Vitalik is back on Bankless to discuss his recent blog post: The Most Important Scarce Resource is Legitimacy.
------ 🚀 SUBSCRIBE TO NEWSLETTER: https://newsletter.banklesshq.com/ 🎙️ SUBSCRIBE TO PODCAST: http://podcast.banklesshq.com/ 🎖 CLAIM YOUR BADGE: https://newsletter.banklesshq.com/p/-guide-2-using-the-bankless-badge 🎧 Get this Episode's Debrief: https://shows.banklesshq.com/p/exclusive-debrief-legitimacy-with ------ BANKLESS SPONSOR TOOLS:
💰 GEMINI | FIAT & CRYPTO EXCHANGE https://bankless.cc/go-gemini
🦊 METAMASK | DEFI PASSPORT https://bankless.cc/metamask
🦄 UNISWAP | DECENTRALIZED FUNDING http://bankless.cc/uniswap
🔀 KWENTA | EXCHANGE SYNTHETIC ASSETS https://bankless.cc/kwenta
------ 📣 UPSHOT | Become an NFT Appraiser! https://bankless.cc/upshot ----- Bankless Podcast #64 - Legitimacy Guest: Vitalik Buterin
Ethereum co-founder Vitalik returns to Bankless – "the greatest Ethereum podcast" – for a deep dive into one of his recent blog posts, titled "The Most Important Scarce Resource is Legitimacy." The catalyzing example for Vitalik's discussion of legitimacy comes from Bitcoin and Ethereum, who both have the power to mobilize a tremendous amount of capital but are restricted in how this capital is used. Vitalik posits that legitimacy is the deep and powerful social force behind this.
Legitimacy is a social phenomenon that describes things that are broadly and generally accepted in a coordination system. Without ascribing moral values, legitimacy can be seen as social reality - the status quo. Legitimate things include the de facto norms and collective expectations of groups, whether you like it or not.
According to Vitalik, there are a number of ways to achieve legitimacy: brute force, continuity (inertia), fairness, process, performance, and participation – these are not mutually exclusive. Cryptocurrencies and blockchain ecosystems 'earn' legitimacy by community acceptance and adoption, but the continued legitimacy of these things is dependent on maintaining that which made it legitimate in the first place: promises and proofs of decentralization & security.
Vitalik turns this discussion towards funding public goods. Ethereum can't summon capital for public goods without sacrificing the decentralization and soundness that give it legitimacy. However, these expectations are not carried as strongly in the app layer. This gives the ecosystem flexibility to coordinate and provide for the health of the network beyond base layer security & decentralization. Legitimacy determines our best practices for interacting with the world – understanding and wielding the power of this concept is necessary to maximize the benefits we bring to it.
------ Resources:
The Most Important Scarce Resource is Legitimacy: https://vitalik.ca/general/2021/03/23/legitimacy.html
Vitalik on Twitter: https://twitter.com/VitalikButerin?s=20
Vitalik's Blog: https://vitalik.ca/
Vitalik's Bankless Appearances: https://youtube.com/playlist?list=PLmkdAgtxf3agqnA5IieA7OkKBjlhx9mn-
------ This Week on Bankless:
🧢 WEEKLY RECAP | Bankless DAO is Born (4/24) https://newsletter.banklesshq.com/p/ethereum-bonds-weekly-recap 🗞️ WEEKLY ROLLUP | Uniswap V3, Bankless DAO (5/7) https://shows.banklesshq.com/p/-rollup-uniswap-v3-btc-in-bank-accounts 🧠 THOUGHT THURSDAY | Crypto Pawn Shops (5/6) https://newsletter.banklesshq.com/p/the-evolution-from-crypto-pawn-shops ✏️ WRITER WEDNESDAY | The Never Sell Plan (5/5) https://newsletter.banklesshq.com/p/the-never-sell-plan 🏴☠️ STATE OF THE NATION | Chainlink 2.0 God (5/4) https://shows.banklesshq.com/p/-sotn-45-chainlink-20-with-chainlink 🛠 IT’S TIME FOR BANKLESS DAO(5/4) https://newsletter.banklesshq.com/p/its-time-for-bankless-dao
----- Not financial or tax advice. This channel is strictly educational and is not investment advice or a solicitation to buy or sell any assets or to make any financial decisions. This video is not tax advice. Talk to your accountant. Do your own research.
Disclosure. From time-to-time I may add links in this newsletter to products I use. I may receive commission if you make a purchase through one of these links. Additionally, the Bankless writers hold crypto assets. See our investment disclosures here: https://newsletter.banklesshq.com/p/bankless-disclosures
No summary for this episode yet.
Welcome to Bankless, where we explore the frontier of internet money and internet finance. This is how to get started, how to get better, and how to frontrun the opportunity. I'm Ryan Chan Adams, I'm joined by David Hoffman, and we're here to help you become more bankless. David, Metallic on the podcast, again, another cannot miss episode. What did we talk about? We talked about legitimacy, this invisible force that Metallic has named as legitimacy that we are exploring in today's podcast. We go through the ways that the concept of legitimacy impacts our lives, our lives as individuals and our lives as part of a greater society.
And Metallic makes the claim that legitimacy is one of the world's most powerful forces. And as a society, we don't really talk about it, but it really guides a lot of our day-to-day lives. And it's even more true in the cryptocurrency space. And I think the fact that legitimacy is one of the most powerful forces in the cryptocurrency space is perhaps why this space is so revolutionary. The answer is the questions as to why this industry is so bottom up, why this industry is by the people for the people, because the people are enabled to bestow legitimacy on the things that they see are good.
We talk about a number of different subjects, both in and outside of the world of cryptocurrency, where legitimacy really has the reins as to what is true and how the world moves forward. And so really enjoy this conversation with Metallic buterin, as always. Yeah, I guess I, you know, I'd say a couple of things that's really impressed upon me with this episode. I feel like if you don't understand the concept of legitimacy, if you don't call it legitimacy, you don't really understand what's going on in crypto. Because legitimacy is really the answer to so many of the questions, like even basic questions, David, why is cryptocurrency trading over $2 trillion?
Right. We're going to grow like, you know, 11 to 12 years ago is when it started. How did we come this far? The answer legitimacy. Why are NFTs valuable? Why was a people NFT? Why did that sell for 68 million dollars? Answer legitimacy. How come when I like try to fork a Bitcoin, how come you can't fork your own Bitcoin, create your own alternative, how come I can't do it, how come there is only one Bitcoin answer legitimacy. Why will, why do we have confidence that Ethereum's monetary policy won't change in the direction of increasing inflation, but only will change in the direction of decreasing inflation answer legitimacy.
Kind of the answer. It's almost like the theory of everything for crypto and until you understand it, like I don't know that you have comprehensive answers to all of these most common questions. Vitalik said it's legitimacy all the way down. I think he's right. And we can even go all the way back into history, modern history and talk about the current situation going on in Russia with Alexei Navalny, but we can go all the way back to just very historical primal examples of how humans choose to coordinate and how legitimacy is like this emergent higher order of acceptance of society and how when everyone chooses the same outcome that outcome is bestowed with legitimacy.
And we can kind of build our social organizations upon that initial kernel of legitimacy and that initial kernel of legitimacy carries on forwards into history. And into the future and gains legitimacy every step of the way. So while it is extremely apt for the world of crypto, it also helps answered so many of the other questions that I think are really confusing to people today in modern society, like why is the left and the right in America have so much strife between them, why do we distrust institutions at all legitimacy has a hand in answering I think every modern day social question. So Vitalik is like again part, part technical mind, part philosopher, part anthropologist just has a fantastic lens on legitimacy.
So he was the perfect guest to explain it and he wrote a fantastic post that we base this episode on so that is the bulk of the conversation you're not going to want to miss it. We also toward the end we talked about Vitalik's thoughts on ultra sound money on either issue. And so I thought that was a definitely stay tuned for that. That was a very interesting part of the conversation and we ended in him giving us a snapshot of time Ethereum in 2021 what is in in store for it as a network will it become a global store of value reserve asset even reflected on that too. So this is an episode you do not want to miss David and I are giving some more convert, we have some more conversation about this episode in the debrief.
So if you are a premium subscriber, you should already have access to that at shows dot bankless HQ dot com. So with that, we want to thank the sponsors that made this episode possible. Bankless is proud to be supported by UNISWAP. UNISWAP is a new paradigm in asset exchange infrastructure. Instead of a cumbersome order book system where trades are matched with other humans, UNISWAP is an autonomous piece of software on Ethereum, which is what Ryan and I call a money robot. No human counterparties or centralized intermediaries, just autonomous code on Ethereum input the token you want to sell and receive the token you want to buy.
Something brand new in the UNISWAP ecosystem is the UNISWAP grants program is now accepting applications for grants. We have been saying this for a while and we'll say it again. Dows have money and they are in need of labor. If you think that you have something to contribute to the UNISWAP Dow, apply for a grant to UNISWAP. Just look at the size of the UNISWAP Treasury. It's almost $3 billion. This mountain of capital is looking for labor. Do you have something of value to contribute to the UNISWAP Dow? No matter how big or small your idea is, you can apply for a unigrant at unigrants.org and help steer UNISWAP in the direction that you think it should go.
That's exactly what we did to get UNISWAP to be a sponsor for bankless and you can do the same for your project. Thank you UNISWAP for sponsoring bankless. Synthetics is Ethereum's decentralized derivatives liquidity protocol. What does that mean? Synthetics is a platform for creating and trading synthetic assets which are assets that are priced via an Oracle rather than bids or asks. Traders can use the Quenta exchange which hosts and trades all of the synthetic assets created by Synthetics. Traders on Quenta can trade synthetic tokens like SBTC, S-OIL or S-D-FI. Because Quenta is powered by Synthetics, Traders experience zero slippage on their trades.
No, I didn't mean low slippage. I meant no slippage because that is the power of the Synthetics platform. No slippage on your trades. You can also easily short assets with I-Synths which are synthetic assets that move inversely to their target asset. Synthetics isn't just for traders. Developers can build on Synthetics to access the infinite liquidity offered by synthetic assets or investors can stake collateral to the protocol and earn fees that the protocol collects. If you're a trader and you're looking for a trading platform and not found in the legacy world, check out Quenta.io. If you're a developer or you just want to earn yield on your collateral, go to www.
