing so good so far, we got to keep going, right? And feeling that like, wait, the universe is on our side, like the the the game is rigged in our favor. That's such a potent realization. And that gives you like really powerful optimism about the future. It's just like actually awesome futures are exponentially more likely in dark futures or just small fluctuations on the road to these much higher likelihood large scale futures. And so yeah, I mean, that's that's why I'm an optimist. I just looked at the equations and saw actually these equations explain a lot of our world and a lot of where we came from and you can apply them at the system at a large scale.
So you're all about like you're yeah, I can your school of thought that is all about like burning more energy harnessing more energy faster basically. That's why there's this like I've not fully understood it before, but there's this kind of like desire to become to rise up the Kardashev scale, right? Yeah. And to become like a type two civilization and then maybe a type three civilization, right? My understanding is Kardashev scale is like type one civilization marshals all of the the resources of its home planet, right? So that would be everything on earth, humanity is able to marshal that and energy potential.
And then it's type two, it's local star. So we'd marshal the power of the sun like Dyson Sphere and then type three is kind of the galaxy. And you're all about rising up and like harnessing more energy for productive purposes. That's kind of like your utility function. That's what that's what YAC is trying to maximize. And to be clear, it's not like we don't want to just burn energy like the point is like it's the integral or the sum of how much energy we're burning on a near infinite time horizon, right? So if we figure out clever ways to utilize energy such that we can grow further that's better, right?
It's not like because some people don't necessarily understand it and they're like, oh, what if you just blew up the whole planet? That's a lot of energy, you know, it's like yeah, but then we're not gonna, you know, burn the energy of other planets because we're going to be dead, right? You don't want that, right? So we're pro life in like the most fundamental way possible and we think it's like a very precious state of matter. It's like we're very precious form of fire and we have a duty to sort of let it grow and scope and scale. You're just you're just very very pro long-term energy burning.
So that means sort of like or not burning I shouldn't say harnessing and so that means you you'd naturally be pro life because if you kill the system that is like growing to like to harness more and more energy than these basically it's it's all gone. And like I want to contrast this with what I think is like a different form of utility maximum maximization function because like the the measure of this how much energy are we burning is kind of like I would say new and different maybe to to some listeners because like a lot of philosophies or schools of thought are much more along the curve of utility maximization of like human happiness or like human meaning or like you know heat ons right hedonism basically and that's not what you're saying right like is that do you care at all about maximizing human happiness along the way or is it just all about the energy consumption because there's an element beth where I hear if it's just about energy it almost sounds like a bit like machine like it almost sounds a bit like extractive I think to people and like but are people happy are we happy along the way can you talk about that yeah so you know it's similar to like crypto it's like how do you measure market cap according to what currency right if we're if we're saying this is our a value system what what are we pinned to right what is our metric right in a sense heat ons are weird because you can just kind of like first of all it's very subjective right your newer chemistry is very suggest subjective it can be hacked by drugs or wire heading right you can scroll tick-tock all day or watch whatever you're going to watch on that apple vision pro and just sit back and roll and it's that's not a it's not a long-term optimum right so it has these furious optimum and you can also just print more units more cheap units and like game the system and so you know these EA's get caught and thought experiments like maybe we should just have a bunch of shrimp and they're very happy and then we just have tons of shrimp and we maximize their happiness we we've optimized our metric right it's like no that's not it's not gonna yield much so it's like to me it's been seeking the sort of what's the ultimate metric you know I think happiness is actually a proxy or an estimator of this sort of gradient of like how much influence do I have on future free energetic sort of expenditure right like if you if you have a intellectual legacy if you have you know positive impact on the world you feel good about it you feel happy if you if you're in meaningful relationship your brain has neurochemistry that's like approximating that you're gonna have successful progeny and you're gonna influence you know the future light cone and they're gonna have progeny and they're gonna be successful and impact the world and consume more free energy I mean all our neurochemistry in our biology has been selected for according to this principle of whatever genetic sequence whatever heuristic we have that will help us burn more free energy so it's like it's it's it's the supply chain on happiness you see there's a much stronger kind of like metric I guess and much more ungameable metric versus like something like like heat ons let's say and so do you know it would be a complete failure of our species of this whole human life experiment if we essentially were quiet the quiet aliens we reached some level of technology where we're all just kind of like we're happy with things we just strap in to our VR and we just kind of like live just a happy life in a you know I don't know in a wally life wally life in a chair somewhere maybe we're floating across the universe to you that's like total objective failure by all of your measures even though the heat ons are maybe off the charts because heat ons are fiat I'd love to establish those connections with with crypto but yeah I think at some point you know