On this episode of Alpha Leak, David is joined by Euler Co-Founder, Michael Bentley. Euler is a non-custodial, permissionless lending protocol on Ethereum with some interesting features you should know about.
This episode was recorded in early July, but the alpha is still very timely.
------ 📣 Galxe | Explore Crypto’s #1 Credential Network https://bankless.cc/Galxe
------ 🚀 SUBSCRIBE TO NEWSLETTER: https://newsletter.banklesshq.com/ 🎙️ SUBSCRIBE TO PODCAST: http://podcast.banklesshq.com/
------ BANKLESS SPONSOR TOOLS:
⚖️ ARBITRUM | SCALING ETHEREUM https://bankless.cc/Arbitrum
❎ ACROSS | BRIDGE TO LAYER 2 https://bankless.cc/Across
🦁 BRAVE | THE BROWSER NATIVE WALLET https://bankless.cc/Brave
💠 NEXO | CRYPTO FINANCIAL HUB https://bankless.cc/Nexo
🔐 LEDGER | NANO HARDWARE WALLETS https://bankless.cc/Ledger
⚡️FUEL | THE MODULAR EXECUTION LAYER https://bankless.cc/Fuelpod
------ Topics Covered:
0:00 Intro 4:20 Euler Explained 5:30 Compound vs. Aave vs. Euler 6:10 Limited Assets on Compound & Aave 8:56 Euler’s Approach 10:00 Euler’s Collateral Risk Strategy 16:20 Cross Tier Differentiation 17:56 Tier Walk Through 22:08 Euler’s Features & DeFi Importance 30:11 Other Euler Features 30:48 Status Quo of Liquidations 36:27 Competition 38:08 Launch Turbulence 41:55 Interest Rate Mechanism 50:47 Euler DAO & $EUL 52:37 Euler Resources 53:15 Closing & Disclaimers
------ Resources:
Euler Twitter https://twitter.com/eulerfinance
Euler Website https://www.euler.finance/
Euler White Paper https://docs.euler.finance/getting-started/white-paper
Michael Bentley https://twitter.com/euler_mab
----- Not financial or tax advice. This channel is strictly educational and is not investment advice or a solicitation to buy or sell any assets or to make any financial decisions. This video is not tax advice. Talk to your accountant. Do your own research.
Disclosure. From time-to-time I may add links in this newsletter to products I use. I may receive commission if you make a purchase through one of these links. Additionally, the Bankless writers hold crypto assets. See our investment disclosures here: https://newsletter.banklesshq.com/p/bankless-disclosures
No summary for this episode yet.
Today on this Alphalic episode, we are exploring ZK Roll-ups on Bitcoin, which I didn't even know was possible until I stumbled upon this website called BitcoinRoll-ups.org, which is a research endeavor out of this man, John Light, who got a grant to go research what can you do when you put a roll-up on Bitcoin, is that even possible? And so it turns out a lot is possible. Also in this episode, I bring on Eric Wall, who's also a Bitcoin or a technical Bitcoin owner to help me co-moderate this conversation because this is something that Eric Wall I know is just very interested in and wants to see happen on Bitcoin.
So we talk about roll-ups on Bitcoin, of course. What that means for the Lightning Network, what you can do on a roll-up on Bitcoin, is it just a payments network that is a better Lightning network, or is it the full suite of smart contracts, tokens, what's it take to put roll-ups on Bitcoin? Do we have to hard fork? Is it just a soft fork? How complex is this? How is the community going to receive this? Because the Bitcoin community is generally resistant to change. But we've kind of been seeing a tide shift in the Bitcoin community lately. Maybe there's more Bitcoiners that are more interested in something like roll-ups on Bitcoin.
And overall, I'm just really fascinated about this concept, roll-ups on Bitcoin. And it's kind of restored my interest in Bitcoin. It's one of the most innovative things I've seen out of the Bitcoin space in a really long time. And so this is something that I hope to see coming for the future of Bitcoin. So I hope you enjoy this exploration into the world of ZK roll-ups on Bitcoin with my two guests, John Lai and Eric Wall, right after we talked to some of these fantastic sponsors that make the show possible. If you've been listening to bank lists, you know that we're fans of the modular blockchain thesis.
The idea that blockchain will separate execution from data availability and consensus, allowing all three to become the best versions of themselves. And fuel has built the fastest modular execution layer in the industry. By supporting parallel transaction execution, fuel unlocks significantly faster throughput for the web through world. Fuel also goes beyond the limitations of the EVM with its own fuel VM, which is more efficient and optimized, opening up the design space for developers. And lastly, fuel brings a powerful developer experience with its own domain-specific language sway, and a supportive tool chain called fork.
With fuel, you can have the benefits of smart contract languages, like solidity, while adopting the improvements made by the rest tooling ecosystem, letting the fuel development environment go beyond the limitations of the EVM. If you want to learn more, there's a link in the show notes to see how you can get involved with a fuel network. Sequence is the all-in-one developer platform you need to build Web3 games and applications. For your users, sequence is a smart wallet, and it's the easiest, most intuitive onboarding your users will ever experience, and comes with all the features users need to feel empowered in the Web3 world.
Multi-chain support, NFT display, and users can buy SFTs, NFTs, and crypto directly with a credit or debit card. For developers, sequence is the plug and play platform for Web3 games and apps. Your APIs let you bring NFTs, SFTs, and tokens into your game or application, and a sequence relayer enables gassos transactions for your users. Sequence already powers some of the best Web3 games, like Skyweaver, NFT projects like CoolCats, and Marketplaces like NiftySwap, and Sequence is compatible with all the EVM chains, including Ethereum, Polygon, Binance Smart Chain, Arbitrum, Optimism, and Avalanche.
So go to Sequence.xyz slash bankless to start building or speak with a sequence team today. TrueFi is DeFi's largest credit protocol, connecting global lenders with institutional grade lending opportunities. TrueFi has completed over $1.7 billion in originations, and paid out nearly $35 million cylinders. Proving that DeFi is ready to take its next big leap into the $8 trillion credit market. TrueFi gets lenders like you, access to sustainable, high-yield opportunities backed by real-world investments, usually reserved for high net worth individuals. At the same time, fund managers use TrueFi's financial infrastructure to bring their portfolios on chain, benefiting from the global liquidity, cost savings, and transparency of DeFi.
TrueFi is a decentralized financial utility. The protocol is owned and governed by the TrueFi Dow, and TrueFi is here to bring DeFi into the Golden Age, bridging the power and access of crypto with institutional grade lending opportunities and portfolio tooling. Explore the diverse financial opportunities available on TrueFi or launch your own portfolio at trueFi.io. Welcome bankless nation to a very special episode of AlphaLeak. Today, I'm joined with John Light. And John Light currently works at the head of product for sovereign, but also moon lights as a Bitcoin researcher in his re-time, and recently got a grant from the Human Rights Foundation to do research on how to do ZK roll-ups on Bitcoin.
