Justin Drake is a researcher at the Ethereum Foundation and is leading the charge of applied cryptography to the Ethereum network. Last time he was on the podcast, we discussed cryptography as the foundation for what we called ‘Moon Math.’
This week, Justin returns to the show to discuss Ethereum’s economic engine and how its design decisions (EIP-1559, Proof-Of-Stake, Issuance, etc.) emerges as an incredibly bullish evolution of sound money: Ultra Sound Money. ------ 🚀 SUBSCRIBE TO NEWSLETTER: https://newsletter.banklesshq.com/ 🎙️ SUBSCRIBE TO PODCAST: http://podcast.banklesshq.com/ ------ GO BANKLESS WITH THESE SPONSOR TOOLS:
⭐️ AAVE - BORROW OR LEND YOUR ASSETS https://bankless.cc/aave
🚀 GEMINI - MOST TRUSTED EXCHANGE AND ONRAMP https://bankless.cc/go-gemini
💳 MONOLITH - GET THE HOLY GRAIL OF BANKLESS VISA CARDS https://bankless.cc/monolith
📱 DHARMA - MOBILE ONRAMP DIRECTLY INTO DEFI https://bankless.cc/dharma ------
🎙️ 57 - Ultra Sound Money | Justin Drake
Last time Justin was on the Bankless podcast, we went in-depth about cryptocurrency's primitive tools: cryptographic hashes and signatures. He described these as the fire and wheel of cryptography technology. This time, we dive into the specific economic design of the Ethereum network and how it is positioned to expand upon the 'stone-age' cryptography of Proof of Work.
Given Ethereum's expressive capabilities, its future has infinite possibilities in terms of both innovation and development. To explore Ethereum's value proposition as Ultra Sound Money, we use the model of the Ethereum Economic Engine. In this metaphor, the basic energy harnessed is monetary value, stored in the 'engine' battery via tokens. The engine itself is structured by the network's consensus mechanism, Proof of Stake. The engine's efficiency is maximized through the issuance structures proposed in EIP-1559.
All of these components (explored in great detail throughout the conversation) contribute to the concept of ETH as 'Ultra Sound Money.' Soundness describes the degree of efficiency and security in the storage and exchange of monetary value. Economic security, anti-fragility, optimized issuance, efficiency, and scarcity combine to create a robust, maximally effective network. This could be the best episode we've ever recorded. ETH is Ultra Sound Money. Pass it on.
------ 🧑🎓 Want access to this episode's exclusive Debrief? Join the Bankless Nation: https://shows.banklesshq.com/p/exclusive-debrief-ultra-sound-money ------
Topics Covered:
0:00 Intro 5:08 The Economic Side of ETH 11:40 Ethereum's Economic Engine 24:00 Integration, The Meme, and Monetary Premiums 35:23 Sound Money & Economic Security 42:58 Cryptoeconomic Horsepower 47:57 Load-to-Power (Towing Capability) 55:59 Competing at the Base Layer 1:02:17 Repairing the Engine (Defense) 1:20:18 POS Plutocracy? Trust? 1:24:43 Engine Fuel 1:33:13 Engine Resilience 1:38:33 Redundance & Security 1:49:10 Stealth & Insurance 1:59:01 Economic Efficiency 2:09:11 Ultra Sound Money 2:18:00 ETH is Money 2:24:12 Hard Money 2:33:13 Closing & Disclaimers
------ RESOURCES
The Bull Case for Cryptography https://shows.banklesshq.com/p/-moon-math-the-bull-case-for-cryptography
ETH is Ultra Sound Money https://newsletter.banklesshq.com/p/eth-is-ultra-sound-money-market-monday
Justin’s Research https://ethresear.ch/u/justindrake/summary
Justin on Twitter https://twitter.com/drakefjustin?s=20
------ THIS WEEK ON BANKLESS:
🗞️ Weekly Rollup (3/19): https://shows.banklesshq.com/p/-rollup-elon-musk-nft-song-stimulus 🧢 Weekly Action Recap (3/20): https://newsletter.banklesshq.com/p/another-1400-weekly-recap ⚫ Token Thursday - Ren (3/18): https://newsletter.banklesshq.com/p/rens-trillion-dollar-opportunity ✏️ Ultra Sound Money (3/15): https://newsletter.banklesshq.com/p/eth-is-ultra-sound-money-market-monday 🐦 Follow Bankless on Twitter: https://twitter.com/BanklessHQ
----- Not financial or tax advice. This channel is strictly educational and is not investment advice or a solicitation to buy or sell any assets or to make any financial decisions. This video is not tax advice. Talk to your accountant. Do your own research.
Disclosure. From time-to-time I may add links in this newsletter to products I use. I may receive commission if you make a purchase through one of these links. Additionally, the Bankless writers hold crypto assets. See our investment disclosures here: https://newsletter.banklesshq.com/p/bankless-disclosures
No summary for this episode yet.
Welcome to Bankless, where we explore the frontier of internet money and internet finance. This is how to get started, how to get better, and how to front-run the opportunity. I'm Ryan Sean Adams. I'm here with David Hoffman, and we're here to help you become more bankless. David, that's got to be the most bullish episode on Ether we've ever had. add. And that's saying a lot. That is saying a lot. Ultrasound money with Justin Drake. Justin Drake is a researcher at the Ethereum Foundation. He also was the guy that led the charge behind one of our previous most beloved episodes ever, which is Moon Math, the bull case for cryptography, where in that episode, Justin Drake took us through the innovations behind cryptography and made the claim that the current state of crypto economic systems design, basically Bitcoin and Ethereum are just in the very primitive ages of the deployment of cryptography.
This is a very similar episode, but instead of talking about cryptography, we're talking about economics, specifically crypto economics. And Justin, again, makes the claim that we are just in the very beginnings of economic innovation when it comes to crypto economics. And he takes us through his vision of the future, his vision for the future of Ethereum and the future of Ether, the asset? And what can it really do when we apply all of the research and development that we've done ever since 2009 when Bitcoin got started? I think historically, David, there's been a little bit of a taboo in Ethereum culture to talk about price.
So we use terms like economic security. And to be clear, we weren't talking about the price of Ether on a given day in this episode. But the monetary premium of the asset, Ether as a store of value in the asset's relationship to the economic security of Ethereum, I've actually never heard an Ethereum researcher or someone very plugged into the protocol design talk about it in this way. So for me, honestly, David, this is kind of like a dream episode. It's one thing for listeners to hear Ethereum bulls like you and I talk about this. It's another to hear from somebody who's actually designing the engine and designing that engine with the intent to produce what?
To produce a sound money? To produce an ultrasound money? This to me was like really a fantastic episode, like a dream episode. Honestly, I've been waiting for an engineer, a developer, somebody who's working on the engine of Ethereum to come out and say this. And, you know, the takeaway here is hold your hat, folks. Like, Ethereum is coming. Ether, the asset, is coming for a store of value position in this ecosystem. It's like we've been saying from day one on. Bankless, David. Ether is money. Justin Drake, to me, is a true cypherpunk. He is really leading the charge of what the legacy of the cypherpunks have left behind, where they maximized innovation in cryptography.
it exploded onto the scene cryptography exploded on the scene with the emergence of bitcoin and crypto economics justin is a cypherpunk 2.0 because it's now not just cryptography it's crypto economics and to me he's the absolute absolute expert on crypto economics and what crypto economics can do there were so many takeaways in this episode and there's just too many to list here i think the one takeaway that i do want to mention is that there has already been the sound money culture in Ethereum. It's just been hidden under behind the scenes. And with the emergence of things like EIP-1559 and the reduction of Ether issuance in proof of stake, we actually get to talk about how that creates a sound money in Ethereum and the beneficial tailwinds that that creates for Ethereum and also for the world.
If the world can have the hardest, most sound money possible, it deserves that. And Ether, according to Justin Drake, is ultra sound money. I would make the statement, guys, that you don't know Ethereum and you certainly don't know ETH asset until you've listened to this episode because ETH asset is going to be defined and Ethereum, the network, is going to be defined by the next engine upgrade it's receiving. And it's receiving that economic engine upgrade now with proof of stake. It's just been live for a few months, EIP-1559, and the eventual merge and ending of proof of work. So if you want to understand the future of Ethereum, if you want to understand ETH asset, you have to listen to this episode.
It is well worth your time. The other thing I would say is you might not understand Bitcoin, the asset, or Bitcoin, the network, until you listen to this episode. And that's the hidden spicy take. David, should we get right into the episode? First, we want to tell you about our sponsors that made this episode possible. Aave is a borrowing and lending protocol on Ethereum and just recently released Aave version 2, which has a ton of cool new features that makes using Aave even more powerful. With Aave, you can leverage the full power of DeFi, MoneyLegos, Yield, and Composability all in one application.
On Aave, there are a ton of assets that you can deposit in order to gain yield and all of those same assets can also be borrowed from the protocol if you have deposited collateral here you can see me getting a 200 usdc loan against my portfolio of a number of different defy tokens and eth i'll choose a variable interest rate because it's a lower rate than the stable interest rate option but i could choose the stable interest rate option if i wanted to lock that interest rate in permanently one of ave's v2 features is the the ability to swap collateral without having to withdraw your assets, trade them on Uniswap, and then deposit them back into Aave.
Aave does all of this for you all in one seamless transaction, so you don't have to repay loans in order to change the collateral you have backing them. Check out the power of Aave at aave.com. That's A-A-V-E dot com. Gemini is the world's most trusted cryptocurrency exchange. I've been a customer of Gemini since I first got into crypto in 2017 and it's been my main exchange of choice to make my crypto buys and sells. Gemini is available in all 50 states and in over 50 countries worldwide and on Gemini there are markets for over 30 various different crypto assets including many of the hot DeFi tokens and it's one of the few exchanges that has liquid die markets.
Gemini just launched their earn program where you can earn up to 7.4% interest on 26 various crypto assets. If you're tired of paying fees in DeFi or you don't want to worry about DeFi exploits but you still want to earn interest on your crypto assets, Gemini Earn is the product for you. Another product I'm stoked to get my hands on is the Gemini Crypto Back credit card which gives you 3% cash back on all of your purchases but paid to you in your preferred crypto asset. When I get my Gemini credit card I'm going to make sure that I get my cash back in ETH so whenever I buy something I get a little bit of ETH bonus back to me at the same time.
You can open up a free account in under three minutes at Gemini.com slash GoBankless. And if you trade more than $100 within the first 30 days after signup, you'll be gifted a free $15 Bitcoin bonus. Check them out at Gemini.com slash GoBankless. All right, Bankless Nation, we are super excited to once again host Justin Drake, who is a brilliant mind and researcher at the Ethereum Foundation. We just had Justin on for one of our most popular episodes, one of my favorite episodes, I think David would agree too. My favorite as well. Moon Math and the Bull Case for Cryptography. The last episode really focused on cryptography.
We touched the economics, but we didn't get into it in detail. I think in this episode, we are about to. So think of this as the sister episode to the Moon Math Bull Case for Cryptography episode. Justin, Drake, it is fantastic to have you. How are you doing today, sir? I'm doing great. Thanks for having me again. So this being sort of the sequel, the sister episode, I felt like the theme from the previous episode was cryptography is really in the Stone Age and we have so much further to take it. And there are all of these cryptographic innovations that are coming down the pipe that we are going to incorporate in crypto, going to incorporate in Ethereum.
But we didn't talk as much about economics? Is there more to talk about on the economic side here? Right. I mean, that's a legitimate question to ask. We have these huge improvements in cryptography. Do we also have huge improvements in economics? And I'd argue that we're still also in the Stone Age when it comes to economics. And in a way, I mean that literally, right? because we're still in the age of gold-driven economics. And gold, you can think of it as a stone, as a shiny rock. So Bitcoin has taken the approach to mimic gold and the economics of gold as much as possible. So you can think of it as skeuomorphic economic design.
It tries to copy the real world. This is very similar to what happened in the early days of the Internet when people were designing websites. They had these buttons which looked like actual press buttons. But when you take a clean slate approach, you have new possibilities. And when you really embrace the digital aspect of trustless sound money, actually, you can really transcend to a large extent this stone age economics. And, you know, when preparing this podcast, I actually realized that the gap between the economics of Bitcoin, which is kind of Stone Age economics, and kind of the future of Ethereum, which you can think of as sci-fi economics, is enormous.
It's 10, 100x, 1000x better. So, I guess I'm excited to dig into concretely what are the improvements of the economic system as a whole. We have various components that are individually improved. So, for example, we have an improved consensus engine where we go from proof of work to proof of stake. take. We have an improved fee mechanism where we go from this first auction mechanism to this EIP-1559 mechanism. And we also have various other economic innovations, such as the issuance policy. And all these things together in this latest design really come together really, really nicely. And so in the same way that Bitcoin is engineered money, and it's engineered to be as close as possible to gold, we can ask ourselves, what if we push forward this economic engineering as far as we can?