Synthetics.io where you can stake your SNX or ETH and earn fees from Synthetics. Welcome, Bankless Nation. We have Vitalik buterin back on the podcast and Vitalik you recently wrote a piece titled the most important scarce resource is legitimacy and we are going to be talking a lot about legitimacy today on this episode. Vitalik, welcome back to Bankless. How are you doing today, sir? Thank you. I'm doing great and it's good to be back on Bankless. The greatest Ethereum podcast that's here. Wow. Wow. You heard it here, folks. It was a T.M. I want to know who has the T.M. though. Hopefully that is settled on Ethereum and not in the nation state.
Vitalik, you started off your blog post illustrating this massive difference between Ethereum and Bitcoin security budgets versus how much each of these respective systems allocates towards research and development expenses. Bitcoin is paying miners $38 million in block rewards plus $5 million more in fees per day and Ethereum is doing $19.5 million in block rewards plus $18 million in transaction fees per day all going to security which is a necessary expense. But you just suppose this with how much the Ethereum foundation has to spend on research and development which is just $30 million per year and you do a similar compare and contrast verse like the Bitcoin innovation expenditures as well, which is similarly very, very low versus the security budget for for the Bitcoin blockchain.
You didn't you didn't do this to suggest that Ethereum and Bitcoin should find ways to direct some of their security budget to pay for human salaries for research and development but rather as a thought experiment as to why this crazy discrepancy and funding exists and why we are okay with massively overpaying for security. There are two paragraphs that I want to read out that are in the blog post themselves for the listeners that haven't actually read the piece you wrote even though we could easily identify some valuable public goods to redirect some funding to as a one off making a regular institutionalized pattern of such decisions carries risks of political chaos and capture that are in the long run not with it.
So I'm going to talk about this with this interesting fact that the organisms that are Bitcoin and Ethereum ecosystems are capable of summoning up billions of dollars of capital but have strange and hard to understand restrictions on where that capital can go. The capital force that underlies all sorts of extremely powerful mechanisms far beyond the blockchain space for this reason that will be clear in the upcoming sections of the article. I will give this powerful social force a name legitimacy the powerful social force that is creating this effect is worth understanding. We would love to explore the power and value of legitimacy with you today so let's start with this very basic question what is legitimacy.
So the thought experiment that I just started the post with right it's basically a kind of calling attention to this strange fact that. Like ecosystems and like groups of humans more generally they have a kind of physical ability to summon up resources like each of us has the physical ability to summon up a certain number of hours of effort every week we have a certain amount of physical resources at hand and so forth. But then there also seems to be this different thing this kind of social ability to actually summon up and direct resources to work particular tasks. And our ability to socially direct resources to work particular tasks is often a kind of wildly out of sync with the physical ability to direct resources that's in the hands of each individual person right and so in this example like we.
Clearly have the physical ability to summon up resources worth billions of dollars potentially to any task but we get socially seem to have the ability to put those resources to ward network security but we don't have the same ability to put those resources to ward other things and like. Funding risk protocol research and development is one big example right and so you start thinking about why this is the case right and we also let us start thinking about well why is it the case that we have these kind of socially mediated resources in a lot of other contexts more broadly right so like a bit after this I brought up this case of.
The steam project and how a Justin Sun bought up a bunch of the steam tokens and he started using them to try to kind of consolidate power and sort of do an authoritarian takeover the steam network, but then the community just like you know no screw you we're going to make our own fork and we're going to delete your money in the fork right and. The fact that this was possible is basically proof that well actually a Justin Sun regardless of what any larger theoretically said never actually owns those coins right like if you own something you have the ability to use it for whatever you want to see clearly as demonstrated by reality did not have the ability to use those coins.
But for whatever he wanted I see his ownership of the coins was actually kind of controlled by these unwritten social contracts that the steam company had with the community that he then inherited when he bought steam the company. We have these situations where basically large collections of resources are controlled not by like physical force not even by private keys and not by any kind of formal arrangement of individuals but by a social contract right and so. Like this is what happens in the answer like with say a blockchain right like if you're watching for example like it's clearly capable of making the decision to switch from.
It's pumping five million dollars a year into proof of work to pump or five million a year into proof of work to pumping one million a year into proof of stake. But it would not be capable of us switching to pumping one million a year into say life extension research even though like I personally really love life extension research and lots of other people of life extension research. So like we need to just like properly think about and understand this concept like what does it mean for coins to be owned by social contracts like what is actually happening in this phenomenon how do we describe this phenomenon.
And if we understand this phenomenon better like it's clearly this very powerful social forest that you know we could potentially even try to like apply and try to use it to find more all kinds of good things that we and that we like. So then I get to this concept of legitimacy right and so the idea behind the legitimacy is basically that like in society in general there's a lot of cases where there's some action or there's some pattern of behavior. And there's this shared except expectation that some pattern of behavior is something that's supposed to happen. And everyone plays their part in enacting the facts that this is a pattern of behavior that's supposed to happen because like at least in in big part because they expect everyone else to share that pattern as well right.
So like the simplest example of this is like which side of the road do you drive on right and I mean for most people listening to this it's you know you can be sure on the right side of the road but no for some in some places on the left side of the road and like there isn't really any like coherent reason why one is better than the other. But there's no right side of the road maximalist then Vittale. Yeah, I guess maybe there are a few but like again to be honest like i'm not really a car person so I say yeah like yeah I had to think for a couple of seconds to remember like which side of the road is which.
But the point is that like even if you know tomorrow the police can be we disappeared you know there are some things that would start going wrong but like I would predict that almost all people like say in the United States which is peaceful we keep driving on the correct side of the road and not driving on the incorrect side of the road because they know that. You know if they start driving on the incorrect side of the road like that's just going against the consensus is the thing that's like is a thing that's bad both for society and for themselves. Like and like there's just this high cost of disrupting the consensus and it's a high cost both of both to kind of the wider society and just a high risk to themselves personally.
And so they just continue driving on the correct side of the road and by doing that they just sort of become part of the process of enacting this consensus. And this is something that exists in a lot of social situations right so like one example of this closer to home in the watching space is like if you look at something like the down for right like. There's the question of you know is what's the down fork legitimate right and if you think that the down fork is legitimate then what when the down fork is happening then you're going to you know go and peacefully download the Ethereum client that implements the down the down fork and you're if you run some Ethereum service you're going to hook up that clients to that particular or your Ethereum service to the client that implements the down fork.
You would talk about if you're going to talk about it as being the coins the coins that are on the down fork. But if you do not like recognize the down fork is being legitimate then you're going to do the opposite and you're just going to keep running the client that does not implement the down for right and so. This is also one of those situations where like you have a yeah there are reasons to wants to favor one side or the other but there also is this kind of strong overriding pressure to sort of favor the side that is brought it everyone else broadly accepts and like this. This pattern of kind of everyone watching what everyone else's expectations are informing their own expectations based on that and like this kind of pattern right of like everyone watching everyone else and this being motivated even in part because like there is even an over this big self self interest and going along with the consensus like this pattern is the thing that I call legitimacy right and so.
Like in 2016 like we found you know the down fork is what was legitimate and in 2017 and the big one. Segwit for example was legitimate and like I'm using the word legitimate in this area kind of positive sense right this is positive as opposed to normative like something could be a legitimate even if you don't like it right like you know the government of North Korea is a legitimate inside of North Korea because there's a pattern of acting like it is so. But like this is the kind of like the social force that we're talking about right like it's you know basically which side of the equilibrium curve fall either way and the question is like which side does it fall on and that ends up just like deciding a huge number of things in the world.
Guys when when I read this post it was sort of a missing link for me because I think legitimacy is a hidden forest is another popular. And so that's why it is so important to understand what it is and and to get your your mind wrapped around this as a mental model. Like is basically in in 2016 with the Dow hard fork there was a fight for legitimacy of which is the the real Ethereum quote unquote and it seems to be the case that the real Ethereum is the Ethereum that did hard fork as a result of of maybe the market cap of Ethereum the DeFi economy that's built on top of it. The community that the Ethereum economy has versus the Ethereum classic fork so that was really a I guess a battle a social coordination game for legitimacy that's how you'd frame it.
Absolutely. And so this was the fetus of this tokens because there was this invisible force this hidden force that exists out there in the world that in inf that force was allowed to influence the control over the system and the force of legitimacy actually put the power of ownership over the steam ecosystem into the hands of the community and away from jump from Justin son. happened, we can retroactively look at what happened and say that, well, Justin Sun had the tokens, but they were removed from him by this invisible power that is legitimacy. And so there is a, is a, while we can't feel it, while it doesn't exist anywhere, it's not tangible.
There is this hidden social force out there, kind of like the dark matter of the universe, this, this hidden force of legitimacy that is directing our lives, both in, like, both in the meat space and in the crypto space, and perhaps especially in the crypto space, anything you want to add on to that. I think that's definitely an excellent summer. And I think like these kinds of hidden forces are definitely everywhere. And they're extremely strong in the crypto space, I think, because the crypto space is like really all about just kind of trying to summon up value and entirely out of a conception of legitimacy in a lot of ways, right?
Like the crypto space control is no physical resources. The crypto space that controls no legal rights, the crypto space controls no guns and boats. So like, you know, what gives Bitcoin the value of what that it has, what gives you the value that it has like legitimacy is pretty much entirely responsible for these things. It's very much a battle for hearts and minds. It's a battle on the layer zero, sort of the, the social layer, as we've said before, I want to prompt back to the original story that David opened with just to see if we can tie that on a boat and maybe answer the question of why legitimacy was such a factor there.
And then we can define legitimacy, legitimacy, a bit more in other contexts. But the reason that Ethereum couldn't just siphon off issuance and put it into a development fund was because we don't like, there's no legitimacy in the governance of that development fund. So if you propose an EIP, for instance, to create Ethereum issuance to fund charity of your choice, that would be an illegitimate use of the Ethereum social contract. I remember just a quick story back in 2019, this was actually sort of a real thing that was contemplated. We were in the depths of the bear market Ethereum. There was kind of the question of, is Ethereum dead?
Price was down, the community was discouraged, even though we were building so much during that time, it was sort of a discouraging time for many being in the space. And an EIP was proposed to answer the question that you posited at the beginning of your article, which is, how do we make sure that Ethereum client development at the protocol level is funded into the future? And so EIP 2025 was proposed. And the title of the CIP was block rewards proposal for funding eith 1.x. And what it actually did was it proposed funding to a good cause, which is the future development of Ethereum and Ethereum clients and the Ethereum protocol.
