Peter Pan has been a key member of the Ethereum Ecosystem, and in 2018, he wrote a 4-part series titled "Before Bitcoin," which covers the modern history of cryptography.
We first bring him onto the podcast for an interview, followed by a reading of the full series by David.
------ 🚀 SUBSCRIBE TO NEWSLETTER: https://newsletter.banklesshq.com/ 🎙️ SUBSCRIBE TO PODCAST: http://podcast.banklesshq.com/ 🎖 CLAIM YOUR BADGE: https://newsletter.banklesshq.com/p/-guide-2-using-the-bankless-badge ------ BANKLESS SPONSOR TOOLS:
💰 GEMINI | FIAT & CRYPTO EXCHANGE https://bankless.cc/go-gemini
🦊 METAMASK | DEFI PASSPORT https://bankless.cc/metamask
🦄 UNISWAP | DECENTRALIZED FUNDING http://bankless.cc/uniswap
🔀 BALANCER | EXCHANGE & POOL ASSETS https://bankless.cc/balancer
------ 📣 DHARMA | From Dollars to DeFi in a Tap! https://bankless.cc/dharma ------
Bankless Podcast #61 - Before Bitcoin Guest: Pet3rPan
Pet3rPan is a community-first investor at 1kx and part of the leadership of both MetaCartel Ventures and VentureDAO. His involvement in the crypto space is broad and deep, exemplified by his authoring of the Before Bitcoin series that we dive into in this episode.
He was compelled to write the piece as he entered the crypto space, determined to build a depth of knowledge about the history and underlying technology of distributed ledgers powered by public-key cryptography. Modern cryptography doesn't exist in a vacuum, and there is a vast historical landscape to explore and provide context for the underlying principles that power the internet today and drive the innovation of the internet tomorrow.
The story of today's cryptocurrency did not begin with Satoshi's Bitcoin whitepaper in 2009. It began decades earlier in the 1970s as cryptography was revolutionized by Cypherpunks, who discovered new mechanisms for the secure transfer of information. They pursued these ends through their shared values of privacy, self-sovereignty, freedom of information, etc.
This episode begins with a brief interview with Pet3rPan, followed by a 'David Reads' of all four Before Bitcoin articles.
------ Resources:
pet3rpan on Twitter: https://twitter.com/pet3rpan_?s=20
Before Bitcoin Part 1: https://pet3rpan.medium.com/history-of-things-before-bitcoin-cryptocurrency-part-one-e199f02ca380
Before Bitcoin Part 2: https://pet3rpan.medium.com/history-of-things-before-bitcoin-cryptocurrency-part-two-94c4576005
Before Bitcoin Part 3: https://pet3rpan.medium.com/before-bitcoin-pt-3-90s-cryptowars-e857915fab82
Before Bitcoin Part 4: https://pet3rpan.medium.com/before-bitcoin-pt-4-00s-new-millenium-426d6e3dcb1a
The Digital Culture Revolution: https://newsletter.banklesshq.com/p/the-digital-culture-revolution
------ This Week on Bankless:
🧢 Weekly Action Recap (4/17): https://newsletter.banklesshq.com/p/price-discovery-mode-weekly-recap 🗞️ Weekly Rollup (4/16): https://shows.banklesshq.com/p/-rollup-btc-and-eth-ath-coin-berlin 🏴 Cryptex & Element (4/13): https://shows.banklesshq.com/p/sotn-42-ethereum-devs-building-defi ⚒️ How to Use dYdX (4/13): https://newsletter.banklesshq.com/p/how-to-trade-on-the-dydx-rollup
----- Not financial or tax advice. This channel is strictly educational and is not investment advice or a solicitation to buy or sell any assets or to make any financial decisions. This video is not tax advice. Talk to your accountant. Do your own research.
Disclosure. From time-to-time I may add links in this newsletter to products I use. I may receive commission if you make a purchase through one of these links. Additionally, the Bankless writers hold crypto assets. See our investment disclosures here: https://newsletter.banklesshq.com/p/bankless-disclosures
No summary for this episode yet.
This is how to get started, how to get better, and how to front run the opportunity. I'm Ryan Sean Adams. I'm joined with David Hoffman, and we're here to help you become more bankless. David, we've got an episode we've never done before. Can you describe what listeners are getting into today? Yeah, I recently put out the article all about crypto culture on the bankless newsletter. That was the first article that I ever did a discovery process on, and so I went out to different people who I knew could speak about crypto culture because the theory is crypto culture is awesome and fantastic, and we don't want to export it to the rest of the world.
But when I was talking to my friend Amin Soleimani, he forwarded me off to this before Bitcoin's series from Peter Pan and Peter Pan has been a key member of the Ethereum ecosystem part of Meta Cartel Ventures, and he has he back in 2018 wrote these four series about what he calls before Bitcoin, the history of cryptography, and this is where I think crypto culture really got instantiated in the first place where the early formation of these early cypher punks who came together to fight these math-based battles, math versus the world, or math versus the government, and it has defined a lot of what this industry has come to be, and I immediately just realized how powerfully awesome these series are, these written series are, and so I wanted to get this information out to the world, to as many people as possible, because the story of Bitcoin and Ethereum and all the things that we're doing today on Ethereum, this story really started in the 70s.
It didn't start in 2009 when the first Bitcoin block was mined, and it didn't start in 2015 when Ethereum was launched, it started in 1970 when some of these early cypher punks shook hands for the first time and decided to build something together. Guys, this is really important listening for you today. If you're in the bankless program, you know that everything in crypto is an intersection between all of these various fields. We've done episodes on the history of money before, and that's important for you to understand. Equally important is the history of cryptography that is one of the underpinnings of this entire system, and this episode gives you the history of cryptography tracking all the way back to the cypher punks roots, and it gives you insight into the culture that surrounds crypto, so it's absolutely required listening.
As far as format goes, guys, we're doing this a bit different. We're doing something we've never done before. Think of this as an audiobook. If you use something like Audible, which I do all the time, you're familiar with the format of audiobooks, that essentially is what the back half of this podcast episode is. It's a full-fledged mini-audio book for you. So, at first, right after this intro, David and I are going to talk with Peter Pan, who is the author of this audiobook and get his insights into what we're about to get into. And then this audiobook is divided into four parts. It starts with part one, the 1970s, around the public key saga, part two, the 1980s, which gets through the origins of decentralization, then the 1990s and the crypto wars, and leads into 2000s and the birth of cryptocurrency.
So, David's going to be reading it as if he is reading an audiobook. The format was fantastic for me to absorb this material, and we think you're going to enjoy it as well. So, today, you get a podcast plus an audiobook. I'm really excited about this episode, David. Yeah, it's truly a hidden gem, and I'm super happy that we were able to get what Peter Pan wrote into more ears. It's well-deserved, and I think some of the information here is underappreciated, and perhaps just unknown. And so, we're going to make this information a little bit more known today. All right, with that, we want to tell you about the sponsors who made this episode possible.
Metamask is your go-to wallet for the bankless journey. If you're going bankless, you need Metamask, period, browser, and mobile, get them both. This is your tool to unlock the world of DeFi. Here's my favorite part. Now you can swap tokens directly in Metamask with a single swipe. This has got to be the easiest way to trade Ethereum tokens. Choose a token you own, a token to exchange it with, and get your quotes. If you like what you see, you hit swap. That's it. What makes swap so useful is what happens behind the scenes. It compares Dexes, aggregators, and market makers to find you the best price with the lowest network fees and the least slippage.
This means you can swap a wider range of tokens and swaps can even automatically split up your trade to give you access to better liquidity. You don't even have to think about it. Try it out, download Metamask for desktop or mobile now at metamask.io and start swapping. Bankless is proud to be supported by Uniswap. Uniswap is a new paradigm in asset exchange infrastructure. Instead of a cumbersome order book system where trades are matched with other humans, Uniswap is an autonomous piece of software on Ethereum, which is what Ryan and I call a money robot. No human counterparties or centralized intermediaries just autonomous code on Ethereum.
Input the token you want to sell and receive the token you want to buy. Something brand new in the Uniswap ecosystem is the Uniswap Grants program is now accepting applications for grants. We have been saying this for a while and we'll say it again. Dows have money and they are in need of labor. If you think that you have something to contribute to the Uniswap Dow, apply for a grant to Uniswap. Just look at the size of the Uniswap Treasury. It's almost three billion dollars. This mountain of capital is looking for labor. Do you have something of value to contribute to the Uniswap Dow? No matter how big or small your idea is, you can apply for a Unigrant at unigrants.
org and help steer Uniswap in the direction that you think it should go. That's exactly what we did to get Uniswap to be a sponsor for Bankless and you can do the same for your project. Thank you Uniswap for sponsoring Bankless. All right, Bankless Nation. We are here with the author of this fantastic series, Peter Pan. He is a community first investor at one KX. He's also an investor and part of the leadership of the Metacartel Ventures Group and also Venture Dow. Peter, how are you doing? It's been great. Thanks, Frank. Peter, this series of articles that you wrote almost reads like an audio book and that's kind of how I listened to it.
Actually, I listened to it before I actually read the series. David was kind enough to record his voice reading through it and I just downloaded it into my brain that way. But I was super impressed with the depth of research, but also kind of the narrative through line that this series of articles put together very much read like an audio book. I was wondering if you could maybe start with, why did you write this piece? That good question. By the way, I'm super honored that you actually picked this up because it was just kind of floating out that right, for a while. And it was actually one of the first things that really worked on in the crypto space.
I joined the crypto space about nearly three and a half, nearly four years ago. It was just firstly me going through the usual cycle of learning about tokens, reading my papers, being fairly lost amongst the buzz. And I think it was in late 2017 where I started going to a local firm meetups where I was like, we're in the first meetup, right? I really went to and I was run by this guy, the Bucky Poo bot, right? He was like the Godfather, the Ethereum, Sydney Ethereum developer community. So he told me, you know, like basic things, it's just like, what is a network? It's like, you know, what is a blockchain network?
What is a firm blockchain network? What is EFA scan? What are private keys? And that was like, you know, I think my first one was in September 2017. And I went down the rabbit hole into learning about the technology. And I was pretty immersed by it. And I realized that, you know, Webfree and Ethereum was going to be a very, very special like, you know, it was going to be a place of special work. Like it was going to be the work that was being built was important. I didn't really know how or when, right? But I knew that there was a lot of catch up work to do. So I, you know, quit my role as a designer late that year and just, you know, I kind of time block myself, like one year to like fully dedicate myself to learning about the firm ecosystem and, you know, to get involved and just to like, figure stuff out and find a job in the space, right?
And, you know, initially as a, I guess, you know, I was a designer doing music, you're like, yes, user research, UX design, non-technical, not don't have a computing background. So I really started to just like, ask questions like, what is the firm network? Really, what is it, right? Like, you know, this network of, you know, computers running software across the internet, like, what is a computing network? What are computers themselves? What is the internet? How does, how do you, I guess, even, you know, transport information across the internet securely, right? And I just like slowly started asking these questions all the way until, like, I started breaking it down to, like, you know, I guess, go through the different abstraction levels of like, you know, from computers, themselves, understanding, like, how we can get rid of the network layer to understanding, you know, what is actual cryptography itself, right?
To, realizing it's just like, you know, it's all number theory in general, right? And discrete mathematics. So try to, like, really gross and, you know, gain a brief appreciation of each layer of abstraction. And only once I did that, did I realize I could really have a solid sense of where blockchains, like, really, fit in this context of technology itself, right? And one of the things I also did was not only learn about the technology, like, I basically, when I learned about each, like, piece of technology, or each live abstraction, I also try to understand and learn about, you know, who was the people behind them, right?
I generally find people much more interesting, just technology itself. And I think when I came to the part about cryptography, I did the standard reading, or I went through, like, obviously, the history of, like, you know, encryption in general, right? From the ancient times, who, like, the modern era. And I think, you know, it was actually, when I saw the learning about, you know, asymmetric cryptography where I realized, you know, just slowly when I went for the history of the people involved, I realized it had really strong linkages to the cipherball movement. And in cryptocurrency in general, I, and I realized that, you know, the lineage here is actually much stronger than, you know, people who made it, like, made it out to be.
And I just, like, you know, when I did this research, it was really, you know, unstructured. I just realized I kept rambling to people about it, because I was like, I thought this was a really cool story, right? And I realized, I should just start writing about this. And when I started writing about it, it was also a part of my, just, you know, kind of research process as well of, like, you know, digging through the different people involved, right? Like, David Chong, you know, the, like, I guess, you know, Diffie and, like, Helm and people like that. Yeah. Kudos to you, Peter, for, for diving deep and going through the research.
