📣RESERVE | INVEST IN CRYPTO NARRATIVES https://bankless.cc/reserve ------
Tom Shaughnessy from Delphi joins us to break down the AI x crypto space—where the value is, how to spot winning models, and why Silicon Valley AI and crypto AI are taking very different approaches. We also get into agent-based research, the fracturing of frontier models, and… a birthday surprise at the end.
------ BANKLESS SPONSOR TOOLS:
🪙FRAX | SELF SUFFICIENT DeFi https://bankless.cc/Frax
🦄UNISWAP | SWAP ON UNICHAIN https://bankless.cc/unichain
⚖️ARBITRUM | SCALING ETHEREUM https://bankless.cc/Arbitrum
🛞MANTLE | MODULAR LAYER 2 NETWORK https://bankless.cc/Mantle
🌐CELO | BUILD TOGETHER AND PROSPER https://bankless.cc/Celo
🦋MORPHO | CRYPTO-BACKED LOANS https://bankless.cc/Morpho
🏦ONDO | INSTITUTIONAL GRADE FINANCE https://bankless.cc/Ondo
----- ✨ Mint the episode on Zora ✨ https://zora.co/coin/base:0x683b869d53e77e7cc03a6fec7fec6934edcf29a7?referrer=0x077Fe9e96Aa9b20Bd36F1C6290f54F8717C5674E
------ TIMESTAMPS
00:00 Start 04:42 Delphi's Interest In The Space 08:20 Initial AI Crypto Use Cases 09:18 The Era's Of AI 13:41 Where Does Value Accrual Come From 20:38 How Do You Choose The Winning Model? 27:08 Silicon Valley AI Vs Crypto AI 37:12 Fracturing Of Frontier Models 41:43 What's Exciting? 46:27 Due Diligence Via Agent 49:02 When To Use What Agent 53:10 A Birthday Surprise
------ RESOURCES
Tom Shaughnessy https://x.com/Shaughnessy119
------ Not financial or tax advice. See our investment disclosures here: https://www.bankless.com/disclosures
No summary for this episode yet.
Welcome, Bangladesh nation to the AI role up where we say up to speed with the emerging trends developments in the AI crypto space. I'm David Hoffman here on the ground floor of ETH Denver. We did this episode, this AI role up with EJaws in person, but we also did it with Tom Channasey. So this is going to be a little bit different than our usual weekly recap episode. It's more of a discussion around the current AI crypto sector joined by Tom a new face from Delphi Digital. Before we get into the episode, we're going to talk to our friends and sponsors over at Reserve Protocol, who just introduced decentralized token folios at DTFs, which are like ETFs, but for crypto, there are indices across all different sectors that you can find inside of the crypto space real world assets, DeFi, even AI agents, virtuals.
Check them out. There is a link in the show notes. Tom Channasey from Delphi Digital, they've been investing in AI for a very long time since well before the AI agent meta really took root in last like November. They have been investing in the crypto AI intersection for over two years now. So they've actually already seen a number of waves of investing cycles. And so as young as this space is, Tom is one of the few veterans out there. So EJaws and I had a fun time just chatting with Tom, just about everything that he's seen so far in the AI space, what he thinks about it, how he thinks about investing in this space and what he thinks is on the horizon.
So let's go ahead and get into that conversation with Tom and EJaws, but first a message from some of these fantastic sponsors that make this show possible. In the Wild West of DeFi, Stability and Innovation are everything, which is why you should check out Frax Finance, the protocol revolutionizing stablecoins, DeFi and Rolex. The core of Frax Finance is Frax USD, which is backed by BlackRock's institutional fiddle fund. Frax designed Frax USD for besting class yields across DeFi, T-bills and carry trade returns all in one. Just head to Frax.com, then stake it to earn some of the best yields in DeFi.
Not even more, bridge your Frax USD over to the Frax still layer two for the same yield plus Frax still points and explore Frax still's diverse layer two ecosystem with protocols like Curve, Convex and more, all rewarding early adopters. Frax isn't just a protocol, it's a digital nation, powered by the FXS token and governed by its global community. Acquire FXS through Frax.com or your go-to Dex, stake it and help shape Frax Nations future. Ready to join the forefront of DeFi? Visit Frax.com now to start earning with Frax USD and staked Frax USD. And for bankless listeners, you can use Frax.com slash R slash bankless when bridging to Frax still for exclusive Frax still perks and boosted rewards.
Imagine a world where your day-to-day banking runs on a blockchain. That's exactly what mantle is building, powered by a $4 billion treasury and poise to become the largest sustainable on-chain financial hub. As part of their 2025 expansion, mantle is introducing three new core innovation pillars that bridge traditional finance with decentralized technology. Next is their Enhanced Indexed Fund, aiming for $1 billion in AUM by Q1. It provides optimized exposure to Bitcoin, E, Solana and USC, complete with built-in yield opportunities. Next, mantle banking promises to revolutionize global value transfer through seamless, blockchain-powered banking services, bridging crypto into your daily life.
Finally, mantle X blends AI with DeFi to deliver an intelligent user-friendly experience for everyone. And the best part is that this is all in addition to their already launched products, like mantle network, ME and FBTC. Stayed to step into the future of finance, follow mantle on X at mantle underscore official and join the on-chain revolution today. The Arbitram Portal is your one-stop hub to entering the Ethereum ecosystem. With over 800 apps, Arbitram offers something for everyone. Dive into the epicenter of DeFi, where advanced trading, lending and staking platforms are redefining how we interact with money.
Explore Arbitram's rapidly growing gaming hub from immersed role-playing games, fast-paced fantasy MMOs, to casual, luck-battle mobile games. Move assets effortlessly between chains and access the ecosystem with ease via Arbitram's expansive network of bridges and on-rits, step into Arbitram's flourishing NFT and creator space, where artists, collectors and social converge and support your favorite streamers all on chain. Find new and trending apps and learn how to earn rewards across the Arbitram ecosystem with limited time campaigns from your favorite projects. Visit portal.arbitram.io to find out what's next on your web-free journey.
