Episode: #25 August 10, 2020
-----
Tools from our sponsors to go bankless:
----
Andre Cronje calls himself just another DeFi dev, but you can't help but wonder, is he's underselling himself with that title?
In a few short months he single-handedly created a fleet of DeFi yield farming money robots that locked up over $400m in assets in his yearn protocol. He launched a YFI token that grew in value by over 1,000% in its first week, one of the most explosive price charts crypto has ever seen.
No pre-mine, no VC, no founders reward.
Maybe a better title is King of the Yield Farmers.
DeFi's Satoshi.
Who is this guy?
What did he build and why is it brilliant?
Why did YFI go from $3 on July 17th to $5000 on August 8th?
This is everything you need to know about yearn, YFI, and Andre.
We cover:
Join us next Monday for a fresh episode!
----- Resources discussed:
----- Episode Actions:
Also...subscribe to Bankless YouTube to watch State of the Nation every Tuesday.
----- Subscribe to podcast on iTunes | Spotify | YouTube | RSS Feed
Leave a review on iTunes
Share the episode with someone you know!
----- Don't stop at the podcast!
Subscribe to the Bankless newsletter program
Watch Bankless shows and tutorials on YouTube
Visit official Bankless website for resources
Follow Bankless on Twitter
Follow Ryan on Twitter
Follow David on Twitter
----- Not financial or tax advice. This podcast is strictly educational and is not investment advice or a solicitation to buy or sell any assets or to make any financial decisions. Do your own research.
No summary for this episode yet.
Welcome to Bankless, where we explore the frontier of internet money and internet finance. This is how to get started, how to get better, and how to frontrun the opportunity. This is Ryan Sean Adams. I'm here with David Hoffman and we are here to help you become more Bankless, David. How are you doing today? Just fantastic, Ryan. It came out of an interview with Andre Cronier, the creator of the Y-Earn Protocol and the Wi-Fi token. Some people may know this token as the YFI token, the YIFI token, the Wi-Fi token. Apparently, according to Andre, it's the Wi-Fi token. And this protocol, YURN, just kind of came out of nowhere and exploded into the DeFi ecosystem and got everyone really, really excited.
Specifically with about how the token came to be, how the protocol came to be, and also the fact that the creator, Andre, allows the token to govern his life. And so that is how Andre came to be on the Bankless podcast. We submitted a proposal to the Y-Earn governance page that asked for opinions as to whether or not Andre should come on the Bankless podcast. Of course, it passed with flying colors at 95%. And so here we are recording with Andre Cronier, creator of the YURN Protocol. So he was compelled to come on the podcast in his words. He had no choice. And as we were interviewing Andre, I was kind of thinking, what should the episode title name be for this?
In fact, what is Andre? He calls himself just an ordinary DeFi dev, but he's almost like this king of yield farmers because he's raised both this group of money robots to do yield farming out of all the DeFi opportunities that are out there. And he's also created a cohort, a group of other yield farmers that are writing strategies for this Y-Earn protocol thing. It's incredibly fascinating the group that he's built and the capability that he's built out. This is probably one of the most effective yield farming technologies and yield farming strategies that's out there. Well, interviewing Andre, I'm reminded of that old comic, I can't remember who made it, but it was an engineer that made us wrote a script, worked his ass off for 36 hours to write a script so that he could automate his job for the rest of his life.
And so he goes into work and just like scroll through read it and doesn't do his job because he made a script that did his job board him. To make that metaphor concrete, that job is yield farming and the script is the Y-Earn protocol. And so we kind of go in to Andre as to what he was doing that spun up the Y-Earn protocol. First, he was using these various protocols to earn interest on his stable coins. And then he had to update it to add a new protocol and then liquidity mining came out. And so all of these technologies stacked on top of each other. And so he finally came out with the Y-Earn protocol, which is this thing that automates everything together all at once so that he doesn't have to do any more work.
Unfortunately, he's super busy and that's kind of what we got into the episode a little bit because this turns out this is, this turned into an absolute cannonball of a protocol into the DeFi ecosystem. And so we kind of, we go through the protocol step by step with Andre to get him to explain it to us so we can understand it so we can pass that knowledge on to the bankless nation. Absolutely. The one thing I was left with with this interview is that Andre really cares a lot about DeFi. And he really cares deeply about DeFi users, particularly people like him, the liquidity providers, as he calls them.
And I think in this in this conversation, you're going to hear a lot of acronyms thrown around, things like LPs, Andre says often, that means liquidity providers, flash loans. For instance, that's a split second sort of loan that happens in a block within the protocol. You're going to hear all sorts of different asset names. So we get pretty deep into DeFi geek talk in this episode. I think if you have hung with us for the previous 24 episodes, you should be able to keep up. But we do try to take some pauses and explain things throughout the interview and summarize things. I think listeners will be able to keep up with things, but we will include a few other resources in this show notes with definitions and prior episodes that you can listen to.
Yeah, I've gone through a number of different attempts to fully comprehend Yifi and Yurn. And it's just, it's so, it really stretches my capacity to be able to understand these things. As a listener, if you are listening to this and you don't really get it the first time around, like don't blame yourself, this shit is complicated. And Andre's bill is one of the most integrated and composable applications, which makes it really requires a ton of prerequisite knowledge. And so this is like DeFi 401 level content that we go through. And so even I had a hard time keeping up. So don't stress about that.
Yeah, totally. And you know, you just sit there, you call it Yifi David instead of Yifi. Hang me up. See? There you go. Yifi, Yifi, same product, same token name for the wire and protocol, but that's the kind of thing. These, these terms you'll hear throughout this episode. It is a fantastic episode for you, advanced folks. And I do think beginners will be able to keep up as well. We should get right into it. But first, let's talk about our sponsors. The first sponsor I want to tell you about is Ave. Ave is a DeFi protocol that you absolutely have to check out. How can you do with it? You can lend.
You can borrow. Banklessly, all on Ethereum. So you can do things like lend die to the protocol. It will magically transform that die into an interest bearing die account, not just die, all sorts of crypto assets on Ethereum. You can also borrow against it. Ave has been climbing up the leaderboard as well. And they've recently released Avonomics, which is their token economics upgrade. You can read more about it when we'll include a link in the show notes. So Avonomics grants key decision making to Ave token holders. It creates more safety and economic incentives to reward protocol growth. One of the coolest things is it actually introduces a safety module.
So there is staked Ave becomes a collateral of last resort. You can find out about Ave, Avonomics, start using the protocol at Ave.com, that's a-a-v-e-dot-com. For those of you that have been transacting on Ethereum, you've noticed that the gas prices have just been insanely high, you know, 60-gway on a good day, and sometimes all the way up to 100-gway, which is really reducing the amount of activities that is really feasible to be able to do on Ethereum. This is where our newest sponsor, Lupring, comes in. Ethereum is a ZK roll-up scaling protocol for Ethereum for both trading and for payments.
ZK roll-ups, that stands for zero-knowledge roll-ups. It's basically cryptographic magic. It allows you to combine activity and transactions into one single bit of information, which means that massive amounts of transactions can be bundled into a very small chunk of information which reduces the gas per transaction. At loopring.io, you can find a ZK roll-ups-based exchange and also a payment mechanism, all with the same security guarantees of the Ethereum L1 blockchain, which is really important. So loopring and ZK roll-ups allows you to scale up transactions, trading payments, in two thousands and throughout thousands of transactions per second, but with the same security guarantees of the main Ethereum blockchain, which is just incredible.
In September, loopring is releasing the loopring wallet. This will be a mobile smart contract wallet, with ZK roll-ups tucked in natively. I'm really excited for how this is going to impact the adoption of Ethereum. The rest of the world will be able to experience Venmo-type transactions, but with the same amount of trustlessness and security of the decentralized future ahead of us. So if you're a trader that's being eaten alive by gas fees, visit loopring.io to get onboarded into Ethereum's cheapest and fastest exchange. All it requires is an Ethereum address and you can trade on a high-performance order book completely gas-free.