And we have 12 years of, I guess, innovation that are compounding. And when you compare what we have to what we will have, the gap is enormous. Justin, our last episode with you was all about the bull case for cryptography. And the claim was that cryptographic hashes and signatures were really just like the stone in the fire when it comes to cryptography. And there's so much more left to tap into, so much more potential to tap into. and i think we're about to do this again with economics where you're claiming that with economics the progress of humanity and innovation behind cryptonomics is just at the very beginning yet i want to i want to plant an idea an image in the listeners heads where while innovation and economics can progress economics as a discipline still follows the same patterns and this is the patterns that humans have come to to understand they're in with every economic system there is an economic engine the uh the engine of an economy is a metaphor that we hear out both inside and outside of crypto and what i think we're going to lead us through is a metaphor that we're going to keep on returning to is how economies are engines and the design of said engine impacts the economy and also the fuel that we put into this engine impacts the economy and so as a frame of reference uh you're going to take us through all of these different ways in this comparison makes sense.
So to kick this off, I want to throw the ball back into your court. Maybe you can elaborate on that metaphor. How is an economy like an engine and where does this conversation start when it gets turned to Ethereum and cryptography and crypto economics? Yeah, so I actually stole an idea from Michael Saylor. So Michael Saylor loves to say that Bitcoin is this economic battery that can be charged with kind of monetary premium. And I kind of agree, you know, with this metaphor. And I was thinking to myself, okay, what if we extend this energy metaphor to the other pieces of the blockchain, not just the battery?
So I guess we have, you know, monetary energy, which you can think of as kind of electric energy. And this monetary energy is stored in battery cells. So you can think of one token, for example, one Bitcoin or one Ether as being a battery cell that can store this energy. And I guess if you look at the battery, there's kind of two separate ways to charge and discharge the individual energy battery cells. So the first one is kind of an exogenous process. So you have the market with supply and demand that will pump in energy into the battery and the battery will store this energy into the battery cells.
and the reverse can happen. You know, you can sell and remove energy from the battery. So buying the token is charging the token. Selling the token is discharging the token, right? Exactly. And so I can pay you to do push-ups, right? I'll pay you like one Ether to do a hundred push-ups and I can pay you to do that labor. I can pay you to do that work. And that is how the stored energy in an asset, in gold, Bitcoin, Ether can turn into real labor, real work in the real world. Exactly. Yes. And like one of the things that we're trying to design for is the concept of soundness. So what does soundness mean?
It means that the energy storage is hold over time, right? So in 10 years time, I still want the energy to be stored in those battery cells. I don't want basically the battery cells to leak. So that's one way where you can charge and discharge the battery is just by buying and selling. And by the way, when we're talking about energy here, Justin, right? The metaphor that Michael Saylor used is the same metaphor that you're using. Energy here is value. Specifically, it's monetary value. We're not talking about like proof of work energy or anything like that. We're actually talking about value being the monetary engine of these crypto economic systems, correct?
Yeah, that is correct. I mean, there's various analogies that are rooted in engineering when we talk about money and value. You know, you can think of it in terms of fluid mechanics, fluid dynamics, sorry, where you have fluids. You know, we talk about liquidity, right? And liquidity pools and things like that. And you can also use heat kind of as, you know, like heat travels from one place to another. But yeah, I guess for today's podcast, we can use energy as the metaphor for monetary value, as you say, exactly. Yeah, we've got the energy, we've got the battery cells. Take us further into this metaphor.
Right. So there's another mechanism, which is basically issuance and burn. So here, what you're doing is that you're creating new tokens, so new battery cells, or you're removing battery cells. And here, you're not really charging or discharging the battery as a whole. Like the amount of energy stays the same, but you're redistributing things. So when you add, for example, battery cells, you create new tokens. these battery cells have the property where they all want to have the same value, right? Because they're fungible. So you print new containers, these battery cells, and then you have this flow of monetary energy from the existing battery cells into the new ones until they all have the same value.
And it's the exact same mechanism when you're burning. From the point of view of a Bitcoiner, issuance is the root of all evil in the sense that when you create these new tokens, well, it's kind of leaking from the existing tokens. And so as a Bitcoin holder, you don't like that because you're being diluted. Your energy is getting stolen from you, right? Because new Bitcoins or new dollars or new Ether are completely fungible with old Bitcoins, old Ether. The issuance is just stealing that energy. It's not creating new energy. It's just tapping into the energy that already exists in these other monetary assets.
Exactly right. Yep. Now that is one component, which is the battery. And then there's kind of another extremely important component in the world of blockchains. And to continue this energy metaphor, think of an electric engine, the engine. So specifically, the engine is going to be a metaphor for our consensus engine. The consensus engine takes in economic fuel, right? And that could be in the form of issuance, which is a way to basically discharge individual cells and take energy and give it to the engine, or you could feed this engine with another type of fuel, which is the transaction fees.
And then the whole point of this economic engine is that as an output is going to give you economic security. And this economic security, which is output, is meant to secure the whole system. And so when you look at the engine, you know, you can look at various things like how powerful is my engine, like how much economic security is it giving me? Or you could look at how fuel efficient is it? Like, how much power do I get per unit of fuel? or you could ask yourself okay what is the best type of fuel to feed into my engine is there like one type of fuel which is better than the other or you could look at what is the ratio of the the load that under which the the engine is and the the power that it has right so if you have a an economic engine of power that's a $10 billion.
It takes 10, you have $10 billion of economic security, meaning that it costs $10 billion to attack the system, but your load is going to be the economy living on top of that. So if we look at Bitcoin, for example, it's a $1 trillion system. It has $5 billion of economic security. So the load to power ratio is going to be 200, one trillion divided by 5 billion. And then you can look at all sorts of metrics like that about your engine and try and understand, okay, what are the properties of my engine? And it turns out that if you take your engine, which is proof of work, and you replace it with proof of stake, then pretty much on every single metric, you get an improvement.
And it's not just like a tiny improvement, like 10% or 20% or 50%. It's 10x better, 100x better, or in some cases, a thousand times better and more. So we're going to dig into all of these components in more depth. But just to kind of establish these components as part of the intro. So the engine, as you said, is the consensus mechanism. And so Bitcoin, of course, uses proof of work. Ethereum, in the future, will use proof of stake. We're going to get into that. And you also mentioned the fuel is basically it's economic fuel, right? This is not gasoline or petrol. This is a fuel that comes from two sources generally in a crypto economic system.
Issuance is the first source of economic power, economic energy, and transaction fees are the second source. But let me ask a question about the engine. So an electric car engine produces something, right? That is motion. It enables the card to go from point A to point B. What does a crypto engine for a layer one like Bitcoin or Ethereum produce? Is this consensus? Is this, or more abstractly, does it produce trust? Right. What is the output of the engine? Right. Okay. So the output is what I call economic security in the context of consensus. So the way I kind of think of it kind of graphically is that imagine you have like some sort of Star Wars or Star Trek kind of shield around your spaceship and it's providing security.
It's like your economic shield. And just to be very concrete in Bitcoin, it's hash rate. Right. So basically, what is the dollar equivalent to your hash rate? So in Bitcoin, the hash rate is 150 million tera hashes per second. OK, and each tera hash, if you were to go buy mining hardware, each tera hash will cost you about 30 bucks. So you have roughly 4.5 billion dollars of economic security. So if you want to overthrow the Bitcoin system, if you want to perform a 51% attack, you're going to have to buy $4.5 billion of mining hardware in order to get that hash rate. And so you can denominate economic security in dollar terms.
It's basically your moat, your defense moat. And for Ethereum proof of stake, your security, economic security is also denominated in dollars. And the way you get the number is basically by looking at the total amount of ETH staked. So right now we have 3.5 million ETH. At current prices, this is over $6 billion. So, you know, even today, you know, this very nascent proof of stake system in Ethereum has more economic security than Bitcoin. So, Justin, there's an interaction here between the energy and the engine, right? And this is the difference that we often talk about on the Bankless podcast is there's Bitcoin, BTC, the asset, and then there's Bitcoin, the network, right?
There's Ether, the money, and then there's Ethereum, the economy. And then there's the Ethereum consensus mechanism, which is proof of stake. And all of these things interact. They're all a part of a composed system. And the viability, what we're going to get to is the viability of the engine and the efficiency of the engine ultimately impacts the moneyness that goes into the engine, right? Because the strength of one impacts the strength of others. And before we get into the differences between like how crypto economics is different than gold economics, because there are important differences there.
I want to ask you about like, well, when all of these things get integrated, when all of these composed systems and we maximize the benefits and efficiencies of all of these systems to generate this maximally efficient engine. That is what gets who gives monetary premium. Can you talk about that? I mean, so one of the things you mentioned is that all of this is a system, right? And it's important to consider them in combination. So for gold, kind of one of the very nice things is that the engine you get for free, right? The engine is mother nature, is the laws of physics. The laws of physics kind of give us for free censorship resistance.
resistance, it gives us for free, no double spend, and it gives us for free, no, you know, no forgery and things like that. Unfortunately, in the world of blockchains, your consensus engine, you just have to keep feeding it, you don't get it for free, you have to pay for it. Now, if you look at the economic design of Bitcoin, especially in the long term, when there's no more issuance, basically what it's done is that it's kind of made a mistake, right? And the mistake is that it tried to mimic gold a little bit too much. And so what it's done is that it's basically isolated, segregated the battery and the engine.
So today, the engine is is connected to to to the battery and so that's that's providing this constant source of fuel that will give you economic security but in the long term you know this link is severed so there's there's there's two separate systems there's the battery and then the engine and then the risk is that you have this amazing battery which is the the btc asset with like 21 million bitcoin guaranteed um but you know it's it's the the real liability is is the is the engine here Now, going back to your question around, I think it's a question around reflexivity, which is basically, you know, what is going to be used as a store of value?
And it's kind of, it really, it kind of starts, in my opinion, at the technology level, right? Because once you have the best candidates for something that could be a good store of value, it could have very nice properties, it could be digital, it could be programmable. It could be scarce, it could be secure, all of these things. Then kind of people start using it as a store of value. And then, you know, you have this reflexivity going on. And so, you know, in the same way that we've seen, you know, the stores of value radically change over time, you know, we've had, you know, seashells and, you know, salt and, you know, yap stones and gold and Bitcoin.
I think we're at the cusp of something new here where technologically speaking, we have something which is radically better than what we have before. And then that is kind of this weird reflexive loop that kind of discharges the previous store of value and then charges the other store of value, the successor. So let's talk about that for a minute, because it's a property, and I'm going to use the term magical, because it's almost a magical property that some assets, some scarce assets get to have, which is this magical meme power of monetary premium. It's the thing that a bunch of humans have collectively decided could be valuable and that they should store their wealth in.
And it's reflexive, as you say, is because the best store of value is the store of value that community, the entire world comes to consensus on effectively. So when you're betting on a future store of values, you're kind of betting that society and culture and communities around the world will choose to store their wealth into one thing. So not everything can have this. You mentioned this history of money where gold had that throughout the centuries, throughout the ages. There were times where silver had it, but assets like copper never had strong monetary premium or it was smashed by some of these harder, more sound assets.
You also mentioned, Justin, that the interesting thing about gold is it's imbued with this economic security due to physics, right? The birth of a explosion of a star, a supernova has created gold on the periodic table of elements, and that is its security budget for its lifetime. It doesn't have to keep repaying it, whereas Bitcoin does. Bitcoin has to keep repaying its economic security, keep feeding the engine as it will, or else it will no longer work. So we're drawing these kind of comparisons, I think. But can you talk a little bit more about this mystical property, this magic meme energy behind a monetary premium?
So where does it come from? People still don't really understand that, Justin. Like we know that it's in gold, but we've grown up with gold being a store of values before our lifetime. We see it maybe emerging in Bitcoin. We see elements of it emerging in ETH. What is this monetary premium thing? Where's the magic here? Right. So if you were to use kind of economic terms, I'd say that, you know, it's all about the selling point. As you said, there's coordination involved. You have various candidates for stores of values and you want to look at their merits and you want to have some sort of mechanism for society to agree on one of them, to coordinate on one of them.
And And basically, you want to have the winner, you know, the natural processes for the winner to stand out in some way. And the fact that it stands out means that it becomes the shelling point. And then that becomes the place where everyone congregates. And, you know, there's various ways to achieve a shelling point, right? One could be like, you know, simplicity, security. One could be like the Lindy effect. Like how long has this thing existed? You know, one could be, you know, how useful is it? This is where commodity monies came from, right? Like the selling point was that the money is useful already.
So, you know, it's a natural place for everyone to coordinate because they already had value. And, you know, you can think of gold as being, you know, um commodity money to to an extent right because you know gold has been used you know for jewelry but also for you know industrial use cases um and i think once we in the the digital world um you know you know there's there's many properties that are very important to have if you want to be that that selling point where everyone congregates and where the narrative kind of um does its does its magic as you say. And I think one of the big ones is programability.