You know, when we introduce you, and you have this in your Twitter tagline, we introduce you as a community first investor, right? And what, what you did was basically not only some, some kind of technical study in terms of what is cryptography and, and defining that, but you're almost an anthropologist in this where you sort of track the, the cultural lineage of this crypto movement all the way back to where it began sometime in the 1970s. And I love how this series of articles, again, it almost reads like an audiobook is laid out where you have the 1970s and you have the 1980s and 90s and all the way up through today and how, how this movement has fed into the crypto native movement, a movement that bankless is, is one part of as well.
So this is fantastic history, but I wondered if you could talk a little bit about the cipher punks because these are the heroes of the journey throughout these decades. What, what was the value system of the cipher punks if we talk about this cultural lineage? What, what did they care about? What did they believe in? Yeah, I would probably call the first cipher punks, you know, I mean, obviously you had the 90s, right, movement of the cipher punks, but I really think that it started with, you know, one helmet in which for Diffie and Ralph Merkel, like there were the people who really came together to really publish the findings on like, on how to solve like, you know, the problem of asymmetric encryption decryption, right?
Like, I guess one distinction, you know, for those who are listening, they'll probably learn this in articles, but those symmetrical encryption and decryption were like the key, you know, for securing information, eight encryption and decryption shared the same key, and because of that, you couldn't really share the key publicly, right? At all. So it was very hard to like actually transmit like secret information across unsecure like communication channels. The key, not the key, but I don't say that, but the innovation of asymmetric cryptography was the fact that it could actually decouple the encryption and decryption keys.
So you could encrypt something and actually publish that encrypted information, and you wouldn't need to, some of the decryption key could then just decrypt that, right? And that encryption information could be published anywhere, right? This was the problem to solve back in the day in the early 1970s. And, you know, cryptography research until then was mostly funded by the government and the military. And because of that, cryptography was really kept in a dark. It was like, no one really understood much about it. It wasn't cool, but it was actually, you know, Martin and Whitfield that they really like, there were two individual researchers that really set out to solve these problems individually, and then they found a cellar.
And when they found a cellar, they started, you know, discussing, you know, the research problems and they realized they were working on the same thing, but the key thing was they were, you know, they had this choice of like, you know, I guess whether they should be working on this problem or whether they should be working for a logical, much more well-paid corporation to do this sort of work. And one reason why they did do this in the public, right? And publish an open source of work was because they believe that this technology way too far, far too powerful, it's for it to just be, you know, kind of be, to be gated by one government to be, you know, kept in the dark, right?
And that was like one set of values that drove them to really like, do kind of do all their research. And that really ushered in this like whole new movement around cryptography when they published the paper. But, you know, it was the first ever piece of like, really strong, you know, and, you know, really strong piece of photography that was pushed out into the public and that created like a renaissance around cryptography itself. And this was like one of the themes, you know, throughout the 80s as well of David Chong's work. He really cared about it. He really, he was an advocate for privacy, you know, he was a person who invented the idea around metadata and how like, you know, encryption only encrypted messages, but not the data around the messages, right?
Like, when it was sent and so on. And all of these people in history who actually pushed these innovations on it, that, you know, did it for because they believe in something bigger than themselves. Really, it was, they did it, you know, for sort of values that we understand as the cypher values, and which is really around, you know, privacy, self sovereignty on the internet, freedom, information, freedom, and so on. And I think a lot of, I took, I, I guess I took a lot of these learnings and, you know, they became kind of us inspiration to a lot of my parcel work in the space, early on, which was like, you know, to do something important.
You know, there's a part of your article where it recapt an email that came out of the cypher punk email thread. And that part really stood out to me. And so I want to read a few lines here. And this is just from the guy that sent out the email to everyone else, inviting all the other cypher punks to come and join him in a cypher punk meeting. And in this email, he gave out a couple of things that he believed what defined cypher punks. And he said, cypher punks know that cryptographic protocols make social structures. Cypher punks don't care if you don't like the software they write. Cypher punks know that software can't be destroyed.
Cypher punks know that a widely dispersed system can't be shut down. Cypher punks will make the network safer privacy and cypher punks write code. How much of these statements, which were just the statements of one man back in, I believe the 90s, one cypher punk, self-identified cypher punk, two other self-identified cypher punks. How much how much of these values and beliefs and definitions of what makes a cypher punk do you think is still held true today by the cultures that surround like Bitcoin and Ethereum and open systems, right? The reason how we ended up talking about your pieces, I went on this discovery process to try and figure out what crypto values actually are.
And it was a mean solomani who focused me back to your work. And so my question here is, how has cypher punk values become extrapolated to the communities and cultures around Bitcoin and Ethereum? It's a really good question. I think one thing about the settlements that they understood was that cryptography was this like tool that could protect the world that they created themselves on the internet, right? It gave them a protection from others created at this certain environment. I think for adapted to web3, it's all about web3, we have these tools known as smart contracts that we can use to create entire new worlds, entire new economies to participate in.
And I think yeah, I do think that the cypher planks have this, they're probably self-identified anarchists in this sense. I think the difference here within Ethereum or web3 in general is that we generally see this not so much as a tool to purely just protect, but also to create and build and coordinate. I think this is the key thing. I think James Young said something a long time ago that resonated where I was like, the whole goal of Ethereum was to create the DAO. The DAO was actually the idea all along. Today we have realized a somewhat decent version of the racial vision, of the decentralized economy that really self runs.
But maybe instead of machines running out, we realize that you really do need these human driven, human people fast communities that actually operate these different economies that run today. I think instead of purely as a means of protection, defending, I do see web3 as a means of coordination. I think that's a key theme. So not anarchy, but coordination instead is part of cryptos legacy now. Yeah, I would think so. Where do you want to go next, Ron? I'll jump to this. Peter. One thing as I was listening to this that kept standing out to me was throughout the decades, this dance between the cypher punks and the government, this interplay that is left with us now.
Crypto folks often talk about the final boss being the government popping up and trying to ban crypto ban if you're in ban Bitcoin. So far that hasn't happened, but that legacy has kind of persisted. And throughout the 70s and the 80s and the 90s and into the 2000s, there was always this dance between the power of cryptography in the hands of the people and governments who weren't sure whether they wanted this power to be propagated. It was super interesting for me to realize how much cryptography as a technology was treated as a weapon. It was on the munitions list, like banned munitions list, the same list that missiles and nuclear weapons are on, right?
Can you talk about this interplay between crypto and governments and what it kind of means for us today as we explore this new horizon in the world of crypto? Yeah, no, cryptography is definitely dangerous in itself, especially when it was closed sourced. And it was on the munitions list, mostly from World War One, really, that's what started. I wouldn't say exactly that they didn't want it to be in the hands of people. I think it was just deeply misunderstood. And it was just by default on the munitions list because every government in the world were competing on these technology arm races. It was a matter of national security, but I think as computerization really hit the US in the early 60s and everyone had computers and technology was really more abundant.
I don't even see open sources of movement, but rather as purely just this natural process of information freeing itself for technology. As this progress really progressed, I think this idea that this sort of technology information was harmful for national security was maybe it had some merit, but it was like futile in the end. Initially, I think in the 90s, the government didn't really understand computers or internet or cryptography or information rights at all. They just went into computer laboratories, rated companies and went through the emails, even sent emails themselves through the same computers.
They didn't really understand any of this. A lot of the initial decisions for the government were pretty misplaced and ignorant to a lot of extent. I would the comparison would be like imagine today, the US government would say that putting vaccination data on the US blockchain, you'd imagine the Al Cry of that today. They would be the equivalent of that maybe in the mid 90s. There's just a lot of ignorance and misinformation, but it took them maybe a decade from early 90s to late 90s. That's really breakthrough. What happened was just that more and more people were educated and then slowly, parts of that educated group increasingly were more like people who work in government.
It's always slow in terms of this education and education of the government itself. It's just this giant system. I think it's a matter of time in general. Even today, you have regulators here and there, really addressing DeFi in general. This process generally goes on very, very slowly until you hit this barrier between, there's always moments in history where really strong technologies, a cryptography or even perhaps soon DeFi really hit the boundaries and comprehension of what a government's mental model of how they regulate and enforce. Usually, this often needs to be settled in the court of law, where all the facts are laid out, where a lot of educational education happens for regulators in the government.
It's a painful, painful process, but for cryptography itself, it took free court cases from the 1995 to 1997 for that, so really breakthrough and how it happened was the first case I think was this teacher who wanted to teach cryptography to their students and they had one international student in the classroom. He was handing out CD-ROMs of cryptography, I think it was something like Key Exchange Protocol. Technically, he got a letter from the government saying you must see synthesis because you're technically giving foreign nationals. He heavily regulated cryptographic information and technology, and this was as educated, he was pretty pissed off because why can't I educate all my students?
So, generally, from this teacher's case against a government, to a few other cases, the natural progression of an understanding cryptography went from the first case was made of cryptography is free speech. At least, cryptography is just math. Math is free speech. You can't ban this, so you can't, it was against the first amendment to ban any sort of information. They mocked the US government's decision by printing out cryptographic protocols as books. You can't ban books. So, this step by step into cryptography, software is free speech. You cannot ban software, and slowly that it was just like a lot more education that the government really relented and finally removed it as a restricted munition.
I do agree that there is a lot of education that had to be done. And yet, also, there does seem to be some sort of conflict with those in government, at least, or those in powerful places who might be a bit more authoritarian, a bit more totalitarian. There was this move by the government to put in clipper chips, for example, which was essentially like a back door that you talked about to modern encryption. Of course, this didn't work out because it was easily, easily cracked. But all of this makes me wonder about this idea of a, you know, we talk about in the US and the Constitution, there are rights protected by, you know, the amendments and the Bill of Rights, of course.
What would a digital Bill of Rights look like for society? Surely it would include something like the right to encryption for individual citizens if we were to create something like that. So, there does seem at least in free societies to be sort of an education process whereby, like once governments understand the benefits to individuals of this technology, they get on board because, you know, freedom of speech is a protected right. Although, encryption itself is kind of anti-authoritarian societies or anti-governments that would seek or powerful individuals who would seek to oppress the people.
So, there's also this kind of conflict. Do you see a little bit of that in the legacy the Cypherpunks left us? Yeah, for sure. I mean, cryptography was math and you can't stop math, right? But, you know, it's no, like, human-ridden law could ever stop that, right? So, there's almost like, you know, the government's trying to ban a few Cypherpunks in the past as well. Like, you know, banning alcohol prohibition, like, that was never going to work. Even like, you know, the war on drugs, right? I argue that there's like, you know, like, kind of issues there. And I guess, you know, yeah, I don't understand the government very well in general.
I don't think too many people do. But, yeah, I do think that there's definitely the sense that, you know, work sort of like, I mean, it's, I guess the US government, let's be specific in general, they have an interest for the, to protect the US dollar, right? To be the economic system, the reserve currency of the world. They have a direct incentive to protect that. So, yeah, I do actually see like, potentially this sort of like, a real conflict of interest here and sort of regulating, you know, for your open, like, economic systems and like, also wanting to actually protect their own, right? Not saying it's a bad thing, you know, necessarily over the US dollar being a reserve currency, but it's been protected, you know, for many means.
You know, yeah, for war, for many other things. And I don't, I definitely, you know, could see a pathway gets ugly, right? But I also could see, yeah, like some sort of nuance, but I, but before we finally get to some sort of resolution, this definitely going to be like a period of time where the worlds do clash. And that's going to need to be reserved one way or another. Yeah. Peter, we're about to send bankless listeners into over an hour and a half of me reading your series. And so as people gear up for that and get ready for that, what would you hope would be the takeaways for people who are going through each, each one of these parts?
There's four parts and they're all, and they're all combined together. What should listeners really be pondering or thinking about while they are hearing this and what do you hope that they take away when they are finished? I would say think about why you're in this space and, you know, how you want to contribute to it. You know, one way, you know, this, this sort of like a personal writing this series really affected me was that made me really think hot about, you know, what I was going to leave behind in many senses, right? You know, and it made, it pushed me to do work that I felt like, I guess that everyone else did and that I wrote about, right?