And transferring Ether and ERC-20 tokens on the platform is completely free. If you visit loopring.io, enter the code bankless in order to get the highest VIP tier for six months. So check that out. There's a link in the show notes. Visit loopring.io, enter code bankless. Alright guys, let's go ahead and get right into the interview with Andre Cronier. Bankless Nation, we are incredibly excited about our next guest. This is a first, I think first in crypto history, first in podcast history, maybe we have a guest who is on the bankless podcast by way of token vote. And we're going to explain what that means in just a moment.
I want to introduce you to Andre Cronier. You may know him from the Y-Earn Protocol or the WIFI token, which has been going crazy for the last month or so. But he'd introduce himself as just another DeFi dev. Andre, how are you doing today, sir? You want to honest answer or you want to polite answer so we continue this call? You know what? Let's do the honest answer because that's how we roll on the bankless podcast. The answer is only. Okay, honest answer is only, well then I'm kind of shit, like I haven't really slept in a few days and I, everything's just a blur at this point, there's just so much going on.
Yeah, I don't know, I'll probably be close to tapping out in a few days and then I'll take it from there again. Isn't it all because of stuff that's going on with the Y-Earn Protocol? Yeah, yeah, there's just too much happening and it's got too much traction to the point where I don't have the support infrastructure to keep up with it. So it's murdering me. There is such a thing as too big too fast. Okay, tell us a little bit more about that. What grew too big too fast and what is sucking up all of your attention and energy? Well, it's expectation management mostly because like the building part, that's fine.
That I do, I love building, I'm going to keep building, I'm going to enjoy building, but there's so much extra onus now, there's a lot more interaction required of me on the social media side. I have so many inbound requests. I don't want to be that guy that doesn't respond. I still try and respond to each person that contacts me. There's sort of the governance stuff I have to jump in every so often because that's just a, I don't know, it's turning into a little bit of a circle jerk on that side. There's just, ever since, that's why I was very apprehensive about, I knew it was going to happen.
I was worried about the token having a price component because as soon as it has a price component, people's mentalities change and I've noticed this in the governance forums and in the communication people have with me because the people that formed it, they're chill and they're some of the strongest supporters and they're actually quite actively engaged and they're trying to benefit the ecosystem, the people that fought it, they feel they're owed something. All of a sudden there's a responsibility towards them and like like, there's a lot of negativity on that side that drags me down quite a bit.
So yeah, it's just trying to keep up with the pace is definitely getting me. So Andre, I think what you're saying is, it sounds like what you're saying is it's more, it's not the building that's tiring you out, right? That maybe, maybe get energy from that, I'm not sure, but it's more, it's more the social side that's really exhausting you and tiring you out and now with the launch of the wifey token and governance and the expectations around that, it sounds like the social aspect of things has just accelerated to a degree that is frankly exhausting, but you've always been someone to dampen expectations, right?
So like famously, go to your Twitter profile right now, go to Andre's Twitter profile right now guys. Here's what it says in the bio, I test and prod, right? That's a lower your expectation type of statement. It means, look guys, I'm not doing all of the audits in this thing, I'm not, well, you know what? Why don't you explain it? Like, why do you make statements like that? Why do you make statements when you rolled out the wifey token that this token has zero value? Why do you have disclaimers that say things like, when I build software, I build for myself, if you interact with it, use caution, there will be bugs.
Why do you do that sort of thing? So a big reason why, so originally when I built out the first IEarn sort of first iteration back in Jan Feibai, I had gotten my audits, I had published them, and people flooded in capital. And what I realized was people use audits like a blanket safety net. And you say it's audit, they think, okay, it's fine, I don't have to do my due diligence, I don't have to do my own research, I'm just going to throw my money in. So a big reason why I emphasize to people that look, I mean, in all honesty, I do still get audits, I just don't publish them and I refuse to publish them because I don't want people to have a sense of false security.
It's important to me that when you manage your money, that's what you should be doing, you should be managing your money. Now I don't necessarily mean actively, I mean most of the Earn protocol is there to automate your management, but you should at least at a high level know where that money is going and why it is going there. I think those are two very important questions to at least answer before you put your money into something. And I feel that's like a baseline due diligence. But if you have a protocol and you start shouting numbers like 100 million TVL, 30% APR and trail of bit audits, then all of a sudden people don't think about that stuff and they just throw money in.
And I think that is more dangerous than me trying to shout at the top of my lungs, the stuff is dangerous, please be careful, I didn't build it for you, you're going to lose money and then they actually invest again. At that point, I have a lot more comfort with them putting their money in it than if they were to just blindly follow because there's a report I published. So I'm seeing a lot of contrast between Yifi and Yerne and why it's so special, why people are so excited about it is the way that it's Genesis, how it was created. And so many people like it because it wasn't created by a VC group that funded a team that did all the tide off all the things before they released it, right?
Instead, Yifi was kind of put out there, put out to Ethereum more or less like using Ethereum as like test production and then it got into the hands of the community basically instantly and that's why people love it so much. But that's also what I'm hearing from you is kind of a big detriment where like there's not a team that got Venture Capital to help support you, Andre, like the CEO or the leader or whatever, whatever one title you would theoretically bestow yourself. Like you are the kind of, there's a lot of weight on one single individual who kind of just built out this protocol just for himself.
And the beautiful thing about it is that you turned over the keys to the community, but then the community is trying to like have things both ways where they are like they love its genesis and they love that you donated this project to the greater Ethereum ecosystem and they love that the VC backing never was there, but also at the same time there, they wish there was this VC backed team that had like these salaries that could go and do all these things. How do you see that checks to position kind of like playing out in your experiences? So first thing first, I agree 100% with what you just said, as a little bit, I mean I also proposed that our necessity, but also proposed that as a little bit of a social experiment because I was curious.
So the platform generates its own rewards and fee systems. And now that it's a very positive market cycle, the fees are actually high enough to cover like audit server expenses, you know, all of those things. I mean, it's not high to run, but it is there. So I propose look instead of any further issuance of the token, because I'm actually quite against any further issuance, I don't believe in liquidity mining at all. So instead of any further issuance, let's use their reward systems and let's take expenses out of that. And if you want to have a read on the forum, the general consensus, it's a good idea, but dividends should flow to token holders.
So everyone says there should be like a minimum cap, so 5% or 10% or whatever, and everything else should go to the token holders. Now as a social experiment, I find that very interesting because again, I did not sell this token to anyone. I was very adamant if you if you gained this token, be sure you earned it without spending any money other than gas costs. But the people that bought it, they feel they bought it for a reason and that reason is future revenue from the protocol versus the ones that formed it that were most likely already using the protocol. And that's why I did who won as a the Y curve token because that means you're already using the protocol and I want people using the protocol to be governing the protocol as a logical sort of next step.
They're the stronger supporters. But again, like I the best way I see this playing out and kind of what I was expecting, but I guess it's, I don't know, maybe it'll still be full or not, but the price has to decline to the point where it's again only in the hands of the people that actually want to govern the protocol and not in the hands of the people that bought it with the idea of future revenue. So I think it's a lot about the intent with which people gained access to the token. And there's, you can see it in the voting structure as well because the votes are more often than not either not quorum or or last minute flips.
And it's often quite a big difference between, you know, the, the original miners, let's call them liquidity providers and the token purchasers. So so so there's a definite conflict between those two. And I actually, last year or the year before, I need to go check, but but I published a few articles about this specifically where where you you you have this conflict between between a token's purpose and an investor's value. So so so even if we look at a theorem, right, if we look at a theorem, a theorems, there's a lot of ideologies. So I'm not going to go into all of them, the theorem is money, et cetera, at its base, a theorem is gas and it's meant to be paid for computational execution.
Now now there's a certain equilibrium there between how much does it cost the network as a collective of miners in the amount of electricity they're spending to execute that instruction and thus secure it. And how much are they being rewarded in financial value for that? Now at equilibrium, it should be, it should the value of the token should be slightly more than the cost of their electricity. But now if you add speculators into the equation, they're not using the token. So it's not cycling between these two. So all of a sudden you're removing supply out of the equation and at the same time this this this band keeps increasing because it's not circulating.
You're moving more and more and more supply demands, supply side crisis and you end up with a token that increases to the point where where the users who are supposed to be paying for these execution no longer want to pay for these execution because it's too expensive. Miners are still happy. They're they're walking away of extra profits, but the users don't want to use it anymore. So so as soon as you add speculative value to a lot of these tokens, you end up destroying the reason they exist. And that that only cycles back to its equilibrium point when when its value normally decreases. But now at the same time we're in a market where it's predominantly investors and your your product is only as good as your green candles or your red candles.