And this is one of the things that is a distinguisher between Bitcoin and Ethereum. But beyond that, if you look purely at economic considerations, I think there's two of them. The first one is economic security, right? So Bitcoiners care very, very deeply about security and for very, very good reason. You know, they're paranoid, you know, it's part of the culture. And one of the amazing things is that from an economic security standpoint, Ethereum is miles ahead than Bitcoin. So that's kind of one check in the checklist that we have. I guess another aspect for being a selling point is for being an economic selling point is economic efficiency, right?
So like how much, how efficient is your system? You know, going back to the security, like how fuel efficient it is. And this is gonna have real impact, you know, on security, on issuance and things like that. And it turns out again, that Ethereum is orders of magnitude 10 to a hundred times more fuel efficient than Bitcoin. And then when you combine these two things together, economic security and economic efficiency, then out pops kind of something amazing, which is economics scarcity, but not just the standard vanilla kind of cap supply economic scarcity, but a new paradigm, which I guess you could call ultrasound money, right?
So if Bitcoin is sound money, because it has this cap supply. Then thanks to all sorts of innovations, that go really, really deep, at the very surface layer, you have ultrasounds money. And the idea here is that the total supply is actually decreasing over time. And this is actually somewhat similar to Bitcoin in the long term. So, it's a natural process for people to lose their keys. For example, as they die, if they haven't set up a proper inheritance mechanism and whatnot, then these coins could go missing. So if you estimate that, let's say, one in a thousand coins goes missing every year, then in roughly 30 years, Bitcoin is going to become ultrasound in the sense that the amount of money, Bitcoin that is lost through natural mechanisms will outpace the inflation, the issuance, sorry.
I guess Ethereum will be ultrasound kind of 30 years earlier than Bitcoin, and it will be ultrasound by not just 0.1%, but potentially much, much more than that. So I want to recap where we've gotten to so far, and then we're going to get into the details about how this comparison works out. So monetary energy, which is the monetary asset, the units, Bitcoin, gold, ether, that's the battery. That's the fuel going into the system. And gold has this privilege because it was birthed in supernovas, right? And there's no such thing as a supernova money printer. That doesn't exist. That's nonsensical.
Yet when we talk about this realm of crypto economics, what you're saying is that just focusing on the battery side, the energy side, the value side of things, is only half of the equation. And if we really want to maximize what is the potential here, we need to both have the best fuel possible, the best energy possible, the best value possible, but we also need the best economic engine. Because if we have a good fuel, but a poor engine, our aggregate output is less. And just focusing on one of these two things is missing the whole picture. And so this is where I think, Justin, and you are particularly optimistic about researching both how to make the best value possible with also making the producing the best engine possible and it's really the aggregate of all of these systems that is what we are calling a new paradigm rather than a skeuomorphic backwards design of replicating what we already know we are actually using innovation research and development to actually progress forward so i think at this point in the conversation i want to turn to the engine design so not talking about the the value or the fuel but instead talking about the system the engine that consumes that fuel and comparing and contrasting the efficiency of proof of work and proof of stake could you lead us into into that conversation yeah for sure um i guess just before we do that i just want to add one more essential component it's actually a three components in the system we have the battery we have the engine and then the third one is the solar panel okay so what does the solar panel do it's a way to convert one form of energy into another form of energy right so solar panels will convert solar energy into electricity and the metaphor here is um the the the fee market right so you have this transactional utility right people have a desire to um to transact and that um translates into transaction fees and this this output of the solar panel um it you know can be fed into the into the engine and And this is how it is right now with both Bitcoin and Ethereum proof of work.
The solar panel is connected to the engine directly. And the solar panel captures the energy of the economy, right? There's a GDP behind Bitcoin. There's a GDP behind Ethereum. There's a GDP behind the United States. The IRS taxes that GDP, you know, gas fees on Ethereum taxes that GDP. Bitcoin fees tax that GDP and injects it back into the system. Right, exactly. So it's important to take into account the solar panel. And I guess one of the key innovations that we have in Ethereum is EIP-1559. And you can think of EIP-1559 as finding a way to basically use the output of that solar panel and connect it to the battery so that you're charging the battery.
So instead of connecting the output to the engine directly, you're connecting it to the battery. And this has very significant consequences in terms of security. And I guess we can talk about that. So I guess you're asking, what are these characteristics of the engine? Can we go through them one by one and try and compare and contrast proof of work? and proof of stake. So, you know, I already mentioned, you know, just in terms of raw power, what is the power of the engine, right? Bitcoin has 150 million terahashes per second, $30 per terahash, that's 4.5 billion. Ethereum has about 6.5 billion of economic security with the EFAT stake.
In the beacon chain. In the beacon chain, exactly. Right. I just want to camp on that for one second, Justin, because I'm not sure like everyone understands that. So what you just did was you multiplied the value of all of the hash rate and you came up with a number because hash rate is essentially its capital. It can be converted into units of value. It can be converted into dollars. And when you compared that and you said, what, that's four point five billion or so or five billion. 4.5, yeah. Let's say 5 billion. 5 billion. Okay. And then what you did was, and that is essentially the economic security of Bitcoin.
So if somebody wanted to attack Bitcoin, they would have to have what? 51% of that 4.5 billion? Is that correct? Well, let's assume that the 5 billion is honest. They don't want to attack. So you as an external attacker, if you want to have 50%, you need to match what's already there. So you kind of need to double the hash rate. So I need to double the hash rate. So I need to have like 5 billion or so of equivalent hash rate. Okay. And let's remind, Bitcoin, just like Ethereum, gives two security guarantees, no double spends and no censorship. So that's why security is so important. That's why we're talking about it.
Now with Ethereum, you just use the number that is based on the amount of ETH staked right now in what we call ETH 2.0, right? In the beacon chain, essentially. And the value of that is what? Six billion at this point in time? Right. Let's say six billion. So it's six billion. So what you're saying is already post-merge, whatever that happens in Ethereum, Ethereum as a economic network already provides more economic security than Bitcoin. This is what you said, and this is what I just wanted to emphasize, because I'm not sure people have fully wrapped their heads around that and understand that.
The Ethereum network is potentially already more secure economically than the Bitcoin network, at least post-merge, once proof of stake is fully activated. That's what you're saying, right? Yes, that's correct. Someone might ask a very natural question, which is, What about in addition to the $5 billion of mining hardware that you need to buy, what about the electricity that you need to expend to perform the attacks? It turns out that the electricity per day is negligible. It's like 10 million, 20 million. So if you're happy to pay 4.5 billion, surely you can afford 20 million. And being able to do the attack just for one day or one week or one month or even a whole year, that's totally possible once you've already made the investment of getting $5 billion of hash rate.
Let's talk about the engine then, the horsepower. Because I think this is where you're leading to. The question in my mind after I hear that is, okay, how is that possible? How is Ethereum providing more economic security with less total market cap? It's a lower value asset from a market cap perspective compared to Bitcoin. So how is this even possible? Right. So I guess this goes back to the next point after we cover economic securities, economic efficiency. So it turns out that, skipping ahead, that Ethereum is roughly 20 times more fuel efficient than Bitcoin. So you get more bang for the buck.
So in Ethereum, if you have $1 of fuel, let's say, you get $20 of security. In Bitcoin, you put in $1 of fuel, you get $1 of economic security. So one of the reasons why even just out of the gate Ethereum is more secure than Bitcoin is due to this efficiency, which we can talk about later. I think an important point I want to bring up is the way that this interacts, the way that the engine interacts with the money is extremely salient here because with the Ethereum economy, Ethereum which runs on Ether and the Bitcoin economy runs on Bitcoin. And when we were talking talking about how do you charge in a unit and how do you make Bitcoin have more value or how do you make ether have more value it's by buying it and and not selling it right so the ratio of buys to sells is how you charge the battery but if your economic engine of Bitcoin requires 15 times as much value to achieve the same result as Ethereum does be under proof of stake, that means you have to discharge 15 times as much Bitcoin versus Ether, right?
So you are selling because Bitcoin miners receive Bitcoins and then they sell them to pay for electricity and hardware. And so as the result of the way that the Bitcoin engine is designed, it discharges 15 times faster the rate of value than the Ethereum economic engine under proof of stake. forcibly sells BTC, the asset on the secondary market, which is like the battery of the unit, the unit battery of Bitcoin leaking because of the persistent selling. Did I get that right? Yes. So if we assume that there's no transaction fees, then it's exactly right. Let's assume that the engine is fully powered by the battery.
Then, you know, for an equivalent amount of economic security, the proof of work engine is drawing power 20 times more than the proof of stake engine. And so, you know, you could, I guess you could compare this a little bit, you know, to to, you know, electric cars versus gasoline cars. So if you want to do, I don't know, 100 miles, you know, it's going to cost you X number of dollars to charge the battery and do 100 miles. miles if you're using electric car. If you're using fuel car, you're going to have to buy, you know, 10x or whatever the number is, the multiple is. It just turns out that the multiple between proof of work and proof of stake is 20.
So even though right now, Bitcoin is kind of providing much more economic fuel to the engine than Ethereum is actually providing, is getting as a result less economic security. And, you know, one of the, you know, my projections, if I were to look into the future, I actually expect that the Ethereum economic engine to be at least 10 times larger than Bitcoin. And then, you know, one of the reasons here is that we're going to have more people staking. So, for example, you know, Coinbase hasn't really launched yet. know they're going to bring in let's say one million extra um ethereum to stake um and then that's going to to increase the power of the engine um and my expectation is that we'll get let's say 10 percent of all ether or 20 percent of all ether staking and that's going to dramatically increase uh the economic security of the of the ethereum system and i guess another possibility is that the ratio of the price of Ether relative to the price of Bitcoin will increase.
And if that happens, that will also improve the relative output power of these economic engines. So Justin, that increased economic value or that increased efficiency means that the Ethereum economy can secure more on top of it, right? So when we think about all of the tokens, all of the assets, all of the in the future roll-ups and layer twos that are secured on top of Ethereum, that value has a certain dollar amount, right? There are 85 billion or so DeFi tokens out there. Right now, there's 30 billion-ish stable coins. All of these things have economic value. But the Ethereum base layer needs to be able to secure that economic value.
And this goes to a concept I think you were talking about a little bit earlier. You hinted at this load to power sort of ratio. And what I think you mean there is, maybe you can explain it further, is how large of an economy can the base layer actually secure? Can you get into load to power and talk about that? Right, exactly. So the load to power, the load is kind of the economic load of the whole system, the whole economy that relies on this engine. So for Bitcoin, we have an economy of a size $1 trillion and we have an engine economic security of $5 billion. So the ratio is 200. And, you know, the greater the ratio, the worse things are.
And the reason is that the incentive for an attacker to attack the system is greater, right? So the attacker only needs to expend $5 billion, and they could potentially break a system of size $1 trillion. So really, you want to be reducing that ratio as much as possible. I think the metaphor here is simply a truck towing something, right? So you have a car, you have a vehicle, it has torque, it has power, and then it also has a load that is pulling behind. And if that load is too big in relation to the power of that engine, that can cause misalignment or misaligned incentives. It will cause, you know, choking and stalling.
You know, the engine will stall. It's not capable of pulling the load. It's not adequate for the amount of load. And one of the scary things with Bitcoin is that the issuance is going to zero. And if the transaction fees can't compensate for the reduction in issuance, then this ratio is just going to get worse and worse and worse. So let's imagine a success scenario for Bitcoin. Let's say that it reaches the market cap of gold, let's say $12 trillion. Now, if there's no issuance, it needs to get all of its economic fuel from transaction fees. Now, let's assume that every single transaction on average pays $100 in transaction fees.
Now there's only, I think, 120 million transactions per year. So that gives us a low to ratio of roughly 1,000 to 1. So over time, even in very conservative estimates, I'm expecting the ratio to worsen from 200 to 1 up to 1,000 to 1. One of the good news in Ethereum is that, like we, I'm expecting, let's say 10% of all the ETH staked, all the ETH to be staking. And so here it's very easy to calculate the ratio, right? Because it's just going to be 10 to 1, right? So if you look at all the ETH out there, there's going to be 10 times more ETH out there than there is ETH staking. So the ratio is 10 to 1.
But actually, as you said, David, we shouldn't just look at ETH, because that's not the only thing that Ethereum is securing. It's securing also all sorts of DeFi and non-ETH assets. And so, you know, let's make some sort of projections. You know, let's say that DeFi is 10 times as large as the Ethereum economy, the ETH economy. then the ratio worsens to 100 to 1, but it's still nowhere near the 1,000 to 1 that this projection would give us. So Justin, when you describe this, this load to power concept, and as David was talking about it, I get this mental image of like a pickup truck, just trying to haul a massively large trailer and it gets to this hill.
And it just, it just can't, it's just not enough, like throttle to be able to make it up this this hillside or this mountain. Can we talk about what actually happens? So if Bitcoin gets to a place where it has an 1,000 to 1 ratio in terms of the amount of value inside of it versus its economic security, right? What practically happens in a transaction? So we can, I think, see glimmers of this when you use lower economic security chains like Bitcoin's Satoshi's Vision is one. I mean, I think exchanges, they will sometimes take days or even weeks to confirm transactions from very low economic security chains.