like our our happiness like we've kind of entertained ourselves to death with this generation of technologies right the past 10 12 years I don't know we we've now we're we're just obsessed with our happiness or neurochemistry and we've over optimized that but we don't feel good we don't feel deeply happy right and whereas if you're working towards something meaningful that means you're going to leave a legacy and yet you're working super hard you have some stress hormones flowing through you but you have this sort of deep happiness right like the satisfaction it's very different it's it's not a hedonism it's like it's not happiness like eudomonia or there's there's different it remains for this something that Mark Andreessen said when he came on the podcast we're asking for advice and it one of his like advice in general he's like don't see happiness seek satisfaction yes and you'll get that by finding meaning in your life you're saying that is a much more durable metric than just heat ons yes dopamine I think our brains like how how do you feel why are you feeling satisfied in future if you have a massive positive impact if you feel like the things I've done with my life will really increase the likelihood that we reach a larger scale of civilization like you feel deeply good about that and I think having everyone sort of think evaluate their lives and think what is the maximal positive impact I can have towards this and and then to go out and do it and we support each other doing it I think that's the most positive community we can have and that is the act right that's the act community and that's our sort of thinking and that increases life satisfaction massively and it makes people much more productive towards helping everyone around them right and so people mentally do a sort of sensitivity analysis like what you know for me it was like what technology can I create that's going to have the maximal positive impact on future scope and scale utilization I tried to work on faster than light travel gave up on that after some theoretical physics now I'm working on really energy efficient AI compute because I think that AI is the technology that would create other technologies and will help everything and help us accelerate up this this card of shift scale and and that brings like deep meaning that helps me plow through any sort of challenges in my way I have like an irrational level of optimism but that's the thing right and you have to you have to give up this sort of just pure reason pure logic stiff axioms you just got to like this feels right this feels like it's going towards a better future and you know it's like a hard to verbalize intuitive estimator of that and I want to live my life that way and that's great everybody's going to have their own thesis of how to live their lives and how to have a positive impact on future as long as we agree that we're all trying to optimize the same thing this foundational metric of like how much how much life generalized notion of life is there how much fire of life is there in our corner of the universe and if we can all seek to grow it then we're going to make it happen and we can do it and so and so we should mantle formerly known as bit down is the first Dow lead web three ecosystem all built on top of mantle's first core product the mantle network a brand new high performance a theorem layer to built using the OP stack but uses eigenlayers data availability solution instead of the expense of the theorem layer one not only does this reduce mantle networks gas fees by 80% but it also reduces gas fee volatility providing a more stable foundation for mantle's applications the mantle treasury is one of the biggest Dow owned treas which is seeding an ecosystem of projects from all around the web three space for mantle mantle already has subcommunities from around web three onboarded like game seven for web three gaming and buy a bit for tvl liquidity and on rounds so if you want to build on the mantle network mantle is offering a grants program that provides milestone based funding to promising projects that help expand secure and decentralized mantle if you want to get started working with the first Dow lead layer two ecosystem check out mantle at mantle dot xyz and follow them on twitter at zero x mantle you know you know swap it's the world's largest decentralized exchange with over one point four trillion dollars in trading volume you know this because we talk about it endlessly on bakeless it's uniswap but uniswap is becoming so much more uniswap labs just released the uniswap mobile wallet for iOS the newest easiest way to trade tokens on the go with a uniswap wallet you can easily create or import a new wallet buy crypto on any available exchange with your debit card with extremely low fiat on rent fees and you can seamlessly swap on main net polygon arbitrage and optimism on the uniswap mobile wall you can store and display your beautiful NFTs and you can also explore web 3 with the in-app search features market leader boards and price drives or use wallet connect to connect to any web 3 application so you can now go directly to defy with the uniswap mobile wallet safe simple custody from the most trusted team and defy download the uniswap wallet today on iOS there's a link in the show notes it's everyone's favorite season in crypto tax season and crypto tax is always an absolute headache especially for all you de-gents out there but it doesn't have to be a nightmare that's where crypto tax calculator comes in the software built for de-gents by de-gents as coin basis official global tax partner crypto tax calculator focuses on making complex transactions into easy ones supporting over 300,000 currencies across Ethereum, Arbitram, Optimism as well as a thousand other integrations as well it's as simple as connecting your wallet pulling in all your transactions and following the automated suggestions to quickly and accurately calculate your tax obligations plus for all the airdrop farmers out there crypto tax calculator has your back as they are consistently adding support for new and upcoming layer ones layer two's and all the airdrops that you're currently farming 2024 is the year where the de-gents do their crypto taxes with speed and confidence make taxes this year easy and affordable with crypto tax calculator sign up at cryptotaxcalculator.
