Ryan Selkis is the Founder and CEO the crypto data analytics platform Messari. Last time Ryan was on the podcast, we debated Ether’s properties as a money and the triple point asset thesis. We revisit many of these topics and explore what has changed in the landscape over the past year.
However, we also discuss a perhaps more pressing issue: the state of regulation for the industry. Ryan is poised to take a strong leadership role in the political side of crypto, and he’s developing offensive strategies for the crypto vs. nation-state conflict. Listen in to learn why he’s now a single-issue voter.
------ 🚀 SUBSCRIBE TO NEWSLETTER: https://newsletter.banklesshq.com/ 🎙️ SUBSCRIBE TO PODCAST: http://podcast.banklesshq.com/ 🎖 CLAIM YOUR BADGE: https://newsletter.banklesshq.com/p/-guide-2-using-the-bankless-badge ------ BANKLESS SPONSOR TOOLS:
⚖️ ARBITRUM | SCALING ETHEREUM https://bankless.cc/Arbitrum
🍵 MATCHA | DECENTRALIZED EXCHANGE AGGREGATOR https://bankless.cc/Matcha
🔐 LEDGER | SECURE YOUR ASSETS https://bankless.cc/Ledger
🦄 UNISWAP | DECENTRALIZED FUNDING https://bankless.cc/UniGrants
------ 📣 TracerDAO | Building DeFi Infrastructure. Join the Discord! https://bankless.cc/TracerDAO ------
Topics Covered:
0:00 Intro 4:00 Ryan Selkis of Messari 6:44 Ryan’s Broad Approach 12:41 Why Do They Hate Us? 18:13 “Protecting Us” 27:30 Single Issue Voters 35:49 It’s a Team Sport 45:00 Aligning with Regulators 54:00 Institutional Reactions 57:23 What the Markets Say 1:01:01 Ether as an Asset 1:08:40 The Flippening 1:10:44 Ethereum’s Narrative 1:13:53 Market Cap vs Money 1:17:37 Institutional Demand 1:19:55 Hot Sectors for Analysis 1:23:24 The Network State 1:26:41 Closing & Disclaimers
------ Resources:
Ryan on Twitter: https://twitter.com/twobitidiot?s=20 Ryan’s Tweet Thread: https://twitter.com/twobitidiot/status/1426020410370449410?s=20 Mainnet Event: https://mainnet.events/ Messari: https://messari.io/
----- Not financial or tax advice. This channel is strictly educational and is not investment advice or a solicitation to buy or sell any assets or to make any financial decisions. This video is not tax advice. Talk to your accountant. Do your own research.
Disclosure. From time-to-time I may add links in this newsletter to products I use. I may receive commission if you make a purchase through one of these links. Additionally, the Bankless writers hold crypto assets. See our investment disclosures here: https://newsletter.banklesshq.com/p/bankless-disclosures
No summary for this episode yet.
Welcome to Bankless, where we explore the frontier of internet money and internet finance. This is how to get started, how to get better, and how to front run the opportunity. This is Ryan Sean Adams. I'm here with David Hoffman, and we're here to help you become more bankless. David, Ryan Selkis on the podcast, we cover two things. Everything that's going on in the government, regulation, nation's safe versus crypto. And second, we got to ask them once again, what is thoughts on Ether? Has that changed since the last time we spoke? Last time we debated it, last time we argued it. Really interesting discussion here.
I really think Ryan could be positioned to become one of our industries leaders. He already is at Missouri, but now that this political conversation has really blossomed, Ryan really seems to be positioned to take even more leadership position, kind of helping the crypto industry navigate a part of the world that everyone really gets frustrated about, and no one really wants to have to partake in yet. You're kind of damned if you don't. And Ryan seems to be having just a fireball of energy behind him with regards to how to approach crypto regulation to get what we want, and rather than acting defensively, which is anytime some sort of bad regulation comes up, crypto rises to the challenge to defend us.
Ryan is thinking offensively, which is how do we attack these issues and instantiate crypto in the parts of the world that we want to instantiate them in before bad regulation even comes about? I think that's a fantastic strategy, and I really enjoyed that part of the conversation. And then like you said, Ryan, in the second half of the show, we turned to a rehashing of a debate that we had last time Ryan came on the show about ether as an asset, whether institutions are going to be interested in it and where it fits in his personal opinion and his portfolio. And there was definitely some concessions from versus last time that he came onto the show, not as many as I would have hoped, but I think if we just keep on revisiting this conversation with Ryan over and over, it's simply going to be a death by a thousand concessions.
Yeah, there's definitely room for growth there, you know, at the same time. Like the last conversation we had, it was literally a debate on whether ether is money or not, what we meant by that was, is it a reserve asset, whether you've monetary premium, is it going to like do well in the future? And well listeners will have to tune into that section to hear what Ryan has to say, leave it there. Before we get into the conversation, we want to think the sponsors that made this episode possible. Living a bankless life requires taking control of your own private keys, not your keys, not your crypto.
That's why so many in the bankless nation already have their ledger hardware wallets, which makes proper private key management a breeze. But the ledger ecosystem is more than just a secure hardware wallet. Ledger is the combination of the ledger hardware wallet and the ledger live app. And if you're used to seeing all of your crypto services and favorite deaps all in one place, ledger is where you want to be. Not only does ledger let you buy crypto assets straight from the app, but it also cooks into decentralized exchange aggregators like periswap, which makes sure that you are getting the best prices on your trades without your assets ever leaving your control.
DeFi never stops growing and the ledger live app grows alongside with it. So click the link in the show notes to see all the DeFi apps that ledger live has. And stay tuned as more and more apps come online. And if you don't have a ledger hardware wallet, what are you even waiting for? Go to ledger.com, grab your ledger, download ledger live and get all of your deaps all in one place. Arbitrum is an Ethereum scaling solution that is going to completely change how we use DeFi. If you've been using Ethereum for the past 12 months, you've probably noticed the high gas fees and the slow confirmation times that have been plaguing DeFi.
Too many people want to use Ethereum and it doesn't have enough capacity for all of us. That's where Arbitrum comes in. Arbitrum is a layer 2 to Ethereum, which means Arbitrum can increase Ethereum's throughput by orders of magnitude at a fraction of the cost of what we are used to paying. When interacting with Arbitrum, you can get the performance of a centralized exchange while tapping into Ethereum's level of security and decentralization. This is why people are calling this Ethereum's broadband moment where we get to add performance onto decentralization and security. If you're a developer and you want to save on gas costs and make an overall better experience for your users, go to developer.
offchainlabs.com to get started building on Arbitrum. If you're a user, keep an eye out for your favorite DeFi apps building on Arbitrum. Arbitrum has been working with over 300 teams including Ethereum's top infrastructure projects and will be opening up to all users shortly. There are so many apps coming online to Arbitrum so you may want to pack your bags in preparation for the great migration to the Arbitrum layer 2. To keep up to speed with Arbitrum, follow them on Twitter at Arbitrum and join their Discord. Bankless Nation, we are super excited about our next guest. He's been on the show before.
This is Ryan Salgas. He's the founder of Crypto Analytics firm Masari Crypto. He's a longtime crypto advocate. He's been a content producer and crypto for quite a long time. And more recently, he's become a single issue voter. We're going to talk about what that means too. Ryan, great to have you back. Welcome to Bankless. Thank you for having me. I'm surprised that you wanted me to come back and slap your own a little bit more. You are alluding to the second topic. We're going to cover which is ETH and whether you thoughts on ETH have changed. We had a debate the last time you were on whether ETH is money or not.
