Episode: #30 September 14, 2020
-----
Tools from our sponsors to go bankless:
🌐 UNSTOPPABLE DOMAINS - GET A HUMAN READABLE CRYPTO DOMAIN
🌈 ZAPPER - ULTIMATE HUB FOR DEFI - ZAP INTO DEFI
💳 MONOLITH - GET THE HOLY GRAIL OF BANKLESS VISA CARDS
💸 AMPLFORTH - MONETARY EXPERIMENT FOR BASE MONEY
---- Synthetix to Billions | Kain Warwick
Kain Warwick is the founder of the Synthetix Platform, a protocol for generating and trading synthetic digital assets. Kain himself is known for leaning towards crypto-anarchist side of the political spectrum
How did this come about? How has this impacted the building of Synthetix?
Synthetix itself has stood resilient against the 2018/19 bear market. Why? What was the unique advantage of Synthetix vs other 2017 ICO platforms?
What's next for Synthetix now that gas fees are 200+ gwei?
WE COVER:
1) Kain's political stance 2) How this reflected in Synthetix 3) Motivation and Grit around building and producing 4) Growing Community and Culture during a bear market 5) Degen Spartan, and 6 dolla SNX 6) Introducing the SIP process 7) Introducing Yield Farming 8) Recursive upside/downside to SNX + ETH collateral in Synthetix 9) L2 scaling with Optimism 10) Bull market predictions ------ FURTHER RESOURCES:
Synthetix & Optimism: https://medium.com/ethereum-optimism/synthetix-exchange-meets-the-ovm-2de3a572d6df
Rate the Podcast 5 Stars
----- Subscribe to podcast on iTunes | Spotify | YouTube | RSS Feed
Leave a review on iTunes
Share the episode with someone you know!
----- Don't stop at the podcast!
Subscribe to the Bankless newsletter program
Watch Bankless shows and tutorials on YouTube
Visit official Bankless website for resources
Follow Bankless on Twitter
Follow Ryan on Twitter
Follow David on Twitter
----- Not financial or tax advice. This podcast is strictly educational and is not investment advice or a solicitation to buy or sell any assets or to make any financial decisions. Do your own research.
No summary for this episode yet.
This is how to get started, how to get better, and how to front-run the opportunity. This is Ryan Sean Adams. I'm here with David Hoffman and we're here to help you become more bankless. David, what an epic interview with Kane, man. It was great. Yeah, I really think that these, this D5 Founders series that we're doing, that we started with Stony with our last episode and this episode with Kane. I really think that these episodes are going to be a fantastic snapshot of the pre-bull market before all this explosion of innovation and development happens, which I'm crossing my fingers does happen.
So what we're trying to do with these episodes is we are both trying to focus in on the founders of these specific protocols, the actual individuals themselves. Stony, Kane, Sergey, Hugh, and focus in on exactly what about them created these protocols, but then also simultaneously create like a canonical, what is Ave, what is synthetics, what is chain link episode at the same time. And also create a snapshot for where these protocols are when the start of the bull market really got roaring, right. So that's what these episodes are about and that's what this episode with Kane of synthetics is all about.
Kane himself is a really interesting figure and he's done a ton of podcasts, right. But the reason why we wanted to get him specifically on is really get the background on Kane himself, right. Because Kane is a pretty interesting guy. He's a crypto anarchist and crypto anarchists are super interesting. And so we get into that conversation, which I've never seen Kane talk about before. And so that was kind of my big highlight of this episode is kind of seeing how Kane thinks in the world and how he thinks and how that got related into this synthetics protocol. Ron, what did you take away from this episode?
Yeah, I think the patterns and archetypes of these crypto native founders are basically, they're really setting the playbook for how other D5 protocols are going to be formed in the future, right. So you see these protocols like constantly learning from each other on, you know, how to how to build a community, how to create your incentives in our episode with stony last week. He talked about how his ovenomics, the ovenomics, the oven a protocol, basically inspired by a whole slew of other D5 protocols. So what we're really seeing is this entire ecosystem leveling up together and some of these protocols, quite honestly, they're experimenting, they're flying by the seat of their pants.
But when something works when they iterate and something works, then that ripples across the entire ecosystem and it becomes like a pattern, a best practice for D5 protocols moving forward. So I think these episodes are key if you're looking for what those patterns are. So you can identify the next synthetics, you can identify the next, you can identify the next crypto native founder and front run the opportunity as we always say here, this is also awesome because we got a chance to hear about synthetics road map. And toward the end came really spelled out what is happening next in three areas, then he sort of added a fourth and I don't know left me very bullish on D5 left me particularly bullish on ETH, which I'm usually training in that direction anyway.
But also bullish on on what synthetics has plans. So it's a great episode to get up to speed on everything synthetics we start with the basics of what it is, but then we get down to sort of the depth in the meat of what it can be in the future. And yeah, fantastic list. So far we're two for two on both of these D5 founders leaving us with a particularly bullish sentiment at the end of their podcast. The flow through this podcast was pretty good. So we, like I said, we start with talking about Kane and his specific politics and personality, how that related to synthetics, then we talk about, you know, the brutal bear market and growing community during that bear market.
And then we talk about rising the ranks of D5 using the conviction and the strength of the community. And really what was the recipe that synthetics created that ultimately created their success. And then as we said, we go into the road map for synthetics and future predictions. The episode speaks with itself, we don't need a long intro. So I think we're just going to go ahead and get right into the podcast. But first we're going to talk about our sponsors. One of the tools I've started to use recently is zapper. For those of you that were a part of the 2017 bull market, it was characterized by just opening up block folio and refreshing it over and over and over again.
And also anytime you ever made a trade, you would have to go into block folio and manually input that trade information to make sure that your portfolio that you think that you have matches what you actually have. With zapper, you don't have to do any of that anymore because all you have to do is zapper is input your Ethereum addresses. And then zapper will give you a really elegant report as to where all your money is. So there will never ever be any disconnect between the money that you think that you have and the money that zapper reports to you. Zapper looks directly on chain and gives you a nice portfolio summary of all your assets and how many assets and all of your debt and all of your lending positions, all of your positions all at once.
So there's no more editing your portfolio because zapper just does it for you. One thing that I thought was really useful about zapper was when I plugged my wallets in, I found that I had submitted liquidity to Uniswap forever ago. And without zapper, I would have probably lost that forever because zapper knows where your money is better than you do. It's also the gateway to investing your money into this ever-expanding list of available DeFi platforms like Curve, Balancer, Uniswap, Yurn. In the bankless nation, there is this growing number of money legos and keeping track of them all is just super overwhelming, which is why you can just go to zapper and zapper will solve the problem of there just being too many money legos to choose from.
So check them out at zapper.fi, enter your Ethereum addresses and check out your portfolio and see if there's anything that you missed. Your Ethereum address is a bankless bank account, but here's the problem. It doesn't have a human readable name. It's represented by this long hexadecimal string that no one can read. Unstoppable domains has the solution to that problem. It provides a domain name for your Ethereum address. So instead of telling someone to send you funds to 0x, e3ba, blah, blah, blah, you can tell them to send funds to your name dot crypto, a domain name for your Ethereum address.
At unstoppabledomains.com, you can search for blockchain domains like this and find tools to easily launch websites on decentralized web technology like IPFS. You can even have unstoppable domains help you manage your dot crypto or dot eth or even dot zil domain name addresses at their unstoppable domains manager. Websites have domain names dot com dot org your bankless bank account on Ethereum should have a domain name too. So go to unstoppable domains dot com register a domain name for your Ethereum address now unstoppable domains dot com. Alright, let's get into the interview with Kane. Thankless nation, we are so excited to have Kane warwick from synthetics on our show.
He describes himself as the formerly semi benevolent dictator of the synthetics foundation, but now he's currently inspiring synthetics Dow super delegate. Kane is really the founding father of DeFi liquidity mining and all of the things that we're seeing going on in the space today. Kane, it's great to have you. We're super excited about this. How are you doing, sir? Oh, yeah, yeah, thanks for having me guys. I really appreciate it. Alright, so first question. As one of the founding fathers of all of his DeFi liquidity mining is hasn't gone too far. Do you have any regrets starting this whole kind of trend?
Kane, what have you done? It's actually it's so funny. I woke up this morning in the first message that I saw was from a guy in discord and he was like, do you ever think like what have I done here? That was literally the best message that I saw and I was like, what's gone wrong? I was like, what's happening? I like immediately went like looked at like sushi and sold a migration happen. I think at times it has gone a little crazy. But I've always been a big advocate for experimentation and so I think this idea of distilling some of these incentives and really kind of testing the edges of them is not necessarily the worst thing.
So you like experimentation, is what you're saying? Yeah, I think it's good. I think it's a net positive in the end. So Kane, you've gone on a bajillion podcasts and so there's plenty of podcasts that are just like, all right, what's synthetics? But all of the podcasts I've heard with you, Kane, I've yet to hear one that talks about your personal politics or your personal attitudes about life. And from what I've listened to, I've gotten a gist that you're kind of a crypto anarchist. Is that right and can you elaborate on that? Yeah, so I definitely have like an anarchist bent. And it comes from I guess like this anti-authoritarian viewpoint of power structures need to be justified and anything, any power structure, any sort of hierarchy or authority that can't be legitimized should be torn down.
And I think that's kind of the sort of core of my worldview from a political standpoint. So anti-authoritarian then, like has it always been that way, Kane, or is this sort of an awakening at some point in your life? No, I think it's always been that way. Probably coming from my upbringing I guess, right? My dad was a professional tennis player. So he was a pretty intense person, is a pretty intense person. And definitely our family got three younger brothers. So there's four boys competing all the time. So we always had this really intense highly competitive environment in my house. And so I think at some point kind of challenging that and sort of questioning authority just becoming brand to me.