And this is what peaked my attention and why I wanted to do a show on this because ZK roll-ups on Bitcoin. I didn't know that that was possible, but according to John's research, it is possible. John, welcome to bankless. Yeah, thanks so much for having me. And also, because I am not the always the best person to ask Bitcoin questions, we're bringing in some help. We're bringing in Eric Wall, who's going to be my technical co-host, my Bitcoiner co-host to ask me and ask John some better questions, more than just the higher level stuff. So Eric, thank you so much for helping me do the show today.
Thanks for having me. How do you do it? Cheers. All right, John, let's get into it. Explain a little bit about yourself, give yourself our bio, and kind of how you came to be working on the intersection of ZK roll-ups and Bitcoin. Sure. So, I'm a long-time Bitcoiner. Bitcoin is my first love, you could say, in cryptocurrency world, and I have had a fascination with a cross-chain Bitcoin protocols, even before sidechain, this term sidechain was even developed. I've been interested in this idea of like, could you move Bitcoin into other chains that have different sets of rules? And the sidechain's white paper came out in 2014.
I was really excited about that. Here's what went by, and the best kind of sidechains we've gotten so far are like federated multisigs that hold people's Bitcoin. And I've always been interested to know, like, can we do better than that? Can we have permissionless, trustless sidechains or release bridges to other blockchains? And a couple of years ago, I was working on a project in the Ethereum world called Eragon. And this is a DAO creation tool, and it was also around the time of like, well, first there was cryptokitties, which kind of caused a lot of congestion on the blockchain. And we were already starting to think about scalability around that time.
So like late 2017, early 2018, but throughout that bear market, gas fees started coming down and it became less of an issue. But it was always something in the back of our mind. So research was ongoing about how can we improve the scalability of this system so that it doesn't cost like $100 to cast a vote or something like that? And eventually, ideas like plasma and state channels and eventually, roll-ups were invented in the Ethereum community as ways to reduce congestion, move transactions off-chain, make transactions cheaper, more scalable, so on and so forth. And so that's how I first became familiar with roll-ups.
And eventually, these two interests of mine kind of converged where I realized, okay, roll-ups are basically like trustless bridges that you can use to transfer coins to other blockchains. This is like kind of the original side-chains vision of having trustless bridges to other blockchains and you can move your coins between different blockchains. And I thought, wouldn't this be cool to bring to Bitcoin? John, I think the most interesting thing about this for me is that ZK roll-ups are a technology that just makes sense to me in the Ethereum ecosystem. It's the logical progression of like state channels to plasma to roll-ups has always felt very like a natural progression of scale for a blockchain.
And so then when we talk about using this, which is just an inherently neutral technology, ZK roll-ups are just a neutral technology. The fact that we can allegedly, which is what we're going to unpack today, that we can apply a ZK roll-up to Bitcoin gets me excited. It's one of the first things I saw a lot of potential out of the Bitcoin space in a long time. Like lightning has never really interested me, liquid has always been a joke. But ZK roll-ups seem like if we can apply them to Bitcoin, it can open up a brand new world. And that's really what has gotten me excited here. And so really just to define these terms, we have ZK roll-ups on Ethereum.
Is it as simple as just taking the technology that we've gotten and started to roll out in the Ethereum world and just applying it to Bitcoin? And also it just like quote works, is it really that simple? Depending on how validity roll-ups are actually enabled on Bitcoin layer one, the smart contracts that secure the bridge between layer one and the layer two validity roll-up could be practically identical to the smart contracts that are used for validity roll-ups on other chains, or they could be quite different because Bitcoin uses a different state model than Ethereum, for example. So Ethereum uses a state model that's known as the account model, Bitcoin uses a state model that's known as the UTXO model, and this has implications for how you program smart contracts to interact with user funds, including in this use case, enabling users to transfer their funds into a layer two protocol such as a validity roll-up.
So while the roll-up features or could be identical between roll-ups that you could build on Ethereum, for example, or roll-ups that you would build on Bitcoin, the actual mechanics of how the funds are secured on layer one could be quite different. Eric, I know you've always been an optimist about the future of Bitcoin innovation. I know that ZK roll-ups has been one of those things. When you saw this paper, and also for the listeners who have a computer handy, Bitcoin roll-ups.org is a useful website, which is kind of the punchline of this whole show. Eric, when you saw this paper, when you read this paper and saw it out of John Light, what did you see?
What got sparked into your imagination? Yeah, so just to give some context on how the research project came to be, the sort of origin story here is that it was actually Ooty Verkheimer that had some argument on Twitter that led to CMS holdings making 100,000 grand to a charity of Ooty's choice. It might have been the podcast that you guys said with the BNB is sound money. High for sound money or something, yeah. So CMS sent a 100,000 dollar grant to the Human Rights Foundation, Human Rights Foundation partnered with Starkware, and Alex Glanstein, who's the Chief Strategy Officer at Human Rights Foundation, has been, he has his own, he's very idealistic with Bitcoin, and he really wants Bitcoin to succeed.
And he's very, I would say, in many cases, he's very intellectually honest about what the complications for Bitcoin is, and then he uses the Human Rights Foundation sometimes to create grants and create research projects to solve the bottlenecks that he's seen. So Alex Glanstein, he has been interested in trying to understand, like, can we use something like CK Roll-Up as an alternative technology or as a complementary technology to the Lightning Network on Bitcoin? And then he did a combined grant between Starkware and the Human Rights Foundation to research this, basically. And I was helping Alex find the right candidate to do the research projects.
We had a bunch of different applications, and I've known John Lyte, like from Twitter, from before, and I know that he's very clued in about what the technology stack already looks like. So it's not going to be completely new pieces to him. So we chose him because he was the best candidate, and the work that he's done, we're very happy with the work that John has done. So from the research project, I would say, has been a success, and it's incredibly interesting to listen to John speak about this because John was previously to having done this work. He was a bit skeptical to whether or not Roll-Up's were actually a fitting technology on Bitcoin.
And I myself have been skeptical whether or not because one of the things that a Roll-Up does, it allows you to segregate state from the main chain to a secondary layer. So one of the scalability bottlenecks in Ethereum is that the main chain state is so bloated, but the Roll-Up is a new state. And in Bitcoin, we don't really have a UTXO set, which is the closest equivalent to a state, the way that we have it in Ethereum. But the state in Bitcoin isn't really, you know, it's not tens of gigabytes or hundreds of gigabytes large as it is in Ethereum. It's much smaller, it's much leaner. So for this reason, it hasn't been really clear, like, do we actually need Roll-Up's on Bitcoin?