Want to get to that. But first, man, I got to tell you, it feels like you've been on a street lately or something. Masari just raised 21 million from some massive names, 0.72. Bill, that's billionaire Steve Cohen. That's his firm. You've been spinning fire about unelected bureaucrats in government. I feel like rallying the crypto industry about what's going on in infrastructure, bill, and in getting the industry involved in politics. How's it feel, man? How's it feel to be right? So it's these days. It feels pretty similar to how it took two weeks ago. I've lived through a lot of chaos in the last eight years in crypto.
That's a lot of dog years. I think generally pretty steady. Social media can be read a bunch of different ways. And I know one to dial down and up intensity, I think, depending on what's going on. But it doesn't really change my day to day. So I think the first thing that is really important about the last couple of weeks is what happened in the way that it happened with the infrastructure bill in this last minute provision that was inserted. And then the bipartisan efforts to amend this particular provision of the bill, and then the last minute stonewalling, everything about the process covered a cover was essentially 100% of what everybody hates about the US government and government and today's decaying institutions in general.
So this was not a very risky position to go out on a limb. But it was an opportunity, I think, to help shake people awake and kind of catalyze people and get them riled up in the Aurea manual, never let a crisis go to waste camp. So I do think that this is a crisis for crypto. I don't think that it's going to shut the industry down. I don't think that it's something that's going to necessarily cripple us. But it's definitely a move in a very negative direction that we're going to need to work hard to overcome. So it is a crisis. And I think to the extent that people are finally starting to take political effort seriously and ongoing engagement down DC seriously, that's important.
Now, when I say engagement, that's a loaded word. And a lot of my frustration, and I think the unique voice that I have in this particular issue is, I'm sick of the bullshit as is everybody else, but most people can't actually say that quite part out loud because they're running regulated businesses within crypto. They're running an exchange, a custodian, they have a token, they're investing other people's money, right? So there's a lot of things that I think are pretty unique about me just from where I sit in the industry, a, running an information business, and b, not necessarily touching other people's money, or processing crypto transactions, so you can be a little bit more vocal about some of this.
The other thing that's important is this is a very bipartisan response right now. If you look back to the early crypto days, it's a lot of libertarians, it's a lot of like, you know, crypto anarchists and small government maximalists more than anything else. But more recently, crypto, Ethereum, all the new application builders, there are a lot of progressives or classical liberals, I guess, that have entered the frame more recently. And it's not that they don't care about progressive issues. They do. They just also happen to be very passionate about text ability to kind of advance humanity and be a part of the solution, particularly when juxtaposed with government and some of these legacy model with the constitutions.
So I think both from right and left, the thing that has changed in the last couple of weeks is people have really fired up. There's an opportunity to get engaged down in DC and force the issue because this is going to be very politically expensive for representatives on both sides if they end up on the wrong side. And I think the big, unique tone or niche that I think I tapped into is the fact that engagement no longer needs to just mean education, advocacy, kissing ass essentially. There is, I think, an opening to play a little bit of offense now. I think everybody right now is scrambling to figure out, how do we do this productively?
Because yes, most of this is still an education problem. And the episode you guys just did with Jake was perfect, right? Like I agree with him. Like anything that can be most required to incompetence versus, you know, malice. Generally, it's incompetence. And it's historically just been that they're not paying attention and they don't understand how this tech works. But I don't think that's really an option any longer for elected representatives to not pay attention because crypto is the fastest growing sector of American tech because it's important for us from the geopolitical perspective, particularly when we compare ourselves to China and our future competitiveness.
And it's basically the only technology that is doing anything to preserve civil liberties in this country and defend against the overreach of the ubiquitous surveillance state. You look at Apple's announcement from last week that was buried or a couple of weeks ago that was buried on a Friday that they're essentially going to incorporate backdoors into their products. You think about basically what Treasuries trend to do with this bill in making sure that all of DeFi has prevailed. And, you know, at some point, we need to push back against the illegalization of all private transactions and play a little bit of offense.
And I think riling up the base, organizing it more of a grassroots level. And yes, ultimately primary and unseeding elected representatives that are openly hostile versus just ignorant about crypto is going to be a good strategy. The difference between this year and years past is we have a lot of money to actually put this in action. And I think it has to be done now because the market has been going up. And if you're going to play offense, play offense in a bull market when there's as much distress as the current currently is in institutions, don't do it after a 50, 60, 70 percent drawdown when they can just slap us around on consumer protection, on fraud, on everything under the song that you know is coming the next time the market picks it up.
I love your voice in the space. And for the listeners, I think we're going to divide this conversation like two parts. The first is we got to talk about regulatory nation state versus crypto. And the second part is I want to hear an update on your opinions on ETH as an asset Ryan. But like let's stay with this theme of playing offense crypto versus nation state. This is for bankless listeners. This is kind of a taste of the fire that Ryan's been spinning lately on crypto. And I think this really resonated. There's a lot of likes on this tweet. But it's basically in the message, I'm sick of feeling like we have to apologize for all our early stage and walk on eggshells around politicians and regulators.
This is Ryan's tweeting this out. We built a two trillion dollar financial market from scratch and less than a decade with absolutely no institutional help and active incumbrances from government. Meanwhile, the banks give you 0.025 percent interest on your deposits in front run your trades legally. And DC grifters overspended debates your tax dollars while they insider trade stocks with impunity. And this really captured I think a lot of the the Zeke guys in crypto and that's kind of that playing offense. And as you said, it feels very much Ryan, like the politicians are kind of like newly experiencing this force and not sure on what side they're going to fall on, right?
So like it's a bipartisan thing. It's not left versus right. Like almost everything else in our political discourse these days. And the politicians haven't yet decided, are they going to be crypto friendly? Like what's the cohort? What's the coalition around crypto that's going to support this? Or are they going to be anti crypto? And what's the coalition that's going to support that? It feels to me like it's all squishy and they haven't figured it out. But can we talk a bit about like I'm curious. It seems in DC that there is a certain contingent. We asked Jake this question as well. But like that is against crypto.
And I want to know why. Like why do they hate us? Because they can't control it. Or they can't control it in the way that they would like to, which is fully, I guess for lack of better term. And for many decades now we've had a two-party system that is really just one big government party with different policy goals. Libertarians lose elections because they always say vote for me. I'll do less work. And it's probably what we need. But it's not a very good message because people want to know, I'm going to vote for someone powerful. They're going to advance my agenda. They're going to advance my interests.
Well, I'm going to get this, this and this from this political leader. And really what we need is just greater grief of decentralization. And I think that's where crypto has been pretty powerful. If you think about crypto basically being like an opt out political movement in many respects, it's a way to play that thesis proactively. And what I've compared to it, you know, you think about like Goldbugs versus people who are building in crypto. Goldbugs are waiting for the end of the world living in a cabin in the woods and digging holes in the ground to put shiny metal like back in from once again.
Folks in crypto might have the exact same thesis as those Goldbugs. But instead of being in a cabin in woods digging a hole in the ground and putting a shine rock waiting to ride out the apocalypse, direction in the front lines building things every day and every single day a new problem is created in crypto because of the unintended consequences of what has been built so far. And almost always someone immediately recognizes the problem and starts a business to solve that problem. We've seen this for a decade now. Every single major problem that crypto has unleashed onto the world, the horror, has ultimately yielded like a billion dollar business.
You look at chain analysis, it's a five billion dollar business right now. They have done data forensics to help regulators and law enforcement worldwide actually track money launders. You look at taxpayer just a few year old business. The narrative is that crypto is full of tax evaders and people that don't want to pay their taxes and this is just a way to kind of cheat the government and your fellow citizens. Tax bid is a 1.3 billion dollar business. Did they get there because people are evading their taxes or they're trying desperately to pay them in a manner that doesn't take a week and a half to understand how to comply with impossible tax policy in the US for a broad.
