✨ DEBRIEF | Ryan & David unpacking the episode: https://www.bankless.com/debrief-the-jeremy-allaire-interview
------ Joining the podcast today we have the man behind the largest US based stablecoin, Jeremy Allaire, the Founder of USDC Circle.
A year ago USDC depegged in the face of major banks like SVB and Silvergate collapsing. How did Jeremy deal with that? What year is crypto in internet years? Why don’t we have a venmo for crypto yet? Fast forward to 2030, what’s the total value of stablecoins?
Stay tuned because we ask all that and much more.
------ 📣 SPOTIFY PREMIUM RSS FEED | USE CODE: SPOTIFY24 https://bankless.cc/spotify-premium
------ BANKLESS SPONSOR TOOLS:
🐙KRAKEN | MOST-TRUSTED CRYPTO EXCHANGE https://k.xyz/bankless-pod-q2
🔗CELO | CEL2 COMING SOON https://bankless.cc/Celo
⚖️ARBITRUM | SCALING ETHEREUM https://bankless.cc/Arbitrum
🛞MANTLE | MODULAR LAYER 2 NETWORK https://bankless.cc/Mantle
🔐 SAFE | ATTEND SAFE{CON} https://conf.safe.global/
🗣️TOKU | CRYPTO EMPLOYMENT SOLUTION https://bankless.cc/toku
🏙️ CONSENSUS | SAVE 20% WITH CODE BANKLESS https://bankless.cc/4aykesD
------ TIMESTAMPS
0:00 Intro 5:47 SVB Crisis Reflections 24:00 Crypto Age in Internet Terms 31:15 The Future of Stablecoins 41:42 The Crypto Venmo 56:18 Blackrock’s BUIDL Fund 1:01:44 US Government 1:16:35 USDC vs Tether 1:22:00 Central Bank Stablecoins 1:28:14 Regulatory Protectionism 1:32:25 Closing Thoughts
------ RESOURCES
Jeremy Allaire https://twitter.com/jerallaire
USDXX - What backs a USDC? https://www.blackrock.com/cash/en-us/products/329365/circle-reserve-fund
Circle https://www.circle.com/en/
------ Not financial or tax advice. See our investment disclosures here: https://www.bankless.com/disclosures
No summary for this episode yet.
Total value of stablecoins, what do you think? By the end of this decade, by the end of 2030, where are we sitting? 2030? Yeah. Yeah. I feel comfortable saying $3 trillion. Welcome to Bankless, where we explore the frontier of stablecoins. This is Ryan Chan Adams. I'm here with David Hoffman, and we are here to become more bankless. We've Jeremy Alair on the podcast today. This is the man behind the largest stablecoin issued in the US. We had so much to talk about. A year ago, at this time, major banks like Silicon Valley and Silvergate were failing. That's the last time we had Jeremy on the podcast.
A moment when US DC had just depagged and was in the middle of recovering, Operation Chokepoint seemed to be a thing that the US government was doing to squelch off crypto companies from banks and debank them. How did he deal with all of that? That's where we start the conversation. And then we discuss what year is crypto in internet terms? Are we in the 80s and the 90s and the 2000s? How much sure is this technology? How much more do we have to go? We also ask, why don't we have a Venmo for crypto yet? And then we get into the BlackRock and Circle partnership. How big of a deal is this? What does the US government want from stablecoins?
Are they going to try to block it and reject it? Or are they going to embrace it? At that point, we had to bring up circles controversial statements on their main competitor, Tether. They made these statements in front of Congress. Does Jeremy believe lawmakers should prefer one stablecoin over another? And finally, we fast forward to 2030. This whole vision is realized. What is the total value of stablecoins at that point? Jeremy is always such a useful guest. He's seen the rise of the internet and then he's also been watching the rise of crypto at the same time. So it's always fun to pick his brain about comparing and contrasting these differences here.
But then he's also kind of just a general polymath. He's very well versed in macroeconomics and geopolitics and government and legislation and operating, being an entrepreneur operator inside of those confines while also being a very big bull of the world of defy, which is strictly outside of those confines. And he kind of has his one foot on both sides of the camp of like very many different things. He's inside of the world of fintech, but he's also on chain. He's inside the world of the regulatory landscape, but so USCC is also on chain and outside of it as well. And so it's just a very diverse perspective and always just like such an articulate guy.
So whenever Jeremy comes on the pod, I always listen. All right, let's get to the episode with Jeremy Alair on stablecoins. But before we do, we want to thank the sponsors that made it possible, including our number one recommended crypto exchange for 2024. That is Kraken, go create an account. If you want a crypto trading experience backed by world-class security and award-winning support teams, then head over to Kraken, one of the longest standing and most secure crypto platforms in the world. Kraken is on a journey to build a more accessible, inclusive and fair financial system, making it simple and secure for everyone, everywhere to trade crypto.
Kraken's intuitive trading tools are designed to grow with you, empowering you to make your first or your hundredth trade in just a few clicks. And there's an award-winning client support team available 24-7 to help you along the way. Along with a whole range of educational guides, articles, and videos, with products and features like Kraken Pro and Kraken NFT Marketplace and a seamless app to bring it all together, it's really the perfect place to get your complete crypto experience. So check out the simple, secure, and powerful way for everyone to trade crypto, whether you're a complete beginner or a seasoned pro.
Go to Kraken.com slash bank lists to see what crypto can be. Not investment advice, crypto trading involves risk of loss. Cello is the mobile first EVM compatible carbon negative blockchain built for the real world. Driving real world use cases like mobile payments and mobile defy, and with Opera Many Pay as one of the fastest growing Web 3 wallets. Cello is seeing a meteoric rise with over 300 million transactions and 1.5 million monthly active addresses. And now, Cello is looking to come home to Ethereum as a layer two. Optimism, polygon, matterlabs, and arbitrum have all thrown their hats in their ring for the Cello layer two to build upon their stacks.
Why the competition? The Cello layer two will bring huge advantages like a decentralized sequencer, off-chain data availability, secured by Ethereum validators, and one block finality. What does that all mean for you? With Cello layer two, Gasties will stay low and you can even pay for gas natively using ERC20 tokens, sending crypto to phone numbers across wallets using social connect. But Cello is a community-governed protocol. This means that Cello needs you to weigh in and make your voice heard. Join the conversation in the Cello forums. Follow Cello on Twitter and visit sellow.org to shape the future of Ethereum.
Arbitrum is the leading Ethereum scaling solution that is home to hundreds of decentralized applications. Arbitrum's technology allows you to interact with Ethereum at scale with low fees and faster transactions. Arbitrum has the leading DeFi ecosystem, strong infrastructure options, flourishing NFTs, and is quickly becoming the web-free gaming hub. Explore the ecosystem at portal.arbitrum.io. Are you looking to permissionlessly launch your own Arbitrum orbit chain? Arbitrum orbit allows anyone to utilize Arbitrum's secure scaling technology to build your own orbit chain, giving you access to interoperable, customizable permissions with dedicated throughput.
Whether you're a developer, an enterprise or a user, Arbitrum orbit lets you take your project to new heights. All of these technologies leverage the security and decentralization of Ethereum. Experience Web 3 development, the way it was always meant to be. Secure, fast, cheap, and friction-free. Visit Arbitrum.io and get your journey started in one of the largest Ethereum communities. Bangladesh Nation, we are on with Jeremy Lair. He is the co-founder and CEO of Circle, which is the company behind USDC, which is the world's largest US-based stablecoin. Jeremy, welcome back to Bangladesh. Yeah, it's great to be back.
Thanks for having me on. It's great to have you. And just to kind of complete the thread, actually, the last time we had you on Jeremy was just over a year ago at this time. And it was kind of in crisis mode, I would say. So there was a literal bank crisis at the time in the US. There's Silicon Valley Bank. Bangladesh listeners may remember this or maybe seems like a long time ago. But Silicon Valley Bank had some issues. Silvergate the bank as well, where USDC kept billions and funds was facing potential insolvency. We didn't really know. And USDC itself, the stablecoin had a brief period of time where it was doing the thing it's not ideally supposed to do, which is depaging from the dollars.
Now we are in much calmer waters. And I just want to kick this off to complete the circus, the circus. It was a little bit of a circus, too. But complete the circuit here. How do you reflect on that? Like was this the most stressful period of time in circles history and what did you learn? Well, we've had a lot of really stressful times in our history. So we've been working on this for 11 years and faced enormous challenges along the way. But definitely when there are a rapid succession of bank failures, large scale government regulatory actions and all that in a rapid succession of a matter of weeks, it's pretty wild.