Does it solve the, I mean, Ethereum is an extremely computationally heavy product, right? Bitcoin doesn't really function in the same way. We don't really have the same type of scalability bottlenecks. So therefore, it really has been a question, like, does a ZK well of some Bitcoin actually solve the correct type of scalability bottlenecks? And sort of the interesting thing that has come out of John's research is that it does address those specific bottlenecks. It is something that we can use to reach orders of magnitude more scale in Bitcoin. So when I hear a Roll-Up on Bitcoin, two things come to mind.
One is a better lightning network. My opinion on the net lightning network is that the UX is too difficult for it to be really adopted as a mainstream technology. And so if with a ZK Roll-Up on Bitcoin, we might be able to have the scalability of that we need in order to scale Bitcoin payments to the world. So I want to go down that rabbit hole. The other rabbit hole I want to go down is expressivity. It's like, okay, what other potential is unlocked by a ZK Roll-Up? Does it make Bitcoin more expressive than the layer one? And so I will take those one at a time. John, is a very simple ZK Roll-Up on Bitcoin just a better lightning network?
Is that something that we've unlocked here? By the way, could I just jump in here and click? Yeah, sorry, let Eric hop in, he probably can ask the question better. Yeah, so no, I just want to mention something that I thought was pretty funny. So I had a bet with the editor of Bitcoin Magazine about whether or not the merge would happen this year. And the bet was for a tungsten cube, and as we know, the merge happened this year. So he was going to send me $333 over the lightning network yesterday, and I downloaded a wallet called the World of Satoshi, and I sent him an invoice, and I wasn't sure it's going to work because the problem that you usually have with lightning is that you don't have enough inbound liquidity.
So in lightning, you need liquidity locked up to be able to receive a payment, which is one of the most fundamental limitations of the lightning network. And in this case, it actually works. I didn't do any setup. I just received a payment of $333. I was like, holy shit, lightning actually works. And I was this close to making, because I feel like I have to be intellectually honest when good things are happening with lightning, like if something really works and it impresses me, it would be intellectually dishonest if I said, you know, I'm not going to publish, I'm not going to tweet about that.
So as I'm writing the tweet, I thought, you know, I'll just, I just have to go and look up that this is actually like a non-custodial wallet, and then it is in the custodial wallet that handles all the lightning channels. Turns out the World of Satoshi is a custodial lightning wallet, so this was all like done in a centralized fashion, and I was like, okay, well, that's the reason that, you know, this works. It wasn't, it wasn't this discovery that the lightning network suddenly works. So I think, you know, this issue with lightning is really, in my perspective, this is the reason why rollups has been such a huge interest for me, it's because these channel limitations that you have a lightning, and John, you've looked at this, like in your, in your rollups paper, you've gone through like the sort of user experience bottlenecks or quirks with the lightning networks and how rollups are sort of different.
So it would be super interesting to hear like how you compare those two technologies. Yeah, yeah, I think it, from what I could tell people's experience using lightning varies. Some people have a great experience all the time, some people have problems, and it's very set up dependent, like dependent on the wallet, dependent on what nodes you have channels open to, dependent on how much liquidity you have. Like I have used Phoenix wallet and breeze wallet and blue wallet, all for lightning. I believe blue wallet's implementation of lightning is custodial, but breeze wallet and Phoenix are mostly non-custodial.
And I haven't had any problems with any of those wallets. I think I've had two or three outbound payments that have ever failed. And it was because the person I was sending it to just didn't have enough liquidity. And so whereas rollups, they're blockchains. So if you have funds on the chain, you can send it to any other address on the chain. And as long as your transaction gets included in a block, the payment is going to complete. The tradeoff that you get is throughput. So lightning throughput on the network itself is not constrained in any way. You and I can pass back and forth a Satoshi, millions of times, and it's not constrained by data.
It's not constrained by the base layer block size limit, good clarification. It is constrained by bandwidth and liquidity, but it's not constrained by the base layer transaction throughput. And the transactions on lightning have what is referred to as local state. So only the parties to the transaction actually even know that really the transaction is happening. And that's like where you get lightning's massive throughput and scalability gains from. Because you don't need to tell your transaction to the entire world. You just keep those transaction details between the parties to a transaction.
Whereas rollups have what is called global state. Where everybody who's using the protocol knows about all the transactions because just like with the base layer blockchain, you're broadcasting these transactions to a global network. Some nodes out there that are performing the role of block producers are bundling those transactions into a block. And then that block has to get confirmed on the layer one or base layer blockchain. And so the amount of transactions that fits in a rollup block has to fit within the L1 data availability capacity, whether that's within the layer one block itself or in some like data blob that's attached to the block.
And so that's like kind of the fundamental trade off. You get these nice user experience benefits where it just feels like using any other blockchain. But you're fundamentally constrained in throughput by the data availability capacity on your base layer blockchain. Okay. So is it fair to say that we've seen rollups grow in adoption on the Ethereum side of things. We haven't seen the lightning network really become adopted on the Bitcoin side of things. Is it fair to say that like with rollups on Bitcoin, we would have a payments network that is superior in its adoption potential than lightning network?
Is that a fair thing to say? Well, I don't know that a fair comparison can really be made between rollups on Ethereum today and lightning on Bitcoin. One, they're used for very different things. So the amount of money that say circulates in a financial system for trading different types of assets is almost certainly going to be different than the amount of money that's circulating through say a peer-to-peer payments application or something like that. Another thing that you have to look at is not just the liquidity, but the actual amount of users and there are thousands of lightning nodes on the network and some of those are custodial.
So they have like customers who are utilizing those nodes that it's hard to even say how many users they have unless they advertise it since they're hidden behind like a custodial interface. And so even the throughput on the network because it's not a global state, we don't know how many transactions are happening across the lightning network. So it's hard to make a comparison and even if you could compare them, like I said, I don't think it's quite comparing apples to apples. With that having been said, I think that because of the UX benefits that you get from having this global state model and like being able to receive offline payments, being able to receive payments without requiring inbound liquidity and having channel limitations and things like that, I think those features do overall improve the user experience.
And so roll-ups could be an alternative for certain use cases and not others. Like if you need really high capacity, high volume, low value transactions like micropayments or nanopayments, then a state channel network such as lightning might still be the better option. But for simple, then-mo like peer-to-peer payments or maybe even like business-to-business payments, roll-ups might be better, like a better user experience, the constraints or requirements of that type of payment just might be better suited to a roll-up. So there's a problem with that manateeer that we don't really know the answer to.