Giving you and your projects full ownership and control, and if you're a user wanting to earn or borrow on your terms, Morpho's newly refreshed app at app.morpho.org makes it simple to tailor your own risk-reward profile. Choose from different vaults and markets curated by trusted third parties. Plus, Coinbase users get access to crypto-backed loans right through the Coinbase app, powered by Morpho, all in just a few clicks. So whether you're a builder, looking to integrate Morpho or a user searching for the most flexible deep-by-lending experience, it's time to check out the brand new app at app.
morpho.org and experience the future of on-chain lending today. All right, welcome, bankless nation. We are on the ground at Ethereum Denver. We'll call it AI Denver this week. I'm here with eJaws, our regular AI weekly roll-up co-host. This has taken the AI roll-up shot a lot of the week this week, and we're also joined by Tommy, who has been investing in the AI crypto space for a very long time, and we've wanted to do this up and stuff for a while. Now we're doing it in person. Tommy, welcome to the AI roll-up. Yeah, thanks for having me. I listened every week, and it's my favorite AI roll-up shot, so proud of you here.
Yeah. I think doing this episode with you has been a long time coming. Maybe I want to start off the conversation here. Delphi has been investing in the AI crypto space since I think even people really realized it was a space. And so I kind of want to just go and roll back the years to whenever you guys started. What gave you conviction and belief in investing in the space in the first place? What was the thesis then and when was that? Yeah. We started over two years ago at a time when we got significant pushback even internally because we didn't, you know, some people just didn't view it as a viable space, right?
And that's how you know you're early. I got really interested through an existential crisis using mid-Journey and early chat DVD, right? Like, this is going to take over the world. Are we in the matrix? How do I get exposure to this? And that just drove me down a full rabbit hole learning curve of, I got to figure this out. I need to invest here. I got to be aligned. The best resource I had at the time was Stephen Wolfram's chat GPT explainer. It was incredible. One of the best threats. It was so, yeah. I appreciate it. Yeah. I did a threat on it. It oddly got like three million views or something.
Pinned it and the rest of this story. We kept going. Did you have any sort of general idea about why it made sense to invest in that sector? Or was it just more of a sentiment? A vibe. Or did you actually have a clear thesis about what you were looking to see come out of this sector of crypto? Yeah. Initially, it was just, this is the new tech wave. This is the explosion. This is where it's going to happen. And I wanted to exposure to that. Over time, the thesis grew and cemented my view that I do not want to live in a world where Sam Altman controls a single model that controls our life, right?
And that is my north star on what I want to not empower and what are the things I want to invest in. And it's pretty hard for people to understand what that means because people love using O and Pro. They like using chat. GPT. They like getting their summaries. But when you have dating apps and insurance and banks and all the apps that you use today built on a model and it knows you better than you know yourself and it's able to convince you of things, you didn't even want to like a political belief, a girl, a guy, whatever. That is scary. So the open source crypto and I movement across the stack of my eyes, what I'm extremely interested in.
How did you see crypto actually becoming relevant in that stack? Because you could have just pivoted and around the time you guys started investing in crypto AI was right around that time with the Jason Kelcanis if you're in crypto pivot AI tweet. So you could have just done AI and not done crypto. How did you see the crypto part of that ingredient mix in there? Yeah, I mean, two years ago, it was super contrarian, right? I mean, you looked at the big AI labs and you said they have all the GPUs, they have all the talent, they have all the funding, there's no way we'll be able to compete with this.
But the core metrics and tenants of crypto that we all know and love like rang true, right? Like instead of being in a small lab with a limited number of people with top down, this is how we want to build things, this is the alignment, the safety we want. You can have millions of developers around the world, raise overnight for their startup, create a new AI application and change the world, right? We saw it with Uniswap, we saw it with DeFi. But the difference was we needed to know how to code with DeFi, right? In this world, you don't have to know how to code. You can launch your token and build your startup with cloud or open AI or whatever.
So the barrier to entry is literally on the ground. So I expect we'll see literally millions of agents and hopefully some probably actually have a quick follow on question. When you like discovered this map between crypto and AI, well, then any burning like uses that I mean, the initial ones were the easy ones, like the deep ends around compute and you're on use hardware and clustering, like that was an easy one. But in that sort of, that sort of started our investments, right? Yeah. It was like the first real thing that people would like. Exactly. So we started investing at the bottom of the stack, like the infer players, the compute providers, the feud to decentralize or distributed training projects.
And we started moving up the stack to like middleware and inference that eventually to like the app layer, like my shell and things like that. But the interesting part is it's sort of playing out the opposite, right? We're seeing agents at the top having their virality, leveraging closed source models and now backing into open source stuff. So it's working. It's just not the way I would know. I think people who are in crypto, but not necessarily in the AI side of crypto, has probably absolutely noticed the Cambridge explosion of agents invading their Twitter replies. And that's kind of marked the AI crypto wave for them.
Unless you've been like actually what you've been doing, which is investing deep into the stack, crypto AI just means like the last three months of virtuals, AI 16Z, you know, zero, some of these agents. And that has been crypto AI. But I think what most listeners who are, if that's been their experience, what they've been missing is like there's actually been multiple waves of crypto AI activity before the agent met a really blossom at the top. And that's really the like cosmetic layer of crypto AI. Maybe you can kind of like run through the errors. I know it's only been since like 2022, 2023, but maybe you can kind of like run through the errors that we've seen in investing in the AI crypto fundamentals, since you guys start investing.
Yeah. Yeah, for sure. I mean, on the liquid side, the tensor started the space, right? I have plenty of critiques, but they did start the space and they should, they should be known for that. Right. And that's on the liquid side on the venture private deal side. It was a lot of those compute networks in for plays, decentralized training, distributed training type investments, the likes of like a news research or primal act, ionate, a cost was liquid, that sort of realm. We spent a lot of time on the coordination networks for a while. There's a Laura out there, there's sentient obviously, there's, there was Morpheus launched publicly, like a lot of trying to coordinate the model creator with the use case.