Sorry, we were created to basically be a first principles Edgar repository for disclosures and other project information. Solve the investment fraud issue. I can tell you right now, some of my investors have relationships with Ripple. One of the first things that I did when we started the company was a multi-month street against Ripple and how horrible their investment practices, their token selling practices were for their and investors and how shady the marketing was around it. So yeah, there are folks in this ecosystem that want to see it survive, advance and ultimately become more anti-fragile and get built out in a way that is going to be a force for good in the world versus just sitting on the sideline saying everything is going to ship, everything is broken, there's no way to fix it.
I'm going to buy gold, wait for the dollar to get the base and then come out of my cocoon or my hiding after a decade when the dust is settled and I think that's pretty powerful because it's techno progressives and it's classical liberals and it's like all the libertarians molded into one of the playing offense instead of just defense and basically saying you know what we're all screwed. I feel like that's particularly true in DeFi this whole idea of like we're building a new better financial system that's the gold more transparent, more open, right? I'm curious what you think about this, it seems like everybody in Washington all the time is trying to protect us from crypto, it's like this protection atmosphere.
It's just a massive projection, right? This is what they do, they're corrupt. Is it code? They're corrupted for like control? They want to control us? Is that what protection is? All of their concerns just project their own corruption? They're worried about grifts whereas the revolving door in DC is just from a seat in influence in DC to a lobbying seat or in-house at a big corporation and then back again. Janet Yellen made $7.2 million last year during COVID when she was giving speeches to financial services companies via Zoom. $7.2 million per time is not that valuable or refuse to believe that unless she was ultimately going to become the new treasury secretary which of course happened.
So that's money well spent but that's just part of the grifts and this happens at all levels of DC. People know that it happens, it's just assumed that this is kind of the way that this is done in DC and there's no real way to stop it. So if you think about the ethos of DC and the people that are working there and what the revolving door looks like and how people actually make their money, then of course they're projecting all the worst things on the tech, onto crypto finance and all the entrepreneurs that are working because this is how they would be operating if they're in the private sector.
It's just in their DNA. Let's call that out. So it's in their DNA but let me ask you this question because this is actually further in the agenda we wanted to get to but let's get to it now. You also tweeted out recently about crypto that we need to spend money, lots of it. Like crypto should also be playing this game which you're saying and we should also, I don't know, maybe pay for Janet Yellen to come speak to us, I don't know, is that are you basically advocating that crypto play the same game that everybody else plays in DC and have a stake at the table? Is that something that's important to crypto and is there a moral issue with that?
I hate it but I think you have to fight fire with fire and I think people are slowly starting to wake up to that and you know here's the issue. Crypto can be shut down. China just proved that it can be. Do I think the US moves that quickly? Do I think it's as dire the political situation and kind of surveillance state in the US is China? No, but it's certainly not where it was 10 years ago, 20 years ago, 30 years ago, you know, certainly a couple hundred years ago when the country was formed. So we are moving in that direction. And I think the reality is there's a lot of damage that regulators and policymakers can do to crypto via tax policy and by overextending the Patriot Act and all the associated provisions related to national security that they'll kind of throw at us.
We saw a sample of this with the Treasury's report on privacy tokens late last year and if you remember December, January when Steve Mnuchin on his way out of office was essentially trying to sneak in some of these last minute provisions that would make it very difficult to support any privacy tokens. This was, you know, is a big part of what they had in mind. So anything that can't control I think is scary to them. And so if you ultimately want to get elected representatives in office that understand why this is important, not just from a constitutional theory standpoint, but from an electoral standpoint and from the perspective of their constituents, then that's going to take active engagement beyond just yelling at people on Twitter.
You're going to have to host floodraisers for politicians that are going to be on the right side of the issue that have this as part of their platform that are going to be going up in primaries against their 70, 80-year-old counterparts that have been in office since before the internet was created. So I think there's no way around that because the alternative is pretty bleak. Everybody likes to talk a big gain that we can just like route around the government and this is permissionless and so even if it is shut down we're still going to be able to operate these systems. That's all true but it's just going to it will cover to cover be a black market and there's a sizable contingent of the world that is not going to play ball like the Americans and Europeans are not going to transact in systems that are deemed illegal by their authorities because those are still relatively functioning, well-functioning societies that have otherwise robust financial services and so you're not talking about situations like Argentina and Venezuela and Sub-Saharan Africa and high inflation countries in Southeast Asia.
People will generally fall and there'll be some contingent that will not and they'll opt out but it doesn't change the fact that it will be illegal or it will be extremely expensive or cumbersome from the user perspective actually participating in these systems. So the folks that are the loudest and have this battle cry on Twitter that we need to play a different game or we need to opt out. The problem with that is there's no new land in the world. There's no place that you can escape to. There's no free world to settle like we had when America was settled and the country was founded. You can't even escape to the metaverse.
They will literally tax. This is what we're talking about. They'll they'll tax and surveil everything that you're doing in the metaverse even and I know that you were being completely facetious. This is more proof that I listen to you guys versus just kind of come on every once in a while to rush. One of you made a comment in the Jake episode about like the IRS literally wants to know when your axes are mating and it's not that far from the truth like any activity that you have in the metaverse they're still going to be they're still going to look at like where was your phone locked in to to establish a tax nexus which is insane and so if there's no place to escape to physically and you're not allowed to do virtual commerce even even if it's completely unplugged and kind of disassociated from the rest of the economy then you have no other choice but the kind of fight on their home turf and I think you can do so intelligently so I'm not advocating for like January 6th insurrection like that's the worst type of undisciplined theatrical dangerous type of revolt and ultimately it's completely counterproductive and it's extreme everybody knows that I'm not even advocating for like online harassment or you know vitriol it's you know directed or you know female you know senators or congressman getting you know misogynistic tweets and threats and and you know all the carvers that you see what what I'm suggesting and advocating for and then I think a lot of people agree with even if there's not as forceful about it because they can't be is you know we have to start grading these folks on one to five system and the five that are allies get a tremendous amount of support an eye-opening amount of support through social channels through grassroots campaign efforts through political donations through super PAC contributions the ones have the act opposite in terms of how well funded their enemies are and their political rivals and then the two through fours is where you can continue to focus on the education and advocacy but the education and advocacy work for the two through fours will be infinitely easier if they see what's happening to the ones in five because on the fives you've got a big carrot and on the ones you've got a big stick and if we can unseat some folks like Brad Sherman that are in the one camp as established as he is and threatened folks like that or even make their lives very difficult during the midterms it's going to pay I think extremely lucrative long-term dividends that's to say nothing of the you know the broader impact that we can have just your social channels because crypto is very very vocal and I think the challenge air is like different but it's it's how do you contain some of that enthusiasm or kind of channel and proactively so we don't look like a bunch of nut jobs which may never be solved Brian I think I would think we definitely need to unpack this because I think this is a fascinating point of the conversation that we should really spearhead here I was going to ask you now that we have this like regulatory drama of the last two weeks in our rear view mirror what have we unlocked but I think you've kind of already answered that question in bits and pieces in the last 10 minutes or so I think where this is going and what you're talking about when we're talking about like reviewing public our regulators on the merits of whether they support our industry or not I think really what has happened in the last two weeks for this industry is everyone has taken a moment to reflect on what crypto really means to them and ask themselves the question am I a single issue voter when it comes to politics and crypto and I think we all know that crypto is has so much tribalism and like a desire to defend our home turf and so much energy and as we all know so much capital behind it that perhaps the measure of a single issue voter body that is that is of the crypto world might actually be one of the most significant cohorts of a voting body that we've seen arise out of any part of the political sphere that we've seen in America in the last I don't know since since the NRA how do you think that the let's go into details on to how you think the crypto voting body can galvanize itself and direct itself to get what it wants in Washington DC what are the next steps now that we have identified that we are here in this moment of time how do we actually adequately capture this energy and direct it to get what we want done in DC well there's a I'll answer that question in terms of like what are the methods and and how can we actually make some forward progress there but but first yeah it's important note I intentionally use the NRA is it like a call to action just because it's good extra-wide comparison and it's provocative so it kind of hits all the Twitter checkboxes but there couldn't be anything that's further from the truth in terms of the fundamental issue that I think crypto single issue voters have with the government right now you know the NRA you know guns are used in in school shootings and mass shootings and and gun violence is a real problem in the country you know other I won't kind of name drop other organizations but but most of the other organizations where you have single issue voters the the issues that they're talking about are extremely contentious there's often like an element of violence or like national security implications that kind of rally people up and in in crypto the issues there's no opposition like there are very few intelligent opposition leaders to crypto it's basically proponents and then people that don't understand it that's an extremely powerful position to be in because like I said it's not just about like right wing or libertarian or progressive voters that are working in the industry right now and