It's because they need all of those blocks to come through before they'll actually like certify that the transaction is valid and can't be double spent. Is that sort of what we're talking about here is in a Bitcoin that is way overloaded here, the transaction speeds will slow down or at least not transaction speeds, maybe I should say confirmation times will slow down? Settlement assurances. Right, exactly. It's actually worse than that in the worst case. So, you know, let's imagine that Bitcoin becomes systemically relevant for the Internet and the world, right? It's like, let's say it's a hundred trillion dollar kind of asset.
You know, if you put yourself in the shoes of a government like China or the United States, you think to yourself, okay, I have the power to manipulate the economy of the internet, this $100 trillion beast, and I only have to spend, what, $10 billion? You know, it's like a no-brainer, right? I'm obviously going to, you know, my military budget is like 100 times that or, you know, a thousand times that. I'm obviously going to, you know, to spend that $10 billion to have control over this world economy. So, yeah, if we want to look in terms of the long-term success, basically, you should think of the load as being the carrot, kind of the incentive for the attacker, the bigger the load, the more kind of value there is to potentially extract and steal and manipulate and do all sorts of bad things.
So yeah, it's actually worse than just being conservative in terms of confirmation times. it could just simply break the system. I mean, it's actually shocking, right? That there's only $5 billion securing Bitcoin. Like a government like China or the United States could definitely pull this off and break Bitcoin as it is today. Yeah, I think a lot of people don't realize this. Hey guys, quick break in the action. There's so much left that Justin Drake has to deliver about Ether as sound money. We go back to the conversation of Ether as a monetary battery and EIP-1559 representing a recycling mechanism that captures that excess energy.
We also talk about the lasting impact of the combination of EIP-1559 and proof of stake, which Justin projects out to have a huge efficiency upgrade to Ether the asset, the fuel that we put into Ethereum. According to Justin, because of these upgrades, We get to recapture an equivalent amount of value of ETH locked in DeFi at today's rates, except we get to get that value back into Ether, the asset, every single year. It's such a cool conversation. And also we talk about Ethereum culture or the layer zero of Ethereum and how it's actually been a sound money culture this entire time. We just didn't know it yet.
Really interesting conversations. We got to take a quick break and talk about some of these fantastic sponsors that make this show possible. If you want to live a bankless life, you need to get a Monolith DeFi Visa card. Monolith is both a one-two punch of an Ethereum smart contract wallet, as well as an accompanying Visa card that lets you spend the money that you have in your Ethereum wallet wherever Visa is accepted. It's really a fantastic tool that lets you use Ethereum for what it does best, which is holding and managing your financial assets, but also keeps you connected to the rest of the world's payment rails.
Monolith also offers on-ramp services for getting your fiat money into the world of DeFi. So it's trivial to top up your Monolith card if ever you need to, and your deposited money goes straight into your non-custodial wallet. So your money is never held by a centralized intermediary because your Monolith wallet is native to Ethereum. Monolith helps you transcend both the legacy and the crypto worlds because the money that you hold in your Monolith wallet has the power of DeFi behind it. Swapping assets on Uniswap or earning yield in DeFi is at your fingertips, but with Monolith, so are the groceries at your grocery store or the coffee at your coffee shop.
Go to monolith.xyz to sign up and get your Monolith Visa card to IsEthereum's Decentralized Derivatives Liquidity Protocol. What does that mean? Synthetix is a platform for creating and trading synthetic assets, which are assets that are priced via an oracle rather than bids or asks. Traders can use the Quenta exchange, which hosts and trades all of the synthetic assets created by Synthetix. Traders on Quenta can trade synthetic tokens like SBTC, S-Oil, or S-DeFi. Because Quenta is powered by Synthetix, traders experience zero slippage on their trades. No, I didn't mean low slippage. I meant no slippage, because that is the power of the Synthetix platform.
No slippage on your trades. You can also easily short assets with ISINTS, which are synthetic assets that move inversely to their target asset. Synthetics isn't just for traders. Developers can build on synthetics to access the infinite liquidity offered by synthetic assets. Or investors can stake collateral to the protocol and earn fees that the protocol collects. If you're a trader and you're looking for a trading platform not found in the legacy world, check out Quenta.io. If you're a developer or you just want to earn yield on your collateral, go to www.synthetix.io, where you can stake your SNX or ETH and earn fees from Synthetix.
You know, I want to draw another connection here because this is something that we've talked about on the Bankless podcast. And I think you're pointing a fine tip on when we brought on Charlie Noyes from Paradigm. we talked about this concept of a base layer like Ethereum, the importance of monetary premium, right? Because monetary premium, as we talked about earlier, is sort of this magic meme power. If the underlying base asset is viewed as a store of value, then it just gives you an insta-boost to your economic security, right? And so we had kind of this, not a debate, but a discussion about where, like my take is kind of that the winning DeFi platform has to have the highest amount of economic security, right?
In order to host the 20X DeFi valuation that you were just talking about, Justin, right? So at some level, all layer one chains are in this competition for monetary premium. And if you are trying to be a layer one chain and your base asset is not money, right? So I'll throw one out there. Love the Cosmos ecosystem, fantastic projects, fantastic team. Atoms are not competing as a base money. They're not competing as a base store of value. Like the project teams will tell you that. But if you're not, you're at a disadvantage because there's a lower threshold of economic security that you can guarantee and settle on top of it.
Is this a conclusion that you would draw as well from the discussion so far, that it's vitally important that a layer one asset, base layer asset, have a monetary premium in order for it to secure the most amount of economic activity on top? You know, absolutely. Very well said. You know, this is part of the shutting point aspect, where you have various options for what can be, you know money and what can be stores of value um and you know as a community you know we're going to go through the catalog and look at what is what has the best properties and security is going to be you know one of the very top of the list um and if if your success scenario means having a low to uh to power ratio of a thousand or more then that's that's scary you know um because Because, you know, let's say that the ratio is 1,000 to 1.
So let's say that your economy is $100 trillion. That means that your security is $100 billion, right? 1,000 times less. That's, you know, that's still peanuts in the context of a government like China or the US. Justin, we were talking about this potential attack on Bitcoin by a nation state level actor. But proof of work versus proof of stake offers another property too. And that is kind of the property of being able to bounce back, almost like an anti-fragile type property, I believe. Vitalik has talked about this on the Bankless podcast in the past a little bit. Can you talk about how a Bitcoin proof of work type system would recover from such an attack versus Ethereum and proof of stake?
Right. So this is one of the places where the improvement between Ethereum and Bitcoin is not just 10x or 100x, it's kind of infinity. It's like black and white, zero to one. So let's assume that there is an attack. Some sort of government does attack Bitcoin. Well, it turns out that it can permanently attack Bitcoin. It's kind of game over. It's a knockout. And the reason is that you can do what Vitalik calls a spawn camp attack, is that you can just repeatedly attack the system over and over and over again. And the key issue is that with Bitcoin, you don't really know who is attacking you. Right.
Like the mining power is kind of anonymous. But maybe even more fundamentally, the other big problem is that even if you knew who was attacking you, you have no way to defend yourself. So you have no way to to kind of destroy that mining power. But with with Ethereum, we have we have these two superpowers. The first superpower is that every ETH staker is identified. So you have a pub key, which identifies you as a staker. And whenever you make an action, whenever you make an attestation, for example, which is one of these votes in the context of proof of stake, we know where this vote came from with cryptographic security.
Hang on, I just want to rephrase that really quick when somebody mines a bitcoin block they publish it to a network but anyone can publish it but in proof of stake when you attest to a block that attestation comes from a specific address with a specific amount of eth in that address when when you say identifying the person or we're not identifying well it's not this isn't kyc this isn't like naming a person this is just the stake which is where the security comes from comes from a very specific address which is not true with bitcoin bitcoin validation comes from miners which don't actually exist anywhere inside the bitcoin protocol it's just anyone can publish a block so just you could be a bitcoin miner and you could find a block and then you could send that that to me you could send me that information and i can publish that block but it's you still have the miners i just wanted to make that that clarifying point absolutely yeah there's no kyc involved this is just the the pseudo-anonymous identification that we have for example in in bitcoin and ethereum with the um with the addresses right you hold some bitcoin but that doesn't mean that you have to do kyc to to hold bitcoin at this specific address um so i guess not only can we identify where the the economic security comes from but we have this other superpower in Ethereum which is that we can slash so we can penalize so the idea of proof of stake is that you put something at stake right you which is if for example and if you do something bad we'll just remove that if so this would be the equivalent of setting on fire you know the bitcoin mining rigs and so we actually have two separate types of slashing mechanisms.
We have what I guess you could call layer one slashing, which is that within the protocol itself, if you do something which is obviously wrong, so for example if you do two conflicting votes, two conflicting attestations, then we have a mechanism to automatically slash you for doing that. And that will deal with many of the worst attacks out there. For example, if an attacker tries to create two finalized blockchains which are inconsistent, then we can prove mathematically that at least one third of the ETH stake will get slashed. So a very significant portion of the ETH will get slashed. And then once you slash that kind of malicious ETH, then as you said, it's anti-fragile.
the the system is self-repairing because now there's less malicious folks and you know we're left with with the the honest folks and um you know the people that were malicious got penalized and the people that were honest did not and by proxy were rewarded because it's reverse dilution it's the elimination of ether from the people that were bad and then therefore the people that were good own a larger percentage of the ether which means that the ethereum is moving into the hands of naturally moving into the hands of people that are good and honest right um and i guess if you want this when you look at the economic game you know in context of game theory you can look at the game in two different ways you can look at it as kind of one game you know can the attacker break the system yes or no if you were to play the game once and then there's notion of an iterated game which is what if you play the game multiple times um so you know for example imagine you're playing poker you can one hand of poker and that would be this this one shot kind of game or you could play the you know a thousand hands of poker and you know when you have this iterated game you know things change because you could learn about your opponent you can mix things up and whatnot it turns out that for coin the the one shot game is a knockout so you can't play you can't play the game anymore once you've been knocked out on the other hand with ethereum every time you get you get attacked you know that's pretty bad um you know i don't want to down downplay this so but um you know the the the system was was broken temporarily it was attacked um but it has this so you know for some period of time let's say a few days there will be chaos right because people would know what is the real finalized change because there's these two inconsistent finalized change but after you know the chaos settles um um a few days later the the system will be in a stronger position and now we can start again with the the second round of the game so let's say that the attacker wants to attack again right well now he needs to go acquire more if and then do the attack again and then get slashed again and every time you do that as you say the the um you know the amount of even circulation reduces and reduces and you can actually put a cap on the number of times that the system can be attacked so let's say for example that there's 10 of all if that is staking and they're honest so they don't intend to attack the system well there's only you know nine times that the attacker could do the attack right because he will need to buy at least 10 million uh eve and then every time he does the attack he loses the 10 million even needs to rebuy another 10 million and there's only 90 million up there so in the worst case scenario if you're going to get attacked nine times um so that's a very nice property which i guess you could call engine repairability this engine if it does break and you you know, things happen in the real life, at least you can repair it.
Bitcoin, the engine breaks, you just scrap it. And importantly, under proof of stake, if somebody, if there's a hundred million supply of ether and there's 10 million ether staked, an attacker needs to match that with another 10 million ether. But because of the nature of proof of stake and slashing, we can punish that person. So they better have gotten an equal amount of value off of that chaos that they created. Otherwise, why would they do this? But the important thing is like, A, there's only nine possible times that they could do this before the world runs out of Ether. But every time that they do this, the value of Ether on the secondary market goes up because this person bought 10 million Ether and then they deleted it.
And then they bought 10 million more and then they deleted it. And so it actually becomes increasingly costly because the cost of Ether goes up. The value that you needed to sell to buy that ether keeps going up every time you try and do this so not only is they're reducing ether available to you to attack the network it's also getting more expensive to purchase that ether exactly and not only do we have this anti-fragility at the iterated game level but we also have this anti-fragility property at the single single game level and the reason is okay you want to you want to acquire you know 10 million ETH you know you buy your first million and then your second million is going to cost you more than your first million because the price gone up etc etc and this is actually the opposite of bitcoin bitcoin has economies of scale for the attacker the larger the attacker is the cheaper he has to spend per tera hash per second in bitcoin you have this economy of scale the more ETH you want to buy the more expensive it's going to get get to you.
So let's say that in Bitcoin, you're Apple, right? If you're going to manufacture, you know, 150 million terahashes per second of hash rate, you bet they're going to pay much less than $30, right? Because the $30 that's, you know, including like the profit margin from Bitmain and including all sorts of inefficiencies. But if Apple were to do But maybe they'd only have to spend, let's say, $2 billion. One of the reasons, for example, is that Apple has priority access to TSMC's leading nodes. So TSMC is the company, Taiwan Semiconductor Manufacturing Company, that produces state-of-the-art silicon for the whole world.