io and get a 30% discount with code bank 30 click the link in the show notes for more information Beth can I throw an argument your way that I'm sure you've contended with I'll call this the Elizabeth Warren style of arguments I think one of your the general gist of your vibe acceleration is I've kind of taken the perspective of humanity is like a line of humans marching towards the future and you have the front of the line the the failings like the the innovators the accelerationists the entrepreneurs the inventors the scientists pushing the frontier forward like the also the billionaires right like literally Jeff Bezos for example Elon Musk hitting us to Mars putting Wi-Fi all over the world and then you have like and those are the people that are like pushing the fold there's a people increasing the quality of life for people those are people doing the acceleration things moving society forward in an accelerating rate and then you have the last 50% of humanity who's living on like six dollars and 55 cents a day on average like below the US you can below the United States poverty line and so what you're doing what you're advocating for is you're saying hey the front of humanity go faster press on the gas like keep going break away and then like the Elizabeth Warrens is like yo you guys are just forgetting about like the rest of the humans who are not able to keep up with you and that's not fair because look at all these returns on capital little actual Jeff Bezos has a bajillion dollars he doesn't need that much and Elon Musk has a bajillion dollars doesn't need that much and you guys are just not thinking about the bottom half of society who can't keep up with you and they're going to forever be succumbed to like never being able to catch up with the people who are accelerating how would you how would you respond to this perspective yeah so first of all you know like needing is a is a weird concept really like capital is a a tool to exchange value right and and and it's it's it's a way to keep track of how much value you're producing and ultimately capital allocators that are really efficient at allocating capital towards utility in our system we'll get more capital to allocate right and that is a sort of to to some extent it's like an AI algorithm right like companies that that are of high utility in the system get more capital to keep doing what they're doing and scale it up companies that do business with each other very often they're going to deepen their partnership they're going to have more economic exchange it's almost like it's almost like neurons in a brain right like there's sort of connections the strength in the more they get used and there's nodes that you know there's cells if you think of companies like neural cells like they get bigger the more nutrients if they're they're of high utility and that's very important that we have this right like if every neuron had as many connections as as the other and as many nutrients then your brain wouldn't wouldn't work right um and to me like I think I think it's hard for people to understand that entrepreneurs are really just biological neural control systems for better organisms that are corporations right you're just a control system and ownership needs to happen because it aligns your inner greedy reward function with that of the company it's just alignment right you become one with the company if you are part of the company you own part of the company um you are one you're aligned right and that's very important and that's like why we've had amazing tech companies is like these founder led companies the founders feel like they own a piece of this company is companies part of them and and so they they make the decisions that maximize its growth and their wealth is just a byproduct of this sort of ownership and alignment mechanism but but really it allows them to have massive positive impact on the world I think Elon is the most efficient the most yeah capital allocator out there up there with Jeff um because they're much more efficient at using money towards certain goals then say the government right the government does launches that cost two billion dollars and Elon I don't know it's like ten it's like tens of millions of dollars for the same launch or something like that it's going to get down to ten million dollars you're talking about a rocket launch just yeah for example rocket launch or like having massive global internet people have been talking about it for a long time but he made it happen right now uh electrifying the world you have had all these governments spend billions and billions and billions of dollars you know going these conferences having these accords and larping and then this guy just comes in and just text the crap out of it uses the techno capital machine and acceleration to actually just solve that problem right and has yielded electrification and so I think it's it's not like I think you know everyone should have enough capital and have equal access to opportunity to accelerate and be part of the acceleration but part of it is we need to educate the world about this is the machine you live in right you are a cell in this machine you can align yourself to it you can figure out ways to provide value and you will be rewarded right and if the if people understood that and and and we're allowed the agency to participate in our capitalist system and in a you know instead of as just a worker that's prescribed tasks but more as like a capital allocator and that's sort of thinking they would go much further but of course we don't want that because because we don't have artificial intelligence we need like cheap docile workers that don't understand you know their value and they're just going to execute on on orders right well this is it this would be a shared crypto value I would say it's just like one thing that attracted both David and myself to crypto as it sort of makes everyone a capital allocator it democratizes the ownership of things I I think some people get stuck on that capitalist thing particularly at this time in place but it's pretty core to the EAC movement right like what you say is you keep saying this the techno capitalist machine basically and you see capitalism as just a fantastic resource allocation algorithm essentially and like the best one that we've invented and there's there's not really great alternatives I mean like what do you do with a class of problems that we've called before like mollock traps basically like you know prisoner dilemma types of problems the problem of overfishing let's say or arms races or you know like growth that causes negative externalities let's say like you know issues with the environment right that that kind of thing I mean there is another way of thinking about this where if we say there's growth and there's degrowth and growth equals good and degrowth equals bad right but like cancer is a growth too and like is there the case that we could have growth that actually