Austin Campbell is the managing partner of Zero Knowledge Consulting, an adjunct professor at Columbia Business School, and used to work at Paxos in both Portfolio Management and Chief Risk Officer. He also was Co-Head of Digital Assets in Global Rates at CitiBank at JP Morgan for a decade.
Austin knows a thing or two about the TradWorld and we brought him on to help us navigate all of the TradNews that has surfaced in the last two weeks around the crypto space.
------ 🚀 Unlock $3,000+ in Perks with Bankless Citizenship 🚀 https://bankless.cc/GetThePerks
------ 📣 CYFRIN | Smart Contract Audits & Solidity Course https://bankless.cc/cyfrin
------ BANKLESS SPONSOR TOOLS:
🐙KRAKEN | MOST-TRUSTED CRYPTO EXCHANGE https://k.xyz/bankless-pod-q2
🦊METAMASK LEARN | HELPFUL WEB3 RESOURCE https://bankless.cc/MetaMask
⚖️ ARBITRUM | SCALING ETHEREUM https://bankless.cc/Arbitrum
🧠 AMBIRE | SMART CONTRACT WALLET https://bankless.cc/Ambire
🦄UNISWAP | ON-CHAIN MARKETPLACE https://bankless.cc/uniswap
🛞MANTLE | MODULAR LAYER 2 NETWORK https://bankless.cc/Mantle
----- TIMESTAMPS:
0:00 Intro 5:12 Austin Campbell 7:14 TradFi Last Two Weeks 10:59 Political Conspiracy 15:05 Timing Analysis 17:17 BlackRock Bitcoin ETF 20:05 Other Bitcoin ETFs Denied 22:47 What's the SEC's Next Move? 24:00 How Bullish is This? 26:13 BlackRock & Coinbase/Kraken Partnership 31:15 EDX Markets 37:22 Unbundling of Crypto Exchanges 42:22 Stablecoins Landscape 49:55 Stablecoin McHenry Bill 56:50 International Stablecoins 57:55 Closing & Disclosures
----- RESOURCES:
Austin Campbell https://twitter.com/CampbellJAustin
----- Not financial or tax advice. This channel is strictly educational and is not investment advice or a solicitation to buy or sell any assets or to make any financial decisions. This video is not tax advice. Talk to your accountant. Do your own research.
Disclosure. From time-to-time I may add links in this newsletter to products I use. I may receive commission if you make a purchase through one of these links. Additionally, the Bankless writers hold crypto assets. See our investment disclosures here: https://www.bankless.com/disclosures
No summary for this episode yet.
Thank you. approved how bullish is it what does this mean for the sec's treatment of crypto but not only that charles schwab and fidelity have a new uh exchange entering into the marketplace the edx markets exchange has entered the fold who is this marketplace for how is it different and what is with the timing of all of this in the worst most hostile regulatory environment some of the biggest traditional players have decided to enter the game. What is the deal with that? There's also a bunch of stablecoin conversations to be had as well. Stablecoins are under attack. Some of them are being labeled as securities, yet also there is a stablecoin bill going through Congress.
Why is this all happening at once? These are some very deep, very big questions about the way that the incumbents of the world are treating our industry, and they're also treating it well. They want to come play the game. The TradFi conversation is definitely a conversation that I need help with. So we are bringing on someone who has been in the TradFi world. Austin Campbell, new to the Bankless podcast, is going to help us navigate some of these conversations. And I will introduce him in just a second. But first, a moment to talk about some of these fantastic sponsors that make this show possible, especially Kraken, our preferred exchange for crypto in 2023.
We're going to talk about another kind of exchange, but Kraken is the exchange for you. And we're going to talk about how that's different. If you do not have an account with Kraken, consider clicking the link in the show notes to sign up for one now. We're going to hear from them right now. Let's go. anywhere you want in your screen. With Kraken Pro, you have that power. Whether you are a seasoned pro or just starting out, join thousands of traders who trust Kraken Pro for their crypto trading needs. Visit pro.kraken.com to get started today. Mantle, formerly known as BitDAO, is the first DAO-led Web3 ecosystem, all built on top of Mantle's first core product, the Mantle Network, a brand new high-performance Ethereum Layer 2 built using the OP stack, but uses Eigenlayer's data availability solution instead of the expensive Ethereum Layer 1.
Not only does this reduce Mantle Network's gas fees by 80%, but it also reduces gas fee volatility, providing a more stable foundation for Mantle's applications. The Mantle Treasury is one of the biggest DAO-owned treasuries, which is seeding an ecosystem of projects from all around the Web3 space for Mantle. Mantle already has sub-communities from around Web3 onboarded, like Game7 for Web3 gaming, and Bybit for TVL and liquidity and on-ramps. So if you want to build on the Mantle Network, Mantle is offering a grants program that provides milestone-based funding to promising projects that help expand, secure, and decentralize Mantle.
If you want to get started working with the first DAO-led Layer 2 ecosystem, check out Mantle at Mantle.xyz and follow them on Twitter at 0xMantle. If you haven't experienced the superpowers that a smart contract wallet gives you, check out Ambire. Ambire works with all the EVM chains that are out there. The Layer 2s like Arbitrum, Optimism, and Polygon, but also the non-Ethereum chains like Avalanche and Phantom. Because of the power of smart contract wallets, Ambire lets you pay for gas and stable claims, meaning you'll never have to spend your precious ETH again. The web app has numerous fiat on-ramps to make it easy to dump your fiat for crypto.
And if you like self-custody, but you still want training wheels, you can recover a lost Ambuyer wallet using an email and password, but without giving the Ambuyer team any control over your funds. Check it out at ambuyer.com for the web app experience. But also the Ambuyer mobile wallet is coming soon for both iOS and Android. And if you want to be a beta tester, you could sign up at ambuyer.com slash app. And since you stayed to the very end of this ad read, you should know that Ambuyer is airdropping its wallet token to early users for simply just using the wallet. So if you want to get started with Ambuyer, all the links that you need are in the show notes.
Bankless Nation, I would love to introduce you to Austin Campbell. Austin is the managing partner of Zero Knowledge Consulting. He's also an adjunct professor at Columbia Business School. He used to work at Paxos, the stablecoin issuer in both portfolio management and also as the chief risk officer. He was once the co-head of digital assets and global rates at Citibank and was also at JP Morgan for over a decade. So Austin knows a thing or two about the trad world, and I'm hoping he can help us navigate all of the trad news that has surfaced in the last two weeks or so around the crypto space.
