Luke Burgis is an author, entrepreneur, and professor. In his new book Wanting, Luke discusses the mimetic (mimicking) roots of our desires and behaviors. Viewing our species from this lens yields a vast wealth of insights about the nature of society, and we discuss how the internet (and crypto) pose to dramatically shift our understanding of these things.
------ 🎙️ EXCLUSIVE EPISODE DEBRIEF : https://shows.banklesshq.com/p/exclusive-debrief-the-power-of-mimetic 🎖 CLAIM YOUR BADGE: https://newsletter.banklesshq.com/p/-guide-2-using-the-bankless-badge ------ BANKLESS SPONSOR TOOLS:
💰 GEMINI | FIAT & CRYPTO EXCHANGE https://bankless.cc/go-gemini
🔀 BALANCER | EXCHANGE & POOL ASSETS https://bankless.cc/balancer
👻 AAVE | LEND & BORROW ASSETS https://bankless.cc/aave
🦄 UNISWAP | DECENTRALIZED FUNDING http://bankless.cc/uniswap
------ 📣 KYBER | Learn about Liquidity Mining with Rainmaker! https://bankless.cc/kyber ------
BANKLESS PODCAST #72: The Power of Mimetic Desire Guest: Luke Burgis
When we explore what crypto is all about, it often brings us back to the fundamental questions. What is money? What is value? What are the characteristics of a good society? In our conversation with Luke Burgis, we dive even deeper: what drives our basic desires and behaviors? Luke makes an incredibly compelling argument that the root of our wants and perceived needs derive from Mimetic Desire -- the idea that we look to others and mimic what they do.
Mimetic desire appears to emerge among all successful social species. As humans, we learn how to exist in a society by observing and processing those around us. Our parents, friends, and communities at large all collectively inform how we perceive the world around us. In this model, the individual melts away, and instead, we become interdependent nodes in a network of ideas, ideologies, actions, and behaviors. We often want things because others want them. Although rationality certainly plays a role, it takes a back seat to the more immediate and salient driving forces of mimesis.
How does this relate to crypto in particular? Well, mimesis certainly drives the patterns we find in markets: speculation and adoption are both functions of mimetic desires. This model also applies more broadly when we consider the coordinative power of the internet and blockchains. If we accept mimesis on the aggregate and individual scale, we can more fully grasp the scale and scope of these new social and economic technologies.
Hot off the release of his book 'Wanting: The Power of Mimetic Desire in Everyday Life,' Luke is fascinated by the potential of blockchains to revolutionize how we interact and function as a species and society. However, Mimetic Desire won't be going anywhere anytime soon.
------ Topics Covered:
0:00 Intro 6:50 Luke Burgis 9:05 What is Mimetic Desire? 16:25 Modeling Desire 23:35 Coping with Abundance 27:19 Collective, Shared Desires 31:30 Genes & Memes 37:25 Mimetic Desire & Memes 45:20 Subjective Scarcity & Rivalries 54:24 The Internet & Mimetic Desire 1:01:00 Bitcoin and The Role of Money 1:12:10 Wealth is What You Want 1:17:43 Markets, Bubbles, Mania 1:26:58 Rivalrous Communities 1:33:00 Mimetic Bubbles & Reflexivity 1:39:45 Algorithms Determining Outcomes 1:43:49 Legitimacy 1:48:40 What about Rationality? 1:52:22 The Take on Crypto 1:55:20 Closing & Disclaimers
------ Resources:
Luke on Twitter https://twitter.com/lukeburgis?s=20 Luke’s Newsletter https://read.lukeburgis.com/ Wanting on Amazon https://www.amazon.com/Wanting-Power-Mimetic-Desire-Everyday/dp/1250262488/
------ Not financial or tax advice. This channel is strictly educational and is not investment advice or a solicitation to buy or sell any assets or to make any financial decisions. This video is not tax advice. Talk to your accountant. Do your own research.
Disclosure. From time-to-time I may add links in this newsletter to products I use. I may receive commission if you make a purchase through one of these links. Additionally, the Bankless writers hold crypto assets. See our investment disclosures here: https://newsletter.banklesshq.com/p/bankless-disclosures
No summary for this episode yet.
Welcome to Bankless, where we explore the frontier of internet money and internet finance. This is how to get started, how to get better, and how to front run the opportunity. I'm Ryan Sean Adams, I'm here with David Hoffman, and we're here to help you become more bankless. David, what an episode. Really cool lens on crypto, memetic desire. What did we cover today? We brought on Luke Burgess, who wrote this book, wanting the power of memetic desire. And this came on my radar when I was listening to Luke on Hidden Forces, the Hidden Forces podcast. We had a Dimitri Cuffinus on that is a past episode.
And I immediately knew that we needed to get this guy on bankless because he's talking about some of these very core fundamental things that we talk about on bankless at times, but in a different lens. And also, I think Luke talks about it just in a little bit more clear and articulate way. The conversation of what memetic desire is is both important for anyone anywhere to understand, but it's especially important in crypto where some of these assets are particularly valued by reflexivity or by groupthink or by collective psychology. We all know in the world of crypto, you survived by understanding multiple different disciplines.
This is a very multidisciplinary industry. And the power of memetic desire transcends all disciplines, all academic studies and applies to crypto in so many different respects. And so we brought Luke on to talk about and teach the bankless nation what is memetic desire? How does it impact our lives? And then we frame it in a crypto conversation in the second half of the show. Yeah, David early on, you know, we've always been starting bankless. We've known that memes are important to this entire industry. And so early on, we did an episode on memes that was so fun. But it didn't have like a ton of research.
It was just kind of crypto natives take on on memes, right? It's just kind of you and I. We've always wanted to return to this concept of memes. Now, this isn't quite like, this isn't just memes because memetic desire is not memes, but it is related to memes. And it's almost the energy that propels memes. But oh my god, it's an important concept. Like again, one of those fundamental concepts that if you don't understand memetic desire, you probably don't understand crypto. You might think you understand crypto, but you actually don't. And I'm just like, this is an episode that I'm going to think about a lot because the implications aren't just like many things we cover on bankless aren't just crypto implications.
These are like life implications and how society is organized implications and like how I'm going to be thinking about this episode because it's going to be one of those things where I start to see it everywhere. And then I'll have to make decisions with this new mental model of framework and see how I'm being influenced, how my memetic desires are being influenced and make more rational decisions as a result. But I think this is going to be a key cornerstone episode for you guys. And it's definitely a key mental model and concept that we're going to keep returning to on bankless. It is that important.
Right. So bankless nation, I want you to step into the side of the matrix and get ready to pull that cord right out of the back of your head because that's what this episode feels like. It's one of those things like this feels very much on par with our Vitalics episode on legitimacy, which we bring up is actually one of the themes of this show. Also felt like the Josh Rosenthal episode where we're really just zooming out and viewing this thing from a very very holistic perspective. And that really helps set the foundations to how to operate inside this industry. But like you said, also just live your life.
This is just good life information. It just also so happens that crypto is also good life information. And it applies to crypto just as well as it does life. David quick prediction. I think Luke is going to go crypto native. I think he's going to become a member of the bankless nation. He's super open-minded about it. You guys should stay listened to the end. Make sure you hear Luke's comments when we ask him the question of what do you think about crypto? Super insightful there too. All right guys, well let's get into the conversation. But before we do, we want to thank the sponsors that made this episode possible.
Balancer is a powerful platform for flexible automated market makers. Typical AMMs just have two tokens inside of one liquidity pool, which can lead to fractured liquidity across the many pairs in DeFi. With Balancer, you can access the full power of multiple tokens inside of one single AMM, which unlocks an entirely new playing field of possibility. This makes Balancer an awesome building block for so many different use cases. Balancer pools can make asset indices, but instead of paying fees to portfolio managers, Balancer lets you collect the fees from traders who use your portfolio for liquidity.
Additionally, Balancer smart pools can be programmed to have properties that change according to pre-determined rules, such as changing the swap fee based on market conditions, or even liquidity bootstrapping pools, which can help you launch and distribute your token with day one liquidity. At Bankless, we use a liquidity bootstrapping pool to sell our BAPT shirts too much success. Balancer V2 brings powerful new features that makes your money work even harder for you. In V2, idle tokens are capable of generating yield in DeFi without sacrificing liquidity in the pool, using Balancer's asset managers.
Balancer's a vault architecture lets you trade between at Balancer pools at a fraction of the cost versus trading on other platforms. Balancer's mission is to become at the primary source of liquidity in V5 by providing the most flexible and powerful platform for asset management in decentralized exchange. Dive into the Balancer pools at app.balancer.fi. The Ave Protocol is a decentralized liquidity protocol on a theory, which allows users to supply and borrow certain crypto assets. Ave Version 2 has a ton of cool features that makes using the Ave Protocol even more powerful. With Ave, you can leverage the full power of DeFi money Legos, yield and composability all in one application.
On Ave, there are a ton of assets that you can supply to the protocol in order to gain yield, and all of those same assets can also be borrowed from the protocol if you have supplied collateral. Here you can see me borrowing 200 USDC against my portfolio of a number of different DeFi tokens and eith. I'll choose a variable interest rate because it's a lower rate than this stable interest rate option, but I can choose this stable interest rate option if I wanted to lock in that interest rate permanently. V2 also features the ability for users to swap collateral without having to withdraw their assets, trade them on unit swap and deposit them back into Ave.
With Ave users can do this in one seamless transaction, saving you time and gas costs. Check out the power of Ave at Ave.com. That's A-A-V-E dot com. Bankless Nation, we are super excited about our next guest. This is Luke Burgess. He is the author of a book titled Wanting, the power of the memetic desire in everyday life, read his book, so is David. Luke really came to our attention after his appearance in the Hidden Forces podcast. We wanted to get Luke on to explain this memetic desire concept, which is that kind of the base of a lot of things in crypto, maybe a lot of things in life, maybe everything in life actually when you dig deep enough.