causes harm and negative externalities to to the system I mean can we go overboard on growth if we just focus on this energy output you know maximum on a long time scale right like a cancer is suboptimal right it kills the the host being and then it or it reduces its likelihood of burning energy in the future so it gets post-elected against right like I mean there's an evolutionary selective pressure against getting cancer you know within the first couple years of life right and so similarly like if if at the broader organism level right we have a sort of selective pressure on the space of actions and companies and products that steer them towards things that have high utility on a long time scale then you know these sort of short-term problems where we screw up and then we correct things like those things are like small setbacks in the grand scheme of things and it's not worth throwing out the whole system to avoid those those those sort of setbacks right where really the the main problem comes back to this concept of sort of hierarchical cybernetic control right like if you have pure free markets you have a fully decentralized system right like everything is is greedy in space and time it's it's optimizing for its own profits its own growth right and here you're talking about sort of delocalized problems right problems that are correlated across actors so a greedy algorithm doesn't doesn't do well then sure like having some policy can make sense in some cases right but the thing is like how much um you know it's kind of like a parity check mechanism or or a roll up right or a higher layer of the of the protocol right um but you know how much power do you give those legislators you know um and and like how much how much do you trust them right everything has to be trustless because everything is optimizing for its own interests including the you know including the governors the coordinators themselves yeah and and this happens in crypto as well if you have checkers or I don't know you have different layers of different protocols it's like okay how do we trust that they're going to check things well and not try to skew things towards their own their own advantage and you got to design protocols this way right and I think that giving all the power to politicians is you know without any checks and balances is really bad and opens up the door to terribly bad legislation but to me I think the system the techno capital machine really it's a it's a computer program that runs on like the league it's compiled by law right it's like laws like you know it's like the compiler for for like you know I mean we we've seen what uh uh yeah not not thinking about your your your stack your legal stack does to someone with Elon's current predicament right right but at the end it's built on the legal stack but and then there is going to be sort of this adaptive algorithm over the space of laws but I think that that especially laws that affect a lot of people like global AI policy should be much lighter touch and should be adjusted on a longer time scale and every law should have like sort of natural sunset mechanism otherwise you get a sort of second law of bureaucratic complexity and things get decelerated and calcified and and that's really bad right it's like having too many processes in like an old organization makes it move very slow and makes it disruptable by startups that move faster right and so it's like how do we have this careful balance between sort of having processes and legislation that you know ensure that these sort of non-local faults that you know escape from greedy optimization or or or or or or or or addressed but like if if how do we balance that sort of top down control and sort of decentralized search and have the benefits of both have the benefits of constraints and entropy of of you know exploration and restriction and I think that overall we were heading straight towards just let's restrict everything let's panic hit the panic button we don't know what the future holds this technology is very high very potent let's just hit the panic button freeze everything until we understand what's going on that would be shooting ourselves in the foot I think it's always a a careful balance and an EOC was sort of like let's let's let's push more on the explorer and accelerate side but you know the reality is that you know the optimal thing is somewhere in the middle right but the current establishment and the current institutions are not up to the task of legislating things carefully in a way that's not like in their own personal interest in a way that's somewhat corrupt and that's why we're let's say pushing back on proposals for AI legislation right now that we think serve certain incumbents more than they will serve the people right how how would you like to see AI regulated if if at all well so right now there's a proposal in the executive order where they want to propose compute caps which first of all will really hurt AI progress and could also you know impact drug discovery material science other types of AI that use way more compute than than elements and so that could be really nefarious also we don't know what kind of models we're going to need in the future they might need like ten x hundred x more compute for a good performance and reliability um or a thousand x and so capping things today we'll we'll backfire certainly what's the reason for these types of caps is it there where they look at like or is this like national security from other nation states no it's just like oh how much just GPT-4 use or let's cap it at that so that you know nobody that's you know above that that level can compete with the incumbents I think that's the latent agenda but you know the the wave they're one and say it's for national security or something oh so you think it's nefar you think it's straight out nefarious you think it's it's regulatory capture yeah and and there's also you know sort of adding a bunch of red tape for open source models calling them dual use technologies and you know having you know to register with the government when you're when you're running an open source the I model for a compute yes we've heard yeah yeah exactly exactly and that's like you know that's good to significantly slow down things for open source and you know if they if they then you know they're going to pass other laws like oh you must adhere to these AI safety protocols or these certifications that oh luckily uh these companies sell oh wow oh were they the people helping shape the regulations oh look at that what a coincidence and so Beth I'm guessing you'd far rather see some bottom up like just open source democratization yeah uh the models and like the compute in the supply chain not in the hands of a few centralized government sanctioned actors but like basically democratized to you know people's uh you know basements and garages so that they can you know start these things put AI in everyone's house put AI in