🚀 SUBSCRIBE TO NEWSLETTER: http://bankless.substack.com/
✊ STARTING GUIDE BANKLESS: https://bit.ly/37Q17uI
❤️ JOIN PRIVATE DISCORD: https://bit.ly/2UVI10O
🎙️ SUBSCRIBE TO PODCAST: http://podcast.banklesshq.com/
👕 BUY BANKLESS TEE: https://merch.banklesshq.com/
-----
GO BANKLESS WITH THESE SPONSOR TOOLS:
⭐️ AAVE - BORROW OR LEND YOUR ASSETS https://bankless.cc/aave
🚀 GEMINI - MOST TRUSTED EXCHANGE AND ONRAMP https://bankless.cc/go-gemini
💳 MONOLITH - GET THE HOLY GRAIL OF BANKLESS VISA CARDS https://bankless.cc/monolith
📈 KWENTA | DEVIRATIVES TRADING WITH INFINITE LIQUIDITY https://bankless.cc/kwenta
------
Vitalik Buterin on Why Proof of Stake?
Vitalik Buterin comes to the Bankless YouTube to discuss a number of topics surrounding Proof of Stake!
We begin discussing the Beacon Chain launch, and the Ethereum's road so far up to this point.
We also discuss the theory and thought-process behind Proof of Stake! Vitalik recently wrote a blog piece 'Why Proof of Stake', and we walk through this piece with him!
Why Proof of Stake:
https://vitalik.ca/general/2020/11/06/pos2020.html
Lastly, we discuss one of Vitalik's blog pieces 'Concave and Convex Dispositions, and how these different personality types characterize Bitcoin and Ethereum, as well as the design of social groups and human governance organizations.
Convex and Concave Dispositions
https://vitalik.ca/general/2020/11/08/concave.html
Other pieces mentioned: Trust Models
https://vitalik.ca/general/2020/08/20/trust.html
------
Don't stop at the video!
Subscribe to the Bankless newsletter program
http://bankless.substack.com/
Visit the official Bankless website for resources
http://banklesshq.com/
Follow Bankless on Twitter
https://twitter.com/BanklessHQ
Follow Ryan on Twitter
https://twitter.com/ryansadams
Follow David on Twitter
https://twitter.com/TrustlessState
-----
Not financial or tax advice. This channel is strictly educational and is not investment advice or a solicitation to buy or sell any assets or to make any financial decisions. This video is not tax advice. Talk to your accountant. Do your own research.
Disclosure. From time-to-time we may add links in this channel to products we use. We may receive commission if you make a purchase through one of these links. We'll always disclose when this is the case
No summary for this episode yet.
Gemini is the world's most trusted cryptocurrency exchange. I've been a customer of Gemini since I first got back into crypto back in 2017 and it has been my main exchange of choice to make my crypto buys and sells. Gemini is available in all 50 states in over 50 countries worldwide and on Gemini there are markets for over 30 various crypto assets including many of the hot deep I tokens like Wi-Fi, Ave, Uni, and also they are one of the few exchanges that has liquid dye markets. Having both the option of logging into the Gemini.com website or instead opening the Gemini mobile app has allowed me to be able to access any and all exchange and honor off ramp services that I've needed to on a moment's notice.
With instant deposits and fast withdrawals I'm able to make my money do the things I want to when I want it to. You can buy crypto safely and securely on Gemini with the peace of mind of knowing that your investments are insured and protected with industry leading cyber security. You can open up a free account in under 3 minutes at Gemini.com slash go bankless and if you traded more than $100 within the first 30 days after sign up you'll be gifted a free $15 bonus check them out Gemini.com slash go bankless. Syntetics is Ethereum's decentralized derivatives liquidity protocol. What does that mean?
Syntetics is a platform for creating and trading synthetic assets which are assets that are priced via an Oracle rather than bids or asks. Traders can use the Quenta exchange which hosts and trades all of the synthetic assets created by Syntetics. Traders on Quenta can trade synthetic tokens like SBTC, S-Oil or S-D-Fi because Quenta is powered by Syntetics Traders experience zero slippage on their trades. No, I didn't mean low slippage. I meant no slippage because that is the power of the Syntetics platform. No slippage on your trades. You can also easily short assets with Isense which are synthetic assets that move inversely to their target asset.
This isn't just for traders, developers can build on synthetics to access the infinite liquidity offered by synthetic assets or investors can stake collateral to the protocol and earn fees that the protocol collects. If you're a trader and you're looking for a trading platform not found in the legacy world, check out Quenta.io. If you're a developer or you just want to earn yield on your collateral, go to www.synthetics.io or you can stake your SNX or ETH and earn fees from it Syntetics. Anklis Nation. We are pleased to bring you Vitalik buterin again in front of the nation. We are talking about a few things that are top of mind.
Vitalik, great to have you. How are you doing? Thank you very much, David and Ryan. It's great. It's great to be on bankless again. It is fun. I feel like this is a really good moment to be on bankless. The first thing we want to talk about with you actually is this pretty momentous, maybe monumental in the history of Ethereum achievement, which is we hit the number 524288E, now deposited in the staking contract. How does that feel? Definitely feels great. I think for a long time, the first few weeks, we were definitely a bit worried because the deposits were coming in slowly at the beginning and it seemed like, oh, with only four days left, we had 20% and what the heck is going on here.
We even saw that there are a lot of people who are starting to get worried on an arched hub thread and saw Eric open up that did have the issue, basically suggesting, hey, just in case there is never enough deposits, let's set a maximum date and there is a bunch of arguments around that. But no, the Ethereum community came in and the Ethereum community delivered and just within the last 24 hours, we ended up having more deposits than we had in the entire period before that. It definitely feels a little bit surprising, though in retrospect, it should not be too surprising, I guess. The one kind of events that happened in the past that this reminds me of is if you were here during the original Ethereum sale back in 2014.
If you remember that whole event, it was this six week long sale, but then the first two weeks were this most important period because that was the period during which you could get the most favorable price for your ETH. There was some amount of deposits on the first day, less on the second day, and then it seemed like it was going really slowly and almost pedoring out at a couple of million dollars. Then just suddenly in the last couple of days, everyone just pushed in and pushed the whole thing up to, of course, to 18 million dollars. The curve feels very similar to that. I guess the subject said you should expect that because why would someone participate earlier if they could just wait until the end?
Just seeing that kind of spike just come first slowly and then all at once is definitely amazing. It's definitely a great testament to the Ethereum community as a level of confidence. That first time in Ethereum itself, and then this second time in the proof of stake and charting stuff that we've spent so many years working on. Vitalik, what does this tell you about the Ethereum community? As a result of this, because we hit the 524,000 ETH, but then we just blew past it by 200,000 more ETH. What does this, if this is a litmus test for the community, what is it telling you? What are your big takeaways about the Ethereum community as a result of this event?
I think, first of all, there's definitely wide community buy-in and confidence in ETH too in general. That's something that I think I definitely believe the whole time, but it's definitely good to have just such a clear sign of it, 300 million dollars worth of people just locking up their ETH potentially, never to see it again, unless the thing either delivers or we find some kind of further thing to do to make those points in the deposit actually valuable again. In some sense, it's the ultimate bet on progress and I think a bet on progress is to some extent what Ethereum is about. I feel like it happened in the perfect way in a very climactic way and really fired the Ethereum community up when it actually happened in the way that it did.
It's almost fitting, I would say, that we weren't sure we were going to cross the threshold until the last 48 to 24 hours, but I'm curious about this number itself. Why was the number selected? What kind of drove that number to begin with? Was it fairly arbitrary that we have to have some amount of stake and so why not this particular number or was there some sort of rhyme or reason behind it? I guess 524,000 was the power of two that seemed like a relatively minimum acceptable threshold for an amount of deposits that we could have to ensure that the chain would actually be safe with that amount.
To give one example, it's the smallest power of two that the Ethereum foundation could not individually 51% attack. Ethereum foundation has slightly above that, but it would have to put everything in and even that it would only be around 50%. If we had less than just the number of actors that would have enough money to be able to take over the thing individually, it would just get higher and higher and so it actually would be the chain would just not be that secure with a lower amount, but on the other hand, I get this level of getting to the point where there's really very few individual actors that actually have the ability to put in the funds to take over the chain.