We want to relate that to the bankless journey as well. Luke, it is fantastic to have you. How are you doing today? Hey guys, I'm doing really well. Thanks for having me on. Man, we have so much to dig into because when Dave and I stumbled across this concept of memetic desire, we just immediately saw so many things in crypto through which are kind of like different or could be seen through this lens and could help people who are investing in crypto, buying crypto on the bankless journey in general. We want to divide this into two acts or two pieces here, Luke, if you could help us with that.
The first is we want to understand this concept that is core to your book, this concept that you call memetic desire. There's another related concept around memes that we've talked about on bankless. We want to talk about those two things, how they're related, how they're different. And then we want to apply the lens of memetic desire to some concepts in crypto, concepts like money, the social coordination game of money, concepts like markets, concepts like NFT, these concepts that exist in the traditional world, but also exist in an accelerated way in crypto, certainly in a digital way, something we want to understand.
So that part one and the part two, you game for that, you ready for that? I'm game. Let's do it. All right, man, let's start with this. memetic desire. What the heck is this? What is memetic desire? So it starts with memesis. This is the key word. Memesis is or memetic. M-I-M. So it comes from mime or mimicry. So this is different than meme or memetics, which is M-E-M. So memetic is just a fancy word for imitation, right? It comes from the Greek word minestie, which means to imitate. Human beings are, as Aristotle recognized 2500 years ago, by far the most imitate of creatures in the world. We are freaky imitators.
We imitate language, facial expressions, social norms. In fact, if we're not good imitators, things get awkward really, really fast. So imitation is foundational to what it means to be human. So we are memetic creatures, not just to say that we're imitative. What Renas Gerard discovered, he was a French academic who wrote, did most of his work in the 60s through the 80s, is that if we're so memetic and if we imitate all of these other things, it would make sense that we also imitate the very desires of other people too. So he coined the phrase memetic desire. So humans have these powers of abstraction.
So unlike animals, which also engage in imitation. They engage in rituals. When one gorilla stands up and beats his chest, another gorilla will do the same thing. They imitate at the superficial level, what Gerard calls the level of representation. They can imitate superficial things. We can imitate interior motives and actions and things that go all the way down to the level of desires. Like we can intuit what other people want and we imitate them almost always subconsciously. So other people's desires legitimize and give social proof to our own and make things valuable or less valuable. Now there have been crazy studies about this.
Like babies that are 18 to 18 months old, the two years old, can look at an adult taking some action and intuit the motivations or the desires underneath the surface level of the adults action and then imitate the adults desire, not the adults external action. So one of the famous studies with this was an adult goes into a room full of very young little babies toddlers and he's got like a toy dumbbell and he starts to pretend like he wants to pull the styrofoam ends off of the dumbbell but he kind of fails and he can't quite do it. They leave the room and nine times out of 10 the babies pick up the dumbbell and they know what the adult was trying to do.
They just immediately pull it apart. So our levels of imitation go very deep to abstract desires of other people and we're constantly reading and taking social cues based on what other people want and allowing that to influence what we want but that is almost entirely pre-conscious or subconscious. So Gerard identified this mimetic nature of the human person. It's just how we are. We're just mimetic creatures. Biologically this stuff's hardwired in. It's also hardwired in and we know that our brain has mere neurons in it. So when we see somebody else do something like eat an ice cream cone, the neurons fire in our brain that would be the same neurons that would fire if we were eating the ice cream cone.
So you know we see external things and it triggers this mimetic response neurologically and does things and kicks hormones and going. So yes I mean this goes down to the level of a biology. It's hardwired into us. The difference between us and animals is that we have these powers of abstraction. So we're talking about things like crypto and lifestyles and career goals. It also comes into play with these things too and that's where it gets really interesting. I think a really important point and when Ryan did the intro he talked about how mimetic desire is at a heart of the heart of the industry that we operate in the heart of crypto but then also zooms out and it's actually at the heart of everything.
I think it's a really important point to drive home is that babies when they are born at day zero, they are geared up to do one thing really above just beyond like living and having a beating heart is to see what other people are doing and try and distill down as to what their goals are, what their objectives are. And so if there's one thing that babies can do when they come out of the womb is that look they can look at other people and understand at a very deep like subconscious level the goals and intentions of others and that's actually one of the ways that babies and young people are growing up that's the scaffolding that they have to become a human being is that they use the understanding of other people and what other people want as a way as a model for operating in the world.
And so the fact that it comes out at day one indicates the how far down in the basement of the human brain this this effect goes and therefore naturally because it's because it's at day one of the human body and of the human brain of course it's in every single thing that we talk about and discuss as adults and to some degree it's also suppressed like it's not really a conscious thing that we we see as adults it's just something that we act out and it's and this is why naturally you came to our onto our radar when you were on the hidden forces podcast talking about the hidden forces that dictate the world is this this power of mimetic desire is this substrate that we all live in it's the air that we breathe it's the water that we swim in yet we don't really identify it really anywhere it's the base layer it's it's layer zero and we can talk about that later because I think there are some other layers and we can't really understand the other layers until we understand layer zero and two interesting points on that you say from day one babies are imitating it's actually from like t minus three months we know they're imitating during the third trimester while they're in the womb they can hear the intonations of their mother's voice so the second that they're born they're already imitating the way that their their mother spoke in their cries so Chinese babies cry differently than German babies because it's a tonal language in German it isn't quite so tonal so that's how deep it goes even before they're born they're imitating from the womb from the womb and we know that here's another really interesting point about this babies imitate facial expressions and follow the eyes of their of their parents from the minute they're born but they only do that with humans they only imitate humans not robots not animals they seem to sense that oh these people are like me and are therefore worth imitating i think it's a fascinating point that we we somehow like mimesis or mimetic desire is something that actually connects us together as human beings yeah that that point is super interesting a book we we talk about a lot on bangles is uh you've all herari's book it's called sapiens right and he makes the point that like the thing that separates human beings from animals is our ability to coordinate our ability to share myths stories tell stories but ultimately our ability to coordinate that is our superpower and if you think about um you know mimetics and our ability to do mimic that is something that uh is incredibly powerful it's given our species the ability to socially coordinate at levels the animals the animal kingdom does not have that is the cornerstone of all of our technology from social technology to like hard technology to things like the internet to everything that we've built up over time this is a superpower for humanity if you will but it's also kind of like a teased dungeons and dragons terminologies kind of chaotic neutral because it is a power but it's a power that can be used for good things but it's also a power that can be used for bad things for for tearing down is that sort of how you see it as it's just a superpower that humans have we have to recognize it but like whether it's good or bad is kind of dependent on context as a great way to think about it it's a double-edged sword i think we have to have like a real ambivalence towards mimetic desire because it can be used for good and it can tend to lead us into conflict and rivalry when we don't realize that it's happening so yes it's an incredible power it's kind of like the sexual powers right they can be used for good they can be used for for bad they can get people into trouble like pretty much most of the human faculties that we have can go and can go in both directions and mimetic desires is the same thing how come this doesn't show up on maslow's hierarchy of needs then look maslow's hierarchy of needs is interesting so you know maslow didn't seem to be concerned with the he was focused on human needs and i don't think he understood the universe of desire and and kind of the structure of human desire that Renee Gerard identified um if you look at maslow's hierarchy of needs it assumes like a teleology right of like things that a human needs and we just kind of like once we once we knock somehow we just we kind of move on to the next ones and there's this very like clean progression as we move towards the top but in 2021 2021 you know we live in a world where it's really dominated less i mean there's there's more models of desire as Gerard calls them the never before so we have to take a step back because i don't think i can explain the difference between maslow's hierarchy and Gerard's non hierarchy of desire without understanding like the way that that Gerard said desire works and by the way for those that aren't familiar with this i just bring this up because this is kind of psych 101 stuff you know some of you listening probably learned this in in high school as well but maslow's hierarchy of needs is like just this triangle the base layer of the pyramid of the triangle is psychological uh no um physiological needs like food, water, warmth and rest that sort of thing and then it kind of scales up to things that are less basic needs and more psychological needs and more kind of you know self-fulfillment but nowhere on this chart do we see mimetic desire and i'm kind of curious why so continue the story.