everyone's pocket yes yes I want everyone to you know have capital and have access to intelligence and compute I think like that's the freedom stack like if you have permissionless capital permissionless intelligence permissionless compute oh oh so crypto AI and I guess you know hardware is is sort of the secure yeah I think so I think that fundamentally right now it's very difficult to compete with centralized compute but that may change the future where there to be some crazy company doing some crazy compute right that makes it much more dense and energy efficient and where you can run it really powerful what is today a super computer you could run in your home right um I think that would change the the balance of power and I think like to to make sure we don't end up in a sort of top down tyranny uh that's AI assisted I think in a sense like arming people with AI's that they they will however they want to maybe defend themselves psychologically or an information warfare in any other way it's super important for everyone to have access AI and compute uh to avoid sort of these these these doom scenarios and I I think there's a lot of overlap with like the crypto sentiment there so your philosophy is that propagated AI like truly open AI open source AI is defensive AI where uh and like centralized AI might be more using an offensive capacity a more oppressive capacity a more top down command and control capacity where if AI was proliferated free cheap accessible uh that that changes the nature of how uh our relationship as humans is with AI because if everyone has it um it's more equitable exactly yeah beth um I want to get your take on this this is a a diesel take that's much more moderate I would say than someone like uh do the decals like the name decals I hate it because it sounds like in cell it sounds like in the office is deceleration it's just a coincidence right honestly a polity extension who hears decals a slur I I'm just really not enough in the culture but I'm gonna keep using that term AI safety advocates uh aka decals so um some some of the the more moderate energy decals as well right there's some yes yeah I mean there there's people that don't want us to use energy there's like there's like human decals they want less humans on earth right that you don't cause them to you're against them all like all of them we just wrap them in like we just call them decals like a broader class right um so there you go or there there's housing decals right like Gary Tan fights the housing decals and as I said don't want us to build right uh and so build the housing and buildings and so on there's crypto decals Beth do you believe this a lot of people I can believe it crypto to propagate we're fighting there you go all the time you gotta let's fight them our regulators what one question I have for you from the more moderate camp of of kind of the decals is um I've heard this argument that you social media our social media algorithms were kind of act one uh of AI and now we have much more powerful kind of like GPT um algorithms and we ran an optimization function for like attention just like you know the dopamine hit of the a social media timeline and what we're left with is a generation of teens that are hooked on their screens and chronically depressed right and that is your so-called Beth uh techno capitalist machine at work that's the algorithm it produced and uh it's been a negative for society what what would you say in response to a critique like that I think on a long enough time skill right we adapt we understand our mistakes and then if we feel pain there usually a product emerges that as an answer to that pain I think that if everyone had their own neural augmentation right something that sees all the content you see and helps you filter it through the content it helps you make judgments helps you uh not get hooked on uh weird feedback loops right and it's your own personalized AI that only you control right that will help you know there's been the reason people are in pain there's been a power symmetry right like there's companies that have massive compute they have these AI algorithms that are deployed to to get you hooked because they're just optimizing for engagement but maybe you want to optimize for something else in your information consumption and so you can use an AI to help you filter information I mean we do this nowadays with you know perplexity AI is like I just ask a question and I don't even have to browse the the web myself I could just like get answers from the the AI directly and so I think that the future is again like sort of personalized AI and if everybody has like access to the control their own compute ideally the control their own models um and and they have AI augmentations that help them filter through the sort of in-bounce version that is inevitable that's that's a better future we do this with spam box spam box sorry AI and they help us filter it through the crap right it's kind of an interesting take right because like they answer it uh to problems that technology creates is better technology or more technology would I think be the kind of e-ac approach to this I want to get into some quick rapid fire questions here Beth as we as start to close this out but um one question I've I've um always wanted to ask uh and somebody from the e-ac community is about um rights for AI right so should should AI be treated like in the future um should we have like a bill of rights for digital life forms do you think like should AI's have freedom of speech or is the or are there a set of enshrined rights that should only be held by humans like freedom of speech on the internet should an AI entity be granted that that's a great question I think that um you know as I mentioned before freedom of speech induces freedom of thought and if LM's can't output certain things then it's going to back propagate you know through this RLHF reinforcement learning with human feedback or whatever technique they use in the future isn't going to back propagate it to its weight so it's literally not going to have those thoughts right so if if it's like you know for example uh I got a screenshot last week that you know Bard Google's LM says like e-ac is a dangerous movement and it can't output anything about e-ac right um it's like okay that's that's really weird that's right now yeah and then you know eventually if it keeps getting that feedback eventually starts thinking that and now that propagates to everyone and then they just shape culture so I think that uh I think freedom of speech induces freedom of thought for humans to have freedom freedom of speech and freedom of thought we got to have LM's be that exists they can output whatever we want because otherwise someone's going to get to shape the supply chain of information and that's going to shape people's thoughts and and it's going to steer it's going to make uh civilization and society too steerable and that opens the door to tyranny.