Aside from the foundation, there's also, obviously, the major exchanges, maybe in census and I don't know how much they have and a couple of whales, but if you go higher and we hope to go higher, then it is going to get out of reach of even those largest holders, but realistically, we don't have to get up to those much higher levels immediately. This is still just the phase zero beacon chain, there's nothing going to keep we relying on it. It's going to start at a medium level of safety and then go up to the higher level over time as people will naturally become more confident in the system. So this process, this getting to that number and exceeding the threshold of youth, that sort of initiates the rocket launch sequence, but the chain is not yet launched, that will happen December 1st, 12 o'clock, UTC time, so what kind of happens next?
What's the next milestone in the beacon chain launch and in-staking now that we filled up the deposit contract to its minimum threshold? So the next milestone is obviously the thing that's happening in five and a half days after I'm saying this, December 1st, the launch itself, we've done lots of test sets, but this is still larger than any test that it's a different set of stakeholders than any test sets. So just making sure that all goes smoothly, then after that, we would hope the proof-of-stake chain just runs smoothly for some amount of time and at some points we want to just start getting onto the task of upgrading it and bringing on all the full functionality that we want youth to have.
So the big ticket items are, one is sharding, the second is, and if the merge, so bringing youth one into the youth system, we're moving the proof-of-work chain and kind of properly folding the system back together, and then there's also some smaller things that we want to do. So, for example, we want to add a life client support fairly quickly. So if you go into the youth 2 specs and get up, there's already a PR that we've been working on for about a couple of weeks to add a life client support, and then there's some just efficiency improvements and some kind of economic tweaks, one example of a type of economic tweak we might want to make is just making the chain more friendly to people who validators who stay online during an activity league, but don't stay online perfectly.
So basically, if you have 90% of performance during an activity league where people who are completely online who is 40%, like you should not lose 4%, right? Really, you should lose much less than 4% and you're really worth doing the best that you can. I have a proposal around fixing that, just general efficiency improvements. So basically, the youth 2 chain is just going to kind of get into this progressing and upgrading mode, and it's basically preparing for the moment when the existing theory of ecosystem can and they got to properly and fully fold into it. Are you feeling a little bit metallic?
This is like the launch sequence initiated, but at some level, we're all kind of standing close to the launch pad watching the SpaceX rocket and it hasn't quite launched yet, and that, of course, is maybe the most nerve-wracking part. So is there any element of you being nervous about December 1st, or what could happen in December 1st? Could we have a failed launch? Could there be some issue? I mean, issues are always possible, right? So I think we should hold off the full cell operation until we get to the ground. We've seen what we've had with different testats. Some of them launched perfectly, some of them had issues.
Even the ones that had issues, they definitely all managed to fix themselves within either a couple of hours or a day or so. I expect that in this time, there's definitely more participants and potentially less experienced participants. So also maybe more experienced participants because the people who participated in the test tests are also going to be in the main net, and it's not going to be a first time for them anymore. I don't think we're going to see the thing that we saw in some of the testats. We're 40% of people just never showed up because this time we actually have a profit motive.
There's just always the possibility of random technical risk, I suppose, but we've done lots of testing at this point, the quality of the testats has definitely just gone up and up over time, but you know, figures crossed, and you know, it hasn't happened until what's happened, so we're definitely hoping and eagerly awaiting everything going well. So Vitalik, the ETH2 research team recently did a Reddit AMA that I thought was really fantastic. And there's one question I recall in there. I think somebody asked you the question about maybe, you know, ETH-ish wins or something. I created the context for the question.
You had this really, I thought, reflective reply where you talked about Ethereum being, you know, while ETH2 is launching, it's also a technology and a network that is somewhat in motion, right? There are going to be a large set of improvements over the next two years, right? It's not necessarily going to be like instant scalability is here and both chains merge, it's going to still be a process. But at the end of that time, like the ETH2 chain will be in a much better place. I was wondering if you could, I'm not presenting it the way you did and the way you answered that question, but I'm wondering if that jogged your memory and you could talk about maybe that answer to the question, like, what's the future for issuance, what's the future for stability, ETH2, where are we going to be on the other side when all of this stuff is done and why should we hang with Ethereum?
Yeah, no, and I definitely think, like, I made that comment for a reason and I think there's an important kind of insight to keep in mind there. So there's a lot of people who have been recently commenting about how ETH doesn't have a finalized issuance to get a jogger, or you can't calculate what the current total supply is, or what is the max supply and so on, or now you're changing things. There's definitely in some extent to which those queries are coming more from the Bitcoin community, then the Ethereum community itself, and so we should definitely not overrate the extent to which we really feel the need to respond and satisfy all of those requests.
But the thing that I think we need to just keep in mind is that just being intellectually honest about the state of Ethereum, if you need a system which satisfies the property that it will stay the same as it is today and it has existing properties that it's going to preserve, then Ethereum as it exists in 2020 is just as a matter of fact, not the system for you for at least the next one to one and a half years, right? There's just a reality that there has been this massive ETH 2.0 transition that's been planned pretty much almost since the project's launched, and now it's finally happening, and then at the same time there is these massive transitions in economics, so EIP 1559 is a big one, and also just activity moving from layer 1 to layer 2 is another big one, and these things are going to fundamentally change how a lot of economic and technical properties of Ethereum work, and so any property of the Ethereum blockchain today may well change in those one to one and a half years, and so if you're interested in long-term economic properties of the Ethereum ecosystem, it matters less what are the properties of the system today, and it matters more what are the properties of the thing that's slowly being built up over the next one and a half years, right?
What even is the point of being able to, you know, verify the current proof of work issuance schedule, like perfectly, if the thing that we really should be verifying is the economic properties of the proof of stake schedule that are going to be guiding Ethereum's economics for the 20 years after 2020 to whenever the merge ends up happening, so I think just explicitly understanding that yes, Ethereum at the moment is a system in flux, and yes, if you want something that's not a system in flux, then Bitcoin may be the thing for you with Ethereum, Classic may be the thing for you, though, and Ethereum Classic itself is, I think, in flux as a matter of necessity, because it's a bit of ability is being threatened by all these 51% attacks, but so that's one example where, you know, in order to protect people's kind of property rights, you actually have to do something other than standing still.
So, so Vitalik, if this is successful, if we cross the bridge, if we make it for the other side, for those that kind of stick with the project, stick like the builders who kind of stick with it, the community that sticks with it, what's left for us on the other side? What do we get in terms of issuance, in terms of improvements, in terms of security enhancements? What's the reward there? I think great things are on the other side. Number one is obviously proof of stake, so much more efficient, much more secure, much less re-killing form of a much less issuance demanding for American census. So, you know, issuance is going to potentially go down by significant amount of efficiency and the network will go up by a lot, and if there is, basically, going to become what I think the 2020s will expect a modern blockchain to be.
So, that's number one. Number two is shorting, and at the same time, the layer two ecosystem. So, those things together are going to give us scalability in the tens of thousands of transactions per second, which is hugely important because ultimately, we're looking to create a platform that can achieve mainstream adoption, create a platform that actually can provide enough security and trust that guarantees to its users, and actually scale that up to millions and potentially tens of hundreds of millions of users, and not just a very small number, like a couple hundred thousand per day. And just proof of stake in shorting are the things that needs to be done to make that happen.
So, that's number two. Number three is that just a better protocol economics. So, EIP5059 is the really big thing. I think the more you use FARM, the more you realize it, like just gas estimation, it's such a stupid and archaic concept. I really think that if all goes well in five years time, like blockchains that rely on this first price auction model is just going to be looked at like caveman economics. So, I'm really looking forward to it. It seems like the model is already working well and increasingly being validated in flour coin. It's increasingly working well on the test that. So, really looking forward to that hitting the main that I think that could be one of the big stories of 2021.
Also, adjust general efficiencies within the Ethereum system. So, replacing the hex tree with binary trees, allowing stateless clients, I'll make it much more efficient to process and to sync the chain. Much more, some of our actual machine improvements that would allow us to just not need any more pre-compiles and be able to have all the advanced cryptography that we want inside of Ethereum. So, basically just everything that you could want if you're building some privacy preserving application or some kind of more complicated smart contract system or some role up for scalability. The tools actually are going to be there and you're not going to have to use kind of clever tricks to anywhere close to the same extent as you do now.
Also, light client support. So, each two were making a go at making it explicitly much more light client friendly. And so, hopefully break the dependence on it if you're and kind of actually have make it so that people's wallets actually can be light clients. And Vitalik, do we get to that place, not fixed issuance, obviously like the Bitcoin model, but do we get to ever get to a place where we have more predictable issuance on the other, on the other side? What does that look like? Yeah. So, I think realistically it will want to wait around, you know, one or two years after, it probably even like the clock is starts ticking next week.