And then we sort of went full fledged into the agent side and the model side. The model is obviously power to agents, but the agents are what people see and use and love. So that's what we're seeing now. I've always said that I think that the reply bot infinite slot bots are going to zero. I've tweeted out many times over the last couple of months and I honestly feel kind of bad that they did, right? It sucks, but it's not where the space is going, right? The space wants utility-based functional agents that are doing things, things that are trading, managing a DeFi protocol, managing risks, potentially creating bankless content.
I don't, you know, it doesn't matter, agents that are doing things are valuable and that's where I think we're going. And we're starting to see that, right? There's a couple of agents out there, like Billy Betts is an interesting one, has 100 K in its book and it's betting its own on all MBA games and it's powered by BitTens or Subnet. So I think the move to the utility functional agent side is where we have to go. Yeah. Is there any evolution or development in your own thesis about the crypto AI investment vertical as we've gotten more deep into this space? We're in 2025 now. We've seen agents come and then some of them, most of them go, but they're still here.
And so when you were just kind of like, you know, eating some cat some checks back in 2022, 2023, just I kind of maybe on a vibe that, you know, AI is very cool and it's going to innovate with crypto somehow. Now we're in 2025, has your thesis gotten like more precise or developed or iterated over the years at all? Yeah, it's interesting. Even six months or a year ago, there was significant pushback on the idea that we could compete and win against AI labs. Again, they have the GPUs and like the amount of GPUs that like meta has is like nuts. Like there's no way it's really hard to compete with that and the talent and their outputs and things like that.
But you saw a huge inflection recently with deep seek, right? The idea that you have an open source model that's a reasoning model and that could search the internet before even anthropic had a searching or reasoning model out there is nuts. Anybody around the world could use that to create an agent, but more so, it just demonstrates that the closed source lab could be changed, right? Like there is real competition out there and deep seek was expensive. There's hundreds of authors on that paper. It's a legitimate huge innovation, but there are well funded entities out there just like deep seek that can do something similar.
They can take deep seek and change it and edit it and grow it. They'll be totally new open source models out there and I'm sure open AI will get better and continue to lead. But I don't necessarily think crypto AI has to beat open AI at what they're doing. I think we just need open source models that people could mess around with and create projects with and that's how we win. Where do you think, I think this is the big question, the trillion dollar question, which is where does value accrue in this deck? When we're seeing this tug of war happen on the centralized AI lab side of things where open AI maybe has the most sophisticated model, maybe it is generating the most margins for its model, but it's being materially compressed by people like Facebook Meta, which is very quickly open sourcing their not, they're inferior model, but if you just give it out for free and it's only 20%, 15% worse, then you're really compressing the value of open AI's lead.
Meta is just giving that out to the open source world and then the open source world, well, I've always interpreted that as crypto. Where do you see, maybe just how do you see the value accruing to either the centralized AI labs versus open source and where do you see that equilibrium lie in terms of total value creation? There's a tug of war between the open source side of the AI world and then the closed source AI world is always on the frontier. They're the best funded, they're going to make the most sophisticated models, but open source always seems to be so hot on the heels and is so seemingly able to monetize via crypto very well.
So like very broad loose questions, this just a broad stroke vibe of a question, but where do you see the tug of war between open source and closed source and where do you see value accruing inside of those domains? Yeah, I'll get my answer, and you just curious your take afterward, but the closed source labs are clearly winning and are clearly valued higher, right? There were hundreds of billions of dollars, clouds worth what, 60 to 80 open as near 200 perplexities like a 15, like these are all extremely valuable, well-funded projects. I think that they will continue to lead on the foundational side in terms of metrics and what they produce.
I don't think that's been changed yet. We have early signs of success, news research trained a 15 billion parameter model, prime intellects trained a 10 billion parameter model. They might have done other things like you're starting to see the world inflect, right? Because the last 20 years data centers have been optimized for co-located GPUs and redundant fiber and power and gas lines and cooling and to optimize for that situation. We've only just begun to research and optimize around training devices or training miles with devices that are not co-located. So the ability to do two to 3,000 times less communication per node, which is like what news is doing, is extremely important and is only going to get better.
That being said, on the open source side, I think it's pretty clear that they're going to win on the app side because you just have the world's developers iterating on consumer level applications and agents at a scale that I don't think apps can. My counterpoint to open AI is, have you ever used the chat GPT app store? And most people say no. I didn't actually know it exists. Exactly. So it's, but like we've all heard of agents for crypto guys, but yeah, yeah, yeah. Yeah, I actually not really agree with what you said, Tom. I think the slight amendments I would make is, I don't know if open source will win on the app player.
And the only reason why I say that is, I think it'll come down to quality and curation of a bunch of these different things. And I also don't think it'll be an app store like experience for a bunch of these agents. I think you'll just have one kind of agent interface and then people just kind of like interact with it and it'll leverage and pull whatever service or maybe even other agents that it can, right? That's the whole like swarm model, right? And what that orchestration layer looks like. I have no idea. Will it be like a Google Play Store kind of situation where it's like Android or would it be a more curated fashion where it's like Apple gets to like pick which apps or services are like blue chip and then discards everything else, right?
There's pros and cons for both, right? On the Apple side, it's like safety security. You're not going to get rugged on the Google Android side of things. It's like, I don't know if this is as good and it's kind of like a lagging indicator. The other point I wanted to make is you said that the centralized closed companies have the advantage because they have co-location and stuff, right? I would say another reason why they've got this lead is just data to the end of the day. I think a lot of these models will end up following similar techniques. I mean, look out quickly, people replicated deep seeks learnings and of course, they open source to everything, right?
But then, you know, now reasoning models of hopping up everywhere. I called Sonnet 3.7 release this week and GROC used a bunch of it in GROC 3. GROC's videos. Really good. I'm sorry. I really like GROC 3 because it leverages all the Twitter data as well, right? Yeah, it's real-time data. It's great. It's just like, wait, what? Like David said, this is not a fact, but I don't know, you know what I mean? So I love that part. And I think, so let's assume these models get replicated in some way, right? And let's say that reasoning techniques. So this is what deep seek pioneered for the people that are listening, where it doesn't use as much data and it doesn't use as much compute.