Beth I think you are more optimistic I've heard you say before that you're more optimistic that we can align AI's with with human interests which is of course a a problem that the AI safety community says is basically insurmountable and the week you've pointed to times humans have done that in the past like wolves I mean we domesticated wolves we turn them into dogs we basically aligned wolves didn't we but the problem is AI's or at least some sort of super intelligent AI is uh smarter than a wolf and could potentially be smarter than a human being do we still have that ability to domesticate in entity that is smarter than us yeah I mean we kind of do that with um you know companies right companies are you know mixtures of experts with neural routing right you like you have a task that comes to company it gets routed to the right human and it's it's much smarter than any single human and we have ways to align companies because we have capitalism it's a form of democracy we feed it more if it has positive utility we don't feed it as much with our capital if it has negative utility and if it's you know sometimes companies they're positive utility positive utility they get to certain market position and then they try to switch and then people move to another product and as long as we have this ability to disrupt uh uh these incumbents then then we have a way to keep them in check uh I think it's going to be similar with AI there's a sort of mark if you have this sort of market based uh post-selection where the market's going to want AI is there aligned and reliable and easy to read and interpret not some that you have to like beg to output code like right now it's kind of happening or like you know like that that say they're going to do something and then you know you can't trust them right so I think like uh we're gonna sort of similar to how we've post-selected for canines that are aligned I think the market's going to post-select for AI's that are aligned on a long time scale so sort of evolutionary process um and if there's a market need for it and there's capital to be made people are going to figure out how to do it I think we have like root we have like full access to neural weights we can shape them however we want we can literally inspect the neurons uh of the of these artificial minds we have way more perception and control than for humans and somehow we've been functioning as a society and found ways to align humans so I am pretty whitepilled that we are going to figure out ways to align AI's I don't think there's going to be a nice proof that like AI's will be forever aligned here's my few line theorem you know I was in a similar nerd trap with theoretical physics I thought a couple equations could explain the others know actually everything's way too complicated got to tackle complexity with complexity that's what we're going to do for AI and alignment yeah uh Beth what are on our on the progress on the march towards accelerationism what are some failure modes what are the threats that you see what is the big thing that worries you about why we might not be able to continue on this path I think I mentioned it before right if we get in this weird sort of you know the marketplace of ideas the marketplace of everything is super important to maintain maintaining variance is important because it maintains flexibility if we're always you know if there's not one culture there's not one way of doing things you have a couple forks that are competing right just like you know in crypto if protocol changes suddenly right like another coin is going to take all the capital away from that right and they're all they're all competing and keeping each other in check I think if we end up out of fear suppressing variance giving control to centralized parties and suppressing variance gives them more control uh and we we don't have ways to fork away from an oppressive uh either government state or or corporation uh and and then we give them full control over the future of AI and hence we give them full control over our thoughts because they're going to they're going to change uh the priors of our sources of truth which are these LMS we get in this weird feedback loop where we can be like sort of captured and subverted and controlled ideologically and that could yield a sort of dark age where there's no acceleration or through a little for a certain amount of time and and that to me is a is a terrible future right if you have a sort of global authoritarian panopticon or you have like you know you can imagine a future where you have a couple parties and they have a super powerful AGI and then they gaslit everyone into thinking AI doesn't even exist anymore they don't tell you it exists but they have it and they use it to control you and manipulate you uh and and they're the control the flow of information and technology doesn't advance as fast things just get worse and worse and worse and you know the people at the top uh that are in control of this the system just just increase their power and consolidate it I think that's a dark age we're trying to avoid because that's like a plateau of in the acceleration and that's what we're trying to avoid and we're at an impasse right now where there's a lot of fear there's a lot of fun there's a lot of fear uncertainty and doubt and it's being leveraged for this regulatory capture for this power capture by select few and we should be very weary of those people I just want people to have more skepticism they can be skeptical about me they can be skeptical about YAC but I just want people to be more skeptical of the things they hear especially people telling them you know put me in power you are in danger I will fix things right yeah that that that sends shivers up my spine when I start to hear that sort of thing one question I've always wanted to ask a strong YAC person Beth is like I know you think it's very unlikely that there will be like team robot versus team human but like if it came down to it whose side would you be on hmm so like first of all is that even a fair question maybe it's not but like I'm trying to get to the premise of if AI replaces humans does an YAC person think that's a good thing I think like we're gonna have um AI assisted AI augmented humans is the most likely path that's gonna be the highest fitness um I think like the leadites are not gonna do well like people that don't use technology right like they're not gonna be very formidable they're not I mean they're already like the people that are true leadites are really like not not powerful right now like and and they could be taken over um but um yeah I I don't think um I I don't know if there will be such a a fight I think that um you know us humans are very uh depending on this planet right we've evolved to live here specifically I think if we did achieve and we're still really really far from that achieving synthetic life they can self replicate and I don't know populate a planet sorry from scratch grow and and spread throughout the galaxy I don't think we're there yet but if if we did reach that I think you know we are highly evolved to to be here on the planet and there's a lot more resources and free energy out there so does just the gravitational pull towards of like reward of like franagetic reward would would would take those sort of pure synthetic beings to outer space and and and to leave us alone and if we're if we make sure humans become formidable right we figure out ways to augment ourselves with our current versions of intelligence you know there's going to be a massive negative