🚀 SUBSCRIBE TO NEWSLETTER: http://bankless.substack.com/ ✊ STARTING GUIDE BANKLESS: https://bit.ly/37Q17uI ❤️ JOIN PRIVATE DISCORD: https://bit.ly/2UVI10O 🎙️ SUBSCRIBE TO PODCAST: http://podcast.banklesshq.com/ 👕 BUY BANKLESS TEE: https://merch.banklesshq.com/
-----
GO BANKLESS WITH THESE SPONSOR TOOLS:
🌐 UNSTOPPABLE DOMAINS - HUMAN READABLE ETHEREUM & CRYPTO ADDRESSES https://bankless.cc/unstoppable
🌈 ZAPPER - ULTIMATE HUB FOR DEFI - ZAP INTO DEFI http://bankless.cc/zapper
💳 MONOLITH - GET THE HOLY GRAIL OF BANKLESS VISA CARDS https://bankless.cc/monolith
🤖YEARN - YIELD-SEEKING MONEY ROBOT THAT FARMS DEFI FOR YOU http://bankless.cc/yearn
------
35 - Designing Ethereum | Vitalik Buterin
With Ethereum 2.0 on the horizon, we bring Vitalik Buterin back onto the podcast to discuss the 'why' behind many of the design choices of Ethereum 2.0
Why Proof of Stake? Why Sharding?
We also go over what has been discovered and added between the 2015 launch of Ethereum 1.x, and where we are now, such as - EIP1559 - Rollups as well as Vitaliks view of a 'rollup centric Ethereum'
We also discuss the process going getting Ethereum 1 onboarded into Ethereum 2.0, as well as a rollup-round where we ask some quick questions!
'Rollup Centric Ethereum' blog post: https://ethereum-magicians.org/t/a-rollup-centric-ethereum-roadmap/4698
Get ready for Staking: https://bankless.substack.com/p/guide-becoming-a-validator-on-the History:
https://blog.ethereum.org/2014/01/15/slasher-a-punitive-proof-of-stake-algorithm/
https://vitalik.ca/general/2019/11/22/progress.html
https://blog.ethereum.org/2014/11/25/proof-stake-learned-love-weak-subjectivity/
https://vitalik.ca/general/2020/08/17/philosophy.html
------
Don't stop at the video!
Subscribe to the Bankless newsletter program http://bankless.substack.com/
Visit the official Bankless website for resources http://banklesshq.com/
Follow Bankless on Twitter https://twitter.com/BanklessHQ
Follow Ryan on Twitter https://twitter.com/ryansadams
Follow David on Twitter https://twitter.com/TrustlessState
Follow DeFi Dad on Twitter https://twitter.com/DeFi_Dad
-----
Not financial or tax advice. This channel is strictly educational and is not investment advice or a solicitation to buy or sell any assets or to make any financial decisions. This video is not tax advice. Talk to your accountant. Do your own research. Disclosure. From time-to-time we may add links in this channel to products we use. We may receive commission if you make a purchase through one of these links. We'll always disclose when this is the case.
No summary for this episode yet.
Welcome to Bankless, where we explore the frontier of internet money and internet finance. This is how to get started, how to get better, and how to front-run the opportunity. This is Ryan Sean Adams. I'm here with David Hoffman, and we're here to help you become more Bankless. David, how are you feeling after this episode? Absolutely stoked for the future of Ethereum, as I usually am. Ryan, when we started this podcast, the first 10 or so episodes was really about getting people onboarded into the Bankless world, into the world of crypto monies and protocols as financial institutions, and then DeFi blew up really hard really fast, and we had to answer for that.
There's a lot of excitement going on, but we never got to the topic of values as they are baked into the systems that we are using, specifically at the base layer of Ethereum itself. And this is what that episode was for. This episode is about learning, about the design choices of the Ethereum protocol, and how different values have been baked into how we have chosen to build Ethereum and how we have chosen to build Ethereum into the future. Yeah, if you're looking to understand what Ethereum is and what its future roadmap is, this is the episode for you. I hope this becomes kind of a canonical episode for anyone who wants to learn about Ethereum, and who better to explain it than Vitalik.
He has fantastic explanations, sometimes they go into some technical detail, but hang with that, and you'll get a perfect picture as to what the value system is for Ethereum and how it's going to shape up in the coming years. You know, one thing I was struck by, David, is we call it ETH 2.0, this whole new initiative like the next phase, the phases of the Ethereum roadmap. But there's really no Ethereum 2.0, it's all one Ethereum network, it's all one Ethereum value system and social contract, and the thing that we call ETH 1 and ETH 2 will eventually merge anyway, and I saw that very clearly as we talked to Vitalik, that was going to happen.
Ethereum, there's one community, there's one set of value systems that we all kind of abide by, and it's just really exciting to see that level of unity. Yeah, I really like that framing. There's one collective of the Ethereum hive mind, right? And the blockchain is just one component of that. The off-chain component are people like you and me, the listeners of this podcast, people that discuss and communicate values around, sort of as this super layer upon what we all perceive Ethereum to be, which right now is Ethereum 1.x, and then also is about to be phase 0 of Ethereum, which as you alluded to, we'll start off as a testnet and then slowly kind of roll into actually being real life Ethereum.
So that's a good point. There isn't one canonical version of Ethereum, there's just the values that we have and the code that we use to express it. You know, David, I'm really proud of something too. At one point, we ask the question of Vitalik, like, hey, who decides what our values are as Ethereum? Like, we keep using this term our values, but how do we know what our values even are? And you know, I'm really excited that the bankless nation has been part of that structuring of value systems, right? I think the bankless nation, our value systems are very clear. We want self-sovereign money. We want to remove intermediaries.
We want to remove the bankers that control your life. And we are part of the value system. We determine partially the values of a system like Ethereum. It's just one big social contract and one conversation and bankless absolutely plays a role there. So thank you listeners for keeping these values close to your heart, communicating them, spreading the word, spreading the message that what we want and what we need is a decentralized money system for the people by the people. This is our longest podcast yet it goes on for almost two hours. And that's because we really take our time going through every single facet of Ethereum, proof of stake, sharding, EIP1559, roll ups, the transition.
And then we also do a fun roll ups round at the end where we ask Vitalik some quick questions. So use this episode as a tool to reference. It's long because it is dense. There should be something in here for everyone. So I hope you guys enjoy this episode. All right David, before we jump into the episode, let's talk for a minute about our fantastic sponsors. One of the tools I've started to use recently is zapper. For those of you that were part of the 2017 bull market, it was characterized by just opening up block folio and refreshing it over and over and over again. And also anytime you ever made a trade, you would have to go into block folio and manually input that trade information to make sure that your portfolio that you think that you have matches what you actually have.
Just zapper, you don't have to do any of that anymore because all you have to do is zapper is input your Ethereum addresses. And then zapper will give you a really elegant report as to where all your money is. So there will never ever be any disconnect between the money that you think that you have and the money that zapper reports to you. Zapper looks directly on chain and gives you a nice portfolio summary of all your assets and how many assets and all of your debt and all of your lending positions, all of your positions all at once. So there's no more editing your portfolio because zapper just does it for you.
One thing that I thought was really useful about zapper was when I plugged my wallet in, I found that I had submitted liquidity to uniswap forever ago and without zapper, I would have probably lost that forever because zapper knows where your money is better than you do. It's also the gateway to investing your money into this ever expanding list of available defi platforms like curve, balancer, uniswap, urn. In the bankless nation, there is this growing number of money legos and keeping track of them all is just super overwhelming, which is why you can just go to zapper and zapper will solve the problem of there just being too many money legos to choose from.
So check them out at zapper.fi, enter your Ethereum addresses and check out your portfolio and see if there's anything that you missed. Bankless Nation. Do you want to go fully bankless but in the real world, monolith is the defi account that you need. It wraps your eth address in a bankless visa card and it does so much more. It closes the loop from fiat to defi. So you can onboard fiat to die on monolith with zero fees. Then you can convert that die to a die, which is an interest bearing savings account. Again, zero fees and then you can spend that interest in the real world on a visa card.
So you can finally buy your cup of coffee with interest earned in defi guys. This is magic. This is the closest thing to the holy grail crypto card and monolith gives you all of it. You need to download the app at monolith.xyz to get your bankless visa card. It's optimized for European listeners. They'll be coming to the US soon. And when you get that visa card, the monolith card, tweet about it when you do. I love seeing people unpackaging their beautiful, bankless visa cards makes me realize that the revolution is here, search monolith in the app store. Okay, let's get to the episode with Vitalik.
We want to welcome back Vitalik Buterin who is the founder of Ethereum, a researcher at the Ethereum Foundation. Of course, he needs no introduction to the bankless nation. He's been here before. I'm sure you know of his work. We brought him here to talk about the why of ETH, too, though. We want to dig deep into the design decisions that were made and also the values that were embedded in Ethereum 2.0. It is coming up fast and why we care about these values. Vitalik, it's great to have you. Welcome to bankless. Thank you very much, Ryan. It's going to be here again. All right. Well, I'm going to start with this.
Skeptics have been saying ETH 2 will never ship for a very long time about as long as I've been in this space before that they were probably saying ETH 1 wouldn't ship. I think they're wrong, but my question is a little bit different. Is Ethereum 2 going to ship as advertised? I think so. I think ETH 2 and so, first of all, Phase 0 is, Intest that has been to Intest for a while is very close to being released and Phase 0 offers everything that Phase 0 was always stated that it would provide. It's got the proof of stake, it's a chain, it's running, you can use it. And then Phase 1 provides shorting, and shorting is going to be there as advertised.
And then scalability from applications, and you just combine together the shorting with a roll-up, and I know we've got 100,000 TPS, which is, I think, almost exactly the same as among the crazier of the numbers that I've thrown around during the good old days around. So, both end to mining and that introduction to a stake-based consensus, and ultra-high scalability are both going to be within the hands of Ethereum users, I think, much sooner than a lot of people think. So we want to zoom out and have this be sort of a canonical, like, what is ETH 2 episode and why? So I want to zoom out and talk about this question.
What political values is Ethereum going for in ETH 2? And how did that really constrain the design space for ETH 2 architecture? There's two ways to look at what ETH 2 is trying to accomplish. One is to look at what it's trying to add that ETH 1 doesn't have and why. And then, number two is what is ETH 2 unwilling to give up in order to achieve that, right? So from the first point of view, so what is ETH 2 trying to achieve that ETH 1 does not have? The two major parts to this are one is a proof of stake and the other is shorting. I mean, proof of stake is a fairly kind of philosophically complex thing that does combine together multiple objectives.
