Today, we're talking about the State of Crypto with Eddy Lazzarin, the CTO of a16z Crypto.
The 2023 a16z Crypto Report was published last week and discussed a number of topics, including developer activity, transaction volume, users, and so much more.
What are the best insights as we look forward to the rest of the year?
------ 📣 SAFE (Gnosis) | Non-Technical Hackathon Sign-up!! https://bankless.cc/AA
------ BANKLESS SPONSOR TOOLS:
⚖️ ARBITRUM | SCALING ETHEREUM https://bankless.cc/Arbitrum
🐙KRAKEN | MOST-TRUSTED CRYPTO EXCHANGE https://bankless.cc/kraken
🧠 AMBIRE | SMART CONTRACT WALLET https://bankless.cc/Ambire
👻 PHANTOM | FRIENDLY MULTICHAIN WALLET https://bankless.cc/phantom-waitlist
🦊METAMASK LEARN | HELPFUL WEB3 RESOURCE https://bankless.cc/MetaMask
------ Resources:
2023 State of Crypto Report https://a16zcrypto.com/content/article/state-of-crypto-report-2023/
----- Not financial or tax advice. This channel is strictly educational and is not investment advice or a solicitation to buy or sell any assets or to make any financial decisions. This video is not tax advice. Talk to your accountant. Do your own research.
Disclosure. From time-to-time I may add links in this newsletter to products I use. I may receive commission if you make a purchase through one of these links. Additionally, the Bankless writers hold crypto assets. See our investment disclosures here: https://www.bankless.com/disclosures
No summary for this episode yet.
We're talking about the state of crypto in the year of our Lord 2023. That's right now. How are we doing in crypto David a report came out last week that was absolutely fantastic. This is a report from a 16 Z. What are we covering today? The a 16 Z crypto report for 2023. These reports come out to as snapshot snapshots for the state of the industry, the state of the ecosystem. Where are we in crypto's development in 2023? I remember Ryan one of these reports, not too dissimilar from the report that we are going through today came out in 2019 and talked about similar metrics, developer activity, transaction volume, users and it was one of the things that I remember way back when in 2019 or 2018 that allowed me to have conviction in what was a dark time in the world of crypto.
It was a bear market. It was a challenging bear market and sometimes these reports are really useful to remind us about the secular bull market that almost all metrics are about crypto. They're up and to the right no matter what you want to look at. This is a way and it's also important to remind ourselves who this audience is for this report is. It's actually not for the crypto industry. It's for everyone else. I'd say this is a way to view the industry from the outside in using some very fundamental metrics to tell the rest of the world, hey, I know 2022, I was a bad look for crypto. But if you look under the hood and look below the narratives and all of the hate that crypto has, the metrics are up and to the right.
So that is what we are going to into today. Yeah. Totally. We've got a guest who's helped write this that we're going to introduce in just a minute. Before we do, we've got to tell them about our friends and sponsors over at NOSIS SAFE. David, what is NOSIS SAFE want bankless listeners to know? First, I'll drop it a meme where they actually would like to let you know that they want you to drop NOSIS. It's now just SAFE. SAFE. Yeah. So SAFE is the brand new account abstraction SDK and stack out of NOSIS that the product is now called SAFE. And so this is if you want to build in the world of account abstraction and smart contract wallets, they have produced an SDK for you along with some APIs and some cool other things to allow your developer activities to be seamless and easy.
Not only that, but they are having an online hackathon starting on May 1st. And this hackathon is actually specifically to enable non technical types. If you are a marketer, a communicator, a presenter, or some others form of non technical devs, a the May 1st hackathon being thrown by NOSIS all around account abstraction is for you. So there is a link in the show notes. If you want to get started building with account abstraction, building with SAFE, accessing their SDK, all of those links in the show notes are available to you. This is one of those core primitives that is so important underlying wallet infrastructure for sure.
And of course, the SAFE is the we use, I'm not going to call it NOSIS SAFE, we use SAFE at bankless all the time. It is our you're trusted wallet for everything that we do at bankless. It's our on chain presence at bankless over at bankless.eats. So this is this is a really important David. Let's talk about the guest who are we are about to bring on. So who are we about to bring on and what's the significance of this episode? Eddie laser in the CTO over at a 16 Z is multidisciplinary and we'll get into a little bit of background when we bring him on to the show in just a little bit, but psychology major, which gets me going philosophy major, masters in computer science.
And so I think he's going to be able to help us express some of the things that are going on in the crypto world that we're about to see in some of these charts that like I said are going up into the right in ways that the rest of the world can understand. But these are also going to be charts that you are probably familiar with. Like I said, transaction count and FT buyers, stablecoin volume, developer activity. All of these things are going to allow us to get a snapshot in time of crypto in 2023. And also this is the second report of this kind that a 16 Z has created, which only eludes to the fact that there might be a third for 2024.
And so we're going to pick Eddie's brain about what might be in that 2024 report when it gets made in one of yours time. Absolutely. This is going to be an episode about the state of crypto right now. And then what we can look forward to in 2024 and what some of the big opportunities might be. Guys, we're going to get right to the episode. But before we do, we want to thank the sponsors who made this possible, including our number one recommended crypto exchange, the bridge from fiat to crypto cracking or check him out. Cracking has been a leader in the crypto industry for the last 12 years dedicated to accelerating the global adoption of crypto.
Cracking puts an emphasis on security, transparency and client support, which is why over 9 million clients have come to love Cracking's products. Whether you're a beginner or a pro, the Cracking UX is simple, intuitive, and frictionless, making the Cracking app a great place for all to get involved and learn about crypto. For those with experience, the redesigned Cracking Pro app and web experience is completely customizable to your trading needs, integrating key trading features into one seamless interface. Cracking has a 24-7 365 client support team that is globally recognized. Cracking support is available wherever, whenever you need them by phone, chat, or email.
And for all of you NFTers out there, the brand new Cracking NFT beta platform gives you the best NFT trading experience possible, rarity rankings, no gas fees, and the ability to buy an NFT straight with cash. Does your crypto exchange prioritize its customers the way that Cracking does? And if not, sign up with Cracking at Cracking.com slash bankless. Bankless is launching the bankless token hub. At bankless, we've been studying the crypto markets ever since 2017, and all of our research has led us to this. The token hub. You're a one-stop shop for alpha to help you navigate through the crypto markets.
Have you ever wished for a trusted resource that would share their thoughts, ratings, and their opinions about tokens? Boy, do we have the product for you. The bankless token hub is where we provide bankless citizens with the alpha and the hottest tokens in crypto. We do the research, so you don't have to. The bankless token hub includes the token ratings, where our team shares their research and outlook on the hottest tokens in crypto. Also the token hub includes bankless bags, our own internal investment club. Bankless bags is where we put our money where our mouth is, and for the bankless power user out there, you can access the analyst team 24-7 inside the bankless nation discord.
You can ask them questions and learn from a group of people deep in the weeds of crypto investing. The last feature of the token hub is the ability to upvote or downvote token ratings. The bankless token hub lets you learn from your fellow citizens to rate these tokens yourselves. The bankless token hub is launching right now, and has already been beta tested by your fellow bankless citizens. So stay tuned in the bankless discord for updates, and if you're not a bankless citizen, well, you better sign up if you want access, because this corner of bankless is available for citizens only. I'll see you in the discord.
