BLACK FRIDAY DEAL: GET LEDGERS for 40% OFF! 🔥🔥🔥
https://bankless.cc/ledger
🚀 SUBSCRIBE TO NEWSLETTER: http://bankless.substack.com/
✊ STARTING GUIDE BANKLESS: https://bit.ly/37Q17uI
❤️ JOIN PRIVATE DISCORD: https://bit.ly/2UVI10O
🎙️ SUBSCRIBE TO PODCAST: http://podcast.banklesshq.com
👕 BUY BANKLESS TEE: https://merch.banklesshq.com/
-----
GO BANKLESS WITH THESE SPONSOR TOOLS:
⭐️LEDGER - 40% OFF LEDGERS THIS WK ONLY! 🔥🔥🔥
https://bankless.cc/ledger
🚀 ZERION - INVEST IN DEFI FROM ONE PLACE (download it now!)
https://bankless.cc/zerion
💳 MONOLITH - GET THE HOLY GRAIL OF BANKLESS VISA CARDS
https://bankless.cc/monolith
🤖YEARN - YIELD-SEEKING MONEY ROBOT THAT FARMS DEFI FOR YOU
------
A Crypto Civilization | Balaji Srinivasan
No one blends the academic, startup, & venture world quite like Balaji Srinivasan. With multiple engineering degrees, multiple exits, being early into Bitcoin, selling a company to Coinbase, being CTO to Coinbase, Balaji lives on the cusp of the frontier of human innovation.
Rumor is that he’s trying to create a digital country, we’re gonna talk about it.
- Legacy of COVID creating distrust In Institutions
Balaji thinks that the world is ready for new institutions and that the movement of time is to generate new solutions rather than repair old ones.
- ‘Crypto-civilization’, or what Balaji calls: The Network State
The leveraging of the most useful modern technology and coordination tools, to produce structurally independent organizations
- Digital Nations vs the Nation-State
How might this independence generate friction with the status quo?
And of course, how does a new 'crypto civilzation' actually manifest.
Balaji is a real Big Brain thinker, so strap yourself in!
------
Don't stop at the video!
Subscribe to the Bankless newsletter program
http://bankless.substack.com/
Visit the official Bankless website for resources
http://banklesshq.com/
Follow Bankless on Twitter
https://twitter.com/BanklessHQ
Follow Ryan on Twitter
https://twitter.com/ryansadams
Follow David on Twitter
https://twitter.com/TrustlessState
-----
Not financial or tax advice. This channel is strictly educational and is not investment advice or a solicitation to buy or sell any assets or to make any financial decisions. This video is not tax advice. Talk to your accountant. Do your own research.
Disclosure. From time-to-time we may add links in this channel to products we use. We may receive commission if you make a purchase through one of these links. We'll always disclose when this is the case.
No summary for this episode yet.
Welcome to Bankless, where we explore the frontier of internet money and internet finance. This is how to get started, how to get better, and how to front-run the opportunity. This is Ryan Sean Adams. I'm here with David Hoffman, and we're here to help you become more bankless. David, we just had Balaji Srinivasan on. What a fantastic episode. I was going to ask you what we covered, but I almost feel like asking you, like, what didn't we cover? We talk a lot on the Bankless podcast about Bitcoin and Ethereum being neo-nations, right? Different new types of organizational structures. And I thought that, I think that's a really compelling thesis.
And it's something that we've been sharing readily on the Bankless program. Balaji takes this a big step forward. And Ryan, you called Balaji the guy that thinks a decade ahead of everyone else. And so Balaji is taking that metaphor that like, you know, these things are kind of digital nations. And he's pondering the idea of what happens if we make a real nation? What happens if we make a real country? A country that starts in the cloud and then actually manifests itself somewhere in the world with a sourcing of capital to purchase property and then actually construct a real country. That's not a joke.
Balaji is actually having this thought about how to make a real country. And so since we talk about this on the Bankless podcast all the time, it was just a perfect fit to get him on the show to talk about how do we go from a metaphorical country in the clouds to a real country on land. So that's what we covered in this very ambitious podcast. I expect this podcast to sound unrealistic to you. Maybe even a little bit crazy. But that's what happens when you have a conversation with basically like somebody who feels like a time traveler, David. It's like, I mean, if you heard Balaji when he first got into crypto and Bitcoin, right?
Like at the very inception of things, Bitcoin is a completely bonkers crazy idea, right? Or even DeFi and Ethereum, completely crazy bonkers ideas. The fact that a Uniswap can deliver 4 billion in trading volume, and it's a tiny protocol written by one individual on a 100K grant, that is unrealistic and crazy. So there's sort of a pattern to these kinds of ideas in crypto. And a lot of times, Balaji has proven to be right. So if this episode sounds crazy to you, that is to be expected, but it might be crazy and right. Right. That's exactly right. And imagine you can go even further back and say like, okay, it's 2010.
You just read the Bitcoin white paper. And for some reason, you're compelled by it. And so you go to your friend and be like, oh my God, there's going to be this new money on the internet. Imagine how crazy you would sound in 2010. Well, now it's 2020 and kind of all bets are off on things. And so I'm kind of hoping that the world can appreciate the effort to maybe create a brand, the idea of creating a brand new nation from scratch. Maybe that's not, maybe because it's a new era, maybe it's not such a harebrained idea. It's cool too, because we start with present times. We talk about the legacy of COVID and this distrust in institutions that has fomented.
And then we get into those broader topics of the crypto civilization, or as Balaji calls it, the network state. So this is definitely an episode that you do not want to miss. All right, we're going to get right into the episode with Balaji. But first, we're going to talk about some of these fantastic sponsors that make this show possible. when you own crypto what really matters is the security and ownership over your assets being a part of the bankless nation means having complete sovereignty over your crypto the easiest way to do that is with a ledger hardware wallet a hardware wall is a little device that manages your private keys for you so you don't have to worry about proper private key management your ledger hardware wallet keeps your private keys private but still lets you have easy access to your crypto.
The combination of my Ledger hardware wallet and Metamask lets me store my crypto assets in the most safe way possible, but still lets me easily access Uniswap or all the other DeFi apps that I use on a daily basis. If you already have a Ledger wallet, you can use the Ledger Live app to participate in some of the money verbs that we discuss in the Bankless program. The Ledger Live app is your headquarters for managing your personal crypto finance. it's a great tool to manage the assets you hold on your ledger as well as receive a portfolio summary of all the assets that you have stored. Using the Ledger Live app you can buy Bitcoin, Ether, and stablecoins and have it sent directly to your ledger hardware wallet skipping over the trusted exchanges and getting your assets into your control.
You can even use the Ledger Live app to swap crypto assets natively inside of the app so you never need to send your crypto assets away from your ledger to make a trade. Buying a ledger is like buying a fire extinguisher. The best time to get one was yesterday, especially if you're doing something silly like holding your crypto in a hot wallet that's always connected to the internet. If you haven't gained full control over your crypto yet, go to the link in the show notes and get your ledger today. If you are looking for the front page of DeFi, look no further than Zerion.io. Zerion is your home base for managing your DeFi portfolios.
Zerion offers a central place for you to engage with all of the DeFi protocols and assets that you engage with on a daily basis but all in one central spot. I've loaded up a wallet and Zerion is giving me the portfolio performance of all the assets in this wallet over time as well as a breakdown of all the assets that I own as well as all of my transaction history that I've ever done in an easy to view fashion. Zerion also lets you invest right into DeFi's best yielding financial opportunities right from their homepage. Zerion also makes it super easy to access interest in DeFi using applications like Compound and Aave in the background.
You can also exchange your assets using the Zerion app using an exchange aggregator in the background to make sure that you always get the best rates. You can even use the Zerion mobile wallet to add your Metamask or Argent or another Ethereum address right into your mobile wallet so you can see your portfolio and engage in DeFi on the go. Here I just loaded up my Argent wallet and now I'm going to load up my Metamask as well. And Zerion will do the same thing. It will add all of my assets and wallets together all in one space and give me a portfolio summary of what's going on. Adding wallets is trivially easy.
If you already have a Metamask, you can get it right into the Zerion app and it can sync with your desktop app as well. And the best part is you can also buy Ether right into the app itself. Use the invest tab to look at all the things that you have invested in as well as other opportunities and coming soon to the Zerion app is the ability to buy and sell your assets straight from your mobile device. So download the app. It works on iOS and Android. Go to zerion.io, plug in your wallets and get a historical report of your portfolio over time, as well as a comprehensive breakdown of all the assets that you own and how much yield they're generating for you.
All right, Bankless Nation, we are super excited to have our next guest. This is Balaji Srinivasan. No one blends the academic plus the startup world plus the venture world quite like Balaji. This is going to be exciting conversation with him. He's got multiple engineering degrees, multiple exits. He was early into Bitcoin. He sold a company to Coinbase as well. I think Balaji lives a decade or two in the future. His superpower, at least it seems to me, is to be able to see things before the rest of us. And we're going to ask just what he sees on the horizon today. Balaji, welcome to Bankless Nation.
Thanks so much for being here. Great to be here. All right, man. So two things just hit all-time highs, Bitcoin market cap and COVID infections in the US. How do you feel about that? Well, so COVID, I haven't been talking about it too much recently simply because it's just become so dumb in the West in many ways. You know, basically, well, I'll say a few things about COVID. First is an interesting thing to do is to Google COVID worldwide deaths. And what you'll see is an interesting graph, which I don't think actually has been circulated that much. It shows this total exponential rise going into May of COVID.
And then it actually does kind of flatten out at roughly 6,000 to 8,000 deaths per day for like the last six months. And with a lot of oscillation that appears to be due in part to, you know, testing mainly on Saturdays and Sundays, or rather not testing on Saturdays and Sundays. And, you know, the thing is that from like the early perspective of COVID, But it wasn't obvious that this was the way people would flatten the curve, namely that the exponential would flatten out at 6,000 deaths per day as opposed to 60,000 deaths per day. Right. That's that's not like an obvious place that it lands up, you know.
And it's actually kind of remarkably flat, given that this is like an average or a summation over the whole world. It's it's like a bunch of different curves that are happening at the same time. You know, some countries are going up and other countries are going down. It's sort of yo-yoing back and forth. That's kind of one aspect. Number two is, you know, look, I'm, you know, as hopeful for the vaccines, you know, as anybody, the Pfizer and Moderna, you know, vaccines that have been announced. But these are sample sizes of like 100 people. We will see what happens when you scale that to a billion.
There's just all this stuff, whether it's manufacturing issues or compliance issues or what have you. compliance. I don't think in the sense of FDA getting, you know, they know enough to not try to block this for dumb reasons, probably, but compliance in the alternative sense of people actually taking it due to, you know, anti-vax or anti-pharma sentiment. And, you know, people might think, oh, the vaccine was rushed, or I believe in vaccines in general, but not this vaccine, whatever. So will you actually get compliance? Will enough people take it? Will it have issues at scale that are not seen in the relatively smaller trials.
I don't know. I mean, the optimistic take is that it'll be fine and COVID will be a memory by this time next year. The pessimistic take, which I think is where I'd probably put more probability away, not 100%, but is that COVID is going to be with us for several years, maybe the better part of the decade. Nobody was expected 10 years of Iraq, right? And nobody expects 10 years of COVID. And yet I think that's something that is a possibility, especially in those places in the world that can't afford a vaccine or won't have great compliance with the vaccine or will resist it for other reasons, whatever, right?
So it's interesting because COVID, I shouldn't say is being stamped out in Asia, but it's just being taken more seriously in Asia. And they just seem to have a functioning public health system that has gotten the thing under control, but not so in the West. So it's not the lesson that anybody wants to hear. Everybody wants to point fingers at this or that political faction in the West, but it feels like there's some systemic, you know, systematic thing that the West is doing incorrectly that Asia is doing right. And that's just sort of hard to copy. It's like, oh, do a social network or a search engine.