And when did you get into crypto? And would you say that all of those same values came before crypto or kind of after crypto and crypto helped instantiate them? Definitely before, I was kind of someone who would read things like Chomsky and a bunch of different political viewpoints in my late teens and early 20s. And just really had a strong view that the status quo was not quite adequate. And that there were a lot of issues in the status quo in terms of how governance worked, etc. And so I think that when I first saw Bitcoin to be honest, I didn't really get it. I read the slash dot red that I think a lot of people read in like 2011.
And coming from a payments background and a retail background, it just didn't quite sync with me. It was probably a couple years later before I really saw the value from like a political perspective rather than just as a payment mechanism. Being a crypto anarchist of sorts, what is your hope for how crypto platforms, crypto crypto protocols, how they help organize people? What is the futuristic sci-fi version of crypto that you see in your head? Well, this is part of the reason why I've been so bullish on tokens for such a long time. Even through the bear market where tokens were seen as this terrible black mark on people who had done ICOs and that sort of thing.
The reason behind that is that I believe that they're such a powerful coordination mechanism. And that if you set up a system of rules that is very clear and you're open and anyone can participate that having a token that kind of unites that rule set is a really powerful way of driving behavior. And so the idea that you can create these coordination games and provide services without needing some sort of like top down hierarchy or structure I think is really exciting. And we're starting to see that and obviously the first kind of wave of this is very financial in nature. But I think there is the possibility to extend it further than that and really kind of open it up and have these sort of self governing systems that don't require a central authority to mediate them.
How is this reflected in this synthetics protocol, right? Because all crypto protocols have values baked into them to some degree. So how would you say that these values have been worked into synthetics? I think it kind of comes from our community where I've been a participant in the community from day one, even when there are only maybe 10 of us that actually cared about the project. And so my view has always been engaged with the community as a community member and even though I do occupy a privileged position as the founder, I've really tried to not exercise that power and not leverage it.
And just to try and advocate for whatever position I'm advocating on its merits rather than relying on some kind of authority. And so I think that the people who participate in our community and who've been kind of attracted to that have a very similar viewpoint. Like they believe that the kind of argument should be one on its own merits and that anyone can participate. And that's another reason why I think we haven't gone down the sort of on-chain governance path. We've kind of stuck with this idea of rough consensus and letting debate kind of live in the community and to decide things. So, okay, and something else, I actually just learned today is you wrote a novel, right?
I did, I did somewhat stupidly. It's never a bad decision to write a book in. It was one of those things where like, I read a lot, right? I read a lot, I read a lot of nonfiction and a lot of science fiction and fantasy and stuff. And I was reading a Nick Bostrom book about AI. And there was this campaign for superintelligence. Superintelligence, yeah, superintelligence. And you know, it gets to the point about like the paperclip generating, you know, optimizer, right? That like is optimizing for, you know, generating as many paperclips as possible. And I was reading it and I fell asleep and kind of, you know, was really stuck with me in the next morning.
I kind of had this idea for like a short story that kind of extended that, that, you know, thought experiment. And so I started writing it and, you know, throughout the rest of the day, like, I, you know, put down like, I don't know, 8,000 words or something like that. Like it just kind of like flowing out. And so then I was like, well, maybe this is a bit bigger than a short story. I'd never written anything longer than a short story before. And that was a huge mistake because the amount of pain and suffering that you go through an editing process. I just was not prepared for it. So it ended up taking me like almost 18 months to finish it because I went through like, you know, five different revisions and really changed a bunch of stuff.
So I'm a bit of perfectionist, which is, which is why starting to write a novel is maybe not the best, best plan given that it was a side project. Well, good for you for sticking with it. But like, so I, I read that book to you, superintelligence. I think Elon Musk was talking about it for a while and just it kind of tuned me into it. And I got to say that book somewhat haunted me, right? Because you're part of the thesis is that basically AI is inevitable and quite possibly an evil AI is the out is the end outcome of all of this. And, you know, Nick's kind of caution to us is we should be preparing for that now.
In fact, I think he works as an ethicist to like come up with protocols to rain in the future AI that's coming. I almost wonder so Peter T. I think has kind of painted this contrast where he talks about AI being almost an authoritarian type of technology versus crypto blockchain being a more classically liberal type of technology and anti authoritarian technology. And I'm wondering if that kind of fed into your interest in that book superintelligence and the novel itself this whole kind of anti authoritarian, like I guess path that you've been on your entire life, it seems to that feed into it.
Well, you know, so I definitely had the naive view of AI right up to that point. And I definitely spent a lot of time reading about general artificial intelligence and for years. Right, like tons of books, you know, and I think reading Boston's book what it was haunting. It was it was really scary like he really painted a picture of, you know, this alternative approach and you know, I think I'm fairly optimistic about the potential for technological progress. But that definitely was an eye opening kind of experience reading. And what I remember in reading it was how fast it could happen, like in a blink of an eye, right?
So it gets to human IQ, you know, 100 IQ, 120 IQ, right? And then a week later, it could be well beyond human's capabilities, even reign it in. Yeah, exactly. And that was part of, you know, writing the novel, I think originally the short story was like just away from me to kind of, you know, take this very sort of troubling alternative viewpoint that I hadn't really considered previously. And process it, you know, as a way of kind of processing and then obviously it took on a lot of its own and took a lot longer than I would have liked, but, you know, I think it was, it was very helpful for me to kind of incorporate that into my worldview.
But I do think it's a little bit, you know, like, I don't know, you know, the heat death of the universal something like that. It's like a thing that you know is true, but you kind of have to just, you know, continue operating it. Yeah, exactly. Like if we sat around all day, like worried about like, you know, this idea of like an AGI emerging, you know, in 10 seconds in the world, being over, you know, maybe that's too pessimistic, right? Maybe we should be trying harder to prevent it, but I kind of feel like it's either inevitable or it's not. And, you know, the hope is that we have some benevolent AGI rather than, you know, something that is malicious.
And I do think, at least for me, right? So AI could grow very powerful, already seeing it today in centralized companies like Google and, you know, Baidu and all of these, all of these companies. But crypto is almost like a little bit of the antidote to that, right? It's it's restore some balance in the universe. It restores some self sovereignty for the individual. And we're starting with money systems, but there could be other systems. So I find personally, like after reading, you know, some of Nick's work and other things, it's just like that's that's kind of the side I want to be on. At least right now is like more the decentralization side of things that's helping to restore a little bit of the balance of, you know, what centralized AI could could eventually become.
But yeah, anyway, yeah, agreed. And, you know, I think I think there's like the risk is really in opacity, right? And this is where, you know, crypto is so powerful, right? Like when the rule system that you're operating under is opaque and you can't, you know, understand what the implications are, you know, it's impossible to kind of see the rules. That's where, you know, power can really aggregate and become abusive. I think when everyone's operating, you know, on the same rules set and the rules are very clear. At least you have that, you know, advantage where you understand how everyone else is playing.
So I think that that is something that I see in crypto is, you know, a very powerful driver for, you know, maybe the potential for more fair outcomes, you know, in the systems. So can you, you wrote this novel out of just pure inspiration and motivation, which, you know, is something in of itself, like a high effort activity, right? And then ever in doing some research for this podcast, I went to the synthetics slash Haven blog, which started in September of 2017. And you've been just pumping out blog posts ever blog posts ever since then, right? And then, and then not to mention just being the leader for this crazy awesome defi protocol.
Where does this motivation come from? Like where do you get the energy and meaning behind what you are doing so that when you wake up in the morning, you're ready to go and build something like what motivates you to do. Yeah, what motivates you? One of my favorite books to stay on the book thread is the hard thing about hard things by Ben Harowitz. And I think, you know, he talks about the idea that like hard things are the reward in themselves, right? I think it's doing something that's really challenging. And I think that, you know, there's definitely certain people who have, you know, a mindset, I think I've fallen into this category of, you know, it's just fun to do difficult things for, you know, it's its own reward.
And so, you know, I think I'm a little bit crazy like that where, you know, I have this kind of perfectionistic streak and feel, you know, really driven to be challenged. And, you know, if I'm, if I'm not challenged, then I get bored really quickly. And so, you know, waking up at the moment and just being, you know, kind of inundated with like the defi fire hose. It's, you know, it's definitely confronting. I think everyone's feeling that. But, you know, there is an aspect of like trying to kind of synthesize it all and pull it all together into some coherent view. You know, it's really fun at the same time, right?
So, you know, you got to be having some fun. But, you know, it's definitely, it's definitely challenging. I've been doing startups for a long time. And, you know, there, there are days where you kind of wake up and you're like, it's been 20 years of startup life. And, you know, you feel a little bit burnt out. But I think it's, it's fun enough to kind of keep going, you know, at the moment. And so, what's the goal? Like, when you are, when you do decide to wake up and decide that, you know, no longer a startup life fit for you and instead walking in the mountains is now fit for you. Like, what do you have hope to achieve?
Like, what are you trying to change the world to be like, or what's your trying, what's the mark that you're trying to leave upon the world? You know, I think I have a very strong sort of streak of like trying to achieve fairness and trying to achieve equitable outcomes. You know, I feel very strongly about that. I think that your arbitrary and this comes back again, like anti authoritarian, you know, the viewpoints, right? I like the idea that someone can exercise arbitrary power for someone else I find to be really important. And so, you know, to build a system or, you know, to contribute to systems being built where that, you know, is is limited and the ability for people to abuse power is limited.
