Guests: Justin Moses - CTO of Synthetix Robbie Ferguson - Co-Founder & President of Immutable Matt Finestone - Head of Business Development at Loopring
We discuss how these three voices in the crypto space have been integral in building successful DeFi products on the Ethereum mainnet. Listen in for a deep-dive into the different methods these protocols have taken to implement their apps on an Ethereum Layer 2.
----- 🚀 SUBSCRIBE TO NEWSLETTER: http://bankless.substack.com/ ✊ STARTING GUIDE BANKLESS: https://bit.ly/37Q17uI 🎙️ SUBSCRIBE TO PODCAST: http://podcast.banklesshq.com/ 👕 BUY BANKLESS TEE: https://merch.banklesshq.com/ ----- 💪BECOME A BANKLESS PREMIUM MEMBER: http://bankless.cc/membership ------ AFTER THE SHOW DEBRIEF: https://shows.banklesshq.com/p/exclusive-debrief-building-layer ----- GO BANKLESS WITH THESE SPONSOR TOOLS:
⭐️ AAVE - BORROW OR LEND YOUR ASSETS https://bankless.cc/aave
🚀 GEMINI - MOST TRUSTED EXCHANGE AND ONRAMP https://bankless.cc/go-gemini
💳 MONOLITH - GET THE HOLY GRAIL OF BANKLESS VISA CARDS https://bankless.cc/monolith
📱 DHARMA - MOBILE ONRAMP DIRECTLY INTO DEFI https://bankless.cc/dharma
------ Topics Covered: 0:00 Intro 5:14 Loopring & ZK-Rollups 13:17 Immutable NFTs & ZK-Rollups 17:31 Synthetix & Optimistic Rollups 21:03 Why Ethereum? Why Rollups? 39:24 Layer 2 Efficacy/Roadmaps 1:01:25 Composability 1:18:22 L2 On-Ramps 1:27:52 Does L2 Compete w/ ETH? 1:34:47 Closing & Disclaimer
------ Relevant Links:
Synthetix https://synthetix.io/
Immutable https://www.immutable.com/
Loopring https://loopring.org/#/
An Incomplete Guide to Rollups (w/ Vitalik) https://youtu.be/wcCHlqgGSH4
------ Don't stop at the video!
Follow Bankless on Twitter https://twitter.com/BanklessHQ
Follow Ryan on Twitter https://twitter.com/ryansadams
Follow David on Twitter https://twitter.com/TrustlessState
----- Not financial or tax advice. This channel is strictly educational and is not investment advice or a solicitation to buy or sell any assets or to make any financial decisions. This video is not tax advice. Talk to your accountant. Do your own research.
Disclosure. From time-to-time I may add links in this newsletter to products I use. I may receive commission if you make a purchase through one of these links. Additionally, the Bankless writers hold crypto assets. See our investment disclosures here: https://newsletter.banklesshq.com/p/bankless-disclosures
No summary for this episode yet.
Welcome to Bankless, where we explore the frontier internet money and internet finance. This is how to get started, how to get better, and how to front run the opportunity. This is Ryan Sean Adams. I'm here with David Hoffman, and we're here to help you become more Bankless. David, how are you doing? Absolutely fantastic. And much more knowledgeable, after we just got done with this L2 implementers panel. We brought on three different individuals who are all working on three different projects who are all implementing their application on a specific L2. So we brought on Matt Feinstone, who works for business development at loop ring, Justin Moses, the CTO of synthetics, and we also brought on Robbie Ferguson, who is the co-founder behind Immutable X, which is a ZK roll up based NFT exchange.
So the through line behind all three of these individuals is that they are working for a protocol that is building something on an L2. They are not an L2, they are building something on an L2. So there's an important differentiator there. And so we talked to them about what it's been like going through the research phase, going through the building phase, and where they are now, and then also where the roadmap is ahead of them. And I found it extremely informative, and I'm sure the listeners will as well. Yeah, absolutely. So two things I want to say here. The reason that this is top of mind and relevant is because Ethereum gas fees are high.
And it needs to scale outside of what we call kind of the main net Manhattan into L2, which are these other chains that represent kind of like the suburbs, as we've talked about before. So this is a very topical issue right now that's really facing Ethereum, and what we think is DeFi is going to have to completely re-architect itself into this layer to mode. The other thing I wanted to say is if you're kind of new to layer two, what we're talking about is layer two is basically a chain that is not on the Ethereum main net, but is secured by the Ethereum main net. This is different than a side chain, which might integrate with Ethereum, but is not secured by Ethereum.
That is the distinction between a layer two solution and something that might be a side chain or a another non-aetherium chain that's not as well secured by Ethereum. And the thing about this panel is these are all application developers. That's why David and I wanted to get folks that were in the trenches actually building on top of these layer two solutions to talk because they can give the most credible perspectives on what's working and what's not because they're actually like users of the product. They're consumers of the layer two. They made a strategic choice and investment choice to build on top of layer two.
So if they're doing that, if they're investing in it, then we wanted to know why, and we figured that they would have the best perspective on what's real, what's not, and when all of this stuff is coming and happening. And I think they gave us this. So if you are looking to try to understand what Ethereum scalability trajectory looks like, what layer two looks like on Ethereum, this is the perfect podcast, I think, to get up to speed. There were two parts in this conversation that I really, really enjoyed. The first is where we asked about the research process. So each one of these guys has worked for a team and there was a research process to go into which L2 was the best choice.
But before we ask that, we asked, well, why did you even stick with Ethereum? I'm like, what you could have gone elsewhere? Why didn't you? And I think that was one of my favorite parts in this conversation. And then the other favorite part of this conversation came at the very end where we asked about their thesis or theories about does the value capture that's going on on L2 actually compete with Ethereum and either the asset or are they value generative to Ethereum and either the asset? I thought that was a really fantastic part of this conversation. You guys are really going to enjoy this conversation, but before we get into it, we want to tell you about the fantastic sponsors that made this episode possible.
So as you guys know, there is always a debrief at the end of every single episode that we reserve for the premium subscribers to the bankless program. But we want to give the free listeners just a taste of what those debriefs are like. So if you are interested in hearing the debrief, you can stay tuned to after the episode and you will be able to hear the 30, 35 minute conversation that Ryan and I have after the episode where we talk about our takeaways, our lessons, our thoughts that we had during the episode, just me and Ryan. So if you are interested in that content again, it's at the end of the episode, it's free for everyone this time.
And if you are interested in the future and if you are interested in accessing the future debriefs, you can subscribe to the bankless premium RSS feed. There's a link in the show notes to get that done. I thought this debrief was pretty cool and so check it out, it's at the end. Awe is a borrowing and lending protocol on Ethereum and just recently released Awe version 2, which has a ton of cool new features that makes using Awe even more powerful. With Awe, you can leverage the full power of DeFi, money Legos, yield and composability all in one application. On Awe, there are a ton of assets that you can deposit in order to gain yield and all of those same assets can also be borrowed from the protocol if you have deposited collateral.
Here you can see me getting a 200 USDC loan against my portfolio of a number of different DeFi tokens and ETH. I'll choose a variable interest rate because it's a lower rate than the stable interest rate option, but I could choose the stable interest rate option if I wanted to lock that interest rate in permanently. One of Awe's V2 features is the ability to swap collateral without having to withdraw your assets, trade them on Uniswap and then deposit them back into Awe. Awe does all of this for you, all in one seamless transaction. So you don't have to repay loans in order to change the collateral you have backing them.
Check out the power of Awe at Awe.com, that's A-A-V-E.com. If you want to live a bankless life, you need to get a monolith DeFi Visa card. Monolith is a one-two punch of both an Ethereum smart contract wallet and an accompanying Visa card that lets you spend the money that you have in your Ethereum wallet everywhere where Visa is accepted. When you swipe your monolith Visa card at the grocery store or at a restaurant, it actually makes a transaction on the Ethereum blockchain that spends some of the money you hold in your monolith wallet. It's insanely cool and it's one of the best tools out there for living a bankless but still normal life.
Monolith also offers on-ramp services for getting your Fiat money into the world of DeFi. So it's trivial to top up your monolith card if you ever need to and your deposited money goes straight into your non-custodial wallet so your money is never held by a centralized intermediary. Because monolith is native Ethereum infrastructure, the money you hold in your monolith wallet still has the power of DeFi behind it. Swapping assets on Uniswap or earning yield in DeFi is at your fingertips. Go to monolith.xyz and sign up to get your monolith Visa card today. All right, bankless nation. We are here with Matt Feinstone of loopring business development at loopring.
We're also here with Justin Moses who's the CTO of synthetics and then also last but not least Robbie Ferguson who is the co-founder of Immutable, which is the studio behind God's Unchained. So Matt, Justin and Robbie, welcome to bankless and we're so excited to have you guys on the show today. Thanks for having us. So L2 implementers assemble. Gentleman, you guys have all been invited here because you share something in common. You have all built and deployed functioning applications to the Ethereum main chain and has seen success and adoption in the usage of your apps, which is already a feat.
But there's something even more unique about their respective projects that all of you guys work on and that each of you guys have implemented or are in the process of implementing which is your guys's app being deployed on an Ethereum L2. This is offloading much of its infrastructure onto optimistic rollups. Loopring is building a complete payments and exchange platform on ZK rollups and Immutable is building an NFT asset exchange platform also on ZK rollups. So again, we brought Jesse Robin and Matt here to tell us the story of their app, their need to scale and their process thus far. So let's start with you Matt and loopring.
Tell us about the nature of your app. What does it do? What point did you realize that Ethereum's main chain capacity just wasn't going to be enough? Thank you David. Yeah, I'm really excited to be here with fellow L2 influencers. Yeah, so loopring is a bit different than I think my my compatriots here in the fact that we had we were a protocol and then we built products and then we built a new protocol ourselves to the layer two protocol to augment the products. So the application did not force us to kind of look elsewhere for a layer two, we built it ourselves. So we're kind of a layer two protocol and layer two products.