I mean, I think the context setting you did, I think is pretty good, right? I think we, you know, going into 2023, you had the start of the year where basically the bank regulators said, don't touch this. The basically given order to all banks do not touch any of this, which was then caused, I think a lot of banks to begin to say, okay, you know, we need to kind of pull back. It was sort of this operation, choke point 2.0, kind of narrative that was sort of out there. And then, you know, really starting in later in January that going into February, you had a wave of enforcement actions principally by the SEC against an enormous number of US based companies and some international companies all sweeping in.
And so the market itself was like, what's happening in the United States? And it was the topic you guys have addressed many times. And then you had, in the matter of seven days, you had three distinct banks that were completely separate from one another, fail or be seized. And then the threat of a broader regional banking crisis that then ultimately had, you know, Secretary Yellen and the federal government basically saying, we will stop any defaults of any uninsured deposits at any major regional commercial bank. And it was sort of a view that, you know, this was, you know, a much broader financial stability.
So that is all happening obviously. And I think what is also really important to remember is during that period of time that one to two weeks, virtually every single company in the entire crypto industry was debanked. They were debanked. They lost their transactional banking because Silvergate was failed. Signature bank was shut down. And so even, you know, thousands of companies, including international companies, lost their ability to transact. So it caused this just enormous kind of set of challenges operationally for a lot of- What does that mean to be debanked, Jeremy? Meaning, meaning if you are a company, let's say you're a firm in the market.
And you had the primary way that you were able to access the trading markets or other things was through a bank like Signature Bank or Silvergate Bank, which was, you know, probably five to 10,000 companies. Those banks stopped, like they literally went away. And so like your accounts went away. And so literally every company in the world that had some, any interaction with digital asset markets was like, I just lost my ability to function. And so just the fiat world kind of was breaking down. So it was a really special time. Now, I think when I look at a year later, I mean, for us, it's been pretty amazing.
I think when we talked a year ago, what was fascinating to see was there was sort of this flight from safety, which is this idea that effectively, like, generally, it's like, oh, you have regulated companies in the US, you have like the US dollar system and the regulated banking system. And, you know, there's sort of a view that that's safe. And then, you know, the rest of the world was saying, like, I actually don't know if the United States is safe. And so you had a kind of flight from safety. And that was pretty dramatic. And that went on, I think, for many months as the whole industry around the world kind of recalibrated.
I think for circles specifically, we've come to the other side of this, just in a far stronger place, fundamentally, from an infrastructure perspective. I mean, we've built up the most transparent reserve structure in the industry. So you can literally look at the reserves in USDC daily through a publicly listed vehicle USDXX, and you can see, and that's independently audited, independently verified, SEC regulated, and that is the circle reserve fund structure. And you can literally see every single T-Bill, every single repo agreement, and you can see their precise maturity, et cetera. And so it's just a level of transparency that does not exist anywhere else.
And then, obviously, you know, what we've been able to do is actually significantly evolve the banking infrastructure. But I think this is an important piece of what's been going on, which is we have taken the path of working with regulators around the world since we started. I think both circle and coin base have really tried to always be like strong, compliant organizations. And that's allowed both of our firms to have really excellent access to the Fiat banking system. And that's the, for us, it's the best it's ever been. We have a global network of transaction banking now. We have the ability to create and redeem USDC in the domestic bank networks in the US, in domestic bank networks in Singapore, in Hong Kong, in the EU, we'll soon be launching in markets like Brazil, and Mexico, we've announced initiatives to enable on and off-rands for USDC in Japan.
So it's like a whole global infrastructure. And we've added multiple, what are called G-SIMS, global systemically important banks, as reserve banks that hold the cash piece of what we do, not the T-Buil part of what we do. So that infrastructure is far more redundant, far more global with very strong global scale infrastructure players behind it. And then we just continue to ramp up the transparency. And so that is now, I think, playing out very, very good as like major companies want to build on top of this infrastructure now. Jeremy, maybe to kind of summarize the big changes here that happened in the wake of that banking crisis, correct me if I'm wrong.
What my understanding is like Silicon Valley, Silvergate, these were banks that would bank crypto companies that were like, quote unquote, like on the margins, from the perspective of maybe like the regulators. And they were banking circle, one of circle's banking partners. And now like kind of the before after of the whole banking crisis is now circle was maybe like banked by like banks on the margins, but has now been brought closer to the fold. You've gotten like stronger, more like inner banking partners. I think JB Morgan is one of them. Is that how you would kind of describe the before and after of the effect of the banking crisis?
Is that like a circle has been like given a route into like more of the center of the financial system? So I did well before SVB saw its challenges. We had been upgrading to the black rock base circle reserve fund structure. And in fact, even at the time around 85% of the circle reserve infrastructure was actually custodied in Bank of New York, Maryland, which is the largest custodian in the world, like $30 trillion of assets and the black rock funds. So then the cash piece, you know, I think every company in this industry has struggled to get major banks to work with them. And in fact, the number of companies in this industry worldwide that have major banks is extraordinarily limited.
And so yes, it's true we've continued to upgrade the kind of scale of the banks that we work with. But you know, some of the other players can't get U.S. bank accounts have to depend on shadow banks in, you know, jurisdictions with no real regulation. So it's, I think we were in a good place. So when, you know, black rock decides, we know they want to work with a company to enable stablecoin transactions with a tokenized fund or when the largest retail bank in Brazil, New Bank, which is an extraordinary company decides to like launch digital dollars, they're working with the companies that have that really deep infrastructure integration into the financial system.
And that's a huge part of the role that we play. One thing to note though is, you know, I think banks like Signature Bank and Silicon Valley Bank actually were like darlings of Wall Street extremely well rated banks, some of the fastest growing banks in their time and quite large. So these were not like niche banks. These are major banks that were institutional and size scale and had decades of being fundamental banks to huge parts of the technology industry, almost every venture company in the world, most venture capital firms, you know, huge amount there. And so these are not like, you know, a nichey community bank in San Diego, you know, these are actually major, you know, some of the largest regional banks in the United States.
And so I think that's why at the end of the day, we saw this first republic, which is another huge, huge, regional bank, huge asset manager failed and was taken over by JP Morgan. You had, you know, one of the largest banks in the world, Credit Suisse failed right at the same time. So you're having these very large banks failing. And so you had, and you had basically central banks say sort of stepping in to say, you know, we're not going to let this happen. I think one of the unfortunate things that happened from that is that, you know, while we now hold the cash pieces of USDC, almost entirely with these global, systemically important banks, it's just concentrating more money in these, in these G-subs, it's sort of concentrating effectively those funds in these two big to fail institutions that effectively have the taxpayer kind of backing them, whether they like it or not.
And prior to that, we actually had a program called Circle Impact, where we had deployed billions of dollars into community banks, minority depository institutions and community banks, because we wanted those banks who offered, you know, fundamentally credit to important communities. And that was part of our like social impact commitment, but those were all deemed too risky. And so we had to pull back billions of dollars from MBI's and community banks, which was really disappointing. And so I think at this point though, when we think about just looking at USDC specifically, our goal here is that this is as close to like government obligation money as you can have as a digital dollar.
And so we've kind of reached that from a fundamental risk perspective. And so if you're gonna have a base layer of money on the internet that you're building software against, you're putting protocols on, you're transacting and you want that to be as low risk and as transparent as possible. Yeah, I hear you. It feels like USDC is now much closer, like much more connected to the mainframe, I guess, of the dollar banking ecosystem, right? And what's interesting is, and by the way, I was looking at the USDXX, which I think I can go see this. If you Google USDXX, you can go Google and see your questions, what backs USDC?
You can kind of see here, right? It's right here. And so in USDC, you see a lot of treasuries. It sounds like they're still an element of cash reserve. But now that cash reserve is one in one of the big banks. And like if I'm just a layman's interpret, what you were saying Jeremy is, like the reason you couldn't spread the cash throughout all of these community banks and kind of like quote unquote decentralized it a little bit, is because it's just too risky. These banks go under and they could go under as a sector, for instance. Then there's no FDIC insurance, like on the books, kind of protecting the cash reserve in those banks.
And so if you're circle, you got to get close to the main frame and you got to park it in the kind of like the, I'll use my term for this, the quote unquote, too big to fail type like major banks basically. And like that's effectively what you've had to do. I think that's right. And it raises like a bigger philosophical question, which is something that we've pursued. And I think it has an enormous amount to do with ultimately what DeFi is trying to accomplish, which is in a world where you have a technology, these blockchain networks that effectively can lower the cost of storing and moving value, the marginal cost of storing and moving value to effectively zero, where effectively you can transact at the speed of the internet.