I think, you know, even if it's not necessarily, you know, synthetics being a world-changing thing, just contributing to, you know, crypto and DeFi, I think is something that keeps me motivated and, you know, I'm hopeful that we can kind of continue experimenting and, you know, add to this, you know, body of knowledge about how you coordinate behavior. And, you know, achieve things like that without necessarily, you know, booking for some specific outcome, right? You know, I don't think it really matters what the outcome is as long as, you know, we're kind of building up this, you know, new kind of technology and new way of core and many people.
So, we're in the middle of our DeFi Founders series here on Bankless and we started with Stony from Ave last week. We're now here with came from synthetics. And one of the questions that we're asking everyone came from our episode with band Spencer of Framework, which was also kind of like the VCs start to this whole thing. And one of the concepts that he talked about was when he is looking for, you know, DeFi Founders and then also DeFi protocols to like invest in or you put their skin in the game into. They said they frequently asked the question for protocols that are looking to hand over governance over the protocol to the community.
The question is, are you really about that life? Because that's a different lifestyle. That's a different choice than running a C-Corp with, you know, board of directors and publicly owned company, right? It's a different, it's a different goal. And so Cain, why are you about that life? Like what about you as particularly suited to building this community owned and operated protocol? I've always, I've always, you know, in all the startups that I've run, you know, some of my friends and people that are close to me have always kind of pointed out that, you know, one of the common threads with all of them is that there, you know, tends to be a community that kind of coalesces around them that gets really passionate about it and really cares about it.
And I think, you know, part of that is this kind of process of engagement, right? Of, you know, genuinely engaging with people and wanting them to contribute. And I think a lot of people pay lip service to that process, right? But really they do want to retain power and they want to retain some sense of control. But, you know, I genuinely do want to engage and kind of hand over control as much as possible, you know, to this protocol. Like it's, you want to be the super delegate instead of the benevolent dictator, right? That's what this is. 100% exactly, exactly. And, you know, even though we don't have super delegates yet, you know, when we do, you know, my, my genuine hope is that people, you know, think that I'm a viable candidate for that role.
And, you know, we might end up in a situation where we have, you know, seven people that are super delegates that are, you know, sort of responsible for, you know, helping to kind of direct the next phase of the project. And, you know, obviously I want to be a part of that, right? But I also want to, to have earned it rather than, you know, be kind of grandfathered in because I happen to be. You want to be, you want to be a voice in the protocol, not the voice in this synthetic protocol in time, over time. Absolutely. And, you know, this is already happening, right? Like people do not listen.
If you go in and, like, honestly, if you go in and look at this court, right, like I'm constantly advocating for things, they're like, no, we're just not doing that. We don't, we don't think you're right on this. So it's, you're already getting overruled then on things. Oh, all the time. Are there times where the, are there times where you're like, oh, you know, the community is right about that. And I was actually wrong and it led to a better decision. And I guess, you know, the opposite. Do you feel like sometimes the communities made bad decisions? You know, I think in the, in the early days, everyone was very passionate.
Everyone felt, you know, very, very strongly about, you know, the direction that things should be, be going in, but it was also very cohesive. Like we were all really bored into what we were trying to do. And so, you know, we would have debates and disagreements, but, you know, generally was about, like, how do we achieve something? And I think what's kind of shifted as the community has grown is it's less debates about how do we achieve something, but, you know, sometimes even like, what are we trying to achieve? Which I think is an important thing, but, you know, even, you know, recently, probably, I think the biggest one, and I've talked about this before, is the monetary policy change.
When we changed the, the inflation schedule, there was a community member, Delta Tiger, who, you know, was advocating for it. And I said, no, this is a bad idea. Like, we don't want to go down that path. We want to, you know, have like a, you know, coherent monetary policy. And he advocated for it, you know, pushed it through and, you know, it was definitely a good change. Like, that was a really positive thing. This was basically the decision, right? I guess I introduced as kind of the, you know, father of founding father of DeFi liquidity mining, right? But the original design for synthetics was like more like Bitcoin, right?
Where it would be some kind of fixed cap and there wouldn't be a change to issuance policy. It was very kind of regimented, right? That was the prevailing thought at the time. So you're saying like this whole shift to liquidity mining wasn't even your idea. It came from the community. That's true. So, you know, I basically said, you know, I had this idea when I think this is going back to like 2018, right? So I think it was around DevCon. So like, you know, maybe October, whatever of 2018. And we were clearly not getting traction, right? Like we weren't getting people to, you know, state. We're having trouble with engagement.
And I started talking about this idea of changing the monetary policy and, you know, essentially shifting to, you know, something more like a halting. Like to, you know, introduce inflation and we would have this harbing process. And so that initial process of changing the monetary policy to reward stakers was pushed through by me. But the stupid part of that was this harbing component, right? And up like each year would have it just created like unnecessary risk and basically six months later someone came in and said, that's a really dumb idea. And I said, no, it's not. And everyone actually said, yeah, no, it is a dumb idea.
We should change and they did. All right. So for folks who have not heard about synthetics, we want this to be kind of a canonical episode about synthetics in the future. Could you just do a quick explain it like I'm five of the protocol. What does it do and what problem is it solving? So basically what it allows you to do is hold a token that gives you exposure to any asset that the protocol supports on Ethereum. So, you know, on Ethereum, you want price exposure to Bitcoin. You want to be able to hold a token that will, you know, move like a bit quick. And so what the protocol allows you to do is hold that token.
It uses our tools to essentially lock the token to that price. And it's effectively the same as holding Bitcoin with obviously some different properties. And the same thing goes for other assets like gold, silver. You know, you can hold an ounce of gold that's tokenized. And you're able to get your price exposure the same way as if you were holding a one ounce gold bar. These things are called synthetics, right? That's what a synthetic is. It's essentially a kind of a price tracker for all of these assets, though it's not the actual asset itself that's getting traded around. It's just kind of the price representation of that asset.
And it's importantly, it's supposed to be redeemable for an equal amount of that asset in real life, although it is not a claim on the real life asset. It should be able to be redeemable for the same amount of value of that real asset. So, you know, there's no, you can't, you know, front up and convert one token, you know, one XAU SXAU token for gold. But, you know, in theory, you should be able to convert that into the right amount of dollars to go and buy a gold bar. And buy an equivalent amount, right? And so how do explain how the oracles get integrated in synthetics and what the oracles do?
So, we made a decision about 18 months ago to work with Chainlink to implement their oracle system. And we worked really closely with them since to get this done. And, you know, very excitingly, finally, we've made the transition. So, we've moved all of our oracles over the Chainlink. And, you know, it essentially allows us to kind of hand over the complexity of managing this oracle network to, you know, people that that's all they do. And so we can, you know, focus on the things that, you know, make sense for us to focus on and kind of outsource this price-beat component. And so, you know, it's a big deal.
It's also very helpful for decentralization because, you know, previously we were running an internal oracle that, you know, was, again, very opaque. We all didn't know what the rules were. You know, it wasn't clear where the price fees were coming, et cetera. So we've now moved away from that. And I think it's made the protocol much more open and decentralized. And, oracles are crucial for synthetics, right? Because all of the synthetic assets available in the synthetic marketplace, they need to be, they need to know what the price of their real world correlate is, right? By a tokenized for a synthetic asset of one ounce of gold, what the oracle does is it takes outside world data of the real world gold price from some source.
And the chain link oracle reports that to the synthetic marketplace to tell the synthetic marketplace to price all of the synthetic gold tokens appropriately tell them what price it should be. We can copy and paste the same model for all possible, you know, assets, right? Like the SMP 500 or the Tesla stock or Apple stock or, you know, maybe something even crazier like the population of a country. Like, so long as it can be like reported by chain link, it can be turned into a synthetic asset on synthetics, correct? That's correct, exactly. As long as there's enough liquidity in the external market as well.
So we don't we don't want the market to be manipulatable. Of course, of course. And so how does the SNX asset come into play here? Where does the SNX asset get involved? So it's essentially the collateral token for the network. So it's this coordination point to get everyone to come together and operate within this rule set. So if you're holding SNX, you stake SNX and you're able to issue debt, which, you know, tracks these price articles and the fees that accrue from people exchanging different synthetic assets between each other. So if someone goes from synthetic Bitcoin to synthetic gold, they pay a fee.
All of those fees go into a pool. And the SNX stakers who have been collateralizing the network get their pro-rata share of those fees each week. And so this is how synthetic assets come into existence, right? Like we don't we don't just get to start with all these assets. They need to be created somehow. And so what someone does is they take the SNX token and say they take a thousand dollars of the SNX token. And then they deposit it into synthetics in a comparable way that they deposit ether into make or dow or something. And then they have a sum amount of credit based on their deposits. And that credit can be turned into a synthetic asset by choosing which oracle to make that credit turn into an asset by, right?
And so you can have if you have like $200 worth of credit by your SNX deposits, you can turn that into $200 worth of synthetic gold or synthetic Tesla. Was all that correct? That's right. But that's not the only thing that that SNX does because the other half of SNX is governance over synthetics, the protocol, right? So it's this dual collateral token for the SNX marketplace and the governance token over how the SNX marketplace works. How has that relationship between like this dual purpose of synthetics? How has that relationship kind of been absorbed and understood by the community? Like how are people thinking about this dual relationship?
So at the moment, the SNX token does not give you governance rights. So the governance process that we use is very similar to Ethereum, right? It's not a direct token vote based on how much ether you have that feeds into the EIP process. We have a similar approach where we've got a community, they're all token holders, but your ability to kind of advocate for a specific change or for something you want to see in the protocol is not limited to your token holding. It's actually your reputation within the community that is what really drives your ability to kind of make changes and propose modifications.