And whenever you have a new node, so for example, the three nanometer node that's up, Apple has monopoly kind of access. And every time you improve the node, you get better power efficiency so that your cost per terahash kind of improves. improves. And there's all sorts of other economies of scale that you have when you attack Bitcoin, which is the exact opposite to Ethereum, where if you want to attack it, you have this economy of scale from the point of view of the attacker. So Justin, it just strikes me that the reason Bitcoin has never been attacked or Ethereum on proof of work for that matter has never been attacked is because no one's tried.
Nation states just haven't tried. That's the only reason. I mean, what you're saying, I think, is in the case of proof of work with Bitcoin, if I am a bad gov agency, let's say I'm bad gov US, I've got Apple that's located within my jurisdiction. I go, I team up with Apple. I spend $5 billion or so on ASIC hardware that they manufacture for me. And because I'm making such a large purchase, they give me 20% off. So thanks a lot, guys. It's less than $4 billion now. And then I go and I attack the Bitcoin network. And then this point about repairing the engine and anti-fragility with proof of work, because I own all of those ASICs, there's no way for Bitcoin to recover using the same hashing algorithms is how I'm understanding it.
Now, what would happen, though, if Bitcoin decided to just use a different hashing algorithm and kill all of those ASICs? We've seen Monero switch around their hashing algorithms in the past. Is that a path for them to get out of this conundrum that badgov.us has caused? Yes. So actually, I simplified the situation a little bit. When I said that Bitcoin is a one-shot game, it's actually a two-shot game. And the reason is that the first shot, you kill the double shot to 56, A6. They're no longer worthwhile. You move to a new proof-of-work system. But what is this proof of work system going to be based on?
It necessarily has to be based on commodity hardware. And by commodity hardware, I mean something like GPUs or CPUs. You can't go manufacture ASICs for another proof of work. There just isn't enough time to organize all of this. And then the attacker, he simply has to do the same thing, but this time with commodity hardware. sufficiently many GPUs and then that's your second shot. The second shot is the real knockout. So it sounds like we really want Bitcoin to be its maximum potential. It would be a much more radical change and it would probably have to be proof of stake. Yes, so that is one option to migrate to proof of stake.
I guess another option, and this is something we discussed in the previous podcast is simply for bitcoin to use the ethereum blockchain as its base layer for security which is using proof of stake in a different yes okay so justin i just just one point on this right because there is this we don't have to get into the to the concept of um strong like weak subjectivity right but one thing that bitcoiners will point out is that hey the great thing about bitcoin is that the the the token the staking token which is a6 plus energy of the bitcoin network is external to the system right so we can always restart it we just have to funnel more energy into it and more like like a hashing algorithm they see this as a virtue rather than a a flaw in the engine design.
Do you think there is a virtue here in having the economic token that powers the Bitcoin system be sort of external, be ASIC plus energy consumption? Is there any merit? Is there a trade-off here that we want to highlight? Yes, so as is almost always the case in engineering, there are trade-offs. There's things that you improve on there's things that you have to give up. Now we haven't gone through the whole list of advantages of proof of state but let's jump ahead and look at the trade-offs. From what I can tell there's three different trade-offs. One of them as you said is this notion of objectivity versus weak subjectivity.
Another one is the concept of complexity of your engine. And the other one is this the distributive nature of Bitcoin. So I guess we could go through these trade-offs one by one. The first one which is the easiest to understand is the engine complexity. So the Bitcoin proof of work is extremely simple. It's so beautifully simple. You could write pseudocode for it in like 10 lines of code. And that's an amazing property to have, you know, simplicity. Unfortunately, you know, Ethereum is two orders of magnitude more complex than proof of work. So, you know, you could write the state transition function for the beacon chain in a thousand lines of code.
So, you know, that's roughly a hundred times more complexity if you if you measure complexity in terms of lines of code, than Bitcoin. You know, that's a real trade-off. The good news is that, I guess, we've already paid the complexity cost, right? We've proved that it is possible to overcome this complexity. We have four different production-grade implementations, you know, securing the beacon chain right now. And this complexity is manageable. And this is found in other places in engineering. I mean, a computer is, what, a hundred times more complicated than a calculator let's say right it's you know it's not necessarily a bad thing right that's a great point yeah there's astounding amounts of complexity you know in your iphone um you know millions of man hours have gone into designing iphones um yeah for sure um i guess it's just a necessary evil um to to to innovation another aspect is um kind of the fuel emissions.
So it turns out that there is one advantage of proof of work in terms of the fuel emissions, the engine emissions, is that it's a forcing function for miners to sell their Bitcoin. And this has a, it's a distributive kind of forcing function. So this is great for distribution. And it's a property that the proof of stake doesn't have in the sense that if you're to become a staker, you need to have ETH to start with, and then the ETH stays with you. You kind of accrue ETH, but you're not forced to sell it. And the reason you're not forced to sell it is because proof of stake is so efficient that you don't have to sell it to pay your bills, your electricity bills and whatnot.
So Justin, I've heard one manifestation of this as a Bitcoin maximalists or Bitcoiners to have you proof of work will say proof of stake just installs a permanent plutocracy would be a way that that's been described. Right. I mean, the way that I see it is that we kind of get the best of both worlds with proof of work and proof of stake in terms of distribution. So we've had the five years, probably six years of proof of work. We've have plenty of distribution. And then, you know, this hybrid approach where after the distribution phase, we move away from the distribution phase then. Yeah, so that's the second trade-off is the distributive aspect.
And then the final point, which is the objectivity point, and I put it at the end because it's a subtle point. So, okay, what is this objectivity all about? And if we were to take the engine metaphor, I think of it in terms of jumpstartability. OK, right. So the way that it works is that you have this master engine, right, which is meant to be replicated all around the world. And when you sync up to the blockchain, you kind of want to have your local copy of the engine and you want to get to the same state as kind of the master state. So in a way, you kind of want your local copy to be jumpstarted by the main engine.
Now, it turns out that for Bitcoin, the length of the jump lead, the cable is infinite. You can go all the way from Genesis. So basically, you could sync from Genesis and you'd still be able to sync to this master engine, even though you started from Genesis. In Ethereum, you have a constraint on the length of the jump-starting lead, these cables that you need to connect between the two engines. It's limited to three months. So if you've been disconnected for more than three months, then you won't be able, in a purely objective way, to sync up to the engine. What you're going to have to do is you're going to have to ask a friend or ask a group of semi-trusted sources you know what is this what is the state of things and and then take that as a as an extra assumption that you have and so bitcoiners hate this because this is compromising with trust right um and and i would say that ethereans are more okay with this because it's in our opinion it's more pragmatic like i could probably find someone i trust who's got the state of ethereum where where Bitcoiners are like, you always, always, always, always need to be verifiably going back to Genesis.
And Ethereans are like, well, you can just go find someone who like that you can trust and download the state from them. And this is the kind of the trade-offs that we've made. Yeah, and it turns out that if you look at the practice as opposed to the theory, they're essentially equivalent. And why are they equivalent? The reason is that as a Bitcoiner, you do have some hidden sources of trust Now, for example, one source of trust is when you go download the client, you're not going to read every single line of code. You're trusting Bitcoin.org or Bitcoin.com, whichever website you've downloaded the client from.
And you're also trusting what I call the seed nodes. right so the very first time you connect to the network to the peer-to-peer network you're gonna connect to so-called bootstrap nodes or seed nodes they're gonna allow you to connect to the broader system but if for some reason your seed nodes are compromised then you're going to be in a little you know fake universe that could be controlled by the attacker so there's there's various uh hidden trust assumptions in bitcoin which means that in practice we have weak subjectivity anyway so it's on an equal footing in the from a practical standpoint all right justin i want to return that was we we just went on a little bit of a detour talking about how these how these engines work i want to return back to the metaphor of a truck pulling a load up a hill right and the The truck is the engine, the load is the economy, the fuel is the money that we put into this engine, and there's different types of fuels.
Can you walk us through that metaphor? Yes. So as I mentioned, there's two types of fuels. There's fuel A, which I'll call grade A, because it's the best of the best in terms of for security, is issuance. So basically it's energy that's drawn from the battery. And why is it grade A fuel? grade A fuel because it's predictable, it's low volatility and you can set it to have a guaranteed minimum for security. And then there's this grade B fuel which is not so great, unrefined fuel if you will, which are the transaction fees. And this is energy that you receive from your solar panel. And the energy that you receive from the solar panel, the transaction fees, are unpredictable, highly volatile, possibly slash likely insufficient for security.
And even worse, the transaction fees have the subtle property that they're stealable, in the sense that if you have and decide, we briefly talked about it in the last podcast, but if you have a block with transactions, and these transactions will pay transaction fees. And the next miner is incentivized to steal those transactions and the associated fees as opposed to building on top of the block. So that leads to chain instability because these fees can be stolen. This is miner extractable value, which bankless listeners may be already familiar with. Exactly, yes. And there was this episode, I think, with the Binance chain when for example they they got hacked and you know there was like rumors that maybe you know binance would you know reveal the private keys associated to the hack and then you know there's an incentive for miners to basically rewind the hack and then give themselves the money um and you know basically stealing the fee um anyway hang on no i don't want to go into that so there was an episode where binance binance was hacked for like 3 000 bitcoins or something and there was it was like 15 million dollars my numbers might be off and there was a big conversation about how cz could public publicize the private keys to uh to the bitcoin address and that would instigate a minor competition to start building a new longest chain on the at the block of the moment that the bitcoins were stolen because the miners could go and and go and reclaim those stolen btc right so the the conversation and if there was 15 million dollars stolen and it would there was a three-day window for this to be an economically viable activity to do because at the end of three days it was going to cost more than 15 million dollars to go back three days and so there's a three-day window where there was this possible time where cz could publish the bitcoin private keys and then all of a sudden the game theory is on where the bitcoin miners are all in competition to go back to claim this block for themselves and take those btcs for the miners instead of the attackers right and this is a this is where the conversation about good feel and bad feel comes from where uh fees or or minor extractable values are in a highly volatile and not dependable versus issuance and if you don't have issuance that dwarfs fees then your then your engine can be unstable exactly and actually you you're right so grade b you know i said transaction fees but it's actually more general than that it's as you said it's mev and you can it's actually different types of of grades of b like b plus and b minus and like you can say b plus is you know the transaction fees you know they're not so volatile but then you have the extr the extreme what i call spike volatility so every once in a while you have this huge spike which would be the binance case you know you just have 3000 bitcoin or whatever it was kind of as one big spike and that would be the b minus uh type of fuel uh which is the most explosive and most most dangerous type of of fuel and so you know one of the the questions you want to ask yourself as a designer economic designer for these blockchains is what kind of fuel do you want to put in your engine And, you know, obviously, well, it's obvious in hindsight, but I guess it wasn't obvious for Satoshi is you want to maximize the use of grade A fuel, right?
And you want to minimize the use of grade B fuel for security. And so what we're doing in Ethereum is we're connecting the battery directly to, well, we're connecting the engine directly to the battery. So that gives us this nice grade A fuel. And then we have MEV minimization techniques, the main one being EIP-1559, where we take this grade B fuel and we destroy it. We just don't want it to touch the engine. It's actually a liability to have the grade B fuel. And then Bitcoin has taken the exact opposite approach, which is we're going to over time, we're going to exponentially decrease the amount of grade A fuel that we're giving to our engine.
The issuance is going to zero. All the good stuff is going away for security. And we're just going to hope that this grade B fuel is going to be good enough to power the engine. Justin, that's always been crazy to me because arguably actually right now, Ryan, you muted yourself on. Okay, sorry. Do you want to start over? Yeah. Actually, Justin, that's very curious to me too, because arguably right now, Bitcoin has better grade A fuel than Ethereum has because it has a stronger monetary premium. It has a stronger narrative meme value, right? So its grade A fuel is worth more on a percentage basis than Ether's grade A fuel.
And yet, Bitcoin is the network with this wonderful premium grade A fuel that is forsaking that and going to this far lower, poorer quality grade B fuel. And I love that analogy you're talking about. It's like solar panels, right? It's like solar panels on a cloudy day, just like they don't work very well, right? And this is like solar panels on steroids. This is as if when you have an episode like the Binance one you're describing, as if someday the sun is magically 100 times stronger and really gives you a ton of energy, right? So it's like solar panels on steroids. But only for five seconds.
Yeah, for five seconds. Exactly. Wow. So that's always been curious to me and not something that I think most Bitcoiners internally rationalize, maybe, that they're swapping out fuel for their economic engine midstream and what the hazards of that might be. Yeah. I mean, my mental analogy is imagine an electric car. Remove the battery. Who needs a battery to power the engine? Just put a solar panel. And then, you know, you drive through a tunnel and then the car just stalls. Or maybe, as you said, it's cloudy and you can only do 10 miles an hour. And this is something that has been predicted academically for Bitcoin.
