Episode: #26 August 18, 2020
-----
Tools from our sponsors to go bankless:
----
What are the paradigms for investing in DeFi?
Charlie is an exceptionally bright & thoughtful investor in crypto assets at Paradigm...one of the leading investment firms in the crypto space. We talk institutions, yield farming, and DeFi protocols...and then we get into one of our favorite subjects. Is ETH money?
Or rather, does ETH need to be money in order to secure itself?
What is dirty little secret many Ethereans and Bitcoiners don't admit? Why is moneyness and security two sides of the same coin? Why won't transaction fees secure Bitcoin? This episode goes from great...to amazing. You won't find this depth of discussion anywhere else. Stay tuned to the very end to catch the conversation on economic security.
We cover:
Join us next Monday for a fresh episode!
----- Resources discussed:
----- Episode Actions:
Also...subscribe to Bankless YouTube to watch State of the Nation every Tuesday.
----- Subscribe to podcast on iTunes | Spotify | YouTube | RSS Feed
Leave a review on iTunes
Share the episode with someone you know!
----- Don't stop at the podcast!
Subscribe to the Bankless newsletter program
Watch Bankless shows and tutorials on YouTube
Visit official Bankless website for resources
Follow Bankless on Twitter
Follow Ryan on Twitter
Follow David on Twitter
----- Not financial or tax advice. This podcast is strictly educational and is not investment advice or a solicitation to buy or sell any assets or to make any financial decisions. Do your own research.
No summary for this episode yet.
This is how to get started, how to get better, how to frontrun the opportunity. This is Brian Sean Adams, I'm here with David Hoffman and you are here to help you become more bankless. David, how are you doing today? Oh, you know, just tending to my fields. There's been a new craze in liquidity mining and yield farming and so that's kind of captured my attention lately. It has been attention grabbing and we get into that a little bit with our guests. Yeah, what was your take on this? Yeah, Charlie noise, really smart guy and I was constantly reminded during our conversation with him is how young he is and that's kind of what gets me like so excited about the future of crypto and it's a part, it's a part of the future of crypto that's not coming in like one year, not coming in two or three or four years but it's really the whole generational shift is that these young, young individuals and I consider myself young and Charlie is even way more young than I am are going to come in as crypto natives and be thinking in crypto native terms and are going to really get familiar with economics with finance, with complicated crypto economic systems and they're going to be that's going to be their first monetary system and I think Charlie is a good representation of somebody who's coming of age as as these crypto platforms like Bitcoin and Ethereum, Ethereum are being understood by the greater world and so I'm very bullish on this younger generation of people that's coming up being crypto native and being able to speak crypto before they're able to speak traditional finance.
So do you know how old Alexander Hamilton was when he joined the revolution? I have no idea. 21. Sounds like Charlie, right? I mean, sounds like Charlie. We think of many of the founding fathers as people like George Washington, Ben Franklin and we see them in Wiggs and that sort of thing, we forget that so much of the revolution was fought and won by the very young Alexander Hamilton 21 Lafayette 19 years old. These are the vanguard of the revolution and why are they doing it? Because they think differently because they're exploring new opportunities and exploring the infinite white space of what could be and you know Charlie is in the revolution for those reasons.
So his story is fantastic. We also talk about some pretty in-depth subjects. So it starts off kind of higher level but then we get into something that is super important and rarely discussed. In fact, I've never heard it discussed on a podcast before and that is the economic security of Bitcoin and Ether and whether those assets Ether and Bitcoin need to become money in order to succeed. I won't spoil it for you but that is a fantastic section near the end that you absolutely have to check out. It's not 101 level or 200 level. This is 400 level material. I think you're really going to enjoy this important stuff to back up the thesis, your thesis for this space.
Yeah and what Ryan's talking about, what we were talking about in the podcast with Charlie, the minor extractable value component of these systems is really an unsolved problem in the crypto space. Largely being spearheaded by Ethereum researchers. And so I always keep an eye on what they're doing with the whole MEV world. We'll go into it in the podcast and make sure that we can explain it but I think it's going to become a regular topic in the bankless podcast because of how important it is. And so I'm looking forward to future content that in future guests that we bring on to discuss minor extractable value because it's a crucial topic.
Yeah and I think you will be most equipped to think about this if you've listened to a bunch of the other podcast episodes. This is episode 26 but people forget we sort of started this sequentially for folks that are new to bankless. Go ahead and go all the way back to episode one if you need to and start listening because it's sort of each of these episodes builds on the last and I think you'll get a great grounding just by starting with one and moving forward all the way to episode 26 which is where we are today. David before we go any further we should talk a little bit about our sponsors.
The first sponsor I want to tell you about is Ave. Ave is a DeFi protocol that you absolutely have to check out. What can you do with it? You can lend, you can borrow, banklessly all on Ethereum. So you can do things like lend die to the protocol. It will magically transform that die into an interest variant die account. Not just die all sorts of crypto assets on Ethereum. You can also borrow against it. Ave has been climbing up the leaderboard as well and they've recently released Avonomics which is their token economics upgrade. You can read more about it when we will include a link in the show notes.
So Avonomics grants key decision making to Ave token holders. It creates more safety and economic incentives to reward protocol growth. One of the coolest things is it actually introduces a safety module. So there is staked Ave becomes a collateral of last resort. You can find out about Ave. Avonomics start using the protocol at Ave.com. That's AAVE.com. For those of you that have been transacting on Ethereum you've noticed that the gas prices have just been insanely high. You know, 60-guay on a good day and sometimes all the way up to 100-guay which is really reducing the amount of activities that is really feasible to be able to do on Ethereum.
This is where our newest sponsor, Lupring, comes in. Lupring is a ZK roll-up scaling protocol for Ethereum for both trading and for payments. ZK roll-ups, that stands for zero-knowledge roll-ups. It's basically cryptographic magic. It allows you to combine activity and transactions into one single bit of information, which means that massive amounts of transactions can be bundled into a very small chunk of information which reduces the gas per transaction. At Lupring.io you can find a ZK roll-ups based exchange and also a payment mechanism all with the same security guarantees of the Ethereum L1 blockchain, which is really important.
So Lupring and ZK roll-ups allows you to scale up transactions, trading, payments, into thousands and throughout thousands of transactions per second, but with the same security guarantees of the main Ethereum blockchain, which is just incredible. In September, Lupring is releasing the Lupring wallet. This will be a mobile smart contract wallet with ZK roll-ups tucked in natively. I'm really excited for how this is going to impact the adoption of Ethereum. The rest of the world will be able to experience Venmo type transactions, but with the same amount of trustlessness and security of the decentralized future ahead of us.
So if you're a trader that's being eaten alive by gas fees, visit Lupring.io to get onboarded into Ethereum's cheapest and fastest exchange. All it requires is an Ethereum address and you can trade on a high performance order book completely gas-free and transferring Ether and ERC-20 tokens on the platform is completely free. If you visit Lupring.io, enter the code bankless in order to get the highest VIP tier for six months. So check that out. There's a link in the show notes. Visit Lupring.io enter code bankless. All right guys, let's go ahead and get right into the interview with Charlie Noise of Paradigm.
Bankless Nation. We are super excited to introduce you to Charlie Noise as part of our venture capitalist series. Charlie is a partner at Paradigm. He is former Pantera. He's an incredible thinker in the space. We've had many back and forths on Twitter in the past. He's just a smart investor. Want to emphasize before getting into this, of course, these are his personal views. He's not speaking on behalf of Paradigm D fund, but he has offered to share his personal views and I think those will be very helpful as we think about the space. Charlie, how are you doing? Doing pretty well. Thank you guys for having me.