Like, you know, I kind of like stopped thinking, I think I had this mental model before I wrote about the series. It's just like, you know, to do big things, you have to like go change the world and things like that, but I realized, you know, it just, the innovation really happens in a huge way, and you know, from outside, it seems like this, you know, a hero kind of requested to change things, but in reality, it's just a lot of really, you know, smart driven people pushing things one step at a time, and, you know, to do something important, what you need to do is just help progress a space one step at a time yourself, right?
So like, figure out what step that is you can actually contribute to. Well, Peter, once again, thank you for, for writing this piece, and as soon as I stumbled upon it, so I'm going to, well, once again, Peter, thank you for writing this piece, and as soon as I stumbled upon it, I actually started just hitting record before I had even read it, because I knew that it was going to be something that I wanted to get out to as many people as possible. And so, again, thank you for writing it in the original. Here we go. And so thank you for originally writing it and putting it together to make sure that this information can actually get out the door.
What would you say, Peter, before listeners get into it, what would you say is the legacy of the cypropunks, and is that legacy still alive today? Absolutely. Exists everywhere, and the hashes that we create today for transactions. It's everywhere. So, for the organizations we called down today, these were imagined long, long, long time before. And, yeah, we're the ones who are now executing upon those ideas. All right, thank you. Let's go into exactly what those ideas are and where they got formed. And so we bring you, before Bitcoin, by Peter Pan. But first, we have to talk about some of these fantastic sponsors that make this show possible.
Bouncer is DeFi's most powerful automated market maker. Typical AMMs just have two tokens inside of one liquidity pool, which can lead to fractured liquidity across the many pairs of DeFi. With Bouncer, you can access the full power of multiple tokens inside of one single AMM, which unlocks an entirely new playing field of possibility. This makes Bouncer an awesome building block for so many different use cases. Bouncer pools can make asset indexes, but instead of paying fees to portfolio managers, Bouncer lets you collect fees from traders who use your portfolio for liquidity. Additionally, Bouncer smart pools can be programmed to have properties that change according to predetermined rules, such as changing the swap fee based on market conditions, or even liquidity bootstrapping pools, which can help you launch and distribute your token with day one liquidity.
At Bankless, we use a liquidity bootstrapping pool to sell our back t-shirts to much success. Bouncer V2 brings powerful new features that makes your money work even harder for you. In V2, idle tokens are capable of generating yield in DeFi without sacrificing liquidity in the pool. To top things off, Bouncer is reimbursing all gas costs with bound rewards, meaning that all your gas costs are returned to your wallet with the Bouncer governance token. Bouncer's mission is to become the primary source of liquidity in DeFi, by providing the most flexible and powerful platform for asset management and decentralized exchange.
Dive into the Balancer pools at cools.balancer.exchange Gemini is the world's most trusted cryptocurrency exchange. I've been a customer of Gemini since I first got into crypto in 2017, and it's been my main exchange of choice to make my crypto buys and sells. Gemini is available in all 50 states and in over 50 countries worldwide, and on Gemini there are markets for over 30 various different crypto assets, including many of the hot DeFi tokens, and it's one of the few exchanges that has liquid die markets. Gemini just launched their Earn program, where you can earn up to 7.4% interest on 26 various crypto assets.
If you're tired of paying fees in DeFi or you don't want to worry about DeFi exploits, but you still want to earn interest on your crypto assets, Gemini Earn is the product for you. Another product I'm stoked to get my hands on is the Gemini Crypto Back credit card, which gives you 3% cash back on all of your purchases, but paid to you in your preferred crypto asset. When I get my Gemini credit card, I'm going to make sure that I get my cash back in ETH, so whenever I buy something, I get a little bit of ETH bonus back to me at the same time. You can open up a free account in under 3 minutes at Gemini.
com slash GoBankless, and if you trade more than $100 within the first 30 days after you're signed up, you'll be gifted a free $15 Bitcoin bonus. Check them out at Gemini.com slash GoBankless. Before Bitcoin, part 1, the 70s, the public key saga. If you ask people where does Bitcoin or cryptocurrency come from, you'll get many different answers, and if they are right, they will likely be vague jabs at the truth. What many people do not know is that Bitcoin was a creation born out of the CypherPunk movement. Originated during the 70s but formed in the 90s, it fought the US government's injustices surrounding digital freedom and pioneered modern rights to personal privacy.
While you can try to understand the CypherPunks through a Google search, you may struggle to deeply understand the full picture, unless you understand the context of the movement itself. You have to zoom out and think bigger. Who stated the movement of the CypherPunks? Where did all the ideas come from? Before Bitcoin is a series which aims to give you a historical perspective of cryptocurrencies technology and philosophy. To do this, I'll be writing a four or five part series focusing on cryptography, the underlying mechanisms of all cryptocurrencies, along with the philosophies of privacy formed over time.
This will be an exploration through the 70s, 80s, 90s, and 2000s, where in each decade an overview of the series is focused on these points. Part one, the 70s. How cryptographic knowledge was democratized through the publication of public key cryptography. Part two, the 80s. The origins of decentralized services, anonymous communication networks, and digital cash. Part three, the 90s. The origins of the CypherPunks. In part four, the 2000s, technology is born out of the CypherPunks movement during the 2000s, and part five, Bitcoin. The original designs of Bitcoin and early coin forks. This series will be a long read.
It won't be your typical 300-word pamphlet disguises a medium article written as a marketer or the usual short-punchy stuff you find. To understand anything, historical context is important, and the time to do in doing so is an investment. This aims to provide just that. Introduction. So, we want to understand cryptocurrency and its history. Where do we start? I want to kick things off by first talking about the 70s and the creation of public key cryptography. While you might groan at a dusty black and white image of the 70s, just like I did when I first researched cryptography, I didn't realize how important this decade was.
Until the 70s, cryptography was mostly used by the military to secure communications. Research was mostly conducted by intelligence agencies, G-C-H-Q-N-S-A, or licensed research labs operating by enterprises such as IBM. Cryptography was used for commercial purposes, and the public had little access to the knowledge. The hold on modern-day cryptography would have been broken by the publication of public cryptography, released by three cryptographers known as Diffie and Merkel. Their work would result in the first big public wave of interest into cryptography. So what is public key cryptography?
Cryptography is the practice of securing and protecting information against enemies, or people who have no right to the information. It is the underlying mechanism that secures the authenticity and integrity of information, and ultimately what makes blockchains and cryptocurrency possible. Public key cryptography is a shift in the use of cryptography that now secures most cryptocurrency protocols. How does it work? Essentially, public key cryptography allows people to send encrypted information to public to a public address over unsecured channels, and only people with access to the public address's corresponding private key can decrypt the information.
The private key is also used to sign off and authenticate information sent away to verify the legitimacy of its origin. In the case of cryptocurrency, while people can send bitcoins to a public address and see how many bitcoins it holds, only the owner with his corresponding private key can use the bitcoins and sign off on transactions. This was extremely important concept for cryptography, and would lead to the first big interest in cryptography. Three cryptographers known as Martin Hellman, Whitefield, Diffie, and Ralph Merkel would be behind, and they would have a very interesting story. So how did these researchers defeat the government's control on strong cryptographic knowledge?
First, let's follow the story of a cryptographer known as Martin Hellman, a young ambitious man. Hellman grew up as a nerd where he was exposed to science at an early age by his father, a physics teacher at a local high school. He remembers that quote, my father had books on the bookshelf that I would pull down and read about things, including one I remember, Gnott's Physics, an old physics text from the 1890s that he bought. Obviously, it was an antique, even for him, and my seventh grade science fair projects came out of that, so I was interested in science, but not particularly cryptography, and I loved math too, end quote.
Early career. Following his interest, he studied electrical engineering from New York University and completed his master's degree in electrical engineering at Stanford University in 1967. Fairly well suited to academia, he did well and enjoyed his time at school. While it might be intuitive to assume that he studied cryptography at some point, he never much associated with the side of computer science until later on. Instead, early on, he was very career driven, having already planned his life at an early age. He envisioned that he would be married at the age of 35, and until then he would be traveling the world working in management for big businesses.
At the age of 22, he set out to complete a PhD in some esoteric way of thinking called decision logic. Hellman saw a doctorate as an opportunity to counter his youth in management based on a logic of quote, if I had this PhD, it would be a way to help the questions like what can this kid do. Ironically, in his first year of his PhD, he had gotten married. That did not slow him down, and within two years of starting his PhD, at the age of 24, he achieved an early breakthrough. He released his dissertation, Learning with finite memory. Hanging on with his grand life plan, he followed his dreams to go work for IBM.
For a brief moment, he was juggling the decision to either teach or work in enterprise, but guided by the allure of traveling the world, and a lot more money. He decided, quote, no thanks, I don't want to be poor. Early influences of Harry Faisal and Peter Elias. So he went off to work for IBM at the Thomas J. Watson Research Center in New York. Hellman worked in the pattern recognition department, building machines that tried to recognize numbers from photographs. While Hellman's work was nothing to do with cryptography, IBM and his own division focused on cryptographic research. From that division, he met a German researcher called Horst Faisal.
Through their friendship, Faisal introduced Hellman into cryptography. They often had lunch discussing cryptographic systems and seemingly unsolvable problems. Hellman regards Faisal as one of the biggest early influences, and would go on to later design the government's data encryption standard, DES. As he mentally matured, and also well when his wife was pregnant, he asked himself, do I really want to be traveling the world, or do I want to have more time with my family? It was the timeless dilemma that we had to face throughout history, wife and child versus money. Choosing family, he became an assistant professor at MIT's Department of Electronic Engineering.
This is where he met Peter Elias, MIT's head of the electronic engineering, who collaborated on research with Cloud Shannon, the father of information theory. If that means nothing to you, he essentially invented the modern day cryptography that was used in World War II. After meeting, Peter gave Hellman a copy of Shannon's landmark paper, a mathematical theory of communication. This was the papers from 1948. This was another major influence of Hellman that shaped his mathematical understanding of cryptography. He became good friends with Elias, which over time deepened his fascinations and knowledge of cryptography.
Hellman regarded Elias as being another pivotal part of his education into cryptographic philosophy, pursuing research. In 1971, Hellman returned to Stanford this time as an assistant professor. While he continued to work on decision-making research by the end of 1971, he had started to pursue cryptographic research. His colleagues and friends, Stanford did not support his decision to do so. They told me I was crazy, Hellman said. The funny thing is, was he didn't exactly disagree with their sentiment, a quote from Hellman. How could I hope to discover anything that the National Security Agency, which is the primary American code-making code-breaking agency, didn't already know?
And they had classified everything so highly that if we came up with anything good, they'd classify it. But driven by his intellectual fascination and previous experience with the influences at IBM and MIT, he believed that cryptography would be a commercial importance in the future. He gave his first talk and released his first technical report on cryptography in 1973. Hellman's work soon spread and did not go unnoticed. In 1973, a researcher called Whitefield Diffie reached out to him. Whitefield Diffie, a very bored young man. In contrast to Hellman, Diffie was first introduced to cryptography early at the age of 10 years old when his father, a history professor, brought home cryptography books from a local library.
He loved mathematics but hated school. Diffie was never described to have performed competently and how he never applied to the degree his father hoped. Diffie barely graduated. Despite his performance, he was smart enough to ace the entrance exams for MIT. Starting mathematics there, he remembers how he tried to teach himself how to program but thought of it as very low-class work. Overall, he was pretty bored and instead spent most of his time studying pure mathematics, skimming daydrops to work on AI and the code-breakers. Just when he graduated, the US government started to draft young men to fight in Vietnam.
Machine guns and screaming Viet Cong did not particularly interest Diffie, so instead he took a job developing software and doing other, quote, low-class work. At the same time, he also started to work part-time at MIT's Project MAC's Artificial Intelligence Laboratory, run by two pretty smart people, Martin Minisky and John McCarthy. Diffie had a very strong relationship with McCarthy and learned a lot from him. Unknown to Diffie and many at that time, McCarthy would go on to later be regarded as the father of artificial intelligence, corning the term AI. Often quoted, McCarthy believed that every aspect of learning or any other feature of intelligence can, in principle, be so precisely described that a machine can be made to simulate it.
He was incredibly focused on the future, believing that the conception of such intelligence will come in five to five hundred years. Under his guidance, Diffie was exposed to his computing philosophy and developed a deep understanding of networking, electronic keys, and authentication. Diffie later followed McCarthy to Stanford to join his new AI lab. During his time at Stanford, Diffie read David Khan's book The Code Rakers, The Story of Secret Writing. It summarized the history of cryptography from ancient Egypt to the time of its writing and was described to have profoundly influenced him and his beliefs surrounding privacy.