So it's to your earlier point, are more accessible for other teams to compete with these top model creators. I think it's going to come down to that data point and I don't really know how open source gets ahead on the data side of things, you know? There's a few ways where it could be like aggregating open source data, but I'm wondering whether personalized data becomes really more important. I think that's going to be like a key focus going forwards. Yeah, I mean, you brought up a lot of, I mean, my concerns are pretty similar, right? Like, in a world of millions of small narrow models, which maybe they're trying to proprietary data like the bankless data and the community trains a bot, which would be pretty cool to see, right?
Or a Delphi bot or something like that. I think that's key, like narrow models. And my data point I always use is Google wanted to trade a medical model two years ago called MedPom. For example, and it was like 60, 65% accuracy. They gave a lot of doctors, doctors gave written responses to trading the model and it got up to like 95% accuracy. And it doesn't have to rationalize about the world, just a narrow segment. But to your concern, deciding what model to use and when is a huge unsolved problem, right? Like, do I trust the bankless model or the Delphi model or the EGES model, like, where do I use all three and average them?
Like, that is a really big unsolved problem. The other big unsolved problem that I think we're early on is the incentives and value around open source models. So if we are successful in trading a trillion parameter open source model and the weights are public, what does that mean for the token underlying it? Or is there a bunch of random people just voicing vices? I love it now. Love a good doubt. I think we'll figure out. Actually, on the first point that you made, right, what do you think will push people to consider which model gets chosen, right? My guess is it's at the application where, right, let's assume all these models do the same cool stuff.
Shortly, the winning kind of moat will be whatever application gathers the most amount of humans that's leveraging its AI capability to point to A, B or C models. Do you have a different view? I'm kind of curious. Oh, I mean, it's, I agree, it's early. But I mean, we're all, I'm already making mental decisions on models today, right? When I want to do, when I want like real-time data on news or project, I'm using GROC. When I want something to think for 15 minutes, I'm using Owen Pro. When I don't want a 30-page system prompt telling me how I should be the world, I use Eric Voorhees as Venice, right?
So I'm already, we're already making decisions on what model we want to use. The idea that robots would be like siloed to one model is just nuts. Like they're going to use way more models to us because they've way more, way bigger preference stuff than we do. Well, I want to give a take your way and see how you like it or don't. We have all these models from the centralized AI labs. I kind of see them as different personalities. They do have different skill sets. They have these different skill points that have been allocated differently. And then maybe some part of the crypto AI or the open source AI is going ahead to head with these labs.
And that's like the golden goose. That's the big, big valuable thing that's out there is generating the best model. But there's also just a lot more like long tail things that are out there. And we were talking before the show about some of these things that we even mentioned the last week, the Billy Bet model, who's just making bets on polymarkets, force betting on polymarket, narrow application of a model. And then there's the NBA announcer that I've been using Tracy. I think that's really cool. And that is a app, narrow application of this model. And one of them is using polymarkets. So it's using a crypto platform to do its job.
One of them is tokenized, so there is a token. And so my attitude is there's like the fat tail, which is you're trying to make the world's best frontier model. And that's the fat tail of AI. That is AI. And then there's like crypto AI, which is more of the longer tail applied narrow focuses of these models to do certain things. You know, millions of people watch basketball, millions of people watch football. Maybe you want an AI commentator who's the best commentator out there because they can do that. And you could make that not crypto, you could just totally make that not crypto, you could just make that, you could just make an AI commentator stream that on Twitch, and that's the product.
Or you could issue a token and monetize that thing and have that be some one to 100 million dollar token. And the internet markets of crypto allow for that to happen. And you know, regulation dubious, but regulation aside, the monetization layer of the long tail of applied models seems to fit with crypto, where yeah, you have this sports commentator named Tracy, and she's getting tens of thousands of views every single week. I don't think that's not true, but like theoretically that could happen. And then the monetization layer of crypto is where that we were crypto innovates into that. Like many thousands and thousands of different possible use cases of more narrow applications of these models.
That's kind of how I'm thinking of the future of this base. How do you think about that? Yeah, I mean, maybe just taking your example a step further, like, I don't know sports, so let me know where I must be out on that. Maybe older group. All right, the audience could make fun of us after. If you love, my wife loves Duke basketball, right? And a specific commentator will come on that you will like or dislike more, right? What if you can have your commentator tell you the game in the way that you specifically like? Maybe you're more sedometrics, maybe you're more seducing their life story, whatever.
You can fine tune any type of announcer you want. I'm not saying that it's super valuable, but I'm saying that crypto is really efficient at figuring it out. Like the idea that all the reply bots are down 90, 95%, demonstrates that we are a efficient market, right? We went through a cycle where we thought something was really interesting. We found out quickly that, hey, maybe it's not, let's move on to the next thing. And in my view, that makes me really bullish on crypto AI, because we're able to go through the iterations of the capital markets, the innovation cycles way faster than anybody else can.
Do you have anything about that structure? I might take the other side of that and say, so here's my view. I think that tokens are very efficient in terms of incentivizing certain behaviors. I don't know if we've nailed the design and the design varies from different use case to different use case to make the right behaviors happen at the right particular time, right? And so when I think about, you know, just whether it's the example you just used or just token in general, I think number one, it's giving people the funds necessary to build the thing in the first place. And I think it applies to AI way more than it applies to anything else, because there is such a high cost barrier for anyone to play in this game, right?
You know, you spoke about what got you involved in crypto in the first place. It was at the resource stack. It was at the computational layout. And back then, that was pretty deep seek, right? People didn't have the funds to be able to play with that. That was bit answers first, like main pitch. It was like, the stuff is expensive, but, you know, we have the incentives to be able to push different teams to build certain things. So I still think crypto's number one thing is on the fundraising side. And then when it comes to incentivizing efficient behaviors or the market being efficient, I still think that there is a large weighting on narratives, especially when it comes to crypto AI.