So, just after phase zero. And just to verifying that the current economic structure approved stake is sustainable, I'm a verifying that that economic structure can survive the addition of shorting, the addition of the ETH one chain, verifying that EIP of 1559 is working as expected. And then once all of those pieces are in place, then I think people are going to just have a much more clear investor understanding of, you know, this is how high proof of stake issuance sales, this is how high the EIP of 1559 Bernays, this is the kind of historical variance of those two parameters. And so, like the issuance and general change of the total supply level is going to walk, I think, much more predictable a couple of years from now, and I think people are going to be very happy with their results.
Last thing for you on this fatelic, then we'll move on to something that is equally exciting in a way. If somebody is just built on the ETH one chain right now, has all of their ether on the ETH one chain, do they have to worry about any of the stuff that, like we were just talking about, or does this merge somehow in the future? Good question. The answer is they absolutely do not. So one of the big compromises that we made for kind of practicality is that, while Ethereum's consensus layer and scalability and all of these things are getting massive, kind of revamps from the ground up, Ethereum's execution layer is actually remaining remarkably constant throughout the transition.
So transactions that were valid before will be valid after a smart contract that executed in one way before will execute the same way after. Basically, all applications, contracts, ETH, everything will just be kind of migrated from the ETH one side to the ETH side automatically. And so you as a user or as an application developer, basically do not need to worry. I mean, there are a couple of corner cases, like for example, if you relied on block hashes for randomness before, then in proof of state block hashes stop being secure randomness. And so instead you would have to use like the rant out output as randomness.
But like these are block times are going to work slightly differently. But you know, these are generally like issues that only affect a very tiny portion of users. So for basically the vast, vast majority of the of the user based at the low experience, and of close to no change from an application perspective. So Vitalic, the conversation about proof of work versus proof of stake was really, really big from what I can remember in 2017 and 2018. Or it should probably even bigger before that, but I came into the world of crypto in 2017. And I actually think it's really valuable that people understand this debate and why and understand the merits of proof of work, and also understand the merits of proof of stake in order to understand like why is Ethereum so committed to proof of stake?
Like why do we want this? And so you wrote this article on your blog, fatalic.ca, everyone should check it out called why proof of stake. And we kind of want to go through some of these points so we can help help the bankless nation, like kind of come to understand the terms that you use here and the arguments of why proof of stake is inherently the right, I'm not going to say superior, but the right consensus mechanism for Ethereum, right? Because many big corners will still say to the state that proof of work is the one true consensus mechanism. So let's go through some of the points that you wrote here, proof of stake offers more security for the same cost.
Like what does that mean and how does staking offer that? So the basic idea here is that if you try to quantify security, so the easiest way to quantify security is just how many dollars you need to spend to break the thing. Then if you look at the ratio of security to cost or cost just means like how many rewards you have to put you have to push out to the participants, then the ratio of the security also to the to the amount you pay for the security just is much more favorable on the proof of stake side than it is for any version of proof of work. And I think the way that you can look at this, right, is that if you look at it just first of all, start off with a comparison between GPU based proof of work and ASIC based proof of work.
So this is a comparison that even Bitcoin people make all the time, right, when they defend why they do their ASIC based proof of work is better than the consistent algorithms is basically that in the GPU case, the cost of mining is only operating costs and there's basically no capital cost rate because you can rent GPUs. If you buy a GPU, you can always sell it after even if the blockchain disappears GPUs continue to be useful. And so if you want to attack a GPU based chain, all you have to do is just rent some GPUs for six hours or however long you want to do an attack. And so the cost of an attack is basically going to be just exactly the same as the cost of the rewards during the time period that you're attacking.
And if you as an attacker receive block rewards and the cost of the attack even drops to zero or becomes profitable by itself, right. So for GPUs, like, while GPU proof of work mining hasn't big advantage in terms of being decentralized from a security perspective, it actually is quite weak and we've seen this, right, as I mentioned in an Ethereum classic has been getting a lot of 51% attacks recently. Now, if you look at ASIC based proof of work, ASIC based proof of work is considerably more secure because ASIC based proof of work has not only ongoing costs, but also capital costs, right. And analysis I did a few years ago suggests that it's about one third ongoing cost and about two thirds capital costs, maybe that ratio changes over time.
I actually have no idea which direction is going to change into, but like that's roughly what it is approximately, right. And if you then if you kind of make some assumptions about how long in ASIC class, you can actually kind of reverse engineer what the capital costs are kind of from the amount of money that you're paying for rewards, right. So the idea basically is that if your your chain is paying $1 a day in rewards, then out of that $1 1 1 third will be operating costs to thirds will be capital costs. And you can think of the two thirds of capital costs as being a kind of amortized over the entire period of time during which that minor is mining, right.
And so if you assume that an ASIC class is about two years, I think now it's a little bit more it's a little bit more than two years. But you know, Moore's law increasing efficiency, wearing tear all these things. So at the two year level, right, all you have to do is you basically take the amount per day that they're spending on the ASIC and then multiply that by the number of days in two years, and that's the cost of the ASIC. And so if your model of an attack is that an attacker just has to buy up as many ASICs as the legitimate network, then you can use this to kind of get an estimate for the cost of the ASIC needed to attack the network.
And so here you get about $4.86 dollars. And so that's the cost of breaking paperwork if you have ASICs, right. Already much better than GPUs, but ASICs have a cost of a centralization. So now if we go to proof of stake. Can I get you to comment on Ethereum 1? If Ethereum 1, if that was the chain that would just carry on into the into the future forever, would you have been in favor of it being GPU based or would you have been interested in making an ASIC version of Ethereum? So at the beginning, that was definitely much more pro GPUs, but I think more recently, well, it's not so much that I've become more pro ASIC.
It's that I've become less pro GPU. And so it's just like it just feels like kind of a tragic choice between two differently, that options to be honest. So maybe you did have this nice property in the early days that it was a much more egalitarian, decentralized way to distribute the tokens, which arguably that's kind of what Ethereum was looking for in the first part of its life. Yeah, I agree. And I think that's very important. And I think Ethereum is definitely better as a result of having that GPU mining further in the first few years of its existence. I think that's the reason why I think that's why I think Ethereum 1, who came into Ethereum because it was able to be GPU mined, I have to say thank you for making that choice.
But not as secure compared to ASICs is the point, at least from an economic security perspective. I think the chain even had managed just to be a GPU mined up until this day only because people realized that proof of stake is coming. Like basically the reason why there isn't much more work on building ASICs is that people realize that any ASICs that get built will only survive like either a year or potentially even a few months, potentially in response to the chain getting taken over by ASICs. We could even just rush the entire transition and just like to do the more check in a couple of weeks.
Like doing that sort of thing would totally be extremely disruptive to the Ethereum ecosystem, but doing something extremely disruptive in response to an already extremely disruptive attack is a sort of thing that would happen. And so like people I think realize that it's just too risky to build ASICs because there's just no guarantee that you're actually going to have enough of a period of time during which you're going to be profitable. And that's why the chain continues to be a GPU friendly. And so the fact that like this GPU friendliness has been possible to this day should not at all be taken as evidence that GPU friendliness is a stable equilibrium going into the long term.
Shall we get into proof of stake? Yeah, so proof of stake. So basically the way that I view proof of stake is I view proof of stake as combining the efficiencies of or this capital cost the property of ASICs but really cranking that property up to the extreme and at the same time having the kind of open accessibility of GPUs. So basically proof of stake is almost entirely capital costs right the cost of like operating a notice fairly small and and the difference is though is that in the case of ASICs the capital cost is only a kind of amortized over the course of about two years. So it's about like 50% a year, but unlike ASICs deposited coins do not appreciate deposited coins deposit them you can stake for a bit and you can get them back.
And so you actually don't even need that high of a rate of return to motivate people to stake. So here I was actually I think understating the case right because I hear saying you know imagine a 15% rate of return is enough to motivate people to be willing to walk up their money and stake. But and I think 15% is roughly the rate of return that we're going to see in this initial phase of you to like I think with the current level of deposits it's about 18%. But you know we're going to see more deposits, but I think in the long run, especially when it's possible to just deposit stake for a bit and then we'll draw get your money back within a day like I fully expect that the rate of the rate of return will just drop to something who are sort of 10% or even 5%.
And so but even with 15% rate a 15% rate of return on the capital that basically means that you know $1 per day of rewards is going to attract 6.667 worth of worth of deposits right. Basically like if you have to if you stick at $2,400 in as a deposit, then your annual return would be $2,400 multiplied by 15%, which would be around you know close to 365. And so 365 dollars a year is equal to $1 a day right. So if we assume 15% rate of return per year, then every $1 a day and rewards is going to correspond to $2,400 or three dollars of deposits. That's at current rates if the rates drop to 5% and this on Broadway so it goes up to $7,500 right.