But yeah, we realized long ago that like we had no business doing what we were trying to do on Ethereum layer one, we were building order book exchanges. The experience was really poor on Ethereum layer one. So we looked for scalability. This was early on, roll ups were just kind of being whispered around and we built our ZK roll up specifically to scale our order book exchange. So we built an application specific ZK roll up and then you know we start learning and we actually have users and iterating. So the product changes a bit and then we enhance the protocol to support AMM's on layer two as well and then payments as well.
So what came from just like an order book deck protocol really turned into an order book and AMM exchange and payment ZK roll up protocol. Yeah, so a bit of a going all over the place there but as you see we kind of did like full loop, no pun intended honestly. And yeah, that's that's where we're at right now. Maybe you can talk a little bit about how and why building an order book exchange on the Ethereum L1 with such a pain like why did that not really work out so well. Right, very briefly, the biggest thing is to get liquidity on order books, you really need market makers or liquidity providers that are in control of their quotes and what they're, you know, quoting to buy and sell and 15 second blocks and gas prices to submit to potentially cancel does not allow them to do their thing and kind of quote as and as the markets moving be quick and cheat like low latency low fee.
So it's really like a non starter. It's maybe one of the one of the worst things you could do if you're trying to replicate that legacy style order book on a blockchain. But layer two allows us to really replicate that that performance. You feel like you're on Coinbase Pro or Kraken, except you're on this layer completely coupled to Ethereum base layer security. Right, so market makers, even with Ethereum before scale was really an issue in the way that gas prices were today, those like 15 second block times and, you know, even pennies worth of a transaction, it was already like without the congestion that we had today, it was already a poor experience for and, you know, people who are managing order books need to be able to basically have instantaneous control, not 15 second delays or pennies at a transaction.
So even before Ethereum was congested, the L1 was never ever going to be able to do what you guys wanted to do. That's a great point, actually. I didn't think of that kind of theme here that like, you know, Justin and synthetics were forced after like large success on layer one already and potentially same with Robbie. We couldn't do what we wanted to do even a few years ago, that's very true. And I guess we'll jump to this, but the layer one not being suitable for this type of behavior is actually kind of what spawned AMMs where these market makers don't need to jump in and be quick. You're just kind of dumping your money and letting a function do the thing.
So it kind of AMMs came out of the environment that optimized for it. Yeah, Matt, they really came out of necessity, right? It was due to this constraint of basically, you know, low amounts of transactions per second that the automated market maker model became so successful and so popular. Maybe Robbie, for you kind of the same question, can you tell us a bit about the nature of your application and at what point you decided that you needed a layer to? Yeah, of course. The point was actually really early when we were first launching the original sale of Gods Unchained. It was at the same time F coin was doing their exchange listing.
And I don't know if everyone watching this remembers, but the way they incentivized that was basically as poor as you yet was they incentivized transactions in the ether network with high gas fees. And so the first time ever we were seeing gas fees of like 150, 180, we did some innovations then, which were fine, but fundamentally we did the math through like, okay, if we even get to 30% the size of heartstone, so a medium sized game, we are taking up some absurd amount of the Ethereum blockchain via NFT transactions, particularly because NFT transactions are a ton more expensive than just ESE 20 transfers.
Like you can transfer a million dollars worth of ESE 20 value for a fixed cost. You're transferring an a million dollars worth of NFT value and Gods Unchained. That looks like probably, you know, 500,000 hearts. So there's a fundamental difference between fundable tokens and non-fundable tokens. And so in picking a solution, really there were there were no available solutions I would say three years ago. There were ideas being thrown around state channels, have yet to come to life. Plasma chains also really have not been implemented in a mainstream way. And this I think was what drove people to things like new layer ones or side chains.
And then we had this magical thing called a zero-knowledge proof come out, which I remember being obsessed with when I first heard about it, especially the different parables of ways of explaining it like the the parable of the cave or, you know, the numbers and how it's all kind of like probabilistically determined, which gave me some rough approximation of the mass, which is probably like 1% of what it actually is. But this is, as Vitalik says, like the way it will scale. And so I think we determined that solution pretty quickly that this was the most obvious way to scale in particular NFT transfers because there were so problematic on Ethereum.
And then it was just a matter of choosing, okay, who do we think the best kind of roll-up provider is? ZK roll-ups a bit of NFT is just because the lack of draw time right now, I think optimistic solutions work better if you want generalized programmability, which I think why, you know, synthetics is going with optimism, which is also an excellent solution. So yeah, I think that was the genesis of when we knew and also when we knew that the solution was when we first saw attraction and deployment of all ups. So to be clear, Robbie, you are going with a ZK roll-up type solution in the same way that Matt's team is with loopering, is that correct?
Yeah, that's right. I think we use slightly different providers. I think loopering to you guys who use meta-labs. We use ourselves loopering protocol was the first ZK roll-up as a 14 months ago. So that's our kind of provider. That's what I was kind of saying. We're a bit of a beast. We're a bit of a different beast, like operate across the stack, but yeah, no hard feelings. No, no, no, very cool. Very cool. I'm sorry, I didn't know that. I mean, creating those proofs is bloody hard. That's why that's how we partnered there and ultimately I see there's a few layers of the stack here. There's proof providers, there's a protocol on top of that.
So I almost call that like an AWS infrastructure right down the bottom, which is clearly what you guys are providing. And then you have what networks are products available on top of that. And then you have applications. Then you have open C, super RAM, marketplaces, games, which sit on top of that protocol. So we went for this level. We said we don't need to make the magic maths. I don't think we wanted to do that. And it's a real need. Exactly. Yeah, literally. Yeah. And the implementation of it for NFTs is already tremendously difficult. So we took on that challenge instead. All right. So let's turn to Justin at synthetics.
Justin synthetics never really was destined to be an L2 in the same way loop ring or or gaussian chain to slash immutable was, but you guys have turned into an L2 just simply out of necessity because if your email one is congested. So let's talk about a little bit of again, the nature of your app and nature of the economic activity that goes on in synthetics. And at what point did you guys realize that, you know, L2 was not just like an option for you guys, but something that you guys must do? So synthetics is a decentralized exchange, a little bit like loop ring, Matt was saying. I guess the big difference for us is we're a bit more like uniswap and that we're peer to contract and we don't have an audible as such.
What's actually happening is people state the token as the next token. And from that they can issue a stable coin and then they can basically reprice that stable coin into any other synthetic asset. So basically what we have is this big shared depot that's comprised of all these different synthetic assets. The more people that go into synthetics, the more the depot is denominated and eat, which is kind of cool because it means that you can get this idea of like input and liquidity. You can take any synth and 100% convert its value to any other synth that is important. But the problem with that is that that means that it's all shared, like it's all shared state.
And so as you've ever written any, and so that we know that that tends to mean things like, you know, you're looping over every synth in the system to figure out how much depth there is. And this stuff is very gas intensive. So I think for us that there's sort of somewhat super on. I actually think you're a little off David on that assertion that we would never have a decent L2. Like if you talk to Kane, he's always been very much that that we he wants to experience like Matt was saying, he wants it fast and snappy like a traditional, you know, decks. And so we know we obviously couldn't do that on L1, but on top of that, we have this very own or as gas fees that are just preventing, you know, regular people who, you know, might only be staking a few hundred SNX for actually doing anything because the code that we have is fairly complex, you know, with some people looking at a hundred, two hundred dollars worth of the time to try to do simple things and minting or now spending, you know, a few hundred dollars worth of the ETH in order to earn maybe a half, fifty dollars worth of SNX.
So for us, there was really those two, those two factors required us to go over. And to answer your second question, he was actually in DevCon 5 in Osaka when we saw the Unipig demo. We saw for those of you who were there or want to see the video, basically, you know, the plasma team who became what they became the optimism team, they worked closely with Hayden and the Unisol team and they put together this Unipig and, you know, just seeing it, you know, just seeing the tactile response, you know, my background is like, you know, full staff web engineering and I was shocked. And when we did our demo on L2, it was funny because our front end engineers were now dealing with, like, regular kind of, you know, concurrency problems that we just never had with a theory.
But like, we have multiple users using app. We need to basically use web software for something to tell the real time what's happening to this shared state, which we never had to worry about, you know, with L1. So yeah, for us, the Unipig demo, which was about, with an October of 2019, was this definitely the moment we were, we started to take a lot of interest in optimistic and we started talking to them in Unisol. So guys, let's dive a little bit deeper into kind of the selection process of L2 and I want to start here. I know none of you are, let's call it, you know, chain maximalist of any sort.
I'm pretty certain. I think that you guys are looking out for your user's best interest. That's what application developers do. They want to provide the best user experience and the best application possible for users. And of course, when, when you think about layer two, you could also go to another direction, which is a non-aetherian blockchain. And there are a ton of what we'll call them, eith killers in quotes out there that are promising, you know, low gas fees, no gas fees, infinite amounts of block space, kind of that all you can eat buffet, please come to my blockchain, just in from six people want you up here.
And yet all three of you have chosen to stay within the Ethereum ecosystem. And not only that, but have chosen the security model of Ethereum as well. So it's not only kind of a side stream based on the Ethereum version machine, you're actually choosing to go down this even harder road where the security of your roll-up is actually based on Ethereum. So there's some really new technology that you're cutting your teeth on. I want to know why. And I think listeners want to know why. Why did you stick with Ethereum? And what was the rationale behind the selection of the layer two that you've chosen?
Let's start with Justin on this question. Yeah, that's a good question. I mean, I think, you know, for us, I don't know if any of you know this, but when we were haven, which is what synthetics was before, before it sort of rebranded, I was actually working on writing and porting our contracts to EOS. I did it for maybe six weeks. I was brushing up on C++ and writing code and getting involved and really trying to get like right open source code, right, a continuous integration that pulled together Docker containers and spun everything up and tested everything. And whenever I tried to ping the community on EOS, it was just crickets.