So if your if your token is going up in value, you're you're a wonderful product and you have the most amazing leadership and everything is wonderful. If that thing starts going down, you're a scam and you lied and and this this insert any random fun you can possibly think of. And the second it switches to green again, all of a sudden you're the most wonderful project ever. So I'm I'm very worried about that because on the one hand, I need that value to significantly decrease for it to have its effect of value in the ecosystem. But when that happens, people start saying the protocol is shit, the platform is shit and it doesn't work as intended.
And I'm curious to see how it plays out like I have no ideas how this is going to turn out. I in none of my models that I expected to turn out the way it did, but but but right now there there is a definite conflict between between governance and speculators that much I can see in the forums. This has been so helpful to you to understand sort of how you think about things and got some other questions, want to dig in your background a little bit later, but you mentioned so much there, one of your points was about speculators versus sort of the users and they're being sort of an inherent mismatch there in terms of alignment.
Part of that I wonder maybe we could dig into later is like is there a difference in your mind between the the short term speculator investor and the long term investor, right? So that's something we could talk about, but but let's let's put that aside for a minute because I'm not sure that everyone listening is actually familiar with some of the things that you just said and sort of the story of why earn and the story of of YFI. So we want to set some context for them for folks who might be new to it, new to what's been going on. Can we start with maybe the why earn protocol? What is the why earn protocol?
Can you do and explain it like I'm five for what the protocol actually does? Yeah, the the the very original first iteration, I'm just going to start there of the of why earn back when it was I earn, which by the way, the the name swap nodar from Zapper actually recommended the why because then it's you earn instead of I earn, which had a much nicer collective idea, which which I enjoyed. But very simplistically back then I I there's a longer background that we can dig into if we want, but but I'm just going to start from I I was at X point where I was managing a lot of friends and families money and I I I'm not a trader I'm not a speculator I don't understand any of these things I think TA is flipping a coin and good luck which side it's going to land on.
So I I had moved almost everything into stable coins, but I still wanted to offer people certain amount of of returns because they had entrusted their money with me. So I started looking at options of putting stable coins to work and at the time, there was Ave, there was full crime, there was compound, there was DYDX, there was a bunch of different services and I would wake up in the morning and I would see which ones are the highest APR and I'd move my funds around and I did this for probably a few days until I finally got annoyed at one moving it around and two having to pay gas fees the whole time.
So I started thinking look I can automate all of this. So the first thing I did was just write a few normalization smart contracts that reads in the different APR numbers from the different systems and then gives me standardized output which I can compare. So that at least I don't have to compare them individually and I can just look at the script and the script, smart contract will tell me where to send it. So that was sort of step one and then step two, I started with this concept of having the tokens do it themselves. So I wrote the first iteration of the Y tokens which Y die, YUSDC, YUSDT and YTUSD and very simplistically they read this normalized APR output and then they see which one it's supposed to be and then they have integrations into all of the downstream sources independent on what that response is where they're supposed to go.
They move between one of those and I used that as my baseline for quite a while until I got to the point where I started realizing number one there's no net loss to me opening this up to other people which is fantastic. Number two the more people that interact with the protocol the more effective it gets. So what I mean by that is every time someone deposits or withdraws it sees if it should rebalance. So the higher the frequency of interaction the more it shifts between protocols to maximize its own yield return. So by opening it up and allowing other people to pull into the protocol they're getting the highest yield from any of these aggregate sources because it's moving and because there's more people interacting with it it's moving more frequently which means in aggregate it gets a higher APR return than any of the downstream sources.
So that was the original, that was the original I earned now year. So a really simplistic concept and a simplistic idea it's what lenders do nowadays as well. You move your capital to where you get the highest returns just automated and with smart controls. I don't know if you want to stop there or you want to now continue digging into how the rest of the platform continued expanding. A few quick questions there as to the technical details. So you said that the tokens move in order to find the best yield. Can you just go into the details as to how the tokens know where the best yield is and then who pays for that who or what pays for that gas for those tokens to move.
So gas is paid during interaction. So when I deposit or I withdraw then it checks if it moves that gas is added onto that deposit or that withdrawal. So it's basically an unlucky lottery whoever is going to hit the contract when it's time to rebalance is going to be paying that extra amount. But they were going to be paying something out of gas anyways, right? It's kind of just like they're also the movement of the tokens are kind of just free writing on that transaction. Correct. And I mean back then gas was what six, so it wasn't you'd be paying two bucks instead of 1.5 bucks. Now it's a little bit more significant but the system also works very differently now.
So the tokens themselves are the white token is really just to think of it as a pool. And in this pool you have a bunch of let's take die and you have a bunch of die. So when I deposit I deposit a bunch of die. When I deposit or withdraw then it asks the APR smart contract for practical purposes think it's a Oracle. I don't like using the terminology Oracle specifically because it's not using any off chance sources. It's just normalizing on chain information for practical purposes. It's called it the APR Oracle. It asks the Oracle where is the highest APR currently and the Oracle tells it Ave.
And if it sees Ave then it goes okay so now I take this all of this die I have and I deposit it into Ave. Now I have a tokens and Ave has my die. And now I'm sitting with that and I'm earning interest. Now next the positive comes along in deposits it checks that again it sees okay I should be going to compound. So it withdraws the die from Ave and by returning its eight tokens deposits into compound and now I have C tokens. And that's all it does. So every time someone interacts it asks the question where should I go and then it simply withdraws from where it is and it goes to where it's supposed to be.
So it's like a robot that finds the highest yield okay so I think that's pretty simple for folks to understand. I have one question on that. So when we talk about reward like putting on an investor cap we think about risk adjusted reward, risk adjusted returns. So it seems like the money robot, the wired money robot is basically showing you the highest yield protocols and investing in that but it can't quantify risk. Is that sort of a blind spot of the protocol? In the V1 version. So in the V1 version I remember we were at about two million die and that was just when Visitex had their whatever you want to call it Black Thursday event or however.
And we managed to pull that out I told the script to no longer use fulcrum and then it removed fulcrum as an option and then it pulled everything out and we were very lucky at that point. But after that we started looking at things like how much tokens is at the downstream source in other words how liquid is the source I'm putting cash into now and it would check how much of that liquidity has moved in X amount of time. With a V3 I also wanted to include the five score I believe it's called what Jordan them are working on but I never ended up getting to that V3 because V2 ended up integrating with curve and it's not going to get much better in terms of its yield than where it's currently setting at.