Sure i mean mimetic desire permeates every single block on that chart all the way from the bottom so when we start at the bottom we're looking at things that are heavily instinctual so we have kind of a biological physiological basis for things like thirst and hunger and warmth and security so those things are the bottom of the pyramid think of it as like our body has things like built in mechanisms built in signals that tell us what we need so if we're dying of thirst in the desert our body just has built in mechanisms that tell us we see water we're going to drink the water even if we're alone right it's very simple as we move beyond the world of purely instinctual responses into the universe of desires think about lifestyles and career choices and abstract things like stocks and crypto and and just just the world of ideas and desires we don't have the instinctual basis anymore we we lack that so like how do we choose one object of desire over another Gerard's finding his really important discovery is that we find them outside of ourselves we don't have the built in mechanism so we have to look externally to to find the signals and we find them in the form of other people or groups that model desires to us and signal to us what is worth wanting and what is not worth wanting so these are called our models of desire they basically generate and shape our desires for us this is very different than the way we normally think of our desires we think that we think in our hyper individualistic world and hyper rationalistic mindset we have this idea that like we generate our desires on our own or we want something purely based on our objective rational analysis of the qualities of the thing itself and that's denying kind of the social process that we're all embedded in and the way that we look to other people to help us value things and to understand whether or not they're desirable now when it comes to Maslow's hierarchy this this mimetic desire has seeped into every level of it so I don't want to pretend that okay there's certain needs and then once we fulfill the needs then we move into the this world of desire it's not like that I mean look at today water itself it you know we typically choose the water that we drink largely based on mimesis it's not just like there's water now there's 50 different brands of water all marketing like different properties like how do we know which one to want so like even the things that maybe used to be more let's call it instinctually driven are no longer that way like mimesis has has pervaded every single part of that pyramid so and most of that pyramid are not needs at all I mean they fall more into this structure of desire that Gerard was describing and you know that if you look at the pyramid it would seem as if one could move up the pyramid individually without anybody else but that's not the world that we live in we live in a world surrounded by other people modeling desires to us all the time so I think that pyramid is not a pyramid at all it's basically a pandora's box after you get past the first two levels especially you can just lap off the top and we've entered the universe of desires I think the context of being in a two thousand's era world really changes up the role that mimesis hire could really offer us like maybe if we go back five thousand years and we talk about like do you have water as in like do you have access to a stream that you can drink water from or else you will die and then also if you talk about clothes and shelters like oh do you have like the height of an animal on your back and also you found a cave like great like you've got you've knocked down those basic things off of off of Maslow's hierarchy in 20 in the world of 2021 like most of these things are largely taken care of for us at this point and so now now to what you say is like no it's not about having access to a stream is now do you like boss water or do you like smart water or do you like dissonny and then also it was carbonated man carbonated all the way Topo Chico I'm a Topo Chico guy and but then also with clothes on our back it's no longer just like oh I found like the height of an animal to keep me warm it's like oh there's a fashion sense that I particularly go for and fashion changes every three to six months and hairstyles change and just you know culture changes and as a and really what mimetic desire is is this game that we all play is like oh you you're picking that so I'm going to pick this so you're going to pick that so I'm going to pick this and all of a sudden we have fashion trends and hairstyle trends and different which is what culture ultimately becomes look does that vibe with you it does vibe with me I mean I heard one person put it like this for the first time in human history we're no longer struggling with scarcity we're having to cope with abundance that that's one way to sort of we're having to cope with abundance so we're no longer struggling to survive and struggling over scarcity I mean there are still scarce things and mimetic desire creates scarcity by the way but for the most part you know we have most of our basic needs taken care of and the challenge for us is coping with abundance and that's where mimetic desire really goes into overdrive coping with abundance I love that line and that I think the way that we are coping with that is that maybe mentally humans are like okay we have all the 50 different types of water but what's the most desirable water what's the most desirable fashion sense and so even though we are in this land of abundance it seems like mimetic desires actually trying to reintroduce scarcity back to really good abundance because that's the game that's the game of mimetic desire I think that's right and you know there's a there's a thousand different altcoins and crypto assets to choose from it's overwhelming right like what's the signal through the noise and mimetic desire seems to be playing a more pervasive and a more important role in today's world than ever before because of this very thing you know because we do live in a world of abundance it's less clear what's desirable and what's not and the objective criteria I mean there are objective underpinnings for you know whether things are beautiful whether things are true or desirable but we all know from having spent some time like in the investment world and just as human beings in romantic life and in politics that there are all kinds of other things going on that influence why people want things and mimesis is really the hidden force that I think once you understand what mimesis is and how it works you start you can't unsee it you start seeing it everywhere around you especially in the markets yeah absolutely I feel like that's a true you do start to see it everywhere and I want to just make sure that this point is underlying this this hidden force as you say this thing that underlines everything with with the things that we want individually and desire individually but also the things that we desire collectively are not our own so it appears this way it appears that I like this certain paint color on my wall because I'm this sort of person that likes that that paint color it's my choice or I drink this specific water or I buy the specific cryptocurrency what you're saying what mimetic desire is saying the theory of of mimetics is basically like no you didn't make any of those choices the clothes that you're wearing the vibe the way that you're talking the accent that you have everything about you is mimicking those around you other humans we we're not individuals in this world we're part of this society this collective group of humans that we mimic to one degree or another and therefore this is the sobering truth that you're bringing to light is our choices and preferences and desires and wants aren't really our own this is what you're kind of unveiling this is the man behind the curtain I just want to make sure that that's underlying for folks I would put it I would put it like this that our desires are not individual our desires are interdivisual and one of Gerard's collaborators coined the term interdivisual psychology and he's saying we can really only understand psychology at the interdivisual level like not just as every as every person is like a stand-alone mind we can only understand psychology in a relational context right to bring other people into it so like if a husband goes to a psychotherapist the psychotherapist can really only understand his psychology if he understands the relationship with the wife right so it's where it's interdivisual psychology here's one way to think about it what what gravity is to physics mimesis or mimetic desire is to psychology that means that it is a this relational force that that desire is sort of generated in and through relationships in the space between people not like ex nihilo from from ourselves and that's a really important point so I think you said it very well that desire is social and desire is generated and takes shape through a social process now one of the first questions that a lot of people ask me is like I'll frame it in crypto terminology in terminology okay like then what's the genesis block here right like is it is it turtles all the way down is it mimetic desire all the way down yeah jack butcher and I actually put out an NFT called mimetic desire all the way down just like poking fun at this concept so I guess if you're the fiest you would say that the genesis block of desires got if you're not a fiest then the genesis block could come through some stage of evolution right you know 2001 a space Odyssey like sort of depicts in the beginning of that like there's this like innovation and so we could admit that like yes some people can do things that are then imitated or copied but it seems like desires are kind of spread and passed down through the ages through some process of of imitation they're derivative you can even see how that works in a family right like that the desires of parents very often get passed down to the children so that's you know it's a little bit mysterious but I think we can just look at our own experience and if we if we look at a lot of the things that we've wanted if we look hard enough we can usually find some hidden model somebody or something that gave us the idea or planted that desire in us in the first place so I see animals having mimetic desire we brought this up so far in the conversation and animals just have a much more blunt version of mimetic desire and so you know proceed you could theorize that when we were apes we and we still are apes large to a very significant degree that we were participating in the same mimetic desire that we were participating now it's just that now that the human brain has grown so much more complex we are able to dive into much more nuanced levels of mimetic desire so perhaps mimetic desire goes back down to life itself right and and maybe this is an interesting time to bring up the subject of memes but before we do that I'll give you a chance to add in any thoughts Luke well I think this is a great time to actually talk about genes and talk about biology and the difference between genes and memes and mimetic desire so I think we have layered thinking is really important and I think the best way to understand this is looking at a few different layers so let's start from the beginning just real quick like what what is a gene a gene is a self-replicating unit of biological information that is stored inside of a chromosome right and it and it replicates it's got some code it's like make more of me that's a gene so a meme this is a term coined by Richard Dawkins in 1967 in his book The Selfish Gene he coined the term meme intentionally riffing off of the biological gene and a meme he's trying to find like an analogous situation for ideas and and and non-organic things and he coined the term meme in that book Susan Blackwell expounded on it in the 80s and 90s so what is a meme well a meme is not a unit of biological information it's a unit of cultural information that is stored in a in a human mind or in a human brain actually where it's stored now is really interesting right because we have like the second brains and extended minds and memes can be stored on the black chain they you know what I mean like so it's literally have a folder on called memes on my computer it's right so it's I have purchased the memes it's a it's a it's a unit of of cultural information that is stored somewhere and and and it's self-replicating right and is and it's passed on but so what's common to both of these things is like the role of replication or imitation in the way that they're spread and they they both have to do with information right so so a meme is about like a stored unit of information so information on its own doesn't really have much meaning right think about it like if I would have said the meme Brexit to you 10 years ago you'd be like what the hell does that mean I mean it's like is that like a kpop band or something like it wouldn't have it was just wouldn't a mean it meant anything to you right but like Brexit is a meme that represent think of it like short code right like like short-hand it represents a bunch of desires it represents rivalry it represents like that it represents a culture it's a very compact unit too like even like like mega right make America great again that is a very compact unit of like four words that just contains four letters so much culture four letters excuse me in the case exactly well that's a really important point CRT meme okay like these things are like what a meme does is like concentrate mimetic desire and concentrate people it's like a it's like what a laser does to light like a like a meme is incredibly powerful right it represents this whole complex set of desires and things and rivals so my point is that memes emerge from from like from culture so there's like a there's a level beef before this like memes this is not the base layer and what I propose is that the the base layer is is mimesis and like human desire is like the base layer layer zero right before there was language people were wanting things there was desire there's this social process out of which culture emerged so so culture and memes are kind of like layer one but you can't really understand that without understanding layer zero which is mimetic desire and the social hidden forces like we know this we know that pre-lingual babies are are I have mimetic desire they they fought they do gaze following joint visual attention with the mother the mother looks at something they want something to right so this is that's the base layer layer one would be culture when the memes come out of the culture and they don't make sense without it they don't have any meaning and then layer three I would say is like the app like like an application layer right it's like it's like the way that that we apply memes and various things to bring about outcomes so like there are application layers and