And I think that that's something that maybe is a little bit different to some of the protocols that we've seen recently where they are using direct-on-chain governance. I've got some serious concerns about the implications of that. I think eventually we will get to a point where we have this delegated voting process and people can delegate towards specific people who are looking to kind of join this governing council essentially. But at the moment, the process is very rough. It's a rough consensus process and we need to get to a point where consensus is really strong in the community before we make any changes.
And there's a risk of that as well, obviously, which is also like we've seen in Bitcoin where it becomes really hard to change things. And I think this is where eventually we will get to a break point where it becomes too hard to change things through rough consensus and we actually need to move to some form of an on-chain governance. But we've been taking that very, very slowly for the kind of reasons that I stated there. Yeah, pardon me for the mistake. The duality of this synthetic token model I should have been referring to was the fact that the SNX token does have rights over the cash flow over the protocol.
And so the SNX token is both the collateral for generating assets and then also the asset that has a claim on the cash flow of the system. And so if people will remember about a year ago and around then I was kind of known, loosely known as generally an SNX asset skeptic because of this self recursion. Like the asset, the token, the quote unquote equity over the protocol is also the collateral of the protocol, which to me I kind of saw that as like a dangerous feedback. But I kind of now consider that I mean kind of think that that attitude came out of like a bear market attitude like a pessimistic attitude because there's also nothing more like awesome in the world of crypto than feedback loops right self recursive feedback loops and you know let it be known.
That ether and Ethereum and proof of stake operates in the same sort of feedback loop. So now in my mind in my 2020 mind, I'm now actually like relatively bullish on just the feedback loop between SNX, the asset being both the collateral for synthetic assets. And also generating collecting the fees from the the synthetic market place. And so has there ever been any community discussion or community like understanding about the duality of the both the cash flow slash collateral model of the synthetic asset. There there has and you know this is something that we we talk about you know a lot, but I think to be fair to maybe you know 2019 David, you know the the reality is that we are still limited right like you know the using SNS is the only collateral is somewhat limiting.
And so you know we're pushing ahead very, very aggressively to add either as a collateral the borrow not just synthetic even which is the current ability that you have, but to actually be able to borrow as you see as well. Because you know in in the current environment in a bull market, you know there's a lot of demand for decentralized stable points both you know die and as you see. And so we need to have a lever to kind of you know extend the supply and you know that's something that we're working on really closely. So I think some of your concerns are still very valid right and we still have to solve some of these issues.
So I don't think it's necessarily a solved a solved problem, but to go back to the question around like cash flow, I think you know it's funny right because in 2018, you know 2019 the skepticism around tokens was you know it's peak right. And my view was always that if you wanted to token have value, it had to you know accrue some cash flow right like it wasn't going to accrue value just from being a payment token that you know was was kind of operating in this world garden. You know I was always pretty skeptical of that idea and so I think that you know the the thing that limited people from approaching things this way was like a regulatory fear right they're worried about you know looking like a security etc.
And so I think you know one of the things that syndetics is contributed you know hopefully is to reduce that fear and for people to realize that you know a passive cash flow asset is a security. But a token that's like this coordination mechanism that allows you to participate in an ecosystem and do work and receive fees for it is something else entirely right it's it's obviously not you know the exact definition of a security. And so I think that one of the things that we've really contributed is is you know to push that you know to open up the over to the window on token design and you know make people more comfortable with the idea of you know these cash flow generating tokens.
It's a fantastic thread on the over to window of you know capital and how there's a range of new options at D5 founders should consider we definitely want to talk about that in a little bit. But is this what you just described is that essentially the upside thesis for SNX that a ton of cash would be generated basically by the synthetics critical and that would have a value accrual mechanism that feeds back into SNX is that the gist of the upside thesis. That's it yeah exactly you know that's that's the idea that you know if we all come together and create this service that allows people to have.
We're talking to Stony about this about you know what you mentioned to you can about the 2018 2019 where everyone was bearish right so 2019 January 2019 David or January 2019. Ryan could have purchased SNX for four cents not to make you feel bad deal but like right now it's five dollars so we had some opportunity cost there and so did everyone but like I guess to be fair. It felt very much felt like at that time that you know D5 was dead that kind of a theorem was maybe I don't know just barely hanging on that tokens all tokens were futility tokens none of them. And now here we are right now and SNX is like 12,000% up in price like mark you have a 2.
5 million to like 500 million right and like little over a year later like absolutely insane. I think our conversation with advance from from framework sort of illustrated the power of a contrarian bet in D5 in 2018 in 2019. But how did how did that feel for you on your side right so you're you're more than kind of an investor obviously in SNX because you're actually investing your life in the protocol and you're investing your team time and that sort of thing. I mentioned Ben's book the hard thing about hard things I remember this always stuck out with me he talked about startups having this WFIO moment this like we're after its over movement before they kind of come out another side did you ever have a moment like that where you thought synthetics is never going to work or even before haven is never going to work.
In late 2018 mid to late 2018 you know regulated stablecoins and a combination of regulated stablecoins and die really had marginalized the utility of the protocol. And so you know we're in the situation where we had to make a decision to either pivot you know or just keep driving off a cliff and you know we were definitely in a bad place I think at the end of 2018 early 2019 where you know okay we had enough runway to kind of keep going but clearly not enough to be able to take on the circle right you know or you know packs us or you know. You know any of these these regulated stablecoins that we're starting to see pop up and so you know we we just basically decided to double down and you know accelerate the movement to this multi currency system and that's where we started season product market fit so you know I think that was that was probably the moment the late 2018 moment where you know we decided just throw it all you know and just.
Kind of a bit of a Hail Mary and change the monetary policy you know the pivot the rebrand all of it and you know I think we're we're pretty lucky in in a number of ways that we know we just happened to kind of you know hit that that inflection point in defi around about the same time but you know there was a part of me that. You know always thought that this was pretty inevitable right you know I was very very convicted that you know what we were doing made sense and that it was necessary and that you know there would that it would work in in spite of the skepticism right and skepticism was totally reasonable you know I think you know we had a number of debates on on Twitter in various places you know back then and you know the people like Tio and you know who are still skeptical about you know can this work.
But I think you know my view was was that you know I really believe that the mechanism would be successful and so you know the vindication of kind of seeing the market respond and you know we're not there yet right like we're not at a point where the cash flow from you know providing this this service this decentralized services sufficient to kind of you know keep the network going in perpetuity. But I think we're getting closer and we're starting to see that you know there is genuine demand for which is which is really good and you had to have that conviction in 2018 to continue to work on what you were working on in 2019 I like at the time like you mentioned it USDC and even tether these centralized stable coins were basically dominating right so it was very hard to be in the decentralized stable coin business but another element that was very difficult.
But was there was no like onboarding of liquidity into DeFi at all like it was all through the centralized exchanges and where were they going to route you while they're going to list tether we're going to list USDC as the trading pairs and it almost seemed like to me this kind of inflection point that that you mentioned for for DeFi kind of occurred as an ecosystem of money Legos right. Like it seemed to me that Uniswap really started to feel fuel a lot of the liquidity for this space and that created almost a feedback loop for synthetics to become more successful and increase its volume. Did you feel that do you feel like the space was kind of you know growing together and that some of these other money Legos I'm a snapped into into place to make synthetics much more feasible.
Absolutely you know Uniswap was a big deal but I think you know we we really can't overlook the fact that it was maker and and die which facilitated this you know if there's if there's no die I don't think any of this happens right so you know die kind of enabled. You know things like compound to to really you know have this like symbiotic relationship right and and I think you know even set protocol and Dharma and like you know all of these things the the ability to you know kind of believe that this is was workable I think a lot of that came from maker and so you know it's it. I think it's it's something that maybe you know it's kind of overlooked these days you know people look at compound and you know the watch the compound token is like this kind of you know moment but I think you have to go way way further back right to like late 2017 and the launch of die that was the genesis.
Do you still feel that cohesion in defi that like the ecosystem is all we're you know we're all kind of in it together. I mean look it's gotten a lot noisier right you know back I think it was you know just before doubt can't write like it was the first defi conference and there were maybe 50 people in the room. You know and it funnily enough though even then there was definitely a little bit of like you know tension right. You know not everyone was necessarily friendly there was there was a bit of competition and I think also you know we were definitely not a mind set of abundance back then right it was a very much a scary city mindset and you know in a little bit zero some and I think I think that improved you know through 2019 as things started to kind of heat up a little bit.
So I think that you know people are probably a lot more friendly these days than they maybe were even back then at times. But you know it's much noisier and there's a lot of crazy stuff going on so you know we don't have the same level of connectivity you know with some of the projects just because it's really hard with everything going on to stay connected. Hey guys before we start talking about this synthetic Spartans we're going to take a moment to talk about the sponsors that make the bankless nation possible. Bankless nation do you want to go fully bankless but in the real world monolith is the defy account that you need it wraps your eath address in a bankless visa card and it does so much more it closes the loop from fiat to defy so you can onboard fiat to die on monolith with zero fees then you can convert that die to a die which is an interest bearing savings account again zero fees and then you can spend that interest in the real world on a visa account.
So you can finally buy your cup of coffee with interest earned in defy guys this is magic this is the closest thing to the holy grail crypto card and monolith gives you all of it. You need to download the app at monolith.xyz to get your bankless visa card it's optimized for European listeners they'll be coming to the US soon. And when you get that visa card the monolith card tweet about it when you do I love seeing people unpackaging their beautiful bankless visa cards makes me realize that the revolution is here search monolith in the app store. Ampliforth is a new base money experiment on Ethereum many people have heard of this new re-basing mechanism and Ampliforth was the protocol to first introduce that into the Ethereum space.