So, for example, there's this paper that looks at the instability of the blockchain once you rely on transaction fees. One of the observations that they make is we have a dip in transaction fees, for example, during the weekend. right so it what will happen is that during the weekend some miners would just not be profitable so they turn off their miners and then the block times you know become you know 20 minutes 30 minutes one hour block times and then you know doing doing peak hours i guess it would it would compensate you know with you know five minute block times or three minute block times um it would get really really funky very quickly i want to take these metaphors all the way to the very end and so we have we have two vehicles two engines towing two different loads right um and bitcoin does have a battery but it has a battery that it can't recharge because it only issues btc right it doesn't there is no long time issuance and so once this 21 million btc is completely issued the bitcoin battery is completely drained and it never gets recharged and so the solar panel for the bitcoin uh vehicle gets plugged right into the engine right and the bitcoin engine is completely subject to the whims of the bitcoin economy is bitcoin generating high fees today or is it generating low fees today and imagine like a truck going up a hill towing a load and it doesn't really know how much energy it's going to be able to receive like in a moment's notice like in the next mile and the next mile after that it just runs on transaction fees and And if the transaction fees go into the engine, then the engine can push it forward according to how much transaction fees there are.
But it doesn't have that sustainability, that assurances that it's going to be able to get up that hill because transaction fees are volatile. Also, if one block comes in with like 10 times as much transaction fees as the next block, it can't actually imagine just like stomping on the gas pedal and then immediately releasing it. Like that's not how you get an engine to go up a hill. Like that's not sustainable. And so what Ethereum has done with putting this solar panel into the battery into the engine is it allows that volatility in transaction fees to get filtered through the battery first and stored in the battery.
And then the battery trickles the energy at a sustainable rate, at a dependable rate that we can count on within long-term assurances into the future. And it's that battery that depresses and dampens the volatility in transaction fees and allows that Ethereum, the proof of stake engine of Ethereum, to consistently climb that economic hill with its load. How is that metaphor? Yeah, absolutely. The economic battery is a dampener of the energy. I mean, one of the things you said, just a slight correction, at the very beginning, you said that when there's no more issuance, the battery is fully depleted.
It's not that it's fully depleted, it's that you can't discharge it anymore. So it's kind of the opposite in the sense that it becomes the perfect battery in isolation. In a vacuum, it would be kind of an ideal store value mechanism because there wouldn't be this leak in terms of issuance. but the problem is that you can't consider this battery in isolation you have to consider the whole system you know one thing that that strikes me justin is that people forget satoshi was an engine designer it it's almost become like this narrative that suddenly like in the beginning there was bitcoin and it was perfect at the at the very outset and the engine was perfect and it was bestowed upon humanity, right?
And then Satoshi disappeared because it was finished, right? But the reality is Satoshi was a crypto economic engine designer. And this was his first kind of iteration of the engine. Model T. It's kind of a Model T. In all of the, I guess, religious warfare and tribalism, Justin, I think people forget that this is a human being designing an engine. This is not gold. that is an asset bestowed to humanity via nature. This is an engine design. Absolutely, right. So this is economic engineering. And, you know, the progress of engineering, generally speaking, is exponential. And, you know, 12 years is a lifetime, especially in the blockchain world.
And as you said, this was the very first design. And, you know, it was heavily inspired by gold. and we had this skeuomorphic idea. And I think Satoshi used gold because that was the best the physical world could provide. But once you enter this new paradigm of digital money, then suddenly the design space increases dramatically. And things happen that are totally unexpected. Like to give you another analogy of skeuomorphism in the DeFi world is decentralized exchanges that will use an order book. right the way that we have exchanges is with all the books so the way that you you do it on the blockchain is you try and try and build an order book on the blockchain turns out that's the utter failure that doesn't work for for the various reasons um well and then out out of nowhere comes this new concept of amms um and this you know this innovation is is part of the this new design space that's been opened up um and once you detach yourself from your your preconceptions in the way of the past then you can really open yourself to the the world of possibilities that this new space offers so justin we are actually just getting started with the comparisons here because there's so much more to talk about and i think something that might blow people's minds is that Ethereum doesn't have just one engine.
It has multiple engines and it can start up even more engines or power down engines. Can we talk about how Ethereum has multiple engines? Yeah, so this is implementation diversity. So it turns out that sometimes engines have bugs. So, and this happens to all blockchains. It happened to Bitcoin. Bitcoin has had various bugs. Ethereum has various bugs and one way to hedge against these bugs to protect yourself is to have multiple implementations. And so, you know, you can think of it as a helicopter, right? Do you want a dual engine helicopter or do you want a single engine helicopter, right? I would want to fly on a dual engine helicopter if possible, just in case the first engine has some sort of problem.
And in Ethereum, we have a four-way redundancy. We have these four separate implementations, four different languages, four different teams in different parts of the world, which is in stark contrast to basically the monopoly that Bitcoin Core has in Bitcoin. And this is not only about bugs, but this is also about all sorts of external pressures, like bribing, for example. One possible attack scenario for the US government is to give every Bitcoin core developer $100 million and to insert malicious code. It would be a possible kind of attack there. Whereas in Ethereum, we have more diversity and more robustness there.
And we've actually already experienced this in Ethereum where one of our engines went down and thankfully we had a secondary engine to keep Ethereum up and running. Can you talk about that scenario? Yeah, absolutely. So in the earlier days of Ethereum, Ethereum, there was a bug in Github and Github just became unusable. I think it was some sort of denial of service attack. And had it not been for parity, had it not been for this backup engine, the Ethereum network would have suffered a very extended downtime because it took a long time to fix the root issue, several days. And that would have shattered the confidence in Ethereum in these very early days.
So yay diversity. I guess one kind of point here is that the way that we've gone ahead with the EVE2 protocol is that we've designed a specification. So this is kind of meant to be the root of trust in terms of what the design is. And it's meant to be maximally simple and readable and understandable. And we've even gone as far as making the implementation executable so the specifications are is itself code. And so that makes it easy for implementers to coordinate around this protocol. In Bitcoin, the way that it has evolved historically is that you have Bitcoin Core that came out and it had various bugs and there was no specification.
So the only way that you could write an alternative implementation is, number one, you reverse engineer how this whole thing works. And number two, you need to be bug for bug compatible, right? Because if you're not bug for bug compatible, that's the possibility for a consensus failure. And this friction of not having a specification and having to adhere to every single bug that is in Bitcoin, and there's quite a few, you know, subtleties, has meant that we haven't really seen an alternative to Bitcoin, Coin, Bitcoin. And we've actually also similarly how Ethereum had its bugs that it experienced and then thankfully had a second client or now in proof of stake for clients.
Bitcoin has also experienced a fault in the Bitcoin code, a breaking of the engine, except it repaired that engine. Thankfully, this happened very early in Bitcoin's history. I think in 2011 and maybe another one in 2013, my Bitcoin history isn't super sharp. Can you tell us what happened there? Yeah, I think it was before my time in Bitcoin. There was an overflow bug, you know, classic bug where, you know, you're storing a balance in some number of bits, like 64 bits or whatever. And there's an overflow. And then you kind of wrap around. And what that means is that, you know, someone was able to craft a transaction, which is essentially minted, you know, a huge amount of Bitcoin out of nowhere, like billions or trillions of Bitcoin, because they exploited that overflow.
How did this system get past this problem? Yeah, so, you know, it caused chaos for a few hours. I don't know exactly how many hours, but it was on the order of 12 hours or 24 hours. So the Bitcoin core developers were very fast and the mining ecosystem had a rapid incident response. But they could have been a more subtle bug or there could have been many bugs that are triggered at the same time by an attacker. or even 12 hours of downtime is kind of unacceptable. And beyond the downtime, there's another issue, which is that now you have potentially two forks which are legitimate, right? And there's this mantra in Bitcoin that after six confirmations, you have finality.
And so you're happy. But this is a way to basically bypass finality, whereby as an attacker, let's say, you do a $1 billion transaction, six blocks go through, your counterparty gives you $1 worth of assets, and then you trigger this attack, and then you can revert the six blocks of finality. So yeah, it is scary. And that's one of the reasons why we want distribution. I guess another aspect here is that in Ethereum, the way that we achieve finality is for two thirds of the network to come to consensus on state. And so the ideal situation is where the stake, the ETH stake is equally distributed across the clients.
So for example, 25%, 25% across all four clients. So if there is a bug in one of the clients, then that's insufficient to reach the two-thirds required to finalize a faulty state. On that note, kind of a quick PSA, it turns out that in practice, Prism has more than 50% of the nodes. So if you're running Prism, please consider no longer running Prism, I guess. This is nothing against Prism per se, but it's just too popular. And it would be good if other clients were more popular. One aspect I'd like to talk about this about is, I'm going to start that over. One aspect I'd like to talk about with regards to all the client diversity in Ethereum is there is more choice and more options for people to use.
And my optimistic scenario is that all these clients will compete, right? When you stake your Ether to Ethereum, you need to choose a client and those clients want to be chosen. And so they are competing to receive Ether to put their power into Ethereum, right? Because power goes into the Ethereum economy via clients and clients attract Ether to be staked via their clients so that they can power the system. Do you see these clients like a competition is supposed to be good for the consumer, right? So do you see this competition aspect being healthy for Ethereum? Or do you perhaps seeing a convergence on maybe just one or two clients in the long term because of, you know, monolithic tendencies?
How do you see this playing out? Right. So one of the advantages of competition or actually of diversity is that each client can try and cater for a different niche. so for example nimbus which is one of the clients they cater for very low powered devices you know think mobile phones or raspberry pi's and you know they can be the best at doing that and then you know you could have teku for example which is um geared towards like in um you know in industrial grade um you know staking um and then you could have um maybe lighthouse which is geared towards the individual staker, for example. I'm hoping that they'll be able to find their niches and that they will get distribution that way.
What you mentioned about competition is correct though. So if, for example, there's one client which is able to aggregate attestations and include them on chain much, much better than the other clients, then when you're running this client as a validator you're going to receive more rewards so there's an economic incentive for you to use that one client the good news is that um you know the clients awful clients are close to optimal in terms of um you know doing their duties and so they're all optimally receiving the rewards and we want to keep it that way all right guys so we are almost done talking about the design of the ethereum engine and the ethereum vehicle and of course when we stitch all of these things together we get something that's greater than the sum of the parts but we have two very quick parts that we want to run through first and that is the first being stealth and our our truck that is pulling up a load up a hill also needs to be stealthy because these systems these vehicles are supposed to be sovereign state level resistance and so stealth is a fantastic feature for vehicles to have that state level resistance think of think of the f uh 111 or 117 like nighthawk this is the first ever stealth fighter or all the investments that the us military has made into stealth vehicles we want our economy our vehicle our engine to also be stealthy um so so justin how is the ethereum system how is the ethereum vehicle a stealth vehicle right um i I guess that comes down to the physical footprint, right?
So to become an Ethereum validator, all you need really is ether, which is purely in the digital world. There's no physical footprint for that. And then you need a Raspberry Pi and an internet connection. And all the computational resources are very limited. You need very little power, very low computation, very little bandwidth, et cetera, et cetera. Now this is in stark contrast to Bitcoin, whereby if you wanna be a miner, you're gonna be in a very, very specific place. You're gonna be where electricity is cheap and you're gonna be consuming huge amounts of electricity, which means that you're gonna be, you know, expanding a large amount of heat and you're gonna need huge warehouses where you're gonna be housing these mining rigs and you're most likely gonna be found in cold places like Iceland.
And so this physical footprint means that you're not at all stealthy, right? Like the government can just show up at your door, you know, in Iceland or wherever, in China next to a dam where you have very cheap electricity and just confiscate your miners or do things like that. Whereas with Ethereum, you could just, you know, be anywhere in the world, you know, you could be behind the toll network for anonymity. So you don't even leak your IP address. and you can just do it on the Raspberry Pi. And I guess if you look at the fight against marijuana, so if you're farming this stuff, you're going to be expending a lot of energy and you're going to be detectable by governments.
Governments will analyze the electric grid to try and find these marijuana farmers. And you can also see them from space. You can see them from satellite imagery. And notably, you can also see bit mains mining facilities in China from space, right? And so if we're talking about nation state level resistance, like if you can see them from space, you can send a missile there. Perhaps that's a crazy example, but it's within the realm of possibility. Absolutely. Yeah. You can't send a missile to an Ethereum staker for which you don't even know the IP address. Right. And even if you did know where the physical location of that little Raspberry Pi was or the validating node, that's not where the ether is.
That's not where the security is. The security doesn't actually exist in the physical world. Absolutely. Yeah. So this is one of these advantages where it's hard to quantify. It's hard to say this is 10 times better or 100 times better. It's just, you know, infinity times better. Well, actually, maybe you could try and quantify it. So if you look, for example, at energy expenditure. expenditure, right? So you have, you know, 1.5 million mining rigs, each rig, one kilowatt. And then in comparison, you have, let's say, 10,000 nodes, each node consume, let's say, 100 watts. So that's like a thousand to one, right?