I know we can debate pretty frequently on Twitter, but I do think this is a really high-quality resource for the community. I'm excited to be on here. Yeah, the advantage of the podcast, of course, is we can carry those things into conversation format and everyone gets to hear about it. Charlie, what I think would be super helpful for our listeners is just to set the context and set the context in two places. Maybe first, your background, and then second, some of the background behind Paradigm because both backgrounds are fairly unique in this space. I was looking through your LinkedIn profile, Charlie, and you've got a very interesting background.
You started as a research scientist at USC, and I think you're doing that during high school. Then there's a point where you went to MITB, dropped out. Then there's this gap of three years, which I'm going to assume, but hopefully you tell us that three-year period is where you may be discovered crypto. Then the resume sort of continues where you're principal at Pantera Capital. Of course, we had Joey Krueck on a few episodes ago. We'll include that in the show notes. Then in probably 2018 or so, you became a partner at Paradigm, which for folks that don't know is I think one of the most interesting crypto funds that are out there.
It was co-founded by the co-founder of Coinbase, Fred Erism. It's got some other notable names, great research coming out of it. One notable thing, one of many, is that Paradigm was actually one of the first funds I believe to raise from a major endowment. In 2008, the Yale Endowment, that's a $29 billion fund, an institutional fund. You've heard the institutions are coming. Well, they came in 2018 and they invested in Paradigm. That's a little bit of background from my perspective, but I want you, Charlie, to help fill in the blanks, maybe starting at the top. How did you go from research scientists at USC in high school to partner at Paradigm?
So, I might need to update the LinkedIn, and I might have taken a little liberty with research scientist on the title there. I think at the time I was like 13, and I was in high school at that point working in a lab at USC that was doing some interesting cryptography research related to some of the earlier SMPC protocols, I'm first trying them like SPDZ, but I actually was in a crypto at that point. So, when I was like 11, a few years before, I was, you know, sound software on the internet and made a PayPal account in my mom's name, and then at some point, they requested her social security number, and she was like, there's absolutely no way that I'm giving this to you to go use on the internet.
So, I started using Bitcoin. And for a couple of years, I just thought it was kind of incredible. I mean, like at that point in my life, you know, it was like the only payment reel that I could actually use on the internet. And eventually, I think in around like 2013, went from kind of a user, casually interested, you know, mining on my own hardware, kind of before the ASIC era, to getting really into the more theoretical and research side of it, and wanting to understand sort of like the basis of these systems, and then got further into that, you know, through some early opportunities to do research, both related and unrelated to crypto, cryptocurrency, cryptography.
And then once Ethereum came out, I wanted to actually to dive in full time, but decided to leave high school to go to MIT instead, spent a year there, realized I was going to miss the boat if I didn't leave and decided to leave MIT to join Pantera, along with Joey, who you guys had on. It's a friend of mine. So yeah, that's kind of the really origin story. All right, so we talk a lot about the unbanked, right, in crypto in general, but I've got to be honest, Charlie, I've never thought about the unbanked preteens, right, like if the kids that are like between, I don't know, I guess eight or so, when they start to get semi-financiale literate and 18, who actually are kind of locked out of the financial system, and you came at this because you were locked out of PayPal, essentially, and crypto was like the only bank, I guess, the only finance, the only money you could really use at any level of scale.
That's crazy to me. Yeah, I mean, it's kind of a wild series of coincidences, and I think like many of the people in the space at this point, it is still so early that you kind of have to have a reason to be here, and I think most people have these kinds of backgrounds where it's just really strange sequence of coincidences that led you to being deeply interested in internet money and for ramble internet money. I want to spend all your time on it, but I got super lucky with that, and then I ended up at Pantera, I spent an awesome year there with Joey, and then in early 2018, I met Matt, who I got introduced to, also did MIT undergrad, and Fred at the time, Fred had left Coinbase the year before, spent a year thinking about what he wanted to do next, and then Matt got together, and then pulled me in in early 2018, and I just had it leaving go start something new with them.
So what's also cool, I think Charlie is, I think there are a lot of millennials, of course, and Gen X, and maybe the odd boomers, though, that listen to Bankless and tune into the Bankless Nation, you are representative of Gen Z, sort of this new generation. Do you think Gen Z is going to just grow up using crypto, just grow up crypto native, similar to the way the millennials maybe grew up with the internet, and became digital natives? I think it's very possible. I'm not sure that it's as much about crypto as it is about sort of not having learned bad habits around what money is or could be, but to be honest at this point, I don't think that crypto is sort of like more millennial money than Venmo.
I do think that we have the opportunity with young people to show them alternatives before they learn bad habits, and I think that a lot of the aversion to cryptocurrency, DeFi, this whole space that you might see from older folks more frequently than young is largely bad habits and ways of thinking they get reinforced over many years. So I do think young people are really, there's a reason that the space is broadly really young, but I'm not sure that it's so much millennials inherently love crypto as it's not as hard to convince them that this is just a much better experience than they can get anywhere else, and that should really be the North Star.
So let's turn a little bit to paradigm. You guys made headlines when in 2018, you got raised $400 million on one of those investors, as I mentioned, was the Yale endowment. So the institution definitely came. But can you tell us a little bit about the thesis of paradigm? So we've talked to many folks in the show. Everyone has sort of their way of thinking about crypto. They're paradigm, if you will, of crypto, right? Whether it's, you know, this is the Internet of Value, or we're building Web 3 in our goals to decentralize Facebook, or there's the fat-critical thesis, which was, you know, famously came out in 2016 and 2017 was sort of a guiding theory.
There are token maximalists we've talked to. There's people who believe in fat money that reserve asset money systems will be sort of the kings of crypto. How would you describe paradigm's thesis? So I think it's, it's difficult to sort of encapsulate in a one-liner, and there's certainly no lack of disagreement. You can just go watch us on Twitter, or, you know, healthy debate internally. I think that, you know, at the highest level, there are a couple of core thesis that we hold and are somewhat non-contentious, you know, in terms of public blockchains are very interesting. They're a novel form of technology.
The idea of crypto-economic security is novel, and there's something fundamentally interesting about the intersection of money, finance, and technology in a much more natural way than we've seen, you know, in sort of the Internet as exists today. Beyond that, I think a lot of the sort of more specific thesis that have floated around, and at different points, you know, risen to prominence, or, or been kind of the meta of the space, are probably too zoomed in to point out individually, but, I don't know, one that we're probably quite well known for is, you know, the general belief that futility token, or utility tokens, or futility tokens, you guys had a great quote on this earlier, and that, you know, ultimately, the ability to create value, durable, long-term value, is sort of like the core maximum that we should organize around, and, you know, to be honest, I think, especially with respect to DeFi and more of the frontier, that idea has taken longer to proliferate than I would have expected, but I'm not sure that it's actually sort of an out there idea anymore, which is really exciting.
So, Charlie, adventure capital firm is composed of many different people each with their own, you know, unique ideas, and I think when all those unique ideas come in coalesce, you generate like the thesis, the generalized thesis of the firm, but each individual person has their own thesis that may not, that may conflict or contrast with other members of the peers of a venture capital firm. So, how do your specific beliefs contrast with your peers at paradigm? Like, what do you believe as a thesis that maybe other members at paradigm don't disagree with? That's a great question. I'll pick out one that, you know, we haven't been shy about publicly debating and say, I'm probably more concerned about the long-term security of existing protocols in particular Ethereum, but not specific to it than some other folks on the team as kind of an urgent issue that will be confronted with quite soon and not in 10 or 20 years.
So, I definitely want to pocket that one because that's a topic that we definitely want to go into, but on a grander scale, how would, are there any examples of just like generalized like attitudes towards, you know, what is investible versus what's not, like equity versus tokens that is a constant, like what are the constant themes of conversation and paradigm that are frequently in debate? So, I think that one and probably the like internal debate is, to what extent we can rely on reflexivity or rather kind of assume that reflexivity will work out rather than work against us. And I think that there's many names that this idea goes by circularity, self-reference, recurrence.