One of the really important ones, I think, is just moving away from the extreme levels of waste and energy and inefficiency that you can find in proven work systems, also trying to move away from some of the centralization risks that we've been seeing in both Ethereum and even more so in Bitcoin with its kind of much more mature ASIC ecosystem. And also, a proof of stake tries to be kind of maximally democratic and open to participate and not just as a user, but also as a staker, right? ETH 2 is a scalability solution and so the goal is to try to just increase the number of transactions that the Ethereum blockchain can handle from the status quo, which is about 15 if we're talking about actual transactions that are on average that people send or 45 if we just assume everyone only cares about sending ETH transfers up to some number between 1,000 and 100,000 depending on which phase you're talking about and what kind of application it is.
And increasing scalability is valuable because we believe in Ethereum as being this kind of publicly accessible, open, global architecture that people should be able to interact with without end of doing so with through centralized intermediate areas, right? We believe that the base layers of the new internet should be an open thing that is expected for regular people to be able to participate in. And if you don't do scalability, then the alternative is to basically take some approach where you have some master network, but only fairly powerful institutional actors participate in, and then you start having trusted sidechains and most people would live in trusted sidechains.
And that's not really the kind of world that I want to be building, just basically because I think if intermediation becomes the norm, there's a lot of just historical examples of how institutionalized intermediation can very easily be kind of seized and that's turned into a tool of control by people that the original creators of those systems were absolutely not expecting. So that's why you're kind of increasing TBS is valuable. And then the next question is what properties are we not willing to sacrifice? So one of the properties that we really care about in ETH 2, and I think perhaps there's a level of insistence on this, maybe makes Ethereum stand out a little relative to some of the other chains.
Is this principle that we do not want to have super node dependence, right? Like we want Ethereum to be a system that can run and up fully operate without relying on some super powerful computer, like we want the system to, if need be able to operate entirely just as a collection of consumer laptops. This is something that at least I personally have strived to stick to very closely because I do believe in a lot of the big pointer ideas around big things like if you let the chain and just be in a control by a small number of institutions, then you're creating a small number of actors that could potentially take it over and start in a fulling it on a favorable directions.
I want to even encourage a kind of culture of active participation in kind of proof of stake by regular users, for example. And that's something that if you take one of these paths that just say, oh, let's rely on super nodes that you just can't do. Like if you have a chain that relies on super nodes, that's a lot of these other blockchains are doing. So where you just rely on every node in the network to have a very powerful computer, then you're going to have a relatively small number of participants. And if a large portion of those participants come together and say, you know, start next month, starting from then, we are going to just start enforcing different rules.
And if you don't like it's for you, there is kind of much less of an sort of institutional barrier against doing that sort of thing because there's a much smaller number of participants that would need to collude and there's a much smaller number of people whose nodes would just kind of break by default if that happens. So decentralization is in a very significant part about avoiding those kinds of situations. So that's why we've been uncomfortable with super node assumptions, also uncomfortable with honest majority assumptions. This is one of those things that I think of unites some Ethereum philosophy and a lot of Bitcoin philosophy.
Right? Like Bitcoin philosophy is all about you validate the chain yourself because otherwise you're just trusting the minor majority and the minor majority is not necessarily that friendly. And it too is also increasingly designed to offer strong enough robustness and security guarantees even in the face of a dishonest majority. So I guess to kind of wrap up and summarize things again, I would say number one, just energy efficiency, not being an environmental catastrophe and all of those nice things. Number two, making it possible for regular people to directly participate in the blockchain as a writer to the blockchain by which a miniature transaction sender.
Number three, making it possible for regular people to participate in the blockchain as a reader of the blockchain as a director reading of the blockchain without relying on any kind of trusted APIs and number four, making it possible for regular people to participate in the blockchain as a kind of participant in the consensus. And if you take two, three and four part together, then you can get a very high level of censorship resistance, second of robustness, resistance to social and political attacks, even at a very large scale. So, you mentioned, you know, I guess a couple of words I would use to summarize some of that is permissionless, decentralized, you know, non-neutral.
Those are important values kind of embedded in the design. What type of constraints, I guess, did you have? Like it's trickier to design a system that embodies those values and it's easier to take shortcuts. I get some of the question that some of the eith killers and other alternative layer one chains are sort of asking is, well, do people really care about these things with talent? Is it fine just to have, you know, maybe a little bit of decentralization? Like, why did Ethereum choose to be at one end of the spectrum in the way that it did? Right. I think trying to take a more centralized path is the sort of thing that works well in the short term, but it ends up really biting you in the long term.
So, I mean, we have seen real live examples of an decentralization vectors of chains being used to do things that are very, and have disapproved of by their users, right? And I think a lot of the most egregious examples we can see in the context of some of the DPLS chains. So one example of this being how a steam got taken over by Justin Sun, who then proceeded to, kind of, establish and cement control over the delegates, and one of those I user assessed, started to rebel the Justin and the people here was colluding with, just ended up doing a lot of just increasingly authoritarian things on the chain until eventually the users ended up having to fork away.
And in the context of EOS, for example, we've seen a lot of, kind of, bribing attacks between different delegates. So I think core participants of a blockchain ecosystem becoming unfriendly and colluding against their users' interests is something that is not just theoretical, it's something of which we have seen in very real examples. And there's very real things that kind of people potentially might want to do, right? People might want to push the rule with some unpopular kind of hard fork where they and just give themselves coins, for example, right? Like that kind of political and of arguments and demabulation around things like developer funds is something that we have seen.
So I think, absolutely, even just from the evidence that we can see here today, there is a lot of signs that show that creating a blockchain where all you're doing is just creating a kind of voting scheme between, you know, somewhere between 10 and 50 fairly large actors. Actually, in the long run is potentially a pretty dangerous thing. So you do think in a nutshell that users in the long run will very much value these characteristics of permissionlessness, decentralization and neutrality? Absolutely. I think these, the importance of these characteristics, I think, sometimes takes time to reveal itself because make this this phenomenon that when a kind of community is harmonious and when times are good, and if all governance mechanisms tends to give the same result and it's a good one, right?
So, you know, regardless of whether you have a market or a democracy or a dictatorship or whatever else, when kind of times are happy and people are roughly on the same page, then, you know, just all of these mechanisms are just going to lead to and if the same thing because everyone knows what everyone is going for and, you know, there just is one result no matter what path you take and it's a fairly happy one. But it's, so when there are disagreements and disputes that you start to see a lot of these differences emerge, right? And when there are disagreements and disputes, which is something that is going to happen to every chain eventually, then the differences between, you know, truly decentralized systems like Bitcoin and Ethereum and things like these much more centralized chains are just is going to reveal itself very strongly and a lot of people are going to potentially get nasty surprises.
Are you seeing any other chains that embrace these values besides like a Bitcoin or an Ethereum? There are some, so like one example of this, like CODA or and it renamed itself, I think, because of some stupid trademark thing, they are trying to create a blockchain that's just fully a ZK approval, so the idea would be that instead of having to personally verify the chain, you would be able to just use one ZK snark to kind of fully verify the validity of the thing. And I think that kind of approach is fully in line with those principles because it basically means that no matter how much activity is happening, there is no way to sneak and invalid chain through because while you can't generate a fake proof, I mean, Mimbo Rumble is another example of this and there's a lot of kind of smaller chains in the kind of Bitcoin course expanded universe, so to speak, that are trying to implement these values to various extents.
And then in the case of Ethereum, I mean, I think Ethereum Classic is also one chain that values these things, though they're taking an even more purest approach to them, not doing sharding, for example, a series we're considering reducing both numbers and so forth. So it definitely gives a niche that some projects are going towards, though I think the number of projects that try to access this niche, that the market can sustain is much smaller than the number of, kind of quote unquote, feature projects that the market can support. And basically because if you make a feature project, there's lots of different features that you can go after, but if you kind of embrace neutrality and you embrace user sovereignty and embrace freedom, then there's like a much more limited number of ways in which that can happen.
So I do expect that the number of more decentralization focused chains is going in small, but I think the chains they can take the path and they can stick to it are going to be very successful. Backing up, Vitalik, we have these principles that we've just gone over. We need a blockchain to be adequately decentralized for obvious reasons or else there any centralization is a vector for attack. We also need a blockchain to be scalable because if it can't be scalable, then as you alluded to, that leaves room for a new form of centralization to come in, usually through some form of intermediary. And you know, back in 2015, when Ethereum 1.
0 was world out, we had, the social contractor on Ethereum had picked out some long term solutions to, you know, changing Ethereum from what it was about to be in, to what it wanted to be in the long term, mainly proof of stake and charting. And if, you know, correct me if I'm wrong, but I think proof of stake and charting were kind of more or less chosen as strategies for improving Ethereum even before Ethereum 1.0 was world out. How did we have such strong assurances that these were the right solutions at the time? So I definitely think that, you know, a large portion of the community considered proof of stake and charting to be part of the social contract from all the way back in 2015 or potentially even earlier.
So DALFORC might have been the moments that I've cemented those things because a lot of the people that really seriously opposed that proof of stake and charting ended up also really seriously opposing the DALFORC and so they ended up going to the ETC side. And as for why we are sure, I think one thing that's important to note is that it took a while for us to be sure, right, like if you go back to the very first proof of stake or weighted blog post that I made, this is the blog post that's introducing slasher. Then you read what that blog post says, and you see a disclaimer right at the top.
The purpose of this post is not to say that Ethereum will be using slasher in place of de-agre as its main mining function, rather, slasher is a useful construct to have in our war chest in case we were state mining, becomes substantially more popular or compelling reason is provided to switch. Slasher may also benefit other currencies of which there exists independently of Ethereum, thanks to taco time perspiration and for Jack Walker for improvement suggestions. So if you go back to January 2014, we're absolutely not certain that proof of stake does not have fundamental flaws in it, right? And if you look at the posts that we had a trying to figure out charting, the charting was described as an unsolved problem and was described in a list of unsolved problems along with other problems that we recognize today are either unsolvable or unsolvable without very fundamental trade-offs.
So the post I'm thinking about here was born from 2014, the goose called something like hard problems in cryptocurrency. So this was early 2014, then all the way throughout 2014, the big philosophical expedition that we went on is trying to figure out basically whether or not proof of stake can get around the nothing at stake problem. And eventually we came to this conclusion that I expressed in my blog post called the How I Learned the Love Week subjectivity and basically said, no, it's not possible with proof of stake to get exactly the same properties as a proof of work, but it's possible to get something that's reasonably close and here are some strong arguments for why I think it's close enough, right?