And there's a thousand details that Facebook and Google get right. And so copying the way that Asia does it may just not be easily possible. And he said, you know, what is a legacy that COVID will leave behind? You know, this is not original to me. This is one of my, one of my friends who made this comment, but I think it's very much true. You know, 2020 is the year the internet began. by which I mean there's this concept I have of the primary in the mirror for example in the mid 90s the New York Times put its first website up and it's just like a curiosity the New York Times on the web we put some articles up here just to look at this new technology the World Wide Web and it was just a few articles And the primary was still the physical paper and the mirror was the website.
And then over time, sort of like Wile E. Coyote. You ever seen Wile E. Coyote from Lintians? Of course, yeah. Yeah. You know how Wile E. Coyote sort of shifts his weight gradually from one leg to the other like this, right? Right. So gradually shifting weight, you know, imperceptibly, you know, and by degrees over time, the New York Times dot com website became the primary and the paper became the mirror. It basically became a printout, an imperfect rendition of what was on the Web, which was the complete version. And there were certain things, of course, like links to tweets or data science or interactive graphs and so on that were really digital first products.
um, where, you know, the, the paper was, um, was not just, just not going to reflect that, right. At best it could include a URL to go and look at it online. Right. And, uh, even still, I, you can still think of the NY times as well as the other, you know, newspaper side says transitional things because, you know, like they still buy, um, they still buy paper, right. They still have like a, like a lumber operation and an ink operation, you know? You know, there's, you can, you can sort of invert the normal dictum, which is never listen to somebody who still buys ink by the barrel, you know, or never argue with someone who still does, right?
So, so the lasting impact that COVID has though, as I think all these legacy institutions will start to get examined and you'll ask, how do you do the digital first version? Okay. So just as an example, I talked but the NY Times, the primary and the mirror, everything is turning to having the digital version being primary and the physical version being the mirror or secondary or the printout or the expensive version. For example, you know, people used to talk about the digital divide, right? Now that 3 billion people have phones and, you know, probably everybody in the world is going to have a smartphone eventually.
It's on pace to get there. Very poor people have, have, you know, smartphones that were only the province of the extremely wealthy, you know, like, like a relative, you know, within our, within our lifetime. Right. So, so everybody has a phone and digital stuff is cheap. And so that actually means is we're flipping it around so that the actual divide is the physical divide. That is to say, you can make an assembly of a thousand people online very inexpensively, but the physical version is, is, is, is no longer cheap. The physical version is the premium. Okay. So it's flipped. And so that means is every event is digital first.
Every document is digital first. That already happened prior to COVID, but increasingly so. Every court hearing, everything for education, everything for healthcare, the hygiene argument has sort of shifted it. Every meeting is digital first. Um, so everything has been shifted to be digital first. And, um, it's the physical that's the premium, even for really important meetings, quote unquote, or get togethers gatherings, like weddings, right? Um, you know, people are doing Skype weddings, you know, and, and right now, that seems like, you know, kind of a sucky sort of thing. But I think that once you start thinking, okay, what could I do with a virtual reality wedding?
Well, actually, it could be extremely fancy. It could be extremely fancy and it could be extremely cheap. It could be better in some ways. Certainly, like video games or whatever, you can have very interesting visuals. You have perfect control over every pixel. Every guest can attend. They can stay the whole time. You know, it's something where, you know, look, I'm not arguing that people won't still want physical weddings, but the digital wedding will be one-tenth or one-one-hundredth as expensive and pretty good, and the physical wedding will be like extremely deluxe. It'll be like the difference between saying, oh, my God, they had a wedding in, you know, that destination wedding, that really fancy location.
Wow, that must have been expensive. It'll be like that. The physical version will be expensive. Hence the physical divide. That's what you mean by the start of the internet being 2020. It's basically like, and that's very weird for us to think about because most people think, oh yeah, the internet, that's sort of old technology. I mean, that's been around for most of my life. But you're saying that previously it was not part of the fabric of our lives in the way it's about to be over the next, over the coming decades. Correct. That's right. So, you know, you can call it the internet flippening.
It's like the internet was just learning to be what it could mature into up to the point we are getting to now. And that's the legacy of COVID. COVID is pulling that into the now. It's pulling the future into now at an accelerated rate. That's right. And I think social distancing caused more social networking. So Balaji, Ryan started off this asking about like, well, the COVID infections in BTC, both are at an all-time high. And the reason why we wanted to start this podcast off is to talk about the juxtaposition, because there's not just only that is extremely juxtaposed, but it seems to be the fabric of society is moving into the extremes, right?
The distrust in institutions and the banding together of different ideologies has created a very polarizing world. And we wanted to get you on the podcast to talk about how you are seeing this distrust in institutions be filled. There's a void that is left by these institutions. How is society coming to terms with this void that is being left? What is scarce today is trust, but what's abundant is computation. And so the rapprochement that we're going to have is we're going to substitute computation for trust everywhere that we can. So what does that mean? Well, so, you know, an obvious version of that is like Bitcoin, right, in the sense that or Ethereum blockchains in general, where you have somebody who is, you know, Democrat or Republican, they're Sunni or Shiite, they are, you know, Chinese or Japanese, they're Turkish or Greek, they're, you know, Protestant or Catholic, they're on one or the other side of some historical divide, right?
But despite all the things they don't agree on, they do agree on the state of the Bitcoin blockchain, on the state of the Ethereum blockchain. And not just do they agree on the state of it, they agree on the state of it not just like in a, oh, yeah, it's true that the sky is blue today. They agree on the state of something that is extremely materially and financially important, which is the kind of thing that people tend to have political arguments over. Scarcity is what causes conflict. So we have an example of something where computation has sort of forced, you know, that's where global consensus is now feasible.
In this environment where everybody is kind of, you know, advocating for their own thing and they've got these politically constructed truths, into the gap is coming crypto. And over time, that's actually where facts are all, all facts are on chain. If it's not on chain, it's not true. That's a very deep point. I can drill into that. There's a lot I can say about that. I want to dig into that for a second, but just to clarify one point that you made. So you said computation is getting cheap. I think people understand that, of course, that are listening, right? Like Moore's Law, these sorts of things.
We've observed this over our lifetimes. But you also said trust is becoming more scarce. Why? What has fundamentally happened in the past 30 years, let's call it, to shake our trust in the institutions that we as a society formerly trusted? I'm probably a little bit older than you. You know, I was a teenager in the 90s. And I remember, you know, before like the internet became very mainstream. You know, probably some of your listeners are in their 20s and may not have that much of a memory of that. But essentially, you know, in that time, even in the 90s, you really didn't hear from that many people.
You heard from your parents. You heard from your teachers. You heard from, you know, the people who were on TV or, you know, you picked up the newspaper. But the number of different people that you heard from was fairly limited. And it was actually a big deal to be on TV. It was a big deal to have a broadcast license. That was like a regulated thing. And so the thing about it was there just weren't that many voices online. Not voices online. There weren't any voices contending for your attention. because there were relatively few of them. They had come into some sort of consensus on their own.
Now, you know, really you can push it all the way back. 1950, I think was peak centralization. And as you move forward and backward in time, things get more quote unquote decentralized or polarized. Okay. So, so in many ways, it's sort of a mirror moment, you know, we're more similar to the 1800s than we are to the 1950s in many ways. But, you know, so for example, you have like the advent of cable news and the advent of CNN and, you know, like the repeal of the fairness doctrine, all those kinds of things allowed for more opinions to be on, you know, on the air. And then things, of course, started to accelerate with the internet.
And especially I'd say blogs in the early 2000s, suddenly you started to hear from way more voices, way, way, way more voices than, you know, microblogging and social media. And, you know, initially with Facebook and Twitter, those sort of started in, you know, like Facebook started at Harvard, you know, Twitter started in SF. And they started among social networks that pretty much agreed with each other. You know, Facebook, for example, is basically taking colleges and then high schools and putting them online. And so there were implicit mores because you could only friend somebody who is at your same institution and so on and so forth.
I think a critical moment was, you know, September 26, 2006, when Facebook networked the networks. Okay. And that was a moment where growth really took off. It was a huge experiment. It was very not obvious that it was going to work, that people would friend each other outside of these institutions because people were sort of cautious about doing that. Oh, will a stranger impact me online? That was like, there's a natural caution or sort of suspicion of strangers in the 90s and the early 2000s. It was weird to do online dating. There's going to be weirdos online, et cetera, right? And then there's a period of about 10, you know, five to 10 years of like the open internet.
Yay. And everybody was just online and they're like, Hey, this social media thing is great. Let's everybody connect with each other. So like from 2006 to roughly 2015. And then of course what happened is by the early 2010s, a lot of people, you know, actually this happened even pretty quickly with Twitter. You know, in the Middle East, voices had been even more constrained than they were in the US. So, you know, the impact of Facebook and Twitter was like, boom, gasoline, you know, on a flame, like all these people could speak where they never could speak before. And once you have multiple voices, that's actually what causes distrust.
And the reason is, if there's only one voice and it's broadcast, then no one can argue with the voice, right? But if there's N voices and they're all arguing with each other, people start to be – they look left, they look right, they look up, they look down. They're trying to figure out who to make sense of. Maybe they make sense of nobody. Maybe they side with one person. More voices, more people with the microphone, more distrust. So I think that was a fundamental thing that caused it. The other thing that caused it was once you network the networks, all of these mores and assumptions – I mean, you know, before some, you know, steel worker in Pennsylvania, rural Pennsylvania, and some, you know, like, I don't know, a graphic designer in LA could blissfully ignore each other's thoughts for their entire lives.
They would never know what each other thought about various things. um you know the the the press would never think of it as you know in the 80s or 90s would never think of it as an important thing to go and you know maybe once in a while they might do a lifestyle story but they're not going to like take a live feed of this guy's thoughts and pipe it into the other guy's thoughts it just wouldn't happen there's there's scarce you know time on television you had a 30 minute you know news segment or whatever right um but now those people can find out what each other thinks and they can't stand it.
They can't stand each other. And the implicit sort of boundaries that had been set up before were just totally collapsed. And it's as if, you know, you took these 3 billion people and you just teleported them into a battlefield, you know, which is the internet. And you took down all borders and all boundaries. No one has a home. They're just, boom, just transplanted to the plains of, you know, Megiddo, where Armageddon is arising. And that's kind of what happened in the 2010s. I find this so counterintuitive because basically what you're saying is this open communication protocol that we call the internet that we think is so great actually destroyed societal consensus.
But I think the way you're talking about it makes sense, Balaji, but is that a good thing? Because it wasn't that these people didn't have the opinions that they had necessarily, It's just that they couldn't express them. Is this move to decentralization from the 1950s forward a good thing or a bad thing? Or is it just neutral? Is it just a thing that happens and we're just in the trend? Well, so I actually – so I do think much of it is good. I think my macro is the internet increases variance. Okay? So that's a macro concept that you can apply to many, many different sectors. For example, you go from 30-minute sitcoms to 30-second TikTok videos and 30-episode Netflix binges.
You go from a 9-to-5 job for the rest of your life to a fail son who stays in mom's basement or a 20-something-year-old tech billionaire. You go from the nightly news where everybody kind of has this normy mainstream opinion to extremely well-researched things where people are reading Google books and PDFs from scientific outlets where you can educate yourself to this incredible level or to the dumbest of online conspiracy theories. And so in every area, what you see is the internet increases variance, even in areas that you wouldn't normally think of. For example, if you look at the data on Uber and Lyft rides relative to taxi rides, they have both much longer and much shorter rides than taxis do.
OK, because it was more convenient to call a new borough lift, sometimes people will take it for a block where they wouldn't normally call a taxi. But also because you you can calculate how much the cost is going to be, you know, and people are sometimes used as a car replacement. They also tend to take longer rides. So it's taken that distribution and just pulled it apart and increased variance. You see this with book sales, with Amazon, the long tail of books, the number of different kinds of books that people are reading, the number of different channels. So why does that happen? First, there's the kind of empirical observation, the internet increases variance.