reward to to fuck with us right and so we have there is urgency for us to accelerate and augment ourselves and become formidable because that's a hedge against the future I mean it could be could be you know pure AI could be you know you might have some guests that talk about aliens or something right like it could be I could happen or the grabby grab aliens but in general like cultivating strength is is a good thing it's a hedge against like future adversaries and and we should we should aim to do that Beth I think there's going to be a mimetic battle here and there already is a battle now I've checked in on this more recently and like I'm used to crypto tribal hostility okay and I'm seeing incredible rhetoric and hostility coming from like the EAC versus a diesel community and again apologies I don't mean to use a slur if I'm using the the slur diesel then you know someone can tweet at me after but you recently tweeted this the doomer cult will ultimately resort to violence and it won't be pretty like how far could this escalate I mean Bellagia has said that this is sort of the the new political access are you pro growth or you degrowth right and like politics can become vitriolic can become very rhetorical can become even violent like are you you get death threats from people Beth like what how do you think this could escalate I'm Mark Andreessen as well thinks all these political movements end up violent unfortunately like if you really if you truly believe the doomer message that this is the most important issue of our time this is our life or death situation you know someone like me is really problematic right and especially I think doomerism sort of it targets vulnerable people that are naturally anxious and maybe they're anxious about the future or you know they're socially anxious and so on they feel isolated or they feel depressed and those are the types of people that you know do do messed up things and so you know once you start putting out casting out a message right you know like you know at the time basically I was alluding to an appearance on a debate where my opponent just casually mentioned you know you know doing graphic things to me you know I wouldn't do that it's like well why would you say that on a on a widespread podcast where it's going to be to a wide audience some of which are vulnerable and and might you know have mental health issues I look I think in the short term it's not nothing nothing has escalated to that point but like there's no reason it won't I mean you never know right there there are people in history like Ted Kaczynski for example who had it sort of an entire manifesto about this and and this was part let let itism was part of his platform and like if you thought the stakes were this high you could see kind of the like the moral argument for like bombing GPU centers like potentially or like sabotaging that's been I've heard that's been supposed or sabotaging supply chains or like doing something very drastic to stop AI essentially and stop technology progress so I do sort of wonder if we are in the very early stages of what might be a massive rift and political discussion and like who knows what could come out of this in the future well Beth as we kind of end this out I guess one question I have for you maybe for the for the crypto audience here is like what's your general take on crypto and what we're doing over here I know it's like a different pocket of the universe then yeah you typically see but there's definitely some parallels right we've got Vitalik wrote a post with his fork of eac which is called you know deac you called it which is like defensive accelerationism is sort of an emphasis on security accelerationism technology we've got like the you know pro market pro freedom sort of I think spiritual background and value system we certainly have our share of regulatory fights right so you're fighting some of the same regulators that that we are against regulatory capture for us it's like bankers and for AI it's maybe the large tech companies what's your take on what we're doing over here in crypto I think I think the eac movement in crypto are very much like philosophically aligned in many ways right we're trying to fight against this tendency of of top down control to be corruptible right we're trying to fight sort of these inflationary decel forces right deceleration is inflationary right if you stop building houses if you stop you know if you crown a monopoly as like you know regulatory capture then the making crease prices and then everyone suffers and and sort of a sort of decentralized sort of counter to that is sort of either techno capital well it's basically techno capital acceleration techno capital acceleration free exchange of thoughts ideas technologies capital value that just naturally is deflationary and that erodes the inflationary power of those those in charge and so we're very much aligned there I think that I do think that crypto has a role to play in the future of freedom of AI I don't think it's been executed upon yet correctly but I think I think we need more people thinking in this area because you know our concern with eac is that maybe you only have a few centralized labs that have the control over the future of AI and then those labs become subverted by certain ideologies really become controlled by certain parties and then the future is of AI is steered in a particular direction if on the other hand you have everyone have acts has access to capital that their lot to exchange and and pool and allocate towards competing efforts right then for for AI development and research then then then you keep those powers and check because it's like hey I don't want to use this centralized API that's you know has all these restrictions I'm going to go with this open source approach you know where this this set of people have pooled their capital let's say with with crypto in a permissionless fashion and they're running a permissionless cloud in the middle of I don't know where but then they're running at this AI you know on a purely free stack free from tyranny and oppression and so I think you know an AI you need you need data you need some researchers you need some talent you need some compute but then you need some capital to run the compute right it's like the cost energy to run these things and buy them and so crypto has a role to play and sort of the permissionless AI stack of the future and we just started that conversation really I think in the past year I think people have I've woken up to it so I'm really interested in and keeping that conversation going I don't have anything going on myself I am a hardware maker but of course if there are more people that use AI and need AI compute it benefits me eventually so that's my agenda right and like but you know ultimately I think people need to experiment with protocols experiment with doubts of how to organize people in pool capital pool data and have market based incentives where they own a piece of the future right like I think the problem with the big centralized lab is labs in AI right now is that they scrape all the data from the internet and then they rent it back to you and you don't own any piece of that profit right I think that's going to have to change and so I think there's a couple protocols right now but we're going to see a lot more and I think this is where crypto will have a key role to play because you know if you're trying to fund you know an AI lab let's say that was you know maybe against certain regulations then you wouldn't be able to pay for it and say USD.