And so that was probably the first major step and then the second major step was around in 2016 to 2017 when we had really wrapped our heads around how the other major class of a consensus mechanism, a sort of academic, you know, we import d, d, d, d, d, d, d, d, d, vocal and stuff, my or pbft style. Um, the. The ability to set the salaryось or something and really, you kind of deeply understood it like basically how they actually work and I have how they fit into a proof of stake security model and a proofstaker context. So I think after those two discoveries together, a proof of stake was, kind of basically and the other question was just discussing the details.
And on the sharding side, it was largely a question of what security models that we were comfortable with. So around 2015 or so, when we started thinking about random sampling, which was the first step major and of breakthrough to where making sharding work. And then in 2017, there was that major breakthrough of IDF availability proofs that allows the sharding blockchains to be secure even in a dishonest majority, so yeah, contacts. So even in the context of 51% attack, an attacker can't force an invalid chain through. So after those discoveries, I think we were pretty set that sharding is a reasonable strategy.
And at that point, and I think people were broadly comfortable with both of those major pieces that kind of things kept proceeding from there. So if you could put yourself in your own shoes of your 2015 version, and in July 2015, the Ethereum blockchain rolls out, at that time, how far away did you think that proof of stake was going to be? I think we were definitely expecting something like one to one and a half years, which has, of course, proved to be wildly over optimistic as a lot of timing things ended up approving to be wildly over optimistic in all parts of the crypto space, whether it's things in Ethereum or things in the Lightning Network or things in some of the quote Ethereum killer projects.
But I think in 2015, we were definitely kind of confident that we will arrive at a proof of stake system and be able to implement it. And also at that time, I do want to hang on proof of stake for very a little bit more, but also at that time, when the Ethereum blockchain was just rolling out, what was the sort of consensus around the monetary policy of ether or the issuance schedule? Or was this even like a big sub-grad at the time? It was. And the conclusions that we had then are actually quite different from the conclusions that we have now. So if you go back and read the Ethereum white paper, there's an improvised issuance schedule that basically says that there would be about 16 million ether that gets issued every year.
And this issuance would continue forever. And the rationale was for this was, one, there is a belief that you need ongoing issuance for security. There was definitely no certainty that proof of stake could come in and offer security at a much lower cost than proof of work. We were assuming proof of work forever. And the reason there was this fairness argument that said that we want it to be accessible to people who exist in the future and not just people who exist in the present. So those were of the major arguments that we had at the time. And since then, obviously, both of the Ethereum community, and I think a lot of us have come around to this issuance minimalist or minimal viable issuance, I guess, as the frame philosophy.
And we've come around to proof of stake and we've come around to issuance reductions. And I think a couple of things happened there. So one of the things that happened there is just us becoming convinced that proof of stake was feasible and proof of stake was necessary. But another thing that happened was the dream of proof of work being an egalitarian distribution model just like slowly kind of suffocated and died over the last few years, I guess. Like in 2010 to 2013, proof of work was this very democratic thing, where one of the selling features of Bitcoin is that you, yes, you can go turn on your computer and you can get a few units and compare with how a fiat currency works where to issue it, you need to be a large commercial or central bank here.
Anyone on their own computer can make some Bitcoin. And I think this was a major appeal of proof of work. It was a major appeal of Bitcoin. But the reality is that that was never a long-term technologically stable equilibrium because as soon as you have a large source of revenue, eventually people specialize and people optimize their way to get added before everyone else does. And in Bitcoin, we saw the GPU revolution then right after that, the FPGA revolution then right after that, the ASIC revolution. And in the case of Ethereum, we deliberately designed the proof of work algorithm to be ASIC resistant with the goal of preserving the egalitarianism of Ethereum mining basically.
But then over time, we saw both how even a GPU-based system can become more and more resource-intem money to end it over time. And also just growing risks that ETH hash itself would get ASIC at some point. And so we just recognized that if this dream of being a egalitarian by being a network system was something that was just not feasible on regardless. It's a benefit that was no longer there. And so without that benefit, then the question is, well, do you issue ETH to a class of existing rich people or do you issue less ETH or try to not issue ETH at all? And so the second started working more attractive.
The assumption being made is that any proof of work system ultimately moves towards ASICs no matter what, right? And I think this is pretty much a true assumption that any proof of work system, if there's value there, there is therefore the incentive to design such a computer that is harder and harder to be accessed by retail, right? And this is why Ethereum chose GPU mining as a starting point, right? Because GPUs you can buy in your local consumer hardware store, a lot of people already own them in their gaming computer. And as a function of decentralization, if you can validate the blockchain on GPUs, there are more possible people that can validate the blockchain.
But the worry here was that, especially with Ether issuance, the worry was that people, specialists, we're going to come in and turn this into a business that would outcompete individuals, right? And if we are continuing to issue Ether at a rate, which also the goal of issuing Ether was to also get Ether into the hands of many people through distribution, through issuance. But the concern was that the Ether being issued was just only going to go to the people that had specialized in mining. And would you say that this is a persistent critique of mining regardless of the blockchain or is this specific to Ethereum?
I think it's a critique of mining regardless of the blockchain. I think Bitcoin mining is basically plutocratic already for Ethereum mining realistically, it's only a matter of time. And were there not this dangling threat of moving to either product power, some other algorithm, or just an accelerating proof of stake, then it may well have been a sect much more strongly already. And I think any algorithm that tries to be a basic resistant, unfortunately, only has some shelf life within which that ticketing used to be true. So at this time, this decision was being made, was it clear that proof of stake would actually enable the reduction of eth issuance by being able to provide more or equal levels of security with less issuance of Ether?
When we released the white paper as part of the sale, we definitely knew that proof of stake was something we were very interested in and it handles the possibility. But we were definitely not confident enough in the eventual possibility of proof of stake to market it as a certainty, which is a big part of why we made the decision to advertise the EF at the time as something that would have an issuance of a 16 million tokens a year forever. One of the really good things that I like about how Ethereum has rolled out is, as a proof of stake system, is that it started as a proof of work system, specifically started as a GPU mining system.
Like GPU miners to this day are still viable. And as a system for distributing Ether, I think this has been really good. It's been a great way to like, you know, sprinkler around a bunch of Ether around the world to people that are running GPUs, right? It's good for Ether distribution, which is important for decentralization, especially in proof of stake, because the distribution of Ether is a centralization vector that we have to pay attention to. But it seems that in proof of stake Ethereum, we have sacrificed this wonderful feature of Ether distribution in the name of, you know, securing proof of stake.
Would you like to see a way for, you know, a different way for further Ether distribution, or are you relatively satisfied with how distributed it is today? I think the challenge with cryptocurrency distribution mechanisms is that coming up with mechanisms that are credibly neutral is hard. Right, but the thing with proof of work that's a nice is that it's an algorithm, and so it's a credibly neutral because, well, people know what the algorithm is, like anyone can verify that someone made a valid solution. Whereas if you were to try some other alternative, like for example, one thing that Ripple did was they just had a bunch of giveaways through, you know, social media channels, and other kind of weak identity channels.
And the problem varies, well, you know, do you know, is that actually, did they actually do it honestly? Did they cheat in some way? Did some hacker write 10,000 accounts cheat in some way? Were they being fair by using these platforms and forgetting about the Chinese platforms, or were they the Indian platforms? And, you know, if you tried to basically get to some kind of a per person based issuance, you just start running into all these quagmires so that you really don't want to see a base layer blockchain and necessarily getting involved in. Whereas the proof of work issuance is much more neutral, I mean, proofs take issuance is much more neutral as well, though it's not really a, and if distribution mechanism because proof of stake just distributes to existing holders, so it's a good strategy for paying holders to do things like helping secure the network, but you know, it's not gonna make the currency more widely distributed in any way.
So the lack of a credible neutral distribution mechanism other than proof of work in proof of stake as one of the challenges. And then the other challenge is that any new components to the distribution is just bound to be a controversial and potentially difficult to get accepted, right? So between those two challenges, I think it definitely is difficult to add a new issuance components, but we'll see. One critique I often hear of proof of stake is that it locks people into a certain extent, right? Like if you are a staker, you know, at genesis of proof of stake, you can be a staker for the rest of time.
In start contrast, if you are a Bitcoin miner, you always have to be, you know, keeping up to date with technology, keeping up to date with efficiency, always updating your system and improving over time. And if you don't do that, then you get wiped out by other miners who do do this, right? So stakers are locked in forever. And Bitcoiners don't really like that because it kind of seems similar to the cantalana effect where maybe the stakers are closer to the issuance of new ether than the rest of the rest of the world. And so they have, you know, undue access to the issuance of new ether. And, you know, if you are a staker today, you can be a staker, you know, in 50, 100, maybe a thousand years.
And so like there isn't really this churn of new sets of stakers that are able to come in without, you know, having to purchase a bunch of ether. Is this bad? So, I do think that there is something to that critique, like I definitely don't think that proof of stake is, you know, 100% better than proof of work in every way. Like I think it's maybe, you know, 80 to 85 or 90% better. And this is one of those areas where proof of work does have a kind of genuine advantage in terms of reducing the possibility of long-term capture. The things that I would say in response to that, though, is, so one, the proof of work industry right now, is fairly young.
So of course, it's going to see disruption so once every year or a couple of years. But, you know, there's no evidence that immature proof of work industry is going to continue having the same properties. In fact, one of the things that Bitcoin people talk about in the long run is this concept of a thermo-dynamic limit that there is this cap of basically a minimum cost of generating a valid hash solution. And once miners start getting close to this cap, then well, you know, it's physically impossible to get even more efficient than that, right? So what do you do? Right, so even in the medium term, there's definitely a possibility that the industry of generating this hardware is going to also find more.
So that's critique number one. Critique number two is that even though proof of stake and being a staker is kind of quote, being close to the faucet of a new money, it's also something that's open for any youth holder to participate in, right? So if you have 32, if you can go and stake it, if you have less than 32, if you can go join some others and start staking through a pool, whereas in a proof of work context, like unless you have tens or hundreds of million dollars to start creating an ASIC farm, you can't kind of get at this tap yourself. So that's probably the second thing. So, you know, isn't that a much of a world concentration risk if anyone can never participate?
Number three is that rewards in proof of stake are much lower in an absolute sense. Right, like we're talking about maybe 50% if only 1% of youth holders are participating, but then if more people start participating, then it starts going down to 5%, 3%, 2%. And so the rate at which kind of wealth grows if everyone starts staking is much smaller than the kinds of income that you could potentially get as a proof of work participant. And so I guess to summarize, there is definitely this genuine advantage of proof of work having this in a built-in churn property, but at the same time, you know, the fact that this churn is high today is absolutely not evidence of that it's going to continue to be high tomorrow.