Why is that happening? Well, the answer is whenever you disintermediate, you remove the mediator, and nodes can connect directly to each other. And that mediator is like an averaging, you know, force, right? It rejects some things, it forces things into like a middle of the road kind of thing, you know, like the person who used to decide who got on TV would de facto enforce a sort of normative consensus, you know? The person who would decide was on the front page of the newspaper. All of those, quote, gatekeepers basically were mediating things. And what they were doing was they were capping the upside because you'd read some dumb, I don't know, Maureen Dowd column or whatever.
She's still, I think, writing columns, but you'd read some dumb column or whatever in the 90s, but it wouldn't be like a completely lunatic conspiracy theory. On the other hand, it also wouldn't be extremely insightful. It'd just be mediocre. And so what's happened is we've gotten more downside and more upside. it. So everything I just described with everybody sort of meeting, you know, to, to, for this Armageddon battle online, I think is absolutely real. But of course, at the same time, we have open source and we have Google and we have, you know, like incredible amounts of, of learning and content and commerce and so on that's happened thanks to the internet.
Right. And, you know, like just like yourself and myself, or most of the people we've met on Twitter, you met all of these really interesting, smart, intelligent, valuable people that enrich your life online. So there's a huge win to it. There's also a huge loss. And what I think happens is, I have this concept that all progress actually happens on the Z-axis. What I mean by that is, for example, you start a company because you're tired of some existing bureaucracy, right? You leave Google, you leave, well, you know, you leave IBM. Okay. You leave Microsoft, then you leave Google, then you leave Facebook.
And each time what's happening is you leave the bureaucracy, you start something, often it fails. If it doesn't fail, you start getting more employees and, you know, you start building up, you know, processes. And eventually what happens, there's a flip from burn rate to bust number. Do you know those two things, burn rate and bust number? Like burn rate I don't know about number. Okay. So burn rate is like how much money you're burning. Bus number is how many people can get hit by a bus whether your company's still alive, right? And it's colloquial or whatever, right? But point being that early in a startup, every single person must be indispensable, okay?
Because you're just trying to control costs. They all have to be total killers, unique, amazing, amazing people. At a certain point, once you've gotten the scalable business model where you're repeating it and you've gotten to 10 or 100 million revenue and you need to get to a billion. At a certain point, now having seen this many times as a venture capitalist and angel investor and having done it myself a few times, what happens is you start having to go from burn rate to bust number where everybody goes from being completely irreplaceable to you're not doing your job as CEO if they're not all replaceable.
Because if one person can get sick or quit or something like that, it had crashed the site and you would not be doing your duty by your now millions of customers. So that is when bureaucracy starts. And in the best sense, what bureaucracy is, is sort of scaling the founder's instincts. The founder kind of writes down what they would do And now you can kind of act as if you were Jeff Bezos or whatever, you know, doing customer service himself, you know, and that sort of scales themselves. And then eventually it becomes Jeff Bezos' designate scaling themselves. You know, that manager says how the manager would do it and on and on.
Right. So in a sense, a properly functioning bureaucracy is like a set of algorithms that humans rather than machines execute. Okay. And it's meant to achieve a result and it's meant to sort of scale what that human would otherwise do themselves, but they can't anymore. And it's meant to sort of put a level of intermediation between, you know, this one unique person rather than having a unique person, anybody or any, any one of a class of people can now come into the role and they can do this legal role or they can do the system and role and amazon.com won't crash if one person quits. Okay. Now, what happens is as you do this, this necessary thing, it's like the transition from a single cellular to a multicellular organism.
As you do this necessary thing, as you introduce this bureaucracy, you introduce stultification, you introduce deadening in a sense of individual initiative. How could you not? Because you're making everybody indispensable, or rather, you're making people dispensable. You have to do this. And as you make people dispensable, their alienation from their job increases because they realize, oh, someone else could do this. I'm not that unique. They don't really need me. I can go and do something else. This isn't that important, and so on. And you can stave this off to some extent as the thing keeps growing, right?
But that's sort of like a necessary thing that happens. And then what happens is you quit because of the bureaucracy, okay? Now, that seems at first to just be a loop where we just came back to where we started, where you quit from the bureaucracy and you rebuild the bureaucracy, right? I call this the libertarian founder rebuilds the state because you find that if you're a small L libertarian or whatever, you find that you actually need to – there's reasons that various progressive or conservative or whatever things are out there, the larger the organization, you start to realize you need to actually have some of these things.
People want a bureaucracy. The first or the 10th employee is simply not the same psychological mindset as a 10,000 in terms of risk reward. Okay, all right. This, Balaji, this is why the pendulum swings back and forth throughout time, throughout history, from centralization to decentralization. But I think what you're saying is, right? I think what you're saying is, if we talk about decentralization, is it good or bad? Well, like what you're saying is there's going to be winners and losers because the 1950s were very good for someone who is average, right? Whereas this more decentralized world is not really built for people, for kind of the average.
It's not built for the bureaucracy. Centralization, even kind of the corporate example you gave, it optimizes for the average. But in this decentralized world, we can sort of optimize is for the exceptional. And the exceptional people and the exceptional individuals, exceptional projects really stand out. Like someone like in the crypto space, like Vitalik, you know, teenager, sort of created a white paper, right? Exceptional individual. And his true talents were able to be fully expressed in this decentralized permissionless world, only possible by the internet. Is that kind of what you're saying?
Yeah. I mean, though, I would say one thing that's very important is I think the right metaphor is not a pendulum because that sort of makes it seem like there isn't any progress. I think the metaphor I think about is a corkscrew. Okay. So if you look down on, right, as you look down on the corkscrew, it looks like the dial is just turning around and around. You go, you know, 12 all the way to six, back to 12 and so on, which is similar to the pendulum metaphor. It seems like you're just coming back to where you are. Right. But if you think about, you know, IBM to Microsoft, to Google, to Facebook, to, you know, Bitcoin and Ethereum, you're making progress there.
You know, like there is a stack of technologies you're building up where you can do more things with more, you know, and as you go and you, you know, centralize, decentralize, you know, you've seen this within computing as well, right? You go from mainframes to personal computers, to cloud, to mobile, to, you know, like, you know, now decentralizing with the, I mean, mobile is in sense, both centralized and decentralized, right? Because, you know, all the services are up in the cloud and the local thing is on your phone. And now, you know, back to crypto where, you know, you bring your private keys locally, progress is happening.
So that's what I'd say there. On your other point, yes, absolutely. Vitalik's a great example of this. I would also note that there are folks who were sort of propped up by that existing system who are now falling as a consequence, you know, and you know, that's like the, you know, in the 1950s, what did you do? You went and you sat on an assembly line and you pushed the same button every day for 30 years. Okay. In 2020, what do you do? You're pushing a different key every second on your keyboard. Right. And so like the, you know, just, just the level of innovation and difference and creativity and novelty you need to put out each day is just very different.
Now, something else to think about is the 20th century was exceptional in terms of how average making and homogeneous it was. That is to say, if you go farther backwards in time, okay, you know, like the idea of there being one telephone company and two superpowers and three television stations was actually a massive destruction of diversity of different ideologies of different cultures, different ways of thinking leading into kind of the homogeneity of 1950 and these two just Geiger empires going at it. Okay. If you go farther backwards in time, you know, you go to the 1800s, you know, like there's Frederick Jackson Turner's concert, the frontier thesis, the U S frontier closed in 1890.
And if you go further backwards, you have the time of the robber barons, where everybody was able to start companies. Robber barons, by the way, today you'd call them entrepreneurs or founders because they built oil, they built railroads, they built mines, they built all the stuff that helped build a country, at least if you're in the US. And you also had private banking where people could issue currencies, you know, very similar to crypto. You had, you know, sort of these communes, which are sort of like the intentional houses. So people would just go out West and take a bunch of people and you'd start a commune, like the Oneida commune and whatnot.
That wasn't actually out West, it was kind of upstate New York. Conceptually West, yeah. And yeah, conceptually West, basically out to the middle of nowhere, pretty much. And so the thinking is that our future is really like our past. You go further backwards in time and a bunch of like pseudonymous people started a new government. That was the 70s, 70s, right? And one of the reasons for that is communications technology at that time imposed necessary decentralization. Okay. You had lags of when a message could get from point A to point B. The telegraph brought people closer together, but before the telegraph, okay, you had the lag of physical mail getting somewhere.
If you go further backwards, you didn't have photos getting somewhere and so on. So the ability to coordinate people was just fundamentally limited. You had to build the whole thing as a decentralized system, and your ability to enact a very centralized thing was less. As you came into the 20th century, you got mass media and you got mass production. And so the ideologies that preponderated like nationalism and communism and kind of the fusion that was the US, right? Democracy slash capitalism. These were all ideologies that sort of justified control of gigantic numbers of people. Okay. And, and, you know, justified control in the sense that those people heard those ideologies, like, okay, that's legitimate for you to control me to at least some extent of sort of like a self-referential loop.
Right. But, but now I think what you've got, thanks to technology shifting, thanks to the fact that, you know, Instagram with 12 people can defeat Kodak with 12,000. thanks to the fact that WhatsApp with 55 people can change text messaging for billions of people, you have new ideologies that are becoming feasible and older ideologies that are really showing their age because they were built under a time when just assumptions were different. And this is the technological determinist thesis, by the way, which is every ideology you can think of has always been around. What's changed is the technology to make them feasible or unfeasible.
I want to take a step back and kind of make sure our listeners are following through the cycles of conversations that we've gone through, because there's a through line here to everything. And I want to make sure that the listener understands how we got here. We started this conversation talking about how there was a, in the 50s, you talked about how that was peak centralization. There was like one canonical newscaster, there was one canonical or a few canonical sources of truth. And we didn't really have this distrust in institutions that we have today. And then you kind of cited how the internet offers variance to the world.
And you cited that it was a good thing. The internet is a democratizing platform. If you have a voice, you can get a voice on the internet. You can create your own blog. Now, you don't need to have to listen to the one canonical source of truth. There are new sources of truth that are perhaps different and alternative and also right and then also perhaps not right. There's fake news and there's real news. But for better or for worse, the internet creates every version of everything, and some versions will be bad and some versions will be good. Either way, we have more people able to have voice.
It's a democratizing technology. And as a result of that, we've lost the signal, right? To some degree, some people have lost the signal, right? The absence of one trusted source of information means that it's harder to find truth, right? It's harder to take trust in these legacy institutions because in some instances, the legacy institutions are being proven wrong and they're also being proven right. But as a result of these democratizing technologies, we are losing our faith in previous institutions. And you've gone through a number of iterations of how the world has responded to this. Regardless of our lack of trust in institutions, there still seems to be some progress.
And we can take an evolution in Silicon Valley tech companies to illustrate some progress forward into the point where you cited, like now we have these things called Bitcoin and Ethereum, and that is also on that same spectrum of progress, right? Like there's cycles of history, revolutions of history. These are all the same patterns. And so what me and Ryan want to get to is, okay, so we're in this period of there's a lot of noise, and the people are looking for signal, especially now. And when we see ahead of us, perhaps we only see more noise. In the next revolution of history, in the next turning of the corkscrew, where do we get that signal?
Like, how do we as a decentralized group of people find consensus, find truth? Where does that come from in the future? Great question. So, you know, one of my sort of one-liners, which I think you also found interesting is, you know, crypto anarchy is interesting, but I prefer crypto civilization. You know, I thought that was clever. You know, right. Okay. So here's what I mean by that. If you were sort of to rank order states of being, right, you know, the worst of all states is sort of tyranny combined with anarchy. That's like Venezuela or to a lesser extent, significantly lesser extent, but still not zero, like San Francisco.