I like reflexivity the best to describe it, but, you know, the core idea is sort of just, is embodied today in DeFi and sort of how far different protocols are willing to push, for example, yield farming, very highly reflexive idea, or make the assumption that they can sort of circularly support value or to what extent they can. And at least personally, I've been very much on the side of not wanting to lean into sort of highly reflexive security assumptions mostly is how I would characterize them, but at this point, I think those are the most interesting experiments that are getting run. And, you know, I suspect that like, it'll take a couple of years to figure out the set point, but it'll be very interesting to see what we can create.
So a comment on that reflexivity, I think our listeners might be more familiar with the term that me and Ryan use on this podcast, which is memes. Reflexivity is like a meme, right? And Bitcoin at its core is like a reflexive asset, where there's a little bit of game theory involved where, like, you know, if everyone else buys Bitcoin, like, you better also be buying Bitcoin, right? And so, do you believe that at the core of these things, there is a reflexive component that it's a part of the fundamentals of these systems? Yeah, absolutely. I think we'll get into this more later in the podcast, but I would say with absolutely 100%, and I don't think it's debatable, actually, but I actually meant on a more micro level when you get beyond sort of these core layer one protocols, which I think are in some way substantively different from, for example, applications built on top of Ethereum, or rather distinct from them, that sort of the amount of reflexivity that we have to lean into for these things to exist in the first place, or are comfortable leaning into, is quite different.
And so, I think, you know, the simplest example of this would be Ethereum miners are paid in Ether. It's entirely circular. The cash flows are denominated in the thing itself. Would we be willing to sort of accept the same maximum for a DeFi protocol, which earns cash flows in terms of itself, or perhaps is lending protocol collateralized by its own asset? And we could get into kind of like the notions of, like, you know, moniness versus equitiveness, the differences between monetary premiums and cash flow evaluation, I suspect we will, but that's I think kind of like the, that's a very abstract debate that has been playing out for years, and I expect we'll continue to play out for a couple more.
And I think like one of the most interesting areas of the space to watch right now. I would imagine that this debate that you're talking about is one of the many debates that all the partners and the members of paradigm have. And so, when you guys are debating about subjects like this, like going back and forth, sharpening each other's sticks, trying to get a grasp on the understanding of things, like, over time, how does that debate, like, evolve inside the firm? And like, because at some point, like, action needs to be taken as a result of, like, the opinions formed in that debate. So, like, how does paradigm go from, like, debate to action?
Like, what does that process look like? It's a great question. I think one feature that we only started to notice more recently in discussing some of these ideas more externally is how much we develop, like, an internal nomenclature that's almost inscrutable to anyone else. And then when you start tweeting about it, you spend as much time clarifying what you mean, as making the point that you want to. And which gets us into trouble. But, you know, in terms of, like, forming an investment lens, right? I think diversity of opinion is critical. But more than just diversity of opinion, sort of, like, open-mindedness, infinite open-mindedness, and a willingness to sort of consider that, you know, the shared investment lens that we arrive at as a team is going to be more considered than, you know, any one individual's opinion.
And in an iterated game sense, you know, a willingness on the part of the individual to believe that we actually should act as a group. Basically, that even if, you know, our shared investment lens might not agree entirely with my own personal views, then I'm always willing to extend the benefit of the doubt to my partners and colleagues that over time, where I'm wrong, you know, they'll help make sure that we don't make the wrong decision. So, Charlie, just talking a little bit more about investor education. And, by the way, we're just talking about YAMS just now. So, if listeners are totally unfamiliar with what the heck we're talking about, go check out Stay the Nation, I think episode nine came out by the time you're listening to this.
It will have come out last week, where David and I try to make sense of what the heck YAMS are. So, you can get caught up on that a little bit. But so, it appears to me, like, you guys paradigm put out a report called Bitcoin for the open-minded skeptic. And that's not a report for the crypto native, right? It's mostly review for people like us. But it seems to me to be the case, that Bitcoin is almost like the gateway drug for institutions getting into crypto. Like, it's 2020 now, and they're finally starting to become comfortable with Bitcoin as a store of value asset, as like a digital gold, as like something that's not just for criminals.
Would you say that's the case? Like, Bitcoin is the gateway drug, if you will. And then from that, institutions will start to get interested in other areas in crypto. Yeah, I think that's generally true. It's certainly the most legible narrative, right? The one that, as of right now, has been around the longest, sort of has the most both, I think, has the most social credibility just to be frank, right? And in many ways, is the easiest for a new entry into the space to underwrite, especially one working at sort of a long-term institution or investment partnership. And, yeah, the Bitcoin thesis, my partner Matt Huang wrote it, I think it's a fantastic synthesis of many of the ideas that have brought new folks from those areas into the space, and probably the most legible narrative to them today.
I do think that, once you're here, once you're kind of willing to make the leap of faith, you pretty quickly recognize how interesting the rest of the space is. Some folks decide to dive headfirst, some just decide not to write off kind of everything, everything else, or the space is a whole. But I think that from any perspective, it's just hugely net positive to see even the Bitcoin narrative alone becoming more legible and credible to a much broader group. So there was this meme, this narrative, going around in 2018. The institutions are coming, right? It was like the beginning of 2018 on the back of, on the tail end of the bold market.
I maybe want to ask you what you think about like are the institutions coming because it sort of didn't pan out the way the hype said it would in 2018. Although you guys managed to raise from some pretty large institutions in 2018. Now we're in 2020. Are like are the institutions coming or have they been coming all along? I think they've been coming all along. And you know it's, I don't think it would be unfair to say that the narrative that institutions were coming didn't pan out the way that some of us might have hoped. But I don't think it's the case that they're reverse to it. Or there was some binary event that broadly flipped people that were or could have been positive negative.
We just realized that some things take time. And I think that we have seen a slow, maybe slower than we would have hoped, but steady drip of folks coming into the space from traditional institutions. And I expect this to continue personally. And you know if I think my main takeaway from kind of having observed this process over the last few years, in particular, is that this is going to be a multi-decade game. And every time it feels like we found the thing or the narrative that will be legible or what will be kind of like you know well defined cryptos legacy or this era of cryptos legacy. We found out that it's probably going to take longer than we thought.
And I think that's just like pretty much broadly true of everything in the space. So Charlie, I want to pivot a little bit and talk about tokens and then get it kind of get into more current DeFi protocols, DeFi topics. But I want to first start with the progression of tokens as we've come to know them, right? So 2017 was kind of more or less like the birth of Ethereum to the rest of the world. Like Ethereum 2015, 2016, we didn't really know. No, the world didn't really know what it was or what it was going to do. In 2017, we kind of started to figure it out because we realized that the ERC 20 tokens standard could be pretty interesting depending on what you do.
And that was like the birth of utility tokens, which we've called like futility tokens. So futility tokens, like they sucked then, do they still suck? And what kind of progression have you seen in the concept of tokens that really makes you optimistic or or perhaps less so? So I think that futility tokens will always be futile, you know. I think that the topic wrote the defining blog post on this in like October 2017, if I remember correctly, and we didn't listen to them, I think more people are listening to them now. You know, tokens that give ownership to decentralized protocols are I think wildly interesting.
There's many different facets to them. Your ability to participate in governance is a feature of some others are really just strictly ownership in an economic margin that the protocol can extract by virtue of adding value to the world, the ecosystem, whatever you want to call it. Now, I think that to the specific question of futility tokens, it's kind of unfortunate that the economic model was just like so bad in 2017, to be honest. And it felt like, you know, talking about sort of real protocol cash flows was more or less shouting into the void. I certainly don't feel that way now. I think that that's kind of just become implicitly or just very slowly, kind of like the shared perspective of everybody in the space, or at least that's been my kind of observation in DeFi.