Austin, welcome to Bankless. Yeah, thank you for having me, David. So that was my attempt at your bio, but maybe you want to explore a little bit. This is your first appearance on Bankless. So welcome to the show, but also just a little bit more about who Austin Campbell is and where your where your position is in the crypto world. Yeah, so I would say, you know, I jokingly describe myself as ultimately a person who wandered into crypto despite being a grouchy fixed income person from traditional finance. So like my background in that space. So I started my mainstream career in traditional finance after some time in reinsurance was largely around cash stability products.
So I was thinking about, and this is going to sound familiar to people who have thought about stable coins, if I've got this underlying pool of assets, and I always need them to trade at a fixed price, despite people coming in and out of this pool, how would I make that happen? And the areas in which I was originally working on that were actually in very traditional markets of the US. So it was bank capital markets, and then the 401k market. it so if anybody has ever looked in their 401k if you're a U.S person and seen a stable value fund that you can blame me right among many other people for making those things happen so I did that for a long time and got interested in crypto you know really because of some of the issues around 2008 and how some of the innovations of blockchain technology and the financial structure that underpins that solves a lot of the problems that we had that really you know I don't have to speech that 2008 was incredibly destructive to people so I I didn't come at it from like call it an ideological maximalism standpoint I was very much a functionalist and like hey this solves problems and so from there I was at Stone Ridge for a while that's the parent of nideg I was through City I was at paxos for a while and now I do a lot of consulting work in the space beautiful beautiful and I think you are the the perfect man to really help us uh guide us through this As I said in the intro, the trad world is not something that I'm familiar with, so I definitely need help here.
Bankless listeners will know that I learned everything I know about money and finance through crypto, not through anything prior to crypto. I want to start with this tweet that came from Delphi Digital, which just says, Over the past two weeks, BlackRock files for a Bitcoin ETF. NASDAQ is launching crypto custody services. Deutsche Bank seeks crypto custody services. Soros Fund Management says crypto is here to stay. Citadel, Fidelity, and Charles Schwab launch a crypto exchange. The institutions are here. Now, not all of this has happened in the last two weeks. NASDAQ has been doing their custody thing for a long while now.
But I think the point still stands and what this tweet's really getting at is man, in the last two weeks, TradFi has entered the game in a very new and very big way. And over the series, that's been a year of just onslaught from regulators and governments and just also onslaught from trad leaders like Jamie Diamond, Larry Fink, all these people, all of a sudden trad is entering the game. And that's what it feels like to me as a crypto native, somebody who lives and breathes inside of the industry. I don't know what it looks like for the perspective of someone who is also extremely familiar with the trad world.
So maybe you could just summarize the sentiment of someone who is both familiar with crypto and traditional finance, like what does the last two weeks mean to you? So I would say anytime something like this happens in a traditional financial firm and you see things come together over about a two week period, that's probably the culmination of six to 18 months of work behind the scenes. Everything moves slowly at these places, right? So like if you're in a crypto startup, if you live in the crypto world, you're used to making decisions by getting together on telegram or, maybe getting on a video call, arguing with each other.
If it's a long one, doing some research, coming back and doing it again a few days later. I launched a product at Citi that took a year and a half to make that kind of decision. So the timescales you operate on are just glacial compared to what you're going to see in the regular world. So if BlackRock filed an ETF application, they've been thinking about it for a while. Part of it is just why do they pick the current moment. And I would say it's important to remember the history there. If you look at ETF applications for Bitcoin ETFs, there have been many of them from genuinely some pretty top-rate institutions, right?
You've got like Fidelity, you've got Invesco, you've got VanEck, you've got StoneRidge, my old employer, all people who live well within the regulated world, the SEC is familiar with. They're not engaging in funny business. Like these are genuine attempts at ETFs. So what's the signal for BlackRock piling on? I would say it's two things. One, it's telling the SEC and the U.S. government, if we can't get our act together here, there's a lot of things that are already happening offshore. Like these products exist in Canada, they exist in Europe, and if you block us here, we're probably just going to take our business there as part of the message.
Another thing is that Larry Fink is pretty influential in the Democratic Party. I think this may be a little bit of a signal from the TradFi world. of we would like you to find a constructive solution to this problem, not just keep blocking it. Because when you look and zoom out from the US and think about the global situation, you have Project Guardian coming out of Singapore. The JFSA in Japan has been very progressive on crypto and also very protective of consumers. FTX Japan didn't lose anybody's money. And I think a lot of people don't realize this. Mika just passed in Europe. So I think US traditional financial firms are genuinely at the point of being very worried about being left behind.
And that's part of the reason you're seeing these things coming forward, because you got to put the pressure on if we wait another six years here, you know, in crypto terms, that's like what eight market cycles at this point. Yeah, certainly. And so there's a sentiment out there that in crypto, we like to wear our conspiracy hats. Sometimes I think it's pretty fun to put it on. And the conspiracy here is that the Democratic Party specifically, the Biden administration, along with Gary Gensler, Elizabeth Warren, that whole axis of power has been hammering all of the crypto native companies and the crypto native industry in order to clear the way for the Larry Finks.
You said the Larry Fink is very influential in the Democratic Party. So the conspiracy is that the regulators have been acting as an arm of the Democrats in order to clear the way for the big traditional incumbents in order to have free and easy access into a market that the regulators have hammered. How on a scale, how much merit does this sentiment have? Or is this just crypto people being conspiracy people? So there's a great scene in the movie Forrest Gump, if anybody's seen it, where Forrest is playing football, catches the ball, runs down the field, scores a touchdown, and then runs out of the stadium and continues running basically forever.
That's kind of what the crypto community does to me with a lot of these conspiracy theories, right? It's like you take an initial grain of truth, but then you're like out the stadium and across the country. So what I would say is this. Yes, regulators have hammered a lot of crypto firms. However, I would say there's two things going on there simultaneously. I would not find this like a great plot to empower TradFi. It's that one, just being blunt, some of our regulators are really uninformed on this technology or under-informed and don't have a complete view of what's going on in the market, why the technology is important, why it should be used, what's progressive.