Compel to pursue his own personal retours of cryptography, he left sale and sale was the organization, the AI lab in Stanford that I mentioned earlier. He left sale in 1973, spending the next year jumping around the country to meet and discuss cryptography with different experts. Quote, I was doing one of the things I am good at, which is digging up rare manuscripts and libraries, driving around visiting friends at universities. In 1974, as part of his research, he visited IBM Thomas J. Watson Laboratory at Yorktown Heights to meet with a cryptography research team. At the time, it was led by Horst Feistel, the guy who introduced cryptography to Helmand.
When Diffie visited, he couldn't learn much as much of the work as was classified by the NSA. Instead, he was referred to Martin Helmand, a professor at Stanford University who was working on similar cryptography. Helmand meets Diffie. In the fall of 1974, Witt shows up on my doorstep. I'll never forget that day. Helmand in 2011. Through a referral, Helmand agreed to meet Diffie at his house in 1974. Diffie came in the afternoon but stayed for dinner in the left at 11 p.m. The short meeting expanded over hours of discussion. Helmand recounted how working in a vacuum had been taxing in a way and finding a kindred spirit was really something.
Soon after, Diffie took a job at a local research group and, like his first job, he would soon spend more time working with Helmand on cryptography than his actual job. Early in 1975, they had something else to worry about. The DES. Data encryption standard. DES. Early in 1975, the government published the DES. It was the first encryption cipher that was approved for public and commercial use. The NSA published the adoption of the DES by financial services and other commercial sectors where strong encryption was needed. SIM cards, network devices, routers and modems. Previous to the DES, the first amendment classified cryptography, along with munitions and other items that were in military and character.
You had to be licensed to handle any form of cryptography and all work related to it was classified by the NSA. This was the first publicly approved use of such technology. How the DES was designed. The need for a national encryption cipher was released after a study conducted in 1972 by the National Bureau of Standards, now known as NIST, the National Institute of Standards and Technology. Basically a shell of the NSA. They requested design proposals from research centers around the U.S. in 1973 and 1974. After running up dry the first time in 1974, IBM conceived of a cipher called Lucifer. Lucifer's design was led by IBM's very own horse feistle.
This cipher was an improvement on previously developed cipher but fit the design request from the NSA. Lucifer went underwent an extra stage of collaboration with the NSA where they wanted to reduce the key size from 64 bits to 48 bits. On a basic level it means needing less processing power to encrypt and decrypt. Their final decision to reduce the key size to 56 bits would later come back to bite them. Hellman and Diffie's criticisms. Hellman and Diffie initially embraced the DES with open arms as they saw as a huge step forward bringing cryptography into the public view. But as they look closer they foresaw how the shortened key length was vulnerable to brute force attacks.
But more importantly, along with amongst the research circles the IBM team accused the NSA of tampering with the cipher. After the cipher was sent to Washington for approval it was returned with an altered s-box, the part of a cipher that returns plain text into cipher text. During the 70s there was a general sense of distrust about the government. This weariness stemmed from a period after WWII. Learning from the control of totalitarian governments, the USSR, Nazi Germany, the public was vigilant against the intrusion by the government. The public fears were reflected in Aurowell's 1984 and other popular texts that explored government surveillance, control of society and personal freedom.
This sentiment continued into the 60s where the decades was rocked by the assassination of JFK, the Cuban Missile Crisis, and the socio-political movements such as the black rights and gay rights movements. In the 1970s this was exacerbated by the Watergate Incident in 1972 which was a controversy surrounding President Nixon's authorized bugging of the Democratic National Committee headquarters in Washington DC. To the public their fears were slowly but surely manifest in before their eyes. People believed that the NSA had built a cipher which they could bypass themselves. Merkel, the kid who knew nothing.
Soon after the release of the DES, Helman and Diffie released a technical paper called the multi-user cryptographic techniques, and they soon learned of Ralph Merkel, a young 23 year old computer science student from Berkeley. Helman was 30 years old at the time and Diffie was only one year younger, older, excuse me. Merkel's puzzles. Before meeting Helman and Diffie, Merkel had already been working on his early concept of public key encryption, which would later be known as Merkel's puzzles. He started working on his ideas during his computer science course CS244, where he stumbled across the riddle, how do you reestablish secure communications when a hostile enemy already knows everything?
He needed to complete a personal project for the course and it seemed perfect for him to develop his ideas. When I thought about how you can possibly establish security when everything is known to the eavesdropper and the eavesdropper can listen in on communications, how can you possibly establish security? So my first thought was, it doesn't look like you can, so I'll try and prove that it's impossible. So I tried to prove that you couldn't establish security and I tried and tried and tried and failed miserably. Then I thought about it some more and I said, well if I can't prove that you can't do it, I'll turn around and try and figure out a method to do it.
And when I tried to come up with a method for doing it, having just tried to prove you can't do it, I knew there were cracks in my proof where, so to speak, and I knew where I could try and slide through. So I worked on those places and lo and behold, it turns out it was possible. I could use the cracks in my proof to come up with a method for actually doing it. And when I figured out how to do it, there was this well, the traditional aha moment where I said, quote, oh yeah, that works, I can do it. That happened very rapidly. And it was, it was all one night of staying up late and thinking and then realizing, oh my gosh, I can do this thing.
It seems very counterintuitive, but I can actually figure out a key. I can establish a cryptographic teak key over an open communications line, even if the enemy, the interluper, the eavesdropper knows everything. With no theoretical or historical knowledge about cryptography, he was unaware of how the problem was considered to be unsolvable. He put everything into a paper and shared it around. The head teacher of the security course couldn't understand his weird work and told Merkel to bug her off. And when he submitted his work to the CACM, a well respected computer science journal, he was rejected.
But this time, not because it was nonsense, but because the editor thought his contents of his work were, quote, not in the mainstream of present cryptography thinking. However, he also shared it with a computer scientist called Peter Blateman, who immediately noticed the value of his work. Unbeknown to Merkel, Blateman was friends with Diffie, who invited him out to a cryptography meetup in Stanford. During a car ride, it might be Blateman. Blateman briefly outlined the problem Merkel was working on. Apparently, Diffie had been obsessing over the problem for years, and upon hearing about how some young computer science student had potentially solved the problem, he dismissed such a possibility erupting into an outburst.
But once Diffie was calm again, he became excited about the possibility of such a solution. Helmet and Diffie had recently submitted a paper which explored the applications of public key encryption under the assumption that it was possible. Diffie gave Blateman a copy to give to Merkel. Quote, there are these guys at Stanford who talk just like you. After reading their work, Merkel sent over his paper. When the other two had read it, they completely shifted their way of thinking. Despite Merkel's youth and complete lack of cryptographic knowledge, his creativity had solved the public key distribution problem.
This young 23-year-old managed to achieve what academics had strived to do for years. But Helmet and Diffie found his solution inefficient. With their cryptographic understanding, they had found a far more compact solution to the key distribution problem and came up with a new iteration of public key cryptography. Soon, their concepts would be formulated into a paper that would be known as new directions in cryptography. Following their collaboration, Merkel left for Stanford taking up Helmet's invitation to work under him as a PhD student. New directions in cryptography. In November 1976, the paper New Directions in Cryptography was released.
It discussed fundamental problems of cryptography, public key cryptography, and protocols that facilitated authenticated communication. Merkel was credited for his independent work, but in the end, the communication protocol was named the Diffie Hellman Key Exchange. However, despite this in 1977, when public key encryption was patented, Merkel was credited as one of the three inventors. Diffie reflected on Merkel as a possibly the most inventive character in the public key saga. The system had since been known as the Diffie Hellman Key Exchange. While the system was first described in a paper by Diffie and me, it is a public key distribution system, a concept developed by Merkel, and hence should be called the Diffie Hellman Merkel Key Exchange.
If the names are to be associated with it, I hope this small pulpit might help in that endeavor to recognize Merkel's equal contribution in the invention of public key cryptography, Martin Hellman 2002. The concepts discussed in the paper are used to design and secure blockchains we use today. One of their purposes of the paper noted at the end was to, quote, inspire others to work in this fascinating area in which participation has been discouraged in the recent past by a nearly total government monopoly. It's a quote from the paper, New Directions in Cryptography. For the time, the public had access to powerful encryption technology.
Their work broke the control on cryptographic knowledge, fueled by the growing distrust of the government's DES Cypher, the technology in the paper enabled the first big wave of public interest in cryptography and encryption. It was later revealed by that Hellman, Diffie, and Merkel were not the first conceivers of public key cryptography. A form of it was initially created and applied to an algorithm by researchers from Great Britain's Intelligence Agency, GCHQ, and while the NSA had access to this, it was all classified and remained in a dark untouched. Now, imagine if these three never published public key encryption.
Our world potentially might be very different. Hellman, Diffie, and Merkel's publication managed to inside a new wave of innovation that would last for decades, whereas governmental agencies kept their findings behind closed doors. This contrasts very much highlights the importance of open collaborative work within cryptography but also other sciences. Fittingly, in the line of the first paper, it had begun with, we stand today on the brink of a revolution in cryptography. While Hellman and Diffie continued to work on cryptography, Merkel was the one that continued to excel. Spending the rest of the 70s as a student of Hellman and Diffie, Merkel continued to impact cryptography in the 80s, later going on to invent cryptographic hashing, closing statement for this part of the series.
These three cryptographers would break down the barrier for cryptography. A cryptographer, known in the 80s, known as David Chong, would go on to directly build upon their work and conceptualize the need for autonomous communications, payments, and ultimately the need for decentralized services. Chong's work, however, would only be made possible through the dedication of Hellman, Diffie, and Merkel. Continuing on from the 70s, the story of decentralization picks up right after the publication of public key cryptography, beginning with a computer science student called David Chong. Like Ralph Merkel, he was also from the University of California Berkeley.
As a graduate student, he recently learned about cryptography in the late 70s through the paper New Directions in Cryptography, 1976. This was Martin Hellman's Whitfield Diffies and Ralph Merkel's publication on public key cryptography. Chong was not alone in his discovery of cryptography. At that time, the San Francisco Bay Area was becoming the world's leader in technology through the local presence of Apple, Intel, and Hewlett Packard. The money and excitement attracted international tech talent. When the paper New Directions in Cryptography was released, interest in cryptography spread like wildfire amongst scientists, academics, researchers, and engineers.
After about a decade of dishing it out between Microsoft and Apple, the 70s personal computing boom was tapering off. Star Wars 4 had just come out in 1977, and the concept of the internet has started to turn heads worldwide. The world was moving towards a digital future, and the tech wasn't the only thing reflecting it. It was a newly found sense of fascination and romanticism revolving around computers, robotics, and technology. Apple's record-breaking IPO of 1.3 billion would later pour fuel into the impending software boom and set Silicon Alley for success for the next 30 years. Being part of the first new wave of interest into cryptography, Chong naturally looked into it through his natural aptitude for breaking things.
While having lived a little about his early life and personal details online, he shared hints of where his natural curiosity for technology had come from. While others were playing in the sun, Chong recounts how he spent most of his childhood breaking locks and playing with safes. He was from a wealthy family and had access to a computer early on. And like many modern days teenagers, he spent his adolescent years staring at a computer screen. But instead of YouTube and Facebook, he spent time trying to break computer systems and cracking passwords. Being part of the first generation that grew up using computers, technology was natural to him.
But so was his hacker paranoia. Having broke and exploited seemingly secure systems, Chong had likely developed a sense of cynicism about most technologies. Having that instinct as he studied cryptography, he saw an aspect that was of cryptography that was overlooked. Metadata. The traffic analysis problem. While public key encryption conceptually solved the problem of encrypted messages, Chong thought it was only one piece of the puzzle. He knew that encryption did not necessarily mean secure. He saw the unprotected data around protected messages of who converses with who and when they converse as a risk to personal privacy.
With this information, he knew that people could theoretically be identified and tracked. Completing his graduate studies at the time, he decided to write his research paper on the traffic analysis problem. How do you keep secret the knowledge of who converses with who and when they converse? He graduated in 1979, releasing his first major cryptography paper, untraceable electronic male, return addresses and digital signatures. While it initially released in 1979, it was only later published in 1981. Siting the Helmandiffian Merkel's work of new directions in cryptography, in the paper, Chong outlines the risk of personal privacy and provides the blueprint of an anonymous mailing protocol using something known as a mixed network.