So it started adding a few smarter things like if it started looking at how big is the pool that I'm moving to and will I affect its APR because when I first started there's ten twenty thousand dollars in there and that doesn't affect APR when it moves. Within a few months there was there was two to five million in there so now when it moves to one of these downstream sources it actually changes the APR from 10% to 5% so now I have to start calculating and okay what is the APR going to be if I move and only move if it is a net benefit with move plus that and then it would look at how much liquidity is the downstream source in other words is it safe can I still get out and it would do smaller adjustments so it would see okay I can move half of it year and get this amount of yield in the other half that side and get that amount of yield in an aggregate that's more but in terms of in terms of intelligent risk no such thing exists as data on chain currently so it was largely my own perceived perspective over these protocols risks and their dangers I'm not sure where to fly score is added in terms of their own chain codification I think they have done it as an Oracle stream already but I haven't touched it recently unfortunately yeah and so for folks that aren't totally familiar with some of the things you're talked about so you know just so I can kind of understand so what you're talking about is obviously annualized returns right that's when you when you were saying APR that's annualized returns and the risk modeling that that why earn is taking into account is from two places right now or in the future versions will be maybe in V2 it is which is the liquidity of the underlying protocol which is certainly one measure of risk not necessarily an intelligent measure of risk but but it does help somewhat and then also there is this I don't know agency I don't know what you call them but a project called DeFi score which is a consensus project that is actually trying to quantify risk almost like a like a morning star I suppose or something in the traditional finance world where there's sort of a you know risk quantification of an underlying asset and they're trying to score each of these protocols and possibly you could you could integrate that but even those two I guess sources are fairly primitive I suppose not I don't know if this is a this is a problem for finance right how do we it's not just a problem for DeFi it's a problem for finance is like how do we quantify risk like humans are really bad at quantifying risk but do you think we can start getting better in DeFi about quantifying the risk across various protocols and if so how I mean like like as a baseline what what do humans consider as low risk versus high risk when it comes to financial things you you'll you'll go to the bank that's been around for longer because they've got the track record record and you'll go to the bank that has more capital because they have less chances of going over so so you know those are sort of the the normal human psyche things we quantify so I think for a large part that's still very much true in DeFi as well because because because even in DeFi in in in which product do you rather put your capital you know the the one that's the that's the the SF backed VC backed funded 100 million dollar protocol or the a non-user that no one knows who they are but they deployed a bunch of smart contracts onto chain I mean right off the bat I can tell you which one I'd feel safer with my money even if that is completely you know just based off of human perception so so I don't know I mean I mean if so so my general rule with anything I code is if if I can quantify the steps in a logical way then I can codify the steps in a logical way I I can't I can't in an analytical way tell you how I measure risk so I'm not sure how that would be codified other than a certain member of a certain level of perception based so Andre let's pick up the thread with the development of the urine protocol we we left off with talking about how stable coins move around in order to get the best yield in the various DeFi protocols but the urine protocol didn't stop there what's the next step in the composition of of urine and wifey so so after after we after I now had this thing where these tokens move between lenders are about the same time curve came out with their stable swap system which now is the curve protocol and the very first pool that launched was the CDI which is the compound I and CU is DC which is the compound USDC and I started speaking to Mitch and and we we started discussing this idea but okay if you can do these swaps with with these heel tokens could you do them with with the the heeled profit switching tokens and we ended up deploying the the Y pool which is built off of the the four base layer urine tokens the YDI the YUSDC the YUSDT and the YT USD and we also later launched the BUSD pool which is YDI YUSDT USDC and YBUSD yeah the Binance USD1 so so so this offered another layer on top because we knew that that if you're in curve there's there's a certain level of stability based on the tokens as long as dyke and manage to keep peg and that allows you to have the the yield maximization with trading fees on top and when it started it was fantastic because the the volume far outseeded the liquidity so we would have 100 plus days which was phenomenal as liquidity increased you know we're at less than 10 percent utilization now so fees don't make up as much as they used to but but that was basically the pinnacle of yield at that time there was there was there was nothing other than centralized services where you could get higher yield than you could in in the Y pool and and and that that sort of stayed for for quite a while so so there was a bit of a a lack of new yield opportunities so to stimulate yield opportunities I started looking for things to build that improves yield so one of the first things I started looking at was how do I get people to trade more on curve because the more you trade the higher the fees the higher the fees the better the yield so I started building things like Y trade and Y leverage we both were just leveraged stablecoin trades why leverage was based off of flash learning USDC from yeah flash loading USDC from dydx putting that into maker as collateral this is just when they release their USDC avals mending dy off of that selling the dye to USDC because dye was trading above peg at about 1.
02 returning the flash load USDC and you get the difference in profit and then when you want to close the vault again it just does the inverse so in our words borrow the the dye closed the vault take the USDC sell back to dye and then return that if you close it out of profit you have to add in the rest if you close it in profit you get profit on both sides why why trade is the is the leverage system I can go up to a thousand x leverage on the UI we limited to a maximum of 250 you can go higher but then we want you to interact with the smart contracts because any higher than 250 and you're liquidated and less than a day so so that's for a lot more experience people and for the the basic website we only allowed up until 5x because then at least you have a few weeks and months before you get liquidated because you're borrow position and that simplistically LPs could provide their Y curve token when a trader comes in it unwinds the Y curve token into the one of the native assets dye USDC to USD or USDT and then it sells it into curve for the opposing asset whatever you want to do so you'll do dye to USDC and now you have a short dye position and you have a USDC amount on the books so that's just allowed people to do higher frequency trading I had closed that down I think around Iver early June maybe late just before that because I wanted to rework the whole way I did design that and everything while I was busy with that rework I started looking at Y swap which is the single-sided AMM solution that's that's a lot more technical so I don't know if we want to go into that because there's quite a lot of detail to unpack around that but but it's just a way to to to to do uniswap basically with just providing a single asset on the one side and having healed the wear systems but but everything I build and everything I designed and the whole year on ecosystem and even the vaults that I have now and the vaults I had to design because the healed world just became massively complex in the last two months so it needed a whole new solution but but but everything has a singular goal maximize healed for LPs that provide that provide liquidity into the ecosystem but but I have I have two very fixed rules when it comes to this number one I I don't swap what you put in so if you put in die I'm not going to swap that to TUSD and put that into M stable because it's going to get a higher healed I'm going to keep it in die so you might not get the highest possible APR strategy but you will get the highest one for die and the reason for that is I did have a solution back in the day that swapped between the stable coins for the highest one but I've noticed that most LPs aren't long-term LPs they're LPs for a few days so so they ended up losing more because of slippage than they would actually make in in interest gain so for for purposes of keeping it more simplistic for them I I decided I'm always going to keep it token to token and then the other rule is no experimental systems but that again is based on my own perceived level of risk which you know I I try and do as much due diligence on these platforms where the money goes as possible because any of my solutions my money will be the first one in so I expose myself to the risk of wherever that goes so I'm very I'm very apprehensive about that so so it might also not always be the absolute maximum APR you could get in DeFi but it is what I consider to be the the safest APR without having any losses on the original asset you put it hey guys going bankless is a journey and you don't have to do it alone so we're going to pause the interview with Andre so we can talk about some of our fantastic bankless sponsors that offer you tools to help you in your journey westward as we all go westward we need to get our values into the crypto world but hopefully escape the tyranny of centralized rent seeking institutions and that's where monolith can help you get your value into the crypto world while skipping over the crypto banks coming soon to monolith is an on-rapt directly from your old world bank account into your smart contract wallet on Ethereum and for those that don't know monolith also has a DeFi card which uses die in your smart contract wallet but on the visa network so you can go to the your grocery store swipe your DeFi card pay for your groceries like a normal person and still be part of the crypto bankless crypto economic future that we are all excited about so you can get your value from your bank account directly into your crypto visa card without having to go through any crypto bank intermediary which is just absolutely fantastic so in order to get started go to monolith.