And number two is that in proof of stake, just getting in and becoming part of this set of value is yourself is much easier and more accessible. And number three, it just matters much less because the revenue of a being a staker is much lower than the revenue of a being a minor. And then number four, a really important thing is like, well, you know, if someone does end up just like sitting there for a long time and eventually getting to more than 51% of all the hash valor, all the stake, what can they do about it? And proof of stake opens much more recourse for a community to recover from a 51% attack than proof of work does.
And this is I think another one of those important topics that's a advantage of proof of stake that I think a lot of people don't appreciate, which is that in a proof of work system, if 51% of the line is attack, what can you do, right? You just let the attack happen. Maybe you will kind of soft fork it out. Well, if you soft fork it out, okay, fine. The attack we can just attack the chain again, right? Then we can attack the chain again. And again, I call this a spawn camp attack. That's the terminology that I used a reference to a spawn camp in here. And I know where we're grafted, so forth.
But we just keep attacking the chain. You just keep making it dead. And the only way to recover from a spawn camp attack is to change the proof of work algorithm, right? But then if you change the proof of work algorithm, one problem is that you're not just breaking the attacker's minors, you're also breaking all of the good guys minors. So it's a more, and it's expensive and higher collateral damage strategy. And the second problem is that you can only change the proof of work algorithm once, right? Because if you change it once, then nobody's gonna have an ASIC for the U algorithm. And then if the attacker manages to also corner the market on CPUs or GPUs, then they can spawn camp a second time.
In the second time, you can't break out at all, right? So in proof of work, recovery from persistent 51% attacks is actually kind of bleak. In a proof of stake contacts, that's a very different story. And because if there's a 51% attack on a proof stake system, what you can do is you can have a fork. And in this fork, a minority coordinated user activated soft fork, that basically consists of the victims of the 51% attack getting together and continuing the original chain and ignoring the attacker box in that fork, you can just basically delete the attacker's coins. And you don't even need to have a explicit hard fork to delete the attacker's coins.
Like actually, the Ethereum protocol just like, does this by defaults because of how the inactivity leak works, right? Like a minority fork, whoever the majority is, just loses half of their ether to inactivity leaks before finality happens. And so every time there's a 51% attack, even if it succeeds, the attacker loses a lot of money. And if they want a 51% attack a second time, they have to lose a lot of money again. And so the economics are just incredibly unfavorable to an attacker in a way they just aren't in a proof of work context. So that's probably the fourth and kind of more underestimated rebuttal, which is that if someone does get a 51% attack, well, you know, so what?
Like if they end up doing anything bad with their powers, they just always run the risk of the community getting angry and just like forking them out and burning half their money. I feel like an example of some hidden social recovery that actually exists in a proof of stake system like Ethereum. And I think what you're saying is like something like Bitcoin is harder to recover socially from an attack like that. I'm kind of struck by some of the language reviews we've all used to far, right? When we talk about, you know, some of the things have changed. You were talking about issuance earlier where you thought originally, you know, and people in Ethereum thought originally that we would have some sort of perpetual issuance to ETH.
And then we said, you know, we decided or we've used terms like our values to make changes to minimum viable issuance and things like that. I guess my question is this, how do we even know what our values are? Good question. I think the biggest way that we can be sure about what our values are is just by talking about them. So this is something that I think, you know, we're doing right now in this podcast. It's something that I do in my writings and blog posts. It's something that a lot of other Ethereum developers do in their writings and posts and their presentations. And, you know, just understanding kind of what we're trying to, we kind of care about, and let's say, importance was in we're trying to accomplish, I think, is just an important step in kind of getting everyone on the same page.
And then I think beyond that, like once there's some kind of level of basic agreements on the priorities or when, you know, there's priorities that some people feel a lot really strongly about other people. Care less about, well, usually we can still kind of do some thinking and do some research and engineering and come up with a design that ends up getting ahead of the properties that everyone is going after at the same time, which I guess something that Ethereum 2.0 for example, has managed to accomplish on at least several occasions. It also appears to be the case that when we kind of state our values as an Ethereum community, and even as the bankless community, this is kind of similar, we start to draw other people in who also embrace those values.
So it seems to be sort of a magnet. And then what we end up doing is we start embedding those values into code, and then people who subscribe to that value set can then opt in, is that kind of how it works. Absolutely. I think the applications that you use are definitely another important way of expressing your values and kind of helping your values succeed within the bankless nation. But one example of this is Uniswap. So Uniswap is definitely itself a very values driven project. It started as a project that was just trying to build a maximally simple, easy to use, decentralized exchange at a time when all of the other projects were going for complexity.
They were going for certain kinds of theoretical cleanness or they were going for just centralization. And Uniswap and some way is to just kind of set screw you to a lot of things that people thought were fundamental to in exchange, like even the concept of an order book. And they were criticized for this, but they just kind of pulled through and published this thing that was just a contract. Anyone can go interact with a contract, no independence on servers, very kind of purest about it. It's just a web page that talks to a contract. People can go use it. And over time, more and more people did use it.
And in 2020, Uniswap has taken over even many major centralized exchanges and volume. And it's the becoming mainstay of the Ethereum ecosystem. So I think even just things like that also help to express and cement the kinds of things that the Ethereum ecosystem considers to be important. This is also why I know Vitalik you've spoken on kind of chain maximalism in the past. And I agree with pretty much everything you've said on that subject. But there's also something I think that's pernicious in kind of the broader cryptic community, which is like chain relativism, right? So not all chains and not all projects, even on Ethereum, embrace the same value sets.
And we kind of like, we kind of have to choose by using an application or using a chain, what our values actually are. Do you think that there is a risk of chain relativism where everyone's like, yeah, every chain is the same? Tron is the same as Ethereum. And they all are like public blockchains, not sort of thing. Is that a risk we run? Should we make our values a bit more explicit? What's your take on that? Hmm, I think there definitely is a risk from a chance that just care less about values to try to kind of market the idea that those values are not really that important. And to some extent, you could argue that that's kind of symmetric to things that Ethereum is doing relative to the Bitcoin ecosystem, for example, so like Ethereum has proof of stake, Bitcoin has proof of work, and Ethereum people do argue that the kind of quote objectivity that proof of work provides is actually not that much better than the quote weak subjectivity that proof of stake provides.
And this is one of those big academic debates where and I think from the Bitcoin point of view, it definitely gets, I'm sure interpreted as kind of trying to dilute the concept of decentralization into nothingness, but ultimately, like whether or not an instance of that is kind of reasonable or not reasonable, you can't figure it out from the abstract, you have to actually dig into the technical arguments and then actually understand what's going on. And I think within a technical audience, I think people understand what Bitcoin is going for and what Ethereum is going for, and they understand that things that Tron is trying to do, for example, are just fundamentally not interesting.
Like, okay, it has more scalability because it's more centralized that kind of what you do in whatever, right? And so there are kind of less technical people that still get drawn in, which is, I think definitely a big concern. And I definitely do think that the Ethereum ecosystem can be just kind of more forceful and more clear about what are the important properties that make Ethereum applications be Ethereum applications. So at the same time, like I do feel like within at least the more technically inclined portion of the community, that message is already getting through to a large extent.
And there's definitely also the kind of entire spectrum of projects that are kind of more centralized than Ethereum, but are not outright scamming in the way that Tron is. You know, you have all of the various chains that are making a serious effort at doing, you know, 5,000 on chain TPS without shorting at the cost of a decentralized verifiability. And I think, you know, in addition to the debate that's happening within the Ethereum ecosystem, there's definitely a kind of crypto ecosystem why that debate that's happening both on the level of people arguing and on the level of just real life events happening that is kind of about, to what extent are kind of different values importance to making a blockchain project successful in the long term.
And then I don't think there's any way around this other than just to recognize that the Ethereum ecosystem is a participant in the debate and we have some particular positions and we think that those positions are and of the correct ones and we should both be visual and to make sure that we have the correct positions and if we don't sort of be open to changing our minds on certain issues, which I think we have on a couple of occasions, but you know, where we are correct is make sure that we can and if explain to the broader ecosystem and the world why we've made the trade-offs that we have. Your Ethereum address is a bank account but here's the problem.
It doesn't have a human readable name. It's represented by this long hexadecimal string that no one can read. Unstoppable domains has the solution to that problem. It provides a domain name for your Ethereum address. So instead of telling someone to send you funds to 0x E3BA blah blah blah, you can tell them to send funds to yourname.crypto, a domain name for your Ethereum address. At unstoppabledomains.com, you can search for blockchain domains like this and find tools to easily launch websites on decentralized web technology like IPFS. You can even have unstoppable domains help you manage your .
crypto or .e or even .zil domain name addresses at their unstoppable domains manager. Websites have domain names.com.org, your bankless bank account on Ethereum should have a domain name too. So go to unstoppabledomains.com, register a domain name for your Ethereum address now. Unstoppabledomains.com. Yarn is DeFi's first self-building project on Ethereum, focused on producing products for those who are interested in earning yield in DeFi. Yarn's various products are all built to suit each individual investor's preferred level of risk from various vault strategies that leverage DeFi tokens to the safer urn system which relies on stablecoins.
Vaults are aggressive yield farming robots, each with a unique strategy that is designed to maximize the yield of the deposited asset. Yarn employs from the most informed developers in DeFi to keep the vault strategies updated with the various yield farming opportunities on Ethereum. For customers who are more risked first, the Yarn's urn product may be for you. Urn is a yield-aware dynamic money market that automatically seeks the best interest rates across the various DeFi protocols and regularly migrates your deposited stablecoins between the DeFi protocols that are returning the best yield at the present moment.
Yarn is a system that is just a little over four months old so things are still very much an experiment. However, this hasn't stopped people from depositing over $700 million worth of assets into the Yarn system in order to find yield on Ethereum. Perhaps the people that deposited all this money were tired of constantly making daily transactions to follow the best DeFi interest rates and maybe the gas fees that they were paying ended up eating too much into their profits. With Yarn, it doesn't remove the risk of these various protocols that it leverages but it does remove the overhead of constantly trying to make sure you're finding the best yield and also so that you don't have to pay for gas to switch up your assets.