You can settle transactions with very high degree of security and settlement assurance in a fraction of a second. And now for a fraction of a cent in many cases, you're creating like one of the highest utility forms of money that's ever existed. You're creating this sort of, and in that world, you're actually increasing the velocity of money. There's this concept in monetary theory around money velocity. And the velocity of money has this huge impact on economic activity, the higher the velocity of money, the more economic activity and that can drive growth. And historically, central banks use interest rates to try and slow down or speed up the velocity of money.
But today, the way in which that velocity is constrained is essentially through the leverage and risk taking of banks. So effectively, I put a million dollars into bank A, I don't actually have a million dollars there. I have a liability and that liability is to that bank. That bank then is an investment company and they make loans and they leverage your capital. So you have a 12x leverage position, that's the average leverage in a bank deposit. So you have this 12x leverage position and that's super risky. And so in a world where basically money is going to like move like data on the internet, it's just going to move everywhere at this incredible speed.
Having that, the underlying asset itself be built up on these stacks of leverage is really, really problematic. And so I think, you know, not only do we want like this hyper efficient, like high utility money, you want the base layer that payment stable coin as people refer to these, the kind of fundamental payment you want that to be as close to the metal as possible. You want that to be basically as close to government obligation as possible because then everyone will feel comfortable interacting with it and using it, whether you're like a trader settling $100 million to our trade or you're an individual.
And where DeFi comes in is my belief is that on chain markets are going to do a far, far better job at allocating capital and risk than traditional banks. And so if I could build an on chain credit market and that on chain credit market has the ability to have different types of underwriters of risk that have highly specialized knowledge and who are able to actually be like the credit pool underwriters. And people can basically sweep into those pools, they understand that it's still lending, but it's actually on 100% transparent infrastructure, 100% real time auditable infrastructure, all the risk management that's embedded in the credit infrastructure is transparent, the source could transparent.
You build a dramatically more open and transparent model that can drive lending. And like right now a lot of that lending that happens in DeFi is sort of leverage lending, margin borrowing for speculative purposes. It's not for real use in the real economy. People are not saying, hey, I would like to borrow USDC to open a new restaurant or hire more employees. Although there is more and more of that and you do see some of these DeFi products that are kind of designed around this kind of on chain credit intermediation, but fundamentally like philosophically, we believe in full reserve money, full reserve banking where you separate the activity of lending from the payment utility.
And that's like a core core philosophy behind circle and USDC as well. Full reserve money, a payment coin. We want to get back to that later in the conversation, the context of like does the US government want that? What does the US government want? Let's hold that side of the conversation because you opened up something else, which is like DeFi and crypto and blockchain and like money at the speed of information, money at the speed of light and kind of this idea of you're like global frictionless kind of payment transactions. So a question we often ask in crypto is what year is it in internet terms?
Okay, so I know Jeremy, this is not your first company that you're building, not your first start. If you saw the birth of the internet, you built protocols on the TCP, IP, internet protocol. And now you're building circle on kind of like crypto native protocols. It's interesting because crypto just hit 15 years old. And Bitcoin started in 2009, as many people know, the internet's birthday, if you go Google this, the internet, like Google says, the internet's birthday was in 1983. And 15 years after the birth of the internet was 1998. Okay, so if you like project that forward, are we in the late 1990s in terms of like blockchain?
I was curious because I know you have a take on this. You've been through the early internet cycles and now you're here for the internet of value cycle. What year is it? Are we in the early 90s and the late 90s is this post.com bubble? I mean, certainly in 2022, felt to a lot of people like it was a bubble and then a pop. Yeah, so I think about this a lot. And I think it's very different than the evolution we saw from like the, basically these unconnected networks in the 80s and connecting those into sort of the birth of the HTTP protocol, which then kind of gave rise to the web and SMTP protocol, which gave rise to email, which were really in 1998, like the killer apps.
They were still pretty difficult to use and it was all dial-up modems. It was a pretty awful infrastructure, but you could build things. Like, you know, we built an app server, you could build apps in a browser and that was like a really powerful thing and people were, you know, wanted this decentralized infrastructure setting up these nodes and let's like everyone was publishing. So you had a sense for like, wow, this is amazing. I think we're further than that though in crypto. And I actually think where we are is very similar to where we were in like 2003. And yeah, and so my view is, so you have like multiple convergent things happening at once.
And you know, back in 2003, you had basically like client software on the internet got much better. Like you could build good user interfaces in browsers and the like, like the standards got better for UX. You had broadband basically taking off. So you didn't have broadband really until 2002. And so then you had residential broadband really starting to take off, which created the ability to have these faster pipes. And so not everyone had the faster pipes that the faster pipes are there. Wi-Fi came out like Wi-Fi didn't exist before then. It was like super niche. And then people started to be able to connect devices that could connect to the broadband and then you could then teleport like the digital media or the software in different ways.
So you had Wi-Fi, you had broadband, you had better client user experiences. And you actually had billions of dollars of capex that had been laid out by companies who had basically invested billions into the .com boom. And that capex became available and became more commoditized as well. And so the ability to like deploy servers, server farms or to build what we now know as cloud, like the commoditization was happening there. So you had all these things kind of coming together. And it really made the consumer internet possible. It made e-commerce really work much more broadly. And it made basically software as a service happen, like that basically starting in like 2003, 2004 SaaS just completely took off.
And so what was interesting about it is from that point forward, it was basically a non-stop period of progress. There was no, I mean, there were some, the public markets did different things, but basically like the progress basically was just never stopped. And I think we're still there, like the progress never stopped. So if I think about blockchain networks, like where we are today, there's a similar kind of convergence that's happening. You basically have like the layering of blockchain networks which is creating these really, really powerful scalability models where you can go very app specific and you can have a deep underlying assurances of security you're seeing the advent of an application of zero knowledge technology which is a critical precondition to people feeling comfortable with their privacy and their data and their identity and other things on these networks.
You're seeing UX abstraction finally arriving. So basically all of the really hard parts of crypto, which is like I need to go buy a crypto token, move it to a third party wallet that I have to set up with like a seed phrase, I have to sign these transactions. I have no idea what I'm doing. Why do I need this gas token and it costs like $7 to do this thing to get that NFT? It was just awful. And so like during that 21 and 22, the reality is like the UX was awful. And so now we have infrastructure and UX abstractions. Gas abstractions, we run a gas station, any developer can build with it. And you can basically take away gas for users.
It's just like really, really cool. And you're seeing modular smart contract accounts that are basically creating pluggable, extensible kind of UX models for wallet experiences that then devs can build all kinds of modules and wallet creators can adapt those. And the UX layers basically like we're seeing that with a number of wallets that are out there right now. And so the combination of the scalable infrastructure, better UX. And then finally, while this doesn't necessarily feel like it's happening, legal clarity is actually happening in most parts of the world. So almost ever in the world, there's legal clarity.
And when you have legal clarity, then households and firms and financial institutions are like, oh, OK, I know what this is. I know how to account for it on my books. I know how to interact with it. And it's like I now have a trustworthy infrastructure. And so all these things are coming together. And the technology progress in these infrastructure layers is speeding up, not slowing down. So I think this is 2003. I think we're going to see wonderful, beautiful apps that get consumer scale over the next 12 to 24 months. We will easily reach a billion users that can transact in something like USDC, but also with other things.
I really think we're in a very different place. And now it's like sufficient that developers can build all kinds of other applications. Obviously, like, farcasters are a wonderful example of like, wow, you can build beautiful apps that have protocols, that have digital tokens, that have extensibility and other things. So I'm very bullish about where we are. And I don't really care about exactly what prices are and all that, but I really think technologically we're in a really excellent place. You don't care about prices, Jeremy, because you run a stablecoin, man. And that's what's the problem.
Yeah, I'm not pumping any token. That's right. It's always fun to do the infrastructure comparisons of the 90s to what we have now in the blockchain world. Because it seems to be like a, I mean, it's of course never going to be a one-to-one comparison, but there's always lessons to be learned, right? There's always patterns, of course. But the always the big difference is that there was never any financial assets in the 90s. And so that's always the thing that kind of breaks down the metaphor, that breaks down the comparisons. One of the fuels for motivating all of this is of course like Bitcoin invented digital goal, digital money, you know, e-thalts, too.
Like a lot of other like we all kind of are playing around with assets. But I think before the paradigm of stablecoins, no one actually really saw the paradigm of stablecoins coming. But now we actually do understand that stablecoins have just an insanely large role to play in both the motivations, the financing of development, where we are going. There's 150 billion dollars of stablecoins in this space. And so it not only has it kind of defined, maybe like the last like four to five years of development, not holistically, but a very big, a very large part of like blockchain development. Where do you think this goes?
As this infrastructure technically, like on an engineering and infra perspective, it will get more sophisticated, it will get better, it will improve. But on the financial asset side of things, for stablecoins and just generally speaking, like where do you think this goes in the next 10 years? Yeah. So what I've sort of, and you can ask anyone who's ever worked at circle, this question is that my view has always been like, this is the progress in basically building an internet financial system that is natively built from the ground up on the internet is like a 10, 20, 30 year project. It takes a really long time.