xyz and get your bankless visa card today I want to tell you about another bankless tool that I personally use it's fantastic this one is for our US listeners it's called rocket dollar so if you have an IRA or a 401k the problem is it's jailed inside of your brokerage show so your fidelity account your Schwab account that means you don't have good access to crypto the only crypto that you can buy is in a trust form and it's marked up like five x six x eight x the price you're getting ripped off so what you need to do is break your retirement account out of jail set up something called a self-directed IRA or self-directed 401k we've written articles about this on bank lists that will include the show notes rocket dollar takes care of all of the pain in getting set up they help you with the paperwork you can break your retirement account out of jail and also use the bankless code to get fifty dollars off so make sure you use that code bankless when you sign up on rocket dollar dot com to get fifty dollars off all right let's go ahead and get right back into the interview with Andre so we can finish up learning about the year in protocol okay Andre so let's let's do our best to recap where where we are so far so you first built out this stablecoin system that moves stablecoins around to access the best yield in the various DeFi protocols and that was that's kind of like layer one and then curve gets introduced which has the curved tokens a curved stable tokens which kind of do this in a more or less automated way and then you started to stitch that into the year in protocol as well kind of like as a layer two on on top of it right and so and then you created these products from the year in system that were are useful products useful building blocks in DeFi useful money Legos and that they also encourage activity in the curve system because the curve system and the year in system are very are like siblings right they're like stitched together very very tightly and and we're not done yet right like we still have like another layer took a perhaps even two layers to go before we're really finished off with the all encompassing year in system however at this point in time how would you disagree in a concise way as possible how would you describe the year in protocol up to this point like what is it what does it do for people at at this stage in the game it automates yield that's that's the most app description I've managed I I sometimes refer to it as a smart savings account which I'm not a huge fan of because you know your your money is always spendable like you like you never lock it up but but but it's it's it's a yield optimizer that's that's its entire purpose okay now what where's the next stack because at some point in time yield farming with governance tokens comes into play here are we at that point yet this this is now when comp launched yeah so so when comp launched they they they were very kind to to both destroy and recreate the whole game which was very exciting because it it gave me a lot of reinvigoration to to engage and so so technically this isn't actually completely true so so in after why pool at that time this synthetic steam we're looking for for something to help their their s usd keep stronger to peg so started working the year in protocol the curve protocol and issue is dean we launched a new pool which was a metapool between the light tokens and the issue is detoken and the output token of this the LP token you get for depositing into this pool you could stake in the rewards contract and it's that same rewards contract I used for my Wi-Fi distribution and that's how I knew about it because back then you would stake the LP token and you would get S&X every week and it was it was by far the most profitable strategy of all of the yield strategies so so so technically I stand corrected in saying that that like like the cycle definitely started because of that hype but but liquidity incentives or liquidity mining started there and like that that mentor rewards pool from S&X was was was the first of its kind and I think everyone else is just playing off of their playbook but what did happen with the the the comp token it added a new option so so now it was a question of which one is higher yield and and the intricacies of the comp token made it also more interesting because for the first few weeks you ended up borrowing as much that as possible and then winding a leverage position so that you could earn as much comp and that's because of the comp distribution model at the time which was based on the size of the the the debt that is accrued on the market and then they changed that model and it changed to to a leverage position and die so you would again wind your position like that and and that had the best ratio and then and then I think next it was valencer that came out with mta and I mean shortly after that it was a challenger with bell and then it was m stable with mta and we're still waiting on the curve token to come out and there was another one that I'm missing oh umma with their y usd so so all of a sudden all of a sudden my my yield system was insufficient because it it no longer was aware of what the best yield strategy was because what the best yield was the definition thereof had now changed a few months before that it was it was um it was which lender provided the highest interest rates and in aggregate which of those could I get while depositing into into synthetics to be a liquidity provider there and get the liquidity incentives um but now all of a sudden you started having to do calculations about okay but what is my what is my wound up that position and how much debt am I accruing and what is the token value so what is the financial dollar value of that debt versus the amount of comp I'm getting and the comp's dollar value which offsets this interest so so now there's so many data points that that all of a sudden becomes a lot more tricky to manage and and one thing we know is that price data on chain is a very dangerous thing to use that's a very easy way to get attacked and that's why we need secure articles the available secure articles though don't have data for all of the things I just mentioned so so yield forming now all of a sudden was at a point where where where robo advisors could no longer do their job because they could not get sufficient data to do their job and they could no longer predict how to do this job so I started thinking about okay but now I need a model how to crowdsource this information because there's a bunch of us that are constantly and defying we're constantly hooked in and we we all have sleeping problems and none of us get more than half an hour sleep every every other four hours so so so we know what's going on and we know where to be so a large inspiration of why why the token needed to become into existence is to have a protocol to to to help these these yield farmers be able to make decisions such as what is the best strategy so objectively speaking what is the best yield strategy at this time and then based over this decision they needed to be able to update which strategy we go to but now now I have this problem where on the one side you've got people that that know that's the best strategy but they can't necessarily codify the strategies and I need someone who can codify these strategies as well and I need it a way to incentivize them to actually codify these strategies and then of course on the other side there's the LPs that still need to provide the liquidity for the strategy and then get through awards so so that's where that's where the V2 came out and that's that's my new YVolt system where where strategy writers can codify these strategies and if approved and voted in by governance that becomes the defective strategy for the current LPVolt and as I mentioned before you'll have one for USDC one for DAI one for Y curve etc.
Strategy writers are incentivized because they get a percentage of additional profit so what I mean by additional profit and this is where the system generates its rewards as well is based interest that the users get and that's to LPs and nothing else that's not touched then there is additional things you know there's there's comp there's MTA there's Bell there's SNX there's all of these other things in this ecosystem that that has additional value and off of that additional value that's where their rewards come from so so the strategy writer for argument sake gets 5% of all of those liquidated rewards that go back to the LPs and the governance decision makers they get let's say 10% or whatever governance needs to decide on those numbers the ones I've been using have just been I think no I'm going to lie to you now it is AT 1010 so so I needed to create this new ecosystem to be able to move fast enough to keep up with what is now happening in this market now I don't necessarily think it's going to last this way very long because I I do think liquidity mining is a is a negative game and we shouldn't try and incentivize it for too long but while it lasts I need this ecosystem that can manage these heel choices and do it in a way that is not based purely out of analytical data it can get on chain and that is the current that's the the first iteration of a why vault site that which was things like the the YUSDC and the Y curve vault and then as a little bit of a sideline I was doing this delegated vault work with with Ave where they want to do delegated credit so they want to be able to say okay well I'm a I made a positive or an Ave and I have $10,000 worth of of a credit line and I'm going to assign $1000 of that to my to my buddy so he can then borrow from my vault he can borrow his credit line so the delegated vault were actually a continuation of that idea where I use the original capital and then deploy the underlying best asset for the highest heeled strategy and then it that ends up being this this whole buyback strategy that benefits the vault and I'm actually really happy with how that turned out it actually turned out much better than I had originally expected and that's that's sort of the current iteration where we're at so so it's it's it's gone from everything happens on chain to I need collective information off chain to be able to to to manage and dictate the system okay so this is brilliant and I hope people are starting to understand the brilliance of what why owners put to get what why aren't his put together what Andre has put together but let me just recap for folks that are getting lost in some of the asset names and that sort of thing like here's the through line so we've been talking on bankless about yield right ever since inception the first chapter of yield has been lending and borrowing yield in DeFi and then the second chapter which opened up we had a Dan Ellitzer on the podcast what we'll add a link in the show notes but that chapter started with the comp token and then yield was super charged with these governance tokens right and I've I've often joked that like I can I'm in the space 24 hours a day so is David and we can't keep up with all of the yield farming opportunities I've I've joked that I need to hire somebody to go to my capital to keep up with all of the yield farming opportunities and optimize that so this is what this is the beauty of wire in Andre system is that rather than hiring someone and a fund you can hire the wire and money robots Andre's money robots that's why people love this because the money robots are really finding the the highest most optimized yield farming opportunities in both lending and borrowing now these governance tokens and what Andre just said is the first phase of all of that has been money robots that he wires up and programs himself for his own use but then he makes available to the public but now the next stage of that is to get strategy writers to tweak the money robots and create these new money robots and then send them with YFI tokens wifey tokens that's what this is that's really what we're talking about guys I hope you see the the through line this is sort of a a way instead of you know hiring the guy to go find all the yield farming opportunities you just hire the robot and everyone kind of crowd sources that the the most optimal way to do it it's it's really genius I Andre I want to ask a question here before we get to the wifey tokens themselves and talk a bit more about the the crowd sourced yield farming strategies can you just do a quick recap of what some of the risks are here just like high level so if I'm depositing my funds into you why earn what are the risks like I could lose it all but how how would I lose it like one of the protocols that are dependent that Uranus dependent on that are critical to its function I mean highly dependent on the strategy so so I in if you look at protocol top level and you look at what it operates on top of I'd say everything there's there's nothing in DeFi that there's nothing in Ethereum that it doesn't touch us if you look at a specific vault and a specific strategy then it's more isolated so you know then it's then it's then it's it might be a balancer pool or it might be a bank or v2 pool or it might be lending and compound so so so so then it's slightly more isolated I mean your your your your numbers one your number one biggest risk is is always we I always start that where where is the money so so if if the the money is sitting in a balancer pool then that is your highest risk point because that's where people see the money and that's where they attack it now luckily and this is why I also only like to use protocols that have you know stood a little bit of a test of time or are so simplistic that that it is only a smart contract and nothing else can happen so so so that's normally your number one point but but that's normally also a little bit safer because these are normally large corporations and lots of audits and lots of eyes looking at it and lots of scrutiny which is good your your next layer is is always my code there as as as much as I I try and make sure as I said my money goes in which means I I I need that for my livelihood but at the same time that's your your technical biggest risk because it's one guy that wrote it while he was sleep deprived it's not a good good combination like like that's not that's not where you should be putting your money so so and since that can be the the entry and the exit point which means it does the calculations on how much of the underlying asset you get so that's that's a very high danger point because that can be manipulated and I've seen it be manipulated so so definitely a high risk there um you you start talking about about lower risk but probability risk stuff so like a a a if USDT now for example were to add a fee to their token transfer which which they can do because it's in their smart contract a lot of my systems would break and when you deposit you'd actually get back less than what you put in um if if there's a if there's a compiler bug in the version I use which I'm I normally I have a leniency towards um 5.