Ampliforth is very comparable to Bitcoin in the sense that it has a non-dilutive supply. However there's one thing about it that's inverse with Bitcoin whereas Bitcoin has a completely inflexible supply meaning any demand for BTC the asset is therefore reflected in the price. And Ampliforth is the inverse of that where Ampliforth is pegged to twenty nineteen dollars and any demand for the Ampliforth token is reflected in the supply of the asset not the price of the asset. So the Ampliforth token tracks twenty nineteen dollars slowly over time so it should never be too far away from twenty nineteen dollars and in order to achieve that goal it adds or burns Ampliforth token supply.
So that the market generally prices it around the value of a twenty nineteen dollar. It is definitely not a stablecoin because the volatility of the value that you hold will fluctuate up and down wildly but the token itself is supposed to track a dollar. Pretty interesting experiment there's been a lot of spin-offs using this rebasing mechanism. They also have this liquidity mining program where you can supply Ampliforth and Ether tokens to the Uniswap pool and you'll be able to get an extra dividend of Ampliforth tokens from the Ampliforth Geyser. So check them out at Ampliforth.org and see if this is an experiment you want to partake in.
I think the best piece of alpha that I think everyone knows about nowadays is that community is everything right and synthetics is known for having one of the earliest and most the strongest communities in the space that we can really think of. And anytime some some community generates this bottom up like their own sort of mascots or icon then that's something to pay attention to and like this synthetic Spartans came really really early. Was there any one particular moment that more or less like triggered the the Spartan meme or the instantiation of the protocol or the of the community around synthetics protocol or was it more of just a grassroots kind of bottom up.
Type of thing where people just for some somebody coin the term and then it just grew from there. How did how did this synthetic Spartan meme come about. Well, I think it kind of came from G right you know that was his avatar. You know, so Dejan Spartan right you know his avatar in discord was you know the one of the Spartans and and so you know when people started to feel that this community was really you know cohesive and you know starting to solidify. And they started looking around for you know what he was one of the people that really drove it you know and kind of gave this identity of you know we don't give a fuck we're just going to you know keep pushing here and it doesn't matter if you don't believe in us it doesn't matter you know the skeptical.
And we know what we're doing and we've got a vision of where we want to go and we're just going to keep pushing her. And so I think that that was where it kind of that was the Genesis. And DJ and Spartan for folks that aren't like on Twitter all the time like many of probably all of us here are he is a pseudo anonymous Twitter account right that tweets about lots of things and defy but was an early believer particularly doing the bear market in what synthetics was doing. I like the Spartans analogy because there weren't a lot of you guys back then you know there's the 300 the mighty 300 again.
It was less than 300. It's against all of the forces that that we're kind of opposing it and yeah it's it's it's fantastic that in crypto you're able to I mean we talked about a chain link God recently in our episode with Vance but in cryptos able to attract these pseudo anonymous yet incentivized very strong and very captivating and very I guess formative community members. It's like I have you seen that anywhere else like you were involved in developing building communities before but is that something unique to crypto in your mind. I really think it is and maybe it's also unique to like this time on the internet and you know that people can really you know kind of create a persona.
You know I think there's been communities you know I like I see you know things like that where you know people didn't necessarily identify with their you know they're the real world persona but I think the kind of cut through and an amount of impact that someone can have on crypto Twitter as an anonymous account is is much much more powerful than anywhere I've ever seen it. Can you compare and contrast what the communities energy was like before and after the introduction of the SIP process and maybe maybe there wasn't any one formalized beginning of the SIP process but I'm going to go ahead and guess that you know at some point there was this team led protocol changes and then now it seems to be that there's this community led protocol changes.
During that pivot between the pre the team governance to the community governance how can you kind of compare and contrast the community energy and you know self self actualization around the the stewardship of the protocol. I think the most most tangible immediate thing that happened when the introduced SIPs was it forced the team at the time to be more transparent you know if it put a check on our power right like we weren't able to just arbitrarily do things we had to actually go through the process ourselves and it was something that I really strongly enforced you know in the team right that we couldn't just pay lip service to this we were responsible for.
We were advocating for the positions and you know we would assign someone within the team to be the champion of that SIP to go out to the community and get it through and I think that that mindset then kind of you know went through the team and then you know kind of further out in the community where they all the sudden again it wasn't just paying lip service to the side the idea of decentralized governance it was you know we were embodying it and we were you know actually you know forcing ourselves to participate. We were doing the process and you know if we got it wrong and the community said no then they said no and it happened multiple times you know where there are things that before the SIPs we would have just done it and then told them afterwards and then all the sudden we had to tell them ahead of time and they had the ability to say actually no you're not doing this we don't want it.
So if you could take a moment and define SIP and also where it came from which are the EIPs and then maybe also comment on how and something like an SIP would enable community engagement. Yeah so you know it's basically this idea of a formalized document that you know allows people to see what an improvement proposal is going to do right so you know there's a structure about here's why we think we should do it here's exactly what's going to happen here's the intent behind it and it puts you know it puts a lot of structure around any change to the protocol. So you know everyone can can feel engaged with it and one of the early ones that was rejected was this proposal that I wrote to allow people to migrate their escrowed SNX tokens from one account to another.
So the issue was that you know we one of the unintended consequences of the staking rewards being locked for a year was that if you started staking with multiple different accounts you could end up with the situation where you had to like maintain these accounts forever right and you know if you abandoned one of them you there was a huge opportunity cost so I propose this idea allowing people to consolidate their escrowed tokens into a single account and people said no we don't like that idea we're worried that it's going to create like a second area. It's going to create a market for escrow tokens and you know all kinds of unintended consequences you know and it was funny because that proposal that you know obviously there was a lot of vested interest in getting it over the line because you know I had a number of accounts that you know test accounts and things like that that I was maintaining and they basically said bad luck sorry you're not doing it and it still hasn't happened to this day.
And just to define SIP stands for synthetic improvement proposal and so this comes out of you know EIPs which are the Ethereum improvement proposals which came out of BIPs or BIPs which are Bitcoin improvement proposals so there's the there's just this common. So you know something IP which is how generally protocols maker has the same thing where they have maker improvement proposals so this is a common theme throughout crypto so when when SIPs kind of just became a thing in the synthetics protocol and also in the synthetics discord how did that change the team's relationship with the community right so now all the sudden the community realizes that it has it has your voice it has power it has a way to.
Voice their wants and desires and then try and generate some sort of rough consensus about what the community wants and then they realize that they can get the team to change things in the ways that they want so how how did this kind of change the team's relationship with it's your guys this community so are the community is the community now steering the ship would you say or who steers this is the synthetic ship. I think the biggest immediate impact that it that it had was to reduce this kind of voting block of the team right because now on suddenly there were people you know who now for contributors right that we have that are funded by the synthetics now but you know we're we're at that time funded by the synthetics foundation it was this idea that you know oh there's the team and the team thinks this right.
And then there's a community in the community thinks this but actually what it what it did which was one of the most meaningful impacts I think was to kind of break that up and you would actually have people on the team who were like well I think this is a good idea and then other people who didn't and they would actually be in the community you know participating and kind of advocating for their view and it really had this impact of kind of flattening you know already we didn't have much of a hierarchy but it allowed for you know someone in the team to disagree with me. For example on a specific point and rally the community and get it over the lot rather than you know needing to kind of all of us agree and presently united front you know it really changed it to where all members of the community and even if we are funded by the foundation we still have the responsibility to participate in this governance process the same way that any other token holder does.
And because of the community being given a voice did you see more community members enter the community did you see that community grow after that. I think what happened is as new people found out about the project and kind of you know join the community they really felt this like powerful sense of there's something different going on here you know for people who've been in crypto for a long time you know communities. Sometimes very shallow right you know it's just a bunch of people that are holding the same bag right but you know I think in in synthetics at that time and even today but you know very specifically at that time if you turned up in the discord you're like call it shit there's something going on here like people are very passionate about this and I think for you know people with the right mindset who genuinely you know wanted to kind of participate in in a protocol and and you have an impact it was really attractive and they often stay.
Every protocol should go through a bear market right like that's where the community is in the trenches it's not in this bull market like you know 10x run up stuff that's not where you build like the the core folks it's those that stick with you during the bear. Yeah exactly so next step in the story of the synthetic Spartan like a community growth growth story was the ability to leverage SNX as like this engagement tool where you know you would purchase SNX and then you would stake SNX to access the inflationary rewards and we were talking about this earlier when we were talking about how the community kind of rallied up to say that canes for year have a new model was stupid.
And there should be a more smooth smooth happening model and again this was this was a community getting a voice to rally for something that an advocate for something that they wanted in the in their protocol that they used but then the inflation rewards are is it was a whole new whole new thing and it started to create this feedback. Can you talk about how the inflation rewards impacted the growth of the community as well. So yeah I think you know if you go back to 2016 2017 this idea of artificial scarcity right you know there's only X million or X thousand or X billion tokens right and therefore you know if people want to use them to pay for something you know in some system and there's only so many of them then the price will go up right which like looking back on it is just like idiocy right like it's so obviously dumb right but we were old you know drinking the Kool-Aid and you know I think we we kind of want to focus my play out right but the the thing that was missing was you know rewarding people for engagement right and I think that that you know what I when I kind of looked at why the engagement was low and took a step back and and really you know took the long view the thing that was obvious to me was you know back in the day if you were going to spend you know I think the first time I set up a Bitcoin minor in like 2012 it took me like an entire weekend I spent like 48 hours didn't sleep like you know sitting on forums like reading different things going through you or hardware config issues etc till I get this Bitcoin minor set up and the reason why I did it was A I was interested but B I wanted to mine Bitcoin I thought it would be cool and if I could mine some Bitcoin that would be amazing right and I think that that was the thing that was missing from all of these artificial scarcity tokens right it was okay we're gonna send all the tokens out everyone's gonna hold the tokens and then we're going to ask them to do something but there was no way that the protocol actually rewarding them and so the change to the the monetary policy to add this inflation component and reward people who were participating was the you know that was the thing that kind of kicked off this cycle and really drove adoption engagement.