And we set out a very specific vision about a protocol for dollars on the internet that could actually be like scalable and you could transact at the speed of the internet and you could do it for nearly zero cost. And that would be programmable and all that. That was like in the founding of the company nearly 11 years ago. And like if I look at where we are today, with just say USDC and this new form of electronic money, like we're basically at the 1.0 vision. Like we basically have reached like the 1.0 idea. And that's great. And it's already like a scaled network and it has a lot of reach. But I think like if you talk about the next 10 years, I think the growth in this can be really dramatic.
I think about the kind of market in a couple ways. I think the first is there is a market for electronic cash or electronic money. And today the market for electronic dollars is a $21 trillion market. There's $21 trillion of electronic dollars. And most of that is kind of bank risk money. It's sort of levered money inside of banks. And what is that $21 trillion? So is that like money in my bank account, my Wells Fargo account, that would count towards that? That's right. That's like M1 money supply. And so that aggregates up all of the kind of dollar liabilities that exist in the banking sector.
And then you can also include on top of that usually the amount of dollars that are held in like money market funds, which is I think currently $5 or $6 trillion. So that's like the dollar electronic money market. And then globally that's about $100 trillion, a little bit more than $100 trillion because there's all these currencies and all these banks all around the world. So if you're in dollars, so you're not talking about... In dollar terms. Yeah, in dollar terms. In dollar terms, what you're talking about like the digital euro for example. But now I'm just talking about like you've got 1.4 billion people in India and they have rupee accounts and all the corporations and households have rupee.
And those are electronic, those are electronic, that's electronic money as well. And M1 rupee is basically. Yeah, M1 rupee is right. So the aggregated kind of that kind of aggregated electronic, the electronic money is over $100 trillion. So 150 billion stablecoins, very, very small, right? And I would argue that in this comes back to something I said earlier that in a world where basically you have money that inherits the physics of the internet where you have basically the speed, the efficiency and reach of the internet. And that is what blockchain networks are now providing. Where you have money that inherits that speed, the best money is going to be, is going to want to be and people want to be the safest money.
They're going to want it to be that kind of almost like government obligation money. And that is going to be the combination of like hyper utility, programmability, transparency, and safety, right, when you put all this together, it's going to be like the new predator form of money. And I believe that it will become the preferred form of money by households, by institutions, by financial players. It will become a preferred form of money because it has the highest utility and safety. And the internet and blockchain networks are going to be providing that ultra high utility. So our belief is that the opportunity at just the money stock, basically just the money stock, there's a huge opportunity to grow the scale of that.
And it's sort of like e-commerce originally was like 0% of retail sales. And when Amazon was a monster company, like e-commerce was still only 10% of retail sales, it's still not even close to the majority of retail sales. Same thing with like streaming media, like the vast majority of television consumed is still a broadcast, right? It's not on streaming platforms. So these migrations take a long time. So in 10 years, could 3% of the or 5% of the electronic money market be in stablecoins? That's conceivable. Over 10 years, could it be 10% or 15% over 20 years? That follows a similar type of adoption arc.
But even in that scale, it's significant. The other way to think about the market is basically the utility side of it, which is, you have the money stock, and then you have the utility of how you can use the money stock. And right now, that's expressed through markets like consumer payments, which is sort of all of these merchant acquiring fees and issuer fees and like this whole stack that imposes essentially a trillion dollar tax on the global economy through all the fees that that has. You have the utility of using that electronic money in capital markets. So the actual volume of activity that goes into capital markets where literally there's trillions and trillions of dollars of activity that happens there.
And the payment utility of the pipes that do that, you have the entire international transaction market and cross-border transaction market, which is households and firms, which is this huge slow, inexpensive, and fee-prone market. And every single one of these can be improved with blockchain infrastructure on chain FX markets, on chain credit markets. You can move so much of the financial primitives into an on-chain world. And you can, I think, fundamentally have the utility of money have that kind of 10X improvement that we've seen in the utility of communications, the utility of publishing, the utility of other mediums that the internet has produced.
That utility can be just that 10X better. And with a completely different unit economic model. And so the business model of extracting fees and tolls on moving value, I think that's going to be challenged just like charging for long distance telephone calls is nearly inconceivable, right? So there's the utility side and then there's the money stock and they both grow and feed on each other. And I think one of the really exciting things about stablecoins is they are kind of platforms and network utilities that exist as protocols that anyone can connect to and build on, like USDC, any developer in the world, any person in the world can download a piece of software, connect to it, and then utilize it as a network.
Any developer who wants to have a digital dollar integrated into their own application for settlement or storage or other things, they just have to write code. And so that hasn't existed in the financial system before. And that's really profound. And so I think similar to when let's just use as another example of a discontinuous jump in innovation, which was the iPhone, for 10 years, people were trying to build smartphones. Like they were awful, like every one of them. Like Nokia phones, NTT.com, Compact, IPAC, Palm Pilot, Blackberry, Windows phone. I mean, it was just a graveyard of people who were like mobile, mobile, mobile software, all this.
And it was awful. And then finally, there was a convergence of things, which was like a good UX, mobile broadband 3G happened, a good UX and a really good development model. And then you had like an open platform for mobile that allowed just enormous amounts of entrepreneurial creativity. Like no one could have predicted that the travel and logistics, you know, infrastructure would get completely reinvented by like a company like Uber. Like that was only made possible. Like that just became possible. And so I use that analogously to what's happening with DeFi and what's happening with stablecoins and this programmable money model is, we actually don't yet know all the things that people are going to invent with programmable composable money.
Like we're seeing stuff every day and it's amazing. But it's actually, we're like right at the front end of that. And so when that UX layer kicks in and the scalability kicks in and these are legal instruments that like governments stand behind and say, yes, this is a legal dollar or a legal euro, then I think you start to see totally unpredictable use cases that will emerge. And so it's like, I can't even predict like what are going to be the five killer apps of money in five years from now. I think it's actually too difficult to predict that. Jeremy, I still hear in the back of my head the critic or this and saying, okay, you say it's a 2003 right now in crypto world, right?
And in terms of internet years. But like the 2003 was sort of the era where, you know, the internet became not just for nerds and geeks. It just like totally went mainstream. And the way we went mainstream was like killer apps. We had killer apps. And here crypto has been in existence for like 15 years now and stablecoins have been in existence for a while now. And 150 billion is like respectable. The only credit where it's due. It's only sliver. And like the most simple app on the planet feels like Venmo for crypto. I just want to take my stablecoin in a mobile wallet and I want to just send David some USDC.
And we don't have Venmo for crypto. Jeremy, where is Venmo for crypto? Where are these apps going to come from? Have you tried Coinbase wallet with base? Yeah, tell me, tell me, where is it? Why hasn't it come until now? And like, is that basically what you're predicting? So I mean, look, I think general payment utility is definitely the killer app that we'll see. And I don't just view it as this is just about the Venmo, the person-to-person type component, right? The beauty of this is that this infrastructure works for every dimension in the market. There are USDC users that are paying 25 cents for a digital object in a Web 3 game.
And they can do it because it actually works. And that exact same technology on that exact same blockchain is being used to settle a $200 million trade bilaterally peer-to-peer between two large trading counter parties. Like, you're not doing a $100 million transaction with Venmo, you're also not really doing a 25 cent transaction, right? So you have this like super scalable model. But I completely agree with you, right? The interoperable, global, you know, direct value exchange is definitely the killer app. And so what's interesting is, and I think what you're seeing is you're seeing the bottom up build, which is like, you know, the crypto-native companies, like Coinbase, building, you know, base and Coinbase wallet and connecting that together.
You see Binance doing similar things across their platform and trust wallet and things. But you also see, you know, like these huge aggregators of end users who are basically building Web 3 into their infrastructure. So like Grab and Southeast Asia, 200 million users, they're using Circles Web 3 infrastructure stack or developer platform to put Web 3 natively in the hands of their users. New bank in Brazil, 90 million users. These are huge, right? These are user bases that are bigger than the biggest crypto companies in many cases that are building, you know, digital dollars into their apps. You know, another major Latin American giant, Miracata Libre, you know, doing amazing things by sort of bringing these in.
And we're seeing this happen around the world, which is super apps, large scale like consumer fintech products that already exist are basically building in blockchain infra and they're building in Web 3 clients. And when that starts to happen, that's when you start to connect all these together, right? You start to actually have a world where you have interoperability, right? And it's not just like a new app that someone created. It's actually within apps that are already widely adopted. And so whether you're in, you know, in Indonesia and you use the dominant e-money app there or in the Philippines, the dominant e-money app there in Japan, these sort of fintech e-money apps that are like the Venmos, right?