So that's three orders of magnitude, more stealthiness just in terms of the power consumption of the Ethereum proof of stake network relative to the Bitcoin proof of work network. All right, Justin, so we have our efficient vehicle pulling the load up the hill, but engines and systems can break down over time. Let's lead into this conversation. How can we make sure to have our engine not break down over time And what can we do about this? Right. So I guess you will want to try and look at engine degradation. Like how does the engine evolve over time as you use it? Now, this is an aspect where Bitcoin kind of the Bitcoin engine degrades extremely fast.
So roughly, you know, every year, one third of the mining hardware becomes obsolete. And so you have to remove it. So basically, the hash rate has this lifetime associated with it, and then it needs to be removed. And so as you're running this engine, the more you run it, in a way, the more it's fighting itself and degrading. On Ethereum, it's the exact opposite, which is amazing. It's negative degradation. The engine becomes stronger the more it is used, which is pretty amazing. And one reason is because of the issuance. So the issuance in proof of stake goes to the stakers, and the stakers are naturally in the disposition to stake more.
And so the ratio of the staking power versus the non-staking ETH grows over time because of this issuance. This is one of the advantages of not being distributive, is that those who are ready to secure the ETH network will grow power over time. I guess another aspect is the transaction fees. The transaction fees are burnt and transaction fees come from non-staking ETH. So that, again, kind of increases the ratio towards the stakers. And then the final thing is tip. The tip is the part of the transaction fee which is not burnt. And that's even more obvious. The tip directly goes from non-staking ETH users to the stakers who are the validators and collect these non-burnt transaction fees.
This has always been, to me, the most elegant part about proof of stake, because what proof of stake does is that it rewards foolishness. It rewards the people who make proof of stake work, right? So the people that make proof of stake work are the people that believe in the asset, that stake the asset. And then proof of stake rewards those people in the asset that they stake. And because we have shed the inefficiencies, the leakage of an engine that must take in transaction fees, and because we've shed the inefficiencies of a proof of work engine, which must inherently sell the native asset into the market to pay for the upgrade costs of both the electricity and the energy, and the engine.
Instead, we have just rewarded the people with the more of the asset that they already believe in, right? Proof of stake rewards bullishness. And what you were saying is like, we talked about the trade-offs behind distribution. Proof of stake is not a distribution mechanism. It's a security mechanism. And it puts more and more ETH into the hands of the people that are willing to offer security to Ethereum. And so there's always this slight tilt in favor of the people that are going to provide security to Ethereum. And so anytime that any transaction is made on Ethereum, it always a little bit ends up in the hands of the people that are most incentivized and most willing to protect the network.
And that, to me, is just perfect mechanism design because it aligns incentives behind the Ethereum economy and the people that secure that Ethereum economy, which is ETH stakers. Do you know, David, it's almost the difference between hiring mercenaries for your national security and your army versus like hiring citizens who have a vested interest in the long-term benefit of the nation state that they're protecting. Who live in their own land and have something to lose if they lose, if they mess up. Exactly. Right. And this incentive alignment is not as strong in Bitcoin, right? You don't have to be a Bitcoin holder to be a Bitcoin miner.
And actually we're starting to see this misalignment in the context of proof of work for EIP-1559, right? We have miners saying, we don't want this. And we might do a show of force and we might even forcefully fork things and attack the system. If it turned out that the miners were ETH holders, it's likely that they would have come to a different conclusion there. All right. Miners believe in Silicon, yet stakers believe in the asset, right? And so miners want to maximize their chips and stakers want to maximize the asset. And it's over at the end of the day, it's the value of the asset that powers the engine, right?
It has nothing to do with the ASIC. To me, it's elegant. So Justin, up to this point, we've talked about the design of the engine and we've contrasted proof of work versus Ethereum proof of stake. We've also talked a lot about the efficiency of the engine, but my sense is there's still more to talk about around economic efficiency of the engine. What else do we need to understand about efficiency? Right. So there's kind of two very key points for the economic efficiency. The first one is around fuel efficiency. How much security do you get per unit of fuel? And here there's a very nice kind of metaphor.
So it turns out that all the inefficiencies of the proof of work engine mean that for every $1 of economic security, you need to spend every year $1 of fuel, you need to feed it $1. So if you think of the economic security as kind of being loaned to the protocol, right, so the miners are loaning their hardware to the protocol, and the protocol receives economic security and has to pay for this economic security. The protocol, in terms of APY for that loan, it needs to pay 100% APY, which is insane. On the other hand, with proof of stake, because you're dealing with pure money, it turns out that the APY is going to match the cost of money.
And what's the cost of money? that's you know three percent four percent five percent really a paradigm shift in terms of economic efficiency where instead of paying the principal you know every year if you have five billion dollars of security every year you need to spend five billion dollars to secure it because of the the electricity that you need to spend but also because of the hardware obsolescence On the other hand, with proof of stake, the protocol only needs to pay for the cost of money, which is, let's say it's 5%, and that's 20x more efficient than proof of work. And this goes back to the conversation about money, right?
And if the Bitcoin network needs to have all of this expenditure, to meet its own expenditure requirements every single year, what that does is battery leakage. That's energy leakage out of the unit of a Bitcoin unit. because all the miners that depend on btc for revenue must sell btc to pay for bitcoin security and so they they sell btc to pay for electricity they sell btc to pay for new hardware and that is how the bitcoin network maintains itself in contrast in proof of stake stakers don't have to sell anything because staking it has been designed to be maximally efficient all you need is a raspberry pi and an internet connection and so that raspberry pi consumes some electricity maybe 50 a year that internet connection costs something but it's nothing to nothing in comparison to turnover of asic chips and nothing compared to energy consumption and and so what we're saying is the cost of bitcoin security costs 5 billion and it costs 5 billion every single year but with proof of stake it's just the opportunity cost of capital and that goes back to what we were talking about about state proof of stake inherently rewarding people who are bullish ether the opportunity cost of capital for them for people who are bullish ether is nothing because there's no other asset in the world that they want more than the asset that they are staking and so in theory the opportunity cost of capital is almost nothing for them and so almost nothing is the cost of proof of stake if we are incentivizing bullishness on ether which is what proof of stake tends to do absolutely yeah you said it very well so let's talk about the uh the second piece here justin of economic efficiency that you hinted at what is that second piece right so the second piece is eip 1559 and the idea here is that if we have excess energy in the system, let's not waste it on fuel that is not going to be useful for security, right?
There's no point in overpaying for security. And instead, we're just going to take the energy and charge the battery. We have a system whereby the amount of fuel that we're giving is always the right amount. We're not underpaying for security and jeopardizing security, and we're not overpaying and jeopardizing efficiency. And one of the amazing things is that when you burn, you open up the possibility of actually reducing the total supply. So the Bitcoiners will often think of issuance as the root of all evil. But actually, what they really mean is the increase in the supply. But it turns out that if your burn more than compensates for the issuance, you have a reduction in supply.
And it doesn't matter that you have this issuance. The net result is still that your economic battery cells will not leak. It actually is the opposite. it, they might get charged over time as the burn is able to overcompensate for the issuance. When I wrote my article on EIP-1559, I think back in 2019, the way that I described EIP-1559 is that the Ethereum protocol is issuing a stock buyback every time a transaction is made. That burning is ethereum the protocol buying back its own ether and this is ethereum the protocol being a persistent buying pressure on ether and going back to the very beginning of this podcast we talked about the way that you charge a monetary unit is by buying it and bitcoin is is a charged monetary unit because everyone is buying it right now but if ethereum the protocol is the net buyer is a persistent net buyer of all ether that tracks the gdp of the ethereum economy and so there's the buyer of last result the buyer of last resort every yeah it's there's always a buyer for ether and it's ethereum the protocol under an eip 1559 paradigm and so every anytime there's excess energy anytime the sun is so incredibly bright that the solar panel is picking up that energy and it's too much to use right now because we don't need it.
The truck is already moving up the hill, towing its load at a steady clock of 60 miles an hour. We don't want to go any faster. We don't want to go any slower. So let's capture that energy and put it into the battery, put it back into the system. And that system is Ether the asset. Absolutely, yeah. And if you look at the net difference between what we're expending today in transaction fees and which goes towards basically buying GPUs and paying for the electricity bills, it's on the order of 10,000 ETH per day. And once we start burning that, the net difference is going to be twice that. We're going to go from plus 10,000 to minus 10,000.
So that's kind of a net, you know, 20,000. And when you look at current prices and you also take into account the efficiency gains from removing proof of work after the merge, we're looking at, you know, $13 billion per year, roughly, of buy pressure relative to what we have today. So just to put that into perspective, it's greater than burning all the ETH locked in DeFi every single year. It's also the equivalent of buying all the ETH in the deposit contract and Grayscale combined every single year. So it's a kind of a tsunami of, it's a huge shock wave in terms of the delta between what we have today, which is a huge amount of cell pressure relative to what we'll have in the future, which is a bi-pressure.
Now, the reason why I'm relatively confident that we're actually going to have a net buy pressure is because you can just look at the transactions today. It turns out that if you annualize over 365 days, if you take a moving average where we have 6,000 Ether per day in transaction fees. So you can make an assumption that some fraction of that is going to get burnt, let's say 70%. And when you compare that to the issuance, that's actually more than twice what you need in order to negate the issuance. So yeah, I'm relatively confident that in the future, we will enter this ultrasound state where the total amount of ETH in circulation will go down over time.
So let's talk about that, all right, because this is almost the climax of the entire episode. You mentioned this term, ultrasound money. Of course, Bitcoin has famously called itself sound money. But what you're referring to with ultrasound money is something even the next level above Bitcoin, something that has maybe negative issuance per year. I want to go to something that just is underappreciated in Ethereum. And I just want to make this statement, and then we'll talk about ultrasound money. And that's this. I think ETH, the asset, is the single most unappreciated thing in the Ethereum ecosystem.
Like everything that you're talking about, people forget that Ether is a cryptocurrency. They're very excited about Ethereum, the network. And you'll get people who say things like, I'm bullish Ethereum, the network, but I'm not bullish on ETH. That, from everything you've described, makes absolutely no sense whatsoever. Because how can you be bullish on Ethereum, the economy, or Ethereum, the network, and not also be bullish on Ether, the asset, when we're talking about these types of burn mechanisms, when we're talking about these types of staking lock-up mechanisms? So let's round this out.
Let's talk about this, Justin. When you say ultrasound money, this whole thing, this whole engine has produced, at the end of the day, economic scarcity. What are we talking about here? What is ultrasound money? Right. So, you know, the way that this meme came about was really a joke. It was a play on words. The idea was that if Bitcoin is sound money and it has cap supply, then if you have a decreasing supply, you must be ultrasound, right? And, you know, you can use the bat emoji to kind of represent the ultrasounds that come from bats. But, you know, it turns out that this meme is much, much, much deeper.
Right. So one of the aspects that we've talked about at length is that economic security on Ethereum is much, much higher than Bitcoin. And that contributes to this ultrasound-ness. And that contributes, for example, towards Ethereum becoming the selling point for a global world internet currency. I guess the other aspect is that Ethereum, once we have EIP-1559, is an income generating asset. So you can think of it in terms of profit and P-E ratios. So if we say that we have roughly 100 million ether and we're burning a million ether every year, well, that's kind of a P-E ratio of 100. So Ethereum is in this really advantageous position where it can do multiple things at the same time.
On the one hand, it can act like a stock, you know, with a PE ratio of, let's say, 100. And it can also act as kind of a store of value with this magic meme energy stored within it. And, you know, these things are complementary, right? So the fact that we now have money that behaves like a stock with a PE ratio makes it more amenable to become a store of value because it makes the selling points even more potent. I want to rehash what you said a minute ago because I want to make sure that it lands with the listeners. Once we integrate all of the research and development that has gone on from the Ethereum researchers about crypto economic system design.
Once we improve our engine from proof of work to proof of stake, it's much more efficient. We don't need to put as much fuel into it, which means we don't need to. We need to. We need to sell less ETH to achieve the same result, which is keeping the ETH battery charged. So we go from having to issue two ETH per block to much, much less than that, 0.1 ETH per block. We bring the issuance down. And so therefore, Ether becomes much harder. Then we add an EIP-1559, which captures so much of the energy of the Ethereum economy and turns that into net buying pressure of Ether, the asset, by Ethereum.
And as a result of all of these efficiencies that we've talked about, we get to have as an Ethereum ecosystem, a net buyer of Ether that is equivalent to the amount of Ether that is in Grayscale and the deposit contract combined every single year, reoccurring a new one of those every single year. And an additional metaphor is all of the ETH locked in DeFi that we like obsess over on DeFi pulse, the I don't know what number of millions of ETH is locked in DeFi. It's $42 billion. We get that net buying pressure every single year. It's recyclable. That buying pressure is recyclable. And so this happens every single year after year after year.
And this is where the sustainability of both Ether, the asset, and Ethereum, the economy, comes from. It's because we have created ultrasound money because we have designed the system in the best possible way. And this is why Ryan is so upset that people don't understand this. It's because it's the most underappreciated asset of all time. It's absolutely crazy. I mean, there are some questions, though. Like, is this fee burn really sustainable? And this is a valid question to ask ourselves. So, for example, what if the price of ETH increases? Does it mean that because people are denominating their transaction fees in US dollar, does it mean that the total amount of ETH that is going to be burnt is going to reduce as the price of ETH increases?