17 then then that can be exploited in all of my contract systems if there is a liquidity crisis in one of the the downstream sources and this can happen a lot because remember you're you're you're often in in a lending position which means there's a borrower on the other side and if if something horrible happens and there's a price that's when you want your money out but that's also when most people are borrowing the money and the utilization rate is high which means you can't actually get access to it so so so that's definitely a systematic risk I I like to call it impermanent locks because you know based on the time it can be locked but in in its entire position you you will always have access to it unless it's trained from the underlying position um I've mentioned code vulnerabilities I've mentioned the the the composability is always dangerous I mean any system each time you add a a a building block your your exponentially increasing um potential risk and and this management um so with regards to the various DeFi protocols that are uh an option to receive yield in urine like there's you know compound balancer and stable like all these different DeFi protocols and each one is a risk but with regards to where the funds are currently deposited by urine there's a chance that like something breaks that doesn't actually impact the current uh way that urine is receiving real yield right so like urine could be depositing most of the of the funds into a combination of like M stable and balancer and compound breaks and and compound breaking doesn't actually impact urine at that present moment because the funds haven't been deposited there but yeah urine governance needs to remove compound from the algorithm correct before it something does happen that is that right that is a hundred percent accurate so so so I've been I've been manually managing that since Jan Finn um but again it's based purely on my perception which is a lot nicer if it's you know a crowd-based source decision so but but 100 percent correct if if there is all of a sudden a a scare that there is high vulnerability somewhere so there's some rumors that something bad is happening at X and it's up to governance to pull those funds as quickly as possible so one other primitive that possibly could be incorporated in this is if we had some sort of DeFi insurance primitive right yes we could use the composability of DeFi to our advantage um Nexus Mutual anything popping in mind for that because I'm sure you'd love to incorporate some insurance if it was available and if you could yeah now I've I've I actually spoke to to to you from Nexus Mutual in this week um they're they're going to roll it out either I think this week or next um that that it has a a base layer staking system which allows me to take a percentage of deposits out at the users opt in choice and then it takes that percentage as a as a base layer stake in Nexus Mutual which then gives them cover on the other side very cool and that would cover them for smart contract technical style hacks is that correct technically no because the way the way Nexus Mutual works it's it's like like I always like to say it's not actually insurance it's more like a binary option so so the people that are the people that are staking funds against a smart contract they're saying they have confidence it's not going to fail the people taking insurance are saying I have confidence it's going to fail but but it's actually just a hedged binary bit um but but it's up to it's up to the people staking on that contract to actually decide what they pay out for so so so Nexus Mutual has paid out for things that were not smart contract because they they felt it it it was good to pay those risks out so so they it's it's a lot more about perceived about what happened so so from from the payouts I've seen basically Nexus Mutual pays out when they feel the the there was nothing the user could have done to prevent it but if there was something the user could have done to prevent it then they don't pay out so so so it's it's less technical and and more what do those stakers vote for when someone submits a claim so Andre we've gone through what happens when you deposit stable coins crypto dollars into the urine protocol we've gone through how you've developed this yield maximizing system uh then we went through how you integrated the the yield farming and liquidity mining uh revolution of DeFi so that the it value of the governance tokens being earned or is also integrated into the profit maximizing system now we're at the last layer the the yf i token the wifey token this is the the capstone to the whole thing and in my mind I kind of view this thing as like a it's a structure right and it's building itself and then at the very top of the structure is the yf i token can you explain uh the the role and reason of the yf i token uh in the urine protocol so so as mentioned with with this new vault structure um there needs to be certain off-chain decisions that need to occur in terms of what is the highest yielding strategy um and and at its at its at its highest level that that is its pure function it is to make those decisions but if you drill it down there's there's a lot of minutia you know there's there's what percentage goes to the contract creator what percentage goes to the original urine protocol and the people using that system if if if a new token were to be air drop for whatever reason um what goes to LPs and what goes to whomever um so so so there's a lot of unknown I want to say and a lot of known which are protocol decisions that that need to occur and and for the longest time I've been making these decisions my whole time but it's it's also getting to a point like like you mentioned you need to hire someone that's that's capable of of watching this the whole time and being aware of this the whole time and then I'm in that same position so I need to crowdsource that information I I would like to have a solid eight hour sleep not having to wake up every two hours because there's a new heel farm that popped up and it's only going to last for the next 40 minutes so in those cases it's good to have this ecosystem and and like like I said and and it wasn't tongue in cheek it was sincere the original reason I distributed this token and I also want to emphasize that it was a token distribution it wasn't a liquidity incentive but the original reason why I distributed this token was to be able to hand off some of these responsibilities so it's not just me taking care of it it's not just me making these decisions it's not just me implementing these strategies and deciding where the capital should go that's how you're that's how you're scaling it basically that's that's how I get to scale the system that's that's how I also get to take a little bit of time off and and I know it's in the hands of people that are also as healed obsessed as I am and and and that's why I distributed to the the three protocols I considered to be where the healed farmers are farming the most healed because I wanted to get it into the hands of people that are as intimately familiar with everything that's going on as I am so as a mental model for for our listeners this is not unlike mkr and mkr governance where you know we call maker dao a dao and in the name dao it's a decentralized autonomous organization right and so the important thing is like autonomous is a little bit nebulous because maker dao needs concrete like proposals for the dao to vote into the protocol right and so at the end of the day humans with mkr vote in governance proposals you know what collateral to accept what risk parameters to provide them they manually vote in the those parameters and that's the same thing that's going on with the YFI the wifey token in the urine protocol where somebody is proposing a strategy and then with YFI holders are accepting or denying that that contract right that that's exactly it so so so at its highest level it is that is its primary function and purpose it is it is to enable people to be able to make those collective decisions on the system and the protocol for for their own greed and the greed of the LPs and with the the the wifey token it means those two are aligned so unlike how mkr was distributed and unlike how any other defy token has been distributed wifey token was distributed in this very unique way can you kind of go through your thought process and your decision making with how you enabled the the wifey token to be distributed among Ethereum?
I I wanted to distribute that's that's I I needed to distribute a a mechanism whereby people have a voting right to these decisions thanks to the as mentioned previously the the yield farm with the s usd I had intimately worked with the the s and x rewards contract which was developed by Anton from one inch along with Kane from synthetics and and it was a very elegant distribution mechanism so simplistically every week they would they would transfer tokens into the contract and then they would notify the contract that they have transferred tokens into it and then over that week the tokens are distributed to the LPs to the people that provide liquidity to the s usd pool so I thought this is the perfect mechanism because the the people using my system are using Y curve because Y curve is built on top of year so these are the people that are the heeled Hunters and that is why I launched the pool one and that is why I I distributed to there the first time now now now people always want to know why what decisions and and and and what rationale and I like I think people want to believe I'm smarter than I am when when the the most logical answer is usually the correct one I'm a very strong believer in Occamiser and and the reason I chose 10,000 wasn't some meme it wasn't it wasn't for any purpose it was just I wanted some low number that can represent voting shares you know I didn't want someone to have 1.
3 billion voting shares and I also didn't want someone to have you know 0.04 so so it was just a nice round number that I could use that that when it comes to voting is sufficient and originally I wanted to do I wanted to do four pools because I actually wanted to incentivize my other products as well Y swap and Y trade but after the first two pools blew up I didn't want to incentivize those two because they were they I consider them higher risk than the rest of the protocols because they haven't we've stood the taste of time yet and they haven't had much AUM and as much much eyes on them so so I decided not to incentivize those two because I was worried that the capital goes in is going to attract the wrong type of attention so so I switched that and stayed to to things like like balancer and the curve pool again but but really the there was no there was no master plan there was no thought out solution it was it was a accidental and somewhat lucky sequence of events with a positive outcome but it was really as simplistic as that it was I needed the distribution mechanism for people that use my system and yours 10,000 tokens to make decisions on.