That are kind of the neo banks, right? They're all moving into crypto infrastructure. Like all of them are moving into crypto infrastructure. And so that's what lights up the kind of global network and global utility layer at an end user level. And then I think, you know, the other side is basically kind of on the institutionalization front, which is where in the, as you guys know, like super early days of tokenization, super early days of RWA's. But you know, long been the promise, which is can you take a existing financial contract and can you represent that in a smart contract and have it, you know, the digital token become the mechanism that you flow value in and out of that then ultimately becomes an instrument that can be used through all of the kind of composable infrastructure that is DeFi.
So that we're at the front edge of that. And, you know, in certain places, laws and regulations are going to help accelerate that. So like Micah in Europe, which goes effective, you know, June 30th, you know, all of a sudden you're going to see it's like legal to issue these digital tokens and, you know, lots of different players can be able to do it. Stable coins are going to become the digital cash for how you use those. And so the kind of capital markets, which is a giant category, right? You'll start to see more capital markets, use cases moving on chain as well. I'm hopeful though that, you know, the utility of a blockchain is way outside of financial, right?
And it's sort of a useful technology for so many other things. And, you know, that can be in, certainly coordinating and incentivizing different kinds of economic behavior to drive an outcome and you see this with like, deep in, but it also can be just a very, very powerful way to have provable data, provable transactions, provable data, and provable transactions at scale are useful in a lot of applications and socials, obviously, one where that's taking hold. Gaming is another one where that's taking hold. We have a relationship that we talk about and it's public with the, I think, the second largest gaming company in Korea called Kraft and they build, they operate one of the largest like massive multiplayer online universes out there as a traditional game and they're building something called Overdrive, which is essentially like a kind of Roblox style, creator game at scale, entirely blockchain native and then using like USDC as the in-game, kind of a unit of account, right, that's there.
And like these kinds of products are really just coming as well. So obviously, but even your analogy of 2003, like 2003, not a lot of people even had broadband yet. And so it was still really early. Like YouTube didn't come out until 2004 and it really didn't take off until 2005, 2006 and it was years, there were still years before a lot of these things. Facebook didn't exist until 2004 and then it was just on college campuses it didn't really take off until 2008, where it really opened up and it exploded. So there's still some work to do for sure. As we do these comparisons to the internet of old, there's always like the ways that it's the same and again, ways that it's different.
I think especially with crypto, like where is the killer app is always like one of the favorite questions that we ask ourselves. But I think like there's really two frontiers that crypto progresses on. There's the frontier of all the financial things that we already do, that we know crypto is better at. But we actually still have to compete with this already entrenched, we still have to compete with Venmo. Like so why is there no Venmo for crypto? Oh, because Venmo exists. Like it's actually a good product. And so we have to compete on that front. And then there's like the actual killer app, the net new thing, because like at least Facebook, MySpace, Instagram, Uber, they actually didn't really have too strong of like historical precedence to compete against.
There was actually somewhat of a vacuum there. Maybe Uber had to compete with the taxi companies and that's like crypto competing on Venmo, like eventually we'll get there. So there's like two frontiers here, right? There's like the pre-existing web to FinTech apps that we have to compete with just on our merits. But then there's also the frontier of just like what are these net new crypto things that like are like friend tech or something like ENS? How do you like to delineate between these two lines, Jeremy? How do you think these things are going to go? Yeah, well, I mean like I think if you believe in the fundamental tenants of web three and read right on and so on and so forth, a huge part of what will make a lot of these apps killer is the way in which people participate in them and build value in them and share ownership in them.
And like that's a fundamental paradigm shift. It's a huge paradigm shift. And the ability to have participatory platforms that's not existed before. And so I think we're all waiting for the examples of that to be born in a lot of different categories that are currently run by like centralized platforms. And so I think that is a huge difference. Obviously one huge barrier to that is consistent treatment of digital commodities and how this digital commodities can be bought and sold and how they're issued and the laws around that, right? Until that's resolved, there's just gonna be this challenge, right?
So we have that issue in the US. We have to have regulatory clarity. It's not sufficient to just have lawsuits, right? We have to have regulatory clarity. We have to be able to know like who issues the digital commodity, when they issue it, what do you have to disclose? What are, there's like a whole bunch of things that are needed, other jurisdictions are providing a path for that. And then that needs to work around the world because these are all internet scale. Like a digital token that exists as a mechanism for participation, governance, incentives, et cetera. Like that has to be able to work around the world.
And so we have to see that progress. I think that is a real challenge. And obviously, at some level, one could be very pessimistic about the outlook for that, say in the United States. I'm always an optimist with a lot of different things, but what I see is Congress is getting smarter and smarter. More and more people understand that there are these distinctions between the different types of digital tokens that exist in the world. And other jurisdictions are actually providing that regulatory clarity. And so I think we'll get there. But I think that's necessary, right? Because if economic incentives and economic incentive design and participation in economics becomes a mass scale phenomenon through decentralized applications and platforms, you need a basis of law around that that works at scale.
For everyone to be comfortable, like saying, just like everyone got comfortable getting in an Uber with a random stranger, letting strangers stay in your house with Airbnb, there's a comfort that has to come. And I think in financial matters, the way that comfort comes is not entirely self-pleasing. Mantle, formerly known as BitDow, is the first Dow-led Web3 ecosystem, all built on top of Mantle's first core product, the Mantle Network, a brand new high-performance Ethereum layer two built using the OP stack, but uses eigenlayers data availability solution instead of the expensive Ethereum layer one.
Not only does this reduce Mantle Network's gas fees by 80%, but it also reduces gas fee volatility, providing a more stable foundation for Mantle's applications. The Mantle Treasury is one of the biggest Dow-owned treasuries, which is seeding an ecosystem of projects from all around the Web3 space for Mantle. Mantle already has subcommunities from around Web3 onboarded, like Game 7 for Web3 Gaming, and buy a bit for TVL and liquidity and on-rounds. So if you want to build on the Mantle Network, Mantle is offering a grants program that provides milestone-based funding to promising projects that help expand, secure, and decentralize Mantle.
If you want to get started working with the first Dow-led layer two ecosystem, check out Mantle at Mantle.xyz and follow them on Twitter at 0x Mantle. Have you heard about Safe? They're not just pioneers in crypto custody, they're also leading the transition to the world of smart accounts. With Safe, managing your crypto has never been smarter or safer. They've recently passed $100 billion in total value secured and are now deployed everywhere with over 15 supported networks. But that's not all. Safe is revolutionizing the game with their full compatibility with ERC4337, making embedding wallets super easy to integrate into your daily crypto activities.
And for the crypto enthusiasts out there, Safe has something special. The Safe Pass Activity Rewards Program. It's a fantastic way to engage and earn rewards, launching just after a Safe Dow voted in favor of Safe Token transferability. So what are you waiting for? Head over to safe.global, sign up for the Safe Pass Activity Rewards Program, and don't forget to check out SafeCon during Berlin Blockchain Week, where the future of smart accounts is unfolding in real life. Click the link in the show notes, secure your spot today, and be a part of the transition that's setting a new standard in the world of custody.
Are you launching a token? Is it already live? How are you managing the legal and tax obligations for providing token grants to your team? It's no secret that token management gets complicated. Between learning all the legal language and tax obligations in every country that your team is in, token grant management can feel like an obstacle course, but it doesn't have to. That's where Toku steps in. Toku provides practical tools to handle token grants, allowing for effective oversight of token distributions and payroll tax compliance for employees, contractors, advisors, and investors. They also handle tax withholdings through their real-time tax calculations that can be done by Toku or integrated into any payroll EOR providers in any jurisdiction.
Toku is a trusted provider of protocol labs, dydx foundation, mean of protocol, and many more. Get started for free and make token compensation simple at toku.com slash bankless. Welcome to Consensus 2024. Consensus is one of the biggest hubs for all things crypto, blockchain, and web through. This may, consensus is celebrating 10 years of decentralizing the future. Going to Consensus means being in good company with over 15,000 attendees from over a hundred countries. You have the opportunity to learn directly from the architects and advocates representing Bitcoin, Ethereum, Solana, along with the teams from popular layer 2s like Mantle, Arbitrum, Optimism, Base, and others.
Well, Consensus is more than just discussions and presentations. Badchholders get access to it and is 10 professional karate combat fights and one unprofessional one between myself and the Carter. For the visionaries, Pitch Fest is your spotlight, presenting a stage for the most promising early stage web three companies. And for the devs, the hackathon offers a unique chance to build your next project or take your existing project to the next level. Immerse yourself in hundreds of side events and hacker houses scattered around Austin. Register for Consensus 2024 today and save 20% with code bankless.
