Eric Wall is a prominent thinker and contrarian in the crypto space. He has an independent mind and is unafraid to bust through groupthink and act as an ideological razor for the crypto community.
In this episode, Eric dives deeply into a variety of profound takes on Bitcoin, Ethereum, and his approach to the community.
------ 🚀 SUBSCRIBE TO NEWSLETTER: https://newsletter.banklesshq.com/ 🎙️ SUBSCRIBE TO PODCAST: https://podcast.banklesshq.com/ 🎧 Get this Episode's Debrief: https://shows.banklesshq.com/p/exclusive-debrief-the-altcoin-slayer ------ BANKLESS SPONSOR TOOLS:
💰 GEMINI | FIAT & CRYPTO EXCHANGE https://bankless.cc/go-gemini
🔀 BALANCER | EXCHANGE & POOL ASSETS https://bankless.cc/balancer
👻 AAVE | LEND & BORROW ASSETS https://bankless.cc/aave
🦄 UNISWAP | DECENTRALIZED FUNDING http://bankless.cc/uniswap
------ Bankless Podcast #66: The Altcoin Slayer Guest: Eric Wall
Eric Wall is CIO of Arcane Assets, and a well-known (and often infamous) writer and thinker in the crypto space. He has engaged in arguments with camps and tribes throughout the space, remaining unapologetically independent and committed to his values. Though a Bitcoiner at heart, Eric has come around on Ethereum as the ecosystem has matured.
In this episode, we dive into values and the ethos of crypto that Eric fights for. As a principled believer in trustless systems and decentralization, Eric walks through many of the big-picture obstacles and accomplishments of the crypto space. Viewing this landscape with a digital biologist's lens, we address these projects as digital organisms, following many of the same laws we see in nature. Wherever organisms exist, Darwin is nearby.
Eric brings a refreshing and unfiltered set of takes to the Bankless Podcast, reminiscent of other independent thinkers we've had on like Hasu. Regardless of your opinions on Eric, he represents an important part of the blockchain conversation. He serves as an ideological razor, giving no one the benefit of the doubt and prioritizing accountability and earned legitimacy.
------
Topics Covered:
0:00 Intro 4:45 Eric Wall, the Altcoin Slayer 7:45 The Term “Trustless” 16:58 Eric’s Approach to Crypto 22:50 Networks are Organisms 31:50 Survival of the Fittest 41:50 Bitcoin vs Layer 2 59:15 Tribes vs Facts 1:06:30 Eric’s ETH Journey 1:21:43 Thoughts on Proof of Stake 1:31:14 Is ETH Money? 1:40:58 What ETH Gets Wrong 1:53:55 Navigating the Frontier 2:01:00 Closing & Disclaimers
------ Resources:
Eric on Twitter https://twitter.com/ercwl?s=20 Proof of Stake is Less Wasteful https://ercwl.medium.com/proof-of-stake-is-less-wasteful-b2854a191766#:~:text=Image%20of%20a%20diesel%20generator,ever%20had%20on%20the%20platform. ETH is Irreplaceable https://newsletter.banklesshq.com/p/eth-is-irreplaceable
----- Not financial or tax advice. This channel is strictly educational and is not investment advice or a solicitation to buy or sell any assets or to make any financial decisions. This video is not tax advice. Talk to your accountant. Do your own research.
Disclosure. From time-to-time I may add links in this newsletter to products I use. I may receive commission if you make a purchase through one of these links. Additionally, the Bankless writers hold crypto assets. See our investment disclosures here: https://newsletter.banklesshq.com/p/bankless-disclosures
No summary for this episode yet.
Welcome to Bankless, where we explore the frontier of internet money and internet finance. This is how to get started, how to get better, and how to front run the opportunity. I'm Ryan Sean Adams. I'm here with David Hoffman, and we're here to help you become more bankless. David, we have the altcoin slayer on the show, Eric Wall. How was that conversation? Yeah, this is the first time I've actually gotten able to talk to Eric Wall. And he's somebody that's really helped me formulate mental models in this space. And Eric Wall, for those that don't know, very, very prominent in 2017, 2018, as a guy that seemed to go against everyone's grain, like not just one particular community's grains, but everyone's grain.
And so like, while he's a big Bitcoiner, he's not afraid to tell Bitcoiners when they're wrong. And while he was never really convinced by the Ethereum crowd, he has, as of late, talked very positively about certain merits of Ethereum's construction. But then we'll also go ahead and say that the overall Ethereum project is a complete mess. So this guy thinks for himself. And that's kind of why we got him on not to go into depth about his mental models and the way that he thinks and his opinions about certain things, but then also as an exploration into the way that he puts thoughts together inside of a space where so many people are telling you how and what to think.
Eric Wall thinks for himself. This is bankless meets tribalist. I really feel like Eric Wall strives as much as possible not to affiliate himself with one particular pattern of thought or one particular tribe. In fact, I think early on, he very much associated himself as a Bitcoiner, very much put the mantle of that tribe on his shoulders. And we talked about almost his like ejection from the Bitcoiners fear by, by the so-called high priest and what that, what that felt like. It was almost like he was excommunicated. So we, we went through that. And I guess maybe the through line here is we have a, a contrarian thinker, a tribeless individual.
And what's interesting to me, David, is he is coming to some of the same conclusions that we've come to as part of the, the bankless platform, some different ones, but also many of the same conclusions, but he's doing it like outside of the Ethereum ecosystem's influence or the bankless ecosystem's influence. He's almost like arriving at these opinions independently. And that's what was so interesting about, I think, this podcast and Eric's journey and his story. It's just the way he thinks, but how he has arrived at these opinions. it's definitely not through groupthink and through like tribe affiliation.
It's like when he says it, you know, that like he actually believes it in that moment, not to say he doesn't change his mind because there are many instances where he he's admitted changing his mind. In fact, you know, the, the tweet that got him on the show, I think was he said in 2020, he stopped being wrong about ETH. Those are his words, not mine. He stopped being wrong about ETH. So this is someone who's also very willing to do like a 180 when he sees that the evidence points in a different direction. So kind of a cool thinker, somebody we've wanted on the podcast for a while. And we actually rent down a rabbit hole that we weren't expecting to towards the beginning of the podcast where we get to talk about my favorite subject of like evolutionary crypto assets.
It was not planned. Yeah, what is it? Biology and the evolution of crypto networks, right? I have a deep-seated belief that the best way to understand this industry is through a biological perspective. And Eric Wall shares that belief. And we actually kind of went down that rabbit hole earlier in the podcast. And I think that's going to be a new line of topic on the Bankless podcast that we haven't really touched on. I'm really happy that we were actually able to touch on it. Yeah, it's kind of like expect the unexpected in this podcast right at the very beginning he actually called me out on some beef that we've had previously right so we just enter in on that conversation so overall really fantastic episode of course you can get a download of David and my thoughts in the debrief episode that is available for premium subscribers on the bankless premium feed.
So make sure you check that out too if you are a premium subscriber. And with that, David, let's talk about the fantastic sponsors that made this episode possible. just autonomous code on Ethereum. Input the token you want to sell and receive the token you want to buy. Something brand new in the Uniswap ecosystem is the Uniswap grants program is now accepting applications for grants. We have been saying this for a while and we'll say it again. DAOs have money and they are in need of labor. If you think that you have something to contribute to the Uniswap DAO, apply for a grant to Uniswap. Just look at the size of the Uniswap treasury.
It's almost $3 billion. This mountain of capital is looking for labor. Do you have something of value to contribute to the Uniswap DAO? No matter how big or small your idea is, you can apply for a UniGrant at unigrants.org and help steer Uniswap in the direction that you think it should go. That's exactly what we did to get Uniswap to be a sponsor for Bankless, and you can do the same for your project. Thank you, Uniswap, for sponsoring Bankless. Aave is a borrowing and lending protocol on Ethereum and just recently released Aave version 2 which has a ton of cool new features that makes using Aave even more powerful.
With Aave you can leverage the full power of DeFi, MoneyLegos, Yield, and Composability all in one application. On Aave there are a ton of assets that you can deposit in order to gain yield and all of those same assets can also be borrowed from the protocol if you have deposited collateral. Here you can see me getting a 200 USDC loan against my portfolio of a number of different DeFi tokens and ETH. I'll choose a variable interest rate because it's a lower rate than the stable interest rate option, but I could choose the stable interest rate option if I wanted to lock that interest rate in permanently.
One of Aave's V2 features is the ability to swap collateral without having to withdraw your assets, trade them on Uniswap, and then deposit them back into Aave. Aave does all of this for you all in one seamless transaction, so you don't have to repay loans in order to change the collateral you have backing them. Check out the power of Aave at aave.com. That's A-A-V-E.com. Bankless Nation, we are super excited to introduce you to our next guest. Eric Wall is a contrarian crypto investor. He is the chief investment officer at Arcane Investment. He's someone I don't always agree with, yet he's also someone I always appreciate.
And I think that's because he busts through groupthink. He isn't afraid to change his mind, yet he manages to stay extremely convicted in his beliefs at the same time. I think we're going to learn a lot from Eric in this podcast. Eric, welcome to Bankless. How are you doing today? Thank you so much, Ryan. I'm kind of surprised to be here because we've had this, you and me, we've had this ongoing spat about a particular argument that we've had in the past about how to correctly apply the term trustless to different types of cryptocurrency systems. And because of our inconsistencies of opinions there, I'm a principled person, and I try to stick to my principles as hard as I can.
And one of my principles is that if somebody uses terminology in a way that I think is harmful to the overall ecosystem, then, you know, I cannot prevent people from saying what they say, but I can at least choose who I engage with. I think the spat that we had was, you know, kind of a mild one. And, you know, now I'm pretty much over it, but it would be good if we could just, you know, just spend a few seconds just, you know, hashing over that little piece of disagreement that we had around trustlessness. I can explain the argument if that's helpful to you. Yeah, let's do it. And to Bankless listeners, as you can see, the introduction did Eric justice because we didn't plan any of this pre-recording and we're jumping right in with the contrarian opinion.