So some people in DeFi would argue that this is the fairest launch of any token ever there was no pre-mine no founders reward no VC yeah some people are even comparing you Andre to the Satoshi of DeFi which is kind of funny so but but when you launch this in your opening post you emphasize you couldn't have made it more clear you said we don't we didn't stress it enough this token wifey has zero value don't buy it earn it and yet when I look at the charts it's like wifey is one of the most explosive price charts I've ever seen in crypto so it started at three dollars you know kind of at launch and then a week later was up a hundred percent so people don't believe you Andre people think it does have value can you explain why a rational actor would pay for wifey tokens no okay why are they do like so so I think what you're saying in that is that these are not rational actors so so so so so the one thing I really like and the wants the framework as he was the first one to pick it up which which I I I had it in the back of my mind but but I never really thought about it and it was very interesting because because I I had always thought about the year and system from an LP perspective because that's what I have you know I want to put in a hundred bucks and I want to see 10 percent whatever growth over the year and then when I pull that out I want to see 110 bucks and then I'm happy but at the same time you know now this thing was sitting with with with 100 million plus in capital I mean at its peak I think it was just over the the 600 million dollars which by the way terrified me to no end it's far too much money to put in my contracts don't do that 600 million I mean what that was got to be the top five in the total value lock lock charts right I that's a different discussion I mean TVL I think is such an absolutely pointless metric for us to use in the space it is insanity sure because like you you can have a billion TVL but no fees and then it's it's it's a much less than the guy with a thousand bucks but 50 percent fees but anyway that's a different conversation in terms of like PE ratios on systems but but a lot of these a lot of these VCs and trading firms and things they they started looking at from the perspective of being the controller of this ecosystem because now if you're the controller of this ecosystem all of a sudden you're not just this degenerate yield farmer that just wants to maximize your own gains because you're an LP but but but but you're a capital deployer you you have a hundred million dollars of capital now that you choose where it gets deployed to and that is also an incredibly powerful leverage tool because now all of a sudden you can start having a very different conversation with you know a a or a component or whatever and you tell them okay but I can deploy this capital to you can you give us extra incentives so so so so all of a sudden being able to make those choices is basically being able to make the choices of you know one of one of the biggest funds in the decentralized space because that's what urine has ended up becoming one of the biggest funds of deployable capital and and I it it it was this amazing like like light bulb moment when when he tweeted about it and and I read his tweet and I was just like holy hell this guy gets it um so so I sort of understand it from that perspective and I I I get it from from the LP because you know his money is in that system and so he wants to have the vote in where it goes because he wants to maximize it otherwise he's going to move it out but but there isn't really an alternative to move it to other than you need to do it yourself um because because a lot of the guys I speak to on a daily basis even even they when when they want to go away for the weekend they they they take their funds and they throw it on my vaults because you know they they they know how to farm themselves but when they just want to take a little bit of a break that Rover have the vaults to it because they know that then they don't have to worry about it so so so from the LP there's a reason why I want I want some say in it from the capital deployment there's a reason I'd want to say in it so so I I guess that is my most logical explanation for why someone would attach a financial value to that kind of control um I still don't get it but but as mentioned like fairly early in the start I I don't understand the speculative side I've never understood why a token really goes up or really goes down other than something to do with green frogs and something with forechan so so so so I I can't fully understand the why um and I'm not someone that that that bought tokens for speculative reasons other than if I was going to use it so so I'm I'm also probably not the most informed to answer that question but but if I had to look at it from a very from a very governance control perspective I'd I'd I mean I want some of the tokens so that I can at least ensure that it doesn't go to a place that I don't trust we were right so so I think so um you've answered you mentioned from framework right they're a they're a fund basically and I believe they announced this week or maybe it's last that they purchased a bunch of waifi tokens and the bankless thesis for some of these governance tokens is basically sort of along the lines of what you said but you know it's it's sort of a next step too so once you have tokens once you have governance over the protocol that gives you voting rights that gives you the ability to vote in cash flows potentially and convert a mere governance token to a capital asset essentially I think that's along the lines possibly of what VC groups like investors like vans are thinking does that sound plausible to you I do not have enough knowledge or information about like like that world so so I I can't make an informed decision there unfortunately so I'm going to hammer on this one more time and see just to see if I I can get something out of you Andre the way I evaluate with the waifi token is that it it's a great way to earn interest on your crypto dollars on your stablecoins and at the same time it's also a great way to responsibly earn governance protocols and so why earn why earn is not only a you know a crypto dollar yield farmer but it's also a governance token yield farmer right and so it seems to me that it kind of fits like this barbell strategy if investing where like you have your you know your non speculative stablecoins and you earn an earn an interest on that but at the same time yearn is also earning the governance tokens of other protocols right and so the waifi value capture system has baked into it like two upsides it's the interest it's the earnings on the stablecoins and then it's also the earnings on the governance protocols so like it's a the why why if I is a governance token that earns you governance tokens over any defy protocol ecosystems governance token and so like you know insert your next defy protocol here compound balancer meta stable curve anybody that has like a governance token that governs over the cash flows the yearn and and why if I token is a system for accruing those tokens and so it's like a meta governance token accrual system does that did I go wrong with that is there something wrong with that analysis or is that generally on the right track so so I don't want to admit that that's on the right track because then there is a a definable financial value you can attach to it and I really don't want people to do that like like stop attaching financial value to the dumb token just use it for governance just make protocol decisions people but but yes your your your your your summary is correct in that by virtue of having that token you make those capital deployment decisions and by virtue of those decisions you you you you end up choosing which of those I don't know if we can call them governance or liquidity tokens but whichever it is you you you indirectly can make the choice of which ones you actually farm up the funny thing about markets is that they are so unpredictable and who would have predicted that such value would be assigned to the wifey tokens certainly it is hard to predict even for folks who are in the space every day but let's let's talk more about the governance itself so there is a thriving why earn governance community it's one of the most I would say organic communities I've seen in in DeFi and I think why earn in yourself Andre it should be really proud of that can you talk about some of the decisions that governance has made already maybe you know one that comes to mind for me is actually a fixed cap for the token itself like an issue in schedule for the token itself maybe talk about that or some of the other governance decisions that have already been made I don't really think there has been an impactful decision made yet the first vote I thought was going to to cap issuance and I was kind of happy with that and then that got overturned at the end and now we've we've got this open-ended issuance which was interesting and then substrate had done his synthetic based proposal which which I really liked but I'm also I'm also glad that it didn't pass specifically because you know there's there's no reason yet to mint more token and and and I like to do it the the the need first way around so so I'm a very strong advocate of let's identify and expense and then let's vote on that expense you know instead of let's have capital and then decide where we deploy it there's there's there's definitely a a a lack of of quorum on that one and and which way it's going to go so so so I find it very entertaining watching I was annoyed with the the proposal because that was that was the issuance of the is an x-style system which I had then coated those contracts and then an hour before and and I mean four was winning by by a resounding mention and then Andrew Kang went on a whole campaign on Twitter and he ended up getting a bunch of the big holders to swap their vote I think it was like an hour or two before closing and then I was sleeping so so I I wake up and I see the vote failed and that means I wasted all of that time building this smart contract sorry I'm gonna wait about that but but that's that's fine I I would have preferred spending that time on my vaults but anyway the the witch vaults get voted in next was quite a cool one because that that allows other communities to rally around it as well that was 33 and the the link marines managed to to overthrow that one quite easily me being on this podcast another another good example maybe the best so so we'll put that right at the top so so but it kind of makes sense because we're still early days but but for now I'm still seeing a lot of indecisiveness when it comes to to the way forward and I understand that as well because I I think a large part of it is a knowledge gap because like a lot of people a lot of people put into this and and they want to get strongly involved but but I I am just a div like like I bold I deploy so so I'm I don't have a bunch of marketing materials I don't have executive summaries there there aren't you know extensive pages of documentation so so so a large part of it I think is this knowledge gap between what I've built and what they know about it and like catching up to it and then understanding where are all of the points of control and all of the decisions so so I think the indecisiveness is good from that perspective because it it's indicating to me that people need to learn more first but it's I I can also see the engagement is decreasing because of the indecisiveness because a lot of people feel okay but you know if no decisions are going to be made there's no point in me participating in the decision so so I do like to sort