Yeah, I do think that comfort is starting to show up on the institutional side, right? Now, institutions, Larry Fink is willing to get in an Uber with crypto, let's say, which is really interesting. Like, we would have been scared to do that. I think he was maybe like five years ago, let's say. And speaking of Larry Fink, a black rock in circle, you were talking earlier, Jeremy, about a tokenized treasury or real world assets, let's say. And one of the biggest real world assets aside from the dollar itself is a treasury, a US treasury. There is something that we've been tracking at crypto has been Black Rock's Biddle Fund where they are using a third party company, more crypto native company called Securitized to actually put treasuries on chain in tokenized form.
That was part one of kind of the release and announcement. We just found out probably a week prior to recording this in the publishing of this episode, Jeremy, that on the other side of that smart contract, again, this is all beautiful, it's all on Ethereum, it's all in code. You can go see it on ether scan. On the other side of that smart contract is a little function in the code, a redeem function. So people who have these Black Rock tokenized treasuries can hit that redeem function button essentially in the smart contract level on chain and redeem those tokenized treasuries for what? For USDC, the stablecoin.
So now for the first time on chain, what I'm aware of anyway, at the level of Black Rock, we have a pipeline, we have some bandwidth coming through from treasuries to stablecoins. I know you can't speak on behalf of Black Rock, of course, maybe you'd speak on behalf of crypto and stablecoins, though, in general, in circle. How big of a deal is this? What just happened with this kind of redeem function and where's it going to lead to? I mean, I think it's a really big deal, obviously. I think it's been interesting to see the evolution at Black Rock, they became a strategic investor in circle a couple of years ago.
So almost two years ago. And we built out this very innovative, highly transparent, reserve structure for USDC. So they were making a big bet on stablecoins. And I think I got to know Larry think and the other leadership there and had a lot of long conversations about digital commodities, digital gold, what are the differences between all these blockchains? And I think the team there, Larry certainly got excited about these things, but I think the team there that was sort of assigned with coming up with strategies and digital assets, they were really getting, I think, the strong support from their leadership to like, we see that this is actually going to be highly disruptive to asset management.
It's going to be highly disruptive to the way capital markets work. And they wanted to be at the forefront, which is amazing because they're 10 trillion, I don't know, their current assets under management are, but they're like the largest asset manager in the world. And a hugely important player. So it's been, I think just seeing that's been really positive. And I think this idea that you can have a financial contract, like I have a contract to own something, I can own a T-Bill, I can own a house, I can own stock in a company, I can own part of a sports franchise, I can own lots of things, the ability to express ownership in digital tokens and the ability to have the way in which you create and redeem ownership be stable coins, just makes tons of sense.
And the ability to have that exist on a public infrastructure, which is auditable, verifiable, secure, global, interoperable, like it just makes so much sense. And so the whole concept of the sort of democratization of capital markets, the ability for far more people in the world to participate in those capital markets, that is only really possible in an on-chain world. So I think having the most popular investable asset in the world, which is T-Bills, become tokenized and then have the cash component of it using the cash settlement piece of it using a digital cash instrument that is also on-chain, just it makes tons of sense.
And so I think we'll see a lot more examples of this, not just in the T-Bills space, but in a lot of other categories. It's a really exciting area. I think one of the big things is gonna be, when do we have exchanges that can trade these tokens and not just in the US, but globally. So regulators that are approving digital asset exchanges are also starting to approve that those exchanges can list these security tokens. So when do you start getting like global markets for these as well? You know, when do you have DeFi protocols that can interact with these and do that like in a compliant way, right?
So there's a lot to build on from here, but I think it's a very, very exciting start. And there certainly have been others that have been experimenting in the same category over the last year, but obviously BlackRock stepping in is a really, really big deal. Okay, so to see some of this vision to fruition, there's another player that has to kind of like wait in on it and a player that seems like almost split brain on the subject of crypto and stablecoin so far. And that is the almighty US government. I'm curious your perspective on this Jeremy, like what does the US government want when it comes to stablecoins?
And let me just lay out a few things that is just like context for this conversation. And like maybe you would know best, there does seem to be some advantage to the US government to essentially kind of like outsource at CBDC kind of like investment structure to the private sector. We already have the ledger, we already have programmable money, like let's just do it with stablecoins, right? And that could be kind of like a CDBC for you. So like there's that, there's also this perceived benefit potentially of what is one of the killer exports of the US right now. It's the dollar. I mean 80% of worldwide transactions are like handled in dollars and denominated in dollars.
I mean, that's absolutely phenomenal. The world loves this product. And we can go get it to countries that have subpar banking systems. That's maybe on the pro side of things. Oh, and you might also add, somebody's got to buy some tea bills, don't they? Well, US debt is continuing to rock it up. So that's on the pro side, on the against side of things though, you were talking about like circle and the idea of a payment coin and like that being backed is kind of like a fully reserved bank. Arthur Hayes put out a post like probably a month ago and made the point, which like I don't know what you think in terms of Zachary C.
It's not clear that treasury in the Fed actually want like a fully reserved bank at all, right? If they did, they would have already like issued licenses to kind of like make fully reserved happens. The reason is some of their monetary dials kind of get dulled. Like they use the bank's lending function to kind of like adjust supply of money and maybe they lose that ability. Maybe they lose some sovereignty here in the process. So maybe they have some concerns with exporting the US dollar via stablecoin. Anyway, zooming back out to the question, that's kind of the context. I asked the question of what does the US government want when it comes to dollar backed stablecoins?
There's a lot in there and there's a lot of great stuff to talk about. I think the first is like, you know, I think saying the US government is never an accurate thing. It's not a monolith, right? It's not like this one mind that is the US government and it speaks with one voice, right? The US government is there's three branches of it. They all have their own thing. You have the actual parts of the government, the agencies that are responsible for things like the dollar, like the Treasury Department or the Federal Reserve. You have parts of the government that are very, very focused, for example, on national security and on all the wars that are breaking out around the world and all of the hostile nation state issues that exist, right?
So the government is a lot of different voices. And so there is no uniform voice on this. But I think the closest thing that we have to a uniform voice on this is that several years ago, the United States government through what is called FSOC, which is the financial stability oversight council, which is basically the heads of all of the big financial regulators. But at the behest of the US Treasury Department, which is the department that is in a sense in charge of the dollar in the world, went around the world and worked with all of the biggest governments in the world at the G20 and said there needs to be a legal and regulatory framework for what they were calling payment stablecoins.
These are going to get really big. They're potentially going to be systemic in size. They have real innovation potential, but there's also like all these risks, there's run risks, there's illicit finance risks, there's all these risks. And we need to agree at a global level that we need to have clear laws and regulations around this new kind of money. And so that was agreed to at the G20. And all the governments at the G20 went back and they have to do their lawmaking process. And lawmaking processes are different in Japan than they are in Hong Kong, than they are in Singapore or Europe or the US.
So what you've had happen since then is basically all the major governments have come forward with regulation of payment stablecoins and relatively consistent. So there were a set of recommendations at the G20 and the US basically said to Congress, here's what those recommendations are. And we want you Congress to act to actually enact laws that introduce this into the US financial system. And that's been happening around the world. I mean, payment stablecoins became legal in Japan last year. June 30th, which is just a couple months away, payment stablecoins will be a legal form of money in Europe.
And if you don't have, if you want to offer a stablecoin to a person in Europe, whether you're offshore or onshore, if you're not issuing it out of an EU regulated entity, whether it's a dollar stablecoin or a euro stablecoin, it'll be illegal. And so you're seeing around the world like very clear rules. And basically they're saying, these are full reserve. They have these narrow set of assets that they can back them so that they're as safe as possible. They have very clear redemption requirements. They have very clear segregation so that if the issue where it has a problem, the users can always get their funds.
They have to follow kind of any money laundering rules. And so you have this happening all around the world and so as we speak, 2024, 2025, stablecoins are becoming a defined part of the global financial system, which is really great. We are right at the finish line of the Payment Stablecoin Act, which is a law that is actively working its way through Congress that the feds contributed to, the Treasury's contributed to, the White House has involved, both chambers of Congress, there's a very, very active effort to codify this in the United States. And to get to the heart of your question, which is what is the government think?
Well, first they think these are gonna be bigger and they're gonna play a bigger role and there's gonna be a competitive marketplace of issuers. There's gonna be kind of non-banks, banks. There's gonna be smaller companies, global companies. These are gonna be a new thing. And in a sense that is outsourcing the production, the manufacturing and distribution of digital dollars to the private sector. But that's what we do today. 95% of electronic money in circulation is privately issued. It's privately issued by commercial banks. The infrastructure that we use every day, whether it's like Swift or your card rails, they're basically technology networks run by consort teams and private sector actors.