And there were a number of great people behind this. Kevin O'Walky was one who created a fantastic distribution mechanism, public goods funding mechanism in Gitcoin. But the difference is this is embedding some sort of issuance to some third party, unnamed third party on the base layer, which is a question of legitimacy. And at the time, I felt like Ethereum needed a bit of a wake up call, a bit more of kind of a Bitcoin or mindset of what could happen if we are naive about the issue of legitimacy. I didn't call it then. And I created a EIP 202208 as just kind of a joke. I'm not sure it landed among everyone, but this was sort of a riff off of the other proposal.
And I basically proposed the IP to report to award block rewards to thought leaders, people in the media space with great Twitter accounts. I think some in the Ethereum community felt like I wasn't being maybe sanctimonious enough about the EIP process. It was it was a joke, but I surfaced the joke. That was the point, that was the point satire. But I surfaced the joke in order to provoke this, this very conversation. If an EIP could be proposed to siphon off issuance for development, why couldn't it be proposed to siphon off issuance for anything? And then what's the governance process for that EIP getting passed?
And it was very hard to justify the legitimacy of those things. Any, any thoughts or reflections on all of that? Yeah, I think let's, you definitely gave a good summary. I would say one of the things that became obvious as a result of that is, and then here we can probably kind of go down a bit to what I talked about in the next section of the post is like where legitimacy comes from, right? Like what kinds of sources of legitimacy there are. And my point there is that like the legitimacy is something that can theoretically come from a lot of places, but it's really heavily independent on a human coordination and consensus.
And so legitimacy can most easily come from like things that intuitively appeal across a broad group of people. And so I gave a few examples, right? Like one example of legitimacy is just legitimacy by brute force, right? Like if someone takes over some community or takes a really strong influence in some community, even if they're not liked, if they're feared by enough people, then people kind of get into this mode where like people realize that no one else is brave enough to stand up against them. And so they, and so they themselves start being not being brave enough to stand against them. And like this isn't a pattern of legitimacy that everyone likes, but you know, it is still a pattern of legitimacy, right?
Is another of this the nation state brute force, Vitalik? Sure. Yes. And many nation states are definitely in the example of this. A second example is legitimacy by fairness, right? And you know, this is a conception of legitimacy that I think we all consider to be much more pro-social, right? And so something is like gains legitimacy if it's perceived as like satisfying some intuitive conception of, you know, being fair of not unfairly favoring some groups of people over other groups of people, the concept of credible neutrality that I wrote about last year, like kind of really ties into this, right?
And I think this gets to the core of why I say funding network security is much more easily accepted than funding developments. Because network security is a very cleanly defined thing. And it's also a process that at least formally anyone can kind of come in and participate in on a kind of formally equal terms. And so it's something that people fairly easily accept as like, yes, this is something we all agree is necessary. And yes, this is something that we all agree is not a give away to a certain group of people, right? And so we're okay with funding blockchains for network security. But once say you start funding developments, the problem is that I think it needs 2025, it didn't just say we want to redirect 0.
45 ETH per block to developers and said we want to redirect 0.04, 5 ETH per block or whatever the number was maybe also for for to this specific group of people that we consider to be that is one point X team, right? And so in order to be okay with that EIP, like you basically had to have an opinion, not just about the cause, but also about that particular group of people. And so that's not a very socially scalable thing to try to convince people of. And that's something that just does not benefit from a legitimacy by fairness at all, right? So now theoretically, like if someone had proposed it, like if Bitcoin grants quadratic funding had existed and someone had proposed to get going to grant quadratic funding as a recipient of that 0.
04, for that, like maybe it would have been more successful. And like maybe one could imagine, you know, a world sometimes down the future where the Ethereum ecosystem has a big enough funding crisis that people realize that, you know, public goods funding is something just needs to be expanded upon and someone suggests, hey, you know, let's take like 20% of like say the EAP 1559 burden directed it to get going grants and like that actually gets accepted. Like that's something that I think the Ethereum ecosystem is far away from today. But, you know, if in the future, like there's just a large necessity for public goods on a larger scale, then as possible, it was just people's existing funds, like that's something that can see, if a way the community could move, could move to word accepting, and it would have an easier time accepting that than it would accepting, you know, hey, let's give 0.
04, 5 years per block to like Alex, the agreement of steam or even suggested Drake's team or to my or to some team led by myself or to pretty much anything that's like organized around specific people. So that's like another example, but, you know, at the same time, like even still like the thing that has even more legitimacy is like instead of trying to change the layer one base, change the base layer is to try to do these things at higher levels of layers of the EAP system, right? Because like status quo pressure itself is something that has higher legitimacy at layer one than it does not layer two.
So that's, so that's legitimacy by fairness. There's also legitimacy by process. So legitimacy by process basically says, if a process is fair, then outputs of that process are fair. There's legitimacy by performance. So if a process had good results in the past, then that process becomes something negative and so legitimacy over time, there's legitimacy by participation. So a mechanism where people feel like they can be part of enacting the process is a mechanism that people are likely to accept more easily. So there's all of these kind of complicated concepts that affect people's perceptions of what is legitimate and what isn't, right?
And like they interact in complicated ways, right? And like the way that public goods funding happens, you know, within the Ethereum ecosystem and even beyond the Ethereum ecosystem is very heavily influenced by all of these things. So these are some of the sources of where legitimacy comes from. And I want to kind of quickly maybe recap some of these for folks. So you said legitimacy by brute force, we defined that legitimacy by fairness, we talked about that a bit. The example of legitimacy by a process, something that most many listeners are familiar with, of course, is probably a democracy, right?
So if I have the ability to vote on a new leader every four years, I'm probably less angry when the the person I picked doesn't go through. And I'm less likely to revolt because, hey, this is just part of the process. I get to pick every four years, so does everyone else. And another four years, I'll get another shot at it. So I'm not going to lead the revolution and support, you know, Canada X as a result. That's an example of legitimacy by process, right? Right. Now, so legitimacy by process goes from process to outcomes. The one right after that is legitimacy by performance, which goes from outcomes to process, right?
And so I gave the example that democracy is an example of legitimacy process, successful dictatorships, sometimes are described as getting legitimacy by performance, like, you know, this person ran the country for 30 or this group of people ran the country for 30 years. And like, we've had six and a half percent said, yeah, economic growth for most of those years, when the rest of the world was moving forward more slowly. And so like, they gain legitimate, like they gain legitimacy as a process as a result of like them being able to achieve this outcome. Now, once again, I was going to say, I just can't help like weaving in some kind of crypto lessons here, because I feel like there are many cryptocurrencies right now that get at least some short-term legitimacy by performance.
So people observe this coin price go up. Oh, it must mean that this is a good asset. It must mean that this chain is decentralized. It must mean that this chain is long lasting, you know, chains like the Binance chain, for example, they are having some success with DeFi, quote, unquote. And so this is legitimacy by by performance, essentially. Yep, that's absolutely true. And the legitimacy by performance is definitely one of those interesting things because it's often how a kind of intellectual revolution happens. Like, there's this sort of equilibrium of conformism among, you know, the right thinking people where the right thinking people have certain ideas that they think are legitimate.
But then something outside of those ideas just starts performing and he keeps performing and it keeps performing. And the people within this kind of self-affirming circle of intellectuals just keep ignoring it for a long time. But then eventually, like, people that are kind of further away from the center, like they just see, you know, hey, this thing on the outside is performing well. And, you know, we don't give a crap about these principles like look, this thing is successful. And like that often ends up reserving things, right? And that's something that some like, once again, you know, I have to keep giving this disclaimer, right?
Like the legitimacy does not something being legitimate does not mean that you like the thing, right? And sometimes the thing that you like loses legitimacy and a thing that you don't like gains legitimacy. One interesting thing that I think the US might be experiencing over the last 10 years or so is actually, it feels the process of democracy is actually losing some legitimacy. And so like one example of this, right, is that on the Democrat side, like we saw the whole not my president move movement, you know, hashtag back in 2017. And that's a very direct and literal example of basically just declaring, hey, I'm going to dip my toes into like basically saying, well, you know, too bad if he was elected by democratic process.
Like I just think that this part that this new person is horrible. And that just overrides the process. And then, of course, on the other side, you know, in to the in 2021, we saw, you know, people denying the legitimacy of the election results, right? And so on both sides, like you, if he wants to try to kind of like analyze that from a social science perspective, you know, that's a process just like people are sort of dipping their toes into the idea of just not accepting the outcome of the process and just acting like, well, if they don't like the results, they should just act like the result isn't a yellow legitimate result.
And you could you you can argue performance is like one of one of the reasons behind that, right? So like this is an example of a of how transitions in legitimacy could happen. And like once again, you know, sometimes these transitions happen in directions that you like, sometimes these transitions happen in directions that you don't like, right? In the crypto space and other example of this is proof of state, right? Like the legitimacy of proof of state, like does a chain running on proof of state sort of get the aura of being a first class decentralized system that you want to put your applications on to.
And that's something that I think is like is rising over time, right? Like maybe five years ago, the proof of work had much more legitimacy, but now as Ethereum's proof of state is getting closer, as we see more and more chains running on proof of state, like it's becoming just more and more accepted by this larger and larger community. And that's something that you know, is definitely really disliked by this kind of self affirming clique of intellectuals within the Bitcoin group of work camp. And they just like keep on shouting their arguments about, no, nothing at stake, no costless simulation, no rich get richer.
And no, of course, you know, we have our intellectual rebuttals to that. But like the it's almost the fact that the intellectual rebuttals are now gaining steam is I mean, but in part, I like I want to think that it's because my arguments are logically amazing, but you know, we as you said, it's not just because the arguments are logically amazing, it's also because of legitimacy by performance of this kind of hidden social forest that subconsciously influencing everyone. And Ethereum just looks like something that's strong and looks like something that's rising. And so that's something that you know, people wants to kind of rally behind, right?
So let's talk about two more of a talent that that you have these these like theories of legitimacy. As we said, we talked about continuity fairness process performance. You mentioned very briefly legitimacy by participation. But I think that's an important one in the context of crypto and has many many aspects. So the fact that anyone can open an Ethereum address, right? All you need is an internet connection. That's something you don't get in the traditional banking system, for instance. So that is more participation. The fact that anyone in a more decentralized proof of stake network can spin up an Ethereum node, validator node provided that you have the necessary stake to validate.