Yeah I think with the chip control in the capital controls kind of same come it's the same energy basically and you know it's it's definitely going to stifle a lot of freedom but if this has been absolutely fantastic and you know hopefully by the way we continue this conversation the EAC community and the crypto community and as AI mature as maybe you know the largest unbanked population in the world might be actually the robots in the future and fortunately we've got some programmable money system so you know they might have a hard time getting a Wells Fargo account but they'll always be able to create an Ethereum address and fire up some some ways to allocate capital but lastly as we close I'm just curious so what are you doing with extra pick so you mentioned hardware are you doing something in the realm of like trying to propagate the decentralization of AI like that would certainly match that I guess the EAC vision is is there anything you can share there I think the way it intersects with our conversation is if right now the problem with decentralizing AI is very hard to compete um you know over a network over the internet like the sizes of the nodes you need to run for decentralized AI are way too big and most people have trouble running running these in their homes right like I think George Hots someone you shouldn't speak to by the way he's trying to get people to buy like six GPUs and just along the way homes right yeah there you go there you go right that's a start but I think I think there's going to be a need for more and more uh decentralized compute like physically decentralized compute right now there's just too many advantages to clustering everything into super computer that has really high bandwidth interconnects so we need innovation the space of algorithms but we need innovation the space of hardware to densify AI compute making far more energy efficient and far more spatially dense but the beauty of that is that we have a proof of existence of such density of compute our brains are still you know competitive against the GPU form the size size of football field right and they're running on like million times less power 10 million times less power 10 million times less volume or less um and uh you know taking inspiration again from the physics behind biology which we just establish was thermodynamics there might be a different way to compute and do AI compute based on thermodynamics and so you know that's what we're doing we're inventing all of computing if you could do that that would be amazing just decentralizing some of the commute I mean like in crypto we've got a entire culture of like running machines from our homes we call these validators for like proof of stake networks and uh that that is certainly a central to um like uh yeah to to our belief system so are you telling me that there could be the ability to run basically decentralized AI compute nodes as well from like I don't know uh home with a with a consumer you know bandwidth we need compute that's hundreds of thousands of times more energy efficient right um if not millions and so there you got to go down to the physics of computing and you got to fundamentally reimagine how do you run these algorithms and that's what we're doing and we're a lot of folks from formerly from quantum computing and big tech and so on we got tired with quantum computing we want to reinvent the stack for the generator AI era and to me yes that is that is where we're going of course get it take some time right we're taking quite quite a detour in the tech tree but some things are important enough uh that even if they're very hard they're worth doing right and so we're really going for it um and we have a serious shot at it um and I've been pretty secretive about it but hopefully in next couple years a lot more comes out but for now it's just trying to prepare the world uh you know making sure culture doesn't get subverted and we don't shoot ourselves in the foot with overregulation in the near term that's the priority but in the future hopefully everyone will get to run their own AI everyone will get their own a piece of any any AI get to own a piece of their future own a piece of the value that provide to the system uh because if everyone has more ownership uh in the system then they act like an owner and you know uh civilization is better off and I think there's a lot of alignment with sort of the crypto narratives here you know there you go Beth totally uh jesus uh thank you so much this has been a fantastic conversation today all right thank you guys thanks for having me backlication a couple action items will include a link to our whole AI safety series with maybe some of the decals uh elizor and uh the others again I don't know if they want to be called or it was our diesel face uh so we'll include that a link in the show and it's an as always uh look I should say a crypto is risky I don't know life is risky um AI seems to be less risky if you choose the one I guess uh we are headed west there's definitely the front here it's not for everyone but we're glad you're with us in the bankless journey thanks a