Ethereum founder Vitalik Buterin returns to the podcast to discuss his recent article Endgame, as well as the massive year we observed in 2021. From the future of Ethereum to the rise of alternative Layer 1 platforms, it only makes sense to kick off 2022 by exploring how far we’ve come and figuring out where we’re headed.
How far are we along on Ethereum’s roadmap? What challenges lie ahead?
In a recent tweet, Vitalik posted a graphic of the updated progress of the Ethereum roadmap, and there are five throughlines that are progressing in parallel:
• The Merge • The Surge • The Verge • The Purge • The Splurge
We dive into what each of these means, as well as discuss what Ethereum will look like as these milestones are met. Holding this up against conversations of maximalism and alternative L1s, now is the time to start asking the big questions.
✨ WATCH THE DEBRIEF ✨ https://youtu.be/v__0GOC-XYE
------ 📣 ONJUNO | Crypto from your Checking Account! https://bankless.cc/OnJuno
------ 🚀 SUBSCRIBE TO NEWSLETTER: https://newsletter.banklesshq.com/ 🎙️ SUBSCRIBE TO PODCAST: http://podcast.banklesshq.com/
------ BANKLESS SPONSOR TOOLS:
⚖️ ARBITRUM | SCALING ETHEREUM https://bankless.cc/Arbitrum
🍵 MATCHA | SMART ORDER ROUTING https://bankless.cc/Matcha
🚀 SLINGSHOT | LAYER 2 SOCIAL TRADING https://bankless.cc/Slingshot
🏦 GEMINI | TURN FIAT INTO CRYPTO https://bankless.cc/Gemini
🦁 BRAVE | THE BROWSER NATIVE WALLET https://bankless.cc/Brave
🦄 UNISWAP | DECENTRALIZED FUNDING https://bankless.cc/UniGrants
------ Topics Covered:
0:00 Intro
4:09 Debrief
7:27 Vitalik Returns after 2021 11:40 2021 Ethereum Milestones 16:33 Roadmap Progress
19:35 The Merge (Proof of Stake)
24:20 The Surge (Rollups & Sharding) 32:59 Life after Sharding
42:40 The Verge (Verkle Trees)
49:35 The Purge (History Expiry) 57:03 State Expiry & Snake 1:03:40 Snakes & States
1:08:20 The Splurge (Everything Else)
1:15:20 What Makes Vitalik Happy
1:20:17 Rise of Alt Layer 1s 1:26:03 Gas Costs & Decentralization
1:29:11 Maximalism
1:34:03 Endgame 1:40:16 Alt L1s and Rollups 1:44:02 Multi-Rollup World 1:49:21 The Ground Floor
1:53:56 Solving the World’s Problems
1:58:33 Closing & Disclaimers
------ Resources:
VITALIK'S ARTICLES Endgame https://vitalik.ca/general/2021/12/06/endgame.html The Limits to Blockchain Scalability https://vitalik.ca/general/2021/05/23/scaling.html Verkle Trees https://vitalik.ca/general/2021/06/18/verkle.html Pragmatic Destruction of Self-Destruct https://hackmd.io/@vbuterin/selfdestruct Crypto Cities https://vitalik.ca/general/2021/10/31/cities.html Legitimacy https://vitalik.ca/general/2021/03/23/legitimacy.html Moving beyond coin voting governance https://vitalik.ca/general/2021/08/16/voting3.html
VITALIK ON BANKLESS Legitimacy https://shows.banklesshq.com/p/-legitimacy-vitalik-buterin Beyond Coin Voting https://shows.banklesshq.com/p/beyond-coin-voting-vitalik-buterin Vitalik Speaks (Playlist) https://youtube.com/playlist?list=PLmkdAgtxf3agqnA5IieA7OkKBjlhx9mn-
MISC. Roadmap Tweet https://twitter.com/VitalikButerin/status/1466411377107558402?s=20 Merge Testnet https://kintsugi.themerge.dev/ ETH TPS https://ethtps.info/
----- Not financial or tax advice. This channel is strictly educational and is not investment advice or a solicitation to buy or sell any assets or to make any financial decisions. This video is not tax advice. Talk to your accountant. Do your own research.
Disclosure. From time-to-time I may add links in this newsletter to products I use. I may receive commission if you make a purchase through one of these links. Additionally, the Bankless writers hold crypto assets. See our investment disclosures here: https://newsletter.banklesshq.com/p/bankless-disclosures
No summary for this episode yet.
Once all of these things are done, like, I will say this. If this is all done and then nothing else ever changes after that, then I'll be extremely happy. Welcome to Bankless, where we explore the frontier of internet money and internet finance. This is how to get started, how to get better, how to frontrun the opportunity. This is Ryan Sean Adams. I'm here with David Hoffman and we're here to help you become more Bankless. Guys, we have a fantastic episode today with a Vitalik Buterin. We talk about the future of Ethereum, the rise of alternative layer ones as well, a few things to watch out for as you listen to this episode.
The first is, we talk about the Ethereum roadmap from the guy who actually helped create Ethereum. How far we are in the Ethereum roadmap as well. It's number two. Number three, what will Ethereum look like when it's all said and done? How long will that take? Number four, can centralized alternative layer ones become decentralized in the long term, or will they remain centralized? Number five, what does Vitalik make of the term Ethereum maximalists? Number six, will crypto actually be able to solve the big scale global problems in the 2020s in this decade that we're in? David, this was a fantastic episode.
They're all fantastic with Vitalik. I hope folks listen to each and every single episode with him. What did you think about this episode? I think this is the perfect episode to kick off 2022. This is a hybrid podcast. One side of it is very granular in detail. That's the first half where we talked about the Ethereum roadmap. Just contextualizing and grounding people in what's left with Ethereum. Some of the obvious stuff comes up first like the merge and charting, but then there's a bunch of other things as well. We talk about those things and why we need them and what they do and what they do for Ethereum both now and into the long term.
Then we actually fold that conversation into the conversation of the growth of the alternative layer ones. We talked about how the first half of 2021 was more or less Ethereum's show. Ethereum is massive success in the first half of 2021. Then the alternative layer ones came on the scene. Now there's this growing ecosystem of many different chains all doing more or less similar things with different design structures. A lot of them have chosen centralization as their competitive advantage, if you will. Getting Vitalik's take on that in relation to the Ethereum roadmap because some of the things we talk about in the roadmap actually lends itself directly towards how some of these centralized layer ones can actually migrate into a long term sustainable robust ecosystem.
Vitalik's not only is unpacking the Ethereum roadmap, but also proposing a roadmap for alternative layer ones to actually be successful into the long term. I really enjoyed that conversation. Then of course just zooming out and grounding ourselves not just inside of the crypto industry but inside of the world at large. Where are we in the 2020s as humans, as crypto people? What's up with the 2020s and what can we do about it? I think that's been top of mind for me. David, because going to this decade, we're just one year into this decade, but we have nine more to go. I'm a little worried. I'm a little concerned about where this decade might leave us, but crypto is the thing that keeps me hopeful.
Seeing Ethereum's roadmap lead out like this also makes me hopeful and bullish on Ethereum. I've never seen Ethereum's roadmap as clearly articulated and stated. Having a precise and concrete roadmap is actually a luxury in the Ethereum world. This does not something that we could have talked about in this depth and with this much future in mind up until now. I'm really excited to unpack all of the Ethereum roadmap with you, the listener, and also what I'm also excited for you, the listener, is to do is to like the video, rate and review us on iTunes or wherever you get your podcasts. If you're watching on YouTube, make sure to subscribe.
Let's go ahead and get right into the future of the Ethereum roadmap and the rise of the alternative layer ones right after we get to some of these fantastic sponsors that make the show possible. Let's go ahead and get into the future of the Ethereum roadmap and let's go ahead and subscribe to Bankless and you will get that every week automatically downloaded to wherever you get your podcasts. Cheers and I hope you enjoyed the debrief. Arbitrum is an Ethereum scaling solution that's going to completely change how we use DeFi and NFTs. Over 250 projects have already deployed on Arbitrum and Arbitrum's DeFi and NFT ecosystems are growing rapidly.
Arbitrum increases Ethereum's speed by orders of magnitude for a fraction of the cost of the average gas fee. When interacting with Arbitrum, you can get the performance of a centralized exchange while tapping into Ethereum's level of decentralization and security. If you're a developer who wants low gas fees and instant transactions for your users, visit developer.offchainlabs.com to get started building your application on Arbitrum. If you're a user, keep an eye out for your favorite DeFi apps or NFT projects building on Arbitrum. Many of your favorite apps are already live with many more coming over soon.
You can find these apps at portal.arbitrum.1 and you can bridge your assets over to Arbitrum using bridge.arbitrum.io in order to experience DeFi and NFTs the way it was always meant to be. Fast, cheap and friction free. When you shop for plane tickets, you probably use kayak, expedia, or Google to compare ticket prices. So why would you limit yourself to just one exchange when you trade crypto? When you make your trades, you want to make sure you're getting the best possible price on your trade and that's why you should be using Machia. Machia has smart order routing that splits your trade across all the various liquidity sources in Ethereum and is also operational on polygon, avalanche, finance, smart chain, and other chains.
Trading on Machia is super easy because it pulls the liquidity from me in a single easy to use platform and allows me to make limit on chain orders so you can set and forget your DeFi trades and they will go through automatically while you're away. So when you're making a trade, head over to machia.xyz slash bankless and connect your wallet to start getting the best prices and most liquidity when you trade your crypto assets. Bankless is proud to be sponsored by Uniswap. Uniswap is a new paradigm in asset exchange infrastructure. Instead of a cumbersome orderbook system where trades are matched with other humans, Uniswap is an autonomous piece of software on Ethereum that lets you trade any token at the current market price.
No human counterparties or centralized intermediaries, just autonomous code on Ethereum. Input the token you want to sell and receive the token you want to buy. The Uniswap grants program is accepting applications for grants. Do you have something of value that you think you want to contribute to the Uniswap ecosystem? No matter how big or small your idea is you can apply for a unique grant at Uniswapgrants.org and helps your Uniswap in the direction that you think it should go. Thank you Uniswap for sponsoring bankless. Bankless Nation, we are super excited to introduce our next guest who requires no introduction really, but on the podcast multiple times.
Vitalik Buterin is on bankless today. He's the creator of Ethereum writer at Vitalik.ca, a popular bankless guest. We have a number of episodes with Vitalik. Welcome back Vitalik. How are you doing? Thank you. It's good to be here. Well, we want to talk about a few things today with you. The Ethereum roadmap of course, the rise of alt ones. That was something that happened last year. The endgame, this is an article you wrote called the endgame, which chronicles I think or describes maybe an endgame situation for all blockchains, all layer ones, but we also have the privilege of recording this toward the end of the year.