It's much more permissionless. Democracies have legitimacy by not just process, but also participation in that every citizen has the ability to vote. Talk a bit more about legitimacy by participation. Then we'll talk about the last one, which is legitimacy by continuity. And that'll give us a grounding for the rest of this. So what about participation? Sure. So legitimacy by participation, basically, just means, you know, if the process just gives you and gives its participants and ability to actually shape it be part of the outcome of the process, then this is something that people are likely to accept.
And participation is not just fairness, right? I think it's like part of it is fairness because systems that everyone can participate in are systems that are more likely to be fair. But it's also a somewhat different psychological force, right? It's more like if you it's like a desire to have a force sort of psychological self-consistency. Like once you go to the ballot box and you make a vote, like you feel invested in the process. And like you feel like, you know, you are a person who is part of doing implementing the democracy thing. And so this, you know, makes you wants to also be a person who is part of implementing the democracy thing in other contexts, right?
And, you know, in the case of the blockchain, your ability to run a node is definitely legitimacy by participation. And it's also other kinds of legitimacy as well, right? It's also just kind of like intellectual legitimacy of just the idea that self-verification is important. And it's like a key part of what makes something a blockchain instead of making it a making it a centralized system. There's some legitimacy by fairness in there as well. Dick Wayne grants is also another example of legitimacy by participation. Like, you know, you yourself can affect which direction the matching pod goes if like you go and participate.
So I guess like one example of this, right? Is that like there are fair systems that you can't participate in, right? So like, for example, if you're 16 years old, then you cannot yet vote. But even if you're 16, like you might be, you might still be convinced by the intellectual arguments that, you know, the average 16 year old is a lower quality political participant than the average adults. And so like they did, we can debate how true that is, but what's with that aside? You might be convinced by the arguments. And you might like, and so, you know, you might still accept democracy being fair despite the fact that only 18 year olds can participate.
But, you know, you're still not going to get the legitimacy by participation components. But and so like this might be part of why, you know, there actually are all of these like youth political movements and like schools and, you know, like often actively encourage like kind of teenagers to start, you know, doing doing civic engagement of some kind, right? Like it's this alternative route to actually getting legitimacy like participation I kind of started earlier. So this is definitely something that happens a lot. And I definitely think that like decentralized systems heavily benefit from this because like there's no part of a decentralized system that is closed off to you, right?
If you want to read the chain, you can read the chain. If you want to send the transaction, you can send the transaction. If you want to participate in consensus, you can go participate in consensus. So like that aspect where like there is no part of the chain that of the chain's activity that is not something that you can conceivably be part of is something that I think like it does really contribute to the legitimacy of public chains. And it's something that I think like is one reason why kind of like more fully decentralized systems like Ethereum and Bitcoin are likely to have more legitimacy than these like more semi centralized chains that really that like intrinsically depend on delegated pools, right?
Because like if you have one of these chains that like relies on like mandatory delegated pools and there's only 21 validators lots, well, you know, everyone knows that they have no chance in hell of becoming one of the 21. And so, you know, like the idea that like you are a second class participants in like there is this one class of a part of participant that's above you in a formal sense. So I think that is going to weigh out you to some extent. Absolutely. So all of these theories of legitimacy we're talking about so much about where we're making analogs to traditional institutions is because legitimacy underpins is the foundation for all traditional institutions.
And of course, blockchains public blockchains cannot like Ethereum cannot use legitimacy by brute force violence is just not an option. So legitimacy needs to come from all of these other sources that we've just named the last one. And then we'll we'll continue on with the conversation is legitimacy by continuity. And I think that's an important applicable one in crypto. Maybe maybe this has some relationship to what we have called previously the Lindy effect. So the idea that if something is legitimate at time t by definition, it is legitimate at time t plus one into the future. Perhaps even more legitimate at t plus one.
Exactly. And so big coiners will say yes. And the Bitcoin network has been humming for the last decade plus. And it's monetary policy has not changed. It has continuity. And therefore, it is a good store of value. Can you reflect on legitimacy by continuity in time? Yeah. And I think legitimacy by continuity is important because it just is the reason why we can have these like social structures that last for like longer than a week at all, right? Like if we did not have legitimacy by continuity at all, then, you know, every political system would be up for like total revaluation, you know, every Tuesday.
And if people thought in this way, then like, you know, it'll just be like hard to coordinate things that last longer than a week. And that's like it's one of those things that we think about the least because it's just something that like by definition happens by default, but it is important, right? And as you said, like the longer a system lasts, then, you know, the longer it does acquire this salinity value. And you know, when you are people are coming in and they're trying to like see, you know, what is the system that I should get behind because it's the one that I expect other people to be getting behind.
Like it's the this long track record of survival is definitely one of the factors that they're taking into consideration. So Vitalik, the through line that I'm really seeing here with all these different forces that a legitimacy arise from is is we call this a social force. And it feels very much like a a bottom up force, a populous force. People choose in these various different mechanisms what is legitimate versus what's not. But is legitimacy explicitly a bottom up phenomenon in the article you wrote in general legitimacy arises because the thing that gains legitimacy is psychologically appealing to most people.
Does that mean that legitimacy is a people first force? Um, legitimacy definitely is something that comes from people first, but two caveats, right? Like, or one caveat basically is that the things that gains legitimacy can be something that's very centralized, right? Like, for example, you know, within the Shron ecosystem, you know, like Justin Sun has a huge amount of legitimacy. Within, you know, the Bitcoin SV ecosystem, Craig Wright has a lot of legitimacy. And of course, the centralized figure can in a lot of cases also gain legitimacy by brute force as well, right? So it is something that comes from the people, but the consequences that it has and the things that it empowers can be centralized in some way, a lot of the time.
And so that is something that is worth watching out for. Right. And so even with, but even with a dictatorship where, you know, legitimacy comes from just raw unbridled power, which the people must be subservient to, even then it's still kind of a bottom up force because the collective people identify that there's a lot of power there. And so they should be subservient to it. And even then we've, we've seen instances throughout history where there is this top-down control. And then something happens that allows the people to question that control. And there's a collective shift where everyone realizes that perhaps they actually have the power to determine what's legitimate.
And there's a populist uprising. Right. So using these kind of mental models, let's talk about a stable equilibrium. How do we find stable equilibrium when it comes to legitimacy and all these other sources of legitimacy that we've gone through? Again, I think that equilibrium are stable most of the time. Right. Like the, the shift in equilibrium is one of those things that's like more catastrophist and gradualist to use in evolutionary analogy. Right. It's a, the sort of thing that kind of is steady for a long time. And then like sometimes you can see that when a shift begins, the shift starts off slow at, at times.
And the shift starts slow. And then when the shift gets to a certain critical point, it just happens quickly. Right. And the reason why things work this way is because like just going back to kind of my characterization of what the legitimate phenomenon is, it's a pattern of people behaving in a certain way because they see everyone else behaving in that way. And like there's a big risk to stepping out of line alone that doesn't exist if everyone steps out of line at the same time. Right. And so if everyone considers some idea or some conception as being legitimate and that's something that's very strong, then if you start kind of going against it, then you're not likely to have much of an effect.
And you're even likely to like see it at best waste time and at most like kind of hurt your own interests by going against it. But then the thing that you can do is that you can sort of start like dipping your feet a little and you can start like say publicly questioning the concept slightly, but not actually going against it in your actions. And then once the first person who does that, they do incur some social cost, but then the second person who does that, it occurs a lower social cost. And so the legitimacy starts kind of slowly decreasing over time. And then eventually there does some come some critical points where like people have done enough public questioning of the concept that it just what it can start flipping from like resistance to the old equilibrium being underground to resistance to the old equilibrium being like very open and very overgrounds fairly quickly.
Right. So I think the more interesting way to frame the question is actually not even how do you identify conceptions of legitimacy being stable because that's the norm. The interesting thing to identify is like how do you identify when a big shift in the AI conception of all legitimacy is about to happen. And I think people have an intuitive feel for these things, especially because in the last five years or so in both crypto and in the world in general, like we've had some of these shifts in legitimacy and they like you can feel at how these things sort of happen gradually and then they happen suddenly.
And sometimes only when they happen suddenly, do you look back and do you realize that like, hey, these things that people were saying and that you're into the two or three years before that actually were pretty alluded to that. I think a very relevant current event here is the Alexi Navalny case with with Russia and Vladimir Putin right now where Alexi Navalny was ostracized from from Russia. He fled. He was poisoned by the Russian inner party that he comes back to Russia and was immediately jailed and is now perhaps on like the last strings of his life in jail under Vladimir Putin. And what you just said recently was that the first person to question legitimacy probably loses a lot of social power and social force.
But then what that person is doing is allows for the people to come after them to more easily question the legitimacy. And if this trajectory flows, Alexi Navalny, who is already a hero of the Russian people and there's already this showing of solidarity behind this individual, I think will a very apt current event to illustrate the power of legitimacy is going on right now in Russia. And I think that would be a useful mental model for listeners to really understand how legitimacy is flowing in current times. Right. Yeah, now it's definitely really interesting, although of course very unfortunate for Alexi, as well, in a situation to be watching.
It's the question to see us basically to what extent or whether or not a serious equilibrium flip does actually happen. Equal equilibrium for lips have happened before in Russia. The whole switch from communism to post-communism was one of those big examples of an equilibrium flip. And you know, someone like my dad definitely remembers it how it was out as it was happening. So that's like there's two ways that it could go, right? Like it could either kind of continue snowballing and eventually, you know, big V either has to make serious concessions or he kind of actually ends up giving you getting taken out of power somehow or in the other possibility, of course, is that it does just sort of fizzle over time.
And the sort of equilibrium does kind of reestablish itself. But even if the equilibrium reestablishes itself, like I think it definitely would be a shift from like like legitimate civil high performance, which is the thing that I think did sort of boy up for the first 10 years of his presidency to like be just like clearer kind of just like brute legitimacy by brute force. And that kind of switch is something that like Kurt can't have like bad long term consequences for him and his government as well. So yeah, I mean, we'll see how it goes, saying I definitely wish the best for the Russian people as I've been on Russian myself.
But we'll see how this goes. Another example that I think is kind of visceral that you give in the article is kind of the general in the army example, or maybe a captain in the army. And I really enjoy listening to Dan Carlin's hardcore history. I don't know if you guys have ever listened to it, but I listen to all of them. Okay, well amazing. So he did this whole series called King of Kings. And it was basically Persian Assyrian history. Anyway, there are many episodes in that like hours of listening. If you get bored of bankless guys, it's a little, you know, get bored of crypto, go to Dan Carlin.