If you haven't yet experienced the superpowers that a smart contract wall it gives you, check out Ambiere. Ambiere works with all the EVM chains, the layer 2s like Arbitram, Optimism and Polygon, but also the non-ethereum ecosystems like avalanche and phantom. Ambiere lets you pay for gas and stablecoins, meaning you'll never have to spend your precious eth again. And if you like self-custody, but you still want training rails, you can recover a lost Ambiere wallet with an email and password, but without giving the Ambiere team control over your funds. The Ambiere wallet is coming soon for both iOS and Android, and if you want to be a beta tester, Ambiere is airdropping their wallet token for simply just using the wallet.
You can sign up at Ambiere.com, and while you're there, sign up for the web app wallet experience as well. So thank you, Ambiere, for pushing the frontier of smart contract wallets on Ethereum. Bankless nation, I want to introduce you to Eddie Lazer and the CTO of A16Z Crypto, overseeing the engineering research and security teams over A16Z and, like Ryan and I, Eddie's interest span across many disciplines, with a bachelor's in philosophy neuroscience neuroscience and psychology, along with a master's in computer science, wow, must have taken you a while, Eddie, we're going to go see what all that very background can do while we unpack the world of A16Z2023 Crypto Report.
Eddie, welcome to the show. Thank you. Yeah, so how long did that background take you? I took a lot of classes every semester. It took me four and a half years, actually. I think every summer. Yeah, no, no, no, just very anxious to take classes. Eddie, like I alluded to in the beginning, anytime we get one of these ecosystem reports out, they're just really valuable to give us a snapshot where we are in time. Crypto often is so frequently tunnel visioned into the week by week meta, right? Like last week, it was Chappelleau week. This week, it's Gary Gensler getting roasted week. But we never actually really have the opportunity to zoom all the way back out and really see the health and vitality or lack of vitality of the ecosystem as a whole.
And so like I said in 2018, there was one of these in 2019, there's one of these. So I want to ask you, just before we go into the more granular details of this report, what about this 2023 report is unique? How is this one flavored? What's the flavor of 2023? Yeah, well, crypto is a very social media phenomenon, right? And that's what leads to that extremely short cadence meta, right? I don't know that social media, I don't know that crypto could have happened without social media in the same way. So that is intrinsic to its character. But in 2023 specifically, it's a unique time, right? Crypto was huge the last 18 months, the biggest it's ever been by basically all measures.
We saw a huge variety of products, new applications and experiments, and a huge number of upgrades. And now we're in a unique time because the macro is a little weird, the regulatory climate is a little bit weird, we're in the denuma, right, of the previous highs. And that just puts it in a new type of setting. Some people might say, crypto is over, it's dead if they just look at the prices. But the whole point of the report, the whole thesis is that there are financial cycles and there are product cycles. And although financial cycles are volatile, connected with the macro, unpredictable, a whole phenomenon of themselves, product cycles are a little bit more predictable.
They're not totally predictable, but you can watch them unfold and you can see the specific milestones as technological progress compounds. That's what we invest in as long-term tech investors. And so the purpose of the report is to remind us in this climate, all these crazy things have happened last year, where is the tech actually and are there public indicators that we can look at, like open data sets that we can look at, that help us put them into their context, their technological context as part of the product cycle. Wonderful, beautiful. And one thing I actually haven't mentioned yet is there's actually an output of this report, a product, maybe if you will, of this report, which A16Z is calling the state of crypto index.
And so we're going to go through a handful of different measures of the crypto industry. Like I said, I talked about some before, like active developers, number of contracts deployed, number of NFT buyers, stablecoin volume. And what's interesting and unique about this report is that A16Z has attempted to create an index of what seems to be like industry vitality. So that is at the end of this conversation, because we are going to walk through all the components of that conversation. But first before we get there, just like at a high level, what does it take to produce a report like this, like what's the process like, how do you collect the data, what are the various sources, I'm assuming this is a big lift, can you just like walk us through the back end of like what it takes to produce a report?
Yeah, it is a pretty big lift. We've done a lot more legwork this year than we did last year and we hope to do a lot more legwork next year than we did this year. Maybe I'll put it in its highest frame is that we're a little bit lucky in crypto, maybe not lucky. It's part of the ethos, right? But there's a lot of public open source data sets. That is unique in crypto, whether it's things that are on chain or whether it's open source code or whether it's the reliance on social media where we can, you know, kind of more less look and check the metrics. The key indicators in crypto are open, so that makes it much, much easier.
On the other hand, what makes it harder is that crypto is complex and despite the fact that the data is public, it takes a little bit of teasing and unraveling, you know, you kind of have to get in there into the nodes and figure it out. A lot of data came from, you know, Friday sources, Nonsense, GitHub, Twitter, Dune, you know, a bunch of dashboards that we're familiar with out there, a bunch of new sources like our academic data. That's kind of a cool one of our, one of our innovation indicators is academic publications. We had to build that out from scratch. So a variety of sources, the vast majority of which are public.
All right, so let's go ahead and break open the first slide here. And the first slide already got me really, really excited because anytime somebody uses the words chaos and order, I get pretty, pretty peaked. And this first slide is apparent chaos has underlying order. And I think this is the most zoomed out slide that we could really start with, which I really appreciate. The price, interest, new ideas, start some projects, all going all the way back to 2011 and all of these eros, of course, go up and to the right. And so Eddie, Eddie, why was this such an early slide in the report? Why did this come early?
Yeah, that's, that's a great, that's a great question. This slide is showing a couple things. The first is that although there are financial cycles, like I mentioned earlier, there are product cycles, which we're going to get into, I hope. Even the, the financial cycles and the sort of the most hype metrics and indicators that we can track, if you zoom out on a wide enough time horizon, they're a little bit more orderly than things may seem. And that's because they are slightly, each of these ones, if you're going to each of them like the price, the interest, even the ideas to some extent and maybe slightly or less, the startups, each of these things are side effects of the financial cycle.
So you're going to notice volatility. There's this post we wrote a couple of years ago, feels like yesterday, but also age is now called the price innovation cycle you can go find, where we talk specifically about the relationship between these things, right? The price leads to interest, price changes, price volatility, you know, price going up leads to interest, interest leads to new ideas, new ideas lead to new projects, and then projects develop the products of the future that end up in a long enough time horizon, catalyzing the price, right? Exactly. Yeah, this exact pattern. And I think, you know, if we kind of internalize this and choose some indicators of each of those facets, each of those dimensions of the space, you go back to the, the apparent chaos, chaos is underlying order slides, like if you use certain metrics for proxies for each of these things, then you can see they all move in some kind of step, and I think if you zoom in a little bit more, you can't do that here, but like, you know, if you're a, if you were to kind of zoom in, you'd see that there is, there is a little bit of a leading indicator property of price, there is a little bit of a leading indicator property and interest with relating to new ideas, and so on and so forth.
It's not an ultra scientific analysis, but this pattern has been true in tech in general. And it's particularly true in crypto, where I think there is a more volatile financial cycle, which we can talk about some of the reasons why, but it's a general property of technological change and technological revolutions. Eddie, I want to ask you about the kind of the, the product cycle versus the finance, the financial cycle, the price cycle, right? But before we get there, just really quick on what's in front of us. So we obviously were measuring price here, and you guys are also saying the market has undergone four cycles.