For example, in San Francisco, you park on the side of the street and you're one minute over and you'll get like $100 plus parking ticket. But you can like defecate in the middle of the street and nothing will happen to you. And so that's the tyranny on the law-abiding, like the poor Uber driver or whatever who is just getting crushed by these fines. And it's actually a really big deal for them because it's like you can take away their – it's very unfortunate. You can take away their entire day's earnings, one of those tickets. But they see the guy who's not working at all just basically have – doing drugs or attacking someone in the middle of the street.
nothing happens to them. So that's like, that's like the worst of all worlds. Then you have actually just pure anarchy where there's like no government. And that sucks as well, but at least you're not, you know, prevented from doing things by the state. You know, you can self-organize. This is a little bit like Russia in the nineties in some ways. There were gangs, what have you, but the oppressive state wasn't there to the same extent. And so the state was at least absent. It wasn't like actively promoting, you know, disorder and tyranny. Then you go up one level and you have crypto anarchy and crypto anarchy is anarchy in, in the physical world in some ways, but you've got a digital order, you know, it's like the apocalypse, but with internet.
Okay. And you know, in some ways that's what COVID is, right? The apocalypse, but with internet, at least it was in the early, early, early months. And, and that's actually what Bitcoin's like disaster model is, crypto disaster models. So crypto anarchy is you now take anarchy and you put a layer on top of it, which is you have contracts, you have a realm in the cloud where there is order and there is logic and there are rules and those rules are enforced by encryption and so on and so forth. Even if, you know, the land around you is, if not Mad Max, you know, like the US this summer, you know, and over the last few months has certainly not been normal.
You know, there's many shades of gray, of course, between like totally copacetic and Mad Max, but it hasn't been normal, you know? And yet, like the internet still works, cell phones still work. There's still incredible degree of order in the cloud. And now you go up on a level and now you talk about crypto civilization, where you say, look, yes, crypto anarchy is better than anarchy, which is in turn better than an arc of tyranny, but I prefer crypto civilization. Crypto civilization is I can bring a group of people together to get to Mars. Okay. I can bring a group of people together to build an integrated circuit or a hardware device.
Cause it's actually still pretty hard to, to build those things, you know, like semiconductors, like the, the actual physical manufacturing still requires the coordination of fairly large numbers of people. Eventually with the robotics, maybe that goes away, but we're not yet there. And so how do we actually build a crypto civilization? Well, there's a lot of pieces to this. I've thought about lots of pieces. I have a book coming out called The Network State. If you want to get updates on it, just subscribe at biologis.com, sign up. It's all free. Um, but, but let me just touch on a few pieces of this.
So the first thing you need is you need some source of absolute truth. Um, I, I give like one, I shouldn't say one cheer. That's not exactly right. I give partial credit to the postmodernists who, you know, have essentially the logic of everything is a power relationship, deconstruct everything. It's all situationally or contingently, you know, true. If you have power, you can change what is true. You can divide truths into a spectrum of political truths on one side and technical truths on the other side. So like a political truth is, you know, who is the CEO or where is the border or what is this money worth?
Okay. And those are things where if you can write enough software to people's brains, you can change who is the leader of some organization or where the border is or what the money is worth. Because if enough of those people agree on it, that thing changes. On the other side of the spectrum are technical truths, which are truths about genetics or physics or mathematics, like what is the genome of this virus and how many microns in diameter is it and how quickly does it replicate? Okay. It's like social consensus versus like scientific truth. Yes, that's right. And the thing about a technical truth, the fundamental difference is a technical truth exists independent of human brains, whereas a political truth can be changed by affecting human brains.
COVID-19 was a huge shock to America because so much of the US has been set up to simply assume that everything was about a political truth. Okay. It's all about lawyers and PR firms and politics and media and Hollywood. And, you know, it's all just like convincing other people to do things versus, um, even finance, even wall street, like is it's the best of the East coast institutions or legacy institutions in some ways, because it's at least zero sum, you know? Right. And so it's all just convincing people to convince people. And that's all fine until there's something that comes in that cannot be convinced because, you know, the coronavirus, and I mentioned this, it's highly non-compliant with regulations.
It is willing to commit murder, you know, and, you know, it cannot be regulated. It's fully decentralized, blah, blah, blah. It crosses borders without the passport, right? Exactly. That's right. So you can't bomb it. You can't regulate it. It doesn't get demoralized by negative press coverage. It has no bank account to freeze or seize. It is just this pure force of nature. And it's something where you realize that much of the U.S., much of the West, it's what I call founding versus inheriting. Much of the West is basically just operating on inherited institutions. It's inherited names, it's inherited fortunes, but it's inherited institutions in the same way that someone who's like the 10th generation scion of a factory, they can collect a check from their trust fund.
Maybe they can tell the factory owner, hey, make t-shirts with this color rather than that color. But they certainly wouldn't be able to repurpose the factory to go from task A to task B, let alone build a new factory from scratch. And that's kind of the problem that COVID presented to Western institutions is it had to do something new. They had to do something new, which they were incapable of doing. As opposed to folks like, let's say, Bezos or Zuckerberg, who have founded something from scratch, like gigantic multi-million person logistics operations or multi-billion person networks, communication networks.
Those are very difficult things to do. Those are from scratch. Whatever you may think of them, they are the kinds of people who can organize large scale things from nothing. And so the point being that these inherited institutions not set up to deal with technical truths, founders do have to deal with technical truths. And so one of the things to think about is how do you get people to agree on technical truths? Now, a big aspect of crypto is it took things that were previously wholly, meaning totally political truths, and started putting them into the realm of technical truths. So like who holds what money?
Well, now we've actually put some cryptography around that. And is that not just the inevitable march of humanity? Is that not the thing that we do? we put things into technical truths and then we build off of that i don't know if that's the inevitable march of humanity i think that um you know there's significant regressions right so if you have you have you studied the renaissance in detail or do you know how much you know about it not since ap euro history no okay yeah so like i mean this is this is a little bit of an exaggeration or you might quibble with this, but, you know, imagine if, you know, like a server went down, like Google went down or something like that, and just all server copies were deleted and someone had to sort of restore what they knew of Google from like one person's Git checkout.
Okay. That's kind of like, you know, after, you know, the Roman empire fell, you know, people copied these manuscripts and it was like a big deal to find like oh another piece of source code from this ancient culture that was like way ahead of us and it was like copying of those like old pieces of sources like whoa they were so much smarter man i was able to recover this we would never be able to do this one from scratch right and so like you sort of piece together like a thousand years later the tattered remnants of what had been a great civilization and then your people were able to rebuild, but it really was like, you know, a thousand year setback, you know, which is, which is a big deal.
Now there's folks who will argue, oh, you know, the dark ages wasn't really dark. There was progress in the medieval era, et cetera. But you know, there's a reason that the Renaissance was a Renaissance is that they were like, wow, those, those old people were actually smart and more advanced than us in some ways. Yeah. So I wouldn't say it's a guarantee of civilizational progress. I do think there are ideologies that can crash a civilization and take it down. Hey guys, there is so much left in this interview. Coming up next, Balaji gets into the differences between what he calls a crypto civilization versus what some people call crypto anarchy.
We also ask him the question, is there room in the world for internet powered coordination groups that have the ability to grow to the size and the influence of a nation state? how a national consciousness might develop among this group of people, how this new nation might generate GDP and revenue for itself, and also why virtual reality is important in the establishment of this new nation. We're going to get into all of those topics. It's such an exciting interview. But first, we're going to take a moment to talk about some of these fantastic sponsors that make this show possible. Bankless Nation.
Do you want to go fully bankless but in the real world? Monolith is the DeFi account that you need. It wraps your ETH address in a bankless Visa card and it does so much more. It closes the loop from fiat to DeFi. So you can onboard fiat to DAI on Monolith with zero fees. Then you can convert that DAI to ADAI, which is an interest-bearing savings account. Again, zero fees. And then you can spend that interest in the real world on a Visa card. so you can finally buy your cup of coffee with interest earned in DeFi. Guys, this is magic. This is the closest thing to the holy grail crypto card, and Monolith gives you all of it.
You need to download the app at monolith.xyz to get your bankless Visa card. It's optimized for European listeners. They'll be coming to the U.S. soon. And when you get that Visa card, the Monolith card, tweet about it when you do. I love seeing people unpackaging their beautiful bankless Visa cards. and makes me realize that the revolution is here, search Monolith in the App Store. Y-Earn is DeFi's first self-building project on Ethereum, focused on producing products for those who are interested in earning yield in DeFi. Y-Earn's various products are all built to suit each individual investor's preferred level of risk, from various vault strategies that leverage DeFi tokens to the safer Earn system, which relies on stablecoins.
Vaults are aggressive yield farming robots each with a unique strategy that is designed to maximize the yield of the deposited asset. Y-Earn employs some of the most informed developers in DeFi to keep the vault strategies updated with the various yield farming opportunities on Ethereum. For customers who are more risk adverse the Y-Earn's Earn product may be for you. Earn is a yield aware dynamic money market that automatically seeks the best interest rates across the various DeFi protocols and regularly migrates your deposited stable coins between the DeFi protocols that are returning the best yield at the present moment.
Y-earn is a system that is just a little over four months old so things are still very much an experiment. However this hasn't stopped people from depositing over 700 million dollars worth of assets into the Y-earn system in order to find yield on Ethereum. Perhaps the people that deposited all this money were tired of constantly making daily transactions to follow the best DeFi interest rates, and maybe the gas fees that they were paying ended up eating too much into their profits. With Y-Earn, it doesn't remove the risk of these various protocols that it leverages, but it does remove the overhead of constantly trying to make sure you're finding the best yield, and also so that you don't have to pay for gas to switch up your assets.
Check out the products that Y-Earn has to offer at yearn.finance, that's Y-E-A-R-N.finance, which they also have a nice statistics page to see what other people are doing. So back to this idea of a crypto civilization, Balaji, right? So some in the crypto space, I think, are content with this idea of Bitcoin citadels and crypto anarchy, right? But you're advocating for something more, something that I think David and I in Bankless have talked about often. We've talked about the purpose of crypto is to solve human coordination problems, particularly the difficult to solve coordination problems.
So what kind of things, what is a crypto civilization? What sorts of things can we build on top of these trust machines? Is there room for completely self-sovereign internet-powered organizations that could even become as complex and as interesting and as coordinated, maybe as powerful as a nation state? One thing I just want to talk about with like Citadels and so on. I mean, one issue is we've seen so many post-apocalyptic movies that people have this sort of romanticized idea of what that is. But all the actors in those movies have perfect hair and makeup and, you know, they go off set, they've still got a flush toilet and, you know, whatever.
And the thing is that in real life, you have supply chains, and lots and lots of things that you just completely take for granted. Supply chains are very important, and supply chains in their own way are a social dependency until you have robotic autarky, which I do think can come. Okay. I'm not, I'm not against that, but you have to actually realize that is itself a serious, huge 20 year plus technological project to have like robotic autarkic farms and mines, you know, where robots would mine and farm everything for you. That's becoming possible. Go look at like vicarious.com. Look at Rio Tinto.
Look at some of the stuff that Boston Dynamics has done, of course. And you'll see how, how, how much robotics has advanced in terms of grasping and packing and, you know, remote mining and stuff, but it's a big deal, right? So supply chains exist. Citadels are still unrealistic from that standpoint because you have social dependencies. So crypto civilization would basically mean using crypto to sort of rebuild civilization. And when I say rebuild, by the way, there's a saying that's very famous from the early age of the internet or the commercial internet, which is there's only two ways to make money online that I know of, unbundling and bundling.