And that's super encouraging because, you know, for a new founder, really anyone that wants to start something in the space, it's really important that sort of the standards as to like what should you be pursuing are, you know, at least not futile to your earlier point. And if there is like anything in hindsight that I'm disappointed about with respect 2017, it's that there were probably some really great teams and ideas that just kind of shot themselves in the foot. And I hope that doesn't continue to happen. So since 2017, there's been a lot of iterations and innovation behind token design over the last three years.
What innovations have you seen that really make you that that turned something like a futility token into an investible asset? The turn of futility token into an investible asset. It's a pretty specific lens on it. I think just generally not necessarily, sorry, just to clarify, but not necessarily thinking of like futility tokens. And I think maybe it's helpful to define utility tokens really quick. To me, I define you futility tokens as something that suffers like the velocity problem, where it's just like a medium of exchange. It's just a inferior form of money in one specific case. Yeah. Yeah, it's like you spin up a candy store and then you print a token and say, okay, pay me in this token.
And that's that's right. But you only get the token by exchanging other currencies for it and the market for your candy shops, you know, currency probably is not super highly liquid. So right. That's kind of like the core. That's kind of the core problem, right? Like that's just not a workable economic model. It's not conducive to success. Regardless of how successful your candy store is, it doesn't really matter for the currency because it's probably unlikely that people are going to be willing to grant that a candy store's proprietary currency becomes a global currency competitive with like Bitcoin or you know, it's just it's fun for us.
This is the reason we don't denominate money and settle debts in Chuck E. Cheese tokens. It's right there. I mean, like you can use it. I do actually think if you if you Twitter search me like at Charlie Nois Chuck E. Cheese tokens, I have there are a couple of tweets. You know, I still have a few. So I don't know if they're still good, but for my childhood in my coin collection, I should check on that. Maybe they've appreciated in value. Yeah. So so as an economic model, like we've basically totally scrapped futility tokens, like no one's making a token like this anymore. So between 2017 2018, when we thought that they were all the rage and now where we understand that they are bad, what specific innovations have you seen come to replace the futilityness of tokens in DeFi?
Yeah. So I think basically the two dimensions are one real protocol earnings and two flexibility. So to the former point, I think Makerdow and Auger pioneered the idea that you know, a decentralized trustless protocol could generate earnings or rather a cashless stream in the way that it adds value to the world, right? Basically, like not not really dissimilar to any other traditional company except again, their trustless, you know, decentralized protocols. So of course, it's like could not be more dissimilar in practice. But I think that was like the first, they were the first kind of like fundamental innovations on this dimension, how it should be done, how you could think about how you could think about that as tokens being sort of the discounted future value of protocol earnings.
And that's basically through osmosis, enter the rest of the space. And that's how people think about designing tokens today. And that's awesome. The second dimension that is different, I think, is the flexibility dimension. So especially more recent experiments like YFI is a great example are certainly not taking like a bad or fundamentally incorrect economic model to a static idea. They're taking like a credible economic model to kind of an undefined idea with hypothetically a lot of future flexibility. Now like as to whether, you know, any specific one of these efforts will evolve into something real and meaningful, you know, that can that builds and can extract durable value.
I think that's an open question. But the idea that we have a good enough idea of what we should be shooting for to evolve towards it rather than sort of starting with this like very static idea for what you're going to do, which like 2017 white papers, basically it's like throw your idea down the table and never change it is, I think, quite important because inflexibility is potentially as kind of harmful to progress as bad economic models. By the way, guys, Charlie mentioned YFI token. If you haven't check out episode 25 where we talk with Andre, and I finally figure out what YFI token actually is and what it does.
It's a great episode on that. I guess Charlie, you know what would be interesting, I think, is I'm assuming that neither you nor nor paradigm would say that everything happening in DeFi is good and investible. That's kind of your job to figure this out for investors, right? I mean, I think to the earlier point, they are separable dimensions, like something can be good and not investible or not good. Well, it's not good. It's probably not investible, but good is kind of separate from investible. And I think that's important to keep in mind. Okay, so let's talk about that lens. Let's use the lens of investible.
Well, we go through some, I guess, categories. And maybe we'll start with the investible in good, right? Like good investments, I suppose, with things that you guys are betting on or you personally are betting on as you're speaking on behalf of maybe your personal penance here. And maybe we can go through some of the things that our public that paradigm has invested in. Most notable, at least to me, is probably a uniswap, which listeners will know is a liquidity robot, automated market maker that we've talked about a whole bunch on bankless. Why is uniswap a good investment? What was the thesis behind uniswap?
Yeah, so I think uniswap is built on a fundamentally interesting idea concept. The X times Y equals K or constant function market maker. And the team going after it is incredible. And very long term oriented. And the very high level way that we thought about it, think about it, and really, you know, would say it's kind of the definition of investible is credibly able to build long term value. And uniswap's case, I think, you know, there is, you can imagine a future in which the innovation, I think we're already seeing this play out to some extent, makes it so easy to create markets that we can run more experiments that allow us to create more markets, run more experiments, et cetera, et cetera.
And that it's almost in some sense a platform, an economic platform, as opposed to an individual product. So what's crazy about uniswap is I saw just on the last week, seven day volume. If you annualize that, it was something like 36 billion in annualized volume that they're doing now. Are you like, is that surprising to you? Those kind of numbers? I did not think we would be anywhere near where we are today for the next year. I thought it would take a lot longer. Definitely. It's been why, why has it not like, why has it been so fast? It's a very, it's an interesting question. You ask 100 people are getting at 100 different opinions.
I think, at the heart of it, people realized how interesting defiance and that allows you to run experiments on a pretty large scale really quickly and iterate quite quickly. It's kind of funny to say, considering that one of our biggest concerns is also the difficulty of writing slidity and getting your contracts audited and the deployment cycle being so much less iterative than traditional software development. But from a financial perspective, the speed of iteration, composition, remixing and remastering of all these different protocols and products is just unbelievable. And I think that at its core, that's really what's driving this kind of growth.
Hey guys, going bankless is a journey and you don't have to do it alone. So here are some fantastic bankless tools from the sponsors that make this show possible. As we all go westward, we need to get our values into the crypto world, but hopefully escape the tyranny of centralized rent-seeking institutions. And that's where monolith can help you get your value into the crypto world while skipping over the crypto banks. Monolith coming soon to monolith is an enraptor, directly from your old world bank account into your smart contract wallet on Ethereum. And for those that don't know, monolith also has a defy card which uses die in your smart contract wallet, but on the visa network.
So you can go to your grocery store, swipe your defy card, pay for your groceries like a normal person, and still be part of the crypto bankless, crypto economic future that we are all excited about. So you can get your value from your bank account directly into your crypto visa card without having to go through any crypto bank intermediary, which is just absolutely fantastic. So in order to get started, go to monolith.xyz and get your bankless visa card today. I want to tell you about another bankless tool that I personally use. It's fantastic. This one is for our US listeners. It's called Rocket Dollar.
So if you have an IRA or a 401k, the problem is it's jailed inside of your brokerage show. So your fidelity account, your Schwab account, that means you don't have good access to crypto. The only crypto that you can buy is in a trust form and it's marked up like five x six x eight x the price. You're getting ripped off. So what you need to do is break your retirement account out of jail, set up something called the self-directed IRA or self-directed 401k. We've written articles about this on bankless that will include the show notes. Rocket Dollar takes care of all of the pain in getting set up.
They help you with the paperwork. You can break your retirement account out of jail and also use the bankless code to get $50 off. So make sure you use that code bankless when you sign up on rocketdollar.com to get $50 off. Charlie, I want to wrap the Uniswap conversation on a bow with this last question. You talked about a potential, you know, gaining upside exposure to Uniswap via a fee via into the protocol. But we've seen people love Uniswap and also love these like new new liquidity mining, yield farming, DeFi protocols based on their credible neutrality, right? So like Uniswap has a fee that goes to the liquidity providers, not the team, right?