Like it was just nothing. And I was pinged different block producers and trying to get them to like help. And it really just just real straightened how strong with Ethereum develop a community if it's massive. You know, there's just so much infrastructure, there's so much tooling, and there's so much momentum there. And I, you know, I'm an engineer, right? So I tend to, maybe I over-index on that. My experience very strongly is that Ethereum's developer community is so rich that it would be, you know, very hot with the way from it. And I didn't, I haven't seen any, you know, each kilowatt that has showed me that there's any developer community, anything quite like it.
So for, for us, it doesn't make any sort of sense to move over to another one. Can we talk as well? Well, I've got you on this, Justin, about why the optimistic roll-up design, specifically, what were the advantages of that versus the other roll-ups or other? Are these layer two scaling solutions out there? Well, I mean, I think, like, assuming we're on a state of sticking on Ethereum, I mean, for us, like, obviously, you know, the ZK, they're not having to worry the one-week control period is obviously a better user experience, there's no doubt about that. But for us, a big part of the decision is how complex our smart contracts are.
Still to this day, there's no easy way to port smart contracts logic, you know, into anything, and to anything ZK at all, right, onto L2. So the solution is to try to, you know, to try to take a little part of it, right? Whatever you need to sort of take on to L2 and create some sort of ZK, you know, compatible solution and create it. And a big part of the decision for us, particularly for me, is maintaining these two different code bases. So I'd like to talk more about this at some point, and this is a good piece, but there's a lot of complexity in now maintaining state on both, not just state, but also contracts code or both L1 and L2.
Like, I'd like to think of it as a new dimension. Now, we have our contracts deployed on different networks, right? Like, you know, co-member Hava, but now we also have this dimension of layer two. And the more, you know, the more cognitive loads you put on your engineering team, the harder it is to get things done. So for me, they could be a really big part of the big appeal of optimism as being out of port, more or less exactly as is the contract code that we have on L1 and run it in L2 and then have two separate systems, which is run out of this to the shards and what I imagine is going to eventually happen is we are going to probably see different L2s.
And there'll be capital moving between the different layer 2s, and we need to handle how that's going to happen. I don't actually think it's necessarily going to be when it takes off. You know, so for us to be able to take our logic and move it over wholesale is a huge value out of optimism. Robbie, let's talk about the process over immutable. When you guys were realizing that the Ethereum L1 wasn't going to be enough for all the data that you guys would need to be able to put on chain, did you guys ever look elsewhere other than Ethereum? And if you did, what was the rationale behind why you decided to stick with Ethereum?
Yeah, of course we looked elsewhere. We even had offers, massive grants from different chains. You know how these things go. This was actually a really simple question for me though. And ultimately, I am an eighth maximalist. I think that it contrary to the original thing. And the reason is not just inherently, hey, this is what I like. I think I'm a decentralized maximalist, and Ethereum is really one of the only public blockchains which fulfills that criterion for me. The alternative blockchains simply like either their consensus mechanisms are so centralized that if I hide a crackpot team of hitmen with 2 million bucks, I could go crack it.
Or if the government crack down, they could go crack it. Or if the CEO of the company of their centralized blockchain, I don't know who I can be referencing here, was to leave that be a significant impact to the blockchain. So I think just speaking pretty candidly, there's very few decentralized alternatives. So my question is, what is the point then? Why don't I run a marketplace on a database on my computer? Why don't I just do another steam? Like the whole point of this is to give users self-carsity, sense of resistance, and it's fundamentally decentralization and sovereignty over hardcap assets and hardcap money.
So I don't think going halfway and just creating a nice experience for trading valuable things that is fundamentally vulnerable to the same things centralized markets are, is doing anything at all. The next thing I would say is, so that's why Ethereum. But the next thing I would say is, it's not sufficient for me to have some sort of relationship with the Ethereum ecosystem, and I think there's a lot of wool being pulled over people's eyes here as well at the same time, which is, I think, I mean, and this is where I actually take my learnings from you guys, because I think you so clearly articulated what are the value propositions of Ethereum, which in my mind are four, ethers are consumable, ethers are capital asset, ethers are sort of value, and ethers are form of economic bandwidth, guaranteeing via security the operations that exist on that protocol.
To me, you have to would therefore rely on Ethereum security. Currently, the only scalability solutions which rely on Ethereum security are raw ups. So I think that that was partially why I chose that. Like at the end of the day, you want to have the cost to attack the stuff you're trading to be the same as the cost to attack your raw ups. I think optimism has a slightly more linear cost to it to attack the proofs, but it's still correlated to Ethereum security, so still really good. And I think Justin was on the money with the fact that it's just way better for DeFi apps right now in optimistic solution.
So that was why I think that was why raw ups, and ultimately at the end of the day for customers, it's way better to like ethers where all the network effects are, it's where all the developers are. That's a really hard thing, even with $250 million to buy, you know, your own ecosystem of developers. It's just, you know, that money will only go so far and that people will be motivated by cash rather than the true kind of cultural genesis of a decentralized community, which we've seen in Ethereum today. And so what about the research phase for immutable and in L2? How did you guys come to a decision as to what L2 was the right L2 for you?
Yeah, so it's really just true decisions. One, what kind of, so in my mind, the only L2 is a raw ups right now. And that's because the definition of an L2 is something which inherits the security of the L1, raw ups, the only solution which do that currently. Other mechanisms like side chains, useful, they just, they have their own consensus mechanism so you're not actually getting any security. They have bridges and it's great for the ecosystem. And this is partially why Polygon said, hey, we want to be this, you know, relationship to future ZK roll ups and things like that. I'll be excited when they release one and they can use us if they like, for NFTs.
So I think that the first choice was out of roll ups, which one zero knowledge was very clearly the choice for us. NFTs have a reduced need for EDM compatibility over complex smart logic and we're also getting there. So immutable X's implementation of a zero knowledge roll up with StarCware already has the proofer on chain, which is able to basically take any EVM logic. We just don't have a language in tooling, which is going to get that this year. So that's future proofed. And the main reason for NFTs is instant withdrawals. So the benefit with ERC 20s and you know, a protocol like synthetics is you can do things with liquidity bridges to kind of get around this problem with the withdrawal time.
They're not perfect, but they're pretty good for fundable tokens. You can't do that for NFTs. If you have a, you know, one of a kind crypto key, Axi, God's Unchain card, I can't, you know, loan you or construct some liquidity bridge, which is going to give you early access to that capital. It's just impossible. So for us, those would be, you know, a zero knowledge roll up was the only solution and if that it was like, okay, well, what provided to be used and StarCware was the obvious choice for us $30 million from Sequoia, a really well class team and just future proofing that as well. All right.
And last but not least, of course, Matt from from loop ring was building on something else other than Ethereum ever, even something that you guys could have considered. Right. So first of all, such a pleasure to hear these guys speak Robbie and Justin and like, so like mind it or spacing similar things and I don't have much else valuable to say except for our own situation, but yeah, I really echo everything they said. Did we ever look somewhere? Here's another little fun tidbit actually, even before scalability was like the big pressure on us or the big thing we were trying to tackle. We actually did look elsewhere off Ethereum back three years ago and I will opt Justin's videos.
We actually deployed smart contracts for loop ring version one on Neo on Neo, the China's answer to Ethereum. That's right. Okay. And someone from a call. No, we'll just edit that out probably we have to know it's okay, Matt, you know, we all have those things that have happened in our past that we're trying to get over now, but tell us more. No, we're, I think it's a great learning moment. We, you know, loop ring is actually a primarily Shanghai based team, most of our engineers and I'm not there. I'm in Canada, but a big part of our team is there and back then it wasn't so obvious to some, even to me, even though I'd also consider myself, you know, just a purely eth person now by a long shot back then, it wasn't clear that you didn't want to deploy your things on other chains, not for scalability reasons, just for, oh, this is maybe the Ethereum I'm trying to know who interoperability different chains like the reasons are fuzzy now looking way back then, but we, we deployed it, but it was really kind of like a, like a tangential effort.
And as soon as we did it, it kind of didn't work for certain technical quirky reasons like the way they're gas, it's actually kind of funny to think about it, they had like two types of gas and like if you did the transaction that is below some type of like consumed gas, it's like free, if I remember correctly, but then it like spikes up, it's like a step function. If you do anything a bit more complex, it was really, so actually the reason why we dropped it was because it was technically not feasible. That was before Ethereum just became the clear place where we wanted to focus our time. As Justin was saying, like the cognitive overhead and just this simplicity.
So, so we actually looked elsewhere. So we have a bit of firsthand experience about dealing with crickets in a community or just facing all those things, but it really was a different world back then in 2017. What's worse, Matt, crickets or high gas fees is kind of the question, right? Yeah, right. Exactly. That that's the first thing I thought of when when you posed the question was like user experience is not like we all think like, okay, speed and cost. That's like actually way down the list on user experience. What's way higher is people, both users and devs, assets, liquidity and like awareness, right?
Like that is, those are prerequisites before anything else in user experience, which we think of like speediness and costly mess. So those are indeed the things about why Ethereum. Now, to get to the next point when we try to tackle scalability, it's funny. Someone mentioned DevCon 5. For us, it was DevCon 4 in Prague and just ZK roll ups. I just remember it. So clearly people were talking about ZK roll ups for scalability. And I remember just writing my team. I was the only one there like, hey, what is this stuff? It sounds like it's a magic bullet to all of our problems. And back then there were no live ZK roll ups.
There was no, like to mind, maybe there was the beginnings of thoughts about companies forming, but there was no startware in this current form, or matter labs, or really any live ZK roll up. So we became overnight a ZK roll up team. And we're not a bunch of cryptographers. As Robbie was saying, these proof systems are hard. But like our team turned into practitioners of zero knowledge cryptography. And really we had a few great engineers leading us building the first ZK roll up from scratch, which was a huge, a huge effort. It took a year. It stopped everything we were doing. But yeah, we built it ourselves.