Is the reason that the lightning network is not taking office quickly as you know other layers on a theorem, for example? Is it because the user experience of lightning is bad or is it because people don't want to make payments with Bitcoin? We don't really know the answer to those questions. Like I can speak for myself as a Bitcoiner, but I would probably make more transactions if the lightning network was more reliable than I would have a wallet with some funds in it. I use it. Whereas with lightning it's always like, I pull up my wallet, it sort of has to sink, my child's are not always configured, and then that sort of leads me to go and put it into a custodial wallet, but I don't want to put a sizable amount of funds in a custodial wallet because I'm sort of worried that it's going to disappear.
So it's not clear exactly what the reason is that people are not using, I think, whether it's user experience related or if it's something else. My perception is that the property that it's the roll-up on Bitcoin, a Bitcoin roll-up or rolls in general, are this persistent thing that has 100% uptime is a big unlock. Whereas the lightning network is this more nebulous thing where parts of the lightning network go offline, then they come off online later, and the lightning network is just loosely connected network of nodes when some of those nodes go offline. Versus a roll-up where the roll-up is one single blockchain with 100% uptime.
I think that's the unlock that I think really gets me excited about the potential of a new layer on Bitcoin that sees a lot of demand. Yeah, John, some thoughts on that? Yeah. Well, to draw another comparison, I think today, roll-ups don't actually fit the full vision of what we imagine a roll-up to be, right, or the full potential of a roll-up. Today, they're secured by multisigs, not by layer one consensus. Today, they have single block producers, not multiple block producers, and so there have been outages on roll-ups where users can't access their funds for 24 or 48 hours or longer. So similar to the way that the lightning network, it's immature, people are still building out tools for managing liquidity and figuring out the user experience at rough edges.
I think some of those rough edges are going to be able to be smoothed out. Some of them might never be able to be smoothed out. Similarly, with roll-ups, I think there is a potential there to get to an ideal state of trustlessness, security, uptime, and we might never reach that full ideal in the same way that even with base layer blockchains today, there are bugs and there are US challenges. But we can move incrementally closer to that ideal. And I think the ideal state of a roll-up, again, for certain use cases, is arguably superior than lightning or other layer two protocols that we can build on Bitcoin today.
So that's one of the things that makes me excited about roll-ups is that I think they can fulfill particular use cases, they can fill a particular potential that just isn't possible today. And one example of that that I think is super interesting is that I can say to you, by the way, I just sent you $40 on the ZK sync roll-up or on the Arbitrum roll-up. And you're like, oh, and you're like, okay, so do I go and claim it with my E and S name, like David Hoffman, buddy, and then you can have access to those funds. And we didn't have to coordinate on which layer, we didn't need to do any setup process before that I just sent you those funds, like an email, like I just know your email address, you not have those assets.
So that's something that you can do on a roll-up. You could do that on a roll-up on Bitcoin also, but you just send them funds without them even downloading a roll-up on it. You can send them funds. And that's something that you can't do with the lightning network the way that it's currently exists. Right, because as a user, as a lightning user, I need to initialize my lightning node and then also maintain that lightning node in order to have like my email address being able to receive emails, which is just like not a UX that people are used to and perhaps just like is insurmountably difficult for a global adoption.
But this idea where you have this persistent address that exists at any layer that works universally and you don't have to maintain a node or initialize a node in the first place to be able to access this. I think that's just a UX that says more resonant with the internet-going people of the modern age. I don't know if this is a problem that could be solved, but you do have to be careful about that. Because I remember there was a problem with some tokens on optimism that the optimism team was distributed to, I think, an investor or something like that. Winter Mew, it was a trading firm. But there was actually a new one there is that it was a nosis multi-sig and it was a very early version of the nosis multi-sig.
So it was a bit of software on top of a layer and that particular software. It was a contract address. So it didn't actually have anything to do with the fact that it was on a new layer. It was a specific multi-sig implementation that created a new address that was different from the address on the layer one. So that was more of an application layer difference than a protocol layer difference. I thought it was something like the case was like they had the contract address on layer one that optimism team sent the tokens to the address on layer two and somebody else deployed the contract to the optimism roll-up and was able to basically create a wallet with the same address and therefore they were the owners of those tokens.
That is what happened. But that's an application layer thing, not a blockchain layer thing. It was the specific code of the actual multi-sig that created that property that was allowed to be exported rather than the actual layer itself. Does that make sense? Yeah, yeah, yeah. I bring it up to say like I don't know if it's you can 100% assume that a user is going to have the same address on all layers so you want to be careful about that but assuming like I said at the beginning like I don't know if that problem can be solved but if you know maybe when it can and you can reliably assume that then then you get to kind of this nirvana state where you can just like you know somebody's address you can send them money anywhere and just tell them like hey your money's over here go get it.
I think that would be a really great place to end up. Certainly. Okay so I think we've unpacked the differences between the payment properties of a Bitcoin roll-up versus lightning. I want to get into expressivity and so when we get into a new layer on top of Bitcoin that's a ZK roll-up. What other things can we do on a layer on top of Bitcoin that's a ZK roll-up that we can't actually do on the Bitcoin layer what? What kind of new features are unlocked for us? Are we getting like the full scope of tokens and smart contracts and DNS names or is it something more more simple? What are the new things that are unlocked here?
Potentially yeah anything that you could do with a blockchain you can full-turing complete expressivity. Yeah. Yeah I mean you need to have a verifier on layer one that is capable of verifying the the proofs of that computation and I discussed in the report that I wrote up about how if Bitcoin developers did not want to enable that level of expressivity for some reason they could restrict the complexity or power of the computations that are able to be verified on layer one. Basically intentionally handicapping the the verifier on layer one. But if you if you weren't weren't to do that then yeah theoretically you could have any kind of blockchain converted to a roll-up and layer one doesn't need to know how to like execute those transactions it just needs to know how to verify the proofs and as long as it can verify the proofs the state can be updated and users can safely make withdrawals and the roll-up just works.
So this is one of the like mind-blowing facts about roll-ups on Bitcoins that they actually enable full-turing complete virtual machines so this was like when I was I was interested in roll-up since 2019 it wasn't like a couple of years after that I realized actually wait a start proof can encode an entire virtual machine it does that on Ethereum and then of course it you can also do the exact same thing on Bitcoins. So the way that you can think about the the validity proofs that you implement on the mainnet is that they're almost like adapters like they're almost like power adapters that can change the entire virtual machine of the system that it's validating.
So it opens up basically like limitless potential any new type of virtual machine which is why like the limitation the comparison between the lightning network and a roll-up is sort of limp because it doesn't really even address this whole new paradigm of applications that they roll up potentially on logs. It would be interesting to think a little bit about okay so we've talked about the transaction throughput benefits when we're only talking about like account to account transfers in a roll-up. If we're talking about like turn complete smart contracts would it even be feasible to run like one like a unit swap or like could we even run one like smart contract application as they exist on Ethereum without like breaking the scalability boundaries of Bitcoin.