then actually care about building this tech and preserving its ability to you know get developed in a way where you can still regulate the decentralized organizations that are you know building broker services and so I think that is just a major difference between some of the other light and rod individual member led organizations that the card carrying member organizations for other lobbying groups now how do you actually win that I think there's probably about a dozen people collectively working in DC right now at the major think tanks and trade associations that everybody knows about crypto 20 tops working on defending this entire ecosystem and you know that I think has worked in the past because we haven't really been on the radar this is one of the first times that crypto has been a major part of the conversation any legislation that's been passed most of the conversations to date have been regulatory in nature right how's the IRS going to treat this for tax purposes what's the SEC say about you know whether this is a whether these tokens are securities or what was going to happen to Bitcoin ETF what does treasury you know think about the AML you know KYC requirements for for crypto brokers things like that um how is Finsen thinking about this from the kind of monitoring standpoint almost the only bills that have been I think even tangentially is tied to crypto haven't really gone anywhere and and so this you know last minute provision it was only included because the politicians thought that was there was some type of money that they could extract from the industry right again fall fall the money and you'll you'll see whether real interest lie um and so I think now that it's on the radar the the big thing this change is is they've we've we've kind of had Pandora's box open on us where they looked at the $28 billion for from the CBO and their estimate as to what tax receipts could be with tighter enforcement and tighter surveillance of of defying particular and now it's something that's something that can't be undone um nor can the kind of battle that ensued over this because now they know that actually this is a much bigger deal to our constituents and and this is a pretty you know fire a community that we didn't really know existed before but the actual people in DC that are funded do this on a full-time basis that you know they're there's probably about 20 so the first thing that that needs to happen is um we need to make sure that that Queensland blockchain associations some of the other groups that are are popping up have the funding that they need and we have the right lobbyist infrastructure in place to do the combination of like education advocacy work and then you just generally have a better coordinated PR campaign that could be you know funding endowing chairs at at think tanks so that the you know the research from the independent heritage foundation or Hutchins or you know Brookings wherever that all of these folks in DC actually rely on to support their policy positions um there's a lot that we can kind of do there and coordinate from a policy support standpoint and the most importantly which is what I've been talking about is just getting more involved in electoral politics and and having this grassroots effort where you have hundreds of thousands of of dues paying members to an individual member dominant organization where you can actually mobilize people in local elections local campaigns you know going to town hall meetings all the blocking and tackling that I think people don't really appreciate until until you see how much politicians care about not having pains in their ass um just harassing them at all times and and it's one of the situations where the squeaky will gets the oil and so combination of of money boots on the ground and um and and just potential bad publicity I think is is is probably enough to get our ultimate policy goal which is not don't tax us give us favorable treatment do this that the other thing it's don't regulate things that you don't understand um and don't penalize crypto unnecessarily particularly versus um traditional financial services companies that were we're talking about or other you know tech giants that would be subject to the same regulation I could I could definitely say I would be a card caring member of the self sovereign crypto lobby group and maybe they could issue that as an NFC that would be a bit more conducive to uh to to to the way I carry things these days but um one thing that gave me hope like you kind of started this episode and I completely agree you use this term states surveillance right as like feels like there is an all out assault on our digital privacy and freedoms it's not just crypto it spans beyond crypto right so like the newest thing with apple releasing a software update to give them the ability to basically scan all of your local photos on any apple device right how dystopian is that and what's weird about this Ryan is like there is nobody in our government who is pushing back against these things right maybe they're not incentive to push back maybe they don't care but what's given me some hope actually recently is crypto has the and I think we've seen this in the last two weeks has the coordination ability and the capital and just the raw community fervor to push for self sovereignty and maybe we launched this thing and it's primarily about crypto cryptocurrency but then maybe it expands and we capitalize other areas we care about because like look if I have the right to own cryptocurrency but apple has the ability to like scan my uh device for whatever it wants like I don't want to live in that world either and this is why I've kind of come I don't know I used to be less enthusiastic about engaging you know on the lobby level and in DC and like you know as as the traditional organizations have but I think we need to for those for these issues because no but if crypto doesn't if the crypto industry doesn't who's going to right like big tech isn't going to come to the defense of privacy and self sovereignty they don't care right so like it's got to be us at some level and maybe we start with crypto and expand from there that is a hopeful future what are your thoughts on that um you know I think that there's multiple ways to do this um but you know generally speaking I think we have the resources right now let's win the battle that's right in front of us and then um we can start talking about how we play with other organizations because I ultimately think this is a team sport and ideally you know we've already seen allies at the you know EFF that fight for the future at a number of other organizations and I think uh generally there there's often a lot of overlap that can be done in terms of research in terms of that because you work and and you know I think across the board um it's uh it's a starting point to just kind of focus on cleaning our own house and then ultimately being in a position where we can cross pop pollinate for many other important issues across the board so I see what you're saying and I think that there's this is like a wedge and that's why I think about it it's like a political movement in and of itself because um there's so much that I think is embedded in in in crypto values more broadly that um we haven't really defined as a community because we're we've generally been so focused on like all the differences between the communities versus you know our uh the the kind of common interests that that have been shared historically and and that's by design right like it's a decentralized community it's not a company that can just kind of lay out its all the square values I'll let's say it like just for me personally it's um it's it's almost been like a little bit liberating because we went we went through this period with Trump in office where you could not talk about politics at all like in in like any uh in any context because the the the tenor was just so over the top charge and I think um you know before that it wasn't entirely different but you know before that in like the 20 2009 to you know 2015 environments um those those a lot of political discussion within crypto because this this movement had political roots and it was was you know kind of anti government I guess anti big government certainly um to start and then you know Trump took office and it's like you you you can't actually talk about anything political because you're like three steps away from from either being referred to as a communist or a Nazi and then so like nothing good comes of it um and then you know again two weeks ago when we saw the bipartisan effort and you see everyone from like Ted Cruz on the one hand to a 21 year old brown progressive writing an open letter to Elizabeth Warren like on literally the same side of the issue I I have trouble thinking of like a starker contrast than those two people articulating the same argument for like why it's important to support crypto long term you know um and it it's kind of like smash the overton window to a certain extent for I think a lot of people that have maybe fallen into the camp of uh what I would think of is like radical centrism um or like you know just like blinders on let's focus on building and not focus on every single debate that has that is basically just like dominated today by the two like five percent extremes of the bell curve with everybody in the middle just getting shut out because you know they don't want to talk about her or they don't want to incur the wrath of being on the wrong side of an issue and um I think this the conversations that I've seen and like the general agreements uh importantly with with yeah I think many of the people in um in crypto on certain kind of core values has been um it's been illuminating and I think it's also been empowering for people to that kind of feel strongly about the why like we're in this industry aside for just the memes and the money which you know is is a nice byproduct I think that's been a good rally points and you know people have been comfortable getting a little bit more politically engaged hey guys coming up next on the show I ask Ryan about his opinion about whether or not we can convince regulators to actually align with defi align with ethereum align with crypto as an attempt to you know increase brand the strength the value of the us dollar as we all know united states nation wants a strong dollar and as we all know dollars are a very important part of the defi economy and therefore perhaps the global economy of the future how can we convince regulators to see this truth and to leverage this fact in the face of the chinese cbdc that's what I ask to Ryan next and then after that we actually turn the conversation towards ether as an asset and his opinions about uh the institutionalization of ether and putting ether on the balance sheets for larger and larger financial institutions and also his own opinions and his own perspective as to where ether fits in his own personal portfolio and teaser Ryan has actually become overweight ether in relation to uh the last time we had him on the show roughly nine months ago so we go into all those details and more but first before we get there we have to take a moment to talk about some of these fantastic sponsors that make this show possible when you shop for plane tickets you probably use kayak expedia or google to compare ticket prices so why would you limit yourself to just one exchange when you trade crypto when you make your trades you want to make sure that you are getting the best possible price on your trade and that you aren't paying high gas costs that you could have otherwise avoided that's why you should be using matcha matcha routes your orders across all the various defi exchanges on ethereum polygon finance smart chain and gives you the best possible prices without taking any commissions matcha has smart order routing that splits your order across multiple liquidity sources if matcha sees that it gets you better pricing trading on matcha is super easy because it pulls the liquidity for me into a single easy to use platform matcha also allows for you to make limit orders on chain so you can set and forget your defi trades and they will go through automatically while you're away new to matcha is an integrated fiat on ramps you can purchase crypto directly with your credit or debit card and have that fiat be instantly traded for any token that has liquidity when you're making a trade head over to matcha.