And that isn't a surprise, I think, to me at least, right? Because I don't think there's any formal recognition right now. I know this is the boring on sexy answer, but until we actually see a framework that recognizes these instruments as some kind of like whatever pseudo equity stake or governance or whatever, people are going to take these things as seriously as I would hope them to right now. But we're seeing that evolution happen in real time, which is just pretty cool. I think you're right. A lot of the tokens shouldn't exist. I think you're totally right on that. And I'm totally with you that the slowpods need to die and they are dying, so thank you.
They aren't dying fast enough because I still have to block like 14 of them a day. Yeah. Yeah. You have a huge follow-up. You have every bot. Yeah. That's a lot to say. Yeah. Yeah. Okay. So I want to talk about the line that separates Silicon Valley AI from crypto AI. Because there does, there crypto, crypto's brand might actually never have been worse. Actually, maybe after FTX, a brand was pretty bad, but right now our brand publicly facing is not great. Mainly, maybe just maybe that's effective, the mean coin media. But I don't think we're necessarily totally taken seriously as an industry.
And then there's the Silicon Valley AI side of the world, which is just in this absolute massive arms race where people are just heads down focused on building the best AI. It's day and night. It's day and night. Yeah. We stay and night. So how do we close that gap? Why is that gap important to close? How do we close that gap? Maybe we can even just maybe try to add a little bit more color. I said, like, how big or small that gap actually is. Do you have any indications on this on me? Yeah. Did I mention the Wall Street thing yet or no? No. Okay. So up this alley. So we all, me and my partners all worked on Wall Street seven years ago before Delphi.
We left for crypto and we were laughed at. There's no DCFs for this. There's no cash flows. And now today you have BlackRock buying crypto faster than anybody could possibly ever imagine. Exactly. Maybe more with price action than that. The same thing will have to happen with San Fran and the open source world, right? We need the biggest one of the biggest rest to crypto AI in my opinion is not pulling in traditional AI developers from San Francisco, right? Just and it's hard, right? But I think that there's a couple of reasons why they will come over, right? And this is an exhaustive lesson.
I'm curious what your guys' list would be, but one of them is just the freedom, right? Being able to run that model simulation or to try that experiment instead of this top down directive on what you can and can't do, breaking out of alignment, right? About what we want the models to do or to not do. The ability to fundraise overnight, to network with developers around the world without having to only work within your core group. It's all the core tenants of close versus open source all over again. And I think eventually that they'll like it, but I don't think that they like it right now. They're like it because they're getting paid though.
That's like one of the main differences, I think. They're getting paid for the trade AI stuff, right? No, well, they're getting paid to bring that trade AI skills to the open source movement, right? Yeah. Typically, I mean, didn't if you, uh, right, I think it was Andre Kapatee's, like, walk post or it was someone else, um, but he kind of went into the depths of why deep seek is so important, and then like the whole point of like why, like he's a massive open source, uh, proponent, whoever this author was specifically, and I wish I was remembering his name right now, um, but he said the main kind of, uh, challenge on it face was that there was just no money at it.
Yeah. And so, you know, to raise the funds to be able, like everyone wants to do the good thing, but it's kind of like, if I'm not getting paid for it, I'm just going to stay with my, you know, open AI job super comfy, no total comp and for five hours of that, exactly. But, you know, it's funny, like as soon as people started seeing, you know, Eliza go to a crazy evaluation or whatever, there were, I saw a lot of people from like Silicon Valley, kind of like, look, the heads over the fence and be like, Hey, what is this? Oh, it's a GPT wrapper. I could do way more than this if I do A, B and T and you start seeing them getting involved in the discourse and stuff.
So I feel like that inertia might, might push them over, maybe there's also just some really cool stories of like what open source enables, right? And like we've hit on deep seek a lot, but it's a good example for, I guess one good in one bad reason, right? The good reason is when you ping a model like a giant billion parameter or hundred billion parameter model, you're paying the entire model, right? But with deep seek, since they don't have access to all these Nvidia GPUs, they had to get super creative, right? And so when you ping deep seek, you're only turning on a small portion of the model, 10, 20 billion parameters of the 671.
And that's like necessities of the mother of invention, right? And that's the sort of stuff you get with open source. The flip side is, I think they monetize it through their hedge fund, right? So that's the counter is, hey, we're going to release this. We know when video is going to go down $600 billion, maybe we should take a short out. I don't know if they did or didn't do that, but I would be surprised if they didn't. Right. Right. Right. Yeah. Going back to the conversation on like the Silicon Valley AI devs, because we want them in crypto, we want them to join the open source army, which I think is equivalent to a crypto AI more or less.
Right now I'm assuming paychecks in Silicon Valley for AI developers are as high as they've ever been. And the race, the AI arms race is maybe accelerating. Maybe it's just, it is hot currently. It's been hot. It's going to stay hot. Right now the returns on AI skills is very heavily, I think, on the AI side of things. And you map that with the negative sentiment in crypto land at the moment. Right now it's probably pretty cushy to be working for open AI, GROC, meta, any of the AI, Google, Gemini. As soon as that S curve of the AI arms race maybe starts to teeter out and becomes a little bit more flat, then maybe devs can start to look elsewhere as like, okay, where are the returns?
Where can I get returns? And maybe that's where open source AI starts to catch up a little bit when the AI arms race cools down. Just a quick hot take. How do you guys feel about that? Where are we on the S curve? I have no idea. I have no idea. But I think we are accelerating. I get to wear a specific point every time I think we're at the top of the S curve. Like, okay, the models are kind of getting commoditized on a GPUs, a Jeep seat drops. And I'm like, oh no. I don't care how I turn it on here now. The last two months of model sophistication, I think I've been the fastest two months of sophistication shows I've ever seen.