Like there are people in the administration and at some of the regulators who just think all of crypto is a scam. And if it all leaves the country, that's a feature, not a bug. On the other hand, there are many people at these regulators and within the administration, within the Democratic Party who don't hold that view. So don't take that as a monolith. Understand that as you describe, quote, the Democratic Party, that's kind of describing like, quote, half the United States. Like there's a big diversity of views to. With that said, some of the objections that regulators have to crypto activities, I would describe as completely legitimate.
it. Like one of the problems in crypto is that there are people who are pridefully ignorant about the financial system and banking because they think banks are the bad guys. And so they just throw it all out. In reality, man, they have broken a lot of stuff historically in the banking and finance world, learned a lot of lessons about how not to let that happen. So like one of the points that the SEC has been on about that I personally agree with is the separation of custody from trading, right? Like things like FTX can't happen if you have an independent custodian that holds the funds and verifies them.
They would know if somebody was taking all the Bitcoin and selling it to buy FTT or something like that. So separating those duties, probably a good thing. And I can see objections to some of the models, you know, that exist currently where like a crypto exchange in a very weird way is like just about the most centralized financial like entity that can possibly exist, right? Which is ironic for crypto to have spawned that. So I don't want to completely say that everything the regulators are saying is bad. Actually, I think some, not all, but some of the SEC's critiques are correct. My problems with them are more how they're going about doing it.
Like I have some issues with rule of law and sort of extra legal and extra judicial actions. But I think some of the core of their critiques like, yo, there's some real BS activity around trading going on here, like wash trading, front running, et cetera. And yo, your custody should probably be separated from your trading activities. Those I think are valid points. Yeah. And there's a whole conversation that we're going to have as we go into the second half of this episode around the new exchange, because that's specifically what this new exchange from Charles Schwab and the other backers from Citadel, et cetera, is built around.
It's built around, it's an exchange without the assets, right? The assets come from elsewhere. But I really want to first continue down this BlackRock ETF conversation. Okay, so we're putting a pin on the whole, like, it's not a conspiracy, but crypto people love those kinds of conversations. So that's why they entertain them. On the flip side of things, maybe a more gracious interpretation of events is, like you said, the trad world moves slowly. Six to 18 months of building up to this point of even submitting papers in order to prepare for this. And so all of these trad institutions have a lot at stake, even though they haven't formally entered the game yet, they are planning to.
And so maybe the timing on this also comes from the fact that they are watching the SEC and regulators hammer down an industry that they see profit from. And so maybe the signal of BlackRock choosing now to submit their Bitcoin ETF, spot ETF with the SEC, is also a signals like, hey, SEC, don't kill that thing. We would like to do business there. This perhaps is a more gracious, more charitable interpretation of timing. What's your take here? Yeah, I think that's probably closer to correct, right? Like the things you can read from the ETF filing are one, BlackRock thinks it's important enough to throw their hat into the ring, even when they know they're going to catch some PR and public flack about it, and they're willing to do it anyways.
So that's a statement of intent. Two, the big guys like the BlackRocks, the Fidelities, the Invescos, the VanEcks, the StoneRidges don't put their hat into the ring unless they think they can do it safely. So it's also a statement about the fact that they do not think the entire crypto market is a scam. They do think this stuff has some long-term value and utility because they're not going to do this for something they really think is completely useless, will be gone in a year, it shouldn't exist in the US. This is a statement of quite frankly, the reverse, at least in this case about Bitcoin.
I would imagine their opinions are probably similar about ETH, if we're being honest. Now, a bunch of altcoins. Now, maybe there's a discussion to be had, but it's telling you they see some fundamental utility in blockchain technology and decentralization. When done, I would describe it in an intellectually honest way. This is a take that I saw from Jake Stravinsky that's along these same lines. He says, the SEC has adamantly refused to approve a spot Bitcoin ETF for years, a view so entrenched that it's litigating the issue against Grayscale, of course, a crypto native trust with BTC right now.
Knowing that the SEC disagrees, BlackRock wants to list a Bitcoin ETF on NASDAQ anyways. And then he finishes up and says, everyone gets how big this is, right? So here is the actual filing here. We're looking at the report here. This is well beyond my pay grade to even understand, but I to imagine that this whatever this document is this filing with the sec is you know par for the course interestingly enough gray uh blackrock has submitted 576 applications for etfs of various kinds and it has gotten approved 575 of them so almost batting 100 with a very large number of at bats uh austin i don't know how to interpret the these kinds of documents but is there anything inside of the grayscale or excuse me the blackrock bitcoin etf that we should understand like how is this thing built how is it constructed is there any nuances here that are worth understanding i mean it so this is one of the problems with the current sec regime you read a document like this and it'll be like you know 100 pages long and probably 10 of them have actual content the majority of it is just cya disclosures so one thing i would say is i've seen a lot of talk about oh my god blackrock has all these things in about forks and risks and they're planning all kinds of evil it's like no the way you write a prospectus having been involved in them in the past is you sit down at a table and you list everything you could possibly think is even maybe kind of sort of a small risk to the thing and you throw it all in there because you're supposed to disclose it like if blackrock thought there was a one percent chance that like aliens would come steal bitcoin it would be in the etf filing right so just to be clear this is the kitchen sink approach and you do that to cover yourself legally because securities litigation is awful and people get sued all the time for, hey, X happened, I lost money and you didn't say it could happen.
And it's super annoying. So this is more about just plaintiff's attorneys and how the US legal system works than any statement of intent. So let's be very clear about that. Two, beyond that, it's a bone stock ETF filing. Like what are we going to do here? We're going to buy Bitcoin when people give us money to buy Bitcoin and we're going to sell Bitcoin when people want their money back. The fact that I stopped talking there is kind of the point, right? Like that's it. The only thing that's novel about this compared to all of the other ETF filings is something about like surveillance and information sharing.
But the reality is everybody else was willing to do that already too, right? They're just codifying it. So this is almost like a clone of the other ETF filings, which to me is actually the interesting part. Yeah. Why is that interesting? There are a bunch of Bitcoin ETFs that have been submitted and denied. I think there have been many that have submitted and are still in limbo waiting, kind of waiting to get denied, perhaps now waiting to get approved if the SEC approves this one. So what's the lay of the land? What's the landscape for the other Bitcoin ETFs that have been submitted? And how does the fact that BlackRock, that they submitted this one, How does that change the game?