These are like boom bust cycles, right? And that pattern persists across each of these metrics. And certainly anybody who's been in crypto and like zoomed out on the charts has seen that reflected, those cycles reflected in the price total crypto market cap over time, which is how you guys are measuring it. We've peaked at like three trillion in this latest cycle. I suppose was that the fourth cycle then, and now we're entering the fifth. Is that right, Eddie? It was definitely the fourth, whether we're entering the fifth, I have to, I must, I must not be ready to say yet, but let's, let's talk about that maybe in a little bit.
Anyway, we have price, and that has had boom bust for different cycles, at least, then we have a measure of interest, which you guys are measuring by social media activity. Is this like all social media platforms like in this case, it's Twitter, although using like crypto specific, like crypto unique words, like, you know, Ethereum would be one example where like people don't really use the word Ethereum, I'm like non-aetherium context, right? Right. Whereas like token, token is a word that's used in a lot of different cases. So we wouldn't count that word. It's just less precise. Okay. Okay.
So we have a measure of interest and then new ideas that is developer activity, which I think people, you're analyzing get hubs, you're seeing how many developers are contributing to that kind of a metric. And then we have a measure for funding activity. And is that the raw amount of like dollars value that is flowing to crypto startups in both private markets and kind of like more public token markets? Is that correct? It's, it's the number of rounds, funding rounds. For rounds. Okay. That's interesting. Some startup raises the series a, that would be one here. Uh-huh. Okay. And each one unit, not any amount of like dollar value, just one unit of, oh my gosh.
Wow. Why do you do that? Why is it just like kind of one unit? Why not dollar? Um, out. Well, the dollar amount is further magnifies the price issue, right? Right. It's if there's capital markets have their own pricing. So you would kind of intermingle the price characteristic. It would be redundant. It would be, it would be a little bit of a, you want a nice clean metric of funding activity, which is just kind of the number of rounds that are happening. Yeah. Although it, to be fair, I think if you were to do it with price, it would look more or less the same. Like the total rate. Yeah. Right.
Which is, that's what we're seeing across all of these different metrics is kind of these, these cycles that sort of mirror one another. And what we're seeing also is a compound annual growth rate, a cager, uh, for price of 75 percent compound annual growth rate for price, uh, from inception up till now, social media activity has been 60, three percent, uh, developer activity has been 84 percent compound annual growth rate and startups and projects like the funding activity we're just talking about has been 62 percent compound annual growth rate. So all similar numbers across these, these various metrics, that has to be no coincidence.
Good question. Who knows? I mean, we certainly didn't select them that way. Um, yeah. I mean, I'd have to speculate. Well, let me ask you this. So, um, we've got the finance cycles, which people are most familiar with. And then we got product cycles, which are making distinction. That's what this report is really, uh, uncovering. Yeah. In my mind, you tell me if this is, um, if this makes sense to you, Eddie, it's like sometimes when we talk about crypto investors, people are like laser focused on, oh, that means somebody who is buying an asset, right? That's right. Something that's affecting price.
But there are also other types of investors and crypto aren't there. So if I am a user choosing to invest my time on a crypto on D5, for example, or in an NFT, for example, that is like a time investment from a user and is another type of investment of attention or time or something like this. And also similarly, developers, when they are choosing where to spend their career, isn't that the most precious, precious investment that they can actually make? Like what tech stack am I going to dedicate my career in? Where am I going to extend all of my energy and all of my, my skills? Developers and users are types of investors too.
And so what we're seeing is it's just like different types of investors that are non, non-financial investments. It's kind of like time, attention, human, human resource type of investments. Is that how A16Z and this report sort of looks at them as just these are also other investors? The more broad, you know, the generous interpretation of investing, I'll go with it, right? Like I believe that when developers decide that they want to do a thing, whether it's just because it's fun and exciting or whether it's because they think that their career, you know, could be built on this. That to me is a really strong sign, right?
And that's what like you go to Chris's thesis many years ago about how what, what the nerds are doing on the weekend, right, is what regular people are going to do on the weekday, you know, in the future, right? I believe that because I think when people have time and attention to dedicate, it ends up attracting to the powerful things, to the exciting things, to the new things. So I definitely take that as a, as a strong indicator. I'd say that developer activity, if you look at it as like a supply chain or something like that, we metabolize it as a supply chain. Developer interest and developer activity is upstream of all the exciting things.
That's why it's a preoccupation for the space and it's incredibly important for us, right? We, we track that we're always listening to what entrepreneurs say they're excited by what they want to be building on, what tools they want to be using, which ecosystems they're attracted to. That's an incredibly key indicator. We use it scientifically like well, pseudo scientific whatever scientifically like in this kind of context, we also use it anecdotally. Just what we're hearing developers are interested in and engineers are interested in. Is there the ones we're going to produce the applications that end up being used by far, far, far more people?
Developers are like the talent inflows into these networks, aren't they? Absolutely. It's sort of like we're talking right before we started the stream at about different cities in the US that seem to be attracting kind of crypto talent New York City versus the Bay Area San Francisco. And these are all sort of networks that individual people choose to live in for some set of reasons, right? Whether it's economic opportunity or they just like the scene in the community, they're really investing. The city you choose to live in or the area you choose to live in is really one of the most important investments that you're making.
And this is very similar to how you know what a tech stack developer decides to spend their time and it's like picking the city that they're going to live in. Totally agree. And we could spend some time unpacking the city metaphor, which I think that there's a lot to actually that is actually how I think about crypto ecosystems, cities, nations, like organic groups. And there's a difference right there's a difference between a city and like a strip mall, you know, or a city and like a. You know, there's any world right there's a huge difference and that's because and cities are worth a serious economic activity happens and that's because people can control the space they can come in and really own something.
And they can build on top of it on top of a solid foundation, a foundation that they can fundamentally control that property that is the property that I think makes crypto distinct as a platform as a computing platform like that specifically that property. So if if you extend that metaphor all the way through, then if you want to track the health of the city, you want to track the health of the nation, how many people are coming in and settling new territory, how many people are investing in terms of their time and building the infrastructure and the businesses and the, you know, interconnects all the infrastructure, all the types of things that are necessary for real economic activity.
How many people are doing that when I see the developers metrics, that's what I feel like I'm interpreting. Yeah, and I want to get your perspective as to why developers tend to be so sticky in this industry. There's just one slide slide 35 on this report ball markets attract new developers who tend to stick around. And this is a measure of active developers in the web three space if we go back all the way to 2016 it looks like we had somewhere around six or seven thousand of them. And according to this slide according to this report, it peaked all the way up to almost 40,000 they height in 2022 it's come down to just below 30,000 where we are today.
But developers tend to be pretty sticky in crypto now. I don't actually know any how this compares to other industries. I don't know if developers are more mercenary in other industries, but what you were talking about just now that like, you know, Ethereum and FT's tokens and not sovereign state money like gives developers more ownership over the things that they're tinkering with, which is my initial like reflex as to the answer to the question why developers are so sticky in this industry. If they actually are, but I'm wondering if you have a perspective on there are developers as sticky as I'm saying that I as I'm saying they are.