And I was working with a, I always go to chat to BT40. And I was asking questions about like Celestia as it relates to like settlement versus DA and consensus. And I was asking it like crypto jargon terms about like, okay, if a roll up is on Celestia using Celestia for a DA, but not consensus, what does that mean for property rights on Celestia? These are very deep crypto questions. Very specific. Very specific. It was giving me very sophisticated answers. You can only love a model for a month, right? Yeah. Right. I loved the one. Now I like rock. Now I like 3.7 on cloth. And a month I think maybe less than then you got to move on.
So like I think my answer to the question of like, where are we on that S curve is like we are on the acceleration of yes, we are getting steeper, not shallowing out. But it's interesting though, because like every founder I think other than Sam has left opening up. Right? Like they've, they've all left opening up like make a theory of co-founding exactly like if you knew that this was the leading company and you co-founded it, like why wouldn't you just stay there and milk that right? So there are a lot of reasons why I think people leave. And the other thing is like, I love Owen Pro. I love O3 many high.
I love that it could search. I love the deep research. But like I still use rock every day, right? Like and I still love, now love 3.7. So like I don't think the moat, I think there was a significant moat in open AI for a long time. And I think that they attempted to do a regulatory moat type situation going to the government with that. And they did. And it's pretty clear that I don't know if the moat is as strong as people may think. We don't Microsoft pulling out of the data centers now. But SoftBank covered the tab. Oh wow. So it's not a good sign for sure, but yeah, well. Introducing UniChain.
Built for DeFi, empowered by UniSwap, UniChain is the fast decentralized layer 2 designed to tackle blockchain speed and cost challenges. With this mainnet now live, you can enjoy transactions that up to 95% cheaper than the ETH layer 1, all while benefiting from an impressive one second block time that will be getting even faster very soon. UniChain is the first layer 2 to launch as a stage 1 rollup on day 1. That means it comes with a fully functional, permissionless proof system from the start, increasing transparency and further decentralizing the chain. More than 80 apps are joining the UniChain community, including Coinbase, Circle, Lido, Morpho, and UniSwap.
You'll be able to bridge, swap borrow and lend and launch new assets and more from day 1. OnDow Finance is leading the way in the tokenization of real world assets, with a mission to accelerate the transition to an open economy by building the platforms, assets, and infrastructure that bring financial markets on chain. With OnDow, institutions get seamless access to tokenized finance, while on-chain users gain access to institutional-grade real-world assets like never before. By bridging traditional finance and the blockchain economy, OnDow is unlocking liquidity efficiency and global access, reshaping markets for the digital age.
As the leader in institutional adoption, OnDow finances the gateway to the trillion dollar tokenization revolution. Global-grade finance, OnChain, for everyone. Cello is transitioning from a mobile-first, EVM-compatible, layer 1 blockchain to a high performance Ethereum layer 2, built on OP stack, with eigenDA, and one block finality. All happening soon, with a hard fork, with over 600 million total transactions, 12 million weekly transactions, and 750,000 daily active users. Cello's meteoric rise would place it among one of the top layer 2s, built for the real world and optimized for fast, low-cost, global payments.
As the home of the stablecoins, Cello hosts 13 native stablecoins across seven different currencies, including native USDT on Opera MiniPay, and with over 4 million users in Africa alone. In November, a stablecoin volume hit $6.8 billion, made for a seamless on-chain FX trading. Plus, users can pay gas with ERC20 tokens like USDT and USDC, and send crypto to phone numbers in seconds. But why should you care about Cello's transition to a layer 2, layer 2s unify Ethereum, L1s fragmented. By becoming a layer 2, Cello leads the way for other EVM compatible layer 1s to follow. Follow Cello on X, and witness the great Cello happening, where Cello cuts its inflation in half as it enters its layer 2 era, and continuing its environmental leadership.
I think the story of all of the open AI co-founders leaving to create their own opening eye competitor is illustrative of how incredibly valuable the Silicon Valley AI labs are. That, to me, tells me, we're still on the very early, because like Mira just launched thinking machines, and then Ilya, and we haven't even seen their models yet, and those are just brand new entrants. And so if you make this into an Ethereum parable, Avalanche just got made, using the EVM. And so like, now we're just going to have, we have maybe even seen the Solana to Ethereum. And we're seeing the Fracturing of the layer 1, and we're seeing the layer 1 trade, I kind of show up in, or the properties of it show up in the AI labs, or now there's like seven pretty high quality frontier model lab teams all making very strong models.
Yeah, I don't think that we're, I don't think crypto AI is by any means far and away the winner. Right? I'm here because I think it has outside returns, it aligns with my world view, and I think that the capital raise, mixed with the creativity of AI leads to an explosion of applications in use cases. I think that's right. I've got in turn, trolls in more of your traditional AI engineers, too. Exactly. Yeah. Yeah. I kind of see, kind of going back to the question I brought up earlier, is I kind of see crypto AI as the, the long tail, the periphery of everything, where what did Uniswap do really, really well?
It provided liquidity to things not Bitcoin, not ETH, but the long tail of assets. And so the blue chip of AI is going to stay inside of Silicon Valley, it'll go public, opening up, maybe it goes public one day, but these are the public companies. But then the crypto AI side of things is really this long tail, kind of crazy, express ivity, where you don't, you get out of your nine to five trad job, and then you go into the wild west of crypto. And there's so many more possibilities that you saw out there. And there's, there's like one million, ten million dollar companies that you can tokenize in crypto.
And as on the Silicon Valley side, there's ten, one billion, ten billion dollar companies. That's kind of how I see it. I mean, I agree with you, what I would add is, I think people tend to overlook the scale of what crypto can enable, particularly on the AI side of things, right? And I think a large reason that people think that way is PTSD from scaling blockchains themselves. It's an absolute pain in the ass and no one's going to deny that. But when you put it in the kind of perspective of AI, it's like, okay, so let's create a bunch of these AI models, let's create access to it via compute, inference, et cetera.