Yeah, I mean, it's kind of a statement that BlackRock thinks a lot of the previous applications were fine. Right. So that to me is interesting. Right. Like they're saying, we think it's possible to do a very vanilla, very boring Bitcoin ETF safely. Right. Obviously, we would like to do it. That's why they filed this thing. So I think it's almost a statement more from like, this is why I said it's more of a statement to the SEC and regulators and the government of like, hey, help us out here. Right. They're saying we think we can do these things safely. We think people should be allowed to do it.
That's the real message I'm taking from this. I will also say on the conspiracy theory note, if the SEC approves the BlackRock run while having continued to deny all the others, that will be a gigantic scandal. Like you are not supposed to play favorites as a regulator. At a bare minimum, if they're going to approve something, they probably approve basically all of these at the exact same time. right and so if if the example is that they just approved the black rock etf then all the conspiracies that the people the crypto people are saying that the sec cleared the way for black rock would come true correct well that that would also like so let's leave the realm of crypto for a moment yeah if the sec starts playing favorites by approving things for like a black rock or a jp morgan in front of everybody else who filed materially identical things first you're now into gigantic political scandal world, because now this is not a neutral rules-based regulator, even if you hate their interpretation of the rules.
Now this is somebody doling out explicit political or financial favors to people. That is not how US regulators operate, right? Like I am lucky enough to know some pretty senior folks at some of our regulators, right? Like New York Fed, Fed, Chicago Fed, CFTC, the credit union administrator. This is not how any of them operate. They actually care a lot about fairness and fair treatment. And so when you look at somewhat janky decisions that are made historically, there's usually a lot more going on behind the scenes than people realize. But this kind of thing, no, it would be shocking to me. That's credibility destroyed for the SEC, even outside of crypto.
So in that case, are we going to see what's the SEC's move here? Like, I think looking at BlackRock's track record, they think that they can get this approved. They've only missed one out of 576. And so assuming that this does get approved, this kind of means that more also need to get approved at the same time. So we're going to have a handful of Bitcoin ETFs and they're all going to compete on the open market. What's the SEC's move here? Because we know Gary Gensler doesn't like crypto and doesn't want to, I would assume. What do you think happens next? Yeah, I mean, you're going one of two paths, either exactly what you just said, or they've got to also deny BlackRock, which I think turns up the pressure in Washington dramatically.
Right. I think if, again, zooming out, a lot of this is probably happening because Europe just successfully passed Nika and is in the process of implementing it. right before when you're in a world where no other major large jurisdiction really has functional crypto legislation we could all just kind of wait fine but now you're in a position where if it takes us again two to six years to get something going well europe is way ahead at that point and so i think the pressure is being put on by some of the traditional financial institutions for that reason like the big u.s asset managers and banks do not want to live in a world where consumer product that is heavily demanded can be offered by all of their global competitors and they are paralyzed so with the assuming that we move forward and we eventually get this uh this etf approved and therefore others as well hopefully uh how bullish is this the idea is like there's a pipeline now between the world of wall street the world of tradfi the the world of money that's out there that still is uncomfortable with crypto native exchanges and now there's a pipe between them and Bitcoin, right?
And downstream of Bitcoin is like all of the risk on assets of crypto. So what's the timing on this? Do you think you have any speculation on timing? And what does this do to the actual market of crypto assets? What do you think? Yeah, so I've said for a long time, one of the problems that crypto has is just being completely inscrutable and unapproachable to normal human beings, right? So I kind of, I look at market adoption cycles in like three ways, right? like sort of canonically speaking is one is can power users use it we're there with crypto like i can use this stuff technologists can use this stuff fine the next one is could one of the peers of like my age or a little bit younger use it without incredible brain damage maybe like not honestly not really for crypto like private key security setting up wallets understanding what to interact with a normal like 30 year old person who's not deeply invested in this space actually it's still pretty hard for them.
The third stage is, could my mother use it? We are nowhere near my mother using it. But the interesting part about an ETF is that's like something people can buy, right? Normal two-legged humans could buy it. No, they're not really using the technology, but they're getting closer. And so it's slower than people want, but faster than it could be. It's a very medium step in that regard. The thing that will need to follow it to be like very, very bullish is the situation where people can actually use the thing as it's intended on a blockchain in a more seamless way. We're not there yet, but this is one of the bricks you need to put in the wall to get people there is what I would say.
There's one last topic of conversation in this Bitcoin ETF, which is the partners that BlackRock has brought to the table in order to enable this. Coinbase is the custodian for BlackRock. And so sure, BlackRock's doing the ETF, but coinbase is holding the bitcoin and then also kraken has a subsidiary called cf benchmarks which is providing the price data to the etf so the actual price that shows up on the on for the etf is actually due to another crypto company kraken what do you make of the partnership between black rock and two very native crypto exchanges what would you say is the significance of this well so what on the pricing front my response there is kind of like duh like where would you go to get good prices on crypto the people who trade all the crypto right so that makes a ton of sense to me on coinbase being the custodian i think one of the mistakes we've made in the u.
s space is blocking our traditional custody crowd from doing crypto custody effectively so i'm gonna specifically lay blame on the sec and the occ for this they have not been able to find a regime to allow people to be qualified custodians in the u.s regulatory space like you would prefer this to be done by somebody like a state street a bony melon the usual custodians but sab 121 and then the occ's refusal to approve trusts has really blocked this activity so who do you go with you go with the people who could do it so i would tell you in some ways one good job coinbase like that is not a denigration of coinbase i'm glad they managed to make it through an rfp and get that done like well done to the institutional people over there and i mean that genuinely but two Two, also, I would have a hard look again at the U.
S. regulatory regime of if your real goal with crypto is we don't like it because it's not safe. And so what we're going to do is block anybody from doing it safely. Like, wait, what? Right. So they've kind of, you know, it's a snake eating its own tail. Like you've really tied yourself into a knot here. Awesome. This was a fantastic exploration into the grayscale, the grayscale, gosh, the BlackRock ETF, the big one. There's a whole entire other conversation around this new exchange, EDX Markets. Charles Schwab, Fidelity, Citadel are all making a big move despite the Gary Gensler crackdown, just like BlackRock is into the world of building an exchange, a crypto exchange.