And that's that. I forget the next part of the question. Why ZK over optimism? I hadn't actually asked it yet, but that's exactly right. It seems like ZK roll ups was the roll up of choice for you guys. And it was seemed really, really conducive to you guys from the get go. It seemed like you guys never really had any doubt that ZK roll ups was the solution for you. What strengths did ZK roll ups have that really just made it crystal clear that it was the right path forward? Right. So I may be mistaken here, maybe somebody could create, but I don't think optimistic roll ups were a thing back then.
I think roll ups, like the idea of like a roll up, like generalized was, I guess it was a thing because people thought cable, literally proof or fraud proofs. But like you didn't have debates, like cool debates now, like ZK versus optimistic. It was like, okay, roll ups. And like, yeah, usually it's validity proofs. As far as I know, we only discussed that. We never thought I could be wrong. But then as we progressed and like we were mid-build and maybe the idea came out a bit, we were still very strongly in the ZK roll up camp because it does offer us what we need. We're not, we don't have those complex kind of arbitrary logic that Justin was describing.
We were building order book exchanges, right, which turned into order book exchanges plus payments plus AMM. So still, just like specific functions we were tackling. So ZK was able to handle that. So that's kind of one reason. The other is indeed the fast withdrawal times. We, that's a big thing, which is live on loopering now. It's really cool. You could exit. It used to be a big thing. The people said, oh, you know, an hour away, two hour wait is way too long. Now you could pay up to kind of eject from layer two in the next Ethereum block, 15 seconds. It might cost you like 60 bucks or 70 bucks right now, but then you don't wait.
Something like that. So, so those, that was it. But really, it's the cold heart fact is like it was just the one that we were aware of. But when we did kind of become aware of optimistic ropes, we just, we like the idea of validity proofs. Maybe we had like these naive debates, which have since been answered. But I remember talking to the team and okay, what about optimistic roll-ups? It's going to be more generalizable. But we also like, we like the idea of just like validity proofs, like not waiting for fraud proofs after. I think we posed the question like, what happens if there's never any fraud on an optimistic roll-ups?
Like, the watchers never like win a bond or something like that. I don't know if that's even since been answered. Like that was like a thing like, okay, if everyone is too well-behaved, then there's everybody like let up their guard because nobody's actually like slashing people or winning like a challenge fraud proof. So, like we had those early probably now answered questions, but we just like the idea of validity proofs. So, I want to frame this question to the the implementers. The Avengers of implementing on layer two right now this way. So, a lot of people when they're seeing kind of Ethereum's congestion as David sort of phrased it, but basically it's high gas fees.
They're getting flashbacks to 2017, where Ethereum had its, you know, crypto-kitties moment, when basically everyone realized that the crypto-kitties application was consuming too much of the Ethereum network and oh my god, Ethereum had to scale. And then we also remember that the Ethereum scaling solutions at that time were not quite ready for prime time. There was like a lot of promise about state channels, for instance, you know, projects like like Raiden would come and solve things. Then there was a lot of promise about Plasma that, you know, Plasma was the next solution to to scale Ethereum.
There was even promise about ETH too. Hey, it's, you know, maybe it's right around the corner kind of like, but we're not sure what the roadmap looks like. So, this is a question I think only the implementers can answer. And this is the reason we brought people who are building apps to this conversation is because you guys can drop the truth on us, right? Like no one else can. I mean, we bring on some of the the layer two providers. They're all going to sell us the vision essentially and try to sell us the platform, but you guys are actually in the trenches building this shit. So what we want to know to the panel is, is layer two really happening this time?
Like how far along are we? Is it here? I mean, because mainstream is coming and they're coming right now. They're coming during this bull run. We got to be ready for them. How ready are we? Let's start with Matt on that question. Yeah, absolutely. Maybe you gave me this one because it's a softball pitch for me because I could say it's not coming. It's here, you know, exclamation point. It's here. Like that's all loopering does without layer two. We wouldn't exist. We wouldn't have a product. We'd have a protocol. So to the extent that like we have stuff to do every day and our users do stuff and his volumes, that's all layer two live main net real value.
So let's get that off right out of the way. It's here. Now it's time to learn and tweak and iterate and everybody else is coming. You know, we've kind of we've been alone for the past year. Now like, you know, mega popular apps are coming, some FedEx apps and protocols. So you know, they're live, they have a function of their platform live on main net. So it's here. It's not just us and it's really amazing is as all these builders know when you actually have users and things are happening, you start improving, right? Like that's like compared to RZK RZK roll up last year. It was barely usable.
Everything was like everything was gas intensive. You couldn't do that much stuff. Now it's like, you know, it's more efficient. It's more flexible. So we're going to see that kind of inflection kick in where people are learning from their L2 experiences and everything is just, I mean, it's here. I'm so bullish. If people don't know that L2 is here and it's only getting better, then I hope this episode really, or maybe I don't want them because that's a nice fun thing against ETH. And I want it, you know, I don't want it to just be realized overnight and then try saying that, oh yeah, this could do everything that that we needed to.
So I don't mind actually some apprehension or some other conspiracy theories that it's not coming because that gives me more time. Yeah. Alpha is, of course, always opportunity. But Matt, at loopering, you guys are still building stuff. You guys are still working on progressing loopering. So if you aren't actually working on building the actual L2 platform, what are you guys working on? Like, where are you guys and your guys's roadmap to actually capture and facilitate L2 scale? Right. So I think we still are definitely working on all fronts. That's our thing. We're a bit of like a different beast.
So we have that whole proving team and the re-layer who's generating the ZK snark proofs, they still have improvement to do. Then we have the actual protocol, what we could write in our ZK circuits. Now, as of a few months ago, AMMs are on our L2. So still improvements there. Maybe next will be a lending protocol or another type of functionality. So those are kind of the two pieces of the ZK roller front, like the re-layer and then the protocol written on top of it. And now we have this new layer of products, which is kind of new to us that's super important, is presenting this in a package to the user on like the loopering exchange on a web, which is an AMM in order book decks and payment application, where you can do everything gas-free.
So just improving the products, which is a huge, huge thing and quite different hat for us. And besides our loopering exchange, we have the loopering wallet, which is kind of another thing that I know you guys are right on top of from the Talix recent episode on social recovery wallets. But loopering kind of, you know, expanded its focus again and we have a smart, a mobile smart contract wallet, so the social recovery wallet with our ZK roller banked in, which is kind of a dual, like a really two-pronged approach at like mass, you know, mass market usability. So, you know, fast and cheap, but also a product that doesn't scare you with a seed phrase and is like socially scalable and like usable there.
So we're still busy on all those fronts, protocol, product, all that. Definitely, definitely, it's only getting busier. Now that we actually have real users and your volume, you know, $250 million worth of value on our ZK roll-up, which is unbelievable for me to think about. I remember being discouraged, you know, mid-last year to say, man, how hard is getting people in layer two going to be? And by no means are we, you know, hanging up our hat like we've achieved it all. We're just getting started, but it's just so nice to see real users, real volume, we're all grateful and really looking forward to continuing that.
Guys, I just want to capture that because Matt, you know, $250 million in locked value on a loop ring. Look guys, like a year ago at this time, we barely had that much locked in DeFi in our DeFi protocols, right? I mean, we just hit like the one billion mark in something like February of last year. So now that we've got like loop ring $250 million, that's huge. And, you know, congrats to the team there and congrats for pushing this vision forward. I just, you know, this space moves so fast, it's unbelievable what you can accomplish in six months a year's time. Very cool. Thank you so much, by the way.
Let's turn to Justin with synthetic stress. And where are you guys in the development of your L2? We're like, what is that roadmap like? Where are you guys in that process? And where do you have left to go? So right now, the optimism is like has a pseudo mainnet. So pseudo in that we're the only ones that can actually deploy right now. But, you know, plans are underway for a full real mainnet, right? And as as Matthew said before, you know, one of the great things about optimism is it's generalizable. And I think to answer Ryan's question before about like how real is this, I think, a generalizable way to start deploying contracts on L2 that's very, very similar to deploying L1.
You need your own compiler that's basically like a superset of the Solsea compiler. And you just switch your provider to optimism. And, you know, a way you go, you need a bit of wrap teeth in there instead of ether. And it's pretty much, you know, going back, you know, you can actually deploy an L2. And I think that knowing that that's coming, you know, around the corner of this year is going to be pretty huge. It's going to pave the way for lots of developers who may not want to sort of get into the nitty-gritty of actually trying to get into the ZK. So I'm thinking like, I just want to be able to write contracts the way I always have and deploy something faster and cheaper.
In terms of our roadmap, so we're right now in a situation where not quite as much as as Matt, I think I just had a quick check now. There's about 160 million right now of USD value of SNX that's on our L2, which is probably even more than perhaps we want considering it's a phase zero. So right now what we have is some stakers, you can stake your SNX on L2. But the SSD that is what happens is when you stake in synthetic shoe basically mid-stable coin, the SSD that's on L2 is basically, you know, useful as the capital company. You can't do anything with a capital right now. There's no other protocols on there, nothing else you can do.
And yet there's still 160 million dollars of value on there, which is pretty wild. The synthetic hours sending 25,000 SNX a week to distribute among people who are staking, but that's it. And yet there's still a lot of values. So clearly, you know, people are really excited to get off paying gas on L1. Our next phase is to basically enable basic exchanges. So probably I'd like having EEPA and Bitcoin and actually being out of slowly, hopefully, if we get some other protocols on there, actually do something with these, with these synths as opposed to just having them static sitting on L2. But for us, you know, a big part of the excitement is as other teams and protocols do develop, as Matt was saying, like as other teams do start developing different things and they're on L2, well then we can get those D5 Legos plugged in.