That I don't know because we've only really lived at like account account transfers where the on-chain footprint is kind of it's like small like 12 bytes for transaction. I would say so I mean if you look at if you look at the size of like even just a raw uncompressed unit swap transaction on-chain it's you know not even kilobytes like it you know it's it's a very small amount of data to actually update the state of the unit swap contract so I think I think you could the same way that we're able to confirm not just a single transaction but batches of EVM compatible transactions within Ethereum blocks which even accounting for call data are much smaller than Bitcoin blocks.
Yeah I think I think it shouldn't be a problem on Bitcoin. So maybe it's fair to say then so the hardest thing maybe to achieve here is when I when I read your research we you also looked at like enabling Zcash style fully private transactions through a roll-up and then the scalability of the system actually goes like it actually decreases so you can't make as many Zcash style transactions using a ZK roll-up on Bitcoin as the main met Bitcoin layer can do regular transaction itself so if you go into like the ZK the Zcash style paradigm through a roll-up then so Bitcoin does like four transactions transaction four transactions per second right now it'll only be able to do like three transactions per second if it tried to do ZK Zcash style transactions using a roll-up right yeah yeah shielded transactions because you have to in like the transactions end to end encrypted it like bloat this blows up the size of the the transaction even with you know the the most efficient proofs that we have today um it it ends up being bite for bite um about 20% bigger 20 25% bigger than a normal one input two output Bitcoin layer one transaction um I think you know you because it that's not a huge hit and it's you're getting a much better privacy profile like if you tried to have a similar similarly private Bitcoin transaction like you just couldn't even do it like you could have fit enough inputs and outputs to match the end-on-indity set of like a shielded transaction um so they're not completely comparable but um uh yeah I think it's I think it's worth the additional 20 25% size to to get that strong level of privacy but um it's up to each user to decide really yeah you could potentially also maybe run an application like tornado cash now that's maybe that's not the one application that you'll see developer rushing into developing right now but you could potentially run an application like that also if you just want to get like a mixer that runs on Bitcoin because I mean we have coin joins on Bitcoin um but the privacy is not perfect the skateability is not very high maybe something like tornado cash through a zk rule up maybe that could be um a use case for people that want to get better privacy uh what do you think that maybe um zcash style transactions are are the better use case here I think I think mixers have a lot of foot guns involved because there are a lot of like rules that you have to follow to use a mixer safely so you don't de-anonymize yourself and as a consequence damage the end-on-indity of everybody else using the mixer um so you know I would I would advocate you know if people want privacy the direction that we need to move in is is getting people to store their money in shielded pools and to make shielded transactions um simply depositing your money into a shielded pool and then taking it out a couple days later uh I don't I you know that doesn't I don't think that really solves the problem because then you have to stay inside the shielded building all the transactions there is sort of more elegant solution to the privacy problem than going in and out of mixers all the time right yeah you like you're you're you're less susceptible to timing attacks uh you're less uh you the you're like questions about post mix privacy are uh easier to reason about um and of course you know z to z you know fully shielded transactions are kind of the gold standard so I would hope that most peer-to-peer payments um that don't need to have any kind of public component move in that direction the reality today is that five corporations control the entire world of social media they own our names they restrict our content they monitor our every move and their time is up thanks to our sponsor deso deso is a layer one blockchain built from the ground up to decentralize and scale social networks with deso you can own your own identity content and social graph and take it with you across hundreds of applications already built on the censorship resistant deso blockchain deso storage advantages make it finally possible to build infinite state applications that can efficiently store and index large amounts of content and data fully on chain deso also offers multiple crypto native monetization primitives for developers and creators including social NFTs social dows social tokens and social tipping so in order to experience the social layer of web 3 go to deso.
com and claim your username that's d-e-s-o.com the brave wallet is your secure multi-chain on ramp into web 3 and it's built directly into the brave privacy browser gone are the days of managing multiple wallet extensions that put you at risk of phishing spoofs and trackers with the brave wallet you can securely manage your crypto assets across more than a hundred different chains including ethereum layer two's salana and more all without downloading risk extensions the brave wallet is easy to set up and removes the headache of jumping between wallets and extensions it's lightweight but packed with great features like built-in token swaps buying and holding NFTs with a gallery view and support for hardware wallets but also much more than that because brave is shipping new features every single month with a mission to make web 3 easier to navigate for its over 55 million users wall extensions are the thing in the past so get started with brave's web 3 ready browser today and experience a decentralized web seamlessly without all the clutter download the browser at brave.
com slash bank list and click the wall icon to get started. Arbitram 1 is pioneering the world of secure ethereum scalability and is continuing to accelerate the web 3 landscape hundreds of projects have already deployed on Arbitram 1 producing flourishing defi and NFT ecosystems with a recent addition of Arbitram Nova gaming and social apps like Reddit are also now calling Arbitram home both Arbitram 1 and Nova leverage the security and decentralization of ethereum and provide a builder experience that's intuitive familiar and fully EV and compatible on Arbitram both builders and users will experience faster transaction speeds with significantly lower gas fees with Arbitram's recent migration to Arbitram Nitro it's also now 10 times faster than before visit arbitram.