We can't pass up an opportunity to talk about some reflections for 2021 just to get us kicked started. What did you think of 2021 for crypto? High level. A lot of people say it was a very good year for crypto. I think they're mainly talking about prices. Maybe they're also talking about adoption and mainstream attention. What are your thoughts on 2021? Was it a good year for crypto? What do you think about it? I definitely think it was a great year for adoption and for mainstream attention. The rise of NFTs was definitely something really fascinating to see. I think it's brought a lot of people into the crypto space that would not have gone into it before.
I think things like, at least to me, blockchains are about creating these innovative new ways to organize society. In some ways to me, what's happening with artists being able to sell NFTs really is a realization of that spirit. We actually are giving people who are creating art new business models for giving the creators of this thing that's very valuable, but that often has a hard time getting business models a new way to actually get funding. That's something that's been very interesting and exciting for me. The rise of DAOs is definitely also interesting and exciting. We've been seeing more and more DAOs that are actually doing lots of interesting things, experimenting with different governance algorithms, projects like Citadel that are actually trying to do things in the physical world.
That has all been fun. The progress that we have seen in Layer 2 scaling, I think, has been really amazing. We've actually, I think, over the course of this year, really seeing Layer 2s go from theory to practice. At the beginning of this year, there were only one or two Layer 2s on Maynet, and they either only supported, pretty much all, only supported a couple of applications. Now, we have this thriving ecosystem and people are really experiencing what a Layer 2 Ethereum looks like firsthand. Lots of progress on adoption, lots of progress on tech, definitely lots of happy things to report this year.
Vitalik, one thing I've gathered while being in this space for a number of years, I got in in 2017, Ryan got in a little bit before me, but I hear all these crazy cerebral conversations that happened in the Bitcoin space in the very early Ethereum space from 2011 to 2015, and just like about the possibilities of crypto could be. From my perspective, my limited perspective, because I've only been here for so long, is that 2021 was a year where so many of these high in the sky, like, you know, very, very cerebral possibilities of crypto actually started to happen. Like NFTs and unique tokens were a conversation very, very early, as well as DAOS, even though we didn't call them DAOS way back when.
Would you say that 2021 was the year that crypto actually started to unlock some of these early theorized use cases that were only conversations back five years ago? I would definitely say so. Fantastic. So Vitalik, let's talk about Ethereum for a minute, and you know, one of these days we're going to have you on bank lists and actually not talk about Ethereum, maybe not talk about crypto, because I know you have tons of varied interests and a lot of insights on many topics. But today is not that podcast, okay? We want to talk about Ethereum. Going into 2022 in particular, so when listeners hear this, it'll be the first week of January 2022.
We want to talk a little bit about the roadmap for Ethereum moving forward. But before we do, let's talk about the progress Ethereum made last year in 2021. So what were some of the main accomplishments milestones? I know you mentioned layer two. That's probably chief among them. Are there any others at the protocol level? Yeah. So I think if we focus on layer one, as some of the big things are, one is that the beacon change has proved itself. It's turned from being this very early thing into an increasingly mature ecosystem. It also had its first hard fork, the Altair hard fork, which of course added the kind of basic scaffolding that we needed to have like client support, and it was also just the first ever beacon chain hard fork, which is an important trial run for the merge.
So the next beacon chain hard fork, and most likely the next execution chain hard fork will actually be the merge. So that's exciting. Speaking of the merge, we also have test nets for the merge now. The Kinsurgi testnet launched them a couple of weeks ago. And of course, the Kinsurgi testnet was not even the first testnet of the merge. There were a couple of other smaller ones that have been running for a couple of months, but Kinsurgi has one that is much bigger than before, many more participants than before, more extensive than before. Anyone could go and participate, and I even got some Kinsurgi eth from the Kinsurgi faucet a couple of weeks ago.
So that has also been I think a lot of great progress. A lot of just interesting infrastructure projects that have been coming of age. So proof of humanity has matured a lot, and it's been seeing a lot of usage. Sign in with Ethereum has been seeing a lot of adoption, and that just like went from, I think, an idea that a few people were thinking about to something that lots of people are excited about starting to adopt in use over the last few months. What crosshair to bridging still in its infancy, but much better than what it was a year ago, which is basically not existing at all, but account upstraction.
There are testnet versions of ERC-4337. This is something that hasn't really gotten into the public discourse yet, but it's moving forward quietly, a lot of progress there. So lots of small things, lots of progress on the various spec items that haven't been released yet, but that we're going to talk about through the rest of this episode probably. Just a whole bunch of really meaningful progress on on, I think, pretty much all of the big things that we care about. And by the way, for people listening on YouTube, this is the test net you were referring to, Vitalik, I believe. So what are we looking at?
So this is Kinsugi, which is the newest, is this the beacon chain plus, like if you're in one sort of test net, this is the basically the merge. This is a test net of the merge. Okay, a test net of the merge. So what can people do here? Is this mainly for developers, or is there anything? Is there, they can connect, they can connect notes, they can become stakers, they can launch contracts and trade coins around. This is the merge, right? This is the thing that is going to be put in production. So what has to happen between now and like the time the merge goes through is it just a lot of testing, a lot of validation.
Yeah, definitely a lot of testing and auditing and all of that. The one piece that I'm aware of that's like still the furthest from being certain is how clients would sync after the merge. Basically, the problem is that the way that proof of work syncs and the way that the way that proof of stake syncs are a bit different from each other. And so there's a bit of engineering that needs to be done to put the two together. But this is something that people have already been aware of for a while. And so there's a lot of things in progress and being implemented. So I think there are so far things that must be going smoothly.
Taking another opportunity to zoom out, the Ethereum protocol has developed throughout 2021. But there's also what I like to call meta development, which is just defining and understanding the long-term roadmap of Ethereum to an actual concrete specific detail. And sometimes in Ethereum's history, there wasn't all that much that with regards to details in the future. I remember in 2017, I didn't really know what was going to be happening next in Ethereum six months out. But it seems to be that the meta development of Ethereum has gotten a lot more robust. And partly, that's illustrated by that infographic that we're going to pull up here in a second.
But Vitalik Ethereum changes every single year 2015 Ethereum is different than 2016 Ethereum and so on and so forth. How would you contextualize overall with the grand Ethereum vision for what it wants to be and then also where it is in 2021? How far along are we? Are we like 60% of the way there? Are we 40% of the way there? And then if we could just give a grade towards just the progress made so far, how would you evaluate it? I would say around 50. I'd be willing to go past 60 once the merge is fully complete and I'd be willing to go past 80 once we have a full sharding implementation. But I think those two biggest items are definitely getting closer and closer, but they're not yet in the real rearview mirror.
That's really cool. Over 50%. We're getting close then. Very neat. So let's talk about what's coming. David uses term, I guess meta development, the roadmap to me, at least this year for Ethereum has never been clear, which is super cool. And you put out this infographic on Ethereum's birthday, sorry, not its birthday, the beacon chain launch birthday in December 1st, that kind of highlighted progress across a number of different work streams. So I'm going to go through those really quick at the high level and then let's take some time to talk about each of them. So and by the way, I love these nicknames that you know you used, you christened, they're nice flow to them.
The first is the merge. The second is the purge. Then we get the verge, sorry, I messed this up. The first is the merge. The second is the surge. The third is the verge, the purge, then the splurge. So these are five different work streams. The merge is really when proof of stake comes about and proof of work finally dies. The surge is about scalability, particularly for rollups. We'll talk about that. The verge is all around stateless clients, making Ethereum nodes easier to run. The purge has been a technical debt elimination, but also eliminating historical data, which you want to find out more in the splurge, of course, any any good splurge is all about the extras, all about the goodies.
And so we got some goodies on the roadmap as well. I'm going to show that infographic as we talk about each of these areas. But like to me, the Ethereum roadmap has really never been been clear and maybe we could address these things one by one, Vitalik. So let's talk about it. I think they're kind of in order maybe of how soon they're going to happen is at the case. So the merge is going to happen first. So time is left to right. Okay, time is left to right. There's no top up to down top time dimension. Okay, it's why the time arrow at the top goes left to right. Okay, very good. But we should say the merge is probably going to be the thing that's that's happening first.
And maybe we should start with that. So tell us about the merge. Sure. So the merge is the same thing that the merge has always been. It's the full transition away from proof of work to proof of stake. So there has actually been a lot there's a lot of stuff that has already been done for proof of stake that's in the kind of what's already behind us call them to the left. And so the beacon channel already exists. There's already been a warm up for proof of stake already has a light client friendliness. But what's left to actually get to the merge, right? And so the most recent thing that was finished is the full specification of the merge process.
So the specification not just of what post burgeon theorem looks like, but even of how the transition process works. So how the process works of like actually changing from one to the other, what is the final proof of work block going to be? How is the first proof of stake execution block going to point to that proof of work block? What happens during edge cases? Like what if the chain reorgs right in the middle of that? So all of that, that's the this back. So this exists. So that's what these test tests have been running. That's what we can see it has been running. So full merge specification, test networks and progress, fork choice improvements.
So basically there just have been a few bugs that have been discovered in the fork choice role. This is the function that nodes used to determine like which block is the head block if there are multiple competing blocks based on all of the votes that all the different validators have made. And this is just like adding some armoured to make it more robust against certain kinds of attacks. So once that's done, then the merge can happen, right? And once the merge happens, then we know no more proof of work, right? And so then that's the merge. After the merge, we have the post merge hard fork. The most important feature of the post merge hard fork is just enabling withdrawals, right?
So the merge itself just to keep it simple does not enable withdrawals. But the post merge hard fork, which there is a spec for enabling withdrawals. But this is something that will actually needs to be done a little bit later. Just to be clear, Vitalik, this is about withdrawals for beacon, chain, ether, depositors and validators. So this is either about tokens or anything else, right? Exactly. So if you threw your 32 ether in your validator, then once the post merge hard fork happens, you will be able to withdraw the ether and the rewards and bring it back into the execution layer. And to be able to be able to withdraw all at once, or how is that?
There is a queue. So if lots of people start withdrawing, lots of withdrawals will have to wait. And so to be clear, Vitalik, those are happening in two different hard forks, right? Two different stages here. And any idea on how far they will be apart will these be like months apart? Realistically, maybe six months. Okay, six months apart. Okay. So that's the merge. And that means proof of work is gone effectively. We just have proof of stake. What does this mean for the typical user or the typical DeFi application? Well, they have to do anything. They have to click a button in Metamask that says like upgrade to, you know, merged eth.
I mean, they'll have to upgrade to merged Metamask, but they will not have to upgrade their ether or their applications. So from the point of view of applications, like it just, it's just to like any of the hard forks that we've already been through. So effectively, effectively nothing, effectively users don't have to do anything at all. Okay, so that's the merge. Let's talk about next. And by the way, with the merge, we haven't mentioned, of course, all the proof of work issuance goes away as well, right? So that's something over 4% or so. And that is now gone. No more proof of work issuance.