And that's something that we're also pretty excited because, you know, you can probably infer, once you sort of take away, you know, 15 second block times and a bunch of other requirements, all of a sudden new ideas of things you can do start to pop up. So Justin, I just want to be clear. Oh, sorry, just one thing. Justin, I just want to be clear on this because this would have felt like a miracle in 2017. What you're saying is your team, what you've done with synthetics on optimistic rollups right now is living proof that generalized smart contracts work in a rollup now. Like that works right now.
That's what you're telling us. That's what we basically, like just forget a little technical, just because I find this useful. Instead of just sending, you know, tokens, right, from L1 to L2, we're actually sending messages by 32 encoded messages. We take users escrow entries because when you stake with us the next every week you claim and you earn SNX that's escrowed, we're taking this payload and actually sending it off to layer 2 and recreating the state that exists on L1 and now we're recreating on L2. So you can actually create this, you can, these generalizable messages, you can actually send data and you can do it both ways.
But as you obviously know that there's that one week withdrawal period, which is very onus. Now for us, as Robbie mentioned, we're, we're talking fungible tokens. So it's not a big deal. You can have a minor filmmaker come and basically solve the problem of liquidity by, if it's SNX or it's SUSD or something else, they can basically, they can, they can basically sit there on both sides and provide liquidity. But yes, we, we do have a generalizing solution. It's just right now, I'm sorry, the noise, it's right now, not anyone can deploy it to it. Yeah, but there is, there is a solution coming soon where anyone can actually deploy to it and, you know, write their code and solidity, transpile it using the OVM compiler and then deploy, as I said, using a regular provider because the thing that the optimist and team are really big on, and I really commend them for is, is, is not reinventing the wheel and just leaning on as much as, as much of standards and developer tooling that everyone's used to.
So there's no, you know, magical lists or magical data, but it tries to be as much, you know, EDM compatible as possible. Now, of course, there's more, there's more complex because of progress and things like that, but they really try to make it as, as compatible as possible. Justin, do you happen to have any sort of like napkin math as to how much gas you've been able to save your users or perhaps like what percentage of synthetic economic activity you've been able to offload? Any numbers like that you could give us? I don't have it on my head, off the top of my head, but I think it's something on in the order of like two orders of magnitude difference.
Like so, a 500K gas transaction ends up being about five K gas. And you think of it, like what the roll up is really what is persisted on to layer one is, is effectively the two things. For every transaction, there's the call data. So the things that, you know, the inputs of the, with the function call, and then the medical hash, right, of the state. And then the only two things that are actually persisted on layer one. So every time that, every time someone transacts, they basically, those two things have to be eventually get pushed onto layer one. So there's about two orders of magnitude difference in terms of, in terms of gas.
Now it's a little hard to compare what's happening on layer two right now to one, just because right now the gas is being basically paid for, the users aren't paying for it right now just during this pseudo-mainnet. So it's hard to really say what's, you know, how many people actually, you know, how much is the real activity? As we all know, people are a bit different when it comes to their own money versus when something's great. Just to go a little bit deeper into that, you know, synthetics has one, has one of the most vibrant communities in all of the theorems. It's kind of the thing that you guys are known for, the synthetics communities, what I would say brought synthetics through the bear market and into the mainstream knowledge as we know today.
I would imagine that the demand for scale must be absolutely massive inside of your community. What can you tell us about community interest in accessing this L2? Like when you guys open up the door, is there just going to be a flood of people that move on to this L2? Or have you guys done any sort of like consumer research in this domain? Sorry, you're talking about how users are talking about other developers, like another product. Your guys' users who want to move on to the synthetics L2 to see? Yeah, I mean, 100%. I mean, what does them really want to see, you know, a real trading app, you know, like Matt was saying before, they want to see, you know, ticking prices, they want, you know, to get their orders filled immediately, they want optimicity, they want all the things that we don't, we can't provide right now on a one.
So yeah, I 100% I see people going over there. Now, of course, the question of how useful is the capital that you've mental, the things that you have at L2 is going to be, it's going to be an issue. So we'll have to see, you know, what else appears on optimism. And then if not, like how, like what other solutions to, as I said before, to get your S&X or your synths back to layer one and play with them if you need to. I think that's still a bit of an open question right now. We need to see where that sort of comes to fruition. But it seems like, based on what I said before, the amount of rewards that are being sent on to layer two are pretty ministerial.
And yet we still have, you know, something in the order of it says like 160 million, like 6.6 million S&X, right, which is what is that? I don't know. 6.6 times roughly $25, yeah. Yeah, no, I mean, the total supply, like I don't have the total scrap of my head. What number that is, but you know, like 3% of something, yeah, which is pretty significant to get considering. Yeah, that's fantastic, fantastic work. And really exciting because you just released kind of the layer two optimism, like what two weeks ago, three weeks ago, something like that. I don't know, time, time moves in a different way.
Yeah, it feels like about three months. I think I'm going to have to go actually now. Month to go now. Thanks for the time adjustment. Time is weird for me right now. These days in crypto. Okay, Robbie, same question to you, right? So you represent the NFT side of these applications. And NFTs are having an absolutely massive moment so far in 2021. This is going to be an absolute breakout year, like it seems so obvious. But same questions to you. How real is layer two for NFTs right now? Like hit us with the truth. Yeah, building a layer two for NFTs is really hard, especially compared to ERC 20s.
NFTs are fundamentally antithetical to liquidity. If you have eight and a half million gods unchanged NFTs, you have eight and a half million order books. Each of those could have their own uni spot market. It's nuts, like they literally have their own bids, asks and spreads. And Robbie, just so, just so people can understand this, this is almost like, you know, like, obviously, fungible tokens are things we see in the real world like coins and dollars. These things are fungible. Yeah, NFTs. They're more like collectibles. They're their individual items like things you might find in a in a pawn shop in the real world, right?
So of course, each NFT is completely unique. You can't trade one FT with another. And that's why you're saying they each represent a separate order book, I must. And each NFT needs to find the right buyer, right? Like it's there's not a global buyer for NFTs in the same way that there's a global buyer for dollars or gold or coins. Because they're fungible. Age of these, you know, goods is unique. What I think, and I steal this from Jesse Walden, who's a great thinker on the NFT space, is DeFi is as to financial services as NFTs are to literal assets in the real world like cards, options, contracts, physical goods, term deposits.
Heaps of stuff in the real world are unique. And that's what financial services exist to serve. So I think fundamentally we're seeing the innovation of tokenization of everything, the final stage. And that's why this space has gone nuts. We have Mark Cuban making NFTs of him tweeting cameos. We have major IP pouring into different partnerships, the amount of people who have reached out to our company over the last three months is 20 fold over the previous year. So the space has been insane. It's really difficult to provide scalability, which is why I flow when I often said, hey, we can do a good competing business to Ethereum by cutting an eShut of NFTs.
And this is why I'm quite excited to say that within six weeks from now, the first ZKL2 transfer of an NFC will occur on a mutable X. And people will be able to do that. So it's definitely here. I've done demos. We're doing test net integrations with basically partner applications because the goal of a mutable X is like, honestly, it's two things. One, I want to make NFTs huge. And I want the future home with those NFTs to be on a blockchain, which is good infrastructure, which is open. Frankly, that's Ethereum right now. You need to use its security fundamentally. And so the way I want to do that, people should just trade, but they want to trade.
They want to try to open C. I want to make open C the most amazing place to trade ever. And have those guys be hugely successful. People want to trade in Fortnite and have an API and just trade in that marketplace. They should be able to do that and have all the benefit of Ethereum level security. So yeah, we've been working on on this for nearly a year and a half now. We're stoked to be able to release it at this time. So Robbie, because we've heard a little bit of this from the other two panelists about sort of the before and after, right? They described like kind of a current state on the main net.
If they had their app, their app exists on the main net versus versus now. And it's world with faster UI, better experience. Can you kind of describe the before and after for somebody who is using NFTs today or trading NFTs today on main net versus when a mutable X goes live? What's the difference? How's a user going to feel this? Yeah, it's a great question. I mean, the main difference is they pay zero a gas ever. If you're a game developer, you pay zero gas to create an NFT to mint one. If you're a user, you pay zero gas to trade an NFT. It's on a validity proof. So you have the same level of security as Ethereum always, which is fundamental at the point.
It's the reason why we're good for Ethereum down the track. If if NFTs become huge, if altres become huge, we're not taking value away from the fundamental chain. That's really important to me. Otherwise, you can't get Ethereum suborders on site. Otherwise, you're essentially just competing at the end of the day. So that's the user experience. The other thing is we're working with Starquare to make it so if you have Leia1E, you don't even have to deposit that. So really, I want the worst, the minimum experience to be identical to current thing. You pay your ordinary gas fee, you use your Leia1E.
The best experience to be, hey, I've literally just signed a transaction. I see this NFT in my account instantly. It feels like magic. It legitimately feels like magic after three years of spending, oh, will this come in two minutes? Will it come in 10 minutes? Am I paying $45 to trade a $1? God's Unchained card? Which is just crazy. So I think the demand is, it's going from being a environment to a pain killer for NFTs, is the way I describe it. Right now, it's going to being general anesthetic, the state of NFTs. So, Robbie, I want to pin you down here because I have a gauss and chain deck that I enjoy playing with, but I'm far from a professional and so I would like to use the marketplace to bolster my deck.
But I remember that it would cost, like you said, it would cost me $5 or $10 to get this card that was worth $2, $3. So when do I get to use the NFTX marketplace to purchase all the gauss and chain cards that I want? Yeah, I'll go with B. For gauss and chain, we'll roll out first in quarter one. So within six weeks, you can create a prediction market on that. Awesome, fantastic. All right, so I think that unless Ryan, you have any other questions you want to follow up here with this section, I want to turn to the conversation of composability because this is a frequent topic of concern that many people have when it comes to L2, which is, well, if loopering gets all the liquidity on the loopering L2 and synthetics has the liquidity on the synthetics L2, well, then A, we're fragmenting liquidity and now that we're all on separate L2s, we're all multiple hops further away from each other than we once were, right?