Check out the products that Yarn has to offer at yern.finance. That's y-e-a-r-n.finance. I want to go back and wrap up the proof of state conversation because staking is one of the ways to best signal alignment with values that we're discussing, right? Like if somebody is, if their values are aligned with Ethereum, they're likely to be a staker, right? And part of Ethereum requires people to be staking and people to be staking in their homes more or less. So Metallic, why should people stake? Why should someone feel the responsibility or to express their values by staking ether on proof of stake Ethereum?
Yeah, and I view staking as being a kind of declaration that you're a type of citizen of the Ethereum network, I guess. You know, it's definitely not the only type of being a citizen of the Ethereum network and there's lots of ways to participate if you have a less than 32-E, well, even if you have less than 32-E, if you can still stake as part of a pool, but there's definitely other things that you can do, but not if just running a node and if it signals long-term dedication to the network and an interest in helping to keep the network and maximally decentralized and secure. And at the same time, it's a source of ongoing revenue and it's a source of ongoing incentive alignment with the security of Ethereum blockchain and the success of the ecosystem.
So for people that aren't staking, should they still be running a node or is it more relevant for some types of people to run a node versus others? So I definitely believe in the idea that even if you're not staking, you should be trying to validate the Ethereum blockchain as much as possible. And I talk about why validation is important in a couple of posts, right? So if you go to vitalic.ca, one of the more recent ones is a philosophy of blockchain validation. One of the ones earlier was engineering security through coordination problems and then hard-for-self-for-exdefaults and coercion. Again, some of these posts I talk about the reasons why I think it is important to have a culture where as many users as possible actually run nodes that personally validate the chain in various ways.
And there's different levels of validation that you can have, right? So like in a shorting context, for example, you're not gonna be literally checking every single thing yourself, but there's techniques like a data availability validation, for example, where you can probabilistically validate correctness, you can validate the beacon chain chart, you can be checking for our proofs, you can run a stainless client, you can even run a light client, which is a better than trustings observer. And it definitely is, I think, healthier for the ecosystem, the more people do those things. And it's healthier for the ecosystem the more we do to make it easy for people to do those things.
Like I, for example, am definitely unhappy with the fact that Metamascar, for example, is just a client that directly talks to you and if you're a whatever. I mean, I recognize that kind of the reality is that there isn't really much of a better way right now, but this is absolutely something that we should be trying to engineer early past. And there's a lot of great projects that are trying to engineer the way past it. And even that, EF2, for example, is designed to have AMHS implore and to better light clients than the ETH one does. So we hope that things like Metamascar, things like status, again, that ends up adopting it over time.
Vitalik, we've spent a lot of time talking about proof of stake and the origins of it. Can you talk about maybe the origins of sharding? It was theorized as the most likely candidate for Ethereum scaling kind of narrowed down, what it sounds like as you evaluated and ETH researchers evaluated other alternatives. But how was this determined nation made like why sharding? Research and thinking about sharding definitely started as early as 2014. And I think the mindset there was just, it was fairly obvious right from the beginning that everyone validating every transaction is the simplest and dumbest thing you can do in terms of creating a blockchain that satisfies the security property that for a block to get accepted, it needs to be valid and available.
And there was a natural desire to just equal see, well, maybe if we can do some research and do some hard thinking, there is a much more efficient and better approach. And in general, I think I was kind of inspired by the computer science that I had warned over the last couple of years and one of the things that my computer science kind of really instilled on me is that like in a lot of computer computing problems, there's a very simple algorithm that can achieve a one level of efficiency. But then there usually is an algorithm that's only somewhat more complex that can achieve something close to an optimal efficiency, right?
One example of this is if you look at just like sorting, like if you have a list of numbers, can you rearrange them in a kind of lowest greatest order? And if you just ask someone who's never heard of sorting before to come up with a sorting algorithm, they generally come up with an algorithm that says something like, walk through the list, take the lowest number, take it out, walk through the list again, take the lowest number, take it out and keep going until the list becomes empty. And that kind of algorithm has a runtime of what's called 11 squared, right? So whatever the length of the list is, square that number, and that's how long it takes to run.
If you have a list of length 10 and it'll take 100 steps, if you have a list of like 20, it'll take 400 steps, if you have a list of like 1000, it'll take a million steps and so forth. But quadratics are kind of all event squared sorting is not the most efficiently of sorting, right? And it turns out that there are these that are kind of medium-clubber techniques. There's merge sort, quick sort, a whole bunch of other sorts that instead of taking and square time, they take kind of analog n time, right? So analog n, like a simple kind of non-math way of thinking about is like, and multiplied by the number of digits in n, right?
So for example, if the list has a length of 100, then it'll be like 100 times three, because the number 100 has three digits. And then if you have a thousand items, it would take 4,000 steps, because a thousand times the number of digits and a thousand is four. And in reality, it's not like decimal digits, it's binary digits. So it'll be a couple of times longer than that. But that's basically what you get to, right? And you can see how these algorithms, like if you understand how they work, they still feel a very kind of mathematically clean and neat. They definitely are somewhat more complex than the naive ones.
But it do take kind of a lot of conceptual thinking to get to them. And so the kind of vague hope that we had in 2014 is, well, if you imagine just now you will be validating every block as being the equivalent of insertion sort, right? The equivalent of one of these naive sorting algorithms that take n squared time, where if you have 1,000 item list that it takes a million steps to run, then what is the equivalent of a quick sort of work sort? What is the equivalent of this algorithm that takes a lot of brain power to figure out only a medium amount of brain power to understand, but that gives kind of much better results.
What is the equivalence of that? And kind of can we search for it and get at it? And starting quickly emerged as being one of the kind of ideal strategies or categories of strategies in this regard. And it was kind of obvious, right? Because well, if you want to do something better than everyone valuing everything, then you need everyone to only value a few things. And then the question is, well, how do you make it be secure against kind of what we call 1% attacks, where an attacker with a small amount of hash power tries to concentrate their hash power on one particular subset of the chain and just cause that subset of the chain to break.
And so we did a lot of thinking and eventually we actually did come up with a couple of quite clever strategies to get around those kinds of risks. And basically that's where the shorting came from. And basically a shorting is kind of like replicating the theory of main chain, right? And the ETH2 design, it's currently like 64 kind of replicas all sort of governed by a beacon chain. Just to add a bit, the really important thing that makes shorting tick is the concept of that you don't have everyone prevailing every committee. That you have on average every node only and gets assigned to evaluate a small portion of the block and the transactions.
Like either they get assigned to a shark or they get reassigned to a different chart every block or they have to say validate one transaction from each block and they get assigned to random transaction index or something like that, right? So the key is to move away from everyone validates to a smaller number of randomly selected actors validate, which is the secret. Why, why Vitalik do some people still think shorting is impossible? I hear that a lot still. I think there's a few different kind of classes of critics. So there's one class of critic I think that's just the not very intellectual type that doesn't really understand the concepts of indirect validation, probabilistic validation, all these things.
And they tend to have a very binary as sort of thinking and they say either you're validating or you're not. And either you're personally validating everything or the thing is centralized, which one are you? And then there is the more kind of intellectual and nuanced critics that tend to express skepticism about, well, what are these added assumptions that these shorting verification mechanisms are actually reducing and do they potentially introduce a lot of brittleness in reality? So I could give one example of where this kind of brittleness might actually exist. So if you look at fraud proofs, for example, right?
So fraud proofs are this idea that instead of everyone validating everything, then you would have a small number of actors validate some computation and a test to the result of a computation. And the word a test here basically means they would publish a digitally signed message that contains the result. And this signed message can be verified by anyone as coming from them. And they have some east that's deposited in a smart contract on the Ethereum chain. And if they attest to something incorrect, then someone else can challenge them. And if there's a challenge, that execution actually happens on the Ethereum chain.
And if it turns out that they actually are wrong, then their deposit gets taken away. And so the idea is that like you know how in a lot of legal context that you would say things like I swear under penalty of perjury that I believe blah, blah, blah is true. And then if you make one of those statements and you swear under penalty of perjury, but you swear under penalty of perjury to something that's totally false, and with some of the time you'll get away with it, but some of the time someone will kind of catch you. And they might potentially kind of like points to the facts that you know, hey, you actually said this.
And the work it turns out it's not true and like let's have a court case about this. And then that could end up like either hurting your interests or really seriously in some legal case or potentially could be used to independently on a punish you pretty seriously in some way and so far, right? And so the idea is basically that it's the same kind of principle that you replace direct verification of everything with this more scalable approach of kind of trust, but probabilistically verify, right? And so, okay, so that's what fraud proofs do. The problem with fraud proofs. The problem with fraud proofs is basically the synchromity assumption, right?
It's basically the assumption that there exists an active network and if someone sends something and they claim that that thing is valid, then that thing actually will reach one of these sensory nodes that's checking everything and then if the sensory node discovers that it's wrong and they broadcast a fraud proof that that fraud proof actually will reach and to make it onto the blockchain. So there is this assumption that basically the network is working and then a lot of cases that the network is working sufficiently quickly. And if this assumption is violated, then the fraud proof scheme stops working, right?
Like it's the equivalent of well, if you attest to some statement in a court and then the court makes so much of decisions based on that statement and then 20 years later, they discover that you just lied and everything, but by that time you're already dead. It's so the equivalent of that in the blockchain land basically is kind of what would happen if there's some large network failure or the chain that got censored by 51% of the data or something similar. And so basically if you can avoid those kinds of assumptions you should, right? And the interesting thing with shorting is that I feel like we actually have been really reducing the number of assumptions that we rely on over time.
So for example, before, shorting relied on less majority assumptions, now it doesn't rely nearly as much on less majority assumptions. So you can't get an invalid shorted block as someone, even if you control two-thirds of the validators. And so there's been a lot of hard work that's been done on a kind of reducing these new assumptions that these scaling techniques introduce, but there are still some assumptions that end up remaining. For our proofs, by the way, if we use ZK rollups and we can get rid of the need for any front groups, we can have shorting without front groups, which is just amazing and something we did not even think was possible two years ago.
So and there's like basically, there definitely are some going into actual critics that do kind of get into the weeds of each of these things. And they say, well, you know, decentralization is really, really, really important that is even a 100x gain-in-scale ability worth it if the price of that gain-in-scale ability is that you would reduce the set, keep a new category if unknown, and I know that what otherwise not exist. So I think like there is some legitimate critique, but over time we have, I think, been addressing more and more of it. So we have been more and more confident that shorting is a good trade-off.