of flip it between more serious decisions and then smaller decisions just just to keep it a little bit more engaged but but it's it's interesting to see how it involves and and it it's very interesting to see the very distinct different communities you know the the people that are are looking it from a purely a purely token governance perspective because because there's definitely a group that doesn't really care about governing yearn but instead care about governing the token itself and and I I I do attribute a large part of the token success and when I say success I mean it's it's it's it's acceptance it's distribution because I'm very happy with with the the distribution percentage and you know how how how how little is centralized to to a single entity or group I am I lost my train of thought there because I went into a different thought from the first and oh what did I say just before that you know so I have a question for you so you know I was mistaken you why why why the issue in tazin been decided yet by the governance process but you have the platform today and unbankless what what would you like to see like personally what would you what would be your choice for wifey issuance I don't see any reason to issue more I I I don't see value in incentivizing liquidity providers because they're just going to move their liquidity as as soon as as it's no longer there the the the the rewards and the fees generated by the system if so chosen can cover the current operational expenses which you know are small because that's the beauty of deploying stuff on a theorem there's there's almost no upex other than the website and you know that cost me a few hundred dollars a month so so depending on on how you want to scale this thing up there there isn't a requirement for additional capital now the one reason why I originally wanted a longer distribution schedule was how I had pictured this play out was the first week goes by and probably no one gives a damn about it and it's just me sitting there with the little bit of money I have in the reward system earning this tokens and I end up having the majority and then I use those tokens I earned as the next week incentive and then hopefully someone else comes in and you know takes five percent of it and then the next week I use the ones I got again so so I I had originally considered a much longer issue in systems because I thought it was going to take a much longer time to get it to a level of distribution where it wasn't just you know two or three guys that have all of the tokens in their wallets but first week cleared that without any issues so so and and I'm confident that a very large portion of the token holders are are healed farmers or at least involved in the healed space in some fashion so that they are the right people to make the the protocol level decisions so so personally I I would like to see a little bit less focus on the token issuance and just touching on the previous point I've forgot to mention is is I I wanted to comment that I think a large part of the success of the token is because governance controls the token because I think that's something that definitely differentiates it from most other tokens out there but but but that's not being the point now is that is that there's there's there's no what what benefit is there assuming non-financial requirements to issuing more the the only reason you would is if you wanted to to add a a new partner that you think could add value and then you do a standard shared illusion which I don't see happening anytime soon I don't see purpose in doing liquidity incentives there isn't a capital requirement it's distributed enough to the point where where the correct people are making the governance decisions so so why why why add more so I have a potential answer to that question because at at the beginning of this podcast you you came on and said that you're really tired and that you don't sleep very much and that you're kind of overworked and and you kind of want to take a break and I see that as a symptom of this super fair distribution that has gone on which is one unfortunate repercussion of that is that we don't have a way to fund development right and and again this goes back to why VCs exist in the in the first place and so do you do you see a role for a year in governance to direct cash flows to a a fund that pays for you know year in development and that could even go to compensating you Andre if that's what you're interested in or I could just go into hiring a an assistant for you or just building out the development and formalizing the development of the year in system out of either YFI issuance or capital you know fees on the capital in the protocol being directed toward the team are you interested in either of these two things playing out yeah so so the proposal I proposed on the forum currently and I'm waiting for people to to discuss before I open a new improvement protocol is specifically let's let's redirect all of the current system rewards into a a capital pool and we take expenses from that and then wherever it's you know quarterly or annually or or whatever it is at that point in time pay out dividends to the token holders but before then everything goes to to to to up x expenditures so so so so that is the proposal I made but it seems most token holders would rather have the dividends than an operational company um so we'll see how that one plays out I'm curious to see but but but that is what I I currently have suggested um and and to to add on to I think a large part of my current fatigue is is that that informational gap that knowledge gap I spoke about like a few minutes ago just now is that is that a lot of a lot of my energy is being pulled from people trying to understand the system better and that's a good thing because they're trying to to to educate themselves to the point where where they are then capable of autonomously doing it themselves but they need that knowledge transfer first and and that knowledge transfer is is is tapping me out because because that's that's that's where all of the engagement is happening and like I've I've spent fatal now you know I haven't really spoken to anyone it's it's full lockdown year so I haven't even lived the house since then um so so now having high social interaction is is is is very draining but but I think it's to do with that knowledge transfer and I think when that knowledge transfers has occurred and everyone knows all of the caveats of the system then then that picture will look better and and then I think there is enough operational cash flow to incentivize those people to do it in a more full-time or at least committed part-time perspective um and and and just closing the loop that's why that's why again I don't think additional token issuance is required other than people that you know want to increase their own capital value and or increase their own rewards which which neither I think are are healthy so Andre with the year in system the year in protocol no one can really predict the future because it's up to the governance right like the governance decides what the future is however if you had to guess what year in would look like in two three four years or maybe what you are hopeful it will look like in that time period can you kind of paint us a picture of of what you are envisioning when you see a maximally successful year in protocol yeah so so there's there's there's always this quote I love to give people um because people always assume that I have a plan or they always assume I thought any of the stuff out um it wasn't the the Heath Ledger Batman movie where where where he tells um Harvey um do I look like a guy with a plan I'm I'm just a dog chasing cars I I wouldn't know what to do with one if I caught up to it summarizes me perfectly so I I know what I want to build tomorrow and after I've built that I know what I want to build after that but there is no way in hell I'm going to try and predict what this thing looks like a month from now let alone two years from now um a month ago I couldn't have told you we would be having this conversation now about what has happened and when I started building it in fab definitely not so so so I'm I'm not even going to attempt to to play that prediction game um if you want to know what I'm currently working on I'll gladly share but don't tell me don't ask me further than that because because I I I'm as informed as everyone else's yeah okay so what is actually concretely in the roadmap or not even in the roadmap but currently being worked on what what are the concrete things that are in development quote unquote well the the delegated vaults I'm very excited to finish off now um after I finished the delegated vaults and we've loaded in a few more of the the native vaults and we've added a few more strategies which probably the next two to three weeks um then I'm planning on going back to iTrade and finishing that off because those leverage trades are still very very good in terms of of of healed on the on both the LP side and the additional volume on the pool side and now that we have so much capital sitting in those pools we we can do much larger trades which is also very nice so so I'd I'd like to see that as a sort of you know stablecoin trading platform um I after that I did want to go back to to iSwap my amm but at this point you know one inch is launching one um black hole swap is coming out with their one uh bankruptcy too is not really so so so I'm first going to see if one of these guys covers the bases um the way I wanted to do it and if they do I'm just going to use their systems because I also don't want to spread out my development capacity to them um probably do one thing well then three things kind of shitty so so so so that I know I'm going to be busy with for like the next month um and then after that I'll re-evaluate and see what's going on in this market Andre I want to thank you for coming on the bankless podcast um even though you didn't have a choice this was you were voted into it but uh you know we had fun and we hope you did I I'm hopeful that you get some rest in the coming days I know the DeFi community the Ethereum community is thankful for the work that you've contributed uh and I love what you said at the ending um it can be a strategic advantage not to have a concrete plan that stretches foreign to the future and just be agile and flexible uh thank you so much for spending some time with us Andre thank you for having me guys it's um it's it's it's nice to have a little bit of break and then be able to talk so that there's a little bit of um perspective coming back as well so I really appreciate it absolutely all right bankless nations some actions for you guys we will include a link to the the urine protocol and remember this code is tested in prod so if you put funds in Andre would be the first to tell the to tell you you could you could lose them all we'll also uh send a link we'll also drop a link to the urine governance form and you can see all of the organic activity that is happening there um lastly last action item for you we have a state of the nation episode seven where we talked with Darryl Lau who is a governor of the wifey protocol so catch that if you haven't yet that'll give you some more background on uh the insanity and the the craziness and the fun that is going on with wifey right now um lastly and this is super important in an episode such as this risk and disclaimers none of this has been financial advice a theorem is risky defi is risky we say it every single show you could lose what you put in but we are headed west this is the frontier it's not for everyone but we're glad you're with us on the bankless journey thanks a lot