Now if we assume that only 90% of the costs are capital costs and they're still 10% that are operating costs, then the 24, 33 goes down to about 2189. But basically even still right we have five times more deposits that are paid for by the same rewards in proof of stake as compared to a signature in proof of work. So and this is now in the long term like I expected to go up to something like 10,000 so it would be 25 times stronger than the proof of work. So does the security is that summarized as the security of proof of stake comes from the fact that either the asset doesn't deprecate in the same way the asick a machine does and so ether gives you a year on year return where an asick gives you a year on year deprecation devaluation of the unit right and so that's the fundamental component of where proof of stake gets its security from.
Yes, that's definitely an excellent way of us getting the point. So where we've come so far is we have GPU based proof of work work which Ethereum is on now that means you can use the GPU card and like your Nvidia like gaming machine to to mine a little bit. And that total cost of attack is like fairly cheap like it you could attack that fairly easily lower economic security and then Bitcoin has asick based proof of work which is a bit more expensive to attack so higher economic security. The economic security comes from the fact that that asick is only doing one job that's only possible to do one job which is mine Bitcoin it's dedicated so it's all sunk capital costs basically you are locked in so and now proof of stake because it's like ultra sunk costs that's the only thing you can really like kind of you know do with do with it it's almost like a tokenized asick on steroids if you will that's even more efficient and how would you quantify this is this like a 5x more efficient.
Like bang for the bang for the security for the dollar or is it a 10x. Like according to the kind of back on the back of the envelope numbers here it's 5x and the shorts are meant up to 20x in the long term wow. So I think of this you know David I've you know often sort of analogized these sort of chains to nation states and this is like the security force this is the defense right and so it's almost like you're upgrading your military from. Calvary and horses to like pans or tanks here right like you're trying to think like what what what's the good a good analogy like okay so here's a really fun in dominoes so.
GPU based proof of work is you have to like basically hire soldiers out every every every day to patrol your borders to make sure the enemy army doesn't get in and you have to keep on paying them. It is the great the great wall of China then proof of stake is imagine a great a great wall of China that has the property that the way that this wall is constructed is that when people are not staying in their own houses they just teleport the walls there are the walls of their houses and they make it part of the well they make it part of the great wall. So whenever you're not in your house whenever you're going off on vacation you just click a button in your house teleports to be in part of the wall and you know the government pays you some small amount of money to do this and you're happy to collect the reward and then as soon as you want to move back into your house you just click a button again and the balls teleport back at their part of your house again right so basically.
It just like you don't even need to kind of create these separate resources you're just kind of taking advantage of existing resources and you're moving on moving them over to a different purpose when people know they don't need them for a long time so much more capital. So the idea is that the great wall this version of the great wall of China would theoretically be a lot higher because of the incentive for everyone to allocate the walls of their house into the walls of the great wall of China in the moments that they are not inside their house using their house as a house. Exactly. The interesting thing so it is I think here.
You talked about this in the article right so we're talking about a five to twenty X gain in proof of stake potentially and the question is what do we do with this efficiency gain as a social contract for a theorem can you talk about that because it seems like there are like you know maybe two options here of what to do with this drastically improved military. Yes, so one of them is to keep the military budget the same but have much higher security and the other one is to have the same security but cut the military budget down and I guess. I guess the reason why I think we're taking the second approach is actually best I got to even describe to the next section right I think I think we like if there is enough security today especially if attacks become much easier to recover from and we actually don't even need to have like too much spending going into going into keeping the wall up.
Because you know if it turns out that basically even if someone successfully invades so like you can do this clever move clever move where you just like hard for it and you delete their army so. So I want to get into that just to to to to link folks into what you're talking about like so the way Ethereum right now the way Bitcoin right now pays for their military is generally through block reward through issuance through supply right so and. Bitcoin's approach is to cut that military budget at least military budget denominated Bitcoin every four years cut it in half every four years so we're we're the Bitcoin protocol government every four years you know what it's forced on you we're going to slash your military like like by by four right at least denominated in Bitcoin by two by two excuse me.
Ethereum's approach is basically to do something that's maybe more what the social contract is kind of called minimum necessary issuance or minimum viable issuance where it's like hey like maybe we can drop this a whole lot more because we have a stronger defense system. And so that that issuance essentially is what goes to pay for the military and maybe that could be slash maybe that could be cut right now it's a four four and a half percent or so and we could go to something less than one percent. Absolutely. So one of the theories I've had about one of the reasons why proof of stake is is more more secure in the long term is that with that reduced issuance that reduction of issuance actually compounds as a benefit over time and I want to get your take on this because I don't know if this is real or not.
And this is the same same dynamic is present in EIP 1559 the more ether that's burned in EIP 1559 the more ether is unable to be leveraged in an attack against takers right the less ether we can make available to the secondary market the less ether there's available for attackers to be able to grab. And use that to attack the ethereum network is that is that a real thing so like the less ether that we issue is that over time adding to security. It's definitely an interesting and kind of novel way to think about it and I guess I mean generally yes like the less ether there is and and even like the higher the price goes the harder it is for an attacker to buy enough to successfully make an attack and it's definitely one of the factors that contributes to security.
And if you have miners that are just constantly selling millions of coins every year then you know some of those coins are going to end up in the hands of people that might be interested in attacking at some point. So let's go into one of the grand ways as to say somebody did somehow manage to get their hands on some enough ether to attack the chain. We actually have a way around this and so one of one of the sections in this pieces is titled attacks are much easier to recover from in proof of stake and maybe we can talk about like the after an attack happens what path to maintaining or you know restoring security does the theorem have.
Yeah so I think in the GPU case the only defense is basically just waiting and hoping the attacker goes away which has worked so far right but like as soon as an attacker comes that's persistent you're basically screwed and you have to try to figure out something else. In an ASIC based system you do have one form of defense which has you just changed the proof of work algorithm and what that does is basically kind of bricks like all the ASICs and renders them useless but it bricks both the attackers ASICs and the honest miners ASICs right but if the attacker is willing to suffer that initial expense.
Then at that point it just turns into a GPU mines coin up until you know after a couple of years where people build ASICs for the new algorithm again and so it just turns into the into the first paragraph and the attacker can just continue the attack really cheaply for as long as they want. In fact I would even argue that it's worse than this because if an attacker starts doing this and if the attacker commits to continuing to attack. Then it actually takes away from the incentive to build ASICs for the new algorithm because anyone building the ASICs knows that if the attacker is going to continue then potentially those ASICs could get ripped a second time.
Basically the fact that breaking hurts both the attacker and the honest miners actually makes the game theory behind all of this even worse. So in the proof of state case basically it gets much better right because like we have this concept of slash it right so if you contribute to breaking the chain you get swatched and even if you contribute to breaking the chain as part of a 51% attack you get swatched. Now there are attacks that are hard to detect and hard to slash for so a big one is like a 51% coalition censoring everyone else but you can get around this by using this wonderful trick that the Bitcoin people invented in 2017 called the UASF the user activated software right basically just.
Users coordinate on participating in a minority chain and they just abandoned the majority chain that censoring them and actually because of the way that the cash per FG rules work the attacker cannot legally kind of move over to the minority chain without contradicting themselves and getting slashed and so the attacker just gets a week and they lose about half their points right so. Basically no matter how you attack the chain it's going to be very expensive for the attacker not very expensive for everyone was not an attacker and so. The game is very asymmetric right like every time the attacker attacks to lose a huge amount of money and potentially like the amount of coins that are burned as a result of an attack when you could even need that an attack would cause the price of ethical up.
So like one of my favorite features about proof of stake is that if an attacker attacks the theorem it makes all the stakers rich by by default well not by default but. But it's highly likely that the price of ether goes up because of somebody's buying up all this ether what one question I had when I had about this like using this as a defensive mechanism in proof of stake this is relying on the social layer right this is. In this moment security has migrated away from the actual code and moved into the social layer which it may be it perhaps is one day this ever does happen it would be coordinated via something like Twitter or Reddit can you talk about that dynamic.
Yeah so there's definitely a lot of kind of discomfort in relying on the social layer for consensus but then actually I wrote about this quite a bit in my original 2014 article the one where it's a called like how I learned still off week subjectivity if you actually just go in and I could go for that now you can probably find it. So basically the arguments that I make is that relying on social consensus is actually reasonable occasionally it's just that consensus is social consensus is not something that you want to kind of keep on keep leaning on forever right so the idea is basically that I mean even Bitcoin relies on social consensus I'm extent right like even you know the UASF that was proposed in 2016.