No more minors on Ethereum for the first time. That's going to be an interesting state to be in. That all happens at the time of the first merge. Is that correct? Yes. Okay, interesting. Let's talk about the second, which is the surge. What's the surge all about? The surge is scalability increases for rollups through sharding. And so basically, rollups by themselves are a way or two scaling solution. And what role the way rollups work is that computation and storage go off chain, but data stays on chain, right? And this allows transactions to happen much more cheaply than they would if everything is done on layer one.
But it's they still inherit the security of layer one, right? So rollups are this compromise that basically gives us a lot more efficiency than layer one with all of the security that users are used to. And it's kind of the best combination of properties among all of the different cellular solutions that have been explored. And it's also, I think, the only one that really properly supports like full EVM scripting, right? Like state channels, for example, they support payments. They can support a few applications, but like you can't easily stay in a swap in a channel, for example, but you know, you can stay in a swap in a rollup.
So about a year and a half ago, I think there was this document that I published called the rollup centric roadmap, where basically say like, look, rollups are realistically the scaling that's going to come the fastest. And so and we know that rollups work that the theory behind the missing stream will all established. So let's simplify the scaling roadmap by kind of re-architecting the scaling roadmap around being based around rollups as much as possible, right? So the main thing that we get out of that is that instead of the shorting that Ethereum has been planning on having all along, being shorting of everything.
So shorting of execution, shorting accounts, shorting of smart contracts, shorting is just shorting of data, right? So it's this very limited form of shorting that basically says, all we're going to do is we're going to have this kind of data layer, this sort of public billboard that people can stick up to around two megabytes a second worth of data on. And when they do this, then the blockchain guarantees that that data is publicly available. I mean, guarantee is that the data actually was published and that nobody is withholding it, but it does not try to interpret the data, right? Now who tries to interpret the data?
That's the job of the rollups, right? So the layer one just handles data and it's the rollups job to kind of convert this highly scalable data plus the little bit of computation that the Ethereum blockchain gives you into a lot of computation. And we've talked about optimistic robots and we've talked about Zika Robes before, right? So I think people are going to know roughly how this happens. But the core insight here, right? And basically is that if you sort of lean on rollups as this machine for converting data into execution, then shorting just needs to support data and shorting can become much simpler.
Like one example way in which shorting becomes simpler is that the shorting design does not need to have any fraud proofs, right? So the shorting designs that we were thinking about earlier were we actually have execution inside of the shards. Like we had to deal with this question of like, well, what happens if one of the shard blocks is invalid, right? Like does someone have to submit a fraud proof to show that it's invalid? And what if there is one of these fraud proofs, then does that mean that the entire chain has to get reverted? And there's like all of this complexity that we have to deal with, right?
But with data sharding, but there's no such thing as an invalid block. All the races there is an unavailable block. And so we don't need fraud proofs, there's just a lot of machinery in terms of managing state, do a cross short transactions, just all of this complexity that can just completely go away. And so the protocol can be really elegant and simple. And it's rollups job into actually convert this into this kind of high performance, I mean, very paralyzed with very secure EVM ecosystem. So what this actual roadmap is, right? So we have that basically for stages here is basically just adding more and more of this data, right?
So step one, short term call data expansion. This is if something like EIP could be something like EIP 4488 could be something like EIP 4498, like just adding more data space in the short term to make rollups cheaper. Then we have basic shorting and steps two and three, like actually you like add on the kind of full on the like the full on shorting specification, right? So they add on this idea that you have these transactions and these transactions that can contain a huge amount of data, except at the beginning, like we might do a we might compromise a bit and we might say, well, you know, everyone still has to download all of this data, but it's just some dedicated space to store the data.
And so we're kind of easing into the shorting model and rollups can kind of re-architect themselves, actually take advantage of this data. And then when we go from a few shards to many shards, like that's when we actually kind of take off the training wheels and we say, like now finally, we don't need to have any node downloading everything, right? Like we just rely on committees, we rely on data availability sampling, we rely on all of these other technologies to verify that the data exists without requiring any single node download everything individually. And then the fourth one, data availability sampling, this is this really sophisticated technology that clients can use to basically check that all of the data has been published by randomly checking like just random pieces without having to download all of it, right?
So it's like first add data, then add more data, then add even more data, and then near the end, we start adding more and more armor to make sure that we have like both the scalability and the security. So more and more data and rollups get cheaper and cheaper. And from a user's point of view, like users once again, they don't really have to notice anything. The only thing users have to do is they just have to move their activity from layer one to layer two at the point when they're comfortable with it, right? And then once they've moved everything to layer two, then all that they see is that layer two just keeps on getting cheaper and then it gets cheaper again and then it gets cheaper again.
So that's the search. And so when you say the layer two just get cheaper and cheaper, are they also getting faster at the same time? Are those hand in hand? Define faster. Faster execution times. So the word faster, like I think there's two kinds of faster, right? There's like wait and see and there's bandwidth. So wait and see is like how many seconds do you have to wait for even one transaction to confirm and then bandwidth is like how many transactions per second? So none of what's happening in the search improves the latency. So so far all of this, like you know, you still have your 12 seconds a lot times.
The slot times might even have to increase a bit to to handle sharding. So it might have to go up from like 12 to 16. But what's going to go up a lot is bandwidth, right? So like the Ethereum blockchain today can handle 15 to 40 transactions a second, roll ups today if they add proper compression can go up to 1500 to 4000 transactions a second and then roll ups with sharding can go up to 100,000 transactions a second. The reason why they get cheaper is basically supply and demand, right? If the chain can handle more transactions, then that means that there's more space and you don't have like all of these users competing for the same very small number of slots.
And so the transaction fees that every single user has to pay just go down by a huge amount. Like that's basically where the cheaper comes from. So it's cheaper because it's a higher bandwidth. By the way, this bandwidth thing, I think a brilliant site to see this is EFTPS. I don't know if you've seen this before, but I have. It kind of showcases the bandwidth of Ethereum when you take into account this polygon, but also all of the other, you know, optimistic roll ups and roll up chains as well. And so Ethereum currently does 65 transactions per second. If you add all of that together and, you know, in this block, it's 87 transactions per second.
And what you're saying is basically that number will go up and up and up and up for higher and higher and higher with the surge. Exactly. And what would this mean for anyone who is still living a life on the layer one with the expansion of the number of shards and also the size of shards? Does that mean L1 gas fees are going to come down or what's the deal with that? I mean, in the short term maybe, but I think realistically in the long term, using L1 is just going to keep getting more and more expensive. So you, like, as a user, I think, like you do needs to be prepared for the facts that Ethereum already is transitioning away from being a layer one centric ecosystem toward being a layer two centric ecosystem.
I like today the gains that you can make from switching to layer two are like maybe only 5x, but, you know, in the future there'll be 10x and then there'll be 50x and then there'll be 1000x. So eventually all activity is going to have to transition to being layer two. Eventually, even bridging from one layer two to another layer two is something that will mostly have to happen without layer ones. And this is a change that users will have to get used to. But I think it's a change that some users are starting to get used to already. But, you know, if they can do it, then everything other than that is going to be fairly under the hood for them.
With regards to the shard size and shard count, I want to unpack this one a little bit because we have a couple phases inside of the surge where first we add in charting in the first place and just a few shards and then we add more shards. But from what I've gathered from other people's writings, Pauli Nias and some other ETH client devs is that long term, there actually could be no cap on both the size and the number of shards so long as the resources that Ethereum has to its availability is sufficient. Is that true? And so then a couple of questions to follow up on that. How will we know when we're ready to add more shards?
And is there an ultimate final number of like we are going for this many shards with this size? Or is this a number that's always going to be dynamic in Ethereum's future? So I actually wrote an article about this like six months ago. And if you go to the post called the limits to blockchain scalability, I think. So sharding gets around a lot of the limits, the scalability of non-sharded blockchains that I talk about above. So the first limit I mentioned is quadratic sharding, right? Which basically is this idea that like it's the beacon chain is going to contain headers of shard blocks and then you're so you have the beacon chain block and then you have shard blocks.
You only have two levels. It's theoretically possible to make blockchain designs that have to be levels or five levels or a dynamic number of levels. And like I think I remember the ton network, for example, like they were trying to do exponential sharding and like they had this huge beam of going up to two to the power of 92 shards eventually. My opinion is that that stuff is possible in theory, but in practice going beyond two levels is just like too hard and adds too much complexity. And so it's not worth it. So theory is staying with quadratic. But there's other reasons why scalability going too high becomes too risky.
And like there we go. So what are these risks? Excellent. So keep going down. So basically what I talk about here is that as the data capacity of the chain increases, you get this property that because no single user is going to be downloading or processing the entire chain, you get a minimum number of users that you're counting on to ensure that the chain continues to be secure. Right. So like I guess one analogy of this is that if you imagine like a blockchain is one city and you imagine you start off with a blockchain that's just a small town. How small is the town? The town is so small that if you make one guard tower and you make the guard tower tall enough, then you can have one security guard.
And the one security guard can watch the entire border of the town and make sure that no attackers get in. Right. So that's like an unscalable blockchain. Now imagine you start scaling the town up more and more eventually you get to the point where like you can't have one guard tower in the center. You have to switch to having guards on the walls and you need multiple guards on the walls. Once you get to a town that's like let's say I don't know like how 100,000 people then you know you might have a wall of your wall might be 10 kilometers long and like you might need let's say 50 guards. Right.
If you have less than 50 guards then the guards can't see far enough and so someone might an attacker might slip through in between two of the guards. If the city expands further and then the city is like say as big as Manhattan, then you're going to need like a thousand guards. Right. And you know if you don't have a thousand guards then you know they're like an attacker might slip through in between two of the guards and like the security of the town might break. So the bigger the town gets the you start get like you start committing to an assumption about how many security guards are you sure that you can that you're always going to have.
Now the good use of is on about a lot of a blockchain here right is that with data availability sampling every user of a blockchain is one of these guards right. Every user is kind of randomly watching a random portion of this sort of metaphorical wall and every and so every user is helping to check that like there aren't any unavailable like data chunks that are getting through. But like whatever your scalability level is that you're committing to you're also committing to saying you were deaf we guarantee that we're definitely going to have at least 100 users or say at least 1000 users active at all times.
Right. So like that is a yeah that is an assumption right and the higher your scalability gets the stronger that assumption gets like once you start talking about blockchains that have like gigabytes per second you're basically committing to saying we are always going to have hundreds of thousands of active notes. So if your chain suddenly becomes much less popular that's that suddenly becomes a security risk. If everyone suddenly like switches to using more centralized clients that's a risk and not for them that becomes a security risk for the entire network right. So security just becomes more and more uncertain and also your ability to guarantee the availability of history also becomes more and more uncertain right.