Eric, yeah, I'd love to hear you. So I think this is in regards to an article that I wrote sometime in March, 2020. And the reason I'm remembering is actually, cause I did pull it up. Cause I was wondering if you would pull this up and want to talk about this first. And the article title is called ETH is Irreplaceable. And it's basically a taxonomy about the trustlessness, the spectrum of trustlessness of certain assets. So I make the basic assertion that different assets on Ethereum have different, or in crypto writ large, have different levels of settlement guarantee. And even in the real world, different assets have different levels of settlement guarantee.
Some are backed by the nation state. Some require legal trust. Some are more bearer asset instruments. And some I put in a quadrant called a trustless quadrant. And again, I pitch this as sort of a spectrum of trust, right? Recognizing that nothing on earth, nothing that can be created, nothing that has ever been created is completely trustless. But I think you take issue with the term trustless in and of itself. And I would love for you to explain that as we start this episode, where you take issue and we'll see whether we actually disagree at the end of this or whether we agree. Yeah. So I can give my take.
The reason that I took issue with how you characterized the trustlessness taxonomy was that if I remember it correctly, and please correct me if I'm wrong, you basically put different cryptocurrency projects on an axis on a spectrum where they went from more trustless to less trustless whereas in in yeah you can see in this in this chart here that basically you can go from more trustless to less trustless where i think that there are things that are completely trusted that should not be on a trustless diagram at all so i don't think that trustlessness can incorporate everything because there are some things that should be completely outside of this spectrum because they're trusted so i don't think that you can say that you know uh a bank is just uh less trustless or or or or and that the die is more trustless i think that banks are 100 trusted and doesn't belong in a diagram of trustlessness at all uh i think that's if i that's how i recall the argument and i try to persuade you to remove completely trusted things from a trustlessness diagram and you rebutted and said well you know that's not how I think about it and I said well if that's the case then I'm going to stop engaging with you until you've refreshed your thinking on it and then we had all these discussions around how you can view this topic and now I'm you know I've listened to your bankless part and I don't think that you are a malicious actor in any way we just had a disagreement about terminology but i don't think that you are harmful or that you're bringing a negative nuance to the industry so that's why i came on that's why i have now come around so i'm on the pub now i think we can get over this and we can we can be friends again and and chat about things that are really important because I think that our main goals with our efforts in the cryptocurrency space are pretty much 90% aligned.
So Eric, I think that if I'm interpreting what you're saying correctly, that what you are really asking to change in this diagram here is really asking to change where like the X and Y axes are. It's like on, and so perhaps, so you do agree that there's this thing in concept called trustlessness that some crypto assets try to emulate like you know bitcoin and ether to perhaps the most degree and i think what you're saying is everything to like perhaps on the left side of this diagram you you are saying like why are we even calling it putting it on the trustless spectrum at all in the first place let's use completely different words for exactly the different part of this zone exactly exactly What different words would you use then, Erik, versus trustless?
No, I just put trusted and trustless in completely different axes. You should have a split here where you put things that ultimately do depend on trust on a completely different axis here. Because right now, if you look at the, you have trustless issuance, on the y-axis and then the trustless settlement on the x-axis, I think that you should have, there should be an axis that goes to the left where you have completely trusted things. But, you know, I don't want to spend too much time on this spat. Can I just say something? I actually don't think there's a real spat there. I think much of this is actually semantics and probably the result of me just being a sloppy diagram drawer.
I think maybe someone who's listening to Bankless and in the Bankless Nation can take the diagram that we're showing right now and come up with something that better illustrates that. Because fundamentally, I think I agree with what you're saying, right? Like some assets are completely trusted on one side of the spectrum. And then you have this spectrum of trustlessness where maybe you get this perfect state on the other side of the spectrum that's completely trustless. But of course, no asset can achieve that. I just think the diagram is maybe drawn in a way that does not make that clear and somebody else could do a better job.
I am not a diagram. That is not my day job. I was just trying to write an article to get a concept out there and a mental model out there, which is the mental model of different assets on Ethereum have different degrees of trust. So if you're buying USDC on Ethereum, final settlement actually happens in meat space. It happens inside of a Coinbase bank account in the traditional finance world. And that has much different settlement guarantees than something like DAI, where you have a larger degree of that settlement happening on-chain. And of course, that is much different than something like Bitcoin, where the entire settlement process, it's a bearer instrument.
The entire settlement process is on-chain. I felt like the crypto world didn't completely understand that at the time. Anyway, I actually think that we are closer in alignment maybe than than was previous thought coming into this podcast. And some of this is just as a result of a sloppy diagram design that could be improved upon. What say you, sir? I'm perfectly happy with this resolution of the argument. And I think that if we just zoom out a little bit and like, why are we having this types of disagreements in the first place? It's because, you know, my interest in the cryptocurrency space um you know i've i got into into the bitcoin industry uh very long ago i purchased my first bitcoin in 2012 uh please don't rob me because i got i lost all of them when mount gox uh collapsed in 2014 so don't think that uh you know don't come to my house and think that you're gonna find find an ocean of bitcoins there that i bought for a ten dollars piece um uh but uh you know i've become so fascinated by cryptocurrencies as a concept and as a revolution that I'm so ideologically and philosophically interested in the space that you know how I view my participation and interest in this space it's not about you know I don't care as much as I probably should from a commercial perspective about uh you know making the right types of business relationships or uh positioning myself strategically like if i had that intention of you know just building out um you know making as much money as possible then i would have been on bankless podcast a year ago or you know so to to to market myself but i care about the space and i care about things being stated correctly so that we can as an industry move in the direction that I think is most interesting and that direction is where how much can we decentralize pieces of the economic world and the finance world to basically create a form of revolution that changes how humans can interact and how society can function that is much larger and much more interesting goal to me than you know caring about who I am friends with.
So that's why I will get into arguments with all sorts of people that I kind of actually like. But I cannot, you know, I'm just trying to make sure that we're all on the right path of optimizing how much we can improve the systems of today. Well, Eric, well, I think that is an extremely noble goal. And it's a goal that we share on the Bankless podcast as well. We very much view this as a very fun industry with a lot of money-making potential, but really at the root of it is much more of a political and cultural revolution. And we see ourselves as people that are attempting to steward that revolution into existence.
And so tip of the hat for being on that same path as well. And I kind of want to just dive deeper into why this industry and why this revolution resonates with you so much. You talked about your philosophical interest in this industry. Let's just dive deeper down that hole. What about this industry do you think really is fitting for the future of the world that you think should come about? Yeah, I just want to add one thing to that before we get into that topic, which is, how come the three of us, we seem to have the same ideological alignment. How come we get into these kinds of spats? And I think that has to do that I am such an old, I describe myself as an old dog.
My terminology and my way of thinking of things comes very much from the early days of Bitcoin. And we shaped the early terminology for things in order to make sense and classify different cryptocurrency systems. And that has been a very conservative and restricted type of terminology and taxonomy. So that's why people that come into the space perhaps a little bit later that aren't as plugged into that type of taxonomy thinking, that's why i think we can get into disagreements it just happens that we come a little bit into this space from different angles i'm a long time bitcoiner we care very very much about very specific anal things and we are a bit ocd in terms of that so that's the only reason that i think that you know we have these kind of kinds of spats uh but to get back to your question um you know i have a i have um i i have actually i i don't have a youtube channel but i have a youtube account and i use that youtube account just to collect all the videos of presentations that i've made that other people have uploaded and i put it into a a playlist so that i can you know gather um all my performances uh in the in the past that have been recorded and one of those performances that i personally uh like the most was when i was invited to a Swedish cryptocurrency, just a meetup.
And they asked me to talk about consensus algorithms. And in that format, I got full control of what I wanted to express and what I wanted to say. And what I wanted to talk about there was, and now I think maybe this sounds like an outdated take or, you know, everyone's heard it before, but when this happened this was four four or five years ago i think it was four years ago when we talked about it i described how i view uh bitcoin as a digital uh a primitive digital form of life because if you think about what actually uh constitutes life what is life form is an amino acid alive form is a bacteria alive form uh there is no discrete step where something uh goes from being you know not alive to more alive it's it's a spectrum just like the trust trustlessness spectrum that we talked about uh we when things are complex enough and they are self-sufficient enough and they act organically enough then we say they are alive so you know a bacteria operates almost entirely algorithmically and i think that bitcoin that when i compare bitcoin to a very uh primitive life form uh like a bacteria or even perhaps a mushroom mushroom is the one that i think bitcoin mostly resembles uh i do classify bitcoin as a as a as a as a as a primitive form of life and i think that there are gonna be more and more uh primitive life forms like everyone knows of course like ai when ai becomes sentient but you know not all life forms are sentient uh but they can still be sent because they can still be life forms so we don't have sentient digital life forms yet, but we are now seeing that we are having digital life forms that haven't reached sentience yet.
So the way that I think about it and what makes me most interested in the cryptocurrency space is just thinking about how we are seeing digital things come to life, and we can analyze those as life forms. And I think that if you look at the Bitcoin system, um you know every 10 minutes there's a block it's almost like a pulse and if you listen if you put your ear uh next to a bitmain server hall you can actually hear bitcoin's breath um so i do think i do think of these things as primitive life forms and i'm very interested in and and all cryptocurrencies are competing with each other, which makes it that we also have an evolutionary aspect to it, which where the strong and the weak, it's the survival of the fittest.