Well, it turns out that that's not the case. So you can look at it from an empirical evidence standpoint. So from Genesis to now, the price of ETH has grown a thousand X, actually two thousand X, from one dollar to two thousand dollars. And over that time, the amount of transaction fees has gone nothing but up. And so you can ask yourself, what is the possible explanation for the fact that the total amount of ETH in transaction fees goes up despite the price of ETH going up? going up. And one possible explanation is that as the price of ETH increases, that's highly correlated with user demand, right?
The price of ETH increases, you have lots of fresh blood coming in, new users. And so that puts more pressure on the fee market and that compensates for the fact that the price of ETH has been increasing. I guess another possible explanation is that ETH is used as economic bandwidth in this economy. And so as the price of ETH increases, you have more economic bandwidth and suddenly you have more opportunities. You have increased economic density, meaning that every single transaction will carry more value. And you maybe have more opportunities in terms of arbitrage, because there's just more money flush slushing around because you have more bandwidth and i guess maybe another possible explanation is that you you simply have a richer user base right and so the the price sensitivity to transaction fees decreases um and maybe like a final kind of possible explanation for this empirical behavior is that if is a what i call i guess a unit of trading right so um this is a a pretty amazing statistic, which is that if you look at the Uniswap volume right now, we're doing a billion dollars of volume on Uniswap.
It turns out that 95% of that volume is in ETH pairs. What I mean by an ETH pair, I mean that there's two ERC20 tokens, one of which is the wrapped ETH. So out of the billion dollars of transaction volume, 950 is basically with ETH. And so if you look at arbitrage opportunities, they're gonna be ETH denominated. And so it doesn't matter if the price of ETH increases, because if you have, let's say, a 0.1 ETH arbitrage opportunity and your transaction fee is 0.05 ETH, and it's an invariant, whatever the price of ETH is, you're gonna want to conduct that arbitrage opportunity. And I guess we're starting to see ETH being used as a unit of account and the use of trading beyond just, you know, Uniswap, for example, we're seeing it in NFTs.
And the more ETH is used as a unit of account, the more the amount of transaction fees in ETH that we can burn is gonna be insensitive to price increases. Well said, what we're seeing right before our eyes is Ether as an asset increasing in moneyness in its ability to be a store of value, unit of account, and unit of exchange, which is super exciting. And all of the reasons why this is important, I think we've gone through, right? ETH has to have value and a lot of value, tremendous amount of value in order for it to host the world's open finance economic activity. It needs it in order to secure itself.
It needs it for economic bandwidth, trustless economic bandwidth. One thing I wanna talk about here as we get to a close here, Justin, is sound money culture. So Bitcoin very much has sound money culture. Thou shalt never touch the issuance schedule of Bitcoin. Even if it means the truck can't pull the economic weight up the hill, thou shalt not touch it ever. Because why? Because hard money, that's why. Can we talk about this? Because we opened this up we were talking about shelling points and money is really sort of a social coordination game, if you will. Is sound money, it sounds like it's being baked into the Ethereum protocol, ultrasound money.
Is it also being baked into Ethereum's culture? Because that's important too. Is it? What do you think about Ethereum's culture? Because ultimately, the layer zero, as we've said so often, Justin, is people. It is culture. We are socially enforcing the value and the economic security of these networks. And if we don't have sound money, minimum necessary issuance in the culture of the system, we won't be able to enforce that as securely. How would you rate Ethereum on that? Right. So one of the big counterpoints of Bitcoiners of the ultrasound money thesis is predictability right for them a big aspect of soundness is predictability um and i guess that that makes sense and that's a fair you know counterpoint that basically if you were at ethereum at genesis it would have been unpredictable for you um to foresee the various changes in issuance that we've seen historically so historically we've seen two major changes The first one is the reduction of the block reward from five ETH to three ETH per block.
So that happened in October 2017. And then we had another reduction from three ETH per block to two ETH per block in February 2019. And I guess we know we're in the process of doing another block reduction, like a third policy change where basically removing proof of work and going to proof of stake and that's roughly a 10x improvement so we're going from two ETH per block to roughly 0.2 ETH per block. Now you could you know ask yourself is this isn't this bad you know we've lost predictability and what I'd say to this is that as you say we have layer zero predictability right the community predictably only goes in one single direction which is hardening right so every time we make a a policy um change we're hardening um as opposed to you know the federal reserve which is often in the other direction so you know lynn alden um has this you know famous quote where she says you know the ethereum developers change the um the their issuance policy as often as the Fed.
Well, first of all, that is just not true in terms of a quantitative standpoint, right? In five years or six years, we're looking to make three issuance changes. Whereas, you know, in the similar timeframe, the Fed has made more like 30, so 10 times more. But maybe more importantly, each of these issuance are in the hardening direction, as opposed to the inflation direction. I guess another thing that I'll say is that I think us Ethereans, we want to maximize for long term predictability. And so we've traded off the short term predictability where we have, you know, this initial experimentation and over the long term, we're going to ossify and we're not going to change.
This is kind of a natural thing that happens to blockchain protocols. They ossify over time. And to my knowledge, we don't have any plans to really change the issuance beyond what is being delivered with proof of stake. On the other hand, Bitcoin talks about predictability, but actually it has skeletons in the closet. So it's optimizing for short term predictability. But because it doesn't have sustainability relative to security, it's actually not optimizing for long term predictability. So, you know, who knows what will happen in the future? We know it's unsustainable. You know, in 30 years, something has to change.
We don't know exactly what's going to change. Maybe Bitcoin will move to proof of stake. Maybe Bitcoin will move to the Ethereum network. Maybe they'll remove the 21 million limit. No one knows. But, and this is kind of a source of long term unpredictability, which we hope to not have in Ethereum. Justin, can you talk about hard money as a design goal of Ethereum? And that might sound foreign to a lot of people because that is, again, like Ryan said, it hasn't really been baked into our culture, but I think it has. And it's actually just been unconscious in the culture. It's not in the consciousness of the Ethereum culture, but it's perhaps in the unconsciousness of Ethereum culture.
Can you talk about that? Yeah, I think I would agree that there's been this unconscious desire to have sound money and it's becoming more and more conscious, partly thanks to you guys and others who can work on this narrative layer. I guess within the research team, I guess there is also a shift, more of an awareness that there is a desire from the community. At the end of the day, we try to cater for the community and there is this desire for soundness. And so we're making explicit design decisions towards that. So to give you one example, we want to cap the total number of validators to roughly one million validators.
So that corresponds to 32 million ETH. And that will basically also cap the amount of issuance that the proof of stake system can do. So we kind of estimate that 1 million validators is more than enough security. There's no need to overpay. So we just cap it. And it turns out that when you have 1 million validators, that corresponds roughly to a maximum issuance of 1 million ETH, which is kind of a nice round meme number that in the worst case scenario, we're going to inflate at 1 million ETH per year. But of course, you know, if we're going to burn 2 or 3 or 4 million ETH, the net amount is going to be negative.
And why is capping validators a good thing to do? Why is that justifiable? Right, so that goes back to the efficiency. So EIP-1559 prevents overspending on security and allowing us to charge the battery, while the cap also allows us to not overspend on security by basically capping the amount of energy that we're drawing from the battery. We're not going to be drawing any more than 1 million Ether per year. You know, one thing I often think is when Ethereans talk about sound money, they just use different terms. They talk about security. And of course, security is just one side of the same coin.
When we talk about monetary premium and Ether as an asset, backing the security of the entire network. So Ethereum has always been optimizing for sound money in a way because it's always been optimizing for security. People also, when you were talking about developers and issuance, and we had Lynn Alden on the podcast, she sort of made this argument. I think people overestimate the ability for developers to just like Fed chair a change to issuance inside of the protocol. At the end of the day, the Ethereum network and the layer zero is minimum necessary issuance. And so if anybody, I'm sure you would agree, Justin, on the Ethereum dev side of things or research side of things, tried to put in some sort of issuance change where funds were going to, Ether issuance was going to a separate deposit to be used for who knows what, the community would reject that.
right so at the end of the day this is backed by the same mechanism that bitcoin is backed by which is this which is this layer zero um you know justin maybe we could kind of sum up what this means uh ultrasound money um this is kind of the the sister episode as we as we said in the intro to the bull case for for crypto economics i feel like this episode has been almost the bull case for ether the asset. Sum this up for us. What does this mean? What are some of the takeaways for crypto natives and people who are interested in these technologies? Yeah. So, I mean, I kind of see it as the bull case of Ethereum economics as a whole, and that includes many different aspects.
You know, one is being able to secure the blockchain, right? We have this crypto economic system. The economic part is kind of a necessary evil. It would be great if we could do it purely with cryptography, but we need economics. So let's make sure that the economics is as robust as we can get it. Let's basically engineer the crap out of it. The other aspect is engineering for soundness and for this store of value aspect. So, you know, I mentioned that soundness, one possible definition is the ability to transport over time. Right. So when you have digital money, it's trivial to transport over space.
But you can you can just use the Internet and travel at the speed of the Internet or, you know, at the speed of light. But travel over time is a difficult endeavor. Now, why is travel over time especially relevant for Ethereum? One of the reasons is that DeFi is built on ETH as collateral. If you take, for example, a synthetic like a stablecoin, you're going to use ETH as collateral. And we're going to see tons and tons of synthetics, not just stablecoins, but stocks and whatnot. And so we need, when you have a synthetic, what you're doing is you're putting if as collateral. Now, it would be a crazy idea to put an asset which is not sound as collateral, right?
Because basically what you want the collateralization ratio to improve over time, right? So that you don't get liquidated. So what do you want to be doing in a sound kind of synthetic framework is you want to be putting the hardest money as collateral and then using that as the backing for all your synthetics. Another aspect of soundness, which is critical for Ethereum, is staking. You know, as David said, you know, staking doesn't work unless you have people who are bullish ETH and are happy to hold it over extended periods of time. And so here we kind of have this reflexivity going on, which is that the more people are happy to hold ETH as a store of value, as a long term store of value, we're going to have more validators which is going to lead to more security which is going to lead to more people being comfortable holding ETH as a long-term store of value so we have all these beneficial mechanics you know at play and then ultimately when we try and sum everything up really we have a new paradigm kind of in in economic you know theory I guess you know we've never seen this before.
We've never seen a kind of deflationary sound money. And we were in uncharted territories. And, you know, it's extremely exciting. Because, you know, people also don't completely realize what the the amazing, you know, system that that we're putting out there, partly because right now the beacon chain is this skeleton chain, right, which is only securing itself, it's not really securing anything else. But once everything comes together, which is a process, which will take, you know, about a year or a year and a half. So the rough roadmap is this year in one of the hard forks, I think is the London hard fork, we're going to have EIP-1559 in July.
And then in 2022, we're going to have the so-called merge where we remove the proof of work and have proof of stake. And at that point, from an economic standpoint, we have something extremely exciting, like the next level of economic engineering, ingenuity, I guess. Guys, this year, burn. Next year, merge and reduced issuance. Justin Drake, we want to thank you for joining us on the Bankless podcast and explaining all this to us. It's been a pleasure, sir. Thank you, guys. Wow. What an episode, Bankless Nation. You know what? I think that's going to take some time to digest. One thing, one of my takeaways, and I'm sure is yours, David, too, is Bitcoin, move over.
There's a new store of value on the scene. Wait until this narrative leaks out into mainstream. We are early. This is the frontier, guys. Super exciting stuff here with Justin. Not just sound money, but ultrasound money. Justin, not only the creator of this fantastic episode, but also the creator of the meme that I think will carry Ether into the very end. Ultrasound money with Justin Drake. Justin, thank you for being here and delivering us this information. Thanks again for having me. This has been a canonical episode, some action items for you guys. There's another sister episode to this that we mentioned a few times we will leave that as an action item in the show notes that is the bull case for cryptography uh also we've got to say emphasize this of course none of this was investment advice we don't know what the short-term price of ether is going to do long-term of course we're bullish but who knows crypto is risky defy is risky you could lose what you put in but as usual we are headed west this is the frontier it's not for everyone but thanks so much much for joining us on the Bankless Journey.
We hope you enjoyed the video. If you did, head over to Bankless HQ right now to develop your crypto investing skills and learn how to free yourself from banks and gain your financial independence. We recommend joining our daily newsletter, podcast, and community as a Bankless Premium subscriber to get the most out of your Bankless experience. You'll get access to our market analysis, our alpha leaks, and exclusive of content and even the Bankless token for airdrops, raffles, and unlocks. If you're interested in crypto, the Bankless community is where you want to be. Click the link in the description to become a Bankless premium subscriber today.
Also, don't forget to subscribe to the channel for in-depth interviews with industry leaders, ask me anythings, and weekly roll-ups where we summarize the week in crypto and other fantastic content. Thanks everyone for watching and being on the journey as we build out the Bankless nation.