It's ultimately a form of social consensus overriding mining so basically you know hard forks are done with social consensus. Even the idea that if miners push a blockchain that would increase the supply to be on 21 million then people would reject that blockchain is ultimately secured by social consensus. The difference between a malicious protocol change and a bug fix is social consensus so relying on social consensus on in these kind of extreme matters where and especially on matters where there is clearly one side which is an attack and one side which is just trying to push the chain forward is I think actually a reasonable thing to do.
The thing that you don't want to do is you don't want to rely on social consensus too often right and the thing to keep in mind is that if you even think about like how an attack on proof of work would be responded to right like even like defenders of a basic base proof of work will say if our 51% attack happens we can just break the a second we can change the algorithm right like if you press them on it they will say that this is what this is a defense. But that defense as well it's also social consensus like changing the work algorithm is also a form of social consensus overriding the overriding the code so.
It's also strike it's also striking that the price of Bitcoin price in itself is one layer of social consensus to. It is indeed yeah and we've seen we've seen this the idea of breaking a six that's played out a number of times I believe in the manero community so this is not hypothetical conversations this is this is strategy that blockchain have blockchain ecosystems have leveraged. Ave is a borrowing and lending protocol on Ethereum and just recently released Ave version 2 which has a ton of cool new features that makes using Ave even more powerful with Ave you can leverage the full power of DeFi money Legos yield and composability all in one application on Ave there are a ton of assets that you can deposit in order to gain yield and all of those same assets can also be borrowed from the protocol if you have deposited collateral.
Here you can see me getting a 200 USDC loan against my portfolio of a number of different DeFi tokens and ETH. I'll choose a variable interest rate because it's a lower rate than the stable interest rate option but I could choose the stable interest rate option if I wanted to lock that interest rate in permanently. One of Ave's V2 features is the ability to swap collateral without having to withdraw your assets trade them on Uniswap and then deposit them back into Ave. Ave does all of this for you all in one seamless transaction so you don't have to repay loans in order to change the collateral you have backing them.
Check out the power of Ave at Ave.com that's AAVE.com. If you want to live a bankless life you need to get a Monolith DeFi Visa card. Monolith is a one to punch of both an Ethereum smart contract wallet and an accompanying Visa card that lets you spend the money that you have in your Ethereum wallet everywhere where Visa is accepted. When you swipe your Monolith Visa card at the grocery store or at a restaurant it actually makes a transaction on the Ethereum blockchain that spends some of the money you hold in your Monolith wallet. It's insanely cool and it's one of the best tools out there for living a bankless but still normal life.
Monolith also offers on-ramp services for getting your Fiat money into the world of DeFi. So it's trivial to top up your Monolith card if you ever need to and your deposited money goes straight into your non-custodial wallet so your money is never held by a centralized intermediary. Because Monolith is native Ethereum infrastructure the money you hold in your Monolith wallet still has the power of DeFi behind it. Swapping assets on Uniswap or earning yield in DeFi is at your fingertips. Go to monolith.xyz and sign up to get your Monolith Visa card today. So let's move on to one of my favorite subjects which is how proof of stake is more decentralized than ASICs.
Some people would call this a bold claim. Vitalik, why can you make such a claim? So I think we do need to break up proof of work into two categories at GPUs and ASICs. There is a very decent case in GPU based on proof of work. It's quite decentralized that I'm happy to admit this. My claim against the GPU mining is not about the decentralization. It's about the security. The problem with ASICs on the other hand is that in order to make an ASIC you need millions of dollars of capital. Now you could say you don't have to make your own ASIC you could buy an ASIC but the reality is that if you're buying an ASIC the side that's making the most profit is not going to be you.
It's going to be the ASIC manufacturer. Exactly. Like in the long run it's like the game is very much one that's kind of skewed to benefit whoever can sell the best shovel. And you know whoever can sell the best shovel has a lot of like they can potentially even like sneaky and code that could allow that ASIC to be bricked remotely like they could do also several evil things that are harder to do with if you're running the thing on general purpose hardware. So basically like ASIC based mining really does and rely very heavily on this very small number of these very wealthy and powerful manufacturers.
And so basically if proof of stake means the rich gets richer will guess what ASIC mining also means the rich get richer except the bar that you needs them pass in order to get richer in the case of ASIC mining is something like $10 million. But in the case of proof of stake it's $20,000 today and much less than $20,000 in the future once taking polls become possible. So one of the I've been chewing around the ideas of staking pools and there's a bunch of different design parameters. But I think the staking pool that retains as much ethos of Ethereum as possible which I think that there is a spectrum of how much does a protocol or company on Ethereum retain the original ethos of the system there's something to be said for that.
And that's kind of where I turn my attention to rocket pool or rocket pulls trying to become a staking pool for people to decentralize the number the amount of people that can participate in staking by being a pool and also decentralizing the nodes by making more total nodes available to be part of the Ethereum proof of stake consensus mechanism. When you think of rocket pull is that what you think of? Yeah, I think rocket pull is definitely one of the good examples of someone trying to do a good job. The ethier protocol is really explicitly designed to make a decentralized staking with things like multi-party computation as easy as possible.
So that's definitely the sort of direction that we're looking into. There's also this subargument that you made here of a talent that proof of stake is more censorship resistant and that's basically because it's not on the electricity grid right for instance like in the way that a GPU mining or ASIC mining footprint might be is that the is at the main argument here. Yes, exactly like if you imagine you know here you want your living in say Venezuela and you want to participate in the Ethereum network then if you're a proof of work miner, then you know realistically you're consuming huge amounts of electricity you have to get huge amounts of hardware.
The government wants to find you they can find right like it's it's not hard to see someone can see like consuming that much electricity. These are tech and the extent they've already perfected for years to figuring out finding people who are growing the wrong kind of plants in their backyard. It does make you wonder how long it would take a motivated government body like the United States or some other government body. Maybe let's not name different governments here to go seek out all of the major mining Bitcoin mining or even Ethereum mining facilities in the world and just confiscate them take them over by for by physical force.
Yes, it's just I think it's kind of a little bit of a game maybe that that some encrypto play as if we've already faced off against these nation states that are actually actually trying to censor us. There's just not even trying yet so yeah that is that is an advantage it may come into play but there are also some advantages that you talked about here Vitalik of proof of work and I think we'd be remiss if we didn't mention that the way is proof of work actually is superior because there are some tradeoffs can you talk about these. Yeah, so these are like what I think are the two best arguments in favor of proof of work like one is this critique that proof of stake feels more like a closed system like there is into this kind of new source of issuance that that kind of brings fresh economic blood into the ecosystem.
And it feels like the system has this kind of natural kind of in tropic pressure to just be more of the same people by default and this is definitely something that does kind of concern me to some extent. And the best rebuttal that I have is that in proof of stake the rewards in general are going to be fairly low right like I think if proof of stake rewards were say 10% of annually then like I could see that very quickly lead to a few stakers very quickly date I'm having a very large portion of the entire supply and just updating everything. But here we're talking about validator rewards equal to like up to 0.
5 to 2% probably closer to 0.5% of the total supply and the more validators are staking the lower the interest rates yet right and so the amount of time needed for this factor to like cause a large amount of concentration is huge right it's potentially over a century. And on such timescale is like doesn't really matter much right like people want to spend money they want to distribute their money among new children they want to give their money to charity and so like aren't the like basically if there are any natural economic pressures toward the concentration at all then like they're going to have an effect that's larger than 0.
5% every year is basically the arguments. Whereas if that rate was instead of 0.5% something like 4.5% then I think this argument would actually have a much stronger case. So this is one of the reasons why I'm pushing for lower rewards. And the reason people make this argument is of course is as we stated earlier. Stake Death is almost like an everlasting asick there's no depreciation there's no capital depreciation unlike a real world doesn't separate exactly. And notably the people that that crypto has in it like accidentally inadvertently made really wealthy are largely people that I'm guessing this my gut tape that weren't wealthy beforehand right and so like what's the point of hanging on to you every single last denomination of ether.
If you like you can't sell it and like have like kind of a nice more comfortable lifestyle like the people that have large supplies of ether are going to have to sell if they ever want that material impact to do something real in their lives. And so that's kind of what I think what you are alluding to Vitalik is that the rewards the passive income rewards to ether a crew slower than people's people find ways to sell their ether to buy a new house or new car or something and so there's like this natural sort of incentive to let go of your ether. What about the second point Vitalik we talked about weak subjectivity earlier does does anything bear repeating here.