politics where like memes are created to represent a certain group and then that meme is either attacked or or it's boosted and so those in my mind and this is kind of complex I have to like write a sub stack about this but those are the layers in my mind yeah I was feel like you're like so the app layer is something that we were referred to on baked listen you're talking about it almost becomes like the the institutions right like some of these memes end up in like legal code in institutions and like you know technology like money is maybe an app layer on top of layers of mimetic desire and the memes I I was trying to get my head wrapped around this because it's difficult because mimetic desire and memes they're spelled differently right and they're kind of related but they're also different so I was wondering if you'd agree with this Luke when I was trying to wrap my head around what's the difference between what you're talking about mimetic desire and memes and like what are some of the similarities so a meme is that unit of information that that idea or that unit of desire but it's mimetic desire that really gives the meme life that's the social force that's like the the energy that propels a meme into existence and without mimetic desire the the unit of information that you have the idea that you have this encapsulated in a meme just dies doesn't get propagated doesn't get pushed out through society you just kind of is out on its own has no energy and it dies but the successful memes are really propelled and pushed through the energy that is like mimetic desire that's what pushes it it's almost like memes are the what but mimetic desire is kind of the how yes and the how around this yeah well I think that mimetic desire is the missing part of fully understanding memes I think they complete each other I think it's really important to understand the relationship between memes and mimetic desire I totally agree with you that memes are like the what they're like the information but they don't describe the how like the behavior the energy that actually does anything and Dawkins himself was not I don't think he really articulated how it happens I mean meme theory by the way is like it's sort of controversial and there's a lot of stuff that hasn't really been figured out and I think one of the missing pieces there was mimetic desire like humans are the carriers of memes and humans have mimetic desire were mimetic creatures and understanding how the behavior of humans gives life to a meme and allows memes to spread is really important here's another important distinction between mimetic desire and and memes mimetic desire is the imitation of desire it's not the imitation of a thing it's the imitation of desire so we're imitating people so we're not imitating like a what we're imitating a who and that means that mimetic mimetic desire is more volatile if the if the person so we're imitating their desire and their desires could change and since we're imitating the person and not an idea as their desires change our desires change to so this is another another difference is that we're talking of the difference between information and imitating and replicating information and then imitating desires and that's where mimetic desire is in a way more chaotic and more volatile it's like it's like looking at a flock of starlings right and like it's still mysterious like how they change direction like the murmuring how it happens and we know like it's probably due to the seven starlings closest to one of them is what determines how they move but we we're still not entirely sure so the movement of desire I think is just there's far more complexity in that system than there is in just looking at memes as discrete units of information so the to keep on going with this metaphor there's more people's genes are largely dormant and and we have way way way more inactive genes in our DNA than we do active ones and depending on what environments that we put ourselves in some genes will deactivate well some genes will activate right well the reason why we have so many dormant genes is that when we go into our particular novel scenario we have the genes that are ready to help us adapt to that novel scenario we just have to activate them and so when it comes to this game of mimetic desire which is largely a game being played at the psychosocial level like it's your brain connected to my brain connected to Ryan's brain connected to the people that we engage with all these brains as like a mesh network this coordination game of who is everyone's looking year-round is like who is wanting what like what do you want well what do I want does that do I want that thing and all of a sudden the activation of a specific meme or gene or whatever is activated by and activated by this psychosocial game of of of mimetic desire and so we have all these potential there's infinite level of memes out there and like Ryan said all meme is is a little kernel of information there's infinite levels of kernels of information but it's the mimetic desire that actually decides to activate one and the reasoning for why something gets activated is largely kind of just like a complete mystery which goes back to the the whole murmuring metaphors like we don't know how or why starlings change their path or behavior but they do and they do it in a coordinated way when you look at it from a bird's eye view and another another metaphor or anecdote that I have as I was watching a YouTube video I shared it with you Luke you know what I'm talking about about these the ways that like the universe just seems to like sink up will some way shape reform and there's a video of people in some concert hall and they were clapping at the end of the show just random clapping as random clapping does and at some point in time it just flips into synchronized clapping and so everyone's a complete chaotic mess and then all of a sudden everyone's clapping on the same beat and it just happened completely organically completely randomly no rhyme or reason no one coordinated this all of a sudden the human brains the psychosocial level layer just synced up and all of a sudden we're all engaging the same pattern of behavior because that's what humans do yeah I mean we see this at um you know like at raves and at like there's certain circumstances where like people just seem like really in sync with each other and that's why I kind of like to describe the way that desire like moves between person to person it's not really a rational process it's more like an energy it's more like it's it's caught by contagion you know the word contagion really comes from you know the Latin root of the word is you know contact right to be in contact so when we're around somebody it's sort of a function of proximity so absolutely I mean if this is not to say that there's not some objective qualities to things that are out there um you know I think like I think of like NFTs right and and like I think some some I can look at and and I'm like this is has some objective value maybe it's tied to a physical asset or it serves some some purpose or like it funds some like social good or whatever and I think I can make some distinctions there so it's not to say that this is totally but there will be a first mover um and if the right people sort of move second and third and fourth and fifth uh mimetic desire has let's call it like an amplification effect in terms of which almost shapes the perception of value I mean value is largely subjective right values objective so like the the mimetic desire shapes the perception of value and then initiates a positive feedback loop or reflexive process through which the more people join this the more the value increases Luke can I like so I don't want to jump into act two yet before we're ready but can I just like illustrate this point with because NFTs are just such a perfect example of mimetic desire that I know our listeners would be familiar with um have you ever heard of a crypto punk Luke yes these things are yeah okay so these look like um when they first came out I thought these were just stupid like to be honest right I mean it's just like pixels of a face like okay cool I could buy that but like who cares but my model of crypto punks has completely changed probably within the last two years and the reason is is because crypto punks are being used more and more as sort of a social status signal in a culture that um I am a part of and that I like so large you know venture capitalists or people who are in DeFi circles DeFi DeGens or like crypto natives that I respect and I like and I appreciate hanging out with and that listen to this podcast they have these crypto punks right Jay Z just changes profile shot to picture of a crypto punk and my world view on these things has completely changed they've gone from like insignificant like pixels to oh my god I want this like I don't want to Rolex I don't care about that I don't want to Porsche a Lambo I don't care but I want a crypt I want my own crypto punk and how much will I pay for that I don't know but this is what you're talking about is this is not something that I natively want that came up through my mass low hierarchy of needs biology like yeah I just thought that suddenly one day I woke up and I wanted a crypto punk I'm doing it through mimicry right it's because I want to copy all of these people that I like and respect and that are part of my my social group so is is that right is this just like the medic desire happening in in in in crypto world yeah I mean what what are they going for these days I was like some astronomical 35000 dollars each for one yeah yeah they they differ right like depending on the qualities of the crypto punk so if I understand them right there are some objective qualities that you know are part of the narrative about why some cost more than others right right but yeah each each one has their own property some of them are smoking a pipe some of them are aliens some are zombies each one has their own property list and each one can have like two properties or six properties and there's this very much this coordination game as to like there are some properties are just more valuable than others and there's no rhyme or there's no rhyme or reason that's why right right so I mean in this case I think you know it's pretty easy to see that mimetic desire the imitation of desire has created the scarcity that has driven up the price of the crypto punks like they wouldn't be the fact that the pixels on the screen we consider extreme extremely scarce goods that that very few people can afford is itself a product of mimetic desire so there's like objective scarcity there are things that are objectively scarce in the world right like water in some places is objectively scarce and then there's subjective scarcity and I would say subjective scarcity is usually the product of mimetic desire it's only scarce because we want what other people want and that's I think it's an important distinction to make look I think it's about time that we get into act two of the show because we're already starting to dabble with it but first the last topic that we need to cross off the list before we get there is the concept of rival risk desire because that's where I think we really introduced the topic of scarcity can you walk us through rival risk mimetic desire is that what happens when David and I want the exact same crypto punks what happens exactly that's exactly what happens yeah so so Gerard thought that you know rivalry was at the heart of the human condition was a fundamental principle of human behavior that we don't acknowledge enough we don't like to think that rivalry is pervasive throughout the world but when you when you realize that rivalry is largely a product of mimetic desire you start to understand why and you see how how much rivalry drives decisions and can be explanatory for decisions that on the surface like aren't rational or don't make any sense right like why would this political party like do something that doesn't seem to benefit anybody well the answer might be because it hurts their rival while also hurting them at the same time and that's like a satisfying thing right so so rivalry so how do we get to rivalry and like what is rivalry have to do with mimetic desire it's pretty simple step so rivalry is like stage two of Gerard's mimetic theory and it's like mimetic desire is at the heart it's the fundamental nature of human desire so humans look to other people to understand what to want and we imitate their desires we want something because they want it that's an important distinction to make too it's not like we both happen to arrive at the same object randomly we arrived at wanting that object because another person wants it okay and it endows that object with some like almost magical sacred value like you can imagine the settlers going out to the west you got two guys that they come on the vata for the first time and one of them just runs over to a certain plot of land and is just fascinated with it and thinks it's just the best plot of land he's ever seen the other guys got the whole state but because that other guy who might be five or 10 years older than him is really good at what he does really thinks that this one is special because of that the other guy becomes fixated on it even though if you just turned around you'd have you know 100,000 acres to play with look do you ever watch have you ever watched like babies like play like you know it's 12 months old or so it's 18 months old we like sitting in a in a circle there'll be like piles of toys kids have tons of toys right all these toys and they'll pick one up and immediately the baby sitting across from them the little kids sitting across from them there's all of these toys in the floor that they could pick from they don't want the toys on the floor they want the toy that the other child just picked up right that's what you're talking about this is the hardwired biology that's with us from like birth even before birth that's what you're talking about that's the rivalry I only want this thing because you have it yes I mean if you look at at the classic Gerardian example of this is a room full of toddlers that have more toys than any of them could possibly play with in the minute one of the children picks up a toy and shows enough fascination with it without a doubt a second child will all of a sudden forget about whatever he cared about before and become interested in that toy and because there's now a second person who desires it there's definitely going to be a third kid and then the third kid makes it easier for the fourth kid to want it and before you know what they're fighting over the same toy and they'll have 100 all around them now why did that first you know cute little girl pick up the red fire truck in the first place when she didn't have a model well it could be because like her dad is a cool fireman so you know he's her model or it could just be because