It's basically like a big Hunger Games game. And what adds an extra interesting quality to this evolutionary game of cryptocurrencies is that what's, you know, in the physical evolutionary world, you know a cat cannot clone the features of a dog a cat it can do that over many many iterations and it can evolve into a dog if it needs to but in the cryptocurrency world one cryptocurrency can actually steal features from another project which changes the entire dynamics of the evolutionary game so charles darwin when he was analyzing different life forms and evolution um that was probably very interesting to him uh to think about and i think that we have a new uh evolutionary game with different rules that are to me because they're new it's it's even more interesting so it's the intellectual uh challenge of being able to actually take all of that in and analyze it from that perspective and that later also translates like if you understand the evolution of cryptocurrencies, if you have that as your framework, that you're thinking about it as things that have different evolutionary characteristics that make them fit to survive, then you can actually become an investor.
Because if you can pick the ones that are likely to survive, then you can also be a good investor. So that's how, even though this sounds very abstract and theoretical and scientific, it actually maps perfectly well with being a cryptocurrency fund manager because i just gotta try to understand the dynamics of the game and the evolutionary game and and and i think david that you've probably written some article that also tunes into this team haven't you yeah yeah this is a really one of my favorite subjects in this industry is is i actually don't think you can really understand the crypto industry at large if you aren't viewing it from a biological perspective.
And one of the reasons, like this industry is famously like so multidisciplinary and that complexity of so many disciplines turns into complexity theory, which turns into just the conversation that you started off with is where does life actually begin? And we don't really know, but the patterns are that life is always about the management of economic resources. And if some sort of organizational entity can manage these economic resources appropriately to the benefit of the life form and growing, because as a life form, it is efficient at consuming economic resources while also capturing further economic resources, all of a sudden we have the groundings for sustainability.
And so I applied this same sort of mental model to DeFi apps, right? Where DeFi apps are, and I used Ether as like the metaphor of like nutrients or food. Value is like the new communication medium inside of the, you know, the internet of money or the crypto world. And so DeFi apps that consume Ether and then output some sort of like useful product that is demanded by the market are able to go out into the world and venture into this new landscape that is the internet, find nutrients, which is value, you know, valuable assets, and then produce something new, right. And so the mental model for this is that like, or more concrete model for this is that MakerDAO, you come in and you submit ether, you can and the MakerDAO consumes that ether, and then it outputs dye.
And that dye is demanded by the environment around Maker. And so So because Maker is a viable economic manager life form, it has sustainability. And we can talk about that with basically every single DeFi app. Like there's some amount of value input. There's some amount of value output. And because the output is demanded and because the DeFi application is efficient, there is more value that is created by the DeFi app more than it is consumed. And all of a sudden, it is a net outputter of economic resources. which is good for the world. There's more value created by these things than what is consumed.
And that's why they are sustainable and we can put them into the category of life forms. And I think this is an insanely interesting topic of conversation that I was not actually, did not know we would actually be going down this rabbit hole, but it's literally my favorite rabbit hole in all of crypto. Might as well. But yeah, that was something that I dived very deeply into into 2015, 2016. and it's been my framework of thinking for a very long time. But I think you phrased it very well and I resonate with what you said to a very large degree. But yeah, let's jump into the other topics that you guys wanted to discuss.
Well, really quick there, because I think we're starting to see how Eric Wall thinks, right? Which is kind of part of the entire purpose of this podcast, because I think you bring some really interesting insights to the table. But you almost just painted yourself just now as sort of a digital biologist of types, right? Just studying the evolution. Yeah, I used to call myself a crypto Darwinist. Well, there you go. I was thinking about actually giving out that, you know, there's this Darwin award that you give to... Someone does something really stupid though, right? Yeah, and I was thinking that I could be the crypto Darwinist, and I could give the Darwin award to like projects like, you know, like IOTA.
Yeah, that has, you know, if a crypto project has, you know, one server and if that server shuts down the entire system fails, then you get the Darwin award. Okay, so this is like the question of like your lens on the world is a crypto Darwinist, a digital biologist, right? The large question is, I think in that perspective, what sorts of digital life forms are more likely to out-survive others? Because if that's your lens of thinking, that's really how you have to think about everything, whether it's Bitcoin or Ether or Ethereum or any DeFi protocols. I'm curious before we get into some like specific takes from you, Eric, about that lens.
What sort of digital life forms do you think have the best fit in crypto? Well, I'm going to answer your question like from how I thought about it from three years ago. But my thinking has changed a little bit since then. But how I used to think of it was that if you're going to think of something as a life form, is decentralization a very big necessary component? And I do think that it is perhaps one of the most fundamental components into creating something into a life form. Because, you know, if a server on your computer, is that a life form? I mean, you can turn it on, you can turn it off.
It doesn't have an ability to sustain itself. Like if you look at the mushroom, the mushroom actually does provide, it takes up nutritions from the soil of the ground, and it transforms that into a resource for the rest of the ecosystem of the nature. so it doesn't live it lives in a kind of symbiotic relationship with nature and I think that all life forms ultimately in order to survive in the long term have to find their place into the ecosystem into the ecologics of it and I think that Bitcoin fits very well in that category because Bitcoin pays for itself so So people want access to the censorship-resistant system of Bitcoin to preserve wealth and transfer value.
So that's how Bitcoin contributes to us as an organism. And then we contribute to Bitcoin by providing energy and electricity to Bitcoin. So there's a symbiotic relationship there where, you know, it's very difficult to kill Bitcoin because Bitcoin provides something to us. And as long as that organism is providing something to us and actually pays for itself with the currency that the miners can get from mining it, then I see a very strong likelihood for that organism to survive. But then, of course, you know, there are, and I'm not saying that that may, you know, that the most decentralized currency, and this goes into my later stage thinking as of late, you know, how much does decentralization actually matter?
You know, is a cryptocurrency, like if you take something like semi-decentralized cryptocurrency, does it naturally have a shorter lifespan, just because it is more centralized? you know my intuition tells me that more centralized platforms they have regulatory regulatory risks around them that could cause them to get shut down at any point in time so that the more centralized platforms are much more likely to survive in the long term but we also have to consider that okay so so what happens if a if a if a if a semi-centralized platform meets regulatory crackdown can they not fork that platform uh to use a more decentralized consensus algorithm and make the organism survive anyway so i'm not as convinced today that you know i used to just look at the current fundamentals of each system but now i am taking much more into account the transmutative qualities that all cryptocurrencies have and i think that perhaps what breathes life into bitcoin is not the code in the bitcoin system it's much more the community and the developer community that breathes life into the bitcoin system as well as the ethereum system.
And that changes the equation a little bit, if you catch my drift. Eric, so I'm reminded of this metaphor about like ant colonies or beehives where like there is this organism, right? But the organism isn't the bee, it is the swarm, right? It's not the, it's not an individual ant, it is the system at large. And these ants seem to be working in like this mindless, just like algorithm this mindless that each ant feels like this little bit of code and just is part of this overarching system and it's the overarching system that is the entity at large right and that very much feels like bitcoin or ethereum right where like the bitcoin is it's one there's one thing there's one bitcoin but uh there are like you know and potentially infinite nodes right and you what bitcoin is when you download the bitcoin uh blockchain you are replicating Bitcoin.
You are going through the life process of copying the DNA and then putting it on your node, your server. So it's not your server that's alive, but it's the desire to replicate Bitcoin. And so holistically, I mean, there's a reason why Bitcoiners on crypto Twitter are called cyber hornets, right? Like the metaphor sticks. And so not one person or individual represents Bitcoin. It's about a collective movement. But also my question to you is like, you know are to some degree ant colonies and beehives aren't really the most paradigm breaking thing as a life form on this planet like you know humans i would say with with more in my opinion centralized energies inside of us you know a a cerebral cortex and just straight up like brain power i would say that is a an analogy towards more centralization and to some degree like The question is like, well, if there's more centralization, is the lifespan of the system shorter?
Perhaps. But if the regulatory risk never comes to some degree, there is some sort of justification for more centralized operation, more prefrontal cortex operation, if you will. because under the paradigm that regulatory risk never actually comes, well, then you can actually plan and progress further into just become more progressive and more iterative faster. How do you feel about this analogy and this comparison? No, I like it because I like the ant colony analogy. And I think that if you apply that to humans, humans are also ant colonies in two ways. the first way is that you know we just like you said each individual individual ant is a very primitive being that can probably only have perhaps 12 different ideas and one at a time in their head go left go right it's hot here it's warm there it's sticky you know and also smell is one of the things that you use but and we humans we are also but but the colony itself ant colony itself is a completely different life form that can resist uh you know if somebody puts a shovel into an ant colony it restructs it's a it reconstructs itself uh so that uh the ant colony is much more uh sophisticated and has much more uh stronger chance to survive than what a single ant does because it works in this unified uh as a unified life life form and we as humans uh we also function that way in in two ways the first one is that we are made up by a bunch of cells and bacteria and all and our internal organs each component within us is also a little bit like an ant they have they do have very very simple tasks that they perform but the collection of all of those components creates the sentient beings that are us.
So in that way, each individual human is an ant colony, but then if you bring it into a larger scale and you think about society, society is also like an ant colony. And because we are compared to a society, each human is pretty, you know, simplistic. They go to work, they have their desires that they want to fulfill and they write and do things or carry objects but in us but if you think about like a nation or a dao or uh um uh you know you might humanity humankind as a whole that's also a very big ant uh colony and uh i mean of course humanity as a whole has much more uh bigger chance to survive than a single human does so i do think that the centralization happens at many different levels and i do think that you know and that's still something that i'm grappling with you know when i'm analyzing cryptocurrencies uh how much the decentralization quality uh is necessary for the uh long-term life line of that project also because the thing that i previously mentioned that these projects can transform, they can change, they can warp very quickly, much more quickly than anything we've seen in the physical world.
So let's talk about applying your brain and that lens to things. So you mentioned earlier in the introduction, Eric, that you're part of the old guard, got into Bitcoin early, got into Bitcoin to study this digital biology that was in front of you, just intellectual curiosity. You also got in for the social movement, decentralization. You got in for the right reasons before everyone knew it was going to jump to like 50K, right? But we had an inkling at that time. I'm curious though, because I've seen you on Twitter and other places. You're also not afraid to break rank with some of the old guard.