So like for example the Ethereum roadmap rated basic the parameters that we have right now is I think it was about 2.6 megabytes per second of blockchain data I think and 2.6 megabytes per second there is 31 million seconds in a year so that's going to be 90 million megabytes a year so that'll be somewhere around like 85 if a terabytes per year so like there's already that's like already a lot of terabytes that with every year that are being added to the blockchain right and people have to store all of that. Now if you crank that up by another factor of 100 then we're talking about like eight petabytes per year right and so the higher the higher you go the the higher and higher the risk there is that just people are gonna like get tired of like all of this data and there's just you're gonna have an accident at some point and you're gonna realize that like some piece of data from somewhere in history nobody's storing it anymore.
Now I think 85 terabytes per year is actually is totally fine right like because 85 terabytes per year like if you have if you have even one that just keeps buying like a hundred dollar hard drive like I think once every month then they can store it right like it's something like that so it's too big for just like a casual user that just wants to run the chain on their laptop but one dedicated user who cares like they can totally afford to afford to store the chain and so 85 terabytes not a big deal right but once you crank that number higher there comes a point at which it starts becoming a really big deal and so like I guess that like the answer is a little bit unsatisfying in that there isn't some point above which like it's obviously scalable up to this point but it's obviously not scalable beyond this point it's like there are these weird systemic risks and as the scalability goes up the systemic risks go up and there just comes some points at which you know it becomes harder and harder to argue that this is like a credibly 100% secure and reliable blockchain but you know do we know what that point is well unfortunately we don't really know until an accident happens and so we have to be careful and so like I think like I personally am convinced that you know the 2.
6 megabyte per second number is very safe I'm like I'm even convinced that going up like another half order of magnitude another order of magnitude is very safe but you know realistically we do want to keep the numbers like on on the lower side so that so that we can actually set so that nobody feels uncomfortable like that that's basically where the limits are at but you know 2.6 megabytes a second is a lot right like if we're talking about ZK roll-ups and implement full compression 2.6 megabytes divided by 16 by such transaction that's like 130 KTPS so and if we add a decade of more than you know we're talking hundreds of hundreds of thousands of TPS so that's just like enough to run most users transactions so I basically I think with quadratic shorting will be fine so we've we've gotten through the the merge and the surge right we still have three other urges to go through but okay so the merge gives us proof of stake basically people know what that is the surge gives us scalability so we get massive bandwidth massive throughput particularly on roll-ups so now we have scalability on Ethereum and now we have proof of stake what about the verge that's the next one on the roadmap so what does that add the verge is the introduction of Virgo trees right so Virgo trees are a replacement for the Merkle Patricia trees that currently store the Ethereum state so the Ethereum state is this database of Nick all of the accounts all of the smart contracts all of the balances all of the contracts code all the contract storage everything that is remembered by the Ethereum blockchain that contracts and users and applications can access and that is all hashed into the tree structure right and Virgo trees replaced that tree structure they replaced the current hash based that tree with a a Virgo tree which is based on vector commitments now you have to ask well what's the benefit of switching to vector commitments the benefit of this has to do with this concept that I think I've talked about many times historically which is a stateless clients so what is a stateless clients right so the like today in order to verify a block n you have to have the entire Ethereum state and how do you get the entire Ethereum state like you have to either you like fast sync and you download everything or you have to download block in block n minus one or you have to verify block n minus one right so in order to kind of keep verifying Ethereum blocks and stay up to date with the chain you have to have this entire database locally this database is big it's about 40 gigabytes I think and it keeps on getting bigger and if we end up like massively increasing the gas limit then it will get even more bigger so it's um so what do stateless clients do stateless clients are basically let you say what if instead of needing this entire database to verify a block we're going to have this thing called a verbal proof which which gives you only the pieces of the state that are read and written to and accessed in a particular block along with a proof that proves to you that those pieces actually are correct right and so if you have that proof then you can verify a block without needing any other information um so you can imagine this proof as being an extra couple hundred gigabytes um so there is the data so there are the accounts to code in the contracts that are being read for that particular block and then there are just these extra intermediate commitments and this is another few hundred gigabytes and that and there was proofs um like basically tell you that the data that is being claimed actually is correct now technically you can make you can make proofs with Patricia trees right but the problem is that the proofs are incredibly big like we're talking like more than 10 megabytes in the worst case we're literally talking about 400 megabytes so it's a little too much for users to be able to actually verify but verbal trees they use like some fancy or technology and if you want to learn more about that technology I once again I wrote an article about it um and uh and the fancy or technology of verbal trees allows you to have these proofs that are that are much shorter and that are fast to verify um and so we actually can't afford to have these sales clients right so what is the benefit of sales clients i'm stainless clients basically like you just like immediately step in and say hey i'm going to verify this block you don't need to have the state you don't need to have anything like literally a fresh node can just swoop in and say hey i want to verify this block and it can ask the network for the block asking that for the proof and once it has the block or the proof it just immediately sweeps through and it just verifies the whole thing um so that now why is that useful um one reason why that's useful is that it allows validators to be much lighter um validators would not have to have this big heavy um database validators could just only verify blocks that they need to verify in real time right so as a ver as a validator you would not need to have a big hard drive you would theoretically be able to just do everything in RAM so it will be scalable faster much much easier to set up much more convenient um so the experience as validator will be much more decentralized um and all you would have to do is you would just um have to um you know verify these blocks with these extra proofs attached and um you know like that that would be all that you need to do it's just uh participate in the network well so does this mean does this mean like running a validator running a node becomes so much easier on a theorem so you know somebody could run it on a phone for example i mean i want to possibly yes right so like and this is a um a design for the decentralization of a theorem right it's like all of all of these urges have the same thing in common which is like scalability without sacrificing decentralization that's what we're doing with the merge and so like if more people are running nodes have the ability to run nodes go back to your point when you're talking about the the verge this gives us more defenders of the city basically so now we have the ability to um add more bandwidth and increase the population of our city because we have more defenders who are able to run nodes um to verify that you know everything in the city is it's going okay um exactly like i guess one analogy might be that like instead of uh having to like actually physically get your armor and weapons and go to the wall to be one of these watch guards like you know you could just sit in the comfort of your home and you could just have a drone uh i mean just like a nice drone so the there's a theme that i'm noticing so far is is some of these update some of these urges are really about increasing scalability and then some of these update some of these uh hard forks other these urges are also about um making sure that those upgrades are secure uh so one is upgrading scalability and then the rest are making sure that that effort is safe uh and the verge really seems to be about democratizing access to the broadest number of participants possible to anyone and everyone who wants to verify the validity of the chain um would you say that's a fair summary yeah i think so okay and then of course the the desire for everyone to be able to verify the chain is that when everyone can verify the chain you as an individual can't be bullied by someone that can propose blocks when you can only verify blocks um cool exactly this brings us to the fourth urge this is uh the purge i think there's a uh you know a popular movie with that title but uh don't really know if you're not a popular movie not a popular movie anyway this is not at all related to that what what are we talking about when we are talking about the purge here on Ethereum's roadmap metallic um basically this is about kind of eliminating the dead weight of history from Ethereum now um in a very broad sense right um so there's different kinds of dead weights of history that we have to deal with um one example of that is just like the the load of the historical chain right so today a client joining the Ethereum network has to download all historical blocks um and they have to store all historical blocks and this is a lot of data this is a hundreds of gigabytes um and post-sharding it will be even more like well it will be terabytes um so the history expiry this is that blue rectangle that's a little bit to the left um base um and by the way like in this diagram time approximately is left to write so i'm hoping that history expiry actually does happen only a little bit after the merge right we see how the history expiry rectangle is like only a little bit to the right of the merge uh so history expiry um basically says we don't we stop requiring all nodes to store all of these historical blocks um instead clients stop storing history that's more than one year old and we kind of uh shift the responsibility of storing and retreating that history to other protocols um so um eip4444 is probably the most popular uh history expiry eip right now it's just very simple and um just says clients don't have to store that stuff anymore um so i think the interesting question there is if all client nodes do not have to store history anymore than who does right there are applications that depend on history that are more than one year old and even rollups do right like a rollup uh in order to actually sink the state of a rollup you like you do have to get it like be either you kind of like trust some state route that's a one week old and you have some separate peer-to-peer network thank me to download the state from or if you want to do it with just a blockchain then you do have to basically walk through the entire history of the rollup and so you do have to process all these blocks one by one right um a lot of like applications depend on old history to tell you about like all instances of when you use that application so like tell you like i'm not sure exactly how like me like die and run all these things work but like maybe you need uh the to scan the history to tell you what all your CDPs are um yeah like i know auger needed to use um like historical logs to tell you like all of the different markets that you've participated in um so there is a lot of value in in history and for at least some applications and so there's this interesting question of like well what are these alternative ways of getting history right now the good use is that history is the sort of thing that is very self-verifying right you can just give someone Merkel proofs and they can verify Merkel proofs um so it's not super hard to create protocols that that kind of replace the Ethereum blockchain and uh actually giving users this data and the other really nice thing about historical data right is that it is a one-of-end trust model um so I think in one of our previous episodes right we talked about trust models like i i wrote this post on trust models and like the difference between an out of two of n one of n zero of n um and the big difference between consensus and history is that consensus is an end of an out of two of n trust model and so we have to worry a lot about it but history like data grabbing is only a one of n trust model and so you know it's uh it's something where we actually can breathe a little bit easier and we don't need to like require everyone to store everything right so the main contenders for getting history data um one is obviously the centralized approach right ether scan ether chain beacon chain beacon scan amber data like all of these lovely folks they are going to keep storing the entire chain because their users want the chain and so if all else fails there are these like about half a dozen centralized backstops that you can go talking to um decentralized protocols um the portal network is the etherium foundation supported uh kind of um protocol for doing this uh basically every node could would only need to store a small percentage of all the data and you would have a network that would just automatically route users to the subset of nodes that store like one particular piece of data so one simple mental model for thinking about this might be that like when you start up your node your node is just gonna pick a random number from zero to a hundred and let's say your node picks a number 67 and then your node is going to just agree it's going to store the entire history for all blocks whose block numbers end in 67 right and so if a user needs a transaction from a block whose block number ends in 67 it's going to talk to you but instead if a user needs a transaction from a block whose block number ends in 45 then it's going to talk to David instead right and you have networks like the portal networks that just automatically make all of this happen um so that is the yeah what like roughly what the portal network is going to do there are also third party protocols right so the graph is one that I think is very far along and doing this sort of stuff that a lot of people are excited about um the graph is a protocol that a lot of applications are switching to already right so a lot of existing applications they stop to using Ethereum native um like history and log grabbing because it was too slow in the switch to the graph because it's faster right and so the graph already provides a lot of this now the graph is not yet fully decentralized the graph still has some a kind of training wheel some centralized trust built in but they do have a roadmap for kind of taking that out over time um so the graph is another option um there's another option is also on like client protocols right so like clients protocols um well I think eventually the are going to end up kind of plugging into the portal network um but there's a lot of work happening with like client for protocols like client protocols they're going to become much easier as a result of the merge because the merge supports sync committees which make being of running a like client much easier um and so we'll have a lot more like clients and allow a lot more of this Merkel proof grabbing infrastructure um so the summary right is that the Ethereum base protocol will stop forcing every node to store all of history but instead there's like this entire like array of alternative solutions um block x centralized solutions like block explorers support on network um the the graph and like all even more protocols that I've forgotten about all of these different alternative solutions that clients will have to instead go to if they want to really old history information now remember most applications don't really even need old history information so this is like for that subset of the applications that do there are these solutions um but for users that don't then you know if the RAM will just keep working exactly the way that Ethereum works today um so that's history expiry um the one the longer term one that we could talk about next is a state expiry right so history is um like the the analogy for history and state that I talk about often is um like history is or the state