And then, you know, the YFI token is, you know, fair launch, you know, VC founders reward. And so as a fee model or some value capture model for Uniswap as a mechanism for upside exposure to the protocol seems to get in the way of it also being a credibly neutral protocol. Do you also see this problem or am I overlooking? I see the tension certainly. I think it's an unavoidable tension. And that's why, you know, the I throw the fee out quite hypothetically. I don't know if that will be the mechanism of value capture. And I think it's important to remember here that Uniswap, as it currently exists, someone's going to force you to move.
No one can force you to move us or the team. And to the extent that this, that that kind of value capture or any other is unacceptable to the community, they won't move where they will fork the protocol. And so I think there is both voice and exit in that dynamic. Now that being said, you know, does a fee erode the credible neutrality of the protocol? I don't think so. Does any kind of value capture mechanism? I don't think so. I think we need to figure out a sustainable way of funding these things. And the clearest answer is for their earnings to be directly tied to the value they create. Again, you know, the extent that users don't want to pay it or it's not the best venue, they'll go elsewhere.
And so, you know, it's it's a tough question to answer. And one that I think we're everybody is going to bump into. I'm not sure what it looks like long-term, but you know, I believe wholeheartedly that we need to figure out sustainable funding for the application layer. And I believe that that probably looks like protocol fees in some form broadly. But maybe it doesn't. Maybe there's an alternative. So Charlie tends to be the case where sometimes first movers win, right? And sometimes it's the second winners who win, right? It's not Yahoo. It's kind of Google who sort of solves it. Another interesting category I'm curious your thoughts on is the decentralized stablecoin category.
So all of us love die, right? Like a pioneer, you know, four or five years in the making really set the D5 market off. But you guys have recently invested in a, I guess a die alternative or die complement certainly another stable ish value protocol called rye if I'm pronouncing that correctly through reflects or labs. Do you think a second mover can win here? And what's sort of the thesis for rye? Sure. So before answering, I do think it's important to point out, you know, we led the most recent sale by the maker foundation of mkr tokens as well as underwrote the majority of the toxic credit, credit auction that took place after black Thursday from care.
So, you know, we have been for years supporters of maker and continue to be. That being said, I do think that reflexor is pursuing an alternative path rise of course most comparable to die. But the way that we think about it is as offering an alternative to die that does not rely as much on governance that is not pegged to one dollar, which, you know, is a core maximum that maker governance is trying to maintain. And I think as maker continues to grow, some ideas on the roadmap are going to be controversial with some factions of the community. Specifically, I think real world assets is, you know, one of the most obvious.
And even today you're starting to see some, I think, a version two, USDC and WTC, et cetera, being included in the protocol. You know, I think maker has a very bright future. I also think that there is room for experimentation and that those dimensions are important to give users choice along and that rise approach of, you know, baking and interest rate directly into the price of the asset, taking only either collateral and minimizing governance is very interesting alternative. So how would that fit into the DeFi universe that we know today? And then also as DeFi develops, how do you think as a building block, how do you think that fits into the future of DeFi?
Well, it's a very different user experience, right? So Rye is a dollar stable asset, but it is not a dollar equivalent asset, meaning the peg of Rye will change every minute or however frequently they update their basically target rate feedback mechanism. So I think that the answer to your question or how I imagine playing this out is that Rye probably is a better fit for more financial use cases than die in some respects, which is, you know, as collateral for some other derivative, it's not really important, most likely, to the owner of that or the protocol that that implements it that die remain equal to one dollar or rather that Rye does.
It's actually probably preferable that it have sort of minimal dollar purchasing power volatility from like a financial mathematics perspective, you know, in terms of what's ideal for that use case. On the flip side, it's probably not great UX and something that maker governance has been very averse to is taking die off of its one dollar peg to implement a negative interest rate, like to the extent that die in your wallet, a hundred dies floating and, you know, next week is one die is 98 cents and like will be forever rather than a dollar. It's a very different UX and I think that's probably the core dimensional on which they're going to kind of differentiate.
So speaking of things that track a dollar but don't actually act as a dollar, Ampliforth has kind of taken this, the world by storm recently because of its insane run-up from an eight million dollar market cap to a six hundred million dollar market cap down to a two hundred million dollar market cap. And Charlie, you tweeted to something as Ampliforth was retracing that insane run-up. It was a screenshot of the price of Ampliforth with a big red negative 40% and you quoted it saying nature is healing. And so can you go into your perceptions on Ampliforth and perhaps why you were maybe alluded to that it shouldn't really be worth all that much?
Yeah, so, I mean, you know, Ampliforth can be worth whatever people want it to be. I'm not going to be wrong about this in the same sense that, you know, it's true of either Bitcoin. I think the reason I tweeted that was, you know, Ampliforth is an accounting trick, right? The price remaining $1 while balance is change in perfect proportion to that is really just flipping price and supply. So, whereas, you know, most assets have a variable price and a fixed supply or rather one that doesn't depend on maintaining a constant market price, Ampliforth does the opposite, which is expands or contracts the supply to maintain a constant dollar price.
But what this doesn't change is the market cap over time. So, you know, I don't mean this in kind of a condescending sense, but Ampliforth is an accounting trick, right? And I think something that concerned me was that it seemed like there were a lot of people that didn't understand this. And I think that although it's very interesting to see kind of like how the market treats this asset, there's a difference between people playing money games because they're fun and they understand what they're doing and thinking that there's like something else is happening, for example, with Ampliforth. Okay, so a brother, a cousin of Ampliforth is this new Yams token asset, right?
So it's the same thing as Ampliforth, very similar. We've gotten into the subtleties earlier, but the distribution is different. So instead of VCs owning it and founders owning it and presale, it's basically DeFi individuals, individuals that are in DeFi, particularly, you know, I mean, let's be honest, the whales who have the capital to put in and start receiving Yams. Is that any different to you? Does that have a better shot at becoming money? I mean, no, definitely not, but my hope is that this might not be true. Yams is more ironic than it is misleading. And I think there's nothing wrong with running fun experiments because everybody's going to mean them because they're hilarious experiments.
I mean, I think, well, I don't want to say there's nothing wrong with that. Rather, I think about that quite differently than the idea that we would say, for example, Ampliforth is going to take over the global financial system because there's like, I don't know, there's something different than an accounting trick is happening. So your question on Yams, like, do I think it's any more likely to like become a viable form of money than Ampliforth? Like, not really, but in some sense, I think it's probably better that people are treating it like a highly reflexive money game than it seems like people are being just glad about it.
But, you know, obviously, you kind of have to pick where you draw that line for yourself. So we started this out, Charlie. We're talking about like some of the good things you see in DeFi and some investments rather than some of the bad things or bad investments. What's your take just in general on yield farming? Is that good for DeFi? Is that kind of something that's investible? I think yield farming is broadly just an incredible innovation. An incredible idea that's going to be around forever. And, you know, I was quite negative on it or have been publicly, especially on Twitter, because I think that yield farming as an idea is different than sort of its implementation in any specific context or protocol.
And in the same way that like, you know, 3% per year, ether inflation is far different than 100,000%. Despite the fact that if you take the limit, you know, to infinity, they're equivalent. Like, there's sort of a similar idea here in yield farming where like, it's, there's no bright objective line between what I would say, like kind of seems somewhat reasonable and what doesn't. But any individual implementation of it, again, you kind of have to pick how credible you find it for yourself, if that makes sense. I guess in short, I would say it's a great idea. I think it's going to be super important to the future of the space and it's not going to go away.
I think that it will take a while for people generally to figure out like how to use it in an additive, you know, long-term sustainable way to build durable value and that a couple of the use cases or implementations today do seem, you know, kind of at odds with that, with that long-term thinking. So, Charlie, earlier in this conversation, we said we would get back to this and now's the time, because I think it's a really interesting discussion and perspective you have on, I think maybe two aspects. One is when we're talking about base layers like a Bitcoin or an Ethereum, economic security is imperative.