And I think, of course, it's difficult to say that Bitcoin has any one singular thought view, but certainly Bitcoin maximalists do, which is there shall be only Bitcoin. Bitcoin will accrue the most value. There are certain other ideals, I would say, that I would attribute to Bitcoin maximalism. I'm curious your thoughts on this, Eric. What do you think Bitcoiners get wrong? Yeah, this is such a tough topic to discuss and something that I've been one of my like main not only professional but also you know there's personal challenges in life you know I as I said I think that you framed it pretty correctly that I'm this digital biologist and I observe these different life forms and I'm very interested in the dynamics and the interplay and the hunger games of crypto that's what I'm primarily interested in so i don't and in that game you know i have things that i root for and i root for the decentralized ones to survive because if they survive and the industry moves in that way then i think that we have very i mean if we focus on centralized systems and then they get shut down and then the game is over and there's nothing more for me to analyze that's why i try to make sure that we keep things as decentralized as possible and that's why i have been a proponent of bitcoin for very long but if uh there is another system that comes along and it can uh flaunt their wings in a way that uh is interesting you know i'm not gonna say that i just want this single life form uh to persist i want the evolutionary process to produce the absolute best winner.
And in order to do that, you can't lock your mind into a single frame of thinking. And what happened to me interacting with the Bitcoin space was that in 2017, what happened was that you saw all these other cryptocurrency projects pop up and you had tons of capital flowing into ICOs and all of them marketed themselves as the next Bitcoin that had unlimited scalability, no fees and perfect decentralization. And I saw that a large of the community that could have become Bitcoiners and that could have contributed to our goals of breathing this life form or helping this life form develop were directed in the wrong direction.
And I knew that because of my computer science background, I was, and I actually, my master's degree in computer science, I did study, I took my degree to specifically arrange it around the cryptographic primitives that underpin blockchain technology. So my master's thesis that I wrote in 2015 was about blockchain technology. So I knew that I had the ability to dive deeply into these different white papers and understand which projects are poorly constructed. So I took it upon myself to try to educate or help people understand which projects are the wrong directions if we want to create everlasting life forms.
so the reason that i became very popular in the bitcoin industry was because they uh they they they used to call me the altcoin slayer they viewed me as a person that could protect bitcoin and you know i had comfort i had i had uh meetups that i would go to here in sweden where they would you know basically before i went up on stage they called let's bring on the altcoin slayer and then everyone applauds and that made me very very likable everyone liked me in the bitcoin industry and of course i liked being liked by a lot of people a lot but my i my intellectual interest in this space has never been tribal in the sense that i just want my coin to survive i i i i zoom out and i just want the industry to survive and in order for the industry industry to survive it means that we need to make the best decisions possible so what happened to me was that i noticed some types of research going on in the ethereum side of things uh if you if you want if we want to get specific, it was actually the ability that you could construct layer two solutions on top of Ethereum that provided very, very attractive decentralization properties, whilst also preserving much, much more of the UX advantages than, for instance, Lightning does.
so i think that lightning is very good at being decentralized but i don't think that lightning has a great user experience whereas if you look at the roll up uh it's it has a very high degree of decentralization because they've solved the so-called data availability problem that used to haunt these they're two solutions on ethereum protocols before but they solve that problem and a roll-up functions very much in a way as a side chain functions where maybe maybe if i'm getting too complicated with things but if i put it simply in a roll-up what you can do uh if you have an ethereum address i right now i can send you money and an endless amount of money or not endless but i can send you any amount in my wallet to your wallet on the roll-up without you even knowing about the roll-up system existing without you running a node all you to do is generate the private key give me the public your ethereum address and i can send you for low fees at an excellent user experience i can send that money to you whereas in lightning that's not possible the recipient has to run a lightning node they need to have inbound liquidity in order to accept the payment um so uh when i noticed this uh that the layer 2 systems on ethereum um were providing benefits that we couldn't do in bitcoin because we don't have uh statefulness we don't have uh and if we look at something like zk rollups we don't even have the um we don't even have the uh the the the uh the virtual a virtual machine in bitcoin or op codes if you will we don't i don't know if you're familiar with the word but bitcoin basically operates on something called opcodes and each opcodes executes a programmatic function and we don't have complex enough opcodes in bitcoin to create something like a zk rollup and zk rollups and optimistic rollups are excellent layer 2 constructions and we can't build those in bitcoin unless we upgrade the system in a little in in some way so So that made me, you know, I tried to, I thought that, you know, I had this naive theory that because I had been a Bitcoiner for so long and I was the altcoin slayer and everything.
And I thought that everyone really believed me when I, that I was intellectually honest. I thought that I had made enough progress as a Bitcoiner and demonstrating how much I'm committed to the right goals and ideals that when I say that there is something happening in the Ethereum space that we should pay interest to, because it moves the needle in terms of technological innovation, I thought that they would believe me. But they didn't. what happened instead uh they called me uh peter todd called me potentially dangerous and john carvalho uh basically called me um uh i don't know if he called me a scammer or many of them called me an idiot uh and uh rejected uh they thought that i'd become a shit corner but yeah shit corner is basically what happened they started to call me like excommunicated from a religion it feels like a little bit by the high priests yes that's that's very much how how it felt like and i um you know i tried to uh uh say like you know if you want to perfect the like you know i'm still on your team and i think like if you want to make bitcoin the best it can possibly be then we need to look at all types of innovation that is happening in the cryptocurrency space all of that is relevant it doesn't matter where it comes from and i think that people like and i don't want to mention names but there's a lot of people that just inherently mistrust any type of innovation that comes outside of the Bitcoin community.
And I think that that comes from ignorance. It's because they don't have the ability to, I mean, it's just a technological system. The roll-ups are a technological construction. It's objectively defined. It doesn't matter at all who's the author if you just look at the code. And that is a part of the Bitcoin philosophy that we don't care about who Satoshi Nakamoto is. We care about the code and what it can do. So I really don't understand how you can be so against innovation coming out of other projects, if the results of what technology can provide is actually helping you. that seems very much to me like some just you know tribalism and unintellectual uh yeah like you said religious type of behavior that saddens me a great deal and actually i i i said that it broke my heart to see bitcoiners not being able to take this in because it did it did break my heart and it made my uh entire cryptocurrency uh experience completely different realizing that you know we weren't people didn't see it the same way as i did and i am still trying to do what i can to to work for the bitcoin system but i do see so much things happening inside of the ethereum system that i think is really really interesting as well and now i mean bitcoin is this digital gold and i do believe that bitcoin has legs as a digital gold but uh and and i am following the the innovations in bitcoin like taproot upgrades i do think that's interesting but um i mean if you are if you are intellectually curious and uh you want to see what you can do with the blockchain protocol, then it's more interesting to, just as a researcher, to look at what's happening inside of Ethereum right now.
And one of the things that made me, that actually cemented my understanding that Bitcoiners weren't acting in a good faith technological view on these things was that after ZK roll-ups were presented and I tried to bring ZK roll-ups as a research project to the Bitcoin community and I asked them on Twitter like let's look at this research that is being done and isn't it quite fantastic what they've been able to achieve and everyone said no no no that's because complete that comes from metallics computer scam nonsense pre-mine blah blah blah blah uh then uh greg maxwell gregory maxwell who's the one of the most respected and original uh long time contributors to the bitcoin uh system uh he came out and said that yeah uh zk roll-ups uh those are awesome but but they were actually my idea.
Look at this forum post that I wrote in 2013. And I was like, you see, like the developers, the most knowledgeable developers of Bitcoin actually resonate so much with how good and how useful this technology is that they've actually been trying to create it themselves. And now that it has been finished because the Ethereum foundations and other cryptographic, like the Zcash community has worked so much on perfecting zero knowledge proofs. Those are now efficient enough that we can actually use them. Now that they are here, and now Bitcoiners are saying, they're calling it a scam, even though that, you know, we've been trying to create these primitives in Bitcoin for such a long time.
So that just made me, you know, what can I argue with? you know they're even the bitcoin designers themselves wanted this and i think there's just this big gap in the bitcoin community where the developers like the the the the the high priests of bitcoin like the the people on twitter uh they have uh one understanding they have a limited understanding of the bitcoin system and they but they're very uh the the the tones like how they phrase themselves and how they act and how they behave, they think that they're carrying the torch for the Bitcoin developers, that they're preaching the gospel of the Bitcoin, the core views of the smartest people in Bitcoin.
But many times they aren't. And that's my problem. Many times the people who are the loudest in Bitcoin are sometimes not the most educated or knowledgeable about Bitcoin. So then I get into arguments with these people because, you know, usually I don't have that much disagreements with real Bitcoin developers. I just have disagreements with people who don't understand what Bitcoin developers truly think. And so, but me being very vocal on repeat a person on Twitter, the Bitcoin developers aren't that vocal on Twitter, put me in a different category and I had to, you know, I thought I thought I would be able to bridge the gap between the Ethereum and the Bitcoin communities.
But I ended up becoming this controversial figure. Ethereums call me a Bitcoin maximalist. Bitcoiners call me a shitcoiner. I'm trying to stick true to the facts and I'm trying to stick true to technological innovation and progress if that makes a shitcoiner and a maximalist of me at the same time so be it I'm not going to change who I am and what I say and I do want to just add a nuance of humility to that because now I'm making it sound like I'm the smartest guy in the room and everyone else is stupid that only happens most of the time some of the time i'm i'm i'm completely wrong i'm kidding i am i'm not the smartest i'm not you know i don't consider myself to be you know so much smarter than everybody else you know i'm also in the space just trying to learn as much as i can and figure things out and and this is the situation that i've gotten myself into Yeah, Eric, I've also attempted to try and bridge the gap between Bitcoiners and Ethereans, and it seems to be just an insurmountable chasm to cross.