It's a yeah, it's a great question. I'd love to compare it with other with other spaces. I know that speaking very generally before I say, you know, specific things about crypto engineers do love their programming languages. They do love their tools. They do love their, you know, their specializations and that in itself creates incredible stickiness. That's why programming languages, for example, have some of the greatest network effects in all of tech, even though they aren't directly monetized usually they're an incredibly incredibly sticky type of thing and developers are excited almost by, you know, just seeing that a specific programming language is used in a new context.
Is it like a crypto tribe, but for languages, is that a way to think about it? Well, yeah, I think there, I think there is that and I'll say just, you know, in my day to day, I talked to a lot of software engineers who are working in crypto and something I've got to say is pretty unique is that software engineers in crypto by and large of fast, fast, fast majority. I'm actually, I don't even know why I'm hedging because I'm just hedging because I'm cautious like that. They, they get it like their crypto native right there, they're die hard like they're there for the mission they understand the reach that is a unique property that I did not really encounter in my career before getting into crypto.
Interesting there's another slide here that I had up here verified smart contracts are an all time high indicating robust pipeline of product launches and this is a graph of verified smart contracts which was around maybe the 2000 mark in the 2019 to 2020 era and then has just been on a linear up trend all the way up to breaking 30,000. So what does this tell you what story does this weave for you? Yeah, this is I take this to be distinct from just smart contract deployments right smart contract deployments you can do all the time there's it's part of the development process. When you're verifying them it means something slightly different right it means you intend other people to look at it.
You want other people to look at this code right for some reason or or or other that in that is an additional barrier to cross right the minimum barrier is you you can actually rearrange some of the metrics in this like a funnel must write for developers. The minimum is just you start a repo and get up. All that means is that you have a good account or something like that you come in you see an interesting thing you start a level further is you download you know web three jazz or ethers. Because that means you're actually experimenting you actually you want to start tooling around something. Another level beyond that I'm skipping a couple steps but is deploying a smart contract and having it verified.
That means you actually build something and that means you wanted some other people to read the code and to be able to use it and in the best case you know remix and recombine it in a production system. So I see these as like gradually narrowing levels of commitment evidence that people are actually trying things. If we could go to our like our city metaphor here and we are like the mayor or the economic development office of some city and we're taking a look at these numbers here and the two numbers that that we just saw one is the amount of developers in the space. This is almost if you're using a city metaphor this is almost like the number of entrepreneurs that are in our city and we can kind of track the increase in our city network of the number of entrepreneurs over time and then the number of verified smart contracts maybe that's like the number of new businesses that have just opened for office.
It's kind of that type of metric here and that's really what we're tracking and so if we want the GDP of our city to actually increase what we're seeing is kind of the ingredients for GDP explosion or at least sustainable growth when we see more entrepreneurs than ever inside of our city and more businesses than ever being being open these are all very healthy signs for our city network. How does that analogy land to you? Yeah, I think that's exactly right. I mean it's of course it's they're not exact analogs but that's the exact idea right is that you're never going to see economic growth from the city without seeing these indicators first right and these indicators change at different different cadence they develop at a different cadence.
Right financial markets can move very, very quickly. Someone just needs to move a little bit of capital around that's all there is to it. It is not that quick unless you're trying to game the metric of course like it's possible to game specific metrics it's always a thing to look at but you have to. Each of the steps to get down this funnel are more complex they're more complex and they're indicative in my opinion of goal behavior goal seeking behavior these are people want to build stuff they want to build products. Yeah, I think that the another point I'd make is this is at a time of course we are in a crypto bear market and as David was mentioning earlier in you know in 2019 we saw similar metrics from these I think many put out by a 16 Z at that time when everyone around us was telling us crypto was dead right some of the some of the settlers in these crypto networks.
So the investors in the crypto networks are saying this doesn't look dead if you look at the number of developers who are here in the space and the number of new businesses new verified smart contracts that are being open. This feels very much alive if you're just looking at one metric and that is price and you're seeing you know 90% off all time highs that can be a very deceiving metric. So when I when I joined the crypto team in 2019 it was pretty you know pretty dead around then people that I knew were asking me like I thought I thought Bitcoin ended. I thought Bitcoin's over right like they because they had heard that it had like crashed right crash like a price crash and then they had understood that as like a software crash like it had kind of like the network had stopped.
And I was hearing that on the one side and the other side as I was getting like deeper and deeper into crypto and spending more time more and more of my I've been crypto for a long time but I was spending you know 80% of my time thinking about it. And I'm hearing about you know swap I'm hearing about compound I'm hearing about maker right you guys remember that time period. I was like I'm hearing about the crazy stuff I've ever heard in crypto at the same time that people are asking me of this things over and it just became very clear to me in that moment that the price is one thing. And the product is another thing that prices are spectacular they're easy to look at they are you know a clear easy to comprehend number price down bad price up good right it's like monkey brain stuff.
When the course the reality underneath the surface is more convoluted more complex more nuanced but probably more signal than the noise. I want to jump back to a similar theme from our very very first slide that we talked about with these macro trends so this is that this slide that I want to show next is actually just this slide below this one but I think this brings us back into a price conversation. Where like I really like the sprite prices spectacular that that spectacular word is is great for that particular that particular metaphor this this next slide is great products guilt get built regardless of financial upswings and downswings and so I think that really carries us next what you're saying were.
Man maker maker Dow was a really just a magical moment I just minted money meanwhile like like you said I had what that same experience where like someone I said I work in the crypto industry and they're like oh big coin is that the thing that's failing right now and so like. Can you walk us through the importance of this slide because I think much of these logos that we're seeing on the screen here which are logos of companies that were founded from 1999 all the way up to where we are today. Yep you're saying this slide is to say like hey innovation happens no matter where we are in the price price doesn't matter can you walk us through the importance of this slide yeah look look at like I'm sure you guys remember 2009 one of the most brutal economic mark micro macro economic markets we've ever been in.
Who doesn't know all those companies who doesn't follow all those companies right for the podcast listener out here we around the 2009 era we got square WhatsApp Uber Instagram stripe also Bitcoin Airbnb Snapchat shortly thereafter zoom shortly thereafter yeah lots of stuff yeah lots lots of stuff and that's because. Even though some may have thought it was crazy to start startups in that time period the reason why each of those companies was found that at that time was because the technology was finally ready. That is the underlying story right we see a bunch of like photo based applications around that time period video based applications you know modern web stack applications mobile specific applications that was like the dawn of iPhone and the mobile computing platform right the reason they were founded at that time and not earlier and not later.
Is because they were founded as soon as the technology was ready. I had nothing to do with a financial cycle Eddie are you saying that. It's actually the best time to invest not financial advice of course is when everyone else thinks the thing is dead but you see underlying life in the product and the technology seems ready. I could never give financial advice in any any such that's that's not my that's not my. Never happened on this show it would be yeah but I'd say you know to be greedy when people are fearful right. I want to jump forward to to this slide slide 23 for the people who might be following along the world's biggest brands are exploring web three beginning with NFTs and then I'll also jump backwards this slide NFT creators have earned.
More than 1.9 billion in royalty revenues and that also reminds me of the one of the first slides that we actually talked about which goes back to the interest in social media activity. Well Eddie you said you probably weren't looking at the word token in Twitter I bet you were looking at the word or phrase NFT on Twitter because we're where else are you going to find that word NFT so. Can I walk us through this story the NFT story and also the brand story as the word NFT is probably lost its its spectacularness to mainstream. David NFTs are dead. Yeah that's what I heard so Eddie walk us through this part of the story.