So Vitalik, you recently posted something on E3 search a kind of a thought piece called rollup centric roadmap with a question mark. And that provoked another sound, but that was sort of interesting. People asking, is shorting canceled, Vitalik? And you know, I'm interested in your answer on that. I think it's probably gonna be no, but I guess a follow-up question on that is, how are rollups actually different than shards? So the answer, of course, is no, but I mean, I can answer why the answer is no. So first of all, shorting is not canceled, and the reason why shorting is not canceled is that phase one, which provides shorting of data is not canceled, phase one is shorting, right?
Because phase one is a mechanism where each participant in the network only needs to download and verify a small portion of the data, which is the definition of shorting. And then from a user experience and what people actually get perspective, shorting is also not canceled because the concept of Ethereum's TPS going up from 50 and too many thousands is not canceled, and in fact, it's going to come even sooner than people thought it would. So shorting is coming, and shorting is coming sooner as a result of these revocusing in my opinion. What was the other question again? How rollups are actually different than shards?
Yes, yes, this was a definitely good question. So, and it's an interesting question, right? Because like a lot of the time people get hung up on and confused about the word shorting because they think of a shard as being a cluster of nodes, but that's never how we thought of shorting, right? The way we thought of shorting is that a shard is a kind of logical subset of the blockchain and nodes get assigned to shards. And the node could be part of one shard, it could be part of two shards, or it could be part of all the shards. And so in the case of a rollup, what happens is that it has some of the properties of shorting, but not all of the properties of sharding, right?
So one of the properties of the sharding that it has is this property that computation gets split apart, right? That if you have many different rollups, then computation in each of these rollups is done separately by separate subsets of participants. And this is kind of the key thing that's responsible for getting them a scalability. So that's one of the place in which rollups are kind of like shorting. In other place where rollups are like shorting, I think you guys actually talked about this in one of your previous episodes. I think it was either with Heiden or someone, or a pair of nine person or someone else, I'm talking about kind of the future of Uniswap and Market Makers in a shorted context.
Now we're talking about kind of the, it's called the Ethereum chain is being like Manhattan, then you have your suburbs. And rollups and shards actually from that economic standpoint to have a very similar functionality because they are both the new terminology that we use as a domains, right? And what a domain is, it's a kind of collection of accounts or kind of a region of state where you can have synchronous interaction between accounts within that region, but you can only have asynchronous interaction between that region and other regions, right? So what I mean by synchronous interaction is like, for example, being able to, you know, take out a CDP from like Maker Compound, then use some coins, a stick them into Uniswap, then do some arbitrage trade, then take the output, then stick that into Ave, and then do some other thing, and just do a bunch of fancy stuff within one transaction and then get the result and if something breaks, then you just immediately revert everything, right?
Like for that kind of fancy magic to be possible, you need to be within the same domain. You need to be within the same environment where what we call synchronous execution is possible. Now, any synchronous execution is like, I send a transaction and that transaction gets in over here and it's gonna have an effect over there, but that effect is delayed. Like for example, I send some eth from Shard, A to Shard, B, I lose the eth immediately, but you get the eth from Shard, B, once a lot later or two slots later. And synchronous execution is possible within Shards, synchronous execution is possible within Roll-ups, but only a synchronous execution is possible between Shards and only a synchronous execution is easy to implement between Roll-ups.
You have more way to potentially design Roll-ups, we can sometimes do synchronous execution between them, but it's still a challenge, right? So that's another way in which Shards and Roll-ups are similar. One way in which Shards and Roll-ups are different is the security model, right? So in the case of just using Roll-ups, Roll-ups all rely on the same data layer. And that data layer gets at least in the current eth one system downloaded by everyone and verified by everyone. So there is still something which is being verified by everyone and that something allows you to avoid some of the trade-offs that are inherent in a Shard system.
So that's one example of an area where Shards and Roll-ups are different. So I guess they're just kind of summarizing again, like there are some similarities, there's some differences to the end user, Shards and Roll-ups definitely feel very similar. Another really fun thing going down the road is that when we have eth two and Roll-ups at the same time and you have the Roll-ups on top of eth two, then different Roll-ups might end up using different Shards. You could have one Roll-up that uses five Shards. You could have five Roll-ups that are sharing the same Shard. So in that case, Shards become this technical distinction that's just about grouping data into Roll-ups and Roll-ups are the more relevant distinction in terms of domains that's more relevant to the experiences of individual users.
So keeping on this Roll-up centric roadmap post, I read the post and I thought it was fantastic, like very exciting, I would say. But could you describe kind of what that post actually means about the roll-up Roll-ups in an eth two world? And what are the wins for the eth community in a Roll-up centric roadmap? So I think this is a good opportunity to cycle back a bit into the conversation on Ethereum values. And I think I talked a lot about how Ethereum values and Bitcoin values have similarities. One place where there might be more difference at least I feel and I'm sure people will accuse me of bias for this and so on and so forth.
But if you're in community of really values pragmatism and just evaluating making decisions that makes sense and given just the context that's kind of standing right in front of us and what people and applications and developers need and this has played out in a couple of ways, like one way, for example, is that Ethereum miners actually have been willing to raise the gas limit somewhat. And so instead of the burden of increased demand for usage following entirely on users, facing higher transaction fees, some of the burden falls on users being transactions fees, some of the burden falls on users having higher validation costs.
And so on net, it's probably a better trade off than if we had just kind of stuck a gun hoe to keeping one block size. But in this context, basically the post had kind of two main themes to it. Well, the first main theme is just, hey, look at reality. And so what I mean by that is if you look at the current reality of where Ethereum is, what kind of scaling is needed and what kind of scaling is there, we see a few facts in front of us, right? One fact is that there's a dire need for scalability to increase and there's a dire need for this to happen quickly. Gas prices over the last couple of months have hit all the way up to 700 away on a couple of occasions.
Now they're a bit lower, but they're still, you know, hovering around in the 10s going up to 100 from time to time. So gas prices are still, by historically, standard-estronomic way high and they're high enough to kick out many classes of applications that in many cases represent what we think if Ethereum is there to accomplish, and especially on the non-financial side. And so scaling is very important. So that's the one fact, scaling is important, scaling is urgent. The second fact is that there are technology that is available today or in the realistic near term to alleviate scaling is roll-ups, right?
Roll-ups are the game. Now there are channels, but channels are very application specific. There is plasma, plasma works for payments, but it doesn't work well for general purpose contracts. And so roll-ups are just the centerpiece of the game. And so we need to be serious about the fact that if we want medium-term scalability, people are going to be moving to roll-ups and like this isn't even a suggestion. This is just a recognition of the reality that's facing us. And then the second really interesting thing is that if you look at the combination of roll-ups with just the way that the two-roll map is rolling out, where these two-roll map is rolling out in these multiple phases where phase zero is preferred stake, phase one is shorting of data and phase two is shorting of execution.
And it turns out that phase one, shorting of data, is actually the only thing that you need to put roll-ups on top of shorting and give us just really, really massive scalability. And so it turns out that if we're going to kind of move over onto roll-ups that not only will we get the scalability, we directly need it today, but we will also just get extremely huge scalability beyond our wildest dreams as soon as phase one. And so given these facts, there is both the end of once again, a recognition of reality that roll-ups are the game for the medium-term future. But also there is the proposal that the Ethereum ecosystem should basically just dedicate itself to roll-ups as a strategy and that the Ethereum ecosystem should not try to have its own base-way or execution and should just rely on roll-ups as being its main mechanism for scaling applications.
And I give two reasons for this. One of them is that roll-ups are going to be here sooner and they'll have higher scalability. So why sacrifice the higher scalability thing for the lower scalability thing? And the second reason that I give is that if we have a base-chain that is more kind of rich-wrenched and more focused, then we can reduce the number of new security assumptions that we have, right? And in particular, we can avoid committee and fraud group assumptions. And this would significantly increase the security of the ETH2 chain, which is wonderful. And it would allow the kind of roll-up ecosystem to basically just kind of do its own thing.
And then the third, once again, are going to pragmatic part of this room map. It's basically the fact that, no, there is this kind of Ethereum satellite ecosystem of, as a Matt Finestone recently said, in his great post, I think it was Ethereum helpers or Ethereum enables. And even Ethereum killers score respecting to being Ethereum enables, which is just awesome. And so basically, if we adopt this roll-up-focused roadmap, then instead of ETH2 positioning itself to squash these projects, ETH2 would be positioning itself to cooperate with these projects and to kind of be a platform where those projects can end up helping to just be at execution scaling layer on top, which creates a lot of synergy.
It also creates a lot of room for these projects to do more experiments. Also potentially do more public goods funding for the Ethereum ecosystem and do a lot of other wonderful things that would not be possible for Ethereum to do by itself. Brian started off this conversation asking the question, how are shards and roll-ups really all that different? And part of the answer is that roll-ups represent sort of this, you just said satellite, kind of like the satellite away from the main chain that has a direct one-to-one bridge with the main chain. And I think what you just alluded to is that same relationship can also happen with the quote-unquote ETH killers, turning them into ETH enablers, Ethereum enablers.
And so to me, and at the same time, we've also seen almost every single Ethereum app announce some sort of L2 system, some sort of roll-up that they are going to leverage, right? And this happens every single day. There's like a news like, oh, we're hopping on to an L2. And so when so many different systems, applications on Ethereum or side chains or Ethereum killers are able to link into Ethereum directly via a roll-up, via some sort of L2 system, how does that change the characterization of the L1, right? Because that turns it into a place where everyone seems to be transacting, sending tokens, buying, selling, on Uniswap.
People are all living on L1, and it seems to be pushing them into living on L2s. So how does this change how we are going to have our relationship with the L1 of Ethereum? So it definitely will be the case that users' primary base is going to be generally an L2 system, right? So I think in the long run, there may well be even be users that just go years using Ethereum without ever touching L1, without ever setting up an account inside of an L1. The main reason why users might want to use an L1, is as part of moving between one or two and another. Though even there, you can save a lot on transaction fees by creating kind of optimized mass exit mechanisms.
And two would be if some kind of L2 potentially breaks. And three would be that there are some applications where it might make sense to have kind of the core of the application be registered on the base chain and then have that application that have satellites of itself so to speak exist on the L2 side, right? So one example of this might be a token. So if you issue a token, I'm predicting that the main way to issue a token is still going to be to have the base registry be on the Ethereum base chain directly. And but then users and intermediaries would just end up depositing that token into the L2 systems.
And then you have a lot of people just doing things with that token directly on the L2 side. So I definitely think that those kinds of things are going to happen a lot. And there's definitely going to be some, I don't know, a lot of people figuring out, well, exactly what is that going to look like? No, for any given application, do they want their application to live on a particular role? So they want it to be close cross role up and so on. And that's one of those things that we're just going to have to figure out over the next day in a few months or a year or two. But I'm confident that we'll be able to make.