xyz slash bankless and connect your wallet to start getting the best prices and most liquidity when you trade your crypto assets bankless is proud to be supported by uniswap uniswap is a new paradigm in asset exchange infrastructure instead of a cumbersome order book system where trades are matched with other humans uniswap is an autonomous piece of software on ethereum which is what Ryan and I call a money robot no human counterparties or centralized intermediaries just autonomous code on ethereum input the token you want to sell and receive the token you want to buy something brand new in the uniswap ecosystem is the uniswap grants program is now accepting applications for grants we have been saying this for a while and will say it again dals have money and they are in need of labor if you think that you have something to contribute to the uniswap down apply for a grant to uniswap just look at the size of the uniswap treasury it's almost three billion dollars this mountain of capital is looking for labor do you have something of value to contribute to the uniswap down no matter how big or small your idea is you can apply for a unigrant at unigrants.
org and help steer uniswap in the direction that you think it should go that's exactly what we did to get uniswap to be a sponsor for bankless and you can do the same for your project thank you uniswap for sponsoring bankless Ryan one possible future I see ahead of us is that we actually have an opportunity to convince regulators that aligning with the crypto industry is in their best interests using the stablecoin side of of defi and is a way to export the us dollar and the value of the us dollar and dollar demand globally and it also if we can get regulators support behind this it can be a huge offensive weapon against the Chinese CBDC which I think if you're paying attention to it is a we all people who do pay attention to it generally agree that it's a massive threat to dollar dominance meanwhile we have US regulators having these banking panels or seminars asking what is crypto even useful for just really broadcasting their complete naivety about what is so cool about this industry so there's a there's a future world where we can actually convince US regulators that instead of being overbearing and over regulating this industry that we can actually get them to use this industry as a weapon against the Chinese CBDC are you optimistic that we can actually make this happen and if we can make this happen do you have any thoughts about the the right path to get there I think that argument it works because it's truthful right if you just look at how quickly the US can move at a centralized government level on certain issues it's just it's not very fast by interest in the imagination and that's actually the one thing that's been like very positive for folks within crypto in in the American in European scenes if if our governments were as functional as China as I'm not saying that we want to live there but if we were as functional as the CCP is and just making unilateral moves then then we could have a real problem if if there was political opposition what we're doing but generally speaking because we move slowly things get funded slowly innovation happens slowly and so I I think there's a credible argument to be made that the installed like tech base that we have is really going to have to be built by private companies and that are facilitating transactions in these open protocols because a like Fedcoin is just not like can you just imagine how inferior like Fedcoin as a product would be if it was rolled out by the big banks it's just like the it's definitely it's it's laughable right like you're you're just not going to have anything near what's what we see in crypto and and maybe the government would argue that's for the good of and for the protection of consumers but I think you know by and large it's the I buy that argument I think we should make that argument that the government should be working proactively with crypto companies and supporting them and yes regulating the centralized businesses that are working on this infrastructure because it is arguably the best way to preserve the dollar strength over time so say we do go down this path in an attempt to get regulators who really really don't like crypto to be more okay with crypto in an attempt to use crypto to be offensive against the Chinese CBDC or other just like or just the dollar protecting the brand of the dollar I'm going to go ahead and guess that if we if this reality plays out the crypto industry is going to have to give some concessions we're gonna have to make some compromises with the way that this industry works the first thing my mind goes to is perhaps something like tether but even usdc has a very non KYC element to it that is probably concerning to a lot of us regulators those are the first two concessions that I come to my mind is probably more regulation around stablecoins but what all of branches can we give to regulators that doesn't just hamstring what makes defying crypto so cool do you have any thoughts on that well I think or what are they really going to ask for probably no matter what I think the hard line in the sand needs to be that developers and code needs to be protected and the ability for someone to actually receive customer information needs to be taken into consideration as to whether certain regulation should be put on any contributor to an open network right so this is basically like the staking and kind of validator issue on the one hand and then just the contributors of code on the other so you know I think that we we have to be realistic and I think the industry is realistic about centralized companies centralized exchanges in particular being very proactive about working with regulators I think we should expect that there's going to be you know continued oversight and tax reporting requirements and in general like customer information sharing requirements with the quain basis of the world the gem and ice and and to be honest I don't even know that any of those organizations are like pushing back on that I think the the big sticking point might be around private transactions and and we already kind of saw a hint of that six you know six nine months ago and aside from the private transactions is going to be defy which is you know just there's a lot of capital gains that are arguably being generated in decentralized exchanges that there's there's no oversight um over and there's no kind of clear tax reporting policy having said that the the data forensics companies exist to get that information so you know again you're you're coming into this um situation where if you are the IRS you can make very clear guidance that transactions of such and such a nature on decentralized exchanges are taxable events and you need to you know if you are attempting to longer money or or you know evade taxes by you know parking your money and defy that's a really bad way to operate um and uh and ultimately you know we're going to get caught because there's a digital vapor trail and and it's it's a it's a terrible way to actually um execute a scheme like that so I think um I don't I don't think that our expectations or or what we're arguing for is is unreasonable by any stretch of the imagination and and that's what makes me so confident that a like a grassroots effort like this could actually um uh work out you know very very effectively because we're on the right side of this and I think the arguments uh that we have uh at our part side make sense and and no one is really pushed back against them other than the very ill-informed takes of well if if this software can exist then it's probably not good for society and and we should shut it down or try to move it offshore yeah we've only heard a few people really say that so yeah I I agree with this like so like I think there are enough wins for uh for regulators and legislators in the US government here in crypto uh for them to get actually excited about it it's like if they're not going to compete with China's central bank digital currency by rolling their own which they can't we just talked about that there's like I don't think there's an appetite to do that what is their strategy well like it's got to be crypto export US dollars on crypto rails right like Ethereum uh what I do worry about the Orion is that maybe just in Congress and then this is a symptom of like where the US government is right now it's just they're too like old and set in their ways to actually do it you know like they're just too content with the status quo so we just roll around like roll roll on like the US is doing on a number of issues don't make any progress forward we just settled the status quo and doing that is not a sustainable strategy for the US so that that is my worry not that there's not enough wins here it's just that they don't care maybe they don't care um but let's talk about something else uh that's sort of related because I know you're very plugged into the institutions and I'm curious what the reaction is from sort of the the big money institutional world to all of this did they freak out that crypto was like it didn't reflect it in the in a market price which is interesting but were they freaking out that crypto is like a potentially contentious issue in front of uh congress and that this you know treasury is possibly against it is that a bad signal to them?