And you also, you talked about reflexivity and the hazards of, I guess, betting the farm, betting the base layer on reflexivity. And another term for that that we've used often on bankless is like the moniness of a given underlying layer, you know, layer. I'm trying to agree with that for what it's worth. I think they're essentially the same thing. So, let's talk about that. And in fact, there's like a concrete reason that they must be the same thing. Okay, so that's what I want to dig into. But while we dig into that, let me just, you know, tee this up for listeners. So, they understand this is, by the way, an ongoing conversation for like you and I have had over the years on Twitter on this first time we're doing a podcast about it.
But the basic problem, if I could state the problem, then maybe you could, you know, iterate and what the problem is, is the value of, let's take ether, for example, the same is true of Bitcoin. The value of ether has to go higher in proportion to, for economic security reasons. So, the value of ether is basically the, the economic security of the network. And the question is, or a question is, what happens if the value of all of the tokens on top of Ethereum starts to far exceed and outstrip the value of ether? Does Ethereum become unable to secure the tokens on, on top of this? And I think there's a lot of implications that fall out of that that one implication is on Ethereum, there could be things such as free rider tokens that consume the economic security bandwidth of Ethereum.
But, but don't really pay forward. Another implication is that there's some scalability limit on Ethereum. And, you know, that's in proportion to a concept we've called economic bandwidth that, you know, the, the Ethereum token economy can't far exceed the value of, of ether or else the network becomes insecure. And I think the last maybe implication that we could dig into is, doesn't this mean that ether must secure monetary premium in order to be a global financial system? So, is that kind of the problem statement, would you add to, to maybe the problem statement or how would you talk about this?
I think it's a great problem statement and, you know, I think this is such a tough issue kind of deeply entangled in so many different, like highly illegible in front to your ideas today that it's, it's really, really hard to talk about, honestly. So, but I would say, yeah, I think at a high level that's, that's a really good problem statement. And then, you know, I think one immediate reaction to the way that you would put it, one hypothetical or pathological case maybe being the value of all tokens on top of Ethereum, vastly exceeding the value of ether or the security premium that it can pay, is, is that that's kind of a binary question, right?
It's kind of, it can sound like we're asking, well, well, at some point, you know, well, there'll be a big double spend on these assets on top of the chain and it just feels very like, maybe this could happen, but, you know, are we ever going to get there? It's kind of a threshold, like maybe people just won't do it. In the same way that on Bitcoin, like you would expect to see selfish mining, but you don't in practice. Does that kind of make sense? The, the issue, like so one way I think of it is, like the US has the strongest military in the world. I think, you know, most, most people would agree with that.
Other nation states are up and coming. But how much is enough to pay for US military defense? Is it 1% of GDP? Is it 5% of GDP? Well, you don't know until you're attacked. So, absolutely. You don't know until you're attacked. That's, that's the, the exact, I think, issue that many people take with the kind of high level framing that you laid out, which again, I totally agree with, but I think, you know, something that only became apparent more recently is that I don't believe it's a binary question. I, when do you get attacked? Rather that it's ongoing. And the, like today, we can see empirically that, MEV is driving socially, at least socially undesirable kind of things to happen.
Can you talk about MEV? MEV, for folks that aren't going to talk about it. So, maybe it'll be helpful to zoom out right on like two, the two kind of ideas that I personally consider core to this platform security question, right? And the first is a paper written by some folks at Princeton called on the instability of Bitcoin without the block subsidy. And it's a fantastic paper. It's worth reading. But the core idea contained within it is that transaction fees are not additive to security. And actually, more specifically, any transaction fees which are proportional to the value of transactions are not additive to security.
So, in the context of Ethereum, a good, like all current gas fees are not, cannot be assumed additive to the security budget. An example of a fee that could be is a constant amount of ether burned. But we can get that later. So, that's the first very key idea. Can you just explain briefly why not? Because that's the entire thesis of Bitcoin. It's Bitcoin security model transitions to transaction fees only. So, yeah, the rough answer is that transaction fees, non-constant transaction fees, those which are proportional to value, which is true of Bitcoin transaction fees today, Ethereum gas, like, are create minor extractable value inherently.
And so, that's the second kind of key idea behind this broad security question. What is minor extractable value? It comes from or is first defined in a paper, a fantastic paper by Phil Diane called Flash Boys 2.0. And what it looked at was the DEX transactions, how bots frontrun them. And specifically, it looked at application, it looked at application behavior, which created opportunities for transaction ordering to net a profit. Meaning, if I can be the first one to get a liquidation in, I can make money doing that. Or if I can frontrun someone's trade on Uniswap, I can make money doing that.
And they looked in this paper at empirically, there are arbitrage bots that do this, which are not minors. But the point that they made in the paper was that actually this value is entirely extractable by minors. Meaning, rather than these arbitrage bots bidding on transaction fees to try and get the ordering that they want, so that they can frontrun you or liquidate you or whatever, that actually what minors should be doing is simply censoring all of those transactions and extracting the value themselves. And so you get into a system where either you expect minor censorship or such that there are zero transaction fees, or if they are not the ones extracting the value themselves, then there is a very strong incentive to revert the chain.
Basically, for consensus to become unstable because some blocks are wealthier than others. Yeah, so to reiterate that, and we can really see this with a lot of the liquidity mining that's going on in DeFi, there's a ton of volume going through Uniswap, and sometimes we see blocks that have 5, 10, 20 ether being paid as a fee. And it's in the miners best interest if there's a 20 ether fee block that only has two ether issued as a reward. And so the discrepancy between the fee and the reward is so large that for the next block, the next like 5, 10 blocks, there's an incentive for miners to reorg the next 20 blocks to go backwards to mine that 20 ether reward fee so they can take that from themselves.
This is right. That's sort of a very pathological case. That kind of attack is what Phil DeAnne calls a time band attack in the paper, which is basically, it's not just the current block that you're in and how transaction ordering within it, impacts the amount of value you can derive as a miner from publishing it, but that in fact, it creates an incentive basically for consensus to become unstable because you would rather to your point reorg the chain than continue extending it. So what implications fall out from this, Charlie? So yeah, to take it back to the earlier point on transaction fees, right?
Like a very core idea, and in fact, one that Vitalik has, especially recently, then quite vocal about in public, is the notion that transaction fees, as we currently think about them, are not additive to security. In fact, they're at best not additive, and at worst, create an immediate incentive to revert the chain, sort of big enough that it actually starts to happen in practice. In the case of Ethereum, I think the net vision for the future that I take away from this is either asking for money, right? And that's kind of the base case that needs to happen for this thing to be secure. And it's the same argument as in Bitcoin, so that was kind of a poor way of stating it.
But rather, I think. So I think the path that you got there is interesting. I want to come back to Ethereum has to be money, and it's just a second, but also you mentioned Vitalik in sort of transaction fees not being enough. Are you bullish on EIP 1559, sort of the burn mechanism? Is that necessary to prevent MEV? Yeah, so that very interesting question. EIP 1559 does not prevent MEV. So what EIP 1559 does do, and I'm super positive on it, is that it creates a base rate fee that all transactions pay. And this fee is burned, a fee is the wrong word. It creates a base burn, and that burn doesn't accrue to miners, right?
So that's awesome. Where earlier I had said proportional to value fees are not additive security because they are MEV. EIP 1559 base fees are additive to security. You can invert the previous logic to say they're not proportional to transaction value, and therefore they can be additive to security. Does that make sense? I think I've got it. So now does EIP 1559 get rid of MEV? No, because there are still tip auctions in it, which are basically the same kinds of priority gas auctions as all transactions participate in today. And so even after EIP 1559, to the extent that any individual transaction has creates an arbitrage opportunity, you would expect there to be a tip auction in exactly the same ways there is a priority gas auction bidding today over it.