is like a country's record of who its citizens are um history is like all the birth records and all the death records right um so it's obvious that history is bigger than state because like when you when someone dies they get removed from the state but they're still part of the history um and then an archive node is like a node that stores like basically that has a separate page storing like who the citizens were during every possible year in history right um so now obviously if you have the history you can use that to regenerate an archive node um and if you if you have the history it can kind of play for the the history and you can use that to generate the current state um but the history is bigger than the state and the archive node data is bigger than the history what much bigger than the history and the state but you can regenerate it from the history um so the state expiry basically says well even though the state is smaller eventually the state is still going to get really big and so we're gonna do is we're gonna read and say say objects in the state that have not been touched for the last year are going to go into the separate expiry and theetherian protocol is not responsible for storing the expiry the expiry tree is part of history but if you care about some account or some application that got moved into the expiry tree you can you can go and provide the Merkel proofs and you can revive it right so state expiry does not impose on anyone like a risk of you know their coins getting deleted if they accidentally go into a cave for two years like if you go into a cave for two years then you're just going to have to provide the Merkel proofs to recover to recover your coins right which is something that you totally can do but in order to do that like you're not going to have be able to just go through the regular ethereum protocol you're going to have to like talk to the popular networker talk to the graph or talk to a block explorer talk to one of these other people in order to actually get that data so state expiry is actually something that I think can wait a very long time so you can see that in this diagram it's the the rectangle is like far to the right of even all of the other rectangles one of the reasons why it's so far to the right has to do with something that is we'll skip briefly ahead to the splurge propose a builder separation this is the buzz word that I think has become very popular over the last few months this is basically this idea that the validator that proposes a block and who actually constructs the block do not have to be the same actor right and instead of forcing validators to create blocks we're going to have an auction and we're going to auction off the right to create the blocks and the reason why we're doing this is because creating a block that like really gives us the the highest gives the creator the highest possible fees gives him the highest possible mev gives him the highest possible revenue in the long term is a pretty hard problem and we don't want to force validators to have to like figure out the complex cities of dealing with that problem because we want anyone to be able to be a validator and so instead we're just going to say that we're there's a separate class of actors that can they're going to create these blocks and there's going to be an auction and so proposals can just easily choose the block to pay some of the most and we'll add some extra protocol armor to ensure that this whole thing is still censorship resistant that transactions can still get in there's a like digrad and different francisco have been doing a lot of research on that but one of the really nice side effects of PBS is that validators are no longer involved in the job of creating blocks right so validators no longer have to store the state this also gets into virtual trees right validators only have to verify blocks it's the builders that have to create blocks so the builders have to store the state but the builders are going to be pretty specialized anyway and so if the state blows up to four terabytes well you know the builders can store four terabytes right so if we have virtual trees and we have PBS technically we don't really ever need state expiry and so if the can gets kicked down the road 20 years on state expiry that's actually totally fine but like I think eventually we do want the Ethereum protocol to be kind of more elegant and to not have this kind of extra junk data that keeps going up and up forever and so adding some kind of state expiry does make sense right so that is like a much longer term thing but if it has to happen it can happen and then the last part of the purge has to do with technical debt right so what has to do with actually simplifying the protocol and actually removing a lot of the complexities from the from the code that currently make it more difficult to create a node that currently make it more difficult to like actually run a node to debug and like to like just you know make an ethereum implementation um so the self-destruct op code is one of those op codes that I really hate um you know that I have good reasons to hate um I think if you just like Google search like Vitalik bands or vbooter and bands self-destruct you can probably find the posts we're advocate for why we should band self-destruct oh no sorry it's a vbooter and pragmatic destruction of self-destruct that's the title um so I talk about like why I think that's a good idea um verbal trees also depend on banding self-destruct because they change the storage layout in a certain way um gas stipends are another thing that I want to remove at some point um a lot of the pre-compiled we can remove and we can just replace them with EVM implementations um we can remove we can simplify logs eventually we can remove RLP eventually uh we can uh find solutions for dust accounts so like if someone has like say 50 dollars of ether 50 dollars of ERC 20 tokens today and they have a hard time paying the gas fees to remove that then there are a number of ideas that can make it cheaper for them to deal with all of that stuff um so a lot of little things right but the core idea here is to basically kind of like leave the past in the past and create an ethereum that actually becomes simpler and simpler over time so I want to try and summarize that using a metaphor and see how well well how well that lands with you and so my my mind is actually going to um the game of snake uh once upon a time the game of snake was played with little squares and the snake you would start off really really short maybe it'd only be four or five blocks long and it would move around this screen and it would eat a block and then it would grow one block longer and that's kind of like a blockchain right blockchains grow uh people add data to them the snake gets a little bit longer and as that snake gets longer it also gets harder to manage and sometimes it runs into them itself and dies I actually think this is a really good metaphor for a blockchain um what you're what you're saying with the purge is there and if ultimately the game of snake ends with you dying because you got too long that's the long-term conclusion of the game of snake and hope maybe also the long-term conclusion of blockchains maybe if there's too much data in a blockchain it just gets too long and then it dies it crashes uh and so what you're saying with a purge is there's a bunch of ways where we can start to trim off the snake and keep it shorter keep it more agile keep it more lightweight uh and when it's shorter more people can manage it more people can use it uh and so uh state expiry history expiry and then just eliminating some of these uh EVM upcodes and some other things are all different ways that we have determined that we can safely trim off the tail of the snake and leave what you said the past in the past so that the snake stays at a manageable length uh that could be managed by more people how is that for a metaphor that is a really fun analogy uh cool okay let's see if i get like you take like to come up with a city analogy for the purge like let's say imagine you have a city right and let's imagine that because of global warming every couple of years you just have to move the city 100 kilometers north right because the earth is warming and so eventually where the city was before it gets too cold um now imagine if like you have a like like for some reason um today we just design design to the city kind of security protocol in such a way that even though the city keeps moving and and we have to keep building new city walls we still have to keep on guarding all of the old city walls forever right so every time there's a new city like and like the number of walls that keep that you have to keep guarding just keep just keeps increasing even if the city's population doesn't go up right so the purge basically is about fixing that problem and about saying like hey these cities are abandoned and you know if you really want to like if you really want to like go and grab stuff from from your old home then you know we can like provide you for some way to like hire some private security so you can go and visit that city but like we're not going to keep maintaining security for that city forever um and then on theme with uh what's been going on so far is is with uh you know first uh some of these changes are Ethereum expanding and growing into new fields and then some of these changes are Ethereum protecting that that expansion right first we built out and then we harden uh and so and one of the questions I had for you is is that you know eliminating state eliminating state in in Ethereum was part of the purge which is kind of antithetical to what a blockchain is blockchain is you're not supposed to eliminate data that's not what they do the in fact it's actually quite the opposite but what you're saying is with some of these strategies we can safely prune some of the data and have strong assurances that that data will still be available somehow some way by some manner in ways that it feels still secure to eliminate that data from the current state while still having strong assurances that that data's available somewhere exactly so like the way that I think about the blockchain philosophically is that it becomes this kind of public billboard where the billboard guarantees that everything that looks like it's on the billboard actually was published in the billboard and it actually was correct um but like you don't actually have to have everyone that's responsible for securing the billboard also be responsible for recording the entire history of the billboard right because uh like we're hoarding history is an easier problem than uh securing um and so you know we only have a smaller number of people actually like record the history of the entire billboard and that smaller number of people is enough because securing the billboard is an end of two of end problem but recording history is a one-of-end problem and so like we just don't need to have this incredibly huge number of people recording the history of the billboard forever there we go guys isn't blockchain funds snakes and cities merges and purges uh here we go with the fifth one is my favorite at least in title is the splurge uh let's talk about the splurge and there's so many things i think we could talk about because this seems like a almost like a uh grab bucket category miscellaneous category of all sorts of other cool things that uh theorem could do in the future maybe some of these things are further out than others but could you pick like maybe one or two metallic uh that uh that you think would be useful to talk about in this catch-all bucket sure um so uh proposed builder separation we've talked about already um account abstraction that's a uh one that we've talked about i think since forever and i think people have heard about that at a long time right like basically the idea is just like make smart contract wallets more like first class citizens and so it becomes as easy to like do all of your ethereum-ing with a smart contract wallet as it is with a zero regular account and today that's not the case because of the way that the ethereum protocol was just structurally assumes that everyone has what's called an externally owned account uh but account abstraction just fixes those issues and so things like multi-sig wallet, things like social recovery wallets uh just become really easy for anyone to use as their primary account um so i think the newest development is account of in account abstraction is erc4337 um so this is a layer like a layer two sort of approach to account abstraction that says instead of changing the protocol to support account abstraction we're just going to create this kind of second transaction layer where we have these user operation objects that um uh directly talk to smart contracts and then there does need to be like a wrapper transaction that wraps around all of the user operations that get included in a block but instead of having the transaction overhead per user operation you just have it once per block right and and this and then you have a separate mempool for user operations miners can listen to that mempool um you couldn't and actors like that participate in flashbots can listen to that mempool um and so like basically you create this kind of like higher level ecosystem where our users can do everything that they need to do with these smart contract wallets and with these user operations um and ever there is there is this kind of higher like higher level construction consisting of these actors part in the ecosystem that are listening to this mempool that actually make sure that everything gets included on chain right so it's like instead of changing the existing protocol you create a protocol that sits on top of the existing protocol so instead of layer two for scaling it's sort of layer two for account abstraction but like the difference here right is that like this this isn't creating like a separate universe that's account abstracted like account abstracted wallets will be able to interact with all existing applications they are like they just they are a theorem address as they are a theorem smart contract right so account abstraction and like another really nice thing about ERC4337 is that the exact same ERC4337 can work on if you're ambly or one it'll work on optimism it can work on arbitrary it can work on polygon um you know it can I think with some modifications work on that um so like all of this uh so it basically is this kind of path toward an ecosystem wide upgrade that that could bring us toward um smart contract wallets actually being a reality that that's very cool hey can I ask the the other thing in this grab bucket maybe there's so many other things we can talk about but um zk snark everything zk snarkifying everything that that might be a bit more uh on the disson horizon but it's that sounds really awesome what is that basically like we like we like we we want to completely move away from this idea of like users verifying things by re-exituting them right so like zk snark the evm so that um users don't even have to verify don't have to run the evm um zk snark the beacon change transition so that users um don't have to run the beacon change transition zk snark um you know signature verification so users don't have to verify signatures right so basically get to the point where the only person who needs to actually run the evm and actually like run the the beacon chain like state transition function or run any of that stuff is whoever is that whoever is creating the block everyone else just verifies one snark and that one snark lets to verify the entire block and so what does that give us like does that provide difference across all of these things that makes it extremely easy for anyone to run a node so does it adds more and more drones watch towers of all types to the city so that everyone is part it participating in the security of the city in an easier fashion yep cool it chops the snake's tail off David so it's a little staking yeah so like so like you had all you have is like the head of the snake and instead of the body of the snake you just have like as it gets dark of a body of the snake and like the snake does it need the body it just has a proof that it doesn't let the body exist oh my god it's okay wait I want to unpack that wait so there's just one head of the snake which is normal and then the whole rest of the body has been z-case snark so it's this tiny little tail that's connected to this normal sized head uh that's how Ethereum just becomes super ultra lightweight exactly me somebody's gonna make a z-case snark game in z-k yeah stark technology somewhere after this episode I think the Gemini Exchange has been my exchange of choice ever since I got into crypto I used Gemini to both buy the dips and also manage my regular automatic monthly purchases of my preferred crypto asset on Gemini you'll find over 50 different cryptos including many of the top DeFi and Metaverse tokens like Wi-Fi and Axi Infinity using Gemini Earn you can earn yield on your various cryptos including 8% on the GUSD stablecoin Gemini is available in all 50 states and more than 50 countries worldwide so if you're looking to upgrade your crypto exchange sign up at Gemini with Gemini.