Okay. And so what sort of happened with social networks is we unbundled the nation state, but I think what's going to happen is we're going to rebundle the nation state into a concept that I'm calling the network state. And the network state starts, you know, a concise definition is a network state is a virtual or VR social network with an integrated cryptocurrency, a sense of national consciousness, and a plan to crowdfund territory. Okay. And so there's a bunch of things there. I'll unpack them. But essentially, it starts with the observation that if you think about the emergence of BTC and ETH, right, 10 years ago, Bitcoin didn't even exist.
Or okay, it existed in 2009. I should say 12 years ago, Bitcoin didn't exist. but basically by about 2013 it was listed on bloomberg and cnbc um you know there's a price ticker for this pure internet phenomenon and it was it was the first of its kind like purely from the internet holy cow you know uh as opposed to something that had been uploaded from the offline world right this was a digital native object like the thing we were talking about at the beginning the primary in the mirror this was primarily digital it had no offline analog right And so being listed there was this huge win. And now, of course, we don't think of that as that remarkable, but it was a big deal.
And in the same way, something I've thought a lot about is if you look at the list of countries in the United Nations, there's 233 countries in the United Nations. Just off the top of your head, do you know how many of them have a population less than 1 million? I would definitely say most of them. Yeah, the majority. But I'm not sure how many. It's about 30% have a population less than 1 million and about 60% have a population less than 10 million. So the reason that's counterintuitive is most people live in big countries. Okay. So most people live in China, India, you know, the U.S., right?
Even Russia, Germany, France, the U.K. So you think, okay, yeah, most countries are kind of like that. Actually, no. Most countries are small countries. And what that suggests is, okay, well, look, if a million people in one place, that's a nation state, it's got borders, we call it Estonia, right? It's got a seat on the UN Security Council, it's got a flag, it's got recognition from these other governments. Could you take a million people online and if they develop a sense of national consciousness, which, to be clear, could take years or decades or even longer? I'm not saying it's like an overnight thing.
But if they do that, well, you know, there's a concept of national self-determination. Could they not crowdfund territory, right? In the same sense that the, you know, Estonians can afford Estonia, right? Like in the sense of like, I haven't looked at the actual deeds and land records, but, you know, it is likely that those million Estonians own most of Estonia, right? a million people could crowdfund territory and they could start by doing it with enclaves so that is to say they don't all have to be next to each other at the beginning um if you think about google or facebook uh have you ever been to a google office i have not i have not not oh really wow crypto really is a different culture you know you it overlaps with tech but crypto is to internet tech as internet tech was to desktop tech.
Yeah, totally. Right. So, so, you know, there's, it's interesting to hear you say that because, you know, I sort of straddle both worlds, right. And there's, you know, just like there are folks who made the transition from desktop to the internet, but yeah. Okay. So you have not actually visited major tech companies. Have you ever been to any of them? Nope. No. Wow. I came, I came from a world of physical therapy. Oh, wow. Okay. That's so interesting. And, and I'm glad to, I'm glad to hear it. Okay. So I'll, I'll say something which you may not know. Okay. So if you have a Google badge, right.
And you visit a Google office anywhere in the world, it's like a little piece of Google. It's a fractal polity. Okay. You walk in and the branding is just so the couches are just so there might be some twist for like, you know, Google Spain or whatever. Maybe it's some of the signage is in the local language or something like that. Right. But it's recognizably Google everywhere in the world. your login works, your internet connection works. You're allowed to be there. Yeah, you're allowed to be there. Exactly, right? Like a WeWork. I do have that familiarity with WeWork. Okay, exactly. And in the same sense, to give one chair to defend the honor of the multinational, this is also why the frequent flyer actually likes Starbucks and McDonald's and so on.
you know, it's, it's like, okay, I've got a familiar experience. Yeah. Maybe it's not going to be that great, but I know they're going to burn the coffee just the way that I know it's going to be burned. You know, it's, it's a devil I know. Right. And so like my day is not going to get worse, right. So speak, right. So, so you just bound downside by going there. And actually that's often a valuable thing to do. Right. Plagy, it's, it sounds like what you're talking about right so like like going back to this funding and territory that sort of thing national consciousness vr i think those are the three things he said are part of a network stake it sounds like you're proposing like the new ico but it's it's not an initial company it's initial country offering well like we could actually like fund one of these countries to be so i i have a friend who uh he's american he found out that um through you know his uh ancestry he has a small portion Luxembourgian, actually, in his family relations.
So he went through the process and applied to the country of Luxembourg. And now he and his family actually have a Luxembourg citizenship, which gives them access to Europe. And it seems very much to me, as I was hearing his story, and I think Luxembourg has a population of like 600,000 people, that this is a country that almost like punches above its world class. It almost like acts like a startup in that it is looking to attract citizens. It's almost like, you know, Dave and I, and I'm sure you have, Balaji, you've read The Sovereign Individual, right? That whole thesis that nation states- I think I probably got a lot of people in crypto Twitter onto that, by the way, if you go back and look.
Yeah, I'm sure you did. And like, but the idea is basically- I got it from Teal. I got it from Teal. So, you know, that's legacy. Give credit to Peter. Yeah, and the idea, thank you, Peter. And the idea is basically that nation states would have to be competitive for population sets, essentially. And I see that in Luxembourg. Is that kind of what you're saying that a digital nation would essentially do is attract some population? And like, I get kind of the VR part. I think the funding a territory part makes sense, right? Because we've seen sort of ICOs and what crowdfunding can do. What is this national consciousness piece?
How do you get that? So one thing I'd say, let me just talk about a couple of things you said first, just on the ICO bit. Um, the thing about ICOs is, you know, like I think they, I'm mostly negative on them, but not completely. Um, the thing that's good about them is that you can do capital formation and so on. Right. Um, instantly all that stuff. The thing that's bad about them is it's a promise of fast money, you know, and, you know, venture capital has many flaws, but one of the things it evolved over time, which you sort of take for granted when you're in the space is a mechanism to select for people who have ambition more than avarice.
Okay. And what that means is you give them $10 million. And the first thing they do is they don't go and buy a sports car with it or whatever. They're putting it into the business, right? This is almost like But it's incredible to the extent to which that sort of assumed that any deal that I refer to somebody or who is referred to me, we have already done sort of that pre-vetting mechanism to such an extent that you forget how important a vetting mechanism that is to some extent, right? When you just open it up to the whole world, of course, there are crooks. Of course, there are people who just want to get money now, right?
And so one of the big problems with ICOs is too much money upfront versus building it over time. Of course, there's some people who can... Obviously, Ethereum's ICO was great. There's some ICOs that have been great. I'm not against it as a thing. What I think happens, the rapprochement that happens is you bring a lot of venture terms into ICOs to protect investors. So for example, for your lockups and agreements on who can sell when and the equivalence of boards and all the type of stuff. And that's entered into by all participants. So you sort of bring some of those structures in there. Okay.
So that's kind of one thing. The reason I just wanted to push back on that is like starting a new country, it's not a money-making endeavor per se. It is something which is, it's meant to actually get to a level of stability. It's a civilization-making endeavor, you know? How do you build a stable civilization that can get to Mars, that can do brain-machine interface, that can do limb regeneration, that can do reversal of aging and life extension? That's my interest in it. Okay. Go ahead. So is this goal to make, to perhaps like generate a community of online individuals and then somehow crowdfund money to purchase real property somewhere, real land.
Is this a goal to answer one of the original questions that we started this podcast with is where are we going to look to for institutions into the future? It's like, well, our current institutions, our current governments aren't really doing their jobs. And so we will just make our own country and we'll do it ourselves. Is this the goal of this whole thing? Yeah. Yeah, so the thinking is I don't think many institutions that predated the internet will survive the internet. Ooh, interesting. Okay. Including the nation state? Including the nation state. Now, the thing is that there's two ways to get to a network state.
One of them is like a retrofit of an existing nation state, which sort of networkifies it. In the same way that buildings that existed in the 1800s got lighting and electrical power. If you go to the East Coast, have you been to like Boston or something like that, or let alone Europe? You see these old buildings that have, you know, have been retrofitted for power and for lighting, which weren't before, right? Okay. So one way of doing it. And, you know, some examples of network states, good versions, you know, coming from below, coming from the state up to the cloud. Good versions would be like Estonia, you know, like Taiwan, Singapore are fairly, you know, computer savvy and so on.
A bad version arguably is like China and maybe where the U.S. is heading actually in some ways where it's like, you know, the technology is used increasingly to oppress and to track and to surveil. Okay. And, you know, China also does good things with technology. It's not purely dystopian. So, you know, I want to give some credit to them. I know it's not that fashionable to do so. It's not like every single person there is like, oh, my God, get me out. But a lot of people are. A lot of people do want to get out. So it's not the ideal vision. The alternative is rather than having a retrofit where you take an existing state and you kind of retrofit it for the network, you start with the network and then you get the state.
Now, how do you do that? Well, that's going to be a process of degrees. But just to give you some proof points, if you think about HQ2, you think about Tesla and the Geiger factory. So Amazon HQ2 negotiated, Amazon negotiated with New York and Washington, D.C. and other places to say, hey, look, if we bring 25,000 people to your district, what can you give us? Can you give us guarantees that we can build there? Can you tell us that you're not going to impose new regulations or fees on us in the next few years? And cities bid on this. right? And, you know, some that didn't like it, but they did also bid on it.
And, you know, Elon did this with Tesla, like his Geiger factory location, he got places to bid on it. Google did this with Google Fiber. And Boeing did this with its plant and eventually based in South Carolina. And an interesting question is, can we take that out to the confines of mere companies? If we do that for communities, okay, can we organize communities to do collective bargaining with governments. Fascinating. Fascinating. And so the thinking is crypto allows you to have binding online commitments. So if you have a million people who each put in a thousand dollars, that is a billion dollars in provable hard currency.
You could show to the government of XYZ and you say, hey, look, this district over here is totally unoccupied. What if we pay you a billion dollars or you can see we're good for it, or we pay you $100 million a year for 10 years, right? And we set up this smart contract, which is doing so on the condition that self-driving cars are legal here and we can build whatever we want. Balaji, how reasonable do you think that this is? I think it's extremely – nothing I've described violates the laws of physics. Right? You're just talking about a large online crowdfunding, and not even that large because Amazon HQ2 is only 25,000 people.
Well, what are the layers of the stack here? So I'm trying to understand, right? So we've got VR, right? You get that, right? So like, but like the crypto- Let me explain why the VR component, by the way, is important here. Okay, do that. And I also want to hear about kind of the crypto components, right? So from crypto, something like a Bitcoin or Ethereum, obviously, we have some kind of a money or we have a stable coin. And then with DeFi, maybe we get basically kind of financial infrastructure. And then like- Some decentralized. Possibly- going to get involved somewhere. Decentralized identity, that seems to be part of it.
But also the smart contract layer can almost act as a financial law system or a corporate law system, if you will. Are those the base components? Or maybe you could describe some of the components we have now that we didn't previously have that make this even feasible. So very briefly, VR is important because VR architecture is important. This is something which people outside the field don't really know, but architecture has gotten into VR as much as like traditional finance has gotten into crypto. Like it's, it's a fairly big thing in architecture for maybe the obvious reasons. You can walk around the building, you can have clients look at it.
It's just way more real when you can see it in 3D, you know, Oh, that's, you know, that beam is in a weird location. Oh, the window sells a weird location. Oh, the light will come in this window. weird. We should move the window. You can get, you can basically virtualize it. Okay. And what that means is what hasn't been done, but which I want to do is make that a social thing where, you know, John Winthrop in the, in the early, you know, kind of pre pre USA, America had this concept of, you know, the city on a hill. Okay. And, and the idea is that the, the city on a hill was how you'd build this amazing city up on a hill that'd be a beacon for everybody and so on, right?
So the update of that is, I think, of the city in the cloud. We build this thing in the cloud, which is this amazing futuristic city, and we can debug it and argue over it and edit it and fork it and whatever in the cloud. yeah because it's it's bytes right so if if somebody disagrees with it you could fork it and materialize a different version in a different location because when i say materialized by the way um you know vr architecture uh you can get it to autodesk quality right you can have the location of every pipe every wire every outlet um every you know like drop of paint can be fully specified in these VR environments.