And you need that to establish priority either in times of congestion or just when a transaction contains MEV. So the point here is any transaction which today bots get into a bidding war over the ordering of, you would expect that still to happen after EIP 1559 is implemented. However, it does, for transactions where that's not true, it's a very good thing that rather that they burn the base fee rather than paying a transaction fee. Got it. So how about validators? So proof of stake rather. So that basically means that the minor and the holder of the ETH become one of the same. I would think that would give the holder of the ETH a longer time preference, let's say.
We don't want to start front running everyone or that destroys the value of Ethereum and my ether. So we don't want to do that. Whereas in Bitcoin with proof of work, like the ASICs are a separate token if you want to think about it. Definitely. So I think it might be helpful first to like take a step back and consider the same question in the context of proof of work. This is like that Brian and I have talked about on Twitter before. And you know, what I said about EIP 1559 that you would still expect to see auctions happen for transactions which contain MEV afterwards, right? Is not actually precisely true.
You would expect that to happen unless miners start extracting value from them, right? Rather than arbitrasures participating or bidding in gas wars over them that miners simply censor those competing transactions and extract all of the value themselves, right? Which is completely separate to EIP 1559 or any other fee question. So does that kind of make sense? It's like there's to the extent that miners are just running the default guess implementation and minor config like they're not going to do this and so far today up until today they haven't. And that's why arbitrasures get into gas wars.
But if miners decided to start extracting it themselves, well, there wouldn't be any gas wars because they would simply censor any competing transaction and order it however they want. Yeah, I totally get it for proof of work. And then yeah, so proof of stake actually the same logic holds which is an individual validator determines transaction ordering within a block. And so they can choose to do this in exactly the same way. What does become more difficult are time-banded attacks at least beyond the finality window. And so I think there's enough uncertainty around what proof of stake will look like in in ETH 2.
0 for for me to comment on sort of like or imagine that I have a perfect vision for how all of these concepts translate. But at a minimum, the potential for you know the incentive to for validators block composers to censor transactions still exists and will still be a problem. And the bear case for this is that the stakers who are staking ETH who participate in this you know MEV, MEV capture are it's the game theory is that you know any staker that doesn't do this loses to the stakers that do right. And so the the value and in fact the losses compound over time and the losses compound over time right.
And so like while proof of stake advocates are concerned about mining centralization in proof of work mines that the miners the proof of work advocates are concerned about a capital centralization in proof of stake. And this the activities being described here where some stakers will be able to extract capture the MEV in some stakers won't definitely is concerning when it comes to a decentralization perspective. Is this right? Absolutely yeah. And so to my earlier point that this is thing Patelix has been talking a lot. I think I can show you guys the links afterwards to include but he has some great comments deep in Twitter replies and on a couple of medium posts about potential solutions.
And I think something that that people are not broadly aware of is like how bad this problem could be in the sense that the solutions at least those that we currently imagine are like kind of a radical departure from what Ethereum looks like today. And you know it's so I think the point here is both that this is kind of becoming more and more of an urgent problem. And like the solutions you know some combination of proof of stake and everything going on to roll ups which I can get into more are like a very kind of radical departure from what Ethereum currently looks like. And especially considering the timeline to e2.
0 or how long like it seems like at least to me it will probably take the DeFi ecosystem to migrate like I think this is the problem that anybody who wants to wants to see Ethereum succeed long-term should like be concerned about. So Charlie is it not so I feel like it's also a problem for Bitcoin though except one difference is it's a largely unacknowledged problem right so Bitcoin is 100%. Okay so like I'm definitely gonna get I'm definitely gonna get tweeted out for this but like yeah I mean it's a completely unacknowledged problem in fairness to them you know like the inflation schedule isn't gonna like drop to zero for a long time but like certainly people don't seem to be Bitcoin people have everyone to define that don't even really seem to be willing to like acknowledge that at some point it will exist.
So entirely separate to the question in Ethereum but I completely agree. Okay so here's how I kind of like summarize I think I may have tweeted something like this like a long time ago but like the dirty little secret of both camps the Ethereum and Bitcoiners. The Bitcoiners don't want to admit that they need their block space to be valuable and they need to deal with the MEV problem in order to be honest. Well actually that's sorry I think just to you put it very concisely there the problem they have to deal with is that valuable block space is MEV there you go that's another dimension yeah and then but the the thing that Ethereum advocates don't like to admit maybe present company excluded give us a pass on this is that ETH needs to have monetary premium so it's issuance policy matters it needs to become a money because if you become a money to the extent you are a reserve asset and a store of value you kind of paper over some of these problems.
Now is that true because like we started this whole thing with almost the the conclusion that we've reached which is these assets need to become money like they need to accrue a monetary premium or the whole thing doesn't work long term. Yeah so how do we get there? I think we're super we're super down the rabbit hole at this point yeah but I'm gonna add even like one further nuance and then maybe we can we can zoom out and kind of like consider the whole picture right and the nuance to Ethereum I think it's awesome that you brought up the Bitcoin analogy the nuance to Ethereum is that Phil Dianne's paper flashboys 2.
0 showed that application layer behavior can create MEV right and so for Ethereum as compared to Bitcoin the problem certainly exists in both systems right the instability without the block subsidy or rather that any proportional value transaction fee scheme is MEV and it's just that in Ethereum we have the further complication of like what every transaction is doing whether it be moving a bunch of tether or trading on Uniswap which creates an arbitrage opportunity in MEV is kind of like in some sense worse or at least could be than a simple transfer and I think like James Presswitch summarized this pretty well in in a tweet the other day you can't write a script that finds all MEV so it doesn't exist sorry that's the rule like that's kind of the problem that we're dealing with here that we don't really even know or can know like how bad it is yeah I get it and I think you know on the on the on the Bitcoin side to you it could become the case that assumptions change finance is buying mining rigs right what if finance becomes a very large centralized binding facility and then it it can maybe extract some of these MEV sort of you know capabilities in its crypto bank but but let's let's let's zoom out again and talk about Charlie why why sort of the summary is these assets eth needs to be money Bitcoin needs to be money by that again we just mean store value asset for this whole thing to succeed why why is that the case so I think you know I'll try and give like the one or two sentence version we know that we can't fund protocol security with competitive transaction fees or not non-constant transaction fees and we know this from the paper on the instability of Bitcoin about the block subsidy which applies equally to Bitcoin and Ethereum we know empirically that MEV quite a lot of it exists on Ethereum today and we know that the amount of MEV that exists is a function of the behavior of applications on Ethereum so we net out from this saying well we can't assume that transaction fees are additive to protocol layer platform security at layer one we know that applications running on top of this platform can parasitically add to you know the incentive to destabilize its consensus process and so you kind of need to assume two things in my opinion one that the base asset is sufficiently valuable to basically socialize the security of the platform as a whole to such a degree that it just doesn't seem like feasible to corrupt and secondly you need to assume that there is a way to constrain the amount of parasitic application layer behavior to like not eventually topple over air go these things need to be reflexively valuable exactly and so there's one there's like one point here which I'm sure is going to get debated which is that you know EIP 1559 the base fee that is burned is additive to protocol security even more so in a proof of state context right so maybe ether doesn't need to be money if like fee burns far exceed you know the amount of MEV or you know we don't need a perpetual block subsidy because the amount of the fee burn exceeds the amount of MEV like empirically that's not the case right because base fee burns scale in the number of transactions that happen on the platform whereas like any two transactions can have zero or a billion dollars of MEV within them and so I think like state rent EIP 1559 base fee burns are great because they're additive to platform security like the vast majority if you break out on a pie chart in my belief will need to be like the moneyness or the ability to socialize platform security with a monetary premium because like personally again I don't believe that fee burns state rent etc will like be sufficient to cover the cost of MEV or parasitic application incentives which is why I think possibly we've come to a similar conclusion maybe it's from slightly different angles which is like the open financial system of the world again to the extent that there's only one or one becomes dominant will have at its base layer a store of value monetary premium type asset it can't maintain first place unless it does but let me ask you a question about alternative