So let's start with Matt. How are you guys addressing this concern of fragmented liquidity and broken composability? What are you guys doing to help mitigate this issue? Or do you even consider this an issue? Right, for sure. This is a huge thing. We haven't had to deal with it practically because we're the only ones. So we've, you know, people kind of jab at this potential weakness in layer two and, oh, you're all going to be in silos. And again, especially loopering because loopering ZKROLUP is quite application specific. We have the DEX, we have the AMM, we have the payments, but like we're not trying to get, like, like, we wouldn't have been a solution for God's Unchained.
Like, we couldn't have told Robby, hey, build on loopering because we're not trying to, you know, like, start where it's power their other applications. So there might, we're not, you know, inviting other teams necessarily to come build and we're going to, hey, like, you know, tweak our backend to optimize for you and stuff like this. So we're kind of doing our thing, you know, which is kind of a, it's an interesting statement to say because, you know, everything as a theory and all of us we do is so open. But yeah, the loopering, you, and this kind of goes back to your other question, did you ever look at alternative L1s?
To some extent, layer two's do become a bit of a silo. You're there and you have to kind of make a transaction to go into there, make a transaction out, and it could be as instant or not instant, depending on ZKROLUPs or optimistic rollups. But I mean, at the best case scenario, then you're in a rollup with other people. So synthetics, you're in a rollup where there's other stuff going on and then it becomes kind of similar to layer one. Synthetics might have plenty of company, probably will have plenty of company on optimism. I'll let Justin speak to that. And then you kind of have those same composability, you know, those great properties.
To go cross rollup, there's a new, now this is the next frontier, cross rollups, right? We all know rollups are here. So how will we go across? Could we have, will it be easier for maybe validity proof to validity proof rollup? So like, will I be able to speak more easily to to Robbie or to another StarCware application because it's loopering ZKROLUP to another ZKROLUP? Can we also go equally as easy to optimistic rollups? So this is the next frontier. There's a few projects working on that. There's connects. There's a hop, which came out recently. So to be honest, we largely leave that to these new solutions to come.
We speak with them. We ask them questions. They ask questions. But we're not trying to solve composability ourselves. We are trying to build the best kind of environment and products that we can on loopering ZKROLUP. And we kind of take it for granted that really smart people, our peers are going to figure out to build bridges. And everything, again, rooted, the most crucial thing rooted in Ethereum security. So if liquidity providers have to bridge an exit from loopering and entrance onto synthetics or onto optimism, then that liquidity provider at least has the assurance that this is all Ethereum level security guarantees.
They don't have to have a mental space for the sidechain that has seven validators. So like, all these rollups, at least they're speaking the same language. And they know the fallback is Ethereum layer security. And then it's just like talking about what is the market rate on their liquidity to front you a thousand die exiting loop ring and then putting the and crediting you that on optimism. What do I need for that? Do I need 50 basis points for the hour? Like it becomes a financial consideration, which clearly Ethereum has excelled at figuring out these these these amazing new models and things like that.
So it's going to be solved, I guess, with a mix of technology and financial innovation and just like the market rate for for liquidity, which sounds maybe like not such a huge thing, but that that's how composability is going to work. Maybe like the equivalent of flash loans, right, from one to the other. And I guess we still are thinking about it in the sense that like we have in our we have conditional transfers. So I could make a message on that that is contingent on a layer two and a layer one action, right? So like again, fronting this liquidity and being in two places at one. So if I do something on layer two, then I take that message and then it allows me to do something on layer one.
We do support these conditional transfers. Those are a big thing that that's what fast our fastest draws are based on. But yeah, at the end of the day, it's I think a lot is to be seen. Like I really have a big chunk of this. I just don't know how it's going to play out. There's still technical pieces to fit in place. There's behavioral pieces to fit in place. Like how often will people be leaving their roll ups? Right. And then again, it's the ZK for self-domestic exit timing. It's just that there's a lot of unknowns here, but it's clear that the work is is is being done. And it's a mix of technical and financial and composability will remain.
But it's it's if I have to say kind of one thing like, you know, that's okay. Let's let's assess a risk here. Composability is not as beautiful as everything being on layer one. That's for sure. But we're going to get over that. Justin, I'd like to pull you into this into this conversation. One of my long-term optimistic cases for for loop ring is that loop ring is a place that will be able to take fiat take a fiat on ramp, right? And so let's say I transfer my 100,000 whatever dollars into loop ring. And then I start trading SNX, right? Buy sale SNX to use the loop ring L2. And then say, I've got my SNX bag filled.
And now I want to take that SNX bag. And oh, and maybe I also have SUSD on loop ring as well. Maybe there's both SNX and SUSD on loop ring. But now I want to go into this synthetic ecosystem. I want to reprise my SUSD debt. And if if in the current form of things, without the theoretical financialization market makers that Matt was just talking about, I would have to exit out of loop ring, which would be one transaction. It would take some time. It would be a little bit more gas intensive than a basic L1 transaction. And then I would have to go into these synthetics optimism L2 in order to do some of the activity going on there.
And that would also take another transaction. And it also takes some time. How do you see some of these frictions being smoothed out and down the road? Look, I think Matt's right. It's like the next frontier. I mean, to just take a slide step back, like, shotting, you know, horizontal scaling is where we're going. Like, this is a theorem. Like, it doesn't matter what we want to say, label this L2. Like, this is inevitable. Like, we have to do something. And I don't think there's any one solutions I said before. And when this is where all coming to a lot of heads of trying to figure out how the hell are we going to do this stuff?
You know, I mean, you're, I mean, you mentioned David, the cost of gas and stuff. And, you know, of course, that will be, that's going to be unpleasant. I'm not. Maybe it's Matt said there'll be a way to connect the dots between, you know, one roll up to another roll up. And I don't, I can see that being possible. I just, I don't see how that's going to come out generalizably, but maybe, um, I don't, yeah, don't really have a great answer for you. But I mean, I guess the, I guess for us, like our attitude and our kind of ethos is always being, let's just iterate, um, let's throw things out. Let's see what sticks.
Let's get MVP's out there. Let's see what people want and use and go with it. So I wish I had a better answer, but we're, we're looking towards, as I said before, market makers who could help get the, the assets back out quickly. But to talk to another L2, it feels too early to really have a good answer to that right now. Just, I'll be sure to, you know, anyone else has thoughts. I want to ask you kind of to follow up questions, but, but the first is this, you know, in putting kind of the, the tactical hat on that, that you wear all the time, I've, I've heard some critics say, well, if you break composability, you're not really solving Ethereum's scalability problem, right?
And, and what they mean is that, uh, L2 is not actually solving scalability because the beautiful thing about Ethereum later one is that all of the applications are composable. So now you're just like, like fragmenting it. So I've, I've heard critics say that, what, what's your response to that? Do you think that this is true scalability? Or do you think because it doesn't preserve some of the nice atomic transactions between all of the, the defi money legos on Ethereum that we're, we're losing something and we're not truly scaling Ethereum. What's your response to that? I think you're, I think we are losing something.
And I mean, Max said the same thing. Like we would, it would be great to stand at one, but I think we've just hit the limits of what we can really do. Potentially, there's some innovation in the future that can, they can fix this, but we've had a lot of smart minds on this problem. And it seems like we're back to this idea again as far as until scaling. So, I think the best thing we can do as protocols is to create such a system where potentially, if need be, we might even need to be able to deploy ourselves on different, um, different layer 2s and find ways that we can bridge. So, maybe the solution to that problem before that, that David mentioned is we find a way to deploy synthetics versions, synthetics on loop ring, um, that can interact very nicely with the loop ring.
And then we have a way to bridge that gap from their layer to our layer 2, but in the day, like, um, if we can't find a nice way to do it, they to go from, from one layer to another layer 2, then yeah, we do great, to some degree, we do great compatibility. And, you know, I'll, you know, I guess they don't really have much else to say on that one. Well, so here's my, my other follow-up to this, Justin's because, you know, synthetics interacts with a ton of the other DeFi protocols in Ethereum today. So, I remember when Dave and I were talking to, to Kane about this on a community asked me anything and he said, uh, hey, you know what synthetics is doing?
We're moving out of Manhattan and we're going to Brooklyn. And, uh, we asked the question, okay, Kane, like, you know, how are you going to get the other DeFi protocols to come to Brooklyn with you? Right? And he was like, well, we're going to make Brooklyn freaking awesome. And everyone's going to want to be there. So, my question to you, Justin, is like, as part of solving this composability, you've got with optimistic rollups, you've got this, this essentially almost like a, a DeFi chain, right? It can, it can host the other DeFi money protocols. My question is one of coordination. How do you get everyone else to come to Brooklyn with you?
What are you seeing along those lines? I mean, I think what we're, what else is really offering optimism is really offering is, um, the ability to, to tinker to play, you know, it's, uh, all one has become pretty, but now, yes, of course, you could tinker on Corván or, uh, Gurley or the other testnet, but L2 provides the ability to tinker. And I think that's exceptionally powerful. I think perhaps people who don't, who aren't engineers don't underestimate the importance of that. Having a playground where you can actually start putting things out there and actually working. Um, so, you know, I think that I expect to see lots of interesting innovation happen on L2.
Now, the big protocols, some of them are probably sitting there thinking, you know, what do I do? Do I wait for, do I wait for a better generalizable decay? Do I join optimism? You know, and my response to them is like, you should be thinking about this regardless. And I don't see why it's, why you should have been considering ways to potentially fragment, right? Potentially fragment. I don't, I don't see why they, you know, I don't see why they wouldn't try and do this. Like now, yes, there's cognitive overhead, but again, I think that the writings on the wall that we need to do something. Now, James probably more, well, wouldn't take fashionable.