io where you can join the community dive into the developer docs bridge your assets and start building your first app with Arbitram experience web 3 development the way it was meant to be secure fast cheap and friction free so just to make sure that I'm tracking this conversation where what we're talking about is there's various applications that we can do on a zk roll up perhaps limitless and it's really a function of the constraints of the bitcoin layer 1 block space and so now we're talking about all right like what applications are like high priority what applications on a zk roll up on bitcoin do we want to emphasize first and I totally understand that private payments probably resonates with bitcoin culture more than tokens and so maybe that's that's kind of where we start and kind of open up the design space for stuff that kind of resonates with bitcoin culture but in theory so long as there's block space on the bitcoin layer 1 there is potential on a bitcoin zk roll up on its own layer 2 and that potential is really just only constrained by the imaginations of the developers that can build on it this is might take away is that correct yeah but it should be said though that bitcoins have recently there are recently waking up to this idea that in order to win the payments use case for any blockchain system it's a good idea to start out with stablecoins so if you can if you can build a stablecoin payments rails that become that becomes universally adopted that'll be much easier to later introduce your own native token into that so if the lightning network for example becomes a leading solution to transfer stablecoins around then bitcoin gets an edge relative to Ethereum and if if roll ups become the leading solution and they're based on Ethereum to transfer stablecoins it'll be easier to sort of sneak ether into that mix and transfer those tokens so but I do think that transferring stablecoins on the lightning network is not that easy they have a solution currently which involves swapping the stablecoin in and out of bitcoin multiple times just to complete the payment which means that they're going to incur like multiple spreads on those payments so they won't just say to be very cheap and the UX as we know it isn't perfect with lightning either so something like a zK roll up on bitcoin where you make stablecoin payments will potentially be advantageous even to the like the path to adoption that the bitcoins have already sort of understood is optimal so the roll ups could fill a use case there where you're using them to transfer tokens also and I don't think that Bitcoin is necessary would be like against that idea one of the things that we we didn't mention that I think is interesting is like this idea of building layer three protocols on top of a layer two roll up in order to compensate for any shortcomings that would be on the roll up such as you know transaction capacity due to layer one throughput limitations so like you could have layer three protocols like validiums or volitions or things like that where you actually have off-chain data availability you reduce the security model a little bit it still ends up being a stronger security model than like your typical federated sidechain and you're not constrained by the base layer throughput capacity so if you wanted to say on board an entire country like all Salvador to Bitcoin you might say well we don't want just everybody to have custodial accounts because that's not the Bitcoin way but they're not all going to fit on layer one or maybe even layer two can we do something that's like in the middle and I think a validium built on top of a roll up could be that sweet spot where it's still not custodial there's a strong guarantee that users can get their funds out with data if the data is available and at the same time you have basically unlimited throughput I mean just as much throughput as the sequencer or block producers are willing to allow for to produce their blocks but yeah that's I think an interesting way as we were talking about those limitations throughput on the base layer that's like an interesting way that you can use ZK roll-ups or validity roll-ups to enable these new protocols that aren't possible on Bitcoin today that offer interesting security and scalability trade-offs and you mentioned in your paper you mentioned the ability to build the lightning network on top of a ZK roll-up so in order to improve the scalability of the lightning network you could run it on a ZK roll-up on Bitcoin so that could be like a layer three but it's true that you point out that I mean the lightning network the way the way that the lightning network is constructed it's designed the way that it's designed because of the limitations of the Bitcoin base layer the script language the scripting language but if you have a ZK roll-up you could build a little bit different like a little bit different scripting language and build a little bit different lightning network that solves some so for example if you want L2 or other things that people are waiting for in lightning you could sort of enable those things with a ZK roll-up module and then you could build more interesting or more user-friendly or more secure perhaps even lightning networks on top of that roll-up so that's do you agree with that assessment?
Yeah yeah I think I think enabling developers to try more things more quickly without having to wait for base layer consensus changes I think we'll help advance the state of L2 or like off-chain protocol development and yeah that's an exciting possibility. We sort of hop to sort of get into what exactly needs to be done on the Bitcoin base layer to even enable this I think this is a should we get into that discussion maybe? Yeah that's exactly where I was going to go next because I've had this discussion with other people who are familiar with building on the Bitcoin blockchain it's like all right like how do we get Bitcoin trustlessly over to Ethereum how do we build like bridges that are trustless and every time I like ask developer-minded friends like how do we do this thing on Bitcoin they're like well we're going to need to change the op-codes and as as soon as I hear that line change the op-codes my mind just goes like well that's not going to happen because that means a hard fork and that Bitcoin just doesn't hard fork like that's the vibe that's the social contract and so John what does it take to actually get AZK roll up into Bitcoin like what changes do we need how do we actually arrive at this at this future state that we all want for Bitcoin?
So there will need to be new op-codes but the good news is that it doesn't take a hard fork okay so the way that op-codes have been added or disabled in Bitcoin or the years pretty much since the Satoshi days is using a style of fork called a soft fork which is considered backwards compatible okay so old nodes don't need to update their software in order to remain on the network and in consensus and able to send and receive coins with other nodes that have upgraded and adopted the the new op-codes so this is how for example p2sh which we use for multi-sig in Bitcoin was adopted this is how segwit was adopted and most recently taproot okay so Bitcoin does soft forks very successful it has successfully implemented soft fork upgrades in its history so it's reasonable to assume that we can do this again if the Bitcoin community wants ZK roll ups yeah yeah for sure well I mean this this still introduces if we think about the risks that AZK roll up introduces on Bitcoin I think a lot of people are afraid if you introduce a turning complete virtual machine module through a ZK roll up on Bitcoin then you can have very complex smart contract that smart contract languages run basically on top of Bitcoin and if there's an exploit above like let's say like a dial hack in that second layer then the base it sort of becomes the base layers problem so now if you have to sort of save all the users in the second layer because there was a bug there then maybe you need to do that through soft fork on the on the on the base layer so sort of the problems that can happen in these external layers can sort of trickle down to the base layer itself and also issues like MEV for example if you have a roll of generating lots and lots of MEV and then the miners that get to include the proofs of the roll up on the on the main it maybe there's like getting to include those proofs pay way more than any other transactions do so then miners are all of a sudden incentivized to sort reorganize the blockchain to be the ones that get to include these proofs instead of just like mining the blockchain as usual so the same similar this the same critiques or similar critiques that have been levied against are theoretically in my opinion could be levied also against ZK roll ups but the advantage of ZK roll ups sort of has here is that it's it's it's it's different it doesn't have the same political baggage that drive chains do all the conflicts between the core developers and Paul Storch who was the pioneer of drive chains is not relevant anymore and ZK roll ups also they have their stronger security guarantees right so it might be worthwhile actually doing this for ZK roll ups while for drive chains it it wasn't really worthwhile because you still it was just a merge mind side chain basically so I wouldn't I think that there's still a conflict that would need it's not just a matter of a technical improvement that when we have time we will get it into Bitcoin it's a whole ideological question of whether or not this upgrade makes sense to Bitcoiners and I think like from my perspective what really would need to happen for people in the Bitcoin ecosystem to seriously evaluate this is if Ethereum started to flip and Bitcoin then it would be like okay you know maybe maybe we need to try something new but unless