But he gives very visceral examples of what it was like to fight at the front lines of, you know, an ancient army essentially. And the captain or the commander's main job was social coordination. The captain had to make sure that his troops would not break rank because if the line broke, there would inevitably be a slaughter. And so the captain would have to have a show of confidence be, you know, decorated and like, you know, bright armor, be standing be sitting on a horse and had to instill this confidence because every soldier with the prospect of certain death and another army about to come kill them, very nervous at that time.
What you're doing as a soldier is you're kind of looking around to your fellow soldiers and you're saying, oh, is he going to run? Is he going to run? Right. So it's like this, it's like this real time human coordination, social coordination game being played out at the highest stakes. That was a fascinating example of how I think some of these legitimacy mechanisms almost emerge in human behavior. Can you talk about that a little bit like sort of the emergence? There's a line from your article that says, with any coordination games that exist for long enough, they're inevitably emerged some mechanisms.
These are not necessarily defined mechanisms in words or legal language, but these are mechanisms nonetheless that emerge. Can you talk about that a bit? Yeah, I think human behavior in general and I just specially collective behavior very easily falls into patterns and it's just something that naturally it happens over time, right? And you can see why it happens. It's easier for each individual person to just repeat the same habits that they've grown accustomed to and then it is for them to follow up their habits and it's also easier to continue a long habit because getting an entire group of people to switch is something that's even harder.
So the ancient armies are definitely a great example. It's fascinating how while two armies are fighting each other head to head, there's generally not too many casualties at least immediately. But then once one of the armies does that equilibrium flip and it starts routing, that's when the carnage begins. Whether or not the equilibrium flips is one of the most important things in a battle and it's something that the captain has to try really hard to prevent. And that's one of those cases where yes, soldiers are exactly like they're watching each other they're seeing who's going to, are these people going to run?
Are these people not going to run? And if other people run, but then you start running five seconds later, like just what, you're at the back of the line and you're the first that's going to get a sort or an accident in the back of your spine. But if you start running and other people don't run, then well, you're a deserter and you're like, we did get your head chopped off by your own army at the end of the battle. So that's, it's a perfect example and it's really tough to be in that kind of situation. And the thing that everyone wants to do is just like see what everyone else is doing because like they just feel like acting the same way that everyone else acts like just is the okay way to act.
Like does this explain maximalism almost sort of an ardent maximalism? David that is before has called some ardent maximalist like almost like barrier troops, right? That prevent your own army. I think that's definitely a fascinating example. Definitely a big grid. Like intellectual legitimacy in general is a really important type of legitimacy. And it's just having people out there just like, you know, saying the Rod Rossilokins and like talking about how they're going to fight till the end and how their belief in the cause is unconditional is definitely a way of like just showing other like the other people in the community that, you know, there is at least this group of people that, you know, is not going to flee before me.
So it's safe. It's kind of safe for me to continue being part of this. And, you know, continue. I'm going to shout this out into myself that absolutely is a thing that happens. Well, but some of it's logical too. And I'll give an example for bankless listeners will listen a few podcasts a day ago. We had on Hatsu who is a crypto researcher also involved in the the Ethereum community, someone who I consider intellectual has some fantastic ideas. And toward the end of that episode, he said something that kind of blew my mind. He said that, you know, there are many, including himself in the Bitcoin community that know that the long-term security model of Bitcoin fixed cap is actually flawed.
But then he also followed up by this. He said he was reticent to proclaim that. It was a lot. And why is the reason it not anti-intellectualism is because actually acknowledging the problem, hastens the demise of Bitcoin because so much of Bitcoin's economic monetary policy in number go up is because of legitimacy of fixed issuance. So if you break rank and you actually talk about that, even bring it up, you could actually be contributing to the de-legitimization of Bitcoin itself. And so it was almost a rational reason why he was reticent to kind of bring it up. Yep, that's very true. Fatalic, how would you, when we're talking about how humans just need to be on the same page in order to create this social force legitimacy?
My mind turned to the concept of shelling points. How would you, where do you see the intersection of shelling points and legitimacy? How do you see those concepts as related? I think what she has a type of shelling point phenomenon. There's definitely some level up which they're almost synonyms. They're definitely within the same category of idea space. So shelling points are just this idea that if you want people to, like basically people, if they have to coordinate with other people on something, like if they benefit from making the exact same choice as other people, then they would just choose about the the course of action.
They think it seems the most intuitive to the largest group of people. And they latch on to just any conception of intuitiveness that seems like it's widely shared enough regardless of whether or not they personally agree with it or whether or not it's logical in some other sense. Thomas Shelling's original example is if you tell someone that you want to meet them in New York, but you don't know what location in New York, like what place should you go to? And the answer that he gave was a grand sensual station. And I guess the theory is that like a grand sensual station is this, it's this big landmark in New York and it's a landmark that where people know that everyone else knows that it's a big landmark.
And so, you know, you're more likely to go there because you're reasoning that the other person is reasoning the same way. Now, of course, to be fair, if I went to New York, I would probably not choose grand sensual station, I would choose Times Square. And I actually am not sure exactly what grand sensual station is, but like this just show this just shows how, you know, there's a conception like these shelling points can be kind of different across different communities. And the conception of legitimacy, I guess, like it's basically the exact same kind of phenomenon. And so it's something that's not just applied to like one-time actions, it's also something that's just applied to these along ongoing processes.
Like basically, like, I mean, it is like, I think the key lesson is just this idea that there's just so many different contexts in our collective human activity, where it makes sense to make the same choice as other people, whatever one's trying to make the choice at the same time without having perfect information of everyone else's choice. And so they just have to latch onto ideas that they expect everyone else to consider intuitive. Like that's, it's just this really important thing and it affects a huge amount of behavior. And so I think a lot of people in history have kind of identified the importance of this.
And also in this article, in many of your other articles as well, you've used this alternative shelling concept as a shelling fence, which I'm actually unfamiliar with. So maybe you can help us learn what a shelling fence is in contrast to a shelling point and how it relates to legitimacy. Yeah, so a shelling fence is this idea that like you can go up to, it's a common agreement that you can go up to a certain point. But you can't go further than that point. So, well, the shelling fence is actually in the ideal analogy because like literal fences, even when they're insecure, are shelling fences in some way, right?
Like because what you imagine, you know, you have two farmers and they both have their farms and there's a fence between those two farms, then like it's beneficial for the two farmers relationships for them to both agree on like this is my land and this is your land. And I'm not going to like go and grab things from your lines that you're not going to go and grab things from my land. And if there is just any kind of natural landmark like whether it's a river or even just like whether it's just an actual fence to someone put there, like that's just the fact that it's the most visible landmark, just like is the thing that makes it clear that, you know, you're not going to go past like that point.
And there's a lot of like one other example of this like say in the crypto space, it might be that you could conceive of a blockchain community where people in that blockchain community are okay with say a portion of transaction fees being redirected to a deaf fund, but they would not be okay with issuance going into a deaf fund. And now you might ask well, like why this arbitrary distinction, right? Like transaction fees are like a unit of currency, a blocker reward is a unit of currency. And like really 20% of transaction fees is as much greater than 0.01 coins of block reward. So why be okay with the first thing but not be okay with the second thing.
And the reason, like there's a very rational reason to be okay with arbitrary distinctions like this. And that the reason basically is like it's a soluble effect, right? Like soluble risks are not policies. You know, there like it is definitely true that once if you start accepting that, you know, let's have a 0.01 coin blocker reward going to a deaf fund, then you've really kind of reduced the strength of the argument against having an even bigger deaf fund. And so if the community agrees that they want a like a medium-sized deaf fund, but they also still want to kind of keep a barrier that like very clearly prevents them from going even further, because they want to, you know, protect like their monetary eligibility than, you know, saying a portion of transaction fees can go to a deaf fund, but a portion of issue, but issuance cannot, like it's just a very clear dividing boundary.
And the existence of that dividing boundary basically allows you to kind of go up to that dividing boundary without compromising on everyone's really strong agreement that you can't do anything beyond that dividing boundary. And so like that's one, that's one example of something that could happen another example of a shelling fence is just like zero as a very common shelling fence. So just the facts that like you don't want to start doing certain things at all, like you don't want to start having a deaf fund at all, you don't want to start like, you know, even just like doing coin rescuers at hard forks at all.
And because if you start doing them at all, then you've severely weakened your argument against going further. And then once you go further, you've severely weakened your argument against going even further. And so like you just have to like put your foot down somewhere and say like this is the limit. And oftentimes, like there is a kind of intuitive spot to put that limit except for zero. And so that's why like sometimes we just have to agree that like, you know, we're going to put our foot down and we're going to say zero is the limit, even though from some so like kind of social optimality sense, the yeah, best amount might be some number higher than zero.
Like just because of limits to coordination, like zero much is being the number that you choose, right? So like these kinds of monetary policy comes to mind. Yes, that's definitely a great example. Like, you know, there's definitely a lot of Bitcoiners who would be willing to privately admit that like, yes, Bitcoin would on that be better if you just said there was a zero point one Bitcoin blocker word that continues permanently. But in practice, like everyone kind of agrees that once you start saying zero point one, then like you've really compromised your ability to argue against, say, increasing to zero point five and then increasing to two and then increasing even further.
And the fact that everyone kind of like believes in this slippery slope itself, like I've continued contributes to everyone's understanding of the strength of not even starting to go down the slippery slope. And so like everyone's belief in the selling of fence essentially is the thing that just contributes to the selling fence being so strong, right? So I definitely expect that you know, Bitcoin is going to have an extremely hard time going beyond the 21 million coin limit. Like I actually think that, you know, if Bitcoin has a security crisis, so there start being successful 51% attacks against it.
Like, there's basically three choices that they could take, right? Choice one is compromising on 21 million. Choice two is just accepting the attacks and choice three is moving to at least hybrid proof of stake. And I mean, I expect that there is a higher chance that if there's a security crisis, they'll move to hybrid proof of stake just because, you know, even if the, kind of like the core Bitcoin or Radi really hate proof of stake, or just the facts that Ethereum and the fact that all these other platforms are running and are using it without a problem actually does contribute to what's what you're going to see.
But if that did not happen, right? If I got the hybrid proof of stake or it was also out of the question, like they would much rather just accept the attacks than they would accept a even slight issuance increase just because of these selling fences. Like basically, like there is parts of the Bitcoin community that are even actively against making a selling fence about any specific guarantee of security, right? Like they even explicitly say things like, oh, you know, the Bitcoin blockchain is explicitly something that never finalizes. And so even reverting a week of activity is something that does not like explicitly violate the Bitcoin blockchain state of guarantee, which I think to an Ethereum person, like sounds very insane.