the color red like really made it stand out because all the other toys are dull right it's like why certain birds are attracted to certain flowers right so there could be some fundamental base like even a biological basis for that but once that happens the mimesis kicks in and medic desire just naturally leads to rivalry if you think about it you know because we're imitating what another person wants we've naturally made ourselves rivals to them in the sense that they're now an obstacle for our possessing it because we want the same thing so if the fundamental nature of human desire is mimetic then there's some principle of rivalry at the very heart of the human condition especially because we normally don't realize that we desire things like this and we kind of just go through life perpetually we're kind of like obstacle addicts okay in the sense that if somebody else doesn't want something we begin to doubt whether it has a lot of value so we kind of are always looking for people to want things and that just causes us to have you know to kind of constantly be looking for new rivals right and if we don't have one it's an uncomfortable place to be sometimes okay so we've established mimetic desire i think we have a firm understanding of that we've talked about rival risk desire now here's the bridge from act one to act two that i think is important before we get into the crypto concepts that is this we now have this new technology that is called the internet um crypto is kind of act two on the internet we would say but act one and in and of itself is a communication protocol now we have social media we have this global communication platform we have influencers on tiktok and twitter and instagram and all over the place what impact did the internet or does the internet have on our mimetic desires does it accelerate is it like a steroid for them i think we're still kind of figuring that out and i would say the answer is kind of ambivalent i think it it it both helps and hurts mimetic desire what do i mean by that well the internet has given us access to more models of desire than ever before um you know if you lived a hundred years ago if you lived in a small town the total number of people modeling desires to you could be like 15 or 20 people like in your in your school now we have smart phones we have mimetic machines in our pocket that allow us to see like what everybody else is wanting at like all hours of the day um we have billions of models so in a sense it's amplified and exacerbated mimetic desire because it's just all around us all the time and i think the pandemic probably accelerated it too um as we were kind of cooped up um i mean i struggled social media probably more than i ever have and you see people different lifestyles and doing different things and quitting their jobs and getting dogs and you know moving to Austin and all in Miami uh you know and it's like very mimetically i might add in most cases um and it's like this amplifies mimetic desire like never before is like have humans had access to so many mimetic models and i don't think we quite know what that's doing to us i like i don't know if we have the i don't know if like the the the human development is kept up with the technological development right like like in terms of virtues morally speaking and i don't think we know quite what it's doing to our desires and there's a lot of talk about what social media is doing to us neurologically the dopamine hits and and and the addictiveness of it i don't think that enough people are talking about what it's done to mimetic desire what it's done to the way that we desire the flip side of that the one way that social media might be um diffusing mimetic desire even as it amplifies it is that we can now sort of distribute um and diffuse mimetic rivalry across billions of people and bits and bytes and nodes so you know you can swap out models for another one very easily whereas before two people that were kind of in a a mimetic rivalry in a town they just go to a duel or something like that right um and so so in a sense like the the the internet like you know like it diffuses the tension i write it like diffuses the things that would have escalated to extremes right in the wild west or something now like the the it's it diffuses mimetic violence is is probably the way that Gerard would say it um because there's always another model and we can't we can't easily become fixated on one we just go find another one so it's this weird paradox uh and i think peter teal is sort of described the technology in the same way like it's both exacerbating and also it's also a weird mechanism for diffusing um some of the the negative consequences of mimetic desire like in in ancient societies they they just you know have to sacrifice somebody or something like that right to to diffuse mimetic tension with technology um we can do all kinds of things right we you can you you can you can i don't know you can cancel people you can go just go do you can you can block them you can meet them there's all different exactly and it's relatively quick and painless and then everybody moves on so i think it's it's it's both it's a double hey guys i hope you're enjoying the episode thus far this was really a mind expanding episode and really happy we were able to talk to Luke about some of these subjects in the second half of the show we get into the subject of crypto punks after we're done it parsing apart the biological relevancy to what Luke is talking about we get into crypto punks and NFTs we bring up our old episode on legitimacy with Vitalik and overall talk about how market forces are largely an effect of mimetic desire and all the other topics of conversation about how the crypto industry is impacted and relevant to the conversation of mimetic desire all of that is coming in the second half of the show but before we get there we have to take a moment to talk about some of these fantastic sponsors that make the show possible bankless is proud to be supported by uniswap uniswap is a new paradigm in asset exchange infrastructure instead of a cumbersome order book system where trades are matched with other humans uniswap is an autonomous piece of software on Ethereum which is what Ryan and I call a money robot no human counterparties or centralized intermediaries just autonomous code on Ethereum input the token you want to sell and receive the token you want to buy something brand new in the uniswap ecosystem is the uniswap grants program is now accepting applications for grants we have been saying this for a while and we'll say it dals have money and they are in need of labor if you think that you have something to contribute to the uniswap down apply for a grant to uniswap just look at the size of the uniswap treasury it's almost three billion dollars this mountain of capital is looking for labor do you have something of value to contribute to the uniswap down no matter how big or small your idea is you can apply for a unigrant at unigrants.
org and help steer uniswap in the direction that you think it should go that's exactly what we did to get uniswap to be a sponsor for bankless and you can do the same for your project thank you uniswap for sponsoring bankless. Gemini is the world's most trusted cryptocurrency exchange I've been a customer of Gemini since I first got into crypto in 2017 and it's been my main exchange of choice to make my crypto buys and sells Gemini is available in all 50 states and in over 50 countries worldwide and on Gemini there are markets for over 30 various different crypto assets including many of the hot DeFi tokens and it's one of the few exchanges that has liquid die markets Gemini just launched their earn program where you can earn up to 7.
4% interest on 26 various crypto assets if you're tired of paying fees in DeFi or you don't want to worry about DeFi exploits but you still want to earn interest on your crypto assets Gemini earn is the product for you another product I'm stoked to get my hands on is the Gemini crypto back credit card which gives you 3% cash back on all of your purchases but paid to you in your preferred crypto asset when I get my Gemini credit card I'm going to make sure that I get my cash back in east so whenever I buy something I get a little bit of east bonus back to me at the same time you can open up a free account in under three minutes at Gemini.
com slash go bankless and if you trade more than a hundred dollars within the first 30 days after sign up you'll be gifted a free $15 Bitcoin bonus check them out at Gemini.com slash go bankless so so this is really the bridge of where we are so we've got this thing that is baked into us biologically that undergirds everything it is the base layer of everything and that is memetic desire now we have this communication technology that amplifies memetic desire propagates it for the good in the bad but certainly makes it digital as well this seems to us to be like act one of the internet but there's also an act two of the internet and this tees up the conversation around crypto so what we always say on on on bankless is like crypto is a technology that adds scarcity back to the internet in the internet the communication technology everything was a button you can copy and paste every gift and jpeg but crypto is a scarcity technology going back to what David was saying and so if the internet as a communication protocol was about propagating our memetic desires crypto is about valuing our memetic desires turning them into property that can be bought and sold and so this affects money this affects markets and fts are an example of this collectibles as well so we want to go through all of those things maybe let's start with with money i don't know look if you've given much thought to like what money is but we think a lot about it on bankless and we think about like the root lever the the base layer of what money is a lot in crypto in general in fact like bitcoin is a project to kind of redefine reinvent money and it's built from the bottom up it's almost built through memetic desire why do i want bitcoin because so and so has bitcoin right what is money through the lens of memetic desire i think that money is probably one of the best ways that we have to measure memetic desire it's not that you know money is the exclusive measurement of memetic desire but i think that money is is probably the most objective one that we have and you know i don't know if i ever start some you know study for memetic memetics and culture someday it's going to have to focus on the markets uh and on and on the financial markets right um because it's just the best proxy that we have to like understand what it's going on it's a way of keeping score it's a way to measure these things especially debt debt that is really interesting if you want to find out how much memetic desire somebody has look at how much debt they have right that's that's pretty good it's a pretty good pretty good indication right um uh memetic desire that exceeds their their ability to uh to pay for it so i think that um i mean some interesting questions around you know like what a George Gilder would say right that like you know money is basically a function of of like time and i've given some thought to that i mean i i don't i'd be interested to hear you've had a few days now to think about this and i'd love to hear your perspective on it one of the interesting things with memetic desire and memetic rivalry and i you know i think about like monetary maximalist and things like that is memetic desire very quickly um untathers uh things from any kind of objective criteria i guess that i mean that can be good and bad um but it can it can completely sort of like untether um uh pursuits from the thing itself right because the the focus of attention begins to be the the rival or the model rather than the thing itself the things can be swapped out the relatively interchangeable what becomes important is is the rival now now whether the rival is the like the federal reserve system whether the rival is like an alternate cryptocurrency um i don't know but this is a fundamental feature of of like memesis and memetic rivalry is that as it continues it it usually is untethered from any kind of objective objective criteria and i find that pretty interesting so like trying to trying to separate or like i think memesis falls in a spectrum i think i think it falls in a spectrum and that's a good way to think about it so looking at like to what extent are things becoming super memetic and to what extent are they grounded in in something right like something real maybe that's just an understanding of like how money and scarcity and the time value of money works or is it is there a cryptocurrency that's solely solely in meme and solely about marketing and that that to me is is a really interesting look you you said some words did the you had some word choice i thought there was really really interesting that it reminds me of from a number of conversations i've had with big coiners and other people who thought about money at a deep level you use the word measure as in money is like a very strong measure of memetic desire and bitcoin proudly has a 21 million hardcap because it offers a measuring stick for value and it's it's supposed to have this really strong ability to measure the value of other things because it has this you know stable supply that never ever changes and then the other thing you talked about is that like the whole concept about money is that the object itself what that object is is not important it's more about the fact that other people wanted so to me to answer the question of like what is money through the lens of memetic desire it's some random object that humans have collectively decided as to be at the instantiation of rival risk memetic desire in the first place as in money is the object that everyone wants because everyone else wants it and some monies are good and bad right like some monies can be minted by some central party and that ruins the game a little bit right because it's easy for one party to get their hands on money and it's hard for another and so bitcoin has been this example our asset that has actually specifically been trying to push out all use cases of the bitcoin blockchain that aren't using bitcoin as money and and bitcoin here's what i have talked about one of the flaws of gold is that you can actually use it in industry as an objectively useful resource and that's a flaw of gold not a benefit of gold and bitcoin we want to push out all utility out of the bitcoin blockchain that is not using btc the asset as money because btc the asset is supposed to be the instantiation of memetic desire it's supposed to be the one thing that everyone wants in the world because everyone else wants it and because it has this very flat topology there's no issue where it's just a protocol it's fair it's and it's it's a it's a game that everyone can play and participate in memetic desire without