So my question to you to really finish off this part of this conversation before we move on to other things is that, you know, you talk about Bitcoin and its merits and then you also talk about the Bitcoin community and their rigidity and thought. Did your experience with being, you know, being called a shitcoiner by the Bitcoin maxis and everything that you've talked about, did that change your stance towards Bitcoin, the system at all? Or do you separate the community from Bitcoin and say, look, well, there's this tribal community around Bitcoin, but it doesn't really impact Bitcoin, the system, Bitcoin, the BTC, the asset, Bitcoin, the protocol?
Or did your reaction in relationship with the Bitcoin community also change your stance to what you think Bitcoin really is? yeah i mean uh when i started to talk about zk rollups and the necessary opcodes that we would need to implement in uh bitcoin in order to facilitate a a state machine and an opcode that can interpret a zero knowledge proof and uh also just seeing how the discussions around drive chains is going i am a little bit more bearish these days that the types of innovations that i think are necessary to create a useful uh a user-friendly payment mechanism out of bitcoin have been restricted because uh you know because bitcoin if we're gonna upgrade and and make the system as you use useful as possible then we need to i need to make sure that when i speak to the bitcoin community and the developers speak to the bitcoin community that they understand uh what is the most rational path forward and if we become stupid as a community a stupid community cannot make a coin survive good and i don't think many bitcoins believe that bitcoin is perfect as it is and it just needs to continue on and then it will win the world but uh it's not like that i mean you're not gonna have you don't have the capacity in bitcoin uh for everyone to open even lightning channels and even if we even even if we say that we did have the capacity to open up lightning channels using channel factories and all other things that you can do with lightning um like then even then the user experience of Lightning may not be sufficiently well equipped to actually become the payment mechanism that the entire world uses.
So I do think that there are challenges to be overcome when it comes to making Bitcoin perfect. I do still think that Bitcoin is the project that I like the most. But yes, getting shunned from, well, I wouldn't say I'm shunned, you know, I still have, I'm still relatively liked by part of the Bitcoin community. So I'm not completely shunned. But yes, of course, you know, it broke my heart. And it also made me perhaps diversify my portfolio. I've made it public that I do hold Ether. Let's talk about that. Can we talk about that, Eric? Hey, Bankless Nation, I hope you're enjoying this conversation with Eric Wall thus far.
We are about to turn to a recent tweet that Eric Wall just made where he said that I stopped being wrong about Ethereum sometime in 2020, where Eric Wall decided to change his mind and be more optimistic about the future of Ethereum. So we asked what did it take for him to really change his mind after he came, after he had these negative experiences with these Bitcoiners. We also turned to an article he wrote that really impacted me where he titled it, proof of stake is less wasteful. And this actually ultimately became one of the core components of ultrasound money, this thesis that proof of stake is inherently extremely efficient because it has to award the least amount of ether because the people that are staking are the most bullish on it.
So they'll compete for the least amount of ether possible. And that's why proof of stake doesn't have to issue all that much. Eric Wall, as a contrarian lone wolf investor, has been through so many crypto cycles. So we finished off this conversation just asking Eric about what does it take to really make it through this industry in a multi-cycle time frame. And so he has a ton of great lessons and takeaways that I'm really excited to share with you guys in the second half of the show. But first, we have to take a moment to talk about some of these fantastic sponsors that make the show possible.
Balancer is DeFi's most powerful automated market maker. Typical AMMs just have two tokens inside of one liquidity pool, which can lead to fractured liquidity across the many pairs in DeFi. With Balancer, you can access the full power of multiple tokens inside of one single AMM, which unlocks an entirely new playing field of possibility. This makes Balancer an awesome building block for so many different use cases. Balancer pools can make asset indexes, but instead of paying fees to portfolio managers, Balancer lets you collect fees from traders who use your portfolio for liquidity. Additionally, Balancer smart pools can be programmed to have properties that change according to predetermined rules, such as changing the swap fee based on market conditions, or even liquidity bootstrapping pools, which can help you launch and distribute your token with day one liquidity.
At Bankless, we used a liquidity bootstrapping pool to sell our BAP t-shirts to much success. Balancer V2 brings powerful new features that makes your money work even harder for you. In V2, idle tokens are capable of generating yield in DeFi without sacrificing liquidity in the pool. To top things off, Balancer is reimbursing all gas costs with BAP rewards, meaning that all your gas costs are returned to your wallet with the Balancer governance token. Balancer's mission is to become the primary source of liquidity in DeFi by providing the most flexible and powerful platform for asset management and decentralized exchange.
Dive into the Balancer pools at pools.balancer.exchange. Gemini is the world's most trusted cryptocurrency exchange. I've been a customer of Gemini since I first got into crypto in 2017, and it's been my main exchange of choice to make my crypto buys and sells. Gemini is available in all 50 states and in over 50 countries worldwide, and on Gemini there are markets for over 30 various different crypto assets including many of the hot DeFi tokens, and it's one of the few exchanges that has liquid DAI markets. Gemini just launched their Earn program where you can earn up to 7.4% interest on 26 various crypto assets.
If you're tired of paying fees in DeFi or you don't want to worry about DeFi exploits but you still want to earn interest on your crypto assets, Gemini Earn is the product for you. Another product I'm stoked to get my hands on is the Gemini crypto back credit card, which gives you 3% cash back on all of your purchases, but paid to you in your preferred crypto asset. When I get my Gemini credit card, I'm going to make sure that I get my cash back in ETH. So whenever I buy something, I get a little bit of ETH bonus back to me at the same time. You can open up a free account in under three minutes at Gemini.
com slash go bankless. And if you trade more than $100 within the first 30 days after sign up, you'll be gifted a free $15 Bitcoin bonus. Check them out at gemini.com slash go bankless. What we've seen up to this point, I think is someone who is a digital biologist looking at these systems. Also not a Bitcoin maximalist, maybe more of a decentralization optimizer, decentralization maximalist. And it seems to be the case that that's part of the reason that they called you the altcoin slayer is because you called a lot of the altcoins out on their shit, on the stuff that wouldn't work. But that intellectual pursuit also brought you to layer twos and Ethereum and some of the improvements in roll-ups that are being made.
And you saw the potential for decentralization in these layer twos that didn't quite exist in Bitcoin. I put this tweet out, I guess, a couple of weeks ago. I was wrong about ETH, I said. No one actually says that I was wrong about ETH, but a lot of people should be saying it. I get a lot of replies, of course. It's just, you know, it's fun on Twitter to like poke the bear a little bit, Eric. Not that you do that at all. It is fun though. And then your reply was the one that actually was most interesting to me out of the many hundreds of replies that that thread got. And you said this, 2016, I was wrong about ETH when I sold it for $6 after the Dow hack.
2017, I was wrong about ETH when I rushed home to grab my 2FA exchange login after the first Enterprise Ethereum Alliance announcement. I think I had missed the rally. 2020, I stopped being wrong about ETH. And I think you linked to a specific tweet that you made in August 2020. Presumably, you purchased some ETH at that time before you hadn't had as much. Can you talk about that journey? I think a puzzle piece to the journey is bullish on roll-ups, maybe bullish on Ethereum scalability in this new avenue. But was that the only part of the journey? Tell us about the journey. First of all, I think the tweet that you're referring to, I bought Ethereum and I had Ethereum before that, but I did acquire as much ETH as I could when it was trading around $110.
And this was during the COVID, the coronavirus driven crash in, must have been March 2020. But yeah, I did, I was wrong about, you know, in 2016 during the DAO hack, I was, like you said, a decentralization maximalist. And when I saw that the way that I thought about Ethereum was that this was an attempt to build an immutable execution engine for autonomous programs. and the DAO hack showed that social consensus overrules the programmatic code which means that at this point in time, in that point in time the project was heavily centralized around the metallic thought it's become it's improved from that now so I didn't think that after the DAO hack and seeing that actually I sold the reason that I sold was just seeing that the DAO got hacked and I that's when I immediately just rushed and sold all my ether at six dollars and then I was skeptical whether or not fixing surgically fixing the DAO hack using social consensus was the right path now I do think that it is the it was the right decision to make I've changed my my mind there But let's perhaps address the thing that you asked specifically, like when did I actually start to come around to the Ethereum system?
And I think it was probably around, I mean, in 2017, that's when I heard about the Enterprise Ethereum Alliance and Ethereum was trading at $11. And I was at work listening to this webcast where it was being announced. And I understood how huge this was going to be. You had enterprises that were going to use Ethereum. Now the Enterprise Ethereum Alliance didn't turn out to be that big of a deal from my perspective. Anyway, they haven't been that major of a contribution, but it did bring so much validation to Ethereum as a project. So I knew that that was going to be massive. And that's why I rushed home to acquire more ETH at that time.
But I wouldn't say that I was like an Ethereum believer at that point. I just saw that there was going to be probably a rush in the price at that point. What happened was that I was working in the traditional financial sector as a technology provider company. So we were building the company that I worked for was called Sinover. not a lot of people know about this name but in terms of providing exchanges like like the New York Stock Exchange or the Australian Securities Exchange like exchanges where stocks and other financial instruments are traded there are two large companies or there were two large companies providing matching engines and clearing house technologies to the world and that was NASDAQ was the largest one.
They actually have their market technology division here in Sweden where they develop the tech that they sell to other exchanges. And the second company is also here in Sweden. It was called Synover. And they were the largest competitors with each other for 20 years. And I joined that firm right after I finished my master's thesis on blockchain technology and actually wrote the master's thesis for Synover. and the thesis was about how can we use blockchain technology to create a decentralized security settlement system. And then I got to work with Sinober for quite a few years and I very quickly became the head of the cryptocurrency and blockchain strategy there.