And I think in the Ethereum case, you know, if like there was a 51% attack that reverted a week of activity, we would just do a hard fork, right? Or at least a soft fork that just like did delete at the attacking chain. But so like that's just like an example where I think, like in the Ethereum case, like just finality ends in non reversion is something just like is a stronger part of the social contract. And like you could even imagine a blockchain community that says, you know, we have a hard community norm against reversions longer than 24 hours. And so if the proof of work system reverse more than 24 hours, well too bad, we're going to have to hard fork it.
And if that happens, like that's just another example of like how, you know, like if you set the fence, then like that fence itself becomes like one of these self reinforcing thing that's things that's really powerful. And so like how you set the norms at the beginning is just really important. I think the two Ethereum examples, one at the at the start of this was the block reward to developers EIP did not get community traction and did not move forward. And that was sort of a shelling fence back to the zero to one. Another example is probably you sort of alluded to this, but the the parody wallet hack that was a an EIP that did not move forward because the question to the community for the shelling fence is, okay, then where does it stop?
Which hack to decide to bail out? Which do we not let's just keep it at zero and not bail anybody out? I think that has some ether in it that I would like to get back and submit an EIP for this. Yeah. So yeah, I think the EIP and 99 case was interesting, right? Because the Dow fork, like it did compromise the shelling fence of like basically no state intervention. And that is something that made a lot of people upset. And that is something that made a lot of people move to ETC. But even the people who did not move to ETC, like they were they were kind of scared as a result. And so I think the rejection of EIP and 99 was in part motivated by this desire to like reestablish a develop a shelling fence and say, you know, yes, we did the Dow fork, but you know, no, despite that, we have standards.
And like, I think that was effective. Like I think that's something that a lot of big pointers were not expecting. Like they really were expecting that, you know, if you do it once, you just keep doing it forever. But you know, no, like the like EIP and 99 not happening, like it did convince a lot of people that like, you know, like the Dow fork happened once, but that does not mean that like if they were M chain intervention is a free for all. So that was an interesting situation as well. So Vitalik say the whole world will listen to this podcast and hopefully that happens. And now the whole world is informed about this and this power called legitimacy.
And now that we have this name on it, we can actually discuss it and talk about it in a more manifested sense. What can humans do with legitimacy? Like if everyone understands that this force exists, can we harness it? Like what if we had more legitimacy in the world? What does it mean to be more legitimate? If we can harness this power, what could we do with it? So one very important form of legitimacy in the world is the property rights, right? Like property rights are something that exists on top of legitimacy, right? Like people are not going to be able to like successfully conquer your house and maintain your position inside the house because like there are these conceptions of legitimacy.
And you know, the police know that if someone conquers your house and sets up camp in it, they have to come in and dislodge them. And then they know this because they know that if they don't do this, then other people and the governments are going to yell at them and they're going to do it themselves. And then at some point it escalates the military. And then if the military doesn't do that, then you know, the government's going to get voted out of office. So there is this kind of towering set of expectations. And it even towers internationally to some extent that are protecting your house, right?
And so if that conception of legitimacy did not exist, then you know, yes, like someone who had more guns can just like conquer your house and set up shop inside of it. So the interesting thing about property rights is that just because of like new technology, you often see new property rights or the need for new property rights emerging, right? So like one example of this is we can talk about Antarctica, right? So right now Antarctica is this backwater that very few people tear about and it's mostly just like a place for scientific research. But there's a possibility that within half a century Antarctica is going to become more important.
So the big part of the reason why is global warming, right? So the climate is expected to warm by several degrees over the course of the next few decades. And like people have done like kind of the analysis of like how this is going to affect the temperature and livability of different places. And western Antarctica, like that peninsula that's like just a thousand kilometers south of South America is expected to potentially become if is somewhat a viable place for settlements like within half a century, right? And so as one of the interesting secondary consequences of global warming is that we could actually see Antarctica becoming this like thing that people tear about considerably more than they did before.
Now the problem right now is that like there aren't really strong conceptions of property rights around Antarctica because like just not enough people tear about doing anything within Antarctica that like like on the at current margins, it's not rival or is basically right? But eventually like we can imagine a future where western Antarctica becomes rival or is saying like you will need a conception of property rights. You could also extend this to the moon or space or other areas. Exactly. So like one thing that we could agree on for like Antarctica right now is we could just say hey how about we agree right now that we're going to like say have some global body, could be the yuan, it could be some special purpose separate thing, put harbor grittaxes on Antarctica and just like instead of just giving it to whoever comes first you just like put this sort of like permanent sort of like half ownership, half a waste type mechanism on it.
And then the revenues from the harbor grittax which is going to a global basic income right? So if you do this then you've basically created this global basic income fine and like you could imagine every person in the world you know gaining like probably not enough money to eat but like at least you know some like tens of dollars a year. And if that happens like that's something that could be good for humanity right? But in order to arrange something like that like you do need to have some conception of legitimacy like you need to have a wide enough common agreement that you know western Antarctica would actually be a kind like or property rights in western Antarctica would be managed under this scheme that has revenue going to this place that then distributes it to among everyone it gives it gives everyone a basic income that you like so that these property rights that would actually just be valid right?
Because if it's only a few people trying to implement this but like actually you know just like some powerful country comes in and says like you know yeah know this things are then like that it's not going to succeed right? And so like that's just like one just one possible example of something where if you start like if you start a kind of like engaging in public discourse and sort of shoring up legitimacy behind this idea that you know if western Antarctica becomes important then we're going to harbor tax it and give everyone a basic income then like that increases the chance that actually that actually does become the equilibrium that happens but on the other hand if no one starts talking about it then like that's just not going to happen and you'll get a result that's probably less interesting.
So I think what we're getting from from that is what can we do with more legitimacy is we can play better social coordination games and that's what human beings are really good at that's how we found success as a species. Hey guys I hope you're enjoying the conversation with Vitalik so far coming up next we've talked about the role of legitimacy inside of NFTs as well as the power of charitable giving in adding legitimacy to the value of an NFT then we also turn to the conversation of legitimacy of the monetary policy of ether the asset and we ask Vitalik will the most legitimate blockchain have the highest level of security and overall we can't miss the opportunity of talking to Vitalik about his thoughts on ultra sound money but we do it inside of the context of legitimacy stay tuned for the second half of this podcast don't go anywhere but first we have to talk about some of these fantastic sponsors that make this show possible.
Metamask is your go-to wallet for the bankless journey if you're going bankless you need Metamask period browser and mobile get them both this is your tool to unlock the world of DeFi here's my favorite part now you can swap tokens directly in Metamask with this single swipe this has got to be the easiest way to trade Ethereum tokens choose a token you own a token to exchange it with get your quotes if you like what you see you hit swap that's it what makes swap so useful is what happens behind the scenes it compares dexas aggregators and market makers to find you the best price with the lowest network fees and the least slippage this means you can swap a wider range of tokens and swaps can even automatically split up your trade to give you access to better liquidity you don't even have to think about it try it out download Metamask for desktop or mobile now at metamask.
io and start swapping Gemini is the world's most trusted cryptocurrency exchange I've been a customer of Gemini since I first got into crypto in 2017 and it's been my main exchange of choice to make my crypto buys and sells Gemini is available in all 50 states and in over 50 countries worldwide and on Gemini there are markets for over 30 various different crypto assets including many of the hot DeFi tokens and it's one of the few exchanges that has liquid die markets Gemini just launched their earn program where you can earn up to 7.4% interest on 26 various crypto assets if you're tired of paying fees in DeFi or you don't want to worry about DeFi exploits but you still want to earn interest on your crypto assets Gemini earn is the product for you another product I'm stoked to get my hands on is the Gemini crypto back credit card which gives you 3% cash back on all of your purchases but paid to you in your preferred crypto asset when I get my Gemini credit card I'm going to make sure that I get my cash back in ETH so whenever I buy something I get a little bit of ETH bonus back to me at the same time you can open up a free account in under 3 minutes at Gemini.