But this one's very, very different. And so this is a whole second part of this conversation. So we're going to enter that conversation as soon as we get back from some of these fantastic sponsors that make the show possible. MetaMask Portfolio is the best way to view your crypto portfolio from a holistic level. See everything across all the chains all at once. In your portfolio, MetaMask will report the aggregate value of all the assets in your MetaMask wallets and even the other wallets you import too. But MetaMask Portfolio isn't just a passive portfolio viewer. It is a place to do all of the money verbs that make DeFi so powerful.
You can buy, swap, bridge, and stake your crypto assets. assets. So not only is MetaMask the easiest place to see your wallets in aggregate, but it's also a powerful battle station for all of your DeFi moves. So go check out your MetaMask portfolio because it's waiting for you to open it up. Check it out at portfolio.metamask.io. You know Uniswap. It's the world's largest decentralized exchange with over $1.4 trillion in trading volume. You know this because we talk about it endlessly on Bankless. It's Uniswap, but Uniswap is becoming so much more. Uniswap Labs just released the Uniswap mobile wallet for iOS.
the newest, easiest way to trade tokens on the go. With the Uniswap wallet, you can easily create or import a new wallet, buy crypto on any available exchange with your debit card, with extremely low fiat on-ramp fees, and you can seamlessly swap on mainnet, Polygon, Arbitrum, and Optimism. On the Uniswap mobile wallet, you can store and display your beautiful NFTs, and you can also explore Web3 with the in-app search features, market leaderboards, and price charts, or use Wallet Connect to connect to any Web3 application. So you can now go directly to DeFi with the Uniswap mobile wallet. Safe, simple custody from the most trusted team in DeFi.
Download the Uniswap wallet today on iOS. There is a link in the show notes. Arbitrum One is pioneering the world of secure Ethereum scalability and is continuing to accelerate the Web3 landscape. Hundreds of projects have already deployed on Arbitrum One, producing flourishing DeFi and NFT ecosystems. With the recent addition of Arbitrum Nova, gaming and social dApps like Reddit are also now calling Arbitrum home. Both Arbitrum One and Nova leverage the security and decentralization of Ethereum and provide a builder experience that's intuitive, familiar, and fully EVM compatible. On Arbitrum, both builders and users will experience faster transaction speeds with significantly lower gas fees.
With Arbitrum's recent migration to Arbitrum Nitro, it's also now 10 times faster than before. Visit Arbitrum.io where you can join the community, dive into the developer docs, bridge your assets, and start building your first app. With Arbitrum, experience Web3 development the way it was meant to be. Secure, fast, cheap, and friction-free. Bankless Nation, we are back with the other half of TradFi that has entered the crypto world. We have this new marketplace, new crypto exchange called EDX Markets. For some reason, we love our acronyms in crypto. EDX Markets has begun trading and has also completed a new funding round specifically for digital assets.
Okay, so this is a different kind of crypto exchange. Are you, bankless listener, able to exchange on EDX markets? And that answer is no. There is no place like, it's not like Kraken. It's not like Coinbase. There's no UI to look at. There's no place to sign up. There's no place to submit your ID. So Austin, what's the deal here? We call this a crypto exchange, but what is going on? What is EDX markets? Yeah, so let's work backwards by talking about how TradFi exchanges work and then we can sort of move forward into EDX. So in TradFi world, when we talk about exchanges and people use something, there's actually three different components going on.
One is the exchange itself, which is a place where people come together and buy and sell, right? So you can think of it as, you know, your classic marketplace. But importantly, that's all the exchange does. It's just there to take and match orders. Behind the exchange, there will be a custodian, right, of some sort, which is the entity that actually is holding the assets. That is not the exchange, importantly. And then there's also what's called a clearing agent. They're the ones who make sure that things get from party A to party B when there's a trade, right? Like the dollars for shares of, you know, JP Morgan stock actually clear.
Now, blockchain doesn't quite work that way. This has been one of the problems the SEC has had. So in Greek mythology, there's this dude named Procrustes, right, who would capture people. And he's got a bed, and the bed is always a fixed size. And so if you're too short, he stretches you. And if you're too long, he cuts some of your limbs off so that you fit exactly into the bed. This is kind of the approach the SEC has taken with banging crypto into the exchange framework. It's like, yeah, we kind of don't really care about the damage. Do it this way. So EDX is basically not really customer facing because there might not be a great way to face retail yet.
Or they want front ends to face retail for them. And all it does is match orders on the assets that they think are not securities. So this is how you end up with the situation of in 2023 launching a project like this, which is it's really designed to work with what U.S. regulations, which on this stuff, by the way, were written closer to the Civil War than the present day. True. You know, and we have an exchange that now 50% of the products they're offering in 2023 are Litecoin and Bitcoin Cash. So it's like, let's be honest, the good innovation here about EDX is splitting the exchange from custody.
I talked about that earlier. I salute them for doing that. That's a good thing. The bad part is the rest of this is really like you're taking a product that's not really great for consumers or anybody to bag it into the U.S. regulatory framework rather than asking, you know, from a first principles basis, what's good for consumers? What's good for the world? What's good for innovation? What are the good parts of this technology? So 50-50. So just to really define what this thing is. there's no place to deposit crypto because it doesn't store crypto. It is just, and so inside of all crypto exchanges, traders and bankless listeners, long-time crypto fans will know the term trading engine.
Is that all this thing is? It's just a trading engine plus some APIs to custodians who have the actual crypto? Is that basically what this thing is? I mean, that's what a TradFi exchange is, right? It's an order matching layer that sits on top of custody solutions. So, yes, it seems so simple. Yeah. So but it also for again, like for people like me who came into the world of money and finance through crypto banks, I was like, oh, yeah, you you give them your money and then and then they give you a trading engine to settle with other customers. But we apparently what you're telling us is that in the world of TradFi, we've learned the dangers of FTX is out there where like, sure, in the best cases that works just fine.