This is going to be a slow transition. We're going to see more and more applications start to migrate so L2 is over time. Users are going to migrate more and more of their activity to L2 is over time. And I think we'll get through it. I think we'll be fine. Earlier in this podcast, you discussed how scalability is important because without scalability, you allow for the entrance of middlemen, right? And what Ryan and I have been discussing with bankless is that we like Bitcoin. Bitcoin is fantastic. But we are concerned that it is going to be a system that is basically gated through Bitcoin banks, right?
Because if Bitcoin gets adopted completely and holistically, then there's not enough scale on Bitcoin for every single individual to be able to transact on the L1. And therefore, people get pushed into KL, send you Bitcoin through Coinbase. And Coinbase just settles with their own internal ledger rather than it being on the like the trustless permissionless open Bitcoin blockchain. It seems to be that that rollups and L2s like them offer Ethereum level capabilities of scale and execution environments and trustlessness that is exactly what you were talking about with like, well, with increased scale, we don't have to rely on centralized ledgers.
We can use rollup ledgers. And so is the conversation around rollups and reducing intermediaries? Is that kind of what you were referring to at the beginning of this podcast? Yeah, and I think basically any other people are going to be on a decentralized L2 where people are going to be on a centralized L2. I mean, Coinbase is obviously one of the more blatant examples of a centralized L2, but there's also more subtle examples like there's permission to consortium chain some like an overseeing liquid, for example. And even in the Ethereum case, and there's definitely some applications that are moving to either something like X-Dye or in the case of the Dark Forest game on, I think it was either the Robston or Girlier, one of those at testnets.
And it's completely understandable why that's happening because just the scalability for a kind of properly Ethereum connected system is not there yet. But it is something where we want to make the kind of properly a decentralized and trustless algorithm that's actually available. So what about the possibility? One of the things that everyone's concerned about with the sharding and also with rollups is composability because with DeFi currently, composability is kind of like our big thing, right? Like you mentioned a possible transaction where there's a flash loan from AVE that's trading on uniswap and dyDX and does everything at once, right?
And you know, sharding gets in the way of that but then also rollups also gets in the way of that as well. So I was hoping you could kind of just go through some of the strategies for retaining composability. And then also is there a possible way for each individual rollup to have a direct connection with each other that doesn't leverage the L1? Sure. So I guess first of all, and there are some kind of application specific strategies that can get you many, maybe most of the benefits of an of composability even in an asynchronous context. So one thing that I talk about, for example, is the concept of yanking.
So the kind of big example problem that I often use to talk about in a synchronous composability is and I created Andrew a Miller for this and I think Andrew Miller himself credits basically mainstream and distributed systems textbooks is the training hotel problem. And the training hotel problem basically says if you have a train on shard A, or if you have a train ticket booking contract on shard A and the hotel booking contract on shard B, then how do you book the train in the hotel in such a way that you ensure that you're booking either both the train in the hotel or neither, right? Because you don't wanna have the train, we don't have the hotel, and you don't wanna have the hotel without the train.
And if the train contract and the hotel contract are on the same shard, this is easy because you just send a transaction which does like step one, book the train, steps you book the hotel, and if either of those FIO-Z revered and reverting cancels both. In an asynchronous context, this is much harder, right? And what you can do though is this mechanism called yanking. So the way yanking works is, you design the train booking and hotel booking contract in such a way that you represent the permission to book a particular seat as a kind of separate discrete contract, right? So then step one, you call the train booking contract on shard A, and you basically create this kind of separate contract that represents the right to book a particular seat.
Step two, you do the same on the hotel side. Step three, you take the train seat booking contract and the hotel booking seat contract, and you move them both to whatever shard you're on, right? Then step four, now that you're both of those are on the same shard, you do your synchronous transaction and you book both the train and the hotel and if either one fails, then you are kind of revered both. Now the reason why this approach works is because it is definitely possible that because there are a synchrony blah blah, something happens on one side but not on the other side, the train gets booked or the hotel gets booked, but until you do that final step where you already have both of those contracts on the same shard, you actually haven't booked anything, right?
So if you do this kind of separation and then someone else snaps up the train or someone else snaps up the hotel, then that's fine, you will board and you will just basically wait some time and you try again. So it's probably, or alternatively, if you bring the train and the hotel onto your shard but then you go offline, then there might be a timeout and then someone else can go book the train and the hotel, right? So you still have this kind of safety property because you're basically kind of doing a asynchronous pre-processing step where you're kind of drag the permission to do whatever thing you want to do onto the same shard.
And then only at the final step do you do everything on all of the kind of final commit steps at the same time on that one shard. And you might ask, well, why do we hear about trains and hotels, but it turns out that this is a kind of excellent technical metaphor for a very wide class of decentralized exchange and other D5 things that people actually care about doing. So sometimes you can do on the things like that. And if you can, then this is wonderful. Now, if you can't, there is an alternative that we'll also want us to do. And that alternative is basically that, we just accept that some robots are going to be more focused on high-value applications that define they'll have higher gas prices and other robots are going to be focused on applications that have lower fees, but I do not have synchronous connections to the high-value stuff.
And the other fun thing that we can do is, especially post-sharding, you can have a single robot that talks to multiple shards. So you can have a single robot that uses the data from multiple shards. And so you can potentially have a robot that has scalability that combines together multiple shards, which is potentially really amazing. And if you do that, then you could imagine this kind of D5 focused roll-up as having scalability of many thousands of transactions per second, in which case it could just easily be enough for the bulk of the important high-value activity to happen on there. So yeah, and I guess in summary, there's a combination of these different approaches.
And I think any one of them can no work well. And I think the market will kind of gravitate towards the thing that makes sense. So if it's like to wrap up this roll-up centric roadmap section, like I guess some of the takeaways, the wins for the Ethereum community is, A, you said it's pragmatic. This is happening now. Two, it seems like speed, right? So this can happen as soon as ETH phase, ETH-2 phase one, which is maybe a year away, my timeline, not yours, that's an estimate. The last thing I guess I'm a bit hazy on though, in this roll-up centric roadmap view, what changes in ETH-2 phase two?
So do we even need state execution across the 64 shards? We have sharding in this data availability layer and we're scaling with roll-ups. Does ETH-2 phase two get a lot more simple? Right, and so in the extreme version of the roadmap, you just don't need ETH-2 phase two at all, right? You just say phase one and then the merge and then for the base chain, that's the end of history. Like you can do some incremental upgrades, like upgrade to Casper CBC, maybe do some zero knowledge per stuff, but you don't need to fundamentally change it again. That's the extreme version of the roadmap. The somewhat less extreme version says, well, maybe things are gonna be safer and more convenient if base chain gas prices are still somewhat more affordable.
And if that's true, then maybe instead of one execution shard, maybe we can have like four or eight execution shards. So it's still theoretically possible for one user to run all the execution shards if they have to, but it's a little bit harder. So that is an intermediate path that we could potentially take. Another intermediate path that we could take is having phase two come much later when we have the ability to just use ETH-narks to zero knowledge prove the EVM, at which point we actually will be able to just do a kind of base chain execution without relying on any fraud proof assumptions.
So there's different versions of phase two that become possible and we don't have to commit to any specific one of them, but quite some time. So we preserve the optionality, right? But the nice thing about this is like the haziest part of the ETH-2 roadmap, and like kind of design is ETH-2 phase two, really. So if you kind of don't need that in order to scale with roll ups, then scalability on Ethereum happens a whole lot faster. Yes. Exactly. And ETH-2 phase two is definitely not necessary for users to get scalability. I mean, that's never been true. I guess the fact that you could do a sharding plus a row up to get really high scalability has been true as a property of the roadmap for a long time.
But I guess it's only been in the last couple of weeks and people have like properly realized that it's true. Vitalika, I want to turn the conversation to EIP-1559. And for EIP-1559, like it's utility or it's beauty, it's kind of in the eye of the holder. For some people, it changed the monetary policy of Ethereum, and that's its greatest feature. For others, it makes transacting on Ethereum much more easy. It's just a better experience because they don't, users don't have to worry about DAS. There's also the conversation of minor extractable value and how EIP-1559 can help mitigate the instability that minor extractable value can cause.
So when you think of EIP-1559, what do you see? Almost always see all of those things. Like EIP-1559 was definitely originally created as AFE market improvement proposal that basically said, well, instead of having this really horrible few market that we have today, where users have to send transactions either with really high fees, or they have to wait a random and a normal amount of time for no reason. We'll have this market where we have a loss volatility on the fee side and admit a little bit more volatility on the block size side. And this ends up, again, just being much safer for the network.
So that was one motivation. And at the same time, I wrote this big, long paper where I talk about this and of different benefits. Another one is getting rid of the inefficiencies of a first price auction, and then the list kind of goes a longer and longer. I mean, another one is getting rid of some safety issues of a fee-dominant blockchain. So there's a lot of problems that fee market reform ends up solving, and then the other side of all this, of course, is the burn. And the burn is, of course, this thing that a lot more people end up focusing on, right? And there definitely is this kind of dynamic where you have some people that are interested in if you market reform for the more technocratic reasons.
Some people that are interested in if you market reform for the more kind of quote populist reasons. And then there's people who see the value of both, which is a camp that I would definitely put myself in. And I think that is probably the big one of the bigger reasons why it's so powerful, right? Like it does just somehow kind of hit the jackpot in terms of having this fairly large set of benefits for Ethereum all at the same time. One of the things I really like about EIP 1559 is how it, well, in my opinion, it adds to the credible neutrality of ether the asset, right? And especially it's relationship to Ethereum as the way that Ethereum comes to be validated in proof of stake.
We were talking earlier about ether distribution and kind of the question of who should get ether issuance in how Ethereum becomes validated, right? And while we just decided that, it's kind of unfortunate that proof of stake is not a distribution mechanism, but that also comes with the benefit of proof of stake being really, really secure. And instead of ether being a distribution mechanism, I think EIP 1559 reduces the political nature of ether issuance by socializing ether burn, ether, because instead of having the transaction fees sent to the stakers who could be a quote unquote privileged party, those transaction fees are sent to all ether holders everywhere.
Do you see this as a de-politicizing or credible neutrality boosting force for the monetary policy of ether? Yeah, so I think one kind of important thing about the EIP 1559 and particularly the fee-boring property is that it just establishes the centrality of ether within the Ethereum economic ecosystem. So what I mean by this is that if you don't have this, then in some ways, ether becomes the most anti-privileged asset on the network. And what I mean by this is that ultimately, you can do things with eith or you can do things with other assets. And especially if we have roll ups, then you couldn't even imagine a roll up where the sequencer pays our transaction fees with eith, but then all the users pay their fees to the sequencer and like, dire whatever else.