com slash go bankless and if you trade more than 100 dollars within the first 30 days after sign up you'll be gifted a free 15 dollar bitcoin bonus check them out at Gemini.com slash go bankless let's let's talk a bit more about crypto because I think what we're unlocking in this concept of legitimacy with the the post and the description thus far is not going to say a theory to everything but it's an answer to most many of the FAQs that I hear when people first come into into crypto so let me give an example a couple we've covered one is like why can't Ethereum just have issue an EIP and fund its public goods that way and we can't because of legitimacy you gave another example of you know why can't a bank for instance acquire a DeFi protocol well they can't we have the the steam versus Justin Sun example because the thing that they're acquiring is actually social consensus and they can't just buy legitimacy they they almost have to earn it here's another question I think people ask when they get the space and this was a common question in 2013 2014 about why bitcoin is is valuable and some critics have said big said back then especially bitcoin will never be valuable because anybody can just create a fork right I could create take my bitcoin and then say this is the legitimate bitcoin it's called bitcoin Ryan and like that turned out to be completely not true because of legitimacy would you agree with that definitely well so the interesting thing also is that like there's bitcoin maximalists who said that you know for bitcoin to maintain and its value like bitcoin has to be accepted as the only one because if people start accepting the legitimacy of other cryptocurrencies then like the ability of bitcoin to maintain any kind of special status just like disappears and people start acting like they're all the same in cryptocurrency as a sector of hyperinflates and we discovered that that's completely not true right like any one can print a new cryptocurrency but printing a new cryptocurrency that has the legitimacy to gain value is something that actually is hard right and it's something that takes a lot of effort it's something like that not everyone can do and and it is very possible for you know bitcoin to have a lot of legitimacy bitcoin cash to have less legitimacy bitcoin ebc to have even less but still non-zero legitimacy and then you know bitcoin Ryan would probably like I mean I'm sure if you mean to let get up to a few hundred thousand dollars but even less legitimacy like that bitcoin diamond or bitcoin a bc basically right so like there being multiple cryptocurrencies is something that has proven to be a yes stable equilibrium which is I think something that a lot of people like especially very early in the crypto space did not expect I also think another example of this is many of the ethereum killers that have come about talk about they emphasize their technology right more scalability this sort of thing and they don't emphasize legitimacy they don't emphasize social scalability and you know they they think this is purely a technical battle but it's not it's a legitimacy battle it's a social coordination battle it's about who where the developers of the future feel comfortable like built which platform they feel comfortable building on top of and where the users feel comfortable actually using without losing their property rights um another example you gave an example in the post that I think is interesting which is why do defi apps it seems like prefer die rather than tether um legitimacy yeah yeah well the interesting thing I gave in that example right is that like traders are often perfectly fine with each other adapts are prefer strongly prefer die over each other and the reason is that which intimacy is fundamentally about coordination and traders don't really have to coordinate right there's just like trading and their main interaction with other traders is competitive and so like for a trader if you personally believe that like well you know maybe tether has some sketchiness inside of it but like whatever it's fine then like that's fine and you can just keep using tether but for if you're building an application then you need something that not just you can trust but that like you can easily convince other observers and even like fairly low information observers that you're building on top of something sound and so make something like die where it's a legitimacy model doesn't fundamentally rely on you know very socially unscalable assumptions about like how honorable bit for next people are like this something like it's just easier to get behind I think we can also extrapolate the confusion perhaps behind NFTs and why NFTs have value and answer that question with legitimacy and a nice example that I like to use is the the creator of the nioncat gift he made this nioncat gift many many many years ago and then recently he remastered it so he made a brand new gift the brand new gift and then he sold that brand new gift for 300 each and there's two two sources of legitimacy that I see coming into this gift one is continuity where even though it's a brand new gift it continues from the same meme of the nioncat that has almost been around for a whole entire decade and legitimacy as the artist who created the NFT in the first place it was the original artist who remastered the nioncat gift not some new unknown artist and I think we can extrapolate this to most all NFTs at large where it's not about the JPEG it's about the legitimacy and so Vitalik how do you see legitimacy in NFTs intersecting yeah I think that's definitely an excellent example right because like the question is like first of all you know an NFT of a nioncat is clearly more successful than the same author making an NFT if some completely new to it all mean but second a nioncat meme made by the author of the original nioncat meme is more successful than just like some random person doing it right and so like there's a legitimacy in the meme there's legitimacy in the person and you know there's other kinds of legitimacy as well and they do sort of kind of add up and stack on top of each other now the reason why legitimacy is important in NFTs is because if you look at the reasons why anyone would want an NFT in the first place right like one of them is you want you want you're more likely to buy an NFT if you know that you can resell it later another one is you want an NFT for a social bragging rights and all these like basically all the motivations for why you you could conceivably want an NFT are very closely bound up with the fact that other people also accept that this is an NFT that should be have value right and so you know even if like you personally think that is you know purple hexagon is something that's like really important to the world and is something that should be worth billions like nobody else agrees that purple hexagons should be worth billions and so you know you're not going to spend much money buying a purple hexagon NFT because like you might get a bit of personal satisfaction but because nobody else cares about purple hexagons like your level of personal satisfaction will be limited and your ability to resell it will also be extremely limited and probably zero as well and like we see these kind of like conformism patterns occurring in markets all the time right like for example one of the reasons why houses tends to be irrelevant we standardized and uncreative is because when you buy a house like you want to buy a house that you can sell easily and then the person you're selling to also wants a house that they know that they can sell easily and so if you buy a house that is just kid forms to the average person's expectations about house done not only do you know that you can you can easily find someone who wants to live in it you know that you can sell it to someone else because you can easily convince the person that you're selling to that they might later be able to sell it along to someone else as well right and so like you can often like get these sort of effects that just like kind of prop up the value of some houses over others for a long time and these are just like these sort of second layer equilibria that just you know exist on top like you know weird social forces and with NFTs it's true as well right and so with NFTs is like yeah someone else made a Nyan cat NFT then it would be much much easier for you to resell it and like you would just gain much less social satisfaction having it and so just for all of the reasons it's much less valuable and so what this means is that NFTs are kind of heavily defined by legitimacy and if we can affect these conceptions of legitimacy then we could potentially kind of turn NFTs or at least nudge NFTs into something that's really really useful for just like funding or funneling valuable resources or resources to things that are valuable for society right so like one example that I gave is if we create a conception that an NFT is more legitimate if it's kind of connected to some non-profit organization and some portion of the revenues go to that organization and if people accept that like NFTs with this property are like more legitimate because they're like more scarce in some way than NFTs that do not have this connection then that's like if that equilibrium exists then that's something that we all just end up like funneling resources to more of these non-profit organizations and like trying to actively participate in trying to create these equilibrium as something that we should be really I think focused on and I get interested in trying to make happen but what you're saying I've seen this in the analog space there's a brand called red I don't know if you seen this but there was a period of time where like Starbucks was branding their coffee red and you'd see red everywhere and I believe that's a non-profits where some portion of the donation from that product went to eight and now I think it's it's COVID-19 but that's the kind of thing you're talking about where they branded all of these products and increased demand because now I buy my Starbucks and I'm feeling like I'm actually giving back to something that I support something like that for NFTs.
Absolutely. It feels I'm reminded of like the event where when somebody buys a new boat they swing a bottle of champagne and it breaks it breaks upon the boat and it's like this christening event for this boat and it has nothing to do with legitimacy but with an NFT when you are selling this NFT and you're committing some amount of funds to charity it feels like a christening event of this NFT you use the term bless in your article where you are blessing this NFT bestowing it with legitimacy and what was interesting to me is not not a week after you published this article did the uniswap v3 x times y equals k NFT come out and not only was a chunk of that revenue of that NFT donated to charity all of it was donated to charity do you do you think that like if we want to give some perhaps some actionable advice to NFT artists that it would actually be be behoove them from a revenue maximalist perspective to donate some of their their NFT sale revenue to charities I think that's absolutely the case I mean I think it's even one of those things that could sort of like flow in one direction because if nobody else is making an NFT going to charity and if you make an NFT where some part goes to charity then you know just buy that fact your NFT is special and people are more likely to pay attention to it but then if lots of people are already making NFTs that go to charity then you know if that fact's just like gains with the fact that an NFT is supposed to be blessed by some charity becomes like this part of it's legitimacy and just like by that pressure as well you know it ends up being just like more effective to make an NFT or some portion goes to a charity so this is something that like I'm hoping not just NFT artists think about but even like major NFT platforms think about not just incorporating like some notion of you know flagging NFTs that have been blessed by a charity as being that and just making this very clear to buyers like I think if this is something that can be coordinated among I think a relatively small number of actors in the ecosystem then the results could be really interesting so Vitalik I think the bankless community would also love your thoughts on another subject that I feel like is actually very quite quite related to legitimacy and that's a topic that has been top of mind for the the last couple of months and that is the topic of ethos ultrasound money so this is kind of a I call it a narrative that you know is that Justin Drake actually helped define it I think you had some role in actually naming this concept as well but the the way it relates to legitimacy is I have sent that podcast to many Bitcoiners I know and I've invited many who have been previously skeptical about Ethereum and its its future guarantees security guarantees monetary guarantees are otherwise to listen to it and I've asked for feedback and many don't listen to it of course many don't go down the journey but but those who do generally have a consistent piece of feedback and that is this the monetary policy is still illegitimate of Ethereum because it's being changed right so the fact that it can be tweaked at this point outside of sound money behavior as as kind of defined by by Bitcoin can we talk about for a minute I guess maybe the contract the context is ultrasound money but also like what do you think a legitimate issuance policy looks like for a cryptocurrency I think that's definitely a great question and I think you know the concept of legitimacy is definitely really important to like this ultrasound question and like a bunch of really subtle ways right I think the thing the key thing that's important here is that there is a shift of legitimacy in thinking of eth as you know a type of money of any kind right like closer to the beginning of Ethereum's history and eth was more viewed as like basically this thing that you would use to pay for gas but not really something that you know if you would actually want to use as an asset and over time if this is I think a push from the community much more than it is anything happening from you know the Ethereum foundation or the core developers actually I think it's entirely a push from the yet community is that people just started like talking about you know eth as an asset and like basically wanting to confer inherent legitimacy to eth as an asset more and more and I think the place where the ultrasound money kind of meme and it's about the discussion around how group of stake and EAB 1559 fit fit into that is that those things like even now they signal a commitment to the facts that a large portion of the Ethereum ecosystem like wants if to be ultrasound money and like a community that wants if to be or a community that wants an asset sorry an asset having a community that wants it to be an ultrasound money is a good property for an ultrasound money to have right like an asset is more effective as an ultrasound money if it has a big portion of its community talking about how that asset is ultrasound money because that community talking about the ultrasound money meme itself make like basically makes it be part of the social contract it makes it more likely that things that are supportive of that asset becoming ultrasound money will be implemented and things that are opposed to that asset being an ultrasound money will not be afforded right so I think just eth gaining kind of legitimacy through this kind of like self-created ultrasound money concept is a definitely a thing that is happening now of course I mean all legitimacy is always something that's a difference in different communities and I think there definitely is a cultural difference between the Ethereum and Bitcoin communities right because I think Ethereum people are more accustomed to like valuing Ethereum based on the future whereas Bitcoin people are much more accustomed to valuing Bitcoin based on its presence right I've expressed this before as Ethereum people think Ethereum or sorry Bitcoin people think Bitcoin is 80% complete Ethereum people think Ethereum is 40% complete and like both sides are comfortable with that and think the other side is crazy for like taking the opposite choice right and and so like at least within the Ethereum community I the fact that there is intent to do 50 59 and the proof stake so a chance that it's about an issue and so all of this stuff is already enough for them right like it's the intent and direction of the social contract that's even the most important thing whereas I imagine to the Bitcoin audience like until it's implemented and coded doesn't count and maybe that's fine like I think I think they almost feel like Vitalik until it's implemented coded and like 20 years have passed it's not fine yes I think yeah I think that said definitely true yeah like Bitcoin people are definitely just like less comfortable with the concept of social contracts defining a direction instead of defining a permanent state and the Ethereum social contract for at least the first 10 years of its existence you know the last few the last six and the next few as well like is one that defines the direction right this all show contract has included proof stake in charting from since before the Ethereum blockchain launched and now over time I do think that the Ethereum social contract is going to switch to one that's more of maintenance and that's just something that like has to happen over time because once we do have proof of stake like there isn't a proof of something that's even better than proof of stake that we want to switch to and once we have charting well like if you want more scalability you just add more shards right like and so like there isn't you know something even better that you want to like make big fundamental economic upgrades to after those upgrades are done and like once you do once we have proof of she's sharding it's proof of stake like we have well what I call functionality escape velocity right and so anything that you want on top you actually can implement with layer two protocols so there's less need to make further changes to layer one right so for those reasons I do think that the Ethereum social contract is going to move toward being a stabilizing one instead of being a directional one over time and once it does that then I expect like a lot of the big one people that are more comfortable with the stabilizing social contracts are just going to slowly accept Ethereum as being legitimate and I think like Ethereum successfully completing its two biggest shifts so the EAP 5059 and the introduction to their proof of stake and like possibly sharding as well like that's is the thing that's going to actually sort of do most of the work and you know convincing them basically it's funny to me because it seems to be the case that if given issuance policy is fixed and the security issues that result of that Bitcoin is going to have to revert to its social contract to decide a direction in the future you know you talked about three possible paths for Bitcoin increasing issuance you know letting transactions essentially take a long time to to process or reverting to some proof of stake proof of work you know so it's almost like it's all social consensus and social contract at the at the base layer anyway and there's no such thing as completely immutable like code that doesn't change yeah it's definitely social contracts all the way down and you can have different kinds of social contracts like you can have social contracts that like prescribe more rigidness like you could have a personal social contract that says you know if a block cannot be verified by this zk smart verifier where the the GitHub hash of the code is 0x5a1ca4c blah blah blah then it is not Bitcoin or it is not whatever currency well like you could be really really strict and try to like define a piece of code as being the social contracts and that's good for preventing change but then the problem is like well if the code even has a bug then you know like just any kind of technical unexpected situation is just going to cause huge problems for your community and possibly even you know lead to a chain split and that's a cost you incur if you have an overly rigid social consensus but if you have a social contract that just says you know we vaguely care about these values and we're just going to do whatever we need to do to implement those values then that's something that's more adaptable to just changes in circumstances and changes in technology but that also is something that just gives participants in the ecosystem fewer guarantees and especially if participants in the ecosystem just like have different views about what it actually takes to realize those values right and so there is this tradeoff like there is such a thing as social contracts being more rigid and social contracts being more loose and there's benefits from one and there's benefits from the other and I think in general like blockchain social contracts should be more loose when a blockchain is new and still rapidly growing and they should kind of just naturally allow themselves to evolve to being more rigid over time as a blockchain like discovers what it's for and that's perfectly fine.