In fact, that's how things are constructed in Autodesk. You just need to, I'm not saying it's trivial, okay, but Autodesk does have stuff where you can upload to the cloud and see it in VR as well, right? So existing architecture firms have software for this kind of thing, and there's already energy towards it in that space. It's not just like one person trying to do it. Point being, you can envision getting to a buildable blueprint in VR that you can walk through, not just for a single building, but for a community, not just for a community, but for a town, not just for a town, but for a city.
Okay. And then Songdo, for example, it is possible to build a city. There are contractors out there. In China, I don't know if you've seen some of these videos, they can snap together a train station in nine hours. They can build a skyscraper in like a few days. You can also, by the way, constrain your VR architecture for the purposes of rapid materialization. You know, for example, maybe you only use shipping containers or you only use these kinds of power outlets or these kinds of windows. You know, it's like your library of things that you can drag and drop into place is constrained in a certain way by cost or materials or weather or whatever.
Right. OK. So that's a VR component. What's a crypto component? Crypto component gives you a lot of stuff. It gives you, you know, the currency, of course. It gives you smart contracts for binding kinds of agreements. You can do crypto credentials. This is something I'm going to write more on, but I think it's a missing component for kind of online work is approval, approval, scarcity of credentials that that would actually remove a lot of interviewing time. If you could just prove you knew Python and how well you knew Python and then, you know, jobs just open up to you. You could just then qualify for GitHub tickets that you could do for a hundred bucks.
If you knew Python, right? Crypto is also something which allows people to crowdfund, it allows them to make long-term provable commitments, it allows them to do encryption, it allows people to do hosting, that sort of sovereign hosting, blah, blah, blah, all the things that we know crypto can do. Perhaps most importantly, and I don't think people realize how important this is, something like ENS is a crypto identity that allows you to earn and speak under one name. You can speak under one pseudonym, earn under another pseudonym. Your state name they use on official forums is yet a different one.
And this is something you can use to log into websites. It's something where everything that you do under your online names, you can have it factored and organized, and you basically own all of that digital property. And this lets you exit and move between network states as well, because you've got the self-sovereign identity. So it's like your identity and your wallet and your private keys and so on all kind of coincide. And you mentioned property, right? So we've often talked about Bitcoin and Ethereum, and especially Ethereum being sort of like a digital property rights system that's independent of the nation state.
Would you depend on something like an Ethereum, for example, for property rights for a network state like this? Yeah, potentially. I mean, lots of small countries, by the way, they do what's called dollarization. or harmonization. Have you heard that term? Yes. So dollarization is they peg their currency to the dollar, right? Harmonization is they outsource their regulation to the US rather than doing it themselves. Relatively few countries actually have their totally own sovereign military and sovereign currency and sovereign regulation and so on and so forth. They actually outsource much more than people think.
And so that's in sovereignty truly is a continuum. And you don't have to start. I mean, very few countries did start this way. You don't have to start as like, okay, I'm going to try and be like, you know, invading Iraq or whatever, you know, that's actually probably a stupid idea. You know, what you want to do is start with mutual positive interactions with local governments, where you are, hey, you know, we're just going to build a self-driving car zone over here in this swamp where we're going to take video of it with drones. Nobody's living there. We'll pay you X dollars per year. We'll abide.
And this is critical. Initially, you're just building new towns or new cities, right? Your initial agreement is probably the first 10 or so that you do of these communities. You are abiding by all local laws. you might ask for one. The first one, you don't even ask for an edit. You just show that you can build a town from the cloud, which is amazing. Okay. The second or the fifth or the 15th, you ask for an edit, which is, hey, let us do self-driving cars. Hey, let us fly drones here. You know, hey, let us, let this be a FinTech regulatory sandbox. We can just start a crypto company here. Sort of like, you know, casinos are allowed on some native American land, right?
Hey, let us, you know, do stem cells here. Like stem cells are allowed in Germany, right? You start asking for regulatory breaks where everybody who comes into this special innovation zone is there for the regulatory break for the innovation, and they've all gone in eyes wide open, right? And then with success in that, you push farther, right? And this is the same model, for example, of special economic zones that the UN and World Bank and others are all very familiar with and have endorsed, except it's not focused on taxes per se. What it's focused on is regulation because a tax is a quantitative thing.
It's like, okay, I would have got an X percent. Now I got Y percent. But a regulation is a qualitative thing where it's literally impermissible to do it in the first place, impermissible to use or drive that self-driving car, right? and making it permissible to do something that's impermissible is a binary thing. And that just unlocks something totally different. We've been talking about this network state, this sort of crypto nation, but two things in my mind seem to be missing. The first question is, what is the economic engine of this thing? Is there some sort of incentive structure to contributing?
And then let's get into the social layer of this thing. But first, the economic engine. What powers, every, you know, nation has an economic engine of some sort. What is this nation's economic engine? So I think it's going to be digital labor for digital currency, where the digital labor aspect comes from a digital university. And so the idea is that, you know, cities in the past were begun on the basis of being near rivers or oceans or coal mines, you know, natural resources of some kind. More recently, they've, you know, that's become more commoditized thanks to shipping and so on. You don't have to be next to a coal mine to get access to coal.
You do pay some surcharge for being far away from it, but you can get a ship to you. And so and not just from one location, but from any of the locations where it's being mined. Right. And so instead, what matters is the proximity of a university of some kind. So Stanford and Berkeley are one example, but certainly, you know, Oxford and Cambridge and other universities around the world have sort of catalyzed these sort of local tech ecosystems. And in the cloud, if you could build a digital university that issued what I call a crypto credential, namely a provable certificate that shows that you have a certain skill, you know, and it could go very micro, right?
It's like I can code a binary tree in Rust, okay? And the code, the source code that you have to do that is put on chain, as is the integration test that evaluates it. And it's maybe co-signed by a proctor who saw you type it in. And maybe it's encrypted so that it's not easy for somebody else to copy, but that you could easily give a view key to somebody so that they could run an integration test against it to confirm that you actually coded at this time, right? and maybe there's other features as well, but those are just some of the things, that gives you something which is like a very fine-grained qualification.
You might say, okay, well, why do I care if they can code a binary tree in Rust? Okay, well, now let's say they've got examples where they can code not just a binary tree, but a skip list and a B-tree, and they've coded a compiler and an operating system. They've basically gone through the list of major algorithms and data structures, and they've done so well in Rust, and they've got like 70 different examples. Okay, that might be somebody who could contribute to the parity code base, right? If they've done the same thing, they've done it in Go, that might be somebody who's qualified to contribute to the geth code base, right?
And so now what you did is you just made the impedance matching from somebody's skill to their work much, much, much easier. And it could be something where, okay, someone who has that crypto credential and they submit a pull request to your open source project, you're more likely to look at it. Or you just may merge it, given that you probably want to review it for security and other types of stuff, but you're much, much more likely to look at it. If they interview with you, you're much more likely to give them an interview. So basically, crypto labors, right? And the crypto nation provides them credentials in this model of things.
And of course, that's a powerful labor force. Of course, they're all a credentialed labor force, which is pretty interesting. Does the crypto nation get its cut? Does a percentage of the earnings go to some tax system as a nation state might do? Or is there some sort of issuance fee, some sort of inflation that happens in the background? So like, what is the economic engine that actually pays for the national infrastructure, if you will? So the simplest is, and, you know, several thoughts on this. First is, if you build an economy, there's like 500 different ways you can take fees off of that economy if you need to do that, right?
But the simplest is you boost people's human capital and then you take a cut. One way of doing that is, you know, the Lambda School model where it's an ISA. Right. You know, that is to say you train, you take a worker at Walmart, you train them in programming, you place them in a programming job and, you know, land of school for some people increases their income like $100,000 a year. And then they take a cut of that via the ISA. Right. So you literally increase somebody's human capital. You take a cut of it. That's a win, win, win all around. Right. Okay. So you educate the individuals and then as a result of that education, they go out into the workforce and you've invested in them with an ISA, an income service agreement, I believe.
Yep. And then you get your dividends paid to you by the labor of that person that you educated. Correct. That's right. And so they've made $100,000 more a year and they give you back $20,000 or $30,000, something like that. That's a Lambda School business model. Another business model is something like OnDeck, where people pay to be part of a community and they get mentorship and help out of it, sort of like a college alumni network if you can't get into a college or you can't attend remote or something. But it's much cheaper than that, still reasonably priced. So that's another version where it's a membership base, a community base.
You're part of a point. And then so the laborer gets credentials, access to these credentials. What other public services do they get from the nation state? So if I'm in the nation of the United States, I get a pretty robust legal system, for instance. It's generally a nice place to live, good rule of law. There's geographic, I guess, weather sorts of advantages. There's economic advantages. If I'm close to a place like York City, that's a financial hub of the world, these sorts of things, those are the network effects that the United States has and the benefits of being a US citizen. how would such a nation state or such a crypto nation attract these types of laborers?
What would be the perks or the public goods? Yeah. So good question. So, well, first I would sort of contest your premise, which is I think that the value proposition of, you know, if you separate out into physical America and digital America. Okay. And you say physical America is, you know, being physically present in the United States and digital America is, you know, having access to internet services, not all of which are American, but many of which are. So that's amazon.com and google.com and Wikipedia and whatnot. Right. I argue that much of the value proposition of being physically in America has been uploaded to the cloud over the last 20 years.
In the sense that you can live an American grade life in Thailand or Poland or, you know, like big swaths of Brazil and, you know, so on and so forth, right? In good chunks of the world, especially in Asia, much of Asia, you can live in Eastern Europe, you know, Western Europe, much of the Middle East or at least parts of the Middle East that aren't in war, but like Dubai, for example, pretty nice place to live, Israel, and good chunks of South America as well, you can live an American-ish life, sometimes American plus, because it's better. The streets are cleaner in Asia. And your email is the same.
You log in and boom, you're in the same Gmail, no matter where in the world you are. Do you mean irrespective of whether you have an American citizenship or not if you're using these quote-unquote American internet services. That's right. The thing is that 20 years ago, 30 years ago, there wasn't even the concept. 30 years ago, you had to come to America to get Starbucks and McDonald's and clean streets and so on and so forth. Over 20, 30 years, the world has dramatically changed and lots more places have become livable. You know, it's like the, the, the sort of things that you take, the reason I just say Starbucks is it signifies a certain level of sort of consumer affluence that you can afford, afford to pay $4 for burnt coffee or whatever.
I like the, I like the particular way they burn it, by the way, but you know, it's just sort of a signal you've got at Starbucks, you've got an Apple store, you've got high-speed internet connection, you've got food delivery, you've got grocery delivery, you've got Amazon delivery, you've got printers and your plugs work, your power works, water works, all that type of stuff, right? The basics, plus a little bit more than the basics, you can get in much, much more of the world now than you could 30 years ago, 20 years ago. So Balaji, one question that I have with the formation of this whole nation is, Why?
The incentives are there. But what about this? How does a social fabric cohere? When the American Revolution established America, there was like a very similar shared set of values that people wanted to see instantiated. And I don't think that while there's plenty of incentive to move to this new theoretical nation that has intrinsic advantages and intrinsic incentives to be there, it seems to be missing a social purpose, a social coherency. How does a community arise in this Newton-like nation? Well, so actually that's a huge part of what I talk about in the book. Like, short version is absolutely, you know, when you think about France, the first thing you think about is not the French stock market.
God bless them. Okay. The first thing you think about is not, you know, the valuations of their tech companies or anything. You think about the Louvre. And, you know, I know I'm pronouncing that wrong. The Louvre. Yeah. You think about, you know, the Eiffel Tower. And you think about baguettes and le fromage and all this stuff. Right. And you think about their culture because they really do have an amazing culture. They've done some amazing things. And that's what kind of defines them as a country. It is their art, it is their food, it is their architecture, it's all that stuff, right? And what's interesting is whenever you have large assemblies of people, there's sort of a default culture forming process.