that happens and Bitcoin just keeps this very dominant role I think people will more think of ZK rolls as something for the future maybe I don't know those are my thoughts I'm less convinced that Ethereum hypothetically flipping Bitcoin would cause that deep of soul searching to say change the calculus of whether or not it would be worth implementing EVM or terrain complete ZK roll ups on Bitcoin I think there's a there's a view in the Bitcoin community that Ethereum is like a tech platform and so Ethereum flippeting Bitcoin would be no more noteworthy than a tech startup you know stock market cap post IPO flipping Bitcoin or something like that at least I'm sure people would try to explain it away in that way and that might not even be that invalid of a viewpoint but I think that part of the debate it involves even more nuance it's like we could enable ZK roll ups on Bitcoin without enabling fully terrain complete EVM compatible or other kinds of fully expressive ZK roll ups we could say we're going to enable the verifier to verify transactions that are uh no more complex than Bitcoin is today like you can't do you it just can't it isn't capable of verifying computation heavier than that um and so you would be you would be limited in the types of scripts that you could build on the the layer to roll up and you know Bitcoiners might say like you know we can start there and maybe in you know a few years down the line after we've done more research on say cross layer MEV or these other like more subtle economic game theoretical concerns um you know we'll we'll make a decision about whether we want to enable these more expressive roll ups um so I I do think that we could see um validity roll ups on Bitcoin before we even have answers to like those those questions about the more expressive roll ups so the the perspective that I'm seeing here is that like in the Ethereum land anyone can build a roll up and deploy at any time there's no like changes to the base layer like we can have a bajillion different roll ups of a different uh bajillion different varieties what I'm seeing here John is that like that's not true in the Bitcoin land the Bitcoin social contract needs to come to consensus about what flavor of roll up they want to enable and that kind of makes that future roll up more enshrined than Ethereum roll ups where Ethereum roll ups are all kind of commercial they're all built as a like a second layer to Ethereum that don't they and they don't really impact the base layer because they don't have requirements upon the base layer a Bitcoin ZK roll up would require things of the Bitcoin layer one and if the Bitcoin layer one changed itself via a soft fork to enable a specific kind of roll up that kind of enshrines that roll up as like a more of a first class citizen to Bitcoin then and then Ethereum does to its own it's own roll ups Eric did that make sense and do you agree with that I agree with that and also one of the things that I think that you're almost touched on is that in the Bitcoin world then we don't have the ability to plug in any type of roll up into the Bitcoin system we have to decide on a specific proof system and then enable that specific proof system so and this is one of the big complications of it like how do we even decide which proof system we want to enable like there's plongs there's red shift there's growth there's all these different types of cryptographic mechanisms I mean we know in Bitcoin that we sort of prefer cryptographic systems with the least amount of new assurance a least amount of assumptions so we want something that is maybe stark based you can go into this also John so we we want something that breaks the least amount of risk by using something that is as tested as possible and we don't want any trusted setups but we still have to choose a specific proof system and then we have to stick to that and then if there's a new one that comes along then that would involve a new soft fork so this makes the way to enable roll ups on Bitcoin way like we have to be way more thoughtful and we can't just be willing nearly about it go ahead John yeah I mean there there might be ways in which you could say enable proofs such that like the the miners verify them but the rest of the full node network doesn't have to so it's still kind of like a soft fork but but the you know the rest of the network doesn't have to verify it and it becomes almost like an SPV security model but yeah if you want if you want the full network to verify it for each new proving system you you enable you might you might need to if you don't if you don't kind of have like a very generic system from the start you're yeah you're going to have to do sequence of soft forks and if we get to the point where like Bitcoin ossifies and like can never fork again because coordination is just too difficult then we're stuck with what we've got and you know good enough we'll have to be good enough I think at that point we might see uh the innovation is shift to higher layers um but uh yeah it's that there there is some path dependency there that the community is going to have to think about um you know really think depth far down the line like how much can we future proof this without enabling things that we might consider dangerous um and so yeah there there there are there are a bunch of decisions to make here um and it's an open question as to how the community would actually make those decisions um how the community actually enables soft forks in general is kind of an ongoing conversation in the Bitcoin community um because with taproot we had speedy trial with segwit we had you know the the the lock-in plus like the ua the the lock-in deadline plus ua sf like they're you know Bitcoin has has tried all of these different things and there's not really consensus on on what is the best way to to go about soft forks yet uh let alone soft forks with so many different options that that have to be considered along with them and I'm I noticed that we didn't fully really respond to what needs to there's more things than just enabling a proof system on in on Bitcoin that you need to enable for a ZK rule up to exist so there's two parts to it that you people usually talk about the first one is being able to validate a validity proof a ZK proof and the second one is a covenant right and you talk in your paper about recursive covenants maybe we should also mention it like talk about what's this other part that needs to be enabled why does it need to be enabled and what exactly is it yeah so we talked about the the proof systems and yeah the other major pieces enabling recursive covenants and a covenant for those who aren't familiar is a type of smart contract that restricts the outputs of your transaction so for example you could have you could lock your coins in a covenant that says you can only spend those coins to a specific address and then when you go to spend those coins you can only spend them to the the address that's defined in the in the covenant and a recursive covenant is where you are able to apply restriction to the outputs of your outputs of your outputs like almost or actually potentially indefinitely restrict how a coin could be spent and we use recursive covenants for validity rollups basically to enforce that when the state of the rollup is updated that all of the coins that are currently held in the rollup remain in the rollup script as those coins are being basically spent in the rollup state transition transaction they're they're rolling over into the same script always unless there's a valid withdrawal transaction coming out of the rollup in which case the covenant is restricting the script such that users can only spend to a valid withdrawal address that has been validated using the validity proof so like if a user deposit some funds into the rollup it's going into a script on layer one then the block producer on the rollup produces a rollup block so updates the state of the rollup they basically spend all of the coins that are in the rollup script to an identical copy of the rollup script so they're like moving the coins from the the rollup script at state a into the rollup script at state b and they're including a validity proof that says you know this state transition is valid and then a user comes along and they say I want to make a withdrawal from the rollup so then the rollup block producer again is going to produce another block they're going to roll over the coins from the script at state b to state c and then they're also going to specify well some of the coins are going to come out of the script and be sent to this destination address and the script is going to consider that valid because there's a validity proof which proves to the layer one full notes you know everything about this transaction including this withdrawal is valid according to the rules of the rollup so the recursive covenant is basically needed just because of how the mechanics of like a Bitcoin transaction works with with the UTXO model so it's not like the most sexy part of a role of the covenant part but it's sort of a required element because an easy way to sort of explain it would be like in Bitcoin you can't have a variable that you update so you don't really have a persistent state that you can update like let's say you want x to be 4 and then some transactions happen now you want x to be 6 and you sort of want to store that variable you can't really do that in Bitcoin because there's no way to store a variable there's no way to store state on Bitcoin but the covenant would sort of allow that and it also is worthwhile pointing out that the covenant that has been discussed in Bitcoin the OPC TV the check time check time check time verify check template we're verifying yeah this one isn't sufficiently general to enable to enable something like ZK wall of some Bitcoin because it's sort