I do you know I think it's a wake up call again I think the um the existing regulated businesses and brokers are going to continue to be regulated uh and and they're going to continue to have big compliance teams and legal budgets and and I think they'll be just fine right um so I I don't think that there's um I wouldn't say that they're alarmed I think it's it's less about it's less about being alarmed by like openly hostile actors within the government and more alarmed that this happened on such short notice it was um you know it was extremely fast how it happened was very dysfunctional and so now we're more or less at the mercy of those that are going to be um writing the rules at the unelected regulatory body level right so how much authority is treasury going to have uh to write rules how much uh authority is the SEC going to have how much you that is where authority is ultimately getting delegated and um that's definitely not a net positive so I think um a lot of what's being done right now with respect to you know kind of arguments um in the house and and trying to uh meet or some of the the native impacts of um of what we already saw past and senate it's really just kind of laying the groundwork and setting the precedent for future work challenges and you know maybe we can get lucky and and there's um improved language it comes out of the house and is ultimately incorporated into any final legislation that passes but um I think right now it's it's more of a long-term game and I can tell you if they're not alarmed everybody is certainly very mobile right now um at at the institutional level and that's you know defy major investors um and then obviously the regulated groups themselves obviously well yeah name individual names but I'd say it's pretty universal that people are fired up and it's taken this very seriously so as we all know this is probably crypto's biggest regulatory event uh it was that we couldn't stop talking about it for two weeks we're still talking about it now and as a community generally everyone kind of feels pretty emboldened after the fact even though technically we kind of lost uh and during the actual um actual debates and the the drama around different amendments uh and everyone was getting scared about crypto being regulated to death crypto asset prices like had a stellar performance uh a week weekly performance uh like ether went from twenty three hundred dollars up to three thousand bitcoin we were was below forty thousand and then zoomed up to forty seven thousand so in the face of crypto's biggest like regulatory hurdle asset prices like had a stellar week what what does this tell you does this tell you anything what signal is this uh people are distracted by pengu's really you do you do you generally think that the asset price movements were just uncorrelated to what the drama that was going on in DC uh honestly I have no idea I've I've a long time ago given up on trying to understand what was crypto markets but um I guess the point is this isn't like China like what when when when China actually like push the miners out that was a major event um and it it had some like fundamental impact on on both you know Ethereum and Bitcoin um I would say long-term it was it was a massive and that positive because it it made proof of work cleaner and you you kind of uh dearest some of that geopolitical element um I think uh with what happened last week it for for folks that are on the outside looking in it doesn't necessarily look like the end of the world per se because it's like oh well you know the folks that passed the the bill ultimately went on the floor and said here's what we meant and so here was our intention in the rule obviously we didn't mean that developers would be captured obviously we didn't mean that stickers would be captured so there was already like a little bit of hedging and people you know kind of hear that and they're like oh okay well this is probably just like lawyers dotting the eyes across the teeth right and um I just I think that's I this is gonna play out over over the course of years right like even in the in the worst worst case in areas some of the rules that we're talking about and some of the policy that's that's going to be implemented we're talking about like 2023 right like you know certainly into like 2022 deep into 2022 um so we're we're still quite a ways um away from that and so I think um there's plenty of time to prepare there's going to be plenty of like you know uh court challenges and you know a lot of procedural issues and and you know this is really just kind of like the first ending in terms of how this ultimately plays out but um it's uh it's not something that would necessarily move the markets you know one way or the other um you know on a day-to-day basis it's funny sometimes I wonder in crypto whether we just like create explanations based on price or like like just like if the market had a fallen out during those two weeks for other reasons unrelated it definitely we definitely would have pinned it the crypto industry on you know regulation it's always hard I I sort of agree with you that like the short term noise in the market it's so difficult to discern whether it's like signal or noise or whether it's based in current events or not um it's definitely have to think about this over the long run this kind of brings us to the to the second topic here Ryan that we wanted to get you on for and this is the topic of ether ether as an asset so um bagless listeners long time bagless listeners may know we had a debate uh last year David was kind enough to host about eth as a store of value compared to bitcoin right I'm not going to use the term money let's not get hung up on the term money but it was basically a debate as to whether ether would accrue monetary premium perhaps surpassing the monetary premium of bitcoin and your take was like hey no eth is not a good monetary reserve asset my take was yes it was and then we had this conversation with like a number of different um different trails on it um but I'm curious so it's been I don't know close to nine months or so since we last talked about this in December has your opinion on eth changed since we last spoke and uh if so in what ways um I think the world has changed so um I ultimately think um your thesis was right for maybe reasons I disagree with I don't want to sit for the wrong reasons but um but but I think that the thesis like there's been new information uh over the course the last six months that I think is pretty important um the the first uh kind of major item for me is we've actually de-risked the move to ether two pretty pretty significantly right when we last talked it was uh it was it was kind of very earliest phases of everybody was celebrating all look at all the that was that was locked in the staking contract so the beacon chain um uh one five five nine uh I think was a big milestone I also just think the continued um evolution and like health of defy all the other markets they continue to predominantly you know ride the ethereum rails the just explosive continued growth in stablecoin adoption and usage and lending markets and basically every conceivable metric for for peace enterprise finance um and then uh importantly the the fact that we still haven't seen a ton of value leakage from ethereum to other smart contract platforms and chains right we're starting to see like interoperability with layer ones we're starting to see layer one versus layer two um you know value flows and that'll play out over time but for the for the most part you know uh big uh ethereum is like the the base layers is you know continue to show that it's resilient and um and primarily responsible for a lion share of crypto transactions not writ large so you know one one thing that you know I would I would like to see more of and and we'll likely have some product come out here is um I think we've gotten so used to like market cap dominance um we just need to have like all of the other like dominance metrics top of mind and um and whether it's like transaction volume you know uh lending capacity AUM for for whatever applications uh ethereum is continued to move up into the right you know aggressively so where I uh where I disagree with you uh in like the whole like Bitcoin to ethereum um debate is you know I actually had the epiphany from Arthur Hayes at Bitmax I think the way that he articulated it um kind of clicked everything in a place uh for me because it it was something that I kind of felt but didn't really have a a good kind of verbalization of and he made the point that if you look at like M zero versus the market cap of like big tech they're about six trillion dollars each is ethereum going to be money or is it going to be the equity in the decentralized financial system and this is not at all at odds with what I've been saying for years uh in fact I don't know if you guys were there but like ethereal two years ago 2019 I was on stage and everyone was talking about you know uh I don't know whatever like the hot um topic of the moment was in like web three or decentralization the internet whatever um and I was on stage and and you know basically said do a room full of uh ethereum world computer maximalists that like if ethereum was just the settlement layer for defy that's literally all that it needs to be and that's kind of where we are now it's not to say that that's the only thing that's happening out of ethereum of course but um the the fact that ethereum is a platform is generating real fees for for the like financial internet um that is a massive multi trillion dollar opportunity itself um that does not necessarily make it a better money or a better shelling points for people who are thinking about just the um the value settlement use case that bitcoin has uh kind of built an narrative around I also just think that the most entertaining outcome would be a 50 50 split um between like the money winner and the financial internet winner so that ethereum maximalists like yourselves and then