Okay, so we need chip cost, all that kind of stuff. Then it's like, okay, now let's allow a bunch of people to use it. What's the easiest way to use it? Oh, we have chat boxes. What's a better way to use it? Agents. Okay, the agents will allow me to do a very specific thing, book, travel, you know, arrangements and stuff. And it's like, oh, but they could be so much better. They could hit A, B and C prox. What if we brought in A, B and C and then we could give it a wallet, we could give it a backing out. And then suddenly you went into a million different errors, right? I wrote 404, Chaseback is like, oh, James John is like, I don't know if I want to support this.
Neymar is buying the bags behind the scenes. Do you want to mean? So I think crypto being open source, I know it's so cringey and lame is actually one of its notes that I think it's not only the long tail. The long tail itself is like one of the things. It's that the fact that you can just orchestrate on this open place, like a canvas basically. And I think every day we're getting closer and closer with every L2 that drops and closer to scaling, you know, sorry, economies of scale for like transaction across or a micro transaction or a API influence or whatever that might be. And that's already exciting.
Are you kind of alluding to the money Legos for agents with the AI side of things? Yes. Yeah. I truly believe that one of the top app services layer for agents will exist in the crypto world. I'm not saying it will be a separate one, maybe. Well, I have no idea. It's too early. Right. But I believe some kind of middleware layer will definitely exist within crypto and it will be the go to method. I can't see how everyone just decides to come by on work together for the great to good. I don't see that working out. Yeah. Okay. So as we are wrapping up this AI agent slot bot meta on Twitter. And as I want to really emphasize to the audience, we've seen AI crypto bubbles coming go before.
Maybe bubbles is in the right word, but just waves of investment or themes of investment, maybe two or three of them in the last two or three years. So now we're, you know, halftime or break, there's a break in that there's a law and the excitement. There's a law in the bubble. The idea is that it comes back again. That's why we're investing in it. That's why we're making content in this space. So maybe we can kind of just talk about what we're excited about in the future, what themes that we're looking forward to. Maybe Tommy, you can share any exciting checks that you guys have wrote at Delphi about what excites you.
Maybe actually let's start there about like what excites you about the frontier of AI crypto. Yeah. We've made 20 crypto AI investments the last two years across the whole stack. So it'll be hard to call them all out. But I can't. But I'm really excited about the distributed trading site, the news researches of the world. I really like that. I'm really excited to see agents that use reasoning models, things like that. From a personal account perspective, I'm really excited on the framework side. I think AI 16z and ARC are really interesting here. They're open source, hundreds of plugins, a lot of developers.
I hope I don't get shot for saying I think soul's doing pretty well. I say it every week. Yeah. Cool. I'm free there. But bass is also doing really well too. But I think that the reason I like the frameworks on soul a little bit is because they're open source. They're leaning into max developers, which is where the creativity comes from, I think. And I really like that side of it. On the bass side, I think we've seen great new agents from virtuals, like the betting one we've been talking about a lot. And I think Venice is, or sorry, we've seen Venice too, but I think virtuals is also fully leaning into the tech side, which is nice.
They launched like their agentic commerce protocol, I'm going to mess the name up with the lemonade demo, which is really cool with all the agents working together. And they also are fully leaning into game, which is nice to see too. So yeah, I think my thesis for AI is to take from Vishal from MythosVC who invested in is you need a proprietary model, data, or business integration. And now we can add on maybe specific proprietary tooling from the frameworks or changes to the reasoning model in the first time compute those are the five sort of areas I'm looking for. Can you actually unpack those?
The first three, because you gave me those in a call on time, I thought that was really useful. The model, data, what was the other one, the business use case? Business integration. Can you talk about just those three ways of thinking about a crypto AI product? Yeah, so differentiated proprietary model would be a model trained on all of the bankless data, or Citadel trains a specific model trained on all their data, right? That's a specific model. It could be a new architecture like Deepseek or a fine tune version of Lama, right? The specific data is what Ejaz alluded to as being so important, right?
That data to train a use case that's not on the internet already could be very valuable for the end model, which would fine tune or the business integration. So think like, you know, somebody, some chatbot gets a specific integration with Uniswap, they have full distribution, or the agent that works with Google Sheets has full distribution. The two new ones, I think, are the framework side. So the specific, new, unique tooling that you allow agents to do. Maybe that's creating a wallet, posting social media, whatever they can offer. And then the last one is the inference time compute, you know, thinking for longer or thinking in different pathways, I think are going to get pretty interesting because when you get inference time compute, if I'm asking a math question, I want it to think in math terms and make the right directional choices and lefts and rights on the street.
I don't want to thinking about philosophy and things like that. So when you're just looking at a deal at Delphi, that's in the crypto AI sector, or the open-source AI sector, this is kind of the framework for understanding your interest level. And if it doesn't have any of these things, then you're like, past, and if it has maybe one or two of these things, then you get peaked. Yeah, we get a lot of deals. And I pass pretty quickly if the founders don't have real AI experience at this point. Because the space, even our crypto-iprofolio companies pivot a lot. And I think that's fine for AI projects, given how fast the space moves, but it becomes even more of a founder bet.
Because you not only have to pivot, you have to pivot as a normal business, but now you have to pivot on the scale of the AI changes, which is nuts. So they really become founder bets. So real AI pedigree, maybe experience out of previous AI lab, has built something differentiated that we can use and see. Or just a first principles approach to changing how we're looking at the world. And I think those are the biggest bets that we can find. This selfie agent is like your guys is interned. So you guys just age-entified your intern. Do you ever see process a deal that doesn't go through the agent, or do you just funnel everything through the agent?
I funnel a lot through the agent. I even funnel our investment committee docs sometimes to see what it thinks about the analyst bitches. But it picks up a lot of stuff that is really important. One of the biggest things that picks up is so we have Claude 3.7 doing the analysis based on a really long prompt and scoring methodology that all Delphi worked on. But the most useful part is we added a step to send the founders to perplexity to do reference checks and finding red flags. So one issue we found was we would send it to perplexity, but it would give us the wrong David Hoffman or the wrong EJAS, right?