having that game be like tainted or ruined by some sort of like central party that's mine that's my like lens of how i've added you know view of medic desire and money so bitcoin is the instant as the instantiation of memetic desire as the new object yeah so so if that that is fascinating and so if that's the case then i mean it's this it's an it's a relatively abstract thing then that has become the object so is it then your is it important that there's a fixed that that there's a there's a there's a max limit of bitcoin that can ever be mined is that then become important as a way of either well i'll stop there like is that is that an important feature when it comes to the memetic desire part i think so and we can we can talk about many many cryptocurrencies fall at this model but the bitcoin or narrative is that like the hard cap really puts the steroids into that game of rivalry it makes you really really want that that bitcoin because of its promise of scarcity right so if this is a rival risk game where we are all trying to compete to get as much money as possible which is largely what most people spend most of their decades doing that game is really souped up when we are talking about a hard capd asset there's a there's a law in economics called crushams law where you spend your bad money money drives out bad money right and so bitcoin as like a theoretical good money it's going to just have it's going to have the same like demand as money as other monies but people will want the bitcoin money more than like the us dollar money because the us dollars being printed bitcoin's not being printed and so the game of rival risk desire is just stronger yeah so it's almost like a bet on rival risk desire in a sense right it does it does better the more memetic rivalry there is and like I guess like you know that's a moral question right like whether that's a good thing or a bad thing right but it's certainly good for bitcoin there's no doubt about that I think what you know one of the things I think about is I find people becoming a little nihilistic about money you know like when people can become extremely rich or extremely poor overnight and it doesn't seem to be sort of like tied to any kind of like real world you know value creation or something like that like and I've had companies I've started that have created a tremendous flash valuation and then like gone away overnight which made me fairly nihilistic about money for a while right like it makes it makes it hard for you to like put your hand to the to the metaphorical plow and like do the hard work when you know that you could like make a trade or invest in something and blow it up so I think that the relationship between value creation and new money creation or the creation of value and the creation of money and the way that money is exchanged is an important discussion I haven't quite worked it out yet but I think that the the cap of bitcoin I've thought about it in that particular context yeah I'm curious what you think about this too is like so if you are like take the example of gold right so how did gold come to be a money right like just we don't know that's lost to history like there's no record of how gold like first started being valued by by humans right we have maybe some kingdoms that are you know based on gold we have some records there but like if you were to think about it through the lens of mimetic desire does that provide a clue and this is what I think about like you know cryptocurrency right so the you know you turn on tv I you know I grew up with like Scrooge McDuck who's diving into a pool of gold like Cartooner and I'm young remolder see rap videos and like we're wearing the bling we've got the gold chain it's all about the gold what's interesting about that is like gold is just a what is gold man it's just a rock like who cares it's it you know has some properties that make it difficult to duplicate of course and possible to duplicate but so does cryptocurrency so does bitcoin if if these rap videos and these Scrooge McDuck cartoons started projecting mimetic desire in the form of like bitcoin or ether some other cryptocurrency instead and that was imbued into our social consciousness like that could easily become a money and that's kind of what what like if you were to think about run through the thought exercise loop of how does a money become a money if it's not top down pushed from a central government right and it seems to me like the lens of mimetic desire is kind of an answer to that question it's somebody buys it we've got rival risk you know competition start talking about how much you have how much it's worth price goes up like this is a ground up new money being born a new asset being born and it's almost like a microcosm of what we're just talking about with the with the NFTs is like and what's interesting to me is like you got act one which is the internet accelerator propagation right and now you blend that with act two which is we create scarcity we can value mimetic desire on the internet digitally and then what do you get well you get oh my god crypto crypto punks in five years created a little gif that is now worth 32k each right and like how fast did that happen and why did it happen so fast it's because of this confluence of internet technologies anyway any thoughts on that hmm I think that mimetic desire is part of the genesis of why we have legitimate money at all is really fascinating right like money in some sense is a product of specialization like we need money to exchange and why do we want to exchange because we want what what somebody else has and why would we want what somebody else has if we weren't mimetic in some way right if if their if mimetic desire didn't exist so I mean to to sort of riff off a program here when he says like well what you want is not money what you want is wealth like you know you could have if you had a machine that could make anything that you wanted and do everything that you wanted then you wouldn't have any need for money right it's like wealth you know it's like somebody that lives somewhere and and has everything they need perfect family and home and they're not let's say they're not exposed to anybody else right so they have no mimetic desire they have wealth right like wealth is wealth is what you want and it's not always the same thing as you as the money that you have right they're not always equivalent things like you could have a billion dollars and be in the middle of Antarctica and you wouldn't be able to buy anything or do anything with it right I mean let's assume you're not on the internet right so like it wouldn't it wouldn't matter right it would be so like in other words you know Paul says like wealth is what you want well I think about this with mimetic desire like wealth is what you want and I could be like wealthy and in terms of like I have everything I want I have my home I have my children I have all the food that I need themselves sustaining but I I look around and I see other people that want other things and through mimetic desire I begin to want them we need a medium of exchange right and that's why we need money right because like you don't want my you know two ducks and I don't want you two apples or whatever right so we needed something and yeah maybe why we landed on certain things was largely random there's a whole connection to sacred here like like a lot of money the earliest money was always found near like sacred temples of worship because one of the first reasons why people needed money was that they needed animals to to sacrifice and they needed to to buy the animal so the for it seems like in courted to René Girard the first systems of exchange happened for the purposes of religious sacrifice but we get totally sidetracked by talking about that so so I think that mimetic desire is probably responsible for the genesis of money I'm just talking off the cuff here but I think that that's probably a whole book that I'd have you know somebody laugh or maybe start with some sub stack posts you get a great sub stack Luke we'll link to that and show notes by those guys well let's talk to that let's talk about the next I think item that relates very closely to crypto but also has obviously a rich history in traditional world which is markets as we talked about money to quote you know Peter Teal again say Peter Teal says money is the bubble that never pops right and of course in financial markets we have all sorts of different bubbles that come and go and of course we have crypto which is kind of creating markets out of everything as much as possible at the speed of the internet let's talk a little bit about bubbles and markets like toloopmania or dot com com bubble or even read recent posts that that you authored about like meme stocks mean kind of a bubble are these all products of memetic desire is this why we are buying these stocks in these assets and taking part in these bubbles what's your lens on that I don't know if memetic desire is the sole reason but I think it's impossible to understand the extreme volatility in any market without understanding memetic desire and I just look at like analyst after analyst on CNBC and these pundits and they're just like you know this is lacking in all objectivity this is a rational they hate it like yeah and it breaks their brains yeah and it breaks their brains and they're just like looking for just like this fundamental like analysis and they're never going to find it right this is like what Renee Gerard calls the romantic lie and and it's this notion that there's always a one-to-one or direct line like this rational basis between people and the things that they want where we're not rational I mean we we are rational creatures but we're also memetic creatures and I think that memesis trumps rationality like almost all of the time especially especially in markets like we don't live in a rational world we live in a memetic world and if like if if the guys in CNBC could just understand this it would just make that make their lives a lot easier I think because yeah I mean like Gerard said that the stock market well he wasn't really he died in 2015 so he didn't really see the rise of crypto he'd say the same thing about crypto he said the stock market is the most memetic institution the most memetic institution and you know he said like when Alan Greenspan uses like ridiculous phrases like a rational exuberance he's just that's just Greenspan speak for like out of control like memetic desire and it happens on the upside and it happens on the downside and it usually happens faster on the downside even historically than on the upside like once people start abandoning everybody wants to abandon because there's like some fear involved in that too so I don't think that I'm not a memetic desire maximalist where I think like everything is explainable by a memetic desire there's fear there's fight or flight there's all kinds of things but I just don't think you can understand game stop meme stocks some of the crazy parabolic rises in crypto without understanding memetic desire because there are people that got in without they didn't know like a damn thing about game stop certainly not about the fundamentals or about crypto but they want in because other people want in and then when you want in like the game then becomes to generate as much memetic desire as possible after you're in because you then profit from the new mimesis that you generate so in a sense it's like create a meme generate as much memetic desire as you can and you know that's certainly becoming kind of the the game and somehow how to play it better than others but without an understanding of a medic desire I think it's harder to play David has three me why'd you buy David did you buy because of the memetic desire I bought it to stick it to the man but maybe there's a memetic desire so that's so that's memetic desire that's called memetic rivalry man what you just said we see a lot of in the crypto space we got the chain link army we got the XRP the excuse me the link Marines we have the XRP army the the cardano army even like the bitcoin maximalist and even some degree we do this in the ethereum side of things as well as like we all try and like you know we write elaborate like medium articles or or sub stack posts as to like my valuation thesis for ether or ethers a triple point asset ethers and ultrasound money chain links going to the moon these are all competitions for attention in order to trigger memetic desire like these are all communities that have all and in one of the I recently wrote a post uh talking about these this frog this frog like meme talk about them with a traditional meme and the the chain link army they're full of frogs and they're very homogenous and that's really the the crazy thing about them is like there's this headless man brand this headless movement of all these frogs and they all chant the same chance and they all say the same things and they're just a very homogenous cohort of people that are all shilling this link token and it's this and it's completely aside from the fundamentals of the project like the team is building chain link and doing chain link things and the chain link army the link Marines and its frog army is just this homogenous headless brand of just like mimicry mimicry mimicry uh and it's one of the most fascinating like social experiments I think that this space has to offer yeah I mean like the the way that mimesis forms culture and and contributes to to group cohesion is is a whole another aspect of all of this right like the foundation of culture through mimesis in crypto and politics in in in towns and communities this happens all the time and I think that that's why you see tribalism right you know you see mimesis you know forming ideas and forming community um there's always an out there's uh there's always an inside and an outside uh you know and Gerard says you know this is probably too much to get into here um but he said that you know mimetic desire always leads to some conflict that's revolved resolved through through some kind of a violence right so you know when I when I look at ethereum right and basically he says there's a founding murder or some founding conflict in every sort of strong culture um so in ethereum like maybe that's like the dalfork okay like I don't I don't know but that like it probably contributed in some way to like stronger like cohesion among the people that were on board probably more so than before so it's actually like a fascinating part of like gerardian cultural analysis where he says that there's always some kind of like founding thing founding mechanism that happened that resolve some mimetic conflict that actually contributes to the social cohesion where other people are looked at as the rivals and it reinforces the group identity that kind of feels like a snake binding its own tail if we if we take that out and extrapolate that to the very very end uh because there's the