And I was involved, well, I was to some extent involved in the, I got to learn how do we supply these exchanges with technology, like when an exchange wants to upgrade, like if a matching engine run by the Australian Securities Exchange wants to upgrade their system and how slow that process was. Like they have to get the technology from a technology provider, and then it goes through all this, you know, Q&A and testing and it's just these types of things could take five years to move from one system to another. The types of innovation that I was seeing happening in the internet overall, you didn't see that in the financial world at all.
And you didn't have open permissionless innovation in traditional finance. It was very clunky and you had all these antiquated systems that were interlinked with each other. and the way that the securities and also the banking system has developed this you know you have the paper-based processes and then you digitize those paper processes to emulate what you could do with pen and paper into digital processes and then you just built on from that and you ended up with this incredibly complex interlinked mess of a system with different moving parts that like if we wanted to recreate the security settlement system and clearing system of today i think we would have done it completely differently but we cannot you cannot change the entire plumbing of the financial world uh by improving the current system i think that you got to start from scratch and i think that uh if you want to start from scratch and you want to give uh you want to make the um the if you want to make the if you want to create the correct environment for innovation then you have to look at how innovation has happened on the internet like when i for instance if i get in if i go to when i went to the u.
s uh i visited a crypto conference in the US in 2018 and I rented a car, a jeep and I wanted to drive through the Nevada desert to go to Las Vegas which was where the conference was and I had a GPS system there and at one point in time I was running out of fuel and I used the GPS system to to point me to the closest gas station. And they said I had to drive two hours to this location. And I was driving on this straight road for two hours. And when I arrived there two hours later, and now I'm almost running out of gas, the GPS tells me that this is the first time that you can turn around your car and go back the other direction and drive four hours that way instead.
and that's the closest gas station so i almost i almost died in the navada desert this was in the death valley part of of the uh of the of the u.s like it's close to the yosemite uh national park so i almost died because of this shitty gps system and it's because uh the car company they got their technology delivered by a specific technology provider provider and if i have my smartphone instead then you know there i can choose between any type of uh map app uh i can choose between apple maps google maps and if they aren't any good there's going to be another app and that's what you want i think of traditional finance as this jeep where i'm restricted to this shitty system that a single company has developed and if you want to upgrade that you have to ask the company give us a better gps system whereas if it's the internet then you can have all people from all over the world deliver apps and you can just install the best one and use the best one and that's why map apps on smartphones are so much superior than than the shitty gps systems that make you die in the Nevada desert that you that you that you'll find in the traditional world so I want that type of permissionless permissionless innovation environment to happen in in the financial world and I wrote a long email to the CEO of our company I still have it it was in 2019, where I told him that, you know, what I'm seeing happening in Ethereum is exactly this vision of not dying in the Nevada desert, because we're having permissionless innovation for financial apps happening right now in Ethereum.
And it's going to move so much faster. It's going to, and because we cannot upgrade, we cannot wait for a thousand engineers to upgrade a thousand antiquated financial systems running on programming languages from the from the 70s that's not gonna we're not gonna get there with it with the current financial system but cryptocurrency like ethereum platforms like ethereum bring us a clean slate where we can create the right type of environment to create the best type of of platform for financial innovation So I think that we basically have like when the taxi industry had their Uber moment. I think that the traditional finance industry is having their Uber moment right now.
And I go and I meet like traditional market making companies and fashion institutions. And I think that they should look at DeFi. And that also makes it complicated for me to talk with Bitcoiners because they hate DeFi. And they hate DeFi because they look at all their rug pulls and they look at all the scams. But I think that's the wrong way to think about it because you could have looked at Bitcoin in 2011 and you could have said, well, the only thing that Bitcoin is used for is to buy drugs on Silk Road. And they would have been correct, but it's the fundamental properties of the system that decides what you can do with it in the future.
It's not how it's currently used. We used to always say, Bitcoin is always used to say, well, yeah, there's a lot of people buying drugs and doing shady stuff with Bitcoin. But if you look at a car, for instance, which demographic was the first demographic to use cars? Well, the cars were very, very expensive. Normal people couldn't afford cars. But people that were making bank robberies, they could spend the money on a car because that could make them actually escape the police when they robbed the bank. So they would buy cars. And that's why criminal people will be the first one to buy Bitcoin because then they can buy drugs and they can make a lot of money.
And in Ethereum, there's going to be a lot of people that are making scams. But if you just focus on that initial usage and you don't think about what can happen with the technology, it's I mean, it's the same way. like maybe internet was mostly used to send around pornographic pictures between horny geeks at one point in time it didn't mean that internet wasn't going to change the entire uh the entire world of finance one day and i have described defy as like a few an hour i think we're moving away away from it but i think that i have described a few a year ago i described defy as in the ASCII version, like the ASCII porn version of the internet, basically.
But you can see that the fundamental properties are there. Everything is working kind of shittily now. But I do think that what's going to come out of this industry is going to be completely amazing and change the entire world. yeah i i like the metaphor of like just the silo data providers or service providers for the gps with as like the current financial institution whereas defy is like this massive crucible survival of the fittest if you don't if you aren't a good product you're not going to make it and and it's all done on this one canonical platform right it's very much like the how we articulate the bull case for defy as well i want to turn to uh one of your also ethereum subjects that you've written about and talked about in the past.
And this was really a pretty like, at least for me, it was very much of a groundbreaking article for how I understood proof of stake. And that was your proof of stake is less wasteful article. And this was, for me, the first articulation of the nature of proof of stake security that is ultimately now a part of a very fundamental piece of the ultrasound money thesis. And so the way that you articulated this is that you it was like you articulated the natural efficiency of proof of stake systems to provide security uh and the way that i articulated this in in response to after reading this your article is that ethereum naturally and proof of stake in ethereum naturally rewards bullishness very much like a defy yield farm right but incentive instead of the incentives of this this ethereum native yield farm which is proof of stake the incentives are so incredibly uh strong because they are being rewarded with ether the asset and naturally the cost of proof of stake is the how much you have to pay people to be bullish on ethereum and if there are plenty of people who are super super bullish on ethereum then the actual cost is to hear ethereum are almost minimal and eric you wrote this piece back at the end of 2019 so um one i want to ask you about like, has your mental models about proof of stake become updated at all since then?
And how do you articulate this, the same kind of thesis, like a year and a half later? Actually, I think that, you know, I spent such an immense amount of time thinking about, you know, I had, I had, you know, I was very influenced by Paul Stork, who's a friend of mine now, that I was very much in the same way as most Bitcoiners at the time thought that you can, it's inherently impossible to create a more cost efficient consensus algorithm because you have a security budget. It means you have a reward that can be farmed by miners or validators. And you're always going to be able to, everyone is always going to spend as much resources as they can to earn that reward, as long as they're still profitable.
So if the reward is $100, you're going to spend at least $99 worth of work, whether it be locking up your capital or burning electricity. So you cannot create a more cost-effective system than what proof of work already is. And that was the way that I thought about it. And then you have this entire conversation around, okay, well, locking up liquidity versus burning energy. If we contrast those two things, Paul Storch's argument was that, well, locking up liquidity also has a cost. It has a cost that now you make capital inaccessible to society that could have been put to bed to better use. that's a that's a very very uh actually complicated uh thing that i go through in the piece and there's multiple ways that you can look at that uh one way that you can look at it is that okay but when you lock up capital uh the value doesn't get trapped there it actually flows back to the like if you have if you have like if you have bitcoin and we take 50 of the supply of bitcoin and we lock it up and only 50% is circulating, then it's going to, and demand can only go into the circulating amount of the supply, the value is going to rise in the in the in the unlock in the circulating pool.
So you cannot fundamentally trap value. But there the nuance there that I go through in the article, I think, is that when when you have specific parties locking up their capital in the the the participants that has this capital to lock up, they are usually people that have accumulated resources. And people that have accumulated resources probably have some type of knowledge. And when they lock up their liquidity and it just flows back and it gets splashed over this uniform blob of people, then you actually do lose some economic potential because it's now, you have concentrated portions of liquidity that can be injected into projects that can it can be invested it can be used to do productive things now it just flows back into a a gray blob of people and they don't necessarily like if everybody if you put a hundred dollars in every a person's pocket it doesn't necessarily mean that anything exciting is going to happen they're going to buy a hot dog and and then it's over.
Whereas this single investor with all that capital could have created a fantastic business. So I do think that there is definitely like some, there is a cost to society for locking up liquidity. But if, like you said, if the person that is locking up that liquidity, if what he wanted to do with that liquidity was just to hold Ether, then there is no negative consequence. And that's what I realized in the article, that if you have these bullish people on Ether, then they are going to be the, when they are staking Ether, they're not causing any cost to the society overall. And just in the same way that we're talking about in Bitcoin mining, the people who are going to be the most profitable mining Bitcoin are the ones that have access to the cheapest source of electricity.
And that's usually people that are monetizing excess renewable energy, like the energy that they can't use for anything else. They can only throw it away or mine Bitcoin with it. Their cost for the electricity is zero. So that's going to be the... Bitcoiners think that that's going to be the predominant source of electricity for Bitcoin. And if you apply that same lens of thinking to Ethereum, then what is the cheapest source of liquidity in Ethereum? Well, it is the people who are committed to holding Ethereum for a very long time. They have no alternative cost. There's nothing else that they would have done with the capital.
They have zero cost to use this capital to stake Ether. They do take on some risk. There's always, of course, some risk. There must be some risk with staking, but there is no cost to society. and with mining you still have like even if we say that all the energy in the world that is being used to mine bitcoin you still have the cost of actually producing the asics the asic miners you cannot make those that cost disappear you cannot say that that is 100% produced by renewable you know you didn't get the steel from from wind i mean so so because of that proof of stake is actually less wasteful.
And I do think if Ethereum becomes a form of money or something that people believe in, like an investment that people want to hold, I don't want to go exactly into that, but if we just take a cryptocurrency system that runs on proof of stake, and we say that this system is going to be the hard sound money that we're going to use in the future, then there's going to be tons of people that just hold the currency because hard money inherently increases in value in alignment with the output of society growing. The production rate of society, as that improves, it's going to increase the value of the currency.