Yeah well we'll we'll get to it but there's another slide in here that's that's great I don't know if it's near excerpts but the NFT buyers slide. Right so kind of for the down I think taking the NFT buyers slide and the royalty slide in both contexts is really really useful NFT buyers definitely down. But down a lot less than I think one would expect it's definitely down a lot less than I expected when we were. Is this saying this chart is saying after expected number of NFT buyers so this is a chart of the number of NFT buyers and we hit something close to like 1.4 million total NFT buyers at the high in 2022 is that what that's saying.
Monthly active addresses purchasing NFTs that's actually higher. So we have a 1.4 million people buy an NFT inside of one month in 2022 is strictly and 1.4 million unique addresses which would be a little difficult to map on to users but like approximate. It's difficult but it's approximate because you have you know some users with many addresses of course but then you have some addresses that sort of account for many users if somebody's using a multi-sig as kind of their you know NFT storehouse. But that was 1.4 million which is larger than I thought and now we are actually like what is this 700 below a million call it below a million that's not down so bad.
Yeah it's not it's not as down as much as I think and but of course you know your original question is framed in terms of the royalties the royalties are way down. And so I'd say what's what's happening with NFTs well NFTs are in the earliest state right there in fact this may be an interesting segue to something else I will try to remember but the NFTs are really simple right now and NFT royalties are really simple. Transfer based royalties are the first time we've tried some kind of economic model to link secondary sales to the authors of those collections. There's going to be a lot of experimentation a lot of contention around what the best royalty models are the evidence right now is that the take rates are shrinking for NFT based royalties and of course I'm putting aside like marketplace competition between like you open sea and blur and others.
So the royalty slide I think shows like there was a huge burst of NFT creator royalties they're down a bit but I expect a lot of experimentation to figure out the best way to link communities interested in collections and the creators of this collection so like that's kind of like what I would say about this slide in terms of the brands it's always interesting to me you know I never really. I never really know exactly what to think I have talked with some of these myself and without naming names like some have definitely impressed me with their crypto nativeness some not as much but in general like brands tend to follow the heat and some can successfully capitalize on it in ways it's impressive.
I'd say that in general I think of the brands as sort of a lagging indicator of development in the space but they are an indicator that there's excitement that there's potential product market fit. It's not something to rest your laurels on right you should. It means that there's we've started to reach some product market fit in some aspects of the products. If they are lead if they're following us that's great and we need to continue to lead or else they will stop following us absolutely it just it means that they there's something that they get there's something that they like there's something that they want right otherwise they wouldn't do all this work.
It doesn't mean that it's done it means that we need to understand what that is and continue to build the infrastructure to make it more accessible. Right we are not passing on the baton of responsibility on taste Starbucks and reddit that still remains in the hands of the developers but it's good signal that we are at least leading them in their right direction at least hopefully. Yep. So I want to go back up to one of the earlier slides here and I'll collect a bunch of them there are some Ethereum focus slides here blockchain extending roll ups are scaling Ethereum. If you go back to the middle of 2021 we basically had 0% of Ethereum layer one block space that were consumed by layer two's now we are up to 7% one quarter into 2023 along with an increasingly exponential you know.
So it's only so much data but an increasingly exponential rate of a blockchain block space and then there's another slide here blockchain transactions exploded as scaling technologies reduce transaction fees and so this is a chart of total unique transactions going what it looks like basically a floor of zero by comparison in 2020 up to. Over a billion transactions and then now also simultaneously Ethereum now consumes point zero zero one percent of the energy that consumes versus YouTube consuming energy annually and so. All of these slides came pretty close together in the report Eddie and so I want to actually ask you about like again this report i'm assuming is is made for the crypto outsiders so they come in and they see a slide about scaling and energy consumption talk about this this angle of the report and what is really meant to do.
Yeah so a bunch of things one is evidence that it's actually scaling right Ethereum is actually scaling and paving the way for other types of blockchain solutions to scale. That is an incredible incredibly important thing right so this actually we can actually spend a long time talking about this i'm going to try to keep really short but. I think scaling is like a perfect kind of like midwit diagram to me right like the the left side they're like blockchain so slow need more transactions need more block space right. The midwits might argue like no what's the point it's never going to reach centralize scale or like you know there's no applications or something like that.
And whereas I think the top says like we need more block space like things need to needs to scale and the reason for that is that. We could touch any area in this report any area in this entire report and I could tell you at least a few ideas that i've heard from entrepreneurs or engineers in the space or they wanted to expand or deepen or make more complex a specific area but they have not even endeavor to because they just know that it wouldn't be economically feasible to do so. Pick an area we can go into it but we need scalability in order for there to be wasteful experimentation and playful experimentation goofy product ideas complicated stuff crazy weird stuff we need that.
We need that and in order to the best evidence that we're getting there that we're setting the stage for whole new waves of experimental applications is showing that there's more throughput and that it's actually happening there's more block space more high quality block space it's unfolding before us that would be kind of the way that I'd sum it all together. Eddie I remember talking to Chris Dixon about the 2022 report and this was just when layer to you cheap block space was was becoming like starting just starting it was a year ago around this time and his comment was this is crypto's broadband moment.
And what i'm sort of seeing on screen here is like it looks like as David was saying number of transactions in the you know i don't know how many this is right at the very bottom it almost looks like it rounds down to zero it's very small and then it just sort of takes off. The number of successful transactions across all truck attract blockchains in 2021 and 2022 and now even Ethereum block space sort of the premium block space is getting even cheaper with layer two is this crypto's broadband moments i'm you guys investing through. Like other internet phases of course where like the internet literally had a broadband moment where before a certain class of applications wasn't possible youtube wasn't possible uber wasn't possible so many things were not possible when we were on dial up modems and then suddenly as broadband infrastructure became widely available people had the fast connections in their homes all sorts of new consumer applications.
And then we went mobile now they were available where we're kind of wherever you were in the world is that what's happening in crypto does that analogy hold yeah that that that's the analogy that i use i think that's exactly right right and i'd say that i think optimistic rollups have been a little slower to unfold than i expected. But i'd say that zero knowledge systems have developed faster than i expected i could give all kinds of qualifications for why it's kind of unfolded exactly the way it's unfolding now. But i think it's a critical prerequisite right i think a lot of people are excited about rolling their own altos a lot of people are thinking about the interoperability solutions between them we're going to get even more scaling with 48 44 as it comes down the the pike i think i do think of it that way i think of it like a.
Like a broadband moment but it's also important to situate all the other types of things that we need right we need a little bit of broadband we also need react right that's that's an interesting one right we need like developer frameworks we need. You know we need whatever the crypto native equivalent is of like forgot my password obviously like there's there's one we need more sophisticated smart contract wall it's account abstraction that type of things improve the user experience i could list off a bunch of things that i think we need and it feels like we're at that precipice it's always a little bit hard to predict exactly but the basic prerequisite building blocks are I think are clear.
When it comes to the idea of having cheap. Block space that developers cannot be worried about the cost so that they can innovate on and an experiment with new things i think that pretty well brings us to a topic of conversation that i want to have which is gaming because i would imagine that gaming. Would produce ample demand for block space but then there's also a few other things in the report as well there's the sad topics the charts that go down into the right. Which are the titled the United States is losing is leading crypto and so this seems to be a theme of the week this week and then there's also the conversation of the index the state of crypto index which is kind of the culmination of all these things so all these topics and more coming right after we talk to some of these fantastic sponsors that make the show possible.