In the best case, you have the Coinbase and the Krakens. In the worst case, or maybe even in the medium cases, you have FTXs where there's a discrepancy between the exchange and the actual custody of funds. And so I think what you're saying is like the TradFi world has learned this lesson throughout history, and there's laws and regulations to separate custodianship and exchange. And so this EDX is an exchange for TradWorld that is now slowly going to be able to custody crypto, but it's an exchange meant for them. That's my interpretation. Is that correct? I mean, it's somewhat correct. I would say, again, importantly, EDX is not the custodian.
They're using another custodian. Because one of the important parts there really is the separation of duties and security. You want the people doing custody to have one job. Don't lose your stuff. And that should be all of their incentives. And that's where it works to separate these things. Because exchanges will have incentives to boost trading and generate profits and create margins and do fun stuff. But when the custodian, they make money by just not losing your stuff and preventing funny business, those two forces interacting produces a safer system, right? And there's multiple ways to do it.
You can have very strict rules for exchanges about segregate your staff, segregate your funds, you can't hold the currency yourself. All the like crypto has got to be in cold storage and externally verified. That's what they do in Japan and it worked, right? You could have totally separate legal entities do it. But the point is, don't let people just glom all these things together. The conflicts of interest eventually lead to bad things happening. So that part, again, is good. The bad part of EDX is like when you take crypto and you trap it in a walled garden and you only have this janky list of assets, like we're destroying a lot of the value.
It's, you know, there's the old blockchain, not crypto thing from TradFi. This is almost like blockchain, but also not blockchain. okay so with this perspective i can kind of see why institutions like coinbase or kraken would offend the regulators because i mean look at what they're doing they're trade they're trading and custodian in the same spot how dare they yet also to me like kraken and coinbase have done a bang up job doing exactly the thing that they said that they would do which is service customers And so I think hopefully what I'm worried about is that now that there's EDX markets as this bastion of compliance for the trad world, I'm worried that there might be regulation that's passed that says, hey, Coinbase, hey, Kraken, separate your custodianship and give it to some other custodian and only run the exchange and unbundle yourself.
And that would lose a lot of the magic, right? A lot of what you're talking about. I don't think that would lose any of the magic if you do it properly, right? Because think about it this way. All Coinbase is really doing is taking all your stuff, putting it in an omnibus account, ledgering everybody's ownership of that, letting people trade against each other. There's no reason you couldn't just have a custodian running that ledger. It's not that hard. Stocks trade very efficiently in the United States, and they use the system that was just described. It doesn't lose the magic. The part that's losing the magic is if you say like 50% of your assets are Litecoin and Bitcoin Cash in 2023.
That's like pants on head dumb. And two, if it blocks the ability of people to get their crypto in and out of it. Because like here's a big difference between a share of Apple stock and Ethereum. You can use Ethereum to transact on the blockchain for utility. That's not true of Apple stock. Right. So if you ignore that distinction, sort of the ironic effect is the critique of crypto is, oh, it's all just price speculation and like slinging shit coins becomes true because the regulators are forcing it to be that if you can't use the tokens for actual utility. Right. So again, this is why I raised like the Procrustean bad sort of methodology is you're saying, well, I've got a regulatory framework from 1940 that didn't even contemplate the Internet.
And you damn well better fit into that if you want to operate here. it's probably not the best way to do things. Interesting. Okay, what do you think this means for the long-term structure of the crypto markets from the crypto native side of things? Do you think eventually Coinbase and Kraken and all the other crypto native exchanges, the crypto banks out there, do become unbundled and start to look more like trad? Or do they kind of get to keep what they've built, which is more of a singularity of services all in the same spot? I would say the good case is we get halfway between those two extremes, which is that you want to keep the good part, which is the ability to trade a variety of assets on something like an omni ledger against each other, and the ability to send assets and receive assets so that we preserve the benefits of self-custody and decentralization.
But we also move to a world where those services don't all need to be provided by the same guy. Because the problem with the Coinbase and Kraken structure is that while their conduct up to this point has been honestly pretty exemplary in the grand scheme of things, that doesn't mean it will necessarily persist. Like I am not okay with the financial system based on trust me, I'm cool. And by the way, all five of my successors, none of whom you know, will be cool for the next 50 years. Right? So like, trust but verify is the way things need to work in this space. Meaning that some degree of unbundling and external verification, I think is required going forward, or it is inevitable that we will have problems because not all people are good people.
Interesting. Interesting. Okay. That's a nuanced take that I now have to interpret and integrate. And so I guess it's one part of the crypto world is pulling the trad world and being like, hey, this is the new meta. Start to look more like us. And the trad world is like, well, we've learned those lessons before. You look a little bit more like us. And then somewhere, the pendulum will rest in the middle of these two extremes. That is correct. The reality is, having come from both worlds, I would tell you a global, neutral, fairly governed, open that's 24-7 is an incredible advancement in technology.
The ability to do it transparently is incredibly important. And the ability to settle things without counterparty credit risk on either side is incredibly important. These are technological innovations that had they existed in 2008, we wouldn't have had some of the problems we had, and we should not lose the benefits of that. On the other hand, missing some of the basic risk management lessons about things like don't let your position sizes get completely out of control and maybe monitor those. Don't let the exchange people who make money on activity wash trade with customer assets because you commingled things with the custodian.
Those sorts of lessons we should also learn. There are kind of best practices on both sides. And rather than saying all one, but none of the other, we should really try to take the best of both. Beautiful. Okay. I feel very content about this EDX and exchange marketplace conversation. I want to tilt the conversation towards the world of stable coins, tapping into your experience over at Paxos. Recently, BUSD was named a security by the SEC in their action against Binance. There's also a stable coin legislation bill passing its way through Congress. So Austin, I'm wondering if you can just kind of set the table, give us the lay of the land.
What is the state of stable coins? What arises to your attention these days? Yeah, so I would say, you know, I teach at Columbia. One of the things we address in my class is stable coins. And I think the debate around stable coins is very confused. So I like to start with the definition, which is this. Stable coins are just a representation of a right and so a couple of important things fall out of that one i am excluding all of the things that are like securities tokens gold back tokens things like that they are tokenized assets but i would not call them stable coins because when people talk about stable coins they kind of mean what we think of in our heads is money and that is an important distinction two it really means the innovation of a stable coin is just taking what we already have and putting it on a blockchain so you're changing the ledger that has implications around like all the people who are saying like oh stable coins are a tremendous threat to the financial system is like wait wait wait wait if you're telling me taking our cash ledger and just changing the ledger technology somehow destroys the financial system like we are screwed right like that is incredibly fragile yeah okay exactly what you're telling me is actually the financial system is a threat to stable coins right Like the causality is backwards.