His protocol protected the identity of the messengers as well as the time of the message being sent. How do mixed networks work? A mixed network is a network made up of nodes that use public key cryptography to authenticate messages. These nodes send information to each other to mix up the original sender's identity and timing of messages. The message addresses was important as it could be used to identify the origins of the message. The timing of the message could also be used to identify the messages that would correspondingly move within a network. With a mixed network, when you send a message to someone, the encrypted message would first be passed to a node where it would be batched with other messages from other senders.
This batch would then be sent to between different nodes. Think of a pinball full of messages bouncing around different nodes. In the end, the message would exit out of the network and end up at the intended address with the original sender hidden. For replies to the message, it would be sent back to the original address that would be unknown to the sender. Thus, the identity of senders and order of messages would stay unknown and prevent the ability to trace and spy on messages. While designing a network, he dismissed a solution that used a single message authenticator believing that would be easily compromised.
Instead, he insisted that, ideally, each participant is an authority. The mixed network protocol would be built, would be used to build a tour. The anonymous browser that you can use to buy drugs or hire hitmen. Yes, incognito mode is not anonymous. Mixing is also used by Manero to anonymize transactions. Untraceable payments. Understanding the potential risk of unprotected metadata, he also sought financial tracked transactions in the same light. In an increasingly digital world, John believed that e-commerce would play a huge role in the world, but so would the traceability of consumed payments.
He believed that the timing of transactions and goods purchased not only enabled the tracking of people, but allowed for the profiling of individual lifestyles, consumer choices, and political leanings. Quote, the time of payment for every transaction made by an individual can reveal a great deal about the individual's whereabouts, associations, and lifestyle. For example, consider the payments or such things as transportation, hotels, restaurants, movies, theater, lectures, food, pharmaceutical, alcohol, books, periodicals, dues, religious, and political contributions. In 1980, he patented a digital cash system, secured by cryptography, which would form the basis of cryptocurrency.
Patent number 4529870 outlined a protocol that was able to conduct financial transactions with an external system, exchange data with an external system, contain an ID linking to the ownership of data within the external system, stored data relating to the interactions within the external system, and secure this stored data through cryptography where it could be accessed using a secret ID known to the owner. Chom later fletches out the concepts of anonymous payments in his paper, blind signatures for untraceable payments, that was later released in 1982. Similar to the concept of mixed networks, he proposed payment, his proposed payment protocol required, including the masking of the sender, the amount being sent, and also the time of the transaction, stumbling onto the concept of decentralization.
Back then, as a student, his work was dismissed as political and radical by his peers. Similar to Martin Hellman in the 70s at Stanford, Chom also faced scrutiny over his work. Upon pursuing his doctorate studies, his head teacher told him, don't work on this, because you can never tell the effects of a new idea on society. Ironically, his head teacher would turn out to be right. Despite the pressure from his peers, Chom decided to continue his doctoral studies. Revisiting the ideas in his first paper about mixed networks, he decided to research the concept of trust in computer systems. As a hacker, Chom did not trust central authorities in computer systems, as he thought they could easily be hacked.
Instead, he believed that systems were part of participants where authorities were harder to compromise. Researching the concept of computer systems that established trust between parties that don't trust each other, Chom argues for the need for decentralized services in his dissertation. Computer systems established, maintained and trusted by mutually suspicious groups, paper in 1982. Here are some quotes. It is not enough that the organization maintaining a computer system trusts it. Many individuals and organizations need to trust a particular computer system. There are many other similar applications of computers which involve private sector records relating to consumers, such as those arising from credit, insurance, healthcare, and employment relationships.
Public sector record keeping, such as areas as tax, social security, education, and military service are quite similar. All of these applications involve one group who owns or control the computer systems and who is particularly concerned with reliability in maintaining the operation of the system and ensuring the survival of the data maintained by the system. They will be called trustees. A second group or set of groups are primarily concerned about the confidentiality of the data which relates to them that is available to the system. There may be a third group or set of participants which may overlap with the first and second groups who are concerned about the correctness of the operation of the system.
Initially led by his concerns towards communications metadata, his idea of mixed networks was one of the first concepts of a decentralized service. His concerns about metadata led him to focus on the need for anonymizing payments. While Chalm was focused on personal privacy after having looked over his work and how he presents the concepts of decentralization, I personally don't think he understood the magnitude and importance of decentralization at that time. Chalm presents decentralized services as a means of solving certain conflicts of interest between consumers and businesses in certain application aspects.
Rather than how it is portrayed in today's world as a socio-political movement, decentralization in his paper was first presented as an economical solution for businesses. Graduating in 1982, Chalm decided to continue his research on cryptography. As the decade continued, Chalm's ideas had started to mature and a vision of the future had started to form inside of his head. Watching the growth of computing explode faster than anyone ever predicted, Chalm was worried. Chalm's warning to the world in 1985. Computerization is robbing individuals of the ability to monitor and control the ways of information about them is used.
Already, public and private sector organizations acquire extensive personal information and exchange it amongst themselves. Individuals have no way of knowing if this information is inaccurate, outdated, or otherwise inappropriate. New and more serious dangers derive from computerized pattern recognition techniques, even a small group of them using them and tapping into data gathered in everyday consumer transactions could secretly conduct master valence inferring individuals, lifestyles, activities, associations. The automation of payments and other consumer transactions is expanding these dangers to an unprecedented extent.
Wow, this is me, David speaking now. This is when in 1985 and I think we can extrapolate that into the world today where we're talking about Twitter, Facebook, YouTube and the control that these technologies implicitly have over our lives due to the metadata that we give these things for free. Pretty great to that, Chalm predicted this in 1985. All right, back to the article. Acknowledging Oral's dystopian world with the paper's title, it talks about the dangers of using data that was building up around computing systems. Chalm's warrant of this continuing trend of computerization, which would render society open to exploitation and mass surveillance.
He also argued that surveillance might significantly chill individual participation and expression in group and public life, the inadequate security and the accumulation of personally identifiable records, Mo over posed, posed national vulnerabilities. Information service providers and other major interests, for example, could retain control over various information and media distribution channels while synergistically consolidating their position with sophisticated marketing techniques that rely on gathering far reaching information about consumers. The main body of his paper summarizes a decentralized economy based on his previous research into the decentralization of messaging and payments.
Despite his ideas being previously fragmented, he then knew the true importance of his ideas surrounding decentralized services. Seeing the future that the world was moving towards, he was acutely aware of the crossroads which lay before society. Chalm understood that the decision of the internet's architecture would have enduring social and political consequences, projecting the vision of two futures, one built with a current technology and one built with decentralized services, he saw that the two approaches appear to hold quite different answers. A quote from Chalm. Large-scale automated transaction systems are eminent.
As the initial choice for the architecture gathers economic and social momentum, it becomes increasingly difficult to reverse. Whichever approach prevails, it will likely have a profound and enduring impact on economic freedom, democracy, and our informational rights. So what is decentralization? One of the most fundamental beliefs Chalm had was the right to personal privacy. With the world becoming ever more interconnected, he saw the need to protect personal data. He saw cryptography as a means of doing so. If you think about it, cryptography is essentially the practice of protecting information against individuals that didn't have access permission to access it.
Cryptography is a digital law enforced by the law of mathematics, a force beyond central control. No one is above it. And when individuals are empowered to control and protect their data using cryptography, only then can true personal privacy be realized. Chalm saw decentralized services as the means of protecting privacy. Enabled and secured using cryptography is something outside centralized control. Hence, this is why decentralized systems are trusted. He could believe in the math. He did not trust governments and companies. Sounds like a nutcase, right? Here is the author, Peter, putting in an image of the Edward Snowden leak from 2014, where the title is.
Edward Snowden leaks that exposed US buy program. I mean, we all know the implication of this. There's a lot of images here. I'm just going to scroll through them. I have Facebook. Cell phone metadata worries are added to the fallout from Facebook's data scandal. The news. Users have been reporting that personal data held by Facebook shows that the social network has collected metadata about phone calls and text messages on Android devices. Facebook says that the logs are part of an opt-in feature, adding that it will never sell this data. And this feature does not collect the contents of calls and messages.
Ah, yes. And then the final picture is Cambridge Analytica. A individual, I believe, who's the president of it could be wrong. Giving a presentation where the title of the presentation is called the power of big data and psychographics in the electoral process. Jesus, like, I don't even need to connect those dots for you. I'm sure the listener can do that. All right, back to the article. Wow, was David Chalm a time traveler? No, he was not a time traveler. He just had an exceptionally clear thought in his vision of the future. He was right, wasn't he? Yes, kind of. Well, it does seem that way.
We haven't gone down the route of decentralization. No system is ever perfect, and I wonder if we would be dealing with the problems of the same magnitude if the world did follow the heat of Chalm's advice. Nevertheless, history has so far pointed towards the need for decentralized services. After 30 years after his paper, the world did indeed build itself around centralized services. With 2.2 plus billion users on Facebook, the world's data was protected by Goodwill. Goodwill did not hold up. Goodwill and the promise of Facebook had a little power against the CIA and government. The lack of cryptographic ownership led to the abuse of data by Cambridge Analytica.
So is it too late? While the internet might have taken a wrong turn, nothing points to the fact that things are too late to change. That's what history is full of. Evolutions in culture, technology, and society. The world will always be moving. The question is just where? After the 80s. Chalm spent the rest of the decade researching cryptography, and by 1988 had moved into the Netherlands, starting his own research group, and after a decade of research, he would finally act on his vision of a decentralized world. He found his company Digicash in 1990 and created eCache, the world's first digital cash system.
Gaining worldwide attention, many cryptographers interned and worked for Digicash, including Halfinney, Nick Zabo, and Eric Hughes, one of the founders of the Cypherpunks, a movement that would be explored in the next part of the series. Digicash would experience highs and lows, rejecting a $180 million acquisition from Microsoft, only to declare bankruptcy a while later. If you want to read more about Digicash, there is a link in the article. By the end of the 1980s, Chalm had become one of the most well-regarded cryptographers in the world. Chalm was one of the people who knew where the world was going.
He understood things that others didn't. Deciding to focus on building a company, he would leave behind the seeds that would ultimately bloom into the 90s Cypherpunk movement. His movement would go on to stand for the liberty and the fight against governmental injustices of the 90s. Do you remember what the head of the teacher said to Chalm back when he was still a student at Berkeley? Don't work on this, because you can never tell the effects of a new idea on society. All right, that is the end of part two, on to part three. Continuing on from the 80s. During the 80s, technology software and computing made massive strides.
In 1982, Adobe, Autodesk, and Sun Microsystems were founded. 83 into it was founded and Microsoft Word was released. In 1984, Cisco was founded. Dell was founded. Hewlett Packard released their first inkjet printer. 1985, AOL was founded. 1987, McAfee Antivirus was founded. 1989, Adobe Photoshop 1.0 was released and Apple broke into the top 100 US companies ranked by revenue. While the world of tech shot ahead, other areas of life, law and society failed to keep up. The Wild West of the internet was soon ruled by hackers with usernames that even 12-year-olds of today would cringe at. Criminals were becoming increasingly sophisticated through technology while the US government had remained recklessly clueless.
Agent Baxter and the legendary Star Wars defense contractor Autodesk. In early April 1990, a rock band lyricist named John Perry Barlow received a call from the FBI asking for an interview. He was an early user of the internet and was and was part of many online communities. And while he didn't know why the FBI had contacted him, he thought it would be suspicious to turn down their request. A few days later, a special agent Richard Baxter from the Federal Bureau of Investigations showed up at his doorsteps. Barlow was accused of being a part of a hacker group called New Prometheus, where they had distributed stolen Macintosh ROM source code.
Despite Agent Baxter producing little evidence of his allegations, Barlow soon realized that he could not get through to Agent Baxter. Since this was a crime involving software and technologies, you would probably assume that someone half-competently knowledgeable would be sent to investigate Barlow. Apparently no. According to Barlow, quote, complicated by Agent Baxter's fairly complete unfamiliarity with computer technology, I realized right away that before I could demonstrate my innocence, I would first have to explain to him what guilt might be. The interrogation dragged on for three hours.
He had been told, for example, that Autodesk, the publisher of AutoCAD, was a major Star Wars defense contractor, and that its CEO was none other than John Draper, the infamous phone freak also known as Captain Crunch. As soon as I quit laughing, I started to worry. Similar to how a dad might initially laugh at the clumsy moron of a son, as Barlow sat there, he soon started to worry for the future of America. At that moment, he realized how the confusion of Agent Baxter and the rest of the government might put everyone else's rights and freedoms at risk. After three hours of beating a dead horse, special Agent Richard Baxter had let him go.