the the community becomes more and more coherent in around a specific group or specific ideology and if that gets too concentrated it can start to just be too circular too fast um and I'm also starting to speak off the cuff here but like what happens when mimetic desire just goes to its end degree to the logical conclusion like what happens then just the thing explode is like what what what happens at the end of the of the logical conclusion of mimetic well gerard's answer is that uh escape there's a scapegoat that the only way that the out of control mimesis that feedback loop is resolved is through a scapegoat right it's like somebody is randomly chosen right in in in in ancient cultures the way that that that they it was prevented from imploding was to find an expel or kill a scapegoat right so it's the idea that you know doing violence to somebody else saves us from the internal violence so it's it's complicated um I do think it's relevant to to the discussion um I think we live in a culture that's like a scapegoat in machine but we make little scapegoats right our scapegoats are usually not like we don't have extravagant rituals anymore but we we we make little ones all the time so that's that's that's the last and most complicated part of mimetic theory is that mimetic desire leads to conflict in the way that humans have resolved conflict mimetic crises throughout history because I think you're right it is like a snake biting its own tail is through the scapegoat mechanism but the scapegoat mechanism only fuels just more violence and and more conflict so I think I think we get off track with that but I mean I that is Gerard's answer to the question I just have a quick question for you this is like just some advice so people coming to crypto and they're always like oh my god it's so tribal why is it so tribal and like David and I are answered that is because humans are tribal and guess what crypto at the base layer is composed of humans but I have a question for you so a lot of cryptocurrencies many people would say in fact we would say bitcoin and ether are kind of a competing for to to be a money to be a world reserve asset essentially you you could think of them as rivalrous in a way like what's your advice for these these communities to avoid conflict because I think in cryptocurrencies like the aim of cryptocurrencies really to decrease humanity's reliance on centralized parties right centralized institutions we don't want all of the eggs in those centralized baskets that can control us and restrict individual community freedoms right but we also don't want to go to tribal wars one cryptocurrency versus another and yet there is this rivalrous thing which is like market cap like total value of the thing do I buy bitcoin or do I buy ethno you should buy eth because xyz what's your advice for these somewhat rivalrous tribes is there a way to step away from that rivalry or is this just how it has to play out well I don't know what your opinion is on how it went I mean I guess if you're kind of a maxilist like it has to end with one currency taking over and being like the global standard and I think that if that happens then I I don't see I don't see any any way out like if the if the goal is for a currency to become like the worldwide adopted standard then I think that the conflict has to happen and will inevitably happen if however and I'm not necessarily even saying that that's like a bad thing right it I'm not I'm not implying that that's bad I'm just saying that that's there's no way around it somebody has to win and and the others will have to lose and it will be conflict along the way I think there's another scenario and again I'm not making a value judgment on it where there's a place more than one and you know each one carves out and defines a specific purpose for for that that currency to solve some specific problem so I mean I'm kind of fascinated by like micro currencies like there's there's like places in Africa with that that have were like people have been like a dropped coins and it's helped them create little micro economies and I think that the only way to prevent the rivalry is if you don't have the same goal and if if your goal is that everybody wants to become the new global standard then there will be if people can sort of define a specific use case and if there's room for more than one and they solve different problems then then I think that and that can be avoided I mean this goes back to the way that Peter Till said he solved conflicts at at PayPal he made sure that you know people had clearly defined objectives and paths for and paths forward so like that was just on the human career level and I think the same is probably true on the level of currency like if you have like a one a specific problem that you're trying to solve that nobody else is trying to solve then you're going to avoid that if if you want to be the one true global currency then you're going to have to do it out with you know with Bitcoin and Ethereum and you know I'm not quite sure how that ends that's that's an interesting approach because it really aligns with I think two kinds of approaches that people have when they come into this space like usually people come into this crypto space and they immediately resonate with monetary maximum and they're like oh yeah I'm a monetary maximalist I mean I'm going to purchase the thing that I think is money usually those people decide that is either Bitcoin or Ether and then that's again that they play or there's like these what I kind of call polychainers or you know the you many many blockchains many many tokens which goes a little bit closer to what you were saying in the in the latter half which is you know each token can find some way to instantiate its own value for its own purpose that's non competitive with money and I kind of actually think that that's more or less the Ethereum app layer right like we have the uniswap token which governs over the uniswap exchange we have the compound token which governs over the compound money market and these are I wouldn't call them currencies they are definitely not fighting to fight the whole monetary I am a money token but they are building out something useful of value that that is what they are for and it's also still leaving the game of monetary maximalism to be played right and so to some degree I think the concept of monetary maximalism is talking about the concept of mimetic desire before people were even allowed even knew to to call it that but people generally had this gist that like there was going to be one single shelling point of money no matter what and I actually think both sides of what you just said are both happening at the same time like one is more or less your Ethereum app layer these are capital assets that govern over protocols and then there's the money that undergirds this whole entire thing yeah yeah I mean so you made a one really good point and it's that like everybody knows about mimetic desire but most people don't have a name for it right we're just like naming giving something a name that exists and we know that it exists and I think that the the app layer of Ethereum is a really important thing because that solves the problem I mean I've talked to some some folks in the crypto space like I think at bank or for instance and there was this idea that like we're all going to be walking around with like 10,000 different currencies on our phone and like we walk in one place and you know we pay with this and there's real time exchange I just don't see that happening I mean I think like the app layer of Ethereum is a far better solution than that and I think I think it's tackling similar things look I want to I want to backtrack really quick because there's we've touched on this this subject a number of times but I really want to just drive this point home we've talked about how mimetic desire is with us from birth like it's in our DNA it's in our genes it's in our brain and we also talked about market bubbles I've recently read this book called Devil Take the Hindmost which is basically a human history of market bubbles and my naive young self I kind of thought that there was the tulip mania there was the dot com bubble and then there was like the ICO of 20 the ICO mania of 2017 and those are like the big bubbles that I know about no no no no no no market bubbles go back as far back as recorded history as possible and to the point and I was talking to the guy that even recommended me me the book and I was like doing a little like debrief with him after I read the book is and I told him even but again even before reading your book like it's crazy how market bubbles are just written into our DNA they just seem to happen and like reading this book and listening to the stories of these market bubbles that happened in the 1400s and the 1500s and the 1600s they're the same story of the of the ICO mania in 2017 they're the same story of DeFi summer in 2020 like I resonated with every single part of the story like I felt myself part of that story and I feel like the only logical explanation is that because market bubbles are 100% mimetic desires and the humans will follow the same path the same narratives over and over and over again because it's built into our DNA have you thought about this I mean I couldn't agree more I mean like so long before there was social media people still look to other people to know what to want social media just exacerbated it right and and before there were financial markets there were still bubbles in all sorts of things they just weren't in and financial assets right there were like rises and falls and people's reputations for instance right and in all kinds of other things right so like the fun the point is that we're like mimetic creatures by nature we almost always like overshoot because the nature of mimetic desire is is to be untethered from the from any kind of objectivity eventually especially the longer and longer that it goes so there are bubbles in all kinds of other areas in life in politics in dating in fashions in in like in all kinds of things and what financial markets have done is just given humans a very easy way to see what already happens in everyday life all the time like that I just freaking bubbles in high school right like you know like in in with people so I think markets basically hold up a mirror to the mesis and hold up a mirror to our humanity and see the way that we are and it's not just like we're like that only in financial markets we're just like that all the time where we we have mimetic desire that's super interesting I don't think I've thought about it that way Luke that like markets are just a mirror for mimetic desire and that markets there are markets for everything like markets even for ideologies or specific types of music or specific types of art or fashion and you also brought up in your book this concept of reflexivity right is is that also what we're talking about how if you know a certain amount of people want a specific asset in a market and drive the price up then people see that price and they're like okay well price going up I better hit in they pile in you you gave this example I think of from your book of Tesla stock right and I was just visually picturing this and you said that when Tesla stock was was pumping someone went to the Google search and they type in you know should I with like you know how Google kind of auto fills with all the suggestions the number one suggestion at that time was should I buy Tesla right this is mimetic desire as expressed through Google algorithms how weird is that that algorithms are maybe now programming humanity's mimetic desires and yet this is the world we live in so yeah we'll talk talk a little bit about reflexivity then and how that applies to markets yeah well I mean the scary thing about the Google example before I talk about real it reflexivity is like think about it what Google did is basically suggest a question and suggest a desire to somebody before they even knew the right question to ask yeah it's not just that they suggested a question they suggested a desire buying a Tesla fanning the flames right they're absolutely fanning the flames so the principle of reflexivity was articulated really well by George Soros in his book highly recommended the alchemy of finance and he talks about how financial markets are always reflexive and that expectations shape reality and then filter like a feedback loop right like investors expectations affect their decisions work sort of guessing what other people's expectations are which affect our expectations which actually causes to make real world decisions in the financial markets which then change expectations right so one of George Soros's you know first big trades was basically taking advantage of this fact right it was a huge currency trade people were trying to figure out if a currency would collapse and by taking aggressive action in the market and causing some price action you change the expectations that the currency would collapse and so like we can affect through our actions expectations which then affect other people's actions and reflexivity just means that the market is constantly reflexive and never static it's completely dynamic right it's like two people on a trampoline like with one of them jumps the other person is going to have a force exerted on them which affects them and their movement so we're all kind of enmeshed in this web and what I try to do in the book is connect that to mimetic desire saying like you can't be in a room full of people having a discussion about about anything without having your desires affected in some way you might not think that they are but does mimetic desire is reflexive especially at the level of markets I think the the interesting implication perhaps the scary implication of this is mimetic desire is like a it's like access having root access to the firmware of our brains and not just our individual brains but like our collective brains and what's scary about that is one thing if it happens kind of organically or naturally right and like the toddler likes the red toy because her dad's a fireman that's one thing right okay cool that was supposed to happen maybe but it's another when you have outside forces or third parties who know about this and are using it using this firmware level access to like program society and what's ultra scary about this is when they can automate it through the use of information technology at the scale of the internet using algorithms right so that Google auto fill example like guys that happens in your Twitter feed in your in your Facebook feed in your Instagram feed right and it's not even individual human beings that are programming the propaganda they've actually just taught algorithms to do this and a tweak here a tweak there can totally change the mimetic desire outcomes of a society that is some power that I'm not sure that like we are ready to to deal with and it's very scary to