So it seems like the thing maybe we thought was the secret sauce of Bitcoin or part of the secret sauce this artificial scarcity and doing that is less important than the other element of the secret sauce which was like community network participation right that's I feel like what you unlocked with SNX. Absolutely and you know we've seen it now play out multiple times subsequently you know things like YFI and yeah and you know where people are doing something that the protocol wants and earning tokens from that and it's an incredibly powerful New York driver behavior. Okay so the high level road map so far during the synthetics 2018 bear market is that you know the the the communities kind of spun up it's pretty it's pretty thin like it's less than 300 but 300 Spartans regardless and then the SIP process gets integrated the community gets a voice and then there is in the inflation rewards that built into that so from if you're on the inside what you are seeing is that the team is starting to listen to the community and the community is starting to like grow a spine grow a voice and then also what the community wants does end up actually end up getting built.
And then not only that but also you are able to get access upside upside exposure to the growth of synthetics through the inflation rewards meaning not not only is the team executing to the will of the community but also the community is getting engagement rewards right so you're able to stake SNX and get inflation rewards and then we're also going to talk about the the farming rewards of Uniswap and and S the East S East pair on Uniswap but this is where we start to get this feedback loop where after these things happen and especially with the inflation rewards there starts to be the price increase of synthetics right and that's where I think synthetics first got on like a lot of people's radar when synthetics first broke a dollar and then I saw Dejan Spartan on Twitter saying like synthetics is going to $6 and like my bear market pessimistic mentality is like no no way dude since $6 that's not happening and you know it's not too long ago synthetics was the token was at seven and a half dollars a couple of months a couple of weeks ago and so at this point we're starting to see this feedback loop where the price goes up and then more community it's created because more people are get people are fundamentally interested in number go up right and so number goes up people go into the discord they get engaged with the community they've access the SNX staking rewards and then and then price goes up for further right and this is this to me this is the story of the synthetics bear market turning into a bull market and in my mind synthetics the synthetics platform along with Ave and perhaps along with chain link to are the direct creators of this this bull market at large right and and perhaps even a little bit more credit to synthetics and maybe even you specifically came because you are the quote unquote father of modern agriculture because synthetics created the whole concept of yield farming right so can you talk about how the community was able to access further rewards SNX denominates rewards through through both through staking but also through providing liquidity to uniswap and then maybe tie that into how that's linked into the to the farms that we see nowadays yeah so so you know all of the things that you described there are the elements that I think are necessary but not sufficient right like strong community you know the the you know this inflation reward your feedback loop et cetera but I think it was it was still really critical that there was some belief that we're building something that was going to be useful right you know if if we hadn't have had this idea that you know we're building this derivatives platform you know after we pivoted away from the the payment network and you know like it's funny because we've now come back to the point where SUSD is is becoming quite useful in people and it's you know it's gaining traction but you know we've we've thrown out the idea of transfer fees and transaction fees et cetera and now going to this this exchange fee but I think we needed to have that core belief that we're building a protocol that was going to have utility right and you know that that was really important to kind of get people as they came into the community to kind of you know to engage I think if there had been nothing there except for these feedback groups it would have it would have kind of petered out but once we realized that you know we had this uh this kind of SNX you know we had this inflation that we could direct at anything right so we could direct it at any time so we could direct it at you know our own protocol but we could actually direct it at other things that were somewhat ancillary to you know to the protocol that we also needed like liquid on ribs and and what was really interesting is you know we went through multiple iterations different people proposing things G was one of them and your author and I actually were on the other side as as often happens you know I was on the dumb side of the day and and you know we're like oh I don't know if it's great idea you know there was still like I still have a bit of good point Maxi in me right where I'm like oh I don't really like the idea of change the monetary policy I feel like we should be careful about that et cetera and you know it's taken a while to kind of beat that out of me but I think the market finally has but you know we we got to this point where we're like we need a liquid on ramp and we have unique swap now you need swap is amazing you know we were one of the early projects that I think really sold utility in you swap and we said okay let's try you know we finally got to a point where the community was comfortable with like okay let's take an easy pair right where there's no impermanent loss you know let's let's direct some inflation at it and you know we went from nothing to you know at one point I think the equivalent of like 85,000 a minute right which was incredible for you you swap incredible for us people were looking at it's going like what is happening here you know what's like how is this even you know this was pre the total value locked you know crazy metrics that we're seeing these days you know the idea that you could lock up 85,000 eight you know the course of like a month was pretty insane and no one pretty I was just personally I was just surprised all this stuff worked like it was like wow it's working yeah yeah absolutely absolutely it was it was very it was eye opening I think for a lot of people you know we had this belief that you could get behavior to kind of happen and you know previously it was only sort of happening internally in this this kind of self-referential feedback group as you sort of said but all of a sudden we're like this is real there's you know 45,000 in there and 45,000 synthetic like this is a real thing like it is money this is real like people are putting real value into Uniswap and you know into this liquid on ramp to get access to SNX and you get access to this reward which I think you know that was really kind of the that you know the crossing the council moment where people were like okay just this works and so to me the last cherry on top for like this bull market story and how synthetics fits into into Ethereum is but into the integration with Uniswap is hugely important because everyone loves Uniswap right but you guys also started to leverage chain link right and chain link has its own extremely robust community as well and you guys really really needed a solution like chain link to exist in order to produce all your synthetic assets and so now like the I for what I'm guessing I was I was not in the chain link community in the in the bear market nor was I in the synthetic community in the bear market but I'm going to go ahead and guess that when the integration between synthetics and chain link you know was announced and then was actually manifested that there was some sort of melding of the communities right and so not only are protocols on Ethereum composable but their communities are also composable as well so can you was there any sort of signal as a result of the integration between the protocols between the two communities I think so and you know for the chain link community it was a very similar situation to the synthetics community right there was a lot of belief they you know they believed in the value prop of what chain link was building you know they believed in in the approach that was being taken and they they believed in the utility that it would bring to the ecosystem right but belief is you know it gets you so far right they needed it to actually manifest in you know someone putting their hand up and saying yes we want to consume this protocol you know this is something that we really see as beneficial and I think synthetics was probably the first you know protocol to really kind of go all in and say like we're going you know we're doing chain link this is it we're going to you know deprecate our external you know sorry our internal Oracle and move to this external Oracle and I think that that was you know huge validation the community right the chain link community that like this thing that they'd been saying was going to happen on the sudden you know this was the first example of it and then you know you had a bunch of other other you know projects then you know kind of come along but I'm pretty confident that we were one of the first to sort of go out there and say this is the right solution we've vetted everything you know we're really happy with not just the solution as it stood then but our confidence and chain link ability to you know augment and improve the solution over time to get it to a point where we really thought it was going to be a long-term solution for synthetics so okay so now here's where we are all right it's in 2020 yield farming is now a thing thanks to the creation of agriculture so thank you Kane we the synthetics community is as a community that you know other protocols would die for the synthetics protocol is also integrated into other protocols like chain link like uniswap and then like and more maybe more passively into protocols like yam and sushi and so it's getting its own integrations kind of organically and the the SIP process is alive and well and things are good and from at least from my perspective of synthetics so where are we going next Kane what's next for a synthetics what's next on the roadmap so you know there's there's still kind of three broad pillars right that you are not quite there you know we're seeing decent volume decent exchange volume but you know it can grow much further right you know we've seen uniswap curve you know a lot of these AMMs generating incredible volumes you know volumes that are outside what I think a lot of us believe could happen this year right and so I think that you know that's something that we just need to nail and we're working on a number of things to make that happen but then we've also got this other issue of you know supply constraints right so we need to get enough supply out there which is which is ensuring that you know we've got equal lateral that you know it's robust and and people can you know lock even issue SUSD and then the final component is you know gas costs and latency and you know through put like we need to get onto L2 we need a scalability solution and so we're working with the optimism team and you know that's that's moving along really well and I think we're we're kind of getting to a point where you know that's that's going to be something that is is going to be the the next kind of big phase shift for the the project and you know get us to be able to scale up to you know tens of thousands of you okay so we've got three things we've got volume supply and gas costs can we talk about each of those so on the volume side of things you guys today just announced synthetics volume program is that important can you tell us about that Kim it is and you know the reason the reason why it's important and we wanted to kind of help the bootstrap this process is that you know synthetics is a protocol and at the moment you know it's fully vertically integrated and you know we have to build the protocol itself you know we have to uh build you know all of the components all the way through to the DAP layer right but eventually we want to get to a point where you know we believe that there are people out there who can build much better DAPs better wallets better integrations and can just consume the protocol and abstract the way all the complexity for their users right and so this is our way of kind of starting that process and bootstrapping it by essentially you know funding this rebate for people who directly integrate synthetics because we believe that you know