com slash go bankless and get 15 dollars of bitcoin after you trade a hundred dollars or more within the first 30 days that's gemni.com slash go bankless slingshot is a decentralized trading platform that combines the performance and ease of a centralized exchange with the openness and transparency of DeFi slingshot aggregates liquidity from all of DeFi in order to find the best price on thousands of crypto assets every token on slingshot comes with a price chart and trade logs to give you insights into the market activity in real time. slingshot is available on polygon arbitrum and optimism saving you from the high gas feeds and low transaction speeds of the Ethereum L1 there are no fees to trade on slingshot and any positive slippage is given to the users trading on slingshot is a social experience you can even set your chat avatar to your favorite NFT or soon a slingshot 2099 NFT avatar once you bridge your assets to polygon arbitrum or optimism go to app dot slingshot dot finance to trade and use the chat box to share your trades with others and find other tokens to ape into the brave browser is the user first browser for the web 3 internet with built in privacy and ad blocking to keep you in charge of your digital footprint inside the brave browser you'll find the brave wallet the first secure crypto wallet built natively inside of a web 3 crypto browser web 3 is freedom from big tech and wall street more control and better privacy but there's a weak point in web 3 your crypto wallet the brave wall is different brave wall is built natively inside the brave browser no extension required which gives the brave wallet an extra level of security versus other wallets with the brave wallet you can buy store send and swap your crypto assets and you can even manage your NFTs and connect to other wallets and DeFi apps all from the security of the best privacy browser on the market whether you're new to crypto or season pro is time to switch to the brave wallet download brave at brave.
com slash bankless and click the wallet icon to get started Vitalik give us kind of the I guess the high level overview so we started this episode you said you felt like you could be convinced in saying that Ethereum is maybe 50% of the way done okay does the end of these things after the merge search purge purge splurge are we a hundred percent at that point in time is everything done I say so I mean there are a couple of these longer-term extras that we haven't talked about but it would probably take too long for us to talk about all of them but I feel like and I do think that like none of these road maps are final right like these road maps are kind of my attempts to reflect the current rough consensus of the research team so like there are new things that did not exist before right like PBS did not exist a year ago and so you did not see PBS in last year's roadmap um so there might be a couple of things but I think once all of these things are done like I will say this if this is all done and then nothing else ever changes after that then I'll be extremely happy right now like I feel like this covers everything that's like necessary for Ethereum to not only survive but even thrive going into the long term so I was just going to ask as well the timeline so Ethereum is six years old is how long is this going to take is this going to take another six years I could definitely see all this happened in six years yeah Vitalik is if one or a handful of these things doesn't happen is everything here crucial does everything here need to happen in order for Ethereum to last multi generations I would say if only the merge in the search happened then Ethereum can already survive and thrive in last multiple generations um to me the I mean it's possible that PBS is necessary for security um and and it's like possible that you know well the the verge is going to become really important eventually but even there doesn't need to right because uh like one alter like one possible alternative to the verge is that eventually if the if the merge in the search finish at some point we just reduce the gas limit all the way back down to three million because we don't like we don't need a layer one gas anymore because everything happens on layer two right so aside from the merge of the storage I do there are alternatives to everything but I think it is still a nice to have um and uh so you know I'm still really excited about all these things taking place and so what what we're looking at guys is for bankless listeners we're breaking into kind of the firmware the the machinery of uh this trust computer that we call Ethereum here right um like that's what we're doing we're kind of almost looking at the motherboard with Vitalik if you will what once this computer is built and and of course I know you remember Vitalik that the meme of um Ethereum the internet computer that went a little wild in 2017 the world computer the internet yeah the excuse me the world's computer uh that went a little wild in 2017 um but like there's some truth to it right this is a world computer that that has been built so once this roadmap comes to fruition what will we have like what is at the other side of this I mean Bitcoin's vision famously is is now become sort of a digital gold if you will it's all about Bitcoin the uh the asset and the scarcity of that asset what do we get when this when this uh world computer is fully built out when you'll get a system where if you want to build an application where you want some piece of that application to have execution that school will bleach rust then you can just use Ethereum to do it and that spawns you know infinite numbers of possible applications some of which we have designed so far and some of which I guess we'll see in the future you did so Vitalik that was a high level summary of the Ethereum roadmap thus far and into the future even though it's a always changing thing uh the crypto industry is always changing and something that we've seen in the last year is the rise of the alternative layer ones and where Ethereum has this goal to get to the state that that we've been discussing alternative layer ones have cropped up um some with different goals and some with other goals and you've also written an article lately called endgame that makes the case that all blockchains ultimately converge on the same future uh and so we we want to unpack this uh this part of this conversation because other all layer ones alternative layer ones have their own roadmap uh and and you think that ultimately long-term blockchains will converge upon the same future so we want to unpack that but before we get into the endgame article I just kind of want to get your take on on 2021 with regards to Ethereum and then all the other smart contract platforms that that came about the first half of 2021 was really just Ethereum's show uh NFTs absolutely blew up DeFi was huge we got we saw the seedlings of web3 platforms put cryptography into corners of the world that had never seen it before so many people got a private key so many people learned how to use metamass so many people approach crypto in a positive light rather than just you know drug dealing internet money um which was really cool uh and Ethereum in the first half of 2021 kind of turned into a victim of its own success in my mind it got so adopted so quickly that it became extremely congested uh just massive adoption turned into exclusionary gas fees expensive NFTs priced out everyone and Ethereum kind of got this negative branding as like a whale chain if you will and that turned this turned into a bunch of pushback into uh alternative newer layer ones and push the users into these newer layer ones because crypto people want to do crypto stuff they want to push buttons on their metamass they want to push buttons on their ledger and so we saw the rise of buying a smart chain salana avalanche phantom terror just a slew of other layer ones to really satisfy the demand of layer one block space um so i don't really have a specific question here but what do you what do you make of 2021 and the distribution of where the average crypto user has fallen with regards to all the different new crypto systems that are out there what what do you make of all this yeah and i think that there's clearly a lot of demand for scaling there's a lot of demand for blockchain space that is cheap um and i'm like ultimately users are going to gravitate to where that space is provided right um so no actually this reminds me of fun um a fact from my yeah recent trip to um argentina um so guess what is what is the alternately or one that it is that the like people just like using cryptocurrency um on the ground for for for for commerce and argentina are using most often that as far as i can tell bitcoin no big ones also expensive right okay it's it's one word transactions are extreme which you okay well let's go through is it um is it madick no is it okay not madick is it uh terror no salana i think you might remember right i think it's tron finance is it going to be tron okay um tron is probably one one of the number two like what's the number one um finance fan uh it's finance not finance marchain finance the centralize exchange okay yeah for for you know like for for doing what what are they doing on finance like they just like need cryptocurrency for payments um then yeah yeah like one of them was just a coffee shop that it's that um accepted crypto there are a couple of other businesses like when i ask if they can pay with if i can pay with ethay just show me the QR code of a deposit address and like it's just obvious that they're used to um like finance to finance transfers which are instant right and like my ethereum to finance that transfer has to wait for 12 confirmations in the app um so yeah you know there we go that's uh you know that uh so far that's the ethereum killer so is is finance like an alternate layer one in your mind or like i've always thought it's really it is right like you're like a guy's database but you know if like if like if we're talking about people who don't care about the level of decentralization then like no one so but just to illustrate this uh if you have a finance address and i have a finance address both finance knows that it has both of our addresses and so if it goes from finance address a to finance address b it just accounts for that on its internal ledgers and just updates is internal balances and the users are apparently okay with that in argentina exactly and they should be because like it's it's better than the existing system which is what makes them users right but you know yeah like i think uh like in argentina i remember that the thing that all of this crypto stuff is competing with is uh one like highly inflationary Argentine pesos and two US dollar cash which is inconvenient you have to hide it under your mattress and potentially have it get robbed or you have to put it in some complicated safety deposit box that you have with like some company that you have to maintain um so like even finance the centralized exchanges already have big improvements over what these people would be using otherwise um now obviously ideally um you know there are these uh ethereum ecosystem would be able to serve all of these users directly but scalability is not high enough for that yet but it is uh as i think we've talked about it's it's coming quite close to being ready so are you making the case metallic i want to make sure i understand so like um do you think it's true that um users don't care about decentralization or like why should they even care about decentralization if finance is going to service their needs and provide what they need and you know maybe i as in uh someone in argentina would you trust cz and finance over my my local banking system i understand why um are you making the case that's true and and that therefore is from these alt layer ones that trade off decentralization for bandwidth and speed and that sort of thing that's that's a good thing what what are your thoughts there um i think a lot of people do care about decentralization but like they're not going to take the decentralization of the decentralization cost eight dollars each transaction there's uh there's this um quote that you had in 2017 that says the internet of money should not cost five cents per transaction and uh i remember when you said that in 2017 and i i think a lot of um you know people who have been angry at uh gas fees high gas fees on ethereum have used that quote recently let me ask you do you still believe that of course i do yeah well so yeah talk about that in the context of the ethereum roadmap yeah i mean i think um no blog like in order for blockchains to be able to actually be something that like people are going to adopt for just mainstream applications like it it it has to be it has to be cheap and it has to be not just cheap by the standards of whales who bought crypto in 2014 and it has to be cheap by the standards of people who are coming into the system today and who are going to be putting you know 20 or 40 dollars into crypto if they put in anything at all right and so if erium to like you know yes if erium today is not a yes like the layer one is not a system that's uh ready for like direct mass adoption by users but that's exactly why we've been like harping the drum of scalability and layer two is enchanting and all these things pretty like since uh uh 2014 right like the ethereum's roadmap like any kind of vision and strategy is like exactly the same as it was back in 2017 when i talked about the need for the need for fees to be low um and uh you know the layer two is are coming close to like close to providing that right like loop ring has been around for a year and it provides uh you know transaction fees that are not quite five cents but they tend to be like around 15 cents or so today um and of course once sharding comes along then like it will be much less than five cents again um so there's uh like the layer two ecosystem is definitely am together with layer one sharding is completely on the way to like bringing us back to the really low fee is that we had back in 2014 and 15 and that allowed so much amazing experimentation early on to start happening um but you know to get there we do need to actually just solve all all of these hard technical problems there's a line that's going around in the crypto twitter sphere and the overall conversation of all the crypto people out there uh about how ethereum maxis are just bitcoin maxis 2.