But at least takes the time to define Web 3 specific vocabulary it is still a jargon free experience for the crypto curious user friendly not scary. Metamask Learn is available in 10 languages with more to be added soon and it's meant to cater to a global Web 3 audience. So are you tired of having to explain crypto concepts to your friends go to learn.mentamask.io and add Metamask Learn to your guides to get onboarded into the world of Web 3. And from both builders and users will experience faster transaction speeds with significantly lower gas fees with Arbitrum's recent migration to Arbitrum Nitro it's also now 10 times faster than before.
Visit Arbitrum.io where you can join the community dive into the developer docs bridge your assets and start building your first app with Arbitrum experience Web 3 development the way it was meant to be secure fast cheap and friction free. The Phantom wallet is coming to Ethereum. The number one wallet on Solana is bringing its millions of users and beloved UX to Ethereum and Polygon. If you haven't used Phantom before you've been missing out. Phantom was one of the first wallets to pioneer Solana staking inside the wallet and will be offering similar staking features for Ethereum and Polygon but that's just staking.
Phantom is also the best home for your NFTs. Phantom has a complete set of features to optimize your NFT experience, pin your favorites, hide your uglys, burn this fam and also manage your NFT sale listings from inside the wallet. Phantom is of course a multi chain wallet but it makes chain management easy displaying your transactions in a human readable format with automatic warnings for malicious transactions or phishing websites. Phantom is already saved over 20,000 users from getting scammed or hacked. So get on the Phantom wait list and be one of the first to access the multi chain beta.
There's a link in the show notes or you can go to phantom.app slash wait list to get access in late February. Thank the station we are back with Eddie who's going to walk us through the rest of this very long report. Actually, no, we are still just crashing the surface. I'm just kidding. There are many, many more slides that we are not able to go through. So if you want to get the rest of this report. It is available in the show notes. It is also available at a 16z crypto.com slash date of crypto and we're going to start where we left off with games. And so Eddie, I've slowly been transitioning towards Web 3 gaming crypto gaming not really not just a narrative also a real product.
Sometimes I think I'm always kind of skeptical about things is like, Oh, like Web 3 gaming. That's a great narrative. I'll wait for the game to show up. I'm starting to see some games show up. And so I want to just throw this to use like Web 3 gaming narrative that crypto people are rotating into or actually real demand for block space. Yeah, I'll be really candid. I think it's a little bit of both. There is a narrative component and then there's things are both right. Yeah, there's there's new there's nuance. Here's the part that's narrative is that really good games take a long time to build.
And they're just not going to pop up in like, you know, a year after the story becomes clear. That's just not how it's going to work. I've been working very closely, some great games projects, both in our portfolio and not. And it's just clear to me it takes a really long time like multiple years at a minimum. That's just how game development works. That makes it tough. The positive is that I genuinely believe as a big gamer myself that gaming is exactly the right space to adopt the most interesting parts of crypto, the fastest because you get if you do things right. And I don't just mean making some assets speculative assets as part of a game.
Like that's like not really exciting to be honest to me, like I'm not a huge fan, but if you make if you instead design the game so that it is composable so that it is remixable so that like mods can be permissionlessly integrated with the game without interfering with its underlying game logic. Or if you can make a make it so that people can extend and modify the client without interfering, you know, without making it cheating right without like violating the principles of the game. These are really, really, really interesting areas composable games places where people can interconnect different types of game logic.
I don't mean like item from one world to another. I feel like that's like a little more narrative than it is reality. I mean something more like, you know, I can make a mod on the game and it's a multiplayer game and other people can play in the mod in the same shared world without me having to set up my own server. Right, the mod just changes the game at that moment and it's not cheating and it's not giving me a weird edge because the mod had to adhere to rules that are verified in consensus. Right, I know that that was kind of a lot, but I think it's a whole new type of multiplayer that will be possible.
But again, I say it's going to be a while. It's going to be a couple of years we have a lot to develop like scaling stuff ways that game development tools are like game developers need frameworks. They need things to make things like performance, make graphics work, make make it easy for game designers to develop, you know, compelling game experiences, all that type of things. So I'll kind of leave it at that. I hope that's not too much. I think the gamer and you're definitely coming out because I think a lot of what you're talking about is like fully on chain games online. Absolutely. Okay, EVMs that I think are is like some of the coolest nerd shit that I can really think of that can come out of the crypto world.
And we've been talking about it for years. And I'm like, I think the best thing that came out that was close to this was like the dark forest prototype. But I would imagine that. Yeah, exactly. And the thing is a bunch of very cool projects that's spun out of dark forest and were inspired by dark forest, which is, it's been a while now, like two years since dark forest came out. And they're still trying to figure out how to make it work. It's not because it's impossible. It's just that it's very, very difficult. So I'd say, although I'm in the long run, extremely bullish and excited about the types of fully on chain game experiences we can make.
I wouldn't hold my breath. And it's not going to just come around the prize. I was going to say the same thing. I'm not sure I would want to hold my breath for that. And so I'll throw it back to the question to you that this slide about the state of 2023 and crypto web three games are a huge opportunity to welcome new users to crypto. Where are we on that assuming that this is a curve that hopefully goes up. If we make that implicitly bullish assumption, where are we on that curve? We're still going to be really early, right? I think I think we are, but what we're going to see is different game projects dipping their toes deeper and deeper into the waters, right?
The fully hard core on chain game, everything, but that's a while out because that's as far as I've seen the maximal articulation of that vision, right? There's a whole spectrum of articulations that get us closer and closer and closer. There's going to be a gradual waves of projects that are getting closer. Let's see, like, you know, there's already some obvious benefits that are. There's kind of business reasons why it's clear they're not happening, but take take as an example, like a skin marketplaces, right? Like for CSGO skins and stuff like that, like in a valve's marketplace. I think it's pretty plain and pretty clear that if these were fully on chain, just for trading the skins, there will be a lot of benefits to the users and to major skin traders and collectors, more liquid markets, more competitive pricing, safer systems, less fraud.
It would be a huge improvement, but of course, because like valves game store and skin trading store is centralized, it's really up to them to include it or up to a competitor to try to leapfrog them and to create a new system that has that property as an example. There's obvious ways that crypto can help right now. It's just a little bit complicated to see from a business angle, how it would take place, but I think many will try. So I'm excited to see. I'm a little surprised we haven't seen it yet, Eddie. I mean, honestly, it's like the open marketplaces with with skins that are tradable. Instead, what we actually have in the gaming communities, at least the loud vocal gaming communities is we hate NFTs.
Like we hate for NFTs out of my game. Yeah, well, it's funny because I know a portfolio company of ours did a survey not that long ago that really tried to get at this question and figure out. Like do people do gamers really just hate NFTs and the thing that gamers hate is needless financialization and I'm like I'm one of them like paid or win sucks. But the Diablo 2 Diablo 3 auction house failed, right? Okay, we can go down to like some specific examples, but underneath the hood, if you get into really like what their concerns are. Their survey showed that kind of an equal portion love and hate NFTs and it's less than 10%.