That's how economics work. And it works very well when the supply of the currency is fixed. So yes, I do think that what's written in that article very much, you know, I think I came to the conclusion. And Paul actually wants to debate me about this article. He thinks that I am wrong. And we have scheduled a preliminary debate. We haven't set the date. But we have decided that we are going to discuss this in deep detail at one point. However, other people say that they want us to do it in written format because it's too difficult to go through these very, very complex nuances online. But I hope I answered your question that, yes, what I wrote there is very much how I think about it today.
Eric, what's so fascinating to me about this is like bringing this full circle to sort of like human beings as a having collective power. Human beings is almost like an ant colony, right? So like, what is money? Money is the collective thought of a society, of a group of human beings in terms of where they want to store their wealth and where they want to store their value, right? There's almost like this mimetic quality to money. What is the best money? It's the money that everyone else chooses to be money. And what's interesting to me about your argument is like, we talked about this with Justin Drake in Ultrasound Money, which is like an Ultrasound Money episode, which is like if a network, a crypto economic network like Bitcoin or Ethereum has a monetary premium in its base asset, it gets this economic security for free, essentially.
And you just extended that in 2019 with your article to proof of stake. So if there's a bunch of people who are bullish about Ether and they hold their Ether, they're going to do this at the lowest possible cost. It's almost like the network gets economic security at a discount. Why? Because the base layer asset has this special privilege in that it is a monetary asset. And not all cryptocurrency networks get to have that privilege. Bitcoin, of course, has had it. We would argue on Bankless that Ethereum is also getting it. But I noticed something, Eric, that you stopped short of calling Ether sound money.
And I'm curious because you have this history in Bitcoin. What is holding you back from thinking about Ether as sound money? Or am I wrong about that? Do you think Ether is sound money right now? I think you know my answer already. And I think that, I mean, Bitcoin is a reaction to that money can be so easily manipulated by politics in the central banking system. And Bitcoin goes in a completely different direction. It takes us back to the gold standard. And we adhere to the philosophy of Bitcoin and Bitcoiners all over the world. We care most of all about the predictability of the monetary policy of Bitcoin.
And we view that as one of the most foundational properties of a good sound money. Whereas in Ethereum, you have a different philosophy where you care more about securing Ethereum. You want to secure your DeFi systems by having a sufficient security budget for that. And you don't have any qualms about changing the emission rate of Ether to accommodate what the system needs. so the reason why I do think of Bitcoin as having an upper hand in becoming a dominant store value and the dominant medium of exchange is because the meme of a strong monetary immutable monetary policy whether or not that actually actually works in practice or not you know that reality facts and facts don't actually uh have so much influence into the thinking and brains of humans but it it it is the memes that that count so i think that the meme of an immutable predictable uh monetary policy that bitcoin has historically followed uh whereas ethereum hasn't and also the the the the very beautiful uh inception of bitcoin of the satoshi nakamoto who never ever uh spent a penny of the early uh bitcoins that he made and then he disappeared and had no influence in the system bitcoin is much more this abstract brand it's it's just bitcoin you don't know who the founder is and the monetary policy is immutable it aligns so it fits so much well uh it's it fits so much better into this category of a digital gold than ethereum does and i do think that there is uh very strong reasons why gold was the most formidable form of money for thousands of years in human history and i think that the cryptocurrency that better emulates those properties are gonna win in the memetic game of of creating a sound uh money because after all it is a magnetic game Now, I do think that the Bitcoin is going to… the mistake that Bitcoiners did was focusing on the stock-to-flow ratio, which is… I mean, gold has an emission rate, right?
There's new gold being brought out, dug out of the ground that isn't 100% predictable, but all we know that is roughly is around 2% every year. year. But because Bitcoin is supposed to have a fixed supply, then this whole idea of, you know, the stock to flow model, of course, I think perhaps most of your listeners do. I mean, now so many Bitcoiners think that the reason that Bitcoin is going to be successful and hyper Bitcoinization is going to happen is because the price is going to go up so much just because Bitcoin has a fixed supply. But if you are now in that frame of thinking, and now Ethereum is going to burn a portion of its fees after EIP-1559 gets activated, and Ethereum could create it, and is already creating a meme of itself in having a deflationary supply, a supply that shrinks because the gas fees are being burnt then now the stock to flow ratio of uh of ethereum isn't even infinity it's goes into the negative because it actually goes into the complex number plane uh so uh i think bitcoiners have shot themselves in the foot by play trying to play the memetic sound money game by looking at the stock to flow ratio and you know how much i did to uh try to get bitcoins away from that uh because i knew that this would uh everything up for bitcoin if we focused on too much on the stock flow ratio and that's why i've spent the last uh year or so trying to uh get people away from the stock to flow ratio obsession and getting them more focused on the rainbow chart which doesn't have this uh supply centric uh way to analyze how the price should develop and that's that's why i'm now uh the rainbow guy uh because i i knew that this was gonna happen i tried to get people away from from uh the stock to flow ratio uh i ultimately i think i perhaps failed and because of that uh ethereum is gonna uh have a great uh chance to compete in the memetic game of being sound money that's the bitcoiners fault on their own they created this situation for themselves and the way that i uh the way that i how i acted in that situation is i just i i i i i built a larger ether exposure in my bags because uh in in 2001 one year ago i i i knew that uh uh first of all i knew that the layer two solutions uh for ethereum were gonna uh work out And I knew that I also knew that there's going to come tons of people into the cryptocurrency debate and they're going to think that Bitcoin uses too much energy.
And also, I understood that EIP, this happened a bit later, I think, a while later that I understood that the supply of Ethereum is also going to shrink. I did see that you know now Ethereum has so much potential to start competing in the memetic game of being money that you know flippening is no longer off the table you know I personally still prefer the predictable monetary policy like that's how I think that we should that's the most powerful principle to stick by if you want to create sound money but I do think that Ethereum has been fundamentally undervalued because it has these other arguments that also resonate very well so i did build out a big uh ethereum uh stack and now i'm outperforming bitcoin because of that so uh thank that's thanks to the stock to flow bitcoiners that made stock to flow such a big part of what cryptocurrency is that i'm now now i can bank on the meme of uh deflationary supply in Ethereum because of that.
So I guess that's the silver lining of being tortured by these stop-the-flow obsessionists. Eric, do you think that Ethereum being sound money, Ethereum is either disqualified from being sound money, or do you think that it could become sound money via different routes other than just a completely hard cap monetary policy is this something that ethereum ether and ethereum can find over time uh and then also uh do you think that if there is a flippening that it is uh pre the prerequisite is of that you know if the ether being quote unquote sound money in the eyes of you know the people that value it or can it or can it flip in bitcoin via other um you know just other merits well i think that Ether can become money.
I don't think that Ether can become sound money in the sense that Bitcoin can become sound money. It can become a kind of money that people may use and they may even use it if this edge case of the flipping does happen and Ethereum wins over Bitcoin and people start to use it as money. it's going to be much much sounder money than any type of fiat money that we have because even though that yes the monetary policy can be changed it's still going to be it's like bitcoiners like to say well bitcoin ethereum is not no different than you know just a central bank designed to buy treasury bonds or changing interest rates and then printing money but But I do think it's different.
I mean, it is, after all, a centralized protocol. And if you're involved a little bit in Ethereum governance, you know that Ethereum at least has the potential to cement its strategy around the monetary policy much more than what you could expect from an Asian state. So I do think that Ethereum can be much sounder money than fiat currency can be. But I don't think that Ethereum necessarily should strive to ever become, I mean, Ethereum can become sound money in the sense that the supply is very constrained, right? We can reach that phase where it's actually a negative emission rate year over year.
But that's not my definition of sound money. My definition of sound money also includes this predictability. And it's never going to get as good of a brand in that category as Bitcoin has because Bitcoin never changed its monetary policy. And Bitcoin also has this immaculate conception and leaderless launch and brand around it that Ethereum can never compete with. But that doesn't mean that, you know, it doesn't mean that it still can't, that it can't win ultimately. So I do think that the flipping can happen. and Ethereum can be relatively sound money, but it's never going to get as far. If Bitcoin succeeds as sound money, it's going to be a sounder form of money than Ethereum can achieve in its best case scenario, if that makes sense.
So, Eric, we've given Bitcoiners a hard time on this episode. I think it's time to give Ethereans a hard time too. what's something you think ethereans get wrong oh my god well it's too much is your brain just spilling over with all of these things i mean uh you know i don't i don't want to point fingers at specific people and specific projects but i think that there is like the i think that like overall the entire ethereum project is an entire mess right now and some can think that it's it's a it's a beautiful innovative mess but i actually do think that governance wise it's uh kind of a a clusterfuck it's not the best uh governed system that you have out there.
I do think that the Ethereans themselves, like the Ethereum people, they don't many times they don't understand the types of, like if you take a DeFi application for instance and then they start to talk about the qualities of this DeFi application and what they're describing, like if you talk about the decentralization and the trustlessness properties of this application compared to what the factual reality is, then Ethereans are very easily misled into thinking that the product is much better than it is. And they underestimate so many of the risks that they are creating in DeFi that, you know, I'm seeing these, I'm constantly seeing these systemic risks being built up inside the Ethereum system.
And I don't think that the stewards of the, like the Ethereum thought leaders and the builders of Ethereum. I mean, I see so many things coming out of Ethereum's mouths that make me shiver on a daily basis. Like, if we just take an example, like, do you remember when we had this whole SupplyGate scandal in when we tried to get just somebody to respond to what the supply of Ether was? Like, how many Ethers there are out there? And for listeners, there was sort of a narrative among Bitcoiners. It's just like, hey, you can't prove what the supply of ETH is, Ethereans. Tell us what the supply of ETH is.