of a very specific type of covenant so that thing doesn't allows to to get to to the roll up version yeah yeah you need you need the fully recursive covenants because you need to be able to restrict essentially forever like as long as the roll-up is an operation this you need to be able to enforce this rolling over of the UTXO from the script from one state to the next and the only way to do that is with recursive covenants unless you change you know you were to change like the the state model Bitcoin completely to like a account model but like I said that would probably be too radical of a change I don't I don't know if that would fair very well politically we both need to decide on which covenant do we want and which proof system do we want before we can enable ZK wall of some Bitcoin and both those things are sort of complex questions for implementation wise for Bitcoin for the Bitcoin system and communities are deciding yeah there have been a number of different proposals for how to get even like recursive covenants specifically into Bitcoin some developers have talked about like up TX some have talked about up or simplicity like just enabling the simplicity language there was a recommend there was a suggestion for chialisp so yeah there's there's a lot of ideas floating around but no consensus yet of how to enable these kinds of generalized or recursive covenants well amazing guys I feel very very educated to the way the Bitcoin works a little bit a little bit better in how ZK rolls might actually get there John what are there like clear next steps like what what are the next steps for getting this done if the Bitcoin community agrees that it this is the next step well I think it's going to take experimentation with those different options to see what what makes sense maybe some more research to find out what is the minimal set of changes that would be required if we wanted to enable only validity rollups I think there tends to be a preference in the Bitcoin developer community that if we're going to make a soft fork it should be usable for multiple different kinds of use cases and not just a single use case so you might be able to argue like validity rollups enable a bunch of different use cases so even if we were to soft fork only for validity rollups we unlock all of these other use cases and so that kind of specialized soft fork might be justifiable you might also say well if your validity rollup can only do Bitcoin style transactions anyways then you know it would be nice if the op codes that we enabled for validity rollups were also useful for other use cases and so then we might you know have have a bit of a conversation about about the trade-offs there but yeah I think more research more experimentation there are already some developers that are like working towards an MVP just getting like a basic Bitcoin style validity rollup working on a test somewhere and so I'm sure they'll be thinking through these questions but yeah I would encourage like there to be multiple work streams multiple different you know experimentation going on and you know we can all compare notes and see what works see what doesn't where the trade-offs and eventually hopefully come to consensus on something so we can bring this to Bitcoin and allow users to experience the benefits I have to ask one like last question here so in your paper you talk about how rollups enable potentially 50 times more transactional throughput with similar security guarantees that Bitcoin has on its base there so this is I mean this is pretty pretty staggering result right but why do you think that this research is coming from like the Human Rights Foundation and we found like a non-core Bitcoin developer to do this research and what like why isn't this type of very interesting research coming from within the Bitcoin core that the like the the regular this traditional Bitcoin developer ecosystem itself like why did it have to come from this like satellite route like of ethereum interested people in order to to explore this area I don't know if I could answer that question I mean everybody's got their own projects going on there have been a number of different research papers that have come out pertaining Bitcoin specifically through non you know not directly from from Bitcoin core contributors for example like BitMix sponsors a bunch of interesting research there's a bunch of interesting research that has historically come out of like academia so yeah I think just people you know certain people get interested in certain things and and and the research bubbles up from from those domains so yeah it's it would be hard to to answer that question any other way because like I said I think everybody's interested in in different aspects of of the Bitcoin's system and just because of my own unique you know personal and professional history I happen to have a background in in both you know EVM and in and roll up research as well as like Bitcoin cross-chain protocols and it just made sense for me to combine those areas of research and see what was possible with Bitcoin and Eric I think this this story of roll-ups on Bitcoin is like personal for you because I consider you like a frustrated Bitcoiner or you're a Bitcoiner who wants Bitcoin to do more just like can you put me in the shoes of Eric Wall like when you see ZK roll-ups on Bitcoin like does it make you optimistic for Bitcoin like what's it like to be you in the middle of this discussion yeah I mean this is the the roll-up discussion that I tried to bring to Bitcoin back in 2019 was one of the things that led to like my departure from the Bitcoin community because I had built up this reputation within the Bitcoin ecosystem for a very long time as the altcoin slayer like someone that was extremely critical to technology's built on altcoins so I thought that like when I discovered roll-ups and I looked at them and I thought holy shit this architecture like this way of architecting a scalability solution on top of a base layer is actually generally interesting so now that I've built up for these years now that I've built up this social capital can I just get my Bitcoin peers to look at this technology and think oh like maybe we should explore that way of architecting layer two and discuss how to implement that on Bitcoin but the whole conversation got completely derailed when people discovered like Eric are you proposing that we that we even accept that research is happening on the Ethereum side is actually valid like aren't you don't you know that everything that comes out of Ethereum is a scam I'm like doesn't matter what come from does it doesn't matter like who made it just look at how it's constructed and then we can have a technical conversation around that but I would I completely failed to make that conversation happen in 2019 and that was like when I started to entertain the idea that the intellectual center was sort of leaving Bitcoin and going moving into other like the Ethereum ecosystem more and that's why I've been spending so much time in the Ethereum ecosystem is because that's where I can have like stimulating conversations around this but I am happy though that now at long last we are starting to see interest in the Bitcoin ecosystem like these ideas are starting to to become accepted and we can discuss them again in Bitcoin so I'm happy about that but it's been like three years out in the cold like being called an idiot and a ship pointer when in reality now like we've done the research now for Zika will there is validity to those ideas and we can probably for the first time entertain that you don't have to be an evil person just to say like maybe we should do this on Bitcoin all right well I have even less social capital in the Bitcoin space than you probably far less yet ZK rollups on Bitcoin what we're seeing out of John's here's research on and again Bitcoin rollups.
org to learn more is like probably the most interesting and exciting thing I've seen out of Bitcoin since I've been in crypto and so I'm hoping this conversation continues and I definitely want to be a part of a part of that story as well because Bitcoin can be more expressive and deserves to be expressed more and I see ZK rollups as the first legitimate path to getting that done so John thank you for all of your all of your research and also coming on the show and talking to me and Eric about it here. Yeah definitely thank you so much for your interest. And Eric thank you for helping me navigate an area that a muscle that I don't flex very often so I needed some help on that one so thank you so much for your help.
Thanks for having me. All right cheers guys. Bankless nation risks and disclaimers of course east east is risky crypto is risky DeFi is risky ZK rollups on Bitcoin are perhaps the new frontier you can lose what you put in we are headed west this is the frontier it's not for everyone but we are glad you're with us on the bank list journey thanks a lot. Hey we hope you enjoyed the video if you did head over to bankless HQ right now to develop your crypto investing skills and learn how to free yourself from banks and gain your financial independence we recommend joining our daily newsletter podcast and community as a bankless premium subscriber to get the most out of your bankless experience you'll get access to our market analysis our alpha leaks and exclusive content and even the bankless token for airdrops raffles and unlocks if you're interested in crypto the bankless community is where you want to be click the link in the description to become a bankless premium subscriber today also don't forget to subscribe to the channel for in-depth interviews with industry leaders ask me anything and weekly rollups where we summarize the week in crypto and other fantastic content thanks everyone for watching and being on the journey as we build out the bankless nation.