it'll be a net positive for their users over time but we need to kind of kickstart that and so you know this is a big deal it's on the we've been planning for probably about six months and you know it's something that we think we can get you know maybe 10 or 15 different integrators to you know jump on to in the next a couple of months during the trial all right so that sounds huge and on the supply question I guess you you mentioned ETH collateral so last I had uh looked at that there was kind of a an initial amount a capped amount of ETH collateral that uh was going to be let in the protocol maybe already has been can you can you give us an update on the status of ETH collateral so there's some in there now is that correct and then how are you looking to expand that there is the the limiting factor those is less the supply cap right now and more the fact that you can only borrow synthetic ETH against grade right so what it effectively means is that you know someone who wants to lock ETH and be able to you know do yield farming or trade or whatever kind of has to short ETH which is obviously not ideal um so the next the next phase which is hopefully you know three or four weeks away is the ability like you can in in maker to lock ETH and borrow S-USD the same way that you can lock ETH and borrow die um and so that will significantly expand the supply of S-USD and will there be a cap on that the amount of ETH they will be initially yeah I probably be about 5,000 ETH um I think initially but you know like maker will will increase the debt ceiling and allow that to to kind of grow over time as we get confidence that you know liquidations are working and everything is working smoothly okay so that's going to be for S-USD right so S-USD is almost would you would you say it's like a die alternative and it like one thing that I think the the bankless space has been really clamoring for is a very bankless stablecoin the most decentralized stable coins there's tons of stable coins in the space right now very few of them are decentralized maybe die can you know kind of hold that title although it's starting to incorporate some more centralized assets as well what's the vision for S-USD so far what's kind of governance thinking is it going to be a more decentralized alternative potentially um but you know I think that what people are demanding in the market is a kind of low governance low complexity uh ETH back stablecoin and I think we will see that I think people will we will build that the the big question right is not you know will they build it but can you actually bootstrap it right and so you know the thing that uh that I think your maker did incredibly well um was uh you know to to kind of bootstrap this initial liquidity right and I've said this on Twitter that it's incredibly hard to do that I think people you know massively underestimate the amount of effort and you know belief that was required to kind of bootstrap the initial die supply and so you know I do think that we uh you know we will be an alternative stablecoin but there is a lot of complexity in the synthetics ecosystem that you know maybe won't satisfy everyone they might want some in some a little uh a little simpler and less complex so what is the incentive for someone to deposit ETH to mint some S-USD then uh well arbitrage profit for one you know so if we're trading above the peg being able to you know sell uh and capture that premium is the first thing the second thing is you know S-USD is used in a lot of yield farming uh system you know you can go and deposit it into curve to farm curve balancer etc and and oftentimes the yield that's paid on S-USD is much higher than on e so it kind of makes sense to lock your ETH up yet S-USD and use that rather than just depositing your ETH directly but access to ETH overall as collateral just on the supply a topic some more you know we've written pieces on banklists about this concept of economic bandwidth right where um you know the the chain the theorem in particular needs to have assets that are highly valuable and highly liquid in order to provide um bandwidth for the entire D5 financial system that's built on top um the the thesis in banklists is that like synthetics has a limited amount of economic bandwidth right right now so let's say the market cap of uh SNX is 500 million that means you can create like you know some um proportion of 500 million in uh in synthetics on top but once you start introducing other economic bandwidth sources like potentially ETH then you can start to create a lot more supply is that does that theory resonate with you is that kind of uh an important aspect when you think about supply and when you think about collateral just collecting all of this economic all these economic bandwidth sources from the theorem it is um you know one thing though that I think uh is really critical that you know we we've kind of as a community uh sort of you know leaned into this idea that we only want to use permissionless collateral right we don't want to go down the path of using you know centralized stable points etc as collateral um so you know being able to expand the the supply of SUSD uh on you know on the back of ETH and maybe potentially you know with some tokenized BPC representations that are permissionless which you know we still need to kind of let them play out a little bit I think before we'll get comfortable enough to to use that but um you know the the ability to expand the SUSD supply which is now you know sitting at around 100 million which is kind of crazy right like I'm sure you guys remember when dye hit 100 million it was this huge deal right and you know SUSD you just quietly hit 100 million uh you know a month or so ago and it was wow I didn't even know that yeah it was just like yeah I bet it's like we didn't even notice it right like it was just like like we're like oh wow yeah it's 100 million right like it's just you know the way the market's gone um but the ability to expand SUSD out like 500 million or a billion just requires uh eat right like that's it's just critical to the functioning of the system so it's always been something that we we've considered um and it was just about trying to find the right way to do it without undermining and this is really critical without undermining the utility of SNX within the system you know SNX is still the backstop of the system is still the uh the thing that you know accrues all the fees um so you know there needs to be the right incentives for people to to use eat as collateral but not undermining incentives to use SNX and a quick definition for our listener so when you say permissioned assets you specifically mentioned ETH and you you mentioned possibly some future version of a tokenized Bitcoin but apart from that are there other permissioned assets on Ethereum and like why isn't something like USDC the stablecoin not a permissionless asset?
I mean you've got essentially a custodian that's managing uh the funds right that's managing the fee that's in a bank account somewhere um and then you know issuing essentially an I or you against it right so you know that's that's a very different uh type of asset to something like ETH right so um you know I think maybe we could consider uh you know like maker using tokens on Ethereum um but even that uh is you know is it brings its own issues right so I think for the time being uh you know it will be ETH and then maybe adding uh you know some some tokenized BTC um but to get the the next step abouting you know ERC20 tokens as as collateral I think would be a uh a stretch for the community but we'll see.
So when you say uh that you'll be able to mint SUSD via your ETH we listeners and correct me if I'm wrong but listeners should also just be hearing that because you can just swap SUSD for any other synthetic asset that you'll be able to maximally leverage your uh ether deposits to create any sort of synthetic asset it just starts with SUSD first right SUSD is like the default it's like the water and it's the it's the substrate for going into any other synthetic asset so you know maybe SUSD isn't really interesting to people because you know dollars aren't interesting to us because we're in crypto but it's just like it's the substrate token to get into every other synthetic asset right that's this is all true absolutely and you know you can go SUSD into SD5 for example which is you know fast doable the different D5 tokens on Ethereum so you know there's there's a number you can go into gold for example right so if you want to you know lock your ETH and and get some exposure to gold but I think for for most people who just want this price exposure probably the safest thing is you know take some of your stablecoins for example and just buy SUSD and then convert it rather than necessarily locking you know ETH and buying gold but you know we'll see it's going to be interesting to see how that plays out and how much demand there is for people to add supply and just participate that way or if they actually genuinely want to lock ETH and start trading yeah as we said before I mean I think ETH is economic bandwidth trustless economic bandwidth or permissionless is the word you used is it's definitely a bull case and a you know tailwind for ETH price but we will see how that pans out and look forward to you guys doing more with it and adding more of it so we talked volume we talked supply the third area which I think is really interesting is gas cost optimization right so we've been living in a gas price are down as we talk as we as we're recording this but yeah I mean it could be back up to 400 next week who knows in one of our conversations can you had talked about the work that you're doing on rollups with OVM and with the optimism team is like we talked about well kind of the main chain is like Manhattan right and this OVM solution rollup solution as a layer two chain that you're building is almost like a Brooklyn right where it's going to have more space the real estate is going to be a little bit cheaper and it's going to have more room for low cost transactions essentially so I'm I'm curious to hear your progress on on that and how are you planning to make Brooklyn a place that other protocols want to live and users want to come to certainly enough we I think we've gone a little bit over time which is totally fine but I was supposed to be on a call with the optimism team which I told them a few minutes ago but I wouldn't be able to make that well that's a little bit funny yeah yeah yeah I know no that's like it's totally fine yeah no we'll message them and apologize yeah we have a weekly catch up that we do it was like right after this but you know obviously we're having a good time here so I just told I'll catch up with them later but you know I'll be on the pod exactly right so I typically do and so so you know I think the heavy lifting of this is obviously on the optimism right you know they're the ones who are building the solution you know we're we're kind of advocates for that solution and that specific you know chain for a couple of reasons one you know they're building something that is going to be sort of you know optimized for getting people onto it as easily as possible so you know with the most minimal changes to contracts and you know ideally they'll just be able to deploy their existing main contracts straight on to on to L2 and that's important for our composability because if we want you know all of the fun that we're having now to continue you know in L2 environment we need those contracts to all be running on the same you know optimistic roll-up and so you know they're they're working with a number of teams but you know one of my you know main main jobs at the moment is like going out and talking to other projects and kind of you know advocating for them coming along and participating in this this optimistic roll-up chain that you know the the OVM supports and so you know that's that's something that is coming really soon and I think he's going to be a huge bonus particularly for smaller SNX takers so you know we've got this very problematic issue right now which is that gas costs are so high and you know the the transaction complexity on synthetics is so high that people are priced out you know they actually can't even participate unless they've got you know a couple thousand SNX for example you know which is maybe ten thousand dollars so there's a whole range of people that you know are just unable to participate in in the system right now which is really problematic so this this first phase of the the OVM migration is going to directly address that and really be targeting the people who've been kind of left out you know for the last month or so with these high gas prices and trying to you know make it a little bit easier for them to participate and you know produce some of the costs that they've been experiencing.