bitcoin maximalists on the other hand can just argue in perpetuity over the flipping and like the the reflippening and the unflippening and and like and and and and and and and we basically just got to run in circles forever because uh everybody's talking past each other about like okay how are people actually valuing these two very different but important things um I will say from a from a fundamental standpoint the other thing that has definitely worked in ethereum's favor that I underappreciated late last year was how rapidly like the ESG narrative was shift um and you know from my perspective we um like the the black rocks of the world um starting to get more active on on you know climate policy and and and the potential risks that that could create for bitcoin as a holding of you know not only individual ambassadors but potentially a treasury holding for other companies um is a pretty meaningful developments that that we saw in q2 and and I think that had a real impact and and I think they're staying power to that negative narrative for for bitcoin potentially having said that that's not something that ethereum solved yet either it's on its way too but until it's solved it's it's not actually solved so I think um you know there there's certainly a a bunch of things that have changed but um my my core thesis for a long time has been um both are valuable bitcoin is more valuable I'm probably slightly overweight ethereum at this point because of that new information I still don't think it's money I still don't think it's money but I think um the risk reward for for both if if you put a gun in my head I'd probably pick big a theorem right now wow overweight ether um that that that is a change definitely when when you say overweight ether Ryan is that overweight versus bitcoin as in you have more ether than bitcoin no I'm not stupid wow they're the slaps are coming in well let me know I'm I'm from from from a yeah I am I am overweight from like a portfolio standpoint got it versus versus where they sit from a uh a market valuation standpoint so so so I'm curious like so I I know the term money can be distracting for people so let's not use this whether it's money whether it's a reserve asset whether it's kind of equity in this GDP that is Ethereum whatever it is right ultimately like asset price go up if it's successful if this thesis is successful it's cut what I think um the last time we talked um ask you about the flipping or you brought it up maybe and you said the answer is definitely no ether would not flip in bitcoin do you still believe it's a definite no I don't think it's a definite no anymore but so I think that's why I've moved over weight but I'm you know I'm I'm also not going to aggressively in the other direction like there are tax reasons also not to you know to go aggressively in the other direction because I think both they're going to succeed long term and um and uh I I definitely think that that Ethereum is potentially relatively undervalued right now um so I'm I'm putting more there progressively but it my position has not flippened um that's not to say I I am not convinced that we will see a flippening of market cap in the next couple of years but the probability is not negligible by the way one thing that's interesting I know you use the term uh theory maximalist for David and myself like I don't think of myself as in a theory maximalist at all like in fact um you know David and I help propose the index co-op this thing we call the bed index which is a third bitcoin a third eth and a third defy right I think that is juxtaposed with possibly bitcoin maximalist who would take up that mantle and clean bitcoin that all they buy is bitcoin right um so so yeah like the term maximalist is a bit different but I have always thought that um for a long time ever since we started bankless that the eth I guess fundamentals and the narrative was not appreciated I want to ask you a question about narrative because I think that was one of the things you mentioned in your your end of um you know 2020 thesis paper where you kind of sort of wrote predictions for 2021 one of the challenges with ether is the narrative is too complex uh as what you said do you think the narrative complexity has that been simplified a bit better is as ether maybe better understood in not quite mainstream but in sort of the circles that are buying it yeah I think narratively it's um I still don't agree with like the triple point asset like that particular mimetic a lot of people have right like I think it's resonated with with a lot of folks but I'm a little bit more simple in that you need eth for working capital for gas and to stake so you you you need ethereum for working capital and it is a capital asset now it's more like equity in the decentralized internet than anything else it just so happens you also use that for transactions for now but you don't necessarily have to right like you can use usdc many many applications on defy denominated in usdc for usdt or other stablecoin so you're already starting to see that um and and you know at the end of the day you know any time that you run a transaction you probably want it to be dollar denominated most people in the world will want it to be dollar denominated so even if it's like an auto conversion to eaf um at the time that you're paying a transaction fee for a specific defy application that's something that can be solved and you don't necessarily need to hoard eaf to pay for eaf at the time that you needed for transaction so the reserve demand is not necessarily the same as it would be for money the reserve demand the reason you would want to hold it is for a combination of convenience today and then staking and collateral so i and that i think it makes a lot of intuitive sense for investors and and like i said it's just it's such a massive market um that um that both narratives can win um and look maybe you will still prove to be right and that you know people use this for money too but i think generally speaking people line around the single best use case for a single technology and in this case um the capital asset for a financial internet i think is is the stronger mimetic that is getting institutions excited about because they look at this like okay jp morgan is a four hundred billion dollar company theorem is a four hundred billion dollar tech you know technological network that you know we can understand because these fees are getting burnt there's like you know real money that's getting earned by those that are securing the network kind of like bitcoin but you know in in more of like a shareholder based perspective um i think that's um it is really easy to to rock and and i think defy reinforces that because some of the other defy applications are very similar right you're providing liquidity you're providing um uh you know lending uh you know capital for for underwriting loans um so like the whole like stake earn deposit kind of ethos um and and the the uh the flywheel that creates in terms of network security i think is like an important fast here when last time Ryan that we had to you on the show to talk about the same debate um we had to take some time to actually define money because it was a question of is eth money uh and we we landed on uh you know monetary premium is is how you determine if something is money or not but i want to ask you this because Ryan Ryan said for a moment setting money aside we're all kind of primarily focused on number go up right market cap what what's the size of these market cap things uh and so say for a world in a in a world where eth does flip in btc and ethereum has a larger market cap than bitcoin in your opinion does that make eth money or or how does the relationship of the market cap and whether a thing is money or not how do those things relate can bitcoin still be money yet still be under the market cap of ethereum uh well i can do you think that the value of text docs will eclipse that of m zero right going back to the co-authored example from from Arthur which which i think is the right framing i think the answer is yes so um will it happen you know how does value accrue to ether versus solana dot you know all these other networks and by the way the other layer once or sorry the other layer two because like each of these other you know layer two they're going to have their own financial incentive you know uh frameworks across the board because if someone's going to need to like actually process transactions on any blockchain and whether it's a shark or there's another network whether it's the main chain and they're going to need that need to be incentivized to do so so um you know we'll see um but like I said i'm bullish on both and um right now the growth in the bitcoin story is still all about like government debt deficits monetary debatement and that trend is not decelerating for ethereum it continues to be all about decentralized finance permissionless you know kind of innovative uh you know marketplace infrastructure and um that is only accelerating and we see the kpi's for ethereum and all the applications that are running on it and the kpi just keep getting crazier and crazier and more applications keep getting built you know on that infrastructure so i think um i think both are you know still very healthy um it's a little bit of a an unfair comparison from a uh a a fundamental evaluation standpoint though because if you think about bitcoin as money and then the medic around money and you think about ethereum as ultimately being priced as a financial internet and like the underlying stock or or asset that secures the the financial internet then one is going to have only mimetics behind it because you know all all currencies are memes and then the other one is going to have some like actual kpi's uh behind it um so again i think uh to to synopsize uh overweight ethereum but not more eth than btc i definitely think that a flipping is possible um maybe not likely but you know certainly and maybe like uh my probabilities up from 0.