Now weak subjectivity is this extremely fascinating topic and I think it's been really the center of the debate all of us like ever since the beginning and up until this day like basically weak subjectivity is this really subtle thing right like the idea is that in proof of work. You know you have this a property that you have your client and you can just started at any time and even if you've been offline for 10 years you just started up and you can seek to the valichet and you have all or the canonical chain and you have all of these economic guarantees. In proof of stake like you can kind of still do that but it depends on what guarantees you want right so like if you're here if the guarantees that you care about are in an honest majority model.
So you just assume that the majority of people are nice then you can still do that but if you want to have a hard economic guarantee so you want to have a guarantee that says you know tricking you requires the attacker to burn a huge amount of money the way the proof of stake. Again if promises a strong economic guarantees then you lose this property to some extent right and the reason why you lose this property to some extent is basically because. Like if an attacker just create like who has say 51% of the stake creates a fake chain and they can and they can see that this fake chain is the real chain then.
Like normally the the the way that they will get punished for this is they would be swatched right like if you create a fake chain that can flex with the real chain that you already contributed to making then you know some large portion of the of the valid data to the sac you can make proofs and you can. And you can publish those proofs into both chains and you can birth in the attackers money so right we offense this is just like standard middle career stake theory like how swatching works with the problem is what if the attacker has already withdrawn their the deposits that they use to make the attack by the time that they actually need to do the attack right so what if someone has been offline for a year.
And you feed them a chain that looks like a valid chain from the perspective of their client that was off on online for the last time a year ago but back in present reality you've already taken out all your points and so whatever slashing happens can't actually hit you. So you could still trick them and you would not get swatched for it and so if you want to be resistant against this attack basically you just have to log on and kind of be online often enough that basically the time difference between any two times during which you come online is less than the time that it takes for something like one third of the validator sent to be replaced right which is.
And that number depends on the size of the validator said it's like somewhere between a couple of days and a couple of months depending on how many people are participating. So like that like that requirement the requirement that in order to have a really kind of economically guaranteed level of security on which chain you're getting you need to log on with your clients at least once every few months like that is the this week subjectivity requirements. And the reason why like a lot of people feel uncomfortable about this is because it basically means that if you're locked if you're just joining the system for the first time then you know you for the first time that you log on you need to basically find some third party source that basically tells you like which chain is the canonical one that you should be following.
Now most of the time this actually isn't a big deal because most of the time there aren't going to be 51% attackers trying to use their old keys to screw people over until there is really going to be like one chain that has enough signatures right but in the extreme case where there are attackers that can like buy up people's old keys. Then basically in order to disemperage you do need to find someone to trust to give you that information and deep fans of proof of work say that you know oh my god this is trust this is fatal what what are you doing you've completely destroyed the point of cryptocurrency.
But my argument is basically that like this level of trust is a level of trust that we already have so like for example you already trust developers to tell you the most recent hard fork version you already trust them to fix bugs you already get self group it's from them once every half a year so and so why not just like leverage that existing level of trust and I use it for proof of stake check pointing as well. So that's basically you know so with with proof of work in Nakamoto consensus we have the ability to actually legitimately and concretely verify the amount of work that is done on a particular chain we don't have that with proof of stake because we're not doing work we are and so they're.
We're verifying signatures that are signed by validators and in order to recognize that those validators actually are real you have to look at the state of the watching itself like at time you know a couple of months ago to a year ago right so. The security of a proof stake chain is definitely more kind of I mean it's not like it's not circular it's more like a spiral right it's like the security of the system today depends on the validity of the chain six months ago and the security of the chain six months ago depends on the validity of what happened 12 months ago and so like if you skip one of those steps then.
And if you're on offline for longer than that period of time that you do you do need some way to kind of help you disindecuate and come back online but if you're there more often then like basically staying in sync with the chain is more of this like necessarily dynamic process right. Right so here's kind of I guess my takeaway to just sort of summarize this article and you guys jump in if you have some other things if you are willing to get past this edge case week subjectivity requirement and you made some compelling arguments why that. That makes sense or it's less important than other thing and if you're willing to get past this issue that stake never depreciates and so there is the capability for people in the system to continue.
Accruing wealth and you sort of mitigate against that against that with lower rewards overall then what you end up with is a chain that is much more economically secure and also more efficient in that economic security so you can do things like. Reduced issuance reduce the cost to actually secure that network essentially get security per dollar exactly that's that's what proof of stake that's what proof of stake provides at least under a theorem right because there are other flavors of proof of stake but yes. Would you add anything to that italic no I think in general it's a great summer. Very cool.
And italic when a lot of the design design decisions behind proof of stake and when you when you you know verbalize your arguments and kind of just like thought out loud about these the weighing the pros and cons. The way that you did that turns to our the next article that we want to talk about which is convexity versus con con cavity. And so like and we were just burning through your articles here so you can put out a blog post faster than anyone and and I totally aligned with this article and Ryan and I chewed on it together and had some conversations about like the implications of this before we get into those conversations maybe you can kind of give us the synopsis on like convex first concave dispositions.
Yeah so I think the core idea here is basically that like whenever there's a trade off and there's like a choice between kind of taking one path and taking another path. One of the kind of more subtle differences between how people view that trade off is basically like do they is how they view the kind of extremes as opposed to what the options in the middle. So basically do they view it as the sort of situation where the moderate option is kind of more likely to be better than the extreme options or do they view it as this scenario where you know it is one or the other and if you try to mix the two together then it just completely doesn't I doesn't make any sense.
And like you know really as if they're this or that and so like those two graphs that are right there they get to a good job of kind of showing what the perspective is right like basically like the graph on the left like the concave world view as they kind of like you have a yeah a graph that's kind of sloped downward so it's kind of like a hill right like so there's there's always some option in the middle that's best but you know whether it's kind of in the middle but much closer to the left or in the middle much closer to the right. That's something you can literally argue on but then you know as you go further to the extremes and then eventually on either side to just start the starts becoming worse versus the convex world view which looks less to the chart looks less like a hill and more like a valley where you know you pretty much you want to be either on one side or the other side in the middle is the worst place to be.
So again like this starts off being very abstract but I mean if you go like once we kind of go forward to go a few paragraphs down like we can see it where it starts becoming more concrete and we can see some like specific examples of like what kind of game and convex means right so here I just like give us some examples of like what kinds of things someone with a concave my calm disposition versus a convex disposition might say. So one of them so one kind of concave statements going to the extremes has never been good for us you can die from being too hot or too cold we need to find the balance between the two that's just right.
If you implement only a little bit of a philosophy you can pick the parts that are the best and avoid the parts that are risky but if you insist on going to the extremes. Then once you've picked the low hanging fruit the next fruit that you have to pick are going to be forced to work harder and harder and you'll have smaller and smaller benefits and the risks might multiply and out way the whole thing. The opposing philosophy the philosophy that you favor less probably has some value to and so you should generally try to combine the benefit the best parts to both and definitely avoid things that the opposing philosophy continues to consider to be extremely terrible.
You know just in case they have more of a point than you realize and then some examples of a convex statements one is we need to focus otherwise we risk becoming a jack of all trades master of none. Another example of a convex concept is the kind of the slippery slope concept that so if we take even a few steps down that road will become a slippery slope and only pull us down even further until we end up in the abyss there's only two stable positions either here or there and we want to stay here. If you give an inch to take a mile whether we're following this philosophy or that philosophy we should just be following something and stick to it stick to it making a wishy-washy mix of everything doesn't make sense and so.
So after this like I get into what's probably the kind of motivating example of this idea for me which is basically the Bitcoin versus a theory on my you know like. Before before before we get there like I feel like I've met these two types of people right like I've met the you know the binary thinker the convex disposition thinker which is like you're with me or against me kind of individual right and then I've definitely met the the concave disposition which is a bit more the pragmatist I could see it this way I could see it that way why don't we find the balance in between. And one of those definitely sounds like more of an ethereum not to stereotype and one of those sounds definitely more like a Bitcoin or again not to stereotype.
Part of me wonders how much people are just hard wired into these modes like from like birth and genetics and like whatever happens to them in the in the in the early ages because I don't know. You like I definitely met these types of people and I'm not sure how much they can kind of help it. And it's definitely noted in the crypto industry like when you come into this world do you find yourself quickly moving into a camp of sorts like usually big corners or a theory and like you kind of find yourself in to be one or the other. And there never really seems to be any of this like moment of flux where people are confused they just kind of come to find themselves aligned with one of their particular communities and it's I think you've totally tapped on to very real parameter of personality that I think would predispose someone for one community or the other.