I might want to use the word of Brooklyn. It wasn't silly. Hardly the, hardly the most fashionable city in the world. Sorry, the Robbie is in the best part. But yeah, I mean, we definitely have been talking to lots of other protocols have been, you know, been asking us and talking to us and like, we want to get on there. I mean, they all have their own concerns. Like, you know, let's say a money market goes over there, like, you know, compound or R8, and they're going to be like, okay, well, we're splitting up a, you know, maybe they were splitting up a, you know, liquidity. We have liquidity on the here and we're going over there and how do we do it?
You know, these are particular problems that these guys have got to do, but we've seen lots of demand. Lots of people have been asking us and reaching it through us and trying to get out and, you know, get on there. And right now, as I said, unfortunately, only synthetics are able to deploy. So I see you coming. I mean, I see, I see it being a pretty cool place, but I, again, don't think it's a be a lendle, you know. Man hasn't still exists. And you know what? I'm not in New York anymore, but, but, you know, I hear Manhattan's sound to come back, you know, to come in the new place because everyone's moved out.
So the artists are coming back here. So, you know, there you go. Robbie, do you have anything to add to the composability discussion before we move the next topic for the panel? Yeah, just quickly, I think I have two things. The first one is that I think that, you know, Justin is totally right. It's about making Brooklyn a playground and a really exciting playground. You know, we're going to ask Cairo, you can build recreations of this functionality and mutable acts. The second thing to say is I think this is why NFTs is an interesting use case for L2. It's less about building that interoperability and more about how can you trade real assets on a blockchain with high security.
And so I think that there's less of a critical need there. The third one though is I guess like, what does a scaling Ethereum mean? Is it you are allowing the network effects of the community to be preserved interoperably? That's one definition. Is it you are allowing people to use the layer one settlement based security as the security under which their logic is transacted? I think that's a really compelling definition is I think that's fundamentally what differentiates Ethereum from every other chain out there because either way, they achieve either their security due a less secure mean by a consensus mechanism that's completely centralized.
All their chain is just a valuable and therefore easy to attack. So I think that's my kind of my real question is what does scaling Ethereum mean? And I think that it has to be on real layer 2s. I don't mind if there's a bunch of fragmented layer 2s. I think that's a great future for Ethereum because at the end of the day, value is being consumed in the form of each proofs being paid on chain and two economic bandwidth is being increased because these assets are being transferred at the same level of security as Ethereum. So I would say it absolutely years more so than any other solution. There's a reason that Vitalik said ETH is on roll-ups as the future.
Centralized side chains are a betrayal of ETH's values, literally equate from him. So I mean, if I'm taking an EQ, I'm taking a Q from the guy I made it. Yeah, and you know, you said the magic words, at least for me, economic bandwidth. I have been, David and I have both been such a proponent of this term because I do think that scalability is so narrowly defined if you just think about it in terms of transactions per second on the main chain, right? Ignores so many aspects of it. Ignores the scalability of the community, ignores the scalability of user experience, ignores the scalability of economic security and ignores the scalability of trustless economic bandwidth.
And when you have an asset like ETH, of course, that acts as a store of value, doesn't have any other centralized intermediary, and you're able to preserve that on a layer too. Well, aren't you scaling? You're scaling trustless economic bandwidth, are you not? So I totally agree with that last point, Robbie, that we have to also broaden and expand the definition of scalability for these money systems. I think David is going to take the next question for the panel. Yeah, speaking of money systems, the current form of getting value into Ethereum is you sign up with Coinbase, you sign up with Gemini, you buy your ether, and then you get it deposited to your own Ethereum address, whether it's your Metamass, your ledger, but that's like you getting injected with like your first little amount of ether, you're getting injected into the heart of Manhattan, where you don't really, like things are scary.
The L2 world is what really gets me bullish about the possibility of L2s, is that each individual L2 offers a unique enramp possibility into Ethereum, where if people are playing with like games on the Immutable X platform, what about the possibility of purchasing your NFTs with your credit card on the Immutable X? And all of a sudden, there's some value flow from the legacy world, the bank world into the Immutable X L2, which is the next step into a bankless life. So, Robbie, let's start with you. What kind of things could happen, or do you have in the works with value flows directly onto the L2?
That's not actually coming straight from Ethereum. Yeah, that's the whole point, and I think that's why we almost have a separate idea to find more financial at DeFi L2s, is that what I specialize in is NFTs, that's obviously what we're trying to scale, and I think NFTs have the potential to capture an enormous amount of value in the real world. That's video game assets for one. There was $90 billion US dollars, where the in-game items, not box copies, literally the items sold last year to gamers, and they received $0 of real value. They could sell none of that. So, I think that's the right market.
Gamers are already digital natives, and we're already seeing major companies starting to dip their toes to space, whether it's the initiatives from Ubisoft, who, by the way, the main thing they care about, because the Ubisoft blockchain team, ultimately the thing that scares them, is what if they put the Ubisoft brand name on something that ends up breaking? That asset is taken. And so, they fundamentally care about security. That's why Ethereum is going to be the winner, because if you put World of Warcraft on a blockchain, you can't put it on a flow. You can't put it on a centralized sidechain, which can't support that upload value.
The 200 billion plus worth of economic bandwidth of Ethereum can. That's why I'm bullish. And 100%, the future is it's not people interacting with apps and things. Maybe that's kind of a developer mindset, and that's where a lot of this value originates. It's, hey, this is a new asset for digital. This is a new standard for digital assets. If you interact with a game, what you expect from your own chip quality is that you can sell it. And you don't even know, you don't even need to know how the security works under the hood. You just know that, hey, these are the rights I get as a user. I pay with your credit card.
I get these tradable properties. And yes, it's being minted into an L2 on Ethereum for free via an API called by that game's publisher. And then I see it going way beyond gaming items as well. I mean, NFTs have the potential to encapsulate the entire world's financial system outside of fundable tokens. Options contracts are unique financial contracts. Insurance contracts are based on the unique underlying circumstances at the home. We've seen digital art sell $100 million worth this year. We've seen sports moments being tokenized. It's this like fundamentally brand new world. And I think that that world belongs to the infrastructure of Ethereum.
You'll have to hear it. Matt, when can I get my bank account injected into the Fiat or into the loop ring L2? Yeah, I mean, well, this is part of your bold case for loop ring now. That's what you said before. So I'll have to work hard around it. But yeah, I mean, this is I guess like a pretty boring topic. It's like how much effort and how hard could we work on like regulatory things, right? Like we've been squarely in Ethereum land for three and a half years. It's nice that like we don't worry too much about regulation. It's, you know, it's I kind of hate having to muddy up the waters of thinking about Fiat and different jurisdictions.
And everything was just so much more simple on Ethereum, the global jurisdiction and stuff like that. So Matt, can I can I ask a question that gets at the heart of this? Like so haven't the crypto banks like Coinbase and Gemini and you know, even finances, some extent already figured that out. Like so why couldn't they just rather than withdraw to if you're in main net for my eth have a button that says withdraw to loop ring, right? And after I make my purchases there, they're kind of the Fiat bridge, the Fiat on ramp. Anyway, I just want an on ramp directly from these crypto banks directly to loop ring and they could solve the regulatory stuff for you.
They already have that out of the box. How close are we to something like that or is there some challenge with that that we're not seeing? Right. Great point. And this is I guess a business. So first of all, that can be done right now. They could have done that six months ago. Although now, I guess gas fees sustainably high would be like a greater impetus on them because either they're swallowing the the high gas costs to give their user assets in a reasonable time or they're passing it on to users for, you know, a $10, $15 withdrawal. So this we have those conversations. I guess a kind of maybe unexpected business answer for for loop ring specifically is so they could just use our API and forget loop ring the exchange the AMM.
It's just this layer two where somebody could, you know, they could just throw some dye across and it goes to an Ethereum address. Right. There's no special you use your own Ethereum address on loop ring. There's no nothing funky that needs to happen. Just an API call and it ends up in this addresses kind of loop ring layer two shelf, which all they need is their Ethereum address to access. But what I was going to say is it's a bit of a business case. Maybe they maybe some exchanges are reluctant to have some some some assets kind of hype in to the loop ring system because then we might eat their cake or eat their lunch a bit like right.
It's like why am I just zapping it into you where you are a Binance that cannot act evil. Like why would Binance like hype a billion dollars of fiat through loop ring in a day when those users kind of could like, oh, maybe I want to get off here and you know, and continue using loop ring. So I'm kind of, if this wasn't already in people's head, I kind of don't like saying it because maybe now I've given them a reason to push back against us. But yeah, the truth is like, yeah, sorry. I see your point, Matt. And like so maybe a Binance because they have their their ETH killer, you know, the Binance chain.
Maybe they might be more reluctant to to do something with loop ring. But it's like, let me bring Justin to this conversation here too and get his thoughts on this. You know, the Winkle Boss twins are regular bankless listeners and they are very involved in in Gemini the exchange, of course. Like Justin, how do you get Gemini to do a direct fiat on ramp into the synthetic optimistic rollup that you're building? Do you think that is the way forward to get fiat into the space or do you have an alternative idea on that? What would you say to the to the Winkle Boss twins if they're listening now?
Yeah, I mean, but basically we just need a we just need a way for for these like centralized exchanges, for example, to to get access to the tokens, right? Like it's no reason why they couldn't once they know the address is the contracts and they've got, you know, they've got balance is set up on layer two for their, you know, various, you know, wallets that's easy enough for them just to send off they could go, okay, those access to S and X. They can right now we have S and X living on L2. Right now transfers are disabled because we're in the studio and mainnet thing, but once real mainnet comes along, there's no reason why they couldn't acquire S and X have it set up on a certain wallet on L2 and then plug in a fiat on ramp and off they go.