We don't usually think of this, but the hundred-something million person social network called Japan created sushi, and the 300 million person social network called Reddit helped create keto. And keto came out of Reddit. It is absolutely a diet of the internet. And you can argue it's a subculture. It's not the entirety of 300 million. I would agree with you, right? But it's not the cuisine of any country yet. But I think it will be. Okay. And so in the same way, once you start thinking about nations as just large collections of people with a shared culture, one should also realize, well, actually, the U.
S. is unbundling, right? Certainly people have talked about it as, you know, like blue versus red or whatever, and that's an important aspect. But it's unbundling in lots of other ways. You know, it's got cloud people versus land people, you know, who are working remote versus working with their hands. It's got, you know, like folks who are secular versus others. Just the commonality that bound the U.S. together is just less there. And so you do have to rebuild that online. And, you know, I think it's a gradual process. It's not going to happen overnight. but you know things like uh you know articles that you agree with piece of art that you like generating culture together hanging out together socializing together i think you know video games are underrated because they're remote play as opposed to remote work um you don't normally think of it this way but you know for example there's a company which i respect and they do like a zoom coffee right and look zoom coffee is fine you know but you're sort of inventing a ritual to do that you wouldn't normally do.
It's a little unnatural to come and drink your coffee in front of the monitor. What is natural is to get on Call of Duty or Fortnite with your friends and blow something up. What's also natural, I think, would also be finding people via Facebook or Twitter. That's a large part of how communities are established. That's right. But in this podcast, we've talked about how Facebook and Twitter kind of represent in Google, kind of represent their own internal nations. Are these nations invited to this new nation or is that against the ethos? Is that against the purpose of this whole thing? So what do you mean?
Are Facebook and Twitter nations invited to this new nation? Is that what you're asking? Yeah. Like is the social fabric of the nation established through a Twitter medium or is that like antithetical because it's using an alternative Twitter, it's using web two technology when it could be using a more decentralized medium? Oh, well, I mean, the technology is certainly one aspect of it, but I think the fundamental thing is that Twitter and Facebook are utilities, not communities. Okay. Right? So the whole point is basically that Twitter in particular is just the public war zone, right? Right.
People there, look, I mean, you're on crypto Twitter. I don't even need to tell you what that means, right? Like people basically, you know, for a number of reasons, Twitter has set it up to optimize engagement. Guess what? A significant number of humans do things that I would never have thought to do, which is like run up to strangers and just say F you at them. Right. And, you know, I remember like a year or two ago, I had a thread, which was like, Twitter is not real life yet, but it will be. It's just before Corona, actually, I think. Right. And the reason is, I think the question I was getting at is what holds the social graph of the network?
Ah, that's right. I think that's what I really meant to ask. So good question. So the answer is different network states are held together by different things. So I think the first network state, the one that I may build, is held together by the goal of immutable money, infinite frontier, eternal life. Okay? So that is to say, Bitcoin, digital currency, of course, I respect Ethereum, but like immutable money, infinite frontier like Mars, and eternal life, meaning reversing aging. And that kind of stands for a sense of progress, technological progress, and really pushing the frontier, the great acceleration as opposed to the great stagnation.
And it's sort of something, it's a little bit of a shibboleth. Do you know what a shibboleth is? It's a term from religion, which is like a seemingly insignificant customer tradition that distinguishes one group from another. So if you like Peter Thiel's Zero to One, if you like my book, if you like my Twitter feed, if you like Mark Anderson's It's Time to Build, if you like Elon's SpaceX feed, if you can do physics, if you are willing to fight back online, not necessarily to start a fight, but certainly to fight back if necessary, and so on and so forth. There's a bunch of these sort of cultural checklist items.
And I'm not saying every single one of them is critical, but all of those things together, that's like a particular kind of person. It's like the pro-tech, pro-future kind of person. And I think that's a network shape I'm interested in building, something which is, it sort of restores what Western civilization used to have, which was the arrow of progress, right? The sense of not manifest destiny, like conquer someone else, but, you know, to get to space, right? To transcend, the sense of transcendence, you know, to overcome our limitations, to advance mathematics, to uncover the secrets of the universe, you know?
that that's the the sense of the explorer the the pioneer to reopen the frontier right that's the kind of um spirit that i'm looking for for the first network state and the the interesting thing about this blotchy is right so somebody could take all of the open source that is built through the network state that you're envisioning fork it and instantiate their own network state with say a different set of values, right? Something like super conservative or super regressive or like they're really passionate about the keto diet, right? Whatever. And then it's almost like a kind of a survival of the fittest sort of which economy, which network state is going to attract the most sovereign individuals to live there and to grow its economy.
Right. That's right. So that's right. So basically, you know, I think the first network state we will set up for forking in much the same way. Imagine if Bitcoin was set up to fork at the beginning. Right. Completely different world if that had been like a design decision from the beginning. I don't think Satoshi could have envisioned what happened with it. You know, like he or she or they figured out a lot of things. But it's pretty hard to predict the craziness of crypto over the last, you know, 10 years. Right. But had you set it up to fork, which I would intend to do, yes, you could build a vegan network state.
You could build one that was focused on, let's say, Latin, right? You know, for example, the Israelis were able to revive Hebrew, which was a dead language, you know? You could have a Latin network state that wanted to revive Latin and Greek, which is, I mean, Greek is obviously a live language, but you know what I'm saying. Those used to be studied, right? You could have one that focused on, like, shipping container housing. And, you know, there's various subcultures and communities where they're full expression. The reason I mentioned veganism, for example, is there's a whole supply chain associated with that, right?
It's everything from food preparation to, it's something where if all the people opt in, you know, and they know it's all vegan by default, you don't have to ask people's dietary preferences, et cetera. You just know they're all vegan, right? You're in the vegan zone. Yeah, you're in the vegan zone. That's right. And so, you know, somebody doesn't have to ask. They don't accidentally eat meat by mistake. They don't accidentally eat eggs by mistake. You know, none of the pots and pans, if you're really religious about it. You know, some people are literally religious vegans. You get it. You get there's a certain benefit from flipping all the switches so you can go full stack on something and the assumptions are just baked into the firmament.
Right. So is this reorganizing the world from – like if we take this experiment, this thought experiment out to the nth degree, is the borders of the world reorganized by shared sets of values in all particular forms? Yeah. So I wrote an essay on this actually in 2013 called Software is Reorganizing the World, where essentially I predicted that because your actual community, it's not about your nation state or your state of mind, right? Actually, to go to something very fundamental, right? The whole piece of Westphalia, you know, 1648, which established what we think of as a modern nation state, you know, what preceded that was, you know, the idea that the Catholic Church could have influence anywhere.
And instead what happened was it was like, okay, this is our turf. That's your turf. We've got a government. It is the sole holder of the monopoly of violence over this territory. That's your territory. Catholic Church, you're not a sovereign here. All of those assumptions actually were not things that just came out of nowhere. They were fought over and negotiated for a long time. there's a fundamental presumption behind that, which is that people in the same geography, people who are close to each other in physical space, implicitly share the same culture and therefore can be bound by the same laws.
Okay. But now when people live in anonymous apartment complexes and don't recognize each other, you know, people live in these huge apartment buildings and literally wouldn't recognize somebody who's living 10 feet away from them, you know. But what they do is they recognize somebody who's 3,000 miles away from them via Snapchat or WhatsApp or whatever, right? And so that's a different distance metric. You know, the distance metric in physical space, you can think of it as a so-called great circle distance, which is the distance between two points on the surface of a sphere, okay? Whereas the geodesic distance is the number of degrees of separation between two people in a social network.
Now, the great circle distance is an approximation because in practice, you know, you're going to be constrained by oceans and by, you know, mountain ranges and deserts and so on and so forth. But roughly speaking, it's like the transit time over land between two people. Okay. Whereas the geodesic distance is, you know, it's basically the speed of light. So it's the distance in a social network. And increasingly, that's the one that really matters because that's where you're spending much of your time. That's where your trade is happening. That's your social network. Those are the people you're talking with.
And so you're in just a totally different headspace than the person next door, who themselves is a totally different headspace than the person next door to them, right? And that's the state of affairs we're in right now. But I think that because humans are still fundamentally physical beings, you know, that's like a rubber band that's going to snap, and it's going to snap in such a way that it pulls people up into the cloud, and then down into an area where they can all coalesce together, right? And COVID, because it just pushed remote everything, because of COVID, because of Starlink, crypto is a big component.
All of this stuff is going to, especially if a vaccine is deployed, which would be wonderful, obviously, but if a vaccine is deployed, the world doesn't just go back to what it was. It is a fundamentally remote world now. Digital nomadism spikes because anybody can work from anywhere. All the stuff we've been talking about for the last decade just goes totally vertical. And it becomes more feasible to just go and live with the people of like mind. It's a plane ticket to go over there. Now, of course, it's harder for people with families. It's harder for people who aren't as mobile. And one of the things you want to do is you want to bring down that cost of exit.
But here's the thing, even if only a relative. Does some of that cost of exit come as a result? I would imagine the legacy world, if you could embody the legacy world into one like Leviathan, the legacy world doesn't want that to change. The nation state isn't interested in this new future world. What are the frictions coming from the legacy world that's going to slow this progress down? Not everyone is ready for this kind of change. It's going to be interesting. I think that it's one important thing is that the world is no longer the United States or China. That is to say, the US is 300 million people.
China is 1.1 billion. 80% of the world is neither American nor Chinese. 96% is non-American. Um, so I think a lot of this is probably going to be done outside the U.S. in various ways. Number one. Number two is, you know, it's, it's not illegal to leave a country. In fact, it's a UN human right to be able to leave, you know, to like the right of people to emigrate. This it's funny, all the stuff I talked about in terms of right to exit, you know, years ago, I think people appreciate that more with lockdown and with planes being shut off and so on and so forth. It's when that's taken away that you're like, oh, wow, the right to exit is actually pretty important.
You know, now the right to exit is not the right to enter. A country may not decide to let you in, maybe due to Corona, maybe do other things, you know. But I think that we're in for an age of much more global migration than was previously possible, and many more nations are going to become nations of not just immigrants, but also emigrants. What's funny, by the way, is, you know, for Ireland, for India, for China, for other countries, you know, Mexico, those countries all encouraged their citizens in different ways, or at least certainly didn't extremely discourage them from leaving. The countries that have discouraged citizens for leaving tend to be the ones that are really bad, like Cuba, like East Germany, which set up the Berlin Wall and shot people for trying to leave, like Russia.
The U.S. actually passed something called the Jackson-Vanik Amendment. Do you guys know what that is? No. Jackson-Vanik was passed to allow Soviet Jews to be able to get out of the USSR because they weren't able to practice. They were particularly oppressed there. And so that's the kind of country which you can't get out of. By the way, do you know why the Berlin Wall was set up in the first place? So people couldn't get out. Yeah, but the context of it was after World War II, the allies, the US, Britain, France, and the USSR split up, whereas the US and Britain and France on one side, really the US coalition and the Soviet Union on the other side.
And Berlin was set up in this odd way. You can look at a map where West Berlin, or rather the West Germany controlled part of Berlin was part of East Germany. Okay. And it was behind enemy lines. Okay. It was in this weird enclave kind of thing. Okay. And so because of that, what that meant was that it was a weird loophole that you could walk out of East Germany into West Berlin. here's here's actually i'm going to paste this into our little document or whatever so you can just kind of get a visual of it um so so you you could walk out of the the eastern block into west germany and gtfo out of this horrible you know communist dictatorship right um now of course that was quite a loophole and east germany did not like that especially once all the professionals started doing it because those are the people that the communist regime was giving the worst deal to So they came up with a term called Republikflucht, which pathologized anybody who left.