And so, by the way, that actually kind of was true with USDC, but we'll come back to that. So I would say there, it's important to understand what they are. So then the question that follows on from that is, okay, now have you done a good job? So craftsmanship is something that I focus on there and frameworks is something that I focus on there. So the whole debate around is BUSD a security is like, to me, a horrible misunderstanding of what's going on here, because by sort of the description the SEC has given, as I read it, I find it hard to draw a distinction between BUSD being a security versus PayPal being a security versus Starbucks gift cards being a security versus maybe your bank account being a security.
because the whole like, well, there's collective efforts between parties and they pay interest. And that's why it's a security is true of all of the things I just said. Right. And again, once you understand blockchain is not magic, it's just a ledger technology like while Starbucks gift cards are just a ledger technology for cash. So like, again, what's different here? So I think it's a really malformed and misguided argument that if it's true, I think actually one plaintiff's attorneys you guys throw a party for yourselves because there's going to be so much securities litigation going around you're all going to be very rich right but two it's going to cripple the u.
s financial system because now like starbucks gift cards have to trade out a registered securities exchange like what it's excuse me it is um it's a little bit silly and so i would say that's one part the second part though and this relates to your point about the stablecoin bill, is it also tells us we really, really badly need legislation around these things. If we put ourselves in a situation that because our regulators are all punching each other and can't decide on taxonomy, that nobody can really do stablecoins effectively in the United States, then let me tell you what's going to happen.
They'll just be outside the United States. We live in a world where the choice that faces our regulators in Congress is not, yes, stablecoins or no stablecoins. It's, yes, stablecoins or yes, but offshore. like the biggest winner in many ways of the drama over the past year in the stable coin space has been Tether. Why? Because they operate offshore. They don't have to deal with a lot of this nonsense. And so I would say my biggest takeaway here, and like looking at the McHenry bill, you know, McHenry waters, if we want to be specific, because the Democrats have had a lot of input there too. And I think that bipartisanship is great, is that we need that thing badly.
Because if we cripple the ability of the dollar to be money on blockchain, it's just to be another currency okay so the the idea of busd as a security for listeners out there who are trying to understand that and why that is happening is it fair to just categorize that in the world of gary gensler wants to overreach and grab as much jurisdictional power as possible and that's that i mean i think that's largely true there are ways you could do a stable coin where it's a security but one of the things about the whole like howie test that the sec tries to ignore is the expectation of profit part right and it's hard to see how you have an expectation of profit with a stable coin their argument is that because binance paid interest to people to put it on the platform oh now there's an expectation of profit so it's a security and my counter is that doesn't make busd a security it might make what binance is doing with its users an investment contract but that interest is not inherent to busd it's something binance chose to do on the platform right which is why i draw the analogy to starbucks gift cards like if they give me extra rewards for using that well there's a financial incentive for using the gift card how is that different than your busd argument and it that's why i said it's malformed i would also tell you i agree with powell who recently said we view stable coins as a form of money i think he's right i think this is a product for the banking regulators they know how to handle those kinds of things that's who deals with the money in the us and i think that's what mchenry waters does it gives regulatory authority to the banking regulators and basically says yo if you want to take a deposit and say it's worth a dollar we know how to do that there's banks there's trusts there's certain forms of secured assets you have to do it that way and that's actually correct right like it is very simple This is just money represented on a blockchain.
So don't go do all the janky pre-2008 stuff. Like, real talk for the crypto crowd. Nothing you're building in the stablecoin space is new. I've seen French quants blow almost all of this up and tradfi in the crisis, right? Like, none of this is new. Algo stablecoins, they're just self-referential equity notes, right? Like, crypto-backed stablecoins, that's called a securitization, right? Like, we've seen all of this before. or, hey, Tether, that's a prime money market fund, right? Like BUSD, that's a government money market fund. All of it. We've seen all of it. None of this is new. So I would say we've learned a lot of lessons there.
Just do the things that work, that are liquid, that scale, that don't break for users and call it a day. Like stop overcomplicating it. We've used the line on Bankless. We are speed running the history of money and finance in the crypto industry. And there's too many people in the crypto world who are, I'll say like me in the sense that I came into the world of money and finance through crypto. And I'm like, algorithmics. I was never like this, but some people were algorithmic stable coins. We can make alchemy like we this is brand new, new paradigm, blah, blah, blah, blah. And then there's people who are familiar with the trad world and can pattern match to experiments that have already come and gone in decades of old.
Man, that's that's a funny thing to think about. the stablecoin McHenry bill, what should listeners know about that bill? What's significant about that? Yeah. So I testified at the House Financial Services hearing on that bill for full transparency. So I've talked with some of the congressional staff about it. I've read that thing. I would say here's your key takeaways at a high level. One, it basically says the only thing you're allowed to call stablecoins are fiat-backed stablecoins with very clean reserves. I also think again that is correct right like the reality is something like algo stable coin something like the crypto backed things they're cool they're financial experiments i think they should be allowed to exist but you should not be able to represent safety and soundness because it's a financial experiment so i don't have a problem with die or lusd existing i have a problem with them being called a stable coin like it is guaranteed they will hold the one-to-one peg i think it's about the brand of the dollar is what's at stake here and so i think what the Bill is saying is that if you are going to be to accept the brand of the dollar, call yourself a stable coin, then you better be real close to actual dollars.
And so I think that's what you mean by clean is that like there's something dollar like backing it. Yeah, it's also a consumer safety thing. Like if you're going to imply that you are safe and stable, you need to actually be that thing. And personal opinion, stable coin issuers should have liability. If they break the peg, they should owe the users the money, right? So if you want to call yourself a stable coin, it should come with all of the consumer protection bells and whistles that come with guaranteed financial products in the United States, right? Like you should not be able to say it's stable, your money is there, and then it breaks the peg and you walk away being like, lol, JK, it was just an experiment, right?