In my episodes with in my other podcast PV crypto with Christian Corollas we talked about this this subject of social contracts when he was very adamant that Bitcoin is not ruled by social contract is ruled by math but we actually came to an agreement when we when when I proposed this alternative to him where I said Bitcoin social contract is to not have a social contract which kind of gets to what Bitcoin wants to be which is ruled by math but still like you said its social contracts all the way down social contracts are unavoidable the the best thing that you could do which kind of goes back to how a zero is a good shelling point has had not the social contract do not have a social contract is the best way to not have a social contract but you still have a social contract.
That's definitely fascinating like I think you know we all agree that like at the end of the day there is a lot of like pretending going on like you know in reality when the contact computers come in they are going to take some very yet kind of directed emergency actions or protect people's coins when if there is some 51% minor that just like start spawn camping the chain they're going to take a very directed action to change the group of work algorithm and so there are these like things at the extremes that are obviously going to happen but like this there is this social contract of like well you know what's like not even talking about the extremes and what sort of like maintain the mindset that these extremes do not exist and like for as long as that survives like that the ideas that just like increases the social pressure against like forcing a change by trying to claim that there's that there's some extreme that justifies it.
So it's interesting like it's definitely one way of designing a social system but I guess that we'll see how it goes. Patelka I want to back up and zoom out a little bit a second ago you were talking about how the ETH can be money if the community wants it to be money and I'm reminded of actually asked you the same question back in Tel Aviv in early 2020 when you were on a Q&A panel with Joel Lubin and you had said something along the lines of how like the Bitcoin could take the monetary use cases of blockchains and the Ethereum can take everything else and I raised my hand and I said well I'm part of this crew that really thinks that Ether could be a really compelling money above and beyond Bitcoin and actually Ryan was really the first person to just instantiate and it started just I'm pretty sure with the tweet ETH is money and that meme just caught like wildfire and to me it became very very obvious that at least there's this core group of Ethereum community members who believe ETH is money and that ETH is money is legitimate and that was a year and a half ago and I think that the narrative around ETH has money as well as the fundamentals which is what backs up legitimacy has really matured and evolved since then and so now that we are at this like the early 2021 2021 phase with EIP 1559 on the horizon and proof of stake merge around the corner do you think the world is ready to accept Ether as a brand new macro store value asset alongside Bitcoin in public consciousness?
I would say it's definitely getting there and I think that like to get the acceptance really up there we do actually we need to finish EIP 1559 and finish the merge and like get to the point where you know the system after all of the big changes is running and it's stable and people see that it's stable but like it's not going I know it's very hard for something to gain legitimacy while there's still this road map to like change everything ahead a few months into the future like I do think that we are already getting some of the benefits so like for example you know people have been talking a lot about environmental issues of proof of work right and like I think that issue is really substantial and I think like it's there's actually a lot of different externalities that are pretty negative from a proof of work right like people focus on electricity and in some ways electricity is even one of the easiest ones to like argue against because like oh you know we have solar power I know we have all of this power in far off places where sometimes it just gets wasted already but like you have to remember that in addition to the electricity issues which there's also the hardware issues hardware is a huge portion of mining costs and last time I made a check it was even something like two thirds of them I'm not sure exactly what the percentage is now but like hardware is a very environmentally unfriendly to manufacture there's also like displacement issues like work that's being done on producing these hard these things is being done instead of work that could be done by the computing industry to make things that benefit humanity more you know gamers are having a hard time not getting like or dealing with a reduced supply of PCs and then you know with A6 as well like if people were working on Bitcoin A6 what other kind of A6 so would they would they be working on and proof of stake does actually solve these issues and so I do think that the Ethereum is gaining some kind of like at least the beginnings of interest as some kind of alternative because people see that this is a shift that's coming and you know basically if you know it is a sort of dual die thing right like you know Ethereum is going to either complete the switch or it's going to die trying and that's the fact that that roadmap exists and the fact that that roadmap is looking more and more credible now now that we have a running beacon chain now that we just finished the Berlin hard fork and we're literally on the finish line to 50-59 and then after that will be on the finish line to the merge you know the fact that there is a hackathon and implementing the merge happening right now though like those things definitely are contributing and those effects will just like become slowly more and more real in people's minds over time as the event gets closer and then the events happening by itself will obviously be a really huge flip so that's going to be interesting to watch yeah people forget that legitimacy particularly for institutions like public blockchains and the store value assets that they might represent I mean it's going to take years to play out many many years and we are so early in this there is it's almost a sense of like there's no rush it would be unhealthy to me if the world suddenly adopt these things as store value assets like overnight right this has to happen in a gradual way of italic thank you so much for sharing all your thoughts on legitimacy I think this is going to be a fantastic mental model for people to try to understand what's going on in this space want to end with this question it's 2021 we are in still the first half but getting close to the second half in the grand scheme of things how would you characterize this era of Ethereum I think it's like the era where the ecosystem is like really growing up and starting to enter its phase of maturity and I think it's happening in a lot of ways right like it's happening because the road the technical roadmap is finally at least seeing its first major pieces get finished it's happening because scalability is finally looking months away from actually happening it's happening because we're actually seeing applications of like serious value and to not just the crypto community but to the mainstream starting to emerge the whole NFT thing I think was actually really interesting for Ethereum because it actually is the thing that sort of started giving Ethereum some legitimacy and its own right right like before the NFT thing I think people mostly talked about Ethereum in reference to talking about Bitcoin right you know there's you have an article about Bitcoin and they just mentioned you know oh there's also these other cryptocurrencies that exist and then there's this thing called Ethereum and then there's you know this thing called Cardano and then there's this thing called pick up truck to know and then you know keep going but they're all the same thing they're all just these other currencies yeah exactly and the look with NFTs like you know you actually have a reason to talk about Ethereum without reference to you know talking about its big brother which is interesting right so then even aside from NFTs there's other things happening as well right like there's just more people experimenting with ETH has a payment mechanism like we saw the announcements from like I think it was PayPal and some of these other you know big US companies they're not just accepting Bitcoin they're accepting like Bitcoin Bitcoin cash ether and Litecoin at the same time and like I think that set of four is just fascinating because like like the sort of like holdover legitimacy my continuity that Bitcoin cash and Litecoin and just like get that allows them to be accepted is just like so fascinating and interesting to observe but like seeing that starts to happen is really interesting and you know I expect that applications are going to continue to mature what scalability is ready and then the applications are really going to go into overdrive and then once the EIP 5059 and per mistake is complete including the merge being complete then you know the ultra sounds money thing will instead of like just being a technical goal actually becomes real and seeing that happen at the same time is just going to be really interesting for the ecosystem absolutely we are at an exciting juncture for sure Vitalik thank you so much for sharing this with us from a macro perspective definitely feels like public blockchains Ethereum crypto as an asset class is entering the world of legitimacy and this decade is going to be super exciting so thanks for hanging with us today thank you very much right thank you David action items for the bankless community we've got some reading assignments make sure you check out Vitalik's post the most important scarce resource is legitimacy that's where he goes through the details we talked about today also read one of his Reddit threads this was a brain dump that he made on proof of stake versus proof of work I think after listening to the ultrasound money post a lot of great comments from the community there too and then we've got almost like a Vitalik bankless anthology brewing there are a few episodes where Vitalik went through why proof of stake designing Ethereum his reflections on 2020 and crypto and beyond we will include all of those resources for you in the show notes of course guys risk and disclaimers this is not financial advice he said eat this risky crypto is risky so as defy you could lose what you put in but we are headed west this is the frontier it's not for everyone but thanks for joining us on the bankless journey hey we hope you enjoyed the video if you did head over to bankless HQ right now to develop your crypto investing skills and learn how to free yourself from banks and gain your financial independence we recommend it joining our daily newsletter podcast and community as a bankless premium subscriber to get the most out of your bankless experience you'll get access to our market analysis our alpha leaks and exclusive content and even the bankless token for airdrops raffles and unlocks if you're interested in crypto the bankless community is where you want to be click the link in the description to become a bankless premium subscriber today also don't forget to subscribe to the channel for in-depth interviews with industry leaders ask me anything and weekly rollups where we summarize the week in crypto and other fantastic content thanks everyone for watching and being on the journey as we build out the bankless nation