think of that level of power being completely centralized by insidious actors anyway this is like an implication I think of what you're saying yeah and people who understand mimetic desire well that understand that this is a fundamental feature of how human beings come to want and desire things people can hack into that that desire and I think the big tech companies are already doing it I mean I think they understand mimetic desire very well but we have to be aware of this and like awareness brings some level of freedom and agency over it and the last thing that we want are a few sort of oligarchs and centralized government pulling the strings of of mimetic desire I tell the example in the book about Eddie Bernays who's basically the father of public relations and propaganda who used who basically understood mimetic desire enough to engineer a campaign to get most of the women in the 1920s to start smoking because he gave them the right models of desire and they just didn't understand right that this that their desires were were being shaped and molded by somebody that understood that they just needed the right model and if they were given the right model that they would take up smoking right powerful very powerful so it's like if I was to start a cryptocurrency today imagine and I went and I I paid like 10 or 12 really powerful models in the cryptocurrency space to to to get behind it they're basically influencers right and then I and then I told them to just pretend that they stumbled on it objectively and spontaneously came to the conclusion right that this is a good investment while I'm seeing this a thousand times a thousand times right so this is the problem right like so many layers of of mimesis they're all underground they're hidden and we only see the surface right and so much of life takes place underground deep underground and we've got to be sort of aware of that right and just like get under the surface kick the tires find out what's happening because desires are being modeled to us all the time and they're it's often disingenuous right like this is the name of the game for influencers yet people keep paying influencers a lot of money because it freaking works like you know Luke we talked at the beginning of this show about how mimetic desires kind of this chaotic neutral force it can have good outcomes it can have negative negative outcomes and also if bankless listeners have been paying attention to bankless they'll they'll know that sometimes around and I bring up the straight up the topic of mindfulness and the importance and role of mindfulness as you try as you go through crypto markets you know markets go go high we get you fork they go low we get depressed being mindful really helps you navigate those waters and overall Sam Harris talks about this a lot with his waking up app and mindfulness and mindfulness meditation can really allow you to step back from your own psyche and actually start to like label mimetic desire and and the forces that are impacting your perceptions that you will forgot or didn't realize or are doing that and so the an action item for listeners is to you know take another look at mindfulness because it is the thing that allows you to start to become immune to mimetic desire when you want to choose to be immune from it and also allow you to tap into it and leverage it when it when it works for you and that brings us to I think our last conversation because we started off saying how you know there's good mimetic desire then there's mimetic desire that can be used for evil we recently had metallic buterin on the bankless podcast to talk about this concept called legitimacy and I actually think to some degree we're also talking about the same thing instead of instead of labeling it legitimacy we're actually now calling it mimetic desire in that podcast with Vitalik he talked about how legitimacy is largely only defined what people collectively agree to be a legitimate as in there's no there's no basement or foundation for what establishes legitimacy legitimacy it's only in the psychosocial level the brain mesh network level of the humans that are around you things are only legitimate if other people other humans also think them to be legitimate and so this is in my opinion mimetic desire for good because what is legitimacy other than a good thing to have or a good property to have for something that is legitimate do you see as like mimetic desire as like a creation of legitimacy a creative force yeah I do I think that it absolutely is like other people wanting what we want gives it a stamp of legitimacy so again this can be good or bad you know there are societies where child sacrifice has been legitimate it's been legitimized you know it's it's a fascinating concept right and and I think it's fundamental to understanding money it's absolutely fundamental to understanding so a lot of things about about social life one thing that Vitalik said I listen to the episode and I watched I read the paper he basically says it's the outcome of coordinated effort and I think it describes a lot of intentionality to it right and talk about game theory so there seems to be a coordinated effort to create legitimacy I think where Gerard would differ from that when he sort of like looks at the way that mimetic outcomes happen through crowds or through large complex systems that we often don't understand that legitimacy is often the product of uh non intentional mimesis right like things that are happening at the unconscious level where something has arrived at as legitimate without a lot of like conscious thinking about it that is just a tension that I would introduce into the discussion and I think we can we can introduce more or less coordination uh but Gerard would say that oftentimes when uh when a mimetic process takes hold it's hard to know who like the first mover was and who the who the real models are it's kind of like looking at the flock of starlings like which one is moving first right it's hard to know so I I'm curious as to like how that actual process works in the context of legitimacy in markets and in and in social life um I mean I don't have an answer I'm just gonna I'm just gonna throw out the gerardian perspective on there um and I think that the intentionality is good right I think that's it's really good to have that but also in a decentralized ecosystem um to what extent are are things arrived on that might be the product of mimesis more than rationality so there's this constant interplay right I think objectivity I do think that like just one observation on that Luke is like I I do think there are a ton of hyper rationalists and engineers and cryptographers and brilliant people in crypto like that just don't fundamentally fundamentally understand why Bitcoin is valuable as an example or why ether is valuable right like they just don't understand because I think they don't approach approach this space from a mimetic desire mean theory perspective right like so and that can allow them to draw incorrect conclusions like why is Bitcoin worth 30k right like it if you look at just the the technology level it's appear to appear you know um transaction network and only seven to eight transactions per second I mean Visa can do thousands already we already have something like that is why is it worth 30k I think it's because of this this hidden force of subconscious mimetic desire that sometimes the technologists and the people the rationalists among us and the really smart people with huge cerebral cortexes like they kind of miss that piece of it well exactly and the smarter you are like the better you are at at justifying things after the fact with all kinds of really smart arguments and like why I love crypto so much is that there are so many absolutely brilliant people that are thinking really hard about these questions I mean I got an undergrad degree in finance a while ago graduated in 2004 I've learned more about finance in the last three years than I that I have in mind because of crypto and I think I think a lot of people can say the same thing right yeah it's fun it's exciting and there's brilliant minds thinking about this stuff but legitimacy is really important to understand one thing I pull the quote from Vitalik and I want to read it because this gets to the heart of what I'm saying he made a I'm quoting him verbatim he said if people do something different they they I think they worry if they do something different they'll only create conflict and suffer or at least be left in a lonely forked ecosystem all by themselves right so he was talking about legitimacy and and like the fear that people have of like breaking away from the legitimacy and I would say that people would rather be wrong than be alone and and this social force of mimetic desire and mimesis can cause people to do things they might think they're rational but it people would rather be wrong than be alone and I think there's a powerful social mechanism at at work there's phomo involved there's alka and there's mimetic desire involved but I would push back a little bit on giving legitimacy in overly rationalistic like explanation I think there are many things that we consider legitimate in our society that we haven't given a lot of thought about or that there wasn't some centralized planning system that that like thought about it I mean I believe in free markets okay and I think that like in in general like we arrive at but they're not always good things and sometimes we we step back and and we realize that through certain circumstances in an era or certain forces that were at work certain things gained legitimacy that that lose legitimacy a decade later and that is what we've been talking about in this entire podcast right it's like how mimesis like gives value to things and takes value away from things there's definitely an aspect of like another book you could write or at least a sub stack article for us Luke is like generational mimetic desire and how that changes things because that that is one thing we're seeing in crypto is like millennials and zoomers are not buying gold man like they just don't value it the way their grandparents did but they are buying crypto but we've taken so much of your time Luke and this has been super insightful for us I got to kind of end maybe with with with this question is what's your take on this crazy thing that we call crypto like you've got kind of a I know you know about it right like you've been following the story all along you probably hold some crypto assets but you're not like deep into the culture necessarily yet maybe we'll be in future what's your take on what's going yeah I want to be deep into the culture I told you guys before we went on the air the only reason I haven't been is I've been hard at work writing a book for the last couple of years and so I couldn't spend as much time as I as I would have liked or I would have wrote a really shitty book my take is that crypto is and then probably the most important thing happening in the world right now from a geopolitical standpoint from an economic standpoint from the standpoint of like human evolution we're learning all kinds of things about ourselves right is causing us to like ask questions like fundamental questions that you would think we would talk about more but they're so fundamental that we forget to ask them like what the heck is money like what is money like most you don't learn that in school right it's like you know people are because people grow up and they've just never asked like fundamental questions but like we're all asking the question right now and I think it's a tremendously positive thing you know I'm very bullish on on Ethereum I think that I think that there's a side from the exciting things that it could do to the global economy and to people's lives I think there's an educational aspect to this that's that's really important that's going to have spill over effects way beyond crypto so like crypto is not just about crypto crypto is about like what it means to be human and I think I I sort of as as somebody that's interested in like interdisciplinary questions I think that it will it will shed light on everything from politics to just social relationships to like the way that cities operate and those I think this can take us a very long time to figure it out but the the speed at which this is all happening is really really exciting and I'm just glad that now that I finally finished writing the book I can begin to dive in the way that I wanted to a couple of years ago and thanks thanks thanks to your show and your and your sub stack it was a little bit easier we're super excited we would love to have you come on down the rabbit hole with us let us know what you think because you've got a exceptional lens on this stuff and it is interdisciplinary it's it takes philosophy takes so sociology takes psychology it takes all of anthropology all of these things together is what forms crypto so glad to have you Luke and what we want to do is we would love to have you on in the future if you take a tour down the rabbit hole you know six months a year and come back on let us know what you think of things but Luke it has been such a pleasure having one bankless thank you so much thanks so much for having me appreciate it I'd love to come back on action items bankless listeners loop did not write a shitty book he spent two years and he wrote a fantastic book it is called wanting the power of mimetic desire in every day life we will include a link to it in the show notes action item one is go download that on audible or something or go pick up a copy of it read it it's fantastic also subscribe to Luke's sub stack it's called anti mimetic this is a field guide to mimetic desire we will include a link in the show notes to that as well risks and disclaimers ethos risky crypto is risky defies risky so our bubble so is mimetic desire it seems like you could lose what you put in we are headed west this is the frontier it's not for everyone but we're glad you're with us on the bankless journey thanks a lot hey we hope you enjoyed the video if you did head over to bankless hq right now to develop your crypto investing skills and learn how to free yourself from banks and gain your financial independence we recommend joining our daily newsletter podcast and community as a bankless premium subscriber to get the most out of your bankless experience you'll get access to our market analysis our alpha leaks and exclusive content and even the bankless token for airdrops raffles and unlocks if you're interested in crypto the bankless community is where you want to be click the link in the description to become a bankless premium subscriber today also don't forget to subscribe to the channel for in-depth interviews with industry leaders ask me anything and weekly roll ups where we summarize the week in crypto and other fantastic content thanks everyone for watching and being on the journey as we build out the bankless nation