And almost every innovation that we've had in payment systems in the US certainly has been like a private sector led innovation. So I think it is in some ways that, now I think the deeper philosophical issue, this kind of monetary theory issue, which you refer to in Arthur's Post and in general, kind of comes back to our own philosophical belief, which is that if you have hyper high velocity money that exists at internet scale, it needs to be full reserve money. It needs to be as safe as possible. It's too dangerous to do something else. So then the question naturally becomes from the central bank perspective, how do you deal with monetary policy transmission?
How do you ensure that when you want to have credit expansion, you can have credit expansion. When you want to have credit extraction, you can have credit contraction. These are sort of the kind of smoothing out of the economic cycles that are interest rates try and play a role, interest rates being a kind of key input into bank lending behavior. And so that has been historically the way that this monetary policy transmission has worked. I believe this is where DeFi and on-chain steps in. I am like a long bull on on-chain credit, a hyper high velocity high utility money that can be programmatically controlled and time locked with very high levels of transparency and auditability and where the actual risk and underwriting and other things can be produced and validated with proofs on-chain.
Like you can produce a radically better credit delivery system than the opaque leveraged banking system. And so this goes back to the founding of circle, which is we believe in the creation of an internet financial system and that internet financial system is gonna be built on full reserve money and it's gonna be built on the programmability of money and the ways in which the time value of money, which is essentially credit, right? The time, credit lending and savings and investing, the time value of money, is better intermediated by on-chain software than it is by persons and small tangent to AI.
I think AI will play an important role in all of that credit decisioning too, but like we could go there and do a whole nother topic, but I think that's how I think about that issue and I think central bankers are now starting to grapple with this like, oh, okay, there is this new super high utility model of hyper-efficient internet scale on-chain money that's happening, like it's not that gene he's not going back in the battle, it's happening. How do we think about monetary policy transmission? We've actually, our chief economist was formerly an economist at the Fed, he's published a number of really exceptional pieces on this topic as well.
And this gets to the heart of the matter. I mean, it really gets to the heart of the matter. Are we building a new internet financial system that is safer, more transparent, more frictionless, more fair, more accessible, economically, globally, right? But we have to be able to perform time value of money transformations, the sort of credit intermediation with this kind of the safer base layer of money. It's interesting to see the trajectory of circles just getting closer and closer to the metal, closer and closer to the firmware here of the dollar and that kind of this last step of a full reserve stable coin base layer, full reserve bank it sort of cuts eutortitional commercial banks out of the loop.
But what I hear, what you just described Jeremy, it almost sounds like a central bank digital currency without using that term. It almost sounds like some form of a proto-CBDC or like a privately issued arm of some kind of central bank monetary policy type of thing. It's my perception that a central bank digital currency does not have the political will power to get through in the U.S. like right now. Other countries may try it, like China certainly can like, they can push in whatever they want. I don't think voters are excited when you tell them we've got a federal CDBC. Totally, there's no appetite.
Yeah, there's no appetite at all. But if you talk about this in terms of a kind of like a stable coin with like a wallet you can use and you kind of like own the private keys and all of these things, I think it's sort of a different story and maybe feels like an upgraded experience. But let me just ask you, what you just described with stable coins in the U.S. Again, we've got some regulation to kind of get there but if they follow suit with other countries is what you described basically a proto or private version of a CBDC central bank digital currency? I mean, I don't know that it is because private intermediaries, whether they're financial technology companies or payment companies like PayPal or banks that decide like JPMorgan that they want to be in this there, you're not the central government.
And I think one of the reasons why there is so much opposition to CBDCs is fundamentally about privacy and this concept that there's an air gap between you and the government. If all encrypted messaging was run by a government server, would you use that or would you use WhatsApp, right? Or if they had a product which was like, hey, there's the government run communications app or there's privately run where privacy standards are upheld, right? I think clearly like society has a preference for some air gap and distance between themselves in their own activities and the government. Even in China, where they do have a CBDC, it's completely failed because people don't trust their government.
They trust Oli Pay and Tencent and WeChat Pay more than they trust the government. Both because of the utility of those products, they're just constantly upgrading, constantly innovating. Like you have like the user experience of those platforms are getting better and better and better. And even where they say, hey, you have to take your disbursement payments in our CBDC. Like people get out of them as quickly as possible and move into private money. So I think that we use the phrase that the future of currency competition is a technology competition. And if the dollar has to compete in a technology competition globally, the United States has done extraordinarily well, like better than any country in the world at harnessing the power of private innovation in technology.
And you can pick any sector like the advancements, the incredible companies that have been built, whether it's Tesla as one example, SpaceX as another Elon Musk example, but all of these amazing companies, Apple and Microsoft and Meta, and then a lot of other industries, obviously in biopharmaceuticals and all these things. There's this extraordinary power of free market capitalism of competition, of a rules-based system. And that unleashes innovation in a way that a government-run system can't. And so if you want to win the technology competition, you ought to work with the companies that are driving technology innovation and we're gonna be part of that constantly upgradable financial system that blockchain represents.
Yeah, I agree with that. I think most Americans would be on board with that, like make it a free market competition and do it privately. We're not comfortable having the government control the keys and the database and everything else. And in this context, Jeremy, I'm wondering if we could talk about Tether for a minute. So Tether is the number one stablecoin right now. USDC is number two. And I think what some people in crypto have concerns about is that when it comes to stablecoins in the US, we go from a position of we've got free market open competition to we go into a position of regulatory capture.
And like with governments, you can easily see how this could happen. And so part of the crypto industry kind of like cried out. There was a headline saying in the stablecoin wars circle and Coinbase acting in Congress to reign in Tether. And here's a quote from Caroline Hill, who's the director of global policy and regulatory strategy at Circle. She said this in the testimony in front of Congress, I personally believe no company should be allowed to reference the US dollar without having democratic values inside their USD backed stablecoin. And went on in the tone antenna of that is like, Tether is not playing by the rule book and you need to reign them in Congress.
What did she mean by the quotes? And like what's your take on that testimony in front of Congress? Yeah, I mean, a couple of things. First, Caroline Hill is an amazing person. I have a huge amount of respect for her. She served in the US government for many years. She's a very high integrity person. And I think she does extraordinary work and she represents the entire crypto industry extremely well in front of major policy makers in the government and internationally, dealing with crypto AML rules and how those are playing out and all the rule setting that has to happen around the world. She's fighting for fair rules so that we can continue to have on-chain innovation.
So first of all, I have a huge amount of respect for Caroline, she's tremendous. Like, I'm not going to comment on everything that she may have said or questions she's asked under oath and testimony. And if you're sitting in front of Congress, you are under oath and you've got to tell them what you think. Like, I think US government speaks for itself on these matters. I mean, Wally Ademo, who is the Deputy Secretary of Treasury, who's in charge of all matters of sanctions, elicit finance, countering terrorism finance, just submitted his own testimony last week. You can read it. He has a lot to say about this topic of stablecoins.
And I think there are realities in the market. And there are bad actors. And I'm not saying Tethers a bad actor, by the way. I think Tethers built an extraordinary business. They've been highly successful. I think they've been innovative for a very, very long time. That is, I'm not saying that. There are bad actors like people who are trying to evade sanctions, people who are funding North Korean weapons programs, people who are funding various types of terrorist attacks. There are fentanyl traffickers that are using stablecoins at a huge scale right now. And it's a plague in the United States.
So there are bad actors all over the place. And they're abusing stablecoins. And they're abusing stablecoins for a lot of different reasons. And I do think that part of what we have to see happen is we do need to have regulation around the world on stablecoins. There should be expectations about the issuers, how they manage risk. They're obligations from a compliance perspective. They're the safety and soundness obligations. Like all of this, we absolutely should have that. And I think, you know, Tethers a multi-billion dollar company. They have incredible resources. And I expect that they have every opportunity to come and register and be a licensed company around the world.
And I would expect that that's what they're going to ultimately do, right? Like why wouldn't you do that, right? So I think laws and regulations should be accessible to everyone. And I think what I expect to see, I mean, even just the prospect of stablecoin legislation coming, and this was in their public announcement, led PayPal to say, with regulatory clarity coming, we now want to get in the game and launch PYUSD. And so a giant company with regulatory clarity, I think when you see stablecoin laws coming in effect, you're going to see a ton of companies, major financial institutions, major payments companies, technology companies, I think the competition will increase immensely.
Right now, people are afraid to get in this market because they don't know where the rules are. And so I do think that, you know, part of the goal of establishing a regulatory regime is to enable free and fair competition. And the congressional acts in the mid to late 90s that came about created free and competitive playing fields in the communications networks and internet service provision and with net neutrality and things like that. And you saw this huge proliferation of competition and everything from data services to communications networks. So I would hope that regulatory clarity, not just on stablecoins, but on crypto asset markets.