So like, I'm not cool with that behavior. You want to rep that, you got to back it up. And so the bill basically says that, like, you need to hold T-bills, certain forms of like repo, they probably need to expand and fix that a little for financial reasons, but that's super technical jargon. And then the other part is basically saying you need to be licensed to do it, right? Which is to say there needs to be oversight. There needs to be a regulatory framework. No, just trust me, it's fine. I'm not going to disclose things. Like, no, you basically, you need to operate like a money market fund or a bank and disclose everything.
And I think, again, that's correct, right? If you're going to tell people, I'm going to take your money. It's worth a dollar. Trust me, it'll be there. You should have to prove it. It's not just like, hey, I'm sitting in some non-extradition jurisdiction with your money, and then I'll just run away if things go wrong. That's how you get more of this three arrows nonsense. What does this bill mean for assets like LUSD or DAI or FRAX, like all of the decentralized stablecoins? Because it kind of puts a line in the sand between stablecoins. is the only way that I think people could actually get the labeling of a stable coin under this bill are like the centralized fiat backed ones.
But where does this leave all the decentralized ones that need to have more exotic assets as collateral, the assets like DAI, LUSD, FRAX? How do we think about what this means for decentralized stables? So in the current bill, there's a prohibition on things like algos, which by the way, I think is overdone. I've told them, I think you should just take that out and focus on the consumer representations. I would say the main impact is just those things can continue to exist. They just need to stop calling themselves stable coins and people offering them and using them like on exchanges for payments, et cetera.
Can't use those and call them stable, right? It's not to say you can't buy DAI or that DAI can't exist. It's just that MakerDAO probably needs to stop representing that it's going to be worth $1 at all times, right? They should probably be saying, will try to keep it at a dollar, but this is experimental and there are ways it could break. So maybe not. But MakerDAO is a DAO of all DAOs that are out there. And there's a lot of decentralization theater that's out there. MakerDAO is further down along the spectrum of actually decentralized than most DAOs. I mean, we can talk about where exactly on the spectrum it is all day, but at least the point of MakerDAO is to be meaningfully decentralized.
And it is actually achieving some of that if not a majority again we can debate that but so like great so we can't have these non-fiat backed stable coins call themselves stable coins but i as an individual and many others like me out there in the crypto world will just call die a stable coin and that is just a brand that we will associate it with and we are not maker dow we are just the public so how does this all work this is all seemingly kind of messy no i mean that's fine right like if you and five of your friends like let's say we get to the other like david dow right we get all people named david in the world we put them in a dow and you guys actually there shout out to dave down 115 days that are in a telegram on uh shout out if you want to if you're named dave listen to this hit me up there you go there you go free marketing um but like if you guys get together and want to use watermelons as a medium of exchange you can do that privately right like in a peer-to-peer way you want to trade a watermelon for a chair you want to trade it for a microphone like whatever have fun guys i'm saying it's much more of an issue when regulated financial entities with legal obligations do that so can jp morgan right say hey we're replacing the dollars in your bank account with water balance no right so to me that distinction doesn't really matter on twitter it doesn't matter and people like talking about things is like them it matters as people offering financial services in a regulated way because those people get special blessings and special status and can do things within the U.
S. system that other people cannot. And along with that comes a lot of restrictions, right? Like Dave Dow with the watermelon currency is not getting a Fed master account, right? But a stable coin bank under the McHenry Waters legislation might. And so I'm saying if you want to be within the regulated perimeter and get the special privileges, obligations should come along with that. I think the obligations of the bill, honestly, are pretty fair. Okay. So if there's all of the orgs that are out there that are designed to be decentralized and don't ever care to get a regulatory license, well, then they just won't care.
Yeah. And as long as they're not lying about it, that's the point I also say. You and I can't just set up an LLC, grab an office space somewhere and call ourselves a bank. That is actually a crime, right? You're committing financial fraud. You need a bank charter and capital if you're going to do that. So to me, again, this is where it comes back to decentralization theater and like how you represent things and what people are doing, where if you're just being honest about this, hey, it's like a decentralized thing. It's kind of experimental. We think it'll work, but guys, it might break. That to me feels okay.
That's honest. It's when you're going around being like, no, it is a stable coin. It's worth a dollar, right? And being kind of absolutist about it, making false representations of safety and implying you have all the bells and whistles. that's where i have a problem awesome this conversation and conversation has been immensely helpful we've talked about blackrock we talked about the separation of exchange and custody with edx talked about stable coins is there anything any rock any stone that we've left unturned that we should definitely talk about before we conclude things here yeah so i would say we talk about stable coins in the us but again i would zoom out on that one so in traditional markets there's a thing called the euro dollar market which is basically dollars that trade offshore Technically, Tether kind of exists in the euro-dollar market as a stablecoin.
I would just point out there are other countries working hard on this problem. So shout out to the MAS in Singapore. I think they've been very constructive. Hong Kong is now moving forward. Again, to reference Japan, whose regulator has done a great job, the JFSA has a complete framework for stablecoins in Japan. And now Mika has one for stablecoins in Europe. So a point I would make to everybody is the action is moving international very quickly. you're going to start seeing stable coins in bigger and better forms that are non-US dollar and offshore US dollars. So expect the space to move pretty quickly, even when we zoom out from the US.
Awesome. This has been a fantastic conversation. I've enjoyed this quite a lot. I've learned quite a lot. If people are looking to follow you on Twitter, where should they go? Or is there any other place that we should point them to if they want to keep on learning about what you've been talking about and who you are, et cetera? Yeah, I would say I'm at Campbell J. Austin on Twitter. You can find me out there and all of the other stuff I do ultimately you're going to get to through Twitter. So that's probably the easiest place to find me. Awesome. And Dave in the Zoom chat has reminded me that those are already in the show notes because he is an absolute Chad on the Bankless backend.
So thanks. Shout out to Dave for that one. Also in Dave Dow. Austin, thank you so much for guiding us through this conversation. I've learned quite a lot. Yeah, absolutely. Thank you for having me. I really enjoyed it. Bankless Nation, you know the deal. ETH is risky. Bitcoin is risky. Bitcoin ETFs that are inevitably on the NASDAQ will also be risky. Crypto is risky at large. You can lose what you put in, but we are headed west. We are on the frontier. We are glad you are with us. I've already said that. We are on the frontier. It's not for everyone, but we are glad you're with us on the Bankless journey.
Thanks a lot. Thank you.