What you really seeing is a very loud minority that hates them. It's surprising. It's not totally. I forgot about that. I've seen that phenomenon. Yeah, so that's like that's a that's a that's a thing. It's a loud minority. In reality, look, if it's done properly, like I just can't I can't see why you wouldn't want it as a gamer. Like if people don't want counter strike skins, they don't need them, right? But the ones who are really into that and really into trading them, they would benefit from a more secure, safer system that gives them more direct ownership over the asset, even though it's.
And what you're saying is what's slowing us down right now is centralization of gaming platforms that are sort of not allowing right now this innovation to leak into their closed ecosystem. So that's it's meant to be an example of a thing that is technically possible now that you could probably do now with a little bit of effort. So we don't need to scale radically to be able to support it in its sort of MVP form, but it depends on incumbents accepting it in so far as it's included into the incumbent systems. What's more likely is probably competitors that come about and have like an interesting distribution model for games, let people, you know, let developers build these features in and use them as part of a native platform.
It's probably just going to be an innovator as opposed to an incumbent. I want to go to the last part of this this PDF is this report, which is the, like I said, the one part that the charts go down into the right speaking of pesky incumbents and this one is titled the US is losing its lead in Web 3 and there are two charts here. percent of crypto developers in the United States started at 40% in 2018 ending at below 30% in here in 2022 and then top crypto website percent of traffic from the United States starting about 2223% in 2018 and now we're down to just above 15% so Eddie what's the story here.
Yeah, we definitely need to go a level deeper, but the story is clear that the US, although there's been general general growth over the last couple of years over this time horizon, if you take this sort of x axis. There's been a lot of growth in crypto developers, but there's proportionately much more growth overseas. I don't know that that's a typical pattern in tech right and it's an unfortunate change of trajectory, I think. I'd have to do a lot more we'd have to do a lot more research and collect a lot more data to figure out exactly what's happening right are like our developers leaving are they stopping working in the US is has it just as the outside US simply accelerated while in US is decelerating right.
It's a little there's a couple different ways that you could see different paths that could explain this type of chart, but either way, I think it's really clear that we need much clearer regulation about around crypto in the US because I get a questions from a lot of engineers asking like, should I move somewhere else like am I taking risk by being in the US like what should I start my company somewhere else to be clear. That comes up a lot. So this is this is the simple fact of the matter is as the as the slide presents the US is losing its lead in web three. That's what the data is showing percentage of crypto developers down percentage of top crypto websites down, but it's almost up to interpretation as to why that's happening.
There are some, you know, I guess ideas we might have around that one on the positive side it might be just mean the rest of the world is really like hitting the pedal of the metal and look this technology has always been about like bank or bank the unbanked right and so so maybe worldwide it's kind of saturating. But at the same time what you are hearing and I think what we feel being the US particularly at this point in time in the last six months is this increasing pressure on crypto basically messages from some of our not all some of our regulators some not all of our lawmakers certainly now it seems like the executive office of the president right now.
That like crypto entrepreneurs aren't exactly welcome in the United States and I want you to contrast that because I know at the a 16 Z has been investing technology for many years in many cycles and you know crypto is just kind of one flavor of of the internet and of like software eating the world which is sort of how I think about the a 16 Z thesis. Just at first as has the US ever been actively aggressive and like pushing technology outside of its borders because I don't recall this in web one in fact it was like the opposite and I also it was the opposite. It was the opposite. It was the opposite now what's happening here.
We as material for all other episode. I think a lot of things have changed without going into like too many dark areas right tech is now where it used to be in the 90s tech was this cute sort of toy it was interesting things were kind of unfolding but a lot of people weren't even sure whether to take seriously take the internet seriously as a competitive product. I don't need to remind you guys about the like Paul Krugman facts machine like you know newspaper cut out right that's how people thought about it right it's kind of hard to regulate a thing to the teeth when you think of it as toy that nerds work on in their garage.
More recently it's become clear that tech isn't profoundly transformative disintermediating force right for some forces for some for some groups take journal changes power structures is what you're saying. That's exactly right and i'm talking about web to right i'm talking about what to i'm actually talking about web three I'm like social networks have totally transformed how the press works how politics has how politics works. I think politicians when they see grandiose claims about transformative technologies their default position now is unfortunately skepticism now i'd like to see that change because my genuine belief is that.
Technological strength has been a part of what has improved quality of life so much for so many across the world over recent decades and it's been an integral piece of the United States lead economically. So I think it's a huge mistake to think of it as a mere risk I think it's only serves to benefit us or in net will benefit us significantly so I wish they treated with a little bit more nuance i'm still hopeful right it's not like the stories over right we're kind of at the beginning of the political stage of the story. But that's certainly what it feels like and of course i'm speaking for myself right yeah it's I guess it's one thing that web to kind of had it easy whether they just waltz into it because no one knew about the revolutionary potential of tech.
And now we have web three which like okay we've seen this once before and now this one's about money and there's already wall street finances integrated into the incentive structure which presents additional friction but I will say that this sad part that we are having in this episode is actually only coming from our the three guests on this show the people on show our US centric bias so like the rest of the world is like. Yeah, there's a silver line there's a silver line look like it crypto is always supposed to be global technology right at that that's been the kind of the promise from the beginning so.
I know that I haven't said that crypto is going to end or be over right I just don't think that instead the shape of its development and the locations of its development will may shift depending on what people do. I mean I can't help though but be sad for the United States be sad for America because you're right this is what this is this is not cryptos lost this is the US is our lost is Americans lost. Yeah, the narrative Eddie that you just painted I think that kind of rings true to me like in the 90s that existing power structures were not afraid of technology they didn't think it was like anything that would change the existing structures now we've seen multiple generations of the internet.
The internet and tech and now the power structures are taking it much more seriously and they are much more threatened by it because they see how quickly things can completely change that might account for the the posture we've seen on web three and crypto. I think that's exactly right and I think I'll just throw this out because i'm very confident about this that it's going to be even worse for AI. Yes. Oh cool. Crypto can use the eyes before the storm. Like go look over there. Go look at AI. We're fine. Gary Gensler did bring up AI in his hearing today. Oh really? Which was crazy. Yeah, but I know we don't want to touch.
We don't want to invoke it too much. I want to actually kind of move on to the conclusion the what I'm calling the product of this whole entire report which is this index. The state of crypto index and so this isn't something new we've like I said we've seen a lot of these reports before but we've not seen an index of this. Can you explain this part of this report data right. Yeah what is this real time we're going to update it monthly we're going to update it. It's not real time but maybe maybe real time at some point. Yeah the way the way I think about this if you scroll down just a little bit so you get all three charts here yeah like perfect perfect.
We talked about some of these metrics but not all so I'll just kind of zoom out and give it its biggest framing. If there's a product cycle then we should be able to see indicators of development in that product cycle right and for any for whatever's happening in a product cycle. There is innovation you can think of it as a supply side like the things that are coming online that are going to show future future adoption that are prerequisites for future adoption and we can see that adoption itself. And you can call it the demand side and each of these sides have different metrics. And if you aggregate them which is exactly what we're doing at the bottom here right with this red graph and this blue graph.
If you aggregate them I think it's pretty clear that the innovation cycle is different from the adoption cycle. The adoption cycle is more volatile it comes and goes like consumers come and go financial metrics drive like short term excitement. But if you look at the innovation side it is much saidier much much smoother and if you click that index parameters that's plus there on the right hand side. Yeah if you click that you'll see all of the metrics inside of the index right and you can see like in the innovation side we have like active developers interested developers contract deployments library downloads academic publications and they'll have weights.