No, definitely I think again it's it's definitely a really interesting question like to to what extent like someone someone's disposition toward this like is you know either genetic or just like some cultural thing that's like so deep like 5,000 year old or whatever that I might as well be genetic like if that's true then you know that does mean that you know for example even if you personally like a theory on more than Bitcoin. There's just no way that you're ever going to convince 100% of the world population to also be in that same camp and so you just have to acknowledge that Bitcoin is going to continue to exist and we're always be some kids you should see that it appeals to and if you're a Bitcoin person then you'll have to kind of pretty much admit the opposite.
So you know if people really are in a difference in that way then that does also just like say something for kind of maximalism versus pluralism in the world and I guess just one of the nice things about cryptocurrency as opposed to say traditional nation states as that it's just so much easier to kind of sort yourself into the community that reflects your values more. So what I want to ask you about your opinion as to the scalability of these social organizations that people find themselves in so the way that I interpreted the convexity versus concavity graphs like one is a you shape and one is a end shape right and so if you put a ball on one of on both of those on the on the con cavity it rolls off to the edges right it falls off to the edge and then there's like a pit that the ball would fall into like a.
And my mind goes to a mean to the money calls a mull lock trap right a little trap where people like fall into where the convexity is a it's a valley right you rock step fall down to the bottom of the valley the center of the valley. So my gut take is that a convex world view or convexity is a more scalable group of coordinated people with the same opinions because they tend to converge upon pragmatism they send to converge upon the same. So I think the idea is where the concavity seems to find itself in falling into a thousand different traps in different directions would you actually think just one quick way to fix your analogy unfortunately I think it's it's the concave world view right that's the one that's more inclined to stay in the middle like the problem is that like in economics the concept of utility is like positive utility is better right and so.
Whereas the gravity analogy is like you know you want to fall down right and so down as like the direction of the tendency or like preference if you want to talk about the physical forces that way so like look at upside down I guess if you want to apologize that way but yes and I think. But like module that it's definitely a great way of looking at the issue because I think one of the challenges with the convex world view is basically that like if your girl view was that right now we're on the top of a mountain and we are going to fall on the left side of the mountain versus the right side of the mountain then your first instinct is going to be well which side of the mountain.
See or that so seems less bad to fall down and we're just going to fight like hell to make everyone fall down that side as fast as possible to avoid the greater evil of people falling down the falling down the other side of the mountain and then if you have people on both sides they're both thinking that way then you know you basically end up getting into what's out of war so and I think. That that's definitely a very kind of good consequence of that intuition pump and so for for for those listening in who maybe. Don't haven't seen that yet do we have some examples from the Bitcoin community for from the Ethereum community that kind of maybe maybe prove this out I consider you almost in this article like it's a little bit philosophy but it's a little bit anthropology as well right where you're like studying the culture of Bitcoin and the decisions that the culture has made and contrasting that to the decisions in the culture that that Ethereum has but what are some good examples of this like for was the block size.
Debate a good example of this cultural temperament. Absolutely so basically and if you remember the block size debate like basically the block size at the beginning was one megabyte and then there were all these arguments about you know doing make blocks unlimited doing eight from 20 megabytes or make them eight megabytes do we do some two four eight sort of thing and eventually. The side that ended up winning is very close to the extreme small block side basically says and in a box are one megabyte and then there's this one kind of software called segway which de facto increases the block size to 2.
3 megabytes and then there's basically. No increase that kind of going from there right and if you remember during the block size debate in the big block camp there were people who are were in favor of moderate increases so people who are in favor of you know eight but not 20 or four but not eight and there were people who are in favor of just not having a block size limit at all because they felt that. You know the system just needs to be able to support as much capacity as the needs are like the market should be deciding block size and like there's a bit of a tangent about how that particular claim is crazy because the mechanism isn't really a market and basically like you did have like these people who wanted very big.
And I remember like one of the arguments that that the very big block people would make is basically that well you know if you oppose the like what the small block people are trying to do is that you should follow that thinking to the quote logical conclusion and you should realize that ultimately the correct approach is no block size limit at all right and remember being fascinated by that because like okay so basically if you're saying that you know moving from. Like points x to point x plus one like if you support moving from x to x plus one then you should also support moving from x x plus 10 to x plus 11 like no I don't believe that.
Like what kind of world view is this that's a convex world view it's a very convex world it is indeed and so that was a convex people on the big block side right and then. Convex people on the small block side like like I argued against them on and a lot of places like red it whatever all the time right like a lot of the small blockers would say things like I would say oh no you know see we need to compromise and we need to make sure that it's possible to read the to read the blockchain and it's also possible to write to the blockchain you think to send the transaction transactions in the blockchain.
I'm at affordable rates and we need to find some way to compromise between those two and they're like no either the system is decentralized or it isn't and if it's 95% decentralized then really that just means it's on a track toward not be a decentralized at all and either you can verify the thing or you can't and everyone should be verified everyone should be totally verifying yet and anything that involves any degree of trust just is trust and you know we should all just dismiss any any level of trust as being basically the same as just using PayPal. And I remember also finding this this world view like very unreasonable and dogmatic as well.
And actually on that specific issue I wrote another of italic.ca article recently if you remember the one that is called on trust models that was from August right like this is the one where I talk about the differences between yeah if you're a philosophy section I think it's there. The third one there it is at twenty twenty August twenty basically you know there is an event trust models there is an over two event trust models there's one event trust there's zero event trust scroll down a bit and you see the graph right there it is so basic like the thing that I argue is that one of one event trust is actually much much closer to zero event trust and then it is to and out of two event trust right and like on the graph like it really does seem like it is much like much closer but a person who asked a convex perspective on trust would say you know no no either you're at zero or then or your trust and if you're trust then you're on team paypal and book a paypal is going to support if you're in now so you know we can't.
Paypal I don't know what we're supposed to hate. What's interesting about it is because this convex bent at first blush it looks very strong because the community absolutely stands for things. There shall be only twenty one million thou shalt not print more bitcoin ever but then when you like when you kind of look at it a little bit more and maybe this is just the concave in me kind of speaking but you also see this brittleness like I wonder quite frankly what the convex bitcoin or communities going to do if it finds out that it needs more security than twenty one million bitcoin at some point as these happenings continue into the future does it does does that convex uh like mode just tear at the center and become brittle does the community completely fracture apart because it can't make any compromise on anything at all.
It has to stick with sort of this this maximalist type of ideology and philosophy so it's weird because it appears that there's a strength to this like philosophy but there's also a brittleness to it and I'm not sure how to see that. I definitely think that's a very good way of describing the trade-off like this concept of shelling fences and just setting heartbound reasons saying we're just never ever going beyond them. That's definitely a powerful thing it's definitely can be a scalable form of social coordination it can be very emotionally appealing as well but yes you know it is brittle and as soon as you enter into a kind of territory that you were not expecting it can easily end up backfiring on you.
So like in the case of bitcoin right like if they discovered that transaction fees are not enough they basically have three choices like one of them is uh for it more than twenty one million the second day is a switch to prove stake and the third is just accepts that the blockchain will get fifty one percent attack from time to time and uh you'll just have like people uh sometimes days worth of transactions being reverted. And it's surprised to be to an insane extreme extent just how many people are willing to accept the third option. Right. Right. Have you seen any of this like even on Twitter?
I've seen a ton of it like oh no no no no no you don't understand that like like like transactions being ever being final was never one of the intended properties of their point. Here pure sharp makes this exact argument that it's no big deal right like we wait days for transactions to finalize. Would you characterize this as a mollock trap. Good question um is this a mollock trap. I guess well a mollock trap would be a situation where like everyone or most people wants the situation to go in a certain direction but just because they can't get along and it ends up going in the opposite direction.
I guess in that Bitcoin case like would it be a mollock trap like one possibility would be that like people actually literally genuinely prefer the blockchain breaking once every few weeks to violating either one of the core tenants. I think what would happen in reality is that there's a small minority that genuine we feel is that way but the average Bitcoiner I think is more pragmatic and they really would rather switch to a proof of stake or add a small amount of issuance then accepts that state of affairs. And so I could I could definitely see just like coordination failures between those two leading to like a split or read or just taking a really long a really long time to resolve the situation and I definitely categorize that as being mollock.
So Vitalik it was very obvious to me when you were writing this that it was coming from the design philosophy of blockchains. The design philosophy of crypto economic networks but on the bank this program right and I talk about how these crypto economic networks are very comparable to like a neo nation a new generation of a nation right and so when we're talking about design philosophy of a blockchain network we're also kind of talking about the design philosophy of a new type of social organization a new kind of nation. And so when Ryan and I resonated with the concave view it seemed to be out of an endeavor and also when we kind of come to the came to the conclusion that Ethereum seems to be resonating with the concave view that Ethereum is trying to offer this credibly neutral layer and what is credible neutrality other than being in the middle being a pragmatist about the middle of a curve.