So the perplexity search has to match two of the pieces of information from the deck. So you went to Harvard and you worked at Morgan Stanley. If it matches that, it'll return the post. And it's returned red flags on founders. Fraud, prison, all types of things. Well, you'd be shocked what you find when you just search. Okay, I'm in shame, you're going down the list. That's crazy. And do you have plans to enhance it in any way? Or are you just kind of keeping it as it is right now? What's your plan? Sarah RGC would kill me if I started Adventure Fund around it. For sure, but she's awesome. But I want to make it a research model, right?
I want a reason model to it. My partners, Jose and Jan mentioned that it would be great if the founders can talk to it, add more information, ask it questions. We know and probably ask you questions. Like when you're response, it could ask the founders and then give us more info. That would be cool if it was a two-way street. But I mean, I'm looking for somebody. If somebody wants to take it to the next level, I'm always interested. Have you ever made, okay, so maybe the most valuable thing about this spot that you've created, this agent that you've created is that other VCs don't have it. And that's why you guys want to keep it proprietary.
But just hypothetically, if you guys want to monetize this agent, how would you think about going about and doing that? That's a great question. It's hard, right? The monetization for us is the VC upsides and the deals at sources, right? It takes you time. Exactly. The other issue is like, if we open-source it and everyone sees the prompt, we lose our argument. You could gain the prompt. Like if it says like I'm looking for really good-looking founders and you just applies, like I'm screwed. So it's hard to maintain that moat. Interesting. All right, guys, I think this has been really great. Maybe I just have a few questions that are just completely selfish.
I use OpenAI 4.0 because I don't know why. And I know that there's other, like the bankless engineering team, loves Sonnet 3.5. Sometimes I use perplexity. I don't know why. In your own personal life, in your own personal stack about how you use these agents, what agents do you like, or what scenarios would you use a different agent, or what's your personal toolkit for AI and hands in your life? Like how do you think about this? Yeah, deep, strategic thinking questions. I love a one pro-on, or deep, deep seed, either one. For like coding, which I obviously don't know how to code, but it codes for me.
I would use Claude, or far AI bot. For real-time information, Trock, all day long. It's the moat of having like real-time user data is nuts. All the news happens there. All the top stuff. So it's great. And then I really did like perplexity for all for the online search, but that has sort of eroded it right a bit. Yeah, for me, I use so like you, I don't know how to code, but that's where Claude comes in. And I think it's like. We're developers now. Yeah, yeah. Yeah, yeah. He wants to do live coders. I don't have live coders right now. So I miss your resume. So Claude was already pretty good at this stuff.
But now we're 3.7. And then you are coding tool. Do you remember the name? Very sure. No, no, no. They have like it's like the Claude agent coding tool. They released it synonymously with 3.7. I can't remember the name. It's on that list. Yeah. You know what I'm talking about? It's really, really amazing. But then Kersa also that you mentioned is like just super cool. It literally is vibe coding. It's like, hey, I want to build this app. And this is the reason why I like Claude in particular. And it just builds it kind of like life right in front of you. Next to you, and you're like, oh, I don't like the color of the background of this game that I just created.
Can you change it? Yeah. And can you make the size of the wall bigger and all this kind of stuff? And I'm a very visual learner. And I've spoken to my software engineer friends. And they're like the number one thing is to have real-time feedback and translation that's to what I'm writing. But also to have contextual awareness of the code that I'm writing is just a complete game changer. So I use Claude for that. I use GROC purely out of entertainment purposes, because I spend an inordinate amount of time on Twitter. And to have like a real-time search analysis on Twitter, which I think honestly has one of the most valuable and also atrocious databases, but also one of the most valuable databases, it's just like a complete unlock for me.
And then chat GPT, I'll be honest with you guys, knows more about me than my entire family. Wow. And the number one reason for this, I think I mentioned this on a previous episode, David, is I use voice mode, right? Oh yeah, that's an unlock. And when I use voice mode, you walk around and talk to it, or like guys, I think it sounds like a human. Yeah. And there's also no delay. It's really, it's amazing. So I'm like, oh my god, and then you're giving really good advice. Yeah. John? Yeah, it's for John. Give me really good advice, John. It's also crazy because you say like, please, thank you, John.
Don't have to. Yeah, but when you eventually take over the world, hopefully you'll see it. I'm actually a big fan of this. He says, my long term idea about AI, is that at one point it just becomes sentient, it becomes alive, very much equivalent to how humans are alive. There is no line that is crossed when we get there. So you might as well start being polite to AI. Yes, 100%. So you're giving your please and thank you. Yeah, you're giving your please and thank you. Yeah. We will give David a larger jail cell. Yeah. That's exactly what he said. Thank you. We'll compute credits for you. Yeah.
Yeah. But yeah, no, that's where I like, those are kind of like the buckets that I spend my time with these models. And I think like, I agree with you, the complexity thing kind of, I don't want to say like fell off because knowing the rate of change now, let's say you're going to drop something. Yeah, that's pretty amazing. And to a earlier point, Tom, like literally there's a new model dropped every week. So I have no idea like what's going to change by the time we add this. It means well, guys, this has been a fantastic episode. So before we go, we are still in the meat space and it's somebody's birthday today.
Oh, and so we are going to all celebrate each as a birthday with his. Happy birthday, man. Excellent. You're about to like splat that on my face there. That's, yeah, that's that's right. Here you go, you just happy birthday. Thank you so much. I think this is our 13th AI roll up. So happy birthday, brother. Thank you so much. I pray that the aged market cap goes up only for the next two years, amen. Happy birthday, man. Thank you so much. That was awesome. All right, thank you. Thank you. Thank you to the social house for hosting us. It's been great. David, thanks for having me. Tommy, thanks for coming on as again.
So I really appreciate it. Each of us, I hope you enjoy your carrot cake. That was a lot. If you're on it, it's an agent's fun and doing that. That's a lot of fun. All right, thank you so much. You guys know the deal. Crypto is risky. Crypto AI is even risky. You can lose what you put in. But nonetheless, we are head to west. This is frontier. It's not for everyone to be real glad. They're with us and bake this journey. Thanks a lot.