We were talking with Stani in the previous episode and he said that if somebody builds a great Brooklyn you know OVM will be like first to try to get in there. Have you been coordinating with any of the other D5 protocols toward this or is it mainly a synthetics initiative? No I've definitely been you know I'd speak to Stani a couple times a week you know so I've been advocating for this you know with most of the D5 projects out there that you know that we talked to and obviously you know the optimism team are working on that as well but it's one thing for you know the project itself to say hey come and you know playing this you know this place that we built it's another thing for you know a project to say hey like we've done our VD we're really comfortable this is the right approach and we're going all in on it so I think that that that carries a lot of weight and so I'm very hopeful that you know we'll be able to have some of the the critical money Legos you know over on this optimistic roll-up shard very very quickly very cool very quickly any timeline on that just curious I mean look at you know the optimism team I've said main net by the end of the year I think we'll have some interesting progress even before that you know specific synthetics progress to you know as I said alleviate some of the gas price issues so you know it's going to be a phased approach but we're working really hard to try and get this done ASAP to to get you know kind of pseudo main that stood up to kind of help with the gas cost for stakers well well well that sounds fantastic I'm really looking forward to that lower gas prices one other topic I guess on roadmap is how the whole synthetic space is shaping up so there's this idea that a decentralized bitmex might might come about and synthetics is certainly part of that story but there are some other protocols as well that have maybe some different trade-offs so of course there's maker which is you know produces dye which is a synthetic in itself but then more recently there are protocols like the UMA protocol and there's of course dy dx that takes a more order book based approach and then there's newer protocols like the perpetual protocol just curious high level what are synthetics's advantages or maybe some of the trade-offs relative to those other initiatives so I think the main trade-off with something like UMA is that you know we don't have the ability to issue the exotic assets that they do right you know because they have this kind of Chrysler's Oracle approach they don't rely on on liquid market externally to pull a price speed in from so you know they can do they can do all kinds of weird exotic instruments which I think it's really cool but the flip side of that is that each of those instruments or you know assets needs to bootstrap its own liquidity you know as we've kind of seen with their early experimentation that can be somewhat challenging sometimes so you know getting liquidity in this environment right now is really really hard right like you know if you whatever liquidity premium you've been able to kind of accrue is a huge advantage and you know obviously we've seen things like you know the vampire mining to to to mini swap which is which is a whole other topic that you know we get spent a long time talking about but you know liquidity modes are still I think a big deal and so you know for us the fact that we've got you know $100 million worth of SUSD and I think you know $130 million in since is a big advantage that we've got do you think like designs like dydx also suffer from that like lack of or the liquidity challenge as well but essentially when you're doing something in synthetics here you already have this nice pool of collateral you kind of bet against the house right and that's that can be a different liquidity absolutely you know it definitely creates it creates you know a lot of a lot of advantages and you're one of the things that it will enable which we've talked about a little bit is this idea of tokenized bridges pools like curve right so you know curve is this AMM that is really amazing at allowing you to convert different assets that track the same price so you know USDC USDT die as USD etc and then you know tokenized Bitcoin and you know tokenized gold but it requires that you know all of those assets track the same price within the same pool and it's hard to bridge the liquidity across but what synthetics is potentially going to be able to to do is be the bridge between two different curve pools so you can imagine a curve pool that had you know EVE and SE and then a curve pool that had you know SBTC TBTC Ren BTC and RAP BTC you'd be able to go E into RAP BTC by this tokenized bridge in these curve pools and you know I'm very competent the next couple months we'll see you know E to to RAP BTC transactions and you know millions of dollars on chain okay and I want to turn the conversation to regulatory compliance because you know we can't there's always kind of this this monster in the back of crypto where with which is like the nation state right this thing that is inherently generally it has an adversarial stance to probably some of the shenanigans that's going on in this base and so how does how do you guys as you know the centralized synthetics team think about compliance and like what would happen if some regulatory three letter agency came in and said like all right you guys need to implement like KYC if that happened what what would be the next steps for the synthetics team so I think this is this is kind of a critical coin and maybe you the the other pillar that what we didn't talk about it amongst those three which is just generally decentralization and decentralized governance and getting to a point where you know the protocol sufficiently decentralized that a regulator would look at and say well this is something that you know we can't actually capture we can't shut down you know it's similar to you know where I think it's you know the the Ethereum protocol got to right you know where the FCC said well it sufficiently decentralized that you know we don't believe it's a security we don't believe that it's within you know our kind of per view to to regulate this thing maybe it's someone else's but you know we're not going to step in and I think that that was you know a very calculated decision on the basis that you couldn't really regulate Ethereum right it was genuinely sufficiently decentralized you know you couldn't just go around up catalic and ask him to you know turn off the master note right that wasn't a thing and so you know I think that I think that we are getting to a point now where for example you know if you said to me shut it down I actually caught you know like I don't have any power that would allow me to to shut down the protocol you know the articles are now decentralized you know governance is decentralized we've got three different dows the control protocol upgrades and distribution of funds etc and you know there's no single party within within the protocol that has a level of control that could actually stop it and I think that that's something that's only really happened in the last you know three months where we've got to that point so I want to drive this home for listeners because I think there's a lot of people that haven't totally appreciated how bullish specifically synthetics it is for synthetics to be completely decentralized and how bullish it is for the rest of defy right because coming coming out of realty and what is going to be coming out of realty is the realty asset which is an aggregate token that has the value of all the real estate of the realty platform like underlying the asset including the rental income right it's it's it's all of realty tokenized into a single token and that token is unfortunately going to be whitelisted because that's how security tokens work like realty is an American company and therefore it answers to the SEC and no one in realty has any interest in you know going against the regulations of the SEC however what can happen when this asset is created is that synthetics can just make a synthetic realty asset which is then therefore completely permissionless and then has all the robustness of the decentralization of synthetics right and so any sort of token that comes to Ethereum that is KYC'd and permissioned can have its decentralized permission list counterpart on synthetics can have you thought about this this potential world we have and you know obviously there's lots of discussions around you know which assets we should support and you know ensuring that there's enough liquidity for them etc and so I think you know the only constraint for us is really liquidity in the the sort of primary market but the asset trades right but you know it's interesting to think about assets that are also on Ethereum for which you know we can we can kind of directly pull a price feed right but there's already an existing price feed and so something like you know realty I think is a good candidate to create like a permissionless version a little bit how you know people have made like wrapped Nexus Mutual to avoid the KYC and allow it to be sort of you know openly tradable so I think that that's something that is going to emerge over time where you know you see this permissionless variance of security tokens and various things but then you know the same thing goes for like synthetic Tesla right you know synthetic Tesla share that you know is is totally open and permissionless and you know can be purchased by anyone anywhere in the world as long as they've got you know in internet connection so we talked about it playbooks for capital formation really quick can as we as we start to wrap up here you mentioned the over 10 window has expanded which means there's basically more possibilities for crypto native DeFi native founders to essentially raise capital and you put out this excellent tweet thread that we can link to in the show notes that sort of talks about some of those things are are you starting to see that manifest now are like what advice I guess would you give a crypto native DeFi protocol founder like yourself on just capital formation yeah I you know one of the nice things about getting you know out of crypto winter and maybe crypto spring or you know whatever maybe started to kind of head into a bull market is that the the ability to raise capital and the power kind of shifts into the back into the hands of founders right you know we've gone from a situation where you know six months ago 12 months ago it was almost impossible to raise capital to a situation now where you know founders and project teams can dictate you know terms which is good it's good in the sense that you know it allows for people to do the things they want to do rather than being forced into you know specific things and so I think the ability to you know raise money directly into a Dow which was probably going to be almost impossible you know six months ago is now very possible we're seeing a lot of that and so you know the ability to to avoid the need for a foundation and you know having all this infrastructure around a project is good the flip side of that is it means you know less sort of protections for you know investors and participants and protocols which is going to lead to you know mosses and scams and things like that but I think you know it's a it's a double edge sword and so you know you'll see protocols that will do the right thing and projects that will do the right thing and be far far better for it for being able to kind of dictate terms and launch them the way that they want to and then you know you'll see you get some some mosses and inefficiency on the outside of it all right so a crypto native founders going crypto native in capital formation is sounds like that's the way to go all right so just because it's fun just because we're in a bull market just a final question for you can price predictions my friend so eth price and of this year so December 2020 what do you say and then in three years what do you say and how about the same for total locked value in defy so I think that there's a very decent chance that it will be back over a thousand by the end of the year you know depending on on the macro conditions that we're in in three years time hard to say you know that's that's probably too far out for me to even you know try and make a prediction just because the way crypto cycles work but you know I certainly hope that we'll get to a point where you know if if each 2.
0 is launched the price will be you know far higher than it is today in in three years and then you know total value locked it wouldn't surprise me at all you know over the next 12 months to see you know 50 billion in total value locked or or more there you go that is bullish and can it's been a pleasure when we talked about particularly the synthetics roadmap the future volume supply gas costs and increasing decentralization that that's a very bullish roadmap sir and the bankless nation is is looking to you guys and the synthetics governance to pull it off very excited about all of that cane thanks for joining us today thanks yeah it was a lot of fun really appreciate it awesome all right bankless nation some action items for you guys we have included a link to the new volume incentive program that we mentioned on the show also a link to cane thread that we mentioned you should also get involved in synthetics governance there's a link to that as well getting getting involved in these protocols is the way you learn about them that's the bankless way for sure we also have included a tactic from bankless on how to use synthetics so if you're just warming up to it if it's just your first time you can check that out as well finally we are looking for your five star reviews on apple iTunes David we're at 154 so we want to get to 200 we want to get to 300 we want to get to 500 we want to overrun we need to break ether price right this is how it works right we are going to get the bankless podcast to the top of the iTunes chart as this as this bull market continues and we need your help to do so right we are now in the top 100 of the iTunes investing and finance categories for podcasts and I totally think that in one two years we're going to be in the top 10 but we need your help to get there so if you could go to wherever you listen to your podcast and give us those five star reviews so we can spread the bankless nation across the world we would really appreciate it all right let's do guys risk and disclaimers eat is risky so is SNX crypto is risky in general so is defy you could lose what you put in so be careful out there but we are headed west this is the frontier it's not for everyone but we're glad you're with us on the bankless journey thanks a lot