1 percent to um to be 20 percent so you got a 200 extra turn on that which is not too bad um i'll take it 200 x anytime uh yeah exactly um and then uh you know ultimately speaking uh it's going to be entertaining for me to watch on the sidelines as people argue about semantics for the next 15 years oh the arguments will be unceasing hopefully we can come together on the regulatory issues but we know that there were still arguments um the last last question on this is what when comment you made was about institutional demand in our last conversation and at the time bitcoin was getting a lot of institutional demand i think sailor had just made some of his you know earlier purchases um institutions were talking about adding into the balance sheet but that time you said institutional demand for eth is a mirage and i think you're kind of right like there wasn't a lot at the time i mean we made the argument that um well you know ether is kind of a cycle behind but it will play that cycle a little bit quicker than bitcoin because big brother helped ether out and like created the channel now ether just has to follow that trail uh as an asset are you starting to see more institutional demand interest for eth as an asset as well i mean i'm not really at the at the front lines of this i'd say anecdotally yes um for for for me the thing that matters um i want to see more institutional adoption of of eth for sure because our business at ponsari is market intelligence for cryptos and asset class you don't need a market intelligence platform if it's just one or two assets that you care about so for us like it's it's critical to have institutions actually interested in supporting eth because that's going to help lead them down the rabbit hole for defy and ultimately like the the universe of potentially interesting applications and assets um so i um i think uh the the half life is um is what we look at i i think the half life to get someone from like interested in bitcoin or not interested uh versus that what it takes to get someone who's already bought bitcoin to buy eth to get to go from uh i have bitcoin and eth now like what's defy and then you know all the way down you know into actually being like an active participant in these ecosystems or you know um NFTs are probably their own complete you know wildcard because it's a more you know kind of consumer friendly and and like retail driven phenomenon but for but for everything else i think um if you like bitcoin you're probably going to look at it at some point if you like it you're going to look at defy and that's going to be kind of the natural progression of things over time okay can i ask uh Ryan so at at msari i've definitely seen a um kind of a an increase in focus on like defy tokens and like the metaverse and some really fantastic research and analysis on these topics um i think a lot of this like didn't exist a year ago in general as kind of you know asset classes but what are the the sectors i guess within crypto that you are most excited about and that msari is most excited about providing uh analytics and and research for is is defy a key sector is kind of NFTs in the metaverse a key sector what are the what are the hot things we should be looking for out of uh msari so i mean we've been uh covering these assets on a sector by sector based i think we're we're one of the earlier ones to kind of come up with these uh designations uh for for you know per asset basis and and have that you know on our homepage we've had that on our homepage for for a year being able to toggle between defy and web three assets and privacy coins and stable coins so that you're not just kind of comparing everything you know apples oranges and bananas uh across the um across the ecosystem i think there's probably more hard data on defy and and those um financial applications like how much capital is locked uh what the what the interest rates are what the exchange rates are um and uh and there's just i think more um infrastructure like open infrastructure like sub graphs have been developed for for all these different markets um NFTs are definitely interesting but i i there's no real like price discovery on like individual NFTs right so like how that factors into like a market intelligence platform for institutions i don't really know i'm sure we'll probably have like rare rocks like digital j like rock jpegs um on the slide at some point it's like the market continues to be insane but um right now i think we're we're just taking a wait and see approach on like how NFTs get incorporated the meantime we definitely have a bunch of research on the NFTs space um and i've been keeping a close eye on that and and down infrastructure and and you know other bits of that infrastructure stack myself um because um we know that they're going to be you know additional plugins over time so um you know mold we'll see um and uh stay tuned we got mainnet coming up just a few weeks you guys are going to be there right i'll be there yeah good abset cups mainnet to number 20 through 22nd we'll be talking about all these things and um the general theme of the event is uh you know basically are are interoperable future and and the multi-chain future so uh will be kind of going through the basics uh obviously for for big planetarium um but a lot focus on defi decentralized web applications and FT infrastructure down infrastructure um and then um interoperability between other layer ones and there are two to try the kind of core themes of the event i'm about to submit my speaker application to mainnet right after this round so maybe you can help me get that one processed it better be good david yeah man it it better be good because i'm not even involved so fair enough don't pull any strings for you davis all right you're on your own man Ryan take care we'll fine we'll find a way every every single year Ryan you put out a you a famously gargantuan report title something along the lines of crypto feces for the following year right so big predictions about cuz it's also a summary about you know crypto over the last year but also predictions over the next year as well uh and in the crypto feces for 2021 you kind of finished off with this uh section that you titled exiting to the the networks state uh and i think this conversation actually uh becomes irrelevant once again as if it never it always was but really becomes relevant with uh the earlier conversation we were having with the regulators and how they are pushing us into compliance pushing us into regulation pushing us into capture so i want to pick your brain a little bit on what is it what does it mean to exit to the network state and how is this conversation becoming relevant once again um i think the the network state um you know a lot of the writing and a lot of the thinking there it has been uh centered around what biology has been talking about for for quite some time and and you know basically you know covid is accelerated a bunch of tech trends and and crypto is kind of the intersection of a lot of them so i think um uh i i can't speak is intelligibly and and is uh with quite the crystal ball that that he has um but i do think that because of how incompatible some of our legacy institutions uh and and kind of legacy laws are with kind of the current reality of of you know where we are at the tech um there's going to be some real you know friction points and and issues to resolve that are going to require some political resolutions and the very best thing that we can do right now is hope that there's just plenty of um uh kind of channeled fury channeled uh uh assertive response to uh to to make sure that people don't unintentionally regulate us out of existence or or to oblivion because you know ironically that would be the very worst thing when you're talking uh talking about protecting investors with a very worse thing in terms of um you know promoting economic growth in the country very worse thing for civil liberties and and and privacy um because the folks that are building in in crypto are the ones that are taking those values seriously so i i think um um the network state um is uh i like the real world uh i don't want to just live in the cloud so i think the network state is is more about the future of the economy and um and and and the future of kind of like individual responsibility and and kind of sovereignty and how we kind of plug in and cooperate since um since more work is crossing borders and um more you know economic activity and social activity is happening online um stay tuned for my 2022 thesis which there's no way i'll be able to write this year because i can't afford to take time off to write a 500 page but i i think you will find a way to do something right you've never let us down before it's going to be a tweet storm there you go we'll take it one one of one of 1179 yeah yeah Brian it's been uh fantastic to to have you on bankless we've really appreciated your your voice in the space uh all along uh especially recently really appreciated everything that missouri has put out and continues to put out as well uh thanks for joining us today thank you how was it for you guys guys action items for you a couple of them of Ryan alluded to it but missouri's main net conference is happening September 20 to 22nd um make sure you check that out david's going to be there i think some other folks from bankless unfortunately i can't make it myself it's going to be a fantastic conference uh you could find more info in the show notes or at mainnet.
events um also check out missouri.io if you already haven't this is uh something i check on a regular basis just fantastic crypto analytics in fact you see it every single week on the weekly roll up when we check your prices and when i'm feeling uh particularly unhealthy about crypto prices i'm checking this like frequently throughout the day uh so anyway great analytics there make sure you check that out as an action item of course guys risks and disclaimers bitcoin is risky eth is risky will the flipping happen we don't know defy is risky all of this stuff you should know you could lose what you put in but we are headed west this is the frontier it's not for everyone but we're glad you're with us on the bankless journey thanks a lot hey we hope you enjoyed the video if you did head over to bankless hq right now to develop your crypto investing skills and learn how to free yourself from banks and gain your financial independence we recommend joining our daily newsletter podcast and community as a bankless premium subscriber to get the most out of your bankless experience you'll get access to our market analysis our alpha leaks and exclusive content and even the bankless token for airdrops raffles and unlocks if you're interested in crypto the bankless community is where you want to be click the link in the description to become a bankless premium subscriber today also don't forget to subscribe to the channel for in-depth interviews with industry leaders ask me anything and weekly rollups where we summarize the week in crypto and other fantastic content thanks everyone for watching and being on the journey as we build out the bankless nation