So there's no technical reason that they couldn't just do that and I'm just curious just in your thoughts on maybe all there has to be is kind of an economic reason to do this, right? So in the very early stages of Ethereum, no exchange supported Ethereum, but as it grew, it became impossible to ignore. And is that sort of what happens with layer two? I mean, mats here on loop ring with 250 million and total octave value, you guys have 160 million. If it's a billion or more, does this just not become impossible for exchanges to ignore? And they build those ramps naturally because that's where the economic value is.
Justin, you see it playing out like that? Yeah, I mean, it's the same way like why they're listing all the waste binoculars thing every token under the sun. Yeah, exactly. People are trading it like you just gotta do it because it's like the market did decide to dictate it, you know? Yeah, really, we're just talking about developer cycles, right? So they've got to decide whether or not they want to invest the time and you know, what it's like to try to invest developer cycles that there's enough, you know, suits saying we need to do this for money, no, the developers usually have to get it total long like I would do it.
So guys, we have a lot of folks that are into crypto investing, obviously, they're bullish on various DeFi tokens, they're bullish on eth. But there's a question, I think, of how layer two constructs might impact the underlying eth value capture thesis. And I'm wondering, Robbie, if you have any thoughts on this, are these layer two solutions value a creative to something like ETH or they value competitive? Do they take away from ETH's value proposition as a whole? Maybe we'll start with you, Robbie. Sure answer. L2s are the savior of Ethereum's price. They're the only thing holding back other scalability solutions who can offer UX that gives people the critical revenue they need right now, but fundamentally don't use Ethereum as a security or settlement layer from destroying us.
And I mean, you know, flow raised a quarter billion dollars the other day. Rome was on Twitter saying, you know, Ethereum is all great in that, but flow is ready for mainstream NFTs. I don't think he's just trying to say that to mainstream NFTs. I think he's trying to say that he wants Ethereum to be zero and he wants flow to be the dominant chain for all transactions. And he thinks NFTs are a good entry point to that. Now that's fine. If you want to use flow, go ahead. You can also use my old laptop with a database. And I'll run it for you for $2 million a year. But fundamentally, if you use the definition that, you know, you guys popularize, which is capital asset, which is a form of economic bandwidth, store of value, the only thing that means three things.
One, you need to at some point consume it. If you're not consuming it, you are not providing consumable demand for Ethereum. Two, you need to rely on Ethereum as your layer one form of security. That is the definition of a layer two. By doing that, you increase Ethereum's value proposition via economic bandwidth. So quite frankly, I think any solution that is not a roll-up on Ethereum right now is an ETH killer, is an ETH competitor. You know, even poker dot the way. And the reason that everyone's positioning themselves is not ETH killer is because it's a dumb thing to do. Like, I don't know what it's worth.
It's like, you're going to be hated by $200 billion worth of capital. It's not a smart move. So that positioning is, hey, we're synergistic. Hey, we're poker dot. We're a power chain. We're doing this, this, and this. We're synergizing. It's crap. Just look at the fundamentals. Either you use Ethereum for your security and you consume it. You're good for its value, or you don't, and you're not. Oh my god, yeah. I really want to see the podcast where it's a meatable ex versus flow. I want to see the kind of that debate sound off now that I've heard. I'll have to be more polite. Yeah. Guys, Matt, Justin, any other thoughts on that value of creative?
Will you, Matt, any, any comments? Robbie is a great spokesperson for that. No, he's 100% right. Like, we kind of lose sight of what the label layer two means, like people say, like anything scaling is layer two. But yeah, it has to be strict. You have to inherit Ethereum security guarantees, which means your pay gas. I like how he says it, you know, it still remains a consumable. You're broadening the economic bandwidth because you're a little vertical. Or once David, I was on here and he described the Ethereum as like a peer, and then you go on to like your, your loop ring ride at the end. You know, like, so, so these things, like the end of that peer is like its own little economy where, you know, toes are going in.
There's so bad with it. It's 100% creative. And I do think it, it is just massively bullish. Roll ups. Yeah, like your time, eat maximalism before, I'm a roll up maximalist. And I didn't even go so far, you know, maybe just to to chat to more friendly job here. But like, I'm a ZK roll up person. Like, I think those, I think ZK rolls are kind of like here now for the application specific stuff. Optimistic roll ups are like right here and they're going to generalizable stuff. And then, you know, ZK rolls kind of re-leap frog when you have like this, the ZK Snark and their fee of advance. And then you have everything back in a validity proof way.
But yeah, it's just massively creative. And I do, you know, it's finally probably say about like the way they're positioning themselves. I like to think that maybe I tried to coin something. I'm not sure, but like Ethereum killers are rebranding themselves as ETH enhancers. Well, they don't use that word, but I use that word. Everything must be an ETH enhancer now. Otherwise, it's just really, really stupid on you. I mean, we saw maybe a sound by these past few days talking, like putting that in jeopardy, but from different chains, saying that there are no network effects that somebody may laugh when he hears about Ethereum network effects.
But you have to respect the network effect. You have to respect the network. It's just it's massively creative. I don't know if there's even a bearish interpretation. I haven't heard one of a layer two for Ethereum. Besides the potential of the composability breaking, I don't see any kind of value. There's no leaky bucket where this kind of bypasses Ethereum accruing the value in my opinion. Justin, do you want to add anything to this conversation? Any thoughts here? Yeah, I mean, totally agree with both Matt and Robbie, and Robbie quite very eloquently. I put forth his thesis, but the layer two needs to be something that relies on Ethereum, which I think is a really nice way of putting it on it.
I guess my main thought and it's a bit more meta is that one thing I really like about Ethereum is I feel like it's decentralized, of course, as Robbie said, but the way that it puts its money where it's mouth is in terms of the way the EF supports various implementations of the protocol, like the EVM. Here's the spec, go at it. There's JavaScript, Rust, yeah, go. And then the same thing with ETH, let's go in my house, it's prismatic. And I feel like this is where the same thing with roll ups, right? Like here are different implementations of roll ups and have added it. I think there is no one solution there, just the specifications based on security and usability, and you know, people, we are all sort of expected to try to put things out to iterate, and things will bubble up, the right things will bubble up, and I love that about Ethereum.
Like I feel like there isn't this, there isn't this, this, you know, dictator down on icing, this is the way it needs to be, and you know, credits of italic because he does a pretty good job of trying to stand back and let things, let things evolve around him, rather than, you know, trying to maneuver them to the issue. You guys, this has been such a fantastic conversation, so thank you guys all for so much of your time and your insights. It's really valuable to me, and of course, also to the listeners. And I want to finish up with this last final lightning question. So in just two, three, four, just a few sentences, can you guys give us the maximally successful scenario of the long-term version of your app?
So like when L2 is completely rolled out, and also under the conditions of maximal global adoption, what do you, what does your app do when you have as much scale as you want, and all of the things that you guys are trying to get done, you do get done just and let's start with you. So the users can basically get a synthetic version of any kind of asset they want. Anyone around the world can take it and no one can stop them, right? They can access to whatever whatever they need, whatever they need it, and it's quickly, quickly, if they can, and it doesn't cost them a normal way. Matt, what's the maximally successful version of loopring?
Luke Ring out competing legacy fintech applications. You know, we don't compete with each other on this call. I mean, some of us are not in the same verticals, but just any user can trade any ethereum-based asset, so not synthetic, not a synthetic asset, but just if it's on Ethereum, or actually we can trade synthetics, but you know, just trade anything, instant finality, super cheap, and payments as well, just complete freedom. You know, we've started using a little slogan for our app freedom at your fingertips. That is what Ethereum allows us. We can never misbehave, nobody could take it from you, nobody could stop you.
That's what we hope loopring becomes. Matt, you must be bearish because I was hoping in your answer, you would have said the words Venmo Robinhood and central bank digital currencies, but I guess you're just focused on a little bit more and more meta level right there. True, I wanted to keep it, you know, somebody actually brought it to my attention that on our site, it says feeling, you probably read it, like Venmo and Robinhood and user experience, but then I said do you still want to say Robinhood on there? Should you remove that? So, but we have all this stuff, but yeah, I'll leave it there.
Robbie, what's the maximally successful version of mutable and immutable X? Yeah, I think it's the marketplace for all unique assets worldwide. It'll be the exchange protocol. That's it, full stop. All right, you guys, this has been such a fantastic episode. Again, we have Robbie Ferguson, who is at the immutable project building out the marketplace for L2s for NFTs. We have Matt Feinstone, business development at loopring the ZK roll-ups, exchange and payments protocol, protocol. And of course, we have Justin Moses, CTO of synthetics, leading the charge to deploy synthetics on optimistic roll-ups.
You guys, I think the listeners are really going to enjoy this one. So, thank you so much for giving us your time and being here. Thanks so much. Thanks, guys. All right, bankless listeners, action items. If you want a primer on roll-ups, we just had Vitalik on the show, who gives a great overview of roll-ups in sort of layman's language. We will include a link to that in the show notes. We will also include links to loopring, immutable X, and synthetics new optimism L2. Because here's the great thing. You can start using layer two now today. It's here, as our panel said. So start using it. You don't have to keep with on the main net and the gas fee transactions.
We could start using loopring immutable and synthetics now on layer two. Also, David, last and final request. We want those bull market stars on iTunes. How are we doing on our five star ratings on iTunes, my friend? We are always trying to do better than where we currently are at. As you guys listen to during this podcast, L2 is here, but yet people somehow don't realize it yet. And you know why? It's because we don't have enough five star reviews on iTunes. If you could, please go to wherever you listen to your podcast and give us those five star reviews. We're trying to get bankless to the top of the iTunes, business, and investing charts so that everyone can hear the great gospel of Ethereum.
So if you could, please go ahead and do that. We would really appreciate it. All right. If you if you care about L2, give us those five star reviews. That's what David said. All right. Ricit Disclaimers, everyone. ETH is risky. So is crypto, of course. As is DeFi, you could lose what you put in, but we're headed west. This is the frontier. It's not for everyone, but we're glad you're with us on the bankless journey. Thanks a lot.