base layers so cosmos for example that is a tenderment anyway is a paradigm investment but I want your personal take on this cosmos is very clear that atoms the token behind the cosmos network are not money never intended to be money inflation schedule and such also sort of makes that true you know protocol validators can can vote on issuance lots of things make that true can it exist as a base layer without becoming money I think what you just said about MEV and other approaches might mean you think it can you think a cosmos is viable without atoms being money yeah I think I'm gonna walk back a little bit to the ethereum case first and say my belief is that ethereum can work if either is money and can socialize like a sufficient security budget for the platform right like I think that's a necessary component but to be honest I don't know that's necessarily enough or that it's not the case that sort of parasitic application incentives like compound on one another to the point where it doesn't matter the monetary premium doesn't matter it's still overridden by sort of the asymptotic MEV behavior of the platform so you know I think that's kind of like a contentious statement um I don't think that it's the obvious conclusion the obvious logical conclusion I think it's very possible that ethereum does work and remains secure economically secure long term um and that's my hope but I also believe like it's possible that it doesn't um and so what alternatives at that point seem credible and is that where a cosmos and atoms kind of you know fit in they're not trying to be money but you know they could develop some sort of premium outside of like some sort of economic security outside of being a store of value exactly yeah um and so that the sort of cosmos holistic thesis maybe not specific to atoms although you know we could we could talk about sort of the hub the cosmos zone that they secure sort of the there are specific dynamics but the cosmos thesis as a whole is that like in short if we figure out that we can't socialize the security of a general platform general smart contract platform by deluding a monetary premium then every application may need to pay for its own security and if every application needs to pay for its own security then like what's important to interoperability is shared standards um shared languages and like the ability to interoperate uh and for a smart contract comparable smart contract ecosystem to develop without relying on the homogenous security of a shared base platform and so what cosmos is is not any one blockchain but rather basically like a set of standards by which to create many of them and like allow them to interoperate uh without needing to share security the difference between an empire and individual city states has been yeah i think that's fair i also think that the cathedral and bizarre uh kind of idea is fair from a security perspective um which is you know in cosmos like uh any individual application security could fail um and that will have ramifications on the broader ecosystem but there is not or there shouldn't be any one individual application whose security is like literally critical to the ecosystems uh survival right in the same way that to be honest like an ethereum to the extent that it becomes insecure ether is not able to pay for the ethereum platforms security like we don't have a platform left right so the central point of security of ethereum rests in this one single asset ether and it's one single mechanism for uh providing consensus uh which is proof of stake right and so since everything has the security of all platforms and all applications on top of ethereum rests upon those two things it becomes the one single point of attack or capture or coercion uh versus like a more distributed system where there are just a mesh network of of platforms and protocols that all kind of stitched themselves together where failure in one of those applications is relatively compartmentalized uh in relation in comparison to if everything is built on top of one blockchain is that is that the right representation yeah i think so that's um it's actually very nice with putting it so Charlie i want to finish this with one last uh line of questioning before before we wrap this up um the medasha test net uh spun up last week and if everything goes according to plan it should be launching in november which which means that phase zero staking of ether goes live in this year hopefully fingers crossed uh and after speaking with a bunch of you know eth two devs they are all sort of on board with this concept of compounding progress where phase zero took a really long time to get to if you want to if you want to count the maximum years it's it's five years since the genesis of ethereum did it take us to get to phase zero but phase one no one really thinks that phase one is all that far after phase zero and phase two all these things are happening in parallel meanwhile we have eip1559 and the burning of ether and of transaction fees which is guestimated to be arriving sometime q1 q2 2020 uh 2021 um based on the uh conversations that have been going on with the eip1559 implementation team my my question and and uh what i'm trying to get out of view is going back to the conversation of reflexivity inside of these crypto application crypto networks and how that will impact the broader sphere so if we are just a few months away from staking which is a core pillar of the eth value accrual mechanism and maybe just after three or four months after that does ethburn go go live and then maybe three four five months after that do we have sharding and scale uh do you do you and do your partners app paradigm think about this uh this bam bam bam one two three four knock down the the obstacles for for ethers value proposition happening in pretty quick succession and and then um making that keeping that relevant to the reflexivity of these uh systems how do you guys think about uh all of these things tied together um so i think i'll make two controversial comments uh on the ethereum road map um i am more confident that it won't fail today than i was a year ago i also think there's uh a greater than 50 percent probability that we never get charted execution environments uh or any eth 2 road map beyond phase one um how about one so how about one dot five Charlie do you know that the idea of one dot five is basically like what we get is um proof of stake and then e data availability data availability and then everything scales with the roll ups yeah so that's that's why i say greater than 50 percent i think you know i'm not sure that it's legible to everyone yet like why all of what we talked about with respect to mev um an application layer incentives is kind of an input to um this question but it's not purely about feasibility of execution environments or like that roll ups are enough you know with eth 2 data availability and proof of stake um it's also about like centralizing mev extraction into roll up proposals um and i think that as of right now like that i'm not sure if it's more likely than like the original eth 2 vision but if not it's like pretty quickly getting there i think um and i think eth 1 5 um you know roll ups uh with charted data availability and basically just execution of fraud proofs on the beacon chain um is a very similar model to cosmos's if you imagine that like the hub uh you know provided like a shared layer for fraud proofs uh you know at least of uh the ones it chose to the idea here basically just being that like in the eth 1 5 world it's important to remember that roll ups can't talk to each other without making idiosyncratic security assumptions right there's fraud on one roll up it can impact another to the extent they're interoperating um and so it looks it looks a lot like cosmos um to be honest and i think i don't know it it'll be very interesting to see how it develops um i don't feel like there's enough clarity yet for me to be really confident in like how it will go both in terms of like how eth 2 will go if we get 1 5 or um kind of the original you know full charted execution vision um but i think it's very interesting um and especially the extent that you know what we're currently seeing with defy kind of continues and maybe even honestly we start seeing minor censorship in practice like that could push it to this must be the vision for ethereum going forward that's what i would look for if in the next year or two we start seeing minors not follow protocol or start extracting by themselves censoring transactions which is quite possible then i think we get eth 1 5 very cool charlie we could spend a whole another hour i feel like talking about these things and going back and forth about them it has been a pleasure to talk to you sir i think you've got a depth of understanding that a folks listening to bankless need particularly with topics around economic security um you know monetary premium and and m e v so we want to thank you for joining us thank you guys for having me i mean to be honest i'm just like a very delayed and less eloquent repeater note uh of the tall uh i would just drop all the links to everything that he's written i i feel like we all are to celebrate so yeah all of us together kind of to generate a mutual understanding of what the hell of italics talking about it takes a village uh it's like the quote the crypto equivalent of sentence data right exactly exactly all right uh bankless listeners this has been charlie noise want to leave you with some action items today um the first thing you should do is read some of paradigms research one of which we will include bitcoin for the open-minded skeptic that is sort of an intro to uh for institutions primarily on why bitcoin is a meaningful asset secondly let's include some will include some links to uh articles that charlie mentioned one on the instability bitcoin without block rewards and then the second the article from fill on m e v will even include some vitalic comments that charlie will send us after the show the third thing david we are at 93 five star reviews my friend do the math how far are we from 100 yeah really really far so we need everyone's help to get to a hundred the bankless nation recently passed ten thousand subscribers and the fact that there's only 93 five star reviews on our podcast makes me a sad boy so if you could go to wherever you listen to your podcast and give us that five star review so we can get the bankless gospel into as many years as possible we would really appreciate it i think we're gonna hit a hundred right after the show david i've just got a feeling uh risk in disclaimers everyone eat this risky cryptos risky bitcoin is risky everything we talk about around yams and deep i are very risky you could lose what you put in we are headed west this is the frontier it's not for everyone but we are glad you're with us on the bankless journey thanks so much