And it was something which was basically like, oh, you're a traitor for leaving. Here, I'm just pasting it in over here. You're a traitor for leaving. I can't believe you're doing this. You know, from the moral standpoint, as well as the interests of the whole German nation leaving the GDR, meaning the German Democratic Republic, is an act of political and moral backwardness and depravity. Those who let themselves be recruited objectively serve West German reaction and militarism. Is it not despicable when for the sake of a few alluring job offers or other false promises about a guaranteed future, one leaves a country in which the seed for a new and more beautiful life is sprouting?
for a place that forevers a new war and destruction, you know, that kind of tone, right? And basically, Republic Flucht was this thing where, you know, the country that sucked, everybody wanted to leave it, and they started to put up barriers to leaving it. And then eventually a wall where they shot you for trying to leave, and that was there for 40 years. So, So, I mean, it's something where, actually, 40 years, not exactly 40 years, 38 years, okay? But that is something where, unfortunately, I think some countries will go down that route. I think other countries are going to be more favorable to migration, either A, because they're net winners, or B, because they're just more enlightened about it.
Okay, so another question I have. So say the right to exit, like citizens start exiting countries in various ways. But what about the idea that countries still can use the threat of force to make lesser countries, smaller countries, less powerful countries, sort of their satellite state, right? Almost subjugate them. Do you think that basically in geopolitics, it's sort of the rule of the jungle, Balaji? Or do you think that there can be a more peaceful coexistence? For a crypto nation, would a crypto nation have to have a military, for instance? I mean, as crazy as that sounds. Well, I think that we're getting to a few things.
First is India managed to get its independence nonviolently. So did Singapore. So it is possible to do. So that's kind of one major concept that's an important inspiration. I think also that, you know, you don't have to go to full sovereignty right away. You can, I mean, just getting a special innovation zone where you're building a new city where you have dispensation from the powers that be, you know, there's 233 countries in the world. Some of them will want entrepreneurs to come near and build, you know, the self-driving car Detroit, right? So I don't think you need a military to do a lot of this stuff, number one.
Okay. um number two though you ask you know could it be possible that somebody you know that governments will get very oppressive and so on unfortunately that is possible however um i i would also say you know in um there's this sort of toy problem in differential equations where you've got two armies and you have the assumption that um like the first army is n soldiers and the second has M soldiers and the N soldiers can kill the M soldiers at a rate K1 and the M soldiers can kill the N soldiers at a rate K2. And so what happens is each side is shooting the other and knocking down its soldiers, which knocks down the ability of the other guys to kill this group and vice versa, right?
So, you know, basically blam, blam, blam, blam, and who wins, right? And, you know, if you've got more firepower, but fewer people, you might, you know, take them to zero faster than they take you to zero, right? Okay. And so in a sense, you know, you're losing power even as you're fighting better guys. There's a modification of that, which is, it's not that a guy is shooting you and therefore reducing your firepower. It is one where using your firepower causes enough public backlash that it reduces your firepower. Okay. So hard power, the use of hard power, especially if it's filmed, depending on how it's filmed and how it's put out there, potentially reduces the support for further ruthless measures of hard power.
It very much depends on the context and so on, but it can be delegitimizing. Okay. So for example, when the USSR went and did, you know, the invasions of, you know, Hungary and of Czechoslovakia, like in 1956, you know, when the Soviets rolled tanks in there, or when in 1968, when they rolled tanks into, you know, the during the Prague Spring, both of those were things where the Soviets put it down. But they did so with just brute force, right. And, and those, you know, like they caused people to know that they were not free people, you know, and it did take 20 years. It wasn't something that happened overnight, but they paid a price for that, which was delegitimization among people, at least behind closed doors, you know?
And, you know, I think that that price paid for the use of very coercive, hard power is faster in the internet age with encrypted, you know, end-to-end messaging and so on and so forth, it's, you know, if you're brazenly, you know, attacking or censoring or, you know, doing something in a way that's non-consensual, you might try to suppress it and it might be partially suppressed in mainstream channels in China, in, you know, the US and whatever country, but it will ultimately erode support for that regime. At least this is the, that's a positive take, right? The negative take is you have a regime that's so efficiently totalitarian that it can actually reprogram people's brains enough that they don't even question it.
You know, I think that's going to be hard in the age of the internet for lots of reasons, but I can't say it's impossible. So we have to work towards that or against that rather, towards a better future instead. So Balaji, this has been so incredibly fascinating. I think it's obvious to many who are listening that like, you know, maybe coming to this podcast thought they were in like the end stages of the internet or the technology's over that this is the very beginning. But to kind of pull this full circle and wrap this up, we talked about COVID at first and the world becoming more decentralized and even more variant leading to this distrust in institutions and trust being the scarce commodity.
And then we've got crypto as this trust substrate. And then we started talking about how crypto could be used not just for anarchy purposes, but to build actual civilizations, even network states, as you call them. But remind us, put a bow on this for us. Why is this all good for the world? What problem would this sort of thing solve? It would solve the problem of how to address regulatory harmonization. I know that seems like it's out of nowhere, but I think of that as actually the most important problem in the world. Okay. Let's say, what? Huh? Okay. I've never heard this term. Okay. Let me explain.
Harmonization is the process by which small countries outsource their regulation to the United States of America. Okay. So this is in the same way that a small company might outsource its log, outsource its login to Facebook, right? A small country might outsource its regulation to the USA, right? And when it does so, that means that the American bureaucrats at the FDA or the FAA or the SEC or what have you basically have a global hammerlock on regulation. That is to say, they are able to just quash innovation worldwide because they're the police. You know, they can literally order raids and fines and seizures.
They can get banks to pull your account. Usually it doesn't come to that. But, you know, lots of threats happen beforehand. Usually when they just point the finger at you in the press, everybody just scurries away because they're so scared of getting hit. Right. And the issue there is that, you know, when's the last time you elected a federal regulator? In the U.S., they typically have career tenure. There's so-called plumb book appointees, which are the folks who are appointed by a new administration, and those are the most senior officials. But the rank and file, including fairly senior people, just one notch below like the commissioner or the director or whatever, the rank and file, including the relatively senior managers, often have career tenure, which means they can't be fired and they're not elected.
So they're not subject to either, whether you have an electoral or market theory of accountability, they're not subject to either. But they also have a hammerlock on worldwide innovation through this process of harmonization. Now, cracks have started to form in this, for example, like, you know, in different ways, like Brazil has more liberal drone laws in some ways. Singapore has been doing self-driving car zones. Germany's experimented with stem cells and, you know, allowing people to do stem cells. The UK has a fintech regulatory sandbox. And, you know, Russia and China kind of have their own regimes for technology in many ways.
So the hammerlock is sort of breaking, you know. And, of course, you've got Uber. You've got Airbnb. B, you've got crypto. The US stranglehold over worldwide regulation is breaking. When I say stranglehold, it's like a few unelected, unnamed, unaccountable, unfireable people who have this hammerlock. But it hasn't fully broken. And in particular, for physical innovation, it hasn't broken yet. And what you really want, because here's the thing, the naive person, I mean, look, I'm sympathetic in some ways to Ron Paul or what have you. But Ron Paul was like, end the Fed, And the reason that's laughable is the Fed is at the center of a thousand, a million different things.
It's like this extremely important hub node. It's like saying, end Google or end AWS. Okay, if you just did that without a replacement, the whole system crashes. um however exit the fed is much more reasonable right exit the fed is btc exit the fed is build something up over time which gains backlinks in a gradual opt-in fashion and gets through a thousand different proof points in a million different tests and it gradually becomes the next financial system, as opposed to trying to do this overnight switchover, just end it without a replacement. You can't just end it. You have to replace with something better.
In the same way, I think exit the ABC agency, exit the FDA, exit the SEC, exit the FAA, et cetera, comes when the 96% of the world that is not American realizes that harmonization may be holding them back. I mean, Corona has really taken the bloom off the rose, right? If you thought that the FDA was like this competent regulator, the fact that it held back the tests that could have prevented the pandemic in the U.S. from becoming a pandemic, like, I don't know if you remember this in February, emergency use authorization was denied to academic labs, preventing them from rolling out coronavirus tests.
So that's why the country was flying blind for weeks, not knowing how many people actually had disease, so it was able to grow exponentially out of sight. Okay. And, you know, that's a very concrete, undeniable, very large-scale consequence example of what, you know, bureaucratic inertia can do. It was something that had the cost of trillions of dollars and hundreds of thousands of lives that was in part on FDA, certainly in part on CDC, in part on the White House, in part on the state of New York and every other state. But it's definitely something where had we had better biomedical technologies, had we had better quantified self, had we had better and faster genomic testing, there's many innovations I can point to that were held back by FDA over the last decade.
For example, your Apple Watch would have had way more sensors in it had FDA not nerfed it. 23andMe would have been at hundreds of millions of people, so you might have been able to get pharmacogenomic analyses of individual drugs and vaccines and immunogenomic analyses of which particular immune things affected your disease response. If uber and airbnb if if you saw the taxi and hotel regulations were holding back hundreds of billions of dollars And that's just taxi and hotel regulations What is the fda? What are the fa? What are the sec holding back? What are these ancient alphabet agencies holding back?
It's going to be in the trillions of dollars But even more than that it's going to be in the millions of lives The only way we can demonstrate that without crashing the system You can't just end those agencies though because they're at the center of everything like every approval goes through them Every company is hooked into them You have to create new opt-in regimes outside where everybody opts into them. They take the risk. They deal with the bugs because there'll be lots of failures at the beginning. And you have much faster innovation. And over time, enough people gravitate towards that, that it proves itself or not.
In which case it's, you know, just like a shit coin or whatever, you know, so to speak, it fails, right? And then, you know, the failure is limited to the hundred people who tried it out rather than trying to impose that new regime on everybody. Makes sense? So this solves for a bunch of things. For those people who are what I'd call technological conservatives, they have an intact regulatory system. If they like the regulations, they can keep them. For those folks who don't, your body, your choice. You get enough people together, and now you can get a jurisdiction where you actually have bodily sovereignty.
Because we can do bungee jumping. We can do skydiving. Euthanasia is legal. Many people believe marijuana, other kinds of drugs, recreational drugs should be legalized. When you add all that up, it doesn't make sense as to why you should be so restricted in terms of other kinds of medical procedures that could help you. And getting new regimes for doing this, I think that's the most important thing we could solve for biomedicine and for other technologies. Balaji, it's very clear that you have spent a lot of time thinking about this. We speak often on the Bankless program about how these crypto economic systems are social scaffolding for organization.
Bitcoin as a money is a tool for people to coordinate around. Ethereum as a property rights management system is another tool for people to coordinate around. And we often speak about the logical conclusion of where this goes. What happens when we find new institutions to coordinate around? And so tip of the hat for being 10 years ahead, a decade ahead of everyone else with how these things can actually manifest themselves as organizational tools in the real world. So thank you for coming on the Bankless podcast and sharing your ideas with us. They have been already extremely valuable to me. And I look forward to listening back on this episode in the future as some of these ideas begin to manifest themselves in the real world.
Thank you. guys action items you can go to bellagios.com sign up i think he is going to be sharing more about his new book a network state that is coming out as well as other items of interest if you enjoyed this conversation we will also include in the show notes hyperlinks to all of the references that bellagio made during the show there are quite a number of them so we will include that check those out lastly five star reviews on apple podcast guys we are moving up the charts with those five star reviews just a reminder if you love bankless give us a five star review tell us what you like and we will pop up the charts and get bankless and crypto up into mainstream risks and disclaimers everyone none of this was financial advice eat is risky so is crypto as is DeFi.
You could lose what you put in, but we are headed west. This is the frontier. It's not for everyone, but we're glad you're with us. Thanks a lot. Thank you.