Barlow posted his experience onto well, the first online community forum, created in 1985, it was where the hipsters of yesterday hung out. Not long after, he was contacted by another member who had similar experience. That member was Mitch Kaper, a software kingpin of the 80s. He was the founder of Lotus, a company that made note-taking software, and had in the last decade released its first spreadsheet software. Lotus would later be acquired by IBM for 3.5 billion in 1990. Kaper was also accused of the same crimes committed by the hacker group New Prometheus, who was also very alarmed by the FBI's lack of understanding with software and technology.
If the authorities didn't understand it, how could they respect the rights that come with it? Within a week, Kaper had flown out to meet with Barlow. As a snowstorm raged outside Barlow's offices, they talked about their experiences as well as the recent secret service raise of Operation Sun Devil. Operation Sun Devil was a part of the Clinton administration law enforcement effort targeting cybercrime. Early in January, they had released a public statement announcing it. Our experience shows that many computer hackers suspects are no longer misguided teenagers misgiviously playing games with their computers in their bedrooms.
Some are now high-tech computer operators using computers to engage in unlawful conduct. The right of the people to be secure in their persons, houses, papers, and effects against unreliable searches and seizures, shall not be violated and no warrant shall be issued, but upon probable cause, not without support by author or affirmation in particularly describing the place to be searched and the persons or things to be seized. This roughly translates into, to fight crime, we can now do anything we want, but hey, we will try to not violate and abuse anyone. One of the first targets of Operation Sun Devil were a hacker group known as Legion of Doom.
And soon after, the members known as Alphaed Freak, fiber optic, and scorpion were raided. Accused of hacking phone systems, the secret service kicked down the doors and turned their house upside down. The computers were confiscated along with books, notes, telephones, audio tapes, and other suspicious electronic equipment. Barely 18 years old and still living at home, their families were also subject to police treatment. Near the end of their discussion, Barlow and Caper both realized that the complete oversight of their civil rights and knew that something needed to be done to defend them. The beginning of the Electronic Frontier Foundation.
Wellthie from his ventures, he agreed to cover all legal costs and defend the hacker's case. Within a week, Barlow and Caper were in New York setting up the legal team for the three teenagers. They decided to work with RB SKL, Rabinowitz, Boudin, Standard, Crinsky, and Lieberman, the law firm renowned for defending civil liberties. The day after acid freak, fiber optic, and scorpion would walk into RB SKL's chamber to become the first cyber conflict of the 90s. After doing so, a journalist reached out to follow up on Barlow's experience with the FBI. During his phone call with the journalist, Barlow happened to talk about his efforts with Caper in defending the hackers.
Unexpectedly, several days later, the newspaper headline, Lotus Founder, Defends Hackers. The headlines stormed the public and soon went viral. Steve Wozniak, the co-founder of Apple, reached out and jumped on board as an advisor, agreeing to give unlimited funding to the legal efforts of Caper and Barlow. Alongside Wozniak, they were joined by John Gilmore, a tech entrepreneur. Gilmore was known as a troublemaker with a hobby that included annoying the NSA. Just the year before 1989, he had leaked an NSA banned cryptography paper. During his career as a self-taught programmer and Sun Microsystems fifth employee, he was known to, quote, never take on a job unless he was convinced it was the right thing to do.
Being rich from Sun Microsystem stock options, he spent the latter half of the 1980s, hosting the alt forums, known for being a place where anarchists, lunatics, and terrorists hung out. More recently, in 1989, he started up a company called Signus Support to pursue his passions. Freedom of speech, freedom of software, and freedom of encryption. As an anarchist and freedom fighter, the group of Barlow and Gilmore represented what he believed in. Soon after the publicity, they learned of the rating of Steve Jackson Games. Similar to the Three Hackers, the game company had their whole office confiscated by the Secret Service.
At the time, Steve Jackson Games was making a video game titled Cyberpunk, which the CIA believed to be a handbook for computer crime. The Secret Service looked into all of their emails and had even deleted many as reported by the company. The Secret Service was recklessly out of control and had no concept of digital rights. On the 8th of June 1990, Barlow released his iconic paper Crime and Puzzlement. He writes about everything that had happened leading up to the involvement of Caper, Wazniak, and Gilmore and the Defense of Three Hackers. America is entering the information age with neither laws, nor metaphors, for the appropriate protection and conveyance of information itself, feeling the need for a formal organization to fight against injustices.
At the end of the article, he reveals the formation of the Electronic Frontier Foundation, EFF, an organization that would raise and disperse funds for education, lobbying, and litigation in the areas relating to digital speech and the extension of the Constitution into cyberspace. Word of the EFF traveled fast into Barlow's surprise, he had touch upon an issue which received overwhelming levels of public acknowledgment. The Steve Jackson Games case would go on to set historical precedent and categorize electronic mail along with voice calls where a warrant was needed to gain access to them. A pretty good bill.
Early in next year in 1991, Senator Biden added an addition to Bill 266, a piece of legislation focused on anti-terrorism. In addition to the bill, allowed for the government to access plain text, contents, and voice data and other communications when appropriately authorized by law, it basically meant that the government would be able to spy on all communications available at will. All forms of communication. At the time, a software engineer who was building an encryption program heard about this news, known as Phil Zimmerman, spent the last decade heavily involved in liberal politics as a nuclear freeze activist and more recently started focusing on technology.
He was building a tool that could allow anyone with a computer to encrypt messages and files, using the RSA encryption algorithm. Considered to be of military grade, RSA had only been used commercially, but Zimmerman believed that everyone should have access to strong cryptography and the ability to communicate privately. His program was called PGP, which stood for Pretty Good Privacy, a name inspired by the grocery store known as Ralph's Pretty Good Grocery. He had been vaguely debating how he was going to make a business from PGP, but when he learned to bill 266, he did not take the news lightly.
He saw it as impending doom. The government was about to legalize spying and the exact activity his software was looking to protect against. Taking the bill as the ultimate deadline, Zimmerman rushed to get it into the hands as many people as possible. Missing five mortgage payments in a row, Zimmerman said, this is not a commercial product, it was a human's rights project. And while version 1.0 was considered to be weak and poorly written, the recipe of sleep deprivation having no money and rush work is not an optimal one for writing software. Zimmerman released PGP in May of 1991, along with his famous article, which included the software docs, why I wrote PGP.
If privacy is outlawed, only outlaws will have privacy. Intelligence agencies have access to good cryptographic technology, so do the big arms and drug traffickers, so do defense contractors, oil companies, and other corporate giants. But ordinary people in grassroots political organizations mostly do not have access to affordable military grade public key cryptography technology until now. PGP empowers people to take their privacy into their own hands. There's a growing social need for it. That's why I wrote it. He started uploading PGP to different forms and sites. It was open source free and didn't require license for commercial use.
He wanted to be, he wanted to put military grade encryption into the hands of everyday people in anticipation of impending doom's day. Helped out by his activist friends, PGP started to spread. Did you know before the rise of most italitarian governments, they confiscated and banned the ownership of guns? This was the case in Nazi Germany, the Soviet Union, and Italy during World War 2, etc. Within a week, people started using it around the world and within a month, thousands had already downloaded it. It was soon used by Burmese freedom fighters and even spread to Eastern Europe where one person replied to Zimmerman, if dictatorship takes over Russia, your PGP is widespread from Baltic to the far east now and will help democratic people if necessary.
However, in spite of Zimmerman's secured efforts, civil liberty groups, including the EFF, had rallied against Senator Biden and the addition was removed from Bill 266. It turned out that it was Biden who ultimately motivated the urgent release of PGP into the public. May and Hughes, two very crazy individuals. Early next year, Gilmore hosted a party in San Francisco where he invited cryptographers together to hang out and drink. That was when Eric Hughes and Timothy C. May met. Hughes was a young mathematician who had just come back from Amsterdam where he was where he worked with David Choms Digicash.
May was originally a hardware engineer at Intel who had just spent the last three years attempting to write a nonfiction novel about David Choms ideas. Whilst Eric was still in his mid 20s and May was in his late 30s, they immediately connected over their equally crazy libertarian views. By chance, they were both also equally obsessed with David Choms work. Timothy C. May was a rugged character, having been brought up by a naval officer. He was a free spirited libertarian from the early age of 12 where he very much enjoyed his guns, holding a pleasantly heavy cold metallic firearm felt liberating and empowering.
In a similar fashion while Chom played with his locks and safes as a child, May's favorite toys were his AR-15 to Salt Rifle and his 357 Magnum. Fittingly, May pursued a career as a hardware engineer. During the 80s, his libertarian views gravitated him towards the wild west of cyberspace and fantasized how encryption makes it easy and even safe to ignore most local laws about what can be done in cyberspace. In 1986, he read David Choms paper, security without identification, card computers to make big brother obsolete and quit his job. He wanted to write about David Choms ideas. Leaving Intel as an employee rich from stock options, he started to write a novel called Degrees of Freedom.
May attempted to write about a rule ruled by digital money. And data heavens, blockchain's question mark, time stamping, and NSA surveillance. And similar to most teenagers who wrote about spy fiction, he never finished his novel. Being an engineer at heart after three years of struggling as a writer, he was done with the sidelines. I don't want to work on this stupid novel. I want to actually build this elaborate world that I was imagining. Eric Hughes had studied mathematics at Berkeley as an undergraduate student. During his time there, he was first exposed to the work of David Chom at a cryptography conference, Crypto 86.
Chom had been talking about a system of digital money where he stressed the importance of anonymous payments in the increasingly digital world. Unlike others, Hughes was captured by the political implications of technology and cryptography. After a short consulting stint, he left for Amsterdam to work for David Choms Digicash. But despite being obsessed about his research, Hughes described how he was not too fonds of Choms personality, a comment that would not surprise any of the past and present Digicash employees. After a short stint that Digicash, he came back home. He had come back earlier in May 1991 to apply for a Berkeley graduate school, as Hughes had mentioned needing a place to stay while he looked for a place to rent may offer to cover him.
While it made sense then, Hughes agreed and came to live with May for a short while. Upon arriving, he ended up doing very little of what he was intending to do, looked for a place to live. Instead, Hughes and May spent the three days straight just talking about crypto. Whilst others had day jobs, May was a rare mix of being rich, as well as a failed author, and Hughes was a young 20-something-year-old with no responsibilities. We spent three intense days talking about math protocols, domain-specific languages, secure anonymous systems. Man, it was fun, said May. The first meeting. Later in September of 1991, Hughes, May and Gilmore came up with the idea of gathering a regular meet-up of tech libertarians.
They liked the idea and sent out Hughes to a newly rented house. So on a September Saturday morning, 30 or so academics, engineers, and crypto advocates sat on the unfurnished floor of Hughes newly rented house, and so it began. May had prepared 57 page handouts detailing concept of cryptography and other background information on the discussion that they planned. They included a discat copy of PGP 2.0, which was released the week before. After ceremoniously distributing the packets, he began the meeting by reading aloud his five-year-old creation to which he called the crypto anarchist manifesto.
It was a political manifesto written back in 1988 during May's short-lived career as an author. It projected a vision of a future where the world's data, liberty, and governance were ruled by laws of cryptography and mathematics. He originally written it for the cryptography conference, Crypto 1988. He printed out hundreds of copies and gave them out, but no one cared too much about the political implications of cryptography. But unlike those present at the Crypto 88 conference, as May read the manifesto out, the motley crew of cryptofanatics who sat on the floor nodded and grumbled in approval.
Exert. If the government can't monitor you, it can't control you. Politics has never given anyone lasting freedom, and it never will. May didn't trust in the protection of privacy and freedom with companies. Instead, he trusted the law of mathematics to do so. May in an early video conference in 2017 commented how at least one or two of the people present had probably created Bitcoin. After initial discussions around the world they lived in, they started to play a series of role-of-playing games that simulated cryptographic concepts. By now, you would probably have realized how huge geeks these people were.
For the rest of the afternoon and evening, they used paper and envelopes to play out digital money, information markets, pseudonyms, hypothetical drug trading systems, and reputation systems. They had naturally arrived at the issue that Chom had originally encountered, metadata, and its exploitability. Frustrated at how cryptography had made little progress since the 80s, they talked about how they would go about implementing Chom's solution of a mixed network. The group talked about cryptography all night long and ended up sleeping on the floor of Hughes' bare floor. During the next morning, while Hughes and May were buying bagels, they asked themselves, why limit the club to the physical world when the real mass of potential cryptography fanatics were on the cyberspace?