And the purpose of these weights is that we're not trying to create like a totalizing objective you know index that's like this is like exactly like the exact number you need to track in the space. The point is that we've assigned them these indicators our own weights this is how we think it makes sense to think of them like for example. You know I think academic publications are probably a little bit stronger than like job search interest as an indicator of innovation in the space right so we weigh them like three times heavier. But you can change that if you disagree if you think job search is like the most important thing you can you know what I do disagree I want to change it to a 10.
Yeah exactly and yeah exactly then you then you'll see like the shape of the graphs will change and you know will aggregate them thusly. Yeah so you should click outside there you go exactly exactly so the way to think about the index is just the key indicators for ongoing innovation and the key indicators for ongoing adoption we're very interested to hear. How people think about the weights how people think about the metrics what other metrics based on ideally public data sets but we'll entertain other things like what are the metrics to people want to add would love to hear it and just to say also specifically that the way to think about the number the number is the cumulative net growth.
For each of these numbers so like a 200 would mean that it like tripled right cumulative net growth for the full set of indicators that were active at that time not all those indicators have been around forever obviously NFTs are newer you know dexas happened at one point right stable coins happen at one point. So we have to kind of choose threshold like a beginning threshold but we're going to add new indicators as they become obvious and will update these hopefully according to people's feedback. Beautiful that sounds like this sound looks like a very hard thing to build but also something that becomes more precise and more useful over time as you can put more data into it.
Yeah I hope so and like if I had to if I could ask people to take away one thing it said there's more to crypto than the price like the fact that crypto has a price is both at superpower and a detriment to it right it's a superpower because we can see capital moving around in real time that's incredible right we can program money that's incredible right that's like an insane insanely powerful thing on the other hand it means that as I said earlier the price becomes the most spectacular thing to track. And there's a lot more going on underneath the hood that if there weren't live prices we probably wouldn't be distracted by it we would be more preoccupied with instead the metrics that actually show how things are unfolding.
We would make a lot less ponseys probably probably so Eddie if you were to summarize the health of crypto right now from a product perspective so ignore price we could see that this public everyone knows what that looks like but from a product perspective. What is it like what what's our health I can I can just imagine all the Twitter troll threads right now just like laying into me but it's stronger than ever right it's stronger than ever is this comparable to like 2019 then where the product was maybe stronger than the you know the price seemed or I don't know there wasn't a lot of health in 2019.
That was a kind of a desert always it's it's always hard to do an analog and in fact I think that the the shape of the space has changed right you you guys have seen this where as it's expanded and as the application layer has advanced and as the infrastructure layer has advanced it's just a very multi-dimensional space now I think it's. And if T world doing their thing we've got like crater economy stuff we've got games world we've got like. Just new decentralized social networks I don't know if this resonates with you guys but you know I have an index just this my gut index right of how everything feels right and and so but what what I've said to people is like this bear market doesn't feel bad to me at all compared to some previous where I was like oh do we have product market fit guys are we sure.
That this crypto thing is actually like going to work and we're actually building products that people are going to want to use. I don't feel that way this time this week this time just like I I feel with very strong certainty that we are going to recover I don't know the total size of the recovery and how big this thing could grow that's still an unknown but you know in some of the previous bear markets like 2019 I mean. DeFi might not have had any product market fit or any traction and then like what is the use of Ethereum there is no such thing is kind of like actual NFTs that anyone cared about what one way that I'd I'd some that up right is that.
Back then it was unclear what we needed next yes there was a lot of doubt in the space now there's so many different efforts happening. And all I can point at each of them and say like they need this they need this they need this like each of these things need to unfold that's just not the feeling I have been and there's so many different efforts that look some of them are going to succeed faster some of them are going to succeed slower some of them require more regulatory clarity some of them just need scalability some of whatever right but the point is the the complexity of the space has gone way up in a positive way the chaos has gone up.
That's that's what you want to see from a city healthy city is burbling with chaos and excitement right and like activity and hustle and bustle that's what I feel like it's like a crypto product. The bear market kids have it so easy these days right and our time is definitely not the same it's definitely not the same. The listeners are going to hate you for that. Man this feels pretty hard. It's not that bad guys promise. Eddie thank you so much for walking us through all of this it's pretty clear you're pretty smart guy so what's going to be in the 2024 report. That's a tough one that's tough to prognosticate hopefully hopefully radical US superiority and all dimensions of crypto.
I don't know I don't know yeah there's a couple areas I can point out right that I think are going to be really interesting I can't wait to see where that percentage of L1 block space graph goes. That's going to be super super super interesting I think that could go way higher than 7% right just the percentage of block space actually consume some people joke around like for half jokingly that L1 could be totally congested with all the activity on L2 right that it might be hard to hard to even use L1. Dare give us a number of layer two block space demand of layer one block space. For next year a year from now I'm going to say I'm going to I'll say 20% 20% or more 7 to 20% all right yeah I think for L2 L2 being consumed on a one.
So let's see so that's one I think the that'll tell a lot of the story I also hope I really hope to see radical improvements in UX like and user experience I mean wallet experiences I even hope that years like a little like rimshot like I hope we don't even really talk about wallets as wallets anymore I don't I think the metaphor is not a good metaphor. They're really an application that for signing but it's for signing it's really an identity system like a wallet right is it's it manages your public private key pairs wallets sticks along with like the coin metaphor I think that it's more of an identity metaphor it's the wall is the thing that has your IDs it's not the thing that has your cash I think that we'll see a lot more there I know.
Like passport better. A little better although that has very state heavy. Yeah but that's it's that's an interesting one and one that we we talked about this a lot in in this episode but we didn't quite use this framing and we do introduce this framing in the report. So I think I hope that we will see a little bit of distance from the casino and a little bit more leaning into the computer. Like programming models programming frameworks better infrastructure better UX things like that. That's one of the more concise illustrations of what crypto is that I've heard before a casino and a computer that's pretty good.
I feel I feel like a bear years are computer years but like bull years are always like they always devolve into casino years like 22 was a total casino year. And when you say that you're what you're saying which is right is that the financial cycle dictates the narrative. Yeah that's what you're saying it does in late stages of the bull cycle it totally does that does that can we change that or is that just always going to be the case. It will probably always be a part of crypto but as there are more explicit applications that are used and to end by the mainstream. It will it will follow a little bit kind of like how like in the 90s people thought of computers as a nerd thing now who thinks of a computer as a nerd thing right you you have to kind of reframe it.
To make it a nerd thing again like by default like a phone which is a computer is an entertainment device and a tool and a work device and all these all these other things so I think crypto will go the same way words not explicitly in people's mind framed as a. Fun merely financial object. Any this is this has been fantastic this is the state of crypto 2023 guys will include some links in the show notes you got to come back again where we can get get some your thoughts on some other topics I think we're just scratching the surface today this has been a lot of fun we appreciate. I love to I love to know there's a lot of fun thank you.
Rest in disclaimers of course got to let you know crypto is risky if you didn't already know least on the financial side but we're talking about the product cycle today that's not as risky got to tell you though you could definitely lose what you put in we are headed west this is the frontier it's not for everyone but we're glad you're with us in the bankless journey thanks a lot. you