And so when a good nation state to me allows people to go about their day and achieve their personal goals without having the any any sort of convexity of the design disposition of a nation state or a crypto economic network. Getting in the way of these individuals goals right like we want to empower the individual but it's important to have an organization where the wins of one individual doesn't impact the wins of another individual in achieving their daily goals and so that's where the neutrality of a nation state or the neutrality of a crypto economic network comes into play in order to really empower the individual without enabling them to get in the way of empowering others.
Is it was this kind of what you were thinking about when you wrote about this? Yeah, and I think it was kind of a concave versus a convex day definitely has implications going far beyond out of crypto politics and I think nation state issues are definitely one place where that this becomes also a really a really important concern. I mean down the line I even give examples around a nation state issues like dealing with the coronavirus and taxation and how convexity and concavity and war like how they end up kind of affecting those. And one philosophical thing that you could argue is that like even the concept of freedom is to some extent a fundamentally concave concept right because like one way to think about freedom is that like if side A is my way of life is better and everyone should live a quarter to my way of life inside B as your way of life is better and everyone should live according to your way of life then.
And the freedom basically says while people who are like my way of life live according to my way of life and people who are like your way of life live according to your way of life and that like that is in some way a compromise between those two options right so. So you can definitely look at each other concavity in that way but then in as we see there's a lot of like a different layering here you can look at concavity in a lot of different ways I mean you can even look at concavity versus convexity or something affecting your personal decisions so. Like a bit further above in the case of Bitcoiners right I mean the carnivory thing was that one great example of this is like proof that this actually does get into like like this is convexity right like.
You know like a concave person would say oh you know you should eat a balanced diet and you should make sure to have like some have some salad have some good like be their fish or whatever you like have some have some grains but a convex person would say I don't know there's one thing that's healthiest and you should you should figure that out using. So carnivores or convex vegans are also convex but in all the other hand normal people end up being a more concave and on the diet issue I find myself more concave to what a coincidence. It's it's funny because I think this this is the type of article that you have to kind of like chew on and you can apply to so many areas of life but I will tell you that one gift it gave me is actually understanding crypto Twitter and understanding like Bitcoin or culture and Ethereum culture because for so long Vitalik like I just didn't understand it to be honest like I didn't understand the perspective.
Where you kind of explain something or you talk about something and there'd be still such a casm such a delta and it's because of these totally different world views like once you see it it kind of explains everything I'm curious where you where you got this mental model of the world. I mean have you seen anything like this elsewhere or you influenced by anything when you're when you were thinking about concave versus convex I haven't seen anything quite that illustrates it in this way. Yeah I'm not sure if like this exact presentation like existed in some literature before like again the like concavity and convexity are definitely like things that you would understand in mathematics and like concavity is definitely a thing and economics like for example and like I talk about taxes below and that's like one of those examples there.
But I think it just like took years of brushing up against this kind of like a versus the logic and eventually just like figuring out like yes this is where the divide is. So what are the implications here does this mean that at some level that aetherians should try less hard to explain their positions to people who are very convex in thinking because there's just going to be a delta there that can't be passed and maybe we should focus more on finding the other concave people in the world is that one implication what are your thoughts on the implications here. It could be I think there's definitely people who I think are just attracted to the convex perspectives in a way that would be very hard to kind of get them to find the Ethereum camp appealing and you know maybe that's okay and again that's just like one property of like of opposition to you know like Bitcoin.
So I guess there can be these multiple ecosystems they can all look at a prosper within their communities and I think ultimately you know for crypto to become mainstream like yes it does need to just to kind of reach out to the wider world that you have to explain its perspective to the wider world more. I do think that we should continue kind of making the case for aetherian and I think one of the ways in which I think the philosophy here can help is that I think Ethereum sometimes gets framed as not having values because it's not willing to just automatically take a direction and stick to it.
I think I don't think that's not necessarily true right because I think Ethereum has values and has things that it's pushing towards but concavity is a good mental model to explain how it's possible to believe in something but at the same time be moderate about it and it's possible to actually have this as something you believe and not just something you are because you just don't know what you are. So say for say we fast forward into 20 30 years into the future and Ethereum is maximally successful to the degree that we all hope that one day it becomes do you attribute that success to a con a concave mindset on behalf of Ethereum.
I definitely think the concave mindset is a very good one for at least what Ethereum's goals are which I think involve a kind of broad adoption and bringing decentralization and permissionlessness to like basically large groups of regular people. And on the big one side it's interesting because I think Bitcoin does have two minds at service of what its goal is like one of its minds is basically replacing gold and like becoming the new digital gold. I'm over as the other one is let's be let's focus specifically on censorship resistant wealth transfer for people in authoritarian regimes or in general people in every regime is authoritarian to some non zero extent.
I want to know like people who brush up against that side of things and like having a convex approach like it can definitely buy you a kind of success in that second side of things because you know there really are people who just need fairly extremely fairly extreme trade offs. Though you know at the same time I do think that a theory was also fairly capable of satisfying those trade offs except. Ethereum's approach is different and it relies more I think on just creating this apply a thing that provides broad value for a large groups of people even if like in some cases the average value per person could end up being a bit lower than you know literally saving your life say rescuing your life savings.
And like Ethereum can still literally rescue your life savings of some context but the median use cases and I guess a little bit more closer to average people's experiences. So there's an element to you I wonder I'm missing the Bitcoin culture community if that second pool that you mentioned that that convex pool who has formerly been ardent supporters of you know censorship resistance if that's not being being driven out a little bit too because it just seems like this narrative of and this this need for like price go up. Yeah has has driven out a lot of the original values and maybe I'm being a little harsh on Bitcoin or culture but it just seems this embrace of kind of crypto banks if you will and like custody and institute like that wasn't part of the original convex plan for for Bitcoin or so.
There's almost this hollowing out effect where you get this convex culture around things like 21 million and number go up and when everything else. When our friend Nick Carter talked on Bloomberg about the happening being priced in and he was absolutely crucified because apparently that's not canon with you know some convex members of the Bitcoin or community. Like it's those types of things that have become more important than elements of censorship resistance so there's almost like this hollowing out type of effect of the values that at least I thought used to matter in in Bitcoin or culture I don't know if you guys observe that but it's something that has been surprising to me these are not necessarily the extremists die for the cause martyrs that maybe they once were I'm not sure if that's harsh.
Yeah and I like one of the kind of big fault lines I'm seeing is basically that so the story the story that small blocker values were originally sold under right is that you don't need that much security on the base chain because the lightning network can basically make up for it right and they brought a lot of their kind of heart and soul into the lightning network but. What's been happening over the last couple of years is that the lightning network has only received really limited adoption and instead we're seeing it'll liquid start taking off and liquid is of course a permission to get sort of a chain so basically the same sort of thing that they did out says evil back in 2014.
People are just like they're cheering on you know ETFs and like being the sort of institutional adopt adoption that doesn't actually translate to any kind of decentralization and like some of those like some level of those things is definitely a kind of natural and good and good for adoption. But it does seem like the problem for me is when it gets to the point where it's so extreme that like these people are literally like start excusing the like the growing lack of accessibility of fully self sovereign options right like basically like when they start saying oh it's totally fine if like centralized intermediaries become used for most things that's when it really starts kind of turning me off so.
It feels like it's kind of just letting the way it feels like it's letting the winds of kind of technical and kind of historical default push it in a direction and then retroactively kind of red conning the narrative to say that it always was that direction all along right and. Like there's definitely a big part of that that's kind of difficult for me to relate to like you know if they think someone who is on a developmental maximizing censorship resistance would realize that intermediary minimization is a pragmatic and needed part of censorship resistance and. If you want to minimize intermediaries you need to have the base chain be able to provide more things potentially even add some level of risk to that making that making the base chain a bit heavier but like if you're just care if you just care about permission was just some of the base chain but you know you can't ask much about the ability to do trustless and permission most things on top that like I definitely get to the point where it starts losing me.
Well metallic I really appreciated your your post because it allows me to put so many of your other posts into perspective right like I understand your proof of stake post better because I read your your concavity first convexity post so thank you for for producing this work and also thank you for coming on the the bankless a bank this show to share some of that work in a new format to a new audience so. And and also congratulations on the east to deposit contract genesis as well. Thank you very much it was good to be here thanks to tally see you later.