They realized that the internet was going to be built in chat rooms, not in someone's living room. Within a week, Hughes developed a mailing list 1.0, a re-mailer list, think like an email chatroom. The mailing list would send emails to and from different users and hide the original sender's identity behind a pseudonym. Howfany would implement PGP 2.0 into the re-mailing list, and another cypherpunk called Cautral would implement message batching to hide the timing of messages. Hughes' girlfriend, Jude Millen, the editor editor of a tech magazine commented how you guys are just a bunch of cypherpunk.
A play on the world cyberpunk and cypher, the term would soon be worn as a badge of pride and political defiance. Within a month of the first meeting, the mailing list was up and members could subscribe by emailing cypherpunk.com. After 13 years, David Chom's concept of a mixed network was finally realized. The birth of the cypherpunk. This mailing list would become the harbor of America's most back channel discussions surrounding cryptography, drug markets, assassinations, and government politics. Julian Assange, along with the creators of Tor, BitTorrent, and most likely, Bitcoin, were part of this list early on.
Within a week, it had hundreds of subscribers, and by the end of the year, there would be over 2000 similar re-mailers hosted around the world. One of the first messages serviced on the 10th of October 1992, which announced the details of the second cyberpunk offline meetup. This time, it would be held in the offices of Cygnus Support, Gilmour's company in Mountain View, where Google now currently resides in. Here's what seems to be an email from the email list. The second meeting, October 10th, 1992. The second meeting will be held in the new Cygnus offices. Exact address and directions to follow.
We do not have yet an exact agenda, but one should be arriving in the next few days. Please mark your calendars now and start telling your friends. For this meeting, and until further announced, we are using a transitive trust system for invitations. Invite anyone you want, and let them invite anybody they want, and so on. The crypto-anarchy game we tried out at the first meeting was a good success as we could have hoped for from an untested idea. The game seems useful and fun enough to want continue play and play testing, so we'll be playing it again in the future meetings. We've observed several interesting emergent behaviors in the first session, including resellers and reputation behaviors.
We'll play a two-hour session this time and discuss it afterwards. The CypherPunks list is a forum for discussion about technological defenses for privacy in the digital domain. CypherPunks assume privacy is a good thing in which there were more of it. CypherPunks acknowledge that those that want privacy must create it for themselves, not expect government's corporations or other large faceless organizations to grant them privacy out of benefits. CypherPunks know that the people have been creating their own privacy for centuries, with whispers, envelopes, closed doors, and careers. CypherPunks do not seek to prevent other people from speaking about their experiences or their opinions.
The most important means to the defensive privacy is encryption. To encrypt is to indicate the desire for privacy, but to encrypt with weak cryptography is to indicate not too much desire for privacy. CypherPunks hope that all people desiring privacy will learn how best to defend it. CypherPunks are therefore devoted to cryptography. CypherPunks wish to learn about it, to teach it, to implement it, to make more of it. CypherPunks know that cryptographic protocols make social structures. CypherPunks know how to attack a system and how to defend it. CypherPunks know just how hard it is to make good cryptosystems.
CypherPunks love to practice. They love to play with public key cryptography. They love to play with anonymous and pseudo-anonymous male and forwarding and delivery. They love to play with DC nets. They love to play with secure communications of all times. CypherPunks write code. They know that someone has to write the code to defend privacy, and since it's their privacy, they are going to write it. CypherPunks publish their code so that their fellow CypherPunks may practice and play with it. CypherPunks realize that security is not built in a day and are patient with incremental progress. CypherPunks don't care if you don't like their software they write.
CypherPunks know that their software can't be destroyed. CypherPunks know that a widely dispersed system can't be shut down. CypherPunks will make the networks safe for privacy. Continued. The second meeting of the CypherPunks will be Saturday at noon. John Gilmore has graciously provided us with a meeting space at the new Cygnist support offices. These offices are so new in fact that Cygnists will not have been moved in yet. This meeting will be a bring your own pillow or chair since it will likely be held in a largely empty space. Directions are at the end of this message. Attendance is transitive trust arbitrarily deep.
Invite whoever you want, let them also do so and so on. Invite them also to join the mailing list. Do not however just post the announcement. Time will come for that. I'd like everyone to do plans on attending this meeting to send me hues at soda.berkeley.edu a message telling me so. I'd like to get a rough headcount before a Saturday for game planning. We are starting at noon because of popular demand. Eat beforehand or bring a burrito or something. It will be fine to eat during the first segment. It won't be any more disruptive than the game is. Bring your own PGP public key for in-person key distribution, preferably on discat.
We need a portable PC or three to do key distribution. If you have one you can bring post it to the list and tell people. We've realized after the first meeting that a strict schedule is nonsense, this meeting will have a very informal schedule. Schedule. Starting at noon we're going to play session two of the crypto anarchy game in which players try to conduct business under the watchful eyes of others. We want to play for two hours and then have a discussion of about experiences afterwards for about an hour. Some of the improvements over last time will flatter denominations of money, wider distribution of commodities, more watchers, governmental and otherwise, and perhaps some pre-printed forms.
We'll take a break to regroup for about ten or twenty minutes. For the second half we'll talk about the security of re-mailers. I'll lead the discussion. We'll be designing protocols and analyzing attacks and defenses. I've done this with DigiCash for electronic money protocols and re-mailers are much easier but still probably more than an afternoon's discussion. We'll do this until six or so when people will have to start leaving. Everyone who wants to will go out to dinner. I don't know any of the restaurants down there. Perhaps someone can suggest one. And then the rest of the emails, this, the directions.
Okay, so back to Peter Pan's article. That was just an email thread that was part of the CypherPunks email thread. Now we're back to the article from Peter Pan. CypherPunks assume privacy is a good thing in which there were more of it. CypherPunks are devoted to cryptography. CypherPunks love to practice CypherPunks write code. Unlike other political movements throughout history, the CypherPunks were able to equally match and defeat the government through direct action. An archive of the messengers are available online. Here's an archive of the first year of messengers. There's a link in the article.
John Gilmoren's genanigans. So while Gilmore was running his company, organizing crypto rebel meetups, he was caught up with another hobby of his, annoying the NSA. He had been battling a court case with the NSA and scored another win for the CypherPunks. Earlier that year in the June of 1991, he had learned of some books written by a cryptographer known as William Friedman. He was the founder of the US Signal Intelligence Service, the precursor to the NSA. After reading two volumes of Friedman's work, he realized that the other four volumes were classified. He asked for them to be classified.
They said no. This was not because Gilmoren was a pain in the ass, but instead he had stumbled across one of NSA's founding documents. So being a curious George, he started hunting for them and ended up in Virginia after being tipped off by a friend. When he found the exact books that were classified by the NSA, he mailed them to himself. However, life was not as simple as that. Under surveillance, the NSA demanded him to hand them over. Denying the request, he argued how these textbooks are relatively simple cryptographic techniques and that he obtained them legally. To get them off his back, he gave his door to the press, and after a front page headline focusing on the NSA, they dropped the pursuit of Gilmoren and the books.
Soon after the books were declassified, the NSA hated the publicity and were forced to give it up. So after all that effort, what value were the books to Gilmoren and the cipher punks? Apparently nothing. Gilmore just wanted to stand up to the NSA and prove that government could be defeated. Gilmoren won NSA zero. PGP 2.0 gets into trouble. Early next year in 1993, PGP fell into the sights of the US government. After having attention drawn to Zimmerman through RSA's intellectual property dispute, regulators initiated a criminal investigation on the violation of Arms Export Control Act. Cryptography since World War II had been considered as a military product and controlled within the same class as munitions.
While back then, the world was made up of stone and chalk, in the 90s, it was a digital one where software and computing led to the US's GDP. With Zimmerman given a court date, the EFF and the public rallied behind him. In response to the government, he printed copies of PGP's source code on hardback to cover as a political stunt. Books were protected by the First Amendment under free speech, but cryptography was outlawed. What about a book that had cryptographic source code? What was that then? But despite all the ridicule the public threw at the government, it was clear as day. Zimmerman could not deny it.
He had violated the munitions act. Things looked grim for the software engineer turned hippie. Quote, to have 10 lawyers tell me unanimously that it was hopeless, it was a ton of bricks. It was the worst day, says Zimmerman. His all-star legal team was sure of defeat until one of them had an idea. Known as Phil DeBoys, he built his reputation through creativity in defending criminals, celebrities, and generally crazy people who did stupid things. Instead of denying and pleading, DeBoys' idea was to go on the offensive and portray the government as a danger to freedom. This would become key to the Zimmerman defense, and luckily for Zimmerman, the government would soon step into its own news.
Shortly after the Zimmerman case in April 1993, the Bill 266 had come back in another form, the Clipper Chip, sinking the Clipper Chip. There is no better time to release an NSA spy device that allowed federal, state, and local law enforcement officials the ability to decode and intercept voice and data transmissions. Its timing was perfect to further piss off an already irritated nation that stood behind Zimmerman. The Clipper Chip set was a manufacturing standard that encrypted data. Similar to the DES of the 70s, it had been part of the Clinton administration's attempts to manage the country's security.
The government just wanted to protect everyone by having access to everything, everywhere, whenever they wanted. And while the DES of the 70s had had suspicions of being backdoored, the Clipper Chip was straightforward about it. It was part of the chip's inherent design and was openly announced through its proposal. It had a slight improvement upon the DES 56 bit key and used an 80-bit key. And like most government projects today, back then you could also trust the quality of the work. That sarcasm, by the way. With a healthy distrust of the government and fresh memories of the last three years when the Clipper Chip was announced, the public erupted against it.
They had just woke this sleeping bear. A very excited crew of cipher punks. Official civil rights groups such as the EFF responded to the proposal in well-tempered criticisms of how it endangered freedom. But in the general public population frenzy and paranoia is ensued. Orwell's dystopian world of 1984 was about to come true. In contrast to the mainstream urgency, the cipher punks were rather excited. Imagine this. You forecasted a doomsday and had started preparing for it, and 10 years later, it happens. And sure, while the world looks like it was going to end, it would be hard to not get excited to watch the world's gamble and arrive at the same conclusions which you had already arrived at.
The cipher punks predicted and expected this day. The war is upon us, announced Timothy C. May. Clinton and Gore folks have shown themselves to be enthusiastic supporters of Big Brother. Timothy C. May, Eric Hughes, John Gilmore, and other cipher punks rally to grince this news with a level of giddy enthusiasm. And while the cipher punks openly oppose the chip and debate raucously about either withdrawal, many others, including May, did not actually take it too seriously. They knew the vulnerabilities of the chip design, and how public key cryptography fundamentally becomes useless the moment anyone else has the private key.
The back door of the chip was almost like a sick joke to them. On the day of the release, May wrote, first, the bad news. The government wants to control encryption. Though they are playing koi about it, it's clear that eventually they will try and ban, quote, the good stuff. It's clear Zimmerman and others have gotten their attention. Now, the good news, it does not matter. The game is over, we won. The government may engage in holding actions, but it still doesn't matter. What we have here is the state's pitiful attempt to make the best of a bad situation. This amazing policy announcement is a tacit admission of defeat.
How can I be so sure? The cat is out of the bag. Free, mill spec data encryption is readily available for all. Within a year, equivalent voice encryption freeware will join it. There is no way the government can stuff the encryption cat back into the bag. They can pass their laws. We will do as we please, and they will help us. Nonetheless, there have been an emergency meeting at the offices of Cygnus support. With 50 cipherpunks tightly packed into a room, they would brainstorm ideas to destroy and rebel against the government. Similar to how in Fight Club, Tyler Durden would hand out assignments that cipherpunks printed off parody stickers that said, Intel inside, and stuck them inside of computer stores where May had originally drawn it on a whiteboard as a joke, referring to Big Brother inside.
Other design t-shirts that shouted, fight the clipper, headlines from May's crypto anarchist manifesto. Whitefield Diff was a major influencer during this clipper chip saga, and would later write a famous public letter to the Clinton administration. Here's an excerpt. No right of private conversation was enumerated in the Constitution. I don't suppose it occurred to anyone at the time that it could be prevented. Now, however, we are on the verge of a world in which electronic communication is both so good and so inexpensive that intimate business and personal relationships will flourish between parties who can at most occasionally afford the luxury of traveling to visit each other.