And so on would bring a lot more competition. That would certainly be what I would expect to see. With the growth of the stablecoin supply and the stablecoin issues, I kind of see like two different vectors or two different frontiers once again, there's like the free market version where there's like a handful of different stablecoin issuers and they are all competing in the private markets, you know, capitalism. You know, the forces of capitalism produces a bread or product for the consumer. The weaker ones lose to the stronger ones. And this is of course like not just a competition from the centralized issuers, but also the decentralized ones as well.
Like Athena is a brand new player on the scene. Microdow has been here for a long time. Facts is of course a player. And so you know, let the best stablecoin win according to the forces of the free market. And that will certainly allow like good strong products to rise to the top. On the flip side of things, there's also a benefit to having like the central bank of the United States and the United States government just like say, hey, this is the one. And we actually back this one with a full faith and credit of our money printer. And so like and trying this one as like the pseudo CBDC provide this one with a liquidity benefits provide this one with like the faith of the government.
And that one would also like be a pretty good product if one if the government actually just says like, hey, that one's the best. Now like how the future actually unfolds. It's probably going to be some sort of medium between the two I'm assuming. How do you see like do you agree with those two like alignments of how this might play out and how do you see these the forces being at play here? I think they're definitely like two distinct arenas so to speak. I think you know, this concept of a payment stablecoin which is a term again, a term of art that like governments have come up with. And that's the name of the legislation in US Congress right now.
But it is very specific. And it is for the Federal Reserve to basically define a standard a set of standards and all the expectations of an issuer and to set those standards and enforce those standards, right? It's to define these standards for a full reserve fiat backed, you know, only backed by things like T-bills and the safest cash instruments and the like with like very strong supervision and audit, right? That there's a framework for that and the federal government is allowing for that and then will allow any entity that meets the qualifications to go in that market. So that's not the Federal Reserve picking one company.
It's saying here's the rules. Anybody can follow these rules. And obviously like anyone who decides to start a bank doesn't necessarily are not successful starting the bank, right? But any, you know, I think the concept here is anyone that wants to become a dollar payment stablecoin issuer can follow that. We're seeing this as a little bit of a preview in Europe right now. So Micah has stablecoin rules and there haven't really been widely successful Euro stablecoins to date. And, you know, ERC, which circle and coinbase both are involved with has some good success, but obviously way, way different than when USDC.
But however, like when June 30th comes around, I think you're going to see a ton of movement in your stablecoin space. You're going to be tons of companies that are entering. You might see 50 different companies competing, including big companies that are competing to do this because it's so clear. Big companies are there like big incumbents too? Like big EU banks entering? I think you're going to see big incumbents that some of whom are like large pan European banks who want to be in this market, some of whom are large pan European fintechs who will want to be in this market and then obviously like firms that are cryptid native, right?
So that's an example where I think you'll see like, okay, here's the level playing field, go. And it'll be like everyone's from the same start, right? There are no winners today there. So I think it'll be an interesting example of that. But coming back to your question, David, like about these different arenas, like payment stablecoins I think are really important. Like a fiat back instrument that is, people understand it's a legal dollar equivalent and it's redeemable and has interoperability into the existing banking system like that's super high utility and will grow in utility. I think there's a whole another category which are these efforts to create kind of synthetic dollars or algorithmically pegged dollars or various types of crypto collateralized, kind of quasi pegged dollars.
Like that's a whole separate area. And I think it's definitely a lot more complicated from a regulatory perspective. It's not straightforward. Like it's not clear what are these and how should they be treated and how should someone who holds them, you know, treated. If I'm a corporation and I'm using one of these, like what is this? Am I holding a synthetic derivative? Do I count for it as a derivative on my books? Does it need to be registered with a derivatives, you know, regulator? Like what are these, like are these securities? Like it's not clear what they are and it was gonna be a lot of, like, you know, jurisdictional kind of arguing over that.
Like the Terro Luna case, obviously the SEC asserted and one, its case. And it won its case that basically UST was, and Luna, the whole thing was an illegal investment management and illegal securities issuance and the CFTC was involved and said they were violating derivatives law. That's just a US matter in that case, but I think like if you asked securities and commodities regulators around the world, they'd all pretty much agree about that. So I think if we want these kind of synthetic dollars to have super high utility value, we're gonna have to update the laws in the financial system to allow them to be used for like every day kind of transactions.
Because I think they won't get used for everyday transactions. They might be like, I'm gonna pump my yield in this. I'm gonna like go over here for a little while because it's got juice or whatever. That's a whole different, like that's a very different set of incentives. Then you wanna have like a full reserve digital dollar that runs on blockchains. It strikes me how early days we still are. If there's like a $21 trillion like opportunity here, I'm like we're at 150 billion. We don't even have legislation. Like we haven't even seen the big banks in the US kind of entered the stablecoin again and explored that.
It means like JP Morgan coin. That was the thing that was talked about like what would that even look like? I'm curious though, earlier in the conversation, Jeremy, when you talked about Mika and other jurisdictions having stablecoin regulation, you also referred to the dollar as a kind of like a predator. I've called it like an apex predator as well. And I'm wondering if- I've heard you say that. You've heard me say that. Okay, so I'm wondering if you see if you think that there's going to be some protectionism that kind of like manifests in some of these jurisdictions, right? So like we got stablecoin regulation.
If I'm like a weaker fiat, I don't necessarily want this animal called the dollar coming into my fiat economy. I'm just trying to get my payment coin working and here's this thing that's going to suck up all the oxygen. Will there be some protectionist policies? Do you think to keep stablecoins and crypto dollars out? Absolutely. And there already are. I mean, dollar stablecoins are illegal in China. They're illegal in India. I mean, they're sort of clearly, I mean, what's happened in Nigeria recently? Fundamentally had to do with the FX market between dollar stables and Naira. Are we talking about finance executives getting kind of arrested and caught up in that or something else?
I mean, that is like a specific incident. But I think that the issue for Nigeria is about essentially that there's an FX market that is a market based FX market, that is a dollar to Naira FX market that's happening with crypto dollars, right? And it reflects a very different value to the Naira than the official value. Well, because for a place like Nigeria, right? Suddenly now in every Nigerians kind of like hands is the power of the U.S. banking system and that's never been available to them. I get the value problem. So to answer your question is yes, there are monetary sovereignty issues, right?
And so I think this, if you bring this up a level, right? Like, and this is a controversial thing to say, but like in the internet, right? Like governments were very against the idea that anyone could publish a website. Like the idea that anyone could do a radio broadcast, you guys, it's your business, right? Like it was like against a law to like make an audio transmission available to people in Italy and lots of other places, right? Open networks, open protocols, open software, it just like had its way. And like, and then the people in those places were like, this is better. Like don't take it away from me.
This is better. And so I think there is a legitimate question, which is does, you know, kind of, it does an internet financial system, which is more likely there are fewer reserve currencies that are like widely adopted and where the people in those places and the businesses in those places say, this is better. Like does law reflect the, the, the, the Hoi Poloi? Does law reflect like the will of the people? And society does it, does it, does it kind of shadow that? And in places where it's too threatening to like a very, very deep, maybe corrupt power structure, does it become violent? Like these are the kinds of things that the internet has played out.
Like open communications network led to the Arab Spring and there were vast crackdowns, right? And then all of a sudden everyone bought like specialized hardware from Cisco to like sensor. And you know, like this nation state interactions around information, around data, around communications, like vulcanization of the internet, we're seeing some of that. And I think we're absolutely gonna see more, more complex issues in this over time. Well, Jeremy, I do hope open networks win and open protocols win. And I think we're at time. This has been a fantastic conversation. Just one last quick lightning round prediction from you.
So total value of stablecoins, what do you think? By the end of this decade, by the end of 2030, where are we sitting? Well, we'll bring you back, you know, in like six years. We'll hold you to account for this prediction. 2030? Yeah. Yeah. I feel comfortable saying $3 trillion. Nice. So almost 2X the current total crypto market. I think this is hyper high utility and we're at the front edge of a really powerful growth phase over the next five years. Well, Bankless Nation, the year is 2003. And we just had Jeremy Lair on the podcast. Jeremy, thank you so much. Thank you. Guys, we will include some links to the Shana, including the link to a dashboard that we talked about.
If you are curious on what backs at USDC, you can go see that. Got to end with this, of course. You know, crypto is risky. Maybe not stablecoins so much though, but you could lose what you put in. We are headed west. This is the frontier, it's not for everyone, but we're glad you're with us on the Bankless Journey. Thanks a lot.