0 uh and it's it's unknown whether this trope is uh actually stated by the users or perhaps uh injected by the vc dl1 builders out there trying to fund ethereum perhaps the truth is somewhere in the middle uh but for talika somebody who originally forked off of bitcoin how do you feel about that line i mean i definitely think that maximalism is something that's uh very unhealthy um and like there definitely are tendencies i think among some people and even the ethereum community to try to kind of brand everything outside of the ethereum ecosystem as being boring and illegitimate which i don't think is true like i think you know there's real fun like interesting stuff happening in z cash lands there's real interesting stuff happening in like say tezos you know there's uh that one of the cities that i talked about in my crypto cities article they're doing everything on tezos um so they're like i do think that you know there are honorable community is that are not just like taking the quickbuck and that that actually do care about decentralization um but at the same time right like it's uh like it's it's also like there's definitely a lot of people that like basically adjust to use the word ethereum maxis it just prefer to someone who supports ethereum which is just crazy right like there's uh like this idea that um decentralization is really important for example right and i think ethereum is like one of the really valuable and important things about the ethereum community is that it does have a core that that strongly believes in decentralization it's willing to continue fighting for it it's uh you know willing to like even delegitimize and stop publicly supporting applications that kind of betray those principles um yeah whereas uh you know on a lot of other ecosystem so like you have entire gaps that are like close source and people just like like barely blink an eye about it um so that's the um so i think um no i i guess my my my view there is is uh somewhere in the middle like i think it's definitely important to like also have our eyes open and look at all and look at what's going on and all of these other ecosystems um but at the same time like we do have to remember because uh or that a lot of people do like support ethereum not just because of uh you know some kind of like you know bias of you know like they got their bags in earlier because like ultimately like you know if you have your bags in ethereum but you decide ethereum is worse than you can just move all your bags to something else you know it's uh it's a free market um but i i i think you know people do believe that um decentralization is valuable and important and they yes see the ethereum community as being a community that is will that is uh willing to actually work hard and to and take all of the necessary steps to actually build the future where we have scalability and decentralization at the same time and that's i think something that's uh you know really really important to keep and i know you personally if italic aren't maximalist about anything read you you know your article about concave versus convex thinking right that sort of thing but if um if you had to be described the label of maximalist something would you would you would you like how closer you to being a decentralization maximalist what was that again how closer you to being a decentralization maximalist does that describe your philosophy on things italic i would not call myself in anything maximalist but i definitely think that decentralization is extremely important um it was like ultimately decentralization is what this space is about right and uh and then like once you start compromising on that then there does come a point where you just have to ask well like what is even difference between what's being built here and uh centralized systems um and uh like i think the more that we can actually get to like genuine decentralization and an ecosystem where you know in order to make changes to the protocol like actually we need to have buy and not just from a couple of protocol elites but from the entire user community like i think that's a really important and beautiful thing um and it's also an important and beautiful thing for um you know if the asset to maintain its credibility it's an important thing for a lot of the applications on Ethereum to maintain their credibility and it's something that we need to like uh uh fight for and support this starts to get into the conversation of the end game paper which i think we want to transition into now um and i think i do agree with you italic that uh obviously the decentralization is the prime thing that we are uh that really supports this entire industry uh but a lot of the alternative layer ones i have cropped up in the in the last half of the year have um penetrated into the crypto markets using cheap fees cheap lock space fees having ample block space supply uh and they got that way via centralization but there's an argument out there that's that says that uh while Ethereum sacrifice scalability first in order to achieve scalability later other uh centralized layer ones sacrifice decentralization first and can achieve decentralization later is just a matter of picking which of the blockchain trillema systems uh points do you want to compromise and then work on um so i want to get your perspective on if you think that's a fair characterization can you compromise on decentralization at the start to achieve it later and do you think all of these alternative layer ones all all layer ones all blockchain layer ones ultimately converge on more or less the same design structure in the very distant long term i mean like first of all like i think this post is in some ways more about the theory than the practice right like in practice i think a lot of these communities pay lip service decentralization but they don't like deeply give much of a crap about it like how many of them even try having multiple clients for example some do right but others don't and i think uh looking at which ones do and which ones don't and it tells you a lot about an ecosystem um but them so the question i asked basically is like if you were uh like say put me in charge of one of these centralized big blockchains and like and i were uh like and you were to ask me like what would it take to actually turn that that chain as it is today into a blockchain that has what i would consider to be acceptable levels of decentralization and trustlessness and censorship persistence right and the like plausible roadmap that i have here basically has a collection of things that a big blockchain can do and basically to add what what what i would call protocol armor that actually adds a censorship resistance and decentralization so which was a big part of the conversation of the ethereum roadmap that we just had exactly um so the core ideas here basically say well okay look we have this chain where block production is uh very centralized but what if we can allow block verification to happen in a way that is decentralized right so you have all sorts of decentralized actors that can propose transactions where those transactions have to be included and so we have censorship resistance and then you have um all of these different actors actually do the verification so that a bad block producer or a bad collusion of block producers can't actually like push an invalid block through right so i talk about like having a second tier of staking with low resource requirements that does some distributed block validation and so you can do some committee verification um you can also do verification with zk snarks or verification with fraud proofs um to check the block data is available and the blocks aren't being hidden you can introduce data availability sampling um secondary transaction channels so different ways for transactions to get to get um like seen by these uh second tier stakers so that they uh the protocol then actually forces then the creator of the next block to include them so all of these kind of pieces of armor that you can add around a protocol so that even if you do have one big block producer the big the what they produce is still validated by this highly distributed process that prevents them from actually using their power to do anything terrible right so this is like the best that you can do if you want to start from what where these blockchain are today and get to a point that i would consider acceptable so just to iterate this is a strategy for crypto systems that uh have compromised on decentralization and they have uh centralized just a small handful maybe just even one uh block producer some one entity or a very small number of entities that actually produce the blocks but what you're saying is there's a series of technologies that allows for the individuals the many of the world to to check the powers of that central party so while that central party does have a lot of power because they're the only ones proposing blocks or maybe there's just a few of these block composers they still have to pass through the many many many individuals that are given power given uh sovereignty through some of these cryptographic techniques is that what we're saying and what what kind of system do we end up with if uh if they did that Vitalik is this um is this what we mean by decentralization so like yeah well what's the right things could the block producers you know have have power over and how could the the verifiers the validators um sort of you know provide a check on that power right so the worst that they could do what one is they can extract all the mev um they could probably delay all transactions by a couple of blocks so like we we have a lot of this research on these alternative transaction inclusion mechanisms that can force transactions to be included but there's met like those mechanisms aren't perfect and they don't like they eliminate a lot of the block producers power but they don't eliminate all of their power um so block producers would still be able to like manipulate ordering of transactions a little bit um you know if like you have an NFT auction suddenly appear then like the block producers would still be the ones they'll be able to get first first dibs on everything um so it's not perfect but it is still a system where like you can't push invalid blocks through you can't completely censor transactions um you can't push unavailable blocks through and so the core things of what a blockchain needs to be a blockchain theoretically are still there so one of the questions I have for you Vitalik is there are some parallels here and this is uh in uh next up in your in your article there are some parallels between centralized L1s with centralized block producers and uh layer two rollups on Ethereum can you can you elaborate for the listeners as to why why so much of these conversations overlap between centralized L1s and L2 rollups?