If we do not accept the right of these people to protect the privacy of communication, we take a long step in the direction of a world in which privacy will only belong to the rich. The import of this is clear. The decisions we make about communication security today will determine the kind of society we live in tomorrow. Early next year in 1994, a national council of 40 experts, industry leaders, and academics wrote a public open letter to the Clinton administration asking for the clipper proposal to be withdrawn. This group of 40 included all three original creators of public key cryptography, Martin Hellman, Whitfield Diffie, and Ralph Merkel.
Ronald Rivest, one of the creators of the RSA encryption, David Chom, founder of Digi Cash, Philip Zimmerman creator of PGP. Here's an excerpt. The clipper proposals should not be adopted. We believe that if this proposal and the associated standards go forward, even on a voluntary basis, privacy protection will be diminished. Innovation will be slowed, government accountability will be lessened, and the openness necessary to ensure the successful development of the nation's communications and infrastructure will be threatened. Next section. Government, don't worry, we have it covered. Next year during May of 1995, the NSA finally responded.
Failing to give an inch of ground, they responded through a fairly pointless press release that attempted to assure the public of the chip security. The cryptographic's strength of the clipper algorithm is very substantial and should be highlighted, with regard to the AT&T TSD 3600 device and other similar devices, these vendors almost exclusively to employ DES encryption. DES encryption is based on the use of 56B key information. Clipper employs an algorithm, which is based upon an 80-bit key. Although it's 20 bits longer, although it's only 24 bits longer, Clipper encryption provides 16 million times as many permutations, which makes it geometrically more difficult to decrypt.
This fact is a critical counterpart to the encryption methodology and makes Clipper encryption attractive. By 1994, the communications manufacturer AT&T had started creating hardware with the chip. Communication companies were starting to use the chip. But despite this, the ideology of the Cypherpunks had reached far and wide. As the chip was released into commercial products, the Cypherpunks soon had eyes on the restricted design of the chip. An AT&T embedded systems engineer called Matt Blaze had the job in testing the chip for production and was able to examine it closely. He discovered that while the Cypher itself was relatively secure, the NSA's key for access to the encrypted backdoor was only a 16-bit hash that could be brute-forced.
It turned out that Blaze was also a Cypherpunk and part of the mailing list. After consolidating his findings, he published them in 1994, effectively breaking the chip's design. Soon after his findings, the Clipper chip was discarded and found impractical by the government and also commercial producers. The tides were finally starting to turn. Next year, the Cypherpunks' efforts will continue and transition into a series of legal battles. Carn vs. the United States. Soon after the vulnerability of the Clipper chip was released, a programmer known as Philip R. Carn stepped up to the challenge the government's classification of cryptography as a munition.
He ordered an assessment of a book that contained cryptographic source codes for encryption algorithms. Unable to dispute the claim, it was found that the book was not subject to the munitions act. Carn continued to request a second assessment of the book's CD disk, which contained the source code detailed inside the book. But unable to prove otherwise, it fell under the munitions act. The nuances here were decided on the potential ability to cause malice through the medium in which the source was held on, but his efforts would not be wasted. Bernstein vs. the United States. Next year, 1995, Carn's case held the legal grounds for another challenge.
A student of Berkeley called Daniel J. Bernstein attempted to publish a paper along with source code about his encryption protocol and through his publication, challenged the munitions act in federal trial court of northern California. Based off the precedent of Carn vs. the United States, the court ruled that the source code inside the paper was speech protected under the first amendment. While Carn's case had ruled text forms of source code to fall outside of the munitions act, Bernstein's case proved it to be protected by the first amendment under free speech. The pieces of the puzzle were slowly coming together.
Junger vs. the United States. Peter Junger would be the next to challenge the munitions act. He was a law professor who enjoyed teaching from first principles and wanted his students to not only study, but also play with concepts explored. For one of his courses, he was restricted to only take in international non-US citizens, as he had included an encryption program in the course materials where it officially recognized as the export of cryptography. Held back from teaching, he announced his case against the munitions act, believing that it violated the first amendment. Leveraging the recent cases of Carn and leveraging the recent cases of Carn and Bernstein, Junger's case would emerge victorious later in 1999 to conclude how software would be protected by the first amendment.
But immediately after Junger's initial challenge, the Clinton administration gave in, Junger's case would only be closed later on. Later that year, on 12 October 1996, President Bill Clinton signed Executive Order 13026. Cryptography was officially removed from the munitions list and placed on a lightly controlled schedule. The export of cryptography was no longer prohibited. Through this order, Zimimman's case would also be dismissed as the consequences of exporting no longer carried anyway. The battle was won. But was it over? No. Coming full circle from Helmand, Diffie and Merkel. Later in 1998, as the remaining legal cases surrounded cryptography were finally being closed, Gilmore looked to press on and completely destroyed the government's claim and involvement on future cryptographic technology.
The Cypherpunks community had set their sights on the DES. Originally released in 1976, it was an encryption standard that was provided for commercial use. The DES was what Martin Helmand and Whitfield Diffie had opposed and what inspired the open publication of public key cryptography. One of their criticisms of the DES was that it was 56 bit key, was theoretically vulnerable to a brute force attack. But back in the 1970s, doing so was considered unfeasible with the degree of computing power available. But in the now in the year 1998, it was a different story. Later that year, RSA data security released a bounty to see who could crack a DES secured message.
After five months, it would be solved. They set a bigger bounty of $10,000 to see if anyone could do it faster and better. After missing the bow on the first challenge, Gilmore, who by then had a successful business, took on the challenge with a cryptographer called Paul Coacher. He worked under and was trained by Martin Helmand, one of the three original public key inventors. Fitting for the mission that would bring history full circle, Gilmore and Coacher spent $222,000 to build a computer called Deep Crack. Within 56 hours, the DES was cracked. After about two decades of controversy, the DES was finally broken and soon officially declared defunct.
By the year 2000, all restrictions and regulations surrounding cryptography had been removed by the government. Open source cryptography was legal and allowed. At the beginning of the 90s, the world wasn't sure where it stood with cryptography until the government gave people a reason to care. The Cypherpunks fought and won. They did so to protect the right of personal privacy and liberty through cryptography. They would continue to rampage through the 2000s, leaving behind in their trail tour, and the rise of the deep web, torrenting and piracy, WikiLeaks and Transparency, but more relevantly Bitcoin and Cryptocurrency.
In the next part, part four, we will explore the creation of Tor, BitTorrent, WikiLeaks and the birth of Bitcoin. Here are some awesome pictures. Standing on the shoulder of giants, huh? Part four, the last part, by the way, on the home stretch. Before Bitcoin, part four, the 2000s, New Millennium. Continuing on from the 90s, this movement fought the injustices of the US government and their treatment of digital rights. It all began over a series of hacker raids that would spark a decade-long skirmish between the Cypherpunks and the government. With civil rights emerging victorious, the world was no longer in 1992.
Cryptography was removed from the Munitions Act, and code was officially deemed under the protection of the First Amendment Act of Free Speech. By the end of the 90s, it was a different world. MSN was founded in 95, Google was founded at 98. In 2001, Apple would soon release its first iPod to change mobile technology forever. MySpace would emerge in 2003, Facebook in 2004, YouTube in 2005. The world was changing and a new era was on the cusp. But what about the Cypherpunks? After the late 90s victory over the government, there was a short time period in which things seemed quiet, and naturally there was no need for an underground dwelling of rebels anymore.
Cryptography was legally open source and its export from the US spread strong cryptography all over the world. By the 2000s, Cypherpunk mailing this activity was dying out. After the attack on 9-11, the government questionably increased their brute force authorization on hosting services for investigations, and soon Cypherpunk mailing lists were shut down. As a joke, one of the last Cypherpunk mailing lists renamed themselves to Cypherpunk at alcada.net. In a recent video conference call in 2016, Timothy C. May remembers that quote, I didn't think it would be too smart to be part of a group labeled alcada.
net. Many others thought the same and the members of the list fled elsewhere. With over thousands of messages banning over nearly a whole decade, it served as the Cypherpunk War Room and the home of the 90s techno-libertarian spirit. With the infamous mailing list coming to an end, things were just getting started for the Cypherpunks. A Cambrian explosion of internet information services would erupt in the following decade and changed society forever. And with developing applications of the internet from file sharing, video streaming, gaming, e-commerce, the Cypherpunk missions of privacy and uncensored technological freedom stayed ever relevant.
The Cypherpunk spirit continually lives on through BitTorrent, the Torrent Network, Pirate Bay, Wikileaks, the Silk Road, Darknet Markets, and all its contributors, where many were part of the original Cypherpunks mailing list. Juliana Saundra was a very active member back in 1995 and so were core members of the Torrent project and other open source advocates. But also through Bitcoin and the Web 3.0. We often lose track of perspective of where we are in history. It is far too easy to look no further beyond the local maximum of technological innovation. That was the reason I wrote this series before Bitcoin.
Bitcoin wasn't a UVika moment. It was a technology constructed with ideas and blueprints spanning over nearly half a century. It is part of a movement that has been brewing for the last 40 to 50 years starting with Martin Helman, Whitfield Diffie, and Ralph Merkel's open source publication of public key cryptography. They started the movement of the Cypherpunks that would seed the ideology behind Bitcoin. It enabled true immutability and censorship-resistant data, but more importantly, it was a significant 0-1 moment for decentralized technologies. The rag-tag bits and pieces making up Bitcoin can be found in the waking trail of the Cypherpunks.
Satoshi built Bitcoin, along with Halfinney, Nick Zabbo, and Wei Dai. It was handcrafted by the veterans of the 90s crypto wars. It was part of the inventing spirit of the Cypherpunk movement that will continue to live on. While this might be a historical series, it is yet to conclude as we are all part of it in continuing it. It seems motionless and still, but one thing is certain in history and that is change, and change has been part of the Cypherpunks movement for the last 40 to 50 years. We have to take a step back and appreciate that Bitcoin and now Ethereum is simply another piece of the puzzle that will fit into our story and the movement of the Cypherpunks.
It is simply just another important stepping stone for the movement, just like public key cryptography, the Cypherpunks mailing list, BitTorrent, Tor, and WikiLeaks. We have to look beyond what is in the present and into the future in order to shape the world that we want. While David Chom knew about the consequences of a centralized internet, no one else believed him to work towards a better future. We may not realize it, but we are moving towards something that is way bigger than anyone can imagineably conceive. A future built on cryptography and liberty. Even back in the 70s, Martin Hellman and Whitfield Diffie knew it themselves.
We stand on the brink of a revolution in cryptography. Here are some more pictures. Here's Andreas Intonopolis, talking about Bitcoin to a crowd of four people in an empty room in 2013. Wow. Here's Gavin Wood presenting Ethereum at DevCon1. Thank you and it has been a pleasure writing this series. I hope you have enjoyed it. History is rich and full of surprises. It simply takes some effort to look around. There's a lot to be gained. Knowledge, gratitude, and wisdom. Next time, look into it. You will find richness and delight on par with the creation of public key cryptography and the Cypherpunks themselves.
The before Bitcoin series pays homage to all the heroes who fought to protect privacy, freedom, and liberty. While the spotlight of this series did land on a select few, I want to also address those individuals who names were not mentioned. The names that fell through the cracks of history. The early internet engineers that wrote and maintained code for public infrastructure. The cryptographers who sought to protect the freedom of speech and privacy. The vendors who risk their freedom to enable free commerce of contraband goods. The contributors who answered this stack exchange queries, the open source project managers, and the whistleblowers who sacrificed their own bringing to bring injustice into the light.
Thank you. And thank you, Peter, for writing this. We hope you enjoyed the video. If you did, head over to Bankless HQ right now to develop your crypto investing skills and learn how to free yourself from banks and gain your financial independence. We recommend joining our daily newsletter, podcasts, and community as a bankless premium subscriber to get the most out of your bankless experience. You'll get access to our market analysis, our alpha leaks, and exclusive content, and even the bankless token for air drops, raffles, and unlocks. If you're interested in crypto, the bankless community is where you want to be.
Click the link in the description to become a bankless premium subscriber today. Also, don't forget to subscribe to the channel for in-depth interviews with industry leaders, ask me anything and weekly roll-ups, where we summarize the week in crypto and other fantastic content. Thanks everyone for watching and being on the journey as we build out the bankless nation.