And a number of prominent Bitcoiners, you know, pushed this out and kind of challenged the Ethereum community to say what the supply of Ether was. That's what you're referring to. Yeah. And then Vitalik said, look at Etherscan. And that was, I mean, I cannot understand. Like, did you just miss eight or ten years of crypto economic history? Like, did you just miss the entire purpose of what we're trying to achieve here? we're trying to build systems that can be independently verified by everyone, then you cannot, if you're creating this acceptance that looking at sources like Infura, looking at sources like Etherscan, if that is the basis that you're, that's how you're educating people in your system, you're gonna end up...
I'm thinking, you know, what I'm most worried about in Ethereum is that you're constantly compromising on decentralizing... I mean, first of all, I gotta give Ethereum kudos that compared to Solana and Avalanche and and Binance Smart Chain and all these other Ethereum killers, then Ethereum has stayed true to the decentralization philosophy much more than those other projects. That is why Ethereum has difficulties scaling and moving fast. and then you know they are you know ethereums are actually trying a little bit to have a decentralized system uh whereas many of you know the affinity in these products they don't care and they're a hashgraph they don't care about it at all ethereum they you do care you didn't care about it so so i gotta give you this for that first of all but uh when you when we're when we're talking about you know syncing the an ethereum node for instance we're always we're always moving uh the gold post so first it was let's sync the entire ethereum uh chain then you know let's just look at the uh the state route of ethereum and let's just sync from that and then we can then we can use what's called fast sync so we just say we just look at the we just look at the current state and then we just verify the proof of work on the headers and now we're moving to snap sync which syncs even like in fast sync you actually did sync you did fully sync part of from from a snapshot you did sync the actual ethereum blockchain but in snap sync you're syncing even less of the uh and that's becoming the default now that you're you're actually validating less and less and less of the ethereum protocols and rules uh all the time in order to make your clients faster and i think also that the determine the terminology and the language uh is deteriorating where because i think it's fine like i think it's completely fine if you want to snap sync your node if you think that security mechanism is enough for you by all means do it there are bitcoiners that run their clients with assume valid flags where they also skip part of the of the validation but if you're going to call that a full node if you're going to call those nodes full nodes and you say it validates them what people are going to think is that they are independently invalidating the entire system then you are creating these systemic risks in the Ethereum system where all of a sudden we've changed the terminology so much and we changed the default settings of everything so much that we can actually have the entire system collapse by very few nodes actually collapsing.
Like if you take Matic for instance, like I did tweet about Matic pretty recently and I did say that I am just learning about the system because I have ignored Matic for a long time because I consider it to be a just a proof of stake side chain and I'm much more interested in the roll-up things but from my understanding a Matic node it gets its the keys, the validators in Matic they are chosen in an Ethereum smart contract on the main net that's where those keys are set but the full nodes in matic they don't sync the ethereum chain so how do they know when they're looking at that contract how do they know that what is inside that ethereum mainnet smart contract is actually valid if the matic nodes don't actually sync the ethereum chain so it's these types of things that i see where you're having applications that are just reading information from completely centralized sources and you're creating not at all in many cases decentralized systems.
I do have to say though that I have changed my... I used to be so anal about decentralization when it came to Ethereum that I didn't think that that I thought everything was going to fail, but I have later changed my thinking now to valuing much more than just the permissionless quality. Like what you really need to have in order to create this innovative environment is just that people can build things permissionless, that they can use it without there being any guardians. So it's permissionless to build. That's the most important quality. And I don't know if decentralization I mean, decentralization saves you from a few, perhaps not very likely risks that may not happen, or regulatory clampdowns that may not happen.
But the way that the DeFi revolution is going to happen mainly comes from the permissionlessness quality and the composability qualities more. So I'm not that concerned about that Ethereum is just semi-decentralized these days. Did that answer your question? It does, yeah. And we absolutely don't have time to go into all of those items. I will note on the supply issue, the Ethereum community eventually provided a much better response than what you said was Vitalik's initial response with some code that sort of validated the Ether supply. But what's super interesting, Eric, is I think among honest Bitcoiners that we see who are drawn towards the thesis of decentralization, we hear kind of a common sentiment of like, the thing I worry about Ethereum is an erosion of the values of decentralization.
And it can happen to a community quickly. And I think that's really what you're expressing in your comments here. One other axis of decentralization that I think the Bankless program emphasizes to you is the axis of having a banking layer that is custodial. So that I feel is an erosion of the Bitcoiner value systems. If you're using instead of a trading system like Uniswap, which is relatively decentralized, you're doing your trading on Coinbase or Binance. when you are using BlockFi instead of Aave, right? So that is another axis that I feel like the Bitcoin community doesn't look at enough.
The decentralization of not just their monetary system, but the banking layer on top. And Eric, we probably don't have time to get into all of that because we've got to come to a close. Is there anything you want to say though, quickly? No, I want to say that I think that you're correct. And I think I was on a podcast with Stefan Levera and Udi Wertheimer talking about okay so what if lightning doesn't work out they said well we're probably going to use you know custodial solutions for transferring bitcoin and i do think that yes because you can do so much more with ethereum we're going to be able to decentralize more things inside the more parts of finance is going to be decentralized in ethereum um so i do very much resonate with what you just said right now and i do think that it is true that bitcoiners do underplay that part of this conversation.
So yeah, I agree with you on that. No, I'm sure that definitely, yeah. Eric, on the Bankless podcast, we like to give out this line about just how we are all like going west. We are all exploring the frontier. You don't have to do it alone. You can join a community, you can join a club, but I see you as venturing off in the frontier very much on your own as like this lone wolf person who very clearly thinks for himself, but has, you know, chosen to specifically not be tribal and really just stick to your own guns and stick to your own values and, and thought processes. And, and you and the other characteristics I would describe to you is that you kind of default to skepticism.
And you generally proceed with caution, which I think are very valuable characteristics to have and perhaps why you have been in the crypto industry for so long and not gotten washed out as so many people do so can you kind of reflect on on these qualities uh maybe the ones i named and maybe the ones i didn't name that you think have really been helpful for you to navigate this industry for such a long period of time and then also what do you have any other advice for you know first cyclers or crypto novices who are just getting into this world of crypto and think that perhaps like cardano or ripple are the future yeah definitely uh you know i um it's pretty crazy, but I did find a unique, what I found in my opinion was a unique niche in the cryptocurrency space was to just stick to the truth, like just stick to the, like what is the actual nature and reality of the situation and speak your mind without bias.
So I try to be as unbiased as possible. And surprisingly, there's almost nobody else that is trying to fill that niche of being as unbiased as possible. Most people, they have their project. They want to make the best out of that project. And I don't know if there are any other unbiasedness maximizers out there. I know that there are some like there I like I think that probably Hasu friend of mine that he also I feel like he sticks to that principle of just not caring about bias and just caring about the reality so so yeah that's that's what I have to add on that and you also asked me about you also asked me about if I have any first cycle recommendations to people So when we started to talk in this podcast, we talked about how I came into this space as this digital biologist.
But it's actually not entirely correct. I actually came into the space as someone that wanted to learn how to become a financial trader. So for it was only a few years down the road when I really understood the components of the blockchain that I understood that it was primitive life form. But I spent two years or three years trying to learn how to trade. And for many of those years, I was using very, very stupid, primitive technical analysis. I was looking at the same dumb indicators that you see all of these technical TA advisors use. I was following the MACD RSI indicators and trading based on that.
And it took me until I learned how to program and backtest my own strategies to understand that I was doing complete nonsense things. And then I started to question the whole field of technical analysis and especially the Bitcoiner technical analysis that I found out that it was basically just a big scam. And if I could give anybody some advice, don't go down the technical analysis route. They don't work. They're not going to sell you a course that's going to make you infinite money for $50 a month. Try to get involved in communities. You can become actually very rich in the cryptocurrency space by just learning how these systems work, producing value and becoming members of for instance dows and ethereum and uh i mean these like i think you have put it in a pretty nice way that like we we have dows in ethereum that are looking for workers and if you can provide work to those dows you you can get crypto coins then you can use those crypto coins to invest in other systems that you understand and then you can build wealth for yourself that is how you become profitable uh in this industry if you're starting with no capital today versus trying to buy a $50, of course, that's pretty much my advice.
There you go, Bankless Nation. That advice from Eric Wall. Of course, none of this was financial excess, but Eric has been in crypto since 2012. He survived up to this point by holding views on decentralization and thinking about the long-term of this space, the long-term trajectory. Eric, It's been a pleasure to have you on Bankless. You know what, man? I feel like we're much more aligned than I thought we were at the start of this podcast. And it's always good to see a kindred spirit in the space who's here for some of the same reasons we are on the Bankless podcast. So thanks for joining us, man.
It was a pleasure. Thanks for having me on. Action items. Of course, you have to follow Eric Wall at ERCWL on Twitter. Got some fire thoughts coming at you. We will also include some of the articles we referenced in the show notes. One that David mentioned, proof of stake is wasteful on cows, volcanoes, and staking. If that doesn't tweak your interest, I'm not sure. Proof of stake is less wasteful. Is less wasteful. Thanks, David. Very important point. Very important point. Disregard what I just said. Anyway, the show notes are available for you to read. Those articles are referenced. Of course, guys, risks and disclaimers.
Bitcoin is risky. ETH is risky. DeFi is risky. you could lose what you put in, but we are headed west. This is the frontier. It's not for everyone, but we're glad you're with us on the Bankless journey. Thanks a lot. market analysis, our alpha leaks and exclusive content, and even the Bankless token for airdrops, raffles, and unlocks. If you're interested in crypto, the Bankless community is where you want to be. Click the link in the description to become a Bankless premium subscriber today. Also, don't forget to subscribe to the channel for in-depth interviews with industry leaders, ask me anythings, and weekly roll-ups where we summarize the week in crypto and other fantastic content.
Thanks everyone for watching and being on the journey as we build out the Bankless nation.