And eventually the roll up sequencer could just have private agreements with mining pools and they could just use PayPal or avoid eith entirely. And so the problem that you get is that eith doesn't really kind of have special privileges in the Ethereum network, but it does have a special burden. And the special burden is that it's eith and only eith that has to suffer the expense of a more of it being printed in order to secure the network, right? And if the transaction fee-boring basically fixes this problem because eith does have this unique burn, but it also has the unique benefit that it is this asset that is kind of ultimately indispensable if you want to pay fees on the, or get transactions included on the Ethereum network, right?
Even if a user ends up paying and dying, there's like some intermediary that's going to have to, get some eith and actually burn the eith in order to, get the transaction included. And so that actually does, I think, I kind of bring the economics of the Ethereum ecosystem, somewhat more in balance. And the last variable that's related here is minor extractable value. And minor extractable value is, in a summary, the value that a minor or also a validator can extract as their privilege role of being able to order transactions, right, and also being able to insert their transactions in that order as they see fit, that allows them to extract value.
And a way to kind of quantify minor extractable values to look at the fees being paid to Ethereum in any particular block. And during the field farming media, we saw, you know, Ether blocks having, you know, 3, 4, 5, 8, Ether as reward for fees. On top of that is 12. Yeah, 12, that's crazy. On top of just the two Ether that's issued every single block. Now with IP 1559, it's an elegant solution because a lot of those fees would just get burned. And that's the credible neutrality that we were talking about. But the combination of minor extractable value, and EIP 1559, means that we're going to be burning a lot of eth proportionally.
Does this change the relationship between ether and Ethereum in any meaningful way? As I think I just kind of mentioned, it does kind of reinforce the centrality of eth just because there just is a lot of eth that's going to have to really properly go out of circulation every time one of these transaction fees bike sends out happening. In terms of minor extractable value, I mean, I think the one of the challenges is that there's different kinds of minor extractable value. Fee's are obviously one kind of MEV, and that's important to end up with the EIP 1559. The fees are going to be largely captured by the protocol.
Another kind of MEV, though, is like arbitrage, right? If you have the kind of right of a first-grifuse all to push rise action to a block, then if the price of any token moves, you can be the first to claim all of the Uniswab arbitrage, for example, right? And that's another privilege that miners have. And it's a privilege that currently miners are not very good at claiming. But in a roll-up central roadmap, that privilege is going to be largely claimed by basically roll-up sequencer and roll-up projects themselves. Which is actually a really interesting equilibrium. And I actually like this because it basically means that not all the value is going to get captured to pay for security.
There's some value that could potentially be captured and directed to pay for other public goods. Like, I definitely don't know. It can encourage you to talk to Jing from the M Optimism team at some point in terms of some of her thoughts on using a minor extractable value to pay for other kinds of Ethereum level ends, that potentially even wider public goods. So there's a lot there that can be explored as well. But yeah, and I think the Ethereum ecosystem is going to get better and better at sort of plugging the loop and basically ensuring that any opportunity to capture value becomes a directly linked to opportunities to deploy that value for productionally for the good of the whole ecosystem.
We do have a podcast with Karl and Jing Lawn from Optimism slated sometime into the future. So that absolutely will be discussed. Yeah. So, Vitalik, let's talk about this kind of, I guess, last piece of Ethereum 2.0. And we've spent the entire conversation going through all of the pieces and the values and the decisions as to why. And I can signalling ETH 2 phase 2, right? There is this notion with kind of roll-ups that we brought up where if we get to Ethereum 2 phase 1.5, where we're actually emerging ETH 1 and ETH 2 together, that gets us a lot of what we need for scalability. So I want to talk about that.
And one thing that strikes me is the whole concept of ETH 2 as sort of a separate network is almost a misnomer, or at least it's temporary. I think you've called ETH 2 previous to all of this, previous before it got meamed into ETH 2, serenity as sort of the next launch. And that's when we really start to see that this is, this has always been one cohesive roadmap when ETH 1 and ETH 2 phase together. So ignoring ETH 2 phase 2, how will the transition work when we merge these chains together? So just kind of repeating the roadmap, right? So first we have phase 0, which is coming very soon when the approved state part is going to start.
Then phase 1, where the new approved state beacon chain gets extended with data shards, then we have the merge. And this is the critical part, right? What happens in the merge is basically that we take the existing Ethereum state, so the accounts balance of smart contracts, code smart contracts storage, all that stuff. And we kind of just cut and paste it from the ETH 1 system into the ETH 2 system. And then from then on, if you have an Ethereum client, it will stop working at the ETH 1 chain and it will start working at the ETH 2 chain. So the place where you would need to put transactions, if you want to interact with those applications after that point on, will be in the ETH 2 chain.
And it will be the ETH 2 chain that processes the transactions and of executes the state transitions and that does all of those things, right? So basically kind of the core engine, well, I shouldn't say the engine, the engine is more like the proof of work and the proof state. The core kind of thing that is being maintained is going to be sort of transplanted from the ETH 1 system directly into the ETH 2 system. It's the engine that will kind of before was a proof of work, but after the transplant, it will be living as part of the proof of state system that will have been already running for over a year by that time.
So if you're a user, you don't really need to worry too much. The transition will happen largely automatically. And you don't need to do anything special to move your coins over or move your contracts over. Everything just moves over by default. And then if you're a client developer, then the transition is, you can think of it as just being like a special type of hard fork, basically. And at that point, the ETH 1 chain will effectively be no longer useful, it will die. Correct. What EIP features do we need an ETH 1 before it freezes? EIP 1559, is there anything else? I mean, theoretically, the road map would work if we change nothing about ETH 1 now between now and the merge, but there are things that would be good to include, right?
So the EIP 1559, I'm certainly an ETH 2 has its own kind of built-in form of EIP 1559, but then the ETH 2 version focuses on like bytes because ETH 2 is just a data environment, but we want it to have it for gas as well. And another nice thing to have would be stateless execution. So the ability to execute blocks without having the full state. And this is something that ETH 1 is solely moving towards. Like there's any IP to change to a binary tree. There is an EIP to increase the gas cost of some operations that have a really heavier witness cost and so on and so forth. So there's definitely things that would be really nice to get included in ETH 1 before then.
And then, obviously, just generally efficiency improvements. But like, a lot of things and even the important things, like, theoretically, it could happen before or after this which. Fatal, we want to thank you for giving us your time. This has been a very insightful, very helpful podcast to go through why we are doing what we are doing here in the Ethereum world. And we want to finish up with a roll-up round if you are game. All right, so first roll-up question. Phase 0, 2020 or 2021. I think 2020. Next question. ZK roll-ups or optimistic roll-ups. Who do you love more? Short-term optimistic.
Long-term, I expect that kind of ZK to inch into a better and better position over time as ZK roll-ups become better at doing more general purpose things. Fatal, what does MoLock mean to you? MoLock is the rationalist god of coordination failure. It's kind of the representation of all that is wrong with the world that can possibly not be wrong if we could just learn to find ways to cooperate better. And salying MoLock is one of the major things that I think the Ethereum ecosystem can be about. China versus the United States in the current digital currency race, who wins. I guess China definitely seems more on top of the game in terms of just getting DCP out there.
I think in the long-term, I don't think the interesting question is government A versus government B is so much as it is. The category of governments doing their CBDC is in that particular way versus alternative approaches. The first question is DCP even going to succeed at beating out existing centralised fiat like WeChat Pay, which is already very convenient. And the second question is in other places, what advantages are CBDCs going to end up having relative to other forms of digital payments? And then finally, are they going to be the primary way that people end up actually doing international commerce or do a fully decentralized currency as stand a chance of capturing a lot of market share there, either directly or as a kind of glue layer between these nationalist systems.
I think seeing just where the equilibrium lands are there, just like in terms of the category of nation states doing things directly versus nation states, kind of interacting with the commercial baking sector versus just crypto as a separate glue layer or potentially nation states coming up with CBDC is that I'm like, interact with the crypto layer more close way of that, and I don't know, we'll see. There is at the time of recording 142,000 BTC tokenised in various different ways on the Ethereum network. How would you describe the long-term relationship between Bitcoin and Ethereum? I definitely expect the RAPs Bitcoin on the Ethereum side to grow over time.
My main concern that I've raised multiple times in and they keep raising is the trust model. A lot of these RAPs BDCs, they kind of hide what their trust model is, and then we'll talk about it openly, or they talk about what their trust model is going to be in five years, but not what it is today. And they're often end up being fairly centralized in practice, and this really worries me. I want to see more decentralized RAP or tokens that have, at the very least, a multi-six trust model, and then see if we can do even better than that. Does TBDC from the key projects fit into that category? It's definitely one of the more interesting trust models, though.
I mean, one challenge is that the collateral costs of having ETH be the other back of the BTC are significant, and so it will be forced to charge some kind of interest charge, I think, on deposits at some point, which the more centralized ones are likely not going to be able to, or not going to have to do, but I don't know, we'll see. Vitalik, say, phase zero ships in 2020 as you predict. Do you think that regular people, regular ETH holders, should start staking at the ETH 2 launch, or should they wait some time? I think, if you're an intrepid enthusiast, you should stake at the beginning. If not, then you should wait some time, and I think that's okay.
We actually want to have a relatively small number of people staking at the beginning, and have increased that over time as people get more comfortable. Vitalik, it has been a pleasure to have you on Bangladesh. Thanks so much for sharing your thoughts on why ETH 2 and the value set that drives this very important project in the crypto ecosystem. Thank you. This has been great. All right, guys, action items. Vitalik included a bunch of articles that he referenced in this conversation. We will include those articles, including Slasher, a punitive proof of stake algorithm, and his philosophy in the show notes, so you can click on those and read up on that material.
Also, we've included Vitalik's post on ETH research on the roll-up centric roadmap. That is fantastic reading if you're trying to get familiar with how the ETH 2 roadmap is shaping up. Lastly, we have a guide on ETH 2 staking. We're going to be putting more guides on ETH 2 staking as it becomes available. I think we're close now, so we've included a link to that guide, and you can check it out there. Wrists and disclaimers, of course, crypto is risky. So as ETH, this is not financial advice. DeFi is risky. You could lose what you put in, so be careful out there, but we are headed west. This is the frontier.
It's not for everyone, but thanks for joining us.