Sure um so this is the second um thought experiment I have here right which is like imagine if you we do layer two scaling and some there is one rollup team that does a really good job of engineering and they get really high levels of scalability right so like imagine arbitrum for example they have an amazing EVMZK rollup and they figure out how to do parallelization they figure out how to do like an amazingly parallel EVM they have a super high performance node and they have you know a rollup that does 10,000 TPS right now the techniques for how to do this are actually are pretty well known right like Daniel Ermer and EOS like has been talking about this stuff since even 2014 right now imagine if you have this system and you have this as a rollup running on top of Ethereum what does that world look like right so I would argue that world actually looks extremely similar to the world where you start with a centralized chain and you add the protocol armor the difference is that in the in the centralized chain like you have the centralized chain that does the centralized sequencing and then it also adds the decentralized validation in this world you would have arbitrum or the arbitrum sequencer whoever that is do the centralized sequencing but then you would have the arbitrum protocol for fraud proof functionality that allows the decentralized validation to happen and then you would have the Ethereum protocol itself provide all of the protocol armor to keep the rest of the decentralization right so like for example you would need rollups already they generally have secondary transaction channels so if main sequencer is not accepting a transaction you have an alternative way of getting your transaction included and the next rollup block is forced to include that transaction you also have data availability verification is done by the Ethereum protocol so today everyone downloads everything but in the future we have data availability sampling and so the Ethereum becomes this kind of guarantee of censorship persistence and availability and all of these other things and then you have like in this case the arbitrum smart contracts that would actually provide the fraud proof like verification and a lot of the rest of the armor that makes sure that whoever does create the blocks can't actually abuse their power right so even though it's implemented using a very like a very different path and you have this different kind of division of labor between the arbitrum lawyer to protocol and the Ethereum lawyer one protocol the result actually still ends up looking fairly similar to what we had in the first section there so that's the that's the second thought experiment and you know we get sort of a similar result similar endgame as the title of the article says but that's probably not what we expect or at least most in a theorem right now expect we probably aren't going to see one rollup dominate and win that's a possibility but we probably won't see that given the plethora of different rollup solutions implementations you know trade-offs that they're making and you're strengths that they have what we'll probably see is a multi rollup world where we have many different rollups from many different teams but you make the argument in this third thought experiment that even if we have a multi rollup kind of world if we live in that world we might still end up in the same place can you walk us through that piece of things sure um so this gets us into this discussion of cross-domain MEV right so the issue here basically is okay you have many different rollups but even if you have many different rollups there's this argument that there is an incentive to try to be a block producer on all of them at the same time and the reason why there's an incentive to be a block producer on all of them at the same time basically has to do with this concept of cross-domain arbitrage right like if you scroll down to that diagram like this is an ex you know the western gate one you have the purple yeah like this is a yeah cross-domain MEV opportunity discovered by western gate right so you're converting 44374 USDT into 4466 USDT and half of the operation happens on I think that's polygon right and then the other half of the operation happens on the Ethereum base chain um so as we move to a layer two centric Ethereum things like this will become normal it will become normal to see that like what there are these arbitrage opportunities where one half of the opportunity gets done in layer two the other half of the other of the opportunity happens on a different layer two so like it might happen on stark x for example or you know it might happen on like you know the as on dy dx um or some some exchange running on optimism you might even have like an arm between the copy of uniswap that's on optimism and the copy of uniswap that's on arbitrum uh so the like in this world there are advantages from being the proposer for everything at the same time um and so if now it's not certain that things will go in this direction right but if things do go in this direction then like we could easily see some kind of protocol take over that basically auctions off like kind of the right to be a proposer for these roll ups as a package deal and so you end up having the second the same actor end up proposing on all of them even if the like the protocols are designed in such a way that you could have different proposers on them right um so now if the world does go this way it's actually not that bad the reason why it's not that bad is because roll ups provide all of this protocol armor to make sure that even if there are centralized actors taking over bar proposing they can't push through in valid things they can't push through unavailable things and because roll ups all have these censorship resistant by-bats channels they can't even censor anyone right so the world of uh roll ups where proposing gets concentrated is still a role a world that is not that bad and also interestingly enough it's a world that is very similar to the world of one roll up or to the world of centralized chains right so basically we end up potentially getting to a future that is very similar to the future that we will get in these other two worlds i i think this all brings up the point to me then Vitalik if all three of these approaches result in the same thing then why not just take the big block approach from the gikgo and scalability and all that are the alt layer ones taking the right approach after all i think the ethereum approach is more future proof right it's more future proof because like it still leaves agnostic the question of you know are we going to be in a single domain world or are we going to be in a multi domain world and it doesn't completely surrender um on the centralization issue right like if it turns out that they're that the optimal way to organize proposers is some decentralized structure where like for example something like the existing flashbots um model where you have a like this internal market consisting of searchers then the ethereum like as system is still friendly to that right so but on the other hand if you start from a layer one we make the assumption of a centralized proposing then like you don't really have a good way of getting out of that right um so i guess the the the question is not like is about like the more you believe in uncertainty and the more you believe that like we really wants to have a system that is open to all of the different possibilities then the more kind of this ethereum approach that is agnostic toward what the future will be but tries to be yeah you know friendly to and have ways to support all of them um looks like the more that approach looks the most attractive it's funny to me as much as ethereum but maybe um big one max plus and others has been criticized in the past for being um i guess moving fast and breaking things too much i often see ethereum in the road from a roadmap perspective taking a very conservative approach it's a very conservative approach to decentralization and in particular it looks very conservative when you contrast it with all of these very high throughput big block uh all the layer ones that have spread every single set one of the dynamics that has really come about in the second half of 2021 is ethereum just got so successful so quickly uh the eth price went from like six hundred dollars in January of 2021 to four thousand three hundred dollars six months later uh and then it took a big crash but in whatever um the and there's this very very strong incentive in the world of crypto for people people want people obviously uh think that crypto is where you get rich really really quickly that's kind of what people think of our industry from the external from the outside in and when people look at this the insane success that ethereum has had they want to emulate that success they want to mimic that success people want to get in on the ground floor of something and i definitely think that incentive is one of the reasons why there's so many newer layer ones out there is just because they incentivize so much um just new new users to come into their new ecosystem because it's brand new and something that i think concerns me vitalic about the possibility of one single dominant rollup on ethereum is that that if if that happens instead of many many many rollups on ethereum then that concentrates wealth into that one single rollup where there could have been five ten fifteen twenty rollups each with their own token each with their own ecosystem that allowed so many people to get in on the ground floor of something that kind of answers to people's desire to you know kind of get uh have exposure to the the growth of these ecosystems and this is definitely what been some of the the one of the big themes of the end of 2021 is people users both want cheap blocks but they also want to get in on the ground floor of something um how do you think is that just like a big wrench that gets thrown in the gears of trying to make a decentralized system or how do you like tussle with this this incentive that users have to always adopt something else yeah i mean i think like users wants to get on the ground floor but then users also wants stability right like if you have a system whose entire legitimacy is based on the idea that this is a system that's uh where you can come in and still be early then you're just setting yourself up to be replaced by the next cycle's version of the thing that let's you get on the ground floor and be early um so but and and then if you want to build something that lasts right then like you want to build something on a base layer that has a long history of last day and that you know is going to last for and be relevant for a long time going into the future i'm so the this kind of hybrid vision where like if there am is the thing that lasts a long time and where you just keep having more layer two rollups uh pop up like it is an interesting hybrid approach right because like there is something that you can still get on the ground floor of and there even is something that might be able to have more activist approaches to token issuance for example like if you look at say optimism's approach of uh retroactive public goods funding um that big that they're up to sending their returns action fees into um that is um like you basically get both that and you get the base layer that lasts a long time and i think that is a combination that is uh really powerful and you're right that is not a combination that you get if you have a theory and with a dominant rollup and in the long term it's not even a combination that you get inside one of these uh alternative layer ones whose uh marketing pitch is being on the ground floor today right because like 10 years from now their marketing pitch is not going to be you're on the ground floor um and so looking at what's going to happen 10 years from now right like what's the ecosystem and like it's not about what is the ecosystem that let's people get on the ground floor today it's about what is an ecosystem that ensures that there is space for ground floors to appear 10 years from now um and uh like an ecosystem that allows for some some kind of room for borrowers and it's pretty much the only way to do that between the two versions of Ethereum's rollup future where there's one dominant rollup versus many many many rollups if to in your own opinion is one more desirable it feels like the the single rollup one is more convenient for users but the second one is like healthier in some important way um right like it's more fragile more future proof there's more opportunity for things to improve if if uh the uh is a thing approach goes bad for some reason whereas the first one is like you know if you can make something that looks like Ethereum but it supports 10,000 TPS then like you know in the short term that is a huge amount of convenience but Talik we've talked about so much on this podcast thank you for spending the time the Ethereum roadmap uh alternative layer ones and and the endgame for all of these systems and and that is incredibly important i think we want to end the podcast sort of where we started but on the flip side where we asked about your your reflections on on the previous year uh now i find myself kind of reflecting on the next decade and wondering like um i i think uh you tweeted this that this meme a year ago or so about the weird 20s right 2020s and now we're 10% of the way through the weird 2020 so 10% of the way through this decade and like i for one i think everyone listening want to avoid wars global chaos all of the things that we're seeing kind of the news cycle as as potentials want to start solving some of the big problems in our world that just remain unsolved by the existing legacy institutions um also i feel like this need to make sure we don't just descend into this digital dystopia that uh peers all around us in various forms do you think crypto has a role to play in the 2020s and preventing some of the worst outcomes and maybe helping to usher in some of the best possibilities i think it really does um i think uh you know there definitely is this really important to need for um some kind of alternative to centralized institutions right um because like we're entering into a world where like it's not disintermediation it's hyperintermediation right like every transaction like has like goes up to having lots of different actors that are in the middle and a hyperintermediated centralized world is a world that can easily become dystopian right because if there are like five different pressure points that i can lean on to stop a transaction between you and david then like that's really friendly for anyone who wants to stop things from happening because all they have to do is just lean on any one of those five um yeah but so if we want to have a future with the kind of intermediation that's necessary to you know get the efficiency and all the good things that we want out of the 21st century then like there needs there need to be some form of the like intermediaries that cannot be corrupted that easily and that i think is what blockchain provide it is what decentralized networks provide um and like it's it's not just theory right like this is something that i think in a lot of different ways people do recognize as a reality right like lots of people you know they've built startups on top of twitter and facebook and then twitter and facebook shut down those APIs and their startups are gone in the day um you know i mentioned urgency and i like people there definitely understand a lot that you know sometimes the local fiat currency really can't be trusted and uh now maybe your local fiat currency in your country is uh is fine today but but it might not be fine tomorrow and if it's not and just in case it's not fine tomorrow then you know you might want to actually have some kind of alternative um if uh no if you're engaged in um international transactions then um you know you you definitely don't want something that goes through like all five intermediaries that that that consists of all five of you know the world's major geopolitical actors because uh you know maybe at one or more of those actors have a very different ideas about what kind of transactions deserve deserve to be allowed to exist than you do um so that is basically um you know moving away from is uh this kind of world where um into hyper intermediation turns into like hyper choke pointization and uh toward a world where these intermediaries can turn into something that is really empowering is something that i think is really necessary but in order to have that kind of world you know blockchains have to actually be decentralized blockchains have to um actually be credibly neutral and blockchains have to actually scale right so that the blockchain can actually provide those benefits uh in practice and not just in theory and i do think that we have a rogue um a rogue map to make that happen and i do think that there are a lot of people who are working really hard to and uh doing a better and better job of executing on making that rogue map happen um so i'm very excited to see what the the future is going to bring five or ten years from now there you go crypto has made me more optimistic about the world as well so it's decentralization and uh so if you in today's episode vitalic thank you so much for uh joining us on bankless thank you too guys a few action items for you today we always leave you with these the first says you can view that diagram of the ethereum road map that i was referencing in this podcast we discussed with vitalic there'll be a link in the show notes also take a look at some of the articles that we mentioned uh in the podcast as well the endgame article is one uh there's a self-destruct article mentioned those will be included in the show notes we also have some previous podcasts with vitalic on bankless an episode on legitimacy an episode on coin voting and a few others we will include in the show notes guys as always risks and disclaimers none of this has been financial advice theorem is risky so is crypto so is defy all of it is you could lose what you put in but we are headed west this is the frontier it's not for everyone but we're glad you're with us on the bankless journey thanks a lot hey we hope you enjoyed the video if you did head over to bankless hq right now to develop your crypto investing skills and learn how to free yourself from banks and gain your financial independence we recommend it joining our daily newsletter podcast and community as a bankless premium subscriber to get the most out of your bankless experience you'll get access to our market analysis our alpha leaks and exclusive content and even the bankless token for airdrops raffles and unlocks if you're interested in crypto the bankless community is where you want to be click the link in the description to become a bankless premium subscriber today also don't forget to subscribe to the channel for in-depth interviews with industry leaders ask me anything and weekly rollups where we summarize the week in crypto and